gravitational antennae for probing the dark side of the...

53
Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the Universe Rana X Adhikari (Caltech)

Upload: others

Post on 23-May-2020

8 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the Universe

Rana X Adhikari (Caltech)

Page 2: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Gravitational Waves

Einstein’s Equations:When matter moves, or changes its configuration, its gravitational

field changes. This change propagates outward asa ripple in the curvature of space-time: a gravitational wave.

“Mass tells space-time how to curve,and space-time tells mass how to move.”

--- John Wheeler

NASA/Dana Berry, Sky Works Digital

Gµ⌫ = 8⇡G

c4Tµ⌫

10�43

Page 3: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

q Gravitational Waves = “Ripples in space-time”q Two transverse polarizations - quadrupolar: + and x

Gravitational Waves:

GW amplitude is a strain: ∆L / L ∆L = strain x L

we need a large L !

Page 4: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

q Compact binary inspirals: “chirp”Ø NS-NS waveforms are well described. R ~ 300 Mpc Ø inspiral is a standard candle.Ø BH-BH merger simulations exist! R ~ 1500 Mpc

q Supernovae / Mergers: “burst” Ø Short signals. Waveforms not well known.Ø Search in coincidence between two or more interferometers and possibly

with electromagnetic and/or neutrinos signals. R ~ 0.03 Mpc

q Spinning NS: “continuous”Ø search for signals from observed pulsars R ~ 0.1 Mpc Ø all-sky search computing challenging R ~ 0.01 Mpc

q Cosmic Background: “stochastic”Ø Metric fluctuations amplified by inflation, phase transitions in early universe,

topological defects too weak to measure (on the earth)Ø Unresolved background sources (BH/BH mergers)

GW Sources in LIGO Band 10 - 5000

Caltech/Cornell - SXS

Adam Burrows

Page 5: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Timeline of the GW Field1. GR 1915 2. Einstein 1916 3. Einstein 1918 4. Chapel Hill (1957) 5. Pirani 6. Gertenstein & Pustovit 7. PPN Formalism 8. Thorne 1968 - 2014 9. Chandrasekhar &

Detweiler (1975) 10.Pretorius (2005)

1. Michelson (1881) 2. Weber (1965) 3. Weiss 1971 4. 1987 LIGO Proposal 5. MIT 1-5m 1982-1998 6. CIT 40m 1981-> 7. iLIGO 1997 - 2007 8. eLIGO 2007 - 2010 9. aLIGO 2010 -> 10.First lock 5/2014 11.O1 start 9/2015 12. GW150914

Page 6: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

How the Michelson Interferometer Works:

Mirror motion -> Optical Phase -> Light Power

Page 7: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

The Michelson Interferometer

Anti-Symmetric (Dark) Port

Ly

LxReflected Port

P ∝ PBS x sin2(ϕ)

dP/dϕ ∝ PBS x sin(ϕ)cos(ϕ)

ϕ = 2π (δLy - δLx) / λdϕ/dh ∝ L

Laser

Phase Shift ∝ Length

Signal ∝ BS Power

BS

dP ∝ sqrt(P)Shot Noise

Poisson Statistics...

Page 8: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 9: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 10: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

200 WLASER

!m

EndTestMass

T = 5 ppm

InputTestMass

T = 1.4%PowerRecycling

MirrorT = 3%

Beam-Splitter Pcav = 800 kW

3995 mSignalRecycling

MirrorT = 20%

100 kW

22 W

T = 30%

Page 11: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Photodetector

BeamSplitter

Power Recycling

Laser

Source100 kW Circulating Power

b)

a)

Signal Recycling

Test Mass

Test Mass

Test Mass

Test Mass

Lx = 4 km

20 W

H1

L1

10 ms light

travel time

L y =

4 k

m

c

c

cw

wp

p

p

p

p

w

Sep. 14 th

Page 12: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

LIGO Hanford Control Room

Page 13: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 14: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 061102

shifted by 7.3 ms

Page 15: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Numerical Sim of the merger on a bright background

SXS collaboration

Page 16: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

More Quantitative Simulation

What do the colors and arrows represent?

Page 17: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Detweiler & Chandrasekhar

(1975)

fring ' 32 kHz

✓M�M

◆h1� 0.63(1� a)3/10

i

Qring ' 2p1� a

Page 18: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

GW150914 Baseball Cardm1= 36; m2 = 29

mfinal = 62; spin = 0.67

distance = 410 Mpc; z ~ 0.09

EGW = 3 M; Lpeak ~ 3x1049 W (1023 suns)

Public data release: https://losc.ligo.org/events/GW150914/

Page 19: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Christmas Night

Page 20: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 21: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

KAGRA..

LIGO India

Page 22: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 23: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

some interesting topicsthe next decade of LIGO upgrades

Quantum Revolution ‘15

mirrors with “no” thermal noise

new Indian LIGO

Mystery Noise ?

Deep Learning for technical noise regression

direct dark matter detection with LIGO

tests of emergent gravity

short, space interferometer for cosmography (in prep.)

https://arxiv.org/abs/1605.01103

https://arxiv.org/abs/1504.02545

Page 24: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

What’s next for LIGO?2016: increase laser power, reduce low frequency noise

take ~6 months of data

2017: install squeezed light system

2019: improved mirrors

2025: Cryogenic silicon mirrors

~2030-2035: New (40 km) Facility

Page 25: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Vacuum Fluctuationsof EM Field

Radiation Pressure -- Photon Fluctuations

Residual Gas➢ random phase fluctuations

ThermodynamicMirror SurfaceFluctuations

Seismic/Gravitational

Vibrations

GW Readout

Laser

Shot Noise --Photon Fluctuations

Page 26: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Calculated LIGO Noise Anatomy

Newtonian gravity noise (a.k.a. Gravity Gradients)

Filtered Seismic

Glass Suspension Thermal Noise

Mirror Coating Thermal Noise

Quantum Noise: Radiation Pressure / Shot Noise

initial LIGO (2007)

Advanced LIGO

Page 27: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

estimated Noise Budget (Louisiana, Feb. 2016)

“mystery” noise

Page 28: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Where do we come from?What are we?Where are we going? -- Paul Gauguin

How can we eat?Why do we eat?Where shall we have lunch? -- Douglas Adams

Page 29: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Ira Thorpe

Page 30: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

What’s next for LIGO?2016: increase laser power, reduce low frequency noise

take ~6 months of data

2017: install squeezed light system

2019: improved mirrors

2025: Cryogenic silicon mirrors

~2030-2035: New (40 km) Facility

Page 31: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Frequency [Hz]10

110

210

3

Str

ain

[1/

Hz]

10-24

10-23

10-22

cre

ate

d u

sin

g g

win

c.m

on

31-J

an

-2016 b

y r

an

a o

n S

ilver7

80.lo

cal

Adv LIGO

A+

Quantum: Pin = 145 W; ζsqz = 10 dBSeismic: aLIGONewtonian Gravity: 10x subtractionSusp Thermal: 123 K Si blades and ribbonsCoat Brown: α− Si : SiO2 Φcoat = 6.5e-05Coating ThermoOptic: ωbeam = 5.9 8.4 cmSub Brown: Si mirror (T = 123 K, mmirror = 204 kg)Residual Gas: 3 nTorr of H2

Sub Thermo-RefractiveCarrier Density: 1013/cm3

Total

Sep 2015

Page 32: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Total Mass (M⊙)101 102 103

Redshift

10-1

100

101

Redshift v. Black Hole mass for LIGO Voyager

Cryo LIGOAdv LIGO

Page 33: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Our view of the Universe (circa 1998)

Page 34: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Fermi / 1 GeV (2012)

PlanckHFI/LFI (2010)

Page 35: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 36: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

– James T. Kirk

“Space, the Final Frontier”

Page 37: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Why Space?

Earth based detectors limited by seismic / gravity noise below ~5 Hz. Enormous challenges going to 1 Hz or below (cf. MANGO report: http://arxiv.org/abs/1308.2074)

Strain Sensitivity ~1/Larm. Hard to beat 100 km on Earth (cf. LUNGO report http://arxiv.org/abs/1410.0612)

Different astrophysical signals at low frequencies: massive black holes, white dwarf binaries (cf. numerous LISA science case reports, as well as BBO & DECIGO)

[1] C. Cutler and D. E. Holz, Physical Review D 80, 104009 (2009) [2] L. Randall and G. Servant, arXiv hep-ph, (2006). [3] K. Yagi and T. Tanaka, arXiv gr-qc, (2009).

Page 38: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Why NOT Space?Its expensive: 1000-2000 M$ for LISA. ~5000 M$ for JWST.

There’s no parts replacement in space: if the suspensions or lasers break, its game over.

It takes FOREVER: LISA concept started ~1975. As of 2014, the earliest launch would be in 2034.

except: Hubble mirror spherical aberration

Page 39: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Space Detectors

LISA, NGO, eLISA, SGO

BBO

DECIGO

AGIS

LAGRANGE(s)

OMEGA

http://pcos.gsfc.nasa.gov/studies/gravitational-wave-mission.phpRFI in 2011, Workshop in early 2012

10−4

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

10−25

10−24

10−23

10−22

10−21

10−20

10−19

10−18

10−17

Frequency [Hz]

Str

ain

[1

/√H

z]

Adv LIGOEinstein TelescopeDECIGOLISABasic AGISBBO

Page 40: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Recent Workshop

J. Harms, D. Shaddock, R. Adhikari, M. Ando, L. Barsotti, Y. Chen, H. Müller (Nov 5-9)

Explore geosynchronous, heliocentric, squeezing, cavities, HP lasers, corner cubes, etc.

Aim for the 0.01 - 10 Hz band (between LISA and LIGO)

Page 41: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

10−4

10−3

10−2

10−1

100

101

10−25

10−24

10−23

10−22

10−21

10−20

10−19

10−18

10−17

Frequency [Hz]

Str

ain [

1/√

Hz]

Adv LIGOEinstein Telescope (D)DECIGOLISABasic AGISBBOUNOGO

⌦GW=2⇥

10 �15

Compare Space Detectors

Page 42: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

DECIGO / BBOL = 1000 km

dmirror = 1 m

mmirror = 100 kg

Laser: 10 W, 532 nm

Finesse = 10

Noise: 5 x 10-19 (m/s2)/rHz

DECIGO Pathfinder not selected in JAXA down-select

Page 43: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Try something else…

Simple Michelson: Plaser = 5 W, wavelength = 532 nm

L = 100 km, m = 10 kg, dmirror = 0.35 m

no transponders(?) in remote satellites

Technical laser noise cancellation

Squeezed Light: 2x reduction of quantum noise

Page 44: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Orbits

NGO/eLISA orbit (NGO “Yellow Book”, http://lisa.nasa.gov/documentation.html)

• Hughes, S. P., & Bauer, F. H. (2002). Preliminary optimal orbit design for the laser interferometer space antenna (LISA)

• NGO “Yellow Book”, http://lisa.nasa.gov/documentation.html• Y. Xia, G. Y. Li, G. Heinzel, A. Rüdiger, and Y. J. Luo, “Orbit design for the Laser Interferometer Space Antenna”, Science China Physics (2010)

• Helio ETO very stable. ~kW of solar energy.• For short baseline and high acc noise reqs, can place orbit closer to Earth• Does the relative velocity of SCs require remote transponders?• How much $ savings by closer orbit? Lower initial velocities?

Page 45: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

LISA Noise BudgetingAcceleration Noise: 10�16(m/s2)/

pHz

“Current error estimates for LISA spurious accelerations”Stebbins, Bender, Hanson, Hoyle, Schumaker, & Vitale, CQG, (2004)

Page 46: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Frequency [Hz]10-3 10-2 10-1 100 101 102 103

Str

ain

[1

/H

z]

10-24

10-23

10-22

10-21

10-20

10-19

10-18UNGO Noise Budget

Total noiseMagneticCosmic raysResidual gasLaser RPRadiometerThermal RPNewtonianThrusterLocal Sensor Backaction

LIGO

Page 47: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

ConclusionsNeed more serious noise analysis (SC thermal, Doppler effects with realistic orbits, beam jitter,…)

Science case: how to exploit 6 decades of frequency space

Possible to get launch, rocket costs from JAXA/ISRO?

What is the real cost savings on payload?

Page 48: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Quantum!Mechanical Limits

Heisenberg!Uncertainty!Principle!

Page 49: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 50: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the
Page 51: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Electric!Field!of Empty Space

Page 52: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the

Carl%Caves,%PhD%‘79%

Yanbei%Chen%PhD%‘03%

Kip%Thorne%BS%’62%

Vladimir%Braginsky%

Page 53: Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the ...colloquium.bao.ac.cn/sites/default/files/PPTNo.33-2016-web.pdf · Gravitational Antennae for Probing the Dark Side of the