gamma-spectroscopy into the neutron-rich a~90 region into the neutron-rich a~90 region volker werner...
TRANSCRIPT
Volker Werner | International Nuclear Physics Conference 2016 | Adelaide, Australia | 13 September 2016
Gamma-Spectroscopy into theNeutron-rich A~90 Region
Volker Werner
Institut für Kernphysik, TU Darmstadt
DAADBMBF
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 2
Overview
● Introduction
● Basic shape evolution
● Energy systematics A~90 region
● Isomer Decay Spectroscopy
● New data on 92,94Se
● Complementary to in-beam SEASTAR
● In-Beam Spectroscopy
● Ge Isotopes up to N=56
● Discussion on triaxiality
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 3
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 4
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 5
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40
N=56
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 6
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40 (semi-)magic
N=56
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 7
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40
well-deformedrotors
(semi-)magic
N=56
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 8
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40
well-deformedrotors
(semi-)magic
N=56
gamma-soft
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 9
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40
well-deformedrotors
(semi-)magic
N=56
gamma-soft
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 10
E(21+) Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40
well-deformedrotors
(semi-)magic
N=56
gamma-soft
?
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 11
E(21+) Systematics at N=56-60
Zr: clear peak at N=56,58 in ZrSr: „peak” N=56, drop past 58Kr: small peak at 56, smooth afterSe: ???Ge: ???
g7/2
, d3/2
s1/2
d5/2
Weak coupling (p-n) was shownfor Z~40, N<56 in prev. works
Assume it here -> E(21
+) depends
mainly on SPEs
No 2+
filled at 56
N=56 N=58
For Z>40 νg7/2
fills and is lowered
because of πg9/2
-> gaps disappear
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 12
E(21+) Systematics at N=56-60
Zr: clear peak at N=56,58 in ZrSr: „peak” N=56, drop past 58Kr: small peak at 56, smooth afterSe: ??? slow drop → S. ChenGe: ???
g7/2
, d3/2
s1/2
d5/2
Weak coupling (p-n) was shownfor Z~40, N<56 in prev. works
Assume it here -> E(21
+) depends
mainly on SPEs
No 2+
filled at 56
N=56 N=58
For Z>40 νg7/2
fills and is lowered
because of πg9/2
-> gaps disappear
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 13
RIKEN-RIBF Overview
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 14
RIKEN-RIBF SEASTAR Setup
DALI2+MINOSin-beam
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 15
RIKEN-RIBF SEASTAR+EURICA
DALI2+MINOSin-beam
Decay StationEURICA+AIDA
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 16
Isomer Spectroscopy
Se Isotopes
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 17
92Se – EURICA Result
So far known from RIBF: Kameda, PRC86, 054319 ('12)
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 18
92Se – EURICA Result
So far known from RIBF: Kameda, PRC86, 054319 ('12)
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 19
92Se – EURICA Coincidences
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 20
92Se – EURICA Result
So far known from RIBF: Kameda, PRC86, 054319 ('12) T1/2
=15.0(1.3) μs
C. Lizarazo,TU Darmstadt
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 21
92Se – EURICA/SEASTAR Result
T1/2
=15.0(1.3) μs
DALI2/MINOSS. Chen
94Se in the works
C. Lizarazo,TU Darmstadt
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 22
In-Beam Spectroscopy
Ge Isotopes
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 23
Particle ID / Reaction Channels
Gated on Reaction Product 8XGe
84Ge
86Ge
88Ge
Through MINOS TPCGated out channels withoutgoing high-E proton(s)
→ vertex reconstruction→ good Doppler correction
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 24
Results 84Ge
85Ge (p,pn) 84Ge85Ge (p,pn) 84Genew γ-ray
new placement
Test case – much known fromβ-delayed spectroscopy
A. Korgul, PRC88, 044330 (2013)K. Kolos, PRC88, 047301 (2013)M. Lettmann, TU Darmstadt
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 25
Results 86Ge
87As (p,2p) 86Ge87As (p,2p) 86Ge
So far only 21+ known
K. Miernik, PRL111, 132502 (2013)
M. Lettmann, TU Darmstadt
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 26
89As (p,2p) 88Ge89As (p,2p) 88Ge
All New !
M. Lettmann, TU Darmstadt
27
E(2+), E(4+) & R4/2 trends
07. June 2016 | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | Marc Lettmann
E(2+) & E(4+) behavior for Ge isotopes: Trend of E(2+):
Trend of R4/2:
• Nearly constant E(2+) & E(4+) after N=52• No strong N=56 sub-shell from E(2+)• No drop of E(2+) either → stabilized ? • No systematic increase of deformation• “γ-soft“ R4/2 ~ 2.5
86Ge88Ge
PreliminaryPreliminary
Preliminary
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 28
Microscopic Models: Triaxiality
R4/2
~ 2.5
typical γ-softlow-lyingγ-band
Tentative Level Scheme LSSM Sieja Beyond-MF Rodriguez
3+ lowered
K. Sieja et al., PRC88, 034327 (2013)
● Energies somewhat high, good match overall● Triaxiality at least in the γ-band
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 29
Mean Field Potential,Wave Functions
86Ge
● triaxial minimum
● some γ-softnessin wave functions
T.R. Rodriguez,brandnew
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 30
Mean Field Potential,Wave Functions
88Ge
● triaxial minimummore pronounced
● wave functionsmore γ-rigid
T.R. Rodriguez,brandnew
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 31
γ-Band Odd-Even Staggering
McCutchan, PRC76, 024306 (2007)
For example: S(4) determines whether 3+ is closer to 2+ or 4+
S(4) < 0 → closer to 4+ ; S(4) > 0 → closer to 2+
Typical γ-soft nuclei:S(4) negativethen odd-even staggering
Zamfir, Casten, PLB260, 265 (1991)
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 32
γ-Band Odd-Even Staggering
Y. Toh, PRC87, 041304(R) (2013)
For example: S(4) determines whether 3+ is closer to 2+ or 4+
S(4) < 0 → closer to 4+ ; S(4) > 0 → closer to 2+
76Ge rigid triaxial, identified at Argonne
76Ge:
● staggering opposite to all others in the region
● S(4) = 0.09 > 0 → some rigid triaxiality
86Ge (this work):
● S(4) = 0.18 > 0
Zamfir, Casten, PLB260, 265 (1991)
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 33
Thank You for your Attention !
Riken Nishina Center: P. Doornenbal, H. Baba, S. Chen, T. Motobayashi, M. Niikura, H. Sakurai, D. Steppenbeck, R. Taniuchi, T. Uesaka, K. Wimmer, T. Ando, S. Momiyama, S. Nagamine, T. Saito, P.A. Söderström
CEA: A. Obertelli, G. Authelet, D. Calvet, F. Château, A. Corsi, A. Delbart, J.-M. Gheller, A. Giganon, A. Gillibert, V. Lapoux, N. Paul, J.-Y. Roussé, C. SantamariaGSI: T. Arici, M. Górska, C. LizarazoUniversität zu Köln: A. Blazhev, M. Dewald,
K. MoschnerUniversity of Brighton: F. Browne, A. Bruce, C. NobsUniversity of Surry: R. Caroll, Z. Patel, Z. Podolyak,
C. Shand, M. RudigierVAEC: L.X. Chung, B. LinhTU Darmstadt: L. Cortés, M. Lettmann, V. WernerChinese Academy of Science: B. Ding, Z. LiuInstitute de Physique de Nucléaire Orsay: F. Flavigny, S. Franchoo, A. Gottardo, L. Olivier, I. StefanCSIC: A. Jungclaus, V. VaqueroUniversity of Hong Kong: J. Lee, J. Liu, Z. XuIFIN-HH: C. NitaJapan Atomic Energy Agency: R. Orlandi,
N. Nakatsuka
The SEASTAR Collaboration:
DAADBMBFsupported by
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 34
Backups
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 35
R4/2 Systematics
from NNDC
Z=40
well-deformedrotors
(semi-)magic
N=56
gamma-soft
?
E(41+)/E(2
1+)
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 36
E(21+) Systematics at N=56-60
Ru: smooth dropMo: small peak at 56, moderate dropZr: clear peak at N=56,58 in ZrSr: „peak” N=56, drop past 58Kr: small peak at 56, smooth after
g7/2
, d3/2
s1/2
d5/2
Weak coupling (p-n) was shownfor Z~40, N<56 in prev. works
Assume it here -> E(21
+) depends
mainly on SPEs
No 2+
filled at 56
N=56 N=58
For Z>40 νg7/2
fills and is lowered
because of πg9/2
-> gaps disappear
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 37
RIKEN-RIBF Overview
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 38
MINOS + DALI2
DALI2 NaI Array
LH2 target length = 100 mmTime Projection Chamber equipped with MicroMegas detector (3604 channels)Settings duration : 22.7 hours for Cr, 26 hours for FeIntensities : I(67Mn) = 1.25, I(73Co) = 0.49 pps/pnA
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 39
MINOS + DALI2
DALI2 NaI Array
LH2 target length = 100 mmTime Projection Chamber equipped with MicroMegas detector (3604 channels)Settings duration : 22.7 hours for Cr, 26 hours for FeIntensities : I(67Mn) = 1.25, I(73Co) = 0.49 pps/pnA
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 40
MINOS TPC
Initial goal: vertex resolution ~4 mm FWHM, detection efficiency > 80%
TPC: (X,Y) et Z (drift time)
4608 padsArea ≈ 2-4 mm2
Micromegas
A. Obertelli et al., EPJA 50 (2014) 8
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 41
(p,2p) Event in MINOS
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 42
69Co(p,2p)68Fe @ 200 MeV/uProof of Principle
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 43
Particle ID / Reaction Channels
Gated on Reaction Product 8XGe
84Ge
86Ge
88Ge
Through MINOS TPCGated out channels withoutgoing high-E proton(s)
→ vertex reconstruction→ good Doppler correction
M. Lettmann, TU Darmstadt
44
Coincidence spectra 86Ge
19. Sept 2016 | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | Marc Lettmann
Gate on 527 keVGate on 766 keV
Energy [keV]
Coun
ts Gate on doublet ~500 keVSingles (mult=1; no addback)
Energy [keV]
Coun
ts
45
Significance of 4+ in 88Ge
19. Sept 2016 | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | Marc Lettmann
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 46
Results 84Ge
84Ge (p,p’) 84Ge84Ge (p,p’) 84Ge
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 47
Results 84Ge
86Ge (p,p’) 86Ge86Ge (p,p’) 86Ge
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 48
Isomer in 94Se
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 49
94Se – Level Scheme to be decided
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 50
Triaxiality in 86Ge ?
R4/2
~ 2.5
typical γ-soft
low-lyingγ-band
Tentative Level Scheme
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 51
Triaxiality in 86Ge ?
R4/2
~ 2.5
typical γ-soft
low-lyingγ-band
Tentative Level Scheme IBM – γ-soft O(6)
3+ high
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 52
Triaxiality in 86Ge ?
R4/2
~ 2.5
typical γ-soft
low-lyingγ-band
Tentative Level Scheme IBM – γ-soft O(6)
3+ high
IBM-2 – γ-rigid “O(6)”
3+ lowered
Gamma-Band odd-even staggering hints at rigid triaxiality !
Volker Werner | TU Darmstadt | AG Pietralla | INPC 2016 | 13 September 2016 | γ-spectroscopy into the n-rich A~90 region 53
84Ge assignments b-delayed
A. Korgul, PRC88, 044330 (2013)