gerring sizedemocracyrevisited

Upload: nilvania-amorim

Post on 04-Jun-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    1/31

    !

    "#$% &'( )%*+,-&,. /%0#1#2%(

    3+4' 5%--#'6!"#$%%&'#()*+$,*-

    )+*#'#, 7&-%,8#!,/0&'&12()*+$,*-

    3/45/' 6'&7$%4&589$:;%50$'5 /< =/>&5&1;> ?1&$'1$

    @A@ 3;8 ?5;5$ B/;,3/45/' CD E@@FG

    #$%%&'() *&+,$%&-.+&/)& 0$ '$( ,1(& *1(2$3( 4&5%1))1$'

    9%; (2$3?2( ($ 7& 1'@&5)&+> 5&+/(&0 ($ 1() 45$)4&,()=$5 0&%$,5/,>A 4$+1(1&) /5& %$5& +1B&+> ($ %/1'(/1' / 0&%$,5/(1, =$5% $= 53+& 1')$=/5 /) (2&> /5&

    )%/++C D' (2& %$0&5' &5/ E!F::GH9 2$*&@&59 *& /5?3& (2/( / +/5?&5 4$43+/(1$' &'2/',&) (2& +1B&+12$$0$= /,21&@1'? /'0 %/1'(/1'1'? &+&,($5/+ 0&%$,5/,>C ;21) 1) )$ 7&,/3)& / +/5?&5 4$43+/(1$' 1',5&/)&),$%4&(1(1$' /%$'? &+1(&) /'0 45$@10&) / @/51&(> $= ,$')(5/1'() /?/1')( *$3+0G7& 4$+1(1,/+%$'$4$+1)()C ;2& /5?3%&'( 1) (&)(&0 *1(2 / )&51&) $= ,5$))'/(1$'/+ 5&)&/5,2 0&)1?') 3)1'? 21)($51,/+/'0 ,$'(&%4$5/5> 0/(/C

    I$50 ,$3'(A !89JKFI$50 ,$3'( *1(2$3( /44&'01LA !!9M::

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    2/31

    8

    D' (2& @1&* $= %$)( ,$%%&'(/($5)9 )1 )$,1/+ ),1&',&C!

    NL&%4+/5) =$5 (2& ,+/))1,/+ 4&5)4&,(1@& /5& =$3'0 1' (2& ,1(>G)(/(&) $= /',1&'( O5&&,& /'0

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`/25/1'9 `23(/'9 `53'&19 `35%/9 #21'/9 N51(5&/9 O31'&/G`1))/39 a$50/'9 W3*/1(9Q17>/9 Q1&,2(&')(&1'9 ]$5$,,$9 R%/'9 ./5/?3/>9 6/301 T5/71/9 6*/ +/5?& ,$3'(5> (2/( 2/) 5&)1)(&0 (2& (5&'0 ($*/50 '/(1$'/+ &+&,(1$')CXD( =$++$*) (2/( *$5B =$,3)&0 $' (2& (&551($51/+ )1 01==&5&'(1/(&0V 1'0&&09 (2&,$55&+/(1$' 7&(*&&' (2& (*$ 1) 5&+/(1@&+> %$0&)( E.&/5)$'e) 5fCMKHC D' /'> ,/)&9 *& )&& '$ (2&$5&(1,/+ 5&/)$' ($ )344$)&(2/( / +/5?&5 +/'0 /5&/ *$3+0 +&/09 7> 1()&+=9 ($ / %$5& 0&%$,5/(1, 5&?1%&G(>4&CKU$5 &L/%4+&9 (2& 4$43+/(1$' $= `51(/1' 1' !\:: 1) 3'0&5)($$0 ($ 1',+30& (2& ,1(1

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    3/31

    X

    ;21509 *1(21' (2& 3%75&++/G(&5% $= 0&%$,5/,> $35 /5?3%&'( =$,3)&) $' 1() &+&,($5/+ /'0+17&5/+ 01%&')1$')C U5$% (21) 4&5)4&,(1@&9 0&%$,5/,> 1) /,21&@&0 (25$3?2 &+&,($5/+ ,$%4&(1(1$'/%$'? +&/0&5)214 ?5$34) /'0 (25$3?2 ,$')(1(3(1$'/+ ,$')(5/1'() $' (2& &L&5,1)& $= 4$*&5C I& )2/++5&=&5 ($ (21) ,$',&4(1$' $= 0&%$,5/,> /) g6,23%4&(&51/'Ch R(2&5 ,$',&4(1$') $= 0&%$,5/,> [4/5(1,14/($5>9 &?/+1(/51/'9 %/Y$51(/51/'9 $5 0&+17&5/(1@& E#$44&0?&9 O&551'? 8:!!H [ +1& $3()10& (2&

    ),$4& $= (2& (2&$5> E/'0 %/> &L2171( ,$'(5/5> (5&'0)HCI1(2 (2&)& ,+/51=1,/(1$')9 *& /5?3& (2/( / +/5?& 4$43+/(1$' =$)(&5) ?5&/(&5 0&%$,5/,>C ;2&=15)( )&,(1$' $= (2& 4/4&5 &L4+$5&) ,/3)/+ %&,2/'1)%)C D' (2& )&,$'0 )&,(1$'9 *& (&)( (2& 2>4$(2&)1)*1(2 4/'&+ 0/(/ =5$% !F!M ($ 8::KC ;2& =1'/+ )&,(1$' )3%%/51 1) '$( 015&,(+> %/'143+/7+& /'09 /) )3,29 1) 01==1,3+( ($ ,$',&4(3/+1 %/'143+/7+&C _$*&@&59 (2& %/1' 01)(/+ ,/3)& $= /,$3'(5>e) ,355&'( 4$43+/(1$' 1) (2& &L(&'( $= 1() +/'09 1' 4/5(1,3+/5 1() /5/7+& +/'0C ;21)9 1' (35'9 1) /45$03,( $= 7$3'0/5>G05/*1'? &@&'() (2/( %/> 7& 5&?/50&0 /) %/'143+/7+& ,/3)&)C

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

    E3'0&5)($$0 /) (2& '3%7&5 $= 01)(1',(1@& )$,1/+ ?5$34)HC ;2& (*$ ,$3'(51&) /5& $(2&5*1)& 10&'(1,/+Cc'0&5 (2&)& ,$'01(1$')9 *2/( %1?2( 7& (2& 1%4/,( $= (21) 01==&5&',& 1' )1 (2&5&+/(1$')214 %1?2( 7& (2& 5&@&5)&C

    =4% >?&11#,&? =4%1#1

    T+(2$3?2 1( 75&/(2&) (2& /15 $= ,$%%$' )&')&9 (2& ,+/))1,/+ (2&)1) 2/) 5/5&+> 7&&' 43( =$5*/50 /) /'&L4+1,1( (2&$5>C #$')&Z3&'(+>9 (2& (2&$5&(1,/+ 3'0&541''1'?) $= (2& (2&)1) /5& )$%&*2/( 01==1,3+( ($5&,$')(53,(C j$'&(2&+&))9 (25&& /))3%4(1$') )&&% 4/5/%$3'(C D' (21) )&,(1$' *& )2/++ /5?3& (2/(9

    *21+& 4+/3)17+&9 (2&)& /))3%4(1$') /5& /+)$ $4&' ($ Z3&)(1$'CU15)(9 1( 1) )$%&(1%&) /5?3&0 (2/( )%/++ 4$+1(1&) $==&5 ?5&/(&5 $44$5(3'1(1&) =$5 &L1(9 /' $4(1$'

    (2/( %/> ,$')(5/1' (2& 5/4/,1(> $= &+1(&) EP$?$*)B1 !\\FV ;1&7$3( !\MJHC ;2& 01==1,3+(> 1) (2/( *&2/@& '$ &@10&',& (2/( ?$@&5'%&'() /5& ,$',&5'&0 *1(2 /((5/,(1'? /'0 5&(/1'1'? ,1(1 7& 2/44> ($ )&& 01))10&'() +&/@&C D= &L1( $4(1$') /5& &/)1&5 1' / )%/++ )(/(& (21) %/>)&5@& /) / )/=&(> @/+@&9 2&+41'? ($ )(/71+1 /'0 ,$')&')3) /5& &/)1&5 ($,$')(53,(9 /'0 )$,1/+ $50&5 &/)1&5 ($ %/1'(/1'9 *2&' ,$%%3'1(1&) /5& )%/++C ;2& +/5?&5 (2& 4$+1(> (2&

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    4/31

    K

    ?5&/(&5 (2& 4$(&'(1/+ '3%7&5 $= ,$'=+1,()9 *21,2 0$&) '$( 7$0& *&++ =$5 0&%$,5/,> E#$+$%&5 8::SAMFV ^/2+9 ;3=(& !\SXV R(( 8:::A \FHC k&(9 1( 1) '$( ,+&/5 (2/( )(5$'? ,$%%3'/+ 10&'(1(> /'0 )$,1/+$50&5 +&/0 / 4$+1(> 1' 0&%$,5/(1, 015&,(1$')V (2&)& =/,($5) %/> )1%4+> 5&1'=$5,& /3(2$51(/51/'(&'0&',1&)C I21+& 1( 1) (53& (2/( @1$+&'( ,$'=+1,() /5& %$5& ,$%%$' 1' +/5?& ,$3'(51&)9 1( 1) /+)$ (53&(2/( (2&> /5& $=(&' +&)) 0&)(/71+1 )3445&))1'? ,$'=+1,(73( 5/(2&5 7> &'+/5?1'? (2& ),$4& $= (2& 4$+1(> )$ (2/( %3+(14+& ,$'=+1,() /5& &%75/,&0 /'0 '$'& /5&(25&/(&'1'? ($ (2& )35@1@/+ $= (2& 4$+1(>9 $5 $= 0&%$,5/,>CM

    ;21509 1( 1) ?&'&5/++> /))3%&0 (2/( &)(/7+1)21'? / 0&%$,5/,> 1) &/)1&5 ($ /,,$%4+1)2 1' / )%/++,$3'(5> (2/' 1' / +/5?& ,$3'(5>C ;21) 1) (53& 1' (2& )&')& (2/( / )%/++ ,$3'(5> ?&'&5/++> 4$)&) =&*&5,$$501'/(1$' 45$7+&%)9 =&*&5 +$?1)(1,/+ ,2/++&'?&)9 /'0 =&*&5 ,$')(1(3&',1&) *2$)& /445$@/+ /'04/5(1,14/(1$' *$3+0 7& 5&Z315&0C P3+& $= +/* %/> /+)$ 7& &/)1&5 ($ &)(/7+1)2 ER+))$'9 _/'))&' 8:!!HC#$')&Z3&'(+>9 / 0&%$,5/(1, (5/')1(1$' 1' `23(/' 1) 45$7/7+> &/)1&5 1) &/)1&5 ($ %/'/?& (2/' /0&%$,5/(1, (5/')1(1$' 1' #21'/C _$*&@&59 (21) /5?3%&'( 5&)() $' / ,53,1/+ /))3%4(1$'A (2/( ,355&'(4$*&5G2$+0&5) *1)2 ($ )2/5& 4$*&5 *1(2 $(2&5) E3'0&5 0&%$,5/(1, /3)41,&)H 5/(2&5 (2/' ($ 53+&

    3',2/++&'?&0C I2&5& (2& /))3%4(1$' 2$+0) (53& E&C?C9 45&)&'(G0/> `23(/'9 )$ =/5 /) *& ,/' (&++H9 (2&/5?3%&'( 1) ,$'@1',1'?C c'=$5(3'/(&+>9 (2&5& /5& 5&+/(1@&+> =&* ,/)&) $= 0&%$,5/(1, (5/')1(1$')3)2&5&0 1' =5$% /7$@& *1(2 '$ 45&))35& =5$% 7&+$*9 1C&C9 1' *21,2 /3($,5/() @$+3'(/51+> ,&0& 4$*&5C;23)9 /+(2$3?2 1( %/> 7& &/)1&5 =$5 7&'&@$+&'( /3($,5/() ($ ,5&/(& 0&%$,5/,1&) 1' )%/++ ,$3'(51&)(2/' 1' +/5?& ,$3'(51&) (21) =/,( E1= 1'0&&0 1( 1) / =/,(H 1) '$( (&5517+> 5&+&@/'( =$5 &L4+/1'1'? @/51/(1$'/,5$)) '/(1$'G)(/(&)C

    R35 (2&$51 *2&' (2&15 $4(1$') /5& +1%1(&0C D')(1(3(1$'/+=/,($5)9 5/(2&5 (2/' (2& @$+3'(/51)(1, 7&2/@1$5 $= +&/0&5)9 /5& (23) (2& =$,3) $= $35 /5?3%&'(C

    >+*@%2#2#0%'%11 &'( >+'12-'21

    D' $35 @1&*9 (2& %$)( 1%4$5(/'( %&,2/'1)%) (>1'? 4$43+/(1$' )1 )1'?+& +&/0&5 E$5 +&/0&5)214 ,+1Z3&H ($ %$'$4$+1'/%1,C

    U15)(9 1' / +/5?& 4$+1(> E,&(&51) 4/5173)H (2&5& /5& / ?5&/(&5 '3%7&5 $= +/(&'( ,+&/@/?&) *1(21'(2& &+1(& /'0 *1(21' )$,1&(> ?&'&5/++>C ;2&)& ,+&/@/?&) %/> 7& 5$$(&0 1' 5/,&l&(2'1,1(>9 ,/)(&9 5&+1?1$'95&?1$'9 )$,1/+ ,+/))9 $5 )&,($5C T'> +/(&'( ,+&/@/?& 45$@10&) / 4$(&'(1/+ 7/)& $= )344$5(9 /'0 1' /

    +/5?&5 E/'0 %$5& 01@&5)&H )$,1&(> (2&5& *1++ 7& %$5& 01@1)1$') /'0 (23) %$5& $44$5(3'1(1&) =$5$44$)1(1$' ?5$34) ($ ,/41(/+1 1) +1B&+> ($ 7& %$5& $5?/'19 (2/( g(2& =5&Z3&',> $= 1'(5/G?5$34 ,$'=+1,( 1) 4$)1(1@&+> 5&+/(&0 ($ (2& )1 5&+/(&0 ($ (2& )1

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    5/31

    M

    /))$,1/(1$')9 3'1@&5)1(1&)9 %&01/ $3(+&()9 /'0 $(2&5 ,1@1+ )$,1&(> $5?/'1 %$71+1 1) +1B&+> ($ 45$@10& / ?5&/(&5 '3%7&5 $= 4$(&'(1/+ +&/0&5) =$5 &/,2+&/0&5)214 4$)1(1$' E*1(21' (2& 437+1, )&,($5 /'0 ,1@1+ )$,1&(>HC Q&( 3) /))3%& (2/( / )%/++ 4&5,&'(/?&$= (2& ?&'&5/+ 4$43+/(1$' 4$))&))&) (2& )$,1/+ /'0 &03,/(1$'/+ 7/,B?5$3'0 5&Z31)1(& ($ Z3/+1=> =$5 /

    +&/01'? 5$+& 1' / ,$3'(5>e) 4$+1(1,/+ /==/15)C I& )2/++ /))3%& (2/( (2&15 '3%7&5) ?5$* 1' / +1'&/5=/)21$' *1(2 4$43+/(1$' )$ (2/( (2& 5/(1$ $= &+1(&)l%/))&) 1) ,$')(/'(C `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

    E]/''9 I$+=1'?&5 !\F:H 73( /+)$ 1' &L(5/G,$')(1(3(1$'/+ ,2/++&'?&) ($ /' /3($,5/(1, 5&?1%& E@1/ )$,1/+%$@&%&'() /'0 1')355&,(1$')HC

    U1'/++>9 1' / +/5?& 4$+1(> 1( *1++ 7& %$5& 01==1,3+( =$5 )(/(& /,($5) ($ %$'1($59 ,$$4(9 ,$&5,&9 $5&L1+& 4$(&'(1/+ 01))&'(&5)C `&/5 1' %1'0 (2/( (2& &+1(& *1(21' / )%/++ 4$+1(> 1) 21?2+> ,$')41,3$3) /'0$=(&' ,$'=1'&0 ($ / =&* B&> =/%1+1&)9 ,+/')9 (517&)9 $5 &(2'1, ?5$34)C 635@&1++/',& $@&5 (21) ?5$34 1)&/)> =$5 (2& 1'(53)1@& /3($,5/(9 &@&' *1(2 / %1'1%/+ )&,351(> /44/5/(3)C ;21) %&/') (2/( 1')(1(3(1$')*1(21' ,1@1+ )$,1&(> /5& +1B&+> ($ 7& *&/B 5&+/(1@& ($ (2& )(/(& /'0 +&)) /7+& ($ 4&5=$5% (2&15 =3',(1$'/) / ,$3'(&5*&1?2( ($ (2& )(/(&C `> ,$'(5/)(9 1' / +/5?& 4$+1(> (2& /,(1$') $= &+1(&) /5& %$5& 01==1,3+( ($(5/,B /'0 ($ ,$'(5$+9 =$5 (2&5& /5& %/'> $= (2&% /'0 (2& )1 $= )$,1&(> $==&5) %/'>4+/,&) ($ 210&C D( 1) ,$')&Z3&'(+> 01==1,3+( =$5 (2& /3($,5/( ($ &L4$)& /'0 5$$( $3( $44$)1(1$'/+/,(1@1(1&)C

    N/,2 $= (2&)& %&,2/'1)%) )3??&)() (2/( 4$43+/(1$' )2$3+0 45$@10& ?5&/(&5 ,$%4&(1(1$'/%$'? &+1(&) /'0 ?5&/(&5 ,$')(5/1'() $' +&/0&5)9 (2&5&7> %/B1'? / 0&%$,5/(1, $3(,$%& %$5& +1B&+>CI& &L4&,( (2/( (2&)& =/,($5) /44+> &Z3/++> ($ %$@&%&'() ($*/50 /'0 /*/> =5$% 0&%$,5/,>9 1C&C9?5&/(&5 4$43+/(1$' )2$3+0 &'2/',& (2& 45$7/71+1(> $= 0&%$,5/(1 0&%$,5/,> /'0 &==1,/,> 2/) 5&,&1@&0 &L(&')1@&

    /((&'(1$' E)&& 45&@1$3) ,1(/(1$')H9 (2& &==&,( $= )1 2/) 5&,&1@&0 @&5>+1((+& /((&'(1$'C I& 2/@& 7&&' /7+& ($ 01),$@&5 $'+> )&@&' 437+1)2&0 ,5$))'/(1$'/+ )(301&) $=6,23%4&(&51/' 0&%$,5/,> $@&5 (2& 4/)( )&@&5/+ 0&,/0&) (2/( 1',+30& 4$43+/(1$' /) / ,$@/51/(&CN))&'(1/+ =&/(35&) $= (2&)& )(301&) /5& )3%%/51

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    6/31

    J

    m;/7+& ! /7$3( 2&5&nR'+> $'& $= (2&)& )(301&) 1) =$,3)&0 $' $35 ($41, $= 1'(&5&)( ER(( 8:::H9 /'0 (2& +/((&5 1)

    +1%1(&0 ($ )1%4+& ,5$))G(/73+/(1$') /,5$)) (*$ 0&,/0&)C ;2& 5&%/1'1'? )1L )(301&)9 /+(2$3?2 %$5&)$421)(1,/(&09 /5& =$,3)&0 $' $(2&5 (2&$5&(1,/+ Z3&)(1$')C ;21) %&/') (2/( %&/)35&) $= 4$43+/(1$')&5@& /) ,$'(5$+) /'0 /5& '$( )37Y&,(&0 ($ )3)(/1'&0 1'Z315>C ]$5&$@&59 @/51$3) /)4&,() $= (2&)&

    5&)&/5,2 0&)1?') %/> 71/) 5&)3+() /?/1')( $35 2>4$(2&)1) $= 1'(&5&)(C ;21) 1',+30&) E/H (25$3?2 (1%&5/(2&5 (2/' ,5$))G,$3'(5> /'/+>)&)9 E7H (2& 1',+3)1$' $= 4$)(G(5&/(%&'( ,$@/51/(&) (2/( %/> 7&/==&,(&0 7> 4$43+/(1$'9 E,H (2& '&?+&,( $= 01==3)1$' /) / 7/,B?5$3'0 =/,($5 1' 0&%$,5/(1)9 &L4+/1' *2> &L(/'( )(301&) 0$ '$( 0&%$')(5/(& / 4$)1(1@& 5&+/(1$')214 7&(*&&' 4$43+/(1$' /'00&%$,5/,>C

    /%1%&-,4 )%1#6'

    ;21) 751'?) 3) ($ / 01),3))1$' $= $35 ,2$)&' 5&)&/5,2 0&)1?'9 *21,2 &L4+$1() ,5$))G,$3'(5> @/51/(1$'1' 4$43+/(1$' /'0 5&?1%&G(>4& $@&5 (2& 4/)( (*$ ,&'(351&) 1' / ?+$7/+ )/%4+&C `&=$5& &L/%1'1'? (2&0/(/ 1( 1) 1%4$5(/'( ($ 01),3)) $35 /))3%4(1$') /7$3( (2& 0/(/ ?&'&5/(1'? 45$,&))C U/,($5) /==&,(1'? /

    ,$3'(5>e) 4$43+/(1$' E1C&C9 /))1?'%&'( ($ (5&/(%&'(H %/> 7& 01@10&0 1'($ (25&& ,/(&?$51&)A 0%;5&/'9,$0/#%;:I&14/'0#$/#%;:I8CT( $'& 4$1'( $5 /'$(2&5 1' 21)($5>9 1'G%1?5/(1$' 45$@10&0 (2& 4$43+/(1$' $= /++ ,$3'(51&)

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

    ^&%$?5/421, 1'=+3&',&) $' 4$43+/(1$' /5& %$5& 45$7+&%/(1,C ;2&5& 1) &@10&',& ($ )3??&)((2/( 0&%$,5/,1&) 2/@& +$*&5 %$5(/+1(> 5/(&) EO&551'? &( /+C 8:!8V 73( )&& P$)) 8::JH /'0 (2&5& 1))(5$'? E/'0 )$ =/5 /) *& B'$* 3',$'(&)(&0H &@10&',& (2/( 0&%$,5/,1&) 2/@& +$*&5 =&5(1+1(> 5/(&)E`&&5 8::\V .5 7/+/',& &/,2 $(2&5 $3(C_$*&@&59 $'& %3)( 7& ,$',&5'&0 /7$3( )2$5(G(&5% &'0$?&'&1(> 7&(*&&' +&=(G /'0 51?2(G)10&@/51/7+&)C T' &@&' %$5& 45$7+&%/(1, =&/(35& 1) (2/( )2$5(G(&5% ,2/'?&) 1' %$5(/+1(> /'0 =&5(1+1(> /5&1'=+3&',&0 7> */59 ,+1%/(1, &@&'() E&C?C9 05$3?2(H9 4$+1(1,/+ 01)$50&59 /'0 /'> $(2&5 )$5( $= 01)534(1$'[ *21,2 %/> /+)$ /==&,( / ,$3'(5>e) 5&?1%&G(>4&C U$5 (2&)& 5&/)$')9 )2$5(G53' 5&+/(1$')214) 7&(*&&'4$43+/(1$' /'0 5&?1%&G(>4& /5& +1B&+> ($ $==&5 / %1)+&/01'? 1'01,/(1$' $= )(53,(35/+ =/,($5) /( *$5BCD'0&&09 (2& 5&+/(1$')214 7&(*&&' J/'0 K1) %3,2 %$5& +1B&+> ($ 5&=+&,( (&%4$5/5> 4&5(357/(1$')(2/' (2& 5&+/(1$')214 $= (2&$5&(1,/+ 1'(&5&)(C #$')&Z3&'(+>9 *& /@$10 (21) )(>+& $= /'/+>)1) 1')37)&Z3&'( (&)()C

    U$5(3'/(&+>9 (2& ?&$?5/421, /))1?'%&'( %&,2/'1)% 1) %$5& (5/,(/7+&C U15)(9 ?&$?5/421,=&/(35&) $= / ,$3'(5> /5& =/15+> &/)> ($ %&/)35&C 6&,$'09 1() 1%4/,( $' ,$3'(5> 4$43+/(1$' 1)1%%&')&C D'0&&09 %$)( $= (2& @/51/(1$' 1' 4$43+/(1$' /,5$)) ,$3'(51&) 1' (2& ,$'(&%4$5/5> &5/ 1)/,,$3'(&0 7> (2& ($(/+ +/'0 /5&/ /'0 (2& ($(/+ /5/7+& +/'0 *1(21' / '/(1$'e) (&551($5> E/ =/,( (2/(

    SU$5 &L/%4+&9 `/55$ E!\\\H 1) +1%1(&0 ($ / )%/++ )/%4+& E!\S8G\MH 0/(/9 /??5&?/(&0 7> MG>&/5 4&51$0)9 /'0 1',+301'?+/??&0 0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+&) E*21,2 5&)3+() 1' (2& +$)) $= $'& 4/'&+HC ;2& ,$%71'&0 &==&,( 1) ($ 0&451@& (2&4$43+/(1$'l0&%$,5/,> 5&+/(1$')214 $= )1?'1=1,/',&CF^/@10 Q&7+/'?9 4&5)$'/+ ,$%%3'1,/(1$' ER,($7&5 !K9 8:!!HC

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    7/31

    S

    1'=$5%) $35 ,2$1,& $= 1')(53%&'() 1' /' Dd %$0&+HC R= ,$35)&9 ?&$?5/421, =/,($5) )3,2 /) /5/7+&+/'0 /+)$ 1%4/,( ?5$*(2 ER+))$' 8::XH9 *21,2 %/> 1' (35' 1%4/,( 5&?1%&G(>4& EN4)(&1' &( /+C 8::JHC_$*&@&59 )1',& 4&5 ,/41(/ O^. 1) %&/)35/7+& (21) 4$(&'(1/+ ,$'=$3'0&5 ,/' 7& 7+$,B&0C

    D( )&&%) 3'+1B&+> (2/( (2& ?&$?5/42> $= / ,$3'(5> 1) /==&,(&0 7> 1() 5&?1%&G(>4& $5 7> =/,($5)(2/( %1?2( 1'=+3&',& (2& 0&@&+$4%&'( $= / 4/5(1,3+/5 5&?1%&G(>4&C U$5 &L/%4+&9 (2&5& 0$&) '$(

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

    j/(35/++>9 / ,$3'(5>e) 7$3'0/51&) /5& /==&,(&0 7> 1'(&5'/(1$'/+G)>)(&% =/,($5) )3,2 /)&,$'$%1&) $= ),/+&9 7350&') $= 2&(&5$?&'&1(>9 '&,&))1(> $= )&+=G0&=&')&9 (2& 45$%1'&',& $=

    1'(&5'/(1$'/+ (5/0&9 (&,2'$+$?1,/+ 0&@&+$4%&'() /==&,(1'? (5/')4$5(9 ,$%%3'1,/(1$')9 */5=/5&9 /'0/0%1'1)(5/(1$'9 /'0 (25&/() ($ )$@&5&1?'(> ET+&)1'/9 64/$+$5& 8::XV _1),$L9 Q/B& 8::!V I1((%/'!\\!9 8:::HC _$*&@&59 7&,/3)& (2&)& =/,($5) /==&,( /++ ,$3'(51&) &Z3/++> (2&> /5& $5(2$?$'/+ ($ $35,5$))G,$3'(5> /'/+>)&)C E;$ (2& &L(&'( (2/( 1'(&5'/(1$'/+G)>)(&% =/,($5) ,2/'?& $@&5 (1%& (2&151'=+3&',& 1) ,/4(35&0 7> /''3/+ 03%%1&)CH

    T ,$'=3)1'? &+&%&'( $= $35 /'/+>)1) 1) (2/( (2& 7$3'0/51&) $= ,$3'(51&) /5& %3(3/++>0&(&5%1'&0C T ,2/'?& 1' $'& ,$3'(5>e) 7$50&5) E1' (2& %$0&5' &5/H /==&,() /'$(2&5 ,$3'(5>e)7$50&5)9 /'0 2&',& 1() 4$43+/(1$'C ;21) /44&/5) ($ @1$+/(& / )(51,( 1'(&545&(/(1$' $= (2& )(/7+& 3'1((5&/(%&'( /))3%4(1$'9 $5 6c;dT EP371' 8::MHC _$*&@&59 (2& 3'1( $= /'/+>)1) 1' (21) )(30> 1) (2&4$+1(> E=$5 *21,2 g,$3'(5>h 1) / 45$L>H9 / 3'1( (2/( %/> 7& )/10 ($ 2$+0 ,$')(/'( &@&' 1' (2& 45&)&',&$= 7$3'0/5> ,2/'?&)C .&52/4) (2& %$5& 1%4$5(/'( 4$1'( =$5 45&)&'( 4354$)&) 1) (2/( 7$50&5 ,2/'?&)

    /5& Z31(& %$0&)( $@&5 (2& 4&51$0 3'0&5 $7)&5@/(1$'C ]$)( 4$+1(1&) 1' $35 0/(/)&( 5&(/1' )1%1+/57$3'0/51&) =5$% (2& (1%& $= 1'0&4&'0&',& ($ (2& 45&)&'(G0/>C ]$5&$@&59 +1%1(1'? (2& /'/+>)1) ($,$3'(51&) (2/( 2/@& 5&(/1'&0 )(/7+& 7$50&5) )1',& 1'0&4&'0&',& 2/) @15(3/++> '$ 1%4/,( $' (2& 5&)3+()5&4$5(&0 7&+$*C

    Q&( 3) '$* )3%%/51 *21,2 (2& 7$3'0/51&) $= '/(1$'G)(/(&) 2/@& 7&&' &)(/7+1)2&0C ;2&@/51$3) ;5&/(1&) $= I&)(42/+1/9 &'01'? 1' !JKF9 /5& ?&'&5/++> 5&?/50&0 /) / 0&,1)1@& (35'1'? 4$1'( 1'(21) 45$,&))C R3()10& N35$4&9 ,$3'(51&) ?&'&5/++> /((/1'&0 (2&15 7$3'0/51&) /) / 45$03,( $= ,$+$'1/+(5&/(1&) /'0 1'0&4&'0&',& )(53??+&) $= %$5& 5&,&'( @1'(/?&C D' &1(2&5 ,/)&9 7$3'0/5> =$5%/(1$'$,,355&0 1'0&4&'0&'( $=9 /'0 ?&'&5/++> 451$5 ($9 (2& 0&@&+$4%&'( $= 6,23%4&(&51/' 0&%$,5/,>C

    ;2/( 1) ($ )/>9 %$)( )(/(&) /((/1'&0 (2&15 ,$'(&%4$5/5> ?&$?5/42> E+&/@1'? /)10& %1'$5 7$50&5,2/'?&)H /( / (1%& *2&' (2&> *&5& '$'G0&%$,5/(1,C j$5 1) 1( +1B&+> (2/( $(2&5 3'%&/)35/7+& =/,($5),$'(5173(&0 ($ 7$(2 E/H (2& ?&$?5/42> $= '/(1$'G)(/(&) /'0 E7H (2&15 &@&'(3/+ 5&?1%&G(>4&C T) )3,29(2& /))1?'%&'( $= ,$3'(5> 7$50&5) %/> 7& 5&?/50&0 /) 5/'0$% *1(2 5&)4&,( ($ (2& $3(,$%& $=1'(&5&)(9 ,$'01(1$'/+ $' $7)&5@/7+&)C

    ;21) ,$',+3)1$' 0&4&'0)9 $= ,$35)&9 $' (2& ,2$1,& $= /' /445$451/(& =$5% $= /'/+>)1)C _&5& 1(1) 2&+4=3+ ($ ,$%4/5& (25&& /5,2&(>4/+ ,/3)/+ %$0&+)A

    K5L ; M )J5NFM 1O5NF NZC !

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    8/31

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    9/31

    \

    51?2() 1'0&L =5$% (2& U5&&0$% _$3)& 0/(/)&( E***C=5&&0$%2$3)&C$5?HC ;21) 1'0&L =$5%) /' 1'(&?&5),/+& =5$% ! ($ SC #$+3%' S /0$4() / %&/)35& $= #$%4&(1(1@&'&)) =5$% d/'2/'&' E8:::H9 ,/+,3+/(&0/) !:: %1'3) (2& 4&5,&'( @$(&) *$' 7> (2& +/5?&)( 4/5(> 1' 45&)10&'(1/+ $5 4/5+1/%&'(/5> &+&,(1$') E$57$(29 /@&5/?&0HC #$+3%' F (&)() /'$(2&5 7&2/@1$5/+ %&/)35& $= ,$'(&)(/(1$'9 (21) $'& =$,3)&0 $' (2&;35'$@&5 $= ($4 +&/0&5)9 ,$%41+&0 =5$% (2& T5,21?$) 0/(/)&( EO$&%/') &( /+C 8::\HC T ,$0& $= ! 1)

    /))1?'&0 ($ /'> >&/5 1' *21,2 (2&5& $,,35) / ,2/'?& $= +&/0&5)214 /,21&@&0 3'0&5 5&?3+/5E,$')(1(3(1$'/+H ,15,3%)(/',&)9 (23) &L,+301'? ,$34) /'0 5&@$+3(1$')V : $(2&5*1)&C!:#$+3%' \ &%4+$>) / )3%%/5> 1'0&L $= #$'(&)(/(1$' ,$')(53,(&0 7> #$44&0?&9 T+@/5& 451',14/+,$%4$'&'() =/,($5 /'/+>)1) 1',+301'? / *10& @/51&(> $= ,$'(&%4$5/5> E!\M:GH 0&%$,5/,> 1'01,/($5)CT) )3,29 1( )&5@&) /) / =1((1'? ,$',+3)1$' ($ $35 )35@&> $= 6,23%4&(&51/' 0&%$,5/,>C

    ;$ =/,1+1(/(& ,$%4/51)$') /,5$)) %$0&+)9 $3(,$%&) *1(2 %$5& (2/' (25&& ,/(&?$51&) /5& 5&G),/+&0 =5$% :G!::9 /55/'?&0 )$ (2/( !:: 5&45&)&'() (2& 21?2&)( 4$))17+& +&@&+ $= 0&%$,5/,>C U$5(2&)& $3(,$%&)9 *& /44+> /' RQ6 &)(1%/($5 *1(2 j&*&>GI&)( )(/'0/50 &55$5) /'0 / $'&G4&51$0 +/?)(53,(35& ($ ,/4(35& (&%4$5/+ /3($,$55&+/(1$'C!!`1'/5> $3(,$%&) /5& /445$/,2&0 *1(2 +$?1( %$0&+)E]QNH /'0 XG,/(&?$5> $501'/+ $3(,$%&) *1(2 $50&5&0 +$?1( %$0&+) E]QNHC U$5 #$%4&(1(1@&'&))9)1',& Z31(& / '3%7&5 $= ,$3'(5>G>&/5) =&/(35& '$ ,$%4&(1(1$'9 (2& 01)(5173(1$' =&/(35&) /'

    /73'0/',& $= &0C ;2& =15)( (&)( 1) 21)($51,/+9 1',+301'? /++

    )$@&5&1?' /'0 )&%1G)$@&5&1?' ,$3'(51&) =5$% !F!M E$5 !F8:H ($ (2& 45&)&'(C #$@/51/(&) /5& 1',+30&0$'+> 1= (2&> /5& &L$?&'$3) 5&+/(1@& ($ (2& =/,($5 $= (2&$5&(1,/+ 1'(&5&)(9 )3==1,1&'( 0/(/ 1) /@/1+/7+&(25$3?2 (2& 4/)( (*$ ,&'(351&)9 /'0 / )(5$'? (2&$5&(1,/+ 5/(1$'/+& ,/' 7& $==&5&0C ;2& 2>4$(2&)18 ),$5&) $= /++ $(2&5 ,$3'(51&) 1' / ?1@&' >&/59 *&1?2(&0 7> (2& 1'@&5)& $= (2& 01)(/',& ($ /,$3'(5> EoHV /'0 /''3/+ 03%%1&)C ]$5& 0&(/1+&0 0&=1'1(1$') /) *&++ /) )$35,&) =$5 (2&)& @/51/7+&) /5&1',+30&0 1' ;/7+& T!C!8

    ;2& 5&)3+(1'? )/%4+& =$5 (2&)& 21)($51,/+ (&)() ,$')1)() $= \9:::o $7)&5@/(1$')C j/(35/++>9)/%4+& )1 ET+@/5&< &( /+C !\\JV .5GI&)( E!\FSH &)(1%/($5 1) /' &L(&')1$' $= (2& _37&5lI21(&l)/'0*1,2 5$73)( &)(1%/($5 EI21(& !\F:H9(/B1'? 1'($ /,,$3'( '$( $'+> 2&(&5$)B&0/)(1,1(> 73( /+)$ /3($,$55&+/(1$'C ;2& )37)(1(3(1$' $= $50&5&0 +$?1( =$5 RQ6 1' (2&

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`/'B 8::SH

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    10/31

    !:

    4/'&+ E)1',& 0/(/ /@/1+/71+1(> 1) 3'&@&' 451$5 ($ !\J:H $5 $= ,2/'?1'? 21)($51,/+ 5&+/(1$')214) 7&(*&&'4$43+/(1$' /'0 0&%$,5/,>C P&/))351'?+>9 (2&5& 1) +1((+& 01==&5&',& 1' (2& /??5&?/(& 4&5=$5%/',& $=(2& B&> 1'0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+& /,5$)) 21)($51,/+ /'0 ,$'(&%4$5/5> )/%4+&)C

    D' (2& (2150 (&)(9 / %/L1%/+ )4&,1=1,/(1$' 1) /0$4(&0 1',+301'? /++ $= (2& 7&',2%/5B =/,($5)4+3) / @/51&(> $= /001(1$'/+ ,$@/51/(&) (2/( %/> )&5@& /) ,$'=$3'0&5) E73( *2$)& (2&$5&(1,/+ $5

    &%4151,/+ 5&+/(1$')214 ($ 0&%$,5/,> 1) +&)) *&++G&)(/7+1)2&0HC ;21) 1',+30&) Q/'0+$,B 03%%> EGHVQ/(1(30&9 (2& 01)(/',& =5$% (2& &Z3/($5 (5/')=$5%&0 7> (2& '/(35/+ +$?/51(2% EoHV N'?+1)2 +&?/+$51?1' 03%%> EoHV N35$4&/' +/'?3/?&9 4&5,&'( )4&/B1'? EoHV N(2'1, =5/,(1$'/+1 ,2$)&' 1'01@103/+) 7&+$'? ($ (2& )/%& &(2'$+1'?31)(1, ?5$34 EiHVP&+1?1$3) =5/,(1$'/+1 ,2$)&' 1'01@103/+) 7&+$'?($ (2& )/%& 5&+1?1$3) ?5$34 EGHV #/(2$+1,9 /) )2/5& $= (2& 4$43+/(1$' EGHV .$43+/(1$' 0&')1(> EoHV /'0 /)&51&) $= 5&?1$'/+ 03%%1&) =$5 I&)( N35$4& EoH9 Q/(1' T%&51,/ EiH9 (2& ]100+& N/)( EGH9 /'0 T=51,/ EGHC T) 45&@1$3)+>9 (2& 2>4$(2&)14$(2&)1) ,$3+0 7& ?/5'&5&0 =5$% (2& +1(&5/(35&9 / Z3&)(1$' %/5B /44&/5)CH

    P&)3+() $= (2& (*&'(>G)1L (&)() 1',+30&0 1' ;/7+& 8 1'01,/(& / 5$73)( 4$)1(1@& 5&+/(1$')2147&(*&&' 4$43+/(1$' /'0 0&%$,5/,>C R'+> =$35 (&)() =/1+ ($ ,5$)) (5/01(1$'/+ (25&)2$+0) $= )(/(1)(1,/+)1?'1=1,/',& /'0 $'+> $'& )2$*) / '&?/(1@& E(2$3?2 '$( )1?'1=1,/'(H 5&+/(1$')214 7&(*&&' 4$43+/(1$'

    /'0 0&%$,5/,>CT))3%1'? (2& 5&+/(1$')214 1) ,/3)/+9 2$* ?5&/( %1?2( 7& (2& 1%4/,( $= 4$43+/(1$' $'

    0&%$,5/,>i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q 1',5&/)& 1' (2& .$+1(>8 %&/)35& $=0&%$,5/,> E*21,29 (2& 5&/0&5 *1++ 5&,/++9 2/) 7&&' (5/')=$5%&0 ($ / :G!:: ),/+&HC D%4/,( &)(1%/(&)

    =$5 (2& $(2&5 ,$'(1'3$3) %&/)35&) $= 0&%$,5/,> (&'0 ($ 2$@&5 /5$3'0 (21) %/5B9 )$%& %$5& /'0)$%& +&))9 /) )2$*' 1' ;/7+& 8C U$5 ,/(&?$51,/+ $3(,$%&)9 1%4/,( 1) %&/)35&0 /) (2& 45$7/71+1(> $=/,21&@1'? (2& 21?2&)( +&@&+ $= 0&%$,5/,>C T?/1'9 *& =1'0 1%4/,( &)(1%/(&) (2/(9 *21+& '$( 23?&9 /5&7> '$ %&/') '&?+1?17+&C

    9?2%-'&2% /%6-%11#+' G+(%?1

    D'(&545&(1'? $7)&5@/(1$'/+ 0/(/ 1) /+*/>) =5/3?2(9 /'0 '$*2&5& %$5&)$ (2/' *2&' 5&+/(1$')214) /5&01)(/+ /'0 (2& (5&/(%&'( 1) '$( /44+1&0 1' 01),5&(& 1'(&5@&'(1$') E/++$*1'? =$5 ,+&/5+> 0&+1'&/(&0 45&G/'0 4$)(G(&)()HC D' (21) )&,(1$' *& &L4+$5& / )&51&) $= 5$73)('&)) (&)() =$,3)&0 $' (2& .$+1(>8 @/51/7+&[ *21,29 *2/(&@&5 1() =+/*)9 2/) 7&,$%& (2& 1'03)(5> )(/'0/50C P&)3+() /5& 01)4+/>&0 1' ;/7+& XC

    m;/7+& X /7$3( 2&5&n

    ]$0&+ ! 5&45$03,&) (2& 7&',2%/5B %$0&+ =5$% ]$0&+ ! 1' ;/7+& 8C 637)&Z3&'( (&)()1'(5$03,& /+(&5/(1$') 1' (2& 7&',2%/5BC #$%%&'(/5> $' (2& 5&)3+() 1) %1'1%1 (&'0 ($,$'=15% (2& 7&',2%/5B %$0&+ /'0 1' /'> ,/)& ,/' 7& $7(/1'&0 015&,(+> =5$% (2& (/7+&C

    ]$0&+ 8 45$@10&) / %1'1%/+ )4&,1=1,/(1$'9 1',+301'? $'+> (2& 01==3)1$' @/51/7+&C ]$0&+ X5&%$@&) $= (2& (*$ +/5?&)( 0&%$,5/,1&) =5$% (2& )/%4+& [ D'01/ /'0 (2& c'1(&0 6(/(&)C ]$0&+ K

    ($ %&/)35& 4&5 ,/41(/ O^. /'0 357/'1%$5& /,,35/(&C

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    11/31

    !!

    5&4+1,/(&) (2& 7&',2%/5B %$0&+ *1(2 / g=3++h )/%4+&9 3)1'? %3+(14+&G1%43(/(1$' (&,2'1Z3&) EW1'? &(/+C 8::!H ($ 1%43(& %1))1'? 0/(/ =$5 /++ )$@&5&1?' ,$3'(51&) /'0 / =&* )&%1)$@&5&1?' (&551($51&) *1(2&'$3?2 /3($'$%> ($ 0&(&5%1'& (2&15 5&?1%&G(>4& E&C?C9 _$'? W$'?HC ]$0&+ M /??5&?/(&) (2& 0/(/ /(!:G>&/5 1'(&5@/+)C _&5&9 (2& 3'1( $= /'/+>)1) 1) (2& ,$3'(5>G0&,/0& 5/(2&5 (2/' (2& ,$3'(5>G>&/5 [ /4+/3)17+& %$0&+ =$5 /'> /'/+>)1) *2&5& ,2/'?& $' (2& +&=(G /'0 51?2(G)10& $= (2& %$0&+ 1) )+3??1)2 /'0

    *2&5& +$'?G(&5%9 5/(2&5 (2/' )2$5(G(&5%9 &==&,() /5& 4/5/%$3'(C]$0&+ J 45&)&'() / )1%4+& ,5$))G)&,(1$'/+ /'/+>)1) =$,3)&0 $' (2& >&/5 8:::C ;21) 1) (2&)1%4+&)( 5&?5&))1$' %$0&+ )1',& 1( 5&Z315&) '$ ,$55&,(1$') =$5 )&51/+ /3($,$55&+/(1$'C D( 1) 4&5)3/)1@&1')$=/5 /) $'& %1?2( 5&?/50 5&,&'( >&/5) /) / 5&=+&,(1$' $= / +$'?G53' &Z31+17513% $3(,$%&C

    ]$0&+ S 1%4$)&) / K:G>&/5 +/? $' (2& @/51/7+& $= (2&$5&(1,/+ 1'(&5&)(9 4$43+/(1$' E$(2&5,$@/51/(&) =$++$* (2&15 )(/'0/50 $'&G4&51$0 +/?HC ]$0&+ F 1) 5&)(51,(&0 ($ / ,$'(&%4$5/5> )/%4+&97&?1''1'? 1' !\J:V 2&5&9 4$43+/(1$' 1) %&/)35&0 1' (2& =15)( >&/5 $= (2& 4/'&+ E!\J:H /'0 2&+0,$')(/'( (2&5&/=(&5 E$(2&5 @/51/7+&) =$++$* (2&15 3)3/+ $'&G4&51$0 +/?HC `$(2 $= (2&)& %$0&+) /5&0&)1?'&0 ($ /++&@1/(& 4$(&'(1/+ 45$7+&%) $= )1%3+(/'&1(> /'0 =&&07/,B 1' (2& (1%&G)&51&)C

    ]$0&+ \ 5&G,$0&) 4$43+/(1$' 1' $50&5 ($ (&)( =$5 4$))17+& '$'G+1'&/51(1&) 1' (2& 5&+/(1$')214*1(2 0&%$,5/,>C ;25&& 03%%> @/51/7+&) 01@10& (2& )/%4+& 1'($ (2150)A 6%/++9 ]&013% /'0 Q/5?&CE;2& &L,+30&0 ,/(&?$5> 1) 6%/++CH

    ]$0&+ !: 1',+30&) / +/??&0 0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+&9 /++$*1'? $'& ($ %$0&+ /3($,$55&+/(1$' 1' /0>'/%1, =/)21$' E`&,B9 W/(< !\\MH /'0 /+)$ )&5@1'? ($ 7+$,B 3'%&/)35&0 ,$'=$3'0&5) EN+*&5(9I1')214 8:!!HC ;2&5& 1) $= ,$35)& (2& 4$))171+1(> $= 1'(5$03,1'? '&* ,$'=$3'0&5) @1/ (2& 7/,B0$$5$4&'&0 7> / +/??&0 0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+& EN+*&5(9 I1')214 8:!!HC

    ]$0&+ !! 1) 0&)1?'&0 ($ 7+$,B / )4&,1=1, =/,($5 (2/( %/> )&5@& /) / ,$'=$3'0&5 1' (2&/'/+>)1)C ;2& ),&'/51$ (21)A )344$)& (2/(9 $@&5 (1%&9 g)3,,&))=3+h 4$+1(1&) 7&,$%& +/5?&5 E7&,/3)& (2&>/5& *&/+(21&5 /'0 %$5& 4$*&5=3+H /'0 3')3,,&))=3+ 4$+1(1&) =5/?%&'( $5 01)/44&/5C ;21) 1) / 45$7+&%1= (2& =/,($5) 051@1'? )3,,&)) /+)$ 051@& 0&%$,5/(1)&)C I& ,$'(5$+ =$5 O^. 4&5 ,/41(/9 )$ (2& *&/+(2 /)4&,( $= (2& /5?3%&'( 1) 7+$,B&0 /) /4$(&'(1/+ ,$'=$3'0&5C ED( 1)9 1' /'> ,/)&9 $5(2$?$'/+ ($ 4$43+/(1$' [ (2& (*$ /5& ,$55&+/(&0 /( $'+>:C:SCH D' %$0&+ !! *& /00 / 1;:;)&>&5&$41'0&L E#RI 8::MH ($ (2& %$0&+C ;21) 1'0&L 1) ,$%451)&0 $=

    )1L ,$%4$'&'()A ($(/+ 4$43+/(1$'9 357/' 4$43+/(1$'9 %1+1(/5> 4&5)$''&+9 %1+1(/5> &L4&'01(35&)9 15$' r)(&&+ ,$')3%4(1$'9 /'0 451%/5> &'&5?> ,$')3%4(1$'C R= ,$35)&9 4$43+/(1$' 1) $35 @/51/7+& $=1'(&5&)( /'0 357/' 4$43+/(1$' 1) /+5&/0> / 4/5( $= (2& 7&',2%/5B %$0&+C Q1B&*1)&9 (2& $(2&5 =$35@/51/7+&) %1?2( 1' )$%& )&')& 7& ,$')10&5&0 &'0$?&'$3) ($ 4$43+/(1$' E,&5(/1'+>9 (2& )1&0 1' ;/7+& K9 *& &L/%1'& *2&(2&5 4$43+/(1$' E/( ;G!H 45&01,())2$5(G(&5% ,2/'?&) 1' 0&%$,5/,>9 %&/)35&0 /) 45&@1$3)+> 7> .$+1(>8C

    m;/7+& K /7$3( 2&5&nD' ]$0&+ !9 (2& 0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+& 1) (5/')=$5%&0 7> =15)(G01==&5&',&) EK5G K5NFH9 /'0 / +/??&0

    0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+& 1) /00&0 /) / ,$@/51/(&C R(2&5*1)&9 (2& %$0&+ =$++$*) $35 7&',2%/5B)4&,1=1,/(1$'C

    61',& *& /5& '$* &L4+$51'? 1I;'#$1' K E=5$% 5F($ 5@H9 5/(2&5 (2/' (2& @/+3& $= KE/( 5FH9 (2&,$')(5/1'&0 '/(35& $= (2& 0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+& 7&,$%&) / 71??&5 45$7+&%C j$(& (2/( $',& / ,$3'(5>5&/,2&) (2& %/L1%3% @/+3& $' (2& .$+1(>8 ),/+& E!:: 1' $35 ),/+&9 !: 1' (2& $51?1'/+ .$+1(>8 ),/+&H 1(4+/(&/3)9 ?&'&5/(1'? / )&51&) $=

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    12/31

    !8

    (2& /3($,5/(1, )10& $= (2& ),/+&9 /) (2& 4&/B @/+3& [ GS $' (2& $51?1'/+ .$+1(>8 ),/+& [ 1) '$( /( (2&7$(($% $= (2& ),/+&CH T )1%4+& =1L ($ (21) 45$7+&% 1'@$+@&) &L,+301'? ,/)&) *2&5& .$+1(>8 f !::CP&)3+() /5& 5&4$5(&0 1' %$0&+ 8C

    ]$0&+ X /44+1&) / O]] &)(1%/($5 ET5&++/'$9 `$'0 !\\!H9 5&?5&))1'? / =15)(G01==&5&',&0$3(,$%& $' (1%&G@/5>1'? ,$@/51/(&) E1'@/51/'( ,$@/51/(&) %3)( 7& /?/1' &L,+30&0 7&,/3)& $= (2&

    =1L&0G&==&,( =$5%/( ?&'&5/(&0 7> =15)(G01==&5&',&)H /'0 / +/??&0 0&4&'0&'( @/51/7+&C D')(53%&'() /5&,$%451)&0 $= / )&51&) $= +/?) &Z31@/+&'( ($ (2& ($(/+ '3%7&5 $= 451$5 $7)&5@/(1$') 1' (2& 0/(/)&( =$5&/,2 @/51/7+& 1' (2& %$0&+C

    ]$0&+) K /'0 M &%4+$> / 71'/5> $3(,$%& @/51/7+& E,3($== /( M $' (2& 8!G4$1'( .$+1(>8 ),/+&H1' $50&5 ($ ,$'03,( &@&'(G21)($5> (&)() $= 5&?1%& (5/')1(1$')C _&5&9 (2& Z3&)(1$' 1) (2& +1B&+12$$0 E$59%$5& )4&,1=1,/++>9 (2& 5/(&H $= (5/')1(1$'1'? =5$% /3($,5/,> ($ 0&%$,5/,>9 1C&C9 ,$0/1%;5&2;5&/'E]$0&+KH $5 =5$% 0&%$,5/,> ($ /3($,5/,>9 1C&C9 ,$0/1%;5&1 )%$;P,/Q'E]$0&+ MHC `$(2 #$L /'0 I&173++%$0&+) /5& 4+/3)17+& /'0 7$(2 2/@& 7&&' &%4+$>&0 1' (2& +1(&5/(35& E`&5'2/50 &( /+C 8::!V W/4)(&1'9#$'@&5)& 8::\HC I& 45&=&5 (2& I&173++ %$0&+ 7&,/3)& 1( &L4+1,1(+> %$0&+) ,2/'?&) 1' (2& +1B&+12$$0$= 0&%$,5/(1 4/5/%&(51, %$0&+)9 5&Z3151'? /))3%4(1$') /7$3( (2& 01)(5173(1$' $= (2&0/(/ (2/( %/> $5 %/> '$( 7& */55/'(&0C D' ;/7+& M *& 45$@10& / %/(,21'? /'/+>)1) (2/( 5&4+1,/(&) (2&,$'(&%4$5/5> E!\J:GH 5&?5&))1$' %$0&+) 01)4+/>&0 1' ;/7+& 8C

    m;/7+& M /7$3( 2&5&n]/(,21'? &)(1%/($5) ?&'&5/++> 5&Z315& / 71'/5> (5&/(%&'(C!Kc'=$5(3'/(&+>9 (2&5& /5& '$

    '/(35/+ 75&/BG4$1'() 1' (2& 01)(5173(1$' $= (2& 4$43+/(1$' @/51/7+& /'0 '$ (2&$5&(1,/+ 5&/)$' ($)344$)& (2/( (2&5& %1?2( 7& (25&)2$+0 &==&,()C T'> 5&,$01'? $= 4$43+/(1$' /) / 71'/5> @/51/7+&1'@$+@&) (2& 1%4$)1(1$' $= /' /571(5/5> 75&/B4$1'(9 1%4$)&) / ,$')10&5/7+& +$)) $= 1'=$5%/(1$'9 /'0?&'&5/(&) / (5&/(%&'( (2/( 1) '$'G3'1=$5% /,5$)) 3'1()C

    R' (2& $(2&5 2/'09 *& 2/@& )(143+/(&0 (2/( (2& 1%4/,( $= 4$43+/(1$' $' 0&%$,5/,> 1) +1B&+>($ 7& 5&/+1 ($ /==&,( 5&?1%&G$3(,$%&)C U5$% (21) 4&5)4&,(1@&9 ?5$341'? '/(1$'G)(/(&) 1'($ (*$ 71') [40;>>/'0 >;%#$[ 1) / 4+/3)17+& 5&,$')(53,(1$' $= (2& 0/(/G?&'&5/(1'? 45$,&))C

    T))1?'%&'( 1'($ ?5$34) 1) 7/)&0 $' ,$3'(5> 4$43+/(1$' 1' !\J: $5 (2& =15)( E4$)(G!\J:H >&/51' *21,2 / ,$3'(5> 7&,$%&) 1'0&4&'0&'(C D' (21) %/''&59 *& ?&'&5/(& (*$ 71') (2/( /5& &Z3/+ 1'

    '3%7&5 $= ,$3'(51&) (2$3?2 '$( &L/,(+> 1' '3%7&5 $= $7)&5@/(1$') E)1',& )$%& ,$3'(51&) 2/@&)2$5(&5 (1%&G)&51&)HC

    ;2& (*$ 5&+1?1$' @/51/7+&) /5& 5&,$0&0 =5$% ,$'(1'3$3) ($ 71'/5> @/51/7+&) 1' $50&5 ($=/,1+1(/(& (2& %/(,21'? 45$,&))C ]3)+1% 1) ,$0&0 ! 1= $@&5 M:q $= (2& 4$43+/(1$' /02&5&) ($ /]3)+1% )&,(C D' )1%1+/5 =/)21$'9 .5$(&)(/'( 1) ,$0&0 ! 1= $@&5 M:q $= (2& 4$43+/(1$' /02&5&) ($ /

    !KR'& %1?2( /+)$ /44+> '$'G714/5(1(& %/(,21'? /+?$51(2%) EQ3 &( /+C 8:!!HC _$*&@&59 0$1'? )$ )(1++ 5&Z315&) (2&10&'(1=1,/(1$' $= /571(5/5> 71') /'0 ,$%4+1,/(&) (2& 45$,&)) $= =1'01'? /445$451/(& %/(,2&) =$5 &/,2 3'1(9 (23) *&/B&'1'?(2& /'/+>)1) $5 =$5,1'? $'& ($ 5&)(51,( (2& '3%7&5 $= %/(,21'? ,$@/51/(&)C

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    13/31

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    14/31

    !K

    !\\MA 8!X9 88:G8V P$>+& 8::!HC D( 2/) /+)$ 7&&' /5?3&0 (2/( 1)+/'0G)(/(&) /5& +&)) %1+1(/51)( 7&,/3)&(2&15 )$@&5&1?'(> 1) %$5& )&,35& (2/' +/'0G7/)&0 )(/(&) /'0 7&,/3)& &L4/')1$'1)( 4$+1,1&) /5& %$5&01==1,3+( ($ 435)3& E#+/?3& &( /+C 8::!A 88GXV U/51) !\\\HC D' )2$5(9 Z31(& / '3%7&5 $= =/,($5) [ 2/@1'?'$(21'? ($ 0$ *1(2 )19 *&0$ '$( 5&?/50 (2& &%4151,/+ 5&+/(1$')214 7&(*&&' 1)+/'0 )(/(&) /'0 0&%$,5/,> /) &@10&',& =$5 $5/?/1')( (2& %/1' 2>4$(2&)1)C

    _$*&@&59 *& 0$ 5&?/50 1)+/'0) /) / 4+/3)17+& '/(35/+ &L4&51%&'( 1' /'$(2&5 ,$'(&L(C#$')10&5 (2/( 1)+/'0 )(/(&)9 7> 0&=1'1(1$'9 /5& +1%1(&0 1' (2&15 (&551($51/+ &L4/')&C 6$%& +1B& T3)(5/+1//5& @&5> +/5?&V $(2&5) +1B& ;3@/+3 /5& &L(5&%&+> )%/++C ;2& 4$1'( 1) (2/( (2& ?&$?5/421, &L4/')& $= /'1)+/'0G)(/(& $5 /' /5,214&+/?$G)(/(& *2&5& (2& /5,214&+/?$ 1) =/15+> *&++G0&=1'&0 E&C?C9 ]1,5$'&)1/H 1) ($)$%& &L(&'( &L$?&'$3)+> 0&(&5%1'&0C ;2/( 1) ($ )/>9 1( *$3+0 7& 01==1,3+( =$5 T3)(5/+1/9 ;3@/+39 $5]1,5$'&)1/ ($ &L4/'0 7&>$'0 (2& 7$50&5) $= (2& 1)+/'0) (2/( (2&> 1'2/71(C D'0&&09 (2& 7$50&5) $=%$)( 1)+/'0) $5 /5,214&+/?$) ,$55&)4$'0 ($ (2& 7$50&5) $= ,$'(&%4$5/5> '/(1$'G)(/(&)C D' / =&*1')(/',&) )3,2 /) _/1(1 /'0 (2& ^$%1'1,/' P&437+1, (2& 1)+/'0 1) )3701@10&0 1'($ )%/++&5 '/(1$'G)(/(&)V 73( (2& 1)+/'0 )(1++ 45$@10&) /' 344&5 7$3'0 $' (2& 4$(&'(1/+ )1$= *21,2 /5& '$'G,$'(1?3$3)H9 *& 0$ '$( ,$0& (2&% /) 1)+/'0)C ;2& B&> ,$',&4(3/+ 4$1'( 1)7$3'0&0'&)) $5 ,15,3%),514(1$' E#/5'&15$ !\S:HC

    ;2& 45$03,( $= (21) )&+&,(1$' 45$,&035& 1) / )/%4+& $= =$5(>G(*$ )$@&5&1?' 1)+/'0G)(/(&)E5&)(51,(&0 ($ ,$3'(51&) =$5 *21,2 1'=$5%/(1$' 1) /@/1+/7+& $' 5&+&@/'( ,$@/51/(&)HC!M]$0&+ ! 1' ;/7+&J /44+1&) (2& 7&',2%/5B %$0&+ 1' ;/7+& 8 ($ (21) )&+&,(1@& )/%4+&C P&)3+() /5& 5&%/5B/7+> )1%1+/59*1(2 / ,$&==1,1&'( (2/( 1) 4$)1(1@&9 )1?'1=1,/'(9 /'0 Y3)( )+1?2(+> *&/B&5 (2/' (2/( $7(/1'&0 =5$% (2& =3++)/%4+&C

    T )&,$'0 Z3/)1G&L4&51%&'(/+ (&)( /+)$ =$,3)&) $' (2& /))1?'%&'( 45$,&))9 (2/( 1) ($ )/>9 $'=/,($5) 45&)3%&0 ($ 1'=+3&',& (2& 4$43+/(1$' $= '/(1$'G)(/(&)C P&,/++ (2/( $35 1'(&5&)( 1) '$( 1' )2$5(G

    (&5% 0&%$?5/421, ,2/'?&) 73( 5/(2&5 1' +$'?G(&5% 21)($51,/+ =$5,&) (2/( 0&(&5%1'& *2&(2&5 / )(/(&7&,$%&) +/5?& E4$43+$3)H $5 )%/++ E)4/5)&+> 4$43+/(&0HC ;*$ ?&$?5/421, =/,($5) /5& 4/5/%$3'( 1'(21) 45$,&))A Q/'0 /5&/ E(5/')=$5%&0 7> (2& '/(35/+ +$?/51(2%H /'0 (2& )2/5& $= +/'0 )31(/7+& =$5/?51,3+(35/+ 45$03,(1$'9 1C&C9 T5/7+& +/'0C I2&' (2&)& (*$ =/,($5) /5& 5&?5&))&0 /?/1')( 4$43+/(1$'E+'H (2&> /,,$3'( =$5 SSq $= (2& @/51/',&C

    D' $50&5 ($ =3',(1$' /) 1')(53%&'() (2&)& =/,($5) %3)( /+)$ 7& 3'/==&,(&0 7> (2& $3(,$%&C D()&&%) 3'+1B&+> (2/( / ,$3'(5>e) 5&?1%&G(>4& *$3+0 1%4/,( 1() +/'0 /5&/ $5 /5/7+& +/'09 )$ (21)/))3%4(1$' )&&%) 3'45$7+&%/(1,C

    ;2& ,2$)&' 1')(53%&'()9 =1'/++>9 %3)( 1%4/,( (2& $3(,$%& $'+> (25$3?2 (2& @/51/7+& $=(2&$5&(1,/+ 1'(&5&)( E(2& &L,+3)1$' 5&)(51,(1$'H9 1C&C9 4$43+/(1$'C T'> /+(&5'/(1@& 4/(2) =5$%J($ K%3)( 7& 7+$,B&0 $5 %3)( 7& )2$*' ($ 1'(5$03,& / '&?/(1@& 71/) E/?/1')( (2& 2>4$(2&)1) 3'0&5

    1'@&)(1?/(1$'HC D( )&&%) 4$))17+& (2/( / +/5?&5 )2/5& $= /5/7+& +/'0 %1?2( +&/0 ($ ?5&/(&5 &,$'$%1,0&@&+$4%&'(9 *21,2 %1?2( (2&' &'2/',& 45$)4&,() =$5 0&%$,5/,> EN4)(&1' &( /+C 8::JHC _$*&@&59(2& (*$ =/,($5) /5& /+%$)( 4&5=&,(+> $5(2$?$'/+ ($ $'& /'$(2&5 /'09 1' /'> ,/)&9 (21) 7/,B0$$5 =5$%

    !MT'(1?3/ r `/5730/9 T3)(5/+1/9 `/2/%/)9 `/25/1'9 `/57/0$)9 #/4& d&50&9 #$%$5$)9 #37/9 #>453)9 ^$%1'1,/9^$%1'1,/' P&437+1,9 U&0&5/(&0 6(/(&) $= ]1,5$'&)1/9 U1Y19 O5&'/0/9 _/1(19 D,&+/'09 D5&+/'09 a/%/1,/9 a/4/'9 W1517/(19]/0/?/),/59 ]/+01@&)9 ]/+(/9 ]/5)2/++ D)+/'0)9 ]/351(13)9 j&* s&/+/'09 .jO9 .21+1441'&)9 6/$ ;$%& /'0 .51',14&96&>,2&++&)9 61'?/4$5&9 6$+$%$' D)9 651 Q/'B/9 6(C W1(()Gj&@1)9 6(C d1',&'( r O5&'/01'&)9 6(C Q3,1/9 ;/1*/'9 ;$'?/9;51'10/0 r ;$7/?$9 cW9 d/'3/(39 /'0 6/%$/C

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    15/31

    !M

    J($ K1) 7+$,B&0 )1',& $35 %$0&+ ,$'01(1$') $' 4&5 ,/41(/ O^.C D= +/'0 /5&/ 1%4/,() 0&%$,5/,>E$(2&5 (2/' (25$3?2 4$43+/(1$'H 1( )&&%) +1B&+> ($ 2/@& / '&?/(1@& &==&,( $' (2/( $3(,$%&9 /) +/5?&5/5&/) 45&)3%/7+> &'2/',& ,$$501'/(1$' 45$7+&%) =$5 (2& $44$)1(1$' /'0 %/> 7& ,$'03,1@& ($ /'/3($,5/(1,9 g1%4&51/+h )(>+& $= 53+&C D'0&&09 @/51$3) )(301&) 2/@& )2$*' / '&?/(1@& 5&+/(1$')2147&(*&&' +/'0 /5&/ /'0 0&%$,5/,> $5 0&%$,5/(1 @/51/7+&9 4$43+/(1$'9 )2$* / 5&+/(1$')214 (2/( 1) )$%&*2/( )(5$'?&5(2/' $35 7&',2%/5B %$0&+9 ,$'=15%1'? $35 ,&'(5/+ =1'01'?C R= ,$35)&9 (2& ,/3)/+ &==&,( %3)( 7&1'(&545&(&0 /) QT;N 5/(2&5 (2/' T;NV (2&> 1'01,/(& (2& ,/3)/+ &==&,( =$5 (2$)& ,$3'(51&) *2$)&4$43+/(1$' 1) 0&(&5%1'&0 7> +/'0 /5&/ /'0 /5/7+& +/'09 '$( =$5 $(2&5) ET'?51)(9 .1),2B& 8::\HC

    ($ 5&?3+/(& /,,&)) ($ 4$*&5(25$3?2 %3+(1G4/5(> ,$%4&(1(1@& &+&,(1$') /'0 ($ )&( ,$')(1(3(1$'/+ ,$')(5/1'() $' (2& &L&5,1)& $=4$*&5C ;21) 1) )$9 *& /5?3&09 7&,/3)& / +/5?&5 4$43+/(1$' 4+/,&) / )&51&) $= ,$')(5/1'() $' (2& /71+1(>$= +&/0&5) ($ %$'$4$+1 $= )4&,1=1,/(1$')9 )/%4+&)9&)(1%/($5)9 /'0 $3(,$%& %&/)35&)9 1',+301'? )&@&5/+ Z3/)1G&L4&51%&'(/+ 0&)1?')C T?/1'9 *& */'( ($&%42/)1 $= (2& %/1' 2>4$(2&)1)C

    D= *& /5& ,$55&,(9 (2& ,+/))1,/+ '/55/(1@& 5&Z315&) )$%& 5&@1)1$'C ;2/( 1)9 )1 $= 0&%$,5/,> 01==&5&'(+> /+$'? 01==&5&'( 01%&')1$')C 64&,1=1,/++>9 1',5&/)1'? (2& )1 %/> 2/@& '&?/(1@& ,$')&Z3&',&) =$5 4/5(1,14/(1$'9 =&&+1'?) $= &==1,/,>9 /'0 4&52/4) =$5 $(2&501%&')1$') $= 0&%$,5/,>9 /) (2& ,+/))1,/+ )>'(2&)1) /))&5() E/'0 %/'> ,$'(&%4$5/5> )(301&) /==15%HCT( (2& )/%& (1%&9 1',5&/)1'? (2& )1 %/> 2/@& 4$)1(1@& ,$')&Z3&',&) =$5 &+&,($5/+l+17&5/+/)4&,() $= 0&%$,5/,>9 /( +&/)( 1' (2& %$0&5' &5/C

    ^&%$,5/,> 1) '$( / )1'?+& &%4151,/++> /'0 (2&$5&(1,/++> ,$2&5&'( ,$',&4( E#$44&0?&9 O&551'?&( /+C 8:!8H )$ 1( )(/'0) ($ 5&/)$' (2/( (2& )/%& ,/3)/+ =/,($5 %1?2( 2/@& 01@&5?&'( ,/3)/+ &==&,() $'01==&5&'( /)4&,() $= 0&%$,5/,>C `> 1%4+1,/(1$'9 ,$'(&%4$5/5> %$@&%&'() =$5 ?5&/(&5 /%/+?/%/(1$'/,5$)) 4$+1(1&) E&C?C9 (2& N35$4&/' c'1$'H9 $5 =$5 01@1)1$' $5 0&@$+3(1$' *1(21' 4$+1(1&)9 %/> 2/@&01@&5?&'( ,/3)/+ &==&,() [ )(5&'?(2&'1'? 0&%$,5/,> 1' )$%& 5&)4&,() /'0 *&/B&'1'? 1( 1' $(2&5

    5&)4&,()C I& 5&?/50 (21) /) /' 1%4$5(/'( ($41, =$5 =3(35& 1'@&)(1?/(1$'CT'$(2&5 ($41, (2/( 7&/5) =35(2&5 )(30> 1) (2& 5&+/(1$')214 7&(*&&' )19 $' (2&$(2&59 1) / *10&G5/'?1'? )$,1$+$?1,/+ 42&'$%&'$'9 / 2>4$(2&)1) (2/( *& /005&)) 1' / )&51&) $=

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    16/31

    !J

    ,$%4/'1$' )(301&) EO&551'?9 s/5&,B1 8:!8V O&551'?9 ;&$5&++9 s/5&,B1 8:!8HC

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    17/31

    !S

    !A!9 !G!FCT,&%$?+39 ^/5$'9 61%$' a$2')$'9 a/%&) TC P$71')$'9 /'0 .1&55& k/5&0C 8::FC gD',$%& /'0

    ^&%$,5/,>ChD0$%&1;' T1/'/0&1 B$7&$Q\F9 F:FGFK8CT,&%$?+39 ^/5$'9 61%$' a$2')$'9 /'0 a/%&) TC P$71')$'C 8::8C gP&@&5)/+ $= U$5(3'&A O&$?5/42>

    /'0 D')(1(3(1$') 1' (2& ]/B1'? $= (2& ]$0&5' I$5+0 D',$%& ^1)(5173(1$'ChU*;%5$%>8 S/*%';> /8 S/*%';> /< T1/'/0&14!!M9 FKSG\:KC

    T+&)1'/9 T+7&5($9 /'0 N'51,$ 64$+/$5&C 8::XC RI$ ?&2$ /< V;5&/'4C ]D; .5&))CT+%$'09 O/751&+C !\MJC g#$%4/5/(1@& .$+1(1,/+ 6>)(&%)ChS/*%';> /< =/>&5&14!F9 X\!GK:\CT+@/5& 1' ]1,5$)(/(&) /'0 6%/++ D)+/'0 6(/(&)Ch Y/%>, 9$7$>/:0$'5

    X8A89 XS\GX\:CT',B/59 ^/?9 /'0 #/5)(&' T',B/5C !\\MC g61Ch ?1;',&';7&;' =/>&5&1;>

    ?5*,&$4!FAK9 8!!G88\CT'?51)(9 a$)23/ ^C9 /'0 a$5'G6(&==&' .1),2B&C 8::\CC/45>8 Z;%0>$44 T1/'/0$5%&14H D' T0:&%&1&45[4

    W/0:;'&/'C .51',&($'A .51',&($' c'1@&5)1(> .5&))CT5&++/'$9 ]/'3&+9 /'0 6(&42&' `$'0C !\\!C g6$%& ;&)() $= 64&,1=1,/(1$' =$5 ./'&+ ^/(/A ]$'(&

    #/5+$ N@10&',& /'0 /' T44+1,/(1$' ($ N%4+$>%&'( NZ3/(1$')Ch B$7&$Q /< T1/'/0&1 ?5*,&$4MFA8ET451+H 8SSG8\SC

    T3%/''9 P$7&5( aC !\JKC g]/5B&() *1(2 / #$'(1'33% $= ;5/0&5)ChT1/'/0$5%&1;X8A!G8 Ea/'3/5>[T451+H X\[M:C

    `/55$9 P$7&5( aC !\\\C g^&(&5%1'/'() $= ^&%$,5/,>ChS/*%';> /< =/>&5&1;> T1/'/08!:SAJ9 4/5( DDE^&,&%7&5H9 6!MFG6!FXC

    `&,B9 j/(2/'1&+9 /'0 a$'/(2/' W/(A T ;2&$5> $= (2& N==&,() $= #$%%3'1(> 61&1 WI/&1$!KXA!G89 JSG!:!C#+/?3&9 #251)($42&59 63&5&1;> ;', ?/1&;> ?1&$'1$SSX9 !JGK!C

    #$+$%&59 a$)&4 ]/51/C 8::SC \%$;5 T0:&%$4] ?0;>> V;5&/'4H RI$ 6'1$%5;&' ^*5*%$ /< 5I$ ?/7$%$' ?5;5$CQ$'0$'A P$3(+&0?&C

    #$44&0?&9 ]1,2/&+9 T'?&+ T+@/5&

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    18/31

    !F

    #$44&0?&9 ]1,2/&+9 a$2' O&551'?9 /'0 6(/==/' Q1'07&5?C 8:!8C gd/51&(1&) $= ^&%$,5/,> EdG^&%HChc'437+1)2&0 45$Y&,( 0&),514(1$'C m@G0&%C'&(n

    #$44&0?&9 ]1,2/&+9 /'0 a$2' O&551'?9 &( /+C 8:!!C g#$',&4(3/+1&5&14\A! Ea3'&H9 8KSG8JSC

    #$)&59 Q&*1)C !\MJC RI$ ^*'15&/'4 /< ?/1&;> W/'&15C j&* k$5BA ;2& U5&& .5&))C

    #$)(/9 ^$5/ QC9 /'0 ]/((2&* NC W/2'C 8::XC g#1@1, N'?/?&%&'( /'0 #$%%3'1(> _&(&5$?&'&1(>AT' N,$'$%1)(e) .&5)4&,(1@&Ch =$%4:$15&7$4 /' =/>&5&14!A! E]/5,2H9 !:XG!!!C^/2+9 P$7&5( TC !\S!C =/>8;%1I8H =;%5&1&:;5&/' ;', _::/4&5&/'C j&* _/@&'A k/+& c'1@&5)1(> .5&))C^/2+9 P$7&5( TC9 /'0 N0*/50 ;3=(&C !\SXC ?&2$ ;', 9$0/1%;18C 6(/'=$50A 6(/'=$50 c'1@&5)1(> .5&))C^1/%$'09 Q/55>9 /'0 6@&(+/'/ ;)/+1BC !\\\C g61 ^1/%$'09 &0C 9$7$>/:&'# 9$0/1%;18H R/Q;%,4 W/'4/>&,;5&/'E`/+(1%$5&A a$2') _$4B1')c'1@&5)1(> .5&))H9 !!SG!J:C

    ^$%%&'9 NC !\F:C g6$%& ^1)(1'?31)21'? #2/5/,(&51)(1,) $= D)+/'0 6(/(&)Ch Y/%>, 9$7$>/:0$'5FA!89\X!G\KXC

    N+*&5(9 U&+1L9 /'0 #251)($42&5 I1')214C 8:!!C gN'0$?&'$3) 6&+&,(1$' `1/)Ch c'437+1)2&0%/'3),514(9 ^&4/5(%&'( $= 6$,1$+$?>9 c'1@&5)1(> $= I1),$')1'G]/01)$'C

    N4)(&1'9 ^/@10 QC9 P$7&5( `/(&)9 a/,B O$+0)($'&9 D0/ W51)(&')&'9 /'0 62/5>' Re_/++$5/'C 8::JC

    g^&%$,5/(1, ;5/')1(1$')ChD0$%&1;' S/*%';> /< =/>&5&1;> ?1&$'1$M:AX Ea3+>H MM!GJ\CU/51)9 PC !\\\C gc'($ ;2&%)&+@&)A D')3+/51(> /'0 ^&%$,5/,>Ch c'437+1)2&0 ]T (2&)1)C c'1@&5)1(>

    $= j$5(2 #/5$+1'/9 #2/4&+ _1++CU/553?1/9 #2/5+&)C !\\XC g;2& 64&,1/+ I$5B1'? N'@15$'%&'( $= 6&'1$5 T0%1'1)(5/($5) 1' 6%/++

    6(/(&)Ch Y/%>, 9$7$>/:0$'58!A89 88!G88JCO/))&7'&59 ]/5(1'9 ]1,2/&+ aC Q/%+/9 /'0 a/%&) P/>%$'0 d5&&+/'0C 8::\C gNL(5&%& `$3'0) $=

    ^&%$,5/,>Ch WRU I$5B1'? ./4&5 t8:KCO&551'?9 a$2'9 /'0 ^$%1'1, s/5&,B1C 8:!8C g61CO&551'?9 a$2'9 a/' ;&$5&++9 /'0 ^$%1'1, s/5&,B1C 8:!8C g6,/+1'? c4A ^&%$?5/421,) /'0

    6,23%4&(&51/' ^&%$,5/,> /( 637'/(1$'/+ Q&@&+)Ch c'437+1)2&0 %/'3),514(9 ^&4/5(%&'( $=

    .$+1(1,/+ 6,1&',&9 `$)($' c'1@&5)1(>CO&551'?9 a$2'9 6(5$% #C ;2/,B&59 /'0 P$051?$ T+=/5$C 8:!8C g^&%$,5/,> /'0 _3%/'

    ^&@&+$4%&'(ChS/*%';> /< =/>&5&14 SKA! Ea/'3/5>H !G!SCO$&%/')9 _&1' NC9 W51)(1/' 6B5&0& O+&01(),29 /'0 O1/,$%$ #21$*5&/' ;', B$)$>>&/' &' 5I$ T;%>8 C/,$%' Y/%>,C `&5B&+&>A c'1@&5)1(> $=

    #/+1=$5'1/ .5&))CO5&&'9 N++1$((C 8:!8C gR' (2& 61/:0$'5C #/%7510?&A #/%7510?& c'1@&5)1(> .5&))C_15),29 I&5'&5 sC !\M\C gNL4&'01(35& D%4+1,/(1$') $= ]&(5$4$+1(/' O5$*(2 /'0#$')$+10/(1$'Ch

    B$7&$Q /< T1/'/0&14 ;', ?5;5&45&14 K!A 8X8GK!C_1),$L9 ]1,2/&+ aC9 /'0 ^/@10 TC Q/B&C 8::!C g^&%$,5/,> /'0 (2& 61C

    _$++/'09 ./3+ IC !\FJC g6(/(1)(1,) /'0 #/3)/+ D'=&5&',&ChS/*%';> /< 5I$ D0$%&1;' ?5;5&45&1;> D44/1&;5&/'F!AX\J E^&,&%7&5H \KMGJ:C

    W'/,B9 6(&42&'9 /'0 R%/5 T9 #$3'(5> 61 $= T++ #$3'(51&)9 ;2&15 ^1@1)1$')/'0 ;$*')Ch 2((4All***C4$43+)(/(C1'=$C

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    19/31

    !\

    Q/))&'9 ^/@10 ^5&>&59 /'0 6$5&' 6&551(AN@10&',& $' D'(&5'/+ .$+1(1,/+ N==1,/,> =5$% +/5?&G),/+& ]3'1,14/+ P&=$5%ChD0$%&1;' =/>&5&1;>?1&$'1$ B$7&$Q!:MA8 E]/>H9 8XFG8MFC

    Q$,B2/5(9 ^$3?+/) OC9 ^/@10 ^5/B/B1)G6%1(29 /'0 a$2' 6,2&%751 E&0)HC !\\XC RI$ 9$7$>/:0$'5 =%/1$44&' ?0;>> X4>;', ?5;5$4C Q$'0$'A P$3(+&0?&C

    Q39 `$9 N+/1'& s/'3(($9 P$7&5( _$5'1B9 /'0 ./3+ PC P$)&'7/3%C 8::!C g]/(,21'? *1(2 ^$)&) 1' /'R7)&5@/(1$'/+ 6(30> $= / ]&01/ #/%4/1?' /?/1')( ^53? T73)&ChS/*%';> /< 5I$ D0$%&1;' ?5;5&45&1;>D44/1&;5&/'\JAKMJ E^&,&%7&5H !8KMGMXC

    ]/001)$'9 T'?3)C 8:!:C g6(/(1)(1,) $' I$5+0 .$43+/(1$'9 O^. /'0 .&5 #/41(/ O^.9 !G8::F T^Ch^$*'+$/0&0 =5$%***C??0,C'&(l]T^^D6Rjl$511'0&LC2(%

    ]/''9 ;2$%/)9 /'0 P/>%$'0 I$+=1'?&5C !\F:C g#/'010/(&) /'0 ./5(1&) 1' #$'?5&))1$'/+N+&,(1$')ChD0$%&1;' =/>&5&1;> ?1&$'1$ B$7&$QSK9 J!SGJX8C

    ]/5)2/++9 ]$'(> OC9 ;&0 P$7&5( O3559 /'0 W&1(2 a/??&5)C 8:!:C g.$+1(> Dd .5$Y&,(A .$+1(1,/+ P&?1%/5/,(&51)(1,) /'0 ;5/')1(1$')9 !F::G8::\C ^/(/)&( c)&5)e ]/'3/+Ch #&'(&5 =$5 6>)(&%1, .&/,&C

    j&*&>9 I21('&> WC9 /'0 W&''&(2 ^C I&)(C !\FSC gT 61%4+&9 .$)1(1@& 6&%1G^&=1'1(&9_&(&5$)B&0/)(1,1(> /'0 T3($,$55&+/(1$' #$')1)(&'( #$@/51/',& ]/(51LChT1/'/0$5%&1;MMAX E]/>H9S:XG:FC

    R+1@&59 aC N51,C 8:::C g#1(> 61&5&1;>?1&$'1$ B$7&$Q\KA8 Ea3'&H XJ!GSXC

    R+))$'9 R+/C 8::XC gO&$?5/42> /'0 D')(1(3(1$')A T P&@1&* $= .+/3)17+& /'0 D%4+/3)17+& Q1'B/?&)ChI$5B1'? ./4&5) 1' N,$'$%1,) j$C !:JC

    R+))$'9 R+/9 /'0 O3)(/@ _/'))$'C 8:!!C g#$3'(5> 61> &4 9$0/1%;5&1H D' T`;0&';5&/' /< ?5;5$ ?&2$ ;', 9$0/1%;5&1 9$7$>/:0$'5C j&*k$5BA O/5+/'0C

    .1(B1'9 _/''/ U&'1,2&+C !\JSC RI$ W/'1$:5 /< B$:%$4$'5;5&/'C `&5B&+&>A c'1@&5)1(> $= #/+1=$5'1/ .5&))C

    .5&5&1;> X'45&5*5&/'4 ;', C;5$%&;> Y$>>N3$&'# &' 5I$ Y/%>,] FaGENFaaEC #/%7510?&A

    #/%7510?& c'1@&5)1(> .5&))CP&%%&59 W/5&' QC 8:!:C g.$+1(1,/+ 6,/+& /'0 N+&,($5/+ ;35'$3(A N@10&',& U5$% (2& Q&))

    D'03)(51/+1&5&1;> ?5*,&$4KXAX9 8SMGX:XCP$?$*)B19 P$'/+0C !\\FC g^&%$,5/,>9 #/41(/+9 6B1++9 /'0 #$3'(5> 61

    /'0 P&?1%& ]$'$4$+> $' (2& R00) $= ^&%$,5/(1, P3+&Ch D' PCIC ^/@1)9 &0C RI$ _%&'4 / /+&9 6(&42&' TC 8::!CD \$/#%;:I8 /< X4>;',4H ?0;>> X4>;', X'4*>;%&58C Q$'0$'A P$3(+&0?&CP371'9 ^$'/+0C 8::MC g#/3)/+ D'=&5&',& c)1'? .$(&'(1/+ R3(,$%&)A ^&)1?'9 ]$0&+1'?9 ^&,1)1$')ChS/*%';> /< 5I$ D0$%&1;' ?5;5&45&1;> D44/1&;5&/'!::9 X88GX!C

    61%%&+9 O&$5?C !\MMC W/'&15 ;', 5I$ Y$) /< \%/*: DC 8::KC g6%/++ D)+/'0 j/(1$') /'0 ^&%$,5/(1, d/+3&)Ch Y/%>, 9$7$>/:0$'5X89 X8\GXK!C

    6(/)/@/?&9 ^/@10C 8:!:C gI2&' ^1)(/',& ]/((&5&0A O&$?5/421, 6,/+& /'0 (2& ^&@&+$4%&'( $=N35$4&/' P&45&)&'(/(1@& T))&%7+1&)ChD0$%&1;' =/>&5&1;> ?1&$'1$ B$7&$Q!:KAK Ej$@&%7&5H J8MGJKXC

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    20/31

    8:

    ;//?&4&5/9 P&1'C !\S8C g;2& 61;&'&'# B$#&0$ WI;'#$ &' 5I$ Y/%>,] Fab@N@EEcC

    #/%7510?&A #/%7510?& c'1@&5)1(> .5&))C;1&7$3(9 #2/5+&) ]C !\MJC gT .35& ;2&$5> $= Q$,/+ O$@&5'%&'( NL4&'01(35&ChS/*%';> /< =/>&5&1;>

    T1/'/08JK9 K!JGK8KC

    d/'2/'&'9 ;/(3C 8:::C gT j&* ^/(/)&( =$5 ]&/)351'? ^&%$,5/,>9 !F!:G!\\FChS/*%';> /< =$;1$B$4$;%1IXS9 8M!G8JMCI&+0$'9 6(&@&'C 8::JC g^$*')1 .$+1(>i ;2& D%4/,( $= 61&5&14!8AK9 KJSGKF!CI21(&9 _/+7&5(C !\F:C gT _&(&5$)B&0/)(1,1(>G#$')1)(&'( #$@/51/',& ]/(51L /'0 / ^15&,( ;&)( =$5

    _&(&5$)B&0/)(1,1(>ChT1/'/0$5%&1;KF9 F!SGFXFCI1((%/'9 ^$'/+0C !\\!C gj/(1$') /'0 6(/(&)A ]&5?&5) /'0 T,Z31)1(1$')V ^1))$+3(1$' /'0 ^1@$5,&Ch

    D0$%&1;' T1/'/0&1 B$7&$QF!A89 !8JG!8\CI1((%/'9 ^$'/+0C 8:::C g;2& I&/+(2 /'0 61 /< W/'&15 B$4/>*5&/'KKAJ9 FJFGFKC

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    21/31

    8!

    R;)>$ FHAJ2&'2 >-+11'&2#+'&? "2D(#%1

    "2D(. CD2,+*%1 /%1%&-,4 (%1#6' K%-#+( L#'(#'6 L+,D1

    T,&%$?+3 &( /+C 8::F .P ;6#6A RQ6 *l =1L&0 &==&,()9 O]] !\J:G8::: : j$

    `/55$ !\\\ .P9 #Q ;6#6A 6cP *l +/??&0 k /( MG>&/5 1'(&5@/+) !\S8G!\\M : j$

    O/))&7'&5 &( /+C 8::\ ^^ E(5/')1(1$')H ;6#6A NL(5&%& 7$3'0) d/5>1'? : j$

    _/0&'13) !\\8 _/0&'13) 1'0&L ;6#6A RQ6 !\FF G j$

    R(( 8::: .P9 #Q9 &( /+C #6A #5$))G(/7) !\SXG!\\M G k&)

    P$)& 8::J .P9 #Q d/51$3) !\J:G8::: : j$

    ;&$5&++ 8:!: .P9 #Q9 .$+1(>8 ;6#6A RQ6 *l +/??&0 ^d !\S8G8::J : j$

    6'&54 /< ;';>84&4 L,$3'(51&) $5 ,$3'(5>G>&/5)C ^&',&'#f '&?/(1@& EGH9 4$)1(1@& EoH9'3++ E:HC ^/1*4 $' 4$43+/(1$'fk&)lj$C W? L,5$))G)&,(1$'C R?W? L(1%&G)&51&) ,5$))G)&,(1$'C ?6B L)&&%1'?+> 3'5&+/(&0 5&?5&))1$'C\CC L?&'&5/+1

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    22/31

    88

    R;)>$ @H=%12#'6 9?2%-'&2% CD2,+*%1E "&*@?%1E &'( "@%,#F#,&2#+'1

    MNO MPO MQO MRO MSO MTO MUO MVO MWO

    _*51/0$=/>&58@ =/>&58@ =/>&58@ JW_V?R =_dW_C= =/> BI54 W/0:$5&5&7$ R*%'/7$% W/'5$45;5&/'

    E.$+1(>DdH E.$+1(>DdH E.$+1(>DdH E.$+1(>DdH E.$+1(>DdH EU_H Ed/'2/'&'H ET5,21?$)H E#$44&0?&H

    ?1;>$ W/'5&'*/*4 R%&1I/5/0/*4 9&1I/5/0/*4 W/'5&'*/*4 W/'5&'*/*4 W/'5&'*/*4 W/'5&'*/*4 9&1I/5/0/*4 W/'5&'*/*4

    T45&0;5/%RQ69jI

    R50&5&0+$?1(

    Q$?1(E]QNH

    RQ69jI

    RQ69jI

    RQ69jI

    ;$71(EPNH

    Q$?1(E]QNH

    RQ69jI

    3TVWZCDBe ZX?R_BXWDd

    K+@D?&2#+' M?'O 8C!\!uuu :C!:\uuu :C!FKuuu XCMJ:uuu !C88Suuu XCSS!uuu :C!!Suuu 8C!J\uuum:C8S8n m:C:!Mn m:C:!\n m:CXXSn m:CXMXn m:CSMJn m:C:8Xn m:C8KJn

    _)4$%7;5&/'4 !:9888 !:9888 !:9888 \9!MK \9!!S \9JXF F9\JF M9F8KW/*'5%&$4 !F! !F! !F! !M\ !M\ !SS !JF !MSK$;%4 !F8:G8::8 !F8:G8::8 !F8XG8::! !F8:G8::X !F8:G8::X !F8:G!\\\ !FJFG!\\\ !\K\G!\\\B@ f:4$*,/g :CKJ: E:C8MJH E:CXS8H :CKM! :CK:F E:C!!XH :CK\8d/# d&P$>&I//, GX:9XK:

    3TVWZCDBe W_VRTC=_BDBK

    K+@D?&2#+' M?'O 8C8X8uuu :C!JKuuu :C!S\uuu !C\JXuuu !C8FKuuu :CFS\uuu !CSKJ :C:F:uuu !CJXSuuum:CX!Kn m:C:!Sn m:C:8:n m:CX\Kn m:CK!Mn m:CXXXn m!C!XXn m:C:8Jn m:C8M!n

    &I//, G!S9!\M

    CDJXCDd

    K+@D?&2#+' M?'O :CSKSuuu :C:!! :C::S !CM8\uuu G:C!J\ !C:M\uuu 8CXF8uuu :C!!Kuuu !CMX!uuum:C8F8n m:C:!\n m:C:8Kn m:CXMJn m:CX\Mn m:CXKFn m:CSK:n m:C:8Fn m:C8KJn

    _)4$%7;5&/'4 F9FSM F9FSM F9FSM F9:K\ F9:!X K98M: F9KJ! S9F!\ M9X:J

    W/*'5%&$4 !KS !KS !KS !8F !8F !KJ !KK !XJ !8FK$;%4 !F8:G8::: !F8:G8::: !F8:G8::: !F8:G8::! !F8:G8::! !\S!G8::! !\J:G!\\\ !\J:G8::X !\J:G!\\\B@ f:4$*,/g :CM!S E:CX:MH E:CKXSH :CM!M :CKS: :CJ!! E:C!X8H :CMFKd/# d&P$>&I//, G8S9M!\

    R3(,$%&) =$5*/50G+/??&0 $'& 4&51$0C #$'(1'3$3) $3(,$%&) 5&G),/+&0 =5$% : ($ !:: E!::f%$)(0&%$,5/(1,HC 3$'1I0;%P 1/7;%&;5$4 f ^1==3)1$'9 O^. 4&5 ,/41(/9 c57/' 4$43+/(1$'9 D)+/'09 .5$(&)(/'(9 ]3)+1%9/''3/+ 03%%1&)C C;`&0;> 1/7;%&;5$4 f `&',2%/5B o Q/'0+$,B9 Q/(1(30& E+'H9 N'?+1)2 +&?/+ $51?1'9 N35$4&/'+/'?3/?&9 N(2'1, =5/,(1$'/+1

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    23/31

    8X

    R;)>$ AH9?2%-'&2% /%6-%11#+' G+(%?1

    MNO MPO MQO MRO MSO MTO MUO MVO MWO MNXO MNNO

    ?;0:>$ j/(35/+ j/(35/+ ID'01/9 c6 ]D j/(35/+ j/(35/+ j/(35/+ j/(35/+ j/(35/+ j/(35/+ j/(35/

    =;'$> T''3/+ T''3/+ T''3/+ T''3/+ !:G>&/5 j$ T''3/+ T''3/+ T''3/+ T''3/+ T''3/

    d;# :$%&/,4 ! ! ! ! ! ! K: ! ! ! !

    T45&0;5/%_d?

    VY?T_d?

    VY?T_d?

    VY?T_d?

    VY?T_d?

    VY?T_d?

    _d?VY?T

    _d?VY?T

    _d?VY?T

    _d?VY?T

    _d?VY?T

    K+@D?&2#+' 8C!\!uuu :CMKFuuu !C8MXuuu :CK\Kuuu 8C:\8uuu !CM::uu !C!JXuu :C!JKuuu 8C::KuuM?'O m:C8S8n m:C8:Fn m:C8SXn m:C!JSn m:CS!\n m:CM\:n m:CM!\n m:C:MMn m:CX:K

    K+@D?&2#+' XC:J8uuuM?'OE NWTX m:CX8Xn

    K+@D?&2#+' :C8\!M*%(#D*O m:C\MKn

    K+@D?&2#+' KCMX\uuuM?&-6%O m:C\JXn

    ^1==3)1$' 8JC\SJuuu M8C!SFuuu 8MCJ!Fuuu KXCKK:uuu 8FCKXXuuu MCMJ\ !XCX\X 8MCK\Fuuu 8JCJS:uuu :CSJFu 8SC:XXum8CJ:!n m8CFMJn m8CM!:n m8C8MJn mJCMSFn mXC\!Fn mFCJMFn m8C8:Mn m8CJKJn m:CKK:n m8CJ:!

    O^. 4&5 ,/4 !MCF:Xuuu !MCFM8uuu !:CFSSuuu !JC!K8uuu MCK8!uuu 8!CS!Kuuu !!CJSXuuu !MCXFFuuu :CS8Xuuu !MCS!:u

    E+'H m:CMX8n m:CMKJn m:CXJKn m!CKK8n m:C\\!n m!CMK!n m:CS8Mn m:CMKXn m:C!XFn m:CMXXc57/' G8JC8MKuuu G8XC8!Xuuu G\C:MSuuu G8JCMKSuuu G!MC::Suuu G!JCX!Su G:C:8\ G8!CK\Muuu G:CFMK G8JC:X8u m8CF:8n m8CFMKn m8CKJKn mSCXS!n mMCKJKn m\CX!:n m:C:X!n m8CS\Mn m:CMFXn m8CS\SD)+/'0 !KCKF\uuu !KCM!Fuuu !XC!KMuuu !KC\!Juuu XCX\\ SC8X!uuu !\CMK:uuu !8CKSJuuu :CMFXuuu !KC!8Mu

    m!C:XSn m!C:XXn m:CF8Jn m8CSJ:n m8CJ:Sn m!CFXMn m!CK:Xn m!C:K8n m:C8!Sn m!C:F8.5$(&)(/'( :C8!\uuu :C8::uuu :C8\Fuuu :C8!\uuu G:C:!F :C8:Muuu :C8!Kuuu :C88!uuu :C:!:uuu :C8!Muu

    m:C:!Xn m:C:!Xn m:C:!!n m:C:XJn m:C:KXn m:C:8!n m:C:!Fn m:C:!Xn m:C::Xn m:C:!K]3)+1% G:C8!Suuu G:C8!Kuuu G:C8!Fuuu G:C8:\uuu G:CS8Juuu G:C8X8uuu G:C8X8uuu G:C88Xuuu G:C:!Muuu G:C8!Fu

    m:C:!Xn m:C:!Xn m:C:!:n m:C:XXn m:C:8Fn m:C:8Jn m:C:!Mn m:C:!Xn m:C::Xn m:C:!X#/4/71+1(1&) !SC:\F

    m\C8\\KE+/??&0H KCSM8uuu

    m:C:8:nk&/5 03%%1&) p p p p p p p p p p_)4$%7;5&/'4 !:888 !SJ\M \\FM !K8:: !:K\ !F: KK!J MJ\\ !:888 !:88! !:888

    W/*'5%&$4 !F! !\K !S\ 8!X !F! !F: !:\ !SM !F! !F! !F!

    K$;%4!F8:G8::8

    !F!MG8::8

    !F8:G8::8

    !F!MG8::K

    !F8:G8:::

    8:::!\M\G8::8

    !\J:G8::8

    !F8:G8::!

    !F8:G8::!

    !F8:G8::8

    B@ :CKJ: :C8:M :CKJ8 :CK\\ :CK\: :CFK\ :CK8! :CKJX :CKMM :C\KF :CKJ:

    CXf %3+(14+&G1%43(/(1$' )/%4+&C _d? f $501'/5> +&/)( )Z3/5&)C VY f j&*&>GI&)(C ?T f )(/'0/50 &55$5)C uuu 4v:C:!9 uu4v:C:M9 u 4v:C! E(*$G(/1+&0 (&)()HC T++ $3(,$%&) 5&G),/+&0 =5$% :G!::C

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    24/31

    8K

    R;)>$ hH/%6#*%I,4&'6% G+(%?1

    MNO MPO MQO MRO MSO

    =/>&58@ 1/,&'# E:G!::Hk(G k(G!

    E:G!::Hk(G k(G!

    E:G!::Hk(G k(G!

    E:l!H!f^&%$

    E:l!H!f'$'^&%$

    T45&0;5/%_d?

    VY?T_d?

    VY?T\CC

    Y$&)*>>Z;2;%,]

    W>*45$% ?T

    Y$&)*>>Z;2;%,]

    W>*45$% ?T

    K+@D?&2#+' M?'O :C!JKuuu :C8!Fuuu XC:FXuuu :C:JXu G:C:M:um:C:MMn m:C:J\n m!C:KKn m:C:XFn m:C:8\n

    ^1==3)1$' :CS8Xuuu :CJKMuuu G!CM8F :C!JJ G!CKMSuuum:C!XFn m:C!J!n m8C:KKn m:C!M\n m:CK!Sn

    O^. 4&5 ,/4 E+'H G:CFMK G:C\8J G8CXXSuuu :CKF8uuu G:CK!\uuum:CMFXn m:CS!Sn m:CSFKn m:C:M8n m:C:JMn

    c57/' :CSJFu !CXS!uuu FCJXKuu G:C\MFuuu :CK\\m:CKK:n m:CM:Mn mXCKX8n m:C8\Xn m:CXX8n

    D)+/'0 :CMFXuuu :CF88uuu :CXFFuuu G:CXJ\uum:C8!Sn m:CX:!n m:C!!:n m:C!S!n

    .5$(&)(/'( :C:!:uuu :C::X :C::Kuuu G:C::Mu

    m:C::Xn m:C::Kn m:C::!n m:C::Xn]3)+1% G:C:!Muuu G:C:!Suuu G:C:!Kuuu :C::Xuuu

    m:C::Xn m:C::Kn m:C::Kn m:C::!nKE+/??&0H G:C8KFuuu G:CX!Muuu :CFS!uuu

    m:C:8:n m:C:8Jn m:C::Sn^&,/0& 03%%1&) p p

    k&/5 03%%1&) p p p^;&>*%$4iR%;'4&5&/'4 XF8Ml!S\ JX\Jl!:\_)4$%7;5&/'4 !:988! F9XSJ !::8M !:88\ !:88\W/*'5%&$4 !F! !S8 !F! !F! !F!K$;%4 !F8:G8::! !F8:G8::! !F8:G8::! !F8:G8::8 !F8:G8::8B@ :C:M! :C:JXY;>, 1I&@ 8X9\MM FXJ JJSd/# :4$*,/>&P$>&I//, !M9KM! 8X9MJ8

    =;'$>H/''3/+C T++ 51?2(G)10& @/51/7+&) +/??&0 $'& 4&51$0C VYf j&*&>GI&)( ?T f )(/'0/50 &55$5)C \CCf ?&'&5/+1

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    25/31

    8M

    R;)>$ GHG&2,4#'6 A12#*&2+-1

    MNO MPO

    "9=A8C!SJuu KC:JXuuu

    E!C:KJH E!C:8:

    T`;15 0;51I&'#k&/59 D)+/'09

    ]3)+1%9.5$(&)(/'(

    k&/59 D)+/'09]3)+1%9

    .5$(&)(/'(

    j 0;51I$, \S \S

    V$;%$45N'$I)/%0;51I&'#

    `&',2%/5B,$@/51/(&)

    ]/L1%/+,$@/51/(&)

    W/*'5%&$4 !FX !SF_)4$%7;5&/'4 JSK8 J8MX

    =$%&/,H!\J:G8::KC _*51/0$H.$+1(>89 5&G),/+&0 =5$% : ($ !:: E!::f%$)( 0&%$,5/(1,HC R%$;50$'5 L ! =$5 /,$3'(5> E1' /++ >&/5)H 1= 4$43+/(1$' =$5 (2/( ,$3'(5> 1' !\J: 1) /7$@& (2& %&01/'C 3$'1I0;%P 1/7;%&;5$4 f^1==3)1$'9 O^. 4&5 ,/41(/ EI^DH9 c57/' 4$43+/(1$' EI^DHC C;`&0;> 1/7;%&;5$4 f `&',2%/5B o Q/'0+$,B9Q/(1(30& E+'H9 N'?+1)2 +&?/+ $51?1'9 N35$4&/' +/'?3/?&9 N(2'1, =5/,(1$'/+1

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    26/31

    8J

    R;)>$ cHHD&1#IAJ@%-#*%'2&? =%121

    MNO MP&O MP:O

    ?;0:>$ D)+/'0) N'(15& N'(15&

    T45&0;5/%_d?

    VY ?TXk

    fF45 45;#$gXk

    f@, 45;#$g

    K+@D?&2#+' M?'O !CSXSuuu XC!88uuum:CMM:n m:C8M8n

    ^1==3)1$' FC:KJuu G:C!XSuu 8XCJSXuuumXC8J\n m:C:MJn m!CS:8n

    O^. 4&5 ,/4 E+'H 8XC88Kuuu :C:XFuu !8CMS8uuum!CKSFn m:C:!\n m:CMF:n

    c57/' GKJC\8!uuu :C::Xuuu G:C:MSuumKC8\Mn m:C::!n m:C:8Kn

    D)+/'0 :C8X!uuu !\CS!:uuum:C:XJn m!C:X8n

    .5$(&)(/'( :C:\:uuu G:C::Fuuu :C8:Kuuum:C:8Sn m:C::!n m:C:!Jn

    ]3)+1% G:CX8:uuu G:C::8uuu G:C8KFuuum:C:SXn m:C::!n m:C:!!n

    k&/5 03%%1&) p p p

    Q/'0 /5&/ :CS:Juuum:C::Jn

    T5/7+& +/'0 :C:MSuuum:C::!n

    _)4$%7;5&/'4 !S:X J88MW/*'5%&$4 K8 !F8K$;%4 !F8:G8::! !\J!G8::!B@ :CKJJ :CSMS :CKMS

    _*51/0$H.$+1(>89 5&G),/+&0 =5$% : ($ !:: E!::f%$)( 0&%$,5/(1,HC R3(,$%&) =$5*/50G+/??&0 $'& 4&51$0C

    ./'&+A /''3/+C _d? f $501'/5> +&/)( )Z3/5&)C VY f j&*&>GI&)(C ?T f )(/'0/50 &55$5)C Xkf 1')(53%&'(/+@/51/7+& /'/+>)1)C X'45%*0$'54HQ/'0 /5&/ /'0 T5/7+& +/'0C uuu 4v:C:!9 uu 4v:C:M9 u 4v:C! E(*$G(/1+&0 (&)()HC

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    27/31

    8S

    9KKAY)

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    28/31

    8F

    R;)>$ DFHB&-#&:?% )%F#'#2#+'1

    9F-#,&; ^3%%> E,$01'? 7> /3(2$5)HCD&@&:#?#2#%1; #/4/71+1(1&) 1'0&L9 ,$%71'1'? 15$'l)(&&+ 45$03,(1$'9 &'&5?> 3)&9 %1+1(/5> &L4&'01(35&)9 %1+1(/5> 4&5)$''&+9

    /'0 ($(/+ /'0 357/' 4$43+/(1$' E#$55&+/(&) $= I/5HC 1;:;)&>&58l1/Q

    >&24+?#,; .&5,&'( #/(2$+1, E#DT I$5+0U/,(7$$B $'G+1'&HC W;5I/>&1

    >#0#? ?#:%-2#%1; D'0&L %&/)351'? (2& +&?/+ /'0 45/,(1,/+ 45$(&,(1$') $= 23%/' 51?2() EU5&&0$% _$3)&HCW&7&>l>&)$%58l^Zl'$#

    >+*@%2#2#0%'%11; !:: G @$(&) *$' 7> (2& +/5?&)( 4/5(> 1' 45&)10&'(1/+ $5 4/5+1/%&'(/5> &+&,(1$') E$5 7$(29 /@&5/?&0H /) q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

    )#FFD1#+'; ;2& .$+1(>8 ),$5&) $= /++ $(2&5 ,$3'(51&) 1' / ?1@&' >&/59 *&1?2(&0 7> (2& 1'@&5)& $= (2& 01)(/',& ($ / ,$3'(5>C=/>&58hl&0:l#$/

    A'6?#14 ?%6&? +-#6#'; N'?+1)2 +&?/+ $51?1' EQ/ .$5(/ &( /+ !\\\HCT'#>&4Il>$#;>l/%&'

    A24'+?#'6D#12#, F-&,2; N(2'$+1'?31)(1, =5/,(1$'/+1'

    /3(2$5)HC X4>;',

    [&'( &-%& M?'O; Q/'0 /5&/9 )Z3/5& B1+$%&(&5) EI$5+0 `/'B 8::SH9 &L(&'0&0 7/,B*/50 (25$3?2 (1%&C

    d;',lD%$;lY9XlEbl$:/>;5$l>'[&'( D1%; .&5,&'( $= )(/(&e) (&551($5> (2/( 1) /5/7+& +/'0 EI$5+0 `/'B 8::SHC d;',l*4$l;%;)>$l:$%1$'5lY9XlEG

    [&'(?+,8; ! 1= ,$3'(5> 1) +/'0+$,B&09 : $(2&5*1)& ET,&%$?+39 a$2')$'9 P$71')$' 8::8HC d;',>/1P

    [&2#' 9*%-#,&; ^3%%> E,$01'? 7> /3(2$5)HC d;5&'D0$%&1;

    [&2#2D(% M?'O; ^1)(/',& =5$% (2& &Z3/($59 (5/')=$5%&0 7> '/(35/+ +$?/51(2%C d;5&5*,$l>'

    G#((?% A&12; ^3%%>C #$01'? 7> /3(2$5)CC&,,>$T;45

    GD1?#*; .&5,&'( ]3)+1% E#DT I$5+0U/,(7$$B $'G+1'&HCC*4>&0

    KC[>CGK; ]&/)35&) (2& 0&?5&& $= 5&?3+/(1$' /'0 ,$%4&(1(1$' 4/5(1,14/'() =/,& 1' (2& 4$+1(1,/+ /5&'/ E.$+1(> DdH+=/>lW/0:l=_dXRK

    K+?#2#,&? -#6421; .$+1(1,/+ P1?2() D'0&L EU5&&0$% _$3)&HC =/>l%I54l^Zl'$#

    K+?#2.P; .$+1(>8 @/51/7+& E.$+1(> DdH9 *1(2 /001(1$'/+ 0/(/ 1%43(&0 /) 0&),517&0 1' (2& (&L(C =/>&58hl&0:l^

    K+?#2.PE (#,4+2+*+D1; : 1= .$+1(>8 vM9 ! 1= .$+1(>8 wfM9 7/)&0 $' 1%43(&0 .$+1(>8 @/51/7+&C =/>&58hl&0:l,&1IGl^

    K+?#2.PE 2-#,4+2+*+D1; : 1= .$+1(>8 vGM9 ! 1= .$+1(>8 wfGM r vM9 8 1= .$+1(>8 wfM9 7/)&0 $' 1%43(&0 .$+1(>8 @/51/7+&C=/>&58hl&0:l5%&1Il^

    K+@D?&2#+' (%'1#2.; .$43+/(1$' 0&')1(>9 4&5)$') 4&5 )Z3/5& B1+$%&(&5 E`/'B) !\\KHC =/:l,$'4&58l3;'P4

    K+@D?&2#+' M?'O; .$43+/(1$' 451%/51+> =5$% Q/2%&>&5) E8::JHV )344+&%&'(&0 7> I$5+0 `/'B E8::SH /'0 $(2&5 )$35,&)C^/(/ %1))1'? &' )$5Q$$'&L(/'( 0/(/ 4$1'() =$5 / )1'?+& ,$3'(5> 451$5 ($ !\J: 1) 1'(&54$+/(&0 1' $50&5 ($ 45$@10& /

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    29/31

    8\

    ,$'(1'3$3) (1%&G)&51&)C ;2& %/Y$51(> $= (2& 1'(&54$+/(1$' 1) 7/)&0 $' 0/(/ 4$1'() / 0&,/0& $5 +&)) /4/5(C R3( $= 8F8S?/4)9 $'+> KF /5& $@&5 (*$ 0&,/0&) +$'?9 !:J /5& 7&(*&&' $'& /'0 (*$ 0&,/0&) +$'?9 /'0 KKK $= (2& %1))1'? (1%&4&51$0) /5& )1'?+& >&/5)C ;2& )/%4+& $= /@/1+/7+& $7)&5@/(1$') 1) (2&5&7> 1',5&/)&0 =5$% 8XXKK ($ XJ:!KC T++ )3,21'(&54$+/(1$') ,$',&5' &5/) 451$5 ($ !\J: /'0 (23) 0$ '$( /==&,( (&)() ,$'03,(&0 *1(2 ,$'(&%4$5/5> )/%4+&)C;5/')=$5%&0 7> (2& '/(35/+ +$?/51(2%C:/:l>'

    K-+2%12&'2; .&5,&'( .5$(&)(/'( E#DT I$5+0U/,(7$$B $'G+1'&HC =%/5$45;'5

    /%?#6#+D1 F-&,2; P&+1?1$3) =5/,(1$'/+1&/*4l E,$01'? 7> /3(2$5)HC Y$45T*%/:$

    Z>CY"=; ]&/)35&) (2& 0&?5&& $= ,$')(5/1'( $' (2& ,21&= &L&,3(1@& *1(2 (25&& ,$01'?)A gE!H c'+1%1(&0 /3(2$51(>9 E8HD'(&5%&01/(& ,/(&?$5>9 /'0 EXH 6+1?2( ($ %$0&5/(& +1%1(/(1$')h E]/5)2/++9 a/??&5) 8::SA !MHC

    T`$1*5&7$lW/'45%;&'54l=_dXRK

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    30/31

    X:

    R;)>$ D@H)%1,-#@2#0% "2&2#12#,1

    B&-#&:?% C:1 G%&' ") G#' G&J

    T=51,/ !:888 :C8: :CK: : !

    #/4/71+1(1&) !:888 :C:! :C:K :C:: :CXF#/(2$+1, !:888 XSCK\ XFCMM :C:: \SCX:#$%4&(1(1$' E.$+1(> DdH \!!J KJCXX K:C!! :C:: !::C::#$%4&(1(1@&'&)) Ed/'2/'&'H \JXM 8JCS: 8MCKJ :C:: S:C::#$'(&)(/(1$' E#$44&0?& &( /+CH MF88 M8CSS 8JCXS :C:: !::C::^1==3)1$' !:888 G:C:8 :C!\ G!C:J 8C:8N'?+1)2 +&?/+ $51?1' !:888 :C8J :CKK :C:: !C::N(2'$G+1'?31)(1, =5/,( !:888 :C8F :C8J :C:: !C::N35$4&/' +/'?3/?& !:888 :CXX :CK8 :C:: !C::NL&,3(1@& ,$')(5/1'() E.$+1(>H \!MX M:CSM K:CX: :C:: !::C::O^. 4&5 ,/4 E+'H !:888 SCSF :C\M MCX! !:CJ\D)+/'0 !:888 :C!S :CXS : !Q/'0 /5&/ E+'H !:!JK !8C!\ 8C:M MC!\ !JC:MQ/'0 3)& MFF8 !KC8K !XCJ\ :C:K S:CJ8

    Q/'0+$,B !:888 :C!K :CXM : !Q/(1' T%&51,/ !:888 :C!S :CXF : !Q/(1(30& E+'H !:!F: G!CK: :CF\ GKCM: G:CXK]100+& N/)( !:8!8 :C!: :CX: : !]3)+1% EqH !:888 !FCMK XXCMF :C:: \\C\:.$+1(1,/+ 51?2() EU_H KF8\ K\C\F XSCK! :C:: !::C::.$+1(>8 !:888 M:CFF XJCJ: :C:: !::C::.$+1(>89 71'/5> !:888 :CXS :CKF : !.$+1(>89 (51,2$($%$3) !:888 :C\\ :CFK : 8.$43+/(1$' 0&')1(> MM!K X!MS !:X\F !S !SK88M.$43+/(1$' E23?&H !:888 :CXX :CKS : !.$43+/(1$' E+/5?&H !:888 :CXX :CKS : !.$43+/(1$' E)%/++H !:888 :CXX :CKS : !.$43+/(1$' E+'H !:888 !MCJM !CJ: !:CMS 8:C\J.5$(&)(/'( EqH !:888 !JCM! 8SCFM :C:: \FC::P&+1?1$3) =5/,( !:8!J :CK: :C8K :C:: :CFJ;35'$@&5 ET5,21?$)H \:8\ :C!K :CXK : !c57/' 4$43+/(1$' E21)($51,/+H !:888 :C!S :C!J :C:: !C::c57/' 4$43+/(1$' E,$'(&%4H J:XX KMCF: 8KCK! 8C:F !::I&)( N35$4& !:888 :C8! :CK! : !

    V/5$H ^/(/ +1%1(&0 ($ $7)&5@/(1$') 1' (2& 7&',2%/5B %$0&+C

  • 8/13/2019 GERRING SizeDemocracyRevisited

    31/31

    R;)>$ DAH>+--%?&2#+' =&:?% +F CD2,+*% G%&1D-%1

    N; P; Q; R; S; T; U; V; W;!C .$+1(>8 ,$'(1'3$3) !C:::8C .$+1(>8 (51,2$($%$3) :C\JF !C:::

    XC .$+1(>8 01,2$($%$3) :C\XK :C\!K !C:::KC NL&,3(1@& ,$')(5/1'() :C\MJ :C\!! :C\:: !C:::MC #$%4&(1(1$' :C\J! :C\K\ :CFF\ :CF\M !C:::JC .$+1(1,/+ 51?2() :C\!! :CF\K :CFJ\ :CFF: :C\:8 !C:::SC #$%4&(1(1@&'&)) :C\:: :CFSJ :CFXJ :CFJJ :CFSS :CFJS !C:::FC ;35'$@&5 :CX:\ :C8\S :CX:J :CX!J :C8\X :C8\! :CX:F !C:::\C #$'(&)(/(1$' :C\8X :CF\X :CFF! :C\:K :C\:: :C\KM :CFJF :C8\M !C:::