gold fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

12
Warren Edward Pollock October 6, 2009

Upload: wepollock

Post on 13-Nov-2014

513 views

Category:

Documents


3 download

DESCRIPTION

Fundamental reasons to own gold from a published report circa 2003. At that time nobody wanted to touch gold...

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

Warren  Edward  Pollock  October  6,  2009  

Page 2: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  The  value  of  gold  pertains  and  relates  directly  to  the  metal  having  acceptance  as  currency.  Gold  finds  its  optimum  value  when  it  can  be  used  as  a  currency  to  store  wealth,  guarantee  paper,  or  effect  transfer  in  goods  and  services.  

  Perceived  or  functional  demand  for  anything  creates  value.  Societal  culture  and  structure  will  dictate  what  has  importance  be  it  a  baseball  card,  oil,  an  automobile,  a  house,  or  labor  hours.  Value  can  be  transitory  or  it  can  endure  as  gold  has  throughout  civilized  history.  

Page 3: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  Currency  translates  through  uniform  quantification  the  relationship  in  societal  value  between  the  desirable  commodities,  services,  and  outcomes.  Both  complex  and  all  but  the  most  basic  societies  need  currency  to  effect  the  transfer  of  wealth.  Gold  provides  a  physical  foundation  point  in  currency  throughout  history,  between  nations,  and  across  culture.  

  Integrated  and  global  societies  have  highly  complex  currency  systems  largely  predicated  on  common  values.  Law,  stability,  and  property  rights  allow  people  to  enjoy  the  benefits  of  a  fast  moving  multiplied  economy  with  a  high  velocity  of  money.  Liberty  may  be  an  additional  component  or  its  presence  may  be  reflected  in  the  rights  to  protection  of  property.  The  three  basic  precepts,  of  law  stability  and  property  rights,  combined  with  currency  provide  the  very  basis  for  productivity  and  most  importantly  these  conditions  foster  investment  and  innovation  with  the  objective  of  societal  returns.  

Page 4: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  In  the  United  States,  unlike  many  other  nations,  value  may  be  found  in  things  tangible  or  intangible  and  in  property  either  physical  or  intellectual.  Investment  and  re-­‐investment  in  productive  enterprises  result  in  economic  success.  The  four  pillars  of  economic  success  are  law,  stability,  property  rights,  and  currency.  These  supports  are  critical  components  of  advanced  economies.  

  However,  Law  property  rights  and  stability,  are  inherently  more  fragile  than  perceived.  Politics,  culture,  war,  natural  resource  depletion,  population  pressure,  mismanagement,  malfeasance,  events,  and  even  collective  rather  than  objective  opinion  can  drastically  detract  from  the  core  requirements  for  societal  success.  

Page 5: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  The  comfort  of  highly  functional  economies  provides  false  shelter  and  harbors  erroneous  perception  in  security.  Therefore  as  the  foundation  currency,  gold,  has  a  role,  in  all  types  of  economies  from  the  most  basic  to  the  most  integrated.  

  By  political  objective,  the  correlation  between  gold  and  currency  has  become  temporarily  more  distant  since  the  1970's.  Just  thirty  years  later  some  banks  and  societies  are  moving  back  towards  the  fundamental  of  gold  today.  A  short-­‐lived  politically  biased  counter-­‐trend  does  not  represent  a  speck  of  time  in  relation  to  the  history  of  gold.  

Page 6: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  Worldwide  political  objectives,  as  well  as  cultural  experience,  are  not  congruent  or  unified  to  common  interests  defined  primarily  by  western  thought  and  influence.  It  can  be  definitively  said  that  interests  are  currently  trending  apart.  Gold  will  become  more  valuable  as  currency  in  a  predictable  long-­‐term  enduring  countertrend.  History  speaks  to  this  and  it  will  outlast  us  all.  

  Today  specific  economic,  political,  regional,  and  international  circumstances  have  the  propensity  to  drive  a  stronger  correlation  between  gold  and  its  role  as  currency.  

  Both  mainstream  and  outlying  contingencies  can  and  will  drive  gold  to  become  more  attractive  as  currency.  Therefore  a  portfolio  that  has  a  percentage  weight  in  gold  proportional  to  the  probability  of  specific  circumstances  will  be  well  served.  

Page 7: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  Finding  that  proportional  level  of  gold  to  probability  of  circumstance  presents  some  challenge.  However,  and  in  general,  the  level  of  gold  holdings  per  capita  needs  to  be  much  higher  to  adequately  reflect  the  probabilities  in  which  its  application  would  be  useful.  

  Inflation,  in  a  paper  money  system  or  fiat  money  system,  has  to  be  considered  part  of  the  normal  range  of  economic  activity.  If  the  economy  were  trending  to  inflation  gold  would  rise  inversely  to  unsecured  paper.  The  value  of  gold  stays  constant  while  the  currency  devalues  as  it  loses  purchasing  power.  

  Central  banks  have  spent  much  of  their  efforts  curtailing  inflation.  The  pariah  of  inflation  has  been  the  watchword  of  every  central  bank  simply  because  inflation  inherently  exists  in  unsecured  paper  money  systems.  

Page 8: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  War  also  provides  potential  accelerants  to  inflation.  I  make  this  statement  with  the  caveat  that  for  structural  reasons  this  may  not  apply  in  total  to  the  present  circumstance  in  the  Untied  States.  

  Gold  provides  a  natural  hedge  against  this  normal  and  mainstream  economic  contingency  of  inflation  yet  few  people  hold  even  1%  of  their  portfolio  in  gold  to  offset  the  high  probability  of  inflation  over  time.  Most  people  are  totally  unprepared  for  the  mainstream,  recurring,  and  relativity  frequent  contingency  of  inflation.  

Page 9: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  Presently  I  believe  the  globe  may  be  in  a  period  of  "stagnation-­‐deflation".  "Stagnation-­‐deflation"  implies  that  a  mix  of  deflation  and  inflation  are  present  in  a  slowing  economy.  Both  an  economic  boom  and  "stagnation-­‐deflation"  represent  outlying  economic  events  one  deviation  outside  the  norm.  ""Stagnation-­‐deflation""  provides  opposite  traction  to  the  dislocation  of  a  boom.  

  In  "stagnation-­‐deflation"  returns  that  can  be  derived  on  investments  trend  lower  therefore  gold  appreciates  because  the  opportunity  cost  for  holding  gold  decreases.  Simply  put,  more  people  want  to  hold  gold  to  offset  uncertainty  and  holding  gold  does  not  cost  much  because  alternate  investments  do  not  provide  meaningful  returns.  Perhaps  after  adjustment  the  United  States  will  correct  to  the  normal  economic  range.  However,  political  interests  are  reticent  to  allow  an  adjustment  to  occur  to  take  the  energy  out  of  a  corrective  force  so  in  the  near  term  therefore  the  US  could  shift  to  a  more  severe  outcome  as  the  potential  energy  of  chronic  and  structural  imbalance  compound  rather  than  release.  

Page 10: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  Unless  the  currency,  stock,  and  debt  markets  shift  to  sustainable  levels  and  valuations,  and  in  the  process  wipe  out  wealth,  the  probability  of  the  "worst  case"  scenario  increases.  In  politics  the  "art  of  the  possible"  in  pleasing  a  constituency  has  much  to  do  with  short  term  perception  rather  than  need  or  circumstance.  Gold  has  absolute  neutrality  to  politics  and  it  has  an  incredibly  long  time  horizon.  

  I  qualify  these  "worst  case"  events  as  two  standard  deviations  away  but  that  does  not  mean  that  they  are  not  probable.  War  and  structural  imbalances  such  as  deficits  can  drive  a  bad  situation  to  a  worse  outcome.  

  Where  do  we  go  from  here?  We  can  go  into  a  recovery,  which  would  bring  us  into  a  normal  economic  range.  Inflation  is  one  of  the  possibilities  because  the  economy  would  bounce  off  a  higher  money  supply,  as  the  velocity  of  money  would  increase  through  accelerated  economic  activity.  Gold  speaks  directly  to  the  inflation  potential  of  this  outcome.  Or  we  move  to  outlying  contingency  two  standard  deviations  from  the  mean.  

Page 11: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  The  two  extreme  potentialities  are  hyperinflation  and/or  a  liquidity  trap.  

  A  liquidity  trap,  depression,  zero-­‐bound,  call  it  what  you  want  circumstances  become  so  unpleasant  that  Gold  might  be  the  least-­‐worst  option.  Gold  becomes  a  Hobson's  choice,  "no  choice  at  all."  Gold  as  currency  thrives  in  inflation  therefore  hyperinflation  would  also  drive  gold  towards  the  role  of  currency.  

  In  either  worst  case  the  risk  of  confiscation  of  gold,  government  intervention,  or  command  of  the  economy  increases  because  of  social  considerations.  A  question  to  ask  would  be  whether  or  not  government  tends  to  reward  the  individuals  who  are  making  the  best  personal  economic  choices?  

  What  is  the  likelihood  of  these  probabilities?  Would  these  contingencies  warrant  one  percent  of  one's  investments  to  be  in  gold?  What  measures  can  be  effective  in  diversification  both  to  gold  and  in  relation  to  gold  holdings?  

Page 12: Gold Fundamentals from my 2003 analysis

  Presently  the  United  States  stands  engaged  in  a  war.  Gold  also  finds  its  value  as  currency  because  war  represents  a  major  uncertainty  and  it  can  cause  rapid  dislocation.  

  Whether  or  not  people  in  the  United  States  believe  that  Gold  has  value  today  many  cultures,  central  banks,  and  individuals  are  quite  convinced  that  gold  provides  utility  as  currency.  Unfortunately  the  common  call  to  any  asset  class  usually  means  that  the  best  time  to  enter  has  been  exhausted.  With  objective  consideration  gold  deserves  to  be  present  at  appropriate  levels  as  part  of  any  portfolios.