gluten free & healthy living: sort the fads from the facts
TRANSCRIPT
Vandna Jerath, MD, FACOG
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital
drjerath.com | optimawomenshealthcare.com | optimavitalitymd.com
February 23, 2016
#glutenfree #healthyliving #factsvsfads @drjerath @optimawhc @optimavitality
FACOG – Board-Certified Ob/Gyn
Private practice – 17 years
Full scope obstetrics & gynecology
Enjoy education and community outreach
Disclosures – no financial affiliations
Healthcare social media expert
drjerath.com
Gluten free for 2 ½ years
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
General Ob/Gyn Services
Women’s health resource/expert
Female empowerment ◦ Be educated Be engaged Be empowered
Spa-like setting
Individualized, personalized, and compassionate care
optimawomenshealthcare.com
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Center for Rejuvenation and Wellness
Alternative, holistic, functional, integrative, and complementary medicine
BioTE® bioidentical hormone pellet therapy ◦ Treatmemt for both women and men
◦ Nutraceuticals
MonaLisa Touch™ vaginal laser revitalization
VitaMedMD™ vitamins and minerals
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
To understand what gluten is and the impact it has on health.
To learn about celiac disease including prevalence, signs/symptoms, diagnosis, and management.
To understand the evolving spectrum of gastroenterological conditions, particularly regarding gluten and gluten sensitivity.
To understand the dietary restrictions of a gluten free diet.
To be able to sort out the health vs. hype regarding gluten.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Source: Grow Magazine, Parker Adventist Hospital, Winter 2016, Volume 8, Issue 1, page 2
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Photo source: someecards.com and glutenfreedude.com
Jimmy Kimmel video ◦ http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AdJFE1sp4Fw
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
What is all the fuss? ◦ Less people eating gluten ◦ Revenue producing for the food industry - $15 billion in 2016 ◦ Potentially life threatening for people with celiac disease
May cause GI symptoms ◦ Allergy vs. sensitivity vs. intolerance
Gluten free may be diet fad vs necessity Why?
◦ GMO crops?
Possible overdiagnosis and overtreatment Media stories
◦ NY Times blog article – 9/29/2014 ◦ Celiac Disease, a Common, but Elusive, Diagnosis ◦ http://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2014/09/29/celiac-disease-diagnosis-
gluten/?_php=true&_type=blogs&_r=0
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Photo source: unearthedcomics.com
Protein found in grains ◦ Wheat, barley, and rye ◦ Gliadin peptides
Found in common foods ◦ Cereal ◦ Bread ◦ Baked goods ◦ Pasta ◦ Battered and possibly fried foods ◦ Malt ◦ Sauces, marinades, salad dressings, soy sauce, gravy ◦ May be hidden in processed foods ◦ Preservatives ◦ Beer
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Natural, plain, or unprocessed foods ◦ Meats/Poultry/Fish
◦ Fruits
◦ Vegetables
◦ Beans
◦ Dairy
◦ Nuts
Source: M. Dennis, S. Case, 2008 as appeared in Practical Gastroenterology, April 2004 and BIDMC presentation by Daniel Leffler, MD, MS and Melinda Dennis, MS, RD, LDN.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Safe grains, starches, & flours ◦ Rice ◦ Corn ◦ Soybeans ◦ Tapioca ◦ Potato ◦ Quinoa ◦ Millet ◦ Flax ◦ Arrowroot ◦ Amaranth ◦ Buckwheat ◦ Sorghum ◦ Millet ◦ Teff ◦ Nut flours (almond, pecan) ◦ Seed flours (sesame) ◦ Legume flours(garbanzo, lentil) ◦ Bean flours
Source: M. Dennis, S. Case, 2008 as appeared in Practical Gastroenterology, April 2004 and BIDMC presentation by Daniel Leffler, MD, MS and Melinda Dennis, MS, RD, LDN.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Source: Thompson T. Celiac Disease Nutrition Guide, 2nd ed. Chicago: American Dietetic Association; 2006.
Allowed Foods
amaranth arrowroot buckwheat cassava corn flax Indian rice grass Job's tears
legumes millet nuts potatoes quinoa rice sago
seeds sorghum soy tapioca teff wild rice yucca
Foods To Avoid
•wheat including einkorn, emmer, spelt, kamut •wheat starch, wheat bran, wheat germ, cracked wheat, hydrolyzed wheat protein
barley rye triticale (a cross between wheat and rye)
Other Wheat Products
bromated flour durum flour enriched flour farina
graham flour phosphated flour plain flour
self-rising flour semolina white flour
Processed Foods that May Contain Wheat, Barley, or Rye*
bouillon cubes brown rice syrup candy chips/potato chips cold cuts, hot dogs, salami, sausage communion wafers
French fries gravy imitation fish matzo rice mixes sauces
seasoned tortilla chips self-basting turkey soups soy sauce vegetables in sauce
The Gluten-free Diet: Some Examples In 2006, the American Dietetic Association updated its recommendations for a gluten-free diet. The following chart is based on the 2006 recommendations. This list is not complete, so people with celiac disease should discuss gluten-free food choices with a dietitian or physician who specializes in celiac disease. People with celiac disease should always read food ingredient lists carefully to make sure the food does not contain gluten.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Challenges ◦ Cross-contamination ◦ Hidden ingredients ◦ Preservatives
Wheat free is not gluten free Not necessarily low fat or for weight loss Make sure adequate vitamins and minerals
Vitamin B Vitamin D Calcium Fiber Iron
Avoid ◦ Wheat ◦ Malt ◦ Modified food starch ◦ Dextrin ◦ Hydrolyzed wheat protein
DO NOT START w/o confirming or ruling out celiac disease
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Digestive disease that damages small intestine ◦ Damaged villi of the small intestine ◦ Malabsorption of nutrients ◦ Celiac disease (CD), Celiac sprue, nontropical sprue, gluten-sensitive enteropathy
Autoimmune reaction Intolerance to gluten
◦ How does it start? ◦ Surgery, infection, cereal < 3mo age, hereditary?
Prevalence 1 in 100 Women > Men
◦ 2/3 of current diagnosis are female
More common in Caucasians Genetic (5-10% first degree relative) May take 10 years or more for diagnosis
◦ Average age of diagnosis is 50 ◦ Confusing symptoms ◦ Delayed diagnosis or under diagnosed
17% of Americans don’t know they have the disease Lifelong gluten free diet is the only treatment
◦ Less than 20ppm
Source: AGA Institute Medical Position Statement on the Diagnosis and Management of Celiac Disease. Gastroenterology. 2006; 131:1977-1980. Source: Celiac Disease. NIH Publication No. 08-4269. September 2008.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Husby, S. & Murray, J. A. (2014) Diagnosing coeliac disease and the potential for serological markers Nat. Rev. Gastroenterol. Hepatol. doi:10.1038/nrgastro.2014.162
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Abdominal bloating Abdominal pain Chronic diarrhea Vomiting Constipation Stool abnormalities
◦ Pale, foul-smelling, fatty
Weight loss Irritability Malabsorption Fatigue Joint pain Muscle pain Osteopenia/Osteoporosis Iron-deficiency anemia Tingling in hands/feet Headaches
Abnormal menses ◦ Infertility ◦ Recurrent miscarriage
Canker sores Skin rash - itchy
◦ Dermatitis herpetiformis ◦ Dapsone treatment
Cognitive impairment – brain fog Ataxia Automimmune diseases
◦ Thyroid disease ◦ Rheumatoid arthritis ◦ Type 1 diabetes ◦ Sjogren’s syndrome ◦ Addison’s disease ◦ SLE (lupus)
Non Hodgkin’s Lymphoma
Source: AGA Institute Medical Position Statement on the Diagnosis and Management of Celiac Disease. Gastroenterology. 2006; 131:1977-1980. Source: Celiac Disease. NIH Publication No. 08-4269. September 2008.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Photo source: someecards.com and glutenfreedude.com
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Must be on a gluten diet for testing Blood tests
◦ IgA tissue trans-glutaminase antibodies (tTG) Most efficient single serologic test
◦ IgA/IgG deaminated gliadin peptide antibodies (DGP)
Genetic testing ◦ Human leukocyte antigen (HLA) haplotypes ◦ DNA PCR ◦ HLA DQ2 (95%)/DQ8 (5%) No celiac if these are negative
Intestinal biopsies ◦ Multiple biopsies ◦ Histological testing for villous atrophy ◦ Gold standard for diagnosis
Skin biopsies Equivocal test results can occur
Source: AGA Institute Medical Position Statement on the Diagnosis and Management of Celiac Disease. Gastroenterology. 2006; 131:1977-1980
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Consultation with a skilled dietitian
Education about the disease
Lifelong adherence to a gluten free diet
Identification and treatment of nutritional deficiencies
Access to an advocacy group
Continuous long-term follow-up by a multidisciplinary team
Source: NIH Consensus Development Conference on Celiac Disease.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Photo source: helloglutenfree.com
Is there a spectrum of disease?
Non-celiac gluten sensitivity (NCGS) ◦ First described in 1980’s now “re-discovered”
GI symptoms responsive to a gluten free diet ◦ May be able to titrate their gluten exposure to avoid symptoms
Prevalence unclear ◦ Many people self-diagnose and start a gluten free diet without
medical consultation (not recommended)
◦ .5-6% based upon different studies
◦ More common in females
Transitory or permanent? Source: Fasano A, et al. Non-celiac gluten sensitivity: the new frontier of gluten related disorders. Nutrients. Oct 2013; 5(10): 3839-3853
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Diagnosis ◦ Difficult to distinguish from irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) or wheat allergy (WA) ◦ Lack of biomarkers for diagnosis
First generation IgG AGA – 7.7%
HLA DQ2/DQ8 – 50%
◦ Different histological changes on intestinal biopsy
Present ◦ Younger age (case reports in children) ◦ Lack autoimmune or family history ◦ Constipation
Less likely to be at risk ◦ Malabsorption ◦ Severe nutrient deficiencies ◦ Lymphoma ◦ No major complication if untreated
Evolving spectrum ◦ Some more like celiac disease ◦ Some more like food allergy ◦ Is GMO wheat contributing? ◦ Possible relationship to autism and schizophrenia ◦ May be related to wheat amylase-trypsin inhibitors ◦ May be related to low-fermentable, poorly absorbed, short chain carbohydrates
Reduced FODMAPs (fermentable oligo-, di-, and mono-saccharides and polyols) diet
Fructans, galactans, fructose, and polyols
Source: Fasano A, et al. Non-celiac gluten sensitivity: the new frontier of gluten related disorders. Nutrients. Oct 2013; 5(10): 3839-3853.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Nonceliac enteropathy (NCE) ◦ Can mimic celiac disease
◦ May cause villous atrophy
◦ Can respond to a gluten free diet
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Gibson et al- Australian study in 2011 ◦ Double blinded, randomized, placebo controlled ◦ Small study ◦ Gluten containing diet caused GI distress in people w/o Celiac
Disease (CD)
Biesiekierski/Gibson et al - repeat study in 2013 ◦ Double blinded, placebo controlled, cross-over trial ◦ 37 patients gluten sensitivity (NCGS) ◦ FODMAPs reduction, low or high gluten, or whey (placebo)
challenge ◦ Improvement with FODMAPs reduction ◦ No specific response to gluten ◦ Nocebo effect – worsening of GI symptoms
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Source: Biesiekierski /Gibson et al. “Is gluten a cause of gastrointestinal symptoms in people without celiac disease?” Curr Allergy Asthma Rep. 2013 Dec; 13(6):631-8. Source: Biesiekierski / Gibson et al. “No effects of gluten in patients with self-reported non-celiac gluten sensitivity after dietary reduction of fermentable, poorly absorbed, short-chain carbohydrates.” Gastroenterology. 2013 Aug; 145(2):320-8.e1-3.
More research needed ◦ FODMAPS ◦ IBS ◦ Wheat Sensitivity ◦ Autism ◦ Schizophrenia ◦ Larger trials – double blinded prospective randomized controlled
trials ◦ Nocebo effect ◦ Other autoimmune syndromes or allergies Hashimoto’s, Sjogren’s, asthma
Diagnosis of gluten sensitivity (NCGS) ◦ Need biomarker ◦ Transitory or permanent? ◦ True prevalence/incidence
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Photo source: snapshots at jasonlove.com
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Photo source: someecards.com and glutendfreefun.blogspot.com and @glutenfreemom on Facebook
Fads ◦ It is a good weight loss diet. ◦ Will make you “sick” or “fat”. ◦ GI symptoms will definitely occur. ◦ Healthy for you. ◦ Everyone is doing it. ◦ Ok to start a gluten free diet without a diagnosis.
Facts ◦ People with celiac disease have a permanent lifelong intolerance and cannot
eat gluten. ◦ May cause an autoimmune response with GI symptoms. ◦ Some people may have an allergy or sensitivity. ◦ Gluten free diet may improve sensitivity symptoms. ◦ Medical information and evidence is evolving. ◦ Do not start a gluten free diet without a medical diagnosis or consultation.
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Americanceliac.org Celiac.com Celiac.org Celiaccentral.org Csaceliacs.org Eatright.org Gluten.net Glutenfreedrugs.com Healthyvilli.org NIH –
http://digestive.niddk.nih.gov/ddiseases/pubs/celiac/ Reallifewithceliacdisease.com
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Facebook ◦ Facebook.com/drjerath
◦ Facebook.com/optimawhc
Twitter ◦ Twitter.com/drjerath
◦ Twitter.com/optimawhc
YouTube ◦ Youtube.com/doctorjerath
Linked In ◦ Linkedin.com/in/drjerath
◦ Linkedin.com/company/optima-women's-healthcare
Google + ◦ https://plus.google.com/101535200386086719829
◦ https://plus.google.com/117179751484494619443
Pinterest ◦ Pinterest.com/drjerath
◦ Pinterest.com/optimawhc
Instagram ◦ Instagram.com/drjerath
◦ Instagram.com/optimawhc
Vine ◦ Vine.com/drjerath
Blog ◦ Drjerath.com
Website ◦ Optimawomenshealthcare.com
◦ Optimavitalitymd.com
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
@drjerath @optimawhc @optimavitality
Vandna Jerath, MD Optima Women’s Healthcare Optima Vitality MD Sierra Medical Office Building Parker Adventist Hospital Campus 9399 Crown Crest Blvd, Suite 450 Parker, CO 80138 303.805.1807 P | 303.595.5390 F drjerath.com optimawomenshealthcare.com optimavitalitymd.com Email - [email protected] Slides – http://slideshare.net/VandnaJerathMD
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Community Health Seminar | Parker Adventist Hospital | 2/23/2016
Photo Source: someecards.com