how censors killed the weird . muy bueno. usar . padid 2014
TRANSCRIPT
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 1/18
How Censors Killed The Weird,Experimental, Progressive Golden
Age Of Comics In the 1940s, comic books were often feminist, diverse, and bold. Then
the reactionary Comics Code Authority changed the trajectory of comic
book culture for good.posted on May 2, 2014, at 4:07 p.m.
Saladin AhmedBuzzFeed Contributor
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 2/18
Charles 'Teenie' Harris / Carnegie Museum of Art / Getty Images
Comics histories sometimes reduce the Golden Age to the Superman Age:
an era of lily white, squeaky-clean, manly-man heroes punching bank
robbers and selling World War II propaganda. But the raucous variety of
early comics is much more complex. For a weird, wild, 15-year spanbeginning in the late 1930s, the comic book racks of America’s
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 3/18
newsstands were bursting with four-color contradictions. Images of half-
naked, subjugated women appeared side by side with comics featuring
independent heroines, like Women Outlaws.
The comics world at this time was a cacophonous bazaar of stories:sometimes thrilling, sometimes confusing, sometimes revolting. But that
bazaar was swiftly and mercilessly dismantled in 1954 by the newly
formed Comics Code Authority. It was replaced with a viciously policed
shopping mall whose effects resonate today.
Conventional wisdom holds that comics today are conservative,
reactionary. In recent years, outlets from The Guardian to The
Atlantic have published articles on sexism in comics, and fanboys foolish
enough to express their fear of a black Spider-Man are likely to be takento task loudly and publicly thanks to the active presence of antiracist fans
and fans of color on social media. Long made by, read by, and starring
only white males, the story goes, comic books need to be dragged —
or must not be dragged, depending on one’s ideological bent — into the
21st century. We marvel at the increasing popularity of comics, as if
collectively witnessing the first sunlit steps of a pale, housebound man
who has lived in his mother’s basement for decades. What is rarely
discussed, though, is how comics ended up in the basement in the first
place.
While they had some experimental antecedents, the first true comic
books appeared in the early 1930s, at the height of the Great Depression.
At first, most were collections of reprinted strips from newspapers. But
publishers soon saw that there was money to be made with original
material. New titles cropped up monthly and, by the time Superman
appeared in Action Comics in 1938, the era that comics fans and historianshave dubbed the “Golden Age” was in full swing. Somehow, in the middle
of an unprecedented economic crisis, comics had managed to become a
boom industry. And it wasn’t just adolescent white males driving this
boom. We know from advertisements, comics letters pages, and old
photos that comic books in the Golden Age were bought and read by a
wide variety of Americans in terms of gender, class, and race. By the
1940s, Americans from all walks of life were going comic book crazy.
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 4/18
Marvel Comics / Via digitalcomicmuseum.com
The early comic book industry had the shifting, molten surface of a new,
unfinished world. Golden Age writers and artists were inventing a new
form as they went, and they were doing so for little money, and under
grueling deadlines. Quantity was often emphasized over quality, and
editorial supervision was in most cases nearly nonexistent.
The comics themselves exhibited wild stylistic variety. A single issue
of Keen Detective Funnies could contain one story with gorgeous Art
Nouveau-ish illustration, and another with glorified stick figures. The
comic books of the Golden Age were also significantly more diverse in
terms of genre than today’s comics. On newsstands across America — inan era when the newsstand was an urban hub and an economic
juggernaut — comic books told tales of True Crime, Weird
Fantasy and Cowboy Love, Negro Romance, andMystery Men. And
Americans bought them all.
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 5/18
Fox Features / Via digitalcomicmuseum.com
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 6/18
Even as Amazing-Man and Blue Beetle were rescuing helpless,
infantilized women, badass superheroines like the Lady in Red, the Spider
Queen, and Lady Satan were stabbing Nazis and punching out
meddlesome, sexist cops.
Dynamic Comics / Via digitalcomicmuseum.com
During the Golden Age, the same newsstand might be selling comics with
ape-like, rubber-lipped caricatures of black people next to the black-
owned and created All-Negro Comics.
And the same issue of Funny Pages might contain both “savage redskins”
and Mantoka, the native superhero who battles “white man’s treachery.”
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 7/18
All-Negro Comics / Via digitalcomicmuseum.com
In the early 1950s, as women who’d worked on the home front during
wartime were being “encouraged” out of the workplace, and anti-
communism was at its height, moral panic over comic books hit a fever
pitch. Cities including Oklahoma City and Houston enacted bans of horror
and crime comics. Spurred in part by the sensationalist book Seduction of
the Innocent (a ridiculous sort of Reefer Madness for comic books), the
Senate Subcommittee on Juvenile Delinquency turned an angry eye
toward comics, and most publishers felt that heavy-handed regulation —
perhaps even outright banning — was imminent. Comic book publishers,in consultation with right-wing politicians, formed the Comics Code
Authority, a self-censorship group, in the hopes that this would forestall
government intervention in the industry. New York Magistrate Charles F.
Murphy, a “specialist in juvenile delinquency” (and a strident racist), was
chosen to head the Authority and to devise its self-policing “code of ethics
and standards.”
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 8/18
Centaur Comics / Via digitalcomicmuseum.com
What Murphy came up with was, in essence, a framework for forcing
comics’ compliance with a uniquely American puritanical fascism. Some
of the Code’s more illustrative points:
“Crimes shall never be presented in such a way as to create sympathy for
the criminal.”
“Romance stories shall emphasize the value of the home and the sanctity
of marriage.”
“Sex perversion or any inference to same is strictly forbidden.”
“Policemen, judges, government officials and respected institutions shall
never be presented in such a way as to create disrespect for established
authority.”
“All scenes of horror, excessive bloodshed, gory or gruesome crimes,
depravity, lust, sadism, masochism shall not be permitted.”
And, perhaps, most amusingly:
“Although slang and colloquialisms are acceptable, excessive use should
be discouraged and, wherever possible, good grammar shall be
employed.”
The Code also contained the surprising provision that “ridicule or attackon any religious or racial group is never permissible.” Given the countless
depictions of monkey-like Japanese and minstrel-show black people in
Golden Age comics, one might think this provision a good thing. But
Murphy soon made it clear that this provision really meant that black
people in comic books would no longer be tolerated, in any form. When
EC Comics reprinted the science fiction story “Judgment Day” by Al
Feldstein and Joe Orlando (which had originally been printed to little
controversy before the Code), Murphy claimed the story violated the
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 9/18
Code, and that the black astronaut had to be made white in order for the
story to run.
EC Comics / Via i218.photobucket.com
EC defiantly ran the story anyway, but Murphy had made a target of them,
and the company was essentially forced out of the comics business. The
message was clear: If comics were to be tolerated in this new postwar
order, they had to be purged of assertive women, of people of color, of
challenges to authority, and even of working-class, urban slang. And so
the Comics Code hacked and mangled comics until they fit into the
patriarchal, conservative, white suburban social order that was taking
over every other sphere of American life.
Distributors agreed not to carry comic books that didn’t abide by the
Code, making it functionally as effective as law. And, indeed, with some
slight modifications here and there, it functioned as the law of land for
mainstream comics for almost 50 years. These days, there’s a broad
consensus that the Comics Code — which has been endlessly discussed
and condemned by comics historians — was disastrous, and that it
damaged comics. But nearly all of the critiques of the Code focus
primarily on its dire consequences for white men’s artistic freedom, or
the disservice done to readers in coddlingly denying them explicit sex and
violence. What’s less discussed is the fact that independent women, and
people of color, and all sorts of stories that didn’t fit with the compulsory
patriotism and cop-worship of the 1950s, essentially vanished from
comics for decades. This is a loss that comics are still wrangling with.
What was left didn’t interest adults nearly as much, and comics slowly
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 10/18
began to become less ubiquitous and more associated with pasty
adolescent boys.
It would be preposterous to claim that the Code destroyed creativity in
the comics industry. Comics in the decades that followed theestablishment of the Code — the Silver Age when Marvel Comics debuted
and Jack Kirby and Stan Lee revolutionized the art form — had no lack of
masterpieces. But, while a handful of writers and artists in the
subsequent decades found sneaky ways to tell subversive stories within
the confines of the Code, there can be little question that for decades the
Code put a severe limitations on what kinds of masterpieces could be
produced.
The dark comics of the 1980s — Watchmen, The Dark Knight Returns — that are often said to mark the emergence of the (post)modern superhero
are almost always treated as eviscerations of the saccharine Silver Age.
But they were in many ways simply a return to the grittier, more “adult”
comic books that existed in the golden age. Only now the sorts of stories
that had once been accessible to nearly everyone were given “for mature
readers” labels, and they were only sold in specialty stores.
Still, these titles proved to be the first signs of changing times. Long
considered outdated by publishers and fans alike, the Code’s influence
began to wane in the 1990s. The new comics publishers that began to
crop up didn’t submit their titles for review by the Code. And distributors,
who had always been the real enforcers of the Code, no longer seemed to
care. Partially because comics had become so marginalized, and partially
because other mainstream media had grown so salacious and violent by
comparison, comics weren’t emphasized in the culture wars of the 1990s.
With the threat of government intervention in the industry effectivelygone, the Code lost its power. It was completely abandoned by the early
21st century.
But rather than returning to their gloriously weird and subversive pre-
Code roots, mainstreamed post-Code comics have — with notable
exceptions — mostly taken the retreat of self-censorship as an
opportunity to revel in cheap violence and exploited female bodies.
With the Comics Code gone, comics have reveled in heroes who gleefully
kill “thugs,” grisly images of women in refrigerators , and superheroine-
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 11/18
as-Maxim-model covers . But the independent women, the queer
perspectives, the radical questioning of the status quo that were stifled by
the Code? Comics have been slower to embrace these. And the films, TV
shows, and video games based on comics have followed suit (theoverwhelming majority of which fail even the Bechdel test ).
It doesn’t have to be this way. The Comics Code is dead, and comic book
narratives are in the mainstream of American culture again. If comics are
to retain the wide audience they have taken so long to regain — and if
they are to enter into a new Golden Age — they must do better. And there
are glimmers of hope. The past couple of years have seen an Arab Green
Lantern and a Muslim Ms. Marvel. Writers like Gail Simone and Kelly Sue
DeConnick are shifting the way superhero comics deal with women. Andminded fan campaigns like We Are Comics are reclaiming the long-lost
sense that comics are for everyone.
Let’s do more to reclaim that sense. Let us leave the Golden Age’s
jingoism, racist caricatures, and exploitation of women on the dustheap.
But let us also remember that comics used to do different things than
they do now, and that some of those things were wonderful and worth
reclaiming.
Saladin Ahmed has written about television, fiction, and video games
for Salon , NPR Books , and The Escapist . His fantasy novel Throne of the
Crescent Moon , which George RR Martin called “old -fashioned sword-and-
sorcery adventure with an Arabian Knights flavor,” was nominated for the
Hugo, Nebula, and British Fantasy Awards, and won the Locus Award for
Best First Novel. He lives near Detroit with his wife and twin children.
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 12/18
More
NEXT ON BUZZFEED IDEAS › USA Network Is Television's Best Answer To The...
YOUR REACTION?
61
LOL1
CUTE0
WIN7
YAAASS0
OLD0
OMG3
FAIL2
TRASHY1
EW0
0
REACT WITH GIF
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 13/18
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 14/18
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 15/18
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 16/18
MORE BUZZ
Talking To My Mother About Our Bulimia
Which TV Show Has The Oldest "Teenagers"?
Why Picking Up The Phone Is Good For Humanity
Is America Having A "Friendship Slump"?
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 17/18
'Confessions From Hotel Employees' Will Make You Never Want ToStay In A Hotel Ever Again
Publishing Partner
brobible.com
18 motivos para reconsiderar algumas amizades no…
22 Things You’re Doing Wrong
8/12/2019 How Censors Killed the Weird . Muy Bueno. Usar . Padid 2014
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/how-censors-killed-the-weird-muy-bueno-usar-padid-2014 18/18
11 Engagement Photos That Will Make You Happy…
Tagged: censorship, comic books, comics, racism, sexism, the comics code authority Facebook Conversations