h s, n t - united states courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,eis6d on the bcrs or...

15
\ 2 N s, \ h \ a \ t GE-1082-0001 1

Upload: others

Post on 21-Feb-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

\ 2 N s, \ h \ a \ t GE

-108

2-00

01

1

NLeBlanc
Exhibit # Case #
Page 2: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

rl

fr-"4!;

q

iroEr rutr PBtcE

!Il'' BI'EBRrlEB CAOUP tlPtetsAtsP.. O. gOX 699tonlfElr, tt 75126

"s; f972)56{-5:i32

J$fii I1 .iln orcE

'n--"r;;l;;---lill.ffiNr'r\,uffi'-_-1lii!

--...-. -. .-, ..|

PBOPEBTY tDDAEsg. Z!73O Z. r-AO (SERqICA iOrD,lltits porx!, rr ?51G9 !,EGnr DESCr Ig! 3, CEERnI SpRrrcS ADDtrtOI,

vtx zlIDlI cODXry, ,EEaS

cLISm! JI,EN rrr.Ul rjnrcr

Ilro$f E\ELASE]Dg

REN'NNrXSSTATEENTIUIH'tOt,,H PA'MNT

lPrRatEII!:9lZ5l2OO4 | zazao u. t-2o (sEnMrcE RorD)

xrliats POIX3, Ir 751A9

300.00

PAYI.JNT Ai/|OIIHIINT}IS COLUAEI

fhmk Yon

GE-1082-0002

2

Page 3: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

REAL ESilAIE APPHAISAT

PreparcdFor:

i,OBI' IIIIY PRICE

PropertyAppnalsed:

23730 E. t-20 (SIRYTCE AOID'rlr,ls Foatt, It 75169

PrepalcdBy

tIaI{ RIIEAAIIER 6ROUP AEPR!'TSIIS

P- O. AOX 699. IORUEY, Et 75L25Pl: (972)561-3332 trl: (922)56{-57s2

GE-1082-0003

3

Page 4: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

ffi r;F#Sffi n{ffi giffi Ei"ffi *f,tr"*ffi ;+*igffi fl*

ldmtllbello ot Plogody tolry Apprtndl-l-l noopss 23730 z, r-20 {EERvrcE RorD, ciV nrr.r.s po:nrE **,or""n Pmpedr${wt/(serffiEl Propertysbt$(Ss€Attact€d) sEE ilrrrcaED

3ffirnlotlt HPrlp.rBzfrr..tldEAmirHEl F$si,npte f] r-easamra ['othsr

SLtilolot hbilb.l lL E ArDtr}3d

$rfil.ltf ot $.ADFi.ll.l prccaaftr. lolbfi.ltD Tnis b a Oompleb Apgtaisd asslgrrneG Al ot the proedut€3 of illr Vatuatio Proc.6J as |€qut]ld !y lhr Ur$Um StErdads ot

Prtt€.dml ApFisital Prsc*,ce (LSPAP) sFdflc qddeilrE3 lora ComCeb AppEbal we]R portomEd. Ifft Re.ficled AppraisdBgport b n* ba8ed (h cllent lllstrug{orlg,

l-il nie U a Umibd Appraieal a6eqFment All sf lhe pIocedrEs o, the vetualion Procass s EqdrBd by lhe thifoam Sbndarde ofP]olb6slonal AppEiaat Prac{ice (USPAP} sPeqnc gddelirrs tor a cflideis ADprrlsql rcre porbmed excep{ tor lttose departur3spGmltbd by tISPAP and re$Es{o.l by the dlenl. T}F di.flt urdergigrde ftc llmitaths or fls appr€hd and agnae that ihep.rbman6 o, lrtrs Lldled Appaatsat E appn prhb, Oepertne3 ,ron ft USPAF rpect'ic gulddlrEo are idgI||med €fit erqralnodln thb B€trtcbd AFpratga[ B6po{t or ln tD dlerde ot t& Gport

9l&rn otot^[A..unDdqtr.ilLt [,'ocidltrolt.ur.t^tffitr.Arltr-.oDlnior,rucorlc&donl-il asUnrmntotltdcd orodtosrylscumptons {,ldttmiilng cordthn3 ic att r$€d b thb l?porlffi e<tranrlrurys$lrutorEorlilalilngcddiEffiar"diidcedwilhctrismcnEoteqcfioplntonaldlaluecorEtrdonthstbalflcted.

DaGlplbnotnraErbntotti.PncarorColtadhgiAoddrhafilrrdF.podfneDrfrra so3aracE rqopE1rr rts pE:rsrcu,[r

StrisEltollr.lpFtb/rOttDbo ortrc tilgllG f .rd B.rf fr..otiffi prlDaily|;I nnsenttrse [Ofrer

Slrbcaot ot D.ltrl{m oltrlvrtr. io laE trn tldEI A dsfinilioD of \lElr8 Ddry s&nabd F attadled b thb

'3porln A deiriton of \,6tue estmated i3

lrlcdneApprEch

Rccqrciliafi qr lle ssa,rlci ;' i;;;' rns*' ;ffi ;iiio' Giii,;'iii "iii;;' ;tIrIlcBr.D 8rrr.Ea @.rD rID mlrs.

EailtrtdarlvdLcolfi.O.!.of^DpNlfld slslzoo4

IEI suPport4gdorunEnGilonfDrthisapprab;lbrdntairEdmlibbythsappraiser.Thsfil.isadlaualorirrspoc0onbytlodrst,such&idpddtesas rmyb.authofzedbydu p!€soof taw, !ilt6rlqdBdIyUSpApcut(,.[rDr.

arxt coocftdottr u!.d io Dtr .r ltll R..tlcbd eie-lret arlort rcrl.ffi Dtlrtdtsrst trd.rdrofPE.ldotr tADrtthrlPr.r0c.(usPAFlotTh^pprabdSirodarilrccnolti-ottraFDrd..rFoord.f|on.

9l26l200t

RESTBICTED BEPORT

/GE-1082-0004

4

Page 5: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

RGldtrisl fil cmmerctrCqEirrPl.,D f] nuresmdtllma l-l tnowtnrsl*hrPupGe f] nemOfs

aroEtf rl!ry EBTCE ./ OmrER: XlllEC tlEltr" !R

croi9os@ oE aF l(t49, @N{ B!.DGS, t [D

io$ zoo0oo aidtGdo.nietvdu-

hrd t r. EGt t GmDoitbnorutcmlgtbododc;em,rdoflhs propedis h l'to@ aid

!o Ba RSCEIICOT.IR tr sElpE laD ts &rcr.ost8o Brm

tlo FE[,A?o!e c FBrArEprih

P8. no rouBi.6t Ar^gEGrlllr oR

a mEsEEte ircirdlno nE(H r€raiE efsrr€d rngr Ern tryItq! ,IIISE Bln! :E lvanlcE

tr"W#S#fgffi{r*t:lrH."* Pre; r'q','edE r'E rr,rnbmi sranaaras o pmffi

:ffir?ffiffi "ffi ffi #ffi 'ffi fi ,ffi H"ffi q#ffiDRTATTAGilGNTS

ESTA

GE-1082-0005

5

Page 6: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

'[Dl'LSS|ltrl" rEne 1il0! tEB rroil[ DIFEIRIDICIS AEIrEllt lEt guB.rEc! rliD Collpg ilt mnnlI:[ED, lEt SugrR]ron rocxlroNsof lltl oOEtr'rBlE SlEEs tar &EEEEcllzD aT IEEIR suE rDJuarlcnrg. .ratEorrcf, tEE suralqps srrE tJ ,TBGErr rErxrEogl ol rE! co@rBrrirrE aErs' rls ar'rcirst lMttRton rnclllolr rg aEDIEcIBD rlr ttrs stg vrxrpi. cc&tps 1 a 2laElocl'ED Dl !{t c;rrt lrxtlls o! crrltw of BIGEL taAvEt[, lorDs rlrE @@ l,rgrBrrdrr rflo Ersr lccralt. corc, 13 ratocr!'!D r'ggr tloRrE or luc rEarELr cnll llLrls rfD Ers cooD vsErBrr.rfr ilm !&ti roclga. EsE gt sirBq! F]toE8nrlrusrocr.E! o" or 3-20 ll|lr r:lngY @OD VtslBrltlr BrE rtrEtgo lcelss. arrt lDlIilrDGA!!! 4DtCltB rE DTFTERAnCTSlI vNdrE tGtIEEa mE suEirscr tlEr oolprBralE gf,!8 Srtas sEclIDtJiss ot stgE. coilp ll,s rc! rs !s!Ir6EE, ;Et!!tIE OIEE lCBg mB lrlEt rBoa ltr REcoRDa.

alcmlrtf8&ltxusro8s: EA r EBtgr r!f AAIE, S,BSIr€r.BIEDE,IrafraAO!G. g.SIORIGE, olc_Or,r.rc! SptC!,FIEsETB&TC!

GE-1082-0006

6

Page 7: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

t

I\

23730 r. r-20 (sERltc ROrD-

Galculations30x37X30x3ax60x30x

. trto- gt0r l8mTor.I Bultdtne sF - ggoo

Olffca lrra r ?80slln Bulldla! lro,30x25X

{/2 8.th

,/2 Ssth 0ffi6 AE.

20rlti!8Eo!Xr*00{

GE-1082-0007

7

Page 8: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

Photograph Addendum

Subject Front

Subject Rear

Subiect Street

I-20 SERVICE ROAD ANDI-20 LOOKING WEST

aU

GE-1082-0008

ApldseisAddres P. O. BOX 699,

8

Page 9: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

popEniq*e$ 23?30 E. r-do-Glffics H6i6t

ItS,'{,4AtMEs I(*!l

Photograph Addendum

Subject Exterior 4

I-20 SARVICE ROAD .UND I-20IjOOAING EAST

Subject Exterior E

vrElg OF !A!ID BEEIITD BI'XI,DING

q

GE-1082-0009

9

Page 10: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

Addms 23?30 E, I-20 (

Photograph Addendum

Subject Interior I

IITTSRTOR WORR AREE

Subject lnterior 2

OFFXCE .An"EA

Subject lnterior 3

r}IAERIOR WORR ARIA

10

GE-1082-0010

10

Page 11: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

Photograph Addendum

Gomparable {

I.,S# 9746478NORTE TEXAS RELIJ ESTATB TNFO

Comparable 2

MLS# 9699655IiIORTE ?EXAS REAL ES?ATE rNrO

Gomparable 3

MLS# 10066683NORTg TEXAS REAI, ESTATE INFO

tlGE-1082-001 1

11

Page 12: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

Prcpared for:Riter Group Appraisals

23l3il lnterstate 20WlIs Poinr, TXZ5169-n19

@t 2002 FloodSource-orpior m ore Info rm afi o n, p teas e e-m a itTitlgiffi

GE-108?-oo1"

patents penoing.lit rilEffinreo.

12

Page 13: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

II DsftillonolHarlretyahe; Ordharf Assunptbns and Limiiing GondltonsI Cortiftcafon

I DEFnmroN oF TARKET YAUTE:

l#ll{f;#i[]Hffi#.#ffi,'tT,j*#,'#-Hffiil?r"""mm'',ffi"i";T,:1Hlffi-il"-3#ffff':ilt"#:HT:"l;ffi,sJ ;,il;; H;;'"1il*"n1** r,, miiam r,i" il;##;;#i$)r?lx#;*rHrHr;r$ffi; j il"J.trj.ff_-,1,L1#;":

I s:",['H]'1,'""#T:i*#H#ffiP:l,i;uixngmhkijlJ'*"###J#l* rho ndm,@midffi,ion,or rh€ Foporty

I

I onDNARy A$$flpnoits Ar{D t-ffiTf,{G COr{DtTroNS:I l. The Eppraisry wil mt be l@wible tor.matieE o, I legal mtuE that attect eithor the proporty belog appEised or iha tiflo to lt Ths apprakor eurc| ,'}|li*rTfrhffir:n{' mukotaDro *o u'reim' "*?ilil-"ilnv .prnio*

"u""r *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er

I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs approx-mie drmssim ed Is incru.rsd onrr to Bs.t the Bldq or rheI _ l-"?*t i, visuatizlng the propeny aru _unaerebnoing r. "'Jprir"7"-i;r"-tmiion a, lts Etze.| 3 lt tho apprateer hB effilned rh:..avdlabJe tr-a .irp" tiiirli-pririliri uy th" lJrir Ei"ire"*y irrug€mnr A,Errcy (or orhs data sow€) ed hrs

; . :m*n,*m,X':,n**ffi.1*,llLT;Hl'i:#:1; il;"i,ffi'il'#ff'o ffiffiL"a * rd .tpp,"r"r r nor , "u,ioi'r," -I 4' I re apprffitr wll rct gi* lcffmony or appor tn urt uaue he o. Eho m!. an appralsr q thg propffg in q*sflon ul6 Equhed to do & by a cosl| 5' rhe aFnbtr hs notsd in rho Epprab.l i"pott *v

"gnmonr-u#ili-arto* t"c;, "i "JioJliiililpr*,"r*rn, rhe prffie or haadow rc16,I ioxie substan*, oE.) obffii dqflng u'l ,."p,i.ta"ii J-iii,i,iuiJr Lprnv * thar he or she *.r" il". or orrtng tt* nom.t 66ar.1 invotv€d rnI porffihs rh6 appratsar rJnt$j olher;ie€ "ta6rl;-il'd;;;6jt m"."p*n* r,* no L_EiA,.IiaDy Nd6on or unappamt 6Mi0ons or rheI prqp"rtv c rdve*e envirmmdhr *noti* (in.rroi,g-nJ;;;#; ,* .d;;;;jr#fffiffiil1*.1 ,n", wourd mke rhe ppp$ry mor€ olI l* Elqble and lB "*d tist ,rse are' nJ suJ ii],,iii"ij'"ii ,** * sr*n!"; ;r;Jr;rii*.ror* il hpre4 ros{dhs rh, mdiron orI ne prcperty. The apmbs wit not t" *p"n"tn tor--i s,il-#,iiii1n .m oo ;xist q is ;ni;;;;ng- o, teting that mtght b€ ,equ?ed to drscowr

| ^ ffi.1mtr*ff*f.11;-ilo;;;;lLi;";;n.,in 'ne

tukr or sryrmmenrii,il;iao'ii',pp,"rar raporr musr no, b€ consrdsed asI 6 The apgrstsor oDttlnsd lhe lntomaton' etlnute, Eod opinim rh6t wore expressad in rho a*sjsar ,epon rrm $urc* that he o, sho @roHerE io bo

| - Sl3?tffi**E lhm to be tnp lnd #;i r;. fi;;.;H'* *rr" *p*'rdriv i"i r,'" arcurrcy or sucrr ir6m r*, re turnrshed byI 7' Tha appEb* will @t dircl@e tft: mton! oJ the @p.alsal FDort €rept G providod fq in tho unilqm stffdeds o, prclesslonat Apprdesl [email protected] 8' The appBis€r h8 b*sd hb orier sppralsl t"pont-inJ i.ritilIonor*ron tor a apprursar-*i [']"irt"t to sat't&tory €mpreron, ,€porre, qI dbtatbm on ilE esumtbn thst cmderio .r il" lrp.*rGi' *ii u. p.*o-"0 In a wtrkrn.n1re ,,*.I s. I hre qrc€d ro soiEr rnb $r. essis"rinr e r"qr.apJ'oi-i"-oii]niL_"o rn $e bport-ro;r,;;;;#ffi !y rho c[or whlcfi b srsted tn t F repsr

I H*,ffifxnlll';*ln:roffim;{m.:,i'*,t#-*g'o-#il#,I;ffi;[or,neuspAp.rheo,ienrh€ssredruif *",,

/

I

II

I

IlcERTtFtcATtoilI

I I @rtfy thlt b tho b6t o, my knqflledge md bo[€t:

I

I l. fte etatarcnte ot t8ct aotain€d h this repqt 4e tr@ ed gq*t I

" Hffif",fflHt#ff;1|Hffi J'^' niii-l"i:ov nre roported *umpriss and ,'nhs mditr6s,6nd a6 my r*o* *o** I

" iH:Ttt|*r"$"$flHj)mh1ff*"iv' lnt.rE't lh thl. prcpodv lhst rs tha subi€cr or rhre r€porl ed r havo rc (or rho 6p46led) pe.onar rntsmr I

;f,dffitiiffi{ffi:f#"*.ffi H#i##H"##ffi l:#il,J,ffi::::::,.:,H::l6' I havt (or hEve mt) G Indb8ted m the Eport made a p€6fla1 inspstim-o, the properg thst is t€ subieqt of thrs report r more than * **n * I, iHH :ffi ',H,rffi J:"j'Hffi.:T** ffi*Hm,*fr l,,*ffi#;rffi5;* d';L#e..'#:,:

*'*" * I

SI.FERI'ISORYAPFMTSER. CffiT*ICAflOTft t

:-;*'T':h*ml'n***i'ri'

jiii#;'dn;3tffi 'I'ffi"ffi 'f; ::r*#--tt*/

#"k il:*T.ffi"l1

GE-1082-0013

13

Page 14: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

IIh Li'dbd Aptrtsd DepartJre Dlstoouto ls port ol a Un*UO

"*';ffi ;"tr;#HHf'ff,f-,im;nff fl H#tpappraruthm*rini*ffi ffi .J;ors urrbd App.t.ur kufd o" *roo,*".

* "' ;*t"'";-mm ;ffilffT,fr,H1#ffi8ffirtr

;g;ffirfffiffinyry g *. un*ls to rr,sd q ft* rc,mer ffi7..Hffi ffiffirj#trffiffi#JHm ffimJmffi5?3fl: rffi J,HffiT rH,m!f,UCATE DEPAR'UiH! AflD Mr.A[ BELO*

I oJlcrrt nrc l -2 (a] .lequtEty.lffry o6 ret daiE, t,mtiry th. rsr prcparttr irterest 6r!rd6r the htEftted urcdbotion DrHs kEnuy &y speld ffieq ondrd* * *,,r, iJ#il. ."re or $o lpp',",l

o d tfio @.rr$t @rd&r tE €xrent ot tE d"1r

f] Urntert nfr t -2 (D) temerctp.t*hp*r:(i)i#";'ff*fftmmlffiJj=:fSbruket U,,ue, uF*onism*tcb,rryirdcab$dEthn thesrimb,s uFE_oEds stDrurtatrirumi! dfradhsr,,thw$!r-r*"-;;:;ffitT"rx toq!ft s tir) hs&.h othq brmrffld*rutb€.tsrb"o"Jiono*n,o*-*"touuuppornBn6ragIFT-drrarri"i,irrg-**r1""-dmybept€cis€ly(Hn€cila€limt orErtb

I-&__ ._ - rEd.edthomrket&rrupeorngmr"r"mr*on****&ililffiFfirfrcfrm6i5sirqts5aml8ti€h,iEm

E strndlrutub r-z(cl tdd&r ** eqDffi-

- oure fterc or a sl,f,{- .-,s.* s**m.'t B8tbb. d}qftDrsrra nws, BnahrR oomts s,oeh, dedaEuons. spechr asss*r* sdna*c q

I Stulrrt e.nr f -A (d, .cordd.r meths u 6,DBo"o ,rct*rd lrb*t ptr!/stcd sg*,,,, 6 plrlid hotdng ffihtut€ ,iD rub q !E tdle of tre wtrte:,

n $f,u'Nd ful! i-a (G, rdsrtty&dqur&f lieettst6'rueot.yporsrFopcrry,t,dorhruotrhhnlibrettffithrtr

- -r

rErs*tr"Bm&mlHlProp€[email protected]

E $rdard RL I -a (r) brxhr Irp sftet o @ ari ho ldG d the tor(mgdatro.n,ocorailcdqnma*,"prroior,daphbi|ry;*;.#;&mtffi:#HrHr#ffiffi*ffi.."*or{drr8rdM

E ilX#ffi;;*lffiarT. trarrreeruseom dEsh@otm,.EiabbrordaEoDmrrorbhir,BtrtldDeEil@*drrEtholepErsdor

EJ $.ltdrd nd. t-l (a) ldE tp dtp ovoopmprtteropnisa mhodq tstiqGfJEl StnrURrrrr-r(b).6{$r

enparaueco*m aJireT;##ffi#ffiff*3119=f dat!.!s @!Ei.r,re b cur*re,rdaqublvffirrod dd *so"a *i- "-il];-,;f =l*ffiInepemtrcdhornenerrcro*rmJ;;".}il;r:.1TT:ttr.tryI(0rsrcho,oerffi.of *,***"-#*,1'HT-,ffiffi"#H,Sj-H LT([im$?tgl*,qm$'r,.e dltr a {6 "tiiil t'*i*r .u" or opibrars n./a E* , #l"**il ;;il;H:HffiT ffi ffi [##:,* itr#fl

El q'ndrd 'rrr'

t'4 (c, ars DrciDtiE of tuture Bt&d *ps* o r€rmbrycr€.r ed rpproprub ar<kpsa

D lfrndl,diut t-l.(dl rirnorr

-duEl€a$(sr -'-' --'*tl'thgtl,tdtlootab€sdtsshledalsa$oE*hte,B,ddersld8ndy*lreett*tffErp.rrery,ofthetomaarr*idno'

[] tnCerrAlb f -a (.] rqfi&- *n*raa**,;";;;-#;fiffiff',*#"J,,#;,1fffim':,t,ffi",HF**tprtso'8,,opor!,8nd&r6h,rcm

E trrrd{dEb t-a (l} .com*

- erimpnctorcr-,,ir;i"omH5r[ffiflffi*tfl.o'ailkli*tedp.uiicdphnroinrromsnck'bdmqodrhoB*a.iotioqrsnrrhalmrr't

n $rdrdRrt r-t(g)tcnuv- ilt€mrrrutarre*;fi"rftilil5ilffnff.*" prGdr.s 6rrd nEtat hrdmoon qurEd b perrm uEepnt'4 hrcritnsd pi!6h.t, rmtbd.

o ffiffit;:sHffi ffiffiffi#ffi rd h&ir'-avq&ile rq ru* *q!,)*nE

-ipecrft.ri*, q oo,s doqmn."unffiqaDbchlr !r! ap,op'ine o*b* *p*s;'ffii:ffi'ffinLffi*H#;ffm#j

Elsl.tdade{bt-a(Il tlperUmtfnromtbtrintbG(!)Ulragn(t)atoasrUb€usahftodewtoprffitofuapFruat.

Ibparfure B<plainatrlons l-a (., i rt&GhoEE tLa

1.Ed

's Ef.B as a r.Aolq G c. bar.d q urk"t e-GEG-EE.r ,:hs IBc@ aoa Cet to Ehq G pot utl,tf:.CE tai',!d€ d.t rpq oc-cri"ili

tqtouu,on "*;@il;=;;

/(GE-1O8'-On1A

14

Page 15: h s, N t - United States Courts · *," llll iii'i,r"riii, b sp,Eis6d on the bcrs or ir berns qn.,er I z if the aP9rdq hss puidod r sketdr ln. th€ apprdeat ropo,t ths sreich shovs

/{GE-1082-0015

I

:6

TEHS APPRAISER LIGENSING AilD CERTIFICATION BOARD

&-itharyntlnt

NANMARIERITER

hcvingfinfificd the mintnunt qnlipatons prcwibenbyrhis Sratqis hrfo autlwreed to praake r*t propo$ rpproAot n f o* * o

**fffiffiffio=*NtmflcnlDt_13pt96j-L

Dae of lsucMdy{.2Cf,H

Dateof@imtioftAFrtn2ffi lnWrarrrllwoJ

l0aryu llfuihsnCotnmlsda|€r

15