high-temperature cyclic oxidation data - nasa...nasa technical memorandum 101468 high-temperature...

468
HIGH-TEMPERATURE" CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA CHARLES A. BARRETT RALPH G. GARLICK 0 0 0 O CLEVELAND, OHIO NASA TM-101468 _4 _0 TURBINE ALLOYS, PART 2 OCTOBER 1989

Upload: others

Post on 14-Mar-2021

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

HIGH-TEMPERATURE"CYCLIC OXIDATIONDATA

CHARLES A. BARRETT

RALPH G. GARLICK

0

0

0

O

CLEVELAND, OHIO

NASA TM-101468

_4

_0

TURBINE ALLOYS, PART 2

OCTOBER 1989

Page 2: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

e-,, J_

9

Page 3: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

NASA Technical Memorandum 101468

High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data

Turbine Alloys, Part 2

Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. GarlickLewis Research Center

Cleveland, Ohio

October 1989

National Aeronautics and

Space Administration

Lewis Research Center

Cleveland, Ohio 44135

Page 4: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick
Page 5: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Contents

Summary ..............................................................................................................Introduction ...........................................................................................................

Alloy Composition ...................................................................................................Comments on the Data .............................................................................................

Page

1

l

1

1

References ............................................................................................................. 2

Table I.--Nominal Alloy Composition for High-Temperature Turbine Alloys .......................... 3

Cyclic Oxidation Data

Alloy 625 ......... .................................................................................................. 4

Alloy 718 ........................................................................................................... 6

Astroloy ............................................................................................................. 10B-1900 .............................................................................................................. 14

B-1900 + Hf ....................................................................................................... 29

IN-100 ............................................................................................................. 37

IN-713LC ......................................................................................................... 50

IN-738 ............................................................................................................. 54

IN-792 ............................................................................................................. 84

IN-939 ............................................................................................................. 128

MAR-M-200 ..................................................................................................... 132MAR-M-200 + Hf .............................................................................................. 142

MAR-M-211 ..................................................................................................... 162

MAR-M-246 ..................................................................................................... 170

MAR-M-247 ..................................................................................................... 174

MAR-M-421 ..................................................................................................... 196

NASA-TRW-VIA ............................................................................................... 200

Nimonic 115 ...................................................................................................... 208

NX-188 ............................................................................................................ 216

Renb 41 .............. : ............................................................................................. 222

Renb 80 ............................................................................................................ 224

Ren_ 120 ........................................................................................................... 231

Ren_ 125 ............................................................................................................ 234

R-150-SX .......................................................................................................... 244

TAZ-SA ............................................................................................................ 252

TRW-R ............................................................................................................. 305

TRW-1800 ......................................................................................................... 315

U-520 ............................................................................................................... 319U-700 ............................................................................................................... 323

U-710 ............................................................................................................... 395

U-720 ............................................................................................................... 399

Waspaloy ........................................................................................................... 407WAZ-20 ............................................................................................................ 435

MAR-M-509 ...................................................................................................... 439

WI-52 ............................................................................................................... 445

X-40 ................................................................................................................. 454

iii

Page 6: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick
Page 7: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Summary

This volume is the second part in a series of cyclic oxidation

handbooks presenting cyclic oxidation data tested at NASA

Lewis Research Center. It contains specific-weight-change-

versus-time data and x-ray diffraction results derived from

high-temperature cyclic tests for the remainder of high-

temperature, high-strength nickel-base _,/-y' and cobalt-base

turbine alloys tested at Lewis. Part 1 of the series is available

as NASA Technical Memorandum 83665 (Rev. 1989).

Introduction

The specific-weight-change-versus-time data and plots and

associated x-ray data complete the presentation of the cyclic

oxidation data for high-temperature nickel- and cobalt-base

turbine alloys tested at NASA Lewis Research Center. The

scope of this oxidation testing program is detailed in reference

1. The initial body of data for this class of alloys was presented

in reference 2. The test rigs and method of deriving the

specific-weight-change-versus-time data for the alloy test

samples are also described in this reference. These gravimetric

data are presented both in graphical and tabular form. X-ray

diffraction analysis of the retained oxide scale as well as the

accumulated scale spall performed after selected exposure

times are also presented in tabular form.

The data are presented for 36 alloys listed in alphabetical

order. There are 33 Ni-base alloys followed by 3 Co-base

alloys. These alloys and their compositions are listed in table I.

The hierarchical order sequence in the report for each alloy

is from high to low temperature in degrees Celsius and fromlong to short cycle time, with the majority of test cycles (i.e,,

standard cycle) being 1.0 hr with a minimum of 20 min

between cycles at ambient temperature. The samples were

removed and weighed at as close to a standard schedule as

possible (i.e., I, 15, 30, 45, 60, 75, 90, 100, 115 hr, and

so on). The cast alloys are listed before the hot-worked alloys.

Under the cast heading, the conventionally cast alloys are listed

before the directionally solidified. The number in the upper

right corner is an internal NASA number giving the alloy code

and run number (see ref. 1).

Alloy Composition

The compositions of the 33 Ni-base and 3 Co-base alloys

tested are listed in table I. In general, these are cast alloys,

although a few such as Waspaloy, Ren_ 41, and U-520 are

hot-worked wrought alloys. U-700 was used in many cases

as a standard involving both cast and wrought forms. IN-738

also included one hot-worked alloy although it is usually a cast

alloy. The comments column indicates whether more than one

heat and/or vendors were involved. The cast alloys were

generally in the as-cast condition. The alloy compositions listed

are within 10 percent of actual heat or sample chemistries

except where noted.

Comments on the Data

In general, the specific-weight-change-versus-time cyclic

oxidation data follow paralinear behavior; that is, the specific-

weight-change values increase with time to a maximum, with

roughly parabolic kinetics, and then reverse and drop in a

linear manner with time. By regression analysis the data canbe fitted to the model

AW/A =kl tl -k2t _ o (1)

where AW/A is specific weight change, t is time, kl _ is an

oxide growth constant analogous to the parabolic growth

constant derived in isothermal oxidation k_'_, and k2 is a linear

oxide spalling constant. This is a useful first-approximationmodel, particularly for these types of alloys, since an attack

parameter defined as

K a = (k__ + 10 k2) (2)

can be used to rank the cyclic oxidation resistance of the alloy.

Over 90 percent of the data in this handbook can be fitted to

equation (1) with an R 2 of 90 percent or greater. (R 2 is the

coefficient of determination, defined as the percent of variation

explained by the regression fit.) The remainder of the alloys

can be fitted more directly to

AW/A = - k2t ± _ (3)

Page 8: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Here Ka is defined as

Ka = 20 k2 (4)

These Ka values, together with the k_a and/or k2 values,

have been discussed in detail in references 1 and 3 to 10. K a

values have been shown to correlate well with either metal

loss due to conversion to oxide or thickness change as the alloy

metal is depleted. Ka also has the advantage that it is

relatively insensitive to the length of test as long as the

oxidation mechanism does not change. Mechanism change

usually means that a less protective scale becomes rate con-

trolling, which leads to "breakaway," or catastrophic, failure.

A simpler method of evaluation is to compare specific weight

change at a given time, say 100 or 200 hr. This is a very rough

ranking method unless the spalling rate is relatively high. In

general, the more negative the AW/A value at any given time,

the poorer the cycle oxidation resistance.

Variability of the data is also a consideration in cyclic

oxidation testing. This was discussed previously for this type

of test in reference 11.

Large differences in specific-weight-change values for a given

alloy for replicate test samples correlate with the variations of

oxide(s) detected by x-ray diffraction. These effects have been

discussed in detail in references 6, 9, 10, and 12. In the x-ray

diffraction results under the designation "spinel," a 0 values of

8.05 to 8.15 A, refer to aluminate spinel, whereas a0 values

of 8.20 to 8.35 A denote chromite spinel.

References

1. Barrett, C.A.; and Lowell C.E. : High Temperature Cyclic Oxidation

Furnace Testing at NASA Lewis Research Center. J. Test. Eval., vol.

10, no. 6, Nov. 1982, pp. 273-278.

2. Barrett, C.A.; Garlick, R.G.; and Lowell, C.E.: High Temperature Cyclic

Oxidation Data, Volume i--Turbine Alloys. NASA TM-83665, 1984.3. Barrett, C.A.; and Lowell, C.E.: Resistance of Nickel-Chromium-

Aluminum Alloys to Cyclic Oxidation at 1100 and 1200 *C. NASA TND-8255, 1976.

4. Barrett, C.A.; and Lowell, C.E.: The Cyclic Oxidation Resistance ofCobalt-Chromium-Aluminum Alloys at 1100 and 1200 *C and a

Comparison with the Nickel-Chromium-Aluminum Alloy System. Oxid.Met., vol. 12, no. 4, 1978, pp. 293-311.

5. Barrett, C.A.; Khan, A.S.; and Lowell, C.E.: The Effect of Zirconium

on the Cyclic Oxidation of NiCrAI Alloys. J. Electrochem. Soc., vol.128, no. 1, Jan. 1981, pp 25-32.

6. Lowell, C.E.; Smialik, J.L.; and Barrett, C.A.: Cyclic Oxidation of

Superalloys. High Temperature Corrosion, NACE-6, NationalAssociation of Corrosion Engineers, Houston, TX, 1983, pp. 219-226.

7. Barrett, C.A.; Miner. R.V.; and Hull, D.R. : The Effects of Cr, Al, Ti,

Mo, W, Ta, and Cb on the Cyclic Oxidation Behavior of Cast Ni-BaseSuperalloys at 1100 and 1150 °C. Oxid. Met., vol. 20, no. 5/6, 1983,pp. 255-278.

8. Stephens, J.R.; and Barrett, C.A. : Oxidation and Corrosion Resistanceof Candidate Stifling Engine Heater-Head-Tube Alloys. NASATM-83609, DOE/NASA/51040-53, 1984.

9. Barrett, C.A.: The Effects of Cr, Co, Al, Mo, and Ta on the Cyclic Oxida-tion Behavior of a Prototype Cast Ni-Base Superalloy Based on a 25

Composite Statistically Designed Experiment. NASA TM-83784, 1984.

10. Barrett, C.A.: The Effect of Variations of Cobalt Content on the Cyclic

Oxidation Resistance of Selected Ni-Base Superalloys, NASATM-87297, 1986.

1I. Barrett, C.A.; and Lowell, C.E.: Comparison of Isothermal and CyclicOxidation Behavior of Twenty-Five Commercial Sheet Alloys at1150 °C, Oxid. Met., vol. 9, no. 4, 1975, pp. 307-355.

12. Barrett, C.A.; Johnston, J.R.; and Sanders, W.A. : Static and DynamicCyclic Oxidation of 12 Nickel-, Cobalt-, and Iron-Base High-

Temperature Alloys. Oxid. Met., vol. 12, no. 4, Aug. 1978, pp.343-377.

Page 9: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

..l<

[-,

U.1

U_

0

Z0

E _ 60

.1 o

< _

I

0

0

°

I I ................... I ° • •I_ I _°I • I ....

..................... I I .....0

I I

IIiooII

,IIi _Ill

:o

J

I I I I i i

I I

I I

I

J_IIdI

I i I, l I

I I

I

' II , l l l

I I

ii

VI

_._o_o-o___ ___o_._ j_ _

+

o

i

Page 10: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

8'I

m

Iq

!

o

o

!

M

I

N

m

ID

O

.J

.J

_d

][

I[

0.

!.'

Q

r

lr

(D

O

W

X

8:

O

"I

O

Z

.J

4(

(J

I[

W

!"

O

lid

4[

II

I

IJ

m

)-

4[

i-

M

U

@.

II

M

M

N

I-

Ill

W

)-

O •

Q

O

O W

Q

Z

W

_ Z

)" 0

o u

o --

u

O.

o

o

N

18

I-

O

.J

..J

m

u

_l_maml_N_l_almMSMNlllh

mamNNmMa_ON_Mgm_lO_Nm_

I1[111111111111

4

_0000000000000000_00000

_0_00000000000000000000

,.**0,.0.**,.,.,****,,,,

I

0

o

O

00

00

0 o0

00

00

I

o

N

ell e / | • * IONYH3 XNOI]H

0

0

O|J|Old|

0

I0

o

o

In

I

0

0

0

0

0

in

o

,IP

_ _,

_ _

o

N

o

o

o

w

E

Page 11: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t N

0 q(

°I

!

nJ

u

z

O

..J

..J

W

!"

l

0.

4(

E

I[:

e[

(D

E

E

0

W

n-

o

I.i

w

E

E

O

U

w

m

0

W

J

c.}

o

u

O

o

N

m

4

4(

O

Z

0

N

4(

8[

Q

I

X

4[

0

M

M

0

0

.J *

4 0

.J

_, U W I1¢ m

d ,J _ 0 _ N

.J 0 .J el. -- E **

4[ O O u) i _ (.j

IL N

o

o

m

° ;

o

;4

• o

o

.J _

J , _p

4 _m

IL " I

U) o w

• .J

• _ • _ O

o O • I/) I-

)4 M

N

4¢ "_ I

I[ I-

M

_,p "^ O

am * o l0

O 4[ '_ G

4U _ • w

Z

W O m- w

Page 12: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

y,I

N

M

o

o

¢)

CJ

N

"r

)..

_d

W

i--

r,.

Q

¢s

Q W

0

Z

E,,,,,0,**,,,.,,,

Illi_Jllllll

• ...... . , ........ .

0o

0

.,J

v[

_C

O[

D.

v(

!"

]C

_[

l-

w

n_

0

0

W

o

W

m

0

3

) i i

0

0

0

0

0

0

I I

ill I / lu * _)0NVH_) ,L H 0 | ",JH

O

O

31,d|33dS

0

0

0

,I

I *

eU

W

I"

e"

Page 13: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

JNI/1M

I

9J

o

o

I

t

IV

o

u_

o,J

.J

4(

w

E

0:

O.

4(

£

E

(o

E

E

O

W

0

Z

Z

.J

U

W

E

r

0

U

I

K

v

U

Z

0-

9

al

nl

w

t,-

,ic

_1

u

q.

N

u

o

o

0

.J

,4

4[

a

Z

O

m

O

>-

n,

X

I:

O

.I 14

4( _D

O. I A

_2 N

I- ..J

4J _J _ Q:,o Z 0

,,J .J _ O iV

,J O .J O. * *. I_

IL N U

U)

_4

,4 I[

IC

o m

W _ U

9"

O [.- W

m .J D

U • ID Z O _ W"U• Z O _ iV

O 4( -- _ *- m •

i[ O I-- Z _ 4J *- b.

U)

Page 14: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

N

o

o

I

I

N

o X

u

o

nj

t,1

N

)-

0

.J

.J

4

..J

kd U

E )-

E

L *.

£

0

?,£

I" u

,4

0 --

0

:I

0

W

1"

O

u

I

bJ

0 )-

0

.J

Z <

w

i-

t.

4

oo0

: wtrl

z

<

X

4n u

w

Q

W

.T

U

LI.

W

W

L

u

IIIIIIIIIIIIIII

1

_O0000000oo00000000000a

_0000000000000000000000

..... ........... 0......

!

I

i

I

I

0

00

0

00

00

0

iII/II*]ONVH_

0

00

0

,LH@ I ':111 g I .t I _)3dS

0

0

__

O

Ic_

ill

i

o

cl

In

1.1"

o

cl

i-

tvl

o

P.

I%1

cl

ikl

II:

M

I-

Page 15: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

!

J

o

o

I

0

N

o

J

W

3:

m.

a.

E

£

4(

(D

0

w

m

0

:Z

0

Z

..J

_)

Q:

W

E

0

U

Z

i-

I-

L.

°o oz

0

bJ u

..j ,_

u 8[

x

u

m

.1

.I

A

o

o

..j .m

4[ m

Q _

W I'-

l,I I_1 U

_ N

o

z

_o_XU_ _

o

0 --

_-. ,j

:°"'

u

• 8[

A U

C_ m

_" _ U

I[ e _ m

Z

Ld

Page 16: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

I

o

Q

I

I

o

0

W

E

I*

r

W

E

O

P

C

Z

.J

U

W

E

O

u

(J

m

U

m

$-

I

0

w

o0

o

o W

Z

u

u

u N

W

_ 3

,I

O U

U

a.

0

O

l

u

_Om_OOM_OM

li$11

::oo:oo:oo00 00 00

*.,,.,,*,,

0

0

0

I i

o

o'

m

!

leille* ]9N¥_0

I0

0

_-HQI]M

@

J m

0

0

!

OIJlO3dl

i

0

I

o

o

0

0

o

o

o

o

, o

°

Page 17: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

N

r_

_r

i

;4

o

o

i

14

i

N

o

_n

0

w

I-

L

K

¢J

E

E

.r-

(D

Cl

bJ

0

:Z

,.I

4[

IZ

1.1

E

o

u

W

m

Z

e

X

Z

I,-

N

o

N

w

: oZ

0

N

w

..i ,I(

(.,) at

o _.

*. o

o

_ m

x

u

).

O

.J

O

Ic

<

q(

o

j

4(

u) kd

..J

G

w _

.J .J N O

j _ .j _ _ rr

U_

4[ '4

o o (/J

IV) gvl u

f'l -I

•,4 ',,4 4[

kJ _ _ V_

• "o I g)

L*. * ° CD W

W W 0

kd _- _ _n, n, kd O k'l _.1"

m

J

OOZ_

x

N

0-

I-IC

(J

_m _ m

4[ "_w u

Z 0 _ Z

r U

W • ¢_ Z * O "_ W

•1( 0 4( G. Z _-

I_ O l- U1 _ 4.) Z k_

]!

Page 18: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

;4

I

W4

r*

t

M

0

0

!

M

Aj

0

m

).

0

.J

.J

<

lld

E

E

0.

4

IC

Z

<

E

£

Q

W

v

0

Z

.1

<

W

E

E

0

W

,(

m

Ig

U

N

I"

W

o •

0

'2 .z

<

w

w

L

u

y

e*, .... ,,*...*.*.

IIIII

_0000000000000000

_00000000_0_00000

.... ,.,..,;.,,-._.

r

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I1

!

0

8u_ liu' )IIDNVH_

12

/HOI]H

O.

31J133dS

|

0

0

0

.1"

c:)

nl

a_

1-

l-

Page 19: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

I

i".

.I.

I

Oq

0

o

I

m

I

N

0

)-

0

.J

.J

W

I-

N

n,

L

E

I"

(D

E

E

,(

O

W

0

=

0

Z

.J

0

W

r

11-

0

(J

W

Ut

I

I

t

U

'1"

W

0

o

o

N

hi.

,.J

U

)p

U

0

U

0

0

4[

t.,.

4K

Q

Q

Z W

< m

OK 0

Q •

L

I z

u

m

Z

.J _

< 0

L Z

X

4[ •

0 1-

14 4

l:

I')

"44 lJ

0 I

kJ _ (J'

. me,

_ W W

_ Z

,_ t,- W.

I.I, .,I "_ 0 _ I+d

4 • lU _ (J

b. " 4 *. I[ *[

I I.,. g I- b.

In

0 0

4 m t

._ a a

a

_0_ m

.J N

.J

IL m

Q

Ill ._. -- L

L3

N X

0

4 _ 4•

_ _ __

O(--L_i-- • 141_''tK_ (

Page 20: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

(0!

o

o

I

o

aJ

o X

¢.)

.!"

)-

I,I

)- ¢#

0 )-

.J r._

,I

I"

n,

n

11"

I: u

l-

W

IC

Q

I#

W

4[ 0

m 0

m

w ¢

!, m

v

4 Illllll

q

_000000000

_000000000

I

I

o

o

o

o

o

o

o fU V_

I t !

im 0 /Im * ]ONVH_ LHO I ]M 01.111 _)]dl

14

o

o

o

M

Page 21: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

k'I

I

o

0

!

o

J

o

0

.I

J

w

E

a.

E

0

E

E

J

U

_g

E

O

U

Z

m •

( u

m.0,,...,,

w

m.-

oo

Z

Z

_ u

w

_- o0 _

U

W

o

o

o_

|

• , , • . . ° . ° .

O

O

O

O

O

t I • Ik_ 0 W

N _n f_

ie# I lu ' 30N¥1+3 LHO 1311 3 I .11 3lids

15

0

o

a

o

ci

i.

Id

I-

M

I--

Page 22: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W0

W

IC

N

IE

O.

Q

!"

E

0

I"

t_

_J

U

W

E

S"

O

fJ

w

W

m

m a.

o

u

j N

o

i

o X

Z

o

N

w

Q

o

o

w

.I

u

w

o

u

Q

Iin

N

o

o

0

I

m

4[

0

0

q(

4(

m

o

OC

I

34

oo

M_

oo

< * U

w w

w •

_U E_WW --_Z

M JO_

x

N

_ U

_ m

_ w

_ _ w

m

16

Page 23: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

N

N

I

.T

O

I

N

o

g

(.,)

X

U

-r

IN

Ul

0 )"

,,.J U

,,,J

E

G.

11-

]C U

,<

° :

I"

r_

<

(,,.)

4

u

m.

w

m-

E

o

w

m

m

z m

w

Z

Z

_ u

w

u

o

w

u

W

a.

u

:11111t

_:::°::°::° o°,,,, .... °

N

F)

0

C)

0

(3

C)

, Iin

|

iae / In _ _gNVH3 _HO! ]M 31JI :)'3dg

IT

0

Ic_

I

o

o

o

O

-

- :

- :

o

_ ,_

-- _

o

Page 24: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

!

N

M

t

o

o

I

z

o

!

N

o

Ul

)-

0

J

,J

w

E

A,

Q.

<

E

E

<

0

E

E

<

Q

D,-

U

J

q

U

a,

W

E

E

0

W

m

M

Z

W

t,

o

W

o

N

o

o

o

m

N

I

m

Q

0

N

I-

(J

m,

Q

E

!

x

• q[

o o

M

M

• . °o o

< m U

• al _j _j

bJ • •

t,. ,_ W _ a, a, m m

,m kl • Z _ _ 0 0

L -- U

X

N

_ Z

_ZOZ_ _

_0__

]8

Page 25: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

(J

m

AJ

W

)..

o

m

0 >-

.J u

.J

s- o

a.

,i(

1£ o

o Q

4[

(g

u

u

E

w

E

£

O

kJ

U_

4[ O

m O

m

Z 01

4(

¢)

W

Z

Z

U

(D

w

u

m_

u

W

#l)

N

u

mo_m_zmN

o,,,,0,,,°

*O00_NNN_

6|111|'1

q

_0OOOOOOOO_DOOOOO'OOO

0

0

J,

I

ilmt lio']@NVH:)

0

IH@ I ]lq

0

,J ,o

N

I

31dl:]d|

0

o

0

o

a;

o bJ

m E

l-

19

Page 26: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

.J

.J

q(

W

E

E

E

<

E

,(

0

<

u

w

E

E

O

q

m

m

!

I

N

M

!

I

o

I

o

Z

I-

o

N

w

t.

o

o

IJ

o

o

N

N

o

o

m

m

!

I

£

k-

,ql

Q

Z

0

0

a,

x

.m

m o

n

u1

ul m

u j

g -,b W

_ < IE .

o

m

x .

N

E

r_J

:w_ (j

o m

w 0 -- I_ /.I

_* _ * (8 w

•m 0 Z _ w Z W

4( Z _ 4V _ _ (.,I

b. Q < IL m _ 8. _[

tn

2O

Page 27: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

Q

o

I

G

I

o

III

0

J

J

_J

E

0.

E

o

E

T"

E

I"

0

U

W

Ln

m

E

<

IJ

m

1l

q,J

N

Z

m

L.

0

W

.J

U

6.

0

U

Q

0

m

i

dD

IIIIIII

::o::ooooo0 O00OO

o,,.,.,,,,

WO_O_O_O0

T

l.J !

W

II.

l.J

llJ

a.

In

0

0

0

0

0

0 0 0 0

t I

0

le= I I a ' 30NVI.I:) J. HO I |H 3 I _11 =3dli,

21

I

D

I

,. ,.

0

I:1

t,,

al

Ill

10

Page 28: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t

f_

M

!

ooI

j.

o

t

N

Q

0

.J

J

,I(

w

E

a.

4.

E

E

o

E

O

U

-I

U

W

E

£

O

U

N

U

N

m

m

P'l

N

W

L.

W

.J

U

CJ

,m

U

O

Z

O

O

i

X

Q

O_OW

I " O

L J _ |

W 0 W 0 •

W * •

""''22W Z -- Z

_ _ 0 N N

i

X

4 IC

]C

,1[ le

k. 40 * _O W

nr | _ [I O[

I_ .j 1,-

_ Z

Ig ..8 .j _

i_ 0 4( IL -- e_ O. 4(

22

Page 29: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

me

!

r,

M

i

o

o

i

c:)

i

hJ

o

E

m

u

u mo_o-M2_loow-_

a0,,,0****,..,*** .

,ooooooooooQ

¢,I

o

S

M

w

Ut ..d

)- cJ

0 )-

.J o

.I

lid 0

O.

E

I* U

._ °I1: _

£

-I

U

0

bJ

U_

• 0

nn 0

OD

-- I

Z m

I-

,I[

0

bJ

t9

Z

q(

"r

4.)

ul

A.

LO000OO0000000000

,.0,,,*****.*,,,*

0

0c_

c:)

n • _ u

0

0

0

0

0

0

lu; lie* ]OMVH_ /HO I )fl 3 I _113]dS

23

0

0

0

Io

I

0

a

o

o

m

o

o

4;

wI"m

o

Page 30: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

r-

Po

I

:r

o

nJ

o

a.

E

111

u

N

z

I-

o

>.

0

J

./

w

E

E

0

I-

¢.b

m

u

W

m-

E

o

t.

8

°o

oo

bJ

..J

U

_m

o

o

Q

Z

0

n.

b.

0

X

,4

0

J _.4

• o

G. <

t/I o

tn D

L, m W _'

• J O O G. • rr

X

m

E

N

m

< D

0

• O

24

Page 31: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

i

_r

N

M

I

O

ID

t

z

D

I

0

o

-4

w

r

a.

Q.

I"

<

6_

i-"

.it

0

U

W

m

u

Q°,,,_°.o.°.,,,,,

*DOOQODDOOOO

_ i|10iiiiJlll

X

¢J

z

M

M

w

D _

Z

,.J _

g.

0

0

0

I

M

. ...... , . . , ......

WQ--_O_O_OO_O_O_OO

0

0

0

O

O

O

O

El _ liU* ]ONYH3 _H813H 3 I _1 3]dS

2_

O

O

O

O

OI

¢)

I0

_U

N N

_U

Page 32: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

N

i

o

w

.I

<

w

Z

I[

0.

E

E

o

E

£

<

O

<

U

-1

U

W

E

E

O

U

E

N

,i(

N

X

N

"I"

w

m.

o

o

u'l

w

.I

u

)-

i.

.I

o

o

GI

I

I

(..

Q

Z

0

M

N

0

*

)(

w

M

o

*II W

WOO

x

T

o I

_ Z

0 • I-- W

26

Page 33: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

I

r_

Jr

I

I

o

4

hJ

¢:1

t,d

O" _"

E

G.

4(

E

E U

_ o

_ °oE _

E

,i(

u

w

E

E

0

u

W

IIn

m o

In

w ;

Z m

0

w

Z

u

w

U

w

G.

u

• .... .,,°,,0..,.0...,..

o_O000000_O000000000000

0

0

0

0

0

0

00

0

0

00

0

0

0

00

I I

o

Illl' I IO' )0HYH0 ,I.l'lOl )l_ 0 I _1 0]dl

27

O

o

Q

b'l

O

=r

1.1

O

O

M

O

v.

b,I

,it

N

I,."

Page 34: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M!

m

r.,

,r

i

o

4

8'

I

I ,

N

I

I

m

91

m

1-

41

Ul

tl

U

m

Z

II

II

M

W

>" U

0 >-

.J

W m

E o

L

IE

E U

O o

E --

X

Q

J

w

A,

W

ii-

E

O

U

: Ia

-- I

• I

¢1

q

O

O

• W

O _

US

( I

b,.

Q

eL

, ;u

i,

,J m

,1[ O

L •

9I

0

Iq

M

0 •

• .=' 9[

I -- e

_ b 4 m w& 6 - I

,l. 4 I A

wiII

I

I

0

,=,l

,.I

s/)

_ O

-- Z

N N

N N

I ,t I

li o o...

I I

• * 0 I

Q ¢C * • I_

l_ • W

I I I ,_, I

I -- I

0 • I,.. w

28

O

_J

U)

I

@.

,d

,J

Z

Z

o

o O

N I

N

N

• I

°I

• o I

I,. • W

N m

O

I

kJ

I

O

,J

.J

z

m

o

_ O

x

l[

Iq

• O I

I il -- I

z

I ,=.l _) sJ_

• 0 0 Z _ **J

Z N N _

m u)

Page 35: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

I

M

J

o

o

!

0

I

N

0

U)

..J

W

E

E

a.

lg

<

0

g

w

E

0

if)

m

Z

k-

W

dK

0

0

U

0

In

N

+

Q

O

m

4[

Q

m

W

U

M

Uw

L

N

u

_ o W m m M _ _ m _

I°,***.**.

Illllll

_OOOOOOOOO

_OOOOOOOOO

**,**,,***

N

i

O

O

P

O

IO

!

ill | / | I ' 10HVHO

29

O

IO

N

I

LHO l ]14

@

31_13]dS

0

0

0

Ia

4+1

I

0

Q

m

0

_J

kJ

I..-

Page 36: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

I

M

ml

I

N

0

0

i

j.

0

t

0

Ul

)b

0

.J

,J

W

1"

OC

IS.

q(

I-

E

,(

+.9

<E

£

<

0

,ii

u

-I

u

i.i

z

E

o

u

m

m

Z

Ig

N

<

N

s.-

m

X

u

Z

o

w

p-

o

_J

..J

1-

U

M

u

o

;+

Z

0

<

n,

k.

G.

12

)-

<

a,

I

X

o

IF)

u M

w +

_m WE

d< Z--Z

<O_Z_zu

X

,I( I[

9[

IC

PI

'-I 0

o m

I+J 0 _ I..1

,.J I,-

k. 0 < IS. _,- -- O( ,1[

O[ 0 w tn T ,< I,- 16

U)

3O

Page 37: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

K

41, ,4

f_

$ N

Q

°t2

o

I

N

0

u

X

I-

W

o

w

_m

4

m .J

>- u

.J u

.J

E o

Q.

q

<

° :%

E

o

4I

.I

u

w

E

O

u

4 O

gO O

m

Z O

%u

4 IIIllll

4

::::°°°:::°°oo , , , . • . . . .

E --M2_'_mo

0

+.)

0

o

T

0

0

0

I;I o

N m

am = i I I ' )ONVH_) IHO I ]1'1 :) I .4 I :)3d$

31

0

I

141

t--

I

i.

bJ

IC

t,-

Page 38: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

j* •

j

o

z

o

!

dr_

o

r_

o

)-

0

.J

.J

E

_r

L

E

r

O

0

L,)

E

W

E

0

u

,4

m

Z

u

+

m

i

m

0

r,a,

u_

¢,,1

l,

J

M

o

W

t

m

0

.J

.J

L

m

u

J _

• 0

L 7

o

• * o

W I(I 0

U N _

m 40 -

E il il

"J Q _ W

4A • • ._

W,J Z Z --

b. _ • it. L 4C -- ,p *.

Ir _- b'! _ D- • .r _j

tn

0

M

o

J

X X

w M

_ o F-

IJ _! i.)

• 0 m

kJ _. _ W

W ;) o W w

Z

tJ n, .j _ (j

W ._ _ 0 ed Z w w

_*J. Z m 0 N N O

• O • -- b 8,. n,. •

_* 0 I-- • T (_1 _-- b*

32

Page 39: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_J

t

W

N

M

I

O

o

I

j.

O

f

O

).

O

.J

q[

Ld

!"

n.

4[

!,"

r

It

,4

,4

_)

.J

<

(.J

I"

][

O

W

I

Z

4 u

"O0000OO00

_ i|'|lltillllil

111

u

2:

¢u

.J

¢J

lb-

o

Q

Q

o

0

O;

e

O0

4[

k-

,I[

O

W

Q)

Z

<

U

T

k,J

¢J

(J

k,I

¢L

:::°:°::°:°°°:::°o o/ o boo O

**********.**,.0,

@

@

O

o

@

0

@

is* : Iw ' ]SNYHO

33

/HOI]H

O

IO

I

31._133d|

o

0

0

O

'00

0

o

m

0

N

.4:

o ;c

t-

O

40

o

Page 40: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Ih)-O.J

.J

4(

w

E

E

0.

4[

i-

4(

o

%

4[

5.-

!"

9(

<

u

-I

<

u

w

£

E

0

u

_J

m

,4

m

Z

W

_d

_) 4.J

_J

),..

,1P

o

I

_J

o x

o

N

-r

)..

o

w

I-

L

Q

N

Z

O

W U

.J ,1(

U n_

)'- t_

O b.

*- D

o )-

o •

_ ",x

u

o

o

m

m

i

m

M

4[ 0

Ut in

U_ ,m

t_ O

u .j

w .

-J 0 0 a. • --

ffl

,4

kJ

0 o

4

b. m

n, i

X

< IIg

<

I

w

w _j

Z

_GZO_

_mm

34

Page 41: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i,o..,.°.°,o°...,

oooooooo

• tililliJ, iltl_

tJ

-r

I-

k_

Iq

hJ

tn

W

0 >-

q( *.

!"

Q.

I;

IC _J

<

E

,f

I"

E

0

_4

as O

Ot

-- j

• m

0

W

Z

<

I,j

W

t.

IJ

• ..... . . . , . , , . ° , .

0

0

0

1_ Im I) I J u ' ]ONYHO

3_

0

nl .

,I. HO I 1H

0

0

I

w

!

Ol_103dS

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

u_

!

o

.T-

Page 42: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in ,1(

u

m N

o

°f

o

U

,,r

I-

v_

N

O

J

,J

W

E

er

L

E

s-

,4

O

E

E

4_

u

,J

w

W

E

E

0

w

W

4(

I

w

4

o

o 4

: oZ

Q

w

u K

u L

t, Q

o 4

I

U

$

¢1

o

I

I

I

Q

kd

n*.

W

Hi

o

..J

.I

,4

0.

I-

X

<

J,J

m

k,.

N

Z

*- O

.J .

4 O

• Z

4

o

M

-- 4 4

W _ k'J 0

w N ,'*

4( 'qe •

k. • I I

., .. .

ffl

o

o

,J 1 *

am

_ U

_ N

I I

N m

. m

0 4 , Q

Z Z

W _00Z_

INtO

36

4

o

_4

14 •

• o

4( -._ .4

41 J O

.,l N .v --

.J _ .

4 • • m

bJ _-

k _ _ I W

• W Z w Z

N U

• I

I! -- l

8_ZONw w

INNO_O

Page 43: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

o

!

o

o

I

o

N

o

u

Z

L,J

Ut .J

lw U

0 ),-

../ U

.J

dl:

E

E _

E

E _

!" --

E

,1(

0

U

..J

a,

ul

E

t-

O

U

,I( O

m o

Z

9(

C;

w

_9

Z

4(

-r

4.)

:Z

k.

IL

_OOS_W_mW

Itlll

4

_mooooOoo

_00000000

@

0

0

iii I t I I ' |ONVHO

3?

J,H@ I ]H

@

O

@

OlJIO]d|

o

ru

o

Page 44: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

AJ

!

o

¢

!

!

o

0

.I

.I

W

i-.

a.

!"

w.

0

£

!"

0

.J

u

Q:

bJ

r

0

W

m

I

N

x

_J

Z

)-

v_

_J

lid

W

.G <

0 I--

0

Z

X

"./I u

w

u _

W

u

o

o

t

Z

u

m*,*,..*..

|1_|11

:o:o:::::Ooo o,..,,....,

0

O

O

I

Io¢)

o o

!

|w * / I • ' ]ONVH_

38

i

O

2H@ I ]H 0 I JI O)dS

O

O

Oo

o

Page 45: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N g

i N

k_ ,I[

0

o 4(

D I-.

.1"

o

I

N

o

u

Z

N

tO

0

.J

.J

k#

E

L

E

E

E

E

0

),-

,1[

U

.I

U

W

E

E

0

W

M

W

I,-

o

Z

0

w u

.J _

u a.

M

0. 0

o •

x

u

o

0

I

Z

N

o

Q

1

Q

W

_ W

_W z

_0_--_

¢_ irl

U N

| 1

Q

_J

b. o 4( i_ *-

m

x

el.

I.*

,f

m

u

w

.)m

m_m

W

m_

39

Page 46: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

e.,

!

o

r-

!

M

o

o

!

o

)

N

o

IC

U

I-

u

x

N

N

W

U

w :I" o

m

I[:

E u

4[ .

O O

E

E

q(

Ul

,4

4J

.J

U

Ig

W

IC

Z

O

U

Id

k_

4 0

m o

I

- E

w

° ;o

oV_

w

Z

_C

zu

O-

Z

lg

3

u

k

k.

u

LJ

g.

u

mom_m

.ONO0_

|ll

q

o

.,,.,,

O

@

, { , i

O

In

!

i_ I /1_* ]ONYH= J, HOI IN O! Ji O]dll

40

o

o

In

t

O

o

40

+

o ,.sr

1,-

+

o

Page 47: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

X(J

t.*

tn

t,-Ulw

u_

taJ

Vt .J

O )-

.J _J

8: ¢)

6.

5"

s- (j

(D o

_C

4[

(D

)..

_n

<

(J

.J

4(

(J

o[

4d

Ic

1.

O

(J

W

Ln

m

I

Z N

q(

g)

O

q(

b.

r,

Q[

J

x

4[

Ih

J

.J

li. m

O

w

_ w Z

J ,J 0 _

.J _ .J -- Q.

a. u

o •

o

b. _ -- *

U_ • • .J

IJ. _*

(3 * * )..

W _,- 4[ bJ U

U .m Q Z -

h. _ • 0. Z e:

=, Ut

tn

<

I_, t,d

.J *_l Q.

,.J * ),.

• l0 P-

IL W

0 _

_ W Z 2[

Vt .J -- G. --

41

N

I--

£

U

N

m

D

W

w

Page 48: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

. uN°°!

(u

o v

u

-r

I-

Ir

W

W

).. 6*

Gm _-

J

r o

a.

E

E _

E

<

0

U

U

IC

I-

0

U

Q

kd Q

US

m z

i

- w

z o

v

_OBOBMm

o.*..*.

.OOSNSm

<

<

Q

w

O

z

<

z

u

o

w

u

u

w

o

0

0

0

L Io 0

o o

o o

N

! I

i m # I I • ' ]ONYH: J. HOl 3H

I0

o

o

I

_1_133dS

42

I iin

0

=r

i

¢:)

4.

w

z:

m

Page 49: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_ri

Jr

.,0

z

i

o

o

i

s

o

$

N

o

0

J

.J

w

I,-

G.

g

i...

Ul

X

Z

J

7.w

m.

.g

U_

w

.J

u

)-

,4

E

E U

0 0

X:

£

4(

0

,(

(J

.J

(J

n_

W

!-

0

o

W o

4( m

m Z

N

!

Z 0

0

Z"

0

0

I

x

• N

mw

w

g2Q _

_ ZZ

j JO _

x

N

O[

I-

i*

u

. N m

W _ W U

qU N O.

_ 7

._ C_ Z :Z _J

4( Z _ _ U

_D )- U1 Z b.

U_

43

Page 50: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

E

U

U

W

J

U

0 _-

./

r

G.

E u

• •

_ olg --

,IE

U

J

U

W

IC

0

U

W

U)

< CS

m o

I

- z

z

Q

z

_J

w

-i

u

u

w

G.

u

E.,..,..,,,,.,..,

_::o:0:oooo::0oo:0 0000 000

*,.,o,**,*,,,*,*,

0

0

0

O,

I

0

0

0

0

0

0

L ,

o

In

0

aos/Im' ]ONVH3 LHO|]M

i

0

0

Io

0

m

I

31310]dSi

0

I i

o

!

o

m

o

Page 51: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

14m

M

0

0

I

0

I

0

W

).

0

.J

.J

.(

w

];

It.

,I[

E

I"

O

E

Z

0

U

J

u

IE

W

E

E

0

U

Z

l

N

t,-

"Jr

N

N

0

0

N

_J

.J

U

)-

U

o

U

o

o

i

Z

N

9[

I--

<

0 •

Z

0

[.

0

I

X

.J

4(

A. •

U_ o

• I 191

tn

m m

0 I

I[ m

_J

.J .J

t. m W

.a 4( Z

.J M 0

..J o 0 --

• ¢: r,. Z 01

A. i_ G.

45

Page 52: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

m

w

$

M

o

o

I

,11"

O

i

o

g

N

,4

U

I,-

u

N

Z

I"

8

W

M

0

U

.I

W

L

¢D o

; zI"

@

6)

g

I[

i..

0

W

ul

. oN

!

-- Z

Z N

w

6o

o W

Z

_ u

W

.J _

_ Z

3

U

1.

u

a,

u

• ..... . ...... .',.,

*_#llllllll

_000000000000'0000

**.,.,*.,,*o,,*,,

0

(

Co

o

0

0

0

I

in

ill; e I | • * ]ONVH3

0

o

o

+HOI]H

0

0

0

3|J|O)d$

0

0

0

Io

0

o

C °flJ

o

m

o

o

u _0

o

4D

o

e.

dt

bJ

Page 53: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W

(J

u

N

"r

m

.J

)- (J

°.J.J

< *.

z- o

I"

lr" (j

<

° :

lr

<

)..

ut

(J

..J

M

tJ

iv

w

I-

l-

o

(J

kJ

m

i

- z

z

bJ

R.-

i.

L

I-

Q

m

Z

0

W U .

4(

m

t,.

0

n,

i

x

m

•J N

,.J

• m

It |

o

bJ

i- .j

,. L) k_

a. w Z

• J =J _ 0

• o In Z

• U

m

M_ Z*

_ON--

OJ--LZ

OOZin_

_U

O

Iq

vl

A

• O

< O • 'u ¢_

b. -- m

In • • .J i-zb.

O * * t- kd

a, • .j : ¢j

k_ k 4' /.,) kJ _1[

U 41 I= * :' v

4[ Z -- m _ (J

a, W. -- U) )- Ik

;) u)

In

X x

4( E

< M 4(

E _

Z_

o4(•--_ <

4?

IJ

.J

4(

4. 4(

U_ 0

In

In •

0

E

k_

.J .J

4 • ][

m O

O O -- 8.

O a_ Z W

x

4( I[

o I-

;4 •

;4

M

0 In

4( . _)

W 0 _ U

IC II _ I[

I L_ W

In . ., ;O )- t*J.

IE ,J :) U

*. _r k,r _*"

• ID Z O _ Id

Z m Itl _ U

O • • -- i[ •

Page 54: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Z

I

!

o

Jr

o

o"I

_J

o

Ub

)-

0

.J

...I

4d

I"

E

8.

E

E

,i[

o

2,E

<

O

u

U

E

E

I-

O

U

W

m

u

T

_m

N

i--

p..

O •

tfl

t_ w

0

Z

<

-r

(It U

w

.j )-

u T

U

t*J

: °

u

w

6.

q,J

o

o

I

N

I

0,A

Q

%u

I,,.*,,,

< ,oommm

tlllt

_00"00000

*,,*.,**

0

0

0

0

I I I I

N

i

0

BIII I I • ' ":] 0 N Y H :)

4_

o

o

Im

I

LH013M 31Jl0]d$

!

o

o

w

1-

N

)..

Page 55: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Z a,

#I <

_r tJ

I m

°Q t-.

=r

D

I

N

0 v

m

2[

t-

;0

nl

w

q,,

o

w

U

.J

E Q

Q.

q(

I"

q(

4(

u

.J

u

O

• 1

m Z

- Lq

Z G

<

0

z

o

o

x

_W

L u

0

o

r_

_J o _1 bJ

lk _ D )- *

o o a W

• • 0 .J

Q ° • o )-

_) Z Z 2[

Z

4g

Page 56: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

N

r_

o

!

i

o

I[

N

4(

(J

iJ

N

.i.

0-

nJ

m

>.

o >,

.t cJ

.i

E o

N

E

8.

E

z u

o o

E

<

U

J

U

,11

E

E

0

U

bJ

In U

,4 M

r_

!

-- Z

Z

_J

¥-

a.

: <o

r.

o

z

4[

z

tn _.)

tu

O

w

IE

w

G.

o

7

%v

mooa_moz_

m,.°..,**,

*OQO_NNN

_DOOOOOOOO

4OOOOOOgOO

..*****+0,

0

ill i Ii * "IONVH_)

0

IHe I ]H

0

31_1131d|

0

0

Il)

IU

!

0

• o

0 o

o

o

¢)

_ o

o

-- N

o

o

e.

41:

bJ

1-

Page 57: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i N

N 4(

O

°I,.,r

o

i

N

o

U

Z

t-

o

t_

Od

W

)*

0

.I

.J

,4

W

E

O.

9(

E

E

,4

%

9(

E

E

q(

O

f..

Ln

<

cJ

.,J

4(

U

t

X:

Q

o

)-

_J

k-

O

o

m

o

¢)

r,J

r_

i

Z

q

k-

,4

O

Z

O .

m

4

4[

k.

Q

4

I[

i

O

i

o

• A

W

0

W

u m

J _ w_

• OU_

L

o U)

I_ kd

.J

• ¢)

4[ _ .qe

_d Q

_) _ w

g[ II _ Z

2) o W

Q " _*- Z

ar .j _) :Z 4(

bJ 4. 4[ _U Q[ _ I_ O O

U _ _1 Z _ O O Z .1"

4[ ][ _ _ IV iV vb. _ 4[ G. n- ,. -- Z _)

4[

Q

Iq

;4

O

4[ 4[

-- v'l O

• • m 4)

IL _ a II

Ul I,d • 0

0

.W -- • Z O

O .J -- n* G. G. *-

o 0 Z *- ul U_

m

,v. 4[

4- o

m o

(J W O

kd _. 4D

Z1

_ _ .J

4[ 0 < D. -- iv

5]

X

4[

I-

,1[

I"

iD

¢_

(,J

W

w

Page 58: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

ee

(J

N

k-

tn

(J

N

:C

i-

0

In

N

N

I*J

0

N

Ut

kJ

J

0

.J U

..J

E Q

Ig --

Q,

E

E U

Q._ .Ig --

E

,I(

O

l-

q

C,J

U

W

E

E

O

U

ffl U

4 _

" 2.I

Z N

N

u

mOMmJmOOON_O--_ON

E,,,J,,.,,,,,,,,.

IIIlillltili I.

vOQOQO00000000000

80000000000000000

-- N

4(

I-

k,J

Z

<

Z

(J

_J

_J

L

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

f Io irl o

o N ,In

,LH@ I _llSio O I I | ' ]IONYH3 OI LIi_|dll

0

0

0

0

.

0

0o

al

E

m N

52

Page 59: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_t E

s u

o° ;I

IP

o

!

N

o X

u

Z

>.

0

.J

.J

,i[

W

E

E

{6

v"

E

E

Z

o

7,u

,J

u

w

E

E

o

_J

w

: oZ

0

u E

u _.

E

O

bl

>

E

W

m

0

.t

4

IL

U

Z

41 _

,.J ffl

L Z

N

N

• K

M

Z

M •

U

0 8

U

W

( Z N _ N U

: m

41

o

fq

vt

A

• o *

In -- 0

.J , !*

_ m

L I m |

.

0

,is bJ Z _ 0 Z

O .J -- G. _r _ 0.

U

m

0

E

• 0 as

b. El • W

I/t • .I t--Z

I_I • l-. w

a. j =l u

"_ Z _ O WZ _ _ N

0 ("* U) I'- 4[. ta.

53

o

o

0 --m,l Z

)4

Z;

4v)

vl U

0 I

(.,) _ w N

4( "w ¢]

t*. m * (D W

_) 0 W o W

Z

I_ .J ..J ¢._

_ n Z 0 w Z W

N Ul

Page 60: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t

N

I

o

o

I

N

o

4 u

4 4 i_N_W_

q

u

N

"1"

b,-

N

N

W

ID IJ

•J U

,J

bl 0

Z 0

E

O.

4

IC

E U

E --

Ig

(D

I-

ra

W

.J

W

E

[0

U

w

m

• I

Z _

0

4

%

U

O

W

Z

U

U

IL

_000000000

_O00QO00OO

.,-,.., ....

0

0

C

o

0

I,

ID

I

i I I / i • ' 30NVH3

54

O

*HDI]H

I, , , .

o

¢)

I

31/_13]dS

0

0

I

II

I

II

cl

II

c_ kd

In l-

0

M

0

Page 61: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

!

o

o

t

o

I

N

0

U

M

U

"r

i,n

I%1

T,,W

o

o

o

U)

I*1

IJ .J

). (4

0 _-

.J

..J

• b

,G

r

G.

E

E U

• o

E

E

0

Ul

4

(J

.J

U

g

E

I*

0

U

lid

< 0

m Be

r_

I

-- I

Q

Z

0

U

b.

Q

L,,

i-

X

0

lq

M

• 0

.j • 'D 0

IJ W _

W * 0-

U

• lid • _ 0 "

.I .J 0 _ _ Ill --

.I 0 .J -- iL IE ** Z

• o b • U) *- _ --

gl

kJ

.I

9[

11

• i,I

Z

..h

.4.

0

• II

X

Z

:)

I,)

b.

I[

UJ

O

*r

lid '*- <

M

<o I-

M 4

E

M

vi W

0,t

* 0 N •

_q -- _q L

0 >" 0

._ • 0 I-

I 0 -- • 31 Id

4[ Z 0 m II _ _

4*. 0 4[ -- 8. ** I • -- _[

I_ 0 _- • _J) _ 1" _ •

Page 62: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

NI

41'

I

o

O

I

JP

O

J

N

O $

4J

M

Z

n...

W

N

N

W

1- f._

J _J

al

T

m

E

L

E

E U

qE°

Z --

E

Q

.J

<

U

W

IC

E

0

Id

14

4 IB

m m

i

- I

Z

41

Q

W

tO

Z

<

Z

U

w

u

u

w

IL

N

u

_OaNm_NNI_

|,....,,,0

*O0_m_mM_O

< _mMW

2 ;I

q

_OOOOOOOOO

_OOOOOOOOO

.,,,,.,,,,

K m_FWP_O

0

0

Ii , u

0

, i i

0

Io

Q

I

is 0 I I • ' 30NVH3

56

O

Ii |, , i,

o

o

N

IH0 I 3H :)1 +il O_idS

0

Io

!

0

a

m

Q

t.

.4=

kJ

l-

Page 63: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

=r

!

In

Q

¢)

i

o

i

(w

o

).

0

.I

E

E

a.

1t-

o

E

E

o

U_

<

u

¢J

nr

W

E

0

U

W

u_

m

Z

Z

U

v

U

m

-r

i-

in

bJ

i.

.I

0

0 ¢[

Z

0

ER_ I-

W U

J •

h 0

o

n,

x

u

o

,J

,d

L

°M

_ m

• 0 m 0

O _ bJ

Pt _ a* Iq _

• 'm )* 0 I

O 1"* "

W lr _ ta

• -I 0 • .I

* I,- D . I.-

Q

< 0 0 Z U_ _ U Z -- _"

tn

x

o

w o _ u

o w w

z

o _ w

u_Q zow

zo _

_o_Z_

57

Page 64: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

I

o

s

I

V)

o

o

0

o

- %M

• u

_o_w_mmwzu

g**l,.**..

x

u

JP

el

N

::'':°:°::. °0 o

bJ 0 _ ira o i_ o b'l o o

b.I IC _ M .1. • /*. a o

k.-

P,.

4[

o 4[

g "o w

-- 0

Z i , i

4[

w

u

0 )-

.J u

.J

E

m

O.

4[

E

IC (J

4[ •

ID 0

I" --

Z

0

4[

U

.1

4[

U

E

0

,.r

U

P

-r

ID

W

"I

W

IL

Id

if*

4 •

f_

t

• ,..,

0

0

0

I

d i ii

0

i. ii i i _11

0

II

I

|ll I t I • ' ]ONYHO

SB

i i i

0

I iii i

I

*HOl]H OI.ilOldl

0

in

m

i

0o

o

¢1

01

o

R r'-

o

m I¢)

o

o

0

0

w

E

Page 65: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0i

o

2

t

i'J

o

o

¢

2'

o

¢

o

(z

o

o

:Z

l-

_J

w

)-

o

ul

l*J

)= U

0 )=

.J U

.i

<Id 0

I_ 0

O.

4[

E

E U

<

• o

E

Z

u

J

u

E

W

!"

T-

O

u

bJ

U)

,( m

m I"1

-- Z

Z

9(

0

Z

0

O[

A

0

w

W

O

W

h N_

MMO v

_ OU_

_ u

M

_4 E

E

_ U

O0 m

U _w

°_ u

u_QO ww _

o

• --- 0

0 _d

.J 14 L " P_

.I . ). _ 0

4[ m I- •

U_ *O • ¢++J

• 0 ,J eb.

kJ • • i- "

[,-,. ¢J l,J * _* ¢J

0 .J _ G. -- m Z

0 0 Z V) Z *-

+<

o

0

° '+'4[

_. gb • i- --

_ .J

,. _[ _J M O[ * G)

0 '< -- O. I,. _ _ Z

O I-" Z ffl U _" Z _

59

N

m,

r

u

m

o

m

x

u

Page 66: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Im

in

J

a"

in

D

!

D

|

O

E

u

_O00mM_O_S

g*.,,o°..i

itllll

9

(J

Z

t-

r_

tD

t_

nJ

th

W

...t

).. c.a

0 >-

..J U

.J

( b

a_

b/ co

IC o

a.

Z

I_ c.I,

_J

,t

E

w

!"

!"

0

W

8.

T

W

w _

< m

m _

- Z

Z _

Q

0

Z

4

u

iz

L

_o0000oo_0

_oo0_ooo0o

....,0...0

_o_o_o_oo

0

0

Ii i

0

o

o

$

6O

1

0

0

M

I

IHOI]H

J

0

0

o

!

01dJ:),ds

0

0

o

m

o

o

Page 67: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

m

!

Jr

a

I

T

o

!

U

U

N

I-

¢@

N

N

w

0

o

w

u

0 >"

J u

J

E o

N

E

O.

4[

,r

E U

0 0

E --

E

<

0

.1

U

m

W

E

O

U _

W

L

Z

bl "_

_ U

I

-- Z

Z "

O

4

Q

I

0

Q

W

k_

< m

w 0

_ ,J

D •L

I

X ,4

b 0

• Z

N

m

4 I

I

,,d U

0 ' O

L_ m U

=) I*l t,_

4

0

• N 0

4

• _ ,*

• I

I _ W* 0_

_U W'I

• W I _

Ij--LJI

_U

I I,-

M 4

I

I •

0 $ Q

L • * . IiII

Q , _ W_JI -J •

,lI GI • Ill _ _I

Z _ 0 -- 0 --

I _ _ • _ N _ m.._

61

Page 68: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

f,.

o

o

o

0

I.I

..j Ul

.J

I,J u

Z )"

Ic

a. *.

Z o

E

E

IC u

4[ ,

Q --

Lid _

X

0

IZ

Z

J

a,

W

E

E

0

U

U

gnu

!

I0

I

_ Z

m E

-- O

• U

0

w

Z

Z

.r

¢D

kJ

.m

L_

W

IL

I

U

mo_zmm_m_

ill

_o_oo_oOoO

_oOoOooO_O

..°.,...°.

O

@

O

I • i

@

I

0

Vl

J

|u e / I I ' "4@NVH_

62

I

o

o

J. H9 I ]u

0

3|_1133d|

O

I• °

o

N

I

o

v

o

w eJ

o

w 40

o

m

0

m

o

m

o

Jr

o

o

o

o

I[

Page 69: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N O_! N

VD

tO _)

Iq

I

N

o X

U

Z

p-

ro

N

)-

0

.J

.I

Id

!"

g

O.

8:

E

(D

S:

l:

4[

fO

O

:Z

O

Z

.J

tJ

W

E

i-

O

U

W

4n

m

m

Z

t.-

u)

w

)-

o 4[

oZ

0

M

tn )-

.J •

u E

). tk

M

o

x

m

I

m

M

0

Z

4

0

4

o

M

,o

N _

• m

e_

Q

14

44 U

(j N I_

• O _ Q

b. m -- t*J

k. _ Z

I:_ * * I- W

a* .J • :) U

_d ** • I*l m (j 4¢

tn

63

Page 70: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

N

I

o

o

t

o

I

N

o

t_

O

..I

..J

,(

W

E

8[

L

_[

E

s-

G

9[

E

1-

o

u

-I

,(

U

w

E

s-

o

u

E N

N •

N • ...... °.°.......

_ _ ,,,,,, ,,!,i

N

Z

I-

N

16i

s.

O

O

0

U

I

O

b/

(0

Z

Z

U

w

11

u

IL

bOOODONO000000000

JQO_OOOQO00000000

,0,0.,.o,.,,,,.,,

o

0

O

0

0

0

0

0

0

Io

awl/l" ' 3@NYHO

0

11'40 I 314

O

Io

I

31 .'11 33d$

64

O

O

Io

I

o

N

o

s0

o

N

o

_. o°

o

o

fu

o

4c

k_

N

Page 71: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

4_

_d

M

t

Wl

¢)

Q

I

2

o

D

N

o

U_

).

0

.J

.J

<

W

E

E

L

,1(

E

l-

E

E

0

U

J

4(

U

W

E

I-

0

Z

N

U

,Jr

%

o

m

w

.J

u

)-

u

o

U

a

t_

i

Z

.4(

o

z

o

n,

o

o_

I

x

a

:)

14 -J

,,4 4(

• c)

4( 0 -- _J

• .J • J

Q _ b.

b.l . j- Z

I.- .j _ o "mr 4(

W Z _ * Z O)

.J ¢3 .J -- L _ _ Z -- Z iV

A. N U

m

)4

q( OC

w

E

..4

c_ o0

4( _ le

W o m U

W ° _ W W

W _ _ W

,d • -J i.-

b. Z

C_ _- Z w

z N <

_n

65

Page 72: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

/q

ul

o

o

i

I

N

o x

u

N

m

N

I,-

i.

oo

o

o

N

u)

w

).

O ).-

J o

..I

4[ *.

41

bJ o

!" o

E

n

<

E

Z: c._

4[

_ °E --

<

O

W

.J

E

W

IC

E

Q

U

m

4 •

m _

P

!

Z _

i-

4

D

W

O

Z

,4

X

u

Z

4J

I1.

L

Q

u

m.,,,,., ...... ,**

4

::-:o:oooo:::ooo-O O OOOO OObO

**,,,,***,,o*0,*.

-- N

.0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

i i i I

0

I

le o t I • * ]0NVH0

66

O

I

a

D

J. HOI3H O|JI0]di

0

0

0_u

O

IO

O

o

g)

O

Page 73: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Nt

.1"

I

In

O

O

I

j.

O

O

in

i-

O

..J

.J

I*l

E

E

G.

4

Z

E

4[

E

E

,ic

u

u

w

E

E

o

u

Z

W

x

u

Z

)..

1-*

u_

i.

o

ILl

J

b

0

M

U

*0

0

m

m

i

z

o

z

o

N

a

i

x

o

* °

mm

L ii _

• m W

0

dd_

_ zZ--O

_0__

w 11 o

o4{

: -.*O

n- j • J

kJ _ _{ _J M (_ bJ

t_ O _ - ik *, Z n

Ul

X

M

I[

I-

I"

N

m

(J

C2

W

n,

I-

Z

W

o

"U

6?

Page 74: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

m

_o

.T

u_

o

.¢)

i

ru

o

N

4

X

U

"r

U)

0

0

Ill

W

° _,,J

kJ 0

E 0

G.

q(

E

E

0 0

_ oE --

E

U

.J

W

E

E

0

U

IdJ

U)

4( 4_

r'*

s

-- Z

Z N

4[

d2

W

:oo_oo_o_o_O_o o o.,..,,,,..,,0,...?

9(

'i"

(J

0

m

bJ

-It

N

(J

bJ

O.

;A

@

@

@

@

@

0

o

_1o _' t | m ' 30NYH3 ,I. H0 I ]H 3 | _ | 3'JdS

68

@

C)

C)

o

c)

.c

o bJ

o ]c

I.-

Page 75: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

}

m

m

.I.

t

o

¢)

i

,ir

o

i

N

o

o

N

:E

i.*

sD

r_

N

_J

u_ .J

)* u

o )-

..J

w

I- o

N

0.

I*

!- (j

1-

,i(

o

9(

.J

a

W

I-"

0

W

41

< O

m

f_

i

- Z

Z

#:2

Z

o

.,(

a-

la.

n.

I

x

Q

I,J

a.

m

¢,

o.

Z

u

z

.J v_

,z 0

Z

X

4[ O[

0 )-

_J 4(!"

M

U

m

_ 'w 0

k, ul

_ W w

_ j F-

-- Z

o ; w

(J • Q 0 - W

4')

. °

.i Iv) _ 6.

.J _e )-

4( 10D * I..*

O. II

u

o W

• I,- )-G

aG. ZOZ_O

ZO_Nmm_

69

_W Z_

X _

N _

_ .W . W

w

aQ OZ-3

O_Z_,Z

Page 76: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

tODVlID

!

Vl

o

t

o

I

AO

0

Ut

la-

0

.J

.J

4

g.

O.

4(

t.-

I:

,,(

4

4

U

.J

4

U

Ilg

W

E

0

U

W

m

E

N

I-

W

Z

N

N

uJ

i,

I-

o 4

0

N Q

Z

W U

ul

lp fl)

W

o U

o m

U

LI

A

U_

W

L

,C

Z

W

lID

i

Z

v

tttt_tt

_O00gO0OO00000000

_00000000000_0000

,,,,o,.,,,,.,,oo,,

@

0

@

Io

c)

iOI0t II ' ]ONYHO

?C)

0

*HOI]H OlJlO]dl

0

@

Io

Q

!

0

0

"C 0N

o

m

0

c)

-I"

0

N

ID

0

- :

Page 77: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

II

qo

+

_r

In

ID

I

S

,0

I

l_d

ID

Ul

.,J

.J

I,d

sT

E

L

,I[

E

E

,4

E

E

O

41

U

J

.1[

U

W

E

E

O

U

Z

W

i.

°o Q

O

La

_ L

N

_ O

o

x

u

o

o

Ul

L.I

O.

4(

Z

In

l-

Id

"1

w

m

I

3[

Q

Id

W

m

a

,.J

J

O.

u)

z

<

4.)

k,.

Z

*,. 0

4

j In

.j --

4[ o

ai. z

lq

o 141

bJ M W

U _ II.

o ;:I*,I s. _ IQ n. .

I*. _ 4[ *. I( --

IIC i,,- 4J' i- Z

Utl

4[

.I

4 Im

II. I

12

kl

I'- -J

_ W Z

D .J -- 4.

_ U

I-- o t-

4 III •

sT" 11-Iq

4.) _1 1.)

ii ¢1 N _ li

U _J' i_) _ W bJ U

w L 113 Z 0 _ '_ "I I*i

U Z _ 0 IV _ w w U<,I[ 0 4( IL -- *,. I_ -- --

k. 0 t- U_ • (J )- Z Z k.

71

4

0 ki til

4[ in )- I- --

• II I-

" :o;.w * O • °

I_ I.* * U iI

W Z "_ 3 * 0

0 0 Z Ill Z Z _ IJ

N

x

"1_

o t-

r

Iq

vl ¸ U

0 41 m

kJ 0 _ kl U

ks. m _. . I- ill

W

D . k- • kJ

4( _J Pl (J g[

• 40+ Z 0 _ 2_ wu

<0 < L -- *. Z _ --

Ill ill

Page 78: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

OI

_D

I

o

I

D

¢

nJ

o

).

O

J

.J

4[

w

s-

I

L

i*

E

(D

£

o

_J

.J

u

bd

0

w

m

N

• ...... , ..... .**.

2 Illl|lllll

q

¢,J

T

8,-

¢U

W

W

J

U

N

U)

w

O.

¢[

-r

U*

C

I

Z

_o_o__.__O_oo o. ...... . .........

4(

(2

W

O

(J

M

_J

(J

L_

N

_J

W

Ul

(

l

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

go: / Iw * 3@NVH_ J. N01 ]M 31,_1_3dS

?2

o

o

AI

o

_r

o

_J

bJ

1-

N

0...

Page 79: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

:riPi

¢)il:i

_J

o

tn

>.

0

.J

..J

<

w

E

E

O.

1-

<

o

E

1-

0

<

J

U

E

0

Z

v

o

z

P

o

r-

nJ

nJ

ul

w

0--

nJ

(n

bJ

)-

u

.c

¢)

o

tit

_J

G.

9(

U)

m

I'1

P

I

z

QQ

Z kJ

¢) >E

,1( m

_ J

O <

G.

I

u

Li.

Z

L Z

1K

N

vl (J

0 m

t;J _ (J

k. * t*J

W t*J

Ub .J PZ

_ u

o

J

P

_w Z__0 _

oOZ_N

bJ o o

4(

t*. _D an

(2

I_ .J "-J

a (2 Z Iv 0 Z

x

IC

U

N

m

u

¢J

w

m

w

w

<

73

..J

.J

4[ • _ N

O. '4

IA U1 t,J kd

! VI iL IL

Ill • )" )"

m p I-

0 I

:'o

_ J

N G.

• -- N

4J 0 kJ

U _q _ O. N0

. _ a t-

022 -

o .;; .• n Z "I 21 0

0 "J_ -- D. -- -- _ Z

U

m

u

0

_J

kJ

Page 80: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

11'1

J

gl

r*"

!

,z

iii

cD

i

Q

i

N

c_

;,n

]p

0

-I

.J

w

r

E

a.

I-

E

0

E

E

4

0

U

-1

U

E

W

I"

E

0

U

bJ

4[

O

N

4

N

.5.

N

W

O

1,1

t_t

U

)-

U

U

kd

G.

3.-

W

I

I

Z

4

D

Z

i"

(.)

O

W

21

U

b.

r(.t

a.

4n

u

E,,,*,,,,..,,,,,*

lilll_

_O00000mOdOO00000

80000_OQO00000000...,.o°.°..°.....

_ N

|

o

0

0

0

0

0

lie e I I •* ]@NVl.iO

?4

0

LHOi]M

i i i

0

0

OId!O]dll

0

0

,

0

o

N

!

0

o

_r

Q

_r

w

E

N

Page 81: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

in

t-

O

i

_r

k'l

O

t

:r

o

I

o

U

N

N

:IC

b.=

IhJ

W

PJ

I=-

tn

s_J

i,=

i.

.i:

m

W

W ..J

)- U

0 2"

.I• Q.

Ld 0

11: o

E

I-

E U

0 o

o£ --

U

..J

U

1.1

E

E

O

W

,II

Z

W

I

-- Z

Z _

CI

O

N

E

O

,4

I

X

O

td

Q[

kd

Ut

m

O

.4

'.j

,I[

L

tn

k4.

L. O

L Z

o m

D

Ld _ (J

k. bJ

O[ _ n.

D bJ _J

D _

0

_ -_

_O_

OOZ_

x

o I-

• T

M_4 _J

N

• O m

• N D

bJ O N tJ

er | M g[

I W _J

Ul _ 'J *--Z

,._ o' )- Ld

.J D ("1

A: O Z O w hJ

Z O _ iV _ (J

O _( -- O. *- O_ "(

o t- Z tn U w G.

75

J

*

i, .I

m

o i

.J .J

,s • z

m O

0 O -- O.

o 0C Z US

_Id G.

o_ _

| I

o ,;;

_ z_O

N

ne

I"

I

D

U

N

O

kJ

n,

LJ

Z

Page 82: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

O

oqll

i

s

Vl

o

i

4'

o

!

N

Q

N

4

I-

,11

I-

W

o

o

o

D

0U

m

ee ,J

,J iJ

J

W a

E O

L

Z

r _

0 o

0

W

UD

d

W

w

w

,I[ m

llm M

r_

!

- z

z

am

w

o

X

II-

X

o

w

z

L_

w

L

. I

I

m

M

_ o _ m m _ _ O O _ O O B m _ a B

oo _ r N N m N O O N Q _ m O N_

_ttlltl|lt

_O'OOOOOOOOOOO.0OOO

_OOOO_OOOOOOOOOOO

I J ' I I

0

0

0

J i i

o

m

!

ii0 e S(IIO ' ]0NVN0

76

O

0

0

0

, , !

g

4D

!

ANOIIN OI J|O|dl

0

0

I

o

o

I

0

0o

0

N

o

_u

N

o

°

0

0

o

N

0

Page 83: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

mw

J

J u

,J

• 4.

g

&

£

E U

O 0

2, °E --

E

o

u

U

Ig

ul

E

E

0

u _

W

6,

T

_ m

!

- Z

Z _

4[

k-

0

Z

0

k,

0

,1(

E

I

x

O

I

w

m

0

.J

.J

L

_m

Z

z

*, O

,J _

4[ • .0

lr Z

w

4[

0

m

M

m

0

(J w

w

m .J

O

E

kJ b 4[ ml I[

(J • ¢2 0

I )" '6) P"

M

m

g

E

m

&)

mr

w

z

w

($

_)

4w

4E

.J ;4 L

., . _.L _

" ."2

,., o _¥- ,j

• _J Z. 21

-J 0 _ --

o 0 • m Z

o I-

Iq " 4[

E

k_ 0 kJ td _ fJ

4[ • ). )" 0 _e O

Q

OI- _'l Z Z • I.) w _- _.

7?

4 *_N

o I

_< Z_

O_Z_ZZ

N_

. :22 2MM

o .;;

N_

N

8[

I-

IC

_)

m

6)

Q

w

8[

w

W

w

b.

Page 84: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

11

I

o

II

SP

I

_P

Vl

o

|

_P

o

ed

0

• v

oo_miBmDMm_mw_mm

Illltlllll

X

m

.Je"

A,O

N

W

W

in ..J

3.- U

0 >"

./ u

J

.E

Z

II.

_ u

E _

!"

,i(

cJ

J

u

I:

w

I"

x:

o

u _

ul

a.

Z

C

_0_0_0_00_0_0_00

0

0

0

0

iI:)III']9NVHO

0

I l

J. HOi :tl, I

0

0

0

:l.tl3]dS

0

Iq

I

78

0

0

m

{:1

m

Page 85: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

¢b

m

Jr

4"t

c_

!

s

o

I

N

o

J_

0

.I

,.J

W

E

K

IL

E

E

!"

E

I..-

U

.J

u

Ig

w

Z:

E

0

Z

4[

U

¢-

X

U

k"

N

2,bJ

O

IA

)..

U

o

U

ID

IO

m

W

8.

q[

.r

L_

).-

k_

"7

a

M

#

Z

'4

¥..

ID

• k/

U M

• I

K O

b.

k. ../

a <

L

)" Ul

ill

)4 4[

U

k.

Z

.J

• .I I

'4 0

L Z

14

q(

0

M

0

W

U

4( •

Q

.mN

OWW

L m

:22

4_

W 0

U

b. •

IC e

II •

gg ,J

X N

E _

U _ U

L_ Nw

O0+

79

• M N

o _LL

0

U eO0

_m w..

O0_L---

NL

U _LL

° j;; .

X

M

I.)

m

u

1:2

W

el,

W

L1

Page 86: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iu

I

112

W

I

lid

Irl

?I+1

I

4_J

a

1,.

O

,.,,I

,..I

91

Ul

S

E

II.

,t

0

Ig

I"

0

Q

W

Q

O

U

E

ul

E

0

l,d

l£rl

<

m

IIC

N

,ii

,,.r

+.,l

I,,,.

41

II

I+1

111

UI

kJ

.,I

4.1

3,-

U

L,P

Q

Q

M

I

I

O

MI

I

Z

r

<

U_

C

U

<O

O

,ii

3C

ILJ

I,-

3CO

Idkl

31

U

I+.

LI

W

O..

l.'tl

N

U

I''00" ........ '',

_ _1111111 II

_:::°°:::::°:0_°: ooooo

o,..0.,,+.....,,.

I

IO

O

O

O

O

O

O

O

O

O

i m I I I • + |ONVHO ,L HO I ",IH 31 ,il O'ld|

8O

C)

m

__ soN

Q

w ,11"

Ci

__ o

-- m

o

llJ

11:

Page 87: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N a,

m

¢0 o

° ;

I

o v

u

z

N

.I

,.J

W

r

N

i,l

E

0

W

o

,.T

Z

J

u

w

!"

E

O

u

w

0

Z

0

W

u E

"- O

o

x

m

!

I

r-

i

z

N

m

o

u

o

w

w

m

o

J

J

<

(J

Z

*. o

J

.J

Q- Z

u_

oo

oo

o ;;

_ m

vm

, o

.j '1.

• 18 o 40

L i _ I

w ;

0 .J -- Q- 4. m_ _.

x

Z:

U

_J hi w

w _ _D

W ,m _ Z 0 --

U Z 0 _ d41

b. o P 5" _ u )-

o

• o *

_M ZwZO *

x )4

(J Q@ M0 4[ 0 I' 0

W b. _D -- W

W _ 0 _ _d W

Z k* _ Z

_j _i_ • )i bJ

W _ _ Z 0 * _ W

U Z 0 _ N -- _ 0

81

Page 88: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

0

I

a

M

!

IA

)-

0

..D

..J

4(

L,

E

IE

9.

Z

o

E

E

<

Q

u

o

z

z

u

Ig

w

E

E

0

u

u

Z

m

N

W

<

0

,i(

-r

ul u

LaJ

u

u _

w

o _

W

L

u

o

I

I

411

!

Z

N

E

0

v

_OOM_mmNBa_NINaN_a_m.

E, .... ,0.,,..,,.,,**,°,"

IIIIM

_oOOooOoo_oooOOO_O_OOO_

_O_O_OOoO_OOOOO0_O_O_O

00

00

0

00

00

0

0

0

0

0

o

dll|me illm' ]OHVH3 ,I, HIII |N 31,il 3]

82

O

Io

c:;

t

O

o

In

.11"

o

o

o

Vl

Iq

o

o

Page 89: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

r_

o

i

m

ira1

TN

I

0

W

>.

O

.J

.J

,4

td

1"

er

a.

<

E

E

,1(

O

9(

!"

E

O

O

W

o

Z

o

T

J

U

W

E

O

U

U

N

"le

UJ

j..

W

W

,J

U

>-

U

O

m

i

m

#

z

N

E

,(

ut

0

u

0

N

t-

u

,<

a:

b.

0

)-

,(

#

0

W

>

td

Ul

m

0

.J

.J

<

L

_n

41

U

Z

b O

,J IJI

'4 O

4. Z

)4

,k m

44 _4 _6_

(J w w

t_m J --I i.-z

Q

_J

:)

td

m

m

0

..#

J

<

tn

IJ

z

:o

o

_ O

CJ _ I

4( "o

_1 .J r-

Z _ _

°

0

w

w

X

M

°E

CJ ,,_

al o i'-

D

(J Id _

(J _ I

)-- _ .J r.-

z

t_ r_ _.. I_.J er D "

83

0

,,q

o t_d

J • ),. ._

o Z m Z

m

N

r

N _

CJ 1'1

Id b. m la

kJ :::) Q t_ WI

Z

td n I.- b_

W am 0 0 Z _ 0 W

_-J Z _ N 0 _ I U

b'l tn

Page 90: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N!m

N

i

O

g

!

m

I

o

).

0

w

Z

K

L

E

0

E

E

4[

O

u

-I

U

a

W

E

!"

0

U

B N

m •

u

_oa_logm_

U mg_N_NmOB_

a.0°0°0.4_

• INMONmm

4

W

m

Z

(...

m

N

ilJ

i-

O

O

O

(J

o

I-

.9[

Q

4_

O

Z

Z

L.)

"0

W

U

W

L

_aO_'OOOOOO

_OOOOOOOOO

_00,0,,,..

_Om_O_O_OO

@

O

c_

O

@

II ot'll + |@NVH_I

84

I

II

II

_NO ! ]11

0

OlJlO3d$

O

O

O

m

o

O

c_l

irl

o

io

o

I.

,41:

hi

!1"

I-

Page 91: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

0q

N

Iq

¢

r_

a

o

i

,iP

o

!

N

o

3-

O

J

J

,,c

Lad

!"

N

0.

,r

E

!"

,r

u

J

u

,,J

E

E

G

u

W

m

Z

E

.It

U

I-

W

N

@-

0

0 D

Z.0

W I.-

W U

J <

)- _.

U ti.

0

E

X

U

N

m

I

Z

4

0

M

M

OW _

L | . M

:2".

M Z3--

X

m

m <

E

M

W M M wL

• O_

ZOrN -_

B_

Page 92: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

f_

nJ

Pi

i

,D

o

G)

I

i

0

IA

),.

0

,J

E

_L

E

4(

U

I1:

I,d

,r

E

0

W

I

- %m

v

m O,*,..,0*0

ul

0,-

w

L1

o

m

IJ

N

I

I

m

M

<

,4

Q

I

<

Z

u

Z

]

t,.

(J

w

tn

_00000_000

*.,°_*...,

0

0

0

o

o

i e • / I• ' ]ONVH3

86

O

I i

o

o

o

I

!

J, HOl ]H

O

OI410]dI

0o

o

m

o

I

o

,o

bJ

Z:

i-

Page 93: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

hJ

tJ

o° ;I

a

!

u

Z

In

N

ul

I-

i.

o

0

o

w

m J

)- u

0 _"

.I U

,J

E o

L

<

E

E U

< •

0 o

E

<

O

u

J

(.

E

w

E

E

0

W

m D

!

Z _

0

Z

0

M

4(

IIg

a

<

i

x

o

Iq

.j vl

L 9[

0 W _ W

I Iq L _ IL

O I

g • • hi 8'

• O .J O

.I .J

*. m I*l * I_

L 4 Z Z _ Z

DO_v_O _

X

°sr

Iq

N

Id 0 bJ -- _J

¢J Iv) •

k. iS I- id

I_ m . ar

:D • • Id Id

_ Z

0 • t,.,

4[ .j , IT =) u

Ld I, _ _ . L_ M

b. 0 4( G. -- -- 8[ t.

• 0 I.- M • Z ;" 4_ k.

*n

Page 94: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

V)ir-pv)

i

¢)

io

.1.

¢D

i

N

GI

101

1.,

O )"

.J O

..J

I*l

Ik

<

° .?,E

E

<

u

_I

,4

u

W

E

E

o

_d

'4 N

m m

r-

I

- Z

Z

E

4

I.)

(J

M

.r

p-

*q

IXt

tU

i,.

• 41

oo ;D

O kJ

Z

X

ol

w

u

w

.T

b_

U

w

a,

N

u

_QmN_m_m

_Qo_wom_

i., .... ,.,

_OOOOOOOOQ

MOOOOOOOOO

.,,** .... *

WO_O_O_OO

O

O

O

O

lip I I Ill ' "IONYH 3

88

i m

I

J, HOI]H

O

0 i _11 3_ldli

0

0

Io

N

!

a

o

c_

$-.

Page 95: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

v'lIP4

I

o

o

!

Z

I

!

N

O

n,

4

U

m

O

-Jr

I.-

rq

_J

w

o

o

U_

w

)- u

.j u

J

E o

G.

<

E

!" U

< •

° :E _

r

0

J

E

0

U

u

N

OO m

r_

!

-- Z

Z

0

0

C_

L_

I

X

4[

M

44

0 _ W W

.J M _ A. O.

.J . _ >- >-

4[ I " )" )"

IL |

,J U W a.

• W Z -- -e .t

J .J 0 ....

.J o -I _ _- n, -- --

4[ 0 0 Z _ r- Z Z

G. "** U

U)

"o

_4

0

111 W

(J N ** CL

• _ 0 )"

D _ _J * ar

I_ I J • 0

_ .I D •

0 4( G. -- Q: _" Z --

x

I

I-

I"

(J

I

:1)

O

W

_J

)-

Z

W

g

o

89

Page 96: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

LD

o

o

i

_r

4o

i

N

o

,4

IC

a.

I-

sr

4[

$:

S:

)..

(J

q:

sr

Z:

O

U

W

(A

,1[

E

U

(J

N

N

r.*

iv

w

i-

o :O

-- 0

Z

ql

.it

(4 L)

W

u

_ 0

u _

w

f- 2

o _

W

u

Q

N

m

r_

t

Z

N

N

u

_oN_o_rom

mO_ONQ_OMm

no*.*..***

*OOI_'M_NIM

loll

m

_ooooaomoo

JoooaoDooo

°o...,,..°

O

@

0

@

0

LI

U;

IS

7

Re e /111' |ONyHO

9O

J. HO I _IH

0

OlJlO]d|

0

O

o

o

.1"

o

k,I

1[:

N

I.,-

Page 97: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

:r a.

! N

)11 '4

(u

Jr _J

o°i=r

o

I

N

o X

Z

p.

N

ffl

W

,,J _J

-J

.ll

IC

G.

.<

E _

2, .E

£

o

u

u

w

E

E

o

u

W

ffJ

< N

m m

8

-- Z

Z _

w Z3 _

j JO _

<OOZ_Z_

L_U

91

Page 98: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

II!

I

KI

.11"

I

O

o

!

B

o

I

Q

u_

).

0

.J

4(

N

I

L

.1[

E

E

0

E

E

O

u

(J

l

w

E

E

O

u

I

,4

u

m

I-

v

m

Z

I,..

w

4.

o

w

,J

u

u

q.

u

v

I*°,,°°,*,

*omoom_mM_

Illl

4

Ld

O

::oooo::o:OOOO I

• .... 0,,.,

<

"Jr"

N

W

N

0.

in

O

O

O

IO

O

I

I

i I I I I I * "aONYH 0

92

O

IHil]#

0

, Ilid

I

0

IU

I .

3ldlO]d|

0

O Io

m

o

I

o

in

c_

o

Page 99: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

in

N

_r

i

ID

o

O

I

.t1"

O

I

N

O

.m

'4

L_

I"

'4

Ul

li

O

N

N

)-

w

)-

0

Q

0

0

W

]p u

O )"

.j 4J

.J

E o

N

K _

8.

E W

o o

E _

E

o

,i[

M

W

w

E

E

o

U

W

• N

m m

|

- Z

z _'

Q

z

o

E

i

N

4

o

M

m

0 hi _'

. p. 'u

L , .T,

O

** IJ tIJ • •

,._ .J 0 _ "

.J 0 -_ -- L -- I_

L _ _J

U_

0 * _* •

,.., • D

U _ N N •

I_ . • -- i- wE

Q ). * 4 W

Id *, • _ _" Id W *

b. O. 4 -- *. I_ • • " 4

IE 0 )- • _LJ I,- _1) _., • li.

:) _ U)

U_

93

Page 100: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Jr

!

ID

N

i.

!

ID

o

I

.1"

¢s

!

ID

US

J

.J

oil

IC

IS.

4[

IC

4

I-

I"

qli

4[

u

.J

4[

U

llJ

!"

It'

O

I.)

IlJ

I(

gl

• %u

_ONOONMm_

g.*..m...*

-ooaNomm_D

_ ,,--_.1|1|

U

N

Z

N

_4

W

q.

o

m

N

m

I

q(

0

w

qD

Z

-r

u

Z

o

I,d

2

O.

Ul

b_OOOaO000

_OQOOOOOQO

0

0

0

o

Io

o

o

I

lie II I I I ' ]0NYH9

94

O

IH01IN

O

3lJl3]d|

0

ID

N

O i

Q

111

O

0,I

1r-

l--

Page 101: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_r|qDru_rI

IO

o

o

I

o

t

_J

o

9[

u

m

x

u

T

N

_J

N

_J

o

o

w

.J

>- u

° ;,,J

L

E _

L

E

,r u

° :

,1[

0

J

u

1.1

I;-

E

o

w

U_

N

m m

r,.

8

- z

z

*[

I-

_[

G

Z

0

L.

Q

>.

,(

E

I

X

0

M

_ Z _

X

0 I-

E

< 0 '_ I,, fl_ , )m kJ

I[ I I- _ m

b. _ " Z

m .J • _

_L C_ Z 0 . w 2[ kJ

• [ Z _ 0 N _ _ _

b. 0 '1[ L

9_

Page 102: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

!

o

o

i

o

i

N

o

tA

).

0

J

.J

<

s-

fr

0.

,(

]:

I-

E

E

<

U

J

U

E

W

E

E

0

CJ

W

o

o

Ih

W

U

).

U

b

o

u

O.*,,..°.,

IlJJ

,I[

0

b,I

Z

,a(

Z

(J

_o

"Jr

4..)

b_

(J

W

O.

0

0

0

0

O

O

o

m

a

lu_llu' 39HVH3 LH913_ 31J133dS

N

I

96

Oo

o

m

o

i.

lid

E

N

t.,-

Page 103: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

W

nJ

_r

i

Q

o

i

.I"

0

i

N

Q

m

)-

Q

..J

.J

,(

t,J

a,

o.

,[

I"

lr

E

E

<

(D

7,,i[

u

J

<

u

z

w

E

£

o

Z

M

<

cJ

N

w

L

: oZ

0

bJ

../ <

U E

:r. la.

(..) G_

o

x

u

N

N

m

r,.

i

z

m

o

.j . ,If :)-

q( CIO - i..-

W • I'- e=

0

O. _ U

U)

,(

_)

4[

b. CO

m

U)

0

O_ .J

IAI _ • w

t_

_s

o

iq _ IL

0 ,in )-

-- - t-,

,, ../ 0

m

x

I[

i..-

(J

::)

u

0

w

bJ

z

G,/

(J

(J

9?

Page 104: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_P

I

I

N

,/.

!

W

o

a

!

o

g

N

o

_n

w

0 >-

.I qJ

.d

4 0.

,m

W o

K o

N

E

I1.

41

X

Z Ca

O O

E --

E

,4

0

_J

.1

U

W

E

E

0

U

W

Um

N

m m

I

• m

E

v

eOMNOO_mO_

|0,.,,,e,0

.oooMmommB

• _ INmm_DN

_ o .... Nlill

q

V

Z

o

m

N

N

I-

0

W

m

X

-Jr

w

cJ

w

L

QO O0 00

.0....,0..

i|

0

0

0

0

,I

0

Q

i

Q

i w, t' I I1_'' )gNVHg

913

O

,I, HIII 3M

O

_l.tl3|d|

0

I

O

c_

N

!

0

o

ID

O

o

O

w

Page 105: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Jr

J

I

iv

4r

i

w

o

o

i

o

i

N

o

I

N

91

u

u

o

I

N

N

u_

¢_

o

u)

bJ

-J

IP U

0 )"

j u

.d

E o

E --

a.

I-

E U

° :

<

0

,,J

U

IZ

w

£

E

0

U

bJ

U_

I m

r-

i

I

I

D

Z

0

N

e_

Q

t

o

ID _ W

.4 , _I )- 0

o .I 0

_ M

,. _,j bJ. . ill

.I 0 -J -- a. _ ** Z

ffl

¢[ ,I 1,- 0

b. II * I- -- I

° "2"-"_ • .J •

• . < bJ Iq rr * _ W

_I 0 Z 0 _ 2[ - Z

::, -- V)

m

99

Page 106: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

B

!

o

_r

i

It

o

o

(

B

0

!

0

I

I

t-

0

I0

cl

II.

ul

IlJ

),. U

0 J."

.I lJ

.I

IL

E

E q.J

41

o

E _

E

L)

.J

U

I

ul

E

E

0

U

Vb

< IU

I

I

-- •

Q

W

:I

3:

_J

I

W

r,a

m

U

Ld

a.

In

I

m

w

_|I--ImIOIO

I,...,,,,.

4 I--_t_MPQ

III

4

illOIlIIlO

8||llm|l||

_ M

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

!

i • o I I • ' 'U@NVHO

0

]O0

IHOIIH OldlOidl

II

o

|

_

a

o

o

o

o

i r..

o

o

o

o

o

,a¢

l.-

m

Page 107: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Z

I

I

_r

i

o

I

i

_r

(D

l

N

0

).

0

.J

..J

q(

w

E

I

0.

r

i.-

(D

E

1"

<

0

U

J

U

E

W

I-

E

0

U

Z

l

U

N

U

.I-

F-

W

N

W

o

0

W

,J

U

U

o

N

m

r_

I

Z

.4(

)-

0

Z

0

N

U

<

I[

t_

U*

0

m

X

0

0

w

L

W

0

_ U N _

_ U

0

U --

b,

Ul .J

E

4[ Z m _

0

0

U7 I • W

• 0 -J •

W . • I.- -

0 .J -- O. -- _ Z

¢D 0 Z U) Z _ --

U

X X

m

mr < I

I • _ 0 I

(/_ • 0 .J ,_ I-ZI

I .j I"=) • _.)

W _ m 0 Z 2[ w I,m,l

U Z 0 N _ _ _ _ _J

0 4( -- *. O. "' O[ Z 4[

t*. 0 t- Z U _ Z _ w I_.

U1

lOl

Page 108: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

it

I

II

s

!

W

o

o

!

B

o

I

o

ul

.I

lu

E

E

D.

IC

!"

,i(

O

E

Z

<

0

U

1[

W

E

£

0

Ig

<

U

N

X

U

'1"

i-

ra

m

_J

,E 9[

o

o

z

4[

,Jr"

w

u

u

t_

t. 3

u

w

I

v

moo_mIM_

i,.°,,°,,,

Itll

:°°°:::0°°000 000

.,..,..,,,

0

0

0

0

0

0

D

Io

o

o

I

ill III ' :IONYH _ 1HO I 3H

I .

o

OlJl3]dS

102

o

0 °

- :

- :

-

-- :

- :

o

o

- :

o

o

z

Page 109: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

10

_r

I

w

o

¢)

t

I

o

E

u

N

W

.I

J

w

IC

N

Iv

L

E

!-

I"

.J

m

w

r

i-

o

u

z

u

z

p-

ro

w

N

it;

b;

: oZ

0

N

w

_j a,

u

o :x

u

o

m

I

Z

4[

0

14

fq

',,4

..j ° 'w )," 0

4( II - I- "

IL illl _ I"fJ_ W _

• J 0 •

_ W Z -- Z 0

.J 0 J -- n a, -- *. Z

4[ 0 0 ][ U) )" Z U

e, _ U

U)

LJ

U

4{

:)

Ub

O

Isi 4. _[

u 4; o

o

I,')

;fl

• -- 4[

0 _ Ill o

).- 0 •

40 • I.- -- •

I _ t- I

taJ Jr _ o_1 0 • •

_,j I_ _ ° U Id

Z 0 w 3[ * Z

i** 0 4( -- IL *. _" -- ][ O.

II[ 0 i- I* I_ _ I- Z w I/)

if)

I03

Page 110: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

3"

t

m

O

O

I

I

o

U

N

T

0 >-

.J u

J

< 6.

G.

<

E

!- _

._ _E --

E

<

<

..1

<

U

W

E

0

U

"W

m

,< N

m 0t

r-

i

z

w

$..

oo0

W

Z

Z

U

W

u

t_

r-

e

• o m

• ( m

W 0 o

0

oI

|otlle']ONVH3

104

I !

a

o

I

IHOI3H 31Jl:3dS

o

m cD

o

-- ..4.

- _

o

w

M

I,-

Page 111: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

B

I

V)

I

o

o

I

o

_J

o

)-

O

.J

J

,(

W

I-

N

rr

a.

]=

!-

,(

O

][

O

_J

.J

_J

W

I"

O

(J

Z

g

_J

m

(J

Z

,n

r-

_J

ru

t_

o ,(

(3

Z

o

_J

U rr

)- b.

O

o '1(

_ L

x

U

o

_J

m

!

Z

if)

o , m

.j w 0 O. N

J _ , )- ,

4[ • m r- O

Q. _ II II

,J

w I,- • • °

_ _ M E .J

U I W * W

I_J -- Z -st Z

M o .J -- nr G. -- G.

q[ 0 0 Z _ (/J Z

r

_. _D ° )- CO -- W

_ _. z

I_. o 4[ - II. n, . O. *. Z <

105

Page 112: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

ill

I

M

s

!

o

o

¢

o

i

N

o

U)

>.

0

..J

..J

W

I-

Q:

8.

][:

l"

r

LO

<

u

..i

N

U

a.

w

E

E

0

U

W

m

n0

E

.4

u

t_J

oo

fJ

N

m

I

I.

• 0 P7

9[ M

I

,q

o o

w o o

E o

4(

a

w

C)

Z

Z

u

w

U

b.

w

o

, I

h:!

iI0/Io' ]ONVHO

106

LH@I]N 31413]dS

0o

o

o

D

o

3-

¢.

bJ

w-

I-

Page 113: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

_r

!

m

o

o

Q

IIJ

o

I

N

4(

U

m

¢.)

.!-

i-

tD

m

_J

w

4.

o

t_

w

0 _"

u

.I

!- c3

m

D.

u

o

I-

<

o

u

.J

u

m

w

E

0

u

kd

< N

I m

f_

m

- z

z

,1[

0

z

o

.(

m

b.

Q

i

x

M

4[ _ 4[

..j . 1_ )- o

. iO-o--M " •

_ J • ,,J

I. U _j _ o Iq U W

W Z _ X 0 * Z

-I ¢) --J -- a. a, -- I. Z 0.

_ U

° 0 _ ' I

_[ . _ )- * O ¢31

b* I • I-" I " t_J

Ul e O m._ •@[

o .;:. ,-NW ,. _ bJ '_ • b_

6)

• Q Z w I Z O * bJ

: .... 2"o • - (L 8[ _. Z _[

107

Page 114: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

qU ql

_Po

m 8-.

BI

I

O U

Z

$.

S

ira,

0 4

I

a wo

m

xu

w

m .J _O z- •,d W _

•t ._ •w o wI t_ ,,.

w

z u

a o

E -E

o

,,J

m

a,,..a

0

W

• !

I N

W

M

o ID II , 0

• O m

1

v I OdI • •

W I •I '0

I

l

m

I'

III OII'|INVN| ANII|N OI _10ldl

10I

, I

Igut

0ooN

o40

4t

0 IdIn !"

I,-

¢S_r

0psi

Im

Page 115: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_r

i

N

M

i

8

0

0

!

_r

o

i

nd

o

).

0

.J

.J

4[

kJ

l-

m

8:

L

I[

!-

4(

CD

Z

<

¢)

u

J

E

E

E

0

u

m

t

4

u

N

W

)..

o

¢)

o

o

w

.J

u

u

o

U

o

I-

Q

Z

0

D,

h,.

O

>.

E

I

x

0

M

M •

0 N hi

4( D • -- I-

lL II _ i-eIR I*l * B

0• .J •

Q -- t*. *

W " _--t '*

w

L -- (J

f_

X

N

I[

r

oN

m

_J

0

bJ

I[

I-

Z

w

be

Page 116: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I N

I'U '4

M

U

t

Q

Q I,-

I

O X

U

Z

f_

ID

W

q.

o ;Q

: w

Z

u

w

)- u

.J _ _

.J w

,ic

IL U

E U

E --

Ig

0

114

U

E

r

0

_J

Q

w

U_

,,( IW

m oi

r-

i

- Z

z

_. 0 Iv)

m 0 _I*

i

W 0 o

, , 1

im + / lu + )ONYH_ LHO I ]H 31 _133dS

llO

0

o w

v'_ It

I-

o

o

o

o

Page 117: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Ill m

N •

: °NO

°b"oI

°

l.J

X

)..

UD

w

P

o

o

o

o

¢/)

_J

Ub J

> u

0

/ (J

J

]C o

E

G.

E

[ U

° :.

0

U

,J

U

gg

W

E

0

W

< N

m m

f_

!

-- Z

Z --

Q

Z

0

E

0

I

4

O

O "" W

.J M -- II •

.J * 1 O )"

. • ID * -- I-.

I/l O l*J _ Ir

• -I • O

a N h.

w .;. ;)- ..I •

•- U l*J • U lq °

dl bJ Z -- ° O 2[

..I .J O N -- -- II

.J O J -- O. n* Z *- --

• O O Z U) I-- w U Z

G. -- U

Ul

X

• IE

o I-

I11 •

e.

rll

vl (J

• o m • m

bJ O _ llJ O IJ

O 14 -- IL _ lq

4( * 'e >* * O Q

k. I • I-- O -- W

n, | -- I _" I[

t,'! " / 0". _ _ ;

_ .1 -I e UUM

_J _1 13 Z w 3[ Z O .* kJ

• Z O _

b. O • -- 8. _ -- I_ *- Z •

O[ 0 _-- l II) *- Z (_ U v _.

Ul

!11

Page 118: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

fU

I

Q

t

r_

I

o

I

N

o

),.

0 >-

.J u

4[ i.

E o

E _

L

E _

° :

E

U

J

Ig

W

E

E

0

IJ

kd

tn

m m

r'*

i

- Z

Z

X

(J

'1"

_d

hJ

bJ

al 4(

oo0

nJ

Z

<

Z

u) q.)

bJ

U0

3

U

Ib

U

G.

C

f-

o

N

u

_O_gMOm_Mm_NW_MO_

I**., .......... *,

_ i$1i11111111

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

El t I | " ' 30NVH_) /HOI]H 31.tl33dS

0

0

t

0o

o

ed

o

m

,4:

1[:

t--

112

Page 119: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N 0c

o 4[

M (J

r_ I.-

<

o

m

N

u

Z

N

o

_n

w

#/) J

o )-

,J (J

.J

9[ *,

r o

D.

E

E U

0 Q

°,r .

U

E

W

E

0

U

w

In

< N

m m

t**

-- Z

Z

4[

0

Z

0

4[

A"

l.h

(3

)-

<

8[

I

x

o

M w

J

4

w * o

• a W

L I_ Z

_ B 0 W N

Q _ N

;j; -_W 3Z _ Z_

_oJ--_[ ZNN

_oOZZ_P

x

M

U

z

_O_Z_Z_ w _

m

113

Page 120: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

i

_D

AJ

Iq

I

o

o

t

Jr

o

i

o

N

• u

N I.*°.,.0.,°0._,..

o

E

I

(L

E

E

<

£

E

<

0

u

.J

u

E

w

E

E

0

u

Z

(.-

w

..J

u

0

bJ

0

Z

T

o

u

0.

:ooo:oooo::oooooOOO OOOO OOO_O

.,,,,o.,.,,.0.,.

I

I O

O

OI

!

o

O

O

O

I

o

m

!

O

aee / I • " )IONVH3

O

I

o

o

1

*Hi I ]_

O

o

OlJlO]dS

0

0

0

I i

o

m

w

!

o

o

m

)-

114

Page 121: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

m

t-oo

I

Jr

o

o

W

0

.J

.,I

kd

8.

E

E

,4

0

2,!"

E

u

D,

W

I:

0

Z

g

m

U

Z

j,.

N

w

o

w

,.J

)-

IJ

U

N

m

r-

,a[

Z

'O

9[

m,

t_

k*

M

)-

t,.

i

)<

0

M -J

4

0 _ W

.j . le )- O Vh

q[ CD * I- _ W

8. I _ I- X

UI 0 IJJ Jr _

• .J 0 • -J

•. W _" • U _ O O

0 .J '* Ii. _ -- Z *- Z _q

• [ O O • _ t-* Z _ (J ::)

G. N (.J

115

Page 122: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

II1

!

II

II

14

!

il

o

o

Jr

4D

I

eU

0

(dD

)..

0

,.J

.J

,4

ill

I[

I[

O.

Z_

s'-

4(

Q

]C

4(

C)

<

u

I

W

s.

E

0

m

N •

4 u

_o-mm_B_ao_o_om

u mooz_mo_moDmo_

; I I t t I I I i i i i

ll

la

m

"r

i-

ID

0

Iq

IU

hi

I-

I.

Ci

II

ill

lli

.i

U

)-

U

I.

0

::ooo:-oo:o:::oo°000 000 0 000

*.,***..,..*,°*.,

41

Q

bi

a

Z

ql

_r

la

I--

-r

N

W

-!

(J

u

IL

ul

J

(

d

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Ill I II ' ]ONYH= J. HO I ]H

I

o

o

I

_iillOidl

116

0

Ii

!

o

0 °

o

m I

o

o

m t_t

o

o

¢)

Page 123: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

N

i

m

o

o

i

o

t

o

M

U

N

W

b..

o.

0

0

_n

bJ

4A .J

),. t.)

0 >"

.J fJ

.J

• t.

Id 0

E r3

O.

E

E

r. --

0

P

_J

.1

m

O

u

W

4 N

m

r.

i

Z

4I

I"

<

Q

1:

0

0

<

I

x

4

0

P)

Iq

_4

, _, 0 N

4 "

0 Id _ kJ

.J M I. _ O.

4( I t" • I..

i. (J W - I_ . ;40

.1 .J 0 w

•J 0 -J -- Q. . _ . o.

o 0 Z _ Z w Z tJ

L N u

Ul

W

:)

,.J

4[

:p

t_

bJ

Z

.J

)4

0 1-

161 4[

!"

,vl tJ

, 0 , OI

4[ -- 4[ _.

W 0 _ 0

4( • 'q_ , 0 1:3

b. ID * m -- lad

w II 0 _ I ). a._j_) td 0

k. Z

m

Z m r.

117

Page 124: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I0

I

I'*

o

o

z

o

I

N

o

IJ

ri-

O

-I

..J

4[

114

iP

i..+

Ih

4[

I:

i.

<

CO

+<!.

¢1

o

4(

u

Q,

r

£

O

E N

U moo_m_N_wm_m_z_

iiiiii

b[

4.)

m

.r

ii

ii

i11

0

M

N

0

a

,

0

0

N

u

N

m

o

z

i-

D

LJ

4O

4[

"r

U

3[

ID

kJ

2

IJ

N

tJ

bJ

0.

C

l

VaO00000000000000

_000_000000_00000

.,.,.,,,,.,,.o,,.

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I

o

I

ie _ I I • * I@NYH 3

118

0

O.

I

o

o

I

LHOI)H 31_II01d|

0

I

o

II1

I

0

0

o

_r

N

io

N

o

N

i.

L

td

1-

i--

Page 125: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

ID

I

r-

i

.1-

II

!

hi

o

o.J

.J

bJ

I[

my

G.

T

r

(D

1,-

T

O

u

.J

,<

(J

8:

t,J

I-

1"

O

u

Z

e

,(

u

bJ

L

O

O

N

W

.J

u

)..

U

e.

,E

o

o

¢J

(--

9[

O

Z

0

I--

(J

9[

E

t**

b.

C_

8C

I

X

4

O

M

M

O LJ a,

.J M •

.,J • _.

M

_ U hdl • I

• W Z Z _

.J o .I - L - E

4 o O • in • t--

L N u

tn

W

9[

tn

Q

E

td Q. <

_J • o

o 0

m Iq

° Q o II

o _ _ W

• 'W O _ )"

I _ • i-

O• ,,J • .J

m b, M

W[NWm*

Z.O._3

_O(_LEhZI"

X

I[

m

Ill

:)

(J

r_

b4

td

I**

Z

w

u

119

Page 126: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

O

I

I

W

o

o

I

!

o

I

<

U

x

u

Z

IG)

N

>.

O _-

.J u

.J

E

K --

E U

° :

E

0

J

m

U

W

E

E

0

bJ

U)

< N

m m

-- Z

Z

_J

[2

O

Z

9[

Z

U

W

u

w

3

u

h

W

Q.

N

u

a**..*,,*.,**0**.

_$1

kO000000000000000

aO00000000000000O

.,,.,...,.,.,.,.,

-- N

(

I

o

o

O

O

O

O

O

O

O

O

fo

o

I

Iw:/iI'3ONYH3 iHOI]H

Io

o

o

t

:) 141 :)]dS

0

0

120

o

ag

w-

Page 127: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W mr

j- u

o° ;I

I

o v

u

Z

w

o

J

),. u

0 )"

J

,,.I

.a=

,r

9C

O.

4(

E

,Jr U

; oE --

:g

<

<

U

.1

<

U

E

W

1"

E

Q

U

w

U'I

m a

I

-- Z

,I(

0

Z

Q

<

¢-1

Ix

x

4(

,,j a.

4( m I-- •

O_ w Z 21 _

,,.I Q -I -- A,. -- n- ,r,.

L _ U

/4

.v,I

0

4(

W V'I --

U (_1 ;4 --4( • 0 le

la. CO --

IZ |0 I--

° ?O-_o-. "*-o-

u)

121

Page 128: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

t

N

M

_r

!

lid

Q

O

;

j;.

o

i

N

o

_4

O

bd

I-

M

0.

q(

I'-

_C

O

E

E

4

u

,,J

u

m

w

E

o

W

m

g

M

u

N

$

u

.5,.

lm

w

@.

o

o

o

O

kd

)..

i.

O

U

O

Q

m

N

0i

I

Z

m

u

o.,.,*.,o,

°ao_m_gom

o--N_OMIO

_ tJll_ NItt

q

4

41

12

0

Z

w

w

2

u

u

L

vOOOOOOOOO

mOOOOOOOOO

..*..0,,0,

o

0

o

0

, , I

o

O

eo

|

i 0t t0•' 30NVH3

122

J. HOI]H

0

3l.dl3]dg

0

00

o

o

w m

o

m tO

- :

- :

- :

o

t_t

o

o

tt_

,it,.

it-

Page 129: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

|

N

j-

I

o

o

I

S

o

I

o

).

O

.J

.J

f

N

8.

!-

<

E

I:

0

u

M

u

E

w

I-

0

u

m

Z

N

u

v

U

m

,,F

p,.

a

N

W _

Q

ul

.J

4,J

U

i.

L

u

o

¢)

m

i

Z

4[

o

z

o

4[

m,

)-

4[

E

I

X

w

D

J

O_W

"4 Q • _ W

I_ 0 J

m <

_ N

< '_ 0 0

O[ II _ )- O[

U L (3 Z O _ " W

123

Page 130: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

I

0

o

!

J

m

0

tn

)-

0

.J

.I

<

bJ

r

N

a,

I.

IC

r

%

(

Z

E

<

0

;J

,J

M

U

Ig

LI

E

0

U

W

'11

m

• %

mOM_mm_OODB_PO

Jem4io,lJe.*.*_*l

• ooom_Om_oMM _80M

; _ I I ' I I ' I , i i , I

q

p..

O

0

o

o

W

J

u

U

Q

U

0

O

m

i.,.

i

e[

10

,i[

Gi

z

4[

x

i-

..r.

(.9

W

u

u

t_t

u1

_000000000000000

_00_0_0000_00000

• ...... .,.,....,,

I I I I I

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

, , I

ig O I I | * ]ONVHO

124

0

I

m

o

!

_NIIIN

0

i i

|141||dl

0

I

II

In

,,I

!

0

)

o

o

o

(u

II

D

o

j.

c)

lU

I.

41

lid

I=

m

I-

Page 131: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Ir II

I N

It '4

ID

Jr l.)

I N

° :o

o l,-

0 In

o

I

N

Z

ID

ID

M

14

W

)- U

0 )"

.J ,kl

..8

W a

L

91

T

Z

4[ • .

E

l-

q

O

q(

u

,../

4(

IJ

tU

Z

E

O

W

W

m

4[ N

m m

r-

z

t6J

I-

Q

O e[

oa II

N

Z

0

a,

12

a,

!

o

M

M

• ° o

=,t III N _

,j ° ° _

ilL. .111 II

lip • • I_

_,, U W _ gll:

• IM Z •

.J -J O -- -- --

.I _. J -- L L I_

0 • U_ Ut J-

• CJ

Ut

N

N

OO_

MM

.ZN_

I

_.*_

m,

44

QI

m_

_M

A

44_

II

mm_W

o .;;

123

X

m

E

W

W

U

hi

U

b,

41

O

A

._.e[ .0

ID -" W

-J N "_'L

.J * •

iN _ lid •

e. ._ O

a m

W • I-. II_

t- .J :) 8:

e. U td 4[ *

4t *- •

IV U

N

• im

4 •

0 ;*

M

' 2. r,

• O _ Q

II*. • -- Id

II II 10- ,., in"

I1 * I_ Id

.J • =J u

t. • W I_ 4.11 4£

• 0 • O * _ ht

O _ ON _," _ U

N

Page 132: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W

I

r,_

vl

lid

I

(0

o

o

$

z

o

I

N

0

N

Z

ed

N

0

0

N

IJ

14

,.,J

)* 1.1

0 )-

J

Z: o

4.

Q o

_ °E --

Ig

4

.I

E

W

I"

E

0

W

'< N

m m

J

- z

q

Q

W

m

Z

4[

Z

4.)

)-

"Jr

_D

(,J

b..

il

eL

N

v

_Q_QM_m_MNNNm_I

mONZ_MmO_D_NN_N

i,,,.,...,,,,,,o,

III

_0000000000000000

i

0

0

i i '

0

0

0

0

0

0

I

t

126

0

I

o

o

M

!

J. HOl 3fl {)1 _101dS

0

0

0

i

0

o

N

m

o

II

i-

Page 133: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

r. •

tJ

b

oo ;I

o

I

o X

W

Z

o--

M

O

,.J

.J

4[

td

I-

E

Q.

r

,1(

4t)

T-

(D

_J

.J

4

tJ

E

0

D-

LO

U

oo

o

o

0

Z

0

m

w

U

!

x

0

E

w

m

0

O.

u

Z

< 0

IL •

om

_M

oo

o

o

Iq

• q,

k'l *

,1[ II

_., .J

• _1 Z --

_ 0 _ _

o O Z U_ *-

-- LJ

)4

°

la , 0 •

tJ _J 0 _ iO

127

0

M

.,It • >- 1

L _J

• W Z 2[ --

D .J -- L -- I_

_J

)L N

N N

I[ • I_

E I:

M

IJ bJ if) b_ _ t_

U N _l. --

kJ k_ _ t- , _J

*0M .I )-_ Z

_ bJ N

b. fa _. • _11 • f,J r- I,.

Page 134: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

N

N

p_

i

(D

I

o

I

_J

o

In

)-

0

J

.J

_J

r

m

Q.

,(

r

r

!"

£

u

u

E

I,I

1"

E

o

u

I

E

N •

< v

_omz_m_m

I,,.*****+

IIII

I+,I

I,,

: <o <

+,..

c0

z

<

2_

u

w

k,l

o

0

&_

u

w

L

u1

u

o

Vl

B

M

m

I

Z

booasaomoo

4000000000

0

(1)

o

, , Io

o

o

I

its e / I • ' ]@NYH3

O

LHOI3N

0

_ I :11 331d$

O

O

I:1

ID

4D

r-

o

o

14

ill

M

i-

128

Page 135: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

m

su

I

o

!

2

o

i

o

.J

w

1-

N

m

1-

w

L

IC

<

0

Ic

o

7,4[

U

.J

4[

U

W

!"

0

Z

q[

¢.J

)-

U_

X

u

Z

(-

o

I-

u)

w

)-

,4:

: oz

o

N

Ld

_J <

U B:

U b.

*. Q

,ic

a,

x

u

m

M

m

t

Z

o

4[ _ 4(

m - aD

G. a

Q _

I,,,, j . ,.I

•_ W Z 0 -- Z

d[ 0 0 Z U_ U )" U_

JJ)

W

• (:3

4( _ 1

4( . '_ Ul

b. m w

n, II _ Z

_/I m .J -J

_. .J ::_ 2[ •

• Q 0 Z w Z CI_

Z_. 0 4[ _ *. O. O[

m C_ )*" Z (.1 _) I-

UI

X

M

E

1"

u

,m

u

0

L*J

m

W

t-.

Z

U

bJ

_J

<

12g

Page 136: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

f_

IU

I

o

I

_r

o

i

o

Ill

O )-

•J U

..4

4( b

IE 0

L

t

E u

0 0

E --

E

0

,J

g

W

IC

g

0

W

W

4 m

II m

II

t

• ,.+

4.)

M

<

3g

O

3:

l-

iv)

IU

W

I-

I-

O •

N ID

<

Z

t J,

1,4

U

m

w

,T

u

u

w

IL

o

_o_gOomaDt_omWoSM

ooo_aa_aMMaD_o_zm

I...1.*.****.*..*

IIIIIli

_000000000_000000

_000000000_0000_0

.,*..*.,.*,,.,,.*

ir

I 0I

1

,o

0

0

0

0

Io

II

l" * / i • * ]ONVHO

130

0

tHOI]_

0

0

01JI0]lll

O

Io

o

¢1

Ill

I

O

O

c}

o

GI

¢1

m III

o

__ Io

o

__ ciN

o

-- ID

ID

_4D

O

C)

141

d_

1,4

E

1-

Page 137: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

N

0

I

:r

o

t

N

o

a,

tJ

X

(J

N

.r

F- .

N

)-

o.J.J

w :t" o

I

G.

E

E u

° :

E --

E

<

0

.i[

u

J

u

W

E

0

u

w

m

m

Z

W

o 4[kk,.

o <

o ¢)

N

O

W

,J <

u E

E

X

I

P1

m

I

Z

o

14

Iq

_4

o

4[ _ 4[

o _ l'J

O * O

Q --

_ W M _ W

L W Z 0 -- Z

( 0 0 Z _ U P

A N (.J

In

)4

N

E

Iv)

PI

U

o I

U

U

_ o W W

_ * ._ _0 _-. W

M _ U

_. O 4( -- G* ** _: 4[

m

131

Page 138: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

7 -"41

M

II P

0 4

0 P

j-

m

a

N

0 W

U

Z

U_

N

W

o

O

o

o

td

o.,J.J

O

,m

E

0.

4

l=

E IJ

4

-. *Jl

E

4

u

,,J

,tl

u

W

ul

IC

0

0

N

• I

m E

I

K

Z E

0

W

Z

<

:[

u

Q

LI

u_

ul

Ik

u

_aUM_BO

I...,o.,,,

) I ' i i 7 "

_DQIDm_mlO

a_00000000

+.,o.°,oo.

__0

r i

O

0

o

o

I

r

I

i

o

0

|_ : / I • ' 3@NVHO J. HO 1 314

lo

o

o

I

3 I .11| 33dS

132

0

,IQ

I

0 °

o

0

0

- :

- :

- :

o

o

d_

k-

Page 139: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

N

m

_q

i

m

o

C2

!

0

I

N

I;)

U

E c_

N

B.

,I-

T U

r

o

In

IJ

,r

_J

E

I[:

0

u

0

b/ o

,In N

• !

m E

I

E

Z

W

o° <

D

Z

0

p,

W

.J •

O:

a

)<

0

, 0

;:S

8W + 3Zw

0

_d

_Z _Z _

• Z--O _

m

m

o

< --

_N w

" ;g_

OOZZ_

133

Page 140: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_J

I

N

!

m

o

o

o

I

_J

o

m

0

,J

,J

kd

E

<

E

(D

I"

<

(J

J

a.

w

£

E

o

w

4[

m

z

E

4[

w

.m •

Q

0

O _

-- O

Z

Z

Ih U

W

U

U --

W

O _

U

W

G.

U

%v

_oo_mmD_

mO--MZM_OMM

|.,,..,.,,

II1|

4

_000000000

4000000000

0

0

¢o

o

0

0

, i

o

, I Io o

o o

o o

I I

iII I I I ' ]@NVH_) JLHO I _IH 3 I JI133dli

0

0

134

o

Z

j-

o

Page 141: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

OI

I

a

o

?o

I

o

ul

),.

0

.J

.J

,4

bJ

IC

O[

6.

II:

(J

N

4[

!"

5'-

4[

o

E

E

O

U

M

U

E

1.1

E

0

U

Z

X

I,J

7,p,.

: oz

o

m

1,1

.j 4(

u E

)- Ii.

G. Q

x

o

o

Ill

t

E

I

E

4l

IE

o

M

M

4--

p EJ_

_ _0 _

_ozz_

M

0_ _

I_

• • • W

o

_ X_Z -

o

_oW

_0------

I

w , 0 ,

I " l'l

_ _ • z--Z

_ z--O------

135

N

at*

E

t$

I

¢J

W

W

t-

Z

w

(J

td

u

b.

Page 142: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IlaPII

D

O

O

$

_r

O

J

NJ

CD

0

-i

-I

<

I+J

E

E

0.

4[

E

E

9[

o

E

E

<

U

U

l[

W

£

E

0

U

_ W

M I°,..° .... ° ......

_ I I I I i I I I I !

X

4J

3:

OI

(U

u

o

o

o

o

IXl

I

E

I

,1[

I"

+:o::o+o:+=::oooo0 O00 Q 0000

4[

Z

I,,-

Z

l.O

l.iJ

-r

U

16.

N

(J

w

O.

o

0

0

o

o

o

o

o

ii a _ / I • * ]ONVH3

o

o

o

Io

LH@ I ".lM

o

31.4133dS

O

O

o

o

111

I

o

o

o

-- 10

o

-- Jr

- _

o

w

136

Page 143: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

Q

P1

I

m

o

o

I

j*

o

I

nJ

o

0

.J

J

<

_J

*r

9.

E

IC

lc

o

J

U

W

E

E

o

Z

U

X

X

m

w

o

o

ta

_J

u

o

U

o

D

o

o

nJ

!

E

!

I"

Q

_Z

0

E

D

a,

i

x

4

o

M

j L_ _

L_U

m

°_

E

m

uW m_w_

137

Page 144: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

M

Ol

@

m

o

o

Q

I

Q

U)

).

0

,.J

.J

<

w

E

I

4.

!-

I-

E

u

u

w

E

E

Q

W W

u

B.°0°...0°..0°°°.

q

N

Z

w

4.)

),.

o

o

N

I

I:

i

8[

4(

7C)

w

w

_J

u

_d

• ..°..,o° .... °.:..

i

0

I

o

0

0

0

0

iw m / I1• 0 _lOHV'H3

138

0

0

,I. HO ! aN

0

0

0

31,1113_1dll

0

Io

0

0

c:l

o

.1'

Page 145: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m14 oN

0

0 k"

0

I

0

U

Z

M

(A

>.

0

..J

.J

Ill

11"

a.

<

!"

!,

0

Q

f--

'1[

U

N

E

W

0

W

m

3[

W ¸

_J

0

)-

0

Z

0

'1[

n.

0 _

I

J LN w

E J

4W 3Z w

_0_

_QOZZ_

L_U

4

O

_4

m

M

4[ 4[

w 0 W k'_

El I-- m *

8 a' o

k. _ 'I[ 4. -- -- 6. 4[

::) _ t/I

_n

4 --

_.

OOZZ_

N_

X N

(j w 0 bi _ _f_ IJ

_ L w N

Z _

b 4( ,bJ * _" *,d

139

Page 146: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

t

(q

!

o

o

0

qD

#

N

B

m

tJ

me

J-

'4

8-

U

N

Z

to.

N

O

N

m .J

W

0 >"

.,J

W O

E O

4

:E

t," U

4

'0 O

: °X _

Z

0

¥.

4.)

,.J

4

p.J

ut

E

E

0

_ S

el N

• 81

!

• H

i,I

Q Im

a 4

0

o

o W

N •

Z

,4

Z

W W

re-

X

0

m

:3

m

b,.

W

0,.

_ • • _ 0 00 mmoMo oP _ 0

om_ • ooN • B _ _ o omomo

i0e0*e0eee0eoe*mB

"OOQN_ONON_ONO_

• limmmNMO_Dl_

iJJJlJltr8-_ II

q

_ O O 0 O_O 0 • O O 0 O 0 0 0 O 0

4ogoooooosomlgaooe.eeee*e6oe'*eeJee

W O _ m O m O _ O _ _ O _ _ O O _

i

@

m

Q

0

@

0

O

@

@

@

@

i I

g

!

eee 0 O• _ |ONVHO

140

,I,NO I _IN

@

01,dl03d|

0

i nnnl

Q

I

I

@

, @en

o

o

o

I

o

N

o

b.t

N

e.-

Page 147: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

U

N

-i"

I.-

w

f.

oo

w

U_ J

0 )'-

J u

.J

E

E --

A

<

E

E U

_E --

Z

<

0

<

U

N

U

E

W

r

T

0

o

W o

I E

I

Z £

(

i,-

<

O

Z

0

K

Q

I

X

4

LN _

_ o

_ • a W

0 • M

Q _ N

_U -WI

JO w_

_OOZZ_

4

O

M

M

--_N _

lO_Z_Z_

4(

O I

:)

_J ..i

,v_ 4[

bJ k'l

..I 0. N

4 _ _ L_J

.J 91

kd 2[ Z _ Z O

N

l 4 I

4 _ 4

_ _*_ W

I [ I_I I

_ _ Z

_Q ]IwZ

U ZO u

N_

141

Page 148: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

$

m

1'1

!

Ot

o

o

!

o

I

N

Q

I/I

).

0

.J

./

9[

bJ

I[

a-

!"

IC

E

E

W

m

<

U

W

E

£

0

U

m

M

mow_mM2_m

_ IIit

U

%

II

B

.T

(U

taJ

o ;• a

O

o w

Z

.r

L_

: °

o.

.,,..,...,

O

O

0

o

I

iI _ / II • * ]ONYH3

142

i HO I "IH

@

0

IU-

!

313132dS

' 0

o

i

o

a

m

o

o

In

0

ar

o

M

Page 149: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

MIN

m

M

t

m

o

O

I

I

N

Q

W

U

m

x

u

2[:

1 Ul

w

t.-

o

ul

bJ

W J

)- u

O >"

.J u

..J

• 6.

r o

K --

L

I-

E U

O o

o

U

U

1.1

E

E

O

u

4.

o

W o

U) N

• o

m E

I

n.

. ¢[

Z lr-

Q

Z

O

N

g[

C3

IE

I

x

o

M

M

_N _

• o W

0 • J

E J

_W 3 zwN

_O _-O

•20ZZ_Z

U

o t-

* • 0 m

&i _J 0 _1 _ U"

• ). , , _ D

I[ I II -- I[

lJ) )"

• • .,. . ). kJ0

iv. .j .j :_ o

kJ _ • * 4d W f£

• Z 0 _ _ _ _ 0 4,)

b. I_ • -- * _L _L I[ *"

Ic _ )- Z Z _ m _m X k.

ul

o

_o_

.OO_

O_.--_

X

m

w w In _6_

u L N

• >. _. Q

w

::)

_ Z

I[ !" ,,J 4.)

b • u

Z -- O _ U

143

Page 150: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

ID

I

N

m

I

m

G

O

!

S

0

I

0

E

N

4[

U

m

(J

N

Z

O-

lq

_J

J u

.J

r

q(

E

E

.J

,(

u

W

E

E

0

U

o

bJ o

ul N

< I

m

K

Z E

_J

o

o •

Q

o

o bJ

0

Z

Z

u

W

u

a.

u

I**.,,.,**

IIII

m

....... . . .

I

II

O

C

O

O

|u e I |a*'.oONYH_ 2H@I]M

0

GI

0

_J

Ol_13]dS

0

O

o

o

o

o

-- .1,

- _,

o

o

Page 151: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N •

m

o

i Ln

I

N

o _

u

X

),-

N

U)

O

.J

..J

,,1[

k_

n,

Q.

¢[

s-

I-

(D

]C

s-

(D

t_

(J

<

(J

a,

t;J

E

I-

0

tJ

i-

tn

t_J

t.

.s

(J

9[

i--

<

Q

I,

0

t.

Q

I

X

_ N w

_ e W

EJD

bU "W_

_W ZZ_N

m

x

.( a,

i*

w)

* • o m

td w o I_1 _ (J

U & -- ¢U w

k*. I- ID m . W

I[ I (I *

:_ a' Q 0 t;J t;J0 • • J *-

J _N_

e_

L_ _Zw_

JO_O

x

!"

N

N * o * m

&_ I- _D * ID bJ

0 _[ -- -- _. l: 8. *,- _(

145

Page 152: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

m

I

0

?j-

o

i

N

o

Vt

).

0

.J

.J

w

I-

G.

,(

I"

E

<

E

I"

e,-

U

J

U

E

LI

E

E

0

U

w

<

m

u

U mO_M_Nmm_W

IIII

4

M

-Jr"

N

w

)..

o

¢J

o

o

N

I

r

I

I

E

I

q/I

a

i-

L"

qD

Z

::::::°oo:• , , .......

E _SW_mO

Z

u

o

w

2

u

w

0

0

0

I 1

o

o

!

llelll*)ONYH_l _HOI]H

]46

O

I i

IU

i

Ol_10]-Ii

O

• t

I

O

4=)

m

O

II

Cl

nJ

O

I.

I*J

lr

i--

Page 153: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

E

M U

° ;

cI

!

o v

u

,.r

m

nl

N

)..

0

.I

J

W

E

IIC

,r

IC

T

E

0

,(

U

.I

u

I

W

E

I-

0

U

bJ

m

m

W

o

o

o

o

o

J

E

J

E

E

t

Q

4

a

Z

0

N

k.

m

D

E

I

X

o

,

4W 3Z _

_OZZ_Z

m

d

ZO .... _0

m

4

0

* 0

X X

U _ U

)- t_ 0 • .J )-ZZ _

147

Page 154: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

_d

Ot

M

I

o

o

i

=r

o

!

N

Q

m

o

.J

.J

r

O.

E

r.

E

E

0

4(

,,J

U

E

ul

£

0

W

4[

g

m

u

I**,*0***,

• o o m m _ m _ m N

w

i-

b

o

u

N

o

o

N

!

sr.

!

I[

r

l

U)

N

l-

q(

)-

0

w

(D

Z

T

U

:11

u

u

w

IL

ffl

_ooo0ooooo

8ooo0ooooo

.,,..***,.

I

ii

I °I0°

0

!o

o

o

t

|w e / i I * ]ONVHO

148

O

LHO | ]H 3 I .d I 3":ldS

.O

Oo

o

m

o

0k

40

-- 40

o

m

o

n

o

t.

d:

,.J

%:

)-

Page 155: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

iNOnP_!ooIoI0

0.J.J

w

N

o.

0

I-

I'-

(.)

_J

_J

I-

E

0

U

Z

E.

,(

U

w

o

o

W

.J

U

u

o

o

N

#

E

I

E

I

o

0

Z

0

M

U

4

0

I

x

0

4_

L e_

LW 3Z_ __0

_sOZZ_

kJ _d _ vrl _ _J

(3 o • ; t" t_J

][ _j ..; _ 0

W _ • • bJ W

< z 0 04(

b. Vl < -- -- O. O. _"

Ut

4

0

_4

_4

Id W --

,.J IL N

,.j _. 1

4( ¢,- gO *

0

0 Z Z

X

_ N w

149

Page 156: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Ic

_J

m

In

b.I

b

o

o

N

W

O 2,-

I[: o

_ U

E --

Ig

ffJ

U

.1

U

W

]g

E

o

U

o

_d o

E

I

Ir

Z

4

I,-

Q

Z

3:

O

N

W

2

C.)

m

N

W

0.

w

i.°.°,°°_0°,...0.

IIIIIIIIII

_0000000000000000

400000000000_0000

._,.°.,,°,°...°,,

C

0

C

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

,_e e S I • * 30HYH:)

150

0

£HO! il8

0

0

0

_ I dl 3":JdS

0o

o

n/

o

nJ

,r

)..

0

_V

Page 157: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

# 8[

o <

M u

m

o •

° ;I

"oI

N

U

X

I.-

0

w

o

Qu

w

>. U

J

E o

M

I[ o

G.

E

E U

,1[

O o

o

E --

E

.(

0

I.-

CJ

.J

U

l

E

E

0

U

¢.

0

W o

m

m !"

I

8[

Z lr

o

_._

U ° W I

_W ZZ_

,_0_--0

N

m

• K

• * _ O •

N_ _

o-O_

ZO__O

l_l

Page 158: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

!

Ot

I

m

o

0

!

I

hJ

0

U)

:t-

O

..f

.J

id

m

E

E

E

<

u

_t

¢,J

E

E

E

O

U

w

,,,,,, .... II

W

o )..

o 4[

0

o

o

N (D

Z

<

-Jr"

u) _j

LJ

_j )-

_j -r

)- t,D

L*J

u

w

L

o

.,..., ...........

__0__o

(

0

v

o

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

In

I

|,,, I_ I I • ' 30NVH:

0

IHO I 311

0

0

31_ll33dS

0

152

0

I,I

N

I-

Page 159: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

14 a-

m

Iq U

o

o P-

o

0

t-,

O

.J

.J

<

bJ

E

a,

8.

,(

!..

E

.(

_D

E

0

.J

<

a,

M

E

0

U

Ill

<

m

onj

z

0

w

_J ,I[

u _

L. 0

X

#

o

O

N

t

i..

I

a,

r

o

• o W

laJ O

4(

b. g0

D

0 *

4[ ./

W *.. 4( W

.m (2 ,Z

_. o < - n.8: O ).- Z V_

D -- ,,/I

_n

m_ Z

W

ZO 0

O_ZZ__

153

Page 160: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

tO

I

M

m

O

_D

I

_J

0

3..

0

J

J

W

E

a:

0.

E

E

4[

4D

Z

E

o

t-

u

.I

w

K

E

Z

O

• %u

I*°o,°,,,*o°*ooo,

o0 ON_I_OOINmIIIiI_NMM_I_aO

_ ' I i ' ' ' ' ! ' --I

4

u

'T

I-

ra

ID

(,-

Q

N I

Z

Z

_ U

W

>- 0

W

i. 3

D _

o m

W

L

I

m

_|IlO|IJJJOOOiI_l

_OOO001IIOOIIOOI

De*,mo0el***_*o**

rr

)

¢

0 I

oo

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

iee Ol•' IIO#¥HO

0

fl

Q

8)

!

0

0

o

LHIIIItl II _ll0!ldI

I

0

!

o

0 °N

o

I I

o

i

o

(D

I

0

o

I I

0

i I

0

0

Page 161: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W I

OI

0

°Io

I

o x

_J

M

-r

W

_d

4/)

W

)- tJ

0 )"

.J t.)

J

4( i.

IC 0

E

0.

4(

r-

E U

,(

E --

E

<

U

-I

it

W

E

E

0

U

0

m E

I

Ig

w

I-

o 91

: oZ

O

m

0

E

I

x

4

o

L_ w

_ JO --_

W 0

0

z _k. 0 _( -- O, _.

<

o

_w

e

2:S

)4

4( 0_

_4

",4

• ° O m

<

ka W a Ill --

" _ --; _if: .J M _-)

_ 3. Z Z -- W _J

o

155

Page 162: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_P

I

II

I

ID

II

I

,5"

O

I

ill

Cll

Ul

)*

O

.J

.J

4

bJ

lr

B.

a.

E

E

<

I"

T,

<

o

u

J

<

u

E

w

E

E

o

u

R

N

w

U

4,

O

O

I

E

I

E

e[

E

I

,'5

e[

Q

L.J

ID

Z

9[

Z

U

w

3

u

u

w

a.

w

u

mo_Dm_NNmUumom

i.,.,,,0,,,,.,.,.

ll!

q

o o : o o _ o o o o o o o : o ooo 0ooooooooo oo

.,.°..,,,,,,,,,,,

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

C

C

C

0

i

lu o I l • * ]0NVH3

156

0

0

0

LHOIiH 31,il 3Jill

Oo

o

ed

o

f_

°o w

E

N

Page 163: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

B I,I N

Ill

14 I.)

i N

o D-

o

o

I

o

U

Z

k-

O

),.

0

.J

.J

hJ

E

O(

G.

q[

E

,I[

Q

4[

Ic

][:

q[

(0

(,.

w

9(

cJ

f.)

O[

kJ

Z

I:

0

U

ka

_n

4[

m

kJ

• ¢D

Q

o

N

U_

_J

.J

(J

).

J.

¢)

qJ

o

o

o

o

N

I

E

I

E

I

0

4

Q

Z

0

t-

LJ

,1[

er

b.

b.

D

)-

!

)4

4

0

M

4_

4 bm

• I_

kU *W_

_0_0

400ZZ_

4

0

4

0 • _

OOZZ_

N_

N X

Z _ _ Z

ZO_O

N_

157

Page 164: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

11

I

m

I

o

I

j,

Q

!

o

lh

),.

0

.I

,.4

<

E

IL

+<

T"

I"

<

4_

<

E

'r

<

<

u

u

w

1+

E

O

u

bJ

l,n

,<

m

Z

< v

I°°*°o,°°*.,..o°*

x

_J

Z

m

m

_u

_J

b

0

_J

2

(J

w

,T

u

u

G.

::::::°'*::::::::o.°• ....... , ..... ° o .

i

I(

{

otI

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I

in

i

0

0

aw _ I I w ' ]ONVH3

158

I

o

I

IHO I ",IH

0

0

0

31.dlg3d$

IU

o

__ tO

N

+...

__ .T

- P+

o

-- +'ll-

P.,41:

°

I--

Page 165: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

w

u) .I

..I GI

.I

,+ _-I' o

0,.

<

T'

£ U

I"

,<

(D

,,,I[

U'

..J

,It

E

I+l

E

Sl-

Q

(.l

21:

+

o

o

I

U) +

,< 0C

,ms ,<

E

I

Z £3

N * Q

W ID

,_ I- m *

4. U • I+I 0:

,m _ 'T Z -- au

< Q 0 Z Z I/I _- Z

L _ ¢,1

<

_J

m I

Q

I_ 6. < W

U Am Q Z

31¢

N

* <I+11

.vl U

, Q a

0 _ U

m W

_ _ Z

.J _l e u_ m

Z -- *, * lU

(J

.1[

I+

Z_O--_O-

__Z_ w

o

+

I_I 111

.I L N +

N

M

m •

o .; .;

mm

159

Page 166: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

I

o

I

o

o

I

o

I

D

)-

0

,.I

J

<

w

x:

8:

<

1-

E

(D

E

,4

I.)

-I

I.)

Z

0

U

w

D

a N

u

_O--Q_m--NDN_mNm_

g,,.,.,o+,,,,o.,,

m_ _ l|llIlitl

4

x

o

.r

l--

iv)

&lJ

I--

i.

.I

00

in

.J

• ).

(.j

c)

+

c)

o

nJ

I

s-

!

In

<

z

<

u

u

w

n

_0000000_00000000

_0000000000000000

.,,o..,,,,,..,,,,

N

C

0

C

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I

m

N

i

ii I II / I II ' ]ONYH:)

0

Imm , n

I

,I, HI) I ]M

a I I i

0

0

i i

OlJl+)lll

o

o

lU

o

ID

o

lid

¢)

n_

4[

3[:

N

@-

o

m

Page 167: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

o

Iq

I

o

?o

I

N

o

0

kd

n_

ri

E

E

£

E

<

o

u

J

u

B,

lg

0

W

m

Z

o

N

u

u

.v.

lr

N

L.

L

u

9

o

I

3:

I

E

!

m

a

0

Z

0

j,.

U

4(

0

n,

I

x

4(

0

vl

.J G. rU

• p m "IO.

a. u . w _.

.j ,.J

.j .j n.

0 0 Z Z _ p* T

O. CU

US

)4

< n.

11C

Iq

m

I,) G. _ I_I --

). , • 1 0

I-- CI Ill • IdII l _ QC

_) B 0 0 lal kd

tll _- 4[ • W kd I_

161

Page 168: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

u

_OImS_M_M

a°,.,,°o,.

q

X

M

,,r

i

a

o

/.

ffl

IA ..J

)- ¢j

0 )-

.J U

.,J

W o

I: o

L

!"

I U

< ,

Q o

E _

E

,(

u

-I

W

Ic

w

IC

E

0

u

,1[ !

!

I

Z I_

ql

Q

Z

91

,,r

u

Q

W

(J

U

W

L

o

:°::°o°::oo ooo o

..,,,,,,,,

0

0

0

0

ii I iii

o

I

162

0

IH9 I 3t1

Q

N

I

_l.il 3lid|

0o

-- I

0

-- I

cl

o

, Q

m

Q

o

o

w

Page 169: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Z

I

p,j

t

N

2

o

t

N

¢)

4(

(J

U

Z

I-

ra

_r

N

taJ

(,-

k,

O

u_

_J

Vl -J

.j u

.I

.eL

I,d C_

E 0

OC

O.

¢(

E

E U

4( •

1" _

E

0

J

u

E

W

E

E

o

u

W _

m it

I

Z S:

<

0

Z

O

,4

0[

b.

0

)-

4(

o[

I

x

m w

m

L_ _

4 _0 W

0 • J J

°

X

m

< Ig

o I-

ra ¢(

iv)

,,4 _J

• o m

4( 0 1 0

b. gD " W

O[ II _ n*

U_ • .J I-

Z

0 o _ W

U _ _ Z 0

4(

163

Page 170: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

N

r.,

i

o

t

_r

o

i

o

_J

_n

W

),. (.J

0 )-

w Q

E Q

Q.

E

° :

<

u

.1

u

E

w

E

11.

0

u

w _

_ N

4I t

M f

I

-- 4

Z

4

k-

4[

D

L,J

0

Z

<

Z

C.)

w

3

u.

u

u

v

mo _ _ _ m m M m o

_tflll$$

_°:::::::°oo

.... 0 .....

wo_o_o_oo

E _MZW_O

0

0

0

I Iin i/I

,.. _u

iI _ /II ' +01,,I+I,I+ IHO I ]H

0

0

:)lJlO)d!

0

0

o

N

o

o

t_

Page 171: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

lidih_r,-

r,l

I

N

0 v

U

'r

I-

ra

N

m

_J

m -J

). u

0 >"

.I u

.J

r_

L

!" U

° :

I-

u

.J

(J

rr

0

u

w

¢n N

q[ !

¢D I"

i

- <

z I-

4[

o

z

o

n,

b.

b.

Q

)-

rr

I

X

o

.j _ w

• _J

Q

u w _ 14oW Z

X

E

U

,o m

Wo_ U

m • W

E m

: OW W

Z

Z_ W

m

Iq w

,v* _(

. >,

• 0

.j • xe 0 _1_

4[ _ - -- i bJ

r. I _ t.- m Z

_ • p * ° Z

•." W n-, (J _J 0

• s _l Z w * Z Z Vt

.,J 0 v

X

N

_ Z

_Z o_Z

z_O

165

Page 172: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

j.

i

o

I

z

o

I

o

V$

0

.J

.J

<

w

lr

I[

II.

9[

IC

E

q[

O

E

<

U

U

E

w

E

0

U

W

,4

m

Z

< u

m....,,,,* ..... ..

X

U

.r"

W

o _0

: wnJ (D

z

.!,

bJ

U

>- O

w

W

in

o

::o-o::oooo-oo:::000 0000000

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I io o

I

8m = I Iw* ]0NVH: ,LHO ! ]H :) I 3 I :)3dS

O

O •

O

o

o

o

w

]c

N

b-

166

Page 173: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W

I

r-

i

D

i

0

I

N

o

kl

:I:

t--

Ul

W

m ..I

)- (j

0 )-

.J

.J

E --

,1[

r

E ¢0

°Z

,[

Q

,4

U

.J

u

E

W

E

O

iII I

m •

I

g

• I"

,(

t,-

(

Q

Q

Z W

m IC

I.- t*l

U tA

< m

E 0

b. .J

Q

D.

,<

I

x '1[

u

t_

:Z

L. o

.J In

.J .

• 0

L Z

In

9[

0

m

• 0

kd IO --

,a( • 'I

k* CD

:) 0 lU

k_ • .J

Q •

O

It -- •

I_ -- Id ID

•J N -- IL

..J" . -Q ). °

(/I 0 kd • el

• .J O •

td • I** e °

.J _ E .,J

_'J Z -- 2[ Z O

.J O N

o 0 Z _/_ I- Z V)

N X

Z

Z_0mN

167

in kJ

.J N 0.

< II

L _

" ."2

¢D .J -- L --

0 O Z In Z

N (J

x

0 I

_" Z

• 4L--_Z 4

Page 174: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t

Ot

I'-

:P

I

N

o_P

o

i

hi

o

I#

.J

.J

w

!-

O_

0.

,I[

i-

3_

0

3_

1-

<

0

_J

_J

,1(

N

_J

0_

W

E

E

0

U

N

m •

< u

I°., .... .,,°,°..°

"O_O0_N_M_SS_ __ ¢llllillllllli

U

IC

W

al

W

F-

nl

W

-J

U

L)

U

1

N

I

IC

t

11:

<

a

u

o

z

4(

._.

_J

0

w

u

u

w

L

::::::°:°::::::::° o......o,........,

0

)Q

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I I I

im ; / II;' )ONVHO IHO ! 3H 0 I .11 :)]dS

168

0n/

t-

o

Page 175: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

:r u

7 "

I

Ill

)-

O

.J

J

W

r

IE

I1.

!"

O

.1I

I-

c,_

J

U

a,

w

E

E

Q

(J

m

,.J

.J

(J

.,c

o

Q

N

N

i

E

I

IC

<

Q

Q

Z W

0 >

_ O

h.

11.

I

X <

Z

j _

J _

L Z

D

M

U N w I,_ N

ob. m _ II0

(,7 -_ •

° :w ,,_ • ,j

_GZO_O*Z

_<_ _--Z_

m

0

A

m

oOZ

x

N

J,.. C) _

ID . 0 ID

D 4[ _ D

t*l 0 -* (J

i_J • 1 G

=) o W W

zZ

k_ _ Q • -- bJ

169

o

• o

m

,J N

_1 °

4 _0

G. I

D _

X

_ K

I=

*.4 U

Z

N _

Page 176: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

I

N

P4

I

_J

?o

t

N

0

I[

;J

U

Z

m

N

N

W

_J

lU

OI .J

)- u

0 )-

.I u

.J

E Q

E

O.

E

E

O D

E _

E

O

U

U

a,

le

E

O

IJ

O

in N

i

i

u

_OI_OM_Ma

mo__mom

i,,°,°.,.0

IIItll

'4

Q

bJ

0

3:

U

Q

W

U

_OOOOO_OOO

.,...,,,,.

0

0

fo

0

0

0

, Io 0

0

,Io

if) o

N m r-

i i i

IHOI 3H :l,tl :]dlIll* I I•' )gNVH3

170

o, :

o

o

- :

- :

- _

-- _

- :

o

Q

Page 177: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

|

N

Ill

it1

i

_U

o

I

o

I

nJ

o

)-

O

.J

.J

4[

bJ

lr

g

L

,4

E

E

4(

(J

t-

4(

o

-i-

t-

m

(V

bJ

[--

L.

O

O

O

E

E

O

u

M

,1(

u

E

E

0

U

m

Z

113

0

N

W

o )"

o qL

m J

X

O

UD

j*

I

lr

I

E

4(

lr-

O

M

, , O

4[ 4 "

j I_ O

.j * ,g

. .o.o 0 --

.j .J o -- -- "

• 0

m• o

tJklJ I_ _ o

IJ Itd +0

4[ . .ll •tlJ

iv,8[ | _ l

D o *'j GO bJr..U)

bJ* )- •

(JO: ,.J _ ")

z..Oo o

171

Page 178: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

,aC

X

I

in

jr

pd

qu

0.-

fA

I*J

p-

p..

o

o

qD

W

,c,.)

O I,..

,,.J

J

]c o

at

o.

cD ,D

!.

qK

u

.o

o

W

!,

E

0

U

LI_ J"

W N

ml Z

¢

E

• £

a

W

0

Z

,4

Z

IJ

Z

W

X

U

N

W

I.

u

_oDm_mBl_m_m_a_

_00_mmBmOOMI_D_BB

a.00,,0.....,.o..

Illlllll

q

.,..._.._,.,.,,..

, I I

I

' I

i !i

II

II

I

I1II

II

I

II

I°O

O.

O

0

0

0

0

0

0

, I0

o

I

iII tll _ ]IINVH3

172

0

0

,LHOI|H

O

O

_lJl3]ldl

• , 0

0IU

0

__ m

o

o

o

-- :

- :

Page 179: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

I

N

Iq

!

N

cs

i

,?,

¢

N

Q

N

4[

u

(J

1:

0,-

m

_d

W

)-

L.

o

W

u

.,j u

,.J

Q.

E

E u

0 o

°E

4"

I-

u

u

m

w

0

u

tO

tJJ 2

N

• I

m E

I

Z E

4

Q

Z

0

o,

0

I

X

0

• o

0

.j It)

j . 1

< gO

o _J

Q

t, U W E

• uJ Z '_

,..,I o .J -- G. _'

N U

U)

X

N

N

U

173

Page 180: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

lq

I

I

_r

I

I

o

M

I

I

o

I

N

o

u)

]p

0

.I

J

w

E

I

L

E

E

<

w

E

U

_a

It

E

W

ul

K

N

U

IJ

w

I.

.m

o

o

W

u

u

I0

m

I

i

E

I

<

IC

N

u

_O_OMOD_MW

I....*$.**

q

0

w

CD

Z

9(

T

w

-!

u

L.

L

:°°o::o:.o000 0 O0

, i , ,

i

Io

0

0

0

0

ilw # I I • " |ONVH3 LHO 1 314

0

Io

Ol ,a133-+I

0

174

!

0 o

o

o

o

s

o

w

E

m

Page 181: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

N

0

1

0

0

I

O

a

I

o

(J

)-

0

kJ

,r

M

Rr

G,

E

E

0

E

r

0

U

W

]C

W

L

X

W

W

11)

GD

Z

4

f.)

N

O-

p-

ro

(J

N

X

F-

0

(3

N

W

,m

o

o

w

J

u

i,

u

o

W

f_

m

!

s

i

E

i

E

<

E

lr

<

O

U

I-

4(

Q

Z

< m

_b

Q <

G.

I

X •

U

Z

i. 0

d _

_ 0

L Z

41

0

M

• N 0

4

W 0 _ ,m

N I. v

_. 18 I- *

• O -J

4[ _ _

ut

X

t-

I-

(J

m

tU

m

t-

Z

ILl

(J

W

U

4

o

,I -- N

.j . , .1_

4( • II

in

o --

bl - ° _-

0 ..i -- 8* _L _ b

o O Z (_ U_ _-" 2[

o

_J

o

UI • • .J

_1_ ,.J -J

•a, Q Z X _ _ 0 0

Z _ O m _ O I_ iU

0 4[ G* -- L _1_ *" ** --

l-- _ Z _ o-. _ _ •

175

x

0

U

Q

bl

a,

_J

Z

I*1

u

t,d

U

t,.

Page 182: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

W

i

o

o

I

m

o

t

0

.J

.J

W

E

N

E

<

Ir

I-

<D

_J

w

1-

w

0.

x

w

u

w

• <

D ¸ _.

Q

-- 0

Z

<

Z

_J

u

)- (._

u _

w

u

w

IJ

o

u

m

i

I

,i[

E

0

u

u

_oom_m_mso

°oooooDooo

°.,,.,,,..

_0_0_0_00

0

0

ilU a t I | * ]ONVHO

176

LN() ! "_H

0

0

0

0

0

, I

3 I 41 _)31dS

O

o

o

o

j-

Page 183: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

_D

_D

I

ID

¢)

I

m

o

I

N

o

m

>.

o

.,i

,.J

It

N

L

E

¢I

,q

I--

U

I-

N

'I[

E

I"

I'*

Z:

q(

0

f.$

Z

w

E

a.

X

W

z

W

oD

Q

Z • W

O

_ J

0 ,11

X •

U

Z

L, 0

_ J ffJ

• 0

L Z

o

_O

m

I

r-

I-

t

<

0

u

o

w

U

m

m

00

• m

e_

m

177

Page 184: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

!

Io

I

o

I

I

o

8:

u

N

X

u

Z

m

N

w

_ u

_ 4J

4

IC

E --

I"

O

,(

U

w

E _

E _

<

Z

C

I

lg

u

g,,..,,,,.

_ IIII

q

::°°o°:°oo0000 000

*,*..***,.

Q

W

0

T

m

ul

0

0

0

0

0

i s I I le _ ]ONVH3

178

0

o

IU

I

,,I,H 0 1 ] II _14133W|

0

a

C °

o

-- II

0

-- III

o

-- p.

.1"

o

o

_s

o

o

w

_B

Page 185: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

l

I

iln

IIO

I

j.

Jr

o

!

!

N

U)

0

J

.J

q[

lu

i-

a.

I.

I-

E

0

!-

IC

<

7,u

J

E

w

E

E

o

u

<

m

z

I

N

U

N

X

u

Z

N

m

N

W

0

(..)

o

In

W

a6

<

"r

-)

I

E

I

w

E

0

0

_ W

0 _

I,- w

u

< I

o

L,. J

o

I

X _

U

Z

I, 0

< 0

L Z

X

m

M_

oo m

W --_ U

.lq

• 0

• m 0

I * -- I

bJ " _" * °

• . (J _1 I U W

_ _ Z _ * Z

0 J -- IL mr Z _.

0 0 Z U) *-" -- U_

w Q_

<

ZO N _0

o_Zw_Z

179

x

I

j-

r

U

I

0

Q

W

8[

k.I

1-.

Z

W

4J

W

u

e[

h.

Page 186: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

1

m

i

o

I

o

N

o

w

o

.J

.J

w

!"

Q.

E

!"

<

u

.J

u

bJ

[

!-

0

U

Ld

Ut

m

4

(J

N

X

U

m

Z

N

m

fU

W

o0

w

Z

x

u

t,d

u

_ o

u _

w

L. -!

o _

b,.

w

L

W

Z

0

0

r-

I

E

!

I[

<

N

v

_oB_m_Oo--

mo_wmNom_N

I0.,,,..,0

.oos_QmmN_

°o oo,,,0,,,,,

F)

0

0

i i

o

ant/ In' ]0NVH3

180

0

0

O

0

I-HOI]N

o

o

i

31J|3]dS

0

o

I

o

o

o

:r

Page 187: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Vlm u

o _!

B

Q

¢

Q _

Z

d

t_

).

O

..J

.J

<

W

E

m

.1

,(

E

0

E

Z

<

0

U

.J

4

u

W

E

0

u

W

k*,

o

Q

Q

m

4

0

0

CJ

o

O

U_

bl

Z

).

Q

D

0

r"

F

fU

I

E

I

K

E

.4

Q

0

)..

U

n.

Q

).

,(

m,

i

r,

W

:J

W

Ul

m

.J

4(

O.

)..

o

Z

.J _n

.j

• o

o. _'

v)

4

M

o

M

W

Q

( Z m N 0

m

.4( 4i

.J , _,

4_ m _ m

0 *

•J 0 -- " 0 --

0 _ _ Z _

X )4

m , m

¢.- o

• I_ 4(

(j v_ u

m o ,(EL

U t_J 0 _ U

I*l b. _ Id

bJ D o I,d L*,I

Z _ Z

t.J 4_ .i 2) _)

*. 4[ t,,I _ I[

(J Z -- N O -- tJ

18!

Page 188: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

II

4[

4.)

i-

4[

X

u

sT

I-

s

o

M

_d

W

0 -J

.J u

u

W t,.

31:

Z

(O (J

Z 0

E --

O

.J

w

E

I •

ul U

x _

m

I

lr

nl

1

Z

I

C

W E

6 E

- O

Z _

I

v

_O_M_MOe_NOIMO

• .... ,,,,.,,,,,,,

lililllllllli

41

4l

kJ

_D

Z

4(

Z

(J

i-

'm

_D

kJ

_J

kJ

6.

U)

V_O00000000000000

.,.,.,,0,,,...,.,,

M _

I

i

0

0

0

0

|1 e / I • ' ]ONYH:)

0

0

o

0

J. HOI ]H _ I _1 3)dl

0

0

0

0

o

0

m

o

oJ

o

o

o

o "

o

W

m

182

Page 189: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

m

B

i

o

I

a

o

r_

o

m

o

.J

I..i

kJ

z

6.

<

E

<

o

2,E

E

<

0

U

J

W

X

• W

I

x

u

Z

Z

o

M

N

W

b

o

w

.J

u

).

u

o.

o

UI

o

m

I

p.

ar

N

I

t

i

i[

<

E

E

.4

ol

0

sJ

O

Q

Z W

0

U m

< a

U q

D

I Z

X <

k.

** Q

.J k_

4 0

a

.J

0

4[ Z _ _ N _ 0

Vl

0

A

4[ _ 4(

.I L N --

.I b- ,

_L | -- a

e0 • .J

** * _,_ _ w

,- (4

N

m

m •

4 J_

ill , 0

er

sJ bl Q _ lid

I _ an

o

td 4 Q Z O -- iv

183

_ w _

O ° _

M e

_0_0_

NU

N

Page 190: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M!

4O

I

Q

I

OI

o

I

t_

c:)

u

N m*...,, .... ,....,

|lJlll|lOIli|

u

o

W

i.

o

_ w

0 ..J

J u

u

w

a.

I"

z:

Q u

o

u

_l

t.-

z

w

w

eL ii0

x _

)

i

i

- o

)-

Q

_J

Z

U

w

u

_00000000000_0000

40000000000000_00

.,,,,,0,.,.,.,,.,

0

0

0

0

0

v¢)

?

i m : I I m ' ]ONVHO

184

0

0

I

I

IHO I ]H

0

o

0

o

0

0

01313]d5

0

Q

il

I

0

0

0

_d

z-

M

Page 191: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq OC

OI

3" (J

I N

o

, 7.4D

o

I

IV

o

rJ

'!"

I,-

o

US +71

IP _a

0 ..J

J (J

..J )-

W *-

IL

".,I[

E

I"

4[

.£ --

0

U

J

W

E

W

I

1"

!

E

<

O E

<

-- 0

Z U

.ll

i,,-

,,i[

Cl

0

Z W

0 :)

)- W

t,) (n

< m

Iv o

b.

t,. .J

o <

a.

,1(

ne _-

I Z

)¢ 4[

cJ

t,.

z

*. (.9

4

.J _n

9[ 0

In

4(

0

m'.4

0

J_a _ if)

(J _ 4'V

t_ Q

ne _ li

tn .J

n, :) ..J

kd *- 4( oe (q tU

• I,) ,i G _ 0 31[

.1[ Z _ lU _ 0

e.. I-- I-- S.) In X

I/i

,11

o

14

I+)

o

0 _ If)

.i Iv w oj le

4[ m o 4D

O. • _ II

0

_- j ,J

W Z -- Z

0 -I O. -- 42_ O. 1- _-

X X

N N

Oc ,< Oc

*" _ "E E

; U) • --.J 2, J"Z

'( 40 "4[ O,. _,, tr -- . <

185

O.

°

• 0 •

4[ m o m

" o-2-_J

Q _

w • I-- •

o

3<

< IC

II:

P1

M

o I

I_ I IlJ

0[ II _ ¢1:

w

_ ,j u

Page 192: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

ul

I

m

o

I

m

o

I

o

ul

.I

J

4{

W

N

E

0.

E

E

0

E

E

U

J

w

E

E

bl

L

x

lid

W

m

i

m

um

v

_m

m

Z

m

W

mm

0

W

.J

U

)-

U

0

0

IJ

m

L"

m

i

s

!

r"

|

E

E

&pT0

0

u

v

_oMMm_um_omm_mo

moo_oNt_o_m_maN_

i,....,,.,,,.***.

i iiilllilllll

_000000000000_000

MO0000000000OO000o*....;,*p,,,,,..

4[

a

's.

,I[

X

0

llJ

"Jr

(J

k.

61

LIJ

I.

U_

0

i

GI

o

0

0

0

0

0

0

lUl II1' ]ONVHO _.Htll ]lq

. 186

OI _11 3]Ill

o

o

0

¢)

lid

o

Iv

,a¢

m N

o

Iv

Page 193: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

g

p. <

0 u

o

,m

o

|

Q _

u

Z

p,.

¢u

m

¢u

o

.t

,J

<

z

m

IL

<

E

r

<

E

E

<

<

<

Z

W

E

g

W

L

x

w

o •

: oZ

0

w

U

U

*,. O

x

U

0

o

Q

m

L

I

E

!

m

<

E

z

.(

o

Q

m_

g

t*J

m

0

.J

.J

O.

tn

i-

X

U

tl.

Z

o. U)

,J m

< 0

8, Z

4

0

M

fq

0

N

kJ J

U

b.

_ I. < ig

IJ ,L ID W _

• Z 0 _

0

M

• mm..-||.M

" ::'2

_O_M _

X

; <

E

N

m * 0

f,J _ v

Z --

4 0 • is _ _ _ ,,.

187

4

0

If)

4 El • t,,

L li _ I,

• _d Z' -- "! Z

.J 0

0 • VD D- Z m

N u

N )t

m • ar

o I,..

• m •

m . _ i

W a_ n Z -- iV Z W

(J Z _ _ 0 0 _ 0

Page 194: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

u

_OMO_mBMDMOMaOMN

U oONWNO_NB__ON_

*O0000QOOOO_N_ li|lllli||l

q

x

o

Z

D--

N

)-

U)

_J

W

0 )-

J

..J

W 0

E

L

4[

E

i," _j

0 O

E

U

U

a,

ul

T _

U IL

,ql

.i-

ra

i-

W

• I

m £

I

•it r

q

0

(.*7

W

'I

u

_J

_J

a.

U)

boOOOOOOO_OoOOoO8

_O0_OQ_QOOOOOaO0

.,,.°...,,,,,.°,,

N

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Io

N

i

le + / le * 30NYH3 ,I, H01]II

188

0

0

3|JI33dS

0

0

J i,

o

N

!

0

o

_0

o

s

CS

N

8

o lid

o :8::

N

l"

O

18

O

Jr

Page 195: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

NI

toI

s

2

o

I

f

o

!

N

o

IA

),,,

O

,J

,41

w

E

IE

41

11"

41

I

ql

_(

u

.J

,(

U

l

W

E

O

u

w

I

91

u

u

Z

m

N

N

w

I-

o

m

W

.J

g

).

Q

D

o

4

Q

0

• t.

0 :"

t- W

U ta

4 m

I 0

b.

t,. .I

et 9[

Ik

,1[

I I-

1 Z

)< <

U

t,_

,m

Z

*. 0

4[ 0

_. Z

W

Q

M

LII •

ID II_ -- I*I

.J IlL O _ lib

,,J . • 5D _.

II I * t-.,

II. l I-

.,2

_ 0

0 .J _ • R. LF _

_ll z I

Ill * l

_O I

189

X

I

I,-

I

I J,

N

I

O

w

I

t*t

ILl

W

LI

14

M

.A N _ L

.C_ m

• J 0

I J -- L I -- •

41

o

p_

a.

,C --

W 0 _ td

t_ • • l-

t_ • .J 0

Q . t- •

_ hi l

A_ Q I _ "! m

Z -- -- -- 0 0

CI _ 8. I --. _ --

IIt,. t_ t- • Z •

N t;)

X

N

I

I-

I

CJ

I

bJ

I

ttJ

w

u

w

Page 196: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

I

*n

i

_a

in

o

i

i

iu

o

)-

0

.I

.I

.I[

w

Z

Ic

L

.1[

C

E

E

E

II)

U

8[

w

E

E

o

U

- %N

• u

U m O _ W M m 2 O O _ _ m _ t _ _ m

i..0.0°...°°.0.1°

IIIIP|IIIIII|I

u

N

X

p..

,t

w

ds

o

co

,,J

u

o

0

Q

W

Q

I

I

n.

:o:o:oooo:ooo:o::O O OOOO _OO O

*........ .... ...*

Z

U

I"

-r

N

lid

"1,

(a

lib

la

W

L

o

o

!

0

0

0

0

0

I

I

i1# I Io ' |+NYHO LH0 I ]H

190

0

0

0

0

0

0

_llJlO]dl

0

0

0

o

II

o

Jr

N

o

_d

cl Id

o Z

N N

I-

c)

Page 197: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

iII1

I

o

I

Z

o

f

¢w

Q

In

w

m J

),. u

o >-

.I U

,.I

E

G.

11-

!-

0 o

N

U

.J

4[

U

W

l-

s-

O

Z

).

O

4:

Q

N

q[ I

m E

I

4:

u

-r

j-

4"

N

lq

N .

O

O

Z bJ

0

E

< m

m o

-- j

G.

t

x •

.u

z

6. Z

4[

0

III

m

O ,

-- ,4

W _ a

u_ D

II_ ,d •

u • _ II - 0 Z

_[

o

Pl

PI

• • 0 --

o Ill _ I,I

4( il ID * I--

• • II

_) o o kd #O• • .J

kJ ° - _ 4)z...J t.J :)

•.. U W W i[

.a; b.J Z .Z _ ".Jr

-,J O

O .J -- G. 0. _" -

o O Z tn to )'.- •

X X

N N

*.. o• Iq

14

18 , 0 ,', m

kJ 0 -- kJ U

W _ I _ m.J

I a, | -- I

in ,I 0 t-

(._ I .J _ I i.)

U Z _ N N 0 _ CJ

191

o

v_

,,4

4[* -- 4[

4 ID "* I- II

m _ II

Ul o W Jr 0

• .J 0 •

** I.) 1,i _: * I*l

Q, ..J -- (L IC --

o 0 Z U_ )- Z v)

Iu cJ

x

4( g[

I'1 4

lr

._ ¢.J,

o M

kd ,in

e[ "o

k,. 80 td

_) ID kJ WUl • .J

-- Z

u .j U

0 4[ IL _ I[ v- -- •

N In

Page 198: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

N

v7

ID

0

I

Ot

0

I

na

o

in

).

0

.J

.J

.1{

w

IE

g:

B.

E

O

E

I-

<

O

J

£

a:

W

X

W

W

<

m

Z

ne

<

U

N

w

o

o

o

.J

u

).

u

t.

.E

o

o

o

O

m

t

r-

2

£

I

r

0

I-

tl

Q

W

0

Z

X

{J

r-

Z

-!

_J

_J

w

In

%u

m.,.,. ...... *°.* ......... ° .......

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0 o

oo 8

000

x

o

II=III*IONYH3 J. Hel 3H 31_l:)]dS

192

0

o

o

m

o

o

m

m

ID

4:)

__ 0

_r

:

w

E

Page 199: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

N

j.

i

II

o

Q

o

o

O

..J

.d

_,j L.

m, Q

E

o _

• Q

I" Q

_ Q

,ii

t-

Z

I-

x _

w

m

d

N

I

E

0

E

W _

m _

-- 0

U

-r

_0

m

N

i-

I/I

_J

I-

o

o •

i-

o •

o Q

a

_-. Z

O

W "

0

m

I

1<

Q

m

0

.1

Z

Z

• o

X

M

N

u

< 0

Z

4 ZO U

0

4d

E

w

m

o

_J

.J

<

G.

)-

Z

o

Q O

Z

4[

o

Pl

_)

(J _ N

b. * m

w ,,

0 )- 4( Z *- g_

ka

)*

I(

W

v)

m

O

.J

..J

,4

4.

14

4[

(J

2

*. cD

U_

o

¢) O

N Z

N X

N

)_ O l-

IeS

m O l0

U _ _ N

Q 4 10 a

W _m. IL • -- kJ

| | I -- (- |

t,- U) • .,I • ("

Z _ k. •

W r_ '* i- • W

(j [ .,J _ e Uu

W vl _ O Z IV _ W

NUt

193

o

Ii.

iii

m

J

.J

u.

8 _

14

N

E

_m ,w$ u

b. ° 0 bJ

.J • ..J _.-

..;

J

G.

u_

0

w

o u

W

u

u)

0

z

¢) 9(

Page 200: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

MIQOImQ

mQ!N

0

0

Id

N

L

E

O

E

E

9[

uJ

Z

Ig

IL

X

LI

I

Em

IJ

11

U

I

m

N

W

Z

Z

W

>" 0

bl

_ 3

0 _

a m

II.

Q

Q

0

IO

Im

!

N

!

E

I

a

Z

m

Q

u

_O_Imaa_O_NI_D_DSB

moo NMNNNNNNN_NO_N

Oo,o,._.°J,oo,°°oo°.°o.

oOOOO_OOOQ_OOOD_OQOOOO

q

bOOOO_OO_OOOO_OOOO_O_O

_O_O_OOOOOOOOO_OOO_O

o,,,_,°,o,°°°_oo°°o_°°°

' 0

@

@

0

0

@

08

0

0

0

@00

0

I 0 IN

O d_

lu0/ll' |0NVH_ _H|| |fl Ol _l|3|dll

O n

lid

o

al),

Iq

o

o

Iq

n_

o

o

N

o

W

Page 201: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

4_

i

O

D

S

I

D

o

I

m

o

o

0

.J

.J

W

E

I

eL

E

Z

4

0

E

t

I"

ee

_J

x

(J

Z

m

m

f_J

u_

w

z w

o

.,.1 • m

_. Q 4

• eL

E I,-

S

0 b m

0 .'J _

,t 0

_ Z

Vl

W

E

a. 0

X _

g

r"

N

i

I"

i

n.

m r

- 0

Z U,

0

Iq

iq

A

o

w

16.

:) W

Vl, .I

O *-

_j • Ci N 0 0

4[ Z O iV lU

O[ I- Z • _J I.-

I/)

W

a

W

W

m

O

.J

.J

G.

),.

4.)

k.

O

O O

Z

• 4

o o

Iq P_

vI ^

4:) cs ,

W *-, _ 0 g

• • 40 gOL_

,,..I _ e •

r* I.,," I,,- *

a. _ ::) ,.J

195

u

4d

V_

m

O

.,4

,,J

O.

v_

)-

oa

N

N

m

E

U

m 0.-,

U _ _ _'1

b. ° gO

II[ I[ _ |

W _ i_ 4)

),. _l -J •

Z

• 0 4( -- _ II_ L

_. O I* • Z t- O_

I

I-

4

r

tJ

m

_d

e-

Z

W

b,J

eC

b.

Page 202: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

_d

UI .J

.J U

E Q

m

el.

E

E U

o

E --

E

41

u

u

w

r

E

0

IJ

N

• t

I E

!

a,

I N

• v

_ I 0 M _ M _ m _ t

eQOQOa_OI_

J

4

vl

bJ

0

Z

0

ul

b.

I,l

Ii1

IL

:_::°:_:°:o o.,...°,.°.

m

0

0

0

0

0

0

¢1

I

ii I I / i I * II 0H IIIH 3 J, HGI 3H 31.410"lllli

o

o

i

196

II

0 °

o

Q

m

o

o

o

41

I

I

t-

Page 203: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N1,1I

I

N

0

a_

.,[

0

N

X

¢.$

'r

)*

m

N

W

Ul

W

)-

O >"

.I u

.J

• t.

E o

L

T-

O o

E --

E

.1

U

n,

W

E

o

IJ

_j N

Ul t

.I( I

_D !-

I

e,

Z 1-

4[

O

Z

O

N

,4

e_

L_

N

O

)-

a(

er

I

X

4

WD

M

4

m_ W

bU W'_; 0_

Z_

N

£

u

u

_ w

197

Page 204: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

m

Pq

t

@4

¢)

I

_r

o

i

nJ

D

)-

0

,.J

-I

4

bJ

N

d[

n

IC

Z

<

Q

IC

!"

9(

0

u

w

E

E

0

w

m

Z

E _

• u

_ I I t I I @ I I ),

"1"

M

m

rJ

W

r_

,L •

0

o

o L,J

rU 0

Z

Z

U) (.,)

Ld

J ;u

>- o

u _

: °

w

m

o

o

I

I

I"

....... ,... ..... .

(

o

¢)

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

ill I / I I * ".iON yH _

198

0

LHOI)IH

0

3J Jl :)'ads

0

o

0 °

o

.1"

o

o

- :

- :

- :

-

o

r-

i

kJ

1"

Page 205: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t

m

N

M

!

o

I

j.

o

I

o

t.A

J

W

n,.

I"

I"

t_

E

.I

u

E

w

E

,r

O

U

Z

$

u

-r

N

i-

t.

.E

fIJ

Ln

w

>.

u

t.

o

o

'4

I-

4[

a

O

t-

OC

k_

0

iv

I

x

-x

m

iv)

Z:

v_ CJ

U Iq _ L

199

Page 206: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

z

I

N

o

I

j.

o

i

nJ

o

U)

o.J

.J

<

W

E

E

D.

.1(

w-

E

<

_.D

r

£

<

o

u

J

E

£

o

u

z

< u

g,°.,,..,°

,oooN_m_mm Ililll|

4

X

CJ

N

Z

W

0

Z

Z

U) ¢.J

W

u

w

o _

u

w

a.

cJ

!i

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

!

la t / $ ° ' 39NVH: J. HO I 1H 3 I 3 I :]dS

2OO

O

o

Page 207: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

N

r,

,1}'

i

I

,z

o

I

N

o

iS:

N

W

I.-

stl

U

-I"

N

W

¢.,

$,.

•0 "0

•,z w

UI _ W

r,A .J 41[ m

o _ _-M _- J

j _ J

,c. a.

w

L X <U

r

E _Z

E "* "J _

E _ O

< a. Z

<

,J

U

gl

IC

g

0

U

I

N

:p

I

tn n,

m i

_n

m. o

W_ _ u

Z

_wZO0

fq

o

_[

• OO

O. _ II

M

0 '--

_ T

.J 0 _ _

o 0 • )" tn

• ,, U

X.

,( 0¢

¢:) $-

iq

o m

4[

w 0 _ U

_ w

w

<0 'I[ O. -- m _ **

201

Page 208: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

I

I

I11

J

o

l

jr

o

I

o

)-

0

.J

.J

b_

I-

Q.

q(

0

I-

E

o

,i(

(J

(J

ar

bJ

I"

s-

O

_J

kJ

tn

q(

I

E W

_omMmasD_

m i,,,.,.,,,

_ Illill;

4

11:

0

I

a

(¢1

.J

U

0

0

0

r

i

I

'I

E

I--

O

a

z

,4

z

u

O

w

u

:o:oo::oo:0 O0 O0

0

GI

0

I

0

0

, Iin

ie I t I • ' ".IONVH3 11.1111 _IN

202

0

Io

6

31Jl3]dl

0

0

o

0 °m

o

o

o

o

o

o

m

i

Page 209: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IO

I

m

in

ID

i

o

!

:r

¢)

0

N

o

K

1.)

u

N

.l-

r-

N

N

w

t--

o 4(

0

_ 12

Z w

_ m:

w _

_ j 4( M

_ u • O

j _ .d

. ._ _

U

E uz

O o t. (.9

E • o

4( IL z

7,4(

.I

U

,r

O

O

o

s-

t

_j 4(

I/I I

-!

_ ¢¢

Z I,-

<

O

_ 4

W _ CD

b. - IO

:_ w o

ul J •

_: _ .J

W _ • Q_ W

_ • . °

Q

_0_

oOZ_

4[ E

O t'-

. 0

w 0 _ N_

b. IB OI LmJ

:_ o bJ o W

Wr_ ° t-.

203

Page 210: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I'

!

/q

f_

_r

I

o

B

o

I

o

W

).

0

.J

.J

4

kd

!"

OC

6.

I-

IC

<

O

,4

E

E

4[

,K

U

J

,K

U

W

E

E

O

U

E

v

_ONI_NOJM_QOU

*O000001DB_ lilllillil

4

W

° ;o

D

o

o kd

0

Z

4[

"Jr

UP

Id

u

_ 0

qJ

ul

IL

U

0

0

_O00000aO000"O0000

8OO000000000000DO

...,.,,......,...

i i i i

0o

0

i

II e I I III * "aONV H 3

204

Io

I

J. Hel 1H 31.11133dS

O

0

O

O

@

@

@

o

o

IU

o

m

W

N 4.

L

o E

o

o

3-

Page 211: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

• Ir|

lq

r,+

=P

I

Ill

Q

!

.11"

o

I

Ai

o

U

,4

u

U

N

Z

01

,11"

r4

N

W

I_ .J

>- U

0 P,.

,.,,,I U

.J

_ a

E --

it

,11

E

Ic u

Z: --

E

u

.J

w

E

IC

0

<

I

!

ill Z

III m

4[ *'--'

m J

U_

Z Z

I--

,4

O

Z

0

I-

U

k,

12

!

X

a

OC

kJ

m

0

,.J

L

Z

_ 0

L Z

<

o

o

w_

_W

Q_

m

205

Page 212: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

4

0k

lid

I

¢)

¢)

I

o

I

_U

¢3

_n

Ii.

0

.J

.J

4[

tdd

s-

a.

E

E

<

%

E

E

,<

<

u

U

E

ul

E

E

0

w

4[

m

Ig

)-

o_

x

(J

N

l-

ID

na

igl

ed

L.J

I"

4D )'*

0 •

Q

O

0 W

(U r.9

Z

4[

X

Ue, U

W

.J

ul

; o

u

w

L

Q

0

IC

!

I

>

I

u

8,*.*,.,.,,*.0.;.

illllltllll

voOoooOooo_ooOoOo

_ooooooooo_oooooo

0

0

0

0

0

0

ii e I $ I' _ONVH3

206

Io

O

O

LHO _ ]1_ 3 | _11 3]d6

O

O

O

O

IID

AI

!

O

O

O

o

m

o

o

.:r

al

s,-

t-

o

as

Page 213: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0[

m

X

(J

(D

Po

N

)-

0

.J (J

n,

¢L

E U

4[

£ --

E

<

0

U

.J

W

IC

E

O

U

0

0

[

I

W <

m

I

-i

- E

z t-

e-

L

o

o <n_d

z

o

Ill b-

_J 4J

.J q(

U

z.

D

I

x

Q

w

m

0

..J

..,i

<

Iz,.

Z

M

,,J

Q. z

m

o

lq

M

,,,4

o

rJ w

D kd

_'1 .J

K D

U ,4 O 0 _ IVo4[ Z W

O: I- • r- Z

_q

4

X

N

;... O

me.

p4

D 4(

_J td O

Q 4[ • 'w

W O * _"

b 4[ _,d 4( N

t,d _ 12 Z _ O

U Z _ _ N O

< O 4[ _. ([ --

4_ 0 1- Ul I-* 4[ Z

207

4[

0

I+I

4[ 0 0

III I,

141) ° 41

0 + II

.J _ ,J

• 4[ _ Z 0"

0 0 -- w IL

N L

31

m

I[ <

I- 0

,l[ Wl

t"

i * 0

=) 4(

O ,el • 1+

_U k. m

O,.., I# • .J

ld 0 * I.-

• . 4 bd 8: Pl

_J • 12 Z _ O

Z _ _ _ O

N m

X

N

it"

!"

_J

I

D

_J

O

_d

8[

ILl

<

Page 214: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

iq

m

tD

I

o

I

I

o

).

0

.J

w

E

a.

z

E

<

E

E

o

Q

w

o

z

J

u

E

w

E

E

o

u

W

_n

<

m

x

u

,r

)..

m

N

w

Q

-- O

Z

_ U

W

g ,-X

u _

_. "I

u

II.

IJ

N_

m

#

CJ

z

0

I"

Z

1[-

<

u)

0

u

i

u

B.,.,,.*..

...o.,..,.

0

0

0

0

0

I I

0

if) Q _1

N In r_

I J s

im = I I'_ ' ]ONtI'H:) LHO I ]H OI Ji 3]d$

208

o

o

o

w

i-

ra

Page 215: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W

!

{0

ID

i

M

T

o

)-

O

..J

.J

.1[

w

E

E

6.

4[

E

E

o

E

E

O

ul

n,

o

3

X

U

E

E

E

0

U

m,

U

U

N

:Z

m

nl

W

W

J

L.

0

U

In

I

u_

I

U

Z

o

l:

z

E

ul

O

(J

O

Z

O

N

4

0:

b.

t*.

a

O[

I

X

<

O

1.1

_4

• (3

J N N

,.a O • ,w

4( _ i0

a [,- 1

VJ _ o I_J

O

L*I * * I--

•.- I .J

L. (J IQ i,.) W at

.J _ ..J I. Z G. n.

< O 4J _ u1

LL (a

tn

1(

N

< a-

o I-.

4

IC

vt

• o 40

IJ/ o --

,1( • .m O {2

D 41 L,J _ w

I_ I .J • I--

• t..- o bJ

u

D _n

t N

O l

A _

* 0 m

• . =)

W O _ U

,l[ , "lD O

b. ql

D o I_ W

0 • P I_

L t_ O Z -- W

2O9

Page 216: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

¢0

I

M

o

i

I

o

m

).

0

...I

_1

E

N

Q.

E

!-

<

0

0

w

v

n.

0

-l-

u

w

E

E

0

u

z

IE

N

u

u

.I-

llJ

I--

•Z 4[

Cl

o ;0

: w

Z

Z

W

U --

W

: °

u

w

L

u

m

!

I

u"

Z

o

£

z

i*

_(

In

0

u

Iv

u

•.. o I_ • IO .11" I le) r_ in _ o _ i_ In N

m o LIO o o _ o o o 01 ol o m Oi o _ o• , ..... . . . . . . , , . ,

.oo °?? ......• I ! t I i I I i I I I !

:Z

"4

0 I

III

o

ie I I t • ' ]ONVH3

210

0

o

0

IHOl IM 3 i._! =|d|

0

0

0

0

o

0

0 --

0

0

0

o

II

o

o

!-

Page 217: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m m

# M

m

m

I "*

M

°IM

m

!

N

D

U

N

¢U

W

a,

O '1[

W N

../ Ul )-

_J

../ <

_/ u m

,1: >.

m _ t_

o. ,_ o,I[

E _

4[ _ h

O X

E U

4[ •

_ O

O

O

21

-r

J

U

E

11: in

o -

u i

in

i

z

Q

I:

w _

I It

m

- o

z i.,

a

w

W

U_

,m

0

..J

.J

O.

tn

LI,

Z

,,J _

'1( O

L Z

(J

° ;

o

ill O

i_, I I-" il

.,I

P J • .J

• kJ Z " • 0

.J -- 8, Z a. *. _"

¢) 0 Z U_ -- U) (J _-.

u

v x

o im

I: !"

P_

N _

m * 0 m

W b. _ W

W :) O t_ W

I-.. &o _1 J I-

#;J Q m'm" W

tU ,_ i_ Z 0 w b,l

< 0 4( IS. -- e,-

211

o

#@

I"1

_r$ M 0

•J N w .

.8 , I; • 0

m, m _ m ¢-

I

P .I _ J e

4s _ Z -- Z O

0 .J -- _,. _" _. *. Z

0 0 Z Ut I'- Ul (J

m (.)

x

< [

cD p

t,-

I*)

,_q -o

o m

bJ o _ (J

b. _ t*J

C[ II _ ([

:) O _1 W

N Z

,.J O

Z N N N U

O 4[ L -- I1_ _[

O P _ • t" b.

It) U)

Page 218: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

j*!

!

14

0

!

14

I

o

I-

o

Ul u'l

0

w

.J

u

E :,-

u

I

L *.

E

,r

< --

O

E

_ U

O Q

o

Q o

W --

X

Q

Z

U

" 2,w

E

E _

O --

u I

|

O

E

W _

_ X

<

m t*

m

- O

U N

• v

_ou_oMRmo_ms_ommom_mB_

mo_mm_Mo_ooa_2ow_

i.,,....°.,,,,.°.,,.°,.

• ooo_ ooooooo_ooo_m

_ Itllllll

X

m

¢,.

O

W

Z

4[

Z

w

u

N

m

:oooo:o::o:oo°oo:°ooo:ooooo o o oo0oo 0ooo o

***********************

0

00

0

00

0

Io

00

0

0

0

0

0

0

00

lee I le* ]@NVH3 LHqD I ]H :)1 _li _]WS

212

00

o

W

Page 219: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

q

tn 4

r-

t0 W

°i_J

N

c_ X

(.)

b'i

n_

i%1

_d

m

>.

O

,.J

,J

(

td

ec

4.

I-

E

(

O

,t

E

Z

4[

kd

n.

O

0"-

O

"r

.J

(J

a:

£

E

Q

_J

bJ

in

.(

la

8-"

in

W

I-

i.

O

O

.5

UJ

W

.J

U

o

,,,9

(J

°O

Q

I

in

I

U

5.

O

!"

Z

Z:

(

tn

O

U

j,.

O

Q

Z k_

0 >

E

L

Q <

L

I 7

X _

q,J

Z

4 _

,,J _

• a

O. 1[

o

m

• 1

Q

4( Z N _ IV

)- tJ ;'- 4[

:oZ

X

4C •

E

P)

(J _1

a O

Q 4 0 _ .

Z k.

td G; . )-

4[ (J _ bJ N

_J .8 G_ . _ 5. 40

4[ 0 4( Z n, O. --

213

4

m

•J _ N

.J 0

4. _,- a

oi

4(

O

Iq

O

O

N

"

,.J

;5_ 8: ul

N_

X )<

4 _q

E . l-

f,.) ,vt u

gl . 0 m

:) 4 _ :)

Q < 0 • ,o

kJ k. _ as . lid

rid : _ O t*l W

t_J • • .I O-h. _ Z

kJ 8 _ * Z _ ka

4( O • Z _ nr ,(

_d U_

0

,*4

o

• _ 4[

if) _ o

4 • -- - •

- -. --

)., ,._ • _ .J

0 _J -- I_. Z ,. n. IS.

0 0 _ 14 _ (J I.* V*

an

x

u

4 Cw

-- Z

°_

Page 220: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

III

i

tit

t'-

o

P_

o

I

o X

u

Z

N

p..

oo

o.J U)

J

w

-- c.)

A,

8. ,-

91 o

E o

E

E

E _.J

o

o

0 o

w

X

K

0

Z

-I

,IE

U

i-

Z _

0 --

I.I !

!

u

z

o

E

w _

_ Z

m E

<

-- 0

Z u

0

0

Z

u

)-

Z

_D

w

3

u

v.

_J

L

U)

w

• II

:**::::**::**::*****:*:O0 O_ _0 00000 0

....,,,,,,,,. .... *.,,**

0

0

0

0

0

00000

%0

00

00

0o

0

Ifl o

I I

io_ / le ' ]OHYH_ J. HOI 3H OI JI ::)3dli

214

0

o

In

o

o

7,

Id

M

Page 221: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

II!

I

f_

_O

I

M

o

I

M

I

N

O

m'

).

o

,J

id

T

Q.

4(

T:

ic

o

1"

_+

Q

I

o

2

o

x

a.

w

!.

c

o

u

u

x

¢J

N

.r

P1

_u

In

bd

..J

¢J

I

I;i

N

I

N

Z

0

E

Z

1[:

<

In

0

U

Q

Z

0

m

4[

14.

Q

4

x

0

_J

b.

sd

• m

0

.I

L

m

b_

Z

8

0

L Z

U_

m ¸

m

M

M

I

N

m

W *. < N a

Q • O 0 -,

4 Z N *._

k. ..* 4 I. II

m

o

k_

td

m

0

..4

.J

L

In

z4[

O

Z

US

O

O 0

_K

; <)- o

s-

M

; °

'q[ _ . 0

i,d b. • 41 --

'." • Q _ :E 0 • O+

IJ 5e M ,* _ _ li

k,+ l) P" ),- I_ I,) _" •

215

o

O

.) O • _)

(l - m

L 0- I

o m ,.j

O

)=. I .d _)

.d - _ N O m

N

X

Z

R O

::) _ (

Q < T 0

e)'* If) ..J •

• _* k.

W O I- *

16 • 12 _ O • Z

N _0

o

M

o

0. • $-- _ •

• ,.J

_ * I-- -

_* Z 0 * _ Z

X X

M el

_ •

aQ Z"

Page 222: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

J_

$

J

m

o

I

N

o

0

-I

-D

W

h-

E

<

o

4(

E

1-

<

<

u

u

w

E

E

o

u

Z

E

,q

M

u

3[

m

w

p-

f.

_ 4

o I-

o <

0

o

o _d

Z

<

Z

Ld

_ Z

u _

ul

L. 3

o _

u

w

Q.

u

m

40

x

Z

I

Q

M

p--

V

_OOMW_m_

m,.,.,0,,,

Illlil

o o°, ...... ..

0

0

o

!

0

0

0

0

,I , I I

o o o

I I I

lllll # Ill' 30NVI't3 IHgl 3t5 31 ill 3"adll

216

0

)-

¢)

,2"

o

Page 223: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

fq I[

•1" •

•1" (J

6

O_ )'-

°Io

J

ru

u

3:

m

N

L.

Q

o

gl

_ u

°.I,J

E

N

L

E

I- u

4I r •

I"

U

I"

0

m

w Q

u3

< i

m x

Z

I

- tn

Z Q

4[

Q

Z

0

,1(

a

Iz

I

x

J o

< m

jD

_ M

_u W

_W Z

J _0_

L_u

W

U o

m

Jm

_._ W

217

Page 224: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t_

I

m

m

i

N

o

i

o"I

N

c:;

.r

t-

110

o

N

bJ

I.-

t.

. <o

N 4D

Z

I

u

o,,,,,,°°,,°°,°,°

.O_WO_MmOB_m_D

illlJ||l|

b_OOOOOOOOOOaO000

80000000000000000

*._ .... °,°.....°,

N _

0o

o

w

0 )-

J u

nl

E o

a,

!"

r U

£ --

!"

4(

,J

M

_J

C

U

m m

-- X

Z Z

<

X

_69

W

N

M

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

I

0

0

0

0

I

o

IU

I

iI ! [ J I ' ]ONVHO

218

0

_.HO I 3tt

0

/

I

o

m

I

OIJlO]dl

0

0

!

IU

o

ml

o

IdD

,at:

__ ...r

I-

Page 225: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N I

Ill qll

0t

,- <I

o

I

Z

o

w

)l

i.

Ul .J

O )-

.J U

.J

.c

E

E _

G.

E

E U

+ :E --

!-

<

U

,.J

,1(

u

w

0

i.+i

,It 1011

i

D X

Z Z •

4[

O

O

N

I,*

4(

.IC

I+.

k,.

D

E

I

x

N

,(

o W

).

• [ m ;-

G. •

W ", ;I,- -1

I_1 Z 'I

.J .J _ O -

.I 0 ..I IL -- --

4[ O O m I[ Z

16 N O

4n

.(

w N_

U O'

I

ffl

D

W _ < W

ULG Z

ZO _

219

Page 226: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

!

M

.1"

I

a

It1

o

I

:r

o

I

N

o

I h

• u

i°°,0,,,o,,I,,,0.

_ I I I I I I , I I I I t

q

_J

M

3:

t.-

W

fU

lp u

0 )-

.J

Ill o

N

I

L

E

E U

o __

E

0

<

U

ul

E

!"

O

iI

b,,I iI

• I

I

Z

!

-- W

Z 0

w

°0

N

Z

W

&.

vO00_O00000000000

_0000000000_00000

.o,.,00..,0,.,oo.

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

i • _ / I • ' 30NYHO

0

0

0

k

i illl

LNel IH Ol.tl _ldl

0

0

!

0

.1"

o

N

o

N

o

I

o

o

N

220

Page 227: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

t

Ol

0

I

0

I

IU

o

m

N

,I[

¢,)

N

¢)

N

Z

@-

qO

N

@-

e.

o

0

¢I

N

Id

m

)- U

0 >"

.I U

.J

i1[. 4-

E 0

N

eL

E

E U

Q 0

°E _

E

0

W

U

E

W

I:

E

0

U

m

m x

Z

i

Z o

4

I-

C_

0

i!,

b.

12

.IC

a,

i

X

O

4

N

• ,o

I*1 m

,._ li. o

.j >. ". Ul

• [ I- II W

• m •

" o': .

•. f,J * W 0 0

• W I • Z in

,J ..J 0 v _ X

,J 0 ,J _ -- • Z N

4[ m 0 Z Z M

IL N U

X

E

W

I

I I I

Z

U_Q IO

ZO_m

_Nm

m

221

Page 228: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

!

o

o

i

us

o

o

i

M

i

N

o

III

).

0

.J

.J

Ld

4_

Q.

,4

r

I"

Q

i(

1"

!"

0

w

0[

o

3

I-

O

"Jr

.I

4.)

E

IC

E

O

I,d

4[

m

m

w

Z

I,-

GO

¢,,.

O

W

O

o

O W

Z

Z

Ul u

kJ

u. _r

Ld

2

-- o

w

o

Ld

kJ

OC

:o_o_oo oooo

i,..0...,,

__0

0

0

0

II1 tll* ]ONYNO ,LH01"IM

222

0

I

o

o

Olll3]dl

0

0

o

¢)

o

o

Id

lC

I,--

Page 229: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

k'l n.

o ,4

i:

u

oI

I

N

o X

X

w

o

w

o

J

w

w u

U

a. h

L

Ic

o

2,E _

0 --

W _

0

0

Z

.J

U

ul

E

E

0

m

4 4

V') Vl

..J _ 0

.J

4( gO OO

O. el |

0

w

,ii w I, z

.J o J _ ¢" J'_

Ul

X

N

K

<

E

N

m

W W

• O

w

E K

Z

O

• ZO_

223

Page 230: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

m

0

I

in

_r

Q

i

N

o

p.

0

,.J

.J

w

E

0.

ar

E

E

U

n-

w

E

E

O

Ig

$-

w

p.-

8

o

o

u

t

o

I¢1

D

z

z

u

z

w

:z

u

u

w

u

J,,.0°10°l

Illll

• ..... ,,_oo

0

o

0

0

0

I Io o

o ooN

I I

I1'1 =.t II * ]ONYH3 IH@ ! ]H

224

0

=l.tl:]dS

,Io

0

0o

o

I=1

m

o

m

),.

Page 231: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M n_

o

u

I M

° ;I

I

o _

u

w

l-

m.

o

in

w

m J

0 _-

..J u

.J

w o

E o

,v

jr,

(

E

T: cJ

< •

E --

I"

0

U

w

E

E

0

U

bA

m

aid

W

Z

- hi

4[

Q

X

0

m

E

Q

a,

I

x

oo

oo

j _w

WW

LW _w

bJ

U

:)

U_

0

Q

,( Z _ 0

0 q[ t. --

225

Page 232: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

ep

i

Q

o

!

in

i%1

o

!

.t.

o

i

N

o

>.

O

.J

.J

,4

W

]C

g[

G.

9(

!-

!"

,4

!"

T

,4

O

u

.I

,4

u

E

uJ

Ic

E

0

u

W

m

m

m.

u

w

m-

r..

oJ_

w

.J

u

)-

u

o

tll

Z

W

I

v

_o_om_msu

E, ........

Jill!

:ooo o:o. :OOO O O

Q

W

0

X

O

w

3

u

u

w

0.

1

o

o

0

0

n , I I

0

o

o

O

,m

I

lie e I I1• '.IONVH0

0

IO

o

O

N

I

J. HO I |H

0

0

Io

o

O

m

1

OlJlO|d|

O:

o

o

o

r'-

o

j,

o

226

Page 233: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Itl

l

O

IO

I

In

In

o

I

.1"

o

I

N '

0

>.

0

.J

.J

w

E

8[

IL

<

I-

_D

E

E

<

0

(/I

.1

U

w

£

£

o

U

w

j-

0

: w-- O

Z

Z

W

..J )-

U Z

U

W

u

w

u

w

L

I"

!

w

z

W

N

u

_ommDz_NMa

g,,,.,,,,.

N_WNW_

*ll$i

..,.,...,,

0

O

O

C)

¢3

O

I , I ,

10 t I I u ' ]ONYH3

O

227

o

o

N

s

J. HOi ]M 3 I _ I 3_d8

v

O

a

o

i_ ¸

i

o

o

o

am

40

ci

I-

o

I0

o

in

c}

Jr

o

IU

o

i.

dl

w

E

N

I"

Page 234: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

m

I

o

I

,1P

o

o

um

>.

o

.J

.J

w

I[

N

E

iL

E

E

0

E

E

O

U

n,

W

E

r

O

4J

g

N

M

X

U

m

Z

I--

lID

w

)-

o

o

uI

w

-1

lp,

o

M

U

"Q

IL

Z

P

Ul

!

Z

_J

q[

O

O

Z W

O

< m

m, O

_ j

O <

8.

I Z

N ,t

u

m

,z.

t, o

• O

L Z

o

P7

o

bJ

k.

I[

Q

_ Z N _

, N

<

II) W

•J N L

.I . >.

" .'2O -

0 _ -- 8* --

N X

_ M

N _ N

m • o N al

)- I_ e -_ 0 ).-

Z _ 441 _ O v (J

_, o _- U) (J _- Z Z k.

_)

228

Page 235: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

|

lit

In

L_

b'1

0

I

8

0

i

0

01

)-

0

.J

.J

t_

r

a_

O.

I"

_D

£

r

,(

(D

u

.J

d(

I..I

,r

,r

0

U

II

ill

q(

m

li

N

41

I_l

N

i-

ll II

: >-91

0

ni 0

Z

<

Z

in I.i

il

u

>- 0"

u

w

a_

: °LI.

U

W

G.

U

W

Z

.-j

w

z

E

N

u

i,,.,,.,o,,,,,,,,

llllll

400000_0000_000_0

**,.,.*,. ....... *

N

I o

I

A

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

wo

o

Q

o

N

I

illl/lil* IONVHI l-HO I IN Ol&133dS

229

0

0

0ad

0

m

0

t.

.i

td

N

t-

Page 236: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

m 4

t0 U

1(3

ot

!

o x

u

5,

k-

rJ

N

m

)-

o

.A

.J

4[

w

1"

8.

£

r

,1(

£

£

o

(J

E

w

1-

0

W

o

o

o

o

N

m

hJ

0.

4(

!

_J

Z

I,d

0:

4

)..

4[

Q

.O

• W

K

[.. w

< m

A, o

o <

o.

I

x •

u

Z

< 0

_4

O0

*.

QO

Z_

0

Q

_0_

_oz_

E

M

m

Z

_ Z 0 _ _ _

230

Q w

, )* 0

0 .J _ 6. _ *- Z

N

X N

N N

E E

m o m

z _ •

ZO_

O_Z_

Page 237: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

=r!m¢)J

T_P

0

J

¢D

LQ

>-

0

..J

4(

W

E

Iv

O.

£

!"

!"

0

m

..¢

q(

u

U

W

[

E

0

u

w

_3

Z

4

"1"

w

_p _..

U X

u N

W

L. "T

w

IL

momm_o_o

.OQO_N_m_

_ Illll

0 O0 O0

• • • ° • , * * o 0

_0_0_0_00

FI

i

0

0

0

¢)

|_ $ I | • ' ]ONVHO J. H9 I ]l'l

231

0

13

_l_JlO3dS

'0a

o

o

f,.

o

o

Page 238: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

j.

m

Q

i

To

I

o

U)

)-

0

.J

.J

<

w

1"

0.

lr

!"

0

!"

£

q[

,i(

t.)

J

u

r,.

w

r

I"

o

u

bJ

U)

<

m

z

E

,(

(J

Ut

(J

N

'!"

I"

tn

O)

¢)

_m

U)

W

.m

0

O

U_

_J

.J

U

)--

U

9..

0

U

i,mJ

Z

W

mr

.I[

I-

,I[

a

Z

0

9[

0

n,

I

X

0 0 Q

WWW

JJJ

W

L_U

X

N

E

M

U

oW -- U

Uw

W

_W W

Z

W

I

Z

z ....

z__

x ....

Z__

232

Page 239: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

k'l

4

D

o

I

CO

O

8

:r

ttJ

o

)..

O

.J

..J

W

l-

n,

.1

Z:

Q

!*

E

<

u

J

w

E

E

0

u

W

IIg

K

N

U

N

<

f,-

W

I-

0

Z

<

"r

_ L,_

W

C,J

U _

W

_. i11

w

o.

o

N

Z

t_J

O:

N

u

• .... .....

bOOmOO0000

_0000000_0

0

(

0

0

0

0

0

I , IQ 0

!

i| _ I I m * 30NVH_ J. HO 1314 OldlO3d9

233

o,

o

-

-

-

o

- _

- _,

o

o

z.

8

w

E

Page 240: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

9[

(J

X

(=)

.it

o

Jr

)-

,1

°o

w

..J

0 _"

• Q.

w :E

E

G.

o o

N

E

£

U

U

b-

W

£

I"

0

w J'b

a

W

z

- W

z I

7

bJ

(D

Z

Z

SJ

w

21

W

b,.

u

w

Q.

u

mozm_s_mW

• .... °°...

-ooo_o_mz

ii1|

m

: o.:.°.oo.:o o o D o "1:) o

_°__o_:_o:

0

0

@

@

@

,Io

o

I

lie :1 / II • ' ]@NVH3

Io

o

I

J. HOI ]H 31_ll:]dS

234

O

Io

o

Iq

!

0

o

o

N

Page 241: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

N

U

° ;I

Q

I

N

U

Z

P

in

)-

o

.J

.J

,g

_J

l-

a.

1[:

!-

,i(

o

r

!-

I(

o

u

.J

u

[

£

0

W

4[

m

Z

0

LO

W

o 0

_J

.J

u

U

oo

u

N

Z

0

D

t

x

J

_o _

i_ Z

e • p Z

._

I"

_4 U

__ Z

°

Ul

235

Page 242: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

,Jr

!

so

J

o

J

.!.

II

i

o

e6lm

O

.if

.if

,4

lid

II

L

l:

E

4

O

1"

E

o

J

4

U

n,

E

Ig

0

U

I

0

0

IJ

W

a

o

Q

o

Ln

k,/

.J

U

>.

W

o

o

.i

'o

N

1-

41

a

IM

O

I t

4

X

U

Z

O

0iI

4J

tii

k.

.i

O

Id

I.

P

I

U

mOO W B M O I _ _

OseJ_0eeee

" O O m O M I I _ _

J|lll

q

_OIIIIDOQI

dOOOOO_lll

iiD*01*l*'_

wo_omo_om

n

0

0

nm

o

II . I

0

0

, !"0

II

eie,_ie'|0NVN0

236

T n

O

I I i

0

,0 ,

g

0

(,,,

o

o

i.

,in:

tJ

E

o,-.

Page 243: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

./, K

m 4(

m

Qo

8

° ;0

O X

Z

I

IR

).

O

.J

.I

9[

tu

E

<

E

I"

O

2,E

E

O

U

J

I1[

W

E

IC

O

U

In

t_

)..

o

o

m

W

.J

(J

),.

(J

L

_,J

9[

q[

O

O

Z _J

K

4 m

Q •

L

U

Z

,tl O

L Z

O o

M

• o o *

_. all • I

_._ _ Q 0 Z _ _ Z

I_. _ 4[ e. 8. II_ -- I[ 8. ,.-

_' J-" (J tlJ I- • t-- UI X

: tn

4/)

0

• o • i._

IO _ 0 k_

e[ (10 * _ t-

" :o

• ; .;• lld Z -- Z -m

• J 0

O .J -- IL _: 4.

0 O • In _.- _ Z

X

o I-

_q ,q

I[:

• _ Am

tu o _ (J

(;It • .J • J.

b. I"

r: * I*- W

w .j =) o *,J• . 4[ W .a_ 115

_'_ Z w O N

Z _ _ N 0 O _ fJ

O I- Ut t- 9[ 2[ Z w b.

237

Page 244: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

j.

!

I

o

I

Z

o

J

o

_m

o

w

1-

a.

G.

E

E

<

2,E

E

Q

U

.1

U

E

1"

0

m m

4 u

ooMmoN_lO_OmmBo0

|..,.l.,.I,.,,..,

,oooooo__Oo_lo

4

1l

U

,.r

!

IP

M

W

i.

o

w

u

Gm

N

0

W

O

Z

:°°°°°°°°::°:::ooooooo0oo o oo

WO--_O_O_OO_O_o_OO

,T

"mr

W

W

0

0

(

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

illl D I | I ' ]ONVH: LHG 1314 31_1133d8

0

0o

o

8d

o

It#

i.

L

238

Page 245: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

j.

I

r_

M

I

r..

o

J

z

o

i

N

o

K

qf

u

t6J

t.

o

o

o

w

.J

O )"

..J

E Q

a.

E

< •

0 0

£

U

n,

w

5"

0

w m

sn (tJ

m

W

Z

bJ

Z E

t-

Z

0

A,

b.

t_

N

¢)

a.

I

x

o14

M

.w 0

bJ _ 0

.J 8. w r4

.J )- _ *9( t" * Q

M •

• , rJ , _r W

aw kJ Z _ Z

.J 0 .J " -- n, Q.

4( 0 0 Z Z ;.- (n

4. rd (J

ut

X

N

4( 4[

4[

IC

M

U

• • 0 _ 8D

td in C_ -_ _ tJ

_'_ ° * h- • I*J

D: ..J .J : It,

W *. 4( bJ tJJ _ *

::) N U_

239

Page 246: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

I

a

I

o

I

i

n_

o

E N

m •

4 u

I,,.o,* ........ 0,

_ _lllil|llltllt

4

W

am

Q

W

0

Z

:::°:::::::°:::::o o.,,°0.,°,,,,,,,,,

N

0

).

0

.J

.J

w

Ic

I[

L

£

¢D

s*

£

(_

)-

U)

n,

E

E

o

u

m

_J

w

G.

3:

In

l-

_J

lil

Itl

taJ

Z

0o

0

0

0

0

0

0

I u

cl

!

;i • = ,, I • * 3@HVH3

240

0

Io

N

IxO ! ]H

0

0

0

3|_1133dS

0

Jo

0

0

m

!

m

o

o

o

o

: w

Page 247: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

I

Om

i

lid

o

I

jr

o

N

o

I[

(J

N

U

_C

)-

oJ

tU

t.

o ¢(

: °N 0

Z W

0 >

W _

t_ J < m

,j _ J

G. x •U

E _

E uz

o o

< L Z

o _

u

u

E

W

E

0

¢.)

Z

X

N

• E

o P

E

U

o D

a

J

m

_ z

N

_ u

m• 0

0 _ U

m

(3 o ).. W

j _ u

• 0 Z _ 0 _ bJ

Z _ _ _ 0 0 U

241

4[

0

Iq

.J

I _J

in CD

o bJ

(j • .,I

j .J

N eL

X

0

o m

_m

_m _

_o W

Z

N_

Page 248: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

s

!

qal

ill

!

r..

o

i

,Y

Q

J

N

o

0

.I

_J

E

O.

4(

E

E

q(

<

E

E

<

0

4(

--1

W

E

E

O

U

Ig

.0

W

W

U

(J

o

D

81

N

bJ

Z

I,d

n.

%v

mOm_O_M_OWSa_W_

8.,,,0,,.,0.,,,0,

lJilill

d

-- N

0

Z

_ 0

0

0

O

0

0

0

0

0

I

8e o / J,' ' 3ONVH:

0

242

0

J. H9 I ]M

0

31.:il 3]ldS

0

0

c)

o

°N

)-

0

m

Page 249: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

.11"

!

am

i

r _

I

IT

0

!

N

m

LO

0

J

L_

T

Q.

E

!"

!"

I"

U

.J

U

m

E

E

0

&.)

W

U_

m

i-

I.)

I-

41

0

Q q[

: oN

Z

Q

u E

: °Q ,iI

X

U

0

O

N

W

1'

E

12

w

a[

w

m

o

..i

.J

8.

u)

,aK

U

Z

_ m

_ 0

L •

IJ

0 0

M

o o

• Z_O_N

•J M

..I

• m

_. i

Q

t.,, .j

_. _J bJ

-4 Q

o .J -- 11.

X

N

m <

°

(J bl 0

W _ E, .

)'-' @7 • .._ oZ

e

W _m t2 Z _ 0 N °(J Z _ -- I_ 0 0 --

G'l

243

.I[

• m * D

..J • >* .

EL I l

am ,1' I k_

• 0 • .J

bJ *

_. I.) W • i,_ 8[

• kJ • "Jr Z v

•-J 0

0 J -- G. -- L m

0 0 Z &_ Z U) $-

N

N N

I- o _.

!" !"

m • o m

0 • ' _ 0 O

_, n* I _ ).- n,

_ b. Z

• a _[ _L _' -- *.* -- Z q[

KJ (M

Page 250: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

$

M

m

i

in

m

!

m

o

i

n_

c_

_A

),.

0

..J

.J

_J

I[

K

L

I"

!"

J

W

Ig

W

L

x

w

IC

m

¥-

m

w

Z

w

h,

$-

, a

X

4[

Z

6,J

bJ

U _

bl

_ Z

ul

G.

U

0

q.)

!

a

I

E

I

X

0

m

u

ill

vO00oo

_ooooo

.00..0

@

O 1

I J

o o

(U en

i i

ilem I |e' ]GNVH3 J. HOl 3H 31 &l 3]dS

O

o

o

o

_D

c_

O

bJ

N

Page 251: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t

Iq

ID

I

QI

D

o

i

m

O

B

,1(

r,J

N

,,e

(J

,it

)-

r-

if)

(u

_J

o

j.

4q tn

)- bJ

O -J

.J U

.j )-

4 tJ

E

N O

8.

O

"or

E

Q

<

_J

.J

w

g

w

L o

x (J

wru

i

o

tl

i

K

i

W x

(n t_

4(

m E

<

V)

. 0

Z u

Z

O

<

oIq

,(

nEM

t,.

b. ,j ,,4

N -J

, U_ II

X 0 •o W

_j ° I-

.J .J

*- m W E

8 4[ Z

_ O --

.J _ O -- L K

4[ I[ Z UI _'-

IL. L

o

m

M

_ _L _

• 0

_ . Z_ _

_O_*_

._._--[

_OZ_'Z_

xm

• D

4[ _ D D

bJ I_ _ _J Id &J

_[. , ,m r* 4[ O

D O bJ W D W

Z

8[ .J D _ n, O

(J • 0 Z _ bJ _ G_

4( Z O _ -- u Z O u

tn

ul

245

Page 252: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

$q

!

jr

I

0

II

i

I

0

I

N

0 Vl

Ib

kD

I

I

f

gI

N

IV

Ul ut

0 ..I

.J U

_j )-

• tJ

W *.

I o

IL

M

q[

I:

1"

0

Q

.I

I:

kJ

L 0

)4 I.)

W

N

t

0

m

I

Ill

I

X

W

I I:

9[

; °W

,Ig

bl

0

I ±li

Z

Z

0

w

"I

IJ

Q.

v

miloim_|Iiio_B

I,°°.**Io,oooB

liII0ill|

q

:_°_°__°°o o oo°, .... °.° .... •

0

0

Q

0

0

0

I i

o

|I I 11 •* )ONVH3

246

o

0

_HOI]H

0

OlJiI]il

0

0

Io

0

II

i

0

o

o

_E '_N

0

m

k PJ

0

0

0

0

0

0

i.

b_

I:

m

Page 253: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

X

u

I-

w

)- w

0 ...I

.I u

• f.J

I[ 4

I.

I:

0 u

• o

!" a

E

¢.g

u

I,d

i.

N

W

Q. 0

X O

kll

N

!

o

I

E

i

u) V)

I !"

U)

- 0

Z u

Q

a

z' w

0 >

-- I[

• a

O: O

6

Q •

'_" ;I

x •

4_

Z

J _

• O

I. Z

o

M

• o

4

W 0

m

O W

R J

W b • II W •

tJ _I Q 0 Z

'1[ • 0 liI *..*

I,. _ < - -- Ik IC

U_

o

• _ *

x

I •

4

0 ^

• _01

_ _o_

247

X X

" 7r '!"

I * -- ¢_ I

W _'- I _ " W

I I I[

W _ *. _J

),- _ e 0 .J o-

4. 4 t_ * I[

k. 0 t- I U) Z I-- _.

ItS Ul

Page 254: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

I

In

I

m

I

m

Q

I

0

4

U

X

N

N

u

I0.* .... °°**.,*.**0.**0

*O000000000QQQO000 _QOg

• I II|IN_

0

.I

.J

W

E

a.

E

E

0

E

E

CD

ul

E

m.

w

L

x

w

o

ul

,.J

(J

0

o

o

0

u

I

o

I

I[

#

i:

(.p

_0_00000000_0_0_000_000

_0000000000000000_0_000

*.*°.*.0..**°.**0..°..*

D

(D

;F

CD !

N

W

J

w

oqo#OIO(OIOI

odc_olOIc(OI

¢

i

0

0

0

I Io

I

i_+ / Io' ]eNYH3 +H@I'I#

i i +

0

o

o

I

OI +l133dli

o

@ °

o

__ 111

,IP

O

0

__ If)

P)

- _

_ __

Q

- _

o

248

Page 255: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Z

b

Q (J

7O

m

0

$

N

4.)

Z

)..

lm

N

lp

0

.J

.J

4[

h)

][:

Q.

<

I"

I:

q[

_[

E

I[:

<

o

)-

4[

u

.J

4[

w

m,

w

x

w

w

j..

o

o

0

m

w

u

Q

o

0

u

o

*,I

!

m

|

X

tn

]c

4[

(n

o

U

<

Q

0

Z 0a

0

M E

u tn

,< m

a* 0

b.

t_ .J

g

i Z

_J

Z

d _

M _

< 0

m

x

Q _

Iq

•,_ rj

o Q

k. _D _J

=) o *_ w

,m I-. _i

(J _ _' Z O -- bJ

Ul

..J

.J

_n Jl

N

o i

(J

i*1

_t

° o

Lit D

4[ • 1_

|

• ,.J

Z N _ _

Q

W

..1 0

0 .J --

0 0 Z

7 *1.

1,7

u

M

m • D

u kJ _

U_ • ,JN

w r_ 0 ,-

o I]: ,J

N

249

o

Iq

1,1

.j . ,m

G. II

e .j

0

III u

M X

_ N

!" I"

U A

Page 256: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

W

I

I

I

p_

I

N

o

f_

0

IE

L

E

Z

<

O

E

E

O

O

W

E

O

2

Z

.I

W

E

Z

O

I

N

¢.1

N

X

X

I

N

W

t,.

L

O

O

w

J

u

)-

u

mm

0

U

0

::o:o-oo:::::--:o-o-:::0 0000 O0 0000

Z i i , i i i

1

i

- J 0

0

0

Od

8

I

llllll '|IINVH_ LHOIIM

Io

0

o

I

+lilOilll

2_0

0

0

Ill

I

I

0

111

0

110

.I"

411

o

k_

N

Page 257: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

O

I

O

r.

m

i

b'l

I

i

m

m

i

N

o

4

(J

im

(J

N

.r

i-

s

O

m

N

N

4[

D.

Z

0

.(

Q

3-

41

a[

I

x

O O

td W

> )

,,r ar

W W

U) in

m m

O O

.,J ,.J

J J

< (

G. 4.

_n _n

_ U

Z Z

IL Z _ r

x

M 4

, # , m ,

Z

251

D

M

d b. •

4[ I." * ID

IL -- If

B W •

O .l •

,. (,,/) . n. _1

• w ::[ _ Z

..I O _ --

O .J -- -- 0[ L

O O Z Z *- -In

N

E

4

N

Nm

o

pl

m

O _ i*i

.,J , s )-

41 IP * '1.*

• .I 0

om

lJJ _ t,.. •

a,, (.,i) I.J gg

O Z 47 _- Z

m

)< )

I[ I"

m

_J ^ IlJ

m 0 _ 40

(j LJ -- IM _J

_ CL

t- _ .J O *'-

Z _ _ Z

*. 4 8[

W _ _ -- 2[ tu

(J Z O _ _ (J

II 0 4[ _ n_ -- •

o )- Z )- Z b.

in In

Page 258: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

p.

l)

?g_

!

Jr

o

i

D

I N

N •

4

W _ON_DM_mO

m I,, 0_._1++

oOONMDomoa

4 4 tl_ON

; )lIM"

4

W

lb]

Z

N

w

$..

.: <<

a

-- 0

Z

Z

ul o

u

>- 0

u M

Ul

0 U

Q m

U

W

a.

0

kOOOOoOOOO

aOooOoOOOO

.,....,,.,

WO_O_OmOO

_M_m_moN

P

0

0

0

0

o

0

O

c)

18

I

N

<

I-

m

0

I

i | I I I • * "I@NVH3

252

1NO I 31'1 01 _113]dli

0

Page 259: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

O

t

r",

o

e.t

i

a

e.i

cl

)

D

i

ed

o

0

),.

0

.J

4

L,.J

E

n,,

O.

e[

!"

It:

CD

I1:

E

0

O'-

,.J

9[

U

s,

W

I"

0

m

I

m

,t

i-

j-

0-

I-

CD

0

0

0

,U)

_J

,.J

)-

U

U

.

0

In

m

!

N

O-

R

u

_oomo_No_m

60_O_BBa

a0elJ01te

Jl

4

41

a

W

0

Z

f,J

0N

W

i

IL

_OoO000ooo

mOOQOOOO00

e*eteeeoee

WOm_O_O_O0

E _MBO_

m

I I nl

0

0

i

o

0

i i f ul i

0

i i i i | ii II i i I I i i i

• 0

• ,D

I

lee/|e'JONVHO IHOI|H O/JlO]ld|

0

c_

C °

o

- :

o

L

253

Page 260: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I0

!

o

m

I

m

w

0

,.J

.J

,1(

w

I-

I[

a.

!"

o

1-

I-

o

9[

u

..I

9(

IC

w

r

i*

0

w

r_

o

i

Jr

Q

I

o

U)

Z

ii

k'!

W

I-

u)

w

J

u

)-

u

o

4[

ID

I

N

),.

0

0

Z

0

m

k..

k.N

Q

m

I

X

W

OQ

W

L _ Z

W WW

_o .

w

K

m

• I

]C

,,,4 U

O m

W _ _1 U

,1[ '_ Q

k. _ * W W

W •

I/I ..I-

Ic o I- • [,- u_ _.

m

254

Page 261: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

I

N

I

m

0

I

:r

o

i

(u

o

(J

.1,.

i,-

in

N

ru

ut

b_

Ui .J

).- u

0 >-

.j o

J

dE

!"

n

E U

l._ Cl

E --

E

<

E

E

0

W

m m

i

N

2 i,,-

pt

0

I,m,I

0

Z

"r

w

21

u

b.

(J

w

n

Ut

I

u

_oNmmo_Qm

mo_WBmmWoo

• 0 0 0

4 I

bOO0000000

_000000000

.,,,,.,,.,

0

0

0

0

,I0

ii w t # 10 ' ]@NVH_

255

f3

J. H913H 31Jl3ldl

0

11

o

o

II

o

r-

Q

M

o

N

II

o

i.

dE

Ill

r

N

j..

Page 262: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq I[

N

°t

i

D _

Z

l

,.J

.J

w

E

a,

o.

<

£

r

I-

I"

(o

)-

b,)

(_

.J

<

r.)

a:

w

E

£

o

o

w

<

m

U)

w

.J

)..

u

.c

Io

I

N

I,,,,

Q

0

)..

(J

<

b.

M

o

)-

i

W

1,1 J

^ •

o * ' •

• J _ • , )- U)

• • I0 m I,- W

(n _J o o • N

• J • • 0 .J

td _- - • I •

i. (J n- W W * 0 tD

.K W _ • • • • O)

.J j (3 v

.J 0 -J -- rr O. O. -- • (_

U

tn

:1<

m

* ¢) m

• -- 3

W 0 -- _)

_J

• ,w (3

CO * bJ

• .J )-

Z

.J _ _J

tU *- _( _J r,- N

(J _1 r_ Z _ (3 N I_1

• • (3 N 0 (J

in

256

Page 263: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

a,

N

,(

_J

x

u

T

I--

¢:1

111

t.I

I--

u)

w

tO .J

)- U

0 _-

.J u

.J

E o

a.

<

E

E _

E _

E

o

-1

E

ul

E

E

O

u

td

(n

< 9[

m Q

!

N

-- <

Z I.-

u

mom_m_Ww

o**,00.*,*

<

Q

_000000000

_OO0000000

0<

T

(J

¢&

w

u

u

W

a.

m

0

0

0

Io

0

0

0

il0.0 I I I ' 30NVH3

257

J.H 0 ! ",I H

c)

31all:3dS

o

o

o

o

o

o

.G

bJ

l-

m

i-

Page 264: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I0 8[ar

o

!

N

U

Z

o

r,,J

.J

L_

N

m-

<

I0

r-

E

Q

<

U

.J

N

U

u

E

E

0

¢_

o •

oQ Q

Z

0

,J _

U m

U _

: °o

_ m

x

o _

_ w

D

J _ w L

• m ° _ W

_ J

_W Z--2 Z_

JO_N_ X

• OOZ_Z D

m

r

^ u

u _

• • ._ o

k. II * _J

II[ I" _ 8[

• .J I-

X

rl . I-* t_l

_ Q Z _ k W

i[ Z -- _ 0 0 i.)

258

Page 265: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

or,

I

N

i

m

0

!

8"

0

I

0

)-

.J u

.J

< 6.

E o

G.

E

E U

<

E _

<

U

M

(J

iv

La

Z

E

0

U

_J

< <

m j

I

N

• _-

a,

(J

0-m

w

t--

Q

o

o W

Z

<

"i"

¢n u

¢d

U

w

2

u

16.

w

|

u

moNM_pmNa

< o N_

4

bOOOOOOOOO

_OOOOOOOOO

° ....... , •

E _ S

.

0

0

0

0

I

o

I

ill I t | u ' ]0NVH0

259

0

I

Q

N

I

J_H0 I ]14

,, I

ID

Iq

I

0 I.li! 0]dll

O

,I

o

ar

I

¢)

¢:)

ID

o k_

m 1[N

I-*

D

o

Page 266: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m a[

i m

N

8" U

Ot _"

0 )"

! tit

0

I

N

U

Z

N

W

_ J

-1 q,J

4:

wEN

m _

G.

,4

E

I- U

<

° :

E

W

q(

u

,.J

<

u

8[

bJ

lr

Z:

0

U

W

III

m m

I

N

Z P"

bJ

L.

o

0

0

E

b.

k.N ¸

o

n,

I

x

<

o

p)

o

tJJ tit

-I .m )- .

4( * )-. _D

• it W

t. U _ • W

JR W w Z Z

,.J ..I 0

,J O J -- _ -- G.

4[ 0 0 Z _" Z _

x

< W

s.

M

, ¢) _ m

4.) Ik

Z

o ,.,

O_ O _- Z _ _- Z L_

26O

Page 267: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IO

I

II1

nl

j.

I

m

?.1"

I

Q

Ol

<

U

U

N

Z

m

/v

_a

m

),.

o >-

..J u

.J

< ..

.41

IC --

E _

,11

° :

E

<

<

w

E

E

o

w

In

9[ • '

m CO

I

N

. _[

_r I--

_J

r.

<o

G

0

o W

Z

w

U

o

w

3

u

w

W

u

o,,**0,,,,

:o:::°°°oo..',.,..°.,

WQ_Q_Q_QQ

O

O

<3

O

f_

O

le+III*]gNVH:

261

0

I

Q

iHO I 3H 3 I J I 3]dS

I

o

I

o

C °

c)

Q

-- r _

o

-- ID

o

o

i,.

w

I,"

1-

Page 268: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t0 a,

fn

N

I N

0t

o ¢,.,

t (7)

B

0

I

N,

X

3,-

O

.J

<

t6J

E

ft.

<

E

!"

,(

O

g-

w.

4[

(J

N

(J

0[

bJ

O

4.)

m

h

)-

O

O

kJ

_- t6.

(J b.

,. r_

n,

X

(J

<

Q

WBo

JOe

W

_W w'_Z

x

< E

0

E

M

A U

o . m m

U _L

_ M Z

E _ U

W L < E W

U4D Z3 W

_ _0 _

_O_Z_Z _

262

Page 269: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

0

I

m

?a-

o

I

ed

o X

t.J

-r

i-*

Fq

AJ

u_

w

0 >-

.J u

•1[ i.

1" o

N

G.

<

I"

I" ¢J

r

<

U

(J

n-

liJ

I"

I"

O

(J

W

In

m OD

I

N

Z w

v

_oom_moo_

mOO_O_oWOS

i*,**.**,*

0

W

0

Z

,(

Z

u

f,-

Z

o

3

u

u

w

G.

::::°ooo:ooooo o

• , , . , • , , . .

0

0

0

0

1o

In

I

Ell t I I • * 'J ON YH 3

263

J. HO I ]M

O

IO

CD

|

3 I ,11 :]dli

0

Io

In

i

o

D

o

c_

Id

IC

N

Page 270: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Io ,I(

11,1

..-,. u

o ;i

i

o x

u

z

),.

w

,.I u

-I

.c

w :E

E

lb.

4(

I"

sr U

,,(

'-+ :; -E

<

-I

<

U

W

E

O

U

m

i

N

-- <

L*J

ra-

P.,

Q

Z

0

<

I1:

o

i

X

^

o bJ

.J O.

.J _ . )- •

• ° gO

.J • 0

Q

6- U _ W

_ W _ Z 21

IL _ (J

In

X

° <I-

M

+,,,+ 1.1

. 0 M

< .,,,, =3

W • m U

I,*. lid + l+,J

g[ I _ m

Z

r.J • i- w

.J =) (.,)

bJ 4. < W _"

-- 4(

in

2_

Page 271: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

E

4(

(j •

<

X

_J

N

I"

),.

nJ

hJ

W

)-

w

u

mo_a_2Qom

8,**,*,,,*

'

.,,,,,,,,.

0

0

..J

.J

9[

w

r

a.

E

I"

q[

E

IC

<

0

U

U

1[

W

!-

0

W

_1

¢J

U

o

in

I.)

W

W

0

0

0

0

0

f_o

?

0

le_/le']ONVH3 LHOl ]N

265

01_133dg

o bJ

N

Page 272: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

er

t

L_ ¢1

rU

o :t

I

N

"IV

N

o

3-

0

.I

4(

w

E

E

G.

E

0

E

E

u

_J

IC

W

E

E

0

U

m

Z

uJ

U

L

0

z

0

S<

n,

N

0

ev

i

x

¢{

II

M

M

A

O kd

G. -- ¢J

X

'4

!1"

1'1

^ U

, 0 m

u 0 -- fJ'

_ 0 W W

_ o I'- W

IZ o _ Z _ t..- b.

:) m U)

In

266

Page 273: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

N

I

m

I

0

I

N

0

L4

).

O

.J

.J

4[

bJ

!"

K

A.

Z:

!-

4[

!-

I:

,1I

u

.1

U

C

w

E

O

U

q[

I

I[

m

9[

u

I-

<

I-

(A

W

I-

o

u

ql

I

I

N

Ill

i-

N

u

I,*..,*,,0

4

0

w

o

Z

3:

U

Z

W

3

U

b.

O

W

O.

U)

_OOIOOOO'OO

aOOOOOOOOO

.,,,,..,.,

O

O

O

o

¢_

4_

o

i I I I I I * 3ONVH3

26"I

0

IaD

!

31_113|dl

Q

O' o

o

Q

O

o

- :

o

o

_ M

o

_ N

O

o

N

Page 274: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M mi m

t N

° ;I

o

I

N

0 M

m

Z

lg

M

w

0 >"

,,J

4 h

E

E m

E U

<

o

,(

E

E

0

u

J

u

0c

w

Ic

E

o

cJ

w

< 4

I •

I

N

- q

Z 8-

GJ

Z

0

E

b.

b.

N

0

).

E

I

X

q

o

m

M

_OW

Wom

_W _Zl

d _0--_ _

L_U

N

E

M •

". I[

Iq

^ U

w 0 _ I_ U

qJ -- _ •

4I • _s l- 0

b. • • b- hi

O _ 8' W

i ,,J _

• • _ O -- w (k,lm

Io, Q LE • _ gE -- •

268

Page 275: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W

I

40

N

z

I

m

N

o

.1.

o

i

N

O

)-

O

.J

.J

4(

_J

0_

o.

,(

E

!-

O

E

E

.4[

O

tn

,(

u

.J

u

n_

w

1-

o

W

Ul

m

g

N

(J

)-

4(

)-

tn

¥

U

:[

o

t-

W

O

o

m

Ld

.J

U

O

U

O

k'l

J

N

N

o

mom_MM_mo

0...*.****

4

4[

Q

W

(9

Z

Z

(J

o

W

,T

u

w

0.

_OOOOoOOOo

_ooooooooo

.°,,...,,°.

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

J

|| ! I II II * ]0NVH3

269

0

1HO I 3H 0 I.'Jl_))dS

0

0

m

o

o

o

o

O

o

o

8

I-

N

j..

Page 276: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

z u

z

o

i

u

z

o

)-

0

.J

.J

t_

[

N

'4

I"

]:

£

I"

"(

Ul

(J

N

(J

E

w

£

E

o

4[

M

|

N

A

w_

1°_

WQB

_W wZ_'

x

N

2, '-4(

!"

^ IJ

4[ -- D

U _ _ L

• • 'u ).- 0

I*. gO * )'* W

0 _ e 1,1

270

Page 277: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

;q 4_

! N

4(

14

i N

0_ ;'-4[

°I_r

o

!

o

u

'1-

ru

o

Ul

-W

° :o

0 r_

0

Z

,1(

.r

U

kJ

car) .J I-

)- U :£

0 )" U)

..J U

..J _J

4[ *- 2

E Q _

IL U

W

• L

E _

E U

4I *

E _

E

<

0

U

-I

U

n.

W

r

0

U

W

< ,1[

m I

I

N

. <

Z t.-

I

u

'_ 0 lr

O O O

• O N

_ '

o o

_" O

m

i

Io

In

i

Ic}

O

m

I

go e / |e* ]@NVH3 2HO I )H O I J133dS

271

0o

• 0

¢)

0

m

0

- :8

_ In lg

- _

o

- :

o

o

Page 278: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M m.

m

pi!

2 U

o ;I

;I-

o

t

N

-I-

N

o

N

)-

0

.J

.J

_J

lr

£

,11

£

o

u

u

w

I"

E

Q

u

LJ

O

0

¢)

Q

<

0

Z

0

<

E

_t

I

X

J N_

o _ W

W -

_U W-E

_W ZX

_OOZ_Z_

<

, o

k. m

_) o w

U ,m ca Z _

I"

m

U

W

m-

z

w

<

b.

272

Page 279: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

U

m

? ;o

o X

z

m

N

N

W

L.

.c

o

o

(11

W

U) ..J

),- U

0 )"

.m,l u

J

,< t.

,c

1,"

a,

if" u

<

,f

o

&n

<

*.)

.J

9[

u

a:

w

E

I-

0

U

W

in

< <

m o

!

N

-- 4(

Z _-

Ill

la

_. 0 Ill

IF, 0 U)

- o r,,

'h 0 0

8 0 0

wo_i-

<

o

w

o

z

I , I 1o In

I I l

im:llm' ]gNyH: IHOI)N :1JI:]dS

273

0o

o

w

,r.

Page 280: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

In E

; N

m

u

I"

c_

I

u

Z

I-

_0

0l

N

o

M

4

o

_4

, N 0

• J N O.

.J • )- "l

• IO _-

$. U kd - OC

M o J -- o. - 8:

,I( 0 0 Z _ Z I,-

L -- U

X

o

IC

M

A U

4( 0 "w O

k. e0 W

o W W

Z

Q * _ W

w _ '4 W E

U 4m 0 Z w _,J

k, O 4t L _ _ ,4

274

Page 281: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

I

m

o

t

_r

o

J

0u

¢)

8[

UN

.r

N

o

N

U_

W

Ul ..L

u

0 )-

.J u

J

Ik

<

E

E U

_ 0

E --

<

U

J

<

U

W

E

E

0

U

w

(A

• 9[

m m

i

N

Z )**

u

o

9[ m

A 0 D

LU 0 0

E 0

)-

i[

)-

m-i

_J

0

Z

0

w

2[

(..)

b.

?,J

LiJ

a.

c3

T N'

!

|I|/|I']ONVH: LHO|]H

275

Io

!

:lJlg3dS

0

r-

i

o

m

o

L[

W

!"

t-

Page 282: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

14 g[N •

14

J* 4J

! m

N

O )"

* VJ

O

o M

X

m

o

,J

.J

E

4.

i-

¢_

I-

ir

o

u

J

u

w

E

E

0

(._

w

tn

m

o

0

0

o

uI

_J

./

u

u

(J

o

In

O

I

N

b..

N.

4C

O

0

le

),.

g

i

x

x

N

E

^ U

o m

_ Z

276

Page 283: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

o

I

f

o

I

N

Q

U_

0

_I

.I

,I(

w

Q.

<

E

,r

<

t_

E

I*

t_

u

,.J

u

0:

t,I

E

t-

O

(J

E

<

u

,(

X

u

.r

)-

N

o

r_

_J

_J

A ¸ 4(

ooQ

o° wZ

Z

u) u

w

u

u _

w

L. 'T

o u

ffl

u

N

v

'_ 0 W

0 I_J

,q

wooI"

I-

,I , I Io _ o

I ! I

ioslim* ]ONVH3 _HOI 3M 31AlO3dS

277

0

o

u

o

W

_do

r

o

M

o

Page 284: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m aT

nJ •

,? (J

oIS

0

!

IJ

-r

r,.J

,,J

tll

E

m_

L

E

E

O

E

E

0

,(

U

M

U

W

E

E

Q

W

W

I

8...

U3

W

6.

0

LJ

i

0

m

Q

I

N

I--

0

Z

0

0

)-

I

N

4[

O

M

A

, O

.I ° 5e

4( O

.I ow.J

O m

0- .J

_. 4J W nr jq

.at W Z _ O

-J -J O N N II

.8 o -_ _ O. IC h.

< o • • _ (- U

X

'4 g(

E

M

^ U

o l

W 0 _ lip (J

Id. m " Q W

n, / _ I IK

O W O Lde

0 t- w

ffl

278

Page 285: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

AI

,1"

!

01

o

!

B

o

I

N

o

4 v

_ON_NONM--

U aOB_l_omoD

1,10,0,l,',

4 4 I/I/liP

q

11I

u

Z

t,-

IIU

I#I

.i

>.

0 )-

.I

E Q

K --

L

E

Q o

E --

r

0

In

U

.J

E

W

E

r

0

U

Id

Ih

,ii 41

III II

I

N

-- <

II I-

4(

0-

el

kl

Z

TI.I

O

M

hJ

T

U

N

II.

I.}

hi

0.

I11

O

vOOOOOOOOO

_OOOOOOOOO

,,,,,.,..,

WO _O_O_OO

m

l'l Ic) l0

II O

I I

i|lllW ' ]9NYHO LHOI]H

279

0

0

0

31Jl_ldll

0

0

0

0

Io

I

Q

10

o

IB

O

.lr

t_

,ll

LJ

!"

I--

Page 286: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N a_

I N

r"

: °N

Ut

!

O

(.I

N

Z

i-

r.

)-

0

.J

.J

<

W

E

IK

a.

!"

• !"

,1[

0

i-

9(

0

I-

u)

,,(

U

qJ

E

W

E

I:

0

U

t,J

U)

,1[

I

w

i-.

L.

o

In

w

J

_J

t.

o

(J

I

I

N

I-.

el

0

I

0

N

<

l

er

I

X

,4

0

M

*vq

0

.J

<

m W

.,J

0

.J _ ..I L, -- _

_ Q U Z _-

L U

o

J

0

A

< I

n

L _ Z _

x x

I ,( I

P1

I • o I

W _ I I W

_ o W o W

zZ

W 0 - _ W

w

280

Page 287: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

1-

,1"

I

.I"

O

I

1"

Q

I

o

u

U moN_OamN_

_ ,0000_ Illilll

X

m

lg

N

0 )-

..J u

.J

¢[ **

E

a.

<

E

t- U

° :E --

£

<

0

U

,J

U

W

E

£

0

U

W m

I/I I

N

CD

l-.

- UI

Z Q

W

l-

I.

oC3

: w-- 0

Z

'I"

In u

w

.j _-

_r

W

]

u

lJ

W

L

In

P

::o:oooo::0 QO_O

,.*,,*°**,

0

ia _' / In * _IONYH3 _flO I 3M

281

0

0

0

I • i

3 I @ I 3]d,S

O

O

G

Io

o

o

- :

-- :

_ ._

-

-

13

0

I.I

Ir-

Page 288: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

j.

nJ

s

o

I

j-

o

I

N

o

0

.J

.J

w

E

Iz

8.

E

<

o

£

£

<

u

w

E

E

o

u

w

w

m

z

E

m

_J

X

u

z

m

.SLd

.g

o •

o Q

Z

0

m

Lid

J 4(

U _

U _

k Q

.I

0o

x

m

|

N

I

0

iJ

.A

L

Q

w

w

LI w

o o

14 M

Iq M

M

• o m 0

4[ _

o _ W

ill I.- _ .

I M p.

I W JI, ,R I_

• .J O •

*'J I[ N - _J I[

.J O -I _ IL i[ i, -- Z 4[

• O O • I_ )-- f.) • _ I-

lL _ U

VD

)4

N

°PI

I[

Iq

vD (j

N

• o m

Id o _ o

• , ._ Q

b. II W

:) 4i W Id

GI o I_ I*l

_. 4 Ld LE M

b, 0 • L • -- b 4

282

Page 289: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i=

N

U

N

I1[

I'*

l

u

_omm_Dw_gmmz_oN_

mo_N_loN_maooo_

0,,..,.,,..,.,,,,

ul

r_

I,-

O

.J

.J

bJ

2-

a.

Q.

q[

I1:

I:

,1[

O

4[

I=

][

_D

,(

(a

.J

,(

N

cJ

_J

]C

I"

O

u

W

m

n_

(/I

w

.J

LJ

)-

u

/.

¢_

t,a

o

o

4(

m

I

N

k-

O

_J

(D

Z

Z

U

w

u

w

G.

::::::::::°:,::::° D' O.,,..,..,,..,..,.

WO_O_O_QO_O_O_OO

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I

ill o / I • * 3ONVHO

0

O.

I 0

IHO I IN 3] ,,f | 3]dl

o

m

o

_J

o W

0

gO

283

Page 290: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

I

Oi

?o

0

)-

O

.J

,.J

,(

k_

E

K

iS.

4

E

4

Q

E

E

,(

0

U

.J

u

I[

ul

E

E

0

K

U

U

al

w

p.

,m

W

w

-I

u

o

N

U

o

o

M

m

I

N

I-

12

ZO

N

CC

b.

b.

C_

>.

a.

I

4[

o

, • o IV

< < .

Id I11 _ . k J

,J t. N o _ 4.

_l )- • • I >.

4[ I- m _ t,-

IL li II

U) _ O Ill kd 4'0 • • .J 0

W * •

6" (J - kd bJ II lit *

• W 2[ Z Z _ 0

_t

284

Page 291: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

t'4

j.

I

m

o:l-

o

!

_J

¢3

W

0 _"

u

_m

qt 0.

E o

O.

E

,r" U

I" --

E

0

<

U

,,,1

U

W

E

!"

O

W

g

I

N

Z I-

w

q.

N

m

i,,...°..,..,0.

4

4

VO000"O00000000000

_O0000000000QO'O00

.,...,,,,,0,**,*

I I+ I

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

O ll

ii i • / le * ]ONVHD

285

0

' ,IO

lItll )H OlJl+ldI

i i,i

II

ID

0

41

o

I

o

R/

IC

0

I

o

I

0

Jr

Jo

o

Page 292: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I0!lel

moI

z

o

I

_d

O

m

).

o

J

w

Ic

E

O.

E

E

E

E

U

U

w

E

E

o

U

W

m

E

U

x

u

Z

hi

o

cl

o

o

N

/Jl

w

..J

(J

)-

(J

8

o

o

U

o

o

,1(

m

!

N

I,m

4[

I"

Q

Z

0

N

0

)-

Q[

I

)4

0

M

A

J _N--

• • W

_ ZZw

LNU

X

N

• 8:

IC

P]

N

* 0 m

• "_ Gm

_. m * W

a, • _ a,

D O w W

U) • ..J

(2 • I-. W

286

Page 293: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

4(

LJ

t-

i-

U_

v

U

.r

0.-

W

m

m

W

m

w

.I

kJ 0

E Q

(I.

(

E

Z: (J

q( ,

(.9 Q

E _

,It

.I

IIg

W

E

£

O

W

I I

!

N

Z _'-

)..

4

W

0

Z

,1I

Z

u

W

3I

U

u

.i

u

<

_O_OOOOOOOOOOOOl_

....... .,°,.**.,*

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Ia

0

0

0

0

i w t i I • * "_9NVH:

287

IHOI]H

i i ,

Ol_13]dI

O

Q

¢)

I

¢)

*0

N

A:

O I

¢1

_r

Page 294: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I01

3*

I

m

?

nJ

o

u)

o.J

.J

w

I-

,I

q[

I-

E

E

<

0

U

u

w

£

£

0

U

K

,i[

U

w

o: o

Z

0

L*J

m 9[

U

,,,.. Q

K

I

!

N

<

O

t,I

>

n-

LiJ

Ul

m

0

.J

,J

.(

G.

US

u

i.

z

6- o

.I ffl

L z

r_

o ,

bJ _ 0

0 +

b. • I

me "_ I

oU • Q _ Z

_ Z _ _ Q N

b. -- '( a, 0. -- k.u_* )- _- _ Z

..

LII

Q

W

_WZZON

x

<

l-

P)

I • o

U _ o M

{j _ w

O ,4 _m

w _ o W

Z

(j m .j

W • O Z _ N

Z -- -- 0 0

< 0 ,l( g6 I -- I.

288

_o

O| m

!

X M

a, _[ i[

m • O m

Q < • _ GI

W Ib I * W

ZZ

• Q Z - 0 0 I W

O < IL I _ -- b <

o i- (4 )- _ • N k.

N

Page 295: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M 91

u

o I-

! u}

Q

0

m

U

Z

i

w

o

o

LO

W

.J U

a.

11"

1- U

° :

I-

0

U_

<

u

.I

u

W

E

0

(J

u_

M D

I

N

_.-

0

u

I.,.°,,,,,,,,.,,,

*00_000000_00_000

<

0

w

...... ...,,, .....

0

0

1

o

0

0

O

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I i i ,

o o

l"i' / !., " _IONYHO

289

IHO I ]H O! JI O]dS

0

o

o

o

M

o

N

o

w

- :

- :

- _,

o

o

o

Page 296: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N I[M •

r.

°I

s

o

t

o _

u

Z

),.

l

W

0

,.J

.1

,1[

w

I"

N

E

L

E

E

<

w

E

IC

<

0

,(

(J

<

M

(J

D,

w

I-

E

0

o 4

Q

N

Z

0

kl U

U •

U _

f- O

.a

x

O

W

Ic

W

U

0

.J

.J

,1[

ul

u

b.

Z

i. 0

_ 0

L Z

Q

Q

W_

Uw

_W

O_

__OO

Z_NN

0

M

• mm

M

,( p1 <

tq

_,J ^ *.,j

• Q (8", < ._. =)

(J td Q _ 4.)

rJ < * "_ G

_J _) e I_ bJ

-- Z

(J II: .J ._ U

kJ .i_ O 0 Z _ N W

29O

m

N

Q

x

o )"

N

• 0 _ll

w _ _ _)

•( • _1 Q

k- _ w

I[ | _ n,

=) I_ W W

• .J t.-,N

•_ 0 _ w 0 N *_J

0 _[ 8, _1: -- -- t, <

N U)

Page 297: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

f,.

m

i

m

?j*

0

I

N

o

N

u

B,,,..,.,.,,,.,..

*OO00_O000000000Q

• I till|Ill

%

CD

fU

),,

0

.J

.J

w

N

L

r

4[

r

I"

'4

e-

V)

4J

.J

<

M

(J

a,

bd

E

£

0

t,)

tU

)..

m

W

I--

° ;o

0

N 0

Z

X

U

W

u

u _

t. -T

IL

ffl

U

o

0

bOQOOOOOOOOOQO000

_O000000000000000

.....*..*.*.*...*

N

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

N

0

0

0

c_

o

I

o

o

N

o

m

o

8

M

k-

,.J

_n

< 4[

|

hi

Z )-

o

is I I I Is * ]@NVH3 LHO I "_H

o

|

31JlO]dS

o

!

291

Page 298: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W

j N

r- •

u

t N

o

i

nJ

o x

u

z

)-

_D

N

_J

0

.J

W

E

M

El"

L

E

!*

E

E

0

k

Q

Z

0

W

.I •

_ Q

° :x

u

o

¢=

m

o

L

u

Z

_ U)

M _

,J m

J _

• 0

L Z

m

_4

• 0

• N

hJ

• 4D

0 bJ

• .J

0

_ U W m

•11 W Z _

o

M

fq

IL • ..

_q . 11

o8 • J

o 0 - 6. _[ *.

o _r Z _J

N O.

)-

U_

_J

.J

_J

_r

w

E

r

0

u

bJ

m

m I

I

N

I-

o

o

I "mM

_ m

m

m

U

m • ¢)

U b_ 0

u b. _ -

Z

bJ (2 . _-

U Z _ _ N 0

• 0 • O. [ --

b. 0 I- _ I- • Z

-- tn

X x

I • I[

(j ,_ (j

m , 0 OI

W _ 41 . _d

Z _ Z

• 0 • O. _[ -- •

N _

292

Page 299: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

!

Ot

f.,

W

Ot

c:)

|

Jr

o

|

nJ

ut

.).

o )-

.J u

.J

4[ ,.

1- o

n.

<

E

z: (._

.<

° :E _

I"

4(

<

U

E

E

0

m _

I

N

Z f'-

W

h

°0

Z

.!.

tn _.J

w

u

u

G.

u

g.,,o°°°.oo°***°

(

:°-°::::::::::::° oooo

.,,,.,,,,,****,,,

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

ii e ! / lie * |gNVH:

293

0

o

IHO I 3H

0

3 I Ji 3_ldli

0o

o

Iru

o

m

o

m

o

_J

E

)-

!.',_

Page 300: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M I

I m

I <

r*

u

i M

® ;° :i

il

I

ill

0 X

Ii

3[

II

Jr

Ut

),

O

.J

,J

9(

w

[

N

*V

G.

]=

4[

O

1"

'(

Q

in

.4

cJ

,J

4(

u

W

it

,It

o

W

m

4(

I

_J

.J

U

u

u

4[

I

I

N

<

4[

_Q

I

0

0

e

I

X

Q

W

lal

m

I

0

.J

.J

G.

<

o

t,.

Z

_. 4.5

J in

< 0

L Z

o

o

N

JN

< Z_NIMO0

..J

.J

O. ,( <

in o iI

ul

iI I m

o i i

g-u

w

kI W_

_4 ZZ

_0_

X

N

E

M

U ^

0

_ww

W _WO

Z

294

..J ^

I/I ° _1,

I

0 I

ollt

I 0 _ --

o 0 -- o. l

o n, Z _

N G.

N

• PI •

E E

M

I . 0 I

_ o W W

Z _ Z

U _" ,../ _ CJ

< <_. 0 • < k ,

41,I Ul

Page 301: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

!

m

W

(

o

)

s

o

I

nJ

o

3-

O

.I

.I

W

E

0.

,1[

!*

E

4(

_g

E

E

O

u

J

u

E

E

Q

W

m

E

N

U

)-

w

a _

Q

Z

.<

X

uI u

lm o

u _

: °Lt.

U

W

U

m

I

N

!-

kO00_O000000OO000

_0000000000_00000

i

@

0

@

@

@

@

0

@

0

i In _ I | • ' ]ONVH3

295

0

0

J. HO I ]M _1JI O]dtJ

0It/

o

li

o

qD

ooN

0

(D

.

o

tsd

Page 302: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

1OI

m

r-

l

o

i

o

i

o

)-

O

..J

L

w

E _

IL

4(

E

E U

.E --

E

O

..J

u

w

E

I"

O

W

m m

I

N

x

u

T

l--

_r

M

N

¥-

W

),.

Z

0

W

..J 4[

)" b.

N

0

)-

n"

!

X

Q

>

E

w

u_

m

O

.J

J

G,

(n

Z

4(

o

t_

z

.J Ul

< 0

L Z

u)

o

N •

(J

b. m

Ih .J

IC D .J

W *. < I[ 14.1 Im

I_ ,m 12 _ Z O N

14. _ 4{ n" -- G. *. *.

o

,.J ^

4[ * O

I _ _ w

In • 41

_ 4( • O Z v

O 0 -- IL *. (L II[

o n, Z _ (J U) I-

x

N

E

N

m o

I El _1

Z M

_OZ -ZOO

o_z__

296

.J ^

• * O

CL •

U)

O II

e_ O W

(J • .J

0 0 -- G. I_

o _ • _1 _-

X x

E

N _ N

m o m

_ w

w _m w

Q

N z

w o _

W _z wO_ w

Page 303: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

;4

I

0

OD

GO

J

m

?j*

o

t

¢)

O

J

9[ i.

.E

It*

4.

11- u

¢c

q(

¢J

.J

,4

#J

(Z

_J

lib

E

O

W

UI

a m

t

Z

M

qJ

N

7

X

¢J

T

t--

I

I

j.

U_

bd

j-,

¢.

o •

0

_ O

Z

Z

u --

3

u

u

W

G.

u

j,..,,..,,.,,°,,.

4

_0000000000000000

_00000000_0000000

O

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Io

N

0

0

i" : / $_1 * _iONVH3 IH| I 'IH

CD

3 I .dl :)':ldS

0o

o

o

o

o

_r

0 kJ

0 !"

I-*

0

297

Page 304: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

a

u

a i-

s

o

i

N

Z

i,-

Ir

b,-

w

.ll

Q

N Q

Z

0

w _ wIA J _ m

_ U m Q

,,J U _ .I

: LL.I >. _

E o _

_ ,, _L X '4

U

E b,,

E IJ _

< Z

O 0 I. ¢_

!" '_ 0

< • Z

O _

U

.1

_J

W

!"

0

U

W

< 4

i m

I

N

-- 4[

• I,..

o

M

14

o

_ w a

Q _

_t

• 4

o o

Iq ¢q

/q ;q

,.I A

4[ * 0 0

IL ,l( • -- --

o • ,qe ,qe

II -- gO

m: e_ okJ

,J ,j 0 J

m 0 -- - N -- -- --

o • -- 6, • ,. • _, er

4 4

o o

M o , o

U _0 _0_

_m _m_,

_ _ -

Z_O_

o

4 . • 0

44_

0 |i_

N_

x x

!- 1-

N _ N

i • o i

E I I _ I

kJ _ 0 _ W

•-J _ Q Z w 0 ** "_

• 0 _ -- L 4[ *- ** <

N I/)

298

Page 305: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

tc

U

u

X

m

;q

N

Ld

J

)- u

0 )-

.J U

.J

kJ o

!- o

a.

E

E

0 o

E --

E

La

E

!"

0

U

w

O

I

N

N

_O_OOOmN_--_WWBO

mOmNW_ON_m_WW_m

0,,,°0..0,°0,°06.

oOO_NNNNNNNNNNN

_ooooo0ooDoaoo-omo

. N

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

0

0

0

0

Io

N

i_ : t I1_ ' 3ONYHg

0

_LH_ ! 3H

I ,

o

0o

o

01.JlO]d$

11:

b.-

Page 306: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

II •

I "+

41 el

m

10 IJ

i am

III I"

o I-

I IA

I'

o

I

N

o tC

IJ

Z

IP.

N

M

• 41

41 11

Pl 14

M '14

.I A _I

.J

M • 0 , 11 ql

Vl • -- . • •

0 l I,., I _

it' o_ oW kJIJ o • • .J .J

le. m

.J ,J o J

O 0 _ L Z 1, • _ Jr

0 o

a • O

4 _ 41

41 11 • 11

k. II • •

• I + I

:) O W o_

vl • ,.J • ,.,J

• am 0 oN *'0

4C

OI

Iq

,J ^

.J ,'.

4_ • . O

I Iq _ v

l# • • 'gl

Ul O •

I_ • • kJ

• dl .I

kl • • l-

.J .,I .I

II Id 161 OC

41 _ Z Z --

o 0 - 8. o. g[

O 8: • VJ P_ l--

IV II.

x X

IE 4( IC

I-- O i-

• Iq <

iP T

M

m+ • 0 N

kJ 0 _

_J b. I kJ

kt _1 o W 1+4

_- Ut • .J t'-

W 12 - o I-- W

(j a_ .J : tJ

4( _ • -- • _: I- _. -- 4[

N _

Page 307: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

|

N

z

I

j.

o

!

Q

!

N

Q

tn

).

O

.J

,J

9[

k_

E

a.

4.

,1(

E

E

<

Q

%

<

z:

I-

<

_n

<

(J

.J

4

cJ

r,.

o

(J

m,

q(

U

)-

<

X

(J

u

T

o

M

nJ

Q I-

0

o

o W

Z

Z

U

W

u

u _

4=* _

u

w

IL

U

9[

m

t

N

,(

D

u

_O_m_W_OOO_MOOW

I*b,,.*.**,*,*,.,

*OOQOOODOOaO_On_O

:°°:::°0=°::::::=o=o°=° o_,.,,.,,,*,_,,,i,

0

0

• ,I ,

0

I

o

|g I I I • * 30HVH3

301

0

rD

IHO I ]111

0

Ird

o

:l.dlO3dS

I i iii

0

0

0

0

,,0

0

o

o

o

o

I-

ra

b,,

Page 308: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!M

IAI

>.O.J.J4(

!"

n,

8.

1-

E

<

<

IC

E

O

u

w

E

I"

O

(0

kd

Ih

m

Z

I

Q

I

o

m

4[

_J

a.9

u

"T

I--

Q

w

t,..

k.

o

o

w

u

1-

IJ

o

!

N

I

0

U

o

o

m

,4

0

0

0

I

302

Page 309: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

s

I

m

o

I

s

D

I

N

0

tll

O

.J

..I

4[

I,1

lr

O:

O.

<

I[:

E

O

E

<

U

U

11-

0

U

ul

¢0

4[

m

X

m

-r

j*

o

nl

I-

ll1

l,J

k-

#-

0

I11 Q

Z

Z

_ U

W

u Z

ul

ul

o

I

N

u

wO_MS_I_OI_ODImmlmO--NM_

i°,..°,°o,°°,°._°_,o.,

************************

0

0

0

0

00

00

00

0

80

00

am e t |1' ]OHYHO ,LHI}I ]H

303

0

I ,

o

DIJl:)]dl

OO

ID

D

_r

o

ivj

i**

4D

¢1

ixl

¢)

ID

m

O

If)

Page 310: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

O n.

r-

_r _J

m )'-

= ;.1P

o

I

N

0

6)

.mr

N

0

.J

.J

<

L,J

IC

n,

n

<

I"

1"

4[

0

E

£

O

,1(

U

E

W

I"

Q

U

W

<

ID 0

l

N

I-

<

Z W

0 :m*

< m

a ,(

x ,1[

u

A _

,J U_

_ Z

x

° ;E

o

W_O

_ J • PZ

O

w

>

r_

kJ

ul

m

o

J

.J

<

L4

<

z

:o_ Z

<

Z_mOON

304

Q

W

I[

m

0

Z

:oN Z

_ X

_ N

_ _w_

W _ "-_ W

W _ WW_ W

Z _ Z

O

w

w

4{

_L

Z

o

_ Z

w _

m

_ : =w

_ZOZ _O

Page 311: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

x

u

Z

[.-

_D

r_

pl

(n

bJ

Ut ..J

)* (j

o./.J

.c

w :l-

n,

n

<

E

!* ¢.)

o o

E --

E

,(

0

<

U

U

W

E

0

U

lld

m

m g

i

'i

-- E

Z P

%

mo_R_a_z

l,.,..,,0.

• ooo _

( lll|lll

ko0000_O00

_OO000QO00

_.0.,,,,0.

4[

t-u

_D

3[ , ,

,4

-r

(J

.r

0

W

-T

U

U

W

a.

0 i

o

o

I

0

, , Io

I

i u I I I • * ]ONVNO

305

0

LH@iIN

0

0

0

0

91 .Ill Oldl

00

o

o

o

o

- :

- :

o

0,.

W

N

Page 312: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

eu

6 M

fq (J

i N

°Io

i

o X

{.)

T

40

f,1

P0

).

O

.J

.J

E

N

n"

a.

It

<

CD

I"

!"

<

O

<

O

.J

4[

O

!"

E

O

u

W

..J

(J

)-

oo

,-j

z

O

N

,I[

t_

b.

Q

)-

n,

I

x

o

m

_4

• o *

.J 14 _ .

.j . 1i .

• II * g

L - ,

O --

4 w Z _ Z

.J o J -- L W a.

IL _ U

m

N

N

: lE

fo

o I

W 0 _ U

b. U W

W

_ Z _ _ N 0 _

ut

3O6

Page 313: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

_r

r,.

L-

!

fU

lq

Q

I

ar

o

I

o

W

)-

O

.J

9[

E

N

0.

9[

S"

I[:

4[

(D

q[

!"

T:

4(

O

.J

8:

bJ

1"

O

4.)

18

m

Ig

q

m

W

3:

I"

41"

*

fU

O I'*

O

GI

Q W

-- O

Z

9[

Z

Ul U

W

U Z

bJ

o U

o _

U

W

Q.

K

!

E

P

I

u

oQQ_wNN_O

qlllltl

.kO000OO_O0

_000000000

l

o

I

i i ' i

0

0

0

0

I

!

Ill : I III ' 30NVH_

307

0

, Io

I

J, HOI 3H

0

01.9133d8

Il'l

I

' 0

0

r'.

o

_0

a

if1

o

w

M

Page 314: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N e,,

! M

: °

0 _L

t

S

0

¢

0 X

U

Z

t"

w

4(

I

w

,I

j,-

0

Z

0

N

W

J

i. 0

Ig

u

o

u_

J _

_ 0

L J

0

_u W

J JO _

OZ_

• U

0

0

o

w_o_

_'mO

_W.oO

_JQI

O_

_ Z_NON

_oo

_ee

E £

m _ m

D _ - D

z

• N W I

308

Page 315: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

tt_

Iq

!

0

6

0

I

_d

o

4[

D-

80

X

Z

p-

t_

w

e.

N

w

0 ),-

J U

.J

r a

L

E

o o

E --

i:

M

u

E

!"

o

u

W

,i(

m K

i

z i,-

%u

_,°..o,,,o,ooo,,°

IJJillllilJJ#

i

Z

u

N

w

w

L

_0000000000000000

_00000_0000_00000

N

0

0

0

0

0

tlllll # I • ' ]ONYH3

0

0

I

o

i

i l,,i II I ] II

o

O

.0

0

31J133dl

> .

0

0

I¢_

|

0

o

II

II

.s

o 4d

o Z:

N

I-

o

,m

,?,

Page 316: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

III

M U

N t,-

M

!

I

eLI

Z

l

VS

0

.I

.J

W

!"

N

I

I.

,11

E

I

4

45

Z

E

<

0

.1

u

E

Ill

E

O

u

w

I

w

h

o

0

o

w

.J

u

)-

c,b

i.

o

W

o

o

I

I

a,

j,.

4

D

z0

N

<

m

0

I

I

X

M

• O

MvO

4 I • I

ew_

Q _

vu wIw_m

_w I--ZQO

m

o

_.) _

:_ _ win ,..i

° ;I_ ,.I

N

• I

£

I

_)

bJ

n.

)..

Z

bJ

_)

,J

cn

W

I

.I

I *

I 4

0 a

310

Page 317: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

411

I

119

I"

Z

l

4tl,l

M

,O

I

.11"

O

I

N

O

In

31,,,

O

.,J

,.,J

IM

sr'

N

IS+

I,"

3C

91

ID

'4

I:

3C

9[

,l(

l,)

.J

l-

l-

0

LV

Lfl

<

R

I I

u

_omBNmmmlm_mOIN_

U mOmNOONB_m_D_mmO

m III*,I.IPI*IIIII I

oOOOOOOOOOOOOOQOO

q 4 IIIIIIIIIIII

m

ILl

_ <Q _

Q

Q

o W

N 0

<

Z

14 W

W

U

ID el)

o _

L.)

w

L

u

0

o

I

I

.I

E

_OOOOOOOOOO_OO_OO

+O_OOOO_OOOOOOOOO"

,.°,**.,,+°.-°..°l*,

i ii

0

0

0

0

iiII I $ • ' "al) NVH 0

311

0

JH01]N

0

0

, IIII

o

II

_ I +11 3_ldl

0

0

0

,,0

0

(

0P+

?+

CD

+

IiJ

E

I-

Page 318: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N l

Ul •

r,

m P-

° ;t

I

o X

u

:g

P

m

N

Ut

D-

O

.J

.J

,4

w

I[:

N

I

4.

E

E

4

E

E

0

U

M

u

bl

£

0

U

L.J

I

Z

4.

4:

O

Q

(J

Q

¢:)

m-

4[

)..

4(

Q

D

Z kd

0

m

l • o

_ .J

Q _

_ m

i

x <

u

b.

z

_ o

4 o

a. z

)4

_ ne

_4 U

O • m

W' _ Itl U

U _ N

° I Wl CC

_) bJ O LdUt .J e

Z

o _ ww I. _ N m Ig bl

O *

.J g

_W_Z Z

oOw_Z_

4[

• C)

W O

4[ * '_

i?"

Q o p

O • _. 0[ *,- -- --

312

o

-

x

t-

4[ iv)

.1:

U ,vl

m . O

U kJ O

bJ b.

,s ¢) Z ¢) --

U I _ N _ O 0

N U)

)c

I-

!"

_J

t

U

0

k_

bJ

k-

Page 319: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

j-

I

N

o

i

j-

o

i

N

o

(J

..r

r_

P_

1.1

N

w

0

J u

.J

E

,i,

ft.

E

E rj

0 o

°oE

!-

o

u

N

u

rr

w

E

£

0

U

W

m m,

!

X

_ r

Z I-

4(

4[

0

_J

0

Z

Z

U

0

u

oDOOOOOOQOOOOQOOO000000

W

(J

L_.

W

0 0 0_::o:o:o:°:°:::::_:::::o oo.. ..... ,,.0.,,, .... ,.,

O

O

O

O

O

O

OO

OO

O

O

O

O

O

OO

OO

I I I

Ee _ / I • ' 3ONYH:) iHID | ]H _) I 3| 33dS

313

0

o

o

m

o

.7

o

o

_ :

_ :

-- :

Q

0

!

Page 320: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I_ 8[

j N

;

(J

Z

k-

f_

uI

O

w

E

a.

E

E

o

E

E

U

.J

U

W

T

t"

0

W

_J

I

w

i--

Im

o0 •

o ;o 0

In

o

W

-I ,4

IJ E

u _

I

X

(J

o

Q

o

0

W

i

w

I

O

.J

J

<

eL

,1(

U

m

i. o

8 m

• J _

d I.,

4( 0

m

W

U

I

Q

er

U • Q m O

4[ Z O (V

ua. P- Z

M

Q

W

I

_J

k')

I

O

.J

.,J

<

O.

me

b,

Z

0 0

_ Z

N_ W

I 4

I,- 0

I

• , 0 ,

k • • I

_,* _ I W •

314

I

Id

II

O

,J

.I

4[

dL

14

i-

Z

4_

k.

Z

U_

N Z

N

m

I *

N

I * O

O 4

_ •

Z m

W dOOI_--

U Z_O_

N_

I

I

0

L

Vl

I-

"Z

Z

4i

u_

I

o 0

In Z

I 4[ I

;4

I ° o I

W _ I I W

LJ _ I U I W

Z _ Z

W • _ 0 • - ** Z 0 W

Page 321: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

40

in

m

i

ot

.r

o

i

j-

o

I

A_

a X

u

Z

I-

v'l

o

tq

N

L

o

W

)- u

O )-

.J u

E o

IL

E

E U

,C •

E --

E

O

,11

U

U

E

W

E

E

O

U

In o

< m

m N

|

..Jr

Z

,4

o

z

4(

z

u

)-

,r

_D

_J

:3

u

b.

w

O.

N

o

m*,*.,*,*0

_ ill |

,,,.,...,,

WOm_O_O_O0

i

Ii

¢_

0

0

,1 i0

#

_w _ L I • ' 39NVH3

315

0

to

o

I

I HO 1 ]l'l

0

Olall_]dS

0

" 0

0

o

o

o

o

m Ill

c_

M

¢3

o

Page 322: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

II1

I

m

!

m

.P

o

6

o

i

o

>.

0

,J

w

E

6.

E

E

4[

O

E

E

<

0

U

W

E

0

(J

w

m

i

,11

N

4[

m

i-

I

m

o

I+I

.,

nJ

ILl

I--

I"

0

10

0

in

t,J

.,J

f..)

),.

4,,,)

t.

o

o

¢)

o

m

i

:31

i.-

I-

O

Z w

0 )

E

< m

a, 0

hb

t,. .J

(3 9[

O.

)" Ut

<

w

u

h.

Z

.J in

,< o

L Z

4

O

m

Q

U

Q

W _ _ m K

m

4 <

*_°

• 0 •

_ Z_Z

N

M

• I

0 _

; + +m _

Z_wO_

316

Page 323: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

ol

in

io

i

ol

o

I

f

a

!

B

(n

bJ

3," U

0 >-

• J u

.14

W o

L

q(

I:

4(

Q o

°I"

(J

.J

m

(J

w

E

I-

0

cJ

w Q

<

m

!

.f

-- IC

Z I-

U W

v

_O_NaO_B_J_EaMI_

_OO_--Om_B_O_mNQO

m i,,,.,,,0°,°,+,,+

*ooOe N_m_OhlO

< itilliil$1Olll

U

.p

j,-

o

pl

N

_O0OOOQOOOOOQOOOO

4000000aOQOOQO00_

,.,,..,..,.,.***.

WO_O_O_OO_O_O_O0

4(

Q

bJ

<

T

4J

2[

U

L_

U

W

U_

I

I

0

0

0

0

I

I

0

0

O

II I I | • * ]ONVHO

317

0

0

J He I ]11 OldlO]lll

0

II"!

r-

i

i

o

.!"

0 r

Page 324: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

lil er

OI •

4"1

W

O) O-

0 P

_r

O

I

N

U

Z

l

N

m

0

.I

J

w

E

A.

L

E

E

0

E

E

0

U

U

w

E

E

o

bJ

m

m

Z

W

C)

N

w

_J

u

u

¢.

o

U

o

o

m

i

z

E

4[

(3

Q

• W

_ m

a, 0

Q •

L

IZ I'-

I •

U

Z

8 _

• 0

IL Z

Q

W _ • N

U_O0

ZN

X

I

[

w u

• m

M

W 0

U m

_ Z

o_-_ •

I,-

IO _ 0

U W 0 bJ

U -- IL

W ::_ 0 j. w

4_ 0 .J

o

o

• o

0

m

_0_

o0-[

O[Z_

N_

M

°M

_N L w

W Q * • _

W _aZ_ 0 w

318

N

M

E

(J

N

m

u

Gm

W

l-

Z

w

U

W

Page 325: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

K

u

m i°,°°***°0°***',°°

_ I__NWmMW_ N

lil,lllllll

4

ill

IJ

N

Z

m

I%1

#%1

kl

I,*

O

D

li

Ul Ill

,,J

4iI ill

,< :]C o

2<E

• U

< •

Q --

W --

E

o

=1

t,-

0

Z

.I

U

W

E

E

0

U

ill a

Z _

"L,_

c_

Z

.i

Z

l.)

w

.T

w

L

::o::ooooo:ooooo:0 00000 00000

,..,,.,°.,,*.,,**

0

0

(

Ill

0

0

0

0

0

1 I

ci o

-* Ii

i !

illl #ill* ]ONYH_ iHI I IN

319

0

0

31ill3]dS

0

0

0

0

i)

Ir

o

¢i

ci

Ill

dl

hi

s-

i-

Page 326: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N 9[

II1

u

o •

I

N

Z

b.

m

N

m

)-

o

.J

.J

q[

w

E

a,

0.

+<

I"

31:

<

,(

I-

£

<

..,.,

o

-.r

I

_I

<

u

w

E

E

0

u

N

w

.J

u

u

0

Z

0

I-

IJ

Q

is.

I

X

<

<O

L+

Q

W

_M

_ U w

_wz

<QO_Z

L_u

. N

u

m

° ;

_O_Z_UZ

_mm

x

M

I-

l-

tJ

(J

bJ

W

z

w

{J

w

u

<

320

Page 327: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

g

q[

N

laJ

)..

A:

m

).

o

,J

w

J

w (J

E )-

u

E o

E

Q

E _

,II •

Q _

v

8"

0

:Z

X

.J

w

E

E

O

W

-- I

Z _

w

_Om_mMm_W_OM_Mm_._WWNO_

***********************

ll|lllllll

,1[

I-

0

_7

Z

u

w

:3

(.)

N

o

O.

(/I

:_=o_o_°o_o_.o_°_oo.°° o °o .°°,.,°_° ..... , .... °°,°°

(CC(

ooD3

00

0

0 o0

0

iiI I I I I ' ".IONYI,I_)

0

0

o

0

0

IHO I 31'I :)lJlO]dS

321

0o

o

if*

o

ul

j,

o"

o

o

,ig

w

,,r.

Page 328: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

irJ

i N

P4 g

i m

Q 4[

°!

I

Qd

O

U

Z

0

E

E

E

0

E

<

Q

W

X

0

Z

.J

U

E

W

E

E

0

U

W

0

0

w

.J

u

¢.1

41

o

o

u

o

o

4

o-

<

Q

0

g

<

E

I

x

.I M iL

m _" td

(L I z

hi * I Z

b (J td .* N 0

• W • _1 0 Z a

X

.Z

N m

k@ 0 w (j

at | _"

tnm O _-

_ ,.J _

b,I _. 4[ td _q •

Ik 0 _ 8. -- t. -- 4[

el' 0 )- U) I _J _ b.

U_

0

• m

_ ZO

dOwN

,4

td N_

<

b. I

Q *

I1_ .J

_ Q Z 0

Z _ 0 N

0 • 6- -- _.u

Vlm

322

X

E

g

m

_J

Q

W

I[

t,J

t,I

iJ

U

4[

b.

Page 329: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IO

I

t%l

I

ill

o

li

I

N

o

).

O

.i

¢[

bJ

E

M

I[

L

4[

Z:

_9

!"

¢[

,4

U

.J

N

U

W

,if-

O

I[

M

,4

¢.J

X

L.)

-r

p.

O

in

bJ

(J

)-

¢.)

o

u

o

u

• .... ,,,°°

4 _2m

tllllil

_ooooOoooo

_OOOOO_ooQ

.,,,,....,

E _MZ_mQ

4[

bJ

Z

u II

I

.t-

O !N

bJ

•v I

(J

N

b.

fJ

bJ

t_

0

0

0

0

o

iS i # | • * ]ONVH3

323

IHli I 3it

0

I

3lJl=3dl

0o

o

o

m

o

I

o

Page 330: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m m

N

IJl 0

N )"

0 I-

Jr

o

I

0 X

0

Z

l.b

o

W

>,

0

_t

E

E

L

E

E

o

<

U

J

W

E

o

U

W

m

W

r-

i

,it

I'm

'ql

0

Z

0

E

M

Q

a[

I

x

.N

_w

NL

L I

Q _

_W X_

L--U

W

,IK ,I_

o

0

o

w

J

(3 Z Z •

X

)..

r

m

U

0

w

O:

w

w

<

324

Page 331: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

l

o

I

tUo

),.

0

,.J

.J

4(

_J

E

O.

r

£

o

E

0

-I

U

gl

!"

O

U

w

a-.

Z

m

u

o

W

r.

w

I.-

L,

.a <

o

a

Z

<

X

r,J

L,d

U

w

: oO _

W

Q.

U

O

I*..,**,°*

:oo::o:::o,,,.,.,,.,

0

0

C)

0

0

I

_d

I

;i I I I | • * ] 0 N V H.:)

325

IH9 I ]H

0

31313]dS

0o

o

t.

4:

w

: =t-.

Page 332: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

JI

Iq

I

o

0

J

J

,I[

E

K

E

E

0

E

I[:

<

u

.1

u

w

E

E

o

u

Ig

_J

N

x

u

N

Z

t.-

m

ID

W

o

Q

Q

w

.J

u

).

u

a.

.c

u

o

I-

Q

X

0

N

)-

_.)

I

0

!

X

9[

0

..J f_)

m

L m

0

W

_, u W

•_ w Z

J ,J 0 _

L _ u

X

N

_ E

°ME

o m

W 0 0 _ U

Z

_OZZ 0-0 _

_O_Z_

326

Page 333: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

e0

84

j.

I

Jr

o

I

Jr

o

i

N

o

ut

).

o

.J

.J

4[

W

E

a:

a.

E

E

4

o

<

Ic

X:

in

,4

u

.J

4

U

I.-

3;

o

4.)

m

4(

Lid

0-.

h

O t-

O <

O

O

Q Id

Z

e(

X

UI U

(J

.tl

Q u

u

w

G.

U

i.

G.

w

l-

m

u

0

o

r-

i

N

I

u

%OMO_O_M_

mOmNBJ_Nm_

.o0_Nmm_Nm

_ IIIIlll

q

OOOOOOO:OOOOO_OO O

.....,....

m

0

t

Ii

Ii

o

o

O

0

0

0

Io

V5

N

!

iWa Ill' _IONYH3

327

,i. HO I 3_

0

|1

01J133111

J i

o

i

i

o

o

o

Page 334: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

E

I N

O •

M

_P

o I-

! IA

t

o :-r

I-

f

Ir

Ut

lip

0

J

J

<

tlJ

E

iv

O.

<

E

E

<

0

<

E

r

<

0

u

,_1

<

(J

w

I-

E

o

u

w

k-

,ig

u

A

I

Ck

E

u

r_

i

<

<

o

z

o

<

b.

tl.

rs

3,-

,11

I

I

Jmt

0

i.1

i.-

-o+o""+ __ '+..J I I,.

L" (a

ul

<

o

IV)

"o

bJ

U

< .i

k.

E

" W

U) .J

a

,., -" o -4( z N

l,i,+ _ 4{ *,, Iv

m" I'- 0 I--

IA

o

Iv)

_4

• o

4( 4[

J

o- ".j '1,

4[ g_ _ gO

I_ " .JQ

kJ • * _-

l- .J • ..J

L. (J lU M (J La E

41 W Z O ° Z w

•J O N el

O .J _ 6. f. Z A. 0C

4J

)4

N

4[ 4(

14

SlL.

0 a

bJ 0 0 _ l.)

(,.I, I+I _ lq

• 0 "le ,'_

b. m li -- I+I

{IC I l i,- "_ n,,

=, - - -,.., ,.,

_" .J J e _ U

4; 4[3 Z O Z O • -- W

o < -- O. -- O. _- Z _ <

328

Page 335: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

Q

.1"

J

Q

!

@1

Cl

I

N

IO

Ul

>.

0

.J u

.J >.

u

W *,-

!- a=

.. o_0.

4[

1-

I:

4[

(D (J

q[

k-

w

W

a.

x

o

I

o

o

u_ v

m _

m E

- 0

Z u

u

U mON_O_m_N

• ° . , ° . ° ° . °

X

Z

i

i,

wZ

m (J

W

W

3

u

w

IL

_o-mo_omoo

I I

0

0

iI

I

o

o

0

, Im

o

o

I

iII ! | u * ]@NYHO

329

,3

0

/H013H Ol _ll_]dl

' ''0

0

kll

N

I

Cl

0

-- (I

I0

-- ID

o

- ,_

- _

o

- _

o

o

8

W

E

Page 336: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N m

i m

• .hi

Jr (J

! N

No ;I

m

o

I

m

o

u

Z

N

UI

>.

O

./

_J

E

8[

8.

9[

Z

E

<

0

E

E

0

J

w

E

Q.

x

W

W

Ul

,1[

m

Z

w

I-

o

o

U

o

,I[

Q

I

O

8[

b.

N

O

E

I

x

,I[

0 UP

pl w

pq .J

_.q 4E

• o

.J Iq

• O * w

L I _ Z

• .J J

O

W * _ Z , ,

b U I_ bJ a, 0 IU 0

W O Z w Z O 41

.J J Id _ N X

J _ .J 0. IL _ Z N

a* _J

OQ

w_

Q

_ Z

_O_

OOl_

U _ L--

| I •

D • B:

4G IO3Z

ZON_--_

330

M .

m

E

I-

E

t_

N

m

(J

o

b_

k_

i-

z

kl

(,)

b.

Page 337: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

7

i

:r

o

I

o

!

N

o

W

0

..J

.J

W

N

L

l-

r

r

.J

m

w

y.

E

0

(J

m

Z N

4

M

.r

l-

tO

0

P3

I-

W

I.

CI

0

0

W

.J

U

t.

0

tJ

0

k'l

!

L

I"

t-

UI

!

D

<

,Q

Q

Z

ul

U

u_

_ooQOO. ooOa

.i,,**,,**

m

0

0

0

0

0

o

ie I I I I ' 30NVH3 LHO I ]lq

331

0

314133dli

o

,I

0o

II

0

0

am

0

0

..11"

0

Iq

,al

o

IL,J

aC

N

i"

Page 338: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Im!P_

IoNo

0.J.J

E

L

E

E

0

E

¢)

M

u

_d

E

0

U

bJ

m

R

m

U

M

m

X

W

N

Z

Jo

M

N

w

u

).

LJ

u

o

M

|

L

E

U)

U

0

0

).

D

0

m

(J

Ir

Q.

IC

!

4

D

M

M

• 0

4 _

,J _ _

,J • ql_

•IK •

• J

Q --

W • l-

id 0 Z --

w J _ _ E

• 0 U M

II. U

Vl

N

4 Ig

o I-

4

Iq

0 , II

bi -- 0 S.)

* IS Id

Id II bl4n ..J e )-

Ig ..J _

4

O

,J

gl. | e

Q

bl

• w z _

.J o _ _

o .J -- L 8.

0 0 • Ill M

kd VJ • kd

(J N N _ •

0 • )-

Jr I _ •

. - .:g• . • o

E

Z C) * _ •

332

N

E-

t-

4[

M

:)

4J

0

IM

U

Page 339: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

p_

I

rd

rU

0

!

Q

I

0

M

X

o

M

W

t.

(/I

w

0 )',

.J u

.,,I

4( t.

1-

Iv

G,

4(

I" u

° :

11-

_.)

,u

e,.

tiJ

:r.,

0

w

® :

-- !

Z

N

I

U

mO_O_mO_

iIio,,,a_,

IIIII|I

q

kQQaQO_QQa

a_QQOOOOO0

WO_O_O_OO

N

-r

0

W

k,

W

U)

0

0

0

0

0

0

,0

a"m film ' 3@NVH3

I i

o

if1

N

i

IHO I 3H 31_flO3dS

333

,

o

i

ag

w

lg

Page 340: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

o

Jg"

!

N

N

o

I

cl

I

o

)-

0

.J

,J

W

I-

ra

I

L

v

!"

<

(D

C

E

W

W

..J

U

L,J

E

E

0

u

W

I

I

M

D"

U

Z

m

o

W

o

M

M

o

tl

I

Q

"Z

0

i[

L

Q

E

I

X

o

L

m W

J

Q

_ U m I

IWO_

_ 0 _ _

L U

N

• I

m

o m

W

I -- a.

_ lad

.I I-

Z

_ _ _ 0 _ W

0

m

Q

,_ W • 0

•J 0 _ _

4

0

• Q

ur _ _ N

q[ • 0 I

• _ I 0 I • 0 --

Z _ N _ -- N _ 0

334

N

N

I

4[

I

I

_J

l

I-

f

kJ

W

Page 341: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

me

9[

tJ

t,,

q[

L)

-r

t-

Crt

Itt

m

).

o )-

.J u

.J

< i.

E o

i,i

a,

l:

E u

<

Q o

_,, in

1[: --

IC

M

m,,

LI

E

!-

O

m

m o

Q

r _

- i

1.1

t-

o _

o

Z

"1-

ul o

t,J

u

O

3

U

W

a.

ffl

u

_ O N • m _ I I I _

OU _ _ U I I I m P

Ill,liLle0

IIIl|ll

q

_O000000QO

8OO00QO000

WO_O_O0

|

0

L 0

0

c_

o

n I I

0

0

IC_

In

_u

!

Ill'I II ' ]ONYHO

335

,I, to O I "n0_

0

, ID

0

m

t

01413]dll

0

o

Ot

o

Page 342: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

B E

t M

4

J- u

!

° _I

z

o

i

N

o _

u

Z

lm

o

)-

O

.J

w

m_

OC

L

m-

mr

<

0

r

0

<

&J

J

U

W

E

£

o

u

w

oo

uI

.J

u

u

4.

.B

u

o

o

o

r.

7-0

Z

0

a,

Q

I

x

0

w

_WOZ

_ J w_

u

<

o

U

m

W

° ;m

o

2"_( Im -- ;

e • ,J

b _ N _

• bJ Z 0 • v

-I 0 -- I_ -- --

_ U

N X

m N

<

u

m m

u _

z z

336

Page 343: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

If)

I

.P

k_

!

N

¢)

I

Ot

o

I

_d

¢)

US

.J

..J

4(

Z:

N

A.

X:

11-

!"

CD

u

J

w

E

w

a.

x

w

u

t,-

w

L.

.E •

0

_ 0

Z

Z

tn u

bJ

X ;1- 0

u _

w

: o

u

w

a.

¢,J

o

f_

o

o

q[

m

0

u

v

g*,,*,,,**

llil

_OOOOQOO00

_O000QO00O

..., .... ,.

0

0

0

ll# / Ii . "40NVH 0

337

0

o

o

o

IHOi3H Ol.dlO3dB

0

o

0 °

o

Ill

0

iD

o

.lr

o

o

.4=

N

Page 344: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m I

i m

Jr '1[

in

19 u

o

-ioo

!

o Ig

u

Z

I-

r_

t_

).

0

J

J

¢[

td

[

E

8.

E

E

0

E

IC

0

U

J

<

E

E

w

L

x

W

W

b,.

o

Qo

m

.I

u

u

Q

U

0

0

!

0

I

E

0

Q

Z

0

<

I=

b.

k.

).

4

a[

¢

X

0

M

m

.J

.J ID

L

4n LL

.J

W )-

• W 0

.J .J N

¢[ 0 ¢.) 4"

8. (J

x

m

< Jr

9[

r

m

,,4 i.)

N

o m

¢[ =l

W -- b'l 0

_[ ,e Q

4,. . El W

_1 IU o kJU_ .J i l-

a[ J (J

L.J t. ,1[ N ee taJ

CJ _ 0 0 _ Z bJ

• Z IU N _ U

b. _ 4[ ** E 41. ¢[

I[ l- U )" Vl h.

tn

u)

"m

m_

m_

L I

_ _ ,.a_ Z_

O_--L--

N

kJ I0 Id 0

• )-

k. I )- I

:* 0 J, II

UP • 0 I

° ;_ J J

• 3[ Z

Z 0 _ el _ m

0 ,,C -- IL *- -- Ik

338

X

m

ar

t-

N

.:)

*,J

e_

W

W

161

Page 345: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

W

!

in

m

!

m

o

I

m

o

!

o

u ¸

m

x

'5-

t-

O

Iv

i

w

[,..

L.

o

o

o

(In

_- ka

0 .J

..I (,J

.J )*

N

O.

4(

!"

1:

O U

I: In

q(

q[

)-

4d

!"

O.

X

Id

m

es

r,,,,

;

)-

,.,.J

E

h,J

l0

t_

j

Z E

4[

7Q

0

Z

2[:

U

0-

-r

0

uJ

2

U

U

W

IL

I

o

_O_OmOO_

g.,,,.,,,,

.Oo_W_OaW

l|ll

4

bO000OO00O

8000000000

o....*,.,.

WQ_O_O_O0

0

0

o

0

, , I

a

Q

i

8e e I I • * ]IDNVH_

339

0

IHOIIH

0

01_Jl0]dl

o

|

' - O

O

o

o

L.*

I[

N

I0

Page 346: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

m

tD

t

m

o

!

O

o

$

N

o

>.

0

.J

.J

q[

_J

E

I[

L

<

sr

2[

<

_D

!"

¢D

q[

.J

zw

I"

w

G6

x

W

m

a

m

G)

N

,i[

M

u

N

.r

p-

w

m

_J

N

r:

i.

oo

tn

w

..I

u

).

U

o.

o

o

o

f.,

!

t-

W

T

N

a

:P

v

In

m

!

E

O

z bJ

0

Ig Q

L

N ,J

O _

iv

X •

U

Z

• J _

L Z

ffl

X

0 J"

M <

E

14

U

o m

td _ U

U

b. id

W W

m ,,J _-

z

_ u

• N

• J N.J o ).

Q _

_ W Z .v

.J 0 _ w

0 .I -- I£ --

N

t*J In w

6) iv 8.

h. ID t--

E

° ;

o _*- • (n /J •

X

N

I-

,1[

s-

(J

as

:)

(J

Q

I

bJ

I-

Z

tu

u

b_

u

.i(

t_

340

Page 347: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Jr E

m 4J

) N

4

I I,-

M

i

N

o X

4,)

M

Z

I--

,I

h.

L

0

i.J u

M U

.C

O

E 0

E

2,,,r

° :Q _

W _

X

IIg

0

,'t

0

Z

..J

E

E

Z:

0

U

E

W

m E

I o

o

r-

z _)

,4

Q

bJ

0

<

Z

U

)-

i.

(D

_J

LJ

b.

LJ

W

eL

U)

N

u

_QmO_BNB

• I_N_ ._

Itil

_o::ooo0ooo OO_QOO

**.,**°....

• i i i i , .

0

0

0

0

0

¢D

|11 S I I • ' ]ONVHO J. Hel]H 31.dl_]dS

34!

0

c =

o

gl_

o

o

o

Jr

o

o

Page 348: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

.Ir

I

I11

410

!

o,

I

lq

I

R,I

1o

1,.

0

.J

..J

4[

w

E

N

O_

O.

4(

E

E

4t

_D

E

IC

4

Q

W

O

3

Z

U

01

E

E

O

U

I,

m

4[

T-4[

X

U

Z

iii

N

I-.

14

kl

Im

I..

0

0

0 +

W

I,d

,.,J

'IJ

U

I,.

0

U

a

In

M

m

4

O

0

O

4

E

b.

k.

Q

3,-

<

E

I

)4

4

O

M

m

o

.J 1

4[

as --

m b,I

.J

Q

w __ U M IX

d J 41 _

4( O U P-

L U

_A

X

N

E

_ m

O • m

kl --' ID

u -- IU

'4 'm Q

k. - Ill kJ

O_ - l a,.w o w

If) ..j • _..

zQ (-. m_J

"_ (4

Ul

• N

.4

If) kd

-4 N A-

.J . )_

O. m

" ."2O _

O J -- G. --

• N

4

_,I If) lld

Ill _I II.

,4 _+ )..

k. MI I'-

,.,, ..- ++

n • ...n_ ,.,i

I,,. 4( l+J M *

+ (3 • Z O :Z

Z O _ w

0 4C --' L L, --

o *.- Z _ (J Z

342

X

N

E

Q

w

Ig

w

Z

_J

Page 349: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

qO

i

0

m

M

!

0

0

t

N

a

).

0

.,J

.._

Id

Z

g

L

Z

I-

U

..J

_4

E

E

0

U

Ill

I

I m

4 v

_Ia_I_MMI_IIMIm. II

_OIMMM_N_mO'_IOI_

I.,..,0DIO,,,OD,.

4 |NMMMMMM_MMS_

_ ; tlllfllltllli4

@.

o

o

o

0

I

!

4

tJ

n

_°°..,,°._,°°.,o°

,0, ,, I........ II o

I I

iII It J • ' ]_NVHO

343

0

0

0

0

O

0

0

0

0

o

0

I

o

I

J, HOI3H _ll Jl Dldl

0

o

,i

o b.I

0

0

Page 350: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

)-0.J-I

E

a,

a.

,1[

Z

E

<

o

2,E

it-

<

0

U

U

IZ

w

E

E

0

U

w

m

I E

Q •

Iq U

°o

1

o x

¢,1

Z

l¢u

w

o

u

),.

u

o

o

I

Qr

0

mr

nr

I

• W

-/

• 0 W

L m Z

Q

LU _ ,Oa2

_W Z ZO_

400Z_

_-NU

X

¢_ _*

!"

vl U

0

_[ -- 2)

ki 0 _ U

U _ w

< '_ CI

_- m kd

w w.J )-

Z

ne _

I*l *" < W 1_ e_

_.) 8 Q Z 0 w W

b. 0 < 8. - _ .1[

u)

344

Page 351: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IJ

N

I"

l-

a0

O

P)

ill

td

t-

O

O

U'J

t_

>- U

0 >-

.; U

.I

r o

s,

L

E

9( •

O

._ °E

Q

U

,d

I-

0

td

in

,<

M Q

Q

r,

- !

z :=

,(

,4

_O_fmW_D_B_IOaO

• ililill _

lilllll

:C

{a

3:

_a

b.

m

(a

taJ

O_

::o::::ooo:::::o:.o o o oll)lililllltlllll

I

I

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

o

I

im I i I • ' 3ONYH3

O

O

O

0

*HOI]H 3131_)]dS

345

0o

o

fu

o

m

o

t_

Z

m

I-

Page 352: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

_P

i

N

_u

o

m

>.

0

.J

.J

qC

kd

IC

E

L

I"

E

O

E

IC

I-

U

./

U

I

W

X

E

0

U

_q

!

m

4J

X

4J

.r

m

N

W

t.

o

N

(J

o

o

Q

0

p-

U

I

h,

N

0

)-

!

x

N

4 I

R 0,.

M

• E

Iq

W

Id a tl_ m U

0 m lid *m w

• • 0 "e Q

b. • • m * Id

iF | | @" _ IZ

• J 0-.

Q • * l- W

td _ 4[ _ Id 4,) lit a.,

Page 353: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

m

N

M

!

Am

N

o

m

0

.J

J

¢

W

E

L

[

E

,J

E

W

E

IC

O

U

m

U

7,

ul

<

el

o

o

N

Z

<

T

II) 4J

I+J

0. 3

: oO _

U

M

a.

u

g.j0,,,.,,,*.****

lll!lllll

I1|11

_°:::°°°_::°:°:°°°0 ooo o o oo_

0

o o

I

0

0

0

0

O

0

i w I' I I w ' ".mON yH 3

0

0

0

.LHGI]H

0

0

0

:l_ll:]d$

0

D

1"

0

N

m

I=

347

Page 354: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

lid

!

la

m

I

nJ

nJ

0

0

I

C2

el

)-

0

.#

J

tud

E

G.

I"

0

E

lr

0

U

M

U

eC

Idd

i*

0

_J

w

m

I

N

W

X

Z

m

w

I-

o

n/

W

.J

u

u

r,.

o

u

o

o

o

o

I

D

0

0

N

I-

ra

L.

b.

N

0

I

X

Q

N 0

• J FO

q[ I i,.- • --

[L e _ I--

_q e _' Ld* 0 .J •

Ld *

• IZ U

W • 2 -- " 0

• J O .J 8. -- -- K Z _.

• O O _n Z Z *- -- U

L N CJ

UI

w m o

9[ • 0

b. ID Q

E ml i I_

U) m • •

b.

C]

n[ j j •

o

w

..J

b/ *. 4[ Ikl _J (J Iq 8[ N

CJ • O Z Z " O _ O

b. O 4[ _. A. Z b _ --

l[ O _- U_ U) -- (J _- 4[

D h_

U)

X

N

1-

4[

IC

UN

m

w

Z

u

u

m_

348

Page 355: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I Im •

lq

lq I-

•I" 4

o

I

N

O

(J

Z

I-

o

N -

w

i.

Q

o

m

kJ

w .J

.d

I-

a.

E

E

< °

0 o

E _

E

0

U

,d

U

ul

r

r

0

U

!

E

m

I O

o

_ t

Z D

<

0

W

(D

Z

,(

T

(J

0

3I

u

W

L

N

u

_O_NO--IB|----ININ |

|ommMIMIMIMIIh|_I

Itlllltll|

_0000000000000000

_OOQ_OQOQOOOOOO_Q

o.°,0,..,0...,.0,

-- N

0

,,0

0

D

I !

I I

O

0

iI* I | i' 3@NVH3

349

0

0

0

0

Im

o

!

LHel]I_

0

0

0

0

3141:]di

0

o

,0

0

(I

I

o

3,

o

i.

4l

I,-

Ill

0

Page 356: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

(D

i

$.

0

I

0

0J

..I

w

IE

I

8.

<

E

E

<

E

r

<

0

,1[

u

u

w

E

E

o

u

w

m

I

(.J

m

X

uN

Z

_m

0

W

_m

o Q

0

w

J •

_' b,.

U _

e. Q

t

(J

A

i

L

E

LA

<

u

Q

I

w

w

I

0

.J

.J

L

<

u

,.J _

.J _

I. z

o

M

o

w

• 1

0

U ,a 0 0 -

J

L

Ul o

_l 0

0 I

2

0 0 _ -- *. I

0

P_

0

o "

o8 0 Z ° 0

X

N N

< M •

E E

.Z _ _ Z

U Z_-- "U

m

o m

I

w

.J .J

*- I w N

Am < I 0

I 0 N i

0 0 -- _ *.

0 I I _J_ U

350

Page 357: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

I

r_

14

!

o

!

m

o

!

N

Q

m

o

..i

E

IIg

IL

E

E

E

E

4

U

.I

41

z

tad

I-

E

uJ

it.

X

W

I

m

D,-

j.-

W

I-

0

W

h

o

0

,

0

0

o

t

o

o

r'.

I

r

U_

O

4[

i-

O

I.J

¢D

Z

3:

¢D

3[

O

k.

m

U

iU

n

cn

N

u

_ODN_D_MMB_BO0_O

i..,.,°°*..J°°*,,

_O00000OO000000_O

_0000000000"0_0000

N

i i.'

0

0

0

0

I

0

n

0

0

Io

o

I

41m t / I W ' ]9NVH_

351

0

I0

o

o

i

,LHOllH

0

0 I.dl 0]dli

r i

O

o

Io

m

!

Q

O °N

O

O

o

N

o

- _,

o

o

W

I-

Page 358: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

f,,

_4

_r

1

o

!

o

I

Q

),.

0

.I

J

<

LU

E

n,

L

E

31:

<

o

£

<

O

u

.I

<

w

31:

w

x

w

<

m

I

N

_JN

x

u

z

t--

w

I.

L

w

..d

u

),.

_J

o

o

40

I

E

O

u

O

O

Z W

O

< m

Ii.

i. j

_ .j

Q <

L

.4

J Z

x <

u

z

L 7

o

P_

o

D W

O

o

./" 14 N

.I O

4[ m

L i • I--

o 2

o

O ..J O. -- L 2[

X

N

o I-

<

E

It*

'.4 t.J

I[ li )- _ I[

0 -- bd _J

4/) m • .I

lib _ Z

0 _. h,

*.,, • kl l,.J .I_ mr

,m 0 Z • O _ t.4

Z -- O -- IV -- 0

0 41[ IL -- Z I- Og 4[

m

352

1O

J _ M

• J O

4[ gO --

O. _ I-

ra

m , •

"_ b.

ILl

J-- ,J •

_' _) ki NI f_

_J Z O

J O _ IV --

O J -- III. *. Z

III lJ

<

IU In

,ILl l,q M

'4 O

k. 4_ --

+, .-2

O

• Q Z O

• O _ 4* --

0 $- • US /,J v

J4

l[

,4

sr

411

D

(J

Q

k_

w

Ld

Page 359: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

C

I N

,11. _J

=r

I

Q

I

o

u

z

I

o

w

u

.J u

• L

t Qm

L

I-

E U

+ :%

E;.

Q

bJ

E

E

0

(J

I

O,

E

In

m

W <

(n U

® :-- !

Z _

a

w

0

4

Z

0

w

3

u

u

L

u

i..,0,,,,,.,,.+,.

_ II1|1

_ IIIII1.111

O0

°, ..... ,.,.....

0

0

II" • ! I • ' ]ONYH3

353

+H01314

0

0

0

0

0

0

,, I

o

!

31_lO'ad$

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

_ 2.

o

__ ID

o

__ Itl

o

o

- _,

o

Page 360: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

In

_P

J

o

I

_r

o

!

tU

o

m

>.

0

..J

k_

E

W

IL

E

E

4

4

E

E

4(

Q

.J

W

E

E

0

u

I

W

m

X

m

'5-

I-

N

kd

I-

0

0

0

w

.J

m,.

o

N

o

o

m

I

Z

tA

UI

4(

Q

0

T_

!

4[

l

0

m

I-

u

ql

t[

k**

O

)-

4(

I

g

X

.J

.I

4[

IL

m

LJ

I-

f kd

.I .I ¢U 0

L u

0

14

_4

4I

fJ _ ild

k. * I

Ii_ .J

m, ..,,1

_. -- 4[ b n, D.

U_

4[

0

M

Pl

• 0

• I -- I

L I 8" I

iN _ M I L_

.I 0 _ -- _ _

N

4

E

M

I

* 4. O_

4 04_--_Zl

354

0 I

_1 m M

..4 0 *

4[ -- * m

• 1- ,I I

!- • .j .j

• bI * 0 Z Z

• J -- Z _ L IL

X X

)" , 0 _-

I • I

N _ N

I • 0 I

I I I Ip. _ I

Z k. M •

Id * • _ I*l

4J • .J • "*

v 4 kd _ L) I

• o 4 it -- • I ,4

k, 0 i- t_ • _ )- Ib

N V*

Page 361: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

%u

_oo_ooa_MDm_mtm_

aO_M_mQ_W_m_NN_

a,,,0°°,,,,,,.°

*o _mooQOO

illllllllll

4

k_

tfl .I

0 >"

.J

._ t..

I" 0

E

E

° :

E

U

m

U

w

m-

E

o

u

W

m 0

0

-- t

7w

p.

Q

o

N 0

Z

Z

U

X

W

2

w

L_OOOOOOO'OOQO0000

_0000000000_00000,,0,.. .... 0,..0,,

ia 0 / I • * :leN ¥H3

0

0

LI'IOI _IN Ol dl'O3dll

0

0

0

0

0

0--

0

0

0

0 --

0

0

II

{I

¢I

I

0

m

355

Page 362: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

0l

,D

Jr

i

nj

o

i

o

J

N

¢)

4[

cJ

w

..r

Fq

_J

I-,.

W

O

In

_J

)* U

O _'

-i U

.J

E Q

Q.

9[

E

E u

0 O

E --

E

W

.J

U

w

E

E

O

k4

a D

O

-- I

Z =

4

0

Z

0

4

g

a

M

o

Q_

b_m

LW_O

o

L |

0

W

_ Z

_O_

X

N

I"

<

+"

m

(J

0

I+l

o,

kJ

bJ

(J

0

356

o

0. 4[ --

U) I_ --

) llJ W

0 I

8g • W

(j m J

-_ .J

I. • _ II

0 0 -- eL n,

N L

<

m

4 ,

_. 4O

0[ e

+A •

Q

Iv .j

4. 4[ kJ 14

• _ Z O

2[ _ N 0

0 4[ O. -- --

_-- u_ 4[ Z

N U)

x

E

u

M

m

O

W

bJ

t.-

Z

_J

SJ

b.

Page 363: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Ut>-0.J.J

,(

w

I[

n-

0.

¢[

!-

lr-

,el

X:

1[;

e[

U)

e[

O

.J

e[

N

(J

(E

kJ

£

0

(J

W

W

m

m

t

I'

#

N

o

@

ar

Q

i

m

u

9[

(J

N

I-

I"

4_

(n

_J

t-,

4-

o

N

U)

W

J

U

)-

u

o

Q

Q

r-

I

4[

Q

W

0

Z t

Z

U

0

,v

u

b.

u

w

G.

u

_oN_mo_m_moa_mgw

moo_zmMmN_mommm

°aN_mmOO_mN_O_D_

Ill N

Itl|ll0illl

4

bO_OODOOOODDOOOOO

_OOmOOOOOQ_OOQOOO

...,,0...,,,,,...

I

!

I 0

0

|u I / I • * ]@NVHO

0

0

0

0

0

0

O

0

0

0

0

N

!

tl.lO I ]lq 3|410]d|

c)

N

Q

T

m

0

m

o

N

357

Page 364: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IS

!

r-

N

o

I

I

A_

¢1 Ill

T

O

N

N

b

O •

o ;o 0

N Q

z _,J

o

E

m -I 4[ m

_ i. a •

,a IL

E

_ ,_ ;

u

E _

tD 0 b _

I_ -- d --

[ • 0

W.

U

.J

m,

w

• " !!"

0

u

W

<

I •

I

- I

* m

< I

_ 4

g

M

_ m

o I

v N

4 'qI . Q

k. * II Ld

K _. I I

kJ • W

Z

I :) .J tb

4[ Z iv _ N (J'

la. " 4: *. II L •

K i- f_ w, U) b,

:) m

U)

.A

L I I

w ._ •_ d

0 .J -- L _.

I..)

4(

k. II

Ig t

:) O

U) •

er .j

b 4[ I,d I_

_1 O Z 0

Z _ 0 NI 4[ I_ _

N

I

It

I

tq

W

a,

t_

t.-

ttJ

t_

w

,(

358

in

• I

L i

O

Id *

I- ,./

am _ 1,

N O

X

• ,u

m .1(

E

lq

"i !Zbw

, I-- w

I J _ •

_ Z 0 _ W

I I.. kl 4[ l? w Ik

N

Page 365: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

¢

O

¢

M

N

o

I

s

o

N

O

)-

0

.I

4(

W

E

L

I-

I-

¢D

I"

!-

0

,4

u

(J

E

W

E

E

0

u

w

m

g N

N •

• u

_OO--_MONODN_NOOmO

g,,,0,°,,°,°,,.0*

4 I_--NNNNMM_MM_

% IIl|lllllllll2

U

zi-

N

m

N

LI

L

o •

Q

Z

X

m

w

Juu

w

b. :Z

u

a.

u

o

o

m

I

II.

I:

Q

D

_0000000000000_00

&OOOOOOOOOOOOOOQO

o,0,°..10,0,,0.0.°

N N

01o

0

i

O

0

0

0

O

O

I , , l

o D

O

O

O

O

0

• io

o o cl o

-- i_ pI .1"

il I / I1' ]9NYH3 IHt_I ]H

359

0

31J133dll

O

o

o

N

_ o

o

_ o°

o

m I

o

m 2

o

o

b_

E

Page 366: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

o 4(

O u

M ,-Jr <

°iz

o

0

N

o X

u

.r

I,.-

M

0

.J

..J

bJ

][

8[

Q.

<

E

][:

<

o

Z

<

0

_J

.J

u

E

w

E

E

o

W

W

4(

m

w

,at

_v

w

.J

u

(J

P,.

o

i

IL

£

w

|

,4

r,

Q

o

< I

Ig 0

tl.

D <

I z

x 4[

u

z

L Z

4[

¢)

P4

_4

0

W

f,.) _ .

• "w

m,

u b • m Iig

U • 12 Q w

• Z 4v

i,b -- 4( f. g¢

gt _m Uw

_0

_0----

N

N

: °ME

Iq

(J _4

_, 4[ --

IJ' bJ 0 --

la _ lq --i_ i[ 0 1

I_ II: I I- --

I_I "i O _ Ill

1-- I_ • e ,.IZ li.

W rm * i-

oId • _ Z

36O

,J

4L 4[

m

I N

u_ m

o •

w

_O--

O_Z_

N_

M

m

m o m

N_

Page 367: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

<

N

x

1=1

N

0

.J

W

J

W U

U

I: o

I:

1:

I: U

.I[ •

_ O

0

Q --

n-

O

-I

ul

E

£

0

u

N

I

_ w

Z _

_Q_O_aOO_mN_IM_

|lllltlllill|ll

<

z

7o

LI

ul

IL

O

?

.,, ..... ,,.,.,,,.

ID

N

ii _ / | • ' ]ONVH=

361

£ HO I ,31't

O

, Io

+*

31,d133dS

1

C

0

0

0

0

__

0

0

0

0

0

m

o

3-

o w

Page 368: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

t

o

m

I

mr)

m

o

t

m

i

o

um

o

.#

-a

161

E

E

L

<

E

E

,1[

o

2,£

E

o

Q

Ig

o

-T

X

u

IIg

w

E

E

O

w

u)

m

E

N

U

x

u

Z

to

a

_th

w

o

#u

N

I

0

It

v

0

0

I

:)

q[

t-

Q

0

91

q[

b.

b.

0

I

x

M

0

.J N

.J 1D

4 a

w . wQ --

hi

• u

Ilm

M

• 0

(J iU

m

2) o W

W • ,J

•, ._• J

o

.m

NL

• e

" :2

o

X

E _

E

M

m • O

_m _

m_

362

m

L • w

m m

o

m m

O I

N X

m _

g4

• , 0 * gl

fJ W m _ in qJ

oJ m v _ M

W b. • * • -- t*J

I[ • I A n I-- I£

W Am 12 • -0 _ • W

'1[ O • L -- I[ • Z 'I[

I*. _ i- tit _ o- ul _ b.

Page 369: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

LIJ),- I._0 )-..J,4 *.

E a

E --

L

O o

_ °E --

E

4

O

U

W _

E --

E *

O W

U Z

2_

Q

4(

• o

Q

N

m

X

cJ

N

X

i-

bl

t.

: <1.+.

o 4

i,s

Z

z

o

w

:11

u

IIII

_oOooOooooooooOoo

_00000000000_0000

I

lo

T

0

.0

0

0

I0

0

O

0

0

0

lie ; I I • ' ]OHVHD

363

, I0

0

,LHOI]H

O

O

OIJl_3"dl

i

O

IO

411

I

Oo

o

411

,o

.11-

II

m

+O

l,-

a

i

o

IO

Page 370: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

14 m

! N

Jr

I

,z

o

I

N

U

Z

l-

lN

0

W

I,-

0 4[

j..

0 _

o Q

Z

0

ill .J ' 4[

)" u E

0 )- kb

-J u

< *- 0

td o )-

E o

L x

E

E (J

0 o

o_E --

E

<

0

U

,&

U

I

w _

Z _

r I

U Z

>.

Q

q

K

Q

W <

_ U

D O

-- I

auJ

Zt_

k_

m

0

.J

.J

4[

4.

V_

I-

Z

4(

(J

Z

*. 0

4

.J .

• 0

IL Z

0

M

M

0

W

U

E

W

m

D _

"N

D

o_Z_z

x

N M

I.- 0 I-

4 M '4

=) _[ . ::)

O 4[ _e Q

I,_ I,,,, II I*I

III III II _ Ic

I_ Q • I,- Id

_, ql Id I_ 41

_, ,,II Q Z 0 _ W

• 0 41 L -- E 4[

364

w

J •

* N

O I •

_ Z

_ Z Z_

._O_ X

mO--_ ZN

O_Z_

N_

O

M

_q

_4

o

41 -- •

kd 0 _ ID

• • 0 *

k, m , . •

I[ II _ I- II

• Id -- II

.

Q • I- *

V4_M_ MM

_QZO-- OZ

N_

N

I[

I-

!,.

4J

IS

Q

kd

_d

I-

Z

_J

(J

W

(J

b.

Page 371: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

ini

o

el

o

I

D

O

!

o

m

O

.J

.J

S

N

(hr.

4_

E

4(

Q

t:

Z:

i.,

E

M

d_

4.

X

W

Z

u

_ o M N g N m _ I _ • a _ m q N m'

_OmUIO_I_g_OWgOO_

O,,,,looo,.*m0***

.OOBDO_a_Oa_'_IIM

_ , , ' I 1 , I I I I "| i

4

I--

el

J.

I/)

W

I--

I.

0

0

¢)

A_

liJ

i6p ¸

).

6)

0

0

6)

*O

0

q

I"

a

w

0

6)

j-

0

_d

6)

IL

bOOOOOOOOlelOOmlelO

400OOODJOelDl_elO_

0o

o

n | n I

0

0

0

0

0

0

is i I Im* ]ONVHD

0

0

0

Io

II

I

IHOlln

0

0

0

3 I J.133dli

0

Icl

cl

0 °I1

o

0

o

ill

o

m

o

w el

o

0

o

Page 372: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I N

W _J

! m

m

O

I

N

m

"IT

i'*

q0

Jr

UI

.J

.J

E

aT

G.

<

E

E

,c

0

Ic

E

u

Z

E

K

G.

x

W

,I[

m

w

)-

o

o •

o ,4

o O

_J

Z

O

(J Ig '

4. Q

0 '(

X

0

I

o

o

|

C

4

0

.J

..J

L

Q

w

)..

wo"J ,J N

4[ O IJ

eL (J

41

O VD

4v) .J

• ,4 ,4

O

_d

q,j --.

4[ ,w fM

O[ -- Z

• "J bJ

In .J .J

• 0

.1

w ;_ .J .J _

4; W Z Z - 0

0 -i -- • _k Z _- II:

)41

N

E '4

4( q

!"

(J _4

I D O

, e

bJ dl 12 • • Z O

(.) • O -- -- *** iV

4[ O 4( -- 0. • IL *. I[

a* 0 t* • Lq w U_ U )-

366

O

O_--L

ooz_

m N

E E

U _ u

, o m

Z

L'_ Z-O_Z W

Page 373: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

!

b'l

Vl

qD

t

o

!

0b

o

o

nl

o

m

o

.i

.J

bJ

E

L

v"

E

0

E

E

0

W

E

W

L

L1

w

Q

4 u

_O--gOI_MDmI_mDNM_

4 ill||J_mN_t_ _

lll

'I'

Q

R

W

t.

0

U

o

o

I

21

_C

U)

0

I,-

0

bJ

Z

-r

U

N

W

3I

m

k.

IL

VO0000000000000_O_0000000000000000

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

, Io

0

II,

!

III t II ' ]ONVH3

367

LH0|]N

s

0

01_llO]dS

0

!o

I

0

N

O

u 4D

O

Q

oo0u

o

_r

o

4u

-- Z

Page 374: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

b'l

!

I1

41

e_

Q

I

¢n

o

!

N

o

).

0

.J

.J

t,J

I"

a:

0.

<

i-

v-

2,Ic

E

o

w

E

w

IL

x

w

w

<

I

IE

N

,1[

u

u

X

N

w

,.I

u

u

u

o

r_

I

o

o

t-

o

:)

E

<

0

(J

Q

a

Z W

0 _,

[

k- IdJ

U Ul

< I

n. 0

b. .J

Q <

/I

a:

x •

z

< o

IL Z

o

• o

_ J

_ J

o: 2, -2• Zl'--I

_<_--

o

Iq

• o

.J . _)

'( m I

4: _ Z O Z _

•J "* "0 _ _

o 0 _ I _ _ )-

X X

o I

_ lIP _ I

z _ _ Z

_ ZZ-O_ 0

U ZO_--_ U

368

.i

• I

- ¢O

w

_[

W o

u Iq

I I

a- .j

oL 0 Z

z _ 0

US

X

N

l

I-

<

u

I

D

u

w

I

W

)-

z

w

u

w

o

Page 375: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

q[

CJ

i.-

9[

(,.)

N

I.-

(V

=r

o

W tn

).* w

O ..J

.J u

4 u

tu *-

E o

A.

IC

IC

m U

Z o

E _

4 --

Q

<

U

p,.

z

L.I

w

a.

x

W

!

E

lld _

m D

U_

Z !"

K

o

JllliltlJ

Q

o

Z

_(

3:

u

)..

..r

(:7

t_J

cJ

b.

W

O.

Us

o..,.,,..o.,,...,

O

OI

@

O

O

@

O

O

o

0

I

ilu_ /6_ ' _lONVH 3 *HOI_IH

369

o

o

o

I

01,:J i 03dS

@

0

. 0

O

o

.l"

D

4D

Page 376: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

m

@

J

M

O

0

!

m

0

I

N

0

m

).

0

.J

.J

W

It

E

L6

It

X

O

E

E

0

U

l

W

a.

X

W

N

7

X

T

p,.

N

,LI

o Q

N

0

k_

U E

o. O

0 •

Ig

X

0

0

r_

!

It

D

!

£

Q

w

Ig

LL

10

0

J

8.

U)

Z

4, 0

• O

L 7

m

0 l,,.

Iq 4

• E

14

•+4 t,J

o m

Id _ In (J

q.) _ N

4 '_ t.,+

L_ * • i*J

8" _ l mr

_J O _J

LO J _

Z

a _ L.Ig J u

W _ • N Be W

9[ • le _ m +,J

b. _ • *. _" Ik "1[

I[ I.- 1,.) )... I_ b.

• lU

IS W o

• J N • m

.J • >.

• I I

. :g :kJ o e *_" -J E iJ

_ LU • N k_

L w Z _l 0 •

o .J _ L "-- _ IL

o 0 Z US • _) k8

m o

4.) N N --o4

L_ I -- •

I[ I _ |

" : 2:

.J • J

• _ Z O • Z

Z 0 _ *" --

0 < -- 8. *. Z Ik

0 )- Z Ii) CJ _ _lJ

370

• le

IR W

li N •

- *g

*. (J W •

• W • 3[

0 0 • M Z

N

41

'4

L_ o kJ

C.) M •

¢[ ).

E i

,,." g

o :_ .J

I. 41 k,J II *

• Q • O •

Z N 0 el v

N

N

E

4[

I[

Cj •

m

im

U

O

W

w

,..J

k_

l.J

Page 377: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

U

N

.r

i-

ra

m

N

l,-

Ill

W

0

0

U)

bJ

Ut .,J

u• J U

.J

• h

Z o

,4

Z

E _

0 o

Z --

E

<

u

.J

u

m

w

E

E

o

u

I

IL

W

w <

<

ID o

o

Z _

m

u

gl**°,°,,,,**ll,,

.Qag_megaomNB_

i||1|111|

bOOOOOOOOOOOOOQO0

_0000000000000000

4

0

w

(D

Z

4(

.r

U

w

u

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

8e # / II 8 ' 3@NVfl O J. HOI3H OIJII3]dS

371

0

0

o

41:

w

t-

Page 378: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I II

m ,it

i..

iii u

M I,m

8" 41

D l--

l W

ill

I

4U

I.I

X

l-

m

O

N

11

31-

0

J

,A

4

W

lc

L

4

E

ql

0

E

r

a

,4

U

U

E

W

E

0

U

W

m

W

-I

u

),.

L.I,

AI

o

o

+l.J

0

I

L

g

_J

0

0

I

4

Q

O

• 4d

0 ),

m

IE o

k. .J

Q •

O.

E

X <

U

Z

_ o

,.J m

,.j _

_ o

• z

41

0

Iq

Iq

_4

0

kJ

_ w

p,_ ..J

° ;E

Id *, • Iq I[

_J LI 0 4) --

• Z N

_. ,.* 9[ *. i[

I[ _- CJ i-

.J

,I

LC

II. <

L0 o

I lq

UP

Im am

0 i

II ii

4,1

.J -I

b a W

41 • Z

0 8: Z m

372

.J

m

o gq

IJ

0 an

u

4d

.J .J

*. II W

,am < Z

i 0

O 0 -- L

Q gC •

N 8.

Page 379: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

NI

41

m

I

Jr

o

i

o

!

0 1

_J

5_

O

01

N

_J

161

UI

el .I

lJ- U

0 )-

.I U

...I

if I,,

E cl

4.

l-

w- u

+ :

E

4:

U

..d

,4

W

IE

uA

E

E

O

i

L

E

m ¢J

,<

B o

a

- !

<

O

1.5

,E

,iZ

L_

Z

O

u

ul

3

a.

ffl

N

v

_O_ON_IM_B_mB_mN

OOOOBImBOO_O_RKm_

!lllilll

voO0oO000oO000O00

_oo0o0000o0000000

o

0

iul Ilu ' "aONVH3

373

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

I

cl

I

,I, HO l ]ll

0

0

:)l _1103d|

0

0

0

i i ,

I

II

O

O

O

O

gU

;C

k-

I

O

Page 380: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N!

I

T'*

O

I

M

O

I

OI

N

o

14

>.

0

./

J

,4

id

X:

m

I

8.

4(

r

!"

,i

¢9

IC

IC

4[

0

F..

U)

<

u

/

,4

u

E

IC

l.,

0

ca

I

m

<

U

Vt

Ia

m

Z

I-

o

m

nJ

ILl

L

N

in

w

.J

u

4.)

o

u

o

13

N

I

L

Z

m

U

o

o

I

Q

0

I

o

E

t

x

Q

W

)

.E

w

I

o

..I

.J

IL

u

Z

8 _

.J _

.J _

• o

4. Z

,4

o

IV)

III

o

W

(J w

L_

=) kJ

In .J

Q

bl t, 4( Im I

U • Q O --

Z N

W

J

oow

Im_

0 Im

4_ IZI

IO_

o_Z_mZ

N

I 4

i- o

4[ Iq

I=

;q

M o

U w O

42 < 0 "$

kl b_ El .

I I I I',

Z ,-'

W 12 • _.

1.4 • _ Z 0 • v

4[ 0 4( IL -- Z I

k. O ).- In 4[ v _.

X x

I I

I 0 _ , M I

4 O(k--IZ_--k---- <

.I

,,.4

IL •

I_ If)

O II

b

ILl

*J .J

*. m kd

VII 4 Z

m O

O er • m

N n

4[

I,_ I

I m

0

I ,.J

374

Page 381: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Tm

o

#

o

J

o

)

N

o

)-

0

.J

,J

Id

E

L

4

IC

IC

q(

m

4(

s-

4(

B.-

qf

4(

m

kJ

Z

E

0

w

4(

_m

4 u

u moDB_lo_M_wMamog

N

0

O0

N

N

w

I-

o

o

o

w

W

.J

U

u

_J

D

Q

o

N

!

L

J:

p-

O

D

!

hi

Z

u

m

Z

u

L

bO0000_OOO0000"_OO

_0000000000000000

_O--_O_O_O0_O_O_O0

. . i i

Q

Q

0

o

, I0

0

T

ii w O / | I ' _mONYHO

• 375

0

.0

O

o

0

o

_I, III I 3N

o

o

0

o

oQ

_ III

N

0

.I'

0

N

0

0

- :

I,

8

r

N

Page 382: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IoIOI

o

I

I

N

o

I,,+

O

J

J

I+J

Ii-

IIC

0.

E

IC

4

Z

E

U

W

E

E

0

U

u

Z

o

m

+..

.c

o

o

tIJ

-I

u

4.)

o

I

IL

l-

m

u

r,

I

Cl

Q

Z I+1

O :D

_ a

_ Q

Q •

IL

t z

u

i. o

.J u'p

,,J .

_ 0

L ='

X

N

o I-

i13 4[

E

4L)

o ID

< I GI

k. l.J

I[ + E

U) ..I I,-

+ Z

•-,+ _ m_ u

, : < o.,..U + I*,I

< Z II _ 0

L _ < *,. g <

_I: I-- (,J I" It.+

D U)

IJ)

,.J

.,.I

<

IL <

IA O

I/l

O I

U

kJ

.J .,J

I. m I*I

m 0

¢) 0 -- L

o 8[ • _)

-- G.

X

N

I_ I-.

M <

11-

III

U

o m

bJ O O _ (,J

< • 0 "_ 0

b. m _ -- W

mr l II I,- _

I/_ e il • ,,,J I.,,.

b. _ Z

•. < l,+J t_ 4.) I_

•m GI _r 2[ * _ IU

376

..J

.I

U_ m

m

0 I

I[

.J J

m 0 -- G.

o ,t, Z U)

N L

41

O

m m

X

/4 •

!"

14

_4 U

w _ W U

1 0 ).. >- 0

* _ !- Q I.-. W

I.- II

"- o. + o ""2 ;

o ; ; ; -m .i • .J U

_,. • bJ _" U I_ * W Ill *

_z (2 Z w * 0 "! Z 0 "! bJ

0 4[ IL -- I_ Z _- _ G. -- -- <

O I-- 4/) Z _- _ U Z U) • Z b.

Page 383: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

4[

(J

x

z

k-

0s

N

_J

In

td

m ,.J

)- (J

O )-

.J _J

.J

< i.

Z o

eL

w-

E U

4I •

E _

E

ID

U

J

U

E

W

E

Z:

O

I

L

E

m Q

0

I

Z _

%u

#,.o,0.00..0,.,,.

% Illll|lll

4

4

t-

'4

Q

Id

I

Z

<

:=

ta

w

w

n

_0000000000000000

400000000000_0000

| I I i i

0

, i ,I

¢_ o

!

0

llll I i I I ' 3GNVH3

377

0

0

1HO I 31,l

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

i

0

0

I0

o

I

31JlgldS

OQ

O

IU

O

I

bl

m

k,-

Page 384: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

AI E

o •

I

I0 LJ

°!o"!

o X

U

N

Z

k..

LV

gt

nJ

Ul

).

O

.16

.J

q

LL

i*

M

I[

8.

T-

IC

(D

I"

r

(D

.4

(J

..J

0

I[

I[

E

0

4J

kd

U_

m

s.

oo

o

o

o

o

J,b

M

O.

Z

U

o '

o

J

Q

Q

Z

0

*.* C

*- W

U •

• •

g 0

..J

0 •

IL

I

IMI •

u

k.

Z

b 0

,,.J .

• 0

i. Z

0

m

A

0

M

W N

W

VS _L

Q

w 4, • II me

U ,m 0 0 --

J

lid 0

; I,l

Ut aid

0 II

IIC •

l,J •

141 *

.J .J

• II I*/

Lp • •

Lll O **,

LD O -- L

• E • •

,', IL

• N

ql I[

• M •

IC * I_

14

U _ LJ

m M am

• ' * • S

ej bl • • m (J

0 4 * 4) _e •

Id b. • • _ " W

:) • • _ b,I W

Illl • "o • ._ I.*

ki' 0 * (*- W

L) E: ,.J _ • :D L_

$, • L*JL W 4.) •

Id a; 0 • • • _ W

• • • • L _" • • •

h. • I- CJl MI • _ I- k.

378

4

0

.J ',,4

.J --

,4 •

W "

ell 0

M

0 I.-

• • • 0

4) O -- -- • *_ Ig

• I • • w U i--

IU L

0

IP4,

M

4[

W 0 M

M

• ' _ 0

Ig I _ )-

UI • .I •

• • W

• Q •

W Vl bJ

L _ L

I

o': gR

. ;ar (j L_ PD* I*J *

-- • O • 3[ O •

GD • • -- I[ • *. -- L -- --

• )" M • _ _ LJo • I1• • Z

eV

)L

IC

_J

N

II

(J

Q

W

i[

W

)-

Z

bJ

W

O

Page 385: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IQ

m

Q

a

cl

I

M

I

N

m

W

),.

0

.J

bJ

E

M

a.

L

]C

¢[

E

I1"

¢[

0

D

W

E

0

#..

0

:[

.J

(

U

I[

t*J

E

1:

0

Ia

m

<

a

g

(a

I-

4[

X

(J

T

i-

N

Ill

W

t-.

i.

p..

o q[

Q

N Q

Z

<

Z

w

U

U _

u

W

cJ

Q

P

W

0

T

w

o

o

P

I

N

u

-OONM_B_U_IONmO_

ltlIIIIIIw_MNN

Illtl

::::°:':::°::::::o . o...,,,0.,..,.,,..

v

0

o

0

o

o

o

o

o

o

II tl II ' )ONyHO

379

o

0

i i i i i |

,I, HOI IH 01,11101dl

0

m

I_b

0

N

I

0

4)

N

o

o

eD

0

s.

Id

Z

m

Page 386: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Lr

!

o

m

In

i

m

4.j

i

N

o

m

).

O

.J

.J

E

w

8.

<

me"

E

O

IC

E

O

Q

X

I

O

Z

Z

.I

u

E

hi

E

O

u

l

4

IJ

N

X

m

T

o

N

w

l-

a,.

.IE

Q

N

O

w

u E

u k.

h. Q

x

u

O

D,-

qlm

i

O

w

o

o

I

Q

W

I

O

J

8.

W

N

*. O

_ N

.J _

4[ O

IL •

In

0

• 4(

lid in 0

4[ , .

b. • •

• O |

In •

Q

0

b,

4

u_JP a • eL *

• • IS _ lU _ O --

b. _ • *- • -- '8. Q., •

D InIn

1,4

O .1;*

• M

v• N

:)

Ill

-* N

.J

L e

• j.a

w •

I,,. U fedo

,-f O _ ae

I .J _ • •

0 O • In 4.1,

N .

• 4[

k- O

• Pl

N

m

• . o

:) 4[ ,M

qF,,IO" _ • ,m

• 4[ * • •

W I*. • * m

Id _ all, , M ,_

I-. In anus ,.,j •

• m t*.

161. a_ . I... *

• _ _ •

e., • W gq0 _ L)

_,J • M 18 _ -- •

• I:) • • -- • Z'--

O _ In 4[ I,,. _ •

38O

L T

• 4

In In

0 e

OO--.

O_ZM

NL

; Je- o

• pl

N

U vlm

"_ 4[ --

W b. •

• 41: i *

bl _ • id

P.. q_ • ..J

I*f a * I.-

0 i[ J

4_ • M W i[

4[ O • -- • I[

b. 0 I,.. `4 M 8--

N In

M

IK

8-

4[

m

(J

Q

_.J

)-

_m

u

w

(J

b.

Page 387: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

O

!

m

d

_V

O

!

;4

I

_V

O

g

)-

0

.J

.J

lid

E

N

K

E

E

m

E

i:

0

0

W

0

3

Z

il

t

E

oW

I

4(

U

p,

¢8

X

W

m

i.

I[I

m

Ill

Ill

o

o

o

o

w

.J

u

u

i,

J

o

o

u

o

o

I.

Z

w

o

I

D

o

r_

i

IC

UJ

0

U

M

_O_OI_mIDB_DIID_

mooO_mMaI_R_B_M

41***it,t,ie*****

* m _ _ m 0 m _ _ M M B • _ • D _

il'lllllllll|

k-

4[

O

bi

4P

4

4J

bl

L

_O_O_OOO_OO_OO

_OOOOOOOOO_OOOOOO

Io O

I I

0

e II o Ill ]ilNVNO

381

0

,, II

!

,I, HO I IH

0

0

O.

0

O14811|dli

0

0

0

! L

0

I.¢1

!

.

0

0

0

Q

a

°

o

o

Page 388: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I!

I

0

I

N

O

i

M

N

O

W

).

0

.J

.J

Id

E

L

E

E

<

O

E

E

Q

E

O

3

O

Z

U

E

E

o

U

W

I

I

W

N

X

N

Z

m

N

N

W

f.

,R

o° ,,

e-,

o

m

IA (.-

u ef

L

u

4. o

J

o )-

o ,(

x

o

o

I"

o

r.

i

o

o

r-

!

Ic

0

o

et

_d

m

o

.J

J

<

L

<

u

m

Z

• O

L 7

i

o

M

M

o

_ w

l A

N

°ee

I.I a _ 0 -

m

N

m

I

D

I.)

O

Id

4 4

k'l O

,J N _ ek

4 I O ,"

I I IN"

• w Z O Z

_J _U _ N0•

a. | | i-

• # ,e

Q

a_ .j .j e

• Q • •

4

o

/4

o

5n

Id

.,J

m

I-

It Iq II

0 0 -

382

N

N

I

t-

I

¢J

N

I

t_

Q

ha

I

td

bl

t#

bd

4

b.

4

OO_

W

a_ i,-

4; Q

N

• l

o I-

_r

_q

vl _.1

• o m

• 4 _ 2;

O O _ f,J

I • bJ

I- t*l

.J ,J --,

Z • 0 0 -- L.,

< • -- G. 8. ** -- I 4

N

Page 389: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

1"I19I0Ir'.

o

J

M

I

t_

o

w

$11111

4

U

Z

W

0

m

0

.J

.J ut

4( L,J

.J

W U

9_

O. 6-

!" o

I"

IC

E U

0 Q

o

0 --

W _

lg

0

.,.I

,1(

(,J

!"

0

_ 0

Ul a,

,4

4i o

o

- i

o

Z

m

_0000000_00000000

_0000000_00000000

o,.,.,_0.0,,.,..,

0

0

0

o

0

0

0

0

0

IO

iii

0

|

iI t / I I' ]|IIIVH_ ,LFt|| |!I

383

0

0

0

Io

0

• 0

I

0

0

c;

o

0

_d

0

e.

W

k-

Page 390: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

_O

t

f_

o

I

p4

I

o

ul

3-

0

.J

Ld

Z:

Iv

O*

'I(

£

I"

9(

(D

X:

1-

,1[

(D

0

w

t_

0

.J

Ic

£

L_

M

,i[

x

u

o

_d

r_

W

e-

6

o

o

rU

W

.J

U

(,I

_c

U

o

o

C)

Q

Z W

0

_ m

b.

_ J

_ j

Q.

I

x •

u

z

A _

.J m

_ 0

_ Z

Q

M

o ,

W -- in

U _ N

_. • CO

O[ g

° ;

_ m

,N

" J2

_¢ • II:

I.- Is t-

4 M •

I: IC

M

r.t _4 _J

m N o m

U lid if) w _ O

(J N lit 8.

O _ O >- _ GI

Z b. _ _ •

4J er .I • I_ :2 (J

kJ • [2 Z O * :3 _ IdU Z O _ N -- _ _ L_

384

Page 391: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

8[

M

9[

U

k"

'4

)-

a.

¢:)

w

m .J

u

J

I'. oN

4.

E

r U

4[ i

0 0

°oE _

E

41

J

u

m

w

E

£

0

u

!

O.

E

k-

_ u

z _

9[

I"

Q

w

0

Z

Z

u

l-

ID

W

k.

U

w

Q.

u

_O--NOOIOmN_Omm_NN

ooMm_o_M_mooMm_

_ooo ooo_

4 III1_

'

_00000000000000_0000

_0000000000000000_00

.,....,. ..... .,.°.*,

0

0

0

000

000000

o

0

I I Io o o

I m

i" + Ilm' 3ONVHO J,+HOI )H

385

31 .1113]dli

0in

o

o

i*)

i,--

0o

Page 392: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

18

idi

I

o

t

o

I

N

o

IJ

)-

0

.J

.J

*4

E

L

I[:

0

I1"

d[

U)

U

J

u

E

W

Z

0

U

(1)

•,

m

K

w.)

N

7.

ca

z

¢..

0

I0

M

N

I+1

I.-

i.

0

0

o

f.)

o

I

8.

E

u

o

o

|

Q

0

). LJ

W

II[ 0

.J

-- .j

0 <

l

x <

u

2

• 0

• Z

<

o

M

O

m

_,a w

I[ *

W I, < Ill I

g • Q 0 --

9[ 1, N

I[ *- U *-

U)

0

.J i_ ¸

m

I* m

0

kl

• I_ Z 0

0 J _. *. --

o 0 I/) _ •

N

N

I[ •

I- o

0 Iq

• r. o

14 k. I--

I[ I[

b_ _ • kJ

t- 40 r'* ,J

Z *

I/ *. =)

td • GI 0

_J • N N --

< a _ I. -- II

b* 0 I- _,) * I_

0

M

Iq

• o ,

,J 0 '_

,I[ • -- * m

IL I I- _ I

• .J

4; _ Z 0 * _ Z

0 .J -- IL • • I[ L

0 0 • _M IJ _ _-

X

u

E < •

• o m

I Ill _ I

m_

386

Page 393: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

lU

lid

M

I

0

I

O

0

I

o

m

N

U

i.i

p-

)-

Ih

W

I-

0

o

m

p- bJ

0 .J'

..,8 u

.j )-

9[ tj

IlJ

_ Q

IIg O

L

41

Z

E

<

O _

E 0

E Q

0

U

.J

I-

Z

W

E

Iv

ul

X

W •

U

0

*

r_

I

o

o

w !

m =

ql

- o

N

v

_o_m_m_omwMoB_momDm

Nt*e_eo**_e4_t#me#e

|Jl|l|

q

I,-

Q

Id

Z

,(

Z

U

w

L

_00000000_0000000000

JO0000000OO00_OOO000

0 o0

00

0000

00

' 0II;

0

I

0

0

0

0

i i

0

, 1

i

leo Ill' ]ONYHO ,i. HOI ]H

387

| i i

OI dl.O]dli

0

i i

0

0

#

o

o

In

Q

t'!

:r

o

o

3"

ID

o

o

o

N

t.

4s

Id

I[

N

(,-

Page 394: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

!

0

M

i

o

J

O

o

i

N

o

m

0

.J

.J

.c

bJ

IC

M

K

L

E

E

0

E

E

.I

,1[

La

E

I

W

II.

X

W

m

N

X

Z

m

Ir

W

,J

Q

Q

Z

0

w

_ E

.ll

I

x

U

o

M

U

0

p.

I

o

o

!

E

W

0

u

0

t_

K

II

0

.J

J

L

u

1.

.,,J _

J --

L •

IA

_ E

0 _-

E

M

0

D

..J I..-

_J ,s m 0 _ bJ

o

0

_0

0

_J _q t

aa

,.J i.

,1_ r, 0 Z

Z IV _ N

N m

m

N

• i

0

_ ZO

M M

N N

_ o _

E E

M

Z _ Z

_ ZO_

388

Page 395: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

I

M

o

I

a

p

o

m

0

E

M

L

<

E

Q

u

u

w

E

0

Z

q

U

m

I

o

o

Q

o

o

o

u

o

o

o

o

o

M

!

L

E

w

0

a

4

O

W

X

u

W

G.

ii!

!

Ii

o

0

I L I

: °0! m

I

lU J / I w* ]eN¥H:* +HOI]H

0

31dlO3dll

0

0

389

i

0

.......

o

o

o

rid

Q

Q

f,

0

o

Page 396: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

!

Ill

tit

8"

I

o

$

Jr

o

I

N

o

D-

O

.J

.J

w

1"

w

8.

,4

1.

I-

0

4(

E

!"

4[

o

<

u

.J

4

u

i.i

E

E

o

u

mJ

tw_

m

l

N

N6_

m

4

m

X

m

X

Q

N

w

p..

L.

o 4[

l--

O

o

-- Z

O

m _

u Ig

u _

q. Q

m

. i

A

I

a.

E

I

Q

W

Ub

m

0

J

.J

<

I).

;4

q

u

Z

.J _

'4 O

L •

x

N

,I[ E

M

o Is

b. td

m .J

Z

4[ i[ ¢4 _ _J

b* _ 4( k. ar 4[

O_ I*- L;) _" L*.

D

U)

0

W

g[

U_

m

0

J

J

Z

o

_ z

X

• l[

0 )'-

I[

14

_4 (J

f8

_J _L! M

b. 49 -- bJ

iL _ Z

c*L * p _,t

• G, • 0 - _ W

Z _ IV -- _ (J

0 < _ ,- Z I¢ 4[

0 I'- I_ t.,) _ ¥" la.

'4

0

;4

;4

**4

0

4[ ",'

0

.J "_

• I0

J

O --

4 kl Z O w

o

Iq

Iq

o

4

W o _*

(J Iq

4[

I,. m

_ .J

° ;I1_ .J

39_

J

L <

o

0 I

]4 x

LY • a.

)-- 0 0..-

,4 P) •

M

kJ If. ID -- W

_" I[ i I-- _ 8[

I;J Z) 0 _ bl W

hi • 0 Z * 0 0 -- 16

4[ 0 • O. Z -- *- I_ 4(

o

.j

L I I-

hl

_. U U

U

Q

Page 397: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

!

OI

14

_r

i

iq

z

o

i

r

o

qD

W

)-

0

.J

..D

<

W

;L

4[

I:

!-

,(

0

E

I[:

0

U)

U

.J

U

w

W

E

I:

0

U

kJ

m

g

m

/J

N

)-

X

i-

ra

0

U_

W

)-

¢:1

0 0

Z

,11

T

Ul U

W

U --

W

_ uO _

ut

II.

U

O

10

I

IL

E

,(

(.)

_00000000000000000000000000000000

_0000_0000000000000000_0000_00000

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

, I I I•1" 14 i_l -,

0 0 0 0

@0 0

0 o

0

80 o0

0

i

o

I_o / I1' |_HVHO /HO I ]_ 31.tl :)]dS

391

o

o

o

0

o

r-

o

o

o

ha

E

Page 398: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Jm

M

j-

!

I

o"l

o

).

O

.J

.J

,1[

LJ

sr

0.

][:

E

4[

o

E

]c

O

u)

.J

,4[

o

4[

w

E

E

o

o

_J

u)

4[

I

B

N

x

o

.T

gl

o

N

I-

L

ac

o

W

.J

i.

U

4p.

!

il.

r

<

o

o

o

I

D

,4

)m

¢:1

a

Z

O

*" Ill

ffl

• m

E 0

L_

O •

I

z

,,J _

IL Z

W

W

U

D

Q

W _ < m

• Z_

D

.J

.J

!

Ul

o

U

w

.J

4(

O

O [ •

x

O[ 4(

r

14

m o

(.) _j

U

4[ 1

W _ W

N

W '_ Q O w

(_ Z iV N

4[ O 4( _. n"

k. O _" U )-

O

W

i[

(4

ID

O

.J

In

b,.

z

o o

_ z

°M!-

;4

m o

:D

u

Z

392

,,J

4[

8.

a

_a

_. u -

._ w

o ..J m

o 0 •

In o

N

°E

N

m o

Q

Id

w

m

0

.J

/

u

u_

o

o o

o z

N

I"

m o

D

U b.I

U w

bJ _.

_I _m W

N

W a I-

U Z N

b. O _" U t-

O

m

X

N

I

_m

E

U

N

m

D

CJ

m,"

W

_D

Page 399: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

8[

N

,4

(J

I-

4[

I-

W

Ul U)

oJ u

I-

G.

9[

1-

]C

4I

!-

,1(

¢D

U

J

w

v-

w

a.

X

D

!

0

0

I,d J

m E

tJ

-- 0

Z U

0

W

_9

Z

4(

_r

U

w

G.

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

o 8

0

0

8

I I

o 0

ii#m m I|o' _lONVl'i3 ,I. HOI ]H 01..,11 :|d|

393

ID

m

la,

I11

.11'

.o

o

D

,1l

E

N

Page 400: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

N

!

II

M

!

o

m

o

0

o

m

w

E

L

E

o

,1[

Q

u

,J

m,

w

L

x

w

E

u

N

x

,T

N

N

w

o

w

w

.J

U

o

o

u

o

I0

o

I

o

o

!

i-

<

V)

0

u

Q

O

z tu

O

I.- Isl

U

4[ II

E O

t**

t,. j

O •

8.

)- Ut

a_

X <

U

X

b 0

.J In

4 0

U

,(

E

D

uJ

D

E

w L. < mq

ou ,18 n

Z gw

D _0

X

N

Z

U

m

m

D

a

I

z

u

w

<

bmm

Q

w

m

0

.J

.J

L

_t

l-

(J

t,.

Z

M

o.

o O

Z

Id

O

b.

II:

D

O

I[

*. • 19

a o O

Z

o • *,.

o )- (J

X

I*.

4

k)

N

II

D

_J

Q

bJ

a,

td

u

u

<

Q

Id

id

tn

II

O

.J

,J

IL .

I-.

_J

b.

Z

** (D

_n

:oN Z

1(

M <

•4 (J

o II

D

• ,e Q

bJ w

Z

Q )- bJ

I[ _ U

Q 0 w I_

Z Itl N U

3_

iA

.A

L

U_

Q

w

8.,.

k. U

•.J O

o o Z

W

U

,l[

b.

Jr

D

M

Q

I[

6* • IN"

•_ Q O

• m

m _

.I

• m

Q

W

_.. .j

o -I 8.

N

Ig •

a o

W

_ m a

U Z _ _

if. 0 _'- (.) I'-

X

M

r

m

m

D

_J

Q

W

IC

W

w

u

<

Page 401: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in is

14 u

| ,.,

wl i-

o i-

Ji.

o

i

iu

4)

z

l-

ca

ru

itl

ru

kJ

@*

i.

D

u)

w

u_ .J

). u

0 _'

E

E --

L

,II

E

0 O

E --

%:

U

J

U

E

W

Ig

O

o

m

_ O

m ul

_ 0

Z _

Q

lid

¢0

Z

Z

U

1"

(0

W

"I

U

0.

ul

u

_om_BMm_m_

mommmo_BmQ

I1_ _I¢¢_#

.,.....,.*

0

0

0

0

o o

o

I

lm I /Im' ]_HVHO LH01"IM

395

0

o

I

_ I .'1 I Oldli

0

o

0 °

o

m

o

o

- _,

_ ._

- _

o

o

o

@-

Page 402: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

! N

;4 CJ

_J

,1;"

O

I

U

Z

)..

I

OS

_4

M

rd

m

o

,J

.J

w

E

g_

it.

]c

E

o

IC

E

<

<

u

J

u

I

w

E

E

o

ILl

'4

R

kl

I,

O 4["

O O

I

0

W J"

_ U

U E

: °.I[

I

X

I.)

o

I(I

m

o

w

I'-

|

I--

lld

• IU

4[

ID W

•.J _ 41.

m

L •

Q _

" ;t, U W 14

4 W Z 3 O

• J 0 .,I -- 6. -- '

400 • U) Z IJ

m

4[ II:

O ).*

IC

M

_4 g

N

o •

4[ -- D

U leJ Iq

• O 5n Q

_6. g _ kd

I t l- _ gl:

D _ _ kd t._

b. _ Z

O ° I=. Id

(J • '_ Z O • _ *,-*

,.* U)

m

396

Page 403: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

z

o

I

N

o X

(J

Z

0t

e,)

i-

1.9

w

I.-

r,.

o

(3

c:l

.J

)- e,J

O )-

.J U

..J

8

E

L

E

E U

4

._ .E --

E

<

<

U

4[

U

E

!.

0

U

Q

N

_J r',

(/t i

to

ID O,d

5"

Z

o

_OBa_MDD_rD_mW_O

illllllt

4

(

t-

(

Q

W

O

Z

,i(

CJ

L_

.i

_J

b.

(J

W

O.

U)

kOQ_OOOOaOOOOOOQO

_OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

0

0

O

0

0

0

O

0

O

ga, S / I e, ' ]0NIFH0 LHO I 3/'t

o "

I

:_lJJ33dS

397

0

0

0o

o

0

N

o

Page 404: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I N

.1" <

I*l O

I N

Jr

o

I

N

o X

u

-r

I..-

M

3,-

O

,.1

.I

91

W

E

I[

Ik

E

0

E

<

U

.J

U

W

E

w

o

o

o

w

w

.1

u

t.

o

u

o

o

m

0

I

E

N

Q

0

Z

0

i-

u

,<

m.

tO

K

!

x

+

o

..I

4[ II -

8. I l-

w

_,. u w lq

_ w z 0 -

--_j M 0 _ 141 --O .J -- O. I. Z

X

N

< m

0 I,,,

I"

II)

U

I_I O m

< _ "l 0

k,. Ol I-- I+4

.J I,-

_ N Z

°" 1;

U _ 4[3 • O 3 -- W

• Z N O 114 _ _ U

k, 0 +_ 0,. _ I,, -- m <

4U U)

398

Page 405: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M

i

10

I

O

N

o

¢

1,4

#

tIJ

o

W

3.

0

.t

.I

,t

_J

8.

_C

<

Q

%

E

E

O

a

_J

E

0

I-

0

.J

U

W

0

Z

me

m

X

W

Z

b.-

Q

N

e-

j-

Z

Z

W

U Z

N

w

Jc

o

U

W

dL

U

o

d_

I"

_r

1.0

i

O

N

r"

I

<

m

0

U

t "

e

u

_OO_mN_O_

_OS_D_Bm_2

liiil

OOOOO:OOOOOOOO OOO

O

O

)

O

O

I ! i

m

I

_e t I _ in,o )IONVH3

3_

O

,I.HO I 3_

0

0

I , !

0 o

M

0o

o

o

m

o

O

o

lid

Q

b_

E

N

Page 406: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

¢0

I

o

o

I

I

N

o

Ul

oJ

W

E

L

<

E

E

O

I,-

£

<

0

Q

w

Ir

0

3

Z

J

u

m

E

!"

O

m

g

,1[

u

X

u

7..

I-

i

_o

N

GJ

I-

o

u)

laJ

)-

(J

u

I

o

N

f_

I

IC

Ul

0

u

4(

Q

Z

0

er

b.

0

E

I

X

0

Iq

III

*v4

¢0

.J

J

W

Q. U _ E

4 W 0

L U

o

P7

**4

o

w _

4( _e

, IM

_[

_J m _J

U N I_.

4[ * _-

s. 4[ Iq hJ *

,I Q 0 Z 21

X X

_ ° _-M •

E E

M

U ,,_ ¢.)

N _ m

U W 0 kJ _ (_

Q 4[ • 0 )" 1, Q

W b. gD -- I- W

W _ a -- . _ taJ

W GI - - e I- WU I[ .J o ]C _) U

W _ ¢2 0 ar • :Z w _d

U Z 0 IW U

4( 0 _[ -- *. IL • -- I[ •

40O

Page 407: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

III

O

I

N

I

m

I

N

0

_J

N

Z

t-

o

N

t_

td

,c

Ut rU

).

0

.J

.4 tO

.J

L,i (j

E )-

E

E o

E

E

E _

Q --

Ig

0

3

,,,,I

Ig

W

I:

I:

0

!

Q

Odd O

_ D

<

m I:

W

u

_O_N_Oa_N_MN_O_M_

i,o,+,,,o.,o,o,,o

|_N__N_ _

_ IIII NNNN__tllllll|

,4

I-

W

Z

4(

-r

4.,)

(.'7

k*J

(.I

L*.

(_

b.I

n

U)

O O OO. OO

°0o.o,0,_o°,o..,.

i

i

I

JJ

O

o

G_

O

O

O

O

0

I

0

o

ire O / I e _ 39HYH:)

401

0

J, HOI3H

0

0

Io

o

o

N

I

OlllO|dI

0

0

, 0

0

Io

0

0

o

4o

tO

o

_P

Page 408: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

M sT

! N

in

ID u

°ill i,,-

i Ul

I

Illt

It tl

u

7

o

M

0

J

W

E

IK

I.

E

E

<

O

E

E

<

_D

1o

Z

u

E

w

E

E

o

u

W

m

w

i-

t.

o

to

w

U

u

.n

u

s

I

o

N

I

E

,4

0

u

ill

0

-i,

,0

,S4

II.

l,b

GI

!

X

0M

0

_m

e W

a

_WZO--

Q

• o

Ig .J D

D _

D

M

• • N O

*

I[ 4( •

)- o I,..

i- _

i o 411

W b. m --

_ D _ _ W W

W 12 • _ IdIg .I • U

L_ _ Q Z 0 " _ _J

• N

o

.A _ L

..11 • >.

• i

ill m •

• 0

0 *

_.. .J

_,J W * M

• w • • O

,.i 0 _ w le

O 0 • US Z 161

• am

o ,-IT

P_

_4 ¢J,

N

o m

4[ _ D

4A _ e$

b. • -- W

k. _ Z

0 _" I- bl

I ./ • _ U

41 O Z * 0 _ I*l

• 0 _ -- 41 _ _,$

o • - • z _ I <

0 t- I I_ + U )"

M

Page 409: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

OI

ar

#

m

No

)M

#N

D

us>.0.a..I4

t,dE

I[a.

q(Icr4(0

EX:4{

QbJ

O:O"1'

OZ

.J4(

UKbJ

EQU

W

<

B

4

t,;

j-

M

w

Q

Q

°Qo

w

.Ju

o

ueoc_o

Sr.

aP

i

Nr-!

=0

wou

m

u

oom_oM_mwoQ_mM_oom_

Iti|ltll

Q

Id

Z4(..ru

I...-ro

_J

b.

(J

ut

_o+O0oooooooO_ooooooOooo_ooooooOooOo_Oooooooooo

_*+*+°_,+.*+++°+,+°.++*l_

09

00

COIOIol(10

0

00

Io

m

I

0

0

0

0

iii /11' ]lINYM= IH+ I |H

4O3

I i

oIn

!

0 I.III 3"adli

0

I

ira

A

0 oIll

0

10

.11"

Cl0.lr

N

0

Q

i.8o

ILll:

I.-

Page 410: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

B

!

_r

r.

I

i

o

N

o

J

_J

m

J

o

4#

0

.J

.J

4[

w

M

I

6.

4[

l*

IC

4O

9[

I-

1C

a

bJ

X

0(

0

Z

J

u

R

w

E

E

O

U

w

n

I

u

N

i..,

u

z

4

i,,,

M

N

w

A

oil

,.J

u

)-

.I

u

o

p.

ar

o

r-

i

E

tn

o

(J

9(

k..

,4

o

O

Z _d

0

w

l O

_ ,.J

_ j

Q 4[

L

M 4[

4[ O

6. •

II

i.i

• I

o l,-

m 4

E

M

0 _ m

_- • i- w

° ;; -

b. _ 9[ *. a. _ 4(

m

m

o

w

>

l

td

m

o

.J

.J

4

Z

4 _

O

O O

_ Z

O

M

14 O

_4

_p

o r.

4( _e --

_* * (--

=) W I

U) .J r-

"_ t- I

_, • N l

Z N _ _

O

O

4[

..I 14 --

,J _e

4( m

,J

Q --

)- .j

0 .J -- O. *- l

N

E •

k* 0

4[ 14

as 0

< ",o

bJ _ O

Z

W Q )-

W 41; Q Z 0

U Z _ 0 *V

• 0 4( IL -- _. I

b. 0 I- _ • (J i-

N

4O4

_4

0

-J 0 "u

•, ° ,." -'

_" _ °

O ..J -- 6. s. Z l

M _

m

E E

M

• o •

W 0 _ U

K I m ;- _ l

• J- _ Z

U l J ,o :_ U

bd • 0 Z 0 - _ Lid

U Z 0 _ eJ -- _ U

k,. 0 I-- I _ U _ ('- k.

Page 411: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

k_

m

J

o

N

II

I

M

I

lti

o

iill

Q

..i

,..l

hi

IC

M

ill

G,

IC

I:

,i[

O

2<E

r

<

O

O

Z

Z

U

E

O

U

W

i

I

4

<

Z

D-

D

a

IU

N

ul

i.

Q

O

Q

ffl

uJ

i

Q

O

r _

Ir

i

o

ill

i

E

.,,(

ul

o

4.,1

ql

Q

kd

0

Z

q(

Z

Z

_d

2

_J

(J

kd

in

m

I

4 IIIIlillRl_lOI

IIIIII

_000000000000000_0_00

_00000000000000_0_000_

_°.,°,_,0.°°°°.*.0..,,,

(0

0000C

oo0

000

0

0

0

0

0

l , L I .... I

N I_ f_

I I I

0

llt / I ii ' )ONYH: LHOJ ]H _1J I 3]dS

405

O

w

o

ill

o

0

0

,11"

o

E

N

Page 412: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

i

In

r-

i

o

N

¢D

I

M

I

o

;J

-r

O_

m

hi

0

0

0

m

>.

0

.,,I

.J U)

4i b_

.J

b/ tJ

• )-

L :,4z :X

O

E

E U

O o

O

10 O

t,a _

X

O

.v

O

Z

..J

U

ul

E

£

O

.1"

I

o

r-

w a

4I

m E

4[

_ u

4[

t-

O

4[

b.

m

I

X

bJ

9[

k,J

ut

m

0

..J

0.

<

Z

*, Q

_ 0

IL Z

X

,11 Ig

0 8.-

M <

* E

M

4.)

0 m

kd _ 4.)

U

bJ

_d b.J

4 a[ N _ g

a, _.- _J i-. b.

:_ tn

Q

t*l

_n

m

0

..J

.J

IL

U)

O

o O

_ Z

o

o °

tU _ lit

° ;

Z N _ _

O • *, IC L

o

_t

• Q

.J N _ I_ m .J iV

•J "_ 0 ..J

• IO0 • - II • IO

(l, • -- )- • • Is

I/) o kd _ M

• _ Z" 0 -- * • _ I*l Z O

0 0 • _ (J )- _ U) 0

tJ m U-

Page 413: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

II

!

NI

_r

o

I

N

o

I

14

I

N

II

i,d

°o• Q

0

O _Id

-- O

Z

4

-i.

in U

W

_ O

W _

III

a U

g,J _

hi

it

_b

o

U

m

i

m

D

0

.J

L

3

E

q

0

u

m

Q

_ONMII_M;I

.mINII_IOIW

• I NNQ_am

3 10

4

_ooooQoaoa

_oooo_oD_o

.°.,°6°,°°

E _mBm'_DI

i

I

[

0

0

0

I

I

i

i I I _ It * _llllNV H 0

40?

0

, I ,

0

Ill

111111111 OI JlO]dl

0

I

o

In

!

0

o

I

o

I

o

I'..

o

ID

D

i[I

ID

..it

o

/q

cs

N

o

b_

,r

N

I-

Page 414: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

a

M

I

o

I

!

o

W

0

W

E

K

¢L

<

Z:

E

<

0

E

<

O

a

W

l

O

.,f

Z

J

u

K

W

I-

E

O

U

m

a.

u

u

x

u

N

m

N

N

w

p-

o

o

w

.J

u

u

o

m

N

!

0

a.

m

E

0

_J

b.-

0

Q

Z w0

-- I

I- w

m

a, 0

b.

b. .I

a

a.

Z

J _

L z

N

° ;E

0

o r_ m

-- D

(J t

• _ - GI

b. • i- _1

z

Z N _ N

:D u)

_J

N

0 Ld

.J _ , Q. .

IL .|

O _

I-- .1 1_

• W Z O 21

_ U

N

o

m

Gg

N

m

w

u

408

Page 415: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

8:

q[

t.

4

0

0

0

0

t JI

)*

0

.J

w

.J

w _

_ o

_ o

l-

r

E U

m

O --

v

0

11

0

Z

,J

u

E

0

,( .j

m ,1[

_L

U_

Z 2

u

mO_O_N_WD

m...,.,*,*

illll

_0oooooooo

_000"000000

*******,0,

0

(

0

0

0

0

lull / I • '+ 30NVH0 LHO I 3PI

O

O

o

0

rU

I

3l_lO_ldS

Page 416: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

6D

1-

o

o

0

..J

.j I_

w

.I

aC

U

IL a.

8

4 o

Z o

IC

0

E

E _

_ 0

0 M

X

0

U

m

W

K

E

0

w ).

in O

m

&

W

Z Z

I-

O

O

Z w

0

Og O

b_

u_ d

0 _

It

I

Z

_ mJ _

4 0

Ib •

IA

• P

M _

• IC

M

_m • 8- • td

b,J e. 4[ W 8C

(61, .am Q • -- .m W4

UI

* N

• W

e

,. ,,j

_ ,J I1:

° N

_4

_# 0 W "

"m .a

410

X

l-

O

'W

B

I-

w

Page 417: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I M

N <

S U

¢

I_ _

I

I

u

I-

m

w

a,

o

0

.J

.j UI

W

-I

W u

E

u

E

J. h

L

< o

E o

r

<

E

r U

O o

a

w

E

0

2

-r.

J

U

W

E

0

U

W lp

_ 0

• .J

m <

L

m

Z '_'

R,...,.*o*

1 t i I

3

Z

W

2_

u

U

_000000000

.**.**,.,°

0

0

0

C_

o

i ,1 i

0

I i •

o

I

i u : I i s* 30NYH3

411

I

I

O

0

, I

i

,LHO I 3M OI J133dS

vo

o

m

o

I

o

r-

o

t.

w

: =t-

7

o

Page 418: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I#l

Q

I

I

N

0

Ul

0

,=1

..J

qi

bl

I

IL

9[

I:

IC

IC

!"

r_

W

0

.I

Z

.,J

U

E

w

E

E

O

u

bJ

I

Z

M

IJ

N

I-

W

U

I

p,.

1

Z

W

N

l-

In

_J

o

o

Q

o

in

t,J

.J

(J

).

(J

.m

N

(J

9I

I--

qI

O

Z

0

_J

4[

I

b.

0

E

I

X

<

_m

_m

Wl

o:

_ U M

< 0 L

L U m U

u I,)

II! I t-

"" 2(3

Xl

I

E

LJ

m

_)

Q

bL

_r

Z

bJ

(J

b.

( I

e

<

_0

<

II

O

412

X

I

I

I

W

I

w

I....

Z

W

b.

Page 419: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

N

.1P

I

Om

N

0

I

0

UI

0

..,I

.J

<

Id

E

a,

IS,

'4

E

Z

'4

O

E

!-

<

Q

w

v

IE

o

O.

U

!"

Q

U

W

m

g

U

N

ro-

w

i,

o

o

o

o

#J

a

o

a

.-m

in

M

0

)-

0

-#

<

0

U

I-

4

I,'-

q

O

mO

q

Z

U

ID

W

ii

u_

In

m

u

#,,.,.,,,,

% III

+000000000

,,.,,,**,,

0

0

.o

0

o

I

C)

,&HO I "#M

• , , L

o

I

:14i3_ldS

0

0

0 °N

,o

-- 01

-- II

,O

-- r.+

- :

- :

- _

-- N

0

o

Z:

m

413

Page 420: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

i

N

I

j-

I

I

o

I

14

!

N

o

O

,J

.J

9(

I

N

I

6.

4[

]c

I"

4(

(D

]C

IC

9[

Q

x

0

]

Z

..,o

<

u

w

E

o

u

<

I

I

U

x

u

Z

I-

I

o

t,J

L.

m

.J

u

).

u

cI

(J

o

tn

a

In

I

)-

0

IL

W

E

<

0

U

q

Q

Q

Z LJ

0 •

< I

E O

•,_ .j

o •

Ig

x _

c.l

.J .

• 0

o

O M

I 6.

U .c t'_ 0

gg I,- _ . _,-

m

N

I

- J

_ d

]K _K

N

I 4( I

_[ M 4I.

I _ ¢_ I

Z z

_ N U l

U Z _ _ 0 _

414

Page 421: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in E

M

0

° ;I

I

o X

Z

a

m

w

o

o

o

0

.J

w

w u

4J

I" o

E

0

E u

0 _

w _

X

n-

O

-t

X

.I

U

E

W

E

I

0

,dl

IL

W <

Ii_ ,.!

M I"

-- 0

Z _

0

w

Z

"le

U

o

w

u

w

&

u

_Dmg_Nm_M

I||

bO000000OO

_O'_DDO0000

_,**°*****

m

I

III

I

|

I!

I

I

I

I

I(b

0

0

0

I

I

!

ee m _ I•* ]ONVNO

415

IH0 I ]H 01410]d|

0

v

c_

I,

td

I

m m

O

O

40

C_

Iq

m

dB

bJ

r

m

Page 422: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

ADIQN

o

I

M

J

N

o

0

.J

.J

q(

W

E

E

IL

.i[

r-

E

<

0

E

E

<

0

0

W

E

Q

.T

X

U

Ig

W

E

E

0

U

w

ul

<

m

g

,i[

u

u)

u

N

-Jr

)..

m

N

w

o

u_

w

.J

u

)..

¢..)

h

o

o

o

O

-I

,1(

G.

m

-se

lr

,(

O

q[

¢2

O

N

m

41.

GI

I[

X

O '

<

J _ N

9[ * O

IL _ ID

(n W

_1 _ .J . 8[ (L

• 0 Z I- _

L U

X

N

< IE

E

o am

o: _ m

z

Z N _ _J

_r i- U i-- (*.

cn

Ul

, N

L |

Q

w_ ZO_

oOZ_Z

I1:

I-

E

CJ

• N m

_) NiL

I[ o I[

_) O _ W

426

Page 423: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Ifl

I

_t

m

It1

¢

o

i

/i)

I

N

C_

LQ

).

0

,,J

.J

td

IC

n.

,,C

(._

I:

I"

0

E

0

]

0

Z

J

,I[

U

W

£

0

U

W

m

Z

g

q(

U

W

oQ

Q W

0

Z

Z

LJ

_J

i =Q _

U

Q

Q

N

u

g.,.,,,,o,,,.,..o

o o o..,,,.o,,.,...,,,

N

i

I!

II

I

O

I

O

O

O

O

O

iw 0 t I- + 30HYH3

417

0

0

0

.LHOI 3H 31 J| 33d|

0

0

0

0

I

It,

Q

N

6.

,it

o

0 Ii1!"

Q

m

Page 424: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

kl I

M •

m

14 U

° :I

I

o X

U

Z

@-

m

).

o

.J

.J

,4

bl

i*

L

E

E

O

E

E

Q

Q

ul

X

0

2

Z

U

I[

E

E

0

W

m

Z

_J

_m

0

N

W

U

0

J

L

"Jr

Q

0

E

Q

k

I

x

o

L i

Q

W

_U W N

4W ZO

_OOZ_u

L_U

W M

m

E I

o_ ZO_

X

N

t

I"

E

_J

Im

6) .

Q

_J

w

z

w

u

418

Page 425: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

¢

Iq

j.

m

4_d

o

I

I

_u

¢)

Lq

).

0

..J

, .j

I,d

I"

K

O. *..

E o

E

0

E U

0 o

o

O --

W --

X

0

"w

Z

J

a,

W

E

0 _

(,J

J

0

L

W 3

m E

- 0

Z U

-- I

_ u

_OO_ZQUmQ_IOm N

• lllllllil_N

o

w

o 4[

0

c_

o bl

_u" cD

Z

4[

.r

U) L,_

kd

.,J I*

U

kd

.lr

4J

b.

G.

4n

vO000_O0000000000

_0000000000000000

.,.o.,.o0.,,0°°.°°

I

(

)

v

o

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

llilll ' IONVH_)

419

0

,I, HOl ]H 3 I.tl _]d$

0

I ,

o

IU

I

II

II

m

o .

II

ID

IIii

all

0 I*1

0 I[

I--

Page 426: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IIi

Jr!gm

N

o

!

8

gu

o

L,J

P

o

0

.J

..J U)

• w

.J

W ¢.)

I[ ' )-

I[

8. m.

• o

E o

r

¢D

,1[

E

E U

¢[

° :O --

W _

X

E

O

Z

Z

U

I[

ul

E

I

1-

O

IL

LI •

<

m E

-- 0

Z U

E

4[

IJ

N

ld

I"

O

Q

Q

O :b

m 8[

4 m

I 0

_ J

I,

X 4[

U

Z

4 _

J _

• O

it Z

m

4

0

fq

lq

0

bd

4 'm

L

Ul .l

O

La *. 4[ N Ir

4 Z _ _

.J

• m

$. m

-I 18 0 _

0 .J *. --

W

o

m

"d

Z . *

x

w

¢[

b.

mr

-s

U)

Q

g[

_ M

_ 0

Z

X

N

w <

E

m

Q

W

Z

W

420

J

..J

,4[

II. _[

4_ m_

a M

&$

o |

I[uw

41 ¢[ Z

¢) O" -- L *.

¢_ 8: • I/_ ¢J

_U L

X

M

v) •

E

o m

u. _.J

I/I J P

_ z

Z IW _ 0 U

0 4[ _.. 0[ -- 4[

Page 427: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

,11If4

iM

o

I

N

o

m N

4 v

i,,°,°°**,,..,°,.

4

X

U

Z

Z

0

W

t,.

0

0

_ N

>.

0

.I

.J

Lu I.I

v- >.

w

G. •

z o

E

o

,q

E _

w _

0

.v

3:

.J

fJ

Ic

gl

0

m 0

4( .J

O.

t_

Z T

'4

Q

G

Z

I-

Z

_J

-e

u

b.

o

w

_O000_OOOO00000_O

.,.. .... ,,.,..,.,

O

@

@

@

O

I I I

I I !

iea' / I • ' _IONVHO LH@ I ]H 31.'il 3]dS

'0

0

o

3-

1"

m

i,-

o

421

Page 428: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

4[

O

M

I-

Ul

N

(..

./

¢)

N

I-

W

o

o

_4 N

>,

0

..J

w

O, *-

Z: o

I"

E

E U

O --

O

21

r,Z

J

u

w

E

E

O

u

W >"

4[ .J

m 4[

6.

Ul

-- 4(

Z 2[

q

i**

Q

Q

Z W

O :P

: w< m

_ .j

O •

L

!

N ,4

U

Z

J _

J _

4 o

L Z

N

• N

o k-

M 4[

!..

m

o 4i

(J

k. kid

I[ _ er

W W

U_ .J )-

Z

Q _ L._ U

U _ O O _ W

N

4

.J _ A.

( O )"

L I

D

i- . ,.J

• W Z 0 _ .st

o .J _ A. _* ¢. --

o O Z _ (J N z

u

)4

N

n,

4[

(J

m

2)

U

W

:) W

Z

• ¢_ 0 w

Z _ (J

o 4( ,_ <

.4

•J N

.J

L

Q

W *

I- .J

6- _J bJ N0• _ W Z

.I 0 *- N

O O • _4

N

N

Q i-

Iv) 4(

14

vl (J

W .J #m

Z

m. 4 N K W

Z N 0 _ _ U

O 4[ *. _ 0: 0, •

N U_

422

Page 429: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IP

!

lip

j.

!

IS

IU

Q

I

lel

N

I

N

U

m

Z

o

o

lp

O

.l

-I m

41 Idd

...I

U

n"

II. 4-

E o

I"

IE u

o

0 --

W --

m,

0

Z

IIc

E

0 _

U

M

!

0

a.

Ul

m E

4[

-- 0

I-

Q

t

<

Z

u

O

b.

W

IL

i

%_OBma_M_OmODNOmB

.oOoooIooOoooOooo

4 0

i i i | i i ,11 , i , i

0

0

0

0

0

I , III Ul

am ii / I • , 3ONVH0

423

0

0

I.11.

0

_x0:].

0

0

,,I

o

_lJlO)d$

0

0

0

o

o

O

lip

Cl

IV

O

AI

O

O

o

It/

O

bl

IC

Page 430: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0I

m

0D

tv

o

t

J

N

o

).

0

.J

w

E

K

IL

E

E

0

2,E

Z

<

O

X

0

"1

0

X

J

U

ul

E

E

0

U

i:

U

m

X

U

m

o

W

Q

W

J

c.l

_J

o

CI

o

m

M

I

0

q

IA

2E

£

t_

0

(J

4(

Q

Q

Z W

0 )

-- a,

< I

'1" 0

E

x _

Z

.J In

.j .

< o

IL Z

W

J

8.

Q

ul

i-

t. U N

as ld O

J N

(=J .J i.

o O (J

U

X X

• •

E S

O_ 0

U I_ U I

'-- Z •

424

m

J

• m

• e

Q

_U _N

)4

m

• 4[

][

14 0

0 r _ i

r* *- I bJ

0 0 _ t_d

0 )'- U I- * t*.

Page 431: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

ini:ro

i

o

ru

o

i

14

i

fu

o

a,

_(

¢3

v

u

-r

i..-

vl

Io

w

).

0

.J

.J u_

4( _,d

.J

E )-

O:

A. e.

I"

E

E u

O o

o

w _

lg

O

3

Z

-I

U

E

E

0 I¢1

m

b,-

O

..J

,<

IL.

CO I"

- 0

Z u

4[

¥-

D

w

Z

q[

Z

U

Z

_7

kJ

4*J

u

_,,....,..,,.*.o*

iill$ili

::°:::oo:.o::°:.:.o° °° ° ..***,,********°,.

C

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

ii w I Iil *e * _gNVH3

425

0

J, H913H

i

0

¢_

E'I

I

_ i _11 3]dli

o

o

o

o

o

o

i.

Page 432: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

t0

!

is

N

o

i

i

N

o

>-

Q

.J

.J

q[

bJ

E

n,

(

3:

3:

<

O

<

E

E

<

m

Q

_J

X

E

O

-w

Z

u

l

W

I"

E

o

u

Z

E

m

u

N

1-

I-

U

a

o

N

m

_1

_J

U

0

U

0

In

PI

),.

0

.J

<"

L

<

-x

0

U

Q

Q

• W

• .b II_

E 0

_ j

O _

Ig

U

t, _D

L Z

¢1

M.

M

o

W

U

< 1

k.

W

Q ),-

E

W ** _ N a*

I_ I.- L) I--

0

Iq

Ft

./ ^

l# in -- IP

1 N w .d Itl

0 II _ iL l0

• .I ,J _1 I,,,

O 0 -- • _ I[ O .d -- Lo i[ Z _ _ )- , o 0 • M

426

I

W

Z

,J

Z

3 4[

O N

Z e;

N

Page 433: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

tD

14

41"

#

4e

0

I

i

Q

).

0

.I

,.J

laJ

E

4.

ql

E

!-

0

E

1"

<

a

W

).,

0

X

J

¢,J

E

E

0

u

R

(J

m

I

in

u

o

o

o

b_

M

i

)-

O

..J

4(

O.

W

<

"mr

E

,,1(

m

O

(J

W

_O_M_mrWaZM_ON_M_M

i#@l

_ooOooOOO_oooooOOOo_

_oooOoOOoOooOOoOOO_O

_,°._,*_,_0,0,,..,,0

_o--_a_O_o_o_oooOoOoO

,4

<

O

kd

1-

(J

_J

:[

(J

N

N

(J

0.

Ul

8000

i

o_O!OIOIO]OI

r"l

c)

0

0

0

I

m

ilel° I|ll' ]9NVH3 ,LH91 ]H

427

31413]d|

0

0

o

=r

u

Page 434: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

JI

tll

_q

j-

0

m

N

o

i

o

ul

o.,J

.J

bJ

l:

N

II:

G.

9(

E

E

0

E

<

O

O

W

I1:

O

U

W

1-

lg

O

U

N

4

U

N

0-

,4

IA

x

u

Z

t-

N

N

_d

W

t-

o

_n

_n

..I

)..

u

,c

I

O

..J

Q.

2[

E

_fP

0

el

a

(2

z w

o •

E

< m

_ o

O _

IL

u

Z

• O

• z

o

O

U

b,.

I[

:::' W

tit ..J

r,

III _'- U 1--

o

Iq

,,4

0

-* p)

• m

(L I

I,- ,J

N X

IJ _,4 ¢J

=) _ =)

U

GI 4[ I rl

k_ b. bJ

I_l =1 tii Id

l- I/I J I-

zZ

ill "_ i-- Wu a, _ u

i, • I_ lie

U Z N _ U

t*. 0 l- U _- t*.

4

0

( 0

4_ ZO

JO_

OOZ_

mu

k_ m

U N *t

< . 0

2

• Q Z O

Z 0 _ IV --

0 4[ -- 8. *. Z

0 1- Z _ U

m u)

)4

ar

i-

!.

(J

m

u

w

m

w

t*l

(J

_J

(J

428

Page 435: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

U

t

Q

Q

Jr

I

m

N

C)

I

M

m

I

N

O X

(J

Z

)..

O

>.

0

,.J

L,J

.J

U

K

_L Q.

E

E

0

E U

_ o

o

0 o

lg

E

0

3

J

U

W

E

I

0

J

W _

m £

-- O

Z U

N

U

,OO_N_NNNNN_NN_NNO__

% l|||

Z

_000_000000_00000000000

_0000000000000_0_000000

M NN_M_

<0

IiJ

0

-r

_J

w

u

w

III

o

I

m

N

i

0

i*_ I1"* ]ONIH= IH81 |H OI _11 _|dl

429

0

0

0

,I

o

m

I

m

o

In

D

o

m I"

N

i-

Page 436: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

o

iO

m

o

!

t

N

o

3*.

O

.J

,.J

q[

W

11"

0.

<

X:

lr

_D

31:

st"

O

W

;[

O

:Z

"r

..J

M

(J

E

E

E

O

u

w

O

E

M

<

U

U

m

Z

!

P

M

W

)--

L

o

,J

w

u

o

u

+

o

P)

I

)-

O

.J

9(

It

u)

:z

IC

4(

O

u

<

0

Q

O )*

I.. 161

W

,It m

It, O

L_

k. .J

.J

IL

I

x <

u

Z

J --

< o

IL Z

4[

o

O

(.,)

4( le

D w

u) j

° ;I[

W *. • iq I[

U a a O --

4[ Z N

b. m 4[ *. 8[

i[ _.- (,) *-

U)

0

M

M

o

L

X 34

m; < .,I- o )-.

f_

8O 0 m

u

Ld k. _J

er I[ _ 0:

I-- _ .J I-*zZ

w 0 _.. w

i. 4[ M

_J ._ Q 0 _

4[ 0 4 b _ 4[

k. 0 I-- _ ;-- la.

o

J

_W OZ

N

° ;

4[ -- D

kJ 0 --

(J fq

• • 1 GI

b. 41 161

mr e _ II[

_) a _J wI11 i .J

O • I.- W

.I Q O Z _ _ W

N _

430

Page 437: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

*0

I

m

_O

!

0

I

ffi

o

|

N

o

)0

0

..4

bJ

l:

E

L

lr

r

e[

(D

E

lr

0

e[

W

O.

X

W

X

u

N

:[

i-

o

N

w

I-

: <Q •

0

tD Q

Z

e[

,r

IJJ 4._

LnJ

U '5-

)- 0

U

I*J

,, -Jr

: °

U

u

o

o

o

m

I

)-

0

-I

4[

it.

u)

!"

.(

U)

0

¢..)

u

_ 0 R _ 0 0 0 0 m _ 0 0 m N • m m 0 _ 0 • N 0

mOO_O_IOOm_m_mMO0

"N,,leOjJtss_c,,*eoe#eeeJ

4

.boooQmoo_oQao_olliQo_

o

o

Booo0o

o

o

i

0

0

0

I I i

I t

i|O Ilqn' ]ONVHO IN|l ]N :)l Jl O]dll

431

o

.,5-

o

o

,,.. .

Sl,.

N

I-,

_o4151,1

Page 438: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0

W

!

o

!

m

D

J

O

).

0

.J

.J

4[

w

E

E

a.

E

E

o

E

E

o

u

.J

w

E

E

w

0.

x

w

m

m

a,

N

<

N

W

Z

El

N

W

O

in

w

.J

u

)-

u

N

(J

0

II1

I

>.

0

..I

n.

.,i(

z

£

0

u

4[

GI

Q

;¢ w

0 )

• m

_ O

L

n.

z

L. O

M _

,4 Q

Q. Z

N

4 I

o I,.-

M <

I-

M

0 4O

t_ _ U

U

t_ bJ

=) '-_ kd

uI

L

O

w

O_h--

_O_Z

W

&.)

<

b.

Q

4. 4[ N

41 o O

z _v

o 4( ,.

o I-. _,)

m

N

L J

Q

_ ZO

X X

I-- Im

11" lr

(J O

N N

m m

4J W (J

Q • Q

bJ t_ W

0C 4: 0[

w _) W

Z Z

w 12 W

4.1 Z N _

N In

432

N

Q

W

_ Z

oOZ_U

4(

b. iO --

E I I,-.

41 Q Z * 0

Z 0 _ -- eli

O 4[ . G* Z *-

x

N

IC

)-

IC

m

u

w

w

(.I

w

tJ

41

Page 439: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

m

Po

!

o

N

o

t.

I

o

m

0

.J

..J

Z

E

a.

l-

s-

O

i-

,1[

¢0

0

L_

n,

0

.v

.,r

-I

U

E

0

U

m

<

N

u

-Jr

I-

I,D

o

t-

L

°o ,,,o

z

i/I ,1_

w

al

I.L

u

G,

M

0

L

=

m

0

u

<

::::::00::::::o:°:0:00°0°00:000°0

i

0

0

0

0

0

0

J i

ID

o

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

%oo

I , IN

0 o

0

8o0 o

lel I le' 301_IWH+ .I. HOI ]H 31.dl 3lids

433

0o

o

I"'.

o

o

N

4:

N

Page 440: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

I

I

0e

N

o

I

pq

I

t_

o

>.

0

,J

w

E

I

It

E

E

o

E

41

o

w

Ig

O

Z

u

I

w

E

O

u

w

<

I

N

I,p

N

lg

w

M

Z

I'--

o

N

_J

o

°o¢)

ul

w

J

u

3-

u

o

N

u

IIn

)-

0

L

U_

[

<

o

u

<

)-

C)

0

I

¢I

>.

o:

i

x

Q

W

I

Ill

ul

I

0

• .J .=1

,=1 .j

• ,4

• L L

.,I Iq j " ,,.I

..I • m I.- J

I _ Z

It. I 0 4[ •

I_ el I (,ji mli U

+_ k. Ill

•410lid • .I _[ 4I _ • Id

._ ..J -- Itl 0 I 0 Ul ..I 0

,4 0 _ _ Z o I Z o 0 o 0 I

X X X

I • II ,lI I 41

¢i1 I11 Ill

I o I o • o

k. k.l k,, l*l. + k. o Ill I*,

I I I[ _ I *" I I

_' _ :_ ka lU D kl *..J _) kl

¢_ t- _ J I,- I_ ,J I- MI .IZ

o + ,, .; + o ; - o ;,¢ tJ K _ Oc _ I

kJ b ,( . *-'I( M I I_.. MI 1,9[ M I

Z N U Z _ M M I N M _ Z _ _

I*. M _ _ 4C 0 4[ *,. I _ 0 ,4 l,, 4[ • 0 4[ *,, I

434

I

• .I N

.I

4[ •

• I

O

hi

,,,j _

o O _,_

N

I •

I,- cl

• Ill

I

I,II

• o

I

,4

E

O

lib

I

k,ll

I--

Z

IiJ

U

Page 441: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

i

_r

_r

i

D

i

Jr

o

i

o x

(.I

N

t..

AI

W

M .J

)- (J

J u

.4

ul O

E Q

M

4.

,at

I: u

0 Q

E --

u

.I

W

IC

Q

U

o

w _

m I

• N

m 4(

:I

I

Z Q

,(

I.-

0

t,I

Z

,r

ca

f-

:Z

Q

W

=1

cJ

Ia

4.

in

,,|

_omo_om_D

oo_o_oMP_f

i,,,,,,b,,

IllJ)

4

_O000000OO

_00000000_.

,,°,_,0,,°

N _

f-

o

0

0

I i ,n ¸ i

o

o

I

iw o I I w ' 3ONVH3

435

0

.I. HO I 314

0

I i

0

o

_d

I

_ I _1 {)':ldli

0

oo

I:

¢l

I'-

0

ID

5"

a

Page 442: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

0 m

,1'

S U

t N

° :!

I

N

o

f,J

Z

O

N

M

(U

m

0

,J

.J

4[

Ld

E

L

E

E

Q

E

E

Q

<

IJ

.J

<

U

Og

W

E

E

0

U

m

W

p..

o

o

o

m

bt

.I

U

u

,s

o

o

o

N

o

N

I

N

:1

!

m

Q

a..

4(

a

o

k.

U

4

E

kb

Q

m,

i

x

L

Wm

* LN

W

0 i

_ J

m • w

4< ZZ

mOw_

o o -- m L

<Q_ZZ_

w w

u L

436

Page 443: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

14

j.

I

w,0

a

I

j.

I

0

in

w

lit ..a

)- U

0 )-

,J U

.J

IC o

K _

IL

,(

r

E

<

U

J

U

E

w

0

u

o

W N

N

m

'.m.

I

Z D

U

I1'

N

U

_om_mDU_DtNmNmQ

mom_Bm_mmmmQDNm

IJlllll

,m

W

Z

I"

_J

u

w

:°::°°°:°::::::°:°ooo o o...,.,.,.,,,..,..

0

J:o

0

0

0

0

I

o

o

I

0

il t / I I ' ]iDNyH:)

43T

0

IHgl]H

0

0

0

, I

31JlO3dS

0

0

0

N

I

a

(:m

(ll

e.

al

m

Page 444: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Ifl

I

m

8"

t

!

_r

o

l

o

t

Q

0

.J

lid

E

m.

L

E

O

E

E

,4

J

U

8:

W

E

E

O

U

uJ

,i(

m

Z

4(

4J

N

X

(.it

1-

14

_d

kJ

_c

_J

m

lid

.J

4.)

U

s.

o

u

o

N

I

N

q(

Z

I

U)

0

Q

0

I[

L_

).

E

I

)_

W

L

0

_ z

_W Z ZW

kd kL k_

it. 0

)- 4D

I1( •

. 2:

° ;_ .T z

• z O _ _

k. 0 '1[ -- . 8.

_" o I,-- • Z _

I-

E

U

m

U

0

w

w

438

Page 445: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Jr

i

N

VJ

!

14

0

0

I

N

0

M

II

I

N

4(

fa

I,-

IA

Ill

U

X

I...

I

It)

i4

W

W"

W

..J

U

U

0

i

U

0

Ut

0

..J

.J

W

m

I

I[

I-

,IC

m

m m

o

I I.

I

IC

E

,4

b-

0

W

0

Z

T

kl

k.

U

Ill

I.

I

i

III!

q

bO0|IOOOOO

aOOOIOllO0

.,,,,*****

WO _I_O_00

E _M_PeO

i i i 1

0

0

0

(

, II

I

I

i

i I I I I I * ]IONYHO

439

o

I0

II

II

N

I

OIJll_]dI

0

01St

I Q

¢)

A

o

Q

- :

- :

_ ._

o

_ M

- :

0

nl o

°

r

Page 446: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

Iq

I

!

o

M

o

Ul

).

0

.J

.J

(

W

Z

I

:)

I.-

v

q(

_J

w

In

I

A,

(

u

)..

,9[

u

-r

I

M

W

I,-

0

U)

W

,.J

u

).

U

Q

o

(J

a

o

In

I

s-

I

a_

E

Q

0

9[

I

tk

b.

0

)-

a-

i

)<

,II

o b_

.J Ill) a

.J • ).

( I I,-

I

Q _

_,- .J

• W Z 3

• J -J 0 _ w

m

k_ o

<

(2

u L Q z

ut

X

M

a_

I--

,1{

IC

(J

I

Q

w

IC

Ld

I.-

Z

t,J

0

td

(J

<

b.

440

Page 447: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

i

o

14

I

o

o

!

fu

o

I+1

o

N

M •

u

i,q,,,004t.,oQ0_0

I1___

,,,,,,---,,,

u

N

.It

N

o,-

ul

k-

.I <

Q

_J 0

Z

<

Z

tn (J

L,J

o

W

w

u

O

.J

.J

td

Z

m

::)

ul

01

W o

0

m

I

E

_O0OO0000000000QO

_OOOO00OO00OO0000

I

i

(

C

(

,__

0

0

0

0

0

0

ii • II I I • + _I@NVH3

441

O

LHO I ]14

i

, I

o

1o

I

31Ji3]dS

O

O

Oo

o

bJ

I"

Page 448: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I N

O 4[

m

f4 _J

! N

O

O

O

o x

u

Z

Im

l

q4

)-

O

.J

.J

4[

kd

X

m

g[

:)

k.-

u

LJ

q[

us

U

W

j..

i.

.a¢

o

o

o

¢)

w

u

D-

u

U

o

o

m

o

m

!

Z

m

mr

E

_m

4[

Q

O

,I[

I

Q

I

I

x

m

< •

0

w

_ .J

_, u W IPo,m hi •

.,I -J -- O 3

.,J al .j • • •

it (V u

u)

Wm

UN

_m

_m

0

Ed

W_W

UdOZ

q Z_O

442

Page 449: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

in

).

o

.J

,4

z

m

n-

=)

I.-

W

gl

M

U

I,-

N

I-,

+.

,iJ

o

o

N

Ln

bJ

.J

IJ

U

m

o

in

!

ic

#

3=

v

mo • • • P N B _ _ O _ r N E N m

_el|l|u|¢||Imt41e

*MemMO_MNNN_EmmAm

##¢II!

Q

W

Z

_r

u

k-

"I'

W

:Z

tJ

U

9.

tn

kOOOOOOOQO_O00000

****..,,*,..,.,,,

N N

O_

<

I

o

0

0

0

0

0

0

o

0

I

le _ I I m * 31DNVH3

443

0

0

0

0

1H91 3H 31 J| :)]dS

O

0O

40

m

o

I

o

_r

o

N

i.

4_

t_

Z:

N

k,.

Page 450: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

41'

I

0

14

i

o

0

I

o

>.

0

,,.I

J

<

l..J

Z

lm

im

+

u

,4

a

o X

U

Z

w

0,.

.J

L.

,m

U

m

o

I

!"

I

m.

E

III

N

<

IJ

m

4

<

Q

0

Q

<

t

x

<

II1

.1

'( B

L m

O

W

b Jr

41 kd Z 4_

-J -.J _ 0 3

.J 0 .J L • •

9[ 0 0 U] U U

L t_r U

4/)

Jr

)0

4[

I"

U

N

m

< =I

w 111 u

< Q

b. D w

:' - +

Z

w

444

Page 451: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

t

I

In

o

I

o

o

!

o

!

o

U

0

..J

.J

9[

kJ

Z

m

m

I.*

I-

u_

,1(

w

U_

4[

m N

in

i

; z

Id

Z

IO

N

N

u

_o_mDNm_Oo

o,,_,,,,,*

4 s_moom_

I11111

4

4[

0

_ L

Z

4[

-r

_J

o

w

4,)

U

_OO0 0 O0

WO_O_OO

O

O

(3

I i

o

V')

_d

I

au _ I I • ' 319NVH3

44_

O

IHOI3H

0

, I

KI

I

3 I .'1t =]dS

v

0

o

o

o

(D

0

_J

Q

bJ

Page 452: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

III

I

II'I

ltl

I

N

o

o

i

o

I

III

l)

m

).

0

.J

J

ki

Z

m

E

:)

)-

w

Iii

Ul

,i[

m

< v

_OMODMNS_m

U m. ONZmNNN_

IIIIII

4

II

l,,l

u

"IP

l--

III

W

N

)*

_J

k

o

D

w

.J

u

o

o

ID

N

I

4

0

w

0

4[

Z

0

m

w

"I

W

w

L

_000000000

_OO0000000

..**,....,

0

f

0

0

0

o

In

I

i I t I I • ' ]I_NVHO

446

J. HOI]N

0

0

0

OIJlO)dl

0

o

OI

ci

Ifl

o

Page 453: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_t K

o

U

t m

o

° ;I

N

o

I

o X

u

X

),.

0

.J

.I

bd

Z

m

E

u

W

4(

m

i,

,iI

0

Z

0

u _

E

x

u

o

4_

L II

Q

W

_ U W W

_W ZZ

_OjeLL

L--u

<

w

u

tJ. 6 r'.

m

!

m

W I. 4[ _1 N a*

4.) • GI Z 0 0

*_ 0 4( 0. b •

n. 0 )- U_ i.J _)

V)

Page 454: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

_u

¢)

¢1

0

o

!

o

m

).

O

.J

,J

_(

w

Z

N

m

a:

I--

O

(J

:][

)..

0S

N

I"

U]

W

)..

0

to

:r w

o

Z

,4

Z

,W1 (J

W

U

U _

O _

W

D..

_omm_m

g..,,,

_::::°. o• • , 0 , ,

WO_O_

_to

0

0

0

I , I Io o o

: - : :o

(v PI .1"

i" * / I'* ]0N¥#: 1#0l 3# 31JI :]dl

448

¢)

_O

o

ID

: wIc

b-

0

3"

Q

N

Page 455: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Io

3.

0

N

o

o

i

N

o

i

PI

o

0

.I

.J

w

Z

m

E

w

tn

,1(

u

t,J

m

m

(J

Jv

N

O

)..

(n

v

(J

M

-r

m

N

nJ

bJ

t,

A:

url

3"

tn

W

.J

(J

)-

(J

i.

o

u

o

Vl

I*

Q

Z

O

m

I-

U

a:

Q

).

iX

t

x

,J

.J

g.

Q

w

.j J N

a. u

m

X

1,1

!["

A vl

• ¢) o m

lld In _ _ U

LJ _j w

4O W

Ul • .J .IZm

Q • I- b- W

U Z _ w W

U]

0

.J

i

0 Vl

W

_J

.J -- O 2[

J G. • o

3" 0 _ _ U

u

w Vl

::) o 1o

_/) • I

W

0[ .J

z _ 2[ O

if1 ,I[ 0. • •

3. )-- u) _.) (J

u_

X

N

oc

IC

m

O

kJ

W

W

U

_d

O

L*.

449

Page 456: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

i

m

t

fu

o

o

t

f_

¢)

t

o

).

0

.J

,.J

,I[

bJ

ir

m

I

t..

,(

CJ

UJ

U_

m

u

E N

m •

m

_OZ_Sm_O_BNNOBw

U mOZmN_IZ_Z_NINO

|li|l'tl|li!

0

o

o w

m t_

<

3:

t_ sJ

t_

U

U _

w

Q _

(J

w

ffl

fU

m

.,m,

-- N

0

0

0

0

0

0

IIi

m

!

I" t I | w * ]ONVH3

450

0

0

0

J. Hei'aM OI jl 3"ads

0

0

_m

0

0

0

o

o

N

_ :

- =

-- ;

o

o

t.

w

Z

N

Page 457: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

Iq

I

D

.1P

I

N

O

O

I

N

O

I

I,q

O

V)

),,

0

-I

W

Z

I

4

.4

m

" I

N

PI

U_

W

i.

o

N

in

w

..J

(J

(J

(J

o

o

m

I

n.

=,

u

w

q[

I Ill

I

u "_

I.-

q[

0Q

Z

O >

< I

_ J

L

E I.-

_ Z

X <

b.

Z

i. 0

.J _

,C 0

L Z

W _

I

¢-1

u

91[ 3[ N

0_. t.- (.,) t61

uJ

ut

.I

( I I-

L " Ul

I

W _

2;

l I

¥. l-

!" !-.

_J

I I

(3 • "

w b. I w

z

IJ _ -1 u

b.

451

o

,,J M

.J

,,_ I I"

_. n

I

0

0 ,J L • •

o

_I

_t

N_

N

N

l

E

N

I

(J

O

W

a.

<

_b

Page 458: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

m

!

ol

i

(d

o

o

!

ev

o

us

o

.J

.J

4(

w

z

m

er

)..

4(

u

ka

k7

m

I m

m •

4 v

_Om_OmMaMMmM_

U mooBu_oBmm_m_

4 _ w • m _ m • • B m w_

t 2 IIIIlllll

4

III

U

Z

I,-

nA

W

o

W

).,

u

4.

o

o

U

N

Vl

I

21

l*

.1(

O

_J

4(

u

X

_7

w

k,.

(J

kJ

8.

u_

_ooooooooooOoo

4ooOoOooOoo0oo

*°**'*''''°''5

0

I ho

¢)

0

0

0

Io

o

I

iI ;) I I 0 ' ]ONVH0

452

0

0

0

0

IH0 I ]H 31 .Jl 3_1d$

O

O-

O

c:0

o

_u

o

o

.11"

o

o

4.

J_

k_

][

N

Page 459: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

;4 g

! N

;4 4[

D

O

° ;I

o

I

O

u

X

t-

III

N

lP

0

.J

4[

W

Z

N

m

(

i-

,1(

IJ

w

<

m

w

Z

0

N

ul

U _

N

: °o 4

0c

_4

N

I1

i

3

4

0 _J

.J _ _L

,1( 40 _"

O. I

I. U W

• W Z Z

.j .J _ 0 --

w ul _

nr |

:2:Q o

_. !" ,.J

U .s a "_ T 0

4.53

Page 460: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

it)

o

m

J

o

o

!

N

o

I

M

0

4

LJ

$-

<

$-

uJ

w

. <

D

0

¢D tiJ

Z

5-

0_ U

L,J

)* (D

td

N

W

O.

U

W

0

J

..I

_J

Z

Ig

t-

U

W

m

N

u

"_ 0 I¢_ N IU r_ M -- Q0 M

m o _ M m .t aD _o m o

• , , . , ° 0 0 . .

• 0 O _ 41D m lid N i_

!

q

O0000OO_Oooooooo o

.,,.,.,,,°

E m_Sm_o

0

0

0

Q

0

Io

o

ml

I

|ml IP t | • ' 30NVH3

4.54

0

J. HOI3N 3 1.4 ! 0"idS

O

O 40

N

O

u j

-- 14

Om

O

40

O_

O

CO

4,

O

WE

b.-

Page 461: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

fit g

.III

0

t

N

0

I

Iii

o X

u

Z

I-

>.

0

.I

.J

Z

m

)-

u

W

w

h

Z

0

M

W u

u m

u

o

x

u

o

o

I

X

L

m

to m

w

aw

_o_eo

m

t.l ill

4.) I_

4[ ,.

| I O"

a O

Q

IJ " Z

e[ Z _ lU 0 "*

a. o

=) _ (n

I/J

455

Page 462: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

IO

I

0

I

I

o

|

o

I

o

U

Z

I

N

Q

4J

0

J

w

Z

m

I

)-

u

w

m

0

S

• I

v

I,**,.*.,°

4[

ba

4(

U

I.-

Z

(,9

U

(J

L,J

O.

Ul

_000o00000

40oo00000o

0

0

0

0

0

(

o

!

ilI /II ' ]I@NVHO 1HO I ]M 31JlO3dS

o

o

o

t

456

0

o

I

o

r'-

o

ID

1-

Page 463: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

I

M

D

1.1

4

o

¢)

¢

N

O

I

M

o

Ul

)-

0

-I

ld

Z

m

I/I

m

u

_ON_UO_MOQNmm_Z_

U mo21m_m__M_M

4 #¢I#I_N_O_WmO

1|111

4

X

O

.k,

)..

2,N

i,*J

.E

O

O

fu

W

4kl

..J

O

),.

U

Q.

4L_

oI

x

,.I[

)..

Q

k,/

O

Z

Z

I1

;:_:::°:'°:_°:::° oo o• ....0.°° ..... °0°

N

0

0

0

0

D

0

0

0

0

0

0

0

Io

I

IHOl"l14 :II ._II O_IdS

457

0

J i

o

I

, ,

0

o

o

Q

Page 464: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

/' I

Iq •

o

!

o

u

-r

I-

f

0

.J

J

w

Z

m

E

u

ul

o

w

w

),,

U

o

4[

0

0

N

m

Li,

0

E

I

x

_ N

o W

J III a.

• m _,.

IL •

_n a 4"

• 0

D

.ll tAI Z •

M .J 0 _

,.J 0 .J • G. --

L _ u

W

W m

_ M

b. •

II[ go

,,, .-Q

K

W k • W N

UaQ ZO

ZO_

_04oLb

458

Page 465: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

National Aeronauticsand Report Documentation PageSpace Administration

1. Report No. 2. Goverriment Accession No. 3. Reciptent's Catalog No,NASA TM-101468

5. Report Date

October 1989

4. Title and Subtitle

High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data

Turbine Alloys, Part 2

7. Author(s)

Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

9. Performing Organization Name and Address

National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Lewis Research Center

Cleveland, Ohio 44135-3191

12. Sponsoring Agency Name and Address

National Aeronautics and Space Administration

Washington, D.C. 20546-0001

6. Performing Organization Code

8. Performing Organization Report No.

E-4263

10. Work Unit No.

505-63-01

!11. Contract or Grant No.

13. Type of Report and Period Covered

Technical Memorandum

14. Sponsoring Agency Code

15. Supplementary Notes

High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data, Turbine Alloys, Part 1, by Charles A. Barrett, Ralph G. Garlick, and

Carl E. Lowell, is available as NASA TM-83665 (Rev. 1989).

16. Abstract

This volume is the second part in a series of cyclic oxidation handbooks presenting cyclic oxidation data tested at

NASA Lewis Research Center. It contains specific-weight-change versus time data and x-ray diffraction results

derived from high-temperature cyclic tests for the remainder of high-temperature, high-strength nickel base 3,/3,,

and cobalt-base turbine alloys tested at Lewis.

17. Key Words (Suggested by Author(s))

Cyclic oxidation

Superalloys

Scale spalling

18. Distribution Statement

Unclassified- Unlimited

Subject Category 26

19. Security Classif. (of this report) 20. Security Classlf. (of this page) 21. No of pages 22. Price*

Unclassified Unclassified 461 A20II i

NASAFORMlesP6OCT86 *For sale by the National Technical Information Service. Slorinflfield, Viroinia 22161I_ U.S. GOVERNMENT PRINTING OFFICE: 1069"- 7_ 8 - 1 5 8 /0 0 2 1 0

Page 466: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick
Page 467: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick
Page 468: HIGH-TEMPERATURE CYCLIC OXIDATION DATA - NASA...NASA Technical Memorandum 101468 High-Temperature Cyclic Oxidation Data Turbine Alloys, Part 2 Charles A. Barrett and Ralph G. Garlick

National Aeronautics and

Space Administration

Lewis Research Center

Cleveland, Ohio 44135

_III Iklllnlll

P,_mlly fo¢ Pdvmte IJ_

FOURTH CLASS MAIL

ADDRESS CORRECTION REQUESTED

IIII!1

N_*I < lift, II A_I i)r, _!Jbc ", Ifi_

_I] tr ,t' A[_I_ i,r_l_,l'il!u jr-,

t_,JA_) A 4'j'