harnessing synergies: responsible private equity investment in smes
TRANSCRIPT
Harnessing Synergies:Responsible Private Equity Investment in SMEs
Noah Beckwith, Partner, Aureos Advisers
TBLI Paris, November 2006
SME Private Equity: An Evolving Perspective
CDCFunds
1989-2000
•10 Aureos SME PE Funds: 2002-06•US$600m under management
AureosFunds
2001—
Private equity≠
Development
Development Impact: Profitability = Precondition
HolisticNDPs
CDC Funds Group Aureos Capital
International Development Community
Reconciling Commercial with TBL Objectives
Aureos and Development—Three Tenets2. Developmental and commercial objectives are mutually reinforcing.
3. Developmental criteria are intrinsic to investment process.
4. Development objectives are pursued within a commercial framework.
Developmentalism v. Commercialism
CommercialViability
Private SectorDevelopment
SMESustainability
Sustainable Outcomes: The Acacia Fund
• Three levels of development impact1. Microeconomic
• Access to capital, increased sophistication, technology and know-how, sectoral development and integration, economic linkages,
export development.
Economic Linkages
Sustainable Outcomes: The Acacia Fund
• Three levels of development impact1. Microeconomic
• Access to capital, increased sophistication, technology and know-how, sectoral development and integration, economic linkages,
export development.2. Macroeconomic/market
• Sales, consumption, fiscal contributions, export generation,
investment mobilisation, multipliers, externalities, demonstration
effects.
The Acacia Fund—Aggregated Indicators
The Acacia Fund—Contribution to Growth
The Acacia Fund—Regional Expansion of Investees
Sustainable Outcomes: The Acacia Fund
• Three levels of development impact1. Microeconomic
• Access to capital, increased sophistication, technology and know-how, sectoral development and integration, economic linkages, export development.
2. Macroeconomic/market
• Sales, consumption, fiscal contributions, export generation, investment mobilisation, multipliers, externalities, demonstration effects.
3. Socio-economic
• Poverty alleviation, sustainability.
Socio-economic impacts:A broader definition of poverty
• What is poverty?– More than starvation, malnutrition and premature mortality.
– “Pronounced deprivation in well-being” (World Bank Group).
• A broader definition– Opportunity: promoting opportunity for employment, enabling the poor to generate
wealth and to accumulate assets.
– Empowerment: reducing vulnerability to exogenous shocks which hit the poor hardest.
– Security: equitable access to market opportunities and opportunities for the under-skilled and unskilled.
Growth, Wealth Creation and Poverty Alleviation
S U S T A I N A B I L I T Y
Income Generation Wealth Creation Poverty Alleviation
AureosEquity Investments
in SMEs
InformalSector
Semi-Formal Sector
Formal Sector
Poor/Marginalised
Groups
Middle & Upper IncomeGroups
Low-IncomeGroups
Kiosks/micro-enterprises
Small enterprises Medium enterprises
Business Development- growth and profitability-professionalisation- formalisation
Socio-economic Impacts - asset accumulation- opportunity, security, empowerment- inclusion and enfranchisement
Economic Impacts- private-sector development- forward/backward linkages- investment generation
Sustainable Outcomes: Lake Harvest
•Kariba, north-east Zimbabwe–Harare: 350km
–Zambian Border: 7km
•Environs: within a National Park
•Transport Links: Road, Air Strip
•Population of Kariba (est.): 30,000
•Local Unemployment Rate: 80%
•% of Population HIV+ (est. 20-30%)
•Date: September 4th, 2002
•Deal Type: Management Buy-Out
•Investment Size: US$285,000
•Stake: 38%
•Instrument: 3,800 Ordinary Shares
•Other investors: Management Team (36.5%), Comafin (25.5%)
•Exit specification: Trade Sale to Strategic Investor
The LocationThe Investment
Sustainable Outcomes: Lake Harvest
Breeds Tilapia With Its Own Parent Stock
Currently Producing up to 2m Fry per Month
Transferred to Floating Cages
Tilapia Kept in Cages Until They Reach Harvest Size
In-house Training Ensures Top Quality Tilapia Product
Designed Own Packaging, With Security Features
Packaging – UK Retail
Advertisements in Trade Magazines
Sustainable Outcomes: Lake Harvest
Lake HarvestAquaculture
Healthcare
Employment
Training
Output
Multipliers Management
Health & SafetyEnvironment
•informal economy ↑•demand for housing ↑•local contractors used •fish feed plant estab-lished nearby
•good governance•improved systems &administration•reduced corruption
•skilling of local staff•workers perceived asstakeholders•staff more employable
•demand ↑•exports ↑•taxes paid ↑
•↑ jobs•↑ income•↑ jobs for women
•demonstration effecton nearby croc farm•resource preservation
•steady meals provid-ed so nutrition ↑•first aid provisions•hygiene ↑ in homes
•nutrition ↑•HIV/AIDS awareness ↑so vulnerability ↓•counselling provided•access to HIV testing