ian pulsford, graeme l. worboys and dave darlington · 2020-05-04 · dave darlington, ba dip ed...

23
Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020 Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington

Upload: others

Post on 20-Jun-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys

and Dave Darlington

Page 2: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

ThisreporthasbeenpreparedbyIanPulsford,GraemeL.WorboysandDaveDarlingtonandisavailableat:https://theaustralianalps.files.wordpress.com/2020/05/revisiting-pest-horse-impacts-to-australian-alps-catchments-2020.pdfImportantnoticeThissupplementary“Observations”reportisprovidedasanupdatetoareportbyWorboysandPulsfordin2013(Worboys,G.L.andPulsford,I.2013).ThisreportisproducedforgeneralinformationandisarecordofpersonalobservationsmadebytheauthorsfortheMtPilotareaofKosciuszkoNationalParkin2013thatwererevisitedinMarch2020.Ithasbeenpreparedwithinthecontextoftheauthorsparticipatingininspectionsofthisareaoveraperiodof47yearsfrom1973to2020andshouldbereadinconjunctionwiththe2013report.Responsibilityforthereportcontentsrestswiththeauthors.TheauthorswereaccompaniedontheirinspectionbyformerNSWEnvironmentMinisterandBoardChairdesignateoftheColongFoundationforWilderness,BobDebusAM.©Thereportisavailableforgeneraluse.Citation:Pulsford,I.,Worboys,G.L.andD.Darlington(2020).RevisitingObservationsofPestHorseImpactsintheAustralianAlps,March2020,Canberra.Availableat:Coverphoto:PhotoofaCowombatFlatferalhorseexclusionplotestablishedin1999,AlpineNationalParkVictoriashowinga21yearnongrazedareawithintheexclusionarea(photo-left)withallotherareasaccessibletoferalhorsegrazing,pugging,compressionanderosionofsoilanddestructionofnativevegetation,3Mar2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 3: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

1

Revisiting2013ObservationsofPestHorseImpactsintheAustralianAlpsinMarch2020Ian Pulsford, MSc.ProtectedAreaandLinkingLandscapesSpecialistandformerSenior Conservation Manager. Graeme L. Worboys, AM PhD Honorary Associate Professor, Fenner School, Australian National University Protected Area Management Specialist and former Senior Protected Area Manager. Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28April2020INTRODUCTIONWemadeobservationsarisingfromaninspectionon22and23March2013oftheupperThredboRiverBigBoggy,CascadeCreek,IngegoodbeeRiver,TinMineCreekandMurrayRiverheadwatercatchments,KosciuszkoNationalPark(WorboysandPulsford2013).Weidentifiedunprecedented,pervasiveanddestructiveferalhorseimpactsforover43kilometresoftreelessdrainagelinesespeciallyinCommonwealth-listedAlpineSphagnumBogsandAssociatedFensEndangeredEcologicalCommunitieswhichoccurinthehighheadwatercatchmentsoftheAustralianAlps.Wereportedthat“theseimpactsweretheworsteverobservedin40yearsofpersonalinspectionsoftheDeadHorseGaptoTinMinessectionofthePilotWildernessofKosciuszkoNationalParkinNewSouthWalesandatCowombatFlatareaoftheVictorianAlpineNationalPark.BothoftheseparksformpartoftheAustralianAlpsnationalparks”.On3and4March2020werepeatedourobservationsofmanyofthesamesitestoevaluateifanychangesinimpactshadoccurredsinceourlastvisit7yearsago.Ourconclusionisthattheconditionofwetlandbogsoncreekflatsandcreekbanksintreelessdrainagelineshascontinuedtodeteriorateduetothecontinuedpresenceoflargeferalhorsepopulations.Sinceourlastobservationsin2013feralhorsepopulationmanagementceasedin2015inthePilotareaand99horseswereremovedfromBlueWaterHolesinthespringof2019inthenorthernendofthePark(DPIE2019).Inaddition,therehasbeenarecentrapidincreaseinpopulationsofdeeraswellassomepigsthatwererecordedbytheNPWSduringaerialsurveys(Cairns2019,NPWS2019).WehadintendedtoalsorevisitsitesalongandneartheIngeegoodbeeTrail,howeverthiswasnotpossibleduetointroductionofCOVID-19travelrestrictions.Wesawnoevidenceofrecoveryatthesiteswerevisitedandinmanyareasdamagetowetlandsandbogsalongriverflatsweremoreextensive.Conditionsweremuchdrierthanduringour2013inspectionduetotheprolongedseveredrought.Theareaswerevisitedwerenotdirectlyaffectedbythemega-firesthatburntlargeareasofeasternAustraliainJanuaryandFebruary2020.However,partsofthenearbywesternfalloftheupperMurrayandGeehiRiversandslopesofthewesternfalloftheKosciuszkoMainRangeuptoDeadHorseGapontheAlpineWaywereseverelyburnt.

Page 4: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

2

HORSEPOPULATIONESTIMATESSinceourfirstobservationsoverthelast40yearsandour2013reportofferalhorsesimpactsinthePilotWildernessAreasouthofThredbo(WorboysandPulsford2013),horsepopulationshavecontinuedtoincreasesubstantiallyinmanyareasoftheAustralianAlps.In1990researcherJennyDyringmadepopulationestimatesofseveralhundredhorsesintheBigBoggy,CascadesCreek,IngeegoodbeeRiverandCowombatFlatareasouthofThredbo(Dyring1990).MichelleDawsonneeWalterconductedanaerialsurveyin2001(Walter2002)thatestimatedpopulationsof2horsespersquarekilometreintheBigBoggyand6.4horsespersquarekilometreintheCowombatpopulationof(Dawson2005).

AerialsurveysintheAustralianAlpsnationalparksestimatedapopulationof5,200in2001;2,369in2003;and7,679horsesin2009,a21.65%perannumincreasesincethepreviousestimatein2003(Dawson2009).InApril-May2014andApril-May2019theNSWNationalParksandWildlifeService(NPWS)conductedrepeatsystematicaerialsurveysacrossthreeblockscoveringtheentiredistributionofferalhorsesintheAustralianAlps(KosciuszkoNationalParkandadjacentstateforestareasinNewSouthWalesandtheAlpineandSnowyRiverNationalParksinVictoria).ThesesurveysweredesignedandanalyzedbyStuartCairns.Thehorsepopulationsincreasedintheseblocksfrom9,187in2014to25,318in2019,anaverageincreaseof23%perannum(Cairns2019),(Figure1).ThepopulationintheByadbo-Victoria(SnowyRiverandAlpineNationalPark)surveyblock,whichincludedthePilotWildernessarea,increasedby15%from4,316to8,518(Cairns2019).Otherlargeintroducedherbivoresincludingdeer,cattle,goatsandpigswerealsoobservedduringtheseaerialsurveys.Themostnumerousoftheseotherspeciessightedwereintroduceddeer.In2014theestimatedpopulationofdeerwas2,280whichincreasedto7,630in2019.Thisequatedtoanannualrateofpopulationincreaseinthedeerpopulationof27%.ThisrateofincreasewasmuchhigherthantherateofincreaseforthehorsepopulationinByadbo-Victorianblock.Populationestimateresultsfromtheseaerialsurveysindicatethathorsepopulationsstillexceedferaldeerpopulationswithinthesurveyblock.Thesurveysalsorecordedgoatsandpigsbuttheywerefarlessnumerousandwerenotobservedinnumbersthatallowedanalysistoprovidestatisticallyrobustpopulationestimates(Cairns2019).

Atthetimeofourlastvisittotheareain2013theNPWSconductedongoinglimitedcaptureandremovalofwildhorsesfromthearea.RemovalofhorsesfromthePilotWildernessareain2015ceasedpriortocommencementofcommunityconsultationandexhibitionofthedraftKosciuszkoWildHorseManagementPlanin2016(OEH2016).In201999horseswereremovedfromtheBlueWaterHolesareainthenorthernsectionoftheParkafterthecommencementoftheKosciuszkoWildHorseHeritageAct2018(R.Gibbspers.comm.).TheNPWSalsoconductedaseparateseriesof9aerialsurveysbetween2006and2019toestimatethenumberofhorsesin3,500haofsubalpineecosystemsintheBigBoggyareaofthePilotWildernesssouthofThredbo(Figure2).TheMay2019surveyrecorded202horsesNinerepeatsurveyscarriedoutatthesametimeofyearfrom2006to2019indicatedthatthepopulationdensityhasincreasedfrom2.7to6.28horses/km2respectively(NPWS2019).TheMtPilot–CascadesCreekandTinMinesareathatweinvestigatediscontiguouswiththeupperThredboRiver“BigBoggy”andconsistsofsubalpinewoodland,treelessdrainagelinesandmontaneforestsonthewatershedoftheGreatDividingRange.

Page 5: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

3

Figure1HorsepopulationestimatesintheAustralianAlps,2001-2009(afterDawson2009)and2014-2019(afterCairns2019).SeeDawson2009andCairns2019forsurveydesignandrespectiveareassampled.

Figure2.Comparisonofhorsestrappedandremovedfromsurveyareaandpopulationestimatesfromannualaerialsurveysinthe3,500haupperThredboRiver“BigBoggy”studyareasouthofThredbo(afterNPWS2019).

Horsesremoved Horsepopulationestimatebasedonaerialsurveys

Page 6: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

4

VEGETATIONDESTRUCTIONIn2013wereportedthatexcessivenumbersofpesthorseswereobservedtobedirectlydestroyingsubalpinenativevegetationandthiswasbestillustratedin2013atexclosureplotsestablishedatCowombatFlatAlpineNationalParkin1999.Thesefourexclosuresare21yearsoldandarelocatedintheupperheadwaterstreamofAustralia’slongestandmosteconomicallyimportantriver,theMurray,justafewkilometresfromitssource.Theimpactswerevisuallyveryclearin2013andtheimagesbelowdemonstratethattheconditionofthevegetationhascontinuedtodeclineasaresultofgrazingbylargenumbersofhorsesanddeeranddrought.Weobservedrelativelylittledisturbancebypigs.Astudyofimpactsofherbivoregrazinginnearbylowerelevationwhitecypresspine–whiteboxcommunitiesalongthelowerSnowyRiverValleywithinthePilotWildernesswasinvestigatedbyJessicaWard-Jonesandcolleaguesin2018.In2013and2017/2018fencedexclosureandpairedgrazedplotswhichhadbeenconstructed1984weresurveyedtoassesstheseverityofimpactsonvegetation,soilandinvertebratesusingarangeoftechniquesincludingLandscapeFunctionAnalysis.Dungcountsconductedin1987and2018wereusedtoassesstherelativepresenceofherbivores.Therewasfourtimesmoredungrecordedin2018thanin1987(totaldryweight).Horseanddeerdungwasabsentin1987,butdominatedin2018.Dungtransectdatacollectedinthegrazedplotsandadjacentgrazedlandscapeshowedthat84%ofdungwasfromhorses,13%fromdeer,2%frommacropodsand1%fromrabbits.Theherbivoreexclusionplots,fencedfor34years,exhibitedsignificantlyhighersoilandvegetationconditionthanthegrazedplots,aswellasinvertebrateabundance.Vegetation structureandcomposition,andsoilstabilityandfunctionwithintheplotswasimproving, whereassoilsoutsidetheplotswerebareanderodinginbroadsheetsacrossslopesandingullies.Densenetworksoftracksandtrampingbyhorsesweremostevidentwithdamagetosteepcreekbankscausedbydeer(Ward-Jonesetal.2019).

In2015themostextensivestudytoassesstheimpactsofhorsesthroughoutpubliclandintheAustralianAlpswasundertakenbyRobertsonetal.(2015).Theirstudydemonstratedthatferalhorsesarehavingasignificantimpactontheconditionofdrainagelinesacrossthisrange.Almostallsitesassessedwithinthebroadhorsedistributionshowedevidenceofhorsepresence,andallofthesitesinpoorestconditionwereoccupiedbyhorses.Theyfoundthatonaverage,about28metresofthestreambedineach50msitetheymeasuredhadamoderatetohighsedimentloadinhorsepresentsites,comparedtohorsefreesiteswherebankswerestableduetothepresenceofundisturbedfringingvegetation.Theyconcludedthelossofstability,modificationofstreambanksandvegetationstructurehavesignificantimpactsontheconservationoffaunaincludingarangeoflistedthreatenedandotherspeciesincludingAlpineBogSkinkPseudemoiacryodroma,AlpineShe-oakSkinkCyclodomorphuspraealtusandAlpineTreeFrogLitoriaverreauxiialpina.Asaconsequencethishasledtothelistingof“DegradationandlossofhabitatscausedbyferalHorses(Equuscaballus)”asapotentiallythreateningprocessundertheVictorianFloraandFaunaGuaranteeAct1988.On30Nov2018theNSWThreatenedSpeciesScientificCommitteelisted“habitatdegradationandlossbyFeralHorses(brumbies,wildhorses)”asakeythreateningprocessundertheNSWBiodiversityConservationAct,2016.

ConsistentwithourownobservationsintheMtPilotarea,Robertsonetal.(2015)concludedthatthemostcriticalimpactofferalhorsesintheAlpsisthedamagetheycausetoAlpine

Page 7: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

5

SphagnumBogsandAssociatedFensalongtreelessdrainagelines.ThisisanendangeredecologicalcommunitylistedundertheCommonwealthEnvironmentProtectionandBiodiversityConservationAct1999.Wefoundthatthatthesehabitatshavecontinuedtodeclinetoanalarmingdegree.Thishighlyendangeredcommunityprovideshabitatcriticalforthepreservationofendangeredspeciesandaswellasimportantlyfilteringlargequantitiesofcleanwaterwhichisreleasedslowlyintostreamsenhancingcatchmentvalueandpreventingsoilerosion.Seephotosbelow.ThephotographsbelowclearlyillustratetheextentofthedamagetonativevegetationalongtreelessdrainagelinesoftheupperThredboRiverBigBoggy,CascadeCreek,IngegoodbeeRiver,TinMineCreekandMurrayRiverheadwatercatchments,KosciuszkoNationalParkfromferalhorses.

Figure3.LocationofobservationsintheMtPilotareaofKosciuszkoNationalParkandAlpineNationalParkintheAustralianAlps22and23March2020.(Source:GoogleMaps:TerraMetrics2020Imagery).

Page 8: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

6

Horseimpactedvegetationsurroundinga1999exclosureplotwithitsprotectedswardofsedgesandgrasses,CowombatFlat,VictorianAlpineNationalPark,neartheNSWborder,23March2013(Source:GraemeL.Worboys).

Horseimpactedvegetationsurroundingexposingbaretrampledandcompactedsoilatthesameexclosurethatwasconstructedin1999withitsprotectedswardofsedgesandgrasses,CowombatFlat,VictorianAlpineNationalPark,VictorianAlpineNationalPark,3March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 9: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

7

Exclosureplotfenceconstructedin1999withprotected(left)andunprotectedsedgeandgrassvegetation,CowombatFlat,VictorianAlpineNationalPark,23March2013.(Source:GraemeL.Worboys).

Exclosureplotfenceconstructedin1999withprotected(left)andunprotectedsedgeandgrasswetland,CowombatFlat,VictorianAlpineNationalPark,3March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 10: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

8

MurrayRiverheadwaterstreamimpactedbyhorsesasitemergesfromdenseprotectedswardofsedgesandgrasseshabitatwithina1999exclusionplotatCowombatFlat,March232013.(Source:IanPulsford).

MurrayRiverheadwatersstreamimpactedbyhorsesasitemergesfromdenseprotectedswardofsedgesandgrasseswithinanexclusionplotconstructedin1999atCowombatFlatinAlpineNationalPark.Notecompaction,bankdisturbanceanderosionhaveincreased,vegetationcoverislowerandvegetationstructureislesscomplexthaninsidethesameexclosures,3March2020.GrazingimpactsattheseplotshavebeendescribedbyProberandThiele(2007)andWildandPoll(2012)(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 11: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

9

Horsetramplingimpactstostreambanksandstreambankcollapse,headwatersoftheIngeegoodbeeRivernearTinMinesHut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,22March2013(Source:GraemeL.Worboys).

Horsetramplingimpactstothesamestreambanks,headwatersoftheIngeegoodbeeRivernearTinMinesHut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,3March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 12: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

10

Horsetramplingincisionofstreambanksandbankcollapse,headwatersoftheIngeegoodbeeRivernearTinMines(Carters)Hut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,23March2013(Source:GraemeL.Worboys).

Horsetramplingandincisionofstreambankscausingbankcollapse,headwatersoftheIngeegoodbeeRivernearTinMines(Carters)Hut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,3March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 13: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

11

FormersubalpineriparianbogtrampledandtransformedintoalargemudpanbyhorsesintheupperheadwatersoftheIngeegoodbeeRiver,23March2013(Source:IanPulsford).Wewereunabletorevisitthissiteduetoheavyrain.

TramplingimpactstoasubalpinebognearTinMinesHut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,23March2013(Source:GraemeL.Worboys).

Page 14: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

12

TramplingimpactstoaformerwetheathandsubalpinebogbetweenCascadesHutandTinMinesHut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,22March2013(Source:GraemeL.Worboys).

TramplingimpactstothesamesiteofsubalpineboganwetheathandbetweenCascadesHutandTinMines(Carters)Hut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,3March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 15: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

13

TramplingimpactstoawetlandbogatTinMinesHut,KosciuszkoNationalPark,23March2013withremnantsoilpedestal(Source:IanPulsford).

TramplingandpuggingimpactsbyhorsestoawetlandbognearTinMines(Carters)Hutsurroundedbycompactedcloselycroppedgrasses,KosciuszkoNationalPark,4March2020withremnantgrassycoveredsoilpedestal,centre.(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 16: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

14

Horsedustbath,CowombatFlat,Victoria,100metressouthandeastoftheNSWborder.Notehardcompactedgroundandveryshort-croppedgrassesduetograzingbyhorses,23March2013.(Source:GraemeL.Worboys).

ThepuggedandbrokenedgesofthebanksoftheupperMurrayRiverheadwaterstreamformamuddyerodingpooltrampledbyhorsesnearitsheadwaters.Thisisthesamepoolseenintheabovephoto.CowombatFlat,Victoria30metressouthandeastoftheNSWborder,3March2020.(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 17: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

15

Horsestrampling,trackingandgrazingthroughshrubbywetheathandsphagnumbogneartheCascadeFireTrail1.5kmsouthwestoftheupperThredboRiver.Notethehorsetracksthroughoutthedissectedvegetation,3March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

SmallSphagnumandCarexbogdestroyedbyhorsestrampingandgrazingexposingandpuggingpeatandsoil,CascadeCreekflatsnearCascadeFiretrail,3March2020(Source:IanPulsford)

Page 18: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

16

SmallSphagnumandCarexbogdestroyedbyhorsestrampingandgrazingexposingandpuggingpeatandsoil,CascadeCreekflatsnearCascadeFiretrail,3March2020.(Source:IanPulsford).

SubalpinebogSpreadingRopeRushEmpodismaminusandSphagnumMossSphagnumcristatumhummock(foregroundright)andsurroundinghabitatdestroyedbyhorsestrampingandgrazinginadrainagelinenearTinMines(CartersHut),3March2020.(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 19: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

17

LargeareaofcompactedhardpansoilsurfacewhichwasonceasphagnummossbogthathasbeendestroyedbytrampingandgrazingsouthwestofTinMines(Carters)HutonthecrestoftheGreatDivide.WetlandsheredrainintoeithertheMurrayRiverorSnowyRiver.Therearemanylargebarepatcheslikethisalongheadwatersandcreekflatsinthisarea,4March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Horsedungpileson“mowed”snowgrassesandboggyvegetation(background)destroyedbyhorsegrazingandtramplingsouthwestofTinMines(Carters)Hut,4March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 20: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

18

Hardcompactedvegetation(left)comparedtoBogSnow-grassPoacostinianathatwasprotectedfromgrazingbyhorsesbyanexclosurefenceconstructedbytheNPWSinNov2011(R.Gibbspers.comm.)southwestofTinMines(Carters)Hut.Notethestripwithintheexclosuregrazedbyhorsesreachingintotheplot,4March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

A1.8mtallhummockofSpreadingRope-rushEmpodismaminus,MountainCord-rushBaloskionaustraleandSphagnumMoss(Sphagnumcristatum)protectedfromgrazinginsideanothersectionofthesameexclosuresouthwestofTinMines(Carters)Hut.TheexclosurefencewasconstructedinNov2011providesimportantevidenceofthealmostcompletelossofsubalpinesphagnumbogvegetationoutsidetheplotandwhichhasoccurredalongsubalpinecreeklinesintheareaduetograzingandtramplingmostlybyhorsesandthemorerecentlyreportedincreaseindeerpopulations,4March2020(Source:IanPulsford).

Page 21: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

19

CONCLUSIONSWildhorsesanddeerspeciespopulationsonsurveyedareasofpubliclandsintheAustralianAlpshavegrownrapidlysince2013(Cairns2019)duetoacombinationoffactorsincluding:(1)naturalpopulationincrease(2)lackofnaturalpredatorsordiseases,(3)cessationofhorsecontroloperationsin2015andonlylimitedcontrolofrapidlyincreasingdeerpopulationsinmanysurveyedareassince2015.Thisisinspiteofthreeyearsofrecorddrought.HoweverdroughtwasclearlywaslesssevereintheMtPilotareathanelsewhereineasternAustraliaduetoitsrelativelyhighelevation,ruggedness,coolerandmoisterconditions.Uncontrolledandincreasingnumbersofwildhorsesanddeerhavereachedrecordlevels.Asaconsequencetheconditionsoftreelessdrainagelineareasthatweobservedin2013havecontinuedtodecline.Weobservedthatthegrowthinhorsepopulationandthemorerecentlyobservedrapidincreaseindeerpopulationsanddroughthaveallcontributedtothefurthercontinuingdeclineincatchmentcondition.Wesawnowetlandhabitatsintreelessdrainagelinesthatexhibitedsignsofrecoverysinceourlastobservationin2013.Anyrecoveryofcatchmentconditionisnotpossibleuntileffectivelong-termmeasuresareimplementedtoremoveorverysignificantlyreducethenumbersofpestspeciesespeciallyhorsesanddeer.Thedamagingimpactsofstockgrazing,whichwasendedbythethreevisionarypolicydecisionsbygovernmentandgreatleaderswhichbannedgrazingin1944,1957and1969(Costin2018)hasbeenreplacedbytheuncontrolledgrowthofwildhorse(Driscolletal.2019)andrecentrapidexpansionofdeerpopulations.BasedontheresearchbyWimbushandCostin(1979)ontherecoveryofsubalpinevegetationfromimpactsofgrazing,evenifhorseanddeernumbersareverysignificantlyreduced,itwilltakealongtimeforthesecommunitiestorecoverandmanyoftheseplantcommunitiesmayremaininasub-climaxstateafterinitialrecovery.Rehabilitationworkisurgentlyneeded.Thiscannotcommenceuntilintroducedherbivorepopulationsareremovedorsignificantlyreduced.InthemeantimetheconditionoftheheadwatercatchmentsofAustralia’smosteconomicallyimportantriversthatprovidewatervitalforirrigationandelectricitywillcontinuetodegrade.________________EndNoteTheauthorshavethehighestregardforhorsesandappreciateandsupporttheirplaceinmostareasofAustraliasuchasfarms,townsandsportingtracks.Weunderstand,appreciateandsharethedelightandcompanionshiphorsesbringtomanypeople.Thisreportisnotanattackonhorsesperse.Rather,itisaboutraisingawarenessoftoomanyhorsesandtheunacceptableandexcessiveimpactsinoneofAustralia’smostimportantconservationareas,theAustralianAlpsnationalparks.Acknowledgements.WewishtoexpressourappreciationtothefollowingNPWSstaff:MickPettitandPamO’Brienforapprovaltoconductthefield-work;RobGibbsforadviceabouthorsepopulationsurveysandconstructionoftheplots;andGenevieveWrightforplantidentification.

Page 22: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

20

References

Cairns,S.(2019).FeralHorsesintheAustralianAlps:theAnalysisofAerialSurveysConductedinApril-May,2014andApril-May2019.AreporttotheAustralianAlpsLiaisonCommittee.Availableat:https://theaustralianalps.files.wordpress.com/2019/12/feral-horses-in-the-australian-alps-the-analysis-of-aerial-surveys-conducted-in-2014-and-2019-cairns-s-2019.pdf

Costin,A.B.(2018).‘Forword’,inWorboys,G.L.,Driscoll,D.andP.Crabb(eds),FeralHorseImpacts:TheKosciuszkoScienceConference-ConferenceAbstracts,AustralianAcademyofScience,TheAustralianNationalUniversityandDeakinUniversity,Canberra:11.Availableat:https://www.science.org.au/news-and-events/events/feral-horse-impacts-kosciuszko-science-conference

Dawson,M.(2005).ThePopulationEcologyofFeralHorsesintheAustralianAlps,ManagementSummary,AustralianAlpsLiaisonCommittee,Canberra.(Availableat:http://www.australianalps.environment.gov.au)

Dawson,M.(2009).2009AerialSurveyofFeralHorsesintheAustralianAlps,AustralianAlpsLiaisonCommittee,Canberra(Availableat:http://www.australianalps.environment.gov.au)

DPIE(DepartmentofPlanningIndustryandEnvironment)(2019).KosciuszkoNationalParkWildHorseControl,Availableat:https://www.environment.nsw.gov.au/topics/animals-and-plants/pest-animals-and-weeds/pest-animals/wild-horses/kosciuszko-national-park-wild-horse-management/wild-horse-control

Driscoll,D.A.,Worboys,G.L.,Allan,H.,Banks,S.C.,Beeton,N.J.,Cherubin,R.C.,Doherty,T.S.,Finlayson,C.M.,Green,K.,Hartley,R.,Hope,G.,Johnson,C.N.,Lintermans,M.,Mackey,B.,Paull,D.J.,Pittock,J.,Porfirio,L.L.,Ritchie,E.G.,Sato,C.F.,...Williams,R.M.(2019).‘ImpactsofferalhorsesintheAustralianAlpsandevidence-basedsolutions’.EcologicalManagementandRestoration,20(1):63-72.https://doi.org/10.1111/emr.12357

Dyring,J.(1990).TheImpactofFeralHorses(Equuscaballus)onSubalpineandMontaneEnvironmentsinAustralia,MasterofAppliedScienceDegreeThesis,UniversityofCanberra.(Availableat:http://www.australianalps.environment.gov.au)

NPWS(2019).ReportonWildHorseAerialSurveyKosciuszkoNationalPark-BigBoggy,22ndMay2019:NSWNationalParksandWildlifeService,Jindabyne:12.

OEH(OfficeofEnvironmentandHeritage)(2016).DraftWildHorseManagementPlan,KosciuszkoNationalPark.Sydney:47.

Prober,S.M.andK.R.Thiele(2007).AnexperimentalmonitoringprogramintheCobberas-TingaringyUnitoftheAlpineNationalPark:Progress1999to2005.AreporttoParksVictoria.

Robertson,G.,J.Wright,D.Brown,K.YuenandD.Tongway(2015).AnAssessmentofFeralHorseImpactsonTreelessDrainageLinesintheAustralianAlps,ReportpreparedfortheAustralianAlpsLiaisonCommittee:30.Availableat:https://theaustralianalps.files.wordpress.com/2016/05/2015-feral-horse-impacts-report.pdf

Walter,M.(2002).ThepopulationecologyofwildhorsesintheAustralianAlps.PhDthesis,UniversityofCanberra.

Ward-Jones,J.,I.Pulsford,R.Thackway,D.BishwokarmaandD.Freudenberger(2019).‘ImpactsofferalhorsesanddeeronanendangeredwoodlandofKosciuszkoNationalPark’.EcologicalManagementandRestoration.20(1).DOI10.1111/emr.12353

Wild,A.andM.Poll(2012).ImpactsofferalhorsesonvegetationandstreammorphologyintheAustralianAlps:Feralhorseexclusionplotmonitoringandanalysis.ReporttotheFriendsoftheCobberas,ParksVictoriaandtheAustralianAlpsLiaisonCommittee.

Page 23: Ian Pulsford, Graeme L. Worboys and Dave Darlington · 2020-05-04 · Dave Darlington, BA Dip Ed Environmental Science, former Senior Protected Area Manager. 28 April 2020 INTRODUCTION

Revisiting Observations of Pest Horse Impacts in the Australian Alps, March 2020

21

Wimbush,D.J.andA.B.Costin(1979).‘TrendsinVegetationatKosciusko.II.SubalpineRangeTransects,1959-1978’,AustralianJournalofBotany.27(6):789-831.

Worboys,G.L.andI.Pulsford(2013).ObservationsofpesthorseimpactsintheAustralianAlps,March2013.Canberra:21.Availableat:https://theaustralianalps.files.wordpress.com/2018/06/horse_impacts_to_alps_catchments_worboys_pulsford2013.pdf

SubalpinebogonCascadeCreekgrazedandtrampledmostlyhorses,650mnorthofCascadeHut,3March2020.(SourceIanPulsford).