Upload File

in all fairness: cross-cultural perspectives on water quality and equity

  • Home
  • Documents
  • In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity
13
In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity Meredith Gartin Doctoral Student, School of Human Evolution and Social Change Amber Wutich Assistant Professor, School of Human Evolution and Social Change Arizona State University June 29, 2011 http://storyofstuff.org/bottledwater/what-you-can-do/support-the-human-right-to- water-and-reclaim-the-commons/

Upload: alika-tyler

Post on 02-Jan-2016

26 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

Report

Tags:

DESCRIPTION

In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity. Meredith Gartin Doctoral Student, School of Human Evolution and Social Change Amber Wutich Assistant Professor, School of Human Evolution and Social Change Arizona State University June 29, 2011. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality

and Equity

Meredith Gartin Doctoral Student, School of Human Evolution and Social Change

Amber Wutich Assistant Professor, School of Human Evolution and Social Change

Arizona State UniversityJune 29, 2011

http://storyofstuff.org/bottledwater/what-you-can-do/support-the-human-right-to-water-and-reclaim-the-commons/

Page 2: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Equality versus Equity

Equality• Uniform distribution and

rights to accessing water

• Easier to define• Easier to create policies

– “one-size-fist-all”

Equity• Overcoming diversity and

exclusionary practices to ensure fair and just access

• Overemphasizes – philosophical representations of

water use – descriptions of cultural values

Efficiency Approach: conserve limited freshwater supplies and make more efficient water distribution and allocation systems.

Page 3: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Global Ethnohydrology Study

• Research Design: Exploratory/Explanatory • Research Theme: Ethnohydrology– Water Quality; Local Water Institutions; Climate

Change; Water-borne Diseases• Research Sites: “Global” – Year 1: Fiji; New Zealand; US (Phoenix); Boliva

• Research Team: Faculty and Students

Page 4: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Fairness and Local Water Institutions

http://hesperian.typepad.com/weblog/environmental/

Page 5: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Fairness in Votua and Sigatoka, Fiji

http://www.fijiwaterfoundation.org/pages.cfm/our-projects/water/villa-maria-settlement-upgrading-of-water-system.html

Page 6: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Fairness in Cochabamba, Bolivia

Page 7: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Fairness in Wellington and Piopio, New Zealand

http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo/3GifmKkd8RDTGykVt71F5w

Page 8: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Comparisons of the Four Sites

FijiBolivia Southwest U.S.New Zealand

Page 9: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Fairness in Phoenix, United States

http://www.flickr.com/photos/mandj98/3075340790/

Page 10: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Comparisons of the Four Sites

FijiBolivia Southwest U.S.New Zealand

Page 11: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Comparisons of the Four Sites

FijiBolivia Southwest U.S.New Zealand

Page 12: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Comparisons of the Four Sites

FijiBolivia Southwest U.S.New Zealand

Page 13: In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Explanatory Model:Equality and Equity

Fair Water Management

Water Cost

Water Quality

VulnerableBy the

Institution

Should people be punished for using more than their fair share of water?

Should people have the right to sell and lease their water rights to others?

Should water be distributed free to everyone?

Is it fair for there to be low water pressure?

Are too few rights allocated to indigenous people?


“FAIRNESS AND EQUITY,” OR JUDICIAL BAIT-AND … · “FAIRNESS AND EQUITY,” OR JUDICIAL BAIT-AND ... that ‘just compensation’ tends ... see Marisa Fegan, Just Compensation

E y - Asia Society · “ Excellence and equity are not incompatible policy goals” EQUITY According to OECD, equity in education can be seen through two dimensions: fairness and

Perspectives on ESG Integration in Equity Investing...Perspectives on ESG Integration in Equity Investing: An opportunity to enhance long-term, risk-adjusted investment performance

Ameriprise Equity Perspectives - Dividend Dynamics: Sector

On justice, fairness and equity in Gothenburg · 2017-06-21 · 2 On justice, fairness and equity in Gothenburg Leif Eriksson Sanna Isemo Hans Abrahamsson Mistra Urban Futures, sept

“Fairness & Equity” in Watermedia.csmfo.org/.../03/Fairness-Equity-in-Water-and... · Got a Brain about Water Rates – This is the Right Session for You!!! Are My Rate Defensible?

On the Self-serving Use of Equity Principles in ... · interpretations of fairness. When different conflicting fairness principles exist, the negotiations process involves a weighing

FPSO: Perspectives from the equity market

Trusts and Equity :// · explain the idea of equity and the symbiotic way in which equity and the common law function. Th e term ‘equity’ can be used to describe social fairness,

Spotlight on Equity: ISSUE 6 Principle of Fairness in Practice ...€¦ · Principle of Fairness in Practice: Challenging Scenarios Equity is the belief that people who are different

FPSO-sector: Perspectives from the equity

MARCH 2015 - RED ROCKS CAPITAL PRIVATE EQUITY PERSPECTIVES ... · PDF fileRed Rocks Capital Private Equity Perspectives ... including UBS, Park Hill Group, ... which provides wealth

In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity Meredith Gartin Doctoral Student, School of Human Evolution and Social Change

Practical perspectives on equity in sport participation · Practical perspectives on equity in sport ... right of access to physical education and sport” (UNESCO 1978) Health, social

Teach for equity with Perspectives TEACHIN G TOLERANCE

Opportunity is about equity and fairness for all. - 124 AMENDED DRAFT JUNE 2017 Guiding Principles Opportunity is about equity and fairness for all. Nashville and the region are becoming

Perspectives on european private equity v5

In All Fairness: Cross-cultural Perspectives on Water Quality and Equity

Inequality: Why equity and fairness should be part of tax

Fairness and Equity via Concepts of Multi-Criteria ...pure.iiasa.ac.at/id/eprint/4890/1/WP-96-137.pdf · Working Paper Fairness and Equity via Concepts of Multi-Criteria Decision

Equity/Fairness Within Conservation Workshop - Summary of Research Findings

MCAT Validity Research · 2019-08-12 · new MCAT exam. Procedural fairness. Societal fairness. Aspiring physicians from different groups have equity in access to preparation materials

A framework for embedding equity, broadening perspectives

Evaluating Transportation Equity · Evaluating Transportation Equity Victoria Transport Policy Institute 2 Executive Summary Equity (also called justice or fairness) refers to the

Assessment of equity principles for international climate ...(Ringius et al. 2002). Following equity principles means establishing overarching general justice and fairness principles,

Health Justice, Equality and Fairness: Perspectives …...The Equal Rights Review, Vol. Six (2011) 127 Health Justice, Equality and Fairness: Perspectives from Health Policy and Human

Differential and Alternative Response: Implications for Fairness and Equity

ACCESS & EQUITY IN HEALTH: Canadian Perspectives

Equity, Fairness, and Uniformity in Tolling - Background ... · Washington State Comprehensive Tolling Study September 20, 2006 Final Report – Volume 2 Background Paper #4: Equity,

Equity and REDD+: Perspectives from CIFOR’s global comparative study

Transit equity final - Transportationtram.mcgill.ca/Research/Publications/Transit_plan_equity.pdf · As issues of equity and fairness gain importance in transportation planning, understanding

Morningstar's Perspectives on Liquid Alternatives & New Equity

Study of Reward Fairness and Equity · internal and external equity or fairness. • Individual performance and work responsibilities associated with the job are high-ranking criteria

PLANNING FOR FAIRNESS: EQUITY IN FRENCH URBANISME …

Group1 - National Treasury€¢ Maturity’in’decision’making’–quick’butresponsible’to’ensure’’all’pillars’of’supply’ chain’are’covered’(fairness,’equity,’transparency’and’accountability’