i got tb in prison_citypress_ruthhopkins

2
City Press || 2 September 2012 7 News Think FAST. Think Telkom Internet. R169 ONLY x 24 mo nt hs Fast Inte rnet *Aut omaticnetwo rkupgradefrom384kbps to1024 kbpswillcommencein Septe mber201 2 F AST AD SL int ern et up to 10 24 kbp s* 5G B Data FREE Wi-F i mode m FREE Internet installation Ge t st arted! ** Or de r tod ay . Ge t it in st alle d in 7 workin g da ys . Tha t’ s a promise! Terms and conditions apply. Landline rental mandatory but not included in the promotion. The R169 p/m promotion is subject to signing a 24-month contract with debit order instruction. Promotion ends 31 October 2012. Subject to infrastructure availability. Telkom reserves the right to withdraw this promotional oer at any time. E & OE. Oer available to new Fast Internet customers only. **Subject to infrastructure and customer availability. The internet is AWESOME. If you have a question, the internet has the answer. From school projects to homework, from looking for a new job to sending your CV to the right people, getting the internet at home is now more aordable than ever. Oer ends on 31 October 2012. So, what are you waiting for? Don’t miss out! Come home to AWESOME today. Call 0800 00 00 11, go to www.telkom.co.za, visit your nearest Telkom Direct Store or SMS ‘internet’ and your name to 34623 and we’ll call you back. EachSMS cos ts R2.Free SMS s don’tapply. THESOUTHAFRICAN PARALYMPI C TEAM LONDON 2012 PROUDPARTNER        1        1        7        2        9        4        9        B        /        E _        3        9      x        8 _        3        0        0 RUTH HOPKINS [email protected] In a landmark case before the Constitutional Courtthis week,the departmentof correcti onal services conceded its prison tuberculosis pro- gramme wasn’t up to scratch. Former Pollsmoor prisoner Dudley Lee, who cont rac ted the dise ase whi le awa iting trial  between1999and 2004,broughtthecase before the country’s highest court. The department has argued in court that Lee (66) cannot prove he wouldn’t have contract ed TBeven ifall theappropriatemeasureshadbeen in place. TB is the main cause of death and illness in South Africa’s heavily overcr owded prisons.  After his release , Lee sued the minister for negligencebeforetheWesternCapeHighCourt, which ruled that the department was liable for damagesasit violateditsown healthregulations andtheConstitutionbyfailingtoimpleme ntef- fective measures. TheSupremeCourtof Appealthenoverturned the decision. Itconfirmedthe statewasnegligent, butruled thatLee coul d notprovewhereand howhe had contracted the disease and it was not clear he would not have caught it anyway. Thedepartment’slawyer,IsmailJamie SC,re- peated this argument before the Constitutiona l Court on Tuesday. In 1999, Lee, a second-hand car and watch dealer , was arrested with four others for fraud, counterfeiting and money laundering.  Ahead of the court case, Lee told City Press other inmates had warned him about contract- ing TB, but he was never tested. “Theylockyouupfor23.5hoursadayinadark dampcell, withother inmatesin closeproximity coughing their lungs up.” Hewasdiagnosedwit hTBin 2003,andbribed hiswarde rsto tak e himto thedoctor. Heforked outmoremoneyforaccessto medicine. Hewas cured, but his lungs remain permanently dam- aged. In 2007,Parliament’ s portfoliocommitteeon correcti ons and the inspecting judge of prisons described conditions in Pollsmoor as a “ health time bomb”. Inco ming inmate s, they found, were not screened for TB. Pollsmoor’s overcr owded cells, combined withpoorvent ilat ionandlack ofsunligh t,made it the perfect breeding ground for the disease. Lee’s attorney , Jonathan Cohen, told City Pres s:“Itwillbenefitallpris oner sif (thedepar t- ment) is forced to respect its own standards on health and accommodat ion. Thedepart menttoldCityPressit was“notin apositionto commentonthemeritsanddemer- its” of the case. In a stateme nt, the department said it was aware of the “unique nature” of the portfolio it managed and the “challenges that an overcon- centration of human beings in confined spaces present”. In its statement, the department said it was “working away at improving the living condi- tionsofinma tesanddoingitsbes ttoensurepeo- ple are detained under humane conditions” .  Judgment was reserved. » Hopkins works for the Wits Justice Project, which was admitted to this case as a friend of the court I got TB in prison, former inmate tells court ed for onl y 14% of the country ’s UHNWIs at the end of last year.  WealthIns ight found there were 75 South African UHNWIs from these groups, and 543 UHNWIs in total. “This is a relatively low percentage consideringthatthese groupsmakeup 90% of the nati onal popu lati on,  Amoils and his team reported . But this group is growing quickly – mostly , resear chers found, because of emerging BEE deals. Other factors boosting the private wealthof SouthAfrica’shigh rollersin- cluded the strong local property mar- ket and the comparatively good per- formance of the JSE all-share index against other indices in dollar terms. multimill ionaires–with wealthofmore than $30 million,” Amoils said. Multimillionaires are referred to in  WealthIns ight’s lingo as UHNWIs: ul- tra-high- net-worth individuals. “Wehavethe personaladdressesand wealth for these individuals, which we usetoworkout theweal thand numb er of mult imil liona ires in each area ,  Amoils said. Thiswasusedto gene rat e therepor t and a paper released last week, called Far from Equal: Previousl y Disadvan- taged Wealth Trends in South Africa.  Accordi ng to this, previously disad- vant agedgrou ps– defi nedin thestudy as black Africans, coloured people, IndiansandChinesepeopl e– account- a swanky pad on the V&A Waterfr ont. These are some of the insights re- veal ed in a new study by British re- search hous e Weal thIn sigh t, titl ed South Africa – The Future of HNWIs to 2016: the Rise of African Wealth. The “HNWI” is what WealthInsight calls a high-net-worth individual – in layman’ s ter ms, some one whos e wealthtotals$1millionormore,includ- ing equities, bonds, cash, real estate and business interests.  WealthIns ight’s senior analyst and hea d of it s repor t team, And re w  Amoils, said the company has a data-  baseof morethan100 000millionaires wor ldwi de– 600ofthemin Sout hAfri- ca. “Most of the people on our list are NAT ASHA JOSEPH [email protected] Meet the new South African multimil- lionaire. He’s a black South African man, in his mid-50s, and the secret to his wea lth is invo lve ment in lucr ativ e BlackEconomic Empower mentdeals. His biggest asset is real estate but he’ sgot plen tyof iron sin thefire:equi- ties, cold hard cash, art, classic cars and private jets. He prob ably lives in Sand hurs t, South Africa’s wealthie st suburb or, if he prefers the Western Cape, he’s got Face of SA’s ultra wealthy Hig h-n et-wo rth individuals’ we alth totals $1 mil lion or mor e, inc lud ing a ra ng e of ass et s Other key findings: » there are 80 women HNWIs in South Africa – 15% of the total. This is below the worldwide average of about 20%. But, researchers say, the number of über-rich women will rise steadily in the next five years; » the average age of a South African HNWI is 56; and » South Africa is setting the pace for African HNWIs – we’re home to nearly 45 000 dollar millionaires. Go gogo, go An old woman from Umgungundlovu district during the Golden Games for the Elderly at Kings Park Athletics Stadium in Durban, KwaZulu-Natal, on Friday || PHOTO: KHAYA NGWENYA ‘‘ In a country well governed, poverty is something  to be ashamed of. In a country badly gov erned,  wealth is something to be ashamed of – Chinese philosopher Confucius

Upload: witsjusticeproject

Post on 04-Apr-2018

221 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

7/31/2019 I Got TB in Prison_CityPress_RuthHopkins

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/i-got-tb-in-prisoncitypressruthhopkins 1/1

City Press || 2 September 2012 7

News

Think FAST.

Think Telkom

Internet.

R169ONLY

x 24 months

Fast Internet

*Automaticnetworkupgradefrom 384kbps to1024 kbpswillcommencein September2012

• FAST ADSL internet up to 1024 kbps*

• 5GB Data•FREE Wi-Fi modem•FREE Internetinstallation

Get started!

** Order today. Get it installed in 7 working days.That’s a promise!

Terms and conditions apply. Landline rental mandatory but not included in the promotion. The R169 p/m promotion is subject to signing a 24-month contract with debit order instruction. Promotion ends 31 October 2012.

Subject to infrastructure availability. Telkom reserves the right to withdraw this promotional oer at any time. E & OE. Oer available to new Fast Internet customers only.

**Subject to infrastructure and customer availability.

The internet is AWESOME. If you have a question, the internet has the answer. From school projects to homework, from looking for a new job to sending your CV to theright people, getting the internet at home is now more aordable than ever. Oer ends on 31 October 2012. So, what are you waiting for? Don’t miss out! Come home toAWESOME today.

Call 0800 00 00 11, go to www.telkom.co.za, visit your nearest Telkom Direct Store or SMS ‘internet’ and your name to 34623 and we’ll callyou back. EachSMS costs R2.Free SMSs don’tapply.

THESOUTHAFRICAN

PARALYMPIC TEAM

LONDON 2012

PROUDPARTNER

1 1 7 2 9 4 9 B / E_

3 9 x 8_

3 0 0

RUTH [email protected]

In a landmark case before the ConstitutionalCourtthis week,the departmentof correctionalservices conceded its prison tuberculosis pro-gramme wasn’t up to scratch.

Former Pollsmoor prisoner Dudley Lee, whocontracted the disease while awaiting trial

between1999and 2004,broughtthecase beforethe country’s highest court.

The department has argued in court that Lee(66) cannot prove he wouldn’t have contractedTBeven ifall theappropriatemeasureshadbeenin place.

TB is the main cause of death and illness inSouth Africa’s heavily overcrowded prisons.

After his release, Lee sued the minister fornegligencebeforetheWesternCapeHighCourt,which ruled that the department was liable fordamagesasit violateditsown healthregulationsandtheConstitutionbyfailingtoimplementef-fective measures.

TheSupremeCourtof Appealthenoverturnedthe decision.

Itconfirmedthe statewasnegligent, butruledthatLee could notprovewhereand howhe hadcontracted the disease and it was not clear hewould not have caught it anyway.

Thedepartment’slawyer,IsmailJamie SC,re-peated this argument before the Constitutional

Court on Tuesday.In 1999, Lee, a second-hand car and watch

dealer, was arrested with four others for fraud,counterfeiting and money laundering.

Ahead of the court case, Lee told City Pressother inmates had warned him about contract-ing TB, but he was never tested.

“Theylockyouupfor23.5hoursadayinadarkdampcell, withother inmatesin closeproximitycoughing their lungs up.”

HewasdiagnosedwithTBin 2003,andbribedhiswardersto take himto thedoctor. Heforkedoutmoremoneyforaccessto medicine. Hewascured, but his lungs remain permanently dam-aged.

In 2007,Parliament’s portfoliocommitteeoncorrections and the inspecting judge of prisonsdescribed conditions in Pollsmoor as a “ healthtime bomb”.

Incoming inmates, they found, were notscreened for TB.

Pollsmoor’s overcrowded cells, combinedwithpoorventilationandlack ofsunlight,madeit the perfect breeding ground for the disease.

Lee’s attorney, Jonathan Cohen, told CityPress:“Itwillbenefitallprisonersif (thedepart-ment) is forced to respect its own standards on

health and accommodation.”ThedepartmenttoldCityPressit was“notinapositionto commentonthemeritsanddemer-its” of the case.

In a statement, the department said it wasaware of the “unique nature” of the portfolio itmanaged and the “challenges that an overcon-centration of human beings in confined spacespresent”.

In its statement, the department said it was“working away at improving the living condi-tionsofinmatesanddoingitsbesttoensurepeo-ple are detained under humane conditions”.

Judgment was reserved.» Hopkins works for the Wits Justice Project, which was

admitted to this case as a friend of the court

................................................................................................

................................................................................................

................................................................................................

................................................................................................

................................................................................................

................................................................................................

I got TB inprison, formerinmate tellscourt

ed for only 14% of the country’sUHNWIs at the end of last year.

WealthInsight found there were 75South African UHNWIs from thesegroups, and 543 UHNWIs in total.

“This is a relatively low percentageconsideringthatthese groupsmakeup90% of the national population,”

Amoils and his team reported.But this group is growing quickly –

mostly, researchers found, because of emerging BEE deals.

Other factors boosting the privatewealthof SouthAfrica’shigh rollersin-cluded the strong local property mar-ket and the comparatively good per-formance of the JSE all-share indexagainst other indices in dollar terms.

multimillionaires–with wealthofmorethan $30 million,” Amoils said.

Multimillionaires are referred to in WealthInsight’s lingo as UHNWIs: ul-tra-high-net-worth individuals.

“Wehavethe personaladdressesandwealth for these individuals, which weusetoworkout thewealthand numberof multimillionaires in each area,”

Amoils said.Thiswasusedto generate thereport

and a paper released last week, calledFar from Equal: Previously Disadvan-taged Wealth Trends in South Africa.

According to this, previously disad-vantagedgroups– definedin thestudyas black Africans, coloured people,IndiansandChinesepeople– account-

a swanky pad on the V&A Waterfront.These are some of the insights re-

vealed in a new study by British re-search house WealthInsight, titledSouth Africa – The Future of HNWIsto 2016: the Rise of African Wealth.

The “HNWI” is what WealthInsightcalls a high-net-worth individual – inlayman’s terms, someone whosewealthtotals$1millionormore,includ-ing equities, bonds, cash, real estateand business interests.

WealthInsight’s senior analyst andhead of its report team, Andrew

Amoils, said the company has a data- baseof morethan100 000millionairesworldwide– 600ofthemin SouthAfri-ca. “Most of the people on our list are

NATASHA [email protected]

Meet the new South African multimil-lionaire.

He’s a black South African man, inhis mid-50s, and the secret to hiswealth is involvement in lucrativeBlackEconomic Empowermentdeals.

His biggest asset is real estate buthe’sgot plentyof ironsin thefire:equi-ties, cold hard cash, art, classic carsand private jets.

He probably lives in Sandhurst,South Africa’s wealthiest suburb or, if he prefers the Western Cape, he’s got

Face of SA’s ultra wealthy High-net-worth individuals’ wealth totals $1 million or more, including a range of assets

Other key findings:

» there are 80 women HNWIs in South

Africa – 15% of the total. This is below

the worldwide average of about 20%.

But, researchers say, the number of

über-rich women will rise steadily in the

next five years;

» the average age of a South African

HNWI is 56; and

» South Africa is setting the pace for

African HNWIs – we’re home to nearly

45 000 dollar millionaires.

Go gogo, goAn old woman from Umgungundlovu

district during the Golden Games for

the Elderly at Kings Park Athletics

Stadium in Durban, KwaZulu-Natal, onFriday || PHOTO: KHAYA NGWENYA

‘‘In a country well governed, poverty is something to be ashamed of. In a country badly governed, wealth is something to be ashamed of – Chinese philosopher Confucius