ggr107 - textbook notes
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
1/148
Chapter 1
Critical Thinking
-A process by which we use our knowledge and intelligence to arrive at the most
reasonable and justifiable positions on issues, and which endeavors to identify andovercome the numerous hindrances to rational thinking.
Steps involve in the process of critical thinking
Step 1: Adopt the attitude of a critical thinker
>Open-mindedness
To investigate in viewpoints different from our own
>Healthy skepticism
Doubt claims and examine the issues
>Intellectual humility
Adhering tentatively to recently acquired opinions>Free thinking
Independent mind
Restrain ones desire to believe because of social pressures to conform
>High motivation
Do necessary studying to reach a sufficient level of understanding before making
judgments.
Step 2: Recognize & avoid critical thinking hindrances
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
2/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
3/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
4/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
5/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
6/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
7/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
8/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
9/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
10/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
11/148
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
12/148
Step 3: Identify and characterize arguments
Argument = Reason + Conclusions
>Argument
-Deductive argument: if one thing follows necessarily from another
-Inductive argument: proof to a degree of probability or certainty
>Reason and conclusions are usually:
-Premises
-Evidence
-Data
-Propositions -
Proofs-Verifications
Step 4: Evaluate information sources
When doing critical appraisal, evaluate the credibility, accuracy and look for potential
biases.
Consider the questions below for the evaluation
1. Does the information source have the necessary qualifications or level of
understanding to make the claim (conclusion)?
2. Does the source have a reputation for accuracy?
3.
Does the source have a motive for being inaccurate or overly biased?
4. Are there any reasons for questioning the honesty or integrity of the source?
-Statistical information may not necessarily a good source to support argument
(Were the samples taken representative of the entire target population?)
Step 5: Evaluate arguments
Assess whether:
1. Assumptions are warranted
(Warranted assumption is one that is either known to be true or it is reasonable to
accept without requiring another argument to support it.)
According to: (i) ones own knowledge and experience (ii) the information source for
the assumption (iii) the kind of claim being made
2. Reasoning is relevant
Assess:
(i) Relevance
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
13/148
(ii)Sufficiency
3. Relevant information has been omitted
-Seek opposing arguments on the subject could help reveal omissions
Critical Appraisal Checklist
1.Identify the key arguments presented in the document
-List sub-argument and the main argument
2.
Evaluate the quality of the argument
Argument Evaluation
1.
Any ambiguity, vagueness or obscurity?2. The arguments embody any hindrances?
3. Any excessively emotional or manipulative language?
4. Credibility, relevancy, sufficiency of the reasons
3.Evaluate the quality of the evidence provided
4.Assess the potential for bias
5.Draw on course material to support your assessment and evaluation
6.Make an overall statement about the quality and strength of the document and
evaluate in general the credibility of the article
GGR107H1 - Environment, Food and People - Reading Note
Week 2 - September 21st 2012 - Chapter 1: A Practical Guide to
Critical Thinking
Defined as: a process by which we use our knowledge and intelligence to effectively
arrive at the most reasonable and justifiable positions on issues, and which tries to
identify and overcome the numerous hindrances to rational thinking
-
critical thinking is about how we use our intelligence and knowledge to reach objective
and rational viewpoints
-- critical thinkers may be better equipped to make decisions and solve problems
-critical thinking = to think rationally/objectively
to think critically...
1.adopt attitude of a Critical Thinker
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
14/148
2.Recognize and Avoid Critical Thinking Hindrances
3.Identify and Characterize Arguments
4.Evaluate Information Sources
5.Evaluate Arguments
What Critical Thinking is Not:-not thinking negatively with a predisposition to find fault or flaws
-not intended to make people think alike
-not threatening one's individuality or personality
-does not discourage or replace feelings or emotional thinking
-does not blindly support everything based on science
-arguements based on critical thinking may not always been the most persuasive
(1) Adopt the Attitude of a Critical Thinker
- you want the attitude - you want to be open minded, have healthy skepticism,
intellectual humility, free thinking, and high motivation-- must be willing to investigate viewpoints different from his or her own, but at the same
time, recognize when to doubt claims that do not merit such investigation
-- intellectual humility: means adhering tentatively to recently acquired opinions; being
prepared to examine new evidence and agruments even if such examination leads one
to discoover flaws in one's own beliefs; think in terms of 'degrees of certainty' - must
have independent mind; must not fold to pressures from society to conform - must
have a natural curiousity; seek to further understanding and work sufficiently to
evaluate multiple sides of an issue
(2) Recognize and Avoid Critical Thinking Hindrances
-
everyday we become exposed to things that hinder our ability to think clearly,accurately and fairly
-a critical thinker must understand how to recognize and avoid deception of everyday
life a) Basic Human Limitations: applies to everyone, we can never be completely
objective - confirmation bias/selective thinking: one tends to notice and look for what
confirms one's beliefs
-false memories: unconciously fill in gaps
-ignorance: lack of essential background knowledge
-testimonial evidence: relying on the testimonies and vivde ancedotes of others to
substantiate one's own beliefs (ie. dramatic stories of Bigfoot sightings do not prove the
existence of Bigfoot)
b) Use of Language: relates to choice of words; can conceal the truth, mislead, confuse
or deceive
-
ambiguity: a word/expression that can be understood in more than one way
-assuring expressions: disarm you from questioning validity (ie. As everyone knows..)
-doublespeak jargon: technical language used to make the simple seem complex -
vagueness: less precise language than the context requires c) Faulty Logic or
Perception
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
15/148
-Ad Hoc Hypothesis: a hypothesis which cannot be independently tested to refute
theory/claim
-Forer Effect: accepting vague personality descriptions that could fit anyone -
Apophenia and Superstition: errorneous perception of the connections between
unrelated events
d) Psychological and Sociological Pitfalls- Ad hominem Fallacy: criticizing the person making the argument, not the
argument itself
- communal reinforcement: a claim becomes a strong belief through repeated
assertion by members of a community
- evading the issue: someone whose been accused trying to divert attention to an
irrelevant issue
(3) Identify and Characterize Arguments
-recognize, construct, and evaluate arguments
-argument = presentation of a reason to support a conclusion (ie. dont trust john
(conclusion) because (indicator) hes a politician (reason))
-there must be one or more reason statements and one or more conclusion statements in
every argument
-- reason(s) may be synonymous with: premises, evidence, or data, proof, verification --
sometimes arguments have indicators, like because, thus, therefore, hence, which must
be picked up on
Arguments may be divided into two categories: inductive or deductive
-
deductive: if one thing follows necessarily from another (ie. All bachelors are
unmarried
--> John is a bachelor --> deductively reach the conclusion that John must be unmarried )-- deductive goes from looking at a theory, hypothesis, observations, then conclusion -
(most commonly encountered) inductive: can never prove its conclusion, but can only
support it with a degree of certainty; given the premise the conclusion is probable
-- inductive goes from looking at observations to formulating a theory
-- do not provide conclusion with necessity; they are based on reasonable grounds for
their conclusion
(4) Evaluate Information Sources
-most arguments reference facts to support conclusions (errorneous facts --> errorneous
conclusions reached)
-
must have a sound approach to evaluating the validity of facts
-sources typically cited in media or published
-- finding unbiased/objective information is often difficult
--> look for sources that are credible, unbiased, and accurate
--- depends on the source's qualifications, integrity and reputation *stats
are an easy way to fool people - ask yourself, were the samples taken
representative of the entire target population?
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
16/148
(5) Evaluate Arguments (3) Step Process 1.
assess whether assumptions are warranted:
- assumption: reasons implied in an argument that are taken for granted to be true -
warranted assumption is: known to be true, or is reasonable to accept without requiring
another argument to support it^ unwarranted if it fails to meet these requirements
2. assess whether reasoning (evidence) is relevant and sufficient:
-relevance can be thought of as 'quality' of the reasoning, and sufficiency as the
'quantity' of the reasoning
^good arguments should have both
-- sufficiency can be thought of in terms of 'reasonable doubt'; understand how you
determine reasonable doubt --> maintain attitude of critical thinker, be aware of
hindrances to critical thining, ask yourself the purpose or consequences of the
argument, become aware of the contemporary standards of evidence for the subject,
and finally the evidence should be as strong as the conclusion being asserted 3. assess
whether relevant information has been omitted - omissions:
-a cogent argument is one which presents all relevant reasoning (evidence), not just
evidence that supports the argument
-arugments that omit relevant evidence can appear to be stronger than they really are
-so, determine if important evidence has been left out
-- can be unintentionally, or done purposely
Week 2 - September 21st 2012 - Chapter 2: Geography: It's
Developments, Research Themes, and Concepts
-
our world is becoming intimately more interconnected via internet, the media, greateraccess to improved transportation networks -- geography helps provide a deeper
understanding of how and why difference exist, how poeple and goods move from
place
to place, and how people relate to each other and with their environment
*ozone depletion, droughts, global warming etc
-humans place high demands on the environment, especially those in urban areas - core
of human geography: looks at how human needs are met and the networks required for
transportation of goods
-
the Canadian Council for Geographic Education defines geography in terms of what
geographers do, and what they study; geography is a discpline devoted to answer
questions related to the biophysical world and to human systems
-ask questions like: why is it there? where is something? how did it get there? how does
it interact with other things? what alternative location exist to situate this activity? what
might be expected in the future? how can benefits be best distributed?
-we are interested in how thigns are interrelated in different regionss over space and
time
--> provide evidence of spatial systems
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
17/148
-geography is often referred to as the spatial science; description of earth, study of
spatial variation (how and why)
-geography matters on a personal scale (being able to get around campus,
neighbourhoods etc) and on a larger scale (corporations being able to make decisions
about where to locate manufacturing plants/warehouses in relation to transportation
routes/target market)-United Nation's Secretary-General, Kofi Annan: believes work of UN is similiar to
work of geographer -- many of the problems facing humanity (climate change,
population, consumption, poverty, and sustainable development) require attention be
paid to importance of peole, borders and science
(4) areas where geographers could make meaningful contributions:
1.the classroom - put students in contact with a world beyond their immediate
community
2.geographic technology - GIS could allow for the creation of warning systems for
natural disasters --> better planning
3.
Millennium Ecosystem Assessment - maps the health of the planet
4.Database by the Geographic Information Working Group
-geography is about space, and the content of space in the past, present and in the future
-geography is concerned about human aspects and biophysical (human/physical geo) -
content of an area has physical and cultural aspects, and geography is always concerned
with understanding both (ie. The Alps; thinking of this place brings to mind skiing and
mountains)
Evolution of the Discipline
-
first - early greek philosophers-geography's name was coined by Greek scientist Eratosthenes over 2200 years ago
-geo ' the earth' and graphein 'to write'
*from the start, writing focused on the physical structure of earth, and the nature and
activities of the people who inhabited the different lands of the known world -
Strabo (ca. 64bce to ace 20) on the tasks of geograpghy: to describe the several parts of
the world, to assess the countries of the world and to treat the differences between
countries
-- Greek, and later Roman geographers measured the earth, devised the global grid of
parallels and meridians and drew upon that grid maps of their known world
**looked at latitudinal variations in climate
*attention placed on what humans did in home and distant areas -- looked at language,
religion, custom, how they used, altered and destroyed the lands they were on etc. --
Strabo cautioned against the assumption that the nature and actions of humans were
determined by the physical environment they inhabited -- he believed we were active
elements in a human-environment partnership
In Europe...
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
18/148
- modern geography as we know it came from Europe during the surge of scholary
inquiry in the 17th century
-- political and social trends influenced what geographers did, and how technological
developments influenced how geographers applied their knowledge
--> Immanuel Kant (1724-1804) - philosophical foundation: a German scholar - felt
geography was an important discipline because it provided spatial and historicalperspectives
-
also felt it important to understand how events occured and changed over time
and space
--> Alexander von Humboldt (1769-1859) and Carl Ritter (1779-1859) - developed
geography as an indepedent branch of study: Humboldt wrote a paper describing the
physical geography of many regions of the world, with a focus on the interactions
between humans and nature, and made comparisons about people and places --
comparability and detailed observations gave scientific credibility to his work --> Carl
Ritter: keen observer of the landscape, looked at the interconnections and
interrelationships that defined regions* Ritter and Humboldt's writings furthered geographic studies by comparing different
parts of the world with each other in order to provide general statements or laws
--> Renaissance Period (1350-1750): european exploration prompted governments to
map new territories
-Gerardus Mercator developed a map that allowed explorers to maintain a compass
bearing along a straight line drawn on his projection
-major developments in surveying and mapping at this time --> allowed for more
accurate maps to be produced
*maps became important with trade among nations-map making (cartography) became dominant aspect of the discipline at this time
-19th century (1800s): introduction of census data and trade statistics to give a firmer
foundation to human geographic investigation
-at this time, saw active participation by influential individuals and government officials
in independent geographic societies, which promoted exploration and held meetings to
hear about far away places from guest speakers
*during this time, geography was largely concerned with mapping, and providing
descriptive inventories of newly explored and colonized places
-
growing importance of geography recognized in late 1800s
-- importance highlighted by the Prussian (now German) government's decision in 1874
to establish permanent chairs of geography at all its universities --> geography as an
academic discipline
-Britian has first department in 1900
-USA has first department in Chicago 1903
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
19/148
*differences exist among nations about how geography should be practised
ie. British geographers were committed to regional geography & physical
geography vs. Americans who did not share this level of interest
** this difference may be attributed to 'excesses of environmental determinism' --
Environmental Determinism: a belief held in the mid 1800s to the mid 1900s which
held that the environmental largely determined human activities and landscapes
-1950s; a sense of disappointment emerged and grew among geographers in North
America that realized that much of their work was becoming irrelevant and provided
only superficial analysis
-- Fred Schaefer (1904-1953): challenged the discipline to adopt more scientific
approaches. His view: geographers should be developing laws that explained location
that might differentiate regions, rather than providing endless descriptions of the world
-1960s; systematic geography become more popular in response ^^ in Britian, USA, and
Canada
-
systematic geographers studied the processes of systems - human and physical
-- worked on regional level provide solutions to problems/understand problems better -
developed a way to get systematic data via reliable published sources; census or traffic
records
-statistical techniques improved with technology ; able to simulate models of systems to
predict future
-mainstream human geography was concerned with urban and economic geography:
focus on the measure of direction, distance, and connectivity = spatial interaction -
generalizations reached via combining geo information with economic theories
-
late 1960s to 1970s; quantitative approach to geography was criticized because many ofits theories provided for poor explanation and/or prediction of actual human use of and
patterns on the landscape
-- shortcomings reflect assumptions made like: people would always make money based
on economic gain
-a new development: geographic research should combine decision making theories
from psychology and sociology with geography's spatial concepts
-since 1970s - two important influences - social and technological - can be identified as
drivers behind developments since the late 1960s
-1960s: public concern for issues like poverty, civil rights, women's rights, Vietnam
War, sexual freedom etc were rising
-- Radical geography: promoted a greater understanding of why and how problems were
evident in space and radical geographers wanted to redress many of the inequities that
were present in socities, particularly those in many developing countries
*term radical applied to these ideas because in most instances, some form of socialism
was seen as the solution to problems emanating from capitalist economies
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
20/148
-- socialism: a form of economic and social organization based on common ownership of
means to produce and distribute products
*we now realize that political and economic systems can influence human impact on the
environment
Technology
-new techonology has influenced the discipline, particularly those related to mapping
and analysis
-satellite use vs. labour intensive exercise by surveyor
-computer based analysis provides more detailed insights and for the manipulation of
large data sets; GIS and remote sensing are big in geography at the moment
Development of Geography in Canada...
-the Canadian Association of Gepgrahers was started in 1951 in MTL; 65 people
attended meeting
-the CAG directory 2003 identified 46 departments of geography across the country, 21
having Ph. D. programs
-- in early development, there was a strong relationship between CAG and the public
service, particularly the Geographical Branch and the Defence Research Board -- this
relationship primarily focused on military geography, the development of Canada's
north, and mapping and analyzing the spatial distribution of populations, cities, and
economic activities
--- Putman suggested that the 'duty of Canadian geographers should be to pursue Canadia
population, Canadian unity, and Canadian outlook on the world
*Canadian geography focuses on large size of country, and challenges posed for
transportation, communication, resource development, cultural diversity and populationn
distribution
-between the 1960s and 1990s, the focus of research shifted from economic
considerations to ones that were often informed by social theory and political economy -
- Wheeler (2002): the use of maps, which had been the traditonal centrepieced of
geographic analysis, has declined
-human-environmental relations have moved beyond environmental determinism,
possiblism and probablism to include --> political ecology, international development,
sustainable development, environmental management, and issues related to human
health
Primary Geographic Research Themes
-according to the Canadian Councial for Geographic Education, there are 6 themes
forming the core
1. World in Spatial Terms: refers to the use of maps and other geographic
representation, tools and techniques to acquire, process and report information
2. Places and Regions: study of a region, the physical and human characteristics of
it; interconnections between society and environment in a specific location
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
21/148
3. Physical Systems: study of the plants/animals in the world 4. Human Systems:
examines spatial organization of society
5.Society and the Environment:
6.Uses of Geography
Human Geography: deals with the world as it is, and with the world as it might be madeto be
- emphasis is on people: where they are, what they are like, how they interact over
space, what kind of landscpaes of human use do they erect on the natural landscapes they
occupy
- human geography serves the objectives of a liberal education; helps us to
understand the world, appreciate circumstances affecting people/countries other than our
own, clarifies the contrasts in societies and cultures and in the human landscapes they
have created in different regions of the earth
* generates better informed citizens, better able to problem solve
Background Basics - Core Geographic Concepts
-
asking questions like: what is it, where is it? how did it come to be what and where it
is? where is it in relation to other things that affect it or are affected by it? how is it part
of a functioning whole? how does it's location affect people's lives and the content of
the area in which it is found
-space: implies areal extent and may be understood in both and absolute or relative
sense
-absolute - objectively and physically real with measurable extend and definable
boundaries
-relative - perceptual and variable, not permanent over time; space can be seen as
socially produced
-
place: companion concept to space, synonym for location or in terms of humangeography, relates to the attributes and values we individually associate with a location
(ie. hometown and neighbourhood, the university we attend, the highschool we
graduate from)
*my sense of place will not be the same as someone else's who cannot form the same
relationships to an area as I can
-placelessness: reduction in the uniqqueness of formerly separated locales and cultures -
spatial: used by geographers as a modifier in framing their questions and forming their
concepts - geography is a spatial science they say, cocerned with spatial relationships
between people and the earth, spatial behaviour of people, and spatial processes that
create/maintain spatial behaviours in people
* the geographers space: the earth space, the surface area occupied or available to beoccupied by humans
...basic observation about location and nature of a space can be important;
-places have location, direction and distance with respect to others
-a place has a size (so scale is important)
-a place has both a physical and cultural structure
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
22/148
-attributes of a place change and develop with time
-elements of a place interrelate with other places
-content of places is structured and explainable
-places may be generalized into regions of sim. and diffs.
^ means by which geographers express fundamental observations about the earth spaces
they examine
Location, Direction and Distance
-everyday ways of assessing space around us and identifying our position in relation to
other items and places of interest
-also essential in understanding the processes of spatial interaction that figure so
importantly in the study of human geography
-- location of places/objects is starting point for all geographic study
-absolute location; identification of place by some precise and accepted system of
coordinates (global grid of parallels and meridians)
-unique to a described place, independent of any other characteristics or observations,
and has value in the legal description of places (say in measure distances between
separating places, or in finding directions between places on earth's surface)
-relative location; position of a place in relation to that of other places/acitivities; shows
interconnections/interdependence -- direction is the second universal spatial concept
-can also be expressed in absolute or relative terms; absolute direction is based on the
cardinal points of north, south, east, west while relative direction references are often
culturally based and locationally variable, despite reference to cardinal compass points
(ie. saying out West, down South, Far Eastern)
-- distance is the third universal spatial concept
-can also be expressed in absolute or relative terms; absolute distance refers to the
spatial separation between two points on the earth's surface measured by some acceptedstandard unit
* people often think of distance in time; 20 minutes by bus, 5 minutes walking
**psychological transformation of distance; sometimes a walk may seem longer than it is
for whatever reason
Size and Scale
- when we say that a place may be large or small, we speak both of the nature of
the place itself and of the generalizations that can be made about it
-- geographers use scale on different levels --> you may want to look at population or
agriculture on a local scale, regional scale or global scale
*scale may relate to the size of the units being studied
-- more technically, scale tells us the mathematical relationship between the size of an
area on a map, and the actual size of the mapped area of the surface of the Earth
*scale is an essential feature to every map
-- scale implies the degree of generalization represented (ie. at a national scale stats
Canada reports the median income of Canadians in 2000 was $55000, however, on a
provincial scale, the median income varied from province to province
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
23/148
Physical and Cultural Attributes
- all places have physical and cultural attributes that distinguish them from other
places and give them character, potential and meanings
- geogrphers are concerned with identifying and analyzing the details of those
attributes, and recognizing the interrelationship between the physical and culturalcomponents of area: the human-environmental interface
-- physical characteristics = climate, soil, the presence or absense of water supplies and
mineral resources, terrain features etc
*such natural landscape attributes provide the setting within which human actions
occurs; they shape, but don't dictate how people live (ie. a resource base is physically
determined, though how the resources are preceived and utilized is culturally conditioned
- the natural environmental simultaneously presents advantages and drawbacks with
which humans must deal
-- however, in occupying a place, people modify it's environmental conditiosn
*Environment Canada
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
24/148
-spatial diffusion: the process of dispersion of an idea or an item from a centre of origin
to more distant points with which it is directly or indirectly connected
*rate and extent influenced by distance separating origin and centre which later adopt
practices/technology
** rates also influenced by population density, means of communication
-geography's study of dynamic spatial relationship recognizes that spatial interaction is a
fundamental organizing principle of human life on earth (globalization)
-- globalization: implies the increasing interconnection of peoples and societies in all
parts of the world as the full range of social, cultural, political, economic, and
environmental processes become international in scale and effect
The Structured Content of Place
-how are objects distributed in an area - placement of schools or grocery stores in a town
^ questions such as these carry the conviction that the contents of an area are
comprehensibly arranged or structured
-- arrangement of items of earth's surface is known as spatial distribution, and may be
analyzed by the elements common to all spatial distributions: density, dispersion, pattern
--> density: a measure of the number or quantity or anything within a defined unit of area
*a count of items in relation to the area in which they are found
-arithmetic density: absolute relationship, population per square km
-- sometimes it is more meaningful to relate item numbers to a specific kind of area -->
Physiological density is a measure of the number of persons per unit area of arable land
* densities are normally employed comparatively, relative to one another
--> dispersion: a statement of the amount of spread of a phenomenon over an area-tells you how far things are spread out
-
close together = clustered = agglomerated
-spread out = dispersed = scattered
*something that might be clustered at one scale may be considered dispered at another
scale
--> pattern: geometric arrangement of objects in space
-a term refering to distribution, but emphasizes design over spacing
-centralized pattern: items concentrated around a single node
-
random pattern: unstructured irregular distribution
Place Similarity and Regions
1.no two places on the surface of Earth can be exactly the same
2.the physical and cultural content of an area and the dynamic interconnections of
people and places show patterns of spatial similarity
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
25/148
-recognizing the existence of spatial regularities allows use to define regions -- regions
are earth areas that display significant elements of internal uniformity and external
difference from surrounding territories
-regions are devised; they are spatial summaries designed to bring order to diversity of
the earth's surface
Types of Regions
-may be formal, functional ad perceptual
-- formal region: one of essential uniformity in one or a limited combination of physical
or cultural features (ie. home province)
-- the formal region is the largest area over which a valid generalization of attribute
uniformity may be made
-- functional region: may be visualized as a spatial system; its part are interdependent,
and throughout its extent the functional region operates as a dynamic, organizational unit
-- perceptula regions: less rigorously structured, they reflect feelings and images rather
than objective data and because of that may be more meaningful in the lives and actions
of those who recognize them
GGR107 CHAPTER 2 - Geography: Its Developments,
Research Themes and Concepts
Geography literally means description of the earth
Definition:The study of spatial variation, of how - and why - physical and culturalitems differ from place to place.
Decisions made by corporations about the locations of manufacturing plants orwarehouses in relation to transportation routes and markets are spatially rooted
-on an even grander scale, judgements about the protection of national power, orthe claim and recognition of spheres of influence and interest among rival
countries are related to the implications of distance and area
Four areas where geographers can make significant contributions:
1.The geography classroom should put students in contact with the world beyondtheir immediate community in order that they learn about distant people andplaces
2.
Geographic technologies, i.e. Geographic information systems, could allow for thedevelopment of early warning systems about natural disasters andenvironmental threats, and better plan our cities, especially in the developingworld
3.Geographers could contribute to the Millennium Ecosystem Assessment, whichwill map the health of the planet
4.The development of a common UN Geographic Database by the Geographic
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
26/148
Information Working Group is another specific geographically oriented initiative
Greek, and later Roman geographers measured the earth, devised the global grid ofparallels and meridians (marking latitudes and longitudes), and drew upon thatgrid surprisingly sophisticated maps of their known world. They explored the
apparent latitudinal variations in climate and described in numerous works thefamiliar Mediterranean basin and the more remote, partly rumoured lands ofNorthern Europe, Asia and equatorial Africa.
Immanuel Kant (1724 - 1804) - German scholar
- Influenced the early development of geography by suggesting that disciplines thatprovided temporal (history) and spatial (geography) perspectives were just as or
more important than disciplines such as economics and sociology, which focusedon specific considerations
- He also implied that history and geography were not merely about memorizing
dates and place names respectively. It was important to understand how eventsoccurred and changed over time and space. Since everything occurs in time andspace, geography and history are defined by the perspective they provide and notby the subject matter (people, groups, culture, trade)
Environmental determinism - Between the mid 1800s and mid 1900s, manygeographers in Europe and North America, studied how humans interacted with
their environment, assumed that the environment largely determined humanactivities and landscapes
Possibilism - Did not deny that the environment placed some limits on humanactivities, it promoted that a more important factor to consider were the choicesmade by people in response to the opportunities and constraints provided by theenvironment
Probabilism - Lies between environmental determinism and possibilism - suggests
that based on the nature of the environment, humans will be more likely to makecertain decisions over other ones. For instance, if forests are in relatively scarcesupply, homes may be more frequently constructed from clay or stone rather thanwood.
Systematic geographers studied the processes of systems - human, (economic,transportation, political, cultural) and physical (water, geomorphic, climatic) - oftenoperating within functional and administrative regions in order that problemscould be understood and solutions provided
-A key focus was the measurement of direction, distance and connectivity - thegeometry of space or what is termed spatial interaction
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
27/148
Development based on traditional measures such as the accumulation of wealth ora rise in a nations gross national product (GNP), was being questioned. Radicalgeographies, which include the philosophies of Marxism and structuralism,adopted a progressive social agenda and provided two contributions to geography.
1.As a body of knowledge, radical geographies promoted a greater understanding
of why and how social problems were evident in space. Ex. Examining whypeople moved to specific houses, behaviouralists and logical positivists wouldfocus attention on issues of choice, preference and/or cost. A radical geographerwould question the role of land developers and urban planners/managers indetermining which sites were built upon, the style of housing available andlocation relative to undesirable land uses.
2.As a social movement, they wanted to redress many of the inequities that werepresent in societies, particularly those in many developing countries. The termradical was applied to these ideas because in most instances, some form of
socialism was seen as the solution to problems emanating from market-driven
(capitalist) economies.3.Socialism is a form of economic and social organization based on commonownership of means to produce and distribute products. It contrasts capitalism,
based on private ownership of production, as the dominant form of economicand social organization in the world.
Primary geographic research themes:
1.World in Spatial Terms - the use of maps and other geographic representations,tools and technologies to acquire, process and report information. In this way,the spatial variation and interrelationships among people, places andenvironments are communicated
2.
Places and Regions - The physical and human systems, their spatial relationships,interactions between society and environment in specific locational settings
3.Physical systems - biophysical systems - physical processes shape Earths surface
ad interact with plant and animal life to create, sustain and modify the culturaland natural environment
4.Human systems - Spatial organization of society, which is a mosaic of populationmovements, settlement patterns, economic activity, transportation,communication, and political organizations
5.Society and the Environment
Core Geographic Concepts:1.Space- implies areal extent and may be understood in both and absolute and a
relative sense.Absolute space- objectively and physically real with measurableextent and definable boundaries. Space is fundamental to areal relationshipsbetween physical and cultural features on the earths surface and is basic to such
geographic interests as making maps, analyzing distributions, and conductingspatial analysis of locational patterns.
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
28/148
2.Relative space- perceptual, not objective, and variable, not permanent, overtime. In this relative sense, space can be seen as socially produced, reflectingactivities and the interrelationships between activities. Since activities andrelationships are constantly changing, relative space adjusts in size and form inresponse to developing socioeconomic processes and the passage of time.
3.
Place- synonym for location - attributes and values we individually associatewith location. The attributes and culture of places shape the lives and outlooks ofthose who inhabit them in ways basic to the socioeconomic patterning of theworld. The sense of place is reinforced by recognized local and regionaldistinctiveness. It may be diminished or lost and replaced by a feeling ofplacelessness.
Places have location, direction, and distance with respect to other places
A place has size, it may me large or small. Scale is important.
A place has both physical structure and cultural content
The attributes of places develop and change over time
The elements of places interrelate with other places
The content of places is structured and explainable
Places may be generalized into regions of similarities and differences
Location:
-Absolute location - Identification of place by some precise and accepted systemof coordinates; it therefore is sometimes called mathematical location (global gridof parallels and meridian - with it absolute location can be accurately described byreference to its degrees, minutes, and seconds of latitude and longitude) Relative
location - the position of a place in relation to that of other places or activities -spatial interconnection and interdependence and may carry social and economicimplications - on a larger scale, relative location tells us that people, things, andplaces exist not in a spatial vacuum but in a world of physical and culturalcharacteristics that differ from place to place
Chapter 2- Introduction Geography: Its
Developments. Research Themes, and Concepts
Geography is often referred to as the spatialscience, that is, the disciplineconcerned with the use of earth space. In fact,geographyliterally means
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
29/148
"description of the earth ," but that task is really the responsibility of nearlyall the sciences.
Geography might be better defined as the study of spatial variation, of how and whyphysical and cultural items differ from place to place on thesurface of the earth. It is, further, the study of how observable spatial
patterns evolved through time.
There are simple examples of the observation that "space matter" in a verypersonal way. You cannot avoid the implications of geography in youreveryday affairs. Your understanding of your hometown, yourneighbourhood, or your campus is essentially a geographic understanding.
United Nations` Secretary of General Kofi Annan believed that the work of
the United Nations and the work of geographers shared a great deal incommon because of the many of the problems facing humanity climatechange, population, consumption, poverty, and supporting the achievementof sustainable development for all people of the world required attention
to be paid to the importance of people, borders, and science.
In 2001, Kofi Annan identified four areas where geographers throughout theworld could make a meaningful contribution`:
First the geography classroom should put students in contact with the
world beyond their immediate community in order that they learnabout distant people and places.
Second, that geographic technologies, such as geographic information
system, could allow for the development of early warning systemsabout natural disasters and environmental threats, and better planour cities, particularly in the developing world
Third, geographers could contribute to the Millenium Ecosystem
Assessment, which will map the health of the planet.
Fourth, the development of a common UN Geographic Database by
the Geographic Information Working Group is another specificgeographically oriented initiative.
Spotlight Box 2.1
Modern geography is both a physical and social sciences, and fosters a wealth
of technical skills
2.2 Evolution of the Discipline
Geography`s name was reputedly coined by the Greek scientistErathosthenes from the wordsgeo, "the earth" and graphein, "to write."
Greek (and , later, Roman) geographers measured the earth, devised theglobal grid of parallels and meridians (marking latitudes and longitudes),their grid was sophisticated of their known world. They employed modern
concepts, they described river systems, explored causes of erosion, patternof disposition, cited dangers for deforestation, described areal variations in
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
30/148
the natural landscape, and noted the consequences of abuse on theenvironment.
2.3 The Evolution of Geography in Europe
Immanuel Kant, a German scholar, influences the early development ofgeography by suggesting that disciplines that provided temporal (history)and spatial (geography) perspectives were just as or more important thatdisciplines such as economics and sociology which focus on specificconsiderations. In his view it was important to understand how eventsoccurred and changed over time and space.
2.4 Primary Geographic Research themes
According to the Canadian Council for Geographic Education, 6 themes form
the core of the discipline:
The first element is the "World in Spatial Terms"- which refers to themap and the use of other geographic representations, tools and
technologies to acquire
The second element is the "Places and Regions"- the physical andhuman system, their spatial relationship, interactions betweensociety and environment in specific locational settings.
The third element is "Physical Systems" or "Biophysical System" thestudy of plants and animals that inhabit the world with us
2.6 Some Background Basics
2.6.1 Core Geographic Concepts
Absolute space
is objectively and physically real with measurable extent
and definable boundaries
Relative space is perceptual not objective, and variable, not permanent,over time.
Place is the companion concept to space. Place is a synonym for location.
2.7.1 Location
Absolute location-- is the identification of place by some precise andaccepted system of coordinates; it is sometimes called mathematical location
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
31/148
Relative location the position of a place in relation to that of other places oractivities
Site an absolute location concept, refers to the physical and cultural
characteristics and attributes of the places itself. It is more than themathematical location, for it tells us something about the internal features ofthat place.
2.7.2 Direction
Direction is the second universal spatial concept. Like location it has morethan 1 meaning.
Absolute directionis based on the cardinal points of north, south , east and
west.
In Canada we commonly use Relational direction, we go "out West" or "down
South"
2.7.3 Distance
Absolute distancerefers to the spatial separation between two point onthe earth`s surface measured by some accepted standard unit such as milesor kilometres for widely separated locales, feet or metres for more closelyspaced points
Relative distancetransforms those linear measurements into other unitsmore meaningful for the space relationship in question.
2.11 Interrelation between places
Spatial Interactionplaces interact with other places in structured andcomprehensible ways.
ConnectivityA broader concept implying all the tangible and intangibleways in which places are connected: by telephone lines, street and roadsystems.
Spatial diffusionthe process of dispersion of an idea or an item from acentre of origin to more distant points with which it is directly or indirectlyconnected.
Globalizationimplies the increasing interconnectionof peoples andsocieties in all parts of the world as the full range of social cultural, political,
economic, and environmental processes becomes international in scale andeffect.
2.12 The Structured Content of Place
The arrangement of items on the earth's surface is called Spatial Distribution
and may be analyzed by the elements common to all spatial distributions:density, dispersion, and pattern
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
32/148
2.12.1 Density
The measure of the number or quantity of anything within a defined unit ofarea is its density.
It is not the counts of items but of items in relation to the space in which they
are found.
Physiological density is a measure of the number of person per unit area ofarable land.
2.12.2 Dispersion
Dispersion (or its opposite, concentration) is a statement of the amount of
spread f a phenomenon over an area. It tells us not how many or how muchbut how far things are spread out.
If they are close together spatially, they are considered clusters oragglomerated. If they are spread out, they are dispersed or scattered.
2.12.3 Pattern The geometric arrangement of objects in space is called pattern.
A centralized pattern may involve items concentrated around a single node.
A random pattern may be the best description of an unstructured irregulardistribution
2.13 Place Similarity and Regions
The distinctive characteristics of the places in content and structure
immediately suggest two geographical important ideas. The first is that no
two places on the surface of the earth can be exactly the same. Not only dothey have different absolute locations, but as in the features of the human
face -- the precise mix of physical and cultural characteristics of a place isnever exactly duplicated.
-
Chapter 3: Agricultural Systems3.1 Introduction
Agriculture or farming is rearing animal and harvest crops
It involves the interaction between people and the environment
It has lasted over 10,000 years
Plants and animals spread from the near east into southern-eastern Europe
Methods of trading began with the Greek and then was adopted by theRomans
Agriculture is from the Latin word agar and Greek word agros meaning field
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
33/148
3.2 The agri-ecosystem
Unlike many aspects of economic activity the contributions of the physical
environment can contribute to nature
Humans are now able to modify plants and crops
The purpose is to harvest the greater number of crops
Farmers use harmful technologies and chemical to produce these crops
3.3 Climate and agriculture
The greatest limitations can be soil type, nutrient availability, topographyand drainage
Even modern plant breeding has its limits
3.3.1 Temperature
Both plant and animal growth needs to be grown in at a certain temperature
There are also different growing seasons for crops
There is usually an optimum yield
Each crops has a critical temperature range (C3 and C4 crops)
The minimum amount is where there is insufficient heat
The optimum at rates of metabolic processes are at their maximum
The maximum beyond growth ceases
Some crop require different amounts of times; some grow during the daywhile others at night
4 different types of crops
Short day, long night: with a photoperiod of under ten hours e.g. soybean,
sweet potatoes, millet. These occur at low latitudes where spring andautumn are warm enough to allow their harvest cycle to be completed
Long day/ Short night with a photoperiod of over 14 hours e.g. small grains,timothy, sweet clover. High latitudes
Intermediate day, with a photoperiod of 12-14 hours and an inhibition ofreproduction either above or below these levels
Day-neutral unaffected by day length
This is important to farmers because they can use their time and space
correctly
There are different growing seasons based on geography
3.3.2 Water Water is important for agriculture
Water provides nutrients for plants
Water can also carry pesticides and chemical from plants causing healthconcerns
Irrigation impacts crop productivity
The salt and alkaline levels of the water can cause problems
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
34/148
3.4 Agricultural Soils
Primary agricultural management practice is the cultivation of soil
Soil can vary due to structure, depth, nutrient content and acidity
Deeper the soil the better it is at storing minerals
Soils that are less deep are not able to store soils
Soil texture is also important for the draining of water
Acidity can also decide whether or not the plant will thrive
3.4.1 Soil Classification
V.V. Dokuchaev developed a method for classifying soils
Three basic types of soils are zonal, intra-zonal and azonal
The United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) produced aclassification known as the seventh Approximation
This recognized 12 different soil orders
The worlds soil map shows trends i.e. unproductive soil in in the northern
hemisphere
3.5 Energy
A range of physical factors that effect agricultural distribution
Energy can be created through photosynthesis
Fertilizers can be used to reduce the amount of energy humans put in
Energy is transferred through a cycle (Figure 3.3)
Energy yield differs fro different crops
The energy ratio: the edible amount of energy produced in net form
The gross energy productivity (GEP): total food energy produced per system
The surplus energy income: energy not consumed by people e.g. crops fed to
animals
The energy yield can come in net food output per hectare
Increase the amount of energy by replacing man power with machines
3.6 Climate change and agriculture
Climate change affects the distribution of crops
Out predictions for the future lead to reduction in crop yield
Long term effects of sea levels rising could destroy crops
Tropical regions that have fertile land can be affected causing unfertile soil
Crop yield analysis can be used to determine growth factors
Different strategies for different farmland systems
Highlighted the role of technological innovations to improve the workplace
It allows us to perform research on areas
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
35/148
3.7 Classifying agricultural systems
Variation in the type of farm management have been summarized: biologicaldiversity, intensity of human management, net energy balance, andmanagement responsibility
Differences in the agricultural systems allows for classification
3.7.1 Land Classification
Based on the physical properties of the land
E.g. the topography, soils and vegetation
UK has a land classification method
Depending on the area certain land is suitable for growing crops on
3.7.2 Land use classification
Focuses on what the land could be used for
It was popularized by J.C. Weaver when he realized that certain crops could
be grown in the same region, crop-combination regions
Classifications may omit crops that are important in financial terms
3.7.3 Type of farming regions
Type of farming depends on crops, livestock, intensity of land use,
processing and disposal of farm procedures, methods and degree of farmmechanisms and types of building and other structures associated with
agriculture Applying this method is important for statistical analysis
3.8 Conclusion
Physical factors can control agricultural activity, but socio-economic and
political factors are more influential in the decision
Other important factors also include tenure, landownership, farm size,
marketing, transport and labour supply and social and cultural variables
GGR107: Chapter 3 NotesGiovanni Sacco
Agriculture is the rearing of animals and the production of crops throughcultivating soil
Agriculture geography includes; spatial distribution of crops and livestock,
the systems of management employed, the nature of links to the broadereconomic, social, cultural, political and ecological systems, the spectrum offood production, processing, marketing and consumption.
6 key factors influence the distribution of farming types, they are:
1.Biological 2.Physical
3. Economic
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
36/148
4. Political
5. Socio-cultural
6. Marketing (food trade)
Reciprocal relationship between environmental factors/agricultural activity(environment affects the nature of farming, and farming affects the
environment)
Agri-ecosystems are simpler, less diverse and not as complex as naturalecosystems
Constraints on agriculture:
1. Average temperatures
2. Amount of precipitation
3. Annual distribution
Each crop has an optimal temperature for growth, the critical temperaturesare:
1. The minimum, below this there is insufficient heat for biological
activity2. The optimum, metabolic processes at their maximum
3. The maximum, beyond which growth stops, higher temperaturecan be harmful or lethal
Some crops are photoperiodic, meaning they need different amounts ofdaylight for optimal growth, there are four main groups:
1. Short-day/long night (low altitude)
2. Long-day/short night (high altitude)
3. Intermediate day (photoperiod of 12-14hrs)
4.
Day-neutral (unaffected by different daylengths) Water is necessary for agriculture, mainly through
precipitation, but farmers can work around problems withnatural water supplies using irrigation methods
Cultivation is the primary method for agricultural management, soil is wherewater, minerals and nutrients are stored that enable plant growth
Soil texture is important, it influences moisture/particle size
Depth in soil also important, greater depth allows for more deposit of water
and minerals
Acidity is another important factor in soil, measures on the PH scale:
-------------------------|-----------------------0(most acidic) 7(neutral) 14(most alkaline)
A way of classifying soils and understanding the relations between soil
properties and environmental factors:
o Climate o
Parent
material o
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
37/148
Biotic factors
oRelief
o Time thefactors have
operated
3 basic soil classes (table 3.2 on page 54)
1. zonal
2. intra-zonal
3. azonal
U.S soil taxonomy shows soil orders based on 12 orders, each with distinctcharacteristics (table 3.3 page 55)
Solar radiation provides the fundamental energy source to support plant and
animal growth, this energy drives the cycling of nutrients throughagriecosystems, aspects of this are the carbon and nitrogen cycles
Ways to keep nitrogen levels suitable in soil were invented in order to
enable optimal land use, for example the Norfolk crop rotation wasdeveloped for this purpose, the whole idea behind it was to allow for the soiltime to regenerate its nitrogen levels.
Key technologies mediating climate variations are mechanical innovations
(irrigations) and biological science (hybrids)
Effects of global warming would ultimately be hindered by both structuralresistance and hindered by both structural resistances and farmerdecisionmaking behavior
Farm management has been summarized with four main parameters:
1. Biological diversity
2.
Human management3. Net energy balance
4. Management responsibility
Land classification regions are based on physical properties and landcapability, physical properties include; topography, soils and vegetation
Soil characteristics are especially important
Land use classification is based on the way land is used, popularized by J.C
Weaver who had the idea of crop-combination regions which showed
regional productions usually includes combinations of crops as apposed toonly one
Type-of farming classifications, based on individual farms that have manyvariables including production and management, and information on yields,crops and livestock
Modern type of farming classifications are based on 5 criteria:
1. Crop/livestock association
2. Intensity of land use
3. Processing/disposal of farm produce
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
38/148
4. Methods/degree of farm mechanization
5. Type association of buildings and structures associated
with agriculture 7 types of enterprise:
1. dairy cattle
2. beef cattle
3.
sheep
4. cash crops
5. fruit
6. vegetables
7. pigs/poultry
Although physical factors can exert controls on agricultural activity, it issocio-economic/political factors that determine detailed characteristics of afarm enterprise
According to farmers the nature of land at their disposal is influenced by ecologicalfactors such as population pressure, technological innovation, structures of social
organizations and societal val
Chapter 4 Exam Review
Soil and Agriculture Soil-is a complex plant supporting system consisting of disintegrated rock,
organic matter, water, gases, nutrients and microorganisms
Soil consists roughly of half mineral matter with organic matter and the other
half pore space taken up with air, water and soil gases The organic matter in soil consists of living and dead microorganisms as well as
decaying plant and animal matter
The composition of soil can have as great an effect on a regions ecosystem as
does climate or temperature
Formation of soil
Parent material- is the base geological material in a particular location. It can
include lava or volcanic ash; rock or sediment deposited by glaciers
Bedrock-the continuous mass of solid rock that makes up the earths crust
The process responsible for soil formation are weathering, erosion and the
deposition and decomposition of organic matter
Weathering-is the physical, chemical, biological processes that break down
rocks and minerals turning larger particles into smaller [articles.
Physical weathering-breaks down rock without changing the parent material
Chemical weathering-results when water or other substances chemically
interact with parent material (example acidic ground water)
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
39/148
Biological weathering-occurs when living things break down parent material
through physical or chemical means (example trees root rubbing against rock
causing erosion
Weathering produces particles and in the first step in soil formation. The second
step is erosion
Erosion- the movement of movement of soil from one area to another.
Biological activity contributes to soil formation through the deposition,
decomposition, and accumulation of organic matter.
Particle decomposition of organic matter creates humus, soils with high humus
content hold moisture very well and are productive for plant life. Soils that are
dominated by partially decayed, compressed organic material are calledpeat
There are five factors that influence soil formation (figure 4.1 pg. 76)
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
40/148
i. Climatesoil forms better in warm wet climates, heat speeds
up chemical reactions and promotes weathering
ii. Organismsearthworms and other burrowing animals mix
and aerate soil
iii. Topographical reliefhills and valleys affect exposure to sun,
wind and water, influencing how soil moves
iv. Parent materialchemical and physical attributes of the
parent influence the properties of the soil
v. Timesoil formation takes a very long time; the four factors
change over time.
Soil Profile
Each layer of soil is known as a horizon, from surface to bedrock is known as a
soil profile. There are five major horizons known as O, A, B, C and R.
O-horizon- is the upper layer consisting mostly of decomposing branches,
leaves, and animal waste. Also known as the litter layer
A horizon-consisting of inorganic mineral components with organic matter and
humus from above mixed in. also known as topsoil
B horizon- minerals and inorganic material that are leached from the topsoil
move down into this level. Also known as subsoil
C horizon-consists of parent material unaltered or slightly altered by the
process of soil formation.
R horizon-contains rock particles that are larger and less weathered than those
above it. The r stands for rock.
Characteristics of soil (grouping of soils 10 characteristics pg. 78)
Soil colorthe color of soil can indicate its composition and its fertility. Black or
dark brown soils are rich in organic matter where paler soils usually are leached
Soil textureis determined by the size of the particles and is the basis on which
soils are categorized as clay, sand or silt. A mixture of all three is known as loam.
Silty soils with medium-sized pores or loamy soils are best for crop and plant
growth
Soil structureis a measure of the organization of clumpiness of soil Soil pHthe degree of acidity or alkalinity influences a soils ability to support
plant growth. Plants can die in soils that are to acidic or alkaline, plants need a
neutral pH.
The characteristics of soil affect its ability to provide plants with nutrients.
Cation exchange is a useful tool in measuring soil fertility
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
41/148
Agriculture-the practice of raising crops and livestock for human use and
consumption
Cropland-land we use to raise plants
Rangeland-land we use for grazing livestock
Due to mismanaged agriculture we have turned grasslands into deserts and have
removed ecologically precious forests
Soil degradation-damage or loss of soil as a result of forest removal, over grazing
livestock, and industrial contamination
Domestication
Domestication began 10,000 years ago, in several places but largely in the Fertile
Crescent. Did not occur on purpose but was an accident. Hypothesis state that it
could have began with seed dispersal through fecal matter, and by dropping
seeds and having them grow near the settlement. Domestication brought on
selective breeding (a process in which natural selection is done through human
intervention)
Agriculture is an intensification of the productivity of a given unit of land
The development of agriculture gave birth to major changes in human history,
commerce, increases in technology, urbanization and social stratifications
Traditional farming (preindustrial farming)also known as subsistence
agriculture, families farmed to feed themselves, used animal and human labor
Intensive traditional farminguses significant quantities of irrigation water and
fertilizers, does not use fossil fuels. Provides for family but sells excess to
markets
Industrial farmingthe industrial revolution introduced large-scale mechanisms
and combustion of fossil fuels, advancements in irrigation, fertilizing, and cropyield, the demands that vast fields be planted with a single crop (monoculture).
This is widely spread due to the Green Revolution (refer to chapter 5)
Soil degradation
The most desirable soil for agriculture is a loamy mixture with a pH close to
neutral. Common problems affecting soils productivity include erosion,
desertification, waterlogging, nutrient depletion, and pollution.
Depositionis the arrival of eroded material at its new location. Erosion and
deposition are neutral processes that in the long run help create soil. However
erosion can be a problem because it takes place much more quickly than soil is
formed, it tends to move topsoil, which is the most valuable soil layer.
People have increased the vulnerability of fertile lands to erosion by
1. Over cultivating fields through poor planning or excessive
ploughing
2. Over grazing rangeland with more livestock than land can
support
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
42/148
3. Clear cutting forests
There are several types of erosion, water erosion, rill erosion, wind erosion,
however humans are the number cause of erosion
Desertification
Desertification is the loss of more than 10% of productivity because of erosion, soilcompaction, forest removal, over grazing, drought, and climate change.
Arid and semi-arid lands are prone to desertification because their precipitation
is to meager to meet the demands of growing human populations
The Dust Bowl
Page 88 4.3.6
Protection against erosion
Crop rotation:the practice of alternating the kids of crops that are grown in a field from
season to season to return nutrients to the soil.
Contour farming:consists of ploughing furrows sideways across a hillside,
perpendicular to its slope, to help prevent formation of rills and gullies.Intercropping and agroforestry- intercropping helps slow erosion by providing more
complete ground coverage than does a single crop. When crops are interplanted with
trees its called agroforestry.
Terracing:on extremely steep terrain, terracing is the most effective method of erosion
prevention. Terracing transforms slopes into a series of steps to help famers cultivate
hilly land without losing huge amounts of soil to water erosion.
Shelterbelt: a widespread technique to reduce erosion from winds. These are rows of
trees that are planted along the edges of fields to slow wind.
Reduce tillage:a tractor pulls a drill that cuts long shallow furrows through the O
horizon of dead weeds and crop residue of the A horizon. The device drops seeds intothe furrows and closes the furrows over the seeds. There are direct and indirect
benefits of this method includingsustainability of high yield crops, shelter and winter
food for animals, reduction of silt deposition in reservoirs, lowers costs of drinking
water. Example to read- Brazil pg. 93
Irrigation
The artificial provision of water to support agriculture is known as irrigation.
Some crops require lots while other require very little irrigation.
Through irrigation people have managed to turn unsuitable dry land into fertile
farmland.
Over irrigation is an issue as soils can become waterlogged. Another problem is
salinization of the soil due to dry lands.
To fix salinization of land s very expensive and difficult. The best way to avoid
salinization is to avoid planting crops that require a lot of water, a second way is
to use water with very little salt content
Over applying fertilizers can also damage soils.
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
43/148
There are two types of fertilizers, organic and inorganic
Organic fertilizers: consist of natural minerals and organic materials compost
Inorganic fertilizers: synthetically manufactured. Inorganic fertilizers are generally
more susceptible to leaching and are likely to cause off-site unintended impacts.
Over grazing:can also impact soils and alter their structure. Soil compaction makes it
harder for water to infiltrate, harder for soils to be aerated, harder for plants roots to
expand, harder for roots to conduct cellular respiration. Over grazings soil degradation
is equal to cropland agriculture but is a great cause of degradation.
Central Case: Mer Bleue: A Bog of International Significance
The Mer Bleue Conservation Area is 35 km2provincially protected wetland
situated just east of Ottawa, OntariooLocated in an ancient, now abandoned
channel of the Ottawa River
Hosts a number of unusual plat species that are specially adapted to moist,boggy, acidic conditions, including Sphagnummoss, bog rosemary,
blueberry, cottongrass, cattails, and tamarack
Provides a specific type of soil peat that has been accumulating in many
northern areas since the end of the last ice age
Northern peatlands are extremely important storage reservoirs for carbon,
and they are thought to hold about one-third of all carbon stored in soils
Through decomposition, peat produces soil gases, such as CO2and CH4,
which function as greenhouse gases in the atmosphere
The storage of carbon in peat depends on the balance between net primary
production and decomposition, with plant storing or sequestering carbon asa result of photosynthesis, then contributing the stored carbon to the peat
soil where it accumulates in the form of plant litter Temperature, light levels, and moisture are important to this balance
The Peatland Carbon Study (PCARS) was initiated by a group of Canadian
scientists in 1997 oWork continues today as part of the Fluxnet Canada
Canadian Carbon Project research networks, to measure and model theinfluence of climatic and seasonal changes on the carbon balance of apeatland
4.1 Soil as a system
Soil is often used as the equivalent to dirt, but this is not true
Soil is not merely loose material derived from rock; it is a complexplantsupporting system consisting of disintegrated rock, organic matter,water, gases, nutrients, and microorganisms
It is also fundamental to the support of life on this planet an the provision offood for the growing human population
It is renewable if managed carefully, but its currently at risk in many
locations around the world
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
44/148
Soil consists very roughly of half mineral matter with varying proportions of
organic matter, with the rest of the pore space being taken up by air, water,and other soil gases
The organic matter in soil:
oLiving and dead microorganisms, decaying material derived from
plants and animals4.1.1 Soil formation is slow and complex
Formation of soil plats a key role in terrestrial primary succession
Parent material is the base geological material in a particular location
Bedrock the continuous mass of solid rock that makes up Earths crustWeathering describes the physical, chemical, and biological processes that
break down rocks and minerals, turning large particles into smaller particles
oPhysical weathering (or mechanical weathering) breaks rocks down
without triggering a chemical change in the parent material
oTwo main forces of physical weathering are rain and wind
Chemical weathering results when water or other substances chemically
interact with parent material oWarm, wet conditions accelerate chemical
weathering
Biological weathering occurs when living things break down parent material
by physical or chemical means
Weather produces fine particles and is the first step in soil formation
Erosion is another process often involved the movement of soil from one
area to another oSometimes helps form soil in one locality by depositing
material it has depleted from another
Erosion is generally perceived as a destructive process that reduces the
amount of life tat a given area of land can support Biological activity contributes to soil formation through the deposition,
decomposition, and accumulation of organic matter
Partial decomposition of organic matter creates humus a dark, spongy,
crumbly mass of material made up of complex organic compounds oSoils
with high levels of humus are productive for plant life
Soils that are dominated by partially decayed, compressed organic material
like the soil at Mer Bleue are called peat oCharacteristics of northern
climates because cool temperatures slow the decay process, allowing greatthickness of organic material to accumulate
4.1.2 A soil profile consists of layers known as horizons
Distinct layers of soil develop which is known as a horizon and the cross
section of as a whole, from surface to bedrock, is known as a soil profile o
Layers are divided by characteristics and the process that take placed
within them 5 layers:
o O Horizon (O for organic)
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
45/148
Uppermost layer consisting mostly of organic matter oA
Horizon (topsoil)
Just below the organic horizon consisting of inorganicmineral components with organic matter and humus from above mixedin
Minerals are carried downwards as a result of leaching (like coffeegrounds in a drip filter), the process whereby solid particles suspended or
dissolved in liquid are transported to another location oB Horizon
(subsoil)
Where minerals and organic matter that are leached from the
topsoil move down
o C Horizon
Below the B horizon and consists of parent material
unaltered or only slightly altered by the processes of soil formation oR
Horizon (R stands for rock)
o
Sits directly below the C horizon, certain soils are characterized bythe presence of a distinct layer of water, called the W horizon permafrost (constantly frozen ice)
4.1.3 Soil can be characterized by its colour, texture, structure, and pH
Soil colour oThe colour of soil indicate its composition and sometimes
its fertility oColour variations occur among sol horizons in any given
location and also among solids from different geographic locations
Soil texture oDetermined by the size of particles and is the basis on
which soils are assigned to one of three general categories
o Clay consists of particles less than 0.002 mm in diameter oSilt
consists of particles 0.002-0.05 mm in diameter o
Sand consists ofparticles 0.05-2mm in diameter
o Soil with a relatively even mixture of the three particle sizes is knownas loam
o Texture influences the soils porosity (measure of the relative volume
of spaces within the material) as well as its permeability (measure ofthe interconnectedness of the spaces and the ease with which fluidscan move around in the material)
Soil Structure oMeasure of organization or clumpiness of soil oSoil
clumps that are too large can discourage plant roots from establishing if
soil particles are compacted too tightly together Soil pH oDegree of acidity or alkalinity influences a soils ability to
support plant growth
o Plants can die in soils that are too acidic (low pH) or alkaline (highpH)
4.1.4 Cation exchange is vital for plant growth
The characteristics of soil affect its ability to provide plants with nutrients
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
46/148
Plants gain many nutrients through a process called cation exchange (plan
roots donate hydrogen ions to the soil particles then replenish by exchangewith soil water)
Cation exchange capacity expresses a soils ability to hold cations
(preventing them rom leaching and thus making them available to plants)
and is a useful measure of soil fertility
4.2 Soil: The foundation for feedings a growing population
Healthy soil is vital for agriculture, for forests, and for functioning of Earths
natural systems
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
47/148
Productive soil is a renewable resource, but if we abuse it through carelessor uninformed practices, we can greatly reduce its productivity
Like other renewable resources, if soil is degraded or washed away at a rate
that is faster than the rate at which it can be renewed, it effectively becomesnonrenewable because the supply or stock of the resource is being depleted
Agriculture practice of raising crops and livestock for human use andconsumption is 38% of the Earths land surface
Cropland land used to raise plants for human use
Rangeland land used for grazing livestock
4.2.1 As population and consumption increase, soils are being degraded
If we are to feed the worlds rising human population, we will need to change
our diet patterns or increase agricultural production and do so sustainablywithout degrading the environment and reducing its ability to support
agriculture We cannot simply keep expanding agriculture into new areas the
spreading or extensification of resource extraction because land suitableand available for farming is running out
Today, many lands unsuitable for farming are being farmed, causingconsiderable environmental damage
Soil degradation damage to or loss of soil, around the globe has resultedfrom roughly equal parts of forest removal, cropland agriculture, and
overgrazing of livestock, with a much smaller contribution from industrialcontamination
This has direct impacts on agricultural production4.2.2 Agriculture began to appear around 10 000 years ago
Agriculture most likely began as hunter-gatherers brought back to their
encampments wild fruits, grains, and nuts
Agriculture is a form of intensification a way to increase the productivity ofa given unit of land
Intensification can increase the carrying capacity of a land area (up to acertain point)
For thousands of years, the work of cultivating, harvesting, storing, and
distribution crops was performed by human and animal muscle power,along with hand tools and simple machines
This biologically powered agriculture is known as traditional agriculture
In the older form of traditional agriculture, known as subsistenceagriculture, farming families produce only enough food for themselves anddo not make use of large-scale irrigation, fertilizer, or teams of laboringanimals
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
48/148
4.2.3 Industrialized agriculture is newer still
The Industrial Revolution introduced large-scale mechanization and fossilfuel combustion to agriculture just as it did to industry, enabling farmers toreplace horses and oxen with faster and more powerful means of cultivating,harvesting, transporting, and processing crops
Industrialized agriculture demands that vast fields be planted with singletypes of crops
The uniform planting of a single crop, terms monoculture, is distinct from
thepolycultureapproach of much more traditional agricultural
Industrialized agriculture spread from developed nations to developing
nations with the advent of the Green Revolution
4.3 Soil degradation: Problems and solutions
Limits to productivity are being set by human impact that has degraded many
once-excellent soils
4.3.1 Regional difference in soil traits can affect agriculture The characteristics of soil and soil profiles can vary from place to place
The traditional form of agriculture in tropical forested areas is swiddenagriculture, in which the farmer cultivates a plot for one to a few years andthen moves on to clear another pot, leaving the first to grow back to forest
4.3.2 Erosion can degrade ecosystems and agriculture
Erosion is the removal of material from one place and its transport toward
another by the action of wind or water
Deposition is the arrival of eroded material at its new location
Erosion and deposition are natural processes that in the long run can help
create soil Erosion can be gradual and hard to detect
4.3.3 Soil erodes by several mechanisms
Several types of erosion can occur, including wind and water
The Universal Soil Loss Equation (USLE) was developed as a tool for
estimating erosion losses by water from cultivated fields, and to show howdifferent soil and management factors influence soil erosion
Wind, like water, is a moving fluid
Wind often flows very quickly over the surface, but it typical does not have
the same ability to pick up and transport large particles that water had
4.3.4 Soil erosion is a global problem In todays world, humans are the primary cause of erosion, and we have
accelerated it to unnaturally high rates
Erosion of agricultural soil has been a significant concern in Canada for thepast 25 years or more, but improvements are occurring
-
8/10/2019 GGR107 - Textbook Notes
49/148
4.3.5 Desertification reduces productivity of arid lands
Much of the worlds population lives and farms in arid environments, where
desertification is a concern
This term describes a loss of more than 10% of productivity because of
erosion, soil compaction, forest removal, overgrazing, drought, salinization,
climate change, depletion of water sources, and other factorsDesertification is a type of land degradation that occurs in arid and semi-aridareas and can result from various factors, including climatic variations andhuman activities
Land degradation is defined as the reduction or loss of the biological oreconomic productivity of a land
4.3.6 The Dust Bowl was a monumental event in North America
Prior to a large-scale cultivation of the Prairies and the Great Plains, native
prairie grasses of this temperate grassland region held erosion-prone soils inplace
Starting in the early 1930s, a prolonged period of drought in the regionexacerbated the ongoing human impacts on the soil from overly intensiveagricultural practices
Strong winds began to carry away millions of tones of topsoil, and oftennewly planted seed
Dust