implementation of doe order 450.1: self-declaration and report letters steven r. woodbury us...
TRANSCRIPT
Implementation of DOE Order 450.1:
Self-Declaration and Report Letters
Steven R. WoodburyUS Department of Energy
March 9, 2005
Overview
• DOE Order 450.1 and DOE Guide 450.1-1
• Role of Self-Declaration Protocol
• Sample Report Letters
• Summary
ResponsibilitiesUnder DOE Order 450.1
• PSOs: ensure that all their sites have implemented EMS by 12/05
• Site Managers: report by 12/31/05 to CSO the status of contractor implementation of EMS
• Site Managers: ensure that contractors update ISM system description to reflect EMS
ISMS/EMS Frameworks DOE Guide 450.1-1 (§8)
Framework 1: Self-Declaration– Implement elements of an EMS, within ISMS– Meet all EMS requirements of DOE O 450.1– Self-declare conformity to DOE O 450.1
Framework 2: ISO 14001 Registration– Implement elements of an EMS, within ISMS– Meet all EMS requirements of DOE O 450.1– Achieve third-party registration to ISO 14001
OFEE Self-Declaration Protocol
• Developed by E.O. 13148 Inter-Agency Work Group
• Issued by Office of the Federal Environmental Executive (OFEE)
• Provides a framework for agencies to establish their self-declaration protocols
• DOE has implemented the Protocol through DOE Guide 450.1-1
OFEE Clarification of Terms
• Developed by E.O. 13148 Inter-Agency Work Group
• Issued by Office of the Federal Environmental Executive (OFEE)
• Will provide a basis for reporting EMS status to EPA
• DOE has included the definitions in the revision to DOE Guide 450.1-1
OFEE Clarification of Terms
• First-party audit– EMS audit conducted by participants within
the scope of the EMS under consideration
• External second-party audit– EMS audit conducted by reviewers from
outside the scope of the EMS in question
• External, third-party audit– EMS audit conducted by ANSI-RAB
accredited independent auditor for conformance to ISO 14001 Standard
Self-Declaration: DOE Guide 450.1 (§9.1)
• Site determines that it fully conforms to requirements of DOE O 450.1
• To be credible, determination should be based on a first-party EMS evaluation (at minimum)
• Self-declaration procedure should– provide effective and objective
assessment of EMS– be designed for ongoing evaluation
and continual improvement
Additional Guidance DOE G 450.1-1 (attachments)
• An acceptable procedure is outlined in Attachment 2 of DOE G 450.1
• Site may use alternative self-declaration procedure (e.g. existing review/evaluation/ audit process established under ISMS)– Must credibly establish and document the
existence of EMS conforming to DOE O 450.1
• In any case, process must address DOE O 450.1 EMS requirements summarized in Attachment 3 of DOE G 450.1
Third-Party RegistrationDOE Guide 450.1 (§9.2)
• DOE sites may choose to seek third-party registration to the ISO 14001 standard
• Not required by DOE Order 450.1
Sample Report Letters
• Guidance being issued as a revision to DOE G 450.1-1
• Includes three sample letters:1. EMS in place – first-party or second-party
assessment
2. EMS in place – third party assessment
3. EMS not yet fully implemented
Sample Report Letter #1:
EMS in Place; Self-Declared
• Declares conformance to EMS requirements of DOE O 450.1
• Identifies basis for declaration– First- or second-party assessment?– Describe assessment procedure
Sample Report Letter #2:
ISO 14001 Registered EMS• Declares conformance to EMS
requirements of DOE O 450.1• Identifies basis for declaration
– ISO 14001 registrar, and date of audit(s)
– Affirms that site EMS meets the requirements of DOE O 450.1, e.g.:• scope• integration with ISMS
Sample Report Letter #3: EMS Not Fully Implemented
• States that sites does not yet conform to the EMS requirements of DOE O 450.1
• Identifies EMS elements not yet developed, and EMS elements not yet implemented
• Identifies basis for statements
• Identifies planned completion dates
Sample Report Letters• All Sample Report Letters also address:
– Incorporation of DOE O 450.1 CRD in site contract (§ 3.b.(2))
– Integration of EMS into updated ISM system description (§ 5.d.(2))
– Inclusion of appropriate environmental elements in Annual ISM review of ES&H perf. objectives, perf. measures, and commitments (§ 5.d.(17))
– Availability of supporting documentation for review
Other Reporting
• DOE: Annual reports to EPA under Greening of the Government E.O.s– DOE O 231.1 requires reporting to EH– DOE O 450.1 provides for “input from
Departmental elements”
• Program Office: Quarterly report of site implementation status
• Site: Annual Site Environmental Report– EMS status – progress toward objectives and targets
Program Office Role
• Program Secretarial Officers are ultimately responsible for ensuring that their sites implement EMS
• Some Program Offices have issued specific guidance to their sites on EMS assessment and reporting
Communication between DOE HQ Offices and Site Offices
• DOE HQ Offices – should be communicating with their site offices about their expectations for EMS self-declaration
• DOE Site Offices – should be communicating with their DOE Headquarters office about their expectations for EMS self-declaration
• No surprises in December 2005
Communication at the Sites
• DOE Field Offices – should be communicating with their contractors about their expectations for EMS self-declaration
• DOE contractors – should be communicating with their DOE field office about their expectations for EMS self-declaration
• No surprises in December 2005
Bottom LineSelf-Declaration process should be• Credible• Based on objective evidence• Designed for ongoing evaluation
and continual improvementSite Manager’s Report Letter should• Affirm DOE site management’s
knowledge of EMS implementation• Be based on available supporting
documentation
