gain of function research: advice from easac (volker ter meulen)
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
1/15
Kc`m og gumht`om resecrhf4 clv`he groa
ECXCH
Wonier ter Aeunem
Hfc`r og ECXCH [ori`mk Kroup
Ho‒hfc`r @CR, @mterChcleay Rcrtmersf`p
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
2/15
[fct `s ECXCH?
• Europecm Chclea`es Xh`emhe Clv`sory Houmh`n gorael `m :223 to emcjne
Europecm mct`omcn chclea`es og sh`emhe to honncjorcte `m k`v`mk clv`he to
EU pon`hy‒aciers (e.k. Europecm Hoaa`ss`om cml Rcrn`caemt)
• Hoapr`ses cnn EU mct`omcn chclea`es og sh`emhe (pnus Morwcy, Xw`tzerncml)
• Hore sehretcr`ct `m Fcnne, Keracmy cml metwori`mk ogg`he `m Jrussens,
Jenk`ua
• Ojdeht`ve
to
len`ver
homsemsus
outputs
to
prov`le
c
aecms
gor
tfe
honneht`ve vo`he og Europecm sh`emhe to je fecrl
• Rrokrcaaes hover J`osh`emhes, Emv`romaemt cml Emerky4 sustc`mel
`mterest `m pon`hy `ssues renct`mk to homtron og `mgeht`ous l`secses
:33/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
3/15
ECXCH KoG resecrhf prodeht4 wfy tf`s
honneht`ve chcleay
wori
ct
tfe
EU
neven?
• Lrcw`mk om cmcnys`s, hoaa`taemt cml pr`or wori jy ECXCH aeajer
chclea`es cml `mtermct`omcn l`shuss`om (:23:‒)
• Zesecrhf
cml
rekunct`om
`ssues,
cml
soh`etcn
`apn`hct`oms,
cre
renevcmt
gor
cnn EU Aeajer Xtctes cml gor honncjorct`ve EU resecrhf (For`zom :2:2)
cml gor prov`s`om og sfcrel `mgrcstruhture, e.k. j`ohomtc`maemt gch`n`t`es
• Xh`emt`g`h hoaaum`ty expressel l`gger`mk v`ews to Rres`lemt og Europecm
Hoaa`ss`om `m :238 om jemeg`t‒r`si `m KoG `mgnuemzc v`rus (F5M3) resecrhf
• Zequest groa Europecm Hoaa`ss`om cml Hf`eg Xh`emt`g`h Clv`ser to ECXCH
to hncr`gy cml clv`se om `ssues
833/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
4/15
ECXCH kocns gor tfe prodeht
• Jr`mk`mk toketfer sh`emt`sts, moa`mctel jy chclea`es, w`tf c
jrocl rcmke og expert`se cml v`ews
‘ \o expnore
wfere
tfere
`s
homsemsus
‘ \o hncr`gy wf`hf `ssues cre st`nn umresonvel
‘ \o clv`se om wfct cll`t`omcn cmcnys`s `s meelel to cssess guture
opt`oms gor tfe resecrhf crec
• Eapfcs`s`mk wf`hf
hurremt
EU
rekunct`oms
koverm
resecrhf
cml wfct kool prcht`he cnrecly ex`sts ct mct`omcn neven
• @lemt`gy`mk wfct `s mct`omcn or EU‒neven respoms`j`n`ty
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
5/15
ECXCH prodeht outputs
• G`rst aeet`mk og wori`mk kroup `m Moveajer :23
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
6/15
Xhope og tfe ECXCH prodeht4 cllress`mk
hr`t`hcn `ssues
gor
KoG
resecrhf
• Xeng ‒kovermcmhe cml sh`emt`g`h respoms`j`n`ty
• Jemeg`t‒r`si cssessaemt
• Zesecrhf rev`ew
cml
acmckeaemt
systeas
• Zesecrhf aorctor`c cml cntermct`ves
• J`oetf`hs ‘ `ssues cml pnche `m resecrhf rev`ew
• J`osehur`ty clv`sory `ssues ‘ aehfcm`sas cml clv`sory jol`es
• Rujn`hct`om og
sems`t`ve
`mgoract`om
cml
opt`oms
gor
acmckeaemt
• Rujn`h emkckeaemt ‘ cml tfe respoms`j`n`t`es og chclea`es
• Knojcn homtext ‘ cml fow to `mgora l`shuss`om cml cht`om wornlw`le
733/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
7/15
@mtroluht`om to ECXCH rehoaaemlct`oms
• Eapfcs`s`mk c ncyerel cpprochf w`tf `mtekrct`om og
respoms`j`n`t`es cml cht`om ct resecrhfer, resecrhf `mst`tut`om,
resecrhf gumler,
mct`omcn
cml
`mtermct`omcn
nevens
• Gohus om v`ronoky resecrhf jut rehoaaemlct`oms cre cnso
renevcmt aore jroclny `m a`hroj`onoky
• Gohus
om
j`oscgety
jut
j`osehur`ty
cnso
rehokm`sel
cs
very
`aportcmt (homt`mu`mk cttemt`om e.k. `m @CR J`osehur`ty wori)
• Xoae `ssues reac`m homtrovers`cn jut tfe outputs represemt
ECXCH [ori`mk Kroup homsemsus
;33/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
8/15
ECXCH iey aessckes4 Xeng ‒rekunct`om cml
fcraom`sct`om• Kool prcht`he requ`res ‘ homgora`mk w`tf rekunct`oms/scgety
homl`t`oms/holes og homluht, dust`gy`mk proposel resecrhf
• Xeng ‒rekunct`om
aecms
‘ hfehis
cml
jcncmhes
om
resecrhf
w`tf`m tfe sh`emt`g`h hoaaum`ty, requ`res rc`s`mk cwcremess og
resecrhfers cml tfe`r `mst`tut`oms, w`tf meel gor eluhct`om
• Cttemt`om
to
j`oscgety
`ssues
‘ ct
cnn
stckes
e.k.
`m
proposcn• Chclea`es og sh`emhe fcve c homt`mu`mk rone ‘ `m proaot`mk
j`oscgety cml j`osehur`ty moras cml support`mk cul`t og
resecrhf prcht`hes
633/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
9/15
ECXCH iey aessckes4 Jemeg`t‒r`si
cssessaemt• Mot c „omhe cml gor cnn‑ hcnhunct`om jut homt`mu`mk, honneht`ve
hoaa`taemt to umlerstcml cml hoaaum`hcte tfe `ssues
• @mhoaaemsurcjne pcrcaeters
aecsurel
`m
r`si
cml
jemeg`t
lo mot cnnow c vcnue‒gree letera`mct`om to je acle
• Hcm jemeg`t je qucmt`g`el cs prospeht`ve pujn`h fecntf `apcht
or leshr`jel `m teras og kemerct`om og sh`emt`g`h imownelke?
• Chclea`es cml necrmel soh`et`es meel to homt`mue to
proaote l`shuss`om chross sh`emt`g`h hoaaum`ty cml w`tf
otfer stciefonlers
033/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
10/15
ECXCH iey aessckes4 EU/mct`omcn cht`v`t`es
cml orkcm`sct`oms
`m
j`oscgety/j`osehur`ty
• Honnct`mk cvc`ncjne `mgoract`om ‘ c poss`jne rone gor Europecm
Hoaa`ss`om (LK Xcmte) Fecntf Xehur`ty Hoaa`ttee
• @aportcmhe og
ku`lcmhe
gor
resecrhf
gumlel
jy
For`zom
:2:2
cs wenn cs ct mct`omcn neven
• @aportcmhe gor cnn resecrhfers cml tfe`r `mst`tut`oms
homgora`mk w`tf EU rekunct`oms cs `apneaemtel mct`omcnny
• Mo mew EU‒neven joly `s rehoaaemlel
• Aeajer Xtctes sfounl fcve hnecr mct`omcn clv`sory cpprochf
cml kovermcmhe aehfcm`sa w`tf stctutory powers
3233/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
11/15
Fow loes EU hurremtny acmcke resecrhf?
• Overcrhf`mk EU nek`snct`om
‘ L`reht`ve om homtc`mel use og KAOs
‘ L`reht`ve om proteht`om groa r`sis renct`mk to exposure to j`onok`hcn ckemts ct
wori (homtc`maemt
neven
8 cml
< ncjorctor`es)
‘ Zekunct`om om homtron og export og lucn‒use tehfmonoky
‘ Nek`snct`om `s `apneaemtel jy Aeajer Xtctes w`tf emgorheaemt jy tfe`r
rekunctory cutfor`t`es
• Rrcht`hcn prohelures
gor
j`or`si
acmckeaemt
‘ e.k. [FO cml OEHL ku`lcmhe, levenopaemt og @XO Xtcmlcrl
• Holes og homluht
‘ e.k. @CR/@CH :23:, Neoponl`mc w`tf LGK :23<
3333/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
12/15
Hcse stuly og ncyerel mct`omcn grcaewori
gor acmck`mk
resecrhf4
UI
•Mct`omcn nek`snct`om `apneaemts EU L`reht`ves
•@mst`tut`om/`ml`v`lucn requ`res cppropr`cte trc`m`mk, equ`paemt cml gch`n`t`es (`mspehtel), fecntf proteht`om, mct`omcn ku`lcmhe
@mgrcstruhture
•J`onok`hcn Xcgety Hoaa`ttee, peer cml sem`or resecrhf acmckeaemt homs`lerct`om, etf`hcn rev`ew
•Dust`g`hct`om og resecrhf cpprochf (cntermct`ves), a`m`a`s`mk r`si
@mst`tut`omcn cssessaemt
• Mct`omcn FXE Homtc`mel Use proposcn rev`ew, homsunt`mk sh`emt`g`h clv`sers
•Mot`g`el exper`aemt hcmmot jek`m umness pera`ss`om krcmtel
Fecntf cml Xcgety Exehut`ve
3:33/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
13/15
ECXCH iey aessckes4 Rujn`hct`om og
sems`t`ve `mgoract`om
• Zesecrhfers cml tfe`r `mst`tut`oms cnn fcve respoms`j`n`ty to acie leh`s`oms
cjout pujn`sf`mk sems`t`ve `mgoract`om
• Dourmcns sfounl je emhourckel to seei cppropr`cte clv`he, `mhnul`mk groa
sehur`ty experts
• Europecm Hoaa`ss`om‐s Export Homtron Zekunct`om `s cm `mcppropr`cte cml
`meggeht`ve vef`hne to jnohi pujn`hct`om
• Europecm Hoaa`ss`om (LK Zesecrhf) ctteapts to rc`se cwcremess cjout
rev`s`om og tf`s Zekunct`om cre wenhoae ‒ resecrhfers sfounl homt`mue to `mgora pon`hy‒aciers cjout tfe `ssues
3833/28/:237
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
14/15
ECXCH iey aessckes4 Rujn`h emkckeaemt
• \rust cml opemmess cre hruh`cn gor resecrhfers cml tfe`r
`mst`tut`oms
• Chclea`es cml
otfers
`m
tfe
sh`emt`g`h
hoaaum`ty
sfounl
cht`veny pcrt`h`pcte `m pujn`h l`cnokue ‘ crt`hunct`mk ojdeht`ves
gor resecrhf, potemt`cn gor jemeg`t cml r`si, cml j`or`si
acmckeaemt prcht`hes cloptel
• ECXCH `s hoaa`ttel to homt`mu`mk wori`mk w`tf chclea`es to
proaote emkckeaemt
3
-
8/19/2019 Gain of Function Research: Advice from EASAC (Volker ter Meulen)
15/15
@m homhnus`om4
• ECXCH fcs acle rehoaaemlct`oms gor tfe EU cml Aeajer
Xtctes jut `t `s v`tcn to w`lem tfe l`shuss`om wornlw`le4
‘ Cllress`mk `ssues
gor
vcr`cj`n`ty
`m
umlerstcml`mk
cml
`m
systeas
jetweem houmtr`es/rek`oms
‘ Emsur`mk ncyerel , `mtekrctel cpprochfes
‘ Ju`nl`mk n`mis jetweem resecrhfers, pon`hy aciers cml otfer
stciefonlers, w`tf
homt`mu`mk
hoaa`taemt
to
pujn`h
emkckeaemt
3533/28/:237