geotechnical data management design applications for rock...

38
January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 1 CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION Lee Petersen, PhD, PE Itasca Consulting Group January 20, 2017 Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock Characterization

Upload: others

Post on 01-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 1

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

Lee Petersen, PhD, PEItasca Consulting GroupJanuary 20, 2017

Geotechnical Data Management

Design Applications for Rock Characterization

Page 2: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 2

• Case histories Large-scale underground mine site characterization

MnDOT T.H. 53 relocation project

• Key points: Both projects required rock characterization

One data set was large, and one was very large

Data integration, software, and visualization are key

Two Case Histories of Data Management

Page 3: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 3

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

Minnesota T.H. 53 RealignmentNear Virginia, MN

Page 4: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 4

• Multiple information sources, each providing a different view of the rockMapping of rock exposures

Drilling

DTH logging

• Integration is key

• Software is critical

Key Points

Page 5: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 5

• Insert Text Here

Roadway Realignment Concepts

W-1

Page 6: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 6

TH53 Realignment

Historic Iron Ore Pit Iron Ore Pit Today

Page 7: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 7

E-2 Alternative

Construct new, shorter, tall bridge through currently inactive mining area, further north of current US 53 alignment.

Page 8: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 8

Principal Motivation–Design of Post Mining Rock Slopes

Page 9: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 9

• RPA Photogrammetry:Extensive rock exposures available, but…

Mapping by personnel—access to large expanses of the slopes was prohibitive

LIDAR—problematic because of the distance across the pit lake

Photogrammetry does not expose personnel to the hazards of working on the rock slopes

Provides joint persistence information

• Acoustic Televiewer / Optical Televiewer loggingOriented core provides orientation, but…

Optical and acoustical logging provides orientation and estimate of discontinuity aperture and infilling thickness

What Methods and Why Chosen?

OrientationSpacing

Aperture & infilling thickness

OrientationSpacing

Persistence

Page 10: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 10

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

RPA-Based Photogrammetry

Page 11: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 11

Equipment & Planned flights

Page 12: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 12

Resulting image with joints identified

3,176 total features mapped

Page 13: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 13

Stereonets

Page 14: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 14

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

Acoustic & Optical Logging

Page 15: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 15

• Mount Sopris Instruments (MSI) 5MXA-1000 Matrix logger

• MSI 4WNA-1000 truck-mounted winch

• MSI 2CAA-1000 three-arm caliper probe

• Advanced Logic Technologies (ALT) ABI40-2G acoustic televiewer

• ALT OBI40 Mark V optical televiewer

• Borehole survey tool: GYRO SHOT®

Down-the-hole tools & methods

ATV

OTV

Photo courtesy of Hager Geosciences, Inc.

Page 16: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 16

Plan View of Boring Program

Page 17: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 17

• Depth

• 3D virtual core

• OTV image (unrolled)

• ATV image (unrolled)

• Caliper

• Features

ATV/OTV Logs

Page 18: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 18

• Seventeen coreholes were logged

• Logged footage was about 6,800 ft

• Number of features logged Total about 12,320

Bedding features logged was about 8,703

Joint features logged was about 3,617

Some statistics

Page 19: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 19

Raw data from ATV/OTV

Page 20: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 20

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

Combined Data

Page 21: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 21

Orientation Results

Photogrammetry (all domains, excl bedding)

ATV/OTV (all domains, excl bedding)

Photogrammetry & ATV/OTV (all domains, exclbedding)

All Data

Page 22: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 22

KATS (Itasca’s In-House Kinematics Analyst)Discontinuity* Dip Dip Direction Friction Angle

Mean St Dev Mean St Dev Mean St DevJoint Set 1 81.7 6.2 110 90.6 43.5 26.3Joint Set 2 79.1 6.9 207 70.2 43.5 26.3Joint Set 3 80.3 7.1 183 89.1 43.5 26.3Joint Set 4 80.5 7.6 214 89.3 43.5 26.3Bedding Plane 11.9 6.5 254 84.2 44.4 24

Page 23: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 23

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

East Highwall Fault

Page 24: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 24

East Highwall Fault

Page 25: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 25

Investigating Fault Location

Page 26: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 26

Oblique View

SB Alignment

NB Alignment

Page 27: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 27

Looking Down Strike of Shear Plane

SB Alignment

NB Alignment

Page 28: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 28

East Pier Fault

Page 29: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 29

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

3D 3DEC Models

Page 30: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 30

Comprehensive Model

Page 31: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 31

Model with Joints

Page 32: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 32

FOS 1.5 Plasticity

Page 33: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 33

FOS 1.5 Displacement Contours~1/2”

Page 34: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 34

FOS 1.5 Magnified Displacements

Page 35: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 35

• GoCAD Data integration and visualization

Targets the geology and geomechanics market

Developed for the petroleum industry

• Excel@Risk

Visual Basic routines

• Access

Software Tools

Page 36: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 36

• Primary input for isthmus slopes, also contributed to design of east pier and abutment

• Increased reliability of kinematics analysis of possible block and wedge failures

• Demonstrated that three joint sets are vertical and one is subvertical, and was critical to identifying a slope failure mechanism by flexural toppling

• Assisted with investigation of a fault near the east pier

How did the characterization help the project?

Page 37: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 37

17 Feb 2016:Pier 2 Foundations Complete18 Drilled Piles

Page 38: Geotechnical Data Management Design Applications for Rock ...kcengineers.org/geotech/wordpress-content/uploads/2017/05/2017-K… · CIVIL MANUFACTURING MINING OIL & GAS POWER GENERATION

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

January 20, 2017 Data Management for Rock Design Slide 38

CIVIL ● MANUFACTURING ● MINING ● OIL & GAS ● POWER GENERATION

Questions?