in bw~xr~yakopanisadshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 ·...

37
CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN - BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts if WO go through the passage8 of the Upan*ads we can 6.8 that they are good literary creation8 rl8o. The aim of any literary work is t o please But Upa- nIpd8 have a higher purpose t o make one aware ef the ultimate truth. Hence litorrture and philo- sophy mews to be divergent in aim and contente But the Upaninads clearly exploit the possibilitie8 of literary methods to bring haw the higher truth. In short. it use. literature as a tool to attain its goal. Infact there 1. no incanpatibility betwoon upaniaadm and l i t e r a r y forms . Since the ultimate object (paramapusiirtha) 8aught t o be achieved by oahitya (literaturd also is final inuncipatioa (mokmha). The Pleasure one get8 fran r -tic

Upload: others

Post on 10-Jul-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

CHAPTER IV

LXTERAFS ASPECTS

IN - BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD

Though Upanisada a r e philosophical thoughts

i f WO go through the passage8 of the Upan*ads w e

can 6.8 tha t they are good l i t e r a r y creation8 rl8o.

The aim of any l i t e r a r y work i s t o please But Upa-

n I p d 8 have a higher purpose t o make one aware ef

the ultimate truth. Hence l i t o r r t u r e and philo-

sophy mews t o be divergent i n aim and contente But

the Upaninads c l ea r ly exploi t the poss ib i l i t i e8 of

l i t e r a r y methods t o bring haw the higher truth. In

short. it use. literature a s a too l t o attain i ts

goal. Infact there 1. no incanpat ib i l i ty betwoon

upaniaadm and l i t e r a r y forms . Since the ultimate

object (paramapusiirtha) 8aught t o be achieved by

oahitya ( l i t e r a t u r d a l so is f i n a l inuncipatioa

(mokmha). The Pleasure one get8 f ran r -tic

Page 2: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

crea t ion i s sa id t o be a bro ther of t he b l i s s i n

the r e a l i s a t i o n of Brahman (Brahmbnanda Sahodar32.

The sages who composed t h e major Upanigads

had a poetic mind. It i s evident f r a n t h e beau-

t i f u l way of presentat ion of even deep upanisadic

ideas couched i n a t t a r a c t i v e combination of words.

B~hadSranyaka can claim a pos i t i on among poems

because of t h e beau t i fu l i deas expressed i n it 3

and t h e arrangement of blemishless words f u l l of

4 a r t i s t i c q u a l i t i e s . A s i n poems f o r pure mundane

enjoyments, w e f ind i n t h i s Upanisads b e a u t i f u l

episodes, dramatic s i t ua t ions , allegory. symbols,

paral le l isms, use of words i n secondary meanings etc.

2. sutva&kapraka$~nandama~a ~amvldv id ran t iykse~ana

Paratrahmasvadanvaridena bhogena parabhyjyate AB P.52 .

3. Jagannatha def ines poem thus: ramaniyzrthaprati- padakah sabdah kIivyam. Rasagangadhara.T.1.

4. Vide: tad adogau sakdzrthau s a g q a u . ... .. . . . . . klammata, Kavyaprakada. 1.4.

Page 3: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

Though t h e concepts of Alankara, g-a, ~ i t ; etc.

w e r e de f ined by r h e t o r i c i a n s long a f t e r t h e comp-

o s j t i o n of t h i s Upanisad, w e f i n d examples of

such concepts i n it. D~.Manudev Bandhu has t aken

pains t o p r w i d e such examples i n h i s s tudy of

5 t h e Upanisad i n Hindi . H e has been gene ra l l y

f o l l m e d i n t h e present s tudy i n dea l i ng wi th - -

AlankZra. g y a , R i t i , etc.

EPIBODES

Brhadsrnyakopaniqad c o n t a i n s many ep i sodes

which a r e b e a u t i f u l l i t e r a r y specimens. They

make t h e abs tuse and monotonous phi losophic i d e a s

i n t e l l i y b l e and i n t e r e s t i n g . They be t r ay t h e

5. Bandhu, Brhadcnyakopanisad - Ek Adhyayan.

P.P 192 - 213

Page 4: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

a r t i s t i c t a s t e of the composer of the upanisad. A s

i n the ~ h a n d o ~ ~ o ~ a n i ~ a 8 and ~ a $ h o ~ a n i ? a d ~ we f ind

thought provoking parables and conversations of a

dramatic nature i n t h i s Upanisad. Speaking through

parables i s a technique employed by great seers i n

d i f ferent pa r t s of the world. 8

THE HORSE - SACRIFICE

~rhadarar)yakopanisad mentions the s tory of

Horse-sacri:Eice. Body of the s a c r i f i c i a l Horse i s

the cosmic form of Prajapati. Prajapati i s t h e

presiding de i t y of the horse-sacrifice. srl Sankara

observes t h a t t he ideas of time, worlds and dut ies ,

the cosn~Ic body of prajapat i a re superimposed on

the horse. It i s only an imagination. Truly it

i s a meditation t h a t w i l l enable a l l t o der ive

6 . e.g. hretaketu - A r ~ i UddalZika dialogue.

7. e.g. ~ a d i k e t a s - Yama dialogue.

8. f o r instance. the Bible and the Koran contain many parables.

Page 5: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

t h e r e s u l t s of t h e horse-sacrif ice even without

the p e r f o m n c e of it. It is n p e r a y 8 1 of t h e

poet ic beauty of t h i s Upaniqad. The head of t h e 9

s a c r i f i c i a l horse i s t h e sun etc . Thus a l l

l i v ing and non-living being are p a r t s of the

horse. I n t h e absense of the horse, he should

imagine himself as the s a c r i f i c i a l horea and L

meditate upon t h e p a r t s of h i s own body a s di - f f e r e n t parts of the c o m i c being. I n olden days

only kings are qua l i f i ed f o r performing t h e horse

sacrifice. But one who is no qua l i f i ed f o r it

w i l l get the same r e s u l t f r m t h i s meditat im.

The horse-sacrif ice i s g r e a t e s t of t h e vedk

rites leads t o the world of Hirar?yagprbha. B u t

t h e r e s u l t of t h e s a c r i f i c e i s a l s o t r a n s i tOry

and cannot s top the transmigration of t h e salf.

~ h u s t h e upaniead mentions the s a c r i f i c e inorder

t o c r e a t e a spirit of dispaesion. The u p a n l e d

therefora exhaust themselvee the unfoldment of

Page 6: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

knowledge, which once attained i s never lost.

PARABLE O F DEATH

The Upanisad mentions t h a t hunger i s

10 death. There was nothing before creation . The universe was cwered with death. Then hun-

ger produced the mind. A s it worshipped

water was produced. H e thought t h a t he was wor-

shipping water sprang up, t h i s is why f i r e l 8

cal led uka l ? Water i s cal led Arka. I n t h i s

work of creation Prajapat i was t i red . Fram t h a t

action f i r e was produced. H e devided the b@y

i n three ways. They u s sun air and f i r e . Pra-

japat i desired m May a second body be born t o m e m 12

w i t h the union of speech(vSk) with t he mind. Thus

a baby w a s born then he opened h i s mouth t o wa-

l l ~ the body a s the was born, The baby cr iad

nBha?Y. it became speech. Then prajapat i pro-

duced a,l lVedas, le Rgveda, Yajwecla, siim v d a

Atharvaveda etc. H e parformelsacrifice again and

Page 7: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

i n . Thus it describes t h e o r ig in md nature

of Agni umd i n the horse sacr i f ice . The fire 13 and the eunare Ar'ka the horae-sacrif ice

Theae two trimghs wer f u r t h e r death, it does

not wercume him. Hiranyagarbha Wanes iden-

t i f i e d with these d e i t i e s .

STORY OF CREATION OF SPECIES

The c rea t ion of hhe world is very intere-

s t ing i n B~ahad&ranyrka ra the r than In any other

upanlsad. It g i v e s a c l e a r account of t h e crea-

t i o n of t h e species. In t h e beginning, t h i s

universe was only t h e se l f i n t h e form of 8

14 person. H e was f r ightened . One i s f r ighte-

ned when one i a alone. Then he r e a l i s e d t h a t

the re i s nothing besides himself. Then t h e f e a r

i s departed t h a t f e a r canes from a second e n t i t y

on account of h i s lonelfness he was s t iden with 15 dissatisfAction. So he desired a mate . Jqs

n i s d e s i r e was i n f a l l i b l e he became as big a s

Page 8: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

a man and wife embracing together. But he did

not become of t h i s s i z e by wiping out h i s or ig i -

n a l e n t i t y , a s milk i s transofrmed i n t o curd. H e

remained a s he was, but projected another body.

he parted i n t o two, male half being Hanu and t h e

16 female half s a t d p a . Fran their union men

w e r e born. Both turned i n t o d i f f e r e n t species,

and from t h e i r union i n each a l l c rea tu res down

t o a n t s w e r e created. Thus the whole animate world

came t o H e fe l t t h a t he vae t h e whole

creat ion, which was not over and &we himself.

A l l men ancl animals d e s i r e f o r mates. This i s

t h e b a s i s c* t h e concept of the half man and

half woman god i n Li terature .

DIALOOUE OF Y - ~ V A L K Y A AND MAITREYI

The sage YPjiiavaUrpa had two wives.

Militreyi and Katya yani. Intending t o embrace

the monastic l i f e . he expressed h i s d e s i r e t o

Page 9: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

divide h i s wealth between the wives before depa-

r ture . Maitreyi asked him whether she would be

immortal i f the whole e a r t h of wealth belonged

t o her1*. The sage rep l ied t h a t the re was no

hope of Immortality through wealth ie, r i t ee

performed, with wealth Maitreyi therefore refused

t o accept, any wealth, but desired t o learn the

means of inmortali ty from t h e sage YajEavaUrga

te l l s her' t h a t the knawledge of the s e l f is t h e

only meanis of immortality, and gives her a grand

descripti.on of the s e l f . It is not f o r the sake

of the husband, wife, sons, wealth, t h e Brahmans.

ksa t r iya , worlds, gods, beings and a l l , t h a t they

a r e dear , but it 1s f o r t h e sake of one's se l f

t h a t they are The r e a l se l f should be

heard of ref lected on and meditated upo~?O-

Brahma~Z8. ksa t r iyas , worlda. gods beings and

a11 r e j e c t the man who knows them t o be d i f f e -

ren t from the s e l f , because a l l these a r e only

Page 10: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

-88-

the self , . A s the par t icular notes of a drum,

conch or l u t e cannot be understood apart from

t h e i r general note2', So nothim par t icular i s 22 perceived apart from the se l f . Sea is the

merging place of a l l s o r t s of water Skin is the

merging place of a11 kinds of touch. Nostr i ls

a r e the merging place of a11 odours, toungue is

t h e merging place of a l l savours, Eye is the

merging glace of a l l colours. E- i s the merging

place of a l l sounds. Mind i s the merging place

of a11 deliberations. I n l e u e c t i s t h e merging

place of a l l kinds of knowledge. Hands a r e t he

merging place of a l l actions. Anus is the merging

place of a l l excretions. Organ of generation i s

the merging place of a l l kinds of pleasures. Feet

a re the merging place of a l l kinds of walking.

Organ of speech i s t h e merging place of a l l vedas 23.

A lump of salt thrown i n t o water only di-

ssolves In to the water, None can pick it up. It

has only a sa l lne tas te . Thus great endless,

Page 11: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

i n f i n i t e r e a l i t y i s only hancgoneoue i n t e l l i g e -

When there i s dual i ty , then one emells

another, speaks another etc. 25. ~PjFiavalkya

advised t h a t ear th is honey t o a l l beings and a l l

h i n g e a r e honey t o t h i s ear th , t h e b t igh t inmar-

t a l being,, who is i n t h i s e a r t h aeeociated with 26 t he body. These four a r e only t h e se l f .

Militreyi came t o r e a l i s e t h a t everything

i n the world is l imlted. It l i a b l e t o bc de-

stroyed and ins igni f icant . Whatever obj-t of

lwe i~; t h i s world i s not and end i n i tself. It

is means t h a t pure lwe which one a t t a i n s i m o r -

t a l i t y .

Cont.inuing the exhertat ion, yajiiavalkya

said t o Uaitreyi, "The s e l f i s not elsewhere it

i s our arn inmost nature. In response t o m e i t -

r eyb9s question a s t o how can convert every hln-

iurance i n t o a help. Yajiiavalkya gave m in-

t e r e s t i n g reply t h a t %he senses a r e i n t h e na- 27 t u r e of a hindrance .

Page 12: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

Gargi again asked t h a t "what pervade8 t h a t

which i s abwe heaven and b e l o w the ea r th? Y*-

navalkya rep l ied t h a t t h e unmanifeeted other.

The knmers of Brahman descr ibe it a s t h e ab-

solute. It i s ne i ther substance nor an a t t r i b u t e

Niether coarse nor f ine , nei ther short nor long 28

nei ther shadow nor darkness and so on . Under

the rule! of t h i s very absolute, days and nights

for tn ights , months, seasons and years a r e main-

tained in t h e i r respective places29. This abeo-

l u t e i s never seen but i s t h e seer, neverheard

but i s the thinker never knovn but is t h e knarer.

There i s no Other seer, no other h e a r e ~ etc.

This absolute pervads the unmanifested e i the r .

Thus t h e episode of y%j;avalkya M i t r e y i debate

i s very in te res t ing and none cm see t h i s in any

other Upanisads.

Page 13: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

DISCUSSION AT JANAKA'S COURT - The s tory of Janaka and Yajnavalkya i s

very in te res t ing . Janaka was the r u l e r of videha.

H e desired t o perform sac r i f i ce . A l a rge number

of learned. men assembled there. I n t h a t state,

he wished t o honour throughly prof ic ien t echolars

among tham.. The most e r u d i t e scholar has a g i f t

of thousand ccws. W i t h t h e home of each cm stu- 3 0

dded with t en padae of gold.

Janaka said t o the Brahmanas t h a t t h e g r e w

test of t h e vedic scholars amongst you d r ive these

cows. The Brahmanas d id not dare. Then yiijiia-

valkya sa id t o h i s pupi l *s*&nae>avas t o d r i v e 31

these cws home. me Brahmanas were angry. Then

t h e invoking p r i e s t *ala resolved t o quastion

him. These questions w e r e very interest ing. One

quest in i s t h a t a l l i s caught by death what does

t h e s a c r i f i c e r transcend t h e reach of death.

~a j i iava lkya rep l ied t h a t t h e s a c r i f i c e r t rans-

Page 14: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

the reach of death. Since a l l t h i s is caught by

t h e bright, and dark halves of the month and wer-

powered by them the s a c r i f i c e r transcend t h e reach

of Udgatf. The v i t a l force of t h e s a c r i f i c e r is

indeed t h e chanting p r i e s t . The v i t a l force of

the s a c r i f i c e r i n vagu ie. vayu is the chanting

pr ies t . The v i t a l force of t h e s a c r i f i c e r i n

vsyu i e v a p i s the chanting priest32. i h a l a

asked e ight questions and yiijiiavalkya quickely an- -

swered them, ~ s i r a l a r ea l i sed t h a t h i s opponent

was more than a mach f o r him and kept quie t .

Deszription of the debate of yzjzavalkpa

and kthab;Zga i s the key noteof vedantic thought.

k thabhaga asked s i x quest ions and y;i jilavalkya

answers t o him. i'he l a s t question i s very in-

te res t ing , GthabhZga asked t h a t she re goes t h e

man who d i e s without a t t a i n i n g the highest

Page 15: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

3 3 knowledge . ~aj i iava lkya sa id t h a t t h i s question

was t o be decided between them only and not i n a

crawd. They went t o a s o l i t a r y place. After

discussion they deoided t h a t work was t h e guide

of a disembodied soul, r e b i r t h is due t o pas t

work. Hence one became noble through righteous

work and ignoble through unrighteous work.

Kahola t h e son of Kusitaka questioned

yZjn"avz1kya Brahman is immediate and d i r e c t - The

self t h a t i s witnin a l l . This i s your s e l f t h a t

Q i s within a l l i s the stqnent. Then which ia it 34

t h a t i s within a l l ? That which i s beyond hunger

and t h i r s t , g r ie f and delusion, dscrpi tude and

death. Realising t h i s very se l f Brahma?as g ive up

the d e s i r e f o r sons, f o r wealth and take up a W a n -

dering rnedicantss l i f e . Deaire f o r son i s the

des i r e f o r wealth, worlds and desires. Therefore

Page 16: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

~ r h a n a having mastered self-knowledge should

seek t o l i v e on t h a t s t r eng th . Having mastered

t h a t s t r e n g t h a s w e l l as t h a t knowledge he beco- 3 5 m e s medi ta t ive , he becomes a r e a l Brzhmana .

DIALOOUE O F UDDALAKA AND YAJNAVALKYA

uddalaka, t h e son of k u n a ques t ioned

yajfiavalkya, t h e sutra by whbch t h i s l i f e and t h e

next l i f e and a l l be ings from vi ra j down t o a

clump of g r a s s a r e s t rung t oge the r and t h e i n t e r n a l

r u l e r by whom they a r e ~ o n t r o l l e d ~ ~ . ~ ~ j F i a v a l k ~ a

r e p l i e d t h ~ a t vzyu i s t h a t s i i t r a and t h e Antarpamtn

or i n t e r n a l ruler. He who i n h a b i t s e a r t h w a t e r ,

f i r e , sky, a i r , heaven, t h e sun, t h e d i r e c t i o n s ,

t h e moon, and s t a r s , e t h e r darkness, l i g h t , a l l

beings, t h e nose, t h e voca l organ. eye, e a r , mind

skin, i n t e ! l l e c t and seed. Although he i s wi th in

them, t hey d o no t know him whose bodiea they are,

who c o n t r o l s them £ran within. and who i s a t t h e

Page 17: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

sametime one ' s w n s e l f . H e i s t h e seer but i s never

seen, H e i s t h e hea re r bu t i s never heard, he i s

t h e t h inke r but is never thought , he is t h e knawer

bu t i s rimer known1 t h e r e i s no o the r seer, heara r ,

th inker , o r knower than He.

PARABLE OF PRANA AND INDRIYAS

The ~ n d r i y a s a r e q u a r r a l w i th each o t h e r

t h a t they a r e super io r among them. The sense organs

went t o p r a j g p a t i t o t ake a decis ion . P ra jSpa th i s a i d

t h a t t h e g r e a t e s t among them was, when whose depar t -

ure would make t h e body more wretched than it was.

Then t h e organs went out one by one t o t r y t hem 3 7

p w e r . ~t l a s t t h e p r z ~ a was on t h e po in t of de-

pa r tu r e t h e o t h e r organs w e r e v i o l e n t l y dielodged

from t h e i r places. Thus pr+a i s c a l l e d Ayseya.

A descendant of Garga named Proud ~ P l & k i

proposed t o t each t h e king about Brahman. B u t h e

Page 18: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

se t fo r th only sane p r h a f a c i e conceptions of

Brahman. But t h e king already knew the being who

i s i n the sun, moon, l ightning. e ther , a i r . f i r e

water, t he looking-glass, t h e sound of foots teps

3 8 t h e quar te rs , shad- and i n t h e se l f . a l l these

re la ted t o the unconditioned Brahman. B u t Ajsta-

s a t r u a l s o knew the unconditioned Brahman. s o he

i&ructed ~ i l a k i i n r e tu rn about tha t . Saying

t h a t i n deep sleep. when the organs are absorbed,

the individual se l f i s merged i n t h e supreme se l f .

3 9 t he unconditioned Brahman When t h e self beco-

mes f a s t asleep. it is not aware of anything. it

remains l i k e a baby o r a g r e a t king, o r a worthy

Brahmans. having reached the very 1Mt of b l i s s .

AS a spider mwes along the thread o r a s from a

f i r e l i t t l e sparks sca t t e r . j u s t so, the se l f

i s sue a l l organs, a l l worlds a l l gods and a l l

l iv ing being. Its secret name i s Truth of Truth

Page 19: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

THE PUZZLlE OF TRANSMIGRATION

The IJpani?ad descr ibes the process of t rans-

migration i n d e t a i l . After narrat ing the supreme

b l i s s , the experience of "I am Brahman*, upanisad

again disc!usa- the transmigration. A t t h e W e of

death the s e l f slowly withdraws i t s organs and

comes t o t h e heart. The organs a r e united With

t h e subt le body4', and with t h e revealed impre-

salons of the next body t h e s e l f depar ts through

some par t of t h e body. It i s accompanied by me-

d i t a t ion , work and previous imprassion. Just a s

a goldanith moulds new things with gold. eo the

se l f takes a body suited t o i ts past work. When

the r e s u l t s of pas t work a r e exhausted. the s e l f

re turns frcxn t h e other world t o t h i s world for

new work. Thus the man w i t h craving Tranmlgra- 4 2

t es . But he has no craving does not transmigrate . The organs of a person whose d e s i r e s a r e dissolved

Page 20: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

i n t he s e l f do not go anywhere. H e i s Brahman

and i s merged i n Brahman. When t h e d e s i r e s

t h a t abide i n t h e mind a r e gone, man becames

immortal. Like t h e l i f e l e s s lough of a snake,

t h e body of a knclwer of t h e s e l f i s c a s t e of f 43

A knower of t h e s e l f i s t h e r e f o r e never wer-

taken by thoughts of reward o r punishment f o r

having done good o r e v i l , nor by those of joy

o r compunction wer d u t i e s done o r l e f t undone 44.

A knower of t h e s e l f becomes con t ro l l ed , poss-

essed of f o r t i t u d e serene, f r e e from d e s i r e s ,

concentrated,, he sees t h e s e l f wi th in h i s body

and t h e un iverse a s h i s s e l f . H e Is f r e e £ran

a l l doubts arid e v i l s , ever b lessed and absolu-

4 5 t e l y f e a r l e s s

S 've taketu went t o t h e c o u r t of k ing Pra-

vahana t o shcw h i s learning. The king asked

Page 21: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

him f i v e ques t ions . The important of them a r e

(1) how people a f t e r dea th t ake t o d i f f e r e n t ways?

? ( 2 ) how they r e t u r n t o t h i s world ; ( 3 ) why t h e

next world :Ls never f i l l e d , though sanany people

d i e here 46? While man who win worlds through

s a c r i f i c e s , g i f t s and penance. The king obl iged

him by expounding t h e d o c t r i n e of t h e f i v e f i r e s -

of heaven, t h e r a i n god, t h i s world, t h e woman

and man. House-holders who know t h i s medi ta t ion

on t h e f i v e f i r e s and hermi ts who medi ta te wi th

f a i t h an Hi1:anyagarbha go t o Brahmaloka, from

which t h e r e i s no r e t u r n t o t h i s world. B u t

p r a c t i s e s s a c r i f i c e , g i f t s and penance Qravel

along t h e way of t h e manes t o t h e moon. Af te r

t h e i r p a s t work i s exhausted. they r e t u r n t o

world i s exhausted. they r e t u r n t o t h i s world.

They r o t a t e l i k e a c i rc le of t ransmigra t ion , till

Page 22: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

they a t t a i n t h e nor thern way of immediate l i b e -

r a t i on . While those who a r e ignorant of e i t h e r

way a r e born a s insects, moths and a l l t h e s e o f t .

4 7 b i t i n g c r e a t u r e s . ~t l a s t it le d s t o - perform t h e Brimanthakarma, ie . ceremony t o t h e

48 b i r t h of a g i f t e d son . GODS, DEMONS AND HUMAN B E I N G S

~ r a j a p a t i ' s sons w e r e of t h r e e k inds , t h e

gods, men and demons. They l i v e with t h e i r

f a t h e r Pra j i ipat i a s s tuden t s , p r a c t i s i n g con-

t inence . Af t e r f i n i s h i n g t h e i r term, t h e gods

sa id t o him rto t each us . H e t o l d them t h e s y l l -

ab le aDaa49. P ra jSpa t i asked i t s meaning. The

gods understand t h e meaning "con t ro l yourselves".

The gods a r e t h e i n h a b i t a n t s of happy re-

gions. They ga in t hose r eg ions a s t h e reward of

Page 23: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

v i r t u e f o r them t h e p e r s u i t of p leasures beco-

mes t h e bus iness of l i f e . Unless they a v a i l

themselves: of t h e super io r opper tuni ty w a i -

l a b l e t h e r e t o a t t a i n t h e knowledge of Brahman.

T o them p leasure was t h e enemy and t h e c o n t r o l

of t h e senses was t h e i r a l l y they mean 'da l

5 0 means damyata . The nien understood t h a t 'da ' means ' d a f t a s

Man always su f f e r ed s e l f i s h n e a s they understood

t h a t t h e t.rue g iv ing i s not t h a t which a man

leaves i n h i s w i l l a s what he has acquired and

accumulated by a l i f e t i m e of prudence, but t r u e

g iv ing i s t h e g iv ing of onese l f .

LastlLy t h e demons understood t h e meaning

' dam i s 'I)ayathvam9 ' thou sha l f be c a p a s s i o -

nate" Each one f e l t t h a t he had made himself

Page 24: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

i n h i s w m : n i n d i v i d u a l i t y by h i s l ack of cm- 5 1

passion

ie. da, da, da means s e l f con t ro l , c h a r i t y

and compassion.

SYMBOLISM - symbols a r e used i n t h e Upanisads which i s

on a par w i th modern symbolic l i t e r a t u r e . A

good example i s t h e horse s a c r i f i c e i n BrhadSr-

apyaka . A . l l ma t e r i a l and non-material o b j e c t s

a r e symbolised i n a horse. Here t h e horse i s

a universa.1 power. Manifestat ions, s t r eng th .

f o r ce and speed a r e d i f f e r e n t formulat ions of

consciousn~ess. In anc ien t t i m e ~ d v a come i n

va r ious names Haya and VSji. Haya i s one of

de l igh t fu l . and sw i f t mwement. V B j i i s t h e

horse of p l e n t i f u l s t r e n g t h and fo r ce and

c a r r i e s gandharvZs of joy, beauty and easb.

As'va i s t h e f i g h t e r fo rce . Thus m a t e r i a l

Page 25: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

and non-material o b j e c t s i n t h i s w ~ r l d a r e

superimposed on a Horse. ~ r u l y it i s a Sacr i -

f i c e without t h e performance of i t . The Adva i s

a mystic represen ta t ion . I t i s a po t raya l of t h e

poe t i c beauty of t h i s Upanisad. The fundamental

conception of! t h e Atman d o c t r i n e appears i n Sym-

b o l i c a l g a i s e and w e should be disposed t o t r a c e

i n a l l e g o r i c a l specu la t ions of t h i s na ture , t h e

e a r l i e s t o r i g i n of t h e Upanisad doc t r ine .

ALNKARAS

~ l a n k ~ l i r a s ( f i g u r e s of speech) are p o e t i c a l

advices t o make l i t e r a r y works a t t r a c t i v e t h e

readers and Learers. They a r e of two types - (1) S'abdalankara, which r e l a t e s t o t h e meaning ( i d e a

experessed). AnuprSsa ( A l l i t e r a c t i o n ) of t h e

f i r s t ca tegory and ~pama(s imi1e) . Rilpaka (metap-

h o r ) , UtprGksa ( ~ a n c y ) . ~ t i d a y o k t i ( ~ y p e r b 0 1 e ) .

etc, of t h e second a r e seen i n t h e Brhadsr-

anyaka. .

Page 26: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

Anuprasa ( A l l i t e r a t i o n )

Repet i t ion of sounds t o g ive phonetic

beauty t o a l i t e r a r y work i s c a l l e d AnuprBsa,

sometimes a s i n g l e sound i s repeated , sometimes

a group of sounds, sometimes a word and s o m e t i m e s

a group of words. Verbal s i m i l a r i t y i n s p i t e of

5 2 t h e difference! i n vowels i s a l s o Anuprasa . In Brhadaranyakopanisad w e f i n d examples l i k e t h e

following:

dve vZva b rahma~o rupe m u r t a m daivam-

u r t a n da martyam damrtam . c a s th i t am c a ya dda

, , 53, sadda tyacca

Sa yatha sarvaq&nap%n samudra evayata-

nam, evam sarvesam spa r sham tvagEvZyatanam,

5 4 evam sarvesan gandhzn-am nas ike evayatanam .

52. nnuprzlsa sabdasamyam vaisamye'pi svara- syapat-SD.X.~

53. B U . I I . i i i . 1 .

54. U U . I I . i V . 1 1 .

Page 27: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

When s i m i l a r i t y of something desc r ibed

w i t h a n o t h e r wel l -kna in t h i n g isshown, t h e

f i g u r e of speech i s Upama, To show t h e ve ry

s u b t l e n a t u r e of t h e n e r v e s known as H i t a s ,

t h e y a re cornpared t o t h e h a i r s p l i t i n t o a

thousand.

t a v?. a s , y a i t a l - I i t a nama nadyo y a t h a k e g 5 5

s a h s a 1.asradha bhinn?istSvataqimna t i s t h a n t i

When something i s compared w i t h mgny

o b j e c t s , t h e r e 1.s mSlopama(chain s i m i l e ) 5 6 . In

t h e BrhadSranyak;Z t h e s u b t l e body i s canpared

w i t h a c l o t h dyed w i t h turmeric, g r e y s h e e p ' s

wool, t h e insec t . c a l l e d Indragopa, a flame of

f i r e , a w h i t e l o t u s and a f l a s h of l i g h t n i n g .

Page 28: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

t a sya ha i t a sya purusasya rClpam

yatha maharajanam vasah, ya tha

pandvavikam, yathendragopah, yathagnyarih

57 yatha pundarIkarn, ya tha sakrdvidyut ta . When t h e meaning of a sentence i s l ikened

t o t h e riieaning o'f another sentence, t h e figu-

re of speech i s VakyZrthoparna according t o

5 8 Dandin . The Brhadaranyaka c o n t a i n s s eve ra l

examples of t h i s l i k e t h e fol lowing :

sa yatha rnahZrZjo janapadan

g r h i t v a sve janapade yathakkam

parivart.etevarnevai?a e ta tp ravan

g r h i t v a sve s a r i r e yathakamam

5 9 p a r i v a r t a t e .

57. BU.II.iii .6.

58. Kavyadairsa 11.43.

59. hU.il.i.18.

Page 29: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

upa aka (Metaphor)

"hen an ob j ec t compared and t h e ob jec t t o

which it i s l ikened a r e descr ibed a s i f they

6 0 a r e i d e n t i c a l , then t h e r e i s metaphor , e.g

tasyah prana rsabho mano va t s ah

( h e r v i t a l f o r c e i s a b u l l and mind,

6 1 a c a l f ) . i s t y u r v a i tamo jyotiramFtam62 (Death

i s indeed darkness, and immorta l i ty i s light 3

UtprGksa (Fancy)

When an ob j ec t i s fancied a s i f it w e r e -6 3 another , t h e f i g u r e of speech i s Utpreksa . e.g

60. VisayyabhedatadriipyaranjSnani vaisayasya yatrupakam ......... Kuvalayananda

6 3 . bhavet sambhavanotpreksa prakr tasya pa rz t - mans - S D . X . ~ ~ .

Page 30: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

ya t r a h i dvaitamiua bhava t i t a d i t a r a

6 4 i t a r a n ~ j i g h r a t i . . . . ~ t i s ' a y o k t i (Hyperbole)

An exaggerated statement i s At i s ' ayok t i e.g.

Indro rnayabhih pururupa i j a t e 6 5

( Indra moves wi th many forms through h i s maya)

Ullekha (Manifold d e s c r i p t i o n )

When something is descr ibed i n d i f f e r e n t 66 ways, t he f i g u r e of speech is Ullekha @.g,

dkf tsno h i s a pra?annGva pravo

nama bhavat i , vadan vak, pasyarhsdaksuh,

6 7 srnvan drot rah: , manvsno rnanah . . .

6 6 . ekasyanekadhollekho yah s a u l l ekha udyate- SD.X.37.

Page 31: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

Sasandeha (doubling )

When t h e r e i s a poe t i c , doubt of something

described a s t h i s o r t h a t , then t h e r e i s t h e

6 8 f i g u r e of speech c a l l e d sasandeha e.g,

tasrnin suklamuta nilamahuh

6 9 pingala in haritam lohitam da .

Drstanta ( b a g i n a t i o n ) . . When an ob j ec t o f idea descr ibed i s shown

w i t h another ob j ec t o r idea resembling an o b j e c t

and i t s re£ l ec t ed image, t h e f i g u r e ' of speech

i s VfstSnta.e.g.

ya tha sminn~kzde &yeno v s suparno vs

v i p a ~ i p a t y a drantah samhatya paksau sGlayameva

dh r iya t e , evemevsyarn purusa etasrna antaya dhava ?P

68. sandehah prakrteranyasya sainsayah prot ibh- o t t h i t a h - SD:X.~S

Page 32: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

Parikara (paraphernalia)

If purposeful adjectives are used to

q u a l i t y a word expressive of the main idea in

the ci,ntext, then the figure of speech is

parika e.g,,

ekadhaivZnud~astavyametadaprameyamdhruvam

virSj5h pSrZ akHs3daja Ztnla mahHn dhruvah 7 1

Here Brahman is qualified by the adjectives apra-

meya (incomprehensible) dhruva (permanent) aja

(unborn) etc.

Virodhabhzsa (paradox)

Where a statement contains apparently oppo- 7 2

site ideas, the figure of speech is virodhabhasa .

72. SD. X . 3.

Page 33: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

a t r a p i t a 'pi tabhavat i . mata 'mZta, 7 3 loka alolcah ...

Anyonya (Mutual i ty)

When two o b j e c t s a r e mutually causes i n rel-

a t i o n t o some event , then w e have t h e f i g u r e of

7 4 speech Anyonya e.g.

i y m p r t h i v i sarves% bhutSnZn madhu,

75 asya i prthllvyai sarvani bhiitgni madhu . -

The f i g u r e of speech Vibhavana i s def ined

a s t he happening of something i n s p i t e of t h e

74. anyonyamubhayorekakriyayFih karanam mithah SD.X.73.

Page 34: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

7 6 absence of i t s cause e.g.

n a t a t r a r a t h a na ra thayoga na

panthallo bhavani a t h a r a t h a n ra thayogan pa thah 7 -

KSvyaliAga ( P o e t i c c a u s e )

When some even t i s e s t a b l i s h e d by c i t i n g a

78 cause . t h e f i g u r e of speech i s Kavyal inga . e.g.

r n a n a ~ a i v ~ ~ n u d r a s t a v y a m neha nSnZs t i kific'ana S .

7 9 rnrtyoh s a rnrtyumapnoti ya i h a nzneva p a k y a t i .

As Manudev Bandhu describes, t h r e e gunas

Page 35: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

a r e seen i n t h e ByhadZranyaka Upani5ad 80. . t h e y a r e Ma7hurya ( s w e a t n e s s ) , Ojas ( f e r e e f u l n -

e s s ) , and PrasSda ( P l e a s a n t n e s s ) .

16d hury a

C~~rnbinat . ion of words w i t h o u t t h e sounds c, $h, da, <h i s t h e main c h a r a c t e r i s t i c of ~ a d h u r y a ,

F i n a l rrasal sounds, r and Q are s u g g e s t i v e of t h i s

8 1 guna . The Urhadaranyaka c o n t a i n s examples l i k e

a t r a p i t a p i t a b h a v a t i rnata m 5 t a l okz a l o k z

-82 deva adeva .

Words w1t.h combinat ion of f i r s t and second

o r t h a t and f o u r of consenant series (Vargae)

80. Bandhu. Op.cit.PP.203-205.

81. SD.VIII.l . 82. BU. IV. iii. 22.

Page 36: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

and t h e sounds f , <h, d, dh, S and s a r e sugge- . . 8 3 s t i v e of Ojas ( fo rce fu lnes s ) . A s example.

Bandhu quotes

sa va esa devataitasam devatanam papnanam

84 mrtywnapahatya ya t rasau disamantasted jamayancakara .

Expression of i deas w i t h words which g ives t h e

meaning a t t h e very moment of hearing i s the

85 c h a r a c t e r i s t i c of Prasada . e.g.

a sa to rnZ sadgamaya

tarnaso mZ jyotirgamaya

86 mrtyormz ' m f t a m gamaya .

Page 37: IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISADshodhganga.inflibnet.ac.in/bitstream/10603/493/10/10... · 2012-01-18 · CHAPTER IV LXTERAFS ASPECTS IN BW~XR~YAKOPANISAD Though Upanisada are philosophical thoughts

~i t i . Dhavani. Rasa

Bandhu h a s t r i e d t o show t h a t some p a s s a g e s

i n t h e Rrhadalanyaka are examples of t h e iti is 87 ( S t y l e s ) namely, vaidarbhj. , g a u g i and p Z n c a i

H e h a s a l s o made e f f o r t s t o e s t a b l i s h t h e r e is

Dh ,vani ( s u g g e s t i v e s e n s e ) i n a few s t a t e m e n t s

i n t h e Upanisad and t h e r e i s S a n t a r a s a a t one

p l a c e . It r e q u i r e s much e f f o r t on t h e p a r t of

a c r i t i c t o e x p l a i n t h e e x i s t e n c e of such p o e t i c

p r i n c i p l e s i n a consp icuous way i n t h e Upani5ad.

However, t h e f a c t t h a t w e f i n d a t l e a s t t h e

t r a c e s of t h e r e i n t h e most a n c i e n t Upanigad

i s i n t e r e s t i n g .

87. Bandhu. Op.cit.P.105-106.