how to critique a

photoBy Cara Del Gaudio

step one

find pros and cons of the photo.

• Begin with an idea of what you like and dislike about the photograph.

• It’s not necessary to write about these. They are just where you’ll begin to analyze.

step two

discuss the technical and artistic pieces

• Use some of the following categories• Subject matter• Color• Composition• Focus• Dust and scratches• exposure

step three

explain what you like and dislike about the photo.

• Point out the strong points• Also elaborate on what improvements

could be made• Be very specific.

step four

summarize your opinion

• Provide a brief description of your evaluation

• Take all the previous steps into consideration

critique one

Pros: Good lighting (not too dark or too bright)

Cons: The green shirt seems out of place compared to the red background, necklace, and hair ribbons.

It’s clear what the main subject of the photo is. The vivid colors make it more exciting. I think it would have been very boring and bland if the photographer chose a random subject.

I like the focus and composition of the photo, and that there are little to no dust or scratches. However, I don’t personally like the vignette.

Overall, this photograph is very, very good.

Steve Mccurry, Tagong, tibet

critique two

Pros: Interesting colors, unique shapesCons: The photo seems a bit dark and

it’s unclear what the subject is. It could either be the doorway or the mirrors on the wall on the side.

There is no dust or scratches, and if the subject is the doorway, then the photographer used the rule of thirds, which is a positive component.

I like the Teal color of the photo, and the hallway and room are very pretty.

Overall, this photograph is very good, though it could be brighter or more exposed.

Lara Jade, NYC Location - Metropolitan