health economics 4 health financing (hf). hf - macroeconomics financing health care has evolved...

53
Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF)

Upload: morgan-freeman

Post on 04-Jan-2016

216 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Health Economics 4HEALTH FINANCING (HF)

Page 2: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HF - Macroeconomics

Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery to financing through health insurance (prepayment) by employer/employee at the work- place.

This has evolved in most industrialized countries toward governmental financing through social security or general taxation, supplemented by private and non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and personal out-of-pocket expenditures.

Ultimately, every country faces the need for governmental funding of health care either for the total population or at least for vulnerable groups such as the elderly and the poor, as in the United States, where governmental funding comes to nearly 50 percent of total health expenditures.

Government funding is necessary also for services that insurance plans avoid or are inefficient in reaching, such as community-oriented services and groups at special risk such as infants and women

Page 3: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HF - Macroeconomics

Health financing involves not only methods of raising money for health care, but also allocation of those funds.

Global health expenditures are derived from government and nongovernment sources and are used to finance a wide array of programs and services.

There is competition for funds in any system, and the way in which money is allocated affects not only the way the services are provided but also setting of priorities, as indicated some so-called “laws” of health economics

The economic consequences of decisions made in resource allocation are major determinants of health care economics. Each country has to cope with similar issues in reforms to correct for changing health needs and the economic results of former decisions

Page 4: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

‘’laws” of health economics

Sutton’s Law - Willy Sutton was a bank robber and when asked by a reporter why he robbed banks, he replied: “Well, that’s where the money is.” This expression is used to indicate that health services emphasize those aspects which are better financed. If more funds are available for treatment services, and preventive care is relatively underfunded, then treatment will have greater emphasis than prevention.

Capone’s Law Al Capone, a well-known gangster, planning the division of Chicago among his colleagues, said: “You take the north side and I’ll take the south side,” i.e., let’s divide things up according to our mutual interest. This expression in the health context is taken to mean that planning may reflect interests of providers, as opposed to that of the general public. An alternative use of the concept is that macroeconomics planning may serve a general interest at the expense of the indi- vidual patient.

Page 5: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

’laws” of health economics

Roemer’s Law - “Hospital beds, once built and insured, will be filled.” The supply of hospital beds is a key determinant of utilization, especially where the public has health insurance benefits covering hospitalization. This “law” was modified by the experience of changing payment systems with incentives to reduce utilization. Following the introduction of the diagnosis-related group (DRG) method of payment in the United States in the 1980s, there has been a reduction in hospital bed supply and occupancy. Incentives to control both hospital bed supply and utilization are crucial elements of health planning in most industrialized countries.

Bunker’s Law “More surgeons; more surgery.” A greater supply of surgeons generates more surgery. This has also been modified as managed care and gatekeeper functions limit referrals and self-referral to specialists, and as professional organizations and governments limit training positions and licensing for such specialists.

Page 6: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HF - Macroeconomics

Health care expenditure involves money spent from all sources for the entire health sector, regardless of who operates or provides the services. The methods of financing health care include tax-supported, social security- supported, employer-employee financed, charitable organizations, or consumer payment at the time of service.

The total of expenditures for health care and how those funds are spent are the most fundamental issues in health economics and planning.

Allocation of resources requires a skillful planning process to balance spending on different sub-sectors of the system and to assure equity between regions and various socioeconomic groups in society.

Page 7: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

What is the “right” amount of health care financing?

This is a political decision which reflects the social and economic value placed on health by a nation. These attitudes affect such issues as how well medical and other health care staff are paid in comparison to other professions, and the supply of physical and human resources for health care in a given society.

Virtually all developed countries have recognized the importance of national health and the role of financing systems to make health care universally available.

Page 8: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Basic principles and recommendations for successful health care financing Universal coverage through social security or tax-based system

Financing within national (pooling) means for social benefits

Adequate overall financing (>6 percent GNP)

Shift from supply-side planning to costs per capita (contestable)

Performance or output measures.

Categorical grants to promote national objectives and specific health target programs

Page 9: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Basic principles and recommendations for successful health care financing

Increase financing at national, state, and local government levels (7–10 percent GNP)

Health insurance as a supplement

Define "basket of services" and consumer rights

Reduce acute care beds to <3.0/1000 population

District health authorities with capitation funding

Incentives for improved performance measures including:

Preventive health measures

Health promotion

Disincentives for excess hospitalization, surgery

Incentives for integration of services

Page 10: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Facts

These rules are not absolute and solutions vary from country to country. But it is important to stress that the system of financing greatly affects the services provided.

There are large differences in levels of expenditures on health between countries: In the established market economies, on average 9.3 percent of GDP goes to health, while the former socialist economies expend 3.6 percent, and developing countries generally under 4.5 percent.

Per capita health expenditures also vary widely. The total per capita expenditure on health, whether as percent of GDP or as dollars per capita, does not reflect the efficiency with which the resources are used. Many countries not only have low overall levels of health expenditures but also allocate those meager resources inefficiently.

Page 11: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Facts Regardless of how efficiently money is allocated, countries spending less than 4

percent of GNP on health will have poorly developed health care.

Those spending between 4 and 5 percent of GNP may try to have universal coverage, but often achieve this through low staff salaries, inadequate equipment, and spreading limited resources too thinly. This is accentuated when a disproportionately large hospital system and excessive supply of physicians create a siphoning effect on health care spending, or when resources are concentrated in cities while most of the population is rural.

Developed countries that spend between 8 and 16 percent of the GNP on health care have made a value judgment. They have placed health care among the vital priorities in their societies. In those countries with high health care expenditures, such as the United States, physicians’ incomes are very high, even when compared with other highly paid professionals.

Where financing is centralized in a single paying agency, administrative costs are less than in countries with multiple funding sources. Canada’s provincial health insurance plans operate with administrative overheads of less than 5 percent, compared to some 30 percent in U.S. private health insurance.

Page 12: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Facts

The World Health Organization issued a Global Strategy for Health Development which stressed the importance of efficiency in use of resources as a vital element of health development.

The WHO recommends preferential allocation to primary and intermediate care services, especially for currently underserved rural populations.

In most countries, reallocation of resources is necessary to strengthen primary care and to adopt new technology and health programs, shown to be cost-effective in terms of costs as well as anticipated benefits

Page 13: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Facts

Where there are multiple sources of health financing, it is more difficult to develop effective national planning. Regulation and supplemental funding by government are needed/required to prevent inequity between socio-economic groups and between urban and rural populations.

When multiple agencies are involved in health insurance or direct government granting systems for specific services, there are gaps (inadequate coverage or access) in services, usually for politically, geographically, and socially disadvantaged sectors of the population, who may have the greatest needs.

Under such circumstances, public health services very often become oriented to provision of basic services for persons excluded from health benefits because of lack of health insurance.

This places a great financial burden on public health services, which are generally underfunded in comparison to clinical services. Such countries often bring in national health insurance for the disadvantaged groups (e.g., the elderly and the poor). These insurance plans may pay less well than private insurance for the middle class and organized workers.

Page 14: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Facts

Where financing of health care is centralized, a potential exists for rational allocation of resources. But this depends on adequacy of total financing and rational allocation policies to promote equitable access to services and a balance between one service sector and another.

Allocation of monies within the total health expenditures means selection from many alternatives.

Misallocation of resources between sectors within the health sector can lead to a wasteful and even counterproductive health system, such as excessive funding of tertiary care while primary care is lacking.

Page 15: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Facts

Where funds are allocated to regional or local health authorities, the potential for shifting resources to meet local needs should be greater. But this may be limited by lack of data or lack of analysis on a local or district basis to highlight priority areas of need.

Where there is a highly decentralized management system, some centralized functions are essential to promote national health needs and equity between regions of the country.

These include setting policy and standards, monitoring health status indicators, and determining health targets with funding to promote national priorities.

Page 16: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Major Categories of Health Expenditures

1. Institutional care Teaching hospitals, general hospitals, mental and other special hospitals, long-term nursing care, residential care, hospices

2. Pharmaceuticals and vaccines

3. Ambulatory care Primary care, family practice, pediatric, prenatal, and medical specialist; medical, diagnostic and treatment; ambulatory and day hospital clinics; surgical, medical, geriatric, dialysis, mental, oncologic, drug and alcohol treatment

4. Home care

5.Elderly support activity/service centers

6. Categorical programs Immunization, maternal and child health, family planning, mental health, STIs, HIV, tuberculosis, screening for birth defects, cancer, diabetes, hypertension

7. Dental health

8. Community health activities Healthy communities, health promotion in the community for risk groups; smoking restriction, promotion of physical fitness and healthy diet; environmental and occupational health; nutrition and food safety, safe water supplies, special groups

9. Research

10. Professional education and training

Page 17: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

COSTS OF ILLNESS

Direct expenditures for health care by type of illness are measured aposteriori in periodic Surveys of the civilian population, covering persons and homes for self-reported expenditures.

The largest items of health care expenditure were for cardiovascular disease, followed by injury, then neoplasms.

Following especially high rates of increase in health expenditures during the 1980s in the United States, measures were taken to restrain growth in health care costs, leading to a slower rate of increase.

In part this was due to growth of managed care and incentives for lower hospital utilization and by shifts in payment schedules for hospital and ambulatory care.

Page 18: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Costs and Variations in Medical Practice

Increasing costs of health care, waste, variations, and fraud/ informal payements in medical practice inevitably come under scrutiny whether pre-payment is in the private or public sector.

Variations due to the different needs of various population groups may be justified. However, if an epidemiologic analysis reveals no apparent reasons for the variations, then they become administrative problems which require other approaches.

Comparing the quantity and quality of services between population groups is part of epidemiologic and administrative health practice. This approach, when supported by review of relevant current literature on methods of treatment, provides a basis for what is termed evidence-based medical practice.

Page 19: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Costs and Variations in Medical Practice

Analysis of medical practice by examination of medical and hospitalization data may show quite startling differences between different cities, regions, and countries.

What has come to be called “small area analysis” looks at patterns of practice and tries to determine what may be the cause of such differences. For example, no evidence exists of benefit from higher rates of some types of surgeries, such as hysterectomy, cholecystectomy, and tonsillectomy. Further, there is a cost attached to a surgical procedure that includes a certain mortality rate from anesthetic mishaps and other iatrogenic complications; that is, caused by medical care itself.

Page 20: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Costs and Variations in Medical Practice

Excess supply of surgeons and the fee-for-service type of payment may lead to an excess of unnecessary and potentially harmful surgical procedures. The cost implications for a health care system are high and can be calculated.

Technological innovations using simpler, less costly, less invasive, and less risky procedures have led to important changes in health care standards.

Continuous evaluation of criteria for “good practice” leads to change based on new knowledge, experience, consensus or leading opinion and meta-analysis, and is essential to quality promotion in health care

Page 21: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Cost Containment

High public and professional expectations from health care can, along with increasing demands of an aging population, costly medical technology, and oversupply of highly techno- logical medical services, lead to a rapid rise in health care costs and a fiscal crisis in many countries.

Cost containment became important as the costs in all health systems increased at rates well above economic growth during the 1970s and 1980s. Governments everywhere sought ways to restrain cost increases.

Cost effectiveness and cost-benefit analyses have become a part of the planning and management review of ongoing or new interventions in health for both operational and capital expenditures as critical tools of health service planning for rational decision making to restrain health cost increases.

Because hospitals are the major consumers of health care expenditures (between 40 and 60 percent in different countries), the emphasis on cost containment has been placed on reducing hospital utilization and developing alternative services or programs of ambulatory and community care.

Page 22: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Cost Containment

Cost containment and high-quality health care can coexist. Indeed, cost-containment measures are associated with greater precision in care and more appropriate use of resources than previous patterns of care.

Some measures relate to substitution of lower-cost care for more costly services such as home care for acute hospital care. Others relate to changes in professional services; for example, outpatient surgery in place of inpatient care, and shorter hospital length of stay following myocardial infarction.

Countries with public funding of health care systems are especially concerned with establishing cost containment in order to reduce the rate of increase in health costs. For example, In Canada, governments have shifted their concern from assurance of access to care to cost containment.

Page 23: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Health Service Programs Promoting Cost Containment

Page 24: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PRIMARY/ COMMUNITY MEDICAL AND HOSPITAL CARE — HF MICROECONOMICS

Resource allocation policy, made at the national, regional, health insurance, or sick fund level, must address many specific factors affecting the way services are provided and paid for.

Incentives and disincentives for efficient care include how doctors and hospitals are paid, and how services are organized.

Payment for doctor’s services includes fee-for-service, case payment, capitation, salary, or a combination of these methods. Each has its historical roots, its advantages and disadvantages, as well as proponents and opponents.

Page 25: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Payment for Doctor’s Services

Fee-for-service is payment for each unit of service, such as a visit or surgical procedure.

Payment for a complete service covering the whole period of an illness or another type of care such as obstetrical care including prenatal care and delivery, or other, is called case-payment.

Fee- for-service is historically the common method of paying for doctor’s services and is still the norm in Canada, Germany, and other countries. In some places, payment may be according to a fixed-fee schedule negotiated between the insurance mechanisms, whether public or private, and the doctors’ representatives. Fee schedules are often weighted toward medical specialists who have greater prestige than primary care physicians.

Page 26: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Payment for Doctor’s Services

Fee-for-service tends to promote an overabundance of the more expensive kinds of care, including surgery, often without real need. This is especially so when the patient is fully fully covered by health insurance and is therefore better able to pay for the service than the person without insurance.

Some insurance systems require participation of the user in the co-payment or user fees or charges.

This is often promoted by the idea that it restrains the consumer from seeking unnecessary care, as well as helping cover costs, while opponents justly reply that user fees affect the poorer sector of any population disproportionately and discourage preventive care.

Page 27: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Payment for Doctor’s Services

Capitation is payment of doctors by a fixed sum of money for the individual registered for care for a specified period of time. This can apply to a comprehensive health service, as in managed care organizations, as well as to general practitioner services, as in the United Kingdom.

Compared with salaried service, this method allows a greater degree of personal identification of the patient with the doctor. It has been in use in the United Kingdom since the introduction of national health insurance in 1911. The recent introduction of incentive fees for full immunization or screening programs has improved performance in these areas.

Capitation is needed when the system is concerned with populational cover with primary care services. For example, in Romania there is a lack of primary practitioners, so they are stimulated to attract patients (on per capita).

Page 28: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Payment for Doctor’s Services

Salary payments for doctors and other health workers are common in hospitals even where fee-for-service or capitation is the prominent method of payment. This has advantages for the physician in predictability of income, with less incentive to promote unnecessary servicing. Salary payment may be combined with incentive payments for additional services.

The method of payment for doctors has an important impact on the way in which medical services are used. Empirical evidence indicates that fee-for-service promotes excessive use of the system, including unnecessary surgical procedures, while salaried services are often criticized for diminished identification with patients and, perhaps, underservicing.

Increasingly mixed systems of payment are emerging, with capitation as a predominant method

Page 29: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Payment for Comprehensive Care

Per capita budgeting is a system of payment based on a defined population registered for care with a specific health service system providing a comprehensive range of services, such as a district health system or a managed care organization.

Capitation payment covers responsibility for total care, so that economies in hospital care can be applied to cost-effective alternatives such as strong ambulatory care, home care, and long-term care. The population may be enrolled either on a voluntary basis, as in health maintenance organizations (HMOs), prepaid group practice systems and managed care systems, or on a geographic basis as in regional or districtual health systems.

Page 30: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Payment for Comprehensive Care

In some financing systems, the per capita payment takes into account the age and sex distribution of the region, locality, or the registered population. It applies national hospital utilization rates for different categories of age and sex.

The capitation method provides an incentive against unnecessary admissions and decreases length of hospital stay, but it is not in a hospital’s best interest to discharge a patient prematurely because of the potential for litigation and because the patient may later return in need of more care, adversely affecting hospital costs.

Page 31: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HEALTH MAINTENANCE AND MANAGED CARE ORGANIZATIONS

Health maintenance organizations (HMOs) are integrated health insurance and provider systems, responsible for hospital, ambulatory, and preventive care for an enrolled population.

It is a system of prepaid health care in which the insured person joins or becomes an enrolled member of a health plan that has received a fixed per capita payment from the insurer to provide comprehensive health care for a defined period of time.

This approach, which was developed in the United States, creates non-profit organizations sponsored by industry, unions, and cooperative groups. Formerly called Prepaid Group Practice, these plans were developed by Kaiser Permanente in California during World War II and later in many other parts of the country.

Page 32: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

DISTRICTUAL HEALTH SYSTEMS

In the United Kingdom and in the Scandinavian countries, a comprehensive service model has existed in the form of district health systems for many years. The residents of a district have their health benefits provided by or contracted out by the district.

In principle, the geographic unit of service allows for efficiency in transfer of resources and patients from one service to another, based on need, and not on the financial interests of the insurance system or the provider.

The Scandinavian countries have a long tradition of management of health facilities at the county level with budgets derived from a combination of local taxation and national grants. In reforms since the 1980s, integration of various services into district health systems with reduced hospital bed supplies has resulted in a leveling off of cost increases for health.

Page 33: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PAYING FOR HOSPITAL CARE

Hospitals are the most costly component of a health service. Traditionally, hospitals were paid on a per diem or flat rate per patient-day.

The per diem may be determined by using actual costs or by national, state, or regional averages. The daily operating costs are divided by the number of beds, with perhaps adjustment for teaching or research functions. The per diem based on actual costs per patient in specific units in a hospital, such as intensive care, may be higher or lower than the budget provides for that specific service.

The per diem method of payment encourages long lengths of stay, rewards hospitals with low technology, and if based on national or regional averages may penalize hospitals with high levels of staffing and technology, such as teaching hospitals. When the service is insured, there is no financial incentive for shortening the patient’s hospital stay. The per diem method is associated with inefficient use of facilities, such as admission to the hospital for diagnostic tests or prolonging a stay for additional testing or care that could be provided in alternative and less costly ways.

Page 34: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PAYING FOR HOSPITAL CARE

The provider has an incentive to hospitalize and provide prolonged care to a relatively healthy patient, while the sicker patient is a financial liability, as are teaching and research functions, unless funded separately. This system lacks incentives to improve efficiency by developing alternative ambulatory or day care services, and it punishes more efficient hospitals which reduce length of stay or occupancy rates.

Fee-for-service payment for each service supplied in a hospital favors unnecessary marginal care, long lengths of stay, high admission rates, and the provision of duplicative or unnecessary services.

This method was common in the United States with its multiple insurance systems but is increasingly being replaced by DRG payment. Fee-for-service payment provides and incentive to over-service with no incentive to reduce costs or admissions of length of stay.

Page 35: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PAYING FOR HOSPITAL CARE

Historical budgeting is remuneration based on the previous year’s budget, adjusted for inflation and the cost of new services.

The budget may be reviewed line by line by the paying authority or be on a global or block budget basis, which frees the hospital to make internal reallocations within the overall allotment. Payment can include a capital fund for renovation.

This method is often used when a hospital is directly operated by the Ministries of Health. As opposed to the per diem payment system, this method should theoretically provide some incentive to reduce length of stay and to search for efficiency in the use of hospital resources.

Page 36: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PAYING FOR HOSPITAL CARE

Payment by norms means financing according to nationally fixed standards of numbers of beds, staffing, and other measures. This method as practiced in the Soviet health system provided national incentives to maintain high hospital bed to population ratios, long length of hospital stay, little investment in improving ambulatory care, low salaries, and generally low quality of care.

Reform in post-Soviet countries requires cancellation of these historic norms, reducing excess hospital bed capacity and adoption of incentives for efficiency in health care

Page 37: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PAYING FOR HOSPITAL CARE

As a result of concern over high costs and utilization rates, alternative methods of payment have developed in the United States since the 1960s. The diagnosis-related group (DRG) system was adopted in 1983 by the U.S. Health Care Financing Administration as the basis for payment for hospitalization of Medicare patients.

The DRG system has been the basis for paying for hospital care in the United States since 1999, and it is increasingly being used in other industrialized countries, such as the United Kingdom and Israel, and some developing countries, such as Romania.

Page 38: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PAYING FOR HOSPITAL CARE

This provides an incentive to reduce length of stay, more efficient use of diagnostic and treatment services, and reduced overall bed capacity. As a result, hospital out- patient services increased rapidly in the United States while bed occupancy rates and the hospital beds to population ratio declined steadily over the 1990s.

The DRG system does not lead to fewer admissions and may encourage falsification of diagnostic criteria or increasing the diagnostic severity of case definition to increase revenues (“DRG creep”)

Page 39: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

PAYING FOR HOSPITAL CARE

Different hospital budgeting methods have advantages and disadvantages. Payment by DRGs is most likely to promote rational use of hospital care.

Regional budgets allocated on a per capita basis with hospital payment by DRGs may be the most effective way of achieving a balance between ambulatory and hospital care, combining regional equity and incentives for efficient use of diagnostic and treatment services.

Prospective payment systems must be associated with quality assurance mechanisms, a vital issue in health management

Page 40: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

CAPITAL COSTS IN HEALTH

The capital cost to build or renovate a health facility is based on long-term considerations but has important effects on current operating costs.

The cost of operating a new health care facility may equal the capital cost in 2–3 years. Capital costs may be financed by public or private donations, risk-capital investment, or government- guaranteed loans. Government regulatory agencies may approve a capital project of construction or equipment of a hospital under a certificate of need procedure and then agree to a grant mechanism to provide funds to match local contributions or to budget or adjust rates to include repayment of long-term loans for capital costs.

Where hospitals are operated independently of government, they may borrow or raise money privately through long-term bonds or low-interest loans. Repayment can be built into the operating costs and amortization of the loan over many years.

Page 41: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

CAPITAL COSTS IN HEALTH

When government finances capital costs, it has greater control over the direction, distribution, and supply of hospital facilities.

Government norms may encourage an increased bed supply by encouraging hospital construction, or maintenance of high numbers of beds that may not be used or may be of poor quality.

Norms may also be used to set upper limits or provide incentives to reduce bed supply. One of the common elements of cost-containment strategies in many industrialized countries is reduction in hospital bed supply, which is occurring without apparent harm to the quality of care. Hospital bed reduction is partly offset by transfer of long-stay patients to home care programs or to nursing homes with a transfer of capital and operating costs.

Overall, maintaining quality of care is not compatible with supporting a large and costly number of beds to population ratio (the converse of the aforementioned Roemer’s law) because of the excessive resources required to maintain these beds. beds at the expense of other needed services in the community.

Page 42: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HOSPITAL SUPPLY, UTILIZATION AND COSTS

Acute care hospital bed to population ratios in the United States and in the industrial developed countries increased from the 1940s to the 1980s and declined thereafter.

The supply and utilization of hospital beds are changing as economic incentives increase pressure to find less costly forms of care, and as ambulatory and community-oriented care is perceived to be more effective in many instances.

For example, In the United States, hospital utilization, average length of stay and percentage occupancy show a decline mainly during the period 1980 till now. Hospital staff per 1000 patient days increased reflecting increased support and technical services and greater severity of illness of those hospitalized. Increased staffing, technological innovations, and expensive medications increased the cost of patient care in hospitals.

Page 43: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HOSPITAL SUPPLY, UTILIZATION AND COSTS

There has been a trend to decrease the hospital bed supply and utilization in the United States and in the industrial developed countries during the 1980s, 1990s, and 2000s.

Despite aging of the population, the trend to lower overall hospital utilization has resulted from the following: changing morbidity patterns, ambulatory services in place of inpatient care, adoption of the DRG system of payment reducing length of stay, greater stress on health economics and cost containment in medical considerations, more efficient methods of care, greater health consciousness in the general population, and improved self-care and prevention.

Page 44: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HOSPITAL SUPPLY, UTILIZATION AND COSTS

Mortality, from coronary heart disease has decreased markedly during this period; however, admission rates for heart disease overall have not declined, while total days of care fell by 38 percent.

This is in part due to changing patterns of care, with shorter length of stay and a more aggressive rehabilitation approach to myocardial infarction, and emphasis on ambulatory care.

Medical treatment during the acute myocardial infarction stage is more effective than previous treatments, with technology such as streptokinase, angioplasty, stents, and other interventions.

All of this has been accompanied by a steady fall in mortality rates

Page 45: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

HOSPITAL SUPPLY, UTILIZATION AND COSTS

Many western European countries began to reduce their hospital beds in the 1980s. For example, Sweden and Finland reduced their hospital capacity by 53 percent and 36 percent, respectively, and Western Europe as a whole by 26 percent.

Countries of Eastern Europe and the former Soviet Union have high but declining hospital bed to population ratios (i.e., beds per 1000 population) and Hospital hospital inventories. Some have increased health spending, but some (Russia) are still relatively low in overall expenditures on health care per capita.

Reducing hospital utilization and bed supply creates a problem of staff and resource reallocation. Hospital facilities themselves can sometimes be converted to other purposes. Often, the most constructive use of obsolete hospital facilities is to transfer them out of the health sector, since the land may be of greater value than its continuing use for health care purposes.

Page 46: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

MODIFIED MARKET FORCES

Classically, market forces are seen as a means of empowering the purchaser to seek the least expensive and/or best goods or services from competing providers. The classical market forces are presented in this Box.

Page 47: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

MODIFIED MARKET FORCES

In health care, there are modifying factors that affect market forces. Understanding the modifiers of market forces summarized in Table is part of the preparation of a manager, provider, and policy planner for a strategic role in health systems.

Some of these modifiers are governmental regulatory factors, such as in supply of hospital beds. Others are related to access to services and the amount and method of payment and other factors that affect needs for care, as well as the quality and efficiency of a service. Market mechanisms are modified by regulations,

incentives, and other factors used to promote a balance of preventive, curative, and rehabilitative services, including health promotion to improve health and help the individual seek and find the most appropriate care at any point in time.

Page 48: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Market Forces and Modifying Factors in the Economics of Health

Page 49: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Market Forces and Modifying Factors in the Economics of Health

Page 50: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Conclusion

In principle health is a human right for everyone, and that management of resources is crucial to achieve improved health. This combination of overall public health commitment with an economic justification and management is the essence of the Public Health.

Advancement in its application requires political commitment, and funding adequate for a balanced program including health promotion, primary health care, hospital care, and long-term care, all essential elements of an effective health system.

Health promotion and primary care are the most cost-effective interventions in improving the health status of the population.

Where there has been an excessive emphasis on institutional care, there is real potential for transfer of resources and emphasis within the health system as part of the process of raising primary care and health promotion standards.

Page 51: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Conclusion

This is the essential direction of health reform in many countries which had overemphasized hospitalization for health care. Innovations in health care financing and administration, such as HMOs, managed care, capitation payment, fund-holding general practitioners, district health systems, and DRGs are all part of the search for more efficient ways of using resources and limiting cost increases.

Innovations in achieving better individual and population health include a wide array of technologies, organizational, and other improvements in medical care and prevention care, health promotion including legislation and regulatory public health functions, smoking reduction and greater awareness of healthy lifestyle, and outreach and home care services for people at high risk.

Page 52: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Conclusion

Many new technologies such as endoscopic and outpatient surgery, early and more effective care for cardiovascular disease, simple and inexpensive diagnosis and cure for peptic ulcers, new vaccines for prevention of cancer, and other innovations are making an impact on health systems.

The effectiveness of new health innovations and the economics of health in society are critically important elements of the New Public Health.

As populations age and as technology advances, costs will inevitably increase, but this can be moderated by resource allocation to pre- vent or delay the onset of complications among chronically ill persons in the community.

Page 53: Health Economics 4 HEALTH FINANCING (HF). HF - Macroeconomics  Financing health care has evolved from personal payment at the time of service delivery

Conclusion

Health must compete with other government programs for resource allocation.

In the Public Health, health care is an investment in human capital for the development of a country, as well as an ethical obligation of a society to its individual members.

The Public Health is involved in management of health care in all its aspects so that an understanding of basic issues in health economics is as vital to its practice as is an understanding of communicable disease or any other element of the broad panorama of health.