iana stewardship transition · 5/28/2015  · define rfp groups draft proposal rfp5 rfp6 21 days...

15
IANA Stewardship Transition A Live Example of a Multistakeholder Process 28 May 2015 WSIS Forum

Upload: others

Post on 06-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

IANA Stewardship TransitionA Live Example of a Multistakeholder Process

28 May 2015

WSIS Forum

Page 2: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

IANA Stewardship Transition: The Big PIcture

NTIAAnnouncement& Criteria

ICANN

CWG-Stewardship

ICGICG Proposal

CWG Proposal

CRISP Proposal

IANAPLAN Proposal

CCWGEnhancing ICANN

Accoutability

CCWG Proposal

CRISP

IANAPLAN

Linkage

1

Note: the information on this page is for illustrative purposes only. It is not intended to be exhaustive.

ICANNBOARD NTIA

Page 3: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

IANA Stewardship Transition Coordination Group: Composition2

Page 4: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

3

CWG-Stewardship: Timeline • Progress to Datev

2014 2015SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR

ICANN 51 ICANN 52Frankfurt IntensiveWorking Days

JUL AUG

Charter Development & SO/AC Approval

RFP1RFP2

RFP3 & RFP3BRFP4

InitialMeetings /

Define RFP Groups

Draft Proposal

RFP5RFP6

21 days

Design Teams

Secure Legal Team Legal Input

Draft Proposal

Istanbul

94 4,688 3,922Total Calls/Meetings

Total Mailing List Exchanges

Working Hours19Members

132Participants

Note: the information on this page is for illustrative purposes only. It is not intended to be exhaustive.

Public Comment 1

April 23, 2015 • v3.0Domain Names Community

Page 5: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

CWG-Stewardship: Proposal Development Overview4

2014 2015OCT NOV DEC JAN FEB MAR APR MAY JUN

ICANN 51 ICANN 52Frankfurt IntensiveWorking Days

21 days 28 days

60 CommunitySubmissions

Design Teams

Istanbul IntensiveWorking Days

Public Comment 1 Public Comment 2

7 Models 2

Models 1 Model

Legal Input

Additional Focus on Structure

vApril 23, 2015 • v3.0Domain Names Community

Page 6: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

IANAStewardship

TransitionProposal

NTIA

CWG-Stewardship: Timeline • The Road Ahead

2015APR MAY JUN

TBD ICANN 53Intensive Working Days

ICG

28 days 17 days

Submitto COs

Submitto ICG Public Comment 2

22 AprilStart ofPublicCommentfor 28 days

24 AprilWebinar Briefing Days

13-14 AprilIntensive working daysPreparing final proposal

Design Teams

Legal Input

Draft Proposal

Review Public Comments / Continue Proposal Development

8 JuneDeliver Names Proposal to SOs/ACs

25 JuneDeliver Names Proposal to ICG

20 MayClose of

Public Comment

28-29 MayHigh-intensityweekend

ICANNBOARD

Note: the information on this page is for illustrative purposes only. It is not intended to be exhaustive.

5

vApril 23, 2015 • v3.0Domain Names Community

Page 7: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

Enhancing ICANN Accountability: The Big Picture6

Enhancing ICANN Accountability

CCWGProposal

CCWGProposal

NTIAAnnouncement & Criteria

CCWG-Accountability

Page 8: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

CCWG-Accountability: Timeline • Progress to Date7

Page 9: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

CCWG-Accountability: Timeline • The Road Ahead8

Page 10: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

CRISP Team: Proposal Development Overview8

vApril 23, 2015 • v3.0Numbering Resources Community

June 2014:IANA Stewardship Transition Coordination Group (ICG) issues Request for Proposalsto three IANA “affected communities.”

Q4 2014:Consolidated RIR IANA Stewardship Proposal Team (CRISP Team) established to prepare an Internet numbers community proposal.

Global discussion platform established: [email protected]

January 2015:Internet numbers community IANA stewardship proposal submitted to ICG.

Page 11: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

10CRISP Team: Proposal Development OverviewNumbering Resources Community

Page 12: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

IANAPLAN WG: Proposal Development OverviewProtocol Parameters Community

11

What are Protocol Parameters?A database of values or mnemonics associated with specific behaviors for IETF protocols

Example:TCP port number 80 means payload will be HTTP (the web)

Developers use these parameters for their implementations

Page 13: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

IANAPLAN WG: Proposal Development OverviewProtocol Parameters Community

12

How things work today:IETF specifications create registries of values and the policies to update those values.(Anyone with an email address may participate in the IETF).

Any individual may apply for an assignment for a specific protocol parameter.

Applications are considered by IETF-designated experts or by the IETF, strictly based on the policy associated with the registry.

All decisions are subject to dispute resolution.

Page 14: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

Numbers

IETF - Proposal Development Overview

1

CWG-Stewardship: Design Teams Status • Pre-Istanbul Meeting IANAPLAN WG: Proposal Development OverviewProtocol Parameters Community April 23, 2015 • v3.0

13

ICG

NTIAIESGIETF

community

IANAPLANWG

NUMBERS

NAMES

Aug 2014 Nov 2014 Dec 2014 Jan 2015

SLA

MoU

RFC

New SLA

1999-2013 evolution

Contracts, service-level agreements, process and role

RFCs, …

Page 15: IANA Stewardship Transition · 5/28/2015  · Define RFP Groups Draft Proposal RFP5 RFP6 21 days Design Teams Secure Legal Team Legal Input Draft Propsoal Istanbul 94 4,688 3,922

NumbersStakeholder Insights and Discussion