hard edge of confrontation - harold weisbergjfk.hood.edu/collection/weisberg subject index... ·...

18
LIFE VOL. 68, NO. 4 FEBRUARY 6, 1970 Black Panthers: the ccording to government estimate, the Black Panthers number only about 1,200 mem- bers. They are scattered across the U.S. in two dozen chapters, some tightly organized, oth- ers so unstable that a single arrest could bring about their collapse. Yet the Panthers have emerged as the symbol of militant black rage, the hard edge of confrontation with the police. "They are convinced," says a senior Justice De- partment official, "that the black man will never get his just dues without the force of violence. Whitey just won't give in. So someone has to overthrow the system, and they're it." The Panthers spout the rhetoric of revolution ("Seize the time! All power to the people!") and in chilling, specific detail exhort their member- ship ("Guns, baby, guns. Kill the racist pig cops. Kill Richard Nixon"). They have armed them- selves heavily in the name of self-defense and they have used their weapons—not only in self- defense. So far, in the running guerrilla war of rooftop sniping, midnight ambush and mass shoot-outs that the Panthers and police have been waging in a number of cities, four policemen have been killed and scores more wounded. In turn at least 19 Panthers are dead (pp. 22, 23) and many have been wounded. (The Panthers claim 28 dead, but it is uncertain that more than a dozen have died of police bullets.) The Panthers charge that law officers are con- ducting a nationally coordinated campaign to ex- terminate them. The police deny it, but a Chi- cago sergeant speaks for many when he argues, "1 don't say cops should have a hunting license to shoot people, but when anybody—I don't care what his color—starts screaming 'Kill the pig cops' or tries to start a revolution, he belongs in jail. And when they start shooting police, they sure as hell are going to get shot back." In December the street war intensified when police raided Panther headquarters in Los An- geles and Chicago. In the latter raid two Pan- thers were killed, and there is evidence that the police did virtually all the shooting. The events gained the group so much public sympathy that a Los Angeles police official suggested, "Maybe we're playing the Panthers' game." Hitherto stand-offish black moderates gave statements of support, and some white liberals gave fund-rais- ing parties and pledged money—especially wel- come because the Panthers are chronically short. But the crackdown will continue. "I don't see the Panthers snowballing enough to succeed in overthrowing the government," says a federal of- ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow it." LIFE asked the noted black photographer and author Gordon Parks, a man respected in both the black and white communities, to report on the Panthers and their leaders, especially El- dridge Cleaver, the Panther minister of infor- mation. After serving a term for rape and as- sault, Cleaver was on parole when authorities ordered him back to prison because of his in- volvement in a Panther-police incident. Afraid that he would be killed in jail, he fled the country and is now living in Algiers. Parks's interview with him begins on the next page.

Upload: others

Post on 13-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

LIFE V

OL. 6

8, N

O. 4

FE

BR

UA

RY

6, 1

970

Black Panthers: the

ccording to government estim

ate, the Black

Panthers num

ber only about 1,200 mem

- bers. T

hey are scattered across the U.S

. in tw

o dozen chapters, some tightly organized, oth-

ers so unstable that a single arrest could bring ab

out th

eir collap

se. Yet th

e Pan

thers h

ave

emerged as the sym

bol of militant black rage,

the hard edge of confrontation with the police.

"They are convinced," says a senior Justice D

e-partm

ent official, "that the black man w

ill never get his just dues w

ithout the force of violence. W

hitey just won't give in. S

o someone has to

overthrow the system

, and they're it." T

he Panthers spout the rhetoric of revolution

("Seize the tim

e! All pow

er to the people!") and in chilling, specific detail exhort their m

ember-

ship ("Guns, baby, guns. K

ill the racist pig cops. K

ill Richard N

ixon"). They have arm

ed them-

selves heavily in the name of self-defense and

they have used their weapons—

not only in self-defense. S

o far, in the running guerrilla war of

roofto

p sn

ipin

g, m

idnig

ht am

bush

and m

ass shoot-outs that the P

anthers and police have been w

aging in a number of cities, four policem

en have been killed and scores m

ore wounded. In turn

at least 19 Panthers are dead (pp. 22, 23) and

many have been w

ounded. (The P

anthers claim

28

dead

, bu

t it is un

certain th

at mo

re than

a dozen have died of police bullets.)

The P

anthers charge that law officers are con-

ducting a nationally coordinated campaign to ex-

terminate them

. The police deny it, but a C

hi-cago sergeant speaks for m

any when he argues,

"1 don't say cops should have a hunting license

to shoot people, but when anybody—

I don't care w

hat his color—starts scream

ing 'Kill the pig

cops' or tries to start a revolution, he belongs in jail. A

nd when they start shooting police, they

sure as hell are going to get shot back." In D

ecember the street w

ar intensified when

police raided Panther headquarters in L

os An-

geles and Chicago. In the latter raid tw

o Pan-

thers were killed, and there is evidence that the

police did virtually all the shooting. The events

gained the group so much public sym

pathy that a L

os Angeles police official suggested, "M

aybe w

e're play

ing th

e Pan

thers' g

ame." H

itherto

stand-offish black m

oderates gave statements of

support, and some w

hite liberals gave fund-rais-ing parties and pledged m

oney—especially w

el-com

e because the Panthers are chronically short.

But the crackdow

n will continue. "I don't see

the Panthers snow

balling enough to succeed in overthrow

ing the government," says a federal of-

ficial. "But they're not too sm

all to kill police, and m

aybe others. We can't allow

it." L

IFE

asked the noted black photographer and author G

ordon Parks, a m

an respected in both the black and w

hite comm

unities, to report on the P

anthers and their leaders, especially El-

dridge Cleaver, the P

anther minister of infor-

mation. A

fter serving a term for rape and as-

sault, Cleaver w

as on parole when authorities

ordered him back to prison because of his in-

volvement in a P

anther-police incident. Afraid

that h

e would

be k

illed in

jail, he fled

the

country and is now living in A

lgiers. Parks's

interv

iew w

ith h

im b

egin

s on

the n

ext p

age.

Page 2: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

ship

("Du

ns, b

aby

, gun

s. Kill th

e racist pig

cops. K

ill Richard N

ixon"). They have arm

ed them-

selves heavily in the name of self-defense and

they have used their weapons—

not only in self-defense. S

o far, in the running guerrilla war of

roofto

p sn

ipin

g, m

idnig

ht am

bush

and m

ass shoot-outs that the Panthers and police have been w

aging in a number of cities, four policem

en have been killed and scores m

ore wounded. In turn

at least 19 Panthers are dead (pp. 22, 23) and

many have been w

ounded. (The P

anthers claim

28 d

ead, b

ut it is u

ncertain

that m

ore th

an a

dozen have died of police bullets.) T

he Panthers charge that law

officers are con-ducting a nationally coordinated cam

paign to ex-term

inate them. T

he police deny it, but a Chi-

cago sergeant speaks for many w

hen he argues, "1 don't say cops should have a hunting license

come because the rantners are chronically snort.

But the crackdow

n will continue. "I don't see

the Panthers snow

balling enough to succeed in overthrow

ing the government," says a federal of-

ficial. "But they're not too sm

all to kill police, and m

aybe others. We can't allow

it." L

IFE

asked the noted black photographer and author G

ordon Parks, a m

an respected in both the black and w

hite comm

unities, to report on the P

anthers and their leaders, especially El-

dridge Cleaver, the P

anther minister of infor-

mation. A

fter serving a term for rape and as-

sault, Cleaver w

as on parole when authorities

ordered him back to prison because of his in-

volvement in a P

anther-police incident. Afraid

that h

e would

be k

illed in

jail, he fled

the

country and is now living in A

lgiers. Parks's

interv

iew w

ith h

im b

egin

s on th

e nex

t pag

e.

Weapons poised, S

an Francisco riot

police (below) face a taunting crow

d outside B

lack Panther headquarters

last spring after they had broken up

a Panther street rally. A

t right, a Pan-

ther in Detroit kept a trigger-ready

vig

il in D

ecember fo

llow

ing a re-

port that a police raid was im

minent.

Page 3: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

hard edge of confrontation

Page 4: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow
Page 5: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

Eldridge Cleaver in Algiers, a visit w

ith Papa Rage

In th

eir hom

e cutsid

e Alg

iers, P

arks photographed Cleaver and

his w

ife Kath

leen b

eneath

a pic-

ture o

f Huey

P. New

ton, founder of the B

lack Panther P

arty, who is

no

w in

priso

n fo

r man

slaug

hter.

by GO

RD

ON

PA

RK

S

ne n

ight, ju

st befo

re left New

Y

ork

to see E

ldrid

ge C

leaver in

Al-

giers, a squad car eased alongside me

and stopped. Tw

o policemen jum

ped out. T

he older one carried a walkie-

talkie an

d th

e younger o

ne b

lock

ed

my

path

and

dem

and

ed so

me id

en-

tification. I was w

alking briskly from

my E

ast Side apartm

ent, late for the th

eater. Desp

ite the fact th

at I, like

many other black people, experience

this ty

pe o

f harassm

ent co

nstan

tly,

I was im

patien

t. Wh

en I ask

ed w

hy

I h

ad to

iden

tify m

yself, th

e young-

er one warned m

e that he would run

me in

if I did

n't. "I'd

prefer th

at," I said

. He co

pped

out, assu

ring m

e th

at th

ings c

ould

be w

ork

ed o

ut

there on the street. Then he inform

ed m

e I was in a w

ealthy neighborhood w

here there had been several robber-ies lately.

"Do I lo

ok lik

e a robber to

you?"

"All ro

bbers d

on't g

o a

round

wearing little black m

asks," he said. "A

nd all ro

bbers d

on't g

o aro

und

wearin

g b

lack faces," I co

untered

. A

s I reached for my w

allet to prove once ag

ain th

at I wasn

't a crimin

al, h

is han

d in

ched

tow

ard h

is gu

n.

"You tw

o are p

retty ju

mpy," I

said, pulling out my L

IFE

card. I h

ave alw

ays tu

ned

out at th

e term

"pig

." But w

hen

those tw

o fat

faces redd

ened

at the sig

ht o

f that

card

, I too g

ot th

e im

age—

very

clearly. I turned and w

alked off. "S

orry

, Mr. P

arks." I k

ept w

alk-

ing

. "Just d

oin

g o

ur jo

b. T

ryin

g to

p

rotect y

ou

. Merry

Ch

ristmas." I

went on w

ithout answering, shocked

at my th

oughts o

f rifles with

silenc-

ers, of rooftops—and pigs.

Sev

eral day

s later I told

Cleav

er about m

y experience. He sm

iled eas-ily

and sp

oke so

ftly. "

Thin

gs

hav

en't ch

ang

ed m

uch

back

in B

ab-

lyo

n sin

ce I've b

een o

n v

acation

." T

o h

im m

y in

cid

en

t mu

st hav

e

seemed

like ab

solu

tely n

oth

ing. H

is last en

counter w

ith th

e Califo

rnia

police ended with 17-year-old B

obby H

utto

n sh

ot to

death

, one B

lack

Pan

ther an

d tw

o p

olicem

en in

jured

, and C

leaver being hustled off to jail w

ith a bullet-shattered leg. C

leaver w

as no

w liv

ing

with

his

wife K

athleen

and th

eir 5-m

onth

-old son, M

aceo, outside of Algiers in

on

e of th

ose y

ellow

ish-w

hite co

n-

crete houses that line the Mediterra-

nean

coast. It w

as wet, w

indy an

d

unusu

ally co

ld fo

r Alg

iers. He w

as slum

ped in a chair, his legs stretched out, th

e in

fant slu

ng a

cro

ss his

sho

uld

er. He g

ently

massag

ed th

e b

oy

's back

. In th

e soft, rain

-filtered

light from the sea, he looked like any

other father trying to burp his child. B

ut h

is min

d w

as on a trag

ic, more

violent thing—the killing of his fel-

low

Pan

thers, F

red H

ampto

n an

d

Mark

Clark

, by C

hicag

o p

olice. "It

was co

ld-b

loo

ded

mu

rder," h

e said

in a low, caustic tone.

I handed him som

e clippings from

the A

merican

press, m

ost o

f which

, I felt, co

ndem

ned

the p

olice actio

n

in th

e killin

gs. C

leaver started

to

read an

d I w

atched

for so

me ty

pe

of reaction. As his eyes m

oved over th

e prin

t his d

ark face w

as imm

o-

bile. Maceo finally burped. E

ldridge called

Kath

leen. "C

om

e get th

is P

anther." As she took M

aceo away,

Eld

ridge fro

wned

. "That little cat

will g

ive th

em h

ell on

e of th

ese d

ay

s." He lit a

cig

are

tte, to

ok

a

healthy swallow

of Scotch and start-

ed re

adin

g a

gain

. I got u

p a

nd

loo

ked

abo

ut th

e ho

use.

There w

ere five ro

om

s, countin

g

a tiled kitchen that also faced the sea. E

mo

ry D

ou

glas, th

e Pan

thers' m

in-

ister of culture, and his wife Judy oc-

cupied one room. C

onnie Matthew

s, an

attractive g

irl who rep

resented

the P

anthers in Scandinavia, had the

other room. O

ff a dark hallway w

as th

e "wo

rksh

op

," littered w

ith ty

pe-

writers, m

imeo

grap

h m

achin

es, p

rintin

g m

aterials, Em

ory

's po

sters an

d p

arty leaflets in

several lan

-guages. T

he large living room-bed-

roo

m in

wh

ich I h

ad left E

ldrid

ge

was the gathering point. T

here w

as very

little laughter in

that house. T

oo many brothers w

ere in

coffin

s or p

risons. T

he co

ld ev

e-nings w

ere spent talking of friends, rev

olu

tion an

d d

eath, th

inkin

g an

d

planning to Otis R

edding's blues, to E

laine Brow

n's protest songs and to the soul-stirrings of A

retha Franklin

and Jam

es Bro

wn. It w

as the clu

t-tered

, temp

orary

shelter o

f a black

m

an

in e

xile

—w

here

bag

s stay

pack

ed an

d all p

recious th

ings are

mad

e po

rtable.

Cleav

er had

finish

ed read

ing th

e clippings w

hen I returned. "Well,

wh

at do

yo

u th

ink

?" I said.

"Crap

. Un

adu

lterated o

bjectiv

e

"Rig

ht o

n," sh

e repeated

. Maceci-

beg

an to

cry. E

ldrid

ge p

icked

him

up. "H

e's angry. He w

as born angry —

like a real P

anth

er." W

hen Maceo quieted I m

entioned that A

rthur Goldberg and R

oy Wil-

kins were form

ing a comm

ittee to do som

e investigating of their own.

"An

d w

hat are th

ose d

ud

es go

-ing to investigate?"

"Th

e k

illing

of H

am

pto

n a

nd

C

lark

." - E

ldrid

ge scratch

ed h

is beard

and

sm

iled fo

r the first tim

e. "An

d th

ey

will w

ind up saying the police were

justified

in sh

ootin

g th

e bro

thers."

"Th

ey m

igh

t find

just th

e op

po

-site."

"It doesn't make m

uch difference w

hat they find. It's too late for their concern. T

he brothers are dead. All

that is left is the problem. T

he Pan-

ther is th

e solu

tion."

"Are

yo

u a

ware

of th

e g

reat

amount of sym

pathy that has sprung up am

ong even the black moderates

since the Chicago incident?"

"Sy

mp

athy

wo

n't sto

p b

ullets.

And w

e can't defend every black per- son in B

abylon. Right now

it's a big jo

b ju

st to k

eep o

urselv

es alive. It's

the b

roth

er's job

, and

righ

t, to d

e- fend his ow

n home. A

nd there's only one w

ay fo

r him

to d

o th

at. When

co

ps b

ust th

rou

gh

yo

ur d

oo

r, pu

t a g

un

in th

eir faces and

say, 'S

plit,

mo

ther!' T

here's altern

atives. C

all th

e U.N

., or th

e civil lib

erty b

oy

s, o

r the p

olice statio

n, an

d tell th

em

you're b

eing sh

ot u

p. T

hen

wait."

"What d

o th

e Pan

thers h

ave to

offer black m

oderates other than vi-

Page 6: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

Ij

lilt I W

t11.:, III a

V

VC

cIlL

ily

where th

ere

had been several robber-ie

s late

ly. "D

o I lo

ok like

a ro

bber to

you?"

"All ro

bbers

don't g

o a

round

wearin

g little

bla

ck masks," h

e sa

id.

"And a

ll robbers d

on't g

o a

round

we

arin

g b

lack fa

ces," I co

un

tere

d.

As I re

ach

ed fo

r my w

alle

t to p

rove

o

nce

ag

ain

tha

t I wa

sn't a

crimin

al,

his h

an

d in

che

d to

wa

rd h

is gu

n.

"Yo

u tw

o a

re p

retty

jum

py," I

said

, pullin

g o

ut m

y LIF

E ca

rd.

I ha

ve

alw

ays tu

ne

d o

ut a

t the

te

rm "p

ig." B

ut w

hen th

ose

two fa

t fa

ces re

dd

en

ed

at th

e sig

ht o

f tha

t ca

rd, I to

o g

ot th

e im

ag

e—

ve

ry

clea

rly. I turn

ed

an

d w

alke

d o

ff. "S

orry

, Mr. P

ark

s." I k

ept w

alk

-in

g. "J

ust d

oin

g o

ur jo

b. T

ryin

g to

p

rote

ct y

ou

. Me

rry C

hris

tma

s." I

iicalt L

uasu It

WcIN

w

et,

IN iiiu

y a

liu

unusu

ally co

ld fo

r Alg

iers. H

e w

as

slumped in a chair, his legs stretched

ou

t, the

infa

nt s

lun

g a

cro

ss h

is

sho

uld

er. H

e g

en

tly ma

ssag

ed

the

boy's b

ack. In

the so

ft, rain

-filtere

d

light from the sea, he looked like any

oth

er fa

the

r trying

to b

urp

his ch

ild.

But h

is min

d w

as o

n a

tragic, m

ore

vio

lent th

ing—

the killin

g o

f his fe

l-lo

w P

anth

ers, F

red H

am

pto

n a

nd

Mark C

lark, b

y Chica

go p

olice

. "It w

as co

ld-b

loo

de

d m

urd

er," h

e sa

id

in a

low

, caustic to

ne.

I ha

nd

ed

him

som

e clip

pin

gs fro

m

the A

merica

n p

ress, m

ost o

f which

, I fe

lt, con

de

mn

ed

the

po

lice a

ction

in

the

killin

gs. C

lea

ve

r sta

rted

to

read a

nd I w

atch

ed fo

r som

e typ

e

of re

actio

n. A

s his e

yes m

ove

d o

ver

the p

rint h

is dark fa

ce w

as im

mo-

gliclg

eb. 1

Ile all ge liv

ing ro

om

-ne

o-

room

in w

hic

h I h

ad le

ft Eld

ridge

was th

e g

ath

erin

g p

oin

t. T

here

was ve

ry little la

ughte

r in

that house. Too m

any brothers were

in co

ffins o

r priso

ns. T

he co

ld e

ve-

nin

gs w

ere

spe

nt ta

lking

of frie

nd

s, re

volu

tion a

nd d

eath

, thin

king a

nd

pla

nn

ing

to O

tis Re

dd

ing

's blu

es, to

E

lain

e B

row

n's p

rote

st songs a

nd to

th

e so

ul-stirrin

gs o

f Are

tha

Fra

nklin

a

nd

Jam

es B

row

n. It w

as th

e clu

t-te

red

, tem

po

rary sh

elte

r of a

bla

ck m

an in

exile

—w

here

bags s

tay

packe

d a

nd a

ll pre

cious th

ings a

re

made p

orta

ble

.

Cle

ave

r ha

d fin

ishe

d re

ad

ing

the

clip

pin

gs w

he

n I re

turn

ed

. "We

ll, w

ha

t do

you

thin

k?" I sa

id.

"Cra

p. U

na

du

ltera

ted

ob

jective

cra

p. S

o w

e h

ave

to b

e sh

ot u

p a

nd

m

urd

ere

d in

our h

om

es b

efo

re p

eo-

ple

be

co

me

ind

ign

an

t. We

ha

ve

ch

arg

ed th

e p

olice

with

am

bush

and

murd

er o

ver a

nd o

ver a

gain

. Now

, a

fter 2

8 m

urd

ers, p

eo

ple

are

takin

g

a look. What are w

e supposed to do, pra

y for d

elive

rance

?" H

e a

sked th

e

questio

n in

a s

oft, d

ispassio

nate

voic

e, th

en a

nsw

ere

d it h

imself.

"Their d

eath

s w

ill have to

be

ave

ng

ed

. Th

e co

ps w

ho

mu

rde

red

th

em

must b

e p

unish

ed in

the sa

me

way th

ey c

om

mitte

d th

e c

rime."

"Rig

ht o

n, P

ap

a R

ag

e," K

ath

lee

n

snapped. H

er b

lue-g

reen e

yes w

ere

sm

old

erin

g b

eneath

a g

reat co

pper-

colo

red b

ush

y Afro

. Her fa

ce, p

ale

, stro

ng

an

d in

ten

se, re

vea

led

a fe

ar-

lessn

ess e

qu

al to

he

r hu

sba

nd

's.

Wounded in a 1968 O

akland police am

bush in which another P

anther w

as killed, Cleaver w

as taken away

in a police ambulance. S

tate au-thorities then re

voke

d h

is pa

role

. .

that is

lel t is

the p

roble

m. T

he P

an-

the

r is the so

lutio

n."

"Are

yo

u a

wa

re o

f the

gre

at

amount of sym

pathy that has sprung up am

ong even the black moderates

since the Chicago incident?"

"Sym

path

y w

on't s

top b

ulle

ts.

And w

e can't defend every black per-so

n in

Babylo

n. R

ight n

ow

it's a b

ig

job ju

st to ke

ep o

urse

lves a

live. It's

the

bro

the

r's job

, an

d rig

ht, to

de

-fend his ow

n home. A

nd there's only o

ne

wa

y for h

im to

do

tha

t. Wh

en

co

ps b

ust th

rou

gh

you

r do

or,, p

ut a

g

un

in th

eir fa

ce

s a

nd

sa

y, 'S

plit,

moth

er!' T

here

's alte

rnative

s. Call

the

U.N

., or th

e c

ivil lib

erty

bo

ys,

or th

e p

olice

statio

n, a

nd

tell th

em

yo

u're

be

ing

sho

t up

. Th

en

wa

it." "W

ha

t do

the

Pa

nth

ers h

ave

to

offe

r bla

ck mo

de

rate

s oth

er th

an

vi-o

len

ce, o

r a fig

ht to

de

ath

?"

"No

thin

g. N

ot e

ven

con

do

len

ces,

for th

ey w

ill brin

g a

bout th

eir o

wn

death

s thro

ugh th

eir o

wn a

path

y." H

e g

ot u

p a

nd

mo

ve

d a

cro

ss th

e

room

. He is b

ig, w

ell o

ver six fe

et,

bro

ad

-sho

uld

ere

d a

nd

po

we

rfully

built. He m

oves with the brutal grace

of a

fighte

r. "Vio

lence

? O

ur p

eople

are program

med into w

orse violence by U

ncle

Sam

. Tell m

e, w

hy sh

ould

bla

ck boys h

ave

to g

o fig

ht K

ore

-ans and V

ietnamese boys, instead of

the Maddoxes, R

eagans and Wallac-

es a

t hom

e? A

craze

d w

hite

lunatic

can attack a black man on the street.

Bu

t wh

en

the

cop

s com

e th

ey first

club th

e 'vio

lent n

igger.' V

iole

nce

?

We

ha

te it. B

ut is it vio

len

t to sh

oo

t a co

p w

ho b

reaks in

to yo

ur h

om

e

be

nt o

n killin

g yo

u?

If so, th

e P

an

-th

ers a

re vio

lent."

I rem

em

bere

d th

at rig

ht a

fter th

e

murd

er o

f Martin

Luth

er K

ing,

Bla

ck Panth

ers sp

read th

rough th

e

ghetto

s c

autio

nin

g a

ngry

young

bla

cks ag

ain

st viole

nce

an

d rio

ting

. C

ON

TIN

UE

D

Page 7: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

Nineteen m

en the Panthers list as `m

urdered' S

purg

eon W

inte

rs, 1

9, s

hot b

y

po

lice, C

hica

go

, No

vem

be

r 19

69

. In

quest ru

led it "ju

stifia

ble

."

Joh

n H

ug

gin

s, 23

, sho

t to d

ea

th,

UC

LA

lunch

room

, January 1

969.

Riv

al b

lack m

ilitan

ts c

on

vic

ted

.

Wa

lter P

op

e, 2

0, s

ho

t by p

o-

lice, L

os A

ngele

s, Octo

ber 1

969.

Inquest: "ju

stifia

ble

hom

icid

e."

Alp

rentice

Carte

r, 26, sh

ot, U

CLA

lu

nchro

om

, January

1969. R

i- va

l bla

ck milita

nts w

ere

con

victed

.

We

lton

Arm

stead

, 17, sh

ot b

y po

- lice, S

eattle, October 1969. Inquest

rule

d it "ju

stifia

ble

ho

mic

ide

."

Fre

d H

am

pto

n, 2

1, sh

ot b

y po

lice,

Ch

icag

o, D

ece

mb

er 1

96

9. In

qu

est

term

ed

it "justifia

ble

ho

mic

ide

."

Sid

ne

y Mille

r, 21

, sho

t by sto

re-

kee

pe

r, Se

attle

, No

vem

be

r 19

69

. T

he sto

reke

eper w

as n

ot ch

arg

ed.

Ma

rk C

lark

, 22

, sh

ot b

y p

olic

e,

Chica

go, D

ece

mber 1

969. In

quest

ca

lled

it "justifia

ble

ho

mic

ide

."

Tom

my L

ew

is, 18, sh

ot b

y police

, Los A

ngele

s, August 1

968. In

quest

rule

d it "ju

stifia

ble

ho

mic

ide

."

CO

NT

INU

ED

It only

giv

es th

e c

ops a

chance to

kill m

ore

of u

s, th

ey w

arn

ed

. An

d I

tho

ug

ht it s

ign

ifica

nt th

at a

fter a

stu

dy o

f viole

nce

, the L

em

berg

Cen-

ter a

t Bra

ndeis

Univ

ers

ity re

porte

d

that "o

f 381 ra

cia

l dis

ord

ers

occur-

ring

betw

ee

n J

an

ua

ry a

nd A

ug

ust

1969, o

nly

17 in

volv

ed B

lack P

an-

thers a

nd o

f those

17 o

nly e

ight w

ere

vio

lent co

nfro

nta

tions b

etw

een p

o-

lice a

nd

Bla

ck Pa

nth

ers."

But th

e p

olice

ha

ve d

em

ande

d th

e

Panth

ers' h

eads, a

nd th

e P

anth

ers

prid

efu

lly tell th

e p

olice

to co

me a

nd

. .

There

he w

rote

Soul on Ice, a

pow

-erfu

l and re

mark

ably

frank in

sig

ht

into

him

self. H

e h

ad b

een in

and o

ut

of ja

il since

he

wa

s 16

, an

d w

he

n h

e

left p

riso

n, a

t 31

, he

go

t invo

lve

d in

th

e b

lack re

volu

tion

, po

litics an

d th

e

Bla

ck P

an

the

r pa

rty.

"An

d fro

m th

en

on

," he

said

wist-

fully

, "the p

aro

le a

uth

oritie

s g

ave

me

mo

re tro

ub

le th

an

the

y did

wh

en

I w

as a

robber. T

he co

ps trie

d to

kill m

e o

ne n

ight in

a p

lanned a

mbush

. T

he

y m

urd

ere

d little

Bo

bb

y H

utto

n

inste

ad

. Th

ey sla

mm

ed

me

into

Va

-

These four policem

en died in

Page 8: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

We

lton

Arm

stea

d, 1

7, sh

ot b

y po

- lice, S

eattle, October 1969. Inquest

rule

d it "ju

stifia

ble

ho

mic

ide

."

Fre

d H

am

pto

n, 2

1, sh

ot b

y police

, C

hica

go

, De

cem

be

r 19

69

. Inq

ue

st te

rme

d it "ju

stifia

ble

ho

mic

ide

."

Sid

ne

y Mille

r, 21

, sho

t by sto

re-

keeper, S

eattle

, Nove

mber 1

969.

Th

e sto

reke

ep

er w

as n

ot ch

arg

ed

.

Mark

Cla

rk, 2

2, s

hot b

y p

olic

e,

Chica

go, D

ece

mber 1

969. In

quest

calle

d it "ju

stifia

ble

hom

icid

e."

Tom

my L

ew

is, 18, sh

ot b

y police

, Los A

ngeles, August 1968. Inquest

rule

d it "ju

stifia

ble

hom

icid

e."

CO

NT

INU

ED

It only g

ives th

e co

ps a

chance

to

kill mo

re o

f us, th

ey w

arn

ed

. An

d I

thought it s

ignific

ant th

at a

fter a

stu

dy o

f viole

nce

, the

Le

mb

erg

Ce

n-

ter a

t Bra

ndeis U

nive

rsity reporte

d

that "o

f 381 ra

cial d

isord

ers o

ccur-

ring b

etw

een Ja

nuary a

nd A

ugust

1969, o

nly 1

7 in

volve

d B

lack P

an-

thers a

nd o

f those

l7 o

nly e

ight w

ere

vio

lent co

nfro

nta

tions b

etw

een p

o-

lice a

nd

Bla

ck Pa

nth

ers."

But th

e p

olice

have

dem

anded th

e

Panth

ers' h

eads, a

nd th

e P

anth

ers

prid

efu

lly tell th

e p

olice

to co

me a

nd

ge

t the

m. A

s I sat th

ere

with

Cle

av-

er, I th

ought th

at to

avo

id th

e e

ven

gre

ate

r trag

ed

y, all o

f us w

ou

ld h

ave

to

be

com

e m

ore

tha

n id

le w

itne

sses.

The p

olice

must b

e u

rged n

ot to

pro

-vo

ke th

e b

lack re

volu

tion in

to a

fe-

rocious blindness; the Panthers m

ust re

alize

that th

ey h

ave

em

erg

ed a

s a

vital p

art o

f ou

r figh

t, bu

t tha

t rea

-so

n, m

ore

tha

n to

ug

h rh

eto

ric, is the

ord

er o

f those

thousa

nds, b

lack o

r w

hite

, who w

ould

support u

s. Sure

-ly, I th

ou

gh

t, som

ew

he

re in

ou

r his-

tory o

f ha

tred

an

d d

ea

th fo

r on

e a

n-

other, there must be an even greater

pla

ce fo

r coura

ge a

nd lo

ve.

"Wha

t is the fu

ture

of th

e yo

ung

bla

ck man in

Am

erica

?" I

said. "R

ight n

ow

their fu

ture

is in th

e

hands of the Wallaces, A

gnews, N

ix-ons, R

eagans, M

cCle

llans a

nd th

eir

cops. T

he b

lack yo

uth

s in B

abylo

n

won't have a future unless they have

the

gu

ts to fig

ht fo

r it." S

o many tim

es during his own life,

I thought, C

leave

r has a

ppeare

d to

have

had n

o fu

ture

. He h

ad fo

und

him

self w

hile

behin

d p

rison w

alls.

There

he w

rote

So

ul o

n Ic

e, a

pow

-erfu

l and re

marka

bly fra

nk in

sight

into

him

self. H

e h

ad b

een in

and o

ut

of jail since he was 16, and w

hen he le

ft priso

n, a

t 31, h

e g

ot in

volve

d in

th

e b

lack re

volu

tion

, po

litics an

d th

e

Bla

ck Panth

er p

arty.

"And fro

m th

en o

n," h

e sa

id w

ist-fu

lly, "the

pa

role

au

tho

rities g

ave

m

e m

ore

trouble

than th

ey d

id w

hen

I wa

s a ro

bb

er. T

he

cop

s tried

to kill

me

on

e n

igh

t in a

pla

nn

ed

am

bu

sh.

They m

urd

ere

d little

Bobby H

utto

n

inste

ad. T

hey sla

mm

ed m

e in

to V

a-

caville

with

a s

hot-u

p le

g a

nd re

-vo

ked

my p

aro

le w

itho

ut a

he

arin

g."

1 was in

Califo

rnia

when S

uperio

r C

ourt Ju

dge R

aym

ond J. S

her-

win

free

d h

im o

n a

writ o

f ha

be

as

corp

us, o

bse

rving th

at C

leave

r had

be

en

a m

od

el p

aro

lee

. I told

Cle

av-

er th

at I

was su

rprise

d a

t this ru

ling

—sin

ce th

e a

uth

oritie

s from

Reagan

on d

ow

n h

ad lin

ed u

p a

gain

st him

. "T

hat d

idn't sto

p th

em

," he w

ent

on. "T

hey tru

mped u

p so

me m

ore

charges and ordered m

e back to pris-on. I kn

ew

that if I

went back to pris-

on I w

ould

be k

illed. S

o I s

plit."

Now

, desp

ite su

ggestio

ns th

at, fo

r his o

wn sa

fety, h

e p

rolo

ng h

is "va-

catio

n fro

m B

abylo

n," C

leave

r told

m

e, "I'm

goin

g b

ack h

om

e to

San

Fra

ncisco

. Tw

o-se

ven

-seve

n-se

ven

P

ine is m

y addre

ss. Nobody is g

o-

ing

to ke

ep

me

aw

ay fro

m it."

I aske

d h

im if h

e co

uld

n't d

o th

e

pa

rty mo

re g

oo

d b

y writin

g fro

m A

l-g

iers, citin

g a

s an

exa

mp

le th

e tre

-m

en

do

us sa

le o

f his b

oo

ks ba

ck in

the S

tate

s. He b

ristled. "Y

ou ca

n't

figh

t pig

s with

elo

qu

en

ce. I've

go

t to

physica

lly com

mit m

yself."

If he co

mes b

ack, a

nd I a

m su

re

he w

ill, I belie

ve it is

to a

void

an-

oth

er kin

d o

f de

ath

. Th

e d

ea

th in

-side him

in exile is as bad as the other kin

d o

f death

I fear a

waits h

im b

ack

he

re. C

lea

ver is a

rmo

red

with

the

bru

tal tru

th o

f Panth

er h

isto

ry, o

f hard

streets a

nd to

ugh p

risons. Y

et

a b

asic n

aive

té m

ake

s him

vuln

er-

able

at tim

es. "D

o yo

u th

ink R

ea-

gan a

nd h

is c

ops re

ally

want m

e

back?" he asked me w

ith all serious-n

ess, "o

r do

you

thin

k the

y wo

uld

sle

ep b

ette

r if I staye

d lo

st?"

I did

n't kn

ow

. "Bu

t do

you

wa

nt

them

to sle

ep b

ette

r?" I a

sked.

"I want th

em

in a

consta

nt sta

te

of nightmare," he answ

ered icily. He

sat d

ow

n, lit a

noth

er cig

are

tte a

nd

crosse

d h

is legs. T

hen, e

yein

g m

e

close

ly, he

told

me

tha

t the

Bla

ck P

anth

ers w

ould

like fo

r me to

join

th

eir p

arty. "Y

ou

cou

ld se

rve a

s a

min

ister o

f info

rmatio

n." I sp

ent a

n

un

co

mfo

rtab

le m

om

en

t thin

kin

g

that o

ne o

ver. "A

lot o

f young ca

ts w

ould

be g

lad to

follo

w yo

u in

." "I'm

honore

d," I fin

ally

said

, "b

ut—

" "W

e n

ee

d yo

u m

ore

tha

n th

e E

s-ta

blish

ment d

oes."

"I'm h

on

ore

d," I re

pe

ate

d, "b

ut

you

mu

st rea

lize th

at a

s a jo

urn

alist

I'd lo

se o

bje

ctiv

ity." O

bje

ctiv

ity, I

thought, the word he hated so m

uch. "I h

ave

thin

gs I w

an

t to re

po

rt to

These four policem

en died in

John Frey, 23, shot arresting H

uey N

ew

ton, O

akla

nd, 1

967. N

ew

ton

was co

nvicte

d o

f mansla

ughte

r.

Fra

ncis R

appaport, 3

2, in

Chica

- go g

un b

attle

, Nove

mber, 1

969.

A P

an

the

r cha

rge

d w

ith m

urd

er.

22

Page 9: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

gunfights with the Panthers

MI A

A

IIli N

ath

an

ial C

lark, 1

9, sh

ot b

y wife

, w

ho P

anth

ers sa

y is police

agent,

in L

os A

ngele

s, Septe

mber 1

969.

Air

La

rry Ro

be

rson

, 20

, sho

t by C

hi-

cago p

olic

e, J

uly

1969, d

ied in

S

ep

tem

be

r. Jud

ge

d "ju

stifiab

le."

iii1111=111 R

obert L

aw

rence

, 22, sh

ot b

y po-

lice, L

os A

ngele

s, A

ugust 1

968.

Inq

ue

st ru

led

it "justifia

ble

."

Arth

ur M

orris

, 28, s

hot in

1968

Los A

ngele

s gun fig

ht n

ot in

volv-

ing p

olice

. No o

ne w

as ch

arg

ed.

Ale

x Ra

ckley, 2

4, to

rture

d, sh

ot,

New

Haven, C

onn., M

ay 1

969.

Panthers are charged w

ith murder.

Jo

hn

Gilh

oo

ly, 2

1, s

ho

t gu

n b

at-

tle in

Chic

ago, N

ovem

ber 1

969.

A P

anth

er c

harg

ed w

ith m

urd

er.

as b

ig a

n a

udie

nce a

s p

ossib

le."

"I'm m

ore

concern

ed a

bout

young stro

ng ca

ts follo

win

g yo

u in

to

the p

arty

." He h

ad m

e th

inkin

g

—back to

the in

flexib

le M

alco

lm X

. C

leaver was proving to be even m

ore in

tran

sige

nt—

the

mo

st un

com

pro

-m

ising in

divid

ual I e

ver m

et.

I exp

lain

ed th

at m

y inte

rests g

o

be

yon

d th

ose

of th

e B

lack P

an

the

rs, to

oth

er m

inoritie

s a

nd fa

ctio

ns o

f th

e b

lack m

ove

me

nt w

ho

wa

nt

change. He eased off, suggesting that

we le

ave

it open. I w

ondere

d w

heth

-er h

e fe

lt my p

ositio

n w

as a

cre

d-

itable

one. L

ookin

g b

ack to

that m

o-

ment I fin

d th

at I a

m d

isple

ase

d w

ith

my a

nsw

er. I sh

ou

ld h

ave

said

: Bo

th

of u

s a

re c

aught u

p in

the tru

th o

f

the b

lack m

an's o

rdeal. B

oth

of u

s are possessed by that truth w

hich we

de

fine

thro

ug

h se

pa

rate

exp

erie

nce

. H

ow

we

cho

ose

to a

ct it ou

t is the

only d

iffere

nce

. You re

cognize

my

scars a

nd I a

cknow

ledge yo

urs. Y

ou

are 35. I am 57. W

e meet over a deep

chasm

of tim

e, th

e e

vents o

f which

fo

rged d

iffere

nt w

eapons fo

r us. If I

we

re 2

0 ye

ars o

ld n

ow

I wo

uld

pro

b-

ably b

e a

Bla

ck Panth

er. I re

mem

-ber a

s a kid

I alw

ays to

ok th

e first

lick befo

re I fo

ught b

ack. B

ut a

fist is n

ot a

bu

llet. I to

o w

ou

ld sh

oo

t a

cop, o

r anyo

ne e

lse, w

ho fo

rced h

is w

ay in

to m

y ho

use

to kill m

e. Y

ou

a

re riskin

g e

veryth

ing

by g

oin

g b

ack

to ch

alle

nge a

system

we b

oth

dis-

like. I w

ill contin

ue to

fight a

lso, b

ut

on m

y te

rms. I p

refe

r to c

hange

thin

gs w

ithout vio

lence

—pro

vidin

g

violence is not thrust upon me. If this

is y

ou

r po

sitio

n, to

o, th

en

yo

ur

weapons a

nd m

ine a

re n

ot a

s irrec-

oncila

ble

as yo

u m

ight th

ink.

Cle

ave

r went o

n: "B

lack p

eople

a

re a

fraid

to jo

in a

milita

nt g

rou

p.

Th

ey're

afra

id th

e co

ps w

ill sho

ot

them

. That's ju

st why w

e m

ade th

e

cops o

ur p

olitica

l targ

et—

to p

rove

to

the b

roth

er th

at co

ps a

re ju

st fat,

gristle

and b

lood."

I asked him w

hat chances the Pan-

thers h

ad a

gain

st the o

verw

helm

ing

police

pow

er. "If w

e w

orrie

d a

bout

the odds, we w

ould be defeated from

the sta

rt," he sa

id.

It was d

usk. K

ath

leen b

rought in

a

bow

l of la

mb s

tew

. Cle

aver

reach

ed o

ver a

nd sp

ooned a

mouth

-fu

l, talkin

g a

ll the w

hile

. "We w

on't

be a

lone. A

lot o

f white

s rela

te to

th

e sa

me

issue

s tha

t we

do

. Th

ey're

ju

st as u

ptig

ht. T

he E

stablish

ment

will h

ave

to d

eal w

ith th

em

as w

ell.

Enough te

ar g

as a

nd h

ead w

hip

pin

g

will e

stablish

the co

mm

on e

nem

y." "D

o yo

u w

elco

me w

hite

s to th

e

fight?

" "O

f course. There has to be som

e in

terco

nnectio

n. W

e h

ope th

rough

som

e s

ort o

f coalitio

n to

brin

g a

ch

ange fo

r eve

ryone. I ju

st don't b

e-

lieve

that m

ost w

hite

s will sta

nd b

y and se

e a

min

ority w

iped o

ut w

ith-

out tryin

g to

put a

stop to

it." "A

nd th

e C

om

munists?

There

are

a lo

t of re

ports th

at th

ey a

re tryin

g

to in

filtrate

your p

arty."

"Bla

ck people

don't n

eed C

orn

-

munists to

teach

them

about tro

u-

ble

. The ja

ils in B

abylo

n p

roduce

m

ore rebels and revolutionaries than th

e C

om

munis

ts c

ould

dre

am

of

pro

du

cing

ba

ck the

re. A

n in

cred

ible

num

ber o

f those

rebels a

re b

lack,

and th

eir n

um

bers a

re g

row

ing b

y th

e h

our. W

e a

re o

ut to

tear d

ow

n

the s

yste

m n

ot w

ith fire

, not w

ith

gu

ns—

bu

t with

solid

po

litical a

nd

scie

ntific kn

ow

-how

. If it com

es to

guerrilla

warfa

re, in

div

iduals

will

die

. But in

div

idual tra

gedy c

an't

blo

ck libera

tion fo

r the m

asse

s." "A

nd

wh

at w

ill yo

u b

uild

in th

e

rubble

?"

"Socia

l justice

. If the b

lacks to

ok

pow

er to

morro

w a

nd tre

ate

d th

e

white

s like th

e w

hite

s have

treate

d

us for 400 years, I'd try to crush them

too. W

e p

rom

ise to

repla

ce ra

cism

with

racia

l solid

arity. T

here

are

no

bette

r weapons. W

e a

re d

isciplin

ed

revo

lutio

narie

s who h

ate

viole

nce

. T

hat's w

hy w

e a

im to

stop it a

t our

front and back doors. Then w

e won't

have

to w

orry a

bout o

ur ch

ildre

n d

y-in

g in

blo

od-d

rench

ed b

eds."

That n

ight I le

ft Cle

ave

r on a

wet,

win

d-sw

ep

t stree

t. It wa

s stran

ge

th

at h

is last w

ord

s were

about so

-cia

l justice

, the kin

d th

at is irre

spec-

tive o

f a m

an's

colo

r. I thought

about o

ther b

rilliant y

oung b

lack

men like

Sto

kely C

arm

ichael, M

al-

colm

X a

nd M

artin

Luth

er K

ing,

one s

elf-e

xile

d, tw

o lo

ng s

ince

gunned d

ow

n. I co

uld

n't h

elp

but

feel that Cleaver's prom

ise, like their dre

am

s, would

go u

nfu

lfilled. S

ocia

l ju

stice, it se

em

s, is much

more

dif-

ficult to

com

e b

y than m

artyrd

om

. ■

23

Ne

lson

Sa

sscer, 2

4, sh

ot, S

an

ta

Ana, C

alif., J

une 1

969. P

anth

er

was a

ccuse

d, is still a

waitin

g tria

l.

Page 10: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

Sylvester B

ell, 34, beaten and shot, S

an D

iego, A

ugust 1

969. R

ival

black militants have been accused.

Bobby H

utton, 17, shot by police, O

aklan

d, A

pril 1

968. G

rand ju

ry

rule

d it 'ju

stifiable

hom

icid

e."

Stev

e Barth

olo

mew

, 21, sh

ot b

y

police, Los A

ngeles, August 1968.

Inquest ru

led it "ju

stifiable

."

John S

avag

e, 21, sh

ot o

n S

an D

i- eg

o street in

May

1969.

Riv

al

black

militan

t is awaitin

g trial.

Fran

k D

igg

s, 40

, fou

nd

sho

t to

death

in L

ong B

each, C

alif., De-

cember 1968. A

ssailant unknown.

Nathanial C

lark, 19, shot by wife,

who P

anth

ers say is p

olice ag

ent,

in L

os A

ngeles, S

eptem

ber 1

969.

Larry

Roberso

n, 2

0, sh

ot b

y C

hi-

cago p

olice, Ju

ly 1

96

9, d

ied in

S

eptem

ber. Ju

dged

"justifiab

le."

Robert L

awren

ce, 22, sh

ot b

y p

o-

lice, Los A

ngeles, A

ugust 1

968.

Inquest ru

led it "ju

stifiable

."

Arth

ur M

orris, 2

8, sh

ot in

1968

Los A

ngeles gun fight not involv- in

g p

olice. N

o o

ne w

as charg

ed.

Alex

Rack

ley, 2

4, to

rtured

, shot,

New

Hav

en, C

onn., M

ay 1

969.

Panthers are charged w

ith murder.

gunfights with the Panthers

on m

y te

rms. I p

refe

r to c

hange

things without violence—

providing violence is not thrust upon m

e. If this is y

our p

ositio

n, to

o, th

en y

our

weap

ons an

d m

ine are n

ot as irrec-

oncilable as you might think.

Cleav

er wen

t on: "B

lack p

eople

are afraid to

join

a militan

t gro

up.

They

're afraid th

e cops w

ill shoot

them

. That's ju

st why w

e mad

e the

cop

s ou

r po

litical target—

to p

rov

e to

the b

roth

er that co

ps are ju

st fat, gristle an

d b

lood."

I asked

him

what ch

ances th

e Pan

--

munists to

teach th

em ab

out tro

u-

ble. T

he jails in

Bab

ylo

n p

roduce

more rebels and revolutionaries than

the C

om

munists co

uld

dream

of

producing back there. An incredible

num

ber o

f those reb

els are black

, an

d th

eir num

bers are g

row

ing b

y

the h

our. W

e are out to

tear dow

n

the sy

stem n

ot w

ith fire, n

ot w

ith

guns—

but w

ith so

lid p

olitical an

d

scientific know-how

. If it comes to

guerrilla w

arfare, indiv

iduals w

ill die. B

ut in

div

idual trag

edy can

't block liberation fo

r the m

asse

s."

Page 11: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow
Page 12: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

Inside Black P

anther national head-quarters in

Berk

eley (left), P

anth

er L

aury

n W

illiams frisk

s a wh

ite girl

visito

r for arm

s, or d

op

e that m

igh

t

be p

lanted

to p

rov

ok

e a po

lice raid.

In a San F

rancisco warehouse, volun-

teers work on T

he B

lack P

anth

er, the

party

's new

spap

er and p

ropag

anda

organ. Each w

eek 100,000 copies are d

istribu

ted n

ation

ally an

d o

verseas.

Page 13: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

him

a b

attle

pla

n d

raw

n u

p b

y the B

erke

ley

po

lice fo

r an

assa

ult o

n th

e n

atio

na

l Pa

n-

ther h

eadquarte

rs: "Assig

n tw

o-m

an sq

uad

to fro

nt w

ith sh

otg

un

(solid

slug

s) an

d a

r-m

or-p

iercin

g rifle

to b

last a

rmo

r pla

te o

ff upper w

indow

s.... Use

bucksh

ot to

shoot

out a

ll low

er w

indow

s. Use

rifle slu

gs to

try and k

nock o

pen m

ain

front d

oor. ... A

s-

sault sq

uad (th

ree m

en) a

rmed w

ith su

b-

machin

e g

uns . . . e

nte

r build

ing. . . .

Tw

o m

en ... fire

30 ro

unds e

ach

thro

ugh

seco

nd-sto

ry floor a

nd re

load. ... T

he e

n-

tire building should be flooded with tear gas.

The e

ntire

upper flo

or sh

ould

be co

vere

d

with

inte

nse

fire.... A

ssault sq

uad w

ill then

pro

ceed u

psta

irs a

nd b

ring d

ow

n th

e

wo

un

de

d a

nd

/or d

ea

d." B

erke

ley P

olice

C

hief Bruce B

aker said he had not seen the p

lan

, bu

t ad

mitte

d it w

as "p

rob

ab

ly th

e

work o

f our se

rgeants." S

o fa

r that a

ttack

ha

sn

't co

me

. "Bu

t," sa

ys P

ark

s, "it w

as

so m

uch

like th

e o

ne in

Chica

go th

at d

id

ha

pp

en

—e

xcep

t for th

e te

ar g

as—

tha

t I co

uld

n't g

et it o

ut o

f my m

ind

. I sat in

the

P

anthers' headquarters and looked at floors w

here

60 ro

unds w

ere

to b

urst th

rough, a

t

Atto

rne

y Ch

arle

s Ga

rry, wh

om

the

P

anthers call "the White P

anther" be-cause he has defended so m

any of th

em

in co

urt, co

nfe

rs with

Bo

bb

y S

eale in a San F

rancisco jail. Above,

Seale's w

ife Artie and their son M

alik, 3, visit B

erkeley headquarters, where

Mrs. S

eale remains an active P

anther.

says P

arks, "yo

u h

ave

to u

ndersta

nd ra

c-ism

as a

bla

ck ma

n kn

ow

s it. Th

eir e

ne

my

is the

po

lice. A

nd

if you

are

pa

rt of th

at si-

len

t ma

jority th

at w

an

ts the

po

lice to

wip

e

them

out, th

en yo

u a

re th

eir e

nem

y too."

Le

ss tha

n fo

ur ye

ars o

ld, th

e P

an

the

r or-

ga

niz

atio

n is

alre

ad

y ric

h in

leg

en

d. In

B

erke

ley, D

avid

Hillia

rd d

escrib

ed

to P

arks

the

first con

fron

tatio

n b

etw

ee

n p

olice

an

d

Hu

ey N

ew

ton

, the

Pa

nth

ers' ch

arism

atic

founder. A

rmed w

ith a

n M

-I and a

law

book, N

ew

ton h

ad fa

ced d

ow

n se

ven co

ps

in fro

nt o

f a b

lack s

tree

t cro

wd

. "Hu

ey

did

what th

ose

people

had w

ante

d to

do

for a

lon

g tim

e. H

e to

ld a

bu

nch

of co

ps

that h

e w

as th

rough b

ein

g kicke

d a

round

by th

em

. Th

e b

lack b

roth

ers g

ot th

e m

es-

sage. S

o d

id th

e co

ps."

New

ton is n

ow

in p

rison. S

o is B

obby

Seale, a P

anther leader who, as a defendant

in th

e C

hica

go

con

spira

cy trial, w

as se

n-

tence

d to

four ye

ars fo

r conte

mpt a

nd a

t one p

oin

t was o

rdere

d b

ound a

nd g

agged

in court by Judge Julius Hoffm

an. Seale also

is fightin

g e

xtraditio

n to

Connecticu

t where

th

ere

is a m

urd

er ch

arg

e a

gain

st him

. P

arks in

tervie

wed S

eale

in a

San F

ran-

cis

co

jail. "O

ur g

oa

ls," S

ea

le to

ld h

im,

"are

the

sam

e o

ne

s the

wh

ite m

an

figh

ts fo

r. A d

ece

nt e

duca

tion fo

r our ch

ildre

n,

good jobs, good housing. We have a break-

fast p

rog

ram

to fe

ed

po

or kid

s. We

wo

rk fo

r vote

r registra

tion so

that e

ventu

ally w

e

can w

rest c

ontro

l of b

lack c

om

munitie

s

from

the p

olice

. In fa

ct we w

ant ju

st about

the

sam

e th

ing

s Ma

rtin L

uth

er K

ing

wa

nt-

ed. It's o

nly o

ur ta

ctics that d

iffer. T

here

are

som

e stre

et cro

ssings in

bla

ck neig

h-

bo

rho

od

s tha

t ne

ed

traffic lig

hts. O

ur kid

s h

ave

to ru

n like

he

ll to ke

ep

from

ge

tting

h

it. We

'll he

lp th

em

ge

t acro

ss safe

ly eve

n

if we h

ave

to u

se g

uns."

Pa

rks fou

nd

the

sam

e co

ntra

st be

twe

en

vicio

us rh

eto

ric and e

arn

est g

oals in

all

the

gro

up

s he

visited

. He

also

no

ted

tha

t P

an

the

r influ

en

ce is sp

rea

din

g in

the

bla

ck com

munity

. "At firs

t I thought m

y s

on

Jam

es w

as ju

st infa

tuate

d w

ith th

e b

lack

leath

er ja

cket a

nd b

ere

t,- M

rs. D

oro

thy

Wood, th

e m

iddle

-class m

oth

er o

f a re

cruit,

told

him

. "But a

fter h

e e

xpla

ined a

bout th

e

bre

akfa

st pro

gra

m a

nd so

me o

f the o

ther

aims it w

as easier for me to accept. N

atural-ly I w

orry fo

r his sa

fety. H

e's b

ee

n a

rreste

d

thre

e tim

es, ju

st fo

r sellin

g th

e P

anth

er

new

spaper. T

hey d

ropped th

e ch

arg

es, b

ut

it'll pro

ba

bly

ha

pp

en

ag

ain

ne

xt w

ee

k."

25

Page 14: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

We w

ant the same things King

wanted. O

ur tactics are different' R

eturning from A

lgiers, Parks sought out

Panthers in the U

.S. to see how

the orga-nization w

orks and to get a sense of why

young blacks join it. In California D

avid H

illiard, the Panther chief of staff, show

ed him

a battle plan drawn up by the B

erkeley police for an assault on the national P

an-ther headquarters: "A

ssign two-m

an squad to front w

ith shotgun (solid slugs) and ar-m

or-piercing rifle to blast armor plate off

upper window

s. . . . Use buckshot to shoot

out all lower w

indows. U

se rifle slugs to try an

d k

no

ck o

pen

main

fron

t do

or. .. . A

s-sau

lt squad

(three m

en) arm

ed w

ith su

b-

mach

ine g

uns . . . en

ter build

ing. . . .

Tw

o men . . . fire 30 rounds each through

second-story floor and reload. . . . The en-

tire building should be flooded with tear gas.

The entire upper floor should be covered

with intense fire.. .. A

ssault squad will then

pro

ceed u

pstairs an

d b

ring d

ow

n th

e w

ounded and /or dead." Berkeley P

olice C

hief Bruce B

aker said he had not seen the plan

, but ad

mitted

it was "p

robab

ly th

e w

ork of our sergeants." So far that attack

hasn

't com

e. "But," say

s Park

s, "it was

so much like the one in C

hicago that did hap

pen

—ex

cept fo

r the tear g

as—th

at I couldn't get it out of m

y mind. I sat in the

Panthers' headquarters and looked at floors

where 60 rounds w

ere to burst through, at

window

s that buckshot would blast out."

The fear o

f surp

rise attack is a fact o

f life for the P

anthers and helps explain their conviction that the w

hole white w

orld is against them

. "To understand these kids,"

says Parks, "you have to understand rac-

ism as a black m

an knows it. T

heir enemy

is the police. And if you are part of that si-

lent majority that w

ants the police to wipe

them out, then you are their enem

y too." L

ess than four years old, the Panther or-

gan

ization is alread

y rich

in leg

end. In

B

erkeley, David H

illiard described to Parks

the first confrontation between police and

Huey

New

ton, th

e Pan

thers' ch

arismatic

fou

nd

er. Arm

ed w

ith an

M-1

and

a law

book, New

ton had faced down seven cops

in fro

nt o

f a black

street crow

d. "H

uey

d

id w

hat th

ose p

eop

le had

wan

ted to

do

fo

r a long tim

e. He to

ld a b

unch

of co

ps

that he was through being kicked around

by them. T

he black brothers got the mes-

sage. So did the cops."

New

ton is n

ow

in p

rison. S

o is B

obby

Seale, a P

anther leader who, as a defendant

in the Chicago conspiracy trial, w

as sen-ten

ced to

four y

ears for co

ntem

pt an

d at

one point was ordered bound and gagged

in court by Judge Julius Hoffm

an. Seale also

is fighting extradition to Connecticut w

here there is a m

urder charge against him.

Parks interview

ed Seale in a S

an Fran-

cisco jail. "O

ur g

oals," S

eale told

him

, "are th

e same o

nes th

e white m

an fig

hts

for.• A decent education for our children,

good jobs, good housing. We have a break-

fast program to feed poor kids. W

e work

rnr v

nfP

r rea

ktra

tinn

cn

th

at e

ventlin

fly

Page 15: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

In th

eir c

hapte

r headquarte

rs in

San

Fran

cisco, fiv

e Pan

thers stare straig

ht

into

Park

s's camera. "A

fter 400 y

ears

of s

truggle

and d

eath

," says C

hie

f of

Sta

ff David

Hillia

rd (c

ente

r), "revo-

lutio

n is

the o

nly

thin

g le

ft. - T

he P

an-

thers

are

care

ful to

dis

tineuis

h b

e-

Page 16: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow

In th

eir ch

ap

ter h

ea

dq

ua

rters in

Sa

n

Fra

ncisco

, five P

anth

ers sta

re stra

ight

into

Pa

rks's cam

era

. "Afte

r 400 ye

ars

of stru

gg

le a

nd

de

ath

," says C

hie

f of

Sta

ll David

Hillia

rd (c

ente

r), "revo-

lutio

n is th

e o

nly th

ing le

ft." The P

an-

the

rs a

re c

are

ful to

dis

ting

uis

h b

e-

twe

en rio

t—w

hich

they fe

el th

e w

hite

com

munity

will a

ccept, s

o lo

ng a

s it

occu

rs in th

e g

he

tto—

an

d re

volu

tion

, w

hic

h im

plie

s a

far m

ore

sw

eepin

g

an

d vio

len

t, bu

t pe

culia

rly Am

erica

n,

change. "It w

on't b

e a

revo

lutio

n like

th

ose in

Chin

a, R

ussia

, Cuba o

r Af-

rica," B

obby S

eale

told

Park

s. "J

ust

a Y

an

kee

Do

od

le kin

d o

f revo

lutio

n."

Page 17: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow
Page 18: hard edge of confrontation - Harold Weisbergjfk.hood.edu/Collection/Weisberg Subject Index... · ficial. "But they're not too small to kill police, and maybe others. We can't allow