geelong modelling program and future upgrades mircea stancu 25 june 2010
TRANSCRIPT
GEELONG MODELLING PROGRAMAND FUTURE UPGRADES
Mircea Stancu 25 June 2010
BARWON WATER
Regional Water Corporation
South west of Melbourne
GEELONG DISTRICT SEWER CATCHMENT
Geelong
GEELONG DISTRICT SEWER CATCHMENT
GEELONG DISTRICT SEWER CATCHMENT
GEELONG DISTRICT SEWER CATCHMENT
POPULATION GROWTH PREDICTION
GREATER GEELONG AREA2045 PREDICTION
New residents: between 88,000 and 142,000
Total ADWFs will increase by between 75ML/day and 100ML/day (over 50% increase)
Increase in ADWF to Black Rock WRP between 69ML/day and 92ML/day (over 50% increase)
GEELONG DISTRICT SEWER CATCHMENT
GEELONG TRUNK NETWORK
Trunk network in Geelong
- Relatively isolated from northern flows
- Relying on two main sewers
- Very difficult to upgrade (going through Geelong CBD
- High impact in case of failure
- Future servicing strategy relying on smart use of interconnections and current capacity.
Flow Retarding Facility
New WRP
GEELONG TRUNK NETWORK
How it works
CURRENT PRACTICE
Current Status Quo
- Extensive use of WSAA code recommendations for smaller divisions- A current MIKE11/MOUSE trunk sewer model mainly used by
consultants- No in-house expertise on model/software package
MONITORING PROGRAM
Location of monitors
Monitoring for:- Level- Flow- EC- Rainfall
Monitoring Program:- Early phase of
implementation- May be enhanced by
temporary monitoring- 3 years long - Main scope is to provide
reliable data for the modelling project
MODELLING PROGRAM SCOPE
MAIN SCOPE- Prove 1 in 5 years compliance- Providing better network behavior understanding- Providing critical information for new Capital Works Expenditure- Providing option analysis tools (best value for money)- Providing information for maintenance purposes (high infiltration areas,
diversion flows, etc.)
ADDITIONAL SCOPE- Confirmation of sewer return ratios- Information regarding effects of water restriction on sewer flows- Confirmation of impact of repairs (e.g. sewer re-lining, de-silting) and
replacements- Better prediction of the impact of new developments- Flow profiles and their impact on sewer mining options- Impact of sewer mining on network- Infiltration level information (including saltwater infiltration)- Horizontal integration with BW’s GIS system
Will attempt to solve main issues we are facing such as:
- How much spare capacity we still have in the pipes
- How the interconnections will work and how the network will respond
- How the new WRP to the north of Geelong will influence the network behavior
- When we will need to upgrade the transport pipe from Geelong to Black Rock
MODELLING RESOURCING AND DELIVERY OPTIONS
Current ideas:DEVELOPMENT: Externally developed, internally maintained
- Provides best combination of risk mitigation and value for expenditure
MODEL TYPE:Detailed network
- Longer setup time of geographical network however far easier to set up parameters and loadings
- Corrected GIS data can be fed back into the GIS system- Less error prone to options analysis and inclusion of new developments
and demands (no bulk catchments)- Provide a good platform for the modelling of other smaller areas for
various purposes (infiltration modelling, sewer mining, flows diversions etc.)
- Easy to improve in the future
MODELLING RESOURCING AND DELIVERY OPTIONS
SUMMARY:
My recommendation is for the model to be:- Detailed network- Externally generated- Internally maintained
MODELLING PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION STEPS
1. Ensure stakeholders agreement and corporate support: Aug-Sept
2. Ask for capabilities statement and/or presentations from major software developers (i.e. write software requirements brief): Sept-Oct
3. Choose software package: Oct-Nov
4. Write consultants brief: Nov
5. Tender process: Nov-Dec
6. Project delivery: Early 2011 with yearly calibrations
7. Maintenance and training: 2011 onwards
MODELLING PROJECT IMPLEMENTATION STEPS
Discussion
MAIN OUTFALL SEWER DUPLICATION
Main Outfall Sewer as a part of the overall network:
MAIN OUTFALL SEWER DUPLICATION
GEELONG DISTRICT SEWER CATCHMENT
MAIN OUTFALL SEWER
Characteristics:
- 10.5 km long
- 1650mm dia
- Strategic asset
- Very shallow slope (1 in 3000)
- Over 30 years old but in acceptable condition
MAIN OUTFALL SEWER AND ITS DUPLICATION
MAIN OUTFALL SEWER
- Close to reaching capacity in wet weather
- We know it will need to be upgraded
- The modelling program will provide better estimates of future flows and upgrade timelines
- Running through major future development hence route needs to be decided before development occurs
- Current capacity: 2000L/s
- Predicted needed capacity (PWWF): 3600L/s
- Will continue to transport all DWFs
Development Boundary
AUGMENTATION OPTIONS
Development Boundary
Same route has been decided
Three options:
1. Identical duplication (1650dia @ 1 in 3000 grade). Price: ~80 mil.
2. Rising main (1100mm dia). Price: ~40 mil.
3. Pressure gravity sewer (1100mm dia @ 1 in 3000). Can be pressurized. Price: ~60mil.
DIFFERENCE IN PUMPED FLOW VOLUMES
Option 2: Rising main Option 3: Pressure Gravity Sewer
WINNING OPTION
NUMBER 3: Pressure gravity sewer
It provides significant advantages and very high flexibility, for a smaller price compared to an exact duplication.
• Questions?