i. · modification order-07executed 06/26/2012, recorded on 08/08/2012, deed book/instrument no....

Q(3

CO RELIEFCO SOUGHT:C>

JURISDICTION:

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

An Order for Disbursement of Escrowed Fundal I

(and Authorization for Direct Payment of Royalties)

Code of Virginia () 45.1-351.(et seq) AND IJ 45.1-361.22(et seq)

UNIT/WELL NAME: W-35

TRACT(S):

LOCATION:

1E, A portion of 1G

BUCHANAN County, Virginia

DOCKET NUMBER: VGOB-98-0324-0627-09

APPLICANTS: CNX Gas Company LLC on behalf of CNX Gas Company LLC, Danny Elder, Hurt McGuirec/o Charles Green, Joseph Horn, Margie Dye, Martha E. Smith, Nancy Stilwell, NellieMaynard, Patricia Horton, Robert Elder, Sarah Jane Day, Tamatha Bednar, Tammy BoydStreet, Tania Yvonne Hess, Wesley Perkins

HEARING DATE AND LOCATION: Russell County Government Center, Lebanon, VirginiaDFebruary 18, 2014 and March 18, 2014

APPEARANCES: Mark A. Swartz on behalf of CNX Gas Company LLC

PRIOR PROCEEDINGS:

1. Original Pooling Order Executed 06/10/1998, Recorded on 06/16/1998, Deed Book/Instrument No.477, Page 580.

2. Supplemental Order Executed 08/28/1998, Recorded on 09/02/1998, Deed Book/Instrument No.481, 67.

3. Modification Order -01 Executed 06/15/2005, Recorded on 06/22/2005, Deed Book/Instrument No.620, Page 286.

4. Supplemental Order -01, Recorded on 08/08/2008.

Page Number I.

5. Modification Order -07 Executed 06/26/2012, Recorded on 08/08/2012, Deed Book/Instrument No.120001616.

NOTICE:

QOThe Unit Operator gave notice to the Applicants that the Board would consider its disbursement petition at theFebruary 18, 2014 hearing and was was continued to March 18, 2014 where the Board considered whether to:

(1)Amend the Pooling Order to provide for the disbursement of funds on deposit in the EscrowAccount attributable to Tract(s) 1E, A portion of 1G identified in the attached petition.

(2) Delete the requirement that the Unit Operator place future royalties attributable to Tract(s) 1E, A portion of 1Grelative to the interests of the Applicants identified in the attached petition.

(3) Continue the escrow account under this docket number.

FINDINGS: Code of Virginia g 45.1-361.22

Applicant has certified and represented to the Board that:

Hurt McGuire Land Trust and Margie Dye, Tammy Boyd Street, Patricia Horton, Nancy Stilwell, Wesley D. Perkins,Tania Yvonne Hess, Martha E. Smith, Sarah Jane Day and Tamatha Michelle Bednar have entered into a royalty splitagreement. Said royalty split agreement allows the Applicant and Designated Operator to pay royalties directly to thepersons identified in Exhibit EE annexed hereto and Exhibit A, further, specifies how said royalties are to be dividedand paid. In March 2011, Unit W-35 was repooled and payments to Hurt McGuire, Nellie Maynard, Danny Elder,Robert Elder and Joseph Horn were escrowed erroneously, rather than being paid directly. The exact dollar amountpaid into the escrow account for Tract 1E must be refunded in order for the recoupment of Tract 1E to take placesystematically and net properly. The attached Exhibits A-1 and AA-1 further specifies the exact dollar amount thatshould be disbursed and paid to each individual.

RELIEF GRANTED:

Page Number 2.

VGOB Disbursement

Unit W-35

VGOB-98-0324-0627-09

Table 1 (pay exact dollar amount based on account balance of 12/31/2013)

Tracts: 1E, A portion of 1G

Item Tract Disbursement Table

Total acreage in escrow before disbursement

Fractional Net Acreage

Ownershi Ownership

P

in Tract in Tract

Royalty Escrowed Percent of Disbursement

Split Acres EscrowedFunds

Agreement Disbursed Disbursed

36.15700

1E1111E

1G

1 1G

2 1G

3 1G

4 1G

5 1G

Tract 1E (total acreage)

1CNX Gas Company LLCt2481 John Nash Blvd., Bluefield WV 24701

Tract 1G (total acreage)Nellie MaynardtBox 296, Raven VA 24639

Danny EtdertPO Box 748, Raven VA 24639

Robert Elder(229 Horton Crest Drive ¹15, Richlands, VA 24641

Joseph Horni492 Gray Branch Road, Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

Hurt McGuire c/o Charles Green(PO Box 1067, Bluefield, VA 24605

33.561/1

15.2137/12600

1/1260

1/1260

1/70

6/319

0.04470.01210.01210.21730.2861

5P P0%

50.00%

5P PP%

5P P0%

5P PP%

0.02230.0060

0.00600.10860.1430

0.0618%0.0167%0.0167%0.3005%0 3956%

$18.49

$5.00

$5.00$89.94

$118.41

33.56001 100.00%1 33.56001 92.8174%1 $27,781.901

VGOB Disbursement

Unit W-35

Fractional Net Acreage Royalty

Ownership Ownership Split Acres EscrowedFunds

Escrowed Percent of

V GOB-98-0324-0627-09 in Tract inTract Agreement Disbursed Disbursed

Table 2 (pay percentage on balance after deducting the above balance)

Tracts: 1E, A portion of 1G


Total acreage in escrow before disbursement 2.31100

1G Tract 1G (total acreage)

1 1 1G 1Margie Dye)784 Big Creek Road, Richlands, VA 24641

2 1 1G 1Tammy Boyd Street(195 Taylor Circle, Raven, VA 24639

15.21

137/12600 1

137/12600 I

o o4471 5p pp%1 0.02231 0.9663a

o.04471 5o.oo 7.1 0.02231 0 9663'Ya1

Page Number 3.

34

56

QOC>

oCO 10~St

1G Tract 1G (total acreage)1G Patricia Hortoni200 Birch Street, Raven VA 24639

1G Nancy Stilwellt140 Rasnake Road, N. Tazewell, VA 24630

1G Wesley Perkins(305 Bane Bottom Ave., Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

1G Tania Yvonne HessH95 Anglewood Lans, Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

1G Martha E. SmilhtP.O. Box 395, Max Meadows, VA 24360

1G Sarah Jane Day>905 Valley View Drive, Pearisburg, VA 24134

1G Tamatha Bednart932 South Bunker Hill Road, Colfax, NC 27235

1G Hurt McGuire Land Trust c/o Charles GreentP.O. Box 1067, Bluefield, VA 24605

15.21

1/1260

1/70

1/140

1/140

1/70

1/70

1/168

3/43

0.01210.21730.10860.10860.21730.21730.09051.0612

50.00%5P PP%

50.00%50.00%50.00%50.00%50 00%50.00%

0.00600.10860.05430.05430.10860.10860.04530.5306

0.2612%4.7011%2.3506%2.3506%4.7011%4.7011%1.9588%

22.9590%

1. The Escrow Agent is ordered, to within ten (10) days of receipt of this executed order, disburse funds forthe unit and applicants detailed in Table 1 and 2.

2. The Escrow Agent is ordered to continue the Escrow Account for the Subject Drilling unit based on theattached Revised Exhibit E which replaces all prior Exhibit E's recorded for the Subject Drilling Unit.

CONCLUSION:

Therefore, the requested relief and all terms and provisions set forth above be and hereby are granted and IT IS SOORDERED.

APPEALS."

Appeals of this Order are governed by the provisions of the Cods of Virginia g 45.1-361.9which provides that any

order or decision of the Board msy be appealed to the appropriate circuit court and that whenever a coal owner, coaloperator, gas owner, gas operator, or operator of a gas storage field certificated by the Stats Corporation Commission

is a party in such action, the court shall hear such appeal de novo.

Page Number 4.

i40000875

DONE AND EXECUTED this 30 day of April, 2014 by s majority of the Virginia Gas and OilBoard,

Chairman, Bradley C. Lambert

DONE AND PERFORMED this 30 day of April, 2014 by Order of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board.

Rick CooperPrlnd pal Executive to thestaff, Virginia Gas and Oil Board

COMMONWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSELL

nAcknowledged on thlaX day of QCyir If, ~gemonally before me a notary publicin snd for the Commonwealth of Vlrglrjja, appeared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworn diddepose and say that he is the Chairman of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board and appeared RickCooper, being duly sworn did depose and say that he is Principal Executive to the staff of theVirginia Gas and Oil Board, that they executed the same and was authorized to do so.

nfi S

My Commission expires: September 30, 201/

)I I I I II ~ rrrr Irr

N~TAriy'rP ~= * .'USUC

G ¹I743= n: urc04IMEA'PRE3

'Illlnllnr "

rnll<l lrrr

..'OTARIr .8PUBLIC: "EG.¹Iraase '. dr

Eaeigfg

"'iiiill H II

tt~"'age

Number 5.

140000875

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

PETITIONER: CNX Gas Company LLC

RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSENIENT FROMO

ESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) 1E, A portion of1Gi:(2) AND AUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECTPAYNIENT OF ROYALTIES

DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL

DOCKET NO: VGOB 98-0324-0627-09

HEARING DATE: February 18, 2014

DRILLING UNIT: W-35

BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA

PETITION FOR ORDER OF DISBURSENIENT OF ESCROW FUNDS

1.Petitioner and its counsel

Petitioner is CNX Gas Company LLC, 2481 John Nash Blvd, Bluefield, WV 24701, (304)323-6500. Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, Swartz Law Offices, 601 Sixth Avenue, Suite 201,P.O. Box 1808, St. Albans, WV 25177-1808..

2. Relief Sought

A petition for lhe disbursement of funds held by the Escrow Agent for Tract 1G, Umt W35, and

the payment of royalties directly for the parties identified in Exhibit A-1, in the Garden District

Buchanan County, Virginia.

3. Legal Authority

Va. Code Ann. 8 45.1-361.1et seq., 4 VAC 25-160-140., and relevant Virginia Gss snd Oil

Board Orders ("Board" ) heretofore promulgated pursuant to law.

4. Type of Well(s)

Coalbed Methane

5. Factual basis for relief requested

Hurt McGuire Land Trust and Margie Dye, Tammy Boyd Street, Patricia Horton, Nancy Stilwell,

Wesley D. Perkins, Tania Yvonne Hess, Martha E. Smith, Sarah Jane Day and Tamatha Michelle

Bednar have entered into a royalty split agreement. Said royalty split agreement allows the

Applicant and Designated Operator to pay royalties directly to the persons identified in Exhibit EEannexed hereto and Exhibit A, further, specifies how said royalties are to be divided and paid. In

March 2011, Unit W-35 was repooled and payments to Hurt McGuire, Nellie Maynard, Danny

Elder, Robert Elder and Joseph Horn were escrowed erroneously, rather than being paid directly.

The exact dollar amount paid into the escrow account for Tract 1E must be refunded in order for

the recoupment of Tract 1E to take place systematically and net properly. The attached Exhibits

A-1 and AA-1 further specifies the exact dollar amount that should be disbursed and paid to each

individual.

Page Number 6.

6. Attestation

The foregoing Petition to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief is true and correct.

Page Number 7.

Z40000SVSl

]F W998CII

.009.04009,JSS.JO

I

OE«wsrs AND CNT«225 To OTINNNsus WITINI Lsoo'NNUD OF CDN.W555aW.2255 5 Sl 4FT W NSESWCDN Essa 5 Os W'25" E

NTTSE'MI

Esss 5 55 Ir57" 2 DOST.OFcsN vsse N 4I'2r45" E 225D.4«CON STOA N ss'SF42" E 25052r /Crsevsss N flows" 2 24odx'

2IELOF /CW.VASN N 5'5555CSN.V254 N II'dlud" W 22ILTff

Q c«I TNT

Q «««« Il«NNIN «u

+««4«4 4«ere

CSM-vsdF N srreso4" W ssdssr FIAT INDE FOOVOTO OT ««445 IICCrNOVDSC N 22 Dw' 22IL42' I $ Ne WETE TNNNCWl-VSSE N 25~F27 N EO24.'79 FDON OTTO DESCDFTNTN «N o«N OFCds.vsse N 25 4F52" N 2542.r TNIE IF INCODOC«l.WSOA 5 52 25'N" W ITDLDF IT DOES NOT OEFOTDENI A e«NEWTCSN.WDOD N d'DFI' ITSLOW SOON«IT NNVET.

EXHIBIT AOAKWOOD F IELO

UNIT W35FORCE POOLING

VGOB-96&324"062T"OT

ond Mucus MIT NSS

Quodranal e KEEN NUUMTAIM

SOOTOI 1 e 400'Oteor o final plat

(Affix Seal l

Eospony ~X oas Cosoanv LLC

6 levantCounty RUCMAMAM pretrial CARUEM

This plat is a new plat X I an updoted plot

r I«-I-r ~/r-Rev. 9/91 Lioensea rrovessionol Enainoor cr Licensed.Lond Surveyor

Page Number 8.

140000875CNX Gas Company LLC

Unit W35Tract Identifications

Hurt-McGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 628.41 Acre Tract) —CoalIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, Inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company —Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC -CBM LeasedDewey Rows —Surlace, Oil and GasCNX Gas Company LLC - Oil, Gas and CBM Leased3.98 acres 4.9750%

1B. Hurt-McGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 628.41 Acre Tract) —CoatIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, Inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company -Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedHassell Davis, st ux -Surface, Oil and GasCNX Gas Company LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM Leased15.31acres 19.1375%

1C. Hun-McGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 628.41 Acre Tract) —CoalIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, Inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company —Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedGuster Clifton, et ux —Surface, Oil and GasCNX Gas Company, LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM Leased6.43 acres 8.037544

Hurt-McGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 628.41 Acre Tract) —CoalIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, Inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company- Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —Oil and GasConsolidation Coal Company —Surface0.13acres 0.1625ye

Hurt4llcGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 628.41 Acre Tract) —CoalIsiand Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, Inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company- Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedDaisy Burke OR Garden Realty Corporation —Oil and GasCNX Gas Company LLC - Oil, Gas and CBM Leased (If owned by Garden Realty Corporation)Daisy Burke —Surface33.56acres 41.9500%

"This title block is for general informational purposes only and does not reflect ananalysis of the severance deed and its effect upon coal bed methane ownership and should notbe relied upon for such purpose."

Page 1 of 2Mamh 4, 2011

Page Number 9.

1400008'75

CNX GBB Company LLCUnit W35

Tract Identifications

1F. Hurt-McGulrs Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 828.41 Acre Tract) -Coalisland Cmek Coal Company/Consol Energy, Inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewel! Smokeless Coal Company —Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC -Oil and GasConsolidation Coal Company- Surface3.10acres 3.8750%

1G. Hurt-McGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 828.41 Acre Tract) -Coalisland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, Inc. —Coal below Tilier Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company -Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedO.H. Keen Heirs - Oil and GasCNX Gas Com pany LLC —Oil, Gas and CBM Leased (86.8815%)Dewey Rows - Surface15.21acres 19.0125%

1H. Hurt-McGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 628A1 Acre Tract) —Coalisland Creek Coal Company/Consol Enwgy, Inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company —Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedHershei Keen, et ux —Surface, Oil and GasCNX Gas Company LLC —Oil, Gas snd CBM Leased1.08acres 1.3625%

HurtWcGuire Land Trust (Lewis Osborne 628.41 Acre Tract) —CoalIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, inc. —Coal below Tiller Seam LeasedJewell Smokeless Coal Company- Tiller and above Coal LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC —CBM LeasedTheodore Osborne - Oil and Gas0.22 acres OM50%

Consolidation Coal Company, et al Big Vein Tr. 85 (37.08Acre Tract) -CoalIsland Creek Coal Company/Consol Energy, inc, —Coal Below Tiller Seam LeasedJewel/ Smoke/ess Coal Corporation —Tll/er and Above Coal LeasedHighland Resources/North American Resources Corporation, et at —Oil snd GasCNX Gas Company LLC - Oil and Gas Leased (1/3)Plum Creek Timberland, et al —CBMCNX Gas Company LLC -CBM LeasedCNX Gas Company LLC, et al - Surface0.97acres 1.2125%

"This title block is for general informational purposes only and does not reflect ananalysis of the severance deed and its effect upon coal bed methane ownership and should notbe relied upon for such purpose."

Page 2 of 2March 4, 2011

Page Number 10.

VGOB Disbursement

Unit W-35

QOVGOB-98-0324-0627-09

~ Table 1 (pay exact dollar amount based on account balance of 12/31/2013)

~ 1E, A portion of 1G

item Tract Disbursement Table

Fractional Net Acreage Royalty Escrowed Percentof Disbursement


in Tract inTract Agreement Disbursed Disbursed


1E

I 1 11E1G

1 1G

2 1G

3 1G

4 1G

5 1G

Tract 1E (total acreage)

(CNX Gas Company LLC)2481 John Nash Blvd., Blusfield WV 24701

Tract 1G (total acreage)Nellie Maynard(Box 296, Raven VA 24639

Danny Elder)PO Box 748, Raven VA 24639

Robert Elderi229 Horton Crest Drive ¹15, Richlands, VA 24641

Joseph Horn<492 Gray Branch Road, Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

Hurt McGuire c/o Charles Green(PO Box 1067, Blusfield, VA 24605

33.56

15.2137/12600

1/1 260

1/1260

1/70

6/319

0.04470.01210.01210.21730.2861

50.00'/o

50.00'/o

50.00 /o

50.00'/o

50.003o

0.02230.00600.00600.10860.1430

0.0618'/o

Q Q167/o

0 0167/o

0.3005'/0

0 3956o/o

$18.49

$5.00

$5.00

$89.94

$118.41

33.56001 100.00'/oI 33.5600I 92.8174'/o I $27,781.901

Page Number 11.

VGOB Disbursement

Unit W-35

VGOB-98-0324-0627-09

Table 2 (pay percentage on balance after deducting the above balance)

1E, A portion of 1GCO


Fractional Net Acreage Royalty Escrowed Percent of Disbursement


in Tract inTract Agreement Disbursed Disbursed


1

2

34

567

8

910

1G Tract 1G (total acreage)

1G Margie Dye>784 Big Creek Road, Richlands, VA 24641

1G Tammy Boyd Street)195 Taylor Circle, Raven, VA 24639

1G Patricia Hortont200 Birch Street, Raven VA 24639

1G Nancy Stilwel8140 Rasnake Road, N. Tazewelk VA 24630

1G Wesley Perkins>305 Bane Bottom Ave., Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

1G Tania Yvonne Hoss>195 Anglewood Lane, Cedar Bluff, VA 24609

1G Martha E. Smith)P.O. Box 395, Max Meadows, VA 24360

1G Sarah Jane Dayt905 Valley View Drive, Pearisburg, VA 24134

1G Tamatha Bednait932 South Bunker Hill Road, Colfax, NC 27235

1G Hurt McGuire Land Trust c/o Charles Green)P.O. Box 1067, Bluefield, VA 24605

15.2137/12600

37/12600

1/1260

1/70

1/140

1/140

1/70

1/70

1/168

3/43

0.0447

0.0447

0.01210.21730.10860.10860.21730.21730.09051.0612

50.00%50.00%50.00%50.00%5P PP%

50.00%50.00%50.00%5P PP%

50.00%

0.02230.02230.00600.10860.05430.05430.10860.10860.04530.5306

0.9663%0.9663%0 2612%4.7011%2.3506%2 3506%

4 7011o/

4 701 to/

1.9588%22 9590%

$124.60

$124.60

$33.68$606.15$303.08

$303.08

$606,15

$606.15$252.56

$2,960.27

Wells contributing to the escrow account: PGP W35A W/PL, PGP-W35B W/PIPELINE

Page Number 12.

Exhibit EUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGOB 98-0324-0627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claiinants that require escrow

QO

CO

C> Tract ¹1E.33.56acres

Escrow Due to Title Conflict

Acres in Unit

Percent ofUnit

5-East0.54807%

Div/sion of Interestln6-East 13-East 14.East

0 28983% 3 6684o/o 8 1032%15 East0A068%

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hurt McGuire Land Trust

c/o Charles GreenP.O. Box 1067Blue6eld, VA 24605(Lewis Osborne 625 41 Acre Tree//

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

33.56 acres 41 9500ol 0 22992ol 0 12158% 1 53689'/ 3 39929% 0 17065%

(1) Daisy Burke1145 Hidden Acre Rd.Vansant, VA 24656

33.56 acres 41.9500% 0.22992'lo 0.12158'lo 1.53889'/o 3.39929lo 0.17065%

OR

(1) Garden Realty Corporation

108 Bexley RoadMooresvi0e, NC 28117

Tract 81G. 15.2f acres

33.56 acres 41 9500% 0.22992% 0 12158% 1 53889% 3 39929% 0 17065'yo

COAL OWNERSHIP


c/o Charles GreenP.O. Box 1067Bluefield, VA 24605(Lewis osborne 62&41 Acre Tract)

15.21 acres 19,0125% 0 10420% 0 05510% 0.69745% I 54062% 0 07734%

OIL 3 GAS OWNERSHIP

O.H. Keen Heirs, Devisees. Successors or Assigns

(3) Mary Elizabeth 5 Linkous W. Hom Heirs, Devisees,

Successors or Assigns

1521 acres 19.0125% 0.10420% 005510% 0.69745% 1.54062% 0.07734%

(s) Arizona Osborne Heirs. Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Page I of 4 rev. 3/14/2014

Page Number (3.

Exhibit EUnit W-35

Docket ¹ VGOB 986324-0627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres in UnitPercent of

Unit5-East

O.54807%

Division of Interest in6-East 13-East 14-East

0.28983% 3.6684% 8.1032'/15-East0 4068'/o

(a.l) Martha Gui¹iams1911 McVihy RoadSalem, VA 24153

0 072 acres1/210 of 15.21 acres

0 0905% 0 00050o/ 0.00026% 0.00332o%%d 0.00734/o 0.00037%

(a.2) Sydney Smith1977 McVitiy RoadSalem, VA 24153

0.072 acres1/210 of 15.21 acres

0.0905'Yo 0 00050% 0 00026o/ 0 00332% 0.00734'/ 0.00037%

(a.3) Kenneth Osborne648 Peyton StreetRoanoke, VA 24019

0.072 acres1/210 of 15.21 acres

0.0905% P P0050% 0 00026% 0 00332% 0.00734'/ 0 00037%

(b) Lydia Bell Osborne Deal Blankenship Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b.1) Mary Jane Keen1077 Longwa8 LN

Raven, VA 24639

0.020 acres1/770 of 15.21 acres

0.02471' 00014% 0.00007% 0.00091% O.D02DO'/ 0.00010'Yo

(b.2) Shirley Keen1665 Honaker Branch RoadRaven, VA 24639

0.020 acres1/770 of 15.21 acres

D.0247% 0.00014% 0.00007% 0.00091% 0.00200'/ 0.00010%

(b.7) Ronnie Osborne"'ox

12Oakwood, VA 24631

0 020 acres1/770 of 15.21 acres

0.0247% 0.00014'/ 0 00007% 0.00091% 0.00200'Yo 0.00010%

* NOTE: Royally Spill was executed, bul the VGOB approvedfo wifhhold the Disbursement at the Apr¹ 19, 2005 hear/ng.

(c) Henry Horn Heirs, Devisees.Successors or Assigns

(c.1) Peery W. HomP.O. Box 33Raven, VA 24639

0.047 acres 0 0588% 0.00032% 0.00017% 0.00216'/o 0.00477% 0.00024%13/4200 of 15 21 acres

(d) Thelma Osborne Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(d.1) Paul Junior OsborneP.O. Box 60Richlands, VA 24641

0.072 acres 0.0905'Yo 0.00050% 0.00026% 0.00332% 0.00734% 0.00037%1/210 of 15.21 acres

Page 2 of 4 rev. 3/1 4/2014

Page Number (4.

Exhibit EUnit WD5

Docket ¹ VGOB 98-0324-0627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

QO

CO(d 2) Curtis McCoy Osborne

P.O. Box 31Raven, VA 24639

Acres in UnitPercent of 5-East

Unit 0.54807'Y

0.072 acres 0.0905% 0.00050%1/210 of 15.21 acme

Division of interest in

6-East 13-East 14.East0.28983% 3.6664%% 8.1032'/o

0.00026% 0.00332% 0.00734%

15-East0.4068'/o

0.00037%

(d.3) Barbara Joyce HarmonP.O. BOx 174North Tszewell. VA 24630

0.072 acres1/210 oi 15.21acres

0.0905% 0.00050% D.ODD26% 0.00332% 0.00734% 0.00037%%uo

(i) Carl Ham Heirs, Oewsees,Successors or Assigns

(j.1) Marilyn TaylorPO Box 285Pounding Mill, VA 24637

(7) James Henry Keen Heirs, Devlsees,Successors or Assigns

0.217 acres1/70 of 15.21 acres

0.2716% 0.00149% O.DD079% 0.00996% 0.02201% 0.00110%

(g) Hester Brawn Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g.2) Michael Ray Brown

IncarceraiedO.O91 acres1/168 of 15.21 acres

0.1132% 0.00062 I, 0.00033% 0.00415'/ 0.00917'/ 0.00046%

(g.3) Loretts Lynn RathboneP.O. Box 1375Clyde, NC 28721

0.091 acres1/168 of 15.2'I acres

0.1132'/o 0.00062'fo 0.00033% 0.00415'Yo 0.00917'Yo 0.00046%

(g.4) Donna Sue Brown

P O. Box 1375Clyde, NC 28721

Freer 611.0.22 scree

0.091 acres1/168 of 15.21 acres

0.1132% 0.00062% 0 00033% 0.00415/o 0,00917% 0.00046%

COAL OWNERSHlP

(1) Hurl McGuire Land Trustc/a Chsdes GreenP.O. Box 1067Bluefield, VA 24605/Lewis osborne 628.41 Acre Yracr/

0.22 acres 0.2750% 0 00151% 0 00080% 0 01009oA 0 02228% O.D0112'fo

Page 3 of 4 rev 3/14/2014

Page Number 15.

Exhibit EUnit W-35

Docket 8 VGOB 98-03244627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants that require escrow

Acres in Unit

Percent ofUnit

5-East0.54807'/

Division of Interest in

6-East 13-East 14 East0.28983'Yo 3.8684% 8.1032/

15-East0.4068%

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

(1l Theodore Osborne - Deceased (doccmontettcn pending)

St Rt 82ARaven, VA 24639

0.22 acres 0 2750% 0 00151% 0 00080% 0 01009% 0 02228o/ 0 00112%

TOTAL CONFLICTSt

Acreage in UnitPercentage of Unit

34.8143.5123%

Page4of4 rev. 3/14/2014

Page Number 16.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGOB 988324-0627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreemsnts

Oe)

Tract ¹1B.15.31scree

COAL OWNERSHIP


Unit5-East

0 54807xi


0.28983% 3.8684% 8.1032%15-East Percent of0.4068% Escrow


c/o Charles GreenP O. Box 1067Blusfleld, VA 24605(Lewis Osborne 528 41 Acre Tracg

15.31 acres 19.1375% 0.10489% 0.05547% 0.70204% 1.55076% 0.07785% n/s

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Hassell Davis, st ux

P.O. Box 213Raven, VA 24639

15.31 acres 191375% 0 t0489ok 005547% 070204% 1 55075% 007785% rr/s

Tract ¹1C.6.43 acres

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hurt McGuire Land Trusto'o Charles GreenP.O. Sox 1067Bluetield, VA 24605(L su is Osborne 628 4 1 Acre Tract/

6.43 acres 8.0375% 0.04405% 0.02330% 029485% 0.65129% 0.03270% n/s

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) Gustsr Cliflon, et ux

1303John Clifton Rd.Raven, VA 24639

8.43 acres 8.0375% 0.04405% 0.02330% 0,29485% 0.65129% 0.03270% n/s

Tract ¹1D. 0.13actgg

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hurt McGuire Land Trustr/o Charles GreenP.O Box 1067Bluefield, VA 24605(Lewis Osborne 628.41 Acre Trscg

013 acres 0 1825% 0 00089Ok 0 00047% 0 00596% 0.01317% 0.00066% nra

Page 1 of12 rev. 3/14/2014

Page Number )7,

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGOB 98-03244I627-09List of Conflicting OwnsrsiClsimants with Royalty Split Agreements

QOCOCO

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

Acres in UnitPsrcerrt of

Unit

Division of Interest in5-East 6-East 13-East 14-East 15-East Percent of

0.54807% 0.28983% 3.6684% 8.1032% 0.4068% Escrow

(I) CNX Gas Company LLC2451 John Nash Blvd.Bluefisld. WV 24701(Previously Consolidai/on Coal Company)

0.13 acres 0.1825% 0.00089% 0.00047% 0.00596% 0.01317% 0.00066% n/a

Tract 57P. 3.10acres

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) Hurt McGuire Land Trustdo Charles GreenP 0 Box 1067Bluefield, VA 24605(Lewis Odroms 528.41 Acre Trsci)

3.10 acres 3.8750% 0.02124% 0.01123% 0.14215% 0.31400% 0.01576'/, n/a

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

(1) CNX Gas Company LLC2481 John Nash Blvd.Bluefteld, WV 24701(Previously Consolidalion Coal Company)

3 10 acres 3.8750/o 0.02124% 0.01123%v 0.14215% 0.3'l400%o 0.01576% n/s

Tract ¹1G. 15.21acres

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hurt McGuire Lend Trustdo Charles GreenP.O Box1067Bluefleld, VA 24605(Lewrs Osbomc 625.4l Acre Trod)

15.21 acres 19.0125'/o 0.10420% 0.05510'/o 0,69745% 1.54062% 0 07734'/o 22.9571%

OtL & GAS OWNERSHIP

O.H. Keen Heirs, Devisees, Successors or Assigns 15.21 acres 19.0125% 0.10420'/o 0.05510'/o 0.69745% 1.54062'/o 0.077347

(1) Stella Keen Clifton Heirs, Devisees,Successom or Assigns

Page 2 of 12 rev. 3(14(2014

Page Number (8.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket 9 %GOB 98-0324-0627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements

Acres in Unit

Percent ofUnit

5-East0.54807%


0,28983% 3.6684% 8.1032%15-East0.4068%

Percent ofEscrow

(a) Jean Davis4871 Riverside Dr.Raven, VA 24639

0.435 acres1l35 of 15.21 ames

0.5432% 0 00298% 0 00157% 0.01993ok 0 04402'Y 0.00221%o

(b) Guster Clifton

1303John Clifton Road, Apt.2Raven, VA 24639


0.5432% 0 00298% 0 00157% 0 01993% 0 04402% 0 00221'Y

(c) Jerreg Clifton

P.O. Box 668 John Clikon RoadOakwood, VA 24631


0.5432'/o 0,00298'Yo 0.00157% 0.01993k 004402ol D.D0221'Yo n/a

(d) Delcia Alderson4701 Florist Road NW

Roanoke, VA 24012

0.435 arses1/35 of 15.21 acres

0.5432%%uo 0.00298% 0.00157% 0.01993%%uo 0.04402% 0.00221% n/s

(e) Andrew Short Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(e.1) Ruby G. Short Wineseu1341 Johnsbury Court NERoanoke, VA 24109

0.435 acres 0 5432o/o D.D0298% 0 00157o/o 0 01993% 0 04402% D 00221% nle1/35 of 15.21 acres

(2) Harve Keen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Pansy Church2948 Baptisl ValleyCedar Bluff, VA 24609


2 7161% 0 01489ok 0 00787% 0 09964%%u 0 22009% 0.01105'k nla

(3) Mary Elizabeth & Linkous W. Horn Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b) Lydia Bell Osborne Deal Blankenship Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b.3) Patsy Moore

6985 Osborne Mtn RoadRaven, VA 24639

0.020 acres 0.0247% 0.00014% 0.00007% 0.00091'Yo 0.00200% 0.00010% nla1/770 of 15.21 acres

Page 3 of 12 rev. 3/14/201 4

Page Number ) 9.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket 6 VGOB 98-0324-0627.09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royally Split Agreements


Urait

Division of Interest in5-East 6-East 13-East 14-East

0 54807% 0 2S983% 3 6684o/o 8 1032%15-East Percent o(0.4068% Escrow

(b.4) Brenda Sue JusticePO Box S22Keen Mountain, VA 24624

0.020 acres1/770 oF 15.21 acres

0.0247% 0.00014% 0.00007% 0.00091%%ua 0.00200'%%uo 0.0001D% n/a

(b.5) James OsborneP.O BOx 484Keen Mountain, VA 24624

0.020 acres1/770 of 15.21 acres

0.0247% 0.00014'/a 0.00007% 0.00091% 0.00200% 0.00010% n/a

(b.6) Cliff'ord Heirs, Devlsees,Successors or Assigns

(b.6.1) Phyllis W. Osborne1109Moore Rd.Raven, VA 24639

0.020 acres1/T70 of 15.21 acres

0.0247% 0 00014'Yo 0.00007ok 0.00091% 0.00200 k 0.00010% nla

(b.8) Charles M. Osborne216 Plantation RoadRichlands, VA 24641

D.020 acres1l770 of 15.21 acres

0.0247 4 0.00014 lo 0.00007 4 0.00091% 0.00200% 0.00010/ aria

(b.9) Richard OsborneP.O. Box 585Keen MountaIn, VA 24624

0.020 acres1/770 of 'i5.21 acres

0 0247ok 0 00014% 0 00007ok 0 00091'k 0 00200% 0.00010% n/a

(b 10) Wilham Osborne Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b.10.1) Joyce Lineberry Maec/o Rose MaeP.O. Box 172Cooleemee, NC 27014

0.020 acresI/770 of 15.21acres

00247% 0.00014'Yo 0.00007% 0.000911o 0.00200% 0.00010% nla

(b.11) John David osborne Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(b.11.1)Darlens B. Osborne1055 Mapleleaf Hallow

Raven, VA 24639

0.020 acres1/770 of 15.21 acres

0.0247 k 0.00014% 0.00007 la 0.00091% 0.00200% 0.00010% rr/4

(c) Henry Hom Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Page 4 of 12 rev. 3/14/2014

Page Number 20.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGOB 98-0324-0627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Sp01 Agresmsnts


Unit

5-East0.54807'k

Division of Interest In

6-East 13-East 14-East0 28983'% 6884%%uo 8 1032oA,

15-East Percent of0.4088% Escrow

(c 3) Ivory Hom Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(c.3 1) Margaret Ellen Dye784 Big Creek RoadRichlsnds, VA 24641

0.045 acres37/12600 of 15.21 acres

0.0558'A 0.00031% 0.00015'k 0.00205% 0.00452'k 0.00023'k 0.9863'/

(c.3.2) Nellie MaynardPO Box 296Raven, VA 24639

0.045 acres37/12600 of 15.21 acres

0 0558% O.DOD31% 0 00016o/o 0.00205% 0 00452% 0 00023% nfa

(c.3.3) Tammy Boyd Street195 Taylor CircleRaven, VA 24639

0.045 acres37/12600 of 15.21 acres

0.0558% 0 00031% 0.00016% 0 00205% 0.00452'Yo 0.00023% 0.9663'k

(c.3.4) Patrida Disnne Horlon

200 Birch StreetRaven. VA 24639

0.012 acres1/1260 of 15.21 acres

0.0151% 0 00008'/ 0 00004%%u 0 ODOM'/o 0.00122% 0.00006'/o 0.2612%

(c.35) Danny W ElderPO Box 748Raven, VA 24639

0.012 acres1/1 260 of 15.21 acres

0.0751% 0.00008% 0.00004% 0.00055% 0.00122% O.D0006%

(c.36) Robert G. Elder229 Horton Crest Drive ¹15Richiands, VA 24641

0.012 acres1/1260 of 15.21 acres

0 0151ok 0 00008% 0.00004ok 0.00055% 0.00122ok 0.00006'k nla

(e) Joseph P. Horne492 Gray Branch RoadCedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.217 acres 0.2716%%uo 0 00149 lo 0.00079% 0.00996% 0.0220'l% 0.00110% role

1/70 of 15.21 acres

(f) Nancy H. Sklweg140 Rssnake RoadN. Tazeweg, VA 24630

0 217 acres 02716/o 000149k 000079% 000996/o 002201% 000110'Yo 4.7011/o1/70 of 15.21 acres

(g) Earnest Hom Heirs, Osvisees,Successors or Ass/gns

(g.1) Dorothy Hom Heirs, DeviseesSuccessors or Assigns

Page 5 of 12 rev. 3/I 4/2014

Page Number 2).

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGO8 984I324.0627-09List of Contlicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements


Unit

5-East0.54807%

Division of Interest in6.East 13-East 14-East

028983% 3.6684% 8.1032%15-EastOA068%

Percent otEscrow

(g.1.1) Wesley D. Perkins305 Bane Bottom AveCedar Bluff, VA 24609

0 109 acres 0.1358% 0.00074%1/140 of 15.21 acres

0.00039% 0.00498% 0 01100% 0.00055% 2.3506%

Enfiffed tc 1/2 of Royalties by Deed of Gift dated September 22, 2011 reccrded sf DS 1101/PG 230

Tania Yvonne Hess195 Anglewood LaneCedar Bluff, VA 24609

0.109 acres1/140 of 15.21 acres

0.1358% 0.00074% 0.00039% 0.00498% 0.01100% 0.00055% 2.3506%

(h) Martha E. SmithP.O Box 395Max Meadows, VA 24360

0.217 acres1170 of 15.21 acres

02716% 000149% 000079% 000996ok 002201'7 000110% 47011%

(i) Sarah K. Day905 Va0ey View Drive

Pearisburg, VA 24134


0.2716'/ 0.00149% 0.00079% 0 00996% 0 02201% 0.00110% 4.7611%

(4) William David Lewis Keen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Edward KeenRt.4 Box 159Bluefisld, WV 24701

0 272 acres 0 3395% 0 00186'/ 0 00098r/o 0.01245% 0.02751% 0.00138% n/aI/56 of 15.21 acres

(b) Homer Keen1771 Hsidelbach School RoadStuart, VA 24171

0.272 acres 0.3395% 0.00186% 0.00098% 0.01245/ 0.02751'y 0.00138% n/a1/56 of 15.21 acres

(c) Virginia Ball Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(c.1) Carol Anita Davis202 Cliff Street, Lot ¹12Richlands, VA 24641

0.091 acres 0.1132% 0.00062% 0.00033% 0.00415% 0 00917% 0 00046% n/a1/168 of 15 21 acres

(c.2) Richard Balt

149 Chestnut StreetFieldate, VA 24089

0.091 acres 0.1132% 0.00062% 0.00033% O.M415% 0.00917% 0.00046% nfs1/168 of 15.21 acres

Page 6 of 12 rev. 3/1 4/2014

Page Number 22.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket 6 VGOB 98-0324-06274tgList of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Spgt Agreements

Acres in UnitPercent of 5-East

Unit 0.54807'7


0.28983'll 3.6684% 8.1032%%d

15-East Percent of6.4068% Escrow

(r,.3) Carl Ball1162 Longview Drive

Bassea, VA 24055

0.091 acres 0.1132% 0.00062%'I/168 of 15.21 acies

0 00033% 0 00415%, 0.00917% 0 00046% s/a

(d) William Albert Keen Heirs, Devisses,Successors or Assigns

(d.1) Bessie Aline Keen Heirs,Devisees, Successors or Assigns

(d 1.1) Shiney Perry6091 Red Root Ridge Rd.Raven, VA 24639

0.023 acres1/672 of 15.21 acres

0 0283% 0 00016% 0 00008% 0 00104% 0 00229'Y, 0.00012% n/a

(d.1 2) Barbers Smith

8091 Red Root Ridge Rd.Raven, VA 24639

0.023 acres1/672 of 15.21 acres

00283% 000016/o 0.00006/ 0.00104%%d 000229% 0 00012% n/4

(d 1.3) Joyce Nipper1111Nipper ROad

Raven, VA 24839

0 023 acres1/672 of 15.21 acres

0.0283% 0 00016% 0.00006% 0.001041v 0.00229% 0,000127o ns

fd 1.4) Melvin Catron Heirs, DeviseesSuccessors or Assigns

(d.1.4.1) Kristy Lynn Catron84 West Maxlow StreetHazel Park, Ml 48030

0.006 acres1/2688 of 15.21 acres

0.0071% 0.00004% 0 00002% 0 00026O%%d 0.00057% 0 00003% n/s

(d.1.4.2) Aiissa Marie Catron39 Eesl Harry StreetHazel Park, Ml 48030

0.006 acres1/2688 of 15 21 acres

0.0071% 0.00004% 0.00002% 0.00026% 0.00057% 0.00003% n/e

(d.1.4.3) Emily Edna Dutkiewlcz

30103 Callahan Drive

Rosevig e, Ml 48068

0.006 acres1/2688 of 15.21 acres

0.0071v%%d 0.00004% 0.00002% 0.00026% 0.00057% 0 00003% n/e

(d.1.4.4) Kaitlynn Williams

3542 Hwy 511Corbin, KY 20701

0.006 acres1/2688 of 15.21 acres

0.0071'/ a.OOOOz%%u. Q.OQOOZ%%u O.OOO26% O.QOO57%%u. O.QOOa3% n/a

Page 7 of 12 rev 3/14/2014

Page Number 23.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGOB 98-0324-06274t9List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements


Unit5-East

0.54807%

Division of Interest in

6-East 13-East 14-East0.28983% 3.6684% 8.1032%

15-East0.4068'Yo

Percent ofEscrow

(d.2) Douglas W, Keen8524 W. Drew Ct.Homosassa, FL 34447

0.091 acres1/168 of 15.21 acres

0.1132'/0 0 00062% 0.00033% 0.00415% 0.00917% 0.00046/. n/a

QO (d 3) Darrell A. Keen8524 W Drew CLHomosasss, FL 34447

0,091 acres1/168 of 15.21 acres

0.1132% 0.00062% 0.00033% 0 00415% 0 00917% 0.00046% n/a

(e) Lillie Mae Cook141 Virginia StreetKingsport, TN 37660

0.272 acres1/56 of 15.21 arses

0.3395% 0.00186% 0.000981v 0.01245% 0 02751 Y, 0 00136rk

(f) Georgie Keen107 Pinewood Acre Drive

Powells Point, NC 27966


0.3395% 0.00186% 0.00098% 0.01245% 0 02751 ok 0 00138%

(g) Bonnie AbsherP.O. Box 835Richlands, VA 24641


0.3395'/o 0 00186% 0 00098% 0 01245% 0 02751% 0.00138%

(h) Ruby Stanley Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(h.l ) Ruth Ann Hunt Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(h.1.1) Sandra Hunt Conner Heirs. Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(h.1.1.1)Roger W. Conner761 Cenierville Rd.

Axton, VA 24054

0.027 acres 0.0340'k 0.00019% 0.00010% 0.00125'Io 0 00275% 0.00014'I n/a

1/560 of 15.21 acres

(h,1,2) Kimberly Hunt Kidd

128 Susan Drive

Collinsville, VA 24078

0.027 acres 0.0340% 0.00019/ 0.0001(P/v 0.00125'Y 0.00275% 0 00014% rr/a

1/560 of 15.21 acres

(h.2) Arlene Gilbert Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(h.2.1) Fred Gilbert Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

Page 8 of 12 rev 3/14/2014

Page Number 24.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket 8 VGOB 96-0324-06274isList of Contlicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Spgt Agreements

Acres In UnftPercent of

Unit5-East

0.54807%

Division of Interest in6-East 13-East 14.East

0.28983% 3.6684'k 8.1032%15-East0.4068'k

Percent ofEscrow

(h.2.1.1) Lies M. Rasnick1498 Mundy Town RoadN. Tazewe6, VA 24630

0.054 acres1/280 of 15.21 acres

0.0679% 0 0003/ok 0 00020% 0 00249'y 0.00550% 0.00028ok

(h.3) William E. Stanley, Jr.326 Grayson StreetMartinsvi6e, VA 24112

D.054 acres1/260 of 15.21 acres

0.0679'k 0.00037% 0.00020'k 0 00249% 0.00550% 0.00028% n/4

(hk) James H. Stanley25 Raceway DriveBassett, VA 24055

0054 acresI/280 of 15.21acres

0.0679% 0.00037% 0.00020% 0.00249% 0 00550'/ 0.00028% n/s

(h.5) Victoria Webb326 Grayson StreetMartinsvi0e, VA 24112

0.054 acres1/280 of 15.21 acres

0 0679% 0.00037% D.DDD20% 0 00249% 0.00550% 0.00028%

(5) Georgie Bell Short Clifton Heirs, Dsvisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Shelby Jean Vandyke Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a.1) Dsrre6 VandykePO Box 540Pounding Mill, VA 24637

0.272 acres 0.3395% 0.00186% 0.00098% 0.01245% 0.02751% 0.00138% n/a

1/56 of 15.21 acres

(a.2) Rite McGlothlin

4815 Rad Root RidgeRaven, VA 24639

0.272 acresI/56 ot 15.21 acres

0.3395% 0.00186'/o 0.00098% 0.01245% 0 0275trk 0.00138% n/a

(a.3) Gerald VandykeP.O. Box 892Raven, VA 24639

0.272 acres'I/56 of 15.21 acres

0 3395% 0 00186% 0 00098'7 0 01245% 0 0275t%%u 0 00138rk n/4

(a.4) Denrss Vandyke (Incarcerated)rJo Rite McGlothlin4815 Rad Root RidgeRaven. VA 24639


0.3395% 0.00186% 0.00098% 0.01245% 0,02751% 0.00138% n/a

Page 9 of 12 rev. 3/14/2014

Page Number 25.

Exhibn EEUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGOB 98-0324-0627-09List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements

Acres in UnitPercent of 5-Eeet

Unit 0.54807%

Division of Interest in6.Eeet 13-East 14-Eeet

0.28983% 3.6684% 8.1032%15.East Percent of

0.4068% Escrow

(b) Frances stella GrossP.O. Box 295Richlsnds, VA 24641

Qp (6) Heny Neet Keen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(a) Lan% Roger KeenP.O. Box 635

CO Keen Mountain, VA 24639

(b) Carnice Keen4777 Hale Creek RoadPilgdms Knob, VA 24634

1.086 acres 1 3580% 0 00744%%uo

I/14 of 1521 acres0 00394% 0.04982% 0,11004% 0,00552% n/a

0.241 acres1/63 of 15 21 acres

0.3018% 0.00165% 0.00087% 0.01107% 0.02445% 0.00123% n/e

0 241 acres1/63 of 15.21 acres

0.00123Vo n/80.3018% 0.00165% 0.00087/ 0.01107% 0.02445%

(c) Phillip Keen

P.O. Box 215Wythevi8e, VA 24383

0.241 acresI/63 of 15.21 acres

03018% 000165Vo 000087% 001107% 002445% 0.00123% n/4

(d) Eddie KeenPO Box 912Raven, VA 24639

0.241 scree1/63 of 15.21 acres

0.3018% 0.00165% 0.00087% 0.01107% 0.02445% 0 00123os „/8

(e) Remus KeenBox 570Doran, VA 24612

0.241 acres1/63 of 15 21 acres

0.3018% 0.00165% 0.00087% 0.01107Vo 0 02445% 0.00123% n/8

(f) Richard KeenP.O. Box 431Oakwood, VA 24824


0.3018'Yo 0.00165% 0.00087% 0.01107% 0.02445% 0,00123% n/e

(g) Inez J Acklin

332 West Mary StreetBristol, VA 24201


0 3018%%uo 0.00165% 0.00087'/ 0.01107%%uo 0 02445% 0,00123Vo n/8

(h) Jenice Cook2914 Clerks Valley Rd.Swords Creek, VA 24649


0.3018Vo 0.00165% 0.00087% 0.01107'/o 0.02445% 0.00123% n/8

(i) Hany D. Keen Heirs, Devisses,Successors or Assigns

Page 10 of 12 rev. 3/14/2014

Page Number 26.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket ¹VGOB 98-0324.06274I9List of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royaky Split Agreements

Acres In UnitPercent of 5-East

Unit 0.54807%

Division of Interest rn

6-East 13-East 14-East9.28983% 3.6684% 8.1032'k

15.East Parce/it of0.4968% Escrow

(1.1) Beautii Honaker Jarvins11205 Bawl Road NW

Baltimore, OH 43105-9471

QO (7) James Henry Keen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

CO(s) Dexter Keene

102 Painter StreetTazeweil, VA 24651

(b) Dorothy CliftonP 0 Box 123Springdale, WV 25986

0.241 acres 0.3018%% 0.00165%1/63 of 15.21 acres

0.00087% 0.01107% 0.02445% 0,00123% nra



0 4527% 0 00248% 0 00131ok 0.01661'yo 0 03668% 0.00184'k n/a

0 4527 k 0.00248% 0.00131% 0.01661% 0.03668% 0.00184% n/a

(c) Zalvia Keen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

No Issue - Inlercsl Io Siblings

(d) William Keen, JrP.O. Box 481Mabscot, WV 25871


0.4527'/. 0.00248'I, 0.00131% 0.01661% 0.03688k 0.00184'k n/a

(e) Della Monk Lancaster625 Prater DriveRichlands, VA 24641

0.362 acresI/42 of 15.21 acres

0.4527% 0.00248% 0.00131'/o 0.01661% 0.03668'/ 0.00184% n/a

(f) Audrey Law102 Loblolly LaneStafford, VA 22554


0 4527o/ 0 00248'/o 0 00131% 0 01661% 0 03688% 0 00184ok n/a

(7) James Henry Keen Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(g) Hester Brown Heirs, Devisees,Sucoessors or Aswgns

(g.l) Tamatha Bednar932 South Bunker Hill RoadColfax, NC 27235

0.091 acresI/168 of 1521 acres

0.1132'yo 0.00062% 0.00033% 0.00415'k 0.00917'/o 0,00046'k 1.9588%

Total tract acresTotal tract percent

14.1817.7252%

Page 11 of 12 rev. 3/1 4/2014

Page Number 27.

Exhibit EEUnit W-35

Docket 8 VGOB 98-0324-06274igList of Conflicting Owners/Claimants with Royalty Split Agreements


Unit5-East

0.54807%

Dhdsion of Interest in6-East 13-East 14-East

0 28983% 3 6684r/o 8.1032%15-East Percent of0.4D68% Escrow

Tract 81/f. 1.09acres

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hurt McGuire Land Trustc/o Charles GreenP.O. Box 1067Bluefield, VA 24605/Lewis Osborne 626 41 Acre Tree//

1.09 acres 1.3625% 0.00747'/ 0.00395'Yo 0.04998% 0.11041% 0005541r n/a

OIL & GAS OWNERSHIP

(I) Hershel Keen, el ux4970 Old Ky Turnpike RoadRaven, VA 24639

1.09 acres 1.3625'/ 0.00747% 0.00395% 0 04998% 0.11041% 0.00554% n/s

TOTAL CONFUCTS RESOLVEi

Acreage in UnitPercentage of Unit

40.2450.3002%

013mI'1'I

Cy ~XO 4 OmCr -qrcr I—-'c r"'r s.L'mnr-

m

inco

mit Cpr~

CO r I//

r3 rlr

r"3~mmC3 3'wr &n-I

rnn14s

-CD~~LOC3I

Cxrr4 Cx Tlknoro& 11"4t.ll

m

Page 12 of 12 rev. 3/14/2014

Page Number 28.

i. · modification order-07executed 06/26/2012, recorded on 08/08/2012, deed book/instrument no....

Documents