immunology and molecular biology of ~ch~~~c~ccus …hidatidosis.com.ar › imgs › immunology and...

8
IMMUNOLOGY AND MOLECULAR BIOLOGY OF ~CH~~~C~CCUS INFECTIONS M. W. LIGHTOWLERS University of Melbourne, Veterinary Clinical Centre, Princes Highway, Werribee, Victoria 3030, Australia A~RCt-LIGHTOWLERS M. W. 1990. Immunolo~ and moiecuiar biology of Echinococcus infections. ~nter~t~o~~Joumdfor Parasitology 20: 471478. Echinococcus spp. are the etiofogical agents of hydatid disease in man and other intermediate hosts. Many questions regarding the factors which determine susceptibility/resistance to hydatid disease, and the factors which influence the viability and fertility of hydatid cysts, remain to be answered. Recent research into the effects of hydatid infection on the immune system of the host has provided some insights into the host-parasite relationships. Immunochemical and recombinant DNA techniques are being applied to improve diagnosis of hydatidosis in man and E. grantclosus infection in dogs, and also in the development of vaccines against infection with taeniid cestode larvae. The successes which have been achieved in these areas are likely to provide valuable tools for the control of cystic hydatidosis in man. These recent studies in the areas of immunobiology, serological diagnosis and vaccination are reviewed. INDEX KEY WORDS: Echinococcus; hydatid; immunology; molecular biology; diagnosis; vaccination. HYDATID disease in the intermediate hosts of Echinococcus spp. is typically a chronic parasitic infection with viable cysts persisting, in many instances, for the life of the host. The factors which influence initial susceptibility to infection and the characteristics of the disease in infected individuals are unclear. Do all individuals of a susceptible host species which ingest viable Echinococcus eggs develop hydatid cysts? What determines the growth rate of the parasite and whether the cysts are fertile or sterile? The answers to these questions remain largely unknown, but recent studies on the effects of hydatid disease on the immune system of the host provide some insight into the host- parasite relationship. Current research on the application of recombinant DNA methods to the production of antigens for diagnosis of infection and for vaccination against infection may soon provide valuable practical tools for the control of cystic hydatid disease. BONE RESPONSES TO INFECTION AND IMMUNOPATHOLOGY IN THE INTERMEDIATE HOST Few studies have been undertaken to determine the factors which regulate innate susceptibility to egg induced infection with E. granulosus or E. muit~~o~laris. Work with other taeniid species has indicated that host age, sex, strain and physiological state all have marked influences in determining innate susceptibility/resistance to infection (reviewed by Rickard & Williams, 1982). These factors are also likely to affect egg-induced infection with Echino- coccus. Secondary hydatidosis can be established and passaged through laboratory animals by inoculation of E. grandosus protoscoleces or part of the E. multilocularis cyst mass intraperitoneally or sub- cutaneously. These infections have provided laboratory models for the study of hydatidosis and have established that host age, sex and strain influence susceptibility/ resistance to hydatid infection (reviewed by Heath, 1986). The intermediate hosts of E. granulosus and E. multilocularis develop specific humoral and cellular responses to the parasites (reviewed by Heath, 1986) and they confer a significant level of resistance to reinfection (Sweatman, Williams, Moriarty & Henshall, 1963; Yarulin, 1968; De Rycke & Pennoit-De Cooman, 1973; Rau & Tanner, 1973; Aminzhanov, 1976). The contribution of these immune responses to the de- struction of the parasite after initial establishment is less clear. A proportion of hydatid cysts in man (Rausch, Wilson, Schantz & McMahon, 1987) and animals (Gemmell, Lawson & Roberts, 1986) die at some point after initial establis~ent of the parasite such that calcified lesions can be observed macro- scopically. It is not known whether the host’s immune response is responsible for the death of these parasites. Both dead and viable, fertile cysts can occur in the same host, and in sheep the death of cysts occurs predominantly in the first 2 years of infection (Gemmeli ef at., 1986). In host species and strains refractory to infection with E. mu~tilocularis, there is evidence that the host’s inflammatory response is associated with restricting the growth and metastasis of the cyst mass (Ali-Khan & Siboo, 1980). Thymectomy and treatment with anti-thymocyte serum also influence the growth and dissemination of 471

Upload: others

Post on 05-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

IMMUNOLOGY AND MOLECULAR BIOLOGY OF ~CH~~~C~CCUS INFECTIONS

M. W. LIGHTOWLERS

University of Melbourne, Veterinary Clinical Centre, Princes Highway, Werribee, Victoria 3030, Australia

A~RCt-LIGHTOWLERS M. W. 1990. Immunolo~ and moiecuiar biology of Echinococcus infections. ~nter~t~o~~ Joumdfor Parasitology 20: 471478. Echinococcus spp. are the etiofogical agents of hydatid disease in man and other intermediate hosts. Many questions regarding the factors which determine susceptibility/resistance to hydatid disease, and the factors which influence the viability and fertility of hydatid cysts, remain to be answered. Recent research into the effects of hydatid infection on the immune system of the host has provided some insights into the host-parasite relationships. Immunochemical and recombinant DNA techniques are being applied to improve diagnosis of hydatidosis in man and E. grantclosus infection in dogs, and also in the development of vaccines against infection with taeniid cestode larvae. The successes which have been achieved in these areas are likely to provide valuable tools for the control of cystic hydatidosis in man. These recent studies in the areas of immunobiology, serological diagnosis and vaccination are reviewed.

INDEX KEY WORDS: Echinococcus; hydatid; immunology; molecular biology; diagnosis; vaccination.

HYDATID disease in the intermediate hosts of Echinococcus spp. is typically a chronic parasitic infection with viable cysts persisting, in many instances, for the life of the host. The factors which influence initial susceptibility to infection and the characteristics of the disease in infected individuals are unclear. Do all individuals of a susceptible host species which ingest viable Echinococcus eggs develop hydatid cysts? What determines the growth rate of the parasite and whether the cysts are fertile or sterile? The answers to these questions remain largely unknown, but recent studies on the effects of hydatid disease on the immune system of the host provide some insight into the host- parasite relationship. Current research on the application of recombinant DNA methods to the production of antigens for diagnosis of infection and for vaccination against infection may soon provide valuable practical tools for the control of cystic hydatid disease.

BONE RESPONSES TO INFECTION AND IMMUNOPATHOLOGY IN THE INTERMEDIATE

HOST Few studies have been undertaken to determine the

factors which regulate innate susceptibility to egg induced infection with E. granulosus or E. muit~~o~laris. Work with other taeniid species has indicated that host age, sex, strain and physiological state all have marked influences in determining innate susceptibility/resistance to infection (reviewed by Rickard & Williams, 1982). These factors are also likely to affect egg-induced infection with Echino- coccus. Secondary hydatidosis can be established and

passaged through laboratory animals by inoculation of E. grandosus protoscoleces or part of the E. multilocularis cyst mass intraperitoneally or sub- cutaneously. These infections have provided laboratory models for the study of hydatidosis and have established that host age, sex and strain influence susceptibility/ resistance to hydatid infection (reviewed by Heath, 1986).

The intermediate hosts of E. granulosus and E. multilocularis develop specific humoral and cellular responses to the parasites (reviewed by Heath, 1986) and they confer a significant level of resistance to reinfection (Sweatman, Williams, Moriarty & Henshall, 1963; Yarulin, 1968; De Rycke & Pennoit-De Cooman, 1973; Rau & Tanner, 1973; Aminzhanov, 1976). The contribution of these immune responses to the de- struction of the parasite after initial establishment is less clear. A proportion of hydatid cysts in man (Rausch, Wilson, Schantz & McMahon, 1987) and animals (Gemmell, Lawson & Roberts, 1986) die at some point after initial establis~ent of the parasite such that calcified lesions can be observed macro- scopically. It is not known whether the host’s immune response is responsible for the death of these parasites. Both dead and viable, fertile cysts can occur in the same host, and in sheep the death of cysts occurs predominantly in the first 2 years of infection (Gemmeli ef at., 1986). In host species and strains refractory to infection with E. mu~tilocularis, there is evidence that the host’s inflammatory response is associated with restricting the growth and metastasis of the cyst mass (Ali-Khan & Siboo, 1980). Thymectomy and treatment with anti-thymocyte serum also influence the growth and dissemination of

471

472 M. W. LIGHTOWLERS

E. multilocularis in mice (Baron & Tanner, 1976). Despite the development of specific immune responses which can be readily demonstrated in in vitro assays, viable hydatid cysts frequently persist for long periods (Gemmell et al., 1986; Rausch et al., 1987). In addition, protoscoleces of E. granulosus, released through accidental rupture of a cyst or during surgery, are capable of generating secondary cysts. This indic- ates that in some circumstances the immune responses to the primary infection do not protect against subsequent infection.

The mechanisms by which established hydatid cysts survive in hosts resistant to re-infection and which have antibody, and cells capable of killing the parasite in vitro (Baron & Tanner, 1977) remain unknown. Evidence exists for the contribution of a variety of mechanisms to the successful evasion of the protective effects of the host’s immune response against the larval stages of Taenia species. These include masking of surface antigens by host-derived or host-like antigens, immunosuppression, antigen sequestration and direct interference with the effector mechanisms of the host’s defence system (reviewed by Rickard & Williams, 1982). In hydatidosis, recent studies have focused attention on the influence of the parasite on the specific and non-specific immune responses of the host. In experimental animals, E. granulosus and E. multi- Iocularis infection induce pathological alterations in the architecture of lymphoid organs (Ah-Khan, 1978a; Riley, Dixon, Kelly & Cox, 1985). These gross alterations are associated with alterations in some immunological responses. During the proliferative growth phase of the E. multilocularis larval cyst mass in permissive mice, cell-mediated immune responses against parasite antigens are suppressed (Ali-Khan, 1978b) and leucocyte chemotaxis is inhibited (Alkarmi & Behbehani, 1989). These alterations reflect complex changes in the host responses rather than generalized immunosuppression, since cell-mediated immune re- sponses to non-specific antigens are not suppressed (Ali-Khan, 1978b). Alveolar hydatidosis in man is associated with impaired T cell function in in vitro

assays, a reduction in the number and percentage of circulating B lymphocytes and a reduction in the number of peripheral blood lymphocytes (Vuitton, Lassegue, Miguet, Her&, Barale, Seillts & Capron, 1984). Reduced reactivity to lymphocyte mitogens in vitro (Riley, Dixon, Jenkins & Ross, 1986) and suppression of antibody responses to sheep red blood cell (SRBC) antigens (Allan, Jenkins, Connor & Dixon, 1981) also occur in mice infected with E. granulosus. The suppression of anti-SRBC reactivity was shown by Allan et al. (1981) to be associated with a population of suppressor T cells which were highly suppressive to anti-SRBC responses of syngeneic recipient normal mice in adoptive transfer experi- ments.

Another immunopathological correlate of hydatid infection is the detection of auto-antibodies to a wide spectrum of antigens in patients infected with E. granulosus or E. multilocularis (Pini, Pastore & Valesini, 1983; Ben Izhak & Tatarsky, 1985; Ameglio, Saba, Bitti, Aceti, Tanigaki, Sorrentino, Dolei & Tosi, 1987; Mori, Wernh, Weiss & Franklin, 1986) (see Table 1). Particularly interesting is the discovery of auto-antibodies to major histocompatibility complex antigens (Ameglio et al.. 1987) because of the pivotal role these molecules play in antigen presentation to T cells in the initiation of immune responses. It may be relevant that a role has been postulated for alloreactive autoimmune T cells in the survival of E. granulosus cysts in mice (Allan et al., 1981). E. granulosus protoscoleces have been found to express a protein with a high degree of amino acid sequence homology with a human protein termed cyclophilin (Lightowlers, Haralambous & Rickard, 1989). In man. the binding of an undecapeptide of fungal origin (cyclosporin A) to cyclophilin has profound suppres- sive effects on T cell function due in part to the suppression of the early events in T cell activation (Hess, Esa & Colombani, 1988). Cyclophilin has been found to be a peptidyl prolyl cis-trans isomerase (Takahashi, Hayano & Suzuki, 1989). The degree of sequence conservation in this protein between a

TABLE I-ANTIGENS TO WHICH AUTOANTIBODIES HAVE BEEN DETECTED IN THE SERA OF PATIENTS

INFECTED WITH Echinococcus granulosus OR E. multilocularis

Parasite infection Antigen Reference

E. granulosus Smooth muscle Erythrocyte MHC* Class I MHC* Class II

E. granulosusl E. multilocularis

Double-stranded DNA Histone Actin Desmin Vinmentin Keratin

Pini et al. ( 1983) Ben Izhak & Tatarsky (1985) Ameglio et al. (1987) Amegilo et al. (1987)

Mori et al. (1986) Mori et al. (1986) Mori et al. ( 1986) Mori et al. (1986) Mori et al. (1986) Mori et al. (1986)

* MHC, Major Histocompatibility Complex; antibodies found to several different Class I and Class II antigens.

Echinococcus immunology and molecular biology 473

cestode parasite and man suggests that the molecule plays an important biological role. The association between the mammalian molecule and immunosup- pression, and the existence of a very similar molecule produced by a chronic, tissue-dwelling parasite, may be merely coincidental. If, however, the parasite were also to produce a ligand for the cyclophilin-like molecule, which had some of the suppressive activities of cyclosporin A, this ligand could have a role to play in the long-term survival of hydatid cysts in infected hosts. It is interesting to note that cyclosporin A has been found to interfere with the deletion of autoreactive T cells in the thymus leading to the appearance of autoimmune disease @hi, Sahai & Green, 1989).

Man SERODIAGNOSIS

Hydatidosis in man leads to the production of readily detectable levels of specific antibody in the majority of infected individuals which allows success- ful serodiagnosis of infection (reviewed by Rickard & Lightowlers, 1986; Schantz & Gottstein, 1986). Not all infected patients are positive in assays for specific serum antibody, and cross-reactivity occurs between Echinococcus antigen preparations and antibodies in the sera from patients with other helminth infections. Cross-reactivity is particularly a problem in differe- ntiating between infections with E. granulosus, E. multilocularis and T. solium. Difficulties with wide- scale application of serodiagnosis occur due to limita- tions in supply of parasite antigens for tests and in quality control of antigen preparations derived from different batches of hydatid cysts. These areas- sensitivity, specificity and antigen supply-are the major topics currently being investigated in research towards improving diagnostic tests for human hydatidosis. Assays based on detection of circulating parasite antigen in the sera of patients infected with E. granulosus are useful for diagnosis of a proportion of cases negative in other serological tests (Craig & Nelson, 1984; Gottstein, 1984; Craig, 1986).

Immunochemical analysis of the diagnostic anti- gens and the development of monoclonal antibodies against the two major lipoprotein antigens of hydatid cyst fluid (Antigen 5 and Antigen B) have provided valuable information on the sensitivity of detection and specificity of individual antigens (Di Felice, Pini, Afferni dc Vicari, 1986; Shepherd & McManus, 1987; Lightowlers, Liu, Haralambous & Rickard, 1989). The antigenic subunits of the major diagnostic anti- gen, Antigen 5, which forms Arc 5 in immunoelectro- phoresis (IEP) (Capron, Yarzabal, Vernes & Fruit, 1970; Yarziibal, Schantz & Lopez-Lemes, 1975) are immunoprecipitated strongly by most sera from patients with either E. granulosus or E. multilocularis infection (Lightowlers, Liu, Haralambous & Rickard, 1989). They are also non-specifically precipitated by sera from patients with no known parasitic disease (Shepherd Jr McManus, 1987; Lightowlers, Liu, Haralambous & Rickard, 1989). This contrasts with

the specificity of the antigen in IEP, where Arc 5 has not been found except in patients infected with taeniid cestodes (see Rickard & Lightowlers, 1986). Shepherd & McManus (1987) found that Antigen 5 contained phosphorylcholine epitopes and that addition of 10 MmOl-’ phosphorylcholine to the serum diluent reduced non-specific reactivity with cyst fluid antigens in ELISA. The lower molecular weight subunits of Antigen B were found by Shepherd & McManus (1987) to be specific for E. granulosus. A pool of sera from four patients with E. multilocularis infection and another pool from two patients with T. solium cysti- cercosis did not show reactivity with these subunits in immunoprecipitation analysis. More detailed invest- igations using larger numbers of sera individually have, however, shown unequivocally that these antigens are not species specific for E. granulosus (Lightowlers, Liu, Haralambous & Rickard, 1989).

Production of antigens for immunodiagnosis using recombinant DNA techniques has the potential to improve the specificity and sensitivity of diagnosis as well as alleviating problems with quality control and supply of antigens derived directly from hydatid cysts. A cDNA library has been prepared from E. granulosus protoscolex mRNA in 1gtll and clones expressing potentially useful diagnostic antigens have been identified using sera from Australian patients with cystic hydatidosis (Lightowlers, unpublished). Two clones in particular show high sensitivity for diagnosis in plaque immunoassay with sera from patients prior to any surgical or chemotherapeutic treatment for hydatid infection (initial diagnosis). One of these clones has been tested extensively in ELISA as a glutathione S-transferase (GST) (Smith & Johnson, 1988) fusion protein and gives a positive reaction with 50% of initial diagnosis sera. A difficulty with this test based on use of GST fusion protein is background reactivity of normal human sera with the fusion protein partner, GST (Lightowlers & Mitchell, 1989). Continuing experiments are investigating the use of this protein expressed using the pGEX2 plasmid vector (Smith &Johnson, 1988) and cleaved from GST at the thrombin cleavage site created by the polylinker sequence in this vector. Other cloned antigens are also being evaluated in the ELISA to improve the sensitiv- ity of the test. These antigens show no cross-reactivity with sera from patients with protozoan, nematode or trematode infections, but they do cross-react with sera from patients infected with E. multilocularis and T. solium. The clones are being investigated for the possible presence of multiple epitopes, some of which may show specificity of E. granulosus and could be subcloned with the cross-reacting epitopes excised.

Immunochemical analyses and antibody affinity chromatography techniques (Rickard, Honey, Brumley Jr Mitchell, 1984) have not been successful to date in identifying an antigen preparation or individual anti- gens specific for E. granulosus. In contrast, Gottstein and his colleagues have been successful in identifying an antigen specific for E. muitilocularis. Rabbit

474 M. W. LIGHTOWLERS

antibodies against E. gram&w were used to affinity deplete a crude E. multilocularis antigen preparation and the depleted antigen, termed Em2, shown to have high specificity for discriminating between sera from E. mu~t~Iocular~s and E. granulosus-infected patients (Gottstein, Eckert & Fey, 1983). The specific com- ponent EmZa was purified and found to be a molecule of molecular weight 54,000, pI 4.8 (Gottstein, 1983, 1985). In an international study (Gottstein, Schantz, Todorov, Saimot & Jacquier, 1986) sera from 50 E. granulosus- and 32 E. multilocularis-infected patients were tested and only three E. granulosus were incorrectly assigned as being E. multilocuIaris on the basis of the reactivity of the sera in Em2 ELISA. Sera from 12,000 blood donors from an E. multilocularis endemic region in Switzerland were screened in Em2 ELISA and five found positive, one of which was confirmed to have been from a patient infected with the parasite (Gottstein, Lengeler, Bachmann, Hagemann, Kocher, Brossard, Witassek & Eckert, 1987).

Using recombinant DNA techniques, a clone ex- pressing an antigen specific for E. multilocularis has been identified, although it does not appear to be related to the Em2 antigen(s) (Vogel, Gottstein, Mfiller & Seebeck, 1988). The clone produces an unstable fusion protein. However subclones from the initial cDNA clone identified in ilgtll have been successful in improving the yield of parasite antigen (Mtiller, Gottstein, Vogel, Flury & Seebeck, 1989; Miiller, Vogel, Gottstein, Scholle & Seebeck, 1989). ELISA with the stabilized protein has been found to have a diagnostic sensitivity of 90% and a specificity of 99%; cross-reaction was detected with only one of 108 E. granulosus sera and two of 15 T. sodium sera (Miiller, Gottstein, Vogel, Flury & Seebeck, 1989). Recombinant E. multilocularis antigens with potential for use in serodiagnosis have also been produced by another group (Hemmings & McManus, 1989).

Animal intermediate hosts Serological diagnosis of E. gramdosus infection

in domestic livestock has not been successful. The principal problems stem from the production of very low or undetectable levels of specific antibody in many animals with fertile cysts and in cross-reactivity between antibodies raised against other parasites, particularly taeniid cestodes, and hydatid antigens (reviewed by Rickard & Lightowlers, 1986). Some success has been achieved in distinguishing flocks of infected sheep (Lightowlers, Rickard, Honey, Obendorf & Mitchell, 1984; Ris, Hamel & Mackle, 1987), however, reliable diagnosis of individual infected animals has not been achieved. The low level of specific antibody production contrasts with the situation in man where E. granulosus typically leads to the production of readily detectable levels of specific antibody. Infected sheep, however, are capable of responding to parenteral immunization with cyst fluid

antigens, including fluid released from an animal’s own cysts (Lightowlers, Rickard &Honey, 1986). This suggests that antigen sequestration in sheep is more likely to be the cause of the low levels of specific antibody rather than antigen-specific or generalized immunosuppression. The finding that some sheep with low levels of detectable specific antibody have circulating hydatid antigens in serum (Judson, Dixon, Clarkson & Pritchard, 1985) appears to contradict the sequestration hypothesis. On the basis of the results of studies published to date, there is little prospect for the development of a diagnostic test for hydatidosis in domestic livestock based on detection of antibody in serum.

Diagnosis of E. granulosus in dogs Dogs infected with E. granulasus have been found to

produce specific circulating antibodies against the parasite (Chordi, Gonzalez-Castro & Tormo, 1962; Movsesijan & Mladenovic, 1971; Jenkins & Rickard, 1986; Gasser, Lightowlers, Obendorf, Jenkins & Rickard, 1988). In a carefully controlled experiment, Jenkins & Rickard (1986) followed the course of production of specific antibodies in experimentally infected dogs through to patency and showed that the protoscolex antigens used in the test did not cross- react with sera from dogs infected with Taenia species or nematode parasites. A diagnostic test for E. granulosus infection in dogs would be of value in studies on the epidemiology of infection and in hydatid control campaigns. The widespread avail- ability of the highly cestocidaf drug praziquantel has limited the use of arecoline purging for diagnosis of infection. The potential for a diagnostic test has been shown by Gasser and his colleagues (Gasser et al., 1988; Gasser, Lightowlers, Rickard, Lyford & Dawkins, in press) using ELISA with protoscolex antigens and sera from dogs with naturally acquired infection. A major limitation in practical application of the test is in the limited supply of suitable antigen. Here again, recombinant DNA techniques have been successful in isolating diagnostic cloned antigens. Initially, immunochemical analyses were used to identify specific diagnostic components of proto- scoleces (Gasser, Lightowlers & Rickard, 1989). Anti- bodies from naturally infected dog sera were affinity purified on Western blots and used to isolate cDNA clones expressing the antigens (Gasser, Lightowlers & Rickard, unpublished). Specificity of one cloned protein tested in ELISA was found to be 100%. but sensitivity was low. Continuing studies aim at improv- ing the sensitivity of the test by combined application of other cloned antigens. Other possible approaches to diagnosis of infection in dogs are the specific identification of E. granuiosus eggs in faeces with monoclonal antibodies (Craig, Macpherson & Nelson, 1986; Craig, Macpherson, Watson-Jones 8~ Nelson, 1988) and detection of copro-antigens (Deplazes, Gottstein, Stingelin & Eckert, 1989).

Echinococcus immunology and molecular biology 415

VACCINATION

Two features common to taeniid cestode infections in their inte~ediate hosts are the natural development of highly protective immune responses against re-infection and the spectacular success achieved in experimental vaccination against infection (reviewed by Rickard & Williams, 1982). High levels of protection have been achieved in vaccination trials against E. grunulosus infection in sheep. Gemmell (1966) used viable E. granulosus eggs or activated oncospheres injected intramuscularly into sheep and demonstrated protection against the establishment of hydatid cysts from a challenge infection (91.2 and 92.0%, respectively) and also protection against post- encystment survival of cysts (99.6 and lOO%, respect- ively). Heath, Parmeter, Osbom & Lawrence (1981) achieved even greater levels of protection following subcutaneous injection of activated E. granulosus oncospheres on two or more occasions. Of 25 vac- cinated sheep only two animals had any cysts and only a single viable cyst was found. High levels of protection against Taenia infection have been achieved using non-living antigen preparations (Rickard & Williams, 1982). Osborn & Heath (1982) have shown that non- living antigens can also be used against E. granulosus in sheep. Medium from in vitro culture of E. granulosus oncospheres was filtered through a 0.2 pm membrane. Following intramuscular injection into sheep it was shown to stimulate 99.4% protection against the es~blishment of hydatid cysts compared with con- trols. Only one of eight vaccinated sheep developed cysts.

The major obstacle in practical application of vaccination against E. granulosus infection in domestic livestock is supply of antigen, particularly since antigens from oncospheres have achieved higher levels of protection compared with antigens from other life cycle stages (Turner, Dennis & Berberian, 1937; Dada & Belino, 1981). The recent development of the first highly successful recombinant vaccine against a parasite (Johnson, Harrison, Lightowlers, O’Hoy, Cougle, Dempster, Lawrence, Vinton, Heath & Rickard, 1989) represents a major advancement in overcoming difficulties with supply of parasite antigens for vaccination. The vaccine, which is being developed commercially, protects sheep against infection with Tueniu ovis. Messenger RNA was isolated from activated T. ovis oncospheres and cDNA cloned into the bacteriophage expression vector ilgtll. The recombinant plaques were screened for reactivity with affinity-purified antibodies prepared against a pair of native oncosphere antigens. These native antigens had been found to be associated with protection in a series of vaccination trials in sheep using fractionated oncosphere antigens. The parasite-encoded protein was isolated from Escherisch~a coii as fusion proteins with the bacterial enzyme Pgalactosidase (pgal). In va~ination trials, these figal fusion proteins failed to protect sheep against chailenge infection with T. ovis. However, they did raise antibodies specific for the two

native oncosphere antigens, for which there was strong evidence to indicate they were likely to be host- protective. A second expression vector was used with the cloned insert DNAs. This vector was a fore-runner in the development of the pGEX series of vectors (Smith & Johnson, 1988) and expressed the T. ovis antigens as fusion proteins with GST. One of the advantages of this vector system was that the GST fusion allows single step purification of the soluble fusion protein from E. coli lysates by affinity chromatography on glutathione agarose under non- denaturing conditions. Antigen purified in this way from one of the clones, designated 45W, achieved 94% protection against T. ovis infection in sheep when given as a total of 50 pg fusion protein over three injections with saponin.

It is possible to achieve a substantial degree of protection against infection with Taenia species and E. granulosus using antigens derived from an heterologous taeniid species (reviewed by Lightowlers, Mitchell & Rickard, in press). Indeed antigens from T. ovis have been found to cross-protect against E. granufosus infection in sheep (Gemmell, 1966; Heath, Lawrence & Yong, 1979). It is possible that the T. ovis 45W antigen may be used directly to vaccinate against E. granulosus. Protection with antigens from an heterologous species has typically been less than that achieved with homologous antigens. Apparently, the native equivalent of the 45W clone protein is exposed on the surface of the T. ovis oncosphere, or performs some important function in its invasion/establishment in the host, since immune responses against this specific molecule are able to prevent infection. Onco- spheres of other taeniid species may contain a protein homologous to the T. ovis 45W clone protein which occupies a similar vulnerable position or performs a similar biological function and may also be susceptible to host immune attack. Nucleotide sequence homology between the T. ovis gene and the equivalent genes in other species would allow rapid identification of clones encoding these genes in recombinant cDNA libraries from oncospheres of these other taeniid species. In this way, the T. ovis vaccine may pave the way towards the rapid development of practical vaccines against infection with other species, including E. granuiosus. The recent development by Dempster and his colleagues (unpublished), of a mouse model system for egg-derived infection with E. granulosus, will provide a valuable model system in research towards development of a vaccine against cystic hydatidosis.

REFERENCES

ALI-KHAN Z. 1978a. Cellular changes in the Iymphoreticular tissues of C57L/J mice infected with Echococcus multi- Iocularis cysts. Ideology 341 831-839.

ALI-KHAN Z. 1978b. Cell mediated immune response in early and chronic alveolar murine hydatidosis. ~~per~rne~ta~ Parasiioiogy 46: 157-165.

ALI-KHAN Z. & SIBOO R. 1980. Pathogenesis and host

476 M. W. LIGHTOWLERS

response in subcutaneous alveolar hydatidosis. I. Histio- genesis of alveolar cyst and a quantitative analysis of the inflammatory infiltrates. Zeitschriftfiir Parasitenkunde 62: 241-254.

ALKARMI T. & BEHBEHANI K. 1989. Echinococcus multi- locularis: inhibition of murine neutrophil and macrophage chemotaxis. Experimental Parasitology 69: 1622.

ALLAN D.. JENKINS P., CONNOR R. J. & DIXON J. B. 1981. A study of immunoregulation of BALB/c mice by Echino- coccus granulosus equinus during prolonged infection. Parasite Immunology 3: 131-142.

granulosus in sheep.] Veterinariya, M&ON 7: 68-70. BARON R. W. & TANNER C. E. 1976. The effect of immuno-

AMEGLIO F., SABA F., BIITI A., Acm A., TANICAKI N., SORRENTINO R., DOLEI A. & TOSI R. 1987. Antibody reactivity to HLA classes I and II in sera from patients with hydatidosis. Journal of Infectious Diseases 154: 673-676.

AMINZHANOV M. 1976. [The biology of Echinococcus

Parasitenkunde 42: 49-59. DI FELICE G., PINI C.. AFFERNI C. & VICAR] G. 1986.

Purification and partial characterization of the major antigen of Echinococcus granulosus (antigen 5) with monoclonal antibodies. Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology 20: 133-142.

GASSER R. B., LIGHTOWLERS M. W., OBENDORF D. L., JENKINS D. J. & RICKARD M. D. 1988. Evaluation of a serological test system for the diagnosis of natural Echinococcus granulosus infection in dogs using E. granulosus proto- scolex and oncosphere antigens. Australian Veterinar) Journal 65: 369-373.

279-291. _I

GASSER R. B., LIGHTOWLERS M. W., RICKARD M. D., LYF~R~

GASSER R. B., LIGHTOWLERS M. W. & RICKARD M. D. 1989. Identification of protein components of Echinococcus granulosus protoscolex antigens for specific serodiagnosis of E. granulosus infection in dogs. Parasite Immunologv 11:

specificity of hexacanth embryos in protecting sheep

_..-

against Echinococcusgranulosus. Immunology 11: 325-335. GEMMELL M. A.. LAWSON J. R. & ROBERTS M. G. 1986.

R. A. & DAWKINS H. J. S. (in press) Serological screening of

Population dynamics in echinococcosis and cysticercosis:

farm dogs for Echinococcus granulosus infection in an

biological parameters of Echinococcus granulosus in dogs and sheep. Parasitology 92: 599-620.

endemic region. Australian Veterinary Journal. GEMMELL M. A. 1966. Immunological responses of the

mammalian host against tapeworm infections. IV. Species peritoneal macrophages. International Journal for Para- sitology 7: 489-495.

suppression on secondary Echinococcus multilocularis

BEN IZHAK 0. & TA~ARSKY I. 1985. Positive direct anti-

infections in mice. International Journalfor Parasitology 6:

globulin test associated with echinococcosis: a case report. Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 88: 389-390.

CAPRON A., YARZ.&BAL L., VERNES A. & FRUIT J. 1970. Le

3742.

diagnostique immunologique de l’echinococcose humaine.

BARON R. W. & TANNER C. E. 1977. Echinococcus multi-

Pathologie Biologie (Paris) 18: 357-365. CHORDI A., GONZALEZ-CASTRO J. & TORMO J. 1962.

locularis in the mouse: the in vitro protoscolicidal activity of

Aportacion al estudio de les helminthiasis intestinales ellos perros. II. Resultados de la prueba de floculatibn con ‘Benthid’ y de la de fijaci6n de complemento en perros con Echinococcus granulosus. Revista IbPrica de Parasitologib 22: 285-290.

GOTTS~EIN B. 1983. Isolation of an antigen fraction from Echinococcus multilocularis with high species-specificity in ELISA and its identification with the western blotting technique. In: Immunoenzymatic Techniques (Edited by AVRAMEAS S., DREUT P.. MASSEYEFF R. & FELDMAN G.), pp. 299-302. Elsevier, Amsterdam.

GOTTWEIN B., ECKERT J. & FEY H. 1983. Serological differentiation between Echinococcus granulosus and E. multilocularis infections in man. Zeitschrif fiir Parasitenkunde 69: 347-356.

CRAIG P. S. &NELSON G. S. 1984. The detection ofcirculating antigen in human hydatid disease. Annals of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 78: 219-227.

circulating antigens in human echinococcosis. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 33: 1185-l 191.

GOTTSTEIN B. 1985. Purification and characterization of a specific antigen from Echinococcus multilocularis. Parasite

GOTTS~EIN B. 1984. An immunoassay for the detection of CRAIG P. S. 1986.. Detection of specific circulating antigen,

CRAIG P. S.. M~CPHERSON C. N. L. &NELSON G. S. 1986. The identification of eggs of Echinococcus by immuno-

immune complexes and antibodies in human hydatidosis

fluorescence using a specific anti-oncospheral monoclonal antibody. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and

from Turkana (Kenya) and Great Britain, by enzyme-

Hygiene35: 152-158.

immunoassay. Parasite Immunology 8: 17 l-l 88. Immunology 7: 201-212.

GOTTSTEIN B., SCHANTZ P. M., TODOROV T., SAIMOT A. G. & JACQUIER P. 1986. An international study on the serological differential diagnosis of human cystic and alveolar echino- coccosis. Bulletin of the World Health Organization 64: 101-105. CRAIG P. S., MACPHERSON C. N. L.,WATSON-JONES D. C. &

NELSON G. S. 1988. Immunodetection of Echinococcus eggs from naturally infected dogs and from environmental contamination sites in settlements in Turkana, Kenya. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 82: 268-274.

DADA B. J. 0. & BELINO E. D. 1981. Immunization of sheep against cystic hydatidosis with homologous and hetero- logous metacestode antigens. International Journal for Zoonoses 8: 20-25.

DEPLAZES P., GOTTSTEIN B., STINGELIN Y. & ECKERT J. 1989. An ELISA for detection of Taenia antigen in fecal samples of dogs. Cited in ECKERT J. 1989. New aspects of parasitic zoonoses. Veterinary Parasitology 32: 37-55.

DERYCKE P. H. & -PENNOIT-D;~ CWMAN E. 1973. Ex- HEATH D. D. 1986. Immunobiology of Echinococcus perimental secondary echinococcosis of Echinococcus infection. In: The Biology of Echinococcus and Hvdatid granulosus. IV. Vaccination of host mice. Zeitschrif fiir Disease (Edited by THOMPSON R. C. A.), pp. 164188.

GOTTS~EIN B., LENGELER C., BACHMANN P., HAGEMANN P., K~CHER P., BROSSARD M., WITASSEK F. & ECKERT J. 1987. Sero-epidemiological survey for alveolar echinococcus (by Em2-ELISA) of blood donors in an endemic area of Switzerland. Transactions of the Ro_val Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 81: 96&964.

HEATH D. D., LAWRENCE S. B. & YONG W. K. 1979. Cross- protection between the cysts of Echinococcus granulosus. Taenia hvdatigena and T. ovis in lambs. Research in Veterinar), Science 27: 210-212.

HEATH D. D.. PARMETER S. N.. OSBORN P. J. & LAWRENCE S _- -. B. 198 1. Resistance to Echinococcus granulosus infection in lambs. Journal of Parasitology 67: 797-799.

Echinococ~ imm~ology and molecular biology 477

George Allen & Unwin, London. HEMMINGS L. & MCMANUS D. P. 1989. The isolation, by

differential antibody screening, of Echinocaccus multi- loculuris antigen gene clones with potential for immuno- diagnosis. Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology 33: 171-182.

Hess A. D., ESA A. H. & COLOMBANX P. M. 1988. M~hanisms of action of cyclosporine: effects on cells of the immune system and on subcellular events in T cell activation. Transplantation Proceedings 20, Suppl. 2: 29-40.

multilocularis (Cestoda). Gene 75: 329-334. OSBORN P. J. & HEATH D. D. 1982. Immunisation of lambs

against Echinacoccus granulosus using antigens obtained by incubation of oncospheres in vitro. Research in Veterinary Science 33: 132-I 33.

PINI C., PA~WRE R. & VALESINI G. 1983. Circulating immune complexes in sera of patients infected with ~chinacacc~ granulasus. Clinicaland Experimental Immunology 51: 572- 578.

JENKINS D. J. & RICKARD M. D. 1986. Specific antibody responses in dogs experimentally infected with Echino- coccus gramdosus. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 3!Fz 345-349.

JOHNSON K. S., HARRISON G. B. L., LIGHTOWLERS M. W., O’HOY K. L., COUGLE W. G., DEMP~TER R. P., LAWRENCE S. B., VIN~ON J. G., HEATH D. D. & RICKARD M. D. 1989. Vaccination against ovine cysticercosis using a defined recombinant antigen. Nature (London) 338: 585-587.

JUDSON D. G., DIXON J. B., CLARKXJN M. J. & PRITCHARD J. 1985. Ovine hydatidosis: some immunologi~l character- istics of the seronegative host. P~~italogy 91: 349-357.

LIGHTOWLERS M. W., RICKARD M. D., HONEY R. D., OBENIKIRF D. L. & MITCHELL G. F. 1984. Serological diagnosis of Echinacoccus granulosus infection in sheep using cyst fluid antigen processed by antibody aflinity chromatography. Australian Veterinary Journal 61: 101-108.

LIGHTOWLERS M. W., RICKARD M. D. & HONEY R. D. 1986. Serum antibody following parental immuni~tion with hydatid cyst fluid in sheep infected with Echin~ace~ gramdosus. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 35: 818-823.

LIGHTOWLERS M. W., HARALAMBOUS A. & RICKARD M. D. 1989. Amino acid sequence homology between cyclophilin and a cDNA-cloned antigen of Echinacaccus granulasus. ~ale~lar and Biochemical Parasitology 36: 287-289.

L~OHTOWLERS M. W., LIU D., HARALAM~~S A. & RICKARD M. D. 1989. Subunit composition and specificity of the major cyst fluid antigens of Echinococcus granulasus. Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology 37: 171-l 82.

LIGHTOWLERS M. W. & MITCHELL G. F. 1989. Assessment of the prevalence and titre of antibodies to a candidate schistosomiasis vaccine molecule, Sj26, in several human serum banks. Acta Tropica 46: 229-238.

LIGHTOWLERS M. W., MITCHELL G. F. & RICKARD M. D. (in press) Cestodes. In: Immunology and Moiecular Bialagy of Parasitic Infections (Edited by WARREN K. S. & AGA~~AN N.), 3rd edn. Blackwell Scientific Publications, Oxford.

MORN H., WERNLI B., WEISS N. & FRANKLIN R. M. 1986. Autoantibodies in humans with cystic or alveolar echino- coceosis. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical medicine and Hygiene 80: 978-980.

MOVSESIJAN M. & MLADENOVI~ Z. 1971. mhe possibility of using different development stages of E. gramdosus for detection of specific antibodies against their parasite.] Veterinarski Glasnik 25: 159-163.

RAu M. E. &TANNER C. E. 1973. Echinacoccus multilacularis in the cotton rat. The effect of preexisting subcutaneous cysts on the development of a subsequent intraperitoneal inoculum of protoscolices. Canadian Journal of Zoology 51: 55-59.

RAUSCH R. L., WILSON J. F., SCHANTZ P. M. & MCMAHON 8. J. 1987. Spontaneous death of Echinococeus muliiiocularis: cases diagnosed serologically (by Em, ELISA) and clinical significance. American Journal of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene 36: 576-585.

RICKARD M. D. & WILLIAMS J. F. 1982. Hydatidosis/ cysticercosis: immune mechanisms and immuni~tion against infection. Advances in Par~italagy 21: 229-296.

RICKARD M. D., HONEY R. D., BRUMLEY J. L. & MITCHELL G. F. 1984. Serological diagnosis and post-operative surveill- ance of human hydatid disease. II. The enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) using various antigens. Pathology 16: 21 l-216.

RICKARD M. D. & LIGHTOWLER~ M. W. 1986. Immuno- diagnosis of hydatid disease. In: The Biology of Echino- coccus and Hydatid Disease (Edited by THOMPSON R. C. A.), pp. 217-249. George, Allen & Unwin, London.

RILEY E. M., DIXON J. B., KELLY D. F. & Cox D. A. 1985. The immune response to Echinocaccus granulosus: sequential histological observations of lymphoreticular and connect- ive tissues during early murine infection. Journal of Comparative Pathology 95: 93104.

RILEY E. M., DIXON J. B., JENKINS P. & Ross G. 1986. Echinoeoccus granulosus infection in mice: host responses during primary and secondary infection. Parasitology 92: 391-403.

MOLLER N., G~TTSTEIN B., VOGEL M., FLURY K. & SEEBECK T. 1989. Application of a recombinant Echinocaccus mulri- locularis antigen in an enzyme-linked immunosor~nt assay for immunodia~osis of human alveolar echino- coccosis. Molecular and Biochemical Parasitology 36: 151- 160.

Rrs D. R., HAMEL K. L. & MACKLE Z. M. 1987. Use of two polysaccharide antigens in ELISA for the detection of antibodies to Echinocorcus granulasus in sheep sera. Research in Veterinary Science 43: 257-263.

SCHANTZ P. M. & GOTISTEIN B. 1986. Echinococcosis (hydatidosis). In: Immunodiagnosis of Parasitic Diseases, Vol. 1, Helminthic Diseases (Edited by WALLS K. F. & SCHAN~Z P. M.), pp. 69-107. Academic Press, Orlando, Florida.

SHEPHERD J. C. & MCMANUS D. P. 1987. Specific and cross- reactive antigens of Echinacoccus granulosus. Molecular and Biachemicai Par~italogy 25: 143-l 54.

SHI Y., SAHAI B. M. & GREEN D. R. 1989. Cyclosporin A inhibits activation-induced cell death in T-cell hybridomas and thymocytes. Nature (London) 339: 625-626.

SMITH D. B. & JOHNSON K. S. 1988. Single step purification of polypeptides expressed in Escherichia cofi as fusions with glutathione S-transferase. Gene 67: 31-40.

SWEATMAN G. K., WILLIAMS R. J., MORIARTY K. M. & HENSHALL T. C. 1963. On acquired immunity to Echinacoccus granuiosus in sheep. Research in Veterinary Science 4: 187-198.

MILLER N., VOGEL M., GOTTSTEIN B., SCHOLLE A. & SEEBECK TAKAHASHI N., HAYANO T. & SUZUKI M. 1989. Peptidyl-prolyl T. 1989. Plasmid vector for overproduction and export of cistrans isomerase is the cyclosporin A-binding protein recombinant protein in Escherichia coli: efficient one-step cyclophilin. Nature (London) 337: 473-475. purification of a recombinant antigen for Echinococcus TURNER E. L., DENNIS E. W. & BERBERIAN D. A. 1937. The

478 M. W. LIGHTOWLERS

production of artificial immunity against hydatid disease in A 2 year follow-up with and without flubendazole sheep. Journal of Parasitology 23: 43-61. treatment. Parasite Immunology 6: 329-340.

VOGEL M., GOITSTEIN B., MOLLER N. & SEEBECK T. 1988. YARULIN G. R. 1968. [Study of the development of hydatid Production of a recombinant antigen of Echinococcus cysts during experimental infection of lambs.] Izvestiia multilocularis with high immunodiagnostic sensitivity and Akademii Nauk SSSR. Seriia Biologicheskaia, pp. 378-382. specificity. molecular and Biochemical Paras~to~ffgy 31: YARZABAL L. A., SCHANTZ P. M. & LOPEZ-LEMES M. H. 1975. 117-126. Comparative sensitivity and specificity of the Casoni

VUFITON D.A., LA&CUE A., MIGUET J. P., HERV~ P., BARALE intradermal and immunoelectiophoresis tests for the T., SEILL~S E. & CAPRON A. 1984. Humoral and cellular diagnosis of hydatid disease. American Journal of Tropical immunity in patients with hepatic alveolar echinococcosis. Medicine and Hygiene 24: 843-848.