homeworks trenton€¦ · school students did not meet math state standards and 80.5% of youth did...
TRANSCRIPT
HomeWorks Trenton Fostering a community of empowered young women who strive to achieve their full potential and
positively impact the world around them.
2019 Communication & Marketing Plan TCNJ Student Production by; Nicole Tampone,Christopher Ortiz, Justin Boston, Matthew Green,
Kerry Silverman & Moneek Coleman
Table of Contents
I. Introduction ……………………………………………..………...…………………..... 1
II. Topic/Problem……………………………………………………………………………1
III. The
Task……………………..…………………………..………………………………..3
IV. Research & Analysis……………………………………………………………………..3 A. General Background B. Organizational Background C. Competitive Framework
1. Boarding Schools 2. After School Programs 3. Boarding Homes
V. Target Audience………………………………………………………………………...14
A. Primary B. Secondary
VI. Marketing Objectives…………………………………………………………………..15 A. Fundraising B. Raising Awareness
VII. Strategies………………………………………………………………………………..16 A. Digital Promotion B. Event Promotion C. Opinion Leaders D. Partnerships
VIII. Tactics…………………………………………………………………………………...17 A. Digital Promotion B. Event Promotion C. Opinion Leaders D. Partnerships
IX. Schedule…………………………………………………………………………………17
X. Measurement & Monitoring…………………………………………………………...18
Page 1 of 19
I. Introduction
HomeWorks Trenton is a nonprofit, 501(c)(3) organization that aims to give underprivileged girls
in the Trenton area a better opportunity for success by partnering with the Trenton Public School system
to offer a boarding school-esque lifestyle. Staff members drop the girls off at school in the morning, pick
them up after school, and house them at their HomeWorks facility where they eat, sleep, socialize, and do
homework - all under adult supervision. By giving these girls a safe, fun, educational environment outside
of the classroom, HomeWorks is able to give its participants an advantage in achieving their goals and
dreams. This communications and marketing plan will advise HomeWorks staff and leadership on how to
improve their program’s awareness, fundraising, public perception, and more.
II. Topic/ Problem
The problem is manifold. Schools in the Trenton School District are pushing students
through the education system who fail to meet objective educational metrics. Perhaps linked to
this flawed system, these schools are also experiencing alarmingly low rates of high school
graduation, which is a key determinant in lifelong financial success. Of the many issues that
cause students to underperform in the classroom, the number one reason is chronic absenteeism.
The Trenton School District is experiencing exorbitant rates of chronic absenteeism that puts
students at an immediate disadvantage. This then begs the question: why are Trenton students
chronically absent? There are many reasons, not the least of which is housing instability. Many
students in the district move at least once per year, affecting their home stability and school
attendance. When not in class, students become influenced by dangerous outside forces, like the
extremely high levels of violent crime.
Page 2 of 19
III. The Task
Our challenge is to make it possible for high school girls in Trenton to:
● Achieve their full academic potential by supplementing the education they receive in the
Trenton School District.
● Build social and emotional skills to succeed individually and to positively impact their
schools and communities.
● Develop a growth mindset, a sense of empowerment and agency, and concrete skills to
identify and solve community challenges.
IV. Research & Analysis
A. General Background and Context
The Trenton Public School is struggling with chronic absenteeism, low high school
graduation rates, and underperforming students because of the negative influences outside of the
classroom.
As the HomeWorks business plan explains, in 2017, nearly 100% of Trenton Public
School students did not meet Math State Standards and 80.5% of youth did not meet English
State Standards. Many attribute these failures to a lack of funding for public high schools, which
is an argument with some merit. But many also argue that new textbooks and even laptops won’t
fix Trenton’s institutional problems with education. So why are Trenton high schoolers falling so
far behind? The number one cause, many believe, is chronic absenteeism. In 2017, 36% of high
school students were chronically absent, missing 10% or more of school days per year. That’s
nearly 3 times the rate of absenteeism in New Jersey as a whole according to 2015-16 data from
Page 3 of 19
the U.S. Department of Education. While chronic absenteeism can be caused by many factors,
one reason is they experience housing instability. Nearly 40% of Trenton Public School students
move at least once per year. Moreover, high schoolers in Trenton report having a lack of hope
and feeling constantly unsafe due to drug abuse, gang activity, and high crime. In fact, according
to 2015 FBI statistics, Trenton’s violent crime rate is 3.3 times that of the national average. I
wouldn’t want to walk to school in that neighborhood – would you?
Chronic absenteeism isn’t contained within Trenton, however. It’s a crisis in
impoverished neighborhoods and urban areas across the United States. In fact, Mike Maciag of
Governing.com reported in 2018 that more than 1 in 7 students are chronically absent from
public school in the U.S. Not only that, but at least a dozen schools in nearly every state reports
having chronic absenteeism over 20 percent. Perhaps the most scary is that 2015-16 U.S.
Department of Education Statistics reports that the District of Columbia leads all states with 31%
chronic absenteeism.
B. Organizational Background
History scope mission challenges
HomeWorks was co-founded by Natalie Tung and Brenaea Fairchild in 2016
which was when it was established as a 501(c)(3) non-profit organization. After
its establishment and search of staff members, HomeWorks ran its first pilot of
five girls during the summer of 2017. This lead to the expansion of the program to
ten girls during the summer of 2018, which was successful and has challenged
HomeWorks to work to pilot a four month school year pilot during the fall of
Page 4 of 19
2019. HomeWorks sees this framework for academic enrichment is something
that is cost-effective and conducive to urban environments across the country, and
the world that could help create positive change in urban youth. HomeWorks has
a mission to create a community-based, after-school boarding program that
provides academic and social-emotional enrichment activities to supplement the
public school system, to empower women, and to build community leaders. The
non-profit organization works to combat issues such as chronic absenteeism,
obstacles to academic success, and systemic injustices in the city of Trenton.
C. Competitive Framework
1. Boarding Schools
The Lawrenceville School Founded in 1810, The Lawrenceville School is an independent college preparatory
boarding school for students both female and male in grades 9 through 12.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
817 students. 8 to 1 student ratio with a class average size of 12. Students get hands on personal experience. (not as personal as HomeWorks). 100% of students go on to attend a 4 year college.
Boarding + Tuition is 62,190 Not affordable. Small amount who can attend. HomeWorks is FREE. Boarding school, so students would not see family regularly.
2018 Annual Report - Revenue & Expenses pgs 8-9 https://issuu.com/thelawrencevilleschool/docs/lville_18annual5sp?e=2194472/66044322 Total Revenue: $63,600,000 Total Expenses: $63,127,000
Princeton Day School
Page 5 of 19
Princeton Day School is a private coeducational day school located in Princeton, New Jersey, serving students in pre-kindergarten through twelfth grade.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Percentage of seniors attending four-year college: 100% Average class size: 12-16 students Top five schools attended by PDS students over a five-year period ('13-'18): New York University (21), Lehigh University (12), Princeton University (15), University of Chicago (11), Boston College (10), Duke University (10) 25% of students on financial aid totalling $5 million
2018-2019 tuition by division: PreK through Fourth Grade: $30,240 Fifth and Sixth Grades: $35,370 Seventh through Twelfth Grade: $37,060 Tuition price is a barrier to entry for HomeWorks target audience
2017 Annual Report - Revenue & Expenses pgs 34-35 https://issuu.com/princetondayschool/docs/journal_fall_2017_singlepages_from_ Revenue: $28,805,191 Expenses: $28,803,333
Christina Seix Academy
CSA is an innovative urban Pre-K-8 independent school focused on providing students from underserved communities with a holistic education, critical habits of mind, and an engaging learning environment.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Small class sizes - 5 to 1 student to teacher ratio Advanced curriculum, including Music, Spanish, Civics, Science, Math, Coding, and English
Prepares students for private high schools, displacing them from the community. High operational costs that make it hard to scale
Page 6 of 19
Literature Wide variety of extra-curricular activities including tennis, fencing, lacrosse, soccer, vocal/performing arts, and more
New Jersey SEEDS
NJ SEEDS is a nonprofit that changes the live of motivated, high-achieving students from low-income families by transforming their educational opportunities.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
100% of high school seniors enrolled in four year college for Fall 2018 A SEEDS family’s average income is $32,677. SEEDS spends $17,000 to educate each student. That investment often yields $450,000 in high school and college scholarships.
Expensive to operate Not scalable to other urban areas
2017 Annual Report - Revenue & Expenses Pgs 36-37 https://njseeds.org/2017-annual-report/ Total Revenue: $3,447,130 Total Expenses: $4,334,411
The Pennington School
Founded in 1838, The Pennington School is an independent, coeducational school serving day and boarding students in grades 6 through 12.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Strong alumni network - 4,600 alumni of record
Very expensive - nearly $40,000
Annual report unavailable
Page 7 of 19
54-acre campus 525 students and 45+ clubs Large, tight-knit community
HomeWorks is FREE Trenton students would leave their own communities to attend
2. After School Programs
The Boys & Girls Club
Founded in 1937, The Boys & Girls Club of Mercer County provides young people, ages 5 to 18, with social, enrichment and recreational activities through after-school, weekend, and summer programs.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Real Estate: Centre Street Community Center (17,000 square foot facility with a gymnasium, arcade, dance/karate studio, art studio, STEM center, Tech center, outdoor pool and numerous classrooms) Funding: With over 2,600 youth memberships, numerous partnerships and donations from the school system, the B&G club is able to afford free after school bus pickup to 9 different elementary schools along with full education and operation staffs. Reputation: With 80 years of operation in Mercer County, in addition to over 4,000
Number of Children: With so many students enrolling in the program and attending summer camp events, the type of attention and education each kid receives suffer. Staff forms temporary relationships, not long-lasting development
Monthly fee: $100 per child +$25 membership fee (annual)
Page 8 of 19
other locations, the B&G club is well known for their after school programs and summer camps
HomeFront Homefront is a social services organization dedicated to aiding those who are homeless and/or poverty stricken within Central New Jersey.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Partnerships: Homefront partners with business like Mathmatica and Educational Testing Service, schools such as Cherry Tree Club preschool & The Pennington School and facilities programs like the Lawrence Community Center Reputation/Approach: Homefront has s cemented reputation of charity through caring in the community. Facilities/Funding: The 42,000-square-foot Family Preservation Center hosts 38 families having just undergone a $6 million renovation project Organization and Staff: HomeFront has a full staff, including a board of directors.
Acceptance: HomeFront is not for those living in the lower-middle class, only the poorest of families are given aid
n/a
Page 9 of 19
Big Brothers Big Sisters (of Mercer County)
Big Brothers Big Sisters is the nation’s largest donor and volunteer supported mentoring network,that makes meaningful, monitored matches between adult volunteers (“Bigs”) and children (“Littles”), ages 6 through 18, in communities across the country
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Partners/Donors: BGBS has a network of corporate, community and individual sponsors around the world, who’s funding is distributed to individual chapter locations Size/”Market” share: Over 500 current students enrolled, operates within over 50 Mercer County schools Volunteer Network
Time spent: Mentors are only required to see their menee twice a week (for an hour+)
n/a: Run on a volunteer basis and funded through donarships
Young Scholar’s Institute
The Young Scholar’s Institute, founded in 1990, is a nonprofit after school learning center that provides educational, cultural and recreational activities for students Pre-K through 12th grade. YSI’s mission is to empower Trenton-area youth and help them develop the skills necessary to excel academically, vocationally and beyond within their career choices.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Location and Housing: YSI’s mansion is located in the heart of Trenton, on Rt. 1. S.A.T/ACT Prep Courses
costs
College Tours are $580 Young Scholar’s Program (Pre-K through 5th grade) is $185 per week
Page 10 of 19
Financial Support from the Harbouton Foundation College Tours and Connections with Princeton University Pre-Med Prep Program
Pre-Med Prep Program is free
YMCA The Capital Area YMCA shares a commitment of nurturing kids, promoting healthy
living and fostering a sense of social responsibility. It is a health and fitness center that also offers a safe place for children to learn and grow as leaders.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Free Food Access for Children Youth basketball, soccer and lacrosse classes Outdoor Pool Facility
More of a focus on health and wellness rather than education Unpersonalized environment with thousands of members
$85 annual membership for pool access $90 Family Membership for up to 4 children
3. Boarding Homes
Anchor House
The Anchor House is a stabilizing place for runaway, homeless and abused youth. It is a safe place to rest, and “wait through the storm while in crisis and a way to move on when the crisis is calmed.” It was founded in 1978.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Housing Only serves ages 12 through n/a
Page 11 of 19
Programs: Shelter, Outreach Program, Connecting Youth Program
21
Hopeworks
Hopeworks combines education, technology and entrepreneurship so youth, ages 16-25
can build professional web design and development skills. It is located in Camden, New Jersey and provides a healing atmosphere to propel trouble students out of a cycle of violence and poverty.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Connections: Hopeworks has an alumni network of business professionals who are skilled in several areas Events: They host many featured events for those who are interested in learning more
Sole focus on business and web design
n/a
LifeTies
LifeTies helps struggling adolescents and young adults successfully transition into
adulthood by giving youth the groundwork for a bright future through safe housing, clinical services and life skills.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Housing: LifeTies has 3 different locations, for both youth, men and women. Volunteer Network and Social Presence (Social
Sole focus on youth ages 14-21
n/a
Page 12 of 19
Media/Website, etc.) Fundraising: One sole fundraiser (“The annual signature event”) raises enough funds to cover operational costs for the year.
Boys’ Hope Girls’ Hope
Boys Hope Girls Hope helps academically capable and motivated children-in-need to
meet their full potential and become men and women for others by providing value-centered, family-like homes, opportunities and education through college.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Online blog/news platform Large network of 14 cities Focus on Academics Housing for 6-12 students 99% of students go to college
n/a
n/a
A Better Chance
Founded in 1963, A Better Chance has a vision to be a preeminent resource for
identifying, recruiting and developing leaders among young people of color throughout the United States.
Strengths: Weaknesses: Costs:
Large School network of over 2,000 students 96% of students gain college
Sole focus minorities grades 4 through 9
n/a
Page 13 of 19
admission College connections with over 100 Universities
D. Five Forces Analysis
1) Threat of New Entrants
Homeworks is a unique service that does have a moderate threat of new
entrants. The entrants can vary from different things such as public school,
boarding programs, and after-school activities. Each of these can pose a threat
because students and their families may be more inclined to sign them up for
different programs other than Homeworks and the blended experience. There is
however a high demand for programs like this to assist in academic and activity
engagement because of Trenton’s high absentee rate and below sufficient test
scores. Homeworks is also very cost-effective and zero costing to students and
their families.
2) Threat of Substitution
It is possible that grantmakers will switch to competitors in the business.
This can be definitely seen in analyzing boarding schools because instead of
adding additional work and assistance like Homeworks, boarding schools will
have a completely different base education and can eliminate the problem of
Page 14 of 19
receiving a poor education through public school systems. This a huge threat to
Homeworks but it is important to recognize that Homeworks additionally brings
benefits like family time as well as the ability to experience public school and an
everyday routine within the community.
3) Bargaining Power of Grantmakers (Buyers)
The mission of Homeworks is to provide a collaborative and enhanced
learning program for young women in Trenton. This is a mission shared by
boarding schools and other after-school programs. Grantmakers should know
when “buying into” Homeworks they are allowing the students to experience
public school, enhance their skills in a variety of wholesome ways, as well as in
an organization that is no-cost to the students and provides them with a close-knit
family environment. Grantmakers are investing in creating a positive environment
for all the scholars that are a part of it.
4) Bargaining Power of Service Providers (Suppliers)
Providers play a key role in upholding the high level of Homeworks. It is
important because its programs must be proven to be effective and influential in
order to justify the program in addition to the public school experience. It is
essential that the trainings that the scholars receive are the best becaus it greatly
Page 15 of 19
influences the organization's power in recruitment and getting donors to be
interested in the effectiveness of their organization.
5) Competitive Rivalry Intensity
In the Trenton area, we have already identified several different
competitors throughout the area that act as major rivals for Homeworks. Trenton
does have a large amount of programs that pose as rivals to Homeworks, but
Homeworks is a different program from them all. It is not a boarding school, and
it is not an after-school program. Homeworks is a blended learning experience
that allows students to experience public school, academic enrichment activities,
after-school type programs, and boarding. This blended experience is the only one
in the Trenton area currently, and it something different than the others which
gives it huge market power.
V. Target Audience
A. Primary: After School Students
HomeWorks’ target audience is high school aged females currently living within
the city of Trenton. The program seeks dedicated young ladies that successfully meet
academic criteria and genuinely wants to improve. These are young females that
showcase a sense of maturity and ambition towards their future. The structure of the
program allows for the young ladies to improve not only themselves but their personal
Page 16 of 19
relationships. In which, every participant must have a parent or guardian involved during
the selection process and continue a relationship. Despite the scholar's personal
circumstances, HomeWorks is dedicated to bridging the gap and providing the tools for a
successful future.
B. Secondary: Day Students
While the core of our program is after-school boarding, we plan to also accept day
students from Trenton Public Middle Schools who will come twice per week for a few hours for
academic support. In addition to providing us with additional funding, this approach will allow
us to reach a wider proposition of the community through educational support. Day students will
have access to the same level of academic support (career prep, college counseling, etc.) as the
boarding students.
VI. Plan Objectives
A. Fundraising
a. Open House: During the fall, an Open House may be an effective way to bring in
serious donors who are interested in seeing how HomeWorks operates and the
effectiveness in the program. However, with the issue of confidentiality of the
location of the home and privacy of the girls, it may be more effective to host a
donors event at a different location where donors would have the opportunity to
meet the girls without entering the home. In this meeting, donors can learn from
the girls as well as ask question involving the activities and learning enrichment
opportunities they take part in throughout the day. This can be hosted at a
Page 17 of 19
restaurant where donors are invited to dine and talk with some appetizers, or a
coffee house event to provide a safer setting.
b. Campus Town Fundraisers Series: On April 26th - 28th campus town restaurants
at The College of New Jersey hosted fundraisers in order to build awareness and
raise monetary funds for HomeWorks. Though the fundraiser was not overall a
large success, it was able to effectively raise awareness for HomeWorks amongst
The College of New Jersey’s campus.
B. Raising Awareness
a. Three Part Trenton Daily Series: These three part newspaper op-eds are essential
in gaining awareness for HomeWorks. The series is designed to inform the reader
about HomeWorks and educate them of the benefits of the program and what
problems it helps solve within the Trenton community. Additionally, the series
helps readers understand the impact the program has on the girls and their
families. It was also to include a call-out to donors to gain more financial
assistance in order for the program to run smoothly.
VII. Strategies
A. Digital Promotion a. Post on social media (i.e. Facebook, Twitter, and Instagram) b. Can also be used to help promote events and fundraisers c. On instagram for example, we can do profiles of some of the girls and have the
explain what the program means to them, in a way to get outside viewers more knowledge of the mission and why it is so important
B. Event Promotion a. Fundraisers such as a 5K, career day, or events held in TCNJ Campus Town (i.e.
Frutta Bowls, Panera, Empower Yoga, etc.)
Page 18 of 19
b. Though the 5K would likely bring more attention it is costly and time consuming c. An event such as a Dine 2 Donate (in which restaurants give a percentage of the
proceeds to the charity) holds the potential to receive definite donations without much cost.
C. Opinion Leaders Leverage the needs of other organizations in the area that have influence to get attention. For example, TrentonDaily is a publication that only writes about positive stories in Trenton, and they are always looking for content to cover. An up-and-coming nonprofit with groundbreaking potential like HomeWorks would be a great story for an Op-Ed or series of Op-Eds in TrentonDaily.
D. Partnerships Opportunity to partner with businesses within the Trenton community or even those who resonate with the mission and are willing to help promote and fund certain projects. It is critical to build partnerships that can sustain a consistent level of funding.
VIII. Tactics A. Digital Promotion
● Leverage social media to attract young people in the local and TCNJ communities to get involved through donations or volunteering. Regular posting online, as well as Sponsored Ads on Facebook and Instagram, would get HomeWorks social media significantly more attention.
B. Event Promotion ● Post flyers for fundraisers on social media and share it with groups in the college
community to raise awareness for the cause. ● Hand out flyers on campus and in the campus town area.
C. Opinion Leaders ● Draft Op-Eds and pitch them to TrentonDaily including information on Natalie
Tung’s personal story, the personal stories of growth from the girls, and the need for more funds to expand the program.
D. Partnerships ● Continue to strengthen the relationships HomeWorks has with its current partners,
such as the Shiloh Community Development Corporation. Use those partnerships
to expand professional network and gain more partners, especially grant-making
institutions and wealthy donors.
IX. Schedule
Page 19 of 19
It is critical to focus on the timing in which we plan to share our digital tools, events,
Op-Eds, and partnerships. First and foremost, with the installation of the new web page, it is
critical we begin with kickstarting social media presence. We must create an instagram, create a
Facebook group for our event inviting people to come learn more about HomeWorks, and
building a presence on other locations such as twitter, and LinkedIn. The LinkedIn will
specifically assist in building the presence in a professional atmosphere, and the content that is
posted may be different and have a more professional undertone compared to the other
platforms. It is critical that our social media is up to date so that we can begin to kickstart
promotions of fundraising and attracting events.
Additionally, after our platforms are established, we must create ways to attain public
attention and gain donors. This can be created through the creation of op-eds in publications, as
well as through fundraising events designed to build brand recognition. Some fundraisers may
not be the most lucrative, but are critical in introducing the organization into different networks.
During the summer leading up to Fall 2019, it is critical to finalize funding for the next
academic year. Funding should be secure and donors should be approved so that the academic
term is prepared to run when the fall begins. During the fall semester, an open house event for
donors or an event attracting donors should be in place in order to begin the process of attaining
new donors for the next year and building a consistent base.
Throughout the year HomeWorks should be advertising their brand consistently and
making sure to gain certain levels of exposure and funding on a monthly basis. A blog may also
Page 20 of 19
be a useful tactic in building viewership and allowing donors to keep up with the progress of
HomeWorks and what the girls are learning.
X. Measurement & Monitoring
The most critical component that HomeWorks must focus on is attracting consistent
donors to contribute to benefiting the program. The most effective way to measure whether
HomeWorks will meet fundraising goals would be to create monthly goals for the amount of
money that we seek to raise by the end of the month. It is critical to monitor at all times the
money that is coming in and seeking out donors that could provide consistent funding. Each
calendar year the goal must be set so that HomeWorks can effectively use advertising strategies
to gain momentum from donors. Additionally, it is absolutely critical that HomeWorks is seeking
consistent donors who will donate each year so that we can have a base of funds we expect
before each academic term. Thus, monitoring HomeWorks advertising and outreach per month is
critical through social media platforms and other areas in which HomeWorks can gain public
attention. Data can be collected on the viewership of HomeWorks site as well as through social
media platforms. Additionally, data should be recorded from donors to track and make sure we
are keeping funding each year.
Additional to building donorship at HomeWorks, HomeWorks could measure student
success by beginning to analyze their performance within the classroom. This can be measured
by comparing report cards previous to HomeWorks and afterward, as well as allowing the
scholars to take part in a pre and post exam involving things such as literacy and math
proficiency. Finally, to track scholar progress in a less qualitative way, weekly reflections by the
Page 21 of 19
scholars to help analyze their progress and emotions throughout the program could be effective
in recognizing differences in attitude and mentality.
Page 22 of 19