historical orthophoto of prague 1945 - eurosdr · 2019-06-25 · historical orthophoto of prague...

24
PRIMIS spol. s r. o. Slavíčkova 827/1a, 638 00 Brno, Czech Republic W: www.primis.cz | E: [email protected] T: +420 534 008 769 Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris, 3 rd –4 th June 2019 Patrik Meixner

Upload: others

Post on 27-May-2020

6 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o.

Slavíčkova 827/1a, 638 00 Brno, Czech Republic

W: www.primis.cz | E: [email protected]

T: +420 534 008 769

Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris, 3rd – 4th June 2019

Patrik Meixner

Page 2: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Basic facts

• Summer 2014 – first contact with Luftbilddatenbank Dr. Carls GmbH, who introduced us to the so far unknown wonder of WWII reconnaissance aerial imagery and its exploitation

• 2015 – PRIMIS started acquisition in Czech Republic – large cities, open-cast mines + surrounding chemical industry (usually founded shortly before or during WWII in Sudetenland), large factories active during WWII (e.g. Skoda Works, Pilsen – arms producer during WWII)

• At the end of 2015 PRIMIS commissioned by IPR Prague to make an orthophotomap of Prague from archival aerial reconnaissance photographs taken by the Allies in the spring of 1945

Page 3: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Aerial photos in Allied archives

• Prague was the target for Allied bombing missions on 5. 11. 1944, then 14. 2. 1945 and finally 25. 3. 1945

• More than 1,200 casualties, and significant material and property damage in NovéMěsto, Holešovice, Smíchov, Vršovice, Vinohrady, Žižkov, Libeň, Kbely, Letňany and Čakovice

• Of course incomparable with German cities, but please take into account that Czechoslovakia was formally on the Allied side via its government in exile and its armed forces fighting both on the western and eastern fronts (UK, USSR)

• Bombing of Prague as collateral damage

• Detailed research by Luftbilddatenbank Dr. Carls GmbH

• Found 10 reconnaissance mission by Allied air forces

• All photos captured in April-May 1945

• Photo scale ranges from 1 : 7 000 to 1 : 50 000

• 1 : 50 000 scale photos used only in places with no coverage by larger scale photos

Page 4: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Aerial photo recce missions found in Allied archives

• 104W-115C, 46 photos

• 104W-136C, 75 photos

• 104W-167C, 71 photos

• 30-6091, 124 photos

• 31-4874, 194 photos

• 31-4875, 145 photos

• 32-1014, 143 photos

• 32-1032, 141 photos

• 7-152B, 124 photos

• 7-160B, 19 photos

• Altogether 1082 photos

Page 5: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

104W-115C, 46 photos, scale 1 : 7 200, 17th April 1945

Page 6: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

104W-136C, 75 photos, scale 1 : 9 000, 20th April 1945

Page 7: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

104W-167C, 71 photos, scale 1 : 7 500, 26th April 1945

Page 8: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

30-6091, 124 photos, scale 1 : 10 000, 4th May 1945

Page 9: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

31-4874, 194 photos, scale 1 : 10 000, 16th April 1945

Page 10: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

31-4875, 145 photos, scale 1 : 10 000, 16th April 1945

Page 11: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

32-1014, 124 photos, scale 1 : 12 500, 16th April 1945

Page 12: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

32-1032, 122 photos, scale 1 : 12 000, 19th April 1945

Page 13: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

7-152B, 124 photos, scale 1 : 7 000, 20th April 1945

Page 14: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

7-160B, 19 photos, scale 1 : 12 500, 26th April 1945

Page 15: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

1044 photos in scales 1 : 7 200 to 1 : 12 500

Page 16: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

32-1032 a 32-1014, 38 photos, scales 1 : 48 000 and 1 : 50 000,16th and 19th April 1945

Page 17: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

All aerial photos available for the orthophoto job

Page 18: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Only 7.9 km2 = 1.6 % of the actual (2018) territory of the city of Prague not covered by the archival photos

Page 19: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Orthophoto production

• Imagery obtained scanned already – no scanning in PRIMIS

• Geo-referencing in ArcGIS – reason given on next slides

• Geo-referenced using CPs from the actual orthophoto (summer 2015)

• Conventional orthophoto production in Hexagon ImageStation OrthoPro

• Automatic seamlines with manual editing

• In case of multiple coverage, the mission with the best visual quality and covering the widest continuous area used

• Final mosaicking in GSD of 25 cm

Page 20: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Geo-referencing in ArcGIS

• Type of transformation – ADJUST - polynomial transformation with triangulated irregular network (TIN) interpolation

• Usually minimum 20 control points used

• RMS below 1 m

Page 21: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Geo-referencing in ArcGIS – adverse effects

• Cuts outside of the “point envelope” caused by the transformation type

• Inconvenient in single photo geo-referencing (PROJECTIVE leads to comparable results without the cuts)

• Careful mosaicking takes care about the problem during standard orthophotoproduction – cuts covered by the overlapping photos

Page 22: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Standard AT – no go in the case of recce photos

• Non-photogrammetric scanning leads to highly distorted imagery

• Fiducial marks identification sometimes dubious – though good IO results obtained more often than not

• Self-calibration ineffective – distortions not systematic

• Long focal lengths (24”, 36”, 40”) do not help the standard photogrammetry – on the contrary – they help the GIS geo-referencing approach

Page 23: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o., Slavíčkova 827/1a, Brno, Czech Republic | www.primis.cz | [email protected] | +420 534 008 769

Representation of results

• Several websites

• Two Pragues http://www.dveprahy.cz/

• Orthophoto Archive http://app.iprpraha.cz/apl/app/ortofoto-archiv/

• Story Map http://iprpraha.maps.arcgis.com/apps/MapJournal/index.html?appid=7b7eccf7075f4d23bf62b6b1d689aa3c

Page 24: Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 - EuroSDR · 2019-06-25 · Historical Orthophoto of Prague 1945 Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris,

PRIMIS spol. s r. o.

Slavíčkova 827/1a, 638 00 Brno, Czech Republic

W: www.primis.cz | E: [email protected]

T: +420 534 008 769

Thank you for your attention.Workshop on Geoprocessing and Archiving of Historical Aerial Images Paris, 3rd – 4th June 2019

Patrik Meixner