holcombe 02
TRANSCRIPT
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 1/28
CHAPTER
2
Principles for Analyzing
Government
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 2/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-2
The Market EconomyThe Market Economy
Process of vol&ntary e'c(angeProcess of vol&ntary e'c(ange
SpecializationSpecialization
Gains from tra#eGains from tra#e
Proses pert&)aran s&)arelaProses pert&)aran s&)arela
SpesialisasiSpesialisasi
!anfaat per#agangan!anfaat per#agangan
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 3/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-3
Economic Efficiency and theEconomic Efficiency and the
Competitive MarketCompetitive Market *eman# C&rve*eman# C&rve + val&e of o&tp&t pro#&ce#+ val&e of o&tp&t pro#&ce#
S&pply C&rveS&
pply C&rve + opport&nity cost of pro#&cing o&tp&t+ opport&nity cost of pro#&cing o&tp&t
Intersection of s&pply an# #eman# c&rves #etermine level ofIntersection of s&pply an# #eman# c&rves #etermine level of
o&tp&t ma'imizing val&e of economy,s reso&rceso&tp&t ma'imizing val&e of economy,s reso&rces
-&rva permintaan +nilai o&tp&t yang #ipro#&)si)an-&rva permintaan +nilai o&tp&t yang #ipro#&)si)an
-&rva pena.aran + %iaya pengor%anan #ari pro#&)si o&tp&t-&rva pena.aran + %iaya pengor%anan #ari pro#&)si o&tp&t
Persingg&ngan )&rva pena.aran #an permintaan men&n/&))anPersingg&ngan )&rva pena.aran #an permintaan men&n/&))an
ting)at o&tp&t yang mema)sim&m)an nilai #ari s&m%er #ayating)at o&tp&t yang mema)sim&m)an nilai #ari s&m%er #aya
e)onomie)onomi
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 4/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-4
Economic Efficiency and theEconomic Efficiency and the
Competitive MarketCompetitive Market
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 5/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
Efisiensi perekonomian dan pasarEfisiensi perekonomian dan pasar
persainganpersaingan
-&rva permintaan0 *0 menggam%ar)an nilai o&tp&t yang #i(asil)an-&rva permintaan0 *0 menggam%ar)an nilai o&tp&t yang #i(asil)an
#i pasar0 men&r&t o&tp&t )ons&men0 )arena )&rva terse%&t#i pasar0 men&r&t o&tp&t )ons&men0 )arena )&rva terse%&t
men&n/&))an %erapa %esar )emamp&an1 )ese#iaan )ons&menmen&n/&))an %erapa %esar )emamp&an1 )ese#iaan )ons&men
&nt&) mem%ayar o&tp&t&nt&) mem%ayar o&tp&t
-&rva pena.aran0 S0 %iaya yang (ar&s #i)or%an)an )arena-&rva pena.aran0 S0 %iaya yang (ar&s #i)or%an)an )arenamempro#&)si o&tp&t0 )arena )&rva terse%&t men&n/&))an %erapamempro#&)si o&tp&t0 )arena )&rva terse%&t men&n/&))an %erapa
%esar pro#&sen (ar&s mem%ayar agar #apat mempro#&)si o&tp&t%esar pro#&sen (ar&s mem%ayar agar #apat mempro#&)si o&tp&t
Ting)at o&tp&t yang mema)sim&m)an nilai o&tp&t #alamTing)at o&tp&t yang mema)sim&m)an nilai o&tp&t #alam
pere)onomian a#ala( 234 5i)a pro#&)si )&rang #ari 23 ma)a nilaipere)onomian a#ala( 234 5i)a pro#&)si )&rang #ari 23 ma)a nilai
o&tp&t &nt&) )ons&men le%i( %esar #ari pa#a %iaya yango&tp&t &nt&) )ons&men le%i( %esar #ari pa#a %iaya yang#i)or%an)an ole( pro#&sen4#i)or%an)an ole( pro#&sen4
2-5
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 6/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-6
Role of GovernmentRole of Government
Private SectorPrivate Sector + vol&ntary e'c(anges+ vol&ntary e'c(anges
P&%lic SectorP&%lic Sector + government activity+ government activity typically fnanced by mandatory taxestypically fnanced by mandatory taxes
monopoly on legitimate coercion and orcemonopoly on legitimate coercion and orce
Sektor swasta – pertukaran sukarelaSektor swasta – pertukaran sukarela
Sektor publik – kegiatan pemerintahSektor publik – kegiatan pemerintah- Biasanya dibiayai oleh pajak wajibBiasanya dibiayai oleh pajak wajib
- Monopoli atau pemaksaan yang sah dan berlakuMonopoli atau pemaksaan yang sah dan berlaku
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 7/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-7
Why is the Pulic !ectorWhy is the Pulic !ector
"ecessary#"ecessary# 6ail&re of mar)et system6ail&re of mar)et system
Government may %e more efficient t(anGovernment may %e more efficient t(an
mar)etmar)et E7&ityE7&ity
!engapa se)tor p&%li) penting8!engapa se)tor p&%li) penting8
9 )egagalan sistem pasar9 )egagalan sistem pasar
9 pemerinta( le%i( efisien #ari pasar9 pemerinta( le%i( efisien #ari pasar
9 pemerataan9 pemerataan
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 8/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-8
Market !ystem and $ndividualMarket !ystem and $ndividual
RightsRights Rig(t to free#om of e'c(angeRig(t to free#om of e'c(ange
Rig(ts protecte# %y"Rig(ts protecte# %y"
policepolice national deensenational deense
court systemcourt system
Protection of rig(ts creates incentives toProtection of rig(ts creates incentives topro#&ce goo#spro#&ce goo#s
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 9/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
!istem pasar dan hak individu!istem pasar dan hak individu
$a) &nt&) %e%as #alam pert&)aran$a) &nt&) %e%as #alam pert&)aran
$a) #ilin#&ngi ole( " polisi0 perta(anan$a) #ilin#&ngi ole( " polisi0 perta(anan
nasional0 sistem penga#ilannasional0 sistem penga#ilan
$a) perlin#&ngan mencipta)an insentif$a) perlin#&ngan mencipta)an insentif
&nt&) mempro#&)si %arang&nt&) mempro#&)si %arang
2-9
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 10/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-10
Government as Protector ofGovernment as Protector of
RightsRights Primary f&nction of government isPrimary f&nction of government is
protection of in#ivi#&al rig(tsprotection of in#ivi#&al rig(ts
Proper level of protection is #e%ata%leProper level of protection is #e%ata%le
!any rig(ts can %e protecte# t(ro&g(!any rig(ts can %e protecte# t(ro&g(
private provisionprivate provision
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 11/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
Pemerintah seagai pelindungPemerintah seagai pelindung
hakhak 6&ngsi primer pemerinta( a#ala(6&ngsi primer pemerinta( a#ala(
perlin#&ngan (a) in#ivi#&perlin#&ngan (a) in#ivi#&
Ting)at yang tepat #ari perlin#&nganTing)at yang tepat #ari perlin#&ngan
a#ala( %el&m pastia#ala( %el&m pasti
Banya) (a) yang #apat #ilin#&ngi melal&iBanya) (a) yang #apat #ilin#&ngi melal&i
penye#iaan s.astapenye#iaan s.asta
2-11
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 12/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-12
The Government as %iolator ofThe Government as %iolator of
RightsRights Any government po.erf&l eno&g( toAny government po.erf&l eno&g( to
protect rig(ts is strong eno&g( to violateprotect rig(ts is strong eno&g( to violate
rig(tsrig(ts
P&%lic sector instit&tions s(o&l# %eP&%lic sector instit&tions s(o&l# %e
#esigne# so as to act in p&%lic interest#esigne# so as to act in p&%lic interest
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 13/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
Pemerintah seagai pelanggarPemerintah seagai pelanggar
hakhak Be%erapa pemerinta( yang )&at mamp& melin#&ngi #anBe%erapa pemerinta( yang )&at mamp& melin#&ngi #an
melanggar hakmelanggar hak
conto( "conto( "
Perlin#&ngan (a) )ons&men melin#&ngi (a) masyara)atPerlin#&ngan (a) )ons&men melin#&ngi (a) masyara)atmelepas)an (arga premi&m )e (arga pasar %erarti
pemerinta( melepas)an tangg&ng /a.a%nya atas
)omo#itas yang ting)at )ons&msi ole( ra)yatnya paling
tinggi0 Pertamina r&giPertamina r&gi
Lem%aga se)tor p&%li) se(ar&snya #irancang &nt&)Lem%aga se)tor p&%li) se(ar&snya #irancang &nt&)
%ertin#a) #alam )epentingan p&%li)%ertin#a) #alam )epentingan p&%li)
2-13
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 14/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-14
The Pulic $nterestThe Pulic $nterest
:(at #oes it mean to act in t(e p&%lic:(at #oes it mean to act in t(e p&%lic
interest8interest8
Greatest goo# for t(e greatest n&m%erGreatest goo# for t(e greatest n&m%er
UtilitarianismUtilitarianism + p&%lic interest meas&re#+ p&%lic interest meas&re#
%y total &tility of society%y total &tility of society
Contemporary UtilitarianismContemporary Utilitarianism + .eig(+ .eig(%enefits an# costs%enefits an# costs
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 15/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-15
Pareto CriteriaPareto Criteria
Pareto s&periorityPareto s&periority + c(ange ma)es at+ c(ange ma)es at
least one person %etter off; no one .orseleast one person %etter off; no one .orse
off off compares two possible situationscompares two possible situations
Pareto optimalityPareto optimality + no one can %e ma#e+ no one can %e ma#e
%etter off .it(o&t ma)ing one person%etter off .it(o&t ma)ing one person
.orse off .orse off applied to a single situationapplied to a single situation
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 16/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
&riteria Pareto&riteria Pareto
Pareto s&perior " per&%a(an yang mem%&atPareto s&perior " per&%a(an yang mem%&at
se)&rang9)&rangnya sat& orang men/a#i le%i(se)&rang9)&rangnya sat& orang men/a#i le%i(
%ai); ti#a) a#a yang men/a#i le%i( %&r&)%ai); ti#a) a#a yang men/a#i le%i( %&r&)
<mem%an#ing)an #&a sit&asi=<mem%an#ing)an #&a sit&asi= Pareto Optim&m " ti#a) a#a seorang p&n yangPareto Optim&m " ti#a) a#a seorang p&n yang
men/a#i le%i( %ai) tanpa mem%&at sat& orangmen/a#i le%i( %ai) tanpa mem%&at sat& orang
men/a#i le%i( %&r&) <apli)asi pa#a sat& sit&asi=men/a#i le%i( %&r&) <apli)asi pa#a sat& sit&asi=
2-16
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 17/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-17
The Pareto CriteriaThe Pareto Criteria
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 18/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
&riteria Pareto&riteria Pareto
2-18
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 19/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-19
The Pareto CriteriaThe Pareto Criteria
!ar)et E'c(ange an# Pareto Criteria!ar)et E'c(ange an# Pareto Criteria Satisfes utilitarian criterionSatisfes utilitarian criterion
Satisfes Pareto superiority in absenceSatisfes Pareto superiority in absence
o negati!e externalities"o negati!e externalities"
Political E'c(ange an# Pareto CriteriaPolitical E'c(ange an# Pareto Criteria Political processPolitical process – i all agree to a– i all agree to a
change# change is Pareto superiorchange# change is Pareto superior
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 20/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-20
'imitations of Pareto Criteria'imitations of Pareto Criteria
ot possi%le to a#(ere strictly to Paretoot possi%le to a#(ere strictly to Pareto
criteriacriteria
Len#s legitimacy to stat&s 7&oLen#s legitimacy to stat&s 7&o
*oes not ran) all possi%le states of t(e*oes not ran) all possi%le states of t(e
.orl#.orl#
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 21/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
&eteratasan &riteria Pareto&eteratasan &riteria Pareto
Ti#a) m&ng)in memat&(i secara )etatTi#a) m&ng)in memat&(i secara )etat
)riteria Pareto)riteria Pareto
!emin/am)an legitimasi stat&s 7&o!emin/am)an legitimasi stat&s 7&o
2-21
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 22/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-22
(ther Measures of the Pulic(ther Measures of the Pulic
$nterest$nterest Potential compensationPotential compensation + gainers val&e+ gainers val&e
gains more t(an losers val&e lossesgains more t(an losers val&e losses
Cost9%enefit analysisCost9%enefit analysis + #ollar val&e place#+ #ollar val&e place#
on costs1%enefits of a pro/ecton costs1%enefits of a pro/ect
Social .elfare f&nctionSocial .elfare f&nction + in#ifference+ in#ifference
c&rves #epicting .elfare of entire societyc&rves #epicting .elfare of entire society
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 23/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
)kuran lain tentang)kuran lain tentang
kepentingan pulikkepentingan pulik -ompensasi potensial-ompensasi potensial
Analisis %iaya manfaatAnalisis %iaya manfaat
6&ngsi -ese/a(teraan sosial6&ngsi -ese/a(teraan sosial
2-23
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 24/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-24
(ther Measures of the Pulic(ther Measures of the Pulic
$nterest$nterest
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 25/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e
)kuran lain * +ungsi &ese,ahteraan sosial)kuran lain * +ungsi &ese,ahteraan sosial
2-25
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 26/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-26
Positive and "ormativePositive and "ormative
EconomicsEconomics Positive economics + .(at isPositive economics + .(at is
conclusions will be either right or wrongconclusions will be either right or wrong
ormative economics + .(at s(o&l# %eormative economics + .(at s(o&l# %e in!ol!es !alue judgmentsin!ol!es !alue judgments
$konomi positi – apa itu$konomi positi – apa itu
kesimpulannya bisa benar atau salahkesimpulannya bisa benar atau salah $konomi normati – apa seharusnya$konomi normati – apa seharusnya
Melibatkan pertimbangan nilaiMelibatkan pertimbangan nilai
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 27/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-27
"ormative Analysis and Pulic"ormative Analysis and Pulic
$nterest$nterest Positive analysis eval&ates effects of policyPositive analysis eval&ates effects of policy
Pareto criteria useul to e!aluate publicPareto criteria useul to e!aluate public
interestinterest
P&%lic sector involves normative analysisP&%lic sector involves normative analysis
Analisis positif mengeval&asi #ampa) )e%i/a)an <)riteriaAnalisis positif mengeval&asi #ampa) )e%i/a)an <)riteria
Pareto %erg&na &nt&) mengeval&asi )epentinganPareto %erg&na &nt&) mengeval&asi )epentinganp&%li)1&m&m=p&%li)1&m&m=
Se)tor p&%li) meli%at)an analisis normatif Se)tor p&%li) meli%at)an analisis normatif
7/23/2019 Holcombe 02
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/holcombe-02 28/28
PUBLIC SECTOR ECOO!ICS" The Role of Government in the American Economy
Ran#all $olcom%e 2-28
Goals of Pulic PolicyGoals of Pulic Policy
Reallocate reso&rces efficiently + positiveReallocate reso&rces efficiently + positive
analysisanalysis
E7&ity + normative analysisE7&ity + normative analysis
T&/&an )e%i/a)an p&%li)"T&/&an )e%i/a)an p&%li)"
!engalo)asi)an )em%ali s&m%er #aya secara!engalo)asi)an )em%ali s&m%er #aya secara
efisien + analisis positif efisien + analisis positif
Pemerataan + analisis normatif Pemerataan + analisis normatif