in the high court of south africa · 1a v m woodcook vs min of police prefdate no file np 71154/11...
TRANSCRIPT
IN THE HIGH COURT OF SOUTH AFRICA
(GAUTENG DIVISION, PRETORIA)
PRETORIA THIS 3RD
DAY OF NOVEMBER 2017
FRIDAY
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GA AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JORDAAN IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY
IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM MASHUPHE CC 156/16
IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOSOPA AJ
Page 2 of 21
CRIMINAL TRIALS
IN COURT GC AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JORDAAN
IN COURT Gga AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TOLMAY
IN COURT GB AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAM
IN COURT GD AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOSOPA AJ IN COURT 4E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE POTTERILL THE STATE VS GUMBI CC 49/08
URGENT COURT
IN COURT A PALACE AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE IN COURT 6E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES
Page 3 of 21
CRIMINAL APPEALS
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAUMELA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEWENHUIZEN BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE THOBANE
Name of Advocate for the state: Van der Merwe
No. Case no. Name of appellant
1. A132/17 M Shabangu + 4
2. A233/17 T Netshifefhe
3. A552/16 W Hove
LAW SOCIETY MATTERS
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANGATA
LAW SOCIETY VS MATHILDA IGNATIUS OLIVIER (WESLEY) 78154/16
LAW SOCIETY VS JOHANNES JURGENS BEZUIDENHOUT 71880/16
Page 4 of 21
ADMISSIONS
IN COURT 4C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MABUSE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANGATA
1. K. RAMONTJA ATT 47338/17
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAUMELA BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEWENHUIZEN
2. H. E TAKALANI ADV 59814/17
3. T. W SIHLANGU ADV 62859/17
4. Z. E S NTULI ATT 66506/17
5. Z. MSIMANGA ATT 66128/17
6. N. N M MKHUMBUZA ATT 47388/17
UNOPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT 2A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VAN DER WESTHUIZEN IN COURT 2B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HOLLAND –MUTER IN COURT 2C AT 9;00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VAN DER SCHYFF AJ
Page 5 of 21
OPPOSED MOTIONS
IN COURT4G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PRINSLOO IN COURT 6D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE DE VOS IN COURT 8D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MUDAU J IN COURT 8A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PIETERSEN AJ IN COURT 8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE PHIYEGA AJ
JUDGMENTS
IN COURT 8G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE VAN NIEKERK AJ T R MAIDI / THE STATE
CASE NO: A43/17
K J MOLOI / THE STATE
CASE NO: A862/14
A MOHLATH / THE STATE
CASE NO: A884/16
F NGWENYA / THE STATE
CASE NO: A372/16
Page 6 of 21
T KHUBEKA / THE STATE
CASE NO: A881/16
A K SHONGWE / THE STATE
CASE NO: A876/16
IN COURT 4A –AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE MADAM JUSTICE JANSE VAN NIEUWENHUIZEN
1. Case No: A805/2015: Albert M Futshane v The State
JUDGMENTS
IN COURT 8A AT 09:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE ACTING JUSTICE RAUTENBACH
E-TRAVEL (PTY) LTD vs AMADEUS IT GROUP SA & ANOTHER (74849/2016)
RENTWORKS AFRICA v. MEC, DEPT OF INFRASTRUCTURE (38522/12)
IN COURT 8A AT 09:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAUTENBACH AJ CASE NO.: 50776/2016
Page 7 of 21
HEROLD LEE DE KOCK APPLICANT VS JOAN CYNTHIA GRIESEL N.O. & OTHERS 1st to 9th RESPONDENTS
IN COURT 4D AT 10:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS
TSOGO INVESTMENT HOLDING CO (PTY) LTD VS MO MOROENYANE 47194/16
IN COURT 6E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES
ANDRE LEON KRITZINGER Vs CHARMAINE MARY KRITZINGER CASE NO: 72228/2017
LEAVE TO APPEAL
IN COURT 8A AT 09:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAUTENBACH AJ CASE NO.: 73982/16 HERMANUS CHRISTOFFEL JOHANNES FLEMMING APPLICANT VS
Page 8 of 21
M.M.I. GROUP LIMITED RESPONDENT
IN COURT 4A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAUMELA J
Firstrand Bank Limited vs Luvhomba Legal Axe 67452/2015
JUDGEMENT
IN COURT 8A AT 09:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAUTENBACH AJ
CASE NO: 50776/2016
HAROLD LEE DE KOCK APPLICANT
VS
JOAN CYNTIA GRIESSEL N.O. & 8TH OTHERS 1st-2nd RESPONDENT
CASE NO: 28384A/2015
LINDIWE AUDREY NSUNTHA APPLICANT
VS
SAMKELO SIBAHLE MAZIBUKO RESPONDENT
IN COURT 8G AT 09:00
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE ACTING JUSTICE PHIYEGA
TECHNIQUE POWERFLOAT FLOORS (PTY) LTD vs ALBA VAN DER MERWE & ANOTHER
(48590/2017)
Page 9 of 21
LEAVE TO APPEAL
IN COURT 8D AT 9/30
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE Holland-Muter KENOSI M D EA Vs mofokeng L case no: 50196/2016 IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN SIPHO MALAZA +13 OTHERS VS MINISTER OF JUSTICE & CORRECTIONAL SERVICES +1 CASE NO: 52882/17
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
PART HEARD MATTERS
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
Page 10 of 21
IN COURT AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE
SPECIAL CIVIL TRIALS
IN COURT 6F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FOURIE IN COURT B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RAULINGA IN COURT 6B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MNGQIBISA THUSI IN COURT 4E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE POTTERILL IN COURT 6G AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TUCHTEN
3RD
COURT MOTIONS
IN COURT 6C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MAVUNDLA IN COURT 2D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE TLHAPI
Page 11 of 21
BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOTHLE BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE WRIGHT
CIVIL TRIAL DRAFT ORDERS
IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P
Page 12 of 21
A M L MABASO VS RAF 26450/15 B N J MADITSE VS RAF 29823/17 C A SEEDAT VS RAF 80437/14 D G M SEKWENA VS RAF 83035/15 E A P BUTHELEZI VS RAF 5489/16 F M L D MAUMELA VS RAF 6894/16 G L KHANYISWA VS RAF 52946/14 H N R GUMEDE VS RAF 26560/17 I M H SKHOSANA VS RAF 82153./15 J MATHONSI R VS RAF 37541/11 K V NEVHUTTALU VS RAF 75739/15 L V TSHALIBE VS RAF 8703/14 M M C ZEZULA VS RAF 9574/15 N P P MTETWA VS RAF 33163/15
CIVIL TRIAL ALLOCATIONS
IN COURT 8E AT 9:30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LEDWABA DJ P AA P T ZULU VS RAF P/P/30/10 26509/13
Page 13 of 21
BB S N MADONSELA VS RAF P/P/17/10 91367/15 CC S E MAKHATA VS RAF P/P/17/10 45505/13 DD L K TLOMATSANSA VS RAF P/P/25/10 22331/13 NP
IN COURT 6E AT 9;30 ROLL CALL BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE AP LEDWABA DJ
PRETORIA THIS DAY OF 3rd NOVEMBER 2017
1A V M WOODCOOK VS MIN OF POLICE PREFDATE NO FILE NP 71154/11
1. L BEKKER VS RAF 43768/16
2 DJ BESTER VS RAF MERITS 24489/15
3 MS MAHLANGU VS RAF NO FILE NP 57264/16
4 DS MYBURG VS RAF MERITS 68561/16
5 S NYAKU VS RAF MERITS 49617/16
6 JM ZIMU VS RAF MERITS 40419/16
7 SEKGOBELA MT VS RAF 66344/16
8 R MABOYA +1 OTHER VS RAF MERITS 37691/15
9 DG BUYS+1 OTHER VS RAF MERITS 6159/1+
10 ADV GIANNI VS RAF MERITS 31183/14
Page 14 of 21
11 R CHIKOMBA VS RAF MERITS 79410/15
12 C CHIPOKOSA VS RAF MERITS 90922/15
13 ADV MOGASWAI VS RAF 46776/12
14 WD SIBIYA VS RAF MERITS 66488/14
15 B MOLELE VS RAF MERITS 38580/16
16 RJ MOHALE VS RAF MERITS 91590/15
17. LL MOKOENA VS RAF NO FILE NP 35721/13
18 JF KHUMALO VS RAF MERITS 62471/13
19 SALMONS VS RAF NO FILE NP 67403/13
20 JD PRINSLOO VS RAF MERITS 54699/16
21 SH NGUBANE VS RAF MERITS 69657/16
22 MA SODINGA VS RAF MERITS 61415/16
23 BC DLAMINI VS RAF MERITS 43031/16
24 SN NDABA VS RAF MERITS 67219/16
25 CR VENTER VS RAF MERITS 27137/16
26 ZJ MOYENG VS RAF MERITS 61276/16
27 SC KHANYILE VS RAF MERITS 29845/15
Page 15 of 21
28 KM SETOKI VS RAF MERITS 26067/15
29 S CHETTY VS RAF MERITS 26222/16
30 OJ MOTEBE VS RAF MERITS 2876/16
31 FM MDLULI obo AM VS RAF MERITS 7564/16
32 BN MPHUTHI VS RAF 78018/14
33 XO SOROSHO VS RAF MERITS 68511/16
34 S RONA
VS RAF NO FILE NP 67353/16
35 L MOMPEI VS RAF MERITS 47567/15
36 J MMUSI VS RAF MERITS 37469/16
37 BG HODSON VS RAF MERITS 62707/16
38 M A LETHAMAGA VS RAF 77302/15
39 TJ PHOKA VS RAF MERITS 61969/16
40 OG POTSE VS RAF MERITS 40402/16
41 MANGWANE obo J TONDER VS RAF CERTIFICATE 34563/12
42 AT GOLEBAMANG VS RAF NO FILE NP 69753/14
43 RM MANAKA VS RAF CERIFICATE 2870/13
44 NXUMALO VS RAF CERTIFICATE 61802/12
Page 16 of 21
45 MJ MOLAODI VS RAF NO FILE NP 24153/15
46 GOLEBAMANG A TAKANG VS RAF 72982/14
47 VAN WYK VS RAF CERTIFICATE
78917/14+9268/1
7
48 MOGOROSI MA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 56404/14
49 A KHUMALO VS PRASA 63374/14
50 Nrb maboko VS RAF CERTIFICATE 58626/16
51 J M MMATLI VS RAF CERT 12543/15
52 TJ MALULEKE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 76580/13
53 SJ LEKULA VS RAF NO FILE NP 12145/14
54 JJ DE VILLIERS VS RAF NO FILE NP 72621/13
55 M CLEMONS VS RAF NO FILE NP 50544/14
56 J DUBE VS RAF CERTICICATE 99199/15
57 MR MOLAYA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 19181/14
58 SK TSHABALALA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 1639/13
59 DL MAPHOSA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 25765/13
60 R NINTERETSE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 29568/13
61 PA LOUBSER VS RAF CERTIFICATE 67319/15
Page 17 of 21
62 R LOUW VS RAF 82698/15
63 CA THOBI obo KE CHABANGU VS RAF CRTIFICATE 74853/13
64 J PRETORIUS VS RAF CERTIFICATE 28946/16
65 J MAKHUBELA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 81644/15
66 MMEBE S VS RAF CERIFICATE 1547/16
67 H SMITH VS RAF CERTIFICATE 16789/15
68 VAN DER WALT VS RAF CERTIFICATE DO NOT REMOVED
97369/15 NP
69 ML PHOGOLE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 68223/10
70 NM MABASA VS RAF CRTIFICATE 47928/11
71 NH JOHNSON VS RAF CERTIFICATE 26149/14
72 BJ MASIAPA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 13890/16
73 TJ MASOPOGA VS RAF CERTIFICATE 3197/16
74
R S MAGOLANE VS RAF CERTIFICATE 2557/15
75 MAKHATHU LJ VS RAF CERTIFICATE 79566/14
76 F KHOSA VS RAF CERIFICATE 69787/15
77 MAGWANA D VS RAF CERT 69025/12
78 H MARAIS P RAF CERTIFICATE 1884/15
Page 18 of 21
79 KT HUMP VS RAF
CERTIFICATE 35681/14
80 G G MASILELA VS RAF CERT 96804/16
81
N NGEMA GROOTVLEIBOERYDER
VS RAF 66811/15
82 B NCUBE VS RAF CIVIL REMOVED 64821/13
83 P L MOTLOUNG VS RAF NO FILE NP 16648/13
84 SK TSHABALALA VS RAF NO FILE NP 1639/13
85 B MAPHIKO
VS PRASA CIVILREMOVED 9811/11
86 FORMA BOUAANNEMERS VS
N MASONDO +61 OTHER CIVIL 34257/16
87 CHANGING TIDES VS L DE JAGER CIVIL 14139/15
88 NJ WALLACRE VS WALLACE & SEUNS CIVIL 41120/10
89
WAITERS INTERNATIONAL+1 OTHER VS
INDEPENDENT COMMUNICATION CIVIL
59491/14 NP
90 RAINBOW INV VS S THANTSA CIVIL 99301/15
91 GROOTVLEIBOEERDERY VS AGRICOL NO FILE NP 53698/15
92 B RAMPHOMANE VS BRITS VAN RHEEDE NO FILE NP 19603/16
93 TANA J MAGAGULA VS
CHIEF ALBERT LUTHULI MUN +2 OTHERS NO FILE NP 67946/13
94 M MOKONE VS RAF NO FILE NP 36202/14
Page 19 of 21
95 L M MOGARAMEDI VS RAF 47531/15
96 MD MAKAMU PRASA REMOVED 49799/14
97 MASIBA L VS RAF 90970/16
98 SS MABUZA VS T KHOZA NO FILE NP 24482/07
99 FNB VS JJ NAUDE CIVIL 27826/16
100 R J BRANDER VS RAF 89726/16
101 P R SEBOLA VS RAF 17624/15
102 JV MONA VS RAF CERT 36836/12
103 JJ MAZIBUKO VS RAF CERT CIVIL 56886/11
104 JM SITHOLE VS RAF CERT 42256/12
105 MODISE K A VS RAF 2868/13
106 R S CHAUKE VS RAF NO FILE NP 89711/16
107 M ESEREPO VS RAF 10002/16
108 I HANGUNE VS RAF 86198/16
109 P Z NYEMBE VS RAF 58860/15
110 XESIBE A T VS RAF 3482/16
111 CINDY NKUNA VS RAF 49794/13
Page 20 of 21
112 MAJOLA N R VS RAF 33558/16
113 SEKGOBELA VS RAF NO FILE NP 66344/16
114 SEROTO S VS RAF 82813/16
115 SS QWAQWA VS RAF 71946/14
116 H NKOSI VS RAF CERT 86964/14
117 S MAPHANGA VS RAF CERT 83409/14
118 H O BALOYI VS RAF 25195/16
119 D B JIYANE VS RAF 59810/16
120 T G MAREMANE VS RAF 74633/16
121 M BADENHORST VS RAF 22613/16
122 TP MOLIFI VS RAF 30361/15
123 C V MEYER VS RAF 20884/15
124 J S FICK VS RAF 86728/15
125 MASILELA S V VS RAF 90653/16
126 E S KHUMALO VS RAF 69037/13
127 K M MATSWETSWE VS RAF 85245/14
128 M ZIKALALA VS RAF NO FILE 37389/16NP
129 H P VAN DER MERWE VS RAF 67602/15
130 F M KULUMAN VS RAF 5052/16
131 K TR LEDWABA VS RAF NO FILE 68687/16NP
132 HLUNGWANI T VS RAF 27002/.15
133 RR MAGUBE VS RAF 100563/15
134 NKADIMENG M J VS RAF REMOVED 45311/16
Page 21 of 21
135 T O MOYO VS` RAF CERT 53374/16
136` CK MOSAGANE VS RAF CERT NO FILE 14128/16 NP
137 F M SEBAKA VS RAF MERITS 81333/16
138 L L LEPHERA VS RAF 866/17
139 MOLAODI M J VS RAF 24153/15
CIVIL COURT JUDGES
IN COURT A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RABIE IN COURT C AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE MOLOPA IN COURT 4F AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE RANCHOD IN COURT 4D AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE FABRICIUS IN COURT 4B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE BAQWA IN COURT 6A AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE KUBUSHI IN COURT 6E AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE HUGHES IN COURT 8B AT 10:00 BEFORE THE HONOURABLE JUSTICE LUKHAIMANE AJ
COURTS AVAILABLE