in the bibliogr aphic cloud · bibliogr aphic cloud connecting the data with the liter ature....

60
Semantic e - Science in the Bibliographic Cloud Connecting the data with the literature

Upload: others

Post on 28-Jul-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Semantic e-Sciencein the

Bibliographic Cloud

Connecting the data with the literature

Page 2: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Semantic e-Sciencein the

Bibliographic Cloud

Connecting the data with the literature

Page 3: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Semantic e-Sciencein the

Bibliographic Cloud

Connecting the data with the literature

Page 4: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Semantic e-Sciencein the

Bibliographic Cloud

Connecting the data with the literature

Page 5: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Connecting the data with the literature

(using Linked Data)

Image: ariz, http://flickr.com/photos/ariz/

Page 6: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Linked Data

Linked Data is about using the Web to connect related data that wasn’t previously linked, or using the Web to lower the barriers to linking data currently linked using other methods. More specifically, Wikipedia defines Linked Data as “a term used to describe a recommended best practice for exposing, sharing, and connecting pieces of data, information, and knowledge on the Semantic Web using URIs and RDF.”

Page 7: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Linked Data

Linked Data is about using the Web to connect related data that wasn’t previously linked, or using the Web to lower the barriers to linking data currently linked using other methods. More specifically, Wikipedia defines Linked Data as “a term used to describe a recommended best practice for exposing, sharing, and connecting pieces of data, information, and knowledge on the Semantic Web using URIs and RDF.”

Page 8: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Documents

★ A global filesystem

★ Designed to be human-readable

★ Documents are primary objects

★ Links are between documents

★ Link semantics are implicit

Page 9: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Documents

Page 10: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of DocumentsProblem:

How are these documents related?

??? ??????

Page 11: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Documents“What’s the favorite recording

artist of all famous people born in the city of West Lafayette who are

depicted in this photo?”

Image: Michael Stephens, http://flickr.com/photos/mstephens7/

Page 12: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Limitations

★ Disconnected data (many silos)

★ Lack of structure

★ Duplication across documents

★ Difficult to integrate documents

★ Can’t execute complex queries

Image: zoomzoom, http://flickr.com/photos/zoomzoom/

Page 13: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Linked Data Principles

★ Use URIs as names for things.

★ Use HTTP URIs so people can look up those names.

★ When someone looks up a URI, provide useful information.

★ Include links to other URIs so they can discover more things.

Image: skipnclick, http://flickr.com/photos/13888282@N02/1478585501/

Page 14: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

★ A global database

★ Designed to be machine-readable

★ Primary objects are things

★ Links are between things

★ Link semantics are explicit

Page 15: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Page 16: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

Page 17: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Page 18: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

Page 19: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Page 20: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

Page 21: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Page 22: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

Page 23: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Page 24: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

Page 25: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

Browsers

Page 26: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

Browsers Mashups

Page 27: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

Browsers Mashups Search Engines

Page 28: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Web of Data

Thing Thing Thing Thing

related related related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

related

Thing

Linked data opens silos,enabling data integration,

network effects,and interoperability.

Browsers Mashups Search Engines

Page 29: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

★ Started in February 2007 by Chris Bizer and Richard Cyganiak

★ Project of the W3C SWEO

★ Publish datasets as Linked Data

★ Interlink all the data

★ Develop apps that consume it

★ A grassroots effort to bootstrap the emerging web of data

Linking Open Data Project

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

Page 30: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

★ MIT

★ University of Southampton

★ DERI

★ U Penn

★ BBC

★ OpenLink

★ Talis

Linking Open Data ProjectParticipating organizations:

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

Page 31: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

May 2007

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

Page 32: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

July 2007

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

Page 33: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

August 2007

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

Page 34: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

September 2007

Page 35: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

Page 36: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

“What’s the favorite recording artist of all famous people born in the city of West Lafayette who are depicted in this photo?”

Page 37: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

“What’s the favorite recording artist of all famous people born in the city of West Lafayette who are depicted in this photo?”

Page 38: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

“What’s the favorite recording artist of all famous people born in the city of West Lafayette who are depicted in this photo?”

Page 39: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

“What’s the favorite recording artist of all famous people born in the city of West Lafayette who are depicted in this photo?”

Page 40: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

“What’s the favorite recording artist of all famous people born in the city of West Lafayette who are depicted in this photo?”

Page 41: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

LOD Growth

Image: Richard Cyganiak, http://richard.cyganiak.de/2007/10/lod/

“What’s the favorite recording artist of all famous people born in the city of West Lafayette who are depicted in this photo?”

Page 42: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Linked Data & Science

★ Ability to query across disparate datasets as if they were integrated & locally available

★ Ability to construct arbitrarily complex search queries

★ Ability to “follow your nose” through links to data you may not have known existed

Image: frankz, http://flickr.com/photos/frankz/

Page 43: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Queries of the Future★ Find data representing the state of

the neutral atmosphere anywhere above 100km and toward the Arctic circle (above 45° North) at times of high geomagnetic activity.

★ ... peer-reviewed papers that incorporate those data?

★ ... other datasets used by authors of those papers?

★ ... by authors of all cited papers?

Image: Jim Grant, http://flickr.com/photos/jimgrant/

Page 44: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Semantic e-Science Efforts

★ IVOA / SKUA

★ VSTO

★ SESDI

★ SWEET

★ GEON

★ Lots of biomedical stuff

Screenshot: SKUA project, http://www.myskua.org/

Page 45: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

A Slight Problem

★ The graph of linked science data is sparse

★ Violates Linked Data principle #4

★ Using RDF improves interoperability, but datasets are still not well connected

★ This makes discovery a challenge

Image: Mike Giovinazzo, http://flickr.com/photos/mike_giovinazzo/

Page 46: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

e-Science Needs Hubs★ Like many network structures,

linked data graphs tend to develop a few “hubs” that are well-connected

★ These hubs create links between data that would otherwise remain disconnected

★ In LOD: DBpedia, FOAF profiles, Geonames

Image: Cobalt, http://flickr.com/photos/cobalt/

Page 47: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

e-Science Needs Hubs

Page 48: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

e-Science Needs Hubs

Page 49: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

e-Science Needs Hubs

Page 50: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

The Point

Image: dulcelife, http://flickr.com/photos/dulcelife/

Library datacan provide the hubs

for a networkof linked scientific data.

Page 51: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

★ Catalog records, authority files, controlled vocab, publisher data

★ Links exist, but not yet machine readable

★ Reference librarians know this from experience

★ Not a new concept (Semantic Association Networks)

The Point

Image: dulcelife, http://flickr.com/photos/dulcelife/

Page 52: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

★ Catalog records, authority files, controlled vocab, publisher data

★ Links exist, but not yet machine readable

★ Reference librarians know this from experience

★ Not a new concept (Semantic Association Networks)

The Point

Image: triplefivedrew, http://flickr.com/photos/triplefivedrew/

Page 53: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

★ Catalog records, authority files, controlled vocab, publisher data

★ Links exist, but not yet machine readable

★ Reference librarians know this from experience

★ Not a new concept (Semantic Association Networks)

The Point

Image: metimbers2000, http://flickr.com/photos/metimbers2000/

Page 54: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Library as Linked Data Hub

VSTO

SKUA

VPIN

Linkhub

bio2rdf

combe-chem

Page 55: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Library as Linked Data Hub

LCSH LOCAuthorities

Worldcat

MESH

FedoraPACS

Pubmed

Topaz/Kowari

VSTO

SKUA

VPIN

Linkhub

bio2rdf

combe-chem

Page 56: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Library as Linked Data Hub

We need a Linking Open Data projectfor library data.

Page 57: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Who’s Working On It?

★ ADS - data linking

★ NLP / text mining

★ Manual indexing

★ Publisher-supplied metadata

★ Microsoft and Google

★ Publishers (Nature, Elsevier, PLoS)

Screenshot: International Virtual Observatory Alliance, http://www.ivoa.net/

Page 58: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

What About Librarians?★ NSDL Metadata Registry

★ DCMI/RDA Joint Task Group

★ OAI ORE

★ LCSH in SKOS @ LoC

★ Bibliographic Ontology

★ OpenLibrary

★ Semantic repositories

★ Semantic MARC @ Talis

Screenshot: Open Library, http://www.openlibrary.org/

Page 59: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Get Involved★ http://metadataregistry.org/

★ http://dublincore.org/dcmirdataskgroup/

★ http://www.openarchives.org/ore/

★ http://lcsh.info/

★ http://bibliographicontology.com/

★ http://openlibrary.org/

★ http://www.fedora-commons.org/

★ http://tinyurl.com/639pp4 (Rob Styles)

Page 60: in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud · Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature. Semantic e !Scienc e in the Bibliogr aphic Cloud Connecting the data with the liter ature

Thanks!★ http://metadataregistry.org/

★ http://dublincore.org/dcmirdataskgroup/

★ http://www.openarchives.org/ore/

★ http://lcsh.info/

★ http://bibliographicontology.com/

★ http://openlibrary.org/

★ http://www.fedora-commons.org/

★ http://tinyurl.com/639pp4 (Rob Styles)

[email protected]