hotel le crystal, montréal, québec...2018 incam research symposium november 9-10, 2018 hotel le...

28
2018 INCAM Research Symposium Complementary and Integrave Medicine Research in an Era of Skepcism Interdisciplinary. Integrative. Investigative. November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec Organized by: Symposium Program

Upload: others

Post on 04-Apr-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Complementary and Integrative Medicine Research in an Era of Skepticism

Interdisciplinary. Integrative. Investigative.

November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec

Organized by:

Symposium Program

Page 2: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

November 9-10, 2018

Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec

ABOUT THE RESEARCH SYMPOSIUM

Over the last 14 years, the Symposium has become established as the premier research meeting in

Canada on complementary and integrative health care. It brings together a diverse group of

individuals from across disciplines, capturing a range of research expertise and research interests.

It has been described as an idea lab as it creates an environment that enables a high level of

interaction and quality discussion to address challenging questions and innovative ways to explore

these questions. SYMPOSIUM OBJECTIVES

To showcase high quality research on complementary and integrative medicine & health care

To discuss and debate the on-going development of this emerging field of research

To bring together people and support their ability to network, create new research

collaborations, and gain access to the researchers in this field.

RESEARCH ABSTRACTS

The 2018 INCAM Research Symposium abstracts are published pre-conference in the Journal of

Complementary and Integrative Medicine. View here: https://doi.org/10.1515/jcim-2018-2000

SYMPOSIUM PLANNING AND SCIENTIFIC REVIEW COMMITTEE

i

Lynda Balneaves Heather Boon Kieran Cooley

Isabelle Gaboury Nathaly Gaudrault Jeremy Ng

www.iscmr.org

Page 3: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

November 9-10, 2018

Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec

PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS:

Main Symposium—November 9 & 10

Keynote Speakers—International experts

in the field

Skepticism and Complementary and

Integrative Research and Practice—

International experts share their

experiences of conducting research in a

context of skepticism

INCAM’s Annual General Meeting

Dr. Roger’s Prize Lecture and Lunch

Research Presentations—oral and poster

Poster Competition—awards for research

trainees

Workshops—practical and engaging

INCAM Networking Reception—meet

other INCAM research symposium

attendees

ii www.iscmr.org

Page 4: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

INCAM Research Symposium SPONSORS

Platinum Sponsor:

Silver Sponsors:

Bronze Sponsors:

Thank you to our sponsors— without whom the Symposium would not be possible!

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

November 9-10, 2018

Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec

iii www.iscmr.org

Page 5: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Table of Contents

Symposium—Friday, November 9 & Saturday, November 10

Skepticism and Complementary and Integrative Research and Practice—November 9____ 1

Symposium Program at a Glance_______________________________________________________ 2

Symposium Program—November 9______________________________________________________ 3

Symposium Program—November 10_____________________________________________________ 7

Poster Presentations—Friday, November 9 & Saturday, November 10

General Symposium____________________________________________________________________ 10

Workshops—Friday, November 9 & Saturday, November 10

Medical Cannabis in Canada: Implications for Integrative Healthcare____________________ 11

Increasing Chances to Have your Abstract Accepted for National and International

Scientific Symposium Events_____________________________________________________________

12

Fostering Fairness in TCAIM Research Dialogue: Struggles and Strategies___________________ 13

Effective Communication and Messaging Strategies for CAM in an Age of Attention

Deficit, Media Transformation, and Universal Skepticism__________________________________

14

Other

Recipients of INCAM Travel Awards______________________________________________________ 15

CCRF Recipients and ISCMR Scientific Article Prize________________________________________ 16

Symposium Delegate Contact List_______________________________________________________ 17

Hotel Le Crystal Floorplan_______________________________________________________________ 20

Space for Notes________________________________________________________________________ 21

About INCAM__________________________________________________________________________ 23

iv www.iscmr.org

Page 6: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Skepticism and Complementary and

Integrative Research and Practice

DATE: Friday, November 9, 2018

TIME: 4:30—5:30pm

LOCATION: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec

A panel of experts who share their experiences on skepticism and

complementary and integrative research and practice

1

FACILITATOR

by Heather Boon, BScPhD, PhD

University of Toronto

PANELIST SPEAKERS

Lynda Balneaves, RN, PhD

University of Manitoba

Colleen Derkatch, PhD

Ryerson University

Pierre Haddad, PhD

University of Montreal

www.iscmr.org

Page 7: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Symposium Program at a Glance

TIME ACTIVITY

8:00am—8:45am Registration

8:45am—9:00am Welcome & Opening of Symposium

9:00am—10:00am Keynote Speaker: Hélène Langevin

10:00am—10:20am Nutrition Break

10:20am—11:05am Poster Sessions (Manual Therapies; Naturopathic and TCAIM Research)

Oral Presentations Session 1 (Reviews)

11:20am—12:20pm Oral Presentations Session 2 (Qualitative Research; Cannabis and Opioid Use;

Acupuncture and Mind-Body Research)

12:20pm—1:15pm Lunch

1:30pm—2:30pm Keynote Speaker: Colleen Derkatch

2:45pm—4:00pm Concurrent Workshops (Medical Cannabis in Canada: Implications for Integrative

Healthcare; Increasing Chances to have Your Abstract Accepted for National

and International Scientific Symposium Events; Fostering Fairness in TCAIM research

dialogue: Struggles and Strategies)

4:00pm—4:20pm Nutrition Break

4:30pm—5:30pm Expert Panel: Skepticism and Complementary and Integrative Research and Practice

5:30pm—7:00pm Reception

TIME ACTIVITY

7:45am—9:00am Theme Breakfast

9:15am—10:15am Keynote Speaker: Mark Ware

10:30am—11:45am Oral Presentations Session 3 (Osteopathy; Surveys)

Workshop (Effective Communication and Messaging Strategies for CAM in an

Age of Attention Deficit, Media Transformation, and Universal Skepticism)

12:00pm—1:30pm Dr. Rogers Prize Buffet Lunch

INCAM AGM

Chair-Elect Election

1:45pm—2:30pm Dr. Rogers Prize Keynote Speaker: Dugald Seely

2:30pm—3:00pm Closing Remarks & Wrap Up

Friday, November 9, 2018

Saturday, November 10, 2018

2 www.iscmr.org

Page 8: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

TIME & LOCATION ACTIVITY

8:00am-8:45am

Bishop’s Lounge

Registration

No Breakfast Provided

8:45am-9:00am

Crescent

Welcome & Opening of Symposium

Isabelle Gaboury and Kieran Cooley

Hélène Langevin, MD Stretching, Connective Tissue, Inflammation and Cancer Director, Osher Center for Integrative Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital and Harvard Medical School

Dr. Langevin received an MD degree from McGill University, completed a post doctoral

research fellowship in Neurochemistry at the MRC Neurochemical Pharmacology Unit in

Cambridge, England, residency in Internal Medicine and fellowship in Endocrinology and

Metabolism at Johns Hopkins Hospital. She is a Professor in Residence of Medicine and

Director of the Osher Center for Integrative Medicine at Harvard Medical School and

Brigham and Women's Hospital, and also a Visiting Professor of Neurological Sciences at the

University of Vermont College of Medicine. Dr. Langevin has been selected as the next

Director of the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health, beginning

November 2018.

Dr. Langevin has been the Principal Investigator of several NIH-funded studies investigating

the role of connective tissue in low back pain and the mechanisms of acupuncture, manual

and movement-based therapies. Her previous studies in humans and animal models have

shown that mechanical tissue stimulation during both tissue stretch and acupuncture causes

dynamic cellular responses in connective tissue. Her current work focuses on the effects of

stretching on inflammation resolution mechanisms within connective tissue, and their

relevance to chronic musculoskeletal pain and cancer.

9:00am—10:00am

Crescent

Introduction: Heather Boon

Keynote speaker: Hélène Langevin

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Symposium Program

Friday, November 9, 2018

3 www.iscmr.org

Page 9: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Symposium Program—Friday, November 9

René-Lévesque

Drummond

Poster Sessions

Poster Session: Manual Therapies (Chair: Isabelle Gaboury)

Poster Session: Naturopathic and TCAIM Research (Chair: Brenda Leung)

Crescent 1.1 Oral Presentations: Reviews (Chair: Kieran Cooley)

Kieran Cooley

Diet and psychosis: A scoping review

Bryn Sumpton

A scan of the Canadian massage therapy education environment

Avery McNair

Beyond affluent wellness: Social justice-geared TCAIM service models in North America

10:00—10:20am

Bishop’s Ballroom

Nutrition Break

10:20am—11:05am Poster Sessions

Oral Presentations Session 1

4

11:20am—12:20pm Oral Presentation Session 2

Drummond 2.1 Oral Presentations: Qualitative Research (Chair: Heather Boon)

Amanda Baskwill

A description of the professional identity of massage therapist in Ontario

Nadine Ijaz

Risky enough to regulate? The profession of homeopathy in Ontario, Canada

Lynda Balneaves

Nursing policies and regulations in the era of medical cannabis

René-Lévesque 2.2 Oral Presentations: Cannabis and Opioid Use (Chair: Nathaly

Gaudrault)

Samah Hassan

Does integrative medicine approach reduce prescribed opioid use/dose for chronic

pain? A systematic literature review

Kieran Cooley

Cannabinoids use in critically ill ventilated patients: A qualitative study using

q-methodology

Jeremy Y. Ng

Evaluating stakeholder perceptions and health policy surrounding natural health

product and medical cannabis regulation: A case study of Health Canada – A

doctorate research proposal

www.iscmr.org

Page 10: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Symposium Program—Friday, November 9

De La Montagne 2.3 Oral Presentations: Acupuncture and Mind-Body Research (Chair: Brenda

Leung)

Marian Luctkar-Flude

Preliminary results of a mixed methods study of effects of neurofeedback on cognitive

impairment and fatigue in post-treatment breast cancer survivors

Linda Zhong

The combination efficacy and safety of body acupuncture and auricular acupressure

for body weight control: A single-randomized sham-controlled trial

Wendy Takeda

Pilot study of acupuncture to treat anxiety in children and adolescents

12:20pm - 1:15pm

Ste-Catherine

Lunch

1:30pm—2:30pm

Crescent

Introduction: Lynda Balneaves

Keynote speaker: Colleen Derkatch

5 www.iscmr.org

Colleen Derkatch CAM Research and the Rhetoric of Evidence

Ryerson University

Colleen Derkatch is Associate Professor in the Department of English at Ryerson University

and the author of Bounding Biomedicine: Evidence and Rhetoric in the New Science of

Alternative Medicine (University of Chicago Press, 2016). Her new book project on rhetorics of

wellness and natural health is supported by a SSHRC Insight Grant.

Page 11: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Symposium Program—Friday, November 9

2:45pm—4:00pm

Concurrent Workshops

4:00pm—4:20pm

Bishop

Nutrition Break

4:30pm—5:30pm

Crescent

Expert Panel: Skepticism and Complementary and Integrative Research and Practice

5:30pm—7:00pm

Bishop

Reception

René-Lévesque Workshop 1

Presented by:

Lynda Balneaves

Medical cannabis in Canada: Implications

for integrative healthcare

De La Montagne Workshop 2

Presented by:

Chantal Morin, Nathalie Trottier

Increasing chances to have your abstract

accepted for national and international

scientific symposium events

Drummond Workshop 3

Presented by:

Nadine Ijaz, John Weeks,

Antony Porcino

Fostering fairness in TCAIM research dialogue:

Struggles and strategies

6 www.iscmr.org

Page 12: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

ACTIVITY

7:45am–9:00am

René-Lévesque

De la Montagne

American Breakfast Provided

:15am-10:15am

Crescent

Introduction: Isabelle Gaboury

Keynote Speaker: Mark Ware

Mark Ware, BA MBBS MRCP(UK) MSc

Cannabis and health: herbal medicine, with a twist…

McGill University

Dr. Mark Ware is currently the Chief Medical Officer of Canopy Growth Corporation. He

has taken a leave of absence as Associate Professor in Family Medicine and Anesthesia at

McGill University from July 2018 to work in this capacity. He previously served as Director of

Clinical Research of the Alan Edwards Pain Management Unit at the McGill University

Health Centre for over 10 years, and was the Executive Director of the non-profit

Canadian Consortium for the Investigation of Cannabinoids since 2007. He has served as

co-director of the FRQS-supported Quebec Pain Research Network, and sat on the

executive management team of the Alan Edwards Centre for Research on Pain at McGill

University. His research has been funded and supported by CIHR, FRQS, private

foundations and pharmaceutical companies. He has published over 100 papers on

cannabis and pain research in academic journals, has written 6 book chapters, and has

given hundreds of lectures to health professionals and the public on cannabis over the last

20 years. He has served as a consultant to several large corporate and academic

research programs internationally. He has advised the Canadian federal government on

cannabis policy since 2001, and 2016, he served as the vice chair of the Federal Task

Force on the Legalization and Regulation of Cannabis in Canada.

7

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Symposium Program

Saturday, November 10, 2018

www.iscmr.org

Page 13: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

10:30am-11:45am

Oral Presentations Session 3

Workshop

René-Lévesque 3.1 Osteopathy (Chair: Nathaly Gaudreault)

Karine Devantéry

Effect of global osteopathic treatment on functional mobility in the Parkinsonian

patient: a quasi-experimental study

Chantal Morin

Quality of randomized control trials and pilot trials in osteopathy according to the

CONSORT checklist

Alexandrine Brisson-Larouche

Can lateral epicondylitis be relief by osteopathic treatments targeting tensions from

the thoracic region? Results of a case study

Gabriel Charlebois

Case study: Can craniosacral osteopathic manual treatment (OMT) decrease intensity

and frequency of headaches in an adult with a past traumatic head injury associated

with abducens nerve paralysis in childhood?

Drummond 3.2 Surveys (Chair: Kieran Cooley)

Jessica LaChance

Unmet care needs, access to a regular medical doctor, and CAM use in Canadian

adults with chronic pain: Findings from the National Population Health Study

Athanasios Psihogios

Preliminary results from the Integrative Pediatric Oncology Program (IPOP) Survey of

OncANP members to determine clinical trends in naturopathic pediatric cancer care

Kieran Cooley

Naturopathy Special Interest Group (N-SIG) research capacity and needs assessment

survey

Symposium Program—Saturday, November 10

8

De la Montagne Workshop 4

Presented by:

Anne Leis, Michael Epstein,

Dugald Seely, Lynda Balneaves

Effective communication and messaging

strategies for CAM in an age of attention

deficit, media transformation, and universal

skepticism

Crescent

12:00pm – 1:30pm

Dr. Rogers Prize Buffet Lunch

INCAM Annual General Meeting

www.iscmr.org

Page 14: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Dr. Rogers Prize Lecture

Dugald Seely, ND, MSc, FABNO Walking the tightrope of integrative medicine in today's climate Founder and Executive Director, Ottawa Integrative Cancer Centre

Winner of the prestigious Dr. Rogers Prize in 2017, Dugald Seely is a naturopathic

doctor and clinician scientist whose focus is on the application and evaluation of

integrative oncology. Embodying a vibrant synthesis of evidence-based

complementary medicine with conventional medicine, integrative oncology offers

a path for improved clinical care that is obvious to the conscientious practitioner

and that best supports patients in the way they most need. Dr. Seely seeks to build

a richer integration of this medicine within the health care system as a respected

path for practitioners and researchers and ultimately for patients to be best served.

Dr. Seely is the founder and executive director of the Ottawa Integrative Cancer

Centre (OICC) and executive director for the department of research & clinical

epidemiology at the Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine. Dr. Seely is an

affiliate investigator at the Ottawa Hospital Research Institute; Adjunct Professor

with the Faculty of Medicine at the University of Ottawa; Integrative Oncology

Section Editor for the journal Current Oncology; and Vice President of the

Oncology Association of Naturopathic Physicians. Dr. Seely has published over 70

peer-reviewed papers and is a frequent speaker at various research symposia. In

clinic, Dr. Seely sees patients three days a week and is thrilled to be able to

combine his passion for research and in the service of the patients he cares for.

Symposium Program—Saturday November 10

1:45 – 2:30pm

Crescent

Dr. Rogers Prize Keynote Speaker: Dugald Seely, ND

2:30pm – 3:00pm

Crescent

Symposium Closing

Closing Remarks, Wrap Up, & Announcement of Poster Competition Winners

9 www.iscmr.org

Page 15: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

View the Posters Online here: https://www.morressier.com/event/5bb22313f0ad580010bd29d9

Manual Therapies:

1. Sabine Beaulieu-Provencher: The importance of lymphatic osteopathic manipulative

treatment (OMT) in the practice and training of osteopaths in Québec: A qualitative research

study

2. Kyla Demers: The inter-rater reliability of the frontal, temporal, parietal bones, and the spheno-

occipital synchrondrosis mobility test as assessed through manual therapy

3. Anne-Marie Fafard: The effect of early osteopathic manual treatment (OMT) care, after

vaginal delivery, on pelvic health recovery

4. Julien Fatisson: Fundamental study of a visceral pericardial osteopathic protocol on heart

physiology

5. Sue Michaud: Patients’ experiences of ending massage therapy care

6. Sandra O'Connor: Assessing the immediate behavioural responses of hospitalized preterm

babies during osteopathic manipulative treatment (OMT): A case series

Naturopathic and TCAIM Research:

1. David Brulé: The use of telemedicine in complementary medicine consulting: A survey-in-

process of homeopaths and naturopaths in Ontario, Canada

2. Elise Cogo: Natural health products in integrative cancer care: Which ones have the most

promising evidence from 218 recent reviews of human controlled studies?

3. Benoît Hogedez: Theoretical foundations and efficacy of osteopathy: A philosophical

approach

4. Dugald Seely: Naturopathic oncology care for thoracic cancers: A practice survey

5. Dugald Seely: Canadian/US Integrative Oncology Study (CUSIOS): Protocol and study status

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Poster Presentations

November 9-10, 2018

10 www.iscmr.org

Page 16: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Medical cannabis in Canada: Implications for integrative health care

Workshop Facilitators:

Lynda G. Balneaves

Workshop Objectives:

Workshop attendees will engage in the following:

1. Develop understanding of the current regulations and policies in Canada related to medical and non-

medical cannabis.

2. Review the current evidence regarding the efficacy and safety of medical cannabis and its role in

integrative health care.

3. Discuss and identify research priorities and challenges for medical cannabis in the context of integrative

health care.

Intended Audiences:

Integrative health care practitioners and researchers

Workshop Description:

This workshop will combine didactic lectures with small and large group discussion to explore the current

regulatory environment surrounding medical and non-medical cannabis, the current evidence regarding the

efficacy and safety of medical cannabis across diverse health conditions, and identify priorities and

challenges to conducting medical cannabis research. The lectures and group discussions will focus on the

role of medical cannabis within integrative health care, drawing on the field's expertise related to natural

health products and experience of being positioned by some as a stigmatized form of health care. Workshop

lectures will cover the following topics: 1) Current regulations of medical cannabis in Canada; 2) Impending

legalization of non-medical cannabis in Canada; 3) Latest evidence regarding the efficacy and safety of

medical cannabis; and 4) Potential role of the integrative health care practitioners related to medical and

non-medical cannabis. Small group discussions will be held with participants regarding the practice

opportunities presented by cannabis as well as related research priorities. Barriers to cannabis research and

practice and potentials solutions will also be identified among the small groups. The workshop will conclude

with a large group discussion identifying the top practice and research priorities related to cannabis.

Anticipated Outcomes:

From this workshop, participants will become more informed regarding the current regulatory context

surrounding cannabis in Canada and identify potential practice and research opportunities presented by

medical cannabis. Research priorities relevant to integrative health care will be identified, as will strategies to

overcome challenges to conducting medical cannabis research in Canada. It is hoped this workshop will

increase awareness among the integrative health care community in Canada about the potential

opportunities and challenges posed by cannabis and to increase capacity within this field.

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Workshops—Friday, November 9, 2018

11 www.iscmr.org

Workshop 1

René-Lévesque B

Page 17: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Workshop 2—Osteopathy Special Interest Group

De La Montagne

Increasing chances to have your abstract accepted for national and

international scientific symposium and events: A practical workshop

Workshop Facilitators:

Chantal Morin, Nathalie Trottier

Workshop Objectives:

At the end of this session, participants will be able to:

* dentify essential elements of a scientific abstract

* Describe essential criteria for an abstract to be accepted for national and international symposium and

events

* Write high quality abstract from research results

Intended Audience:

Osteopaths, osteopathic students, osteopathic research teachers and other symposium participants with an

interest for the scientific abstract writing skills.

Workshop Description:

An important number of abstracts is submitted in various health related congresses each year. How can we

produce high quality abstracts that stand out? What are the key components that the reviewer is expecting?

Even if a study is very interesting and well done, abstracts that are not well structured and incomplete are

often refused. Since abstract is the only written available description of a research to participants in a

conference, writing high quality scientific abstracts can significantly increase the chances of being accepted

into national and international conferences. Unfortunately, many clinician-scientists had no or few training or

experience with scientific abstracts writing.

The creation of a workshop to foster those writing skills was one of the activities request by participants of the

Osteopathy-SIG 2016 workshop and the subsequent need assessment online survey. This workshop thus aims

to inform participants of the essential elements to be included in a high quality scientific abstract. Examples

of abstracts will be discuss and improve with suggestions from the group and the facilitators. A practical

session is also planned to allow participants to practice writing a scientific abstract and to received

constructive feedback about their specific research abstract. This workshop may lead to the creation of a

mentorship program for the SIG members.

Anticipated Outcomes:

This workshop may help members to review more critically their abstract before submission to national or

international congresses. It may also create some collaboration or networking opportunities. Finally, we thing

that the experience of this workshop might help us to develop a mentorship program for the Osteopathy SIG

members in 2019 (a priority also identified in the need assessment online survey results).

12 www.iscmr.org

Page 18: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Fostering fairness in TCAIM research dialogue: Struggles and strategies

Workshop Facilitators:

Nadine Ijaz, John Weeks, Antony Porcino

Workshop Objectives

* To clarify the distinctions between advocating for traditional, complementary, alternative and integrative

medicine (TCAIM) and advocating for balanced respect for the state of TCAIM science.

* To empower those working in the TCAIM field to more pro-actively and effectively respond to ongoing

attacks on this area of research

* To share experiences and perspectives as to the strengths and challenges associated with particular

strategic responses

* To foster the formation of collaborative response networks between those working in diverse TCAIM areas

• Intended Audience

Researchers, practitioners, educators, and policy advocates working in the field of traditional,

complementary, alternative and integrative medicine

Workshop Description

Across the globe, the science supporting traditional, complementary, alternative and integrative medicine

(TCAIM) and the work of TCAIM researchers are frequently and sometimes ruthlessly attacked. The scientific

community’s silence—even from other scientific supporters and researchers—effectively condones the

attacks. One outcome is that TCAIM policy discussions that shape access to TCAIM services are frequently

informed more by bias than by evidence. For example, the UK National Institute for Health and Care

Excellence (‘NICE’) held acupuncture to a different standard, effectively excluding it from treatment

guidelines for backpain and osteoarthritis. The US government’s National Center for Complementary and

Integrative Health (NIH NCCIH) regularly hears calls to end funding of its “quackademic medicine”. Here in

Canada, TCAIM research positions, projects, and institutions have been threatened and publicly derided with

seeming impunity. At times, entire fields or professions are subject to actions based on assertions that they

have no scientific basis, even as evidence increasingly emerges. Usually these attacks on the science go

unanswered. Who is supposed to respond?

This workshop aims to help address this gap: by empowering those working in the TCAIM field take positions

for respectful science and craft appropriate strategies to respond pro-actively and productively to attacks on

this area of research. Structured as an interactive session framed by short presentations from TCAIM

researchers, practitioners, and policy advocates (names to be confirmed), participants will have a chance to

discuss their experiences, concerns, and strategies related to the workshop theme.

Anticipated Outcomes

By the end of the session, participants will be able to identify key resources needed for a quick, effective

response. They will know the key features and language needed to shape the dialogue, and ways of

responding so that defensible TCAIM research viewpoints are heard. Finally, we hope to establish the

groundwork needed for collaborative networks to aid timely response to future attacks on TCAIM.

13 www.iscmr.org

Workshop 3

René-Lévesque A

Page 19: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Effective communication and messaging strategies for CAM in an age of

attention deficit, media transformation, and universal scepticism

Workshop Facilitators;

Anne Leis, Michael Epstein, Dugald Seely, Lynda Balneaves

Workshop Objectives:

* The workshop is intended to explore strategies for effective communication and message formulation

pertaining to complementary and integrative medicine within conventional and social media.

* Through a combination of discussion, reflection, and experiential methods involving participatory

educational theatre, participants will have the opportunity to learn and apply some of the basic principles of

effective communication in a variety of media contexts.

Intended Audience:

This workshop will focus on developing effective strategies to communicate complementary/integrative

medicine information within popular media, including social media as well as more traditional media sources.

As such the workshop will be of interest to a diverse audience of complementary and integrative

professionals who would like to explore ways to become media content creators. It may also appeal to

researchers and others eager to increase the quality and quantity of media stories to represent the growing

evidence base for the safe and effective use of an integrative approach to health and wellness.

Workshop Description:

This workshop will focus on developing effective strategies to communicate complementary and integrative

medicine information within social media as well as traditional media sources. In partial response to negative

media portrayals of complementary and integrative medicine, we will advocate for people working in this

field to either become media content creators or otherwise influence the production of media content. Our

intention is to promote media coverage that provides a balanced, informative, and accurate representation

of the growing evidence base for the safe and effective use of an integrative approach to health and

wellness.

Anticipated Outcomes:

The workshop will follow the educational theatre format. The presenters will enact a series of skits, each

focused on a different workshop goal, for example understanding the relationship between traditional and

social media, ways that participants can develop their own media content, or means to facilitate

collaborative relationships with traditional journalists. Facilitated discussions will help reinforce key learning

concepts and allow participants the opportunity to role-play and identify opportunities for applying these

concepts in their professional work. Throughout the workshop, we will use current examples to highlight

common issues within popular media representations of complementary and integrative medicine, and

promote thinking about innovative ways to address those issues in future communication.

14 www.iscmr.org

Workshop 4

De La Montagne

Page 20: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Alexandrine Brisson-Larouche

Centre Ostéopathique du Québec

Montréal, Québec

Samah Hassan

Institute of Medical Science

University of Toronto

Toronto, Ontario

Jessica LaChance

Arthur Labatt Family School of Nursing

University of Western Ontario

London, Ontario

Jeremy Y. Ng

Faculty of Health Sciences

McMaster University

Hamilton, Ontario

Athanasios Psihogios

Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine

Toronto, Ontario

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

INCAM Travel Award Recipients

15 www.iscmr.org

Page 21: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Canadian CAM Research Fund (CCRF)

Grant recipients and funded projects at the Symposium

Elise Paradis, PhD; Nadine Ijaz, MSc, PhD; David Brulé, BA, University of Toronto (presented by David Brulé):

The use of telemedicine in complementary medicine consulting: A survey-in-process of homeopaths and

naturopaths in Ontario, Canada (Poster Session)

Monique Aucoin, ND, Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine (presented by Kieran Cooley):

Diet and psychosis: A scoping review (Oral Presentation: Reviews)

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

CCRF Recipients and

ISCMR Scientific Article Prize

ISCMR Scientific Article Prize

In line with ISCMR’s goal to encourage and support high quality research in the field of CAM and integrative

health care, the ISCMR Executive and Board of Directors are very excited to announce the launch of

the ISCMR Scientific Article Prize.

Establishing an annual award for the best scientific article in the field provides a way to highlight and share

excellent research no matter where it was published. This kind of prize allows us to acknowledge the best

research in the CAM/IHC field, and helps establish CAM/IHC as a legitimate area of research.

The ISCMR Scientific Article Prize includes:

$5000 CDN cash prize

Coverage of travel expenses and free registration to the ISCMR Congress where the article prize will be

presented (not to exceed $5000 CDN in value)

1 year free membership to ISCMR

The competition will ideally be announced at the annual ISCMR Congress and information will be

subsequently circulated via the ISCMR Newsletter.

For more information, please visit: https://www.iscmr.org/

The submission deadline is the 30th of November this year.

16

Funded by:

www.iscmr.org

Page 22: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Symposium Delegate Contact List

17 www.iscmr.org

Name Email Organization

Muhammad Naveed Akhter [email protected] Ideal Kawish Enterprises

Lynda Balneaves [email protected] University of Manitoba

Amanda Baskwill [email protected] Humber College

Olivier Beauchamp [email protected] COQ

Sabine Beaulieu-Provencher [email protected] Collège d'Études

Ostéopathiques de Québec

Miguel Angel Blasco Carlos [email protected] ISCMR

Sophie BOISVERT [email protected] Centre Ostéopathique du

Québec

Heather Boon [email protected] University of Toronto

Alexandrine Brisson-Larouche [email protected] Centre Ostéopathique du

Québec

David Brulé [email protected] University of Toronto

Elise Cogo [email protected] Canadian College of

Naturopathic Medicine

Kieran Cooley [email protected] The Canadian College of

Naturopathic Medicine

Kyla Demers [email protected] Concordia University

Karine Devantéry [email protected] Collège d'Études

Ostéopathiques

Michael Epstein [email protected] University of Saskatchewan

Anne-Marie Fafard [email protected] Anne-Marie Fafard

Julien Fatisson [email protected] Collège d'Études

Ostéopathiques

Isabelle Gaboury [email protected] Université de Sherbrooke

Cynthia Gariepy [email protected] Clinique Cynthia Gariepy

Nathaly Gaudreault [email protected] Université de Sherbrooke

Isabelle Gilbert [email protected] Université de Sherbrooke

Donelda Gowan [email protected] University of Saskatchewan

Pierre Haddad [email protected] Université de Montréal

Samah Hassan [email protected] Canadian College of

Naturopathic Medicine

Nicole Henry [email protected] Canadian College of

Naturopathic Medicine

Benoît Hogedez [email protected] Physiotherapy

Page 23: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

18

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Symposium Delegate Contact List

www.iscmr.org

Name Email Organization

Nadine Ijaz [email protected] University of Toronto

Georgio Kassab [email protected] Centre Osteopathique du

Quebec

Jessica LaChance [email protected] UWO

Helene Langevin [email protected] Brigham and Women's Hospital

Richard Lebert [email protected] Lambton College

Anne LEIS [email protected] Community Health &

Epidemiology, College of

Medicine, University of

Saskatchewan

Brenda Leung [email protected] University of Lethbridge

Marian Luctkar-Flude [email protected] Queen's University

Avery McNair [email protected] McMaster University

Suzanne Michaud [email protected] Massage Vita Dolce

Carol Middlemiss [email protected] Lotte & John Hecht Memorial

Foundation

Chantal Morin [email protected] Université de Sherbrooke

Jeremy Ng [email protected] Department of Health Research

Methods, Evidence, and

Impact, Faculty of Health

Sciences, McMaster University

Marc Noel [email protected] Fushigina Choowa sprl

Sandra O'Connor [email protected] Université de Sherbrooke et

Collège d'Études

Ostéopathiques

Clovis Piché [email protected] Centre Ostéopathique du

Québec

Antony Porcino [email protected] ISCMR

Athanasios Psihogios [email protected] Ottawa Integrative Cancer

Center

Dugald Seely [email protected] Ottawa Integrative Cancer

Centre (OICC)

Nancy Spence [email protected] Canadian Federation of

Osteopathy

Bryn Sumpton [email protected] Humber College & Sutherland-

Chan Clinics Inc.

Wendy Takeda [email protected] Elements Physical Therapy and

Acup Ltd

Page 24: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

19

2018 INCAM Research Symposium

Symposium Delegate Contact List

www.iscmr.org

Name Email Organization

Nathalie Tétreault [email protected] Centre ostéopatique du

québec

Nathalie Trottier [email protected] Consensio clinic

Ann Van de Winckel [email protected] University of Minnesota

Mark Ware [email protected] McGill University

John Weeks [email protected] JACM-Paradigm, Practice and

Policy Advancing Integrative

Health

Wissam Wehbe [email protected] COQ

Linda Zhong [email protected] University of Toronto, Hong

Kong Baptist University

Page 25: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

Hotel Le Crystal Floorplan

20 www.iscmr.org

Page 26: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

Notes

21 www.iscmr.org

Page 27: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

______________________________

Notes

22 www.iscmr.org

Page 28: Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec...2018 INCAM Research Symposium November 9-10, 2018 Hotel Le Crystal, Montréal, Québec PROGRAM HIGHLIGHTS: Main Symposium—November 9 & 10 Keynote

ABOUT INCAM

INCAM is an interdisciplinary research community in Canada generating knowledge

through research on complementary and integrative medicine and health care to

enhance the health of Canadians. Since its launch in 2004, INCAM has been

instrumental in defining a research community focused on research on complementary

therapies and their integration into health care systems. Today, INCAM is the place to

go for researchers, educators and practitioners who are Interested in research which

aims to address challenging questions in innovative ways in this emerging area of

practice and research.

INCAM CHAIR

Isabelle Gaboury, PhD

Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Sherbrooke

INCAM CHAIR-ELECT

Kieran Cooley, ND

Canadian College of Naturopathic Medicine

CO-FOUNDER AND PAST-CHAIR

Heather Boon, BScPhm, PhD

Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Toronto

INCAM BOARD OF DIRECTORS

Lynda Balneaves, RN, PhD

Rady Faculty of Health , Sciences University of Manitoba

Brenda Leung, ND, PhD

Department of Community Health Science, University of Lethbridge

Nathaly Gaudrault, PhD, PT

Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Sherbrooke

Chantal Morin, OT, DO (Can), PhD

Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, University of Sherbrooke

Teresa Tsui, MSc, ND

Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Toronto

INCAM PROJECT ASSISTANT & SOCIAL MEDIA CHAIR

Jeremy Ng, MSc

Faculty of Health Sciences, McMaster University

www.iscmr.org