inclusilver european personalised nutrition strategy · the sacn concluded that the dietary...

40
This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349 Page 1 of 40 – European Personalised Nutrition Strategy – Helen Griffiths, Monique Raats, Dominick Burton, Chloe Wilmot University of Surrey

Upload: others

Post on 03-Jun-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page1of40

–EuropeanPersonalisedNutritionStrategy–HelenGriffiths,MoniqueRaats,DominickBurton,ChloeWilmot

UniversityofSurrey

Page 2: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page2of40

1. Introduction

Foodchoiceschangewithageandareinfluencedbymanyfactorsincludingchangingtaste,budgetaswellaslifestyle.Superimposedonfoodchoicefactors,arenutritionalrequirements;thesealsochangewithage.

Thisreviewgatherstogetherevidencethatmayinformdecision-makingtosupportnutritionforolderadults.Itincludesevidenceonnutritionalrequirementsforpeopleovertheageof65yearsweretheyaredifferentfromadultsingeneralandconsiderswhetherornottheserequirementsarebeingmet;theassociationbetweenlowernutrientlevelsandhealthoutcomesisconsideredforolderadults,althoughbecauseofthedesignofthesestudies,theevidencecannotimplythatrestoringanutrientlevelthatisdeficientinolderadultswillimprovehealthoutcomes;andfinallyweconsidertheeffectsofdietsthataresupplementedwithparticularnutrientswithininterventiontrialsonage-associatedhealthoutcomes.

Inundertakingthereview,weconsiderednutritionalevidenceaboutpeopleovertheageof65years.Historically,themajorityofstudieshaveincludedpeopleuptotheageof79years.In19601.4%ofEuropeanswereover80andreached4.1%in2010.By2060,11.5%ofEuropeansarepredictedtobeabove80yearsofage1.In2012,healthylife-expectancyforEuropeanmenwasfor61.2healthyyearsandforEuropeanwomenwas61.9healthyyears.Thereisa10yearvarianceacrossEuropeinhealthylifeyearsformencomparingWesternEurope(64years)withEasternEurope(54years).Thenumbersofandageswhenolderpeoplerequireandreceivecarevariesaccordingly.Veryfewnutritionalstudiesfocusonthepopulationover80yearsofageandonthoselivingincarehomes;wehaveidentifiedtheage-groupsandwhethertheyareindependentlylivinginthesectionsbelow.

2. Nutritionalrequirementschangewithage

Itisdifficulttogeneraliseabouttheenergyrequirementsofolderadultsbecauseofthevariationinhealthandmobility.Nevertheless,ittherequirementsarelikelytobethesameasyoungeradultsduringgoodgeneralhealthandwhenmobilityismaintained.However,intheoldestadultsandforthosewhohavemuchlessmobility,itishighlylikelythattheirphysicalactivitylevelswillbelower;consequentlytheirenergyrequirementwillbelower.TheScientificAdvisoryCommitteeonnutritionintheUKhasestimatedenergyrequirementsbasedonaverageage,sizeandmobility(Figure1)2.Thechangeinrequirementismoststrikingovertheageof65yearsandmostlikelyrelatestoslowermetabolismandlossofmuscle.

M a le F e m a le0

5

1 0

1 5

Es

tim

ate

d a

ve

rag

e e

ne

rgy

req

uir

em

en

ts (

MJ

/da

y) 1 9 -2 4

2 5 -3 4

3 5 -4 4

4 5 -5 4

5 5 -6 4

6 5 -7 4

7 5 +

Figure1.GenderandageeffectsonEstimatedAverageenergyrequirementsatcurrentmeanheightandBMI(22.5Kg/m2;2)

1Eurostat.ExtractedJune2017.Population structure and ageing 2ScientificAdvisoryCommitteeonNutritionDietaryReferenceValuesforEnergy2011

Page 3: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page3of40

AsimilarpictureisdescribedbyEFSAfortheEuropeanpopulationandseptuagenarianmenwithaveryphysicallyactivelifestylecouldhaveanenergyrequirementupto11.9MJ/d3.

IntheUK,totaldailyenergyintakeisestimatedas9.8MJ/dfortheaveragemanaged65-74ordroppingto9.6MJ/dforamanmorethan75years.Forwomen,totaldailyenergyintakeisestimatedas9.86MJ/ddroppingto9.6MJ/drespectively.

Ifenergyintakeismaintainedwithreducingenergyexpenditure,bodyfataccumulatesaroundtheorgansofthebody,withmuchlessinthesubcutaneousfatdeposits.Visceralbodyfatincreasestheriskfordiseasesliketype2diabeteswhichincreasesinprevalencewitholderadults.

Macronutrientrequirementsinpeopleover65years

Thedietaryproteinintakethatisneededbypeopleofdifferentagestomeettheirnitrogenbalancehasbeendiscussedextensivelyinthepublishedliterature.Thesafelimitforproteinintaketakesintoaccountthestudiesthathavelookedatwhetherrenalfunctioniscompromisedbyhighproteinintakeinolderadultsandthosethatareconcernedwithdelayingage-associatedmuscle-loss,sarcopenia,byincreasingdietaryproteintopromotemusclesynthesis.

TheWorldHealthOrganisationrecommends0.75gproteinperKgbodyweightperdayforolderadultsandisnothigherthanforadultsunder65yearsofage4.ThepopulationReferenceIntakesforproteinreportedbyEFSAare0.83g/dforadultsovertheageof60years3.

Somerecentstudiesthatuseadifferentmethodtostudyproteinrequirement,havesuggestedthattherecommendationcouldbeincreasedbyafurther25%inolderadultsandthereareanumberofstudiesthatareinvestigatingwhetherparticulartypesofdietaryproteinarebettertoincreasetherateofaminoacidaccretionintomuscle.

Carbohydratesareamajorenergysourceinthedietthataremadeupofthesameconstituents,carbon,hydrogenandoxygen,butcanbehaveinverydifferentwaysinthebody.The“free”sugars,mono-anddi-saccharides,provideareadyburstofenergy.Highintakeoffreesugarshasbeenassociatedwithincreasedriskforobesityandtype2diabetes.TheWHOextendedthedefinitionoffreesugarstoincludemonosaccharidesanddisaccharidesthatareaddedtofoodsandbeveragesbythemanufacturer,cookorconsumerandincludesugarsthatarenaturallypresentinhoney,syrupandfruitjuices(WHO,2015).TheUKgovernmentcommissionedaSACNreportofcarbohydratesandhealththatalsoreportedin20155.

TheSACNconcludedthatthedietaryreferencevaluefortotalcarbohydrateintakeofanaverageadultshouldbe50%oftotaldietaryenergyanddietaryintakeoffreesugarsshouldnotexceed5%oftotalenergy.Theaveragepopulationintakeofdietaryfibre6foradultsshouldbe30g/day.

FatsareamajorsourceofenergyforthebodyandalsoareimportanttocarrycertainvitaminsinthebloodsuchasvitaminA,D,EandK,andsomeothernutrientssuchascarotenoidswhichareonlysolubleinfat.Dietaryfatsarefoundinthreemajortypes;triglycerides,sterolssuchascholesterolandsmalleramountsofphospholipid.

Foradults,overallintakefordietaryfatinallitsformsshouldnotexceed35%oftotalenergyintake.

3https://www.efsa.europa.eu/sites/default/files/assets/DRV_Summary_tables_jan_17.pdf4WHO/FAO.ReportofaJointExpertConsultation.Proteinrequirementsofadults,includingolderpeople,andwomenduringpregnancyandlactation.Geneva(Switzerland):WHOPress;2007(UNUreport05123054).5https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/445503/SACN_Carbohydrates_and_Health.pdf6Fibre=carbohydratesthatarenotdigestedandnotabsorbedinthesmallintestineandarepolymersofthreeormoresubunits;andlignin

Page 4: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page4of40

Fattyacidsaretheconstituentoftriglyceridesandcanbegroupedintosaturated,monounsaturatedandpolyunsaturatedfattyacids.Manyofthesefattyacidscanbesynthesisedbythebodybuttwopoly-unsaturatedfattyacids(n-3andn-6)cannotbemadeefficientlyandareconsideredtobeessential.Theessentialn-3fattyacidisα-linolenicacidandtheessentialn-6fattyacidislinoleicacid.Then-3fattyacidsareconsideredtobeanti-inflammatoryandhavebeenthefocusofmanystudiesthathavesupplementedwithothern-3fattyacidssuchaseicosapentaenoicacid(EPA)anddocosohexaenoicacid(DHA).InstituteofMedicineGuidelineshavedefinedadequateintakesofn-3essentialfattyacidsandtheydonotdifferforadultsbetweenagegroups7.

TheInstituteofMedicinestatethatinsufficientinformationisavailabletoestablisharecommendeddailyintakeforn-3fattyacidsbutadequateIntake(AI)levelsareconsideredtobe1.6g/dformenand1.1gperdayforwomen.EFSAreportAIsof4%and0.5%oftotalenergyforLAandALArespectively3.

Trans-fattyacidsareproducedduringfoodprocessingandhavebeenassociatedwithnegativehealthoutcomes8.TheUKScientificAdvisoryCommitteeonNutritionrecommendsthataverageintakesoftransfattyacidsshouldnotexceed2%offoodenergy.

Micronutrientrequirementsinpeopleover65years

Thereferenceintakesforvitaminsdonotincreasewithagealthoughforsomee.g.forniacin,thereisaminorreductioninrequirementsbetweenyoungandolderadultsovertheageof50.Table1describesvitaminrequirementsforUKolderadultpopulations.ThedataiswascollatedbytheBritishNutritionFoundation9in2016.AttheEuropeanlevel,informationisavailableforadultsingeneralovertheageof18yearsbutnotforolderadults.

Gender Thiaminmg/d

Riboflavinmg/d

Niacinmg/d

VitB6mg/d

VitB12μg/d

Folateμg/d

VitCmg/d

VitAμg/d

Male 0.9 1.3 16 1.4 1.5 200 40 700Female 0.8 1.1 12 1.3 1.5 200 40 600

Table2–EuropeanFoodSafetyAgencyPopulationReferenceIntakes(PRIs)andAdequateIntakes(AIs)forvitaminsinadults

Gender Thiaminmg/d

Biotinmg/d

Niacinmg/d

VitB6mg/d

VitB12μg/d

Folateμg/d

VitCmg/d

VitAμg/d

Male 0.1 40 1.7 1.7 4 330 110 750Female 0.1 40 1.7 1.6 4 330 95 650AcomprehensivereviewofvitaminDintakeinolderadultswasincludedintheUKSACNreportonvitaminDandhealth10andconcludeswitharecommendedintakeof10μgdailyintakeformenandwomenintheUKover50yearsofage.Currently,intheUKtheaverageintakefromthedietaloneis3.3µgi.e.1/3oftherequirement.Forthosetakingsupplements,themeandailyintakeswere5.1µgvitaminDformenand5.2µgforwomen.Thisisapproximately50%oftherecommendedintakeforvitaminD.Itisclearthatthoseonlowerincomesandpeoplewhoarelivingincarehomesalsohavelowerintakes;incarehomes,meandailyvitaminDintakeformenwas3.9µgandwas3.4µgforwomenfromallsources.Similarrequirementsare7https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Omega3FattyAcids-HealthProfessional/#h2InstituteofMedicine,FoodandNutritionBoard.Dietaryreferenceintakesforenergy,carbohydrate,fiber,fat,fattyacids,cholesterol,protein,andaminoacids(macronutrients).Washington,DC:NationalAcademyPress;2005.8https://www.bda.uk.com/foodfacts/TransFats.pdf9https://www.nutrition.org.uk/attachments/article/234/Nutrition%20Requirements_Revised%20Oct%202016.pdf10https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/537616/SACN_Vitamin_D_and_Health_report.pdf

Page 5: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page5of40

alsoanticipatesforotherNorthernEuropeancountries,however,inFrance,vitaminDrequirementsarelowerinanticipationofefficientproductionintheskinthroughUVexposure.

PopulationReferenceIntakes(PRIs)andAdequateIntakes(AIs)forvitaminshavebeenreportedbytheEuropeanFoodSafetyAgencyforadultsingeneralratherthanforolderadultsspecifically.

Table3.DietaryreferencevaluesforvitaminD(μg/day)inEuropeancountriesforolderadults(adaptedfromSpiroandButtriss11)

Country AU BE FR IE ES CH TU NL UK EC IOM WHOVitaminDrequirement

20 15 5 20 10 20 10 20 10 10 10-15

10-15

TheNIHrecommendsanintakeof15mg(22.4IU)vitaminEperdayforadultsbutdoesnotspecifyanyage-dependencyinrequirements12.

ApartfromthemanystudiesthathaveconsistentlyshownthatvitaminDintaketendstobelowinolderadults,othervitaminintakerequirementsappeartobeadequatelymetthroughahealthybalanceddiet.

NutritionalintakemineralrequirementsforolderadultsintheUKhasbeenreportedbytheBritishNutritionFoundationandaresummarisedinTable3.

Table4.UKReferenceNutrientIntakesforMineralsforolderadults

gender calcium phosphorous magnesium sodium potassium iron zinc copper selenium iodineMen50+years

700mg/d

550mg/d 300mg/d 1600mg/d

3500mg/d

8.7mg/d

9.5mg/d

1.2mg/d

75μg/d 140μg/d

Women50+years

700mg/d

550mg/d 270mg/d 1600mg/d

3500mg/d

8.7mg/d

7.0mg/d

1.2mg/d

60μg/d 140μg/d

IntakesforpotassiumandmagnesiumaresignificantlyreducedinUKolderadultpopulationswhoarelivingindependently.Intakesofthesetwomineralsarealsolowerinolderadultswhoarelivingincare.TheUKreferencenutrientintakeforironisthesameinoldermenandwomen,andthisrepresentsareductionintherequirementforwomenwhoarepost-menopausal.

Table5.EFSAPopulationReferenceIntakes(PRIs)andAdequateIntakes(AIs)forminerals

gender calcium phosphorous magnesium manganese potassium iron Zinc* copper selenium iodineMen 950

mg/d550mg/d 350mg/d 3mg/d 3500

mg/d11mg/d

9.4-16.3mg/d

1.6mg/d

70μg/d 150μg/d

Women 950mg/d

550mg/d 300mg/d 3mg/d 3500mg/d

11mg/d

7.5-12.7mg/d

1.3mg/d

70μg/d 150μg/d

*Variesaccordingtophytate

11https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4288313/12https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/VitaminE-Consumer/

Page 6: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page6of40

Ingeneral,EFSAreferenceintakesformineralsaremarginallyhigherthanthespecificUKdatabutthesedatarepresentadultpopulationsasawholeandarenotreferencesforolderadults.

Phytochemicals

Thepreviousreviewshavefocussedonessentialnutrientsthatarefoundwithinfoodandforwhichknownfunctionshavebeenascribed.Foodoffersabenefitthatgoesbeyondtheindividualnutrientsbecauseofinteractionsbetweendifferentcomponentsandbecausetheratesofnutrientreleasefromdifferentfoodswillvary.Theconsumptionofphytochemicalssuchascarotenoidsandpolyphenolsthatarefoundwithinwholefruitsandvegetablesmayalsohavebeneficialeffectsonhealth.Asthesearenotconsideredessential,referenceintakelevelsarenotrequired.Anumbersofstudieshaveconsideredtheassociationbetweenphytochemicalintakeandhealthoutcomes,andthereareanumberofexamplesofdietaryinterventionstudiesthathaveincludedphytochemicals.PhytochemicalsareimportantcomponentsintheMediterraneandietandtheircontributiontooverallnutritionalqualityofnutsisreviewed13.

Foodversusnutrientenrichment

Nutrientsinthedietinteractinthewaythattheyareabsorbed.Forexamples,foodsthatarerichinphytateswillimpedezincabsorptionandforiron,absorptionisalsoinhibitedbyvitaminCandcalcium.Ironbioavailabilityforvegetariansisestimatedatbetween33-66%ofthatfornon-vegetarians.Othernutrientsactpositivelytogetherfortheirphysiologicalactivity;forexampleBvitaminswithfolateforDNAsynthesis;vitaminCandEforantioxidantfunction;andvitaminDandcalciumforbonehealth.Indeed,oneofthelimitstotheepidemiologicalassociationstudiesthatwehavereviewedinsection2isthattheytendtoreporttheassociationbetweenonenutrientandhealthoutcomesbutofcourse,thissinglenutrientismostlikelytohavebeenconsumedaspartofamixeddiet;othercomponentsinthedietactingeitheraloneorincombination,maycontributetoanoverallimprovementinhealth.Associationstudiesareretrospective,thereforeonlyindicativeandcanbehighlyvariable.Thestrongestevidenceforthevalueofanutrientordietforhealthoutcomesisachievedbyinterventionstudiesthataredesignedtotesttheeffectofnutrientordietonaspecificallydefinedhealthoutcomeinaprospectiveway.

Personalisednutritionforolderadults

Movingforwardfromgeneralisednutrientrequirementstopersonalisednutritioncaninvolvemanydifferentvariables.Theolderadultpopulationisveryheterogeneousandwillbeinfluencedintheirpersonalchoicesbymanydifferentfactors.Theconceptofconveniencemayoutweighnutritionalvalueforexampleinonepopulationwhereasanothermaybemotivatedtotryprotein-enriched,functionalfoodproducts.Understandingconsumerbehaviourwillbeanimportantfactorforthesuccessofpersonalisednutrition.

Arecentstudyhashighlightedhowpersonalisingnutritionatanindividuallevel,usingfoodsthatarereadilyavailable,canresultineffectivelifestylechangesthatincreasetheintakeofessentialnutrientssuchasfolate14.

Foractiveandhealthyolderadults,adequateenergyintakeandabalanceddietprovidingmacronutrientswithintherecommendedrangeswillmostlikelymeetthemajorityoftheirnutritionalneeds.Therewillbeseasonalityinrequirements,forexamplevitaminCintakebydietistypicallyhigherduringthesummermonthswhenmorefreshfruitandvegetablesareavailablebutcorrespondinglylowinthewinter.

13BrJNutr.2015Apr;113Suppl2:S79-93.doi:10.1017/S000711451400325014https://academic.oup.com/ije/article-abstract/46/2/578/2622850/Effect-of-personalized-nutrition-on-health-related

Page 7: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page7of40

Conversely,ironintakeandproteinistypicallyistypicallylowerduringthesummeraslessredmeatisconsumed.

Geographyandethnicityalsoplayanimportantpartinthenutritionalintakepatternsofotherwisehealthyolderadults,withPakistanimenandwomenlivingintheUKtypicallyconsuminglesscalcium15andhighlightaspecificcalciumrequirementforhealth.ThecapacitytomakevitaminDfromsunlightisalsoaffectedbyskinpigmentation.However,theprevalenceofvitaminDdeficiencyinolderadultslivinginEuropeaccordingtoethnicityisunclear,casesofricketswererecordedinmuchgreaterfrequencyinchildrenofSouthAsian,MiddleEasternorsub-SaharanAfricanbackground.IncreasingvitaminDintakeisbeingincreasinglyrecognisedasanimportantpublichealthgoal.Theaforementionedevidencepointstoethnicityasafactorinpersonalisednutrition.

Peoplewithlongtermconditionssuchashighbloodpressure,highcholesterolandtype2diabeteswhichincreaseinprevalenceinolderadults,havedietaryrequirementsforfoodsthatarelowerinfat,saltandrefinedsugars.Therearecertaingenotypesthatincreaseriskforthesemetabolicdiseases.Inthenearfuture,ariskcalculationbasedongenotypeforsuchlong-termconditionsislikelytoemergethatwouldencourageapersonalisednutritionapproachtoreducediseaserisk.OneofthefirstEuropeanstudiesthatusedgenomicinformationtoadviseindividualsontheirpersonalriskprofileandtodevelopanappropriateonnutritionalprogrammehasnowconcluded.Thestudyidentifiedthatpersonalisednutritionadviceresultedinparticipantsselectingamuchhealthierdiet,irrespectiveofwhetherthegenomicinformationwasused.Thissuggeststhatpersonalisednutritioncouldbeasustainablewaytoimprovehealth16.

Animportantconsiderationinfoodsforadultswithpoororalhealthanddentalproblemsistominimisemealsthatrequirechewingwhilemaintainingfibrousandproteincontent.Proteinenrichedfoodshavebeensuccessfullyusedinthehospitalsettingbutcost,tasteandscepticismfromconsumershasnothelpedwithwideruptake.

Nutritionalhealthmaybeaffectedbydrugtreatmentsthataffectappetite,absorptionandmetabolism.Conversely,somefoodsalsoaffectdrugmetabolism,mostnotablygrapefruitthatimpairstheactivityofacytochromep450metabolisingenzymesandsoincreasesbloodconcentrationsofdrugs.Thesefactorsareaddressedindrugsafetynotesthataccompanymedicines.

Theaforementioneddataassumesthatabsorptionofnutrientsisalsounaffectedalthoughifanindividualhasphysiologicalchangeswithageinge.g.ingastricacidsecretion,theabsorptionofBvitaminsmaybeimpairedhenceintakerequirementsmaybehigher.Inthiscase,thestateofanindividual’shealthwillimpactontheirpersonaldietaryrequirements.TheclinicalpractitionerwillassesswhetherthisisthecaseonapersonalisedbasisifanindividualpresentswithsymptomsofBvitamindeficiency.Inthiscase,themotivationtoincreaseaspecificnutrientwouldbehealth-relatedviaapharmacistratherthanlifestylechoicedependent.

Nevertheless,healthyolderadultsdoexperienceanage-relateddeclineinmanyphysiologicalsystemswithoutthedevelopmentofovertdisease.Thesystemsaffectedbyageincludetheimmunesystem,musculo-skeletalsystem,brainandmetabolicsystem.Theoutcomesofdecliningfunctionatthesystemslevelincludeincreasedsusceptibilitytoinfectionandtodevelopstrongvaccinationresponses,increasedriskoffallsandfractures,decliningcognitionandweightgain.Wehavereviewedtheevidenceforwhetheradequateorenrichednutritionassociateswithbetterphysiologicalsystemsfunctionsinpopulationsof

15http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1046/j.1365-277X.2003.00461.x/epdf16https://clinicaltrials.gov/show/NCT01530139

Page 8: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page8of40

healthyolderadults(Section3)andprovideastateoftheartreviewofevidencesupportingdietaryenrichmentorsupplementationonhealthyolderadults(section2).

Overall,successinadoptingpersonalisednutritioninanolderadultpopulationwillbetheresultofintegratingdifferentapproachestoimproveddietaryintakeofnutrients.Theseshouldtakeintoaccountanypersonalmonitoringdevicesthatanindividualhasforexistinghealthconditionse.g.forbloodsugarandbloodpressure,wearablesthatmonitoractivityandmobileappsthatoffercoaching.Togetherthesecouldhelptointegratelifestyleandmedicalvariablestoimprovetheperceivedimportanceofdietandcompliancewithhealthynutrition.

Page 9: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page9of40

Section2Systematicreviewofnutritionalinterventionstudiesinolderadults

Thefollowingsectiondescribesafocussedsystematicreviewofthoseclinicalstudiesthathavedeterminedhealthoutcomemeasuresinolderadultsfollowingnutrientordietaryenrichmentorsupplementationinordertounderstandanyvalueofnutritionforgeneralhealthandwell-being.ThereviewwasconductedinJulyandAugust2017.Alldatawasreviewedbytwopeopleindependently.

Searchstrategy

Bibliographicdatabasesweresearchedforrandomised,placebo-controlledtrialsinvestigatingtheeffectofnutrientsonhealthoutcomesinolderadults.Thesearchwasconductedbycombination(usingBooleanoperators)ofthesearchtermsintable2.1.Thefollowingdatabasesweresearched:PubMed,CochraneLibrary,WebofKnowledge,Controlled-TrialswebsiteandScienceDirect.Theexclusioncriteriawereasfollows:populationage<65years;animalstudies;andstudiesofindividualswithdiseaseonlyandnotofhealthycontrols.

Table2.1.Searchstrategyforsystematicreviews

Agecategory Food Outcomeolderadult vitaminA frailtyelderly thiamin musclestrengthseptuagenarian riboflavin immuneresponseoctogenarian niacin lifespannonagenarian folate longevitycentenarian dietary-protein cognitionpensionage, omega3fattyacid falls,

retirementage,polyunsaturatedfattyacid fractures

Geriatricmonounsaturatedfattyacid dentalhealth

seniorcitizen, iron infectionOAP, calcium bodyweightoldage magnesium potassium vitaminB6 vitaminB12 vitaminC vitaminD vitaminE fibre zinc MULTIVITAMINS

Page 10: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page10of40

Dataextraction

Forinvestigationoftheeffectsofnutrientsonhealthoutcomes,wefocussedonmeasuresofphysiologicalsystemsthatdeclinewithageratherthaneffectsonovertexistingdisease.TheageingsystemsthatweincludedasoutcomesinoursearchesaredescribedinTable1.Weextractedmeasuresoffunctionatbaselineandattheendofthenutritionalinterventionforboththecontrolandtreatmentgroups.Thefollowingparticipantcharacteristicswerenotedaspossibleconfounders:nutrientformandamountordoseconsumed,studyduration,numberofparticipantspergroup,participantagerange.Themethodologicalqualityofstudieswasassessedtoeliminatebiasbydropoutrateandcompliancewerepossible.Thethresholdlimitssetforthecriticalappraisalwerethatstudiesshouldberandomisedcontrolledtrials,withacontrolgroupandsingleblinding.Inadditionbothcomparatorgroupsmusthavebeensubjectedtoidenticaltreatmentanalysis.ThosestudiesmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaarelistedintheTables2.2etc.

Macronutrients

Fibreinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Onestudyonfibresupplementationinolderadultsthatmetinclusioncriteriawasidentified(Table2.2).Thereportedinterventionoutcomewasweightgain.Thestudynotedthatfibretreatmentswereeffectiveandreportednoincreaseinmeanbodyweightsfollowingfibreintervention(Baghurstetal,1985).Onestudyinhealthymenshowedthatincreasedfibreintakemaintainedbodyweight.

Proteininterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Fourstudiesthatfocusedondietaryproteinenrichmentwereidentified;oneofthestudiesrecruitedamalepopulationonlywithallstudiesusingage-groupsgreaterthan65years(Table2.3).Interventionoutcomeofthesestudiesincludemuscleloss,musclegainandskeletalmusclehypertrophy,physicalperformancefrailty.Onestudyconcludedthatadditionalproteinintakewasrequiredtoallowmusclemassgainduringexercisetraining in frail elderly people (Tieland et al, 2012b). Another study reported that timed proteinsupplementation immediatelybeforeandafterexercisedoesnot furtheraugment the increase in skeletalmuscle mass and strength after prolonged resistance-type exercise training in healthy elderly men whohabitually consume adequate amounts of dietary protein (Verdijk et al, 2009). Dietary proteinsupplementation improvedphysicalperformance,butdidnot increaseskeletalmusclemass infrailelderlypeople (Tieland et al, 2012a). Finally, a study on frailty reported that protein-energy supplementationadministeredtofrailolderadultswithlowsocioeconomicstatusshowedevidenceofreducingtheprogressionoffunctionaldecline(KimandLee,2013).Insummary,threeoutoffourstudiesshowedpositiveoutcomesofproteinsupplementationonfunctionalmusclestrengthormusclemassgain in frailolderadults.Onestudyinhealthymeanshowednoeffectofproteinsupplementationonmusclemassstrength.

Omega-3fattyacidinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Twelvestudiesinvolvingomega-3supplementationwereidentifiedasmeetinginclusioncriteria,oneofwhichfocusedonafemalepopulation,twoonmaleonlypopulationsandtheremainderweremixedgender(Table2.4).Sixofthestudiesrecruitedpatientsfromupwardsof50-64years.Theinterventionoutcomesrelevanttoourstudywerecognitionandall-causemortality.Onestudyhasyettoreport.Sixsmallerstudies(<100peopleanalysedineachstudy)ofomega-3fattyacidsupplementationinolderpeoplewereidentified;threestudiesrecruitedpeoplewithMCIandallfocusedoncognitionastheinterventionoutcome.Theinterventionhadpositiveimpactsoncognitionincludingimprovedlearningandmemoryinallcases(Boetal2015,Tokudaetal,2015,Strikeetal,2010,Leeetal,2011,Randanellietal,2012,Nilsonnetal2012).Onelargestudywith

Page 11: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page11of40

485participants,showedabenefit forcognitiveperformanceforpeopleof55years (Yurko-Mauro,2011).However,inthreeotherlargerstudiesomega-3fattyacidsupplementationnosignificanteffectsoncognitivedeclineover3yearsinelderlypeoplewithorwithoutmemorycomplaintswereobserved(Andrieuetal,2017,vandeRestetal,Dangour2010).ThesefindingsareconsistentwithasystematicreviewbyJiaoetalin2014andtheCochranesystematicreview(Sydenham,Dangouretal.2012)whichconcludedthattheavailabletrialsshowed no benefit of omega-3 PUFA supplementation on cognitive function in cognitively healthy olderpeople.

InaNorwegianpopulationatriskforcardiovasculardisease,astatisticallysignificantreductiononall-causemortalitywasobservedfollowingthreeyearsofomega-3supplementation(Einviketal,2010).

Insummary,inhealthyolderadultsthreeoffourlargeomega3interventionstudiesshowedneitherbenefitnor riskoncognitionandone large interventionstudyshowedpositivebenefit.A reduction inall-causemortality formenwithcardiovasculardisease riskwasobserved inone largeomega-3supplementationstudy.

Micronutrients

VitaminB6,B12andfolateinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

EightvitaminB12studiesinelderlypersonsthatmettheinclusioncriteriaforthisreviewwereidentified.Oneof the studies included vitamin B6, one study included omega-3 fatty acids and two included folatesupplementation (Table 2.5). Seven of the studieswere conducted on subject aged 65+,with one studyrecruiting participants from the age of 60;men andwomen participated in all studies. The interventionoutcomes were cognition, brain atrophy, bone mineral density, fractures, immune function and physicalperformance. TwoofthefourstudiesfocusedontheimpactofvitaminB12onbrainatrophyorcognitionreportedbeneficialsignificanteffects;andbothalsoincludedomega-3fattyacidsupplements(Walkeretal,2012)andonealso includevitaminB6supplementation(Jernerenetal,2015).Athird largestudyof2919participantsdidnotdescribeanycognitiveimprovementfromvitaminB12supplementationinhealthyolderadults(vanderZwaluwetal,2014).OtherstudiesconcludedthatvitaminB12supplementationhasnoimpactonbonemineraldensity,fractures,physicalperformanceandimmunefunctioninolderadults(Ennemanetal,2015,Wijngaardenetal,2014,Swartetal,2015,vanDijketal,2016).Insummary,inhealthyolderadultstwoofthreelargevitaminB12combinedwithomega-3fattyacidinterventionstudiesshowedbenefitoncognitionandonelargeinterventionstudyshowednoeffect.Noadverseoutcomeswerenoted.

VitaminCinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

ThreevitaminCsupplementationstudiesinelderlypersonswereidentifiedasmeetingtheinclusioncriteriafocusedonsubjectsagedmorethan60years(Table2.6).Onestudyrecruitedonlymaleparticipants. Theinterventionoutcomesmeasuredwerecognition,acuterespiratoryinfectionsandphysicalperformance.Withregard to cognition, vitaminC intakedidnot enhance cognitiveperformance in elderly personswithmildcognitiveimpairment(Naeinietal,2013).VitaminCwasshowntosignificantlyimproverespiratoryfunctionin thepresenceofacuterespiratory infection in individualswith lowvitaminCconcentrations (Huntetal,1994).HighdosageofvitaminCandEsupplementationwasshowntobluntcertainmuscleadaptationstostrengthtraininginelderlymen(Bjornsenetal,2015).Insummary,olderadultswithlowplasmavitaminCshowed benefit from supplementation whereas high dose supplementation with vitamin C and E hadnegativeeffectsonmuscletraining.

Page 12: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page12of40

VitaminDinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Thirteen vitaminD supplementation studies in elderly personswere identified (Table 2.7). Twelveof thethirteenstudiesusedsubjectsaged65+andonerecruitedpeopleolderthan60yearsofage.Threeofthestudiesrecruitedwomanonlyandonestudiedmenonly.Theinterventionoutcomesrelevanttothisstudywerecognition,falls,musclestrengthandfractures.OfthefourstudiesfocusedonvitaminDintakeandfalls,twosuggestedsuchinterventionwaseffectiveatreducingfalls(Imaokaetal,2016,Flickeretal,2005)andtwostudiessuggestvitaminDsupplementationwasnoteffective(Burleighetal,2007,Lathametal,2003).All four studies focusedon vitaminD intake and the incidenceof fractures; this didnotdemonstrate anypositiveimprovements(Lawetal,2006,Salovaaraetal,2010,Meyeretal,2002,RECORDtrialgroup,2005).Of the four studies focusedon the impactof vitaminD supplementationonmuscle strength, two studiessuggesteditwasinsufficientforimprovingmusclestrength(Kennyetal,2003,Janssenetal,2009),whereastwostudiessuggestedapositiveresponse(Moreira-Pfrimeretal,2009,Pfeiferetal,2008).OnestudyfoundnoassociationbetweenvitaminDtreatmentandtheincidenceofcognitiveimpairment(Rossometal,2012).Insummary,fouroutoffourteenvitaminDinterventionstudiesinolderadultsshowedpositivebenefitonhealthoutcomesandtenotherstudiesshowednobenefitandnoincreasedrisk.

VitaminEinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

FourvitaminEsupplementationstudiesinelderlypersonwereidentified(Table2.8).Threeofthefourstudiesusedsubjects65+yearsold,onestudywasconductedonmalesubjectsonlyandonestudyfocusedonfemalesonly.Theinterventionoutcomesincludedcognitionandimmunefunction.Inthepresenceoffishoil,vitaminEwasshowntoimproveimmunefunction(Wuetal,2006),whereasanotherstudyreportedthattherewasnoclearindicationofimprovedimmuneresponses(Parketal,2002).AstudyonriskforpneumoniaconcludedthatalthoughtheevidenceforthebenefitfromvitaminEtoreduceriskofpneumoniaisstrong,theoverallfindingsarecomplex(Hemila,2016).AnotherstudyreportedthatvitaminEdidnotprovidecognitivebenefitsinhealthyolderwomanafterfouryearsoffollow-up(Kangetal,2006).Insummary,twooutoffourvitaminEinterventionstudiesinolderadultsshowedpositivebenefitonimmunefunctionandtwootherstudiesshowednobenefitandnoincreasedriskforhealthoutcomes.

Multivitamininterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Fivestudiesthatfocusedonmultivitaminsupplementationinhealthyolderadultswereidentifiedasmeetingthestudyinclusioncriteria(Table2.9).Twostudiesrecruitedfemalesonly.Interventionoutcomesmeasuredincludecognition,nutritionandbonedensityandimmunefunction.Twostudiesoncognitionconcludedthatmultivitaminsupplementationhadnoimpactoncognitiveperformance(Woltersetal,2005,Harrisetal,2015)whereas another study suggested that combinedmultivitamins, mineral and herbal formulamay benefitworkingmemoryinelderlywomanatriskofcognitivedecline(Macphearsonetal,2012).Astudyfocusedonbonemineraldensityconcludedthatsupplementationhadapositiveeffectonbonedensity(Griegeretal,2009).Astudytoinvestigateimmunefunctioneffectsofmultivitaminandmulti-mineralsupplementationofolder people living at home did not show any improvement in self-reported infection related morbidity(Avenelletal,2005).Insummary,threeoutoffivemulti-vitamininterventionstudiesinolderadultsdidnotshowbenefitsorrisksfromsupplementation.Otherstudiessuggestsimprovedmemoryandbonedensityinatriskpopulation.

Calciuminterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Ninecalciumsupplementationstudiesinelderlypersonswereidentifiedasmeetingthestudycriteria,fourofwhichwerecombinedwithvitaminDsupplementation(Table2.10).Sixoftheninestudiesusedsubjectsaged65+and threeof theninewere conductedon femaleparticipantsonly. The interventionoutcomeswere

Page 13: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page13of40

concernedwith bonemineral density (BMD), dementia, dental health and fractures. Two of the studiessuggestthatcalciumsupplementationmayhaveapositiveimpactonBMD(Dawson-HughesandHarris,2002,Nakamura et al, 2012). Three studies investigating the impact of combined calcium and vitamin Dsupplementationondentalhealthgenerallyfoundpositiveoutcomesregardingtoothloss,dentalplaqueandperiodontalhealth(Kralletal,2001,Adegboyeetal,2013,Garciaetal,2011).Theimpactofcalciumintakeonfractureswaslessconsistent.Noevidenceofreducedriskoffractureswasreportedinonestudyfocusedoncalcium/vitaminDintake,areductioninfractureriskwasobservedinanotherinvestigation,whereasthethird study stated that the relationship between calcium intake and fracture susceptibility is complex(Porthouseetal,2005,Bischoff-Ferrarietal,2008,Choetal,2008).Finally,onestudyconcludedthatcalciumsupplementation may increase the risk of developing dementia in elderly woman (Kern et al, 2016). Insummary,sixoutofninestudiesshowedpositiveoutcomesofcalciumsupplementationforavarietyofhealthmeasures;onestudysuggestedacomplexeffect;anotherstudydescribednobenefit;andonestudysuggestedrisk.

Potassiuminterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Threestudiesfocusedonpotassiumsupplementationinelderlypersonswereidentifiedasmeetingthestudycriteria,twoofwhichwerebasedonafemalecohortonly(Table2.11).Onlyonestudyrecruitedanage-groupof65+whiletheothertwoselectedparticipantsover55yearsofage. The interventionoutcomeofthesestudieswere bonemetabolism and calcium balance. One study reported that treatmentwith potassiumcitrateforthreemonthsinanall-femalecohortreducedboneresorption(Marangelloetal,2004),whereasanothertwo-yearstudy,alsowithagroupofwomanconsistingof276participantsagedbetween55-65didnot find evidence that potassium citrate reduced bone turnover or increased bone mineral density(MacDonaldetal,2008).Thethirdstudyfocusedoncalciumbalanceconcludedthatpotassiumcitratehasthe potential to improve skeletal health (Mosely et al, 2013). In summary, the effects of potassiumsupplementationonbonehealthonolderadultsisvariedbuttherewasnoevidencefornegativeeffects.

Magnesiuminterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Threestudiesonmagnesiumsupplementationinelderlypersonswereidentifiedasmeetingthestudycriteria(Table2.12). Twoofthethreestudieswereconductedonparticipantsaged65+andonerecruitedpeoplebetween51and85years.Onestudyrecruitedonlyfemales.Outcomesmeasuresrelevanttothisreportwerebonemineraldensity,muscleperformance,glucosehandlingandimmunefunction.Dailymagnesiumoxidesupplementationimprovedphysicalperformanceinhealthyelderlywoman(Veroneseetal,2014).Inanotherstudy, correctionof a lowerythrocytemagnesium concentration associatedwith improvementof glucosehandling (Paolisso et al, 1992). Finally,magnesium supplementationwas shown to reduce inflammation(Nielsonetal,2010).Insummary,magnesiumsupplementationinhealthyolderadultsimprovedthehealthoutcomesstudiedhere.

Ironinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Onestudywhich investigated ironsupplementation inelderlypersonswas identifiedasmeetingthestudycriteria, which was in combination with 5-aminolevulinic acid (Table 2.13). Combined iron and 5-aminolevulinic acid intake augmented exercise efficiency and thereby improved interval-walking training(Masukietal,2015).Insummary,magnesiumsupplementationinhealthyolderadultsimprovedphysicalhealth.

Page 14: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page14of40

Seleniuminterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Sevenstudiesfocusedonseleniumsupplementationwereidentifiedinolderadultswereidentifiedasmeetingthereportcriteria,withonlytwostudiesusingagegroups65+;allstudiesrecruitedparticipantsover50yearsofage(Table2.14).Interventionoutcomesmeasuredincludedimmunefunction,mood,thyroidfunctionandmortality. Regarding thyroid function,one study reported that selenium intakedoesnot improve thyroidfunctioninanelderlyUKpopulation(Raymanetal,2008)andanotherstudysuggeststhatseleniumintakeonlyminimally anddosedependently affects thyroid function (Winther et al, 2015). A study focusedonimmunityfoundthatseleniumintakecanhavebothbeneficialanddetrimentaleffectsoncellularimmunitytoflu thatwas affectedby the formof selenium, supplemental dose anddeliverymatrix (Ivory et al, 2017).Anotherstudysuggeststhatintakeofselenium-enrichedyeastresultsinanimmunostimulatoryresponseinelderlyhumans(Peretzetal,1991).Afive-yearlongsupplementationstudyreportednoimpactonplasmacholesterolconcentrations inanelderlypopulationconsistingof492participantsagedbetween60and74(Coldetal,2015).Inanotherstudyconsistingof501individualsagedbetween60-74years,noevidencewasfound to suggest that selenium treatment improves mood or quality of life (Rayman et al, 2006).SupplementationwithSeleniumandCoenzymeQ10wasshowntoreducecardiovascularmortalityinelderlywithlowseleniumstatus(Alehagenetal,2016). Insummary,seleniumsupplementationinhealthyolderadults does not exert consistent effects and attention should be paid to the form inwhich selenium isavailable.

Zincinterventionstudies;effectsonolderadulthealthoutcomes

Onestudyonzincsupplementationconductedonagroupof5055-87-year-oldmenandwomanfor12months(Table 2.15). It reported that the incidenceof infectionwas significantly lower following supplementationsuggestinganimprovementinimmunefunction(Prasadetal,2007).

Dietenrichmentinterventions

Thesearchstrategywasdesignedtoinvestigatespecificdietarynutrienteffectsinolderadults.Somepreviousstudieshaveconsideredawidercontextofdietanddietaryenrichmentinolderadults.Themostsignificantof these studies is the PREDIMED study; in a healthy older adult population, a Mediterraneandietsupplementedwitholiveoilornuts isassociatedwith improvedcognitive function, immunefunction,boneandhealth(Valls-Pedret,Sala-Vilaetal.2015,Casas,Sacanellaetal.2016,Savanelli,Barreaetal.2017).AMediterraneandiet is considered todeliver thenutrientbalance thatpromotesgoodhealthoutlined inSection1andpointstotheimportanceofdietforpositivehealthoutcomes.

Page 15: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page15of40

References

Casas,R.,E.SacanellaandR.Estruch(2016)."TheImmuneProtectiveEffectoftheMediterraneanDietagainstChronicLow-gradeInflammatoryDiseases."Endocrine,Metabolic&ImmuneDisordersDrugTargets14(4):245-254.Savanelli,M.C.,L.Barrea,P.E.Macchia,S.Savastano,A.Falco,A.Renzullo,E.Scarano,I.C.Nettore,A.ColaoandC.DiSomma(2017)."PreliminaryresultsdemonstratingtheimpactofMediterraneandietonbonehealth."JTranslMed15(1):81.Sydenham,E.,A.D.DangourandW.-S.Lim(2012)."Omega3fattyacidforthepreventionofcognitivedeclineanddementia."CochraneDatabaseofSystematicReviews(6).Valls-Pedret,C.,A.Sala-Vila,M.Serra-Mir,D.Corella,R.delaTorre,M.A.Martinez-Gonzalez,E.H.Martinez-Lapiscina,M.Fito,A.Perez-Heras,J.Salas-Salvado,R.EstruchandE.Ros(2015)."MediterraneanDietandAge-RelatedCognitiveDecline:ARandomizedClinicalTrial."JAMAInternMed175(7):1094-1103.

Retrospective,epidemiologicalstudiesoftheeffectsof

Page 16: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page16of40

SECTION3Systematicreviewofepidemiologicalstudiesofnutrientsandhealthoutcomesinolderadults

Thefollowingsectiondescribesafocussedsystematicreviewofthoseepidemiologicalstudiesthathavedeterminedhealthoutcomemeasuresinolderadultslivingindependentlyandwithoutdiseaseinordertounderstandanyassociationsbetweennutritionandgeneralhealthandwell-being.ThereviewwasconductedinJulyandAugust2017.Alldatawasreviewedbytwopeopleindependently.

Searchstrategy

Bibliographicdatabasesweresearchedforstudiedreportingtherelationshipsbetweennutrientsandhealthoutcomesinindependent-living,healthyolderadults.Thesearchwasconductedbycombination(usingBooleanoperators)ofthesearchtermsintable2.1.Thefollowingdatabasesweresearched:PubMed,CochraneLibrary,WebofKnowledgeandScienceDirect.Theexclusioncriteriawereasfollows:populationage>65years;animalstudies;andstudiesofindividualswithdiseaseonlyandnotofhealthycontrols.

Table3.1.Searchstrategyforsystematicreviews

Agecategory Food Outcomeolderadult vitaminA frailtyelderly thiamin musclestrengthseptuagenarian riboflavin immuneresponseoctogenarian niacin lifespannonagenarian folate longevitycentenarian dietary-protein cognitionpensionage, omega3fattyacid falls,

retirementage,polyunsaturatedfattyacid fractures

Geriatricmonounsaturatedfattyacid dentalhealth

seniorcitizen, iron infectionOAP, calcium bodyweightoldage magnesium potassium vitaminB6 vitaminB12 vitaminC vitaminD vitaminE fibre zinc MULTIVITAMINS

Page 17: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page17of40

Dataextraction

Forinvestigationanyassociationbetweennutrientsandhealthoutcomes,wefocussedonmeasuresofphysiologicalsystemsthatdeclinewithageratherthaneffectsonovertexistingdisease.TheageingsystemsthatweincludedasoutcomesinoursearchesaredescribedinTable3.1.Thefollowingparticipantcharacteristicswerenotedaspossibleconfounders:follow-upduration,numberofparticipantspergroup,participantagerangeandgender.ThosestudiesmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaarelistedintheTables3.2etc.

Macronutrients

Fibre

Twostudiesondietaryfibrewereidentifiedasmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaforthisreview,oneofwhichwasstudiedwithproteinintake.Thesetwostudiesfocusedonfrailtyanddentalhealth.Onestudyconcludedthatcarbohydrate,fat,protein,anddietaryfibreshowednoconsistentassociationswithfrailtystatus(Shikanyetal, 2013). The other study reported that only fruits that were good to excellent sources of fibre wereassociatedwithlowerriskofprogressionofABL,probingpocketdepth,andtoothloss(Schwartzetal,2012).Thelaststudyhighlightsthedifficultyininterpretingretrospectivestudies;itispossiblethatpoordentalhealthmayhavecontributedtoolderpeopleselectedfewer“hard”orfibrousfoodstoeatratherthanthefibreitselfofferinganybenefitforprogressionofperiodontitis.

Limitedepidemiologicalstudiesoffibreintakehavebeenreportedforolderadults.Apossiblebenefitexistsfordentalhealthandnoriskswereidentified.

Protein

Sixteenstudieswereidentifiedwhichfocusedontherelationshipbetweendietaryproteinintakeandhealthoutcomes. Normal protein intake varies between 15-35% of the energy intake. Nine of the studies usedpopulations >65yrs and 6 studied all-female cohorts. Outcomemeasures included fractures, bodyweight,proteinintake,bonemineraldensity,infection,frailty,musclemass/strength.Thefivestudiesfocusedontherelationshipbetweenproteinintakeandfractureincidenceallagreedthatacorrelationexistedbetweenlowproteinintakeandfractureoccurrence(Wengreenetal,2004,Misraetal,2011,Mungeretal,1999,Martinez-Ramirezetal,2011,Frassettoetal,2000).Onestudyreportedthateach20%increaseinproteinintakewasassociatedwithasignificantlyhigherbonemineraldensity(BMD),fortotalbodyandhip(Beasleyetal,2014),whereasanotherstudyconcludedthatbonemineraldensitywasnotsignificantlyassociatedwiththeratioofanimal tovegetableprotein intake(Sellmeyeretal,2001). Investigatinganyrelationshipbetweenproteinintakeandbodyweight,onestudyreportedthatinthetotalpopulation,proteinintakewasassociatedwithhigher percent body fat, but in the subgroup with intermediate BMI and stable weight, there was noassociationbetweenproteinintakeandpercentbodyfat(Vinknesetal,2011).Anotherstudyreportedthata1%increaseincarbohydrateandproteinconsumptionwasassociatedwitha14%and16%lowerlikelihoodofbeingobese(Tyrovovlasetal,2011).

With regard to the relationshipbetweenprotein intakeand frailty, one study reported that subjectswithhigherproteinintakehadlowerriskoffrailty(Kobayashietal,2013).Insupportofthis,anotherstudyreportedthata20%increaseinuncalibratedproteinintake(%kcal)wasassociatedwitha12%lowerriskoffrailty,whilea 20% increase in calibratedproteinwas associatedwith a 32% lower risk of frailty (Beasley et al, 2010).Similarly,afurtherstudyconcludedthatdietwithacombinationofhighproteinandhightotalantioxidantcapacity isstronglyassociatedwith lowprevalenceof frailtyamongoldJapanesewomen(Kobayashietal,2017).

Page 18: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page18of40

Investigatingmusclestrength/mass,onestudyreportedthatnotmeetingtherecommendeddietaryproteinintakewas associatedwith significantly lower appendicular leanmass at baseline (Scott et al, 2010) andanotherreportedthatgreaterproteinintakewasassociatedwithlessage-relateddecreaseingripstrength(McLeanetal,2015).Itwasreportedthatmalnutritionandinadequateproteinintakewereverycommonandassociatedwithpoordentalhealthamongolderpeoplewithmultipledisabilities inassisted living facilities(Saarela et al, 2014). Finally, a study on infection incidence concluded that a lower protein intake wasindependentlyassociatedwithhospitalisationduetoinfection(Whametal,2015).

Insummary,higherprotein intakewasassociatedwithlowerriskforfrailty, improvedbonedensityandstrengthbuttherewasnoconsistentrelationshipbetweenproteinintakeandbodymass.Lowerproteinintakewasassociatedwithnegativehealthoutcomes.

N-3fattyacidsandPUFA

Cognition

SixteenstudieswereidentifiedthatfocusedonN-3fattyacid/PUFAintakeandmettheinclusioncriteriaofthisreview.Elevenwereconductedon65+yearsorusedameangroupagegreaterthan65years.Allstudiesexcept one (male only)were ofmixed gender populations.Health outcomemeasureswere cognition (9),fracturerisk(3),dentalhealth(2)musclestrength(2).

Higher omega-3 fatty acid/PUFA intake was associated with positive health outcomes in several studies.Seafoodconsumptionwasassociatedwithslowerdeclineinsemanticmemoryandperceptualspeed(VandeRestetal,2016). Anotherstudyreportedthatconsumptionof leanfriedfishhadnoprotectiveeffectbutconsumptionoffattyfishmorethantwiceperweekwasassociatedwithareductioninriskofdementiaby28%andAlzheimer’sdiseaseby41%incomparisontothosewhoatefishlessthanoncepermonth(Huangetal,2005).Fishconsumershadsignificantlylesscognitivedeclineoverfiveyearsthandidnon-consumers(VanGelderetal,2007). Anotherstudy reported that low intakeofEPAandDHAwerepredictorsofcognitiveimpairment and were negatively associated with cognitive function, assessed by the Mini Mental StateExamination(Gonzalezetal,2010).HigherglobalcognitivefunctionwasalsoreportedtobeassociatedwithhigherlevelsofserumEPAandDHA+EPAaftercontrollingforconfounders(Nishihiraetal,2016).PlasmaEPAhasalsobeenassociatedwithaslowerdeclineintheBentonVisualRetentionTestinApoEe4carriersanddepressivesubjects(Samierietal,2011).AfurtherstudyconcludedthatMontrealCognitiveAssessmenttestscoreswererelatedtofishservings(Bruttoetal,2015). Finally,therewassignificantassociationbetweenreported fish consumption and a verbal language score (Dangour et al, 2009). High fish consumptionassociatedwithlesscognitiveimpairmentandslowercognitivedecline.

Fractures

Inastudyofassociationsbetweenfish-oilconsumptioninearlylife,midlife,andlatelifewithosteoporoticfracture risk, in the highest tertile of omega–3 fatty acid consumers (daily) a decreased fracture riskwasobservedinmenthatalmostreachedsignificanceinwomen(Harrisetal,2015).Onestudyreportedinverseassociationswithvegetableconsumption,fishconsumptionandpolyunsaturatedlipidintakewithhipfracture,whereassaturatedlipidintakewaspositivelyassociatedwithhipfracturerisk(Benetouetal,2011).AthirdstudyreportednostatisticallysignificantassociationbetweenintakesoftotalPUFA,totaln-3PUFA,totaln-6PUFA,n-6/n-3PUFAratioorindividualPUFAsandhipfracturerisk;however,womenwithlowintakesoftotalPUFA,n-6PUFAandlinoleicacidwereatincreasedriskoffractures(Virtanenetal,2012).

Page 19: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page19of40

Dentalhealth

Two relevant studies were retrieved. They reported that a high dietary n-6:n-3 PUFA intake ratio wasassociatedwitha greaternumberofperiodontaldiseaseevents (Iwasaki et al, 2011); similarly a lowDHAintakewasassociatedwithmoreperiodontaldiseaseevents(Iwasakietal,2010).

Musclestrength

Tworelevantstudieswereretrieved.Onestudyconcludedthathigherconcentrationsof totalPUFAswereassociatedwithlargermusclesizeandwithgreaterkneeextensionstrength(Reindersetal,2014).Asecondstudyconcludedthatthemostimportantdietaryfactorinrelationtogripstrengthwasfattyfishconsumption(Robinsonetal,2008).

Insummary,fishconsumption(particularlyoilyfishrichinomega-3fattyacids)associatedpositivelywithmusclestrength,dentalhealthandcognitivefunction.Inaddition,twoofthreestudiessuggestthatdailyfishconsumptionassociateswithreducedfracturerisk,particularlyinmen.

MUFA

Four studies were identified thatmet the inclusion criteria of this review and evaluated the relationshipbetweenmonounsaturatedfattyacids(MUFA)andhealthoutcomes.Twoofthefourstudieswereconductedwitholderpeopleof65+yearsandonefocusedonfemales.Measuredhealthoutcomesincludedcognition,fracturerisk,and longevity. OnestudyreportedthatMUFAintakewas inverselyassociatedwithcognitivedecline(Naqvietal,2011);asecondstudyreportedthattheoddsratioformildcognitive impairmentwasreducedinthosewithhighvegetableintakeandwithhighmono-pluspolyunsaturatedfattyacidtosaturatedfattyacidratio(Robertsetal,2010).Astudyonfracturesreportedthatadose-dependentincreaseinriskofhipfractureswasassociatedwithhigherintakesoftotalfat,animalfat,saturatedfattyacidsandMUFA(Zengetal,2015).HigherMUFAintakewasassociatedwithanincreasedchanceofsurvivalinolderadults(Solfrizzietal,2005).

Insummary,MUFAintakewasassociatedwithpositivehealthoutcomesinthreeoffourstudies.

VitaminA

ThreestudiesonvitaminAwereidentifiedthatmettheinclusioncriteriaofthisreview;twoincludedanall-femalepopulationand lookedat relationships inpeopleover50yearsofage.Healthoutcomesmeasuredwerefractureincidenceanddentalhealth.Inrelationtofractureincidence,onestudyconcludedthattherewasnosignificantassociationbetweenvitaminAintakeandtheriskoffracturebutthatthosewithinhighestquintileforvitaminAintakeandwithlowvitaminDintakeweremorelikelytohaveincreasedfracturerisk(Caire-Juveraetal,2009).AsecondstudyreportedthatusersofsupplementscontainingvitaminAhada1.18-fold increased risk of incident hip fracture compared with non-users, but there was no evidence for anincreasedriskofallfracturesamongsupplementusers(Limetal,2004).Regardingoralhealth,thosewithlowerHealthyEatingIndexscoresandsignificantlylowervitaminAintakeweremorelikelytohavepoororalhealth(Baileyetal,2004).

In summary,highest vitaminA intakewasassociatedwith increased risk for fracture,particularlywhencombinewithlowvitaminDintwoofthreestudies.PoororalhealthassociatedwithlowvitaminAintake.

Page 20: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page20of40

VitaminB12

EightstudiesthatfocusedonvitaminB12andmettheinclusioncriteriaofthisreviewwereidentified.Fiveofthese studieswere conducted on cohorts older than 65 years and all studiedmixed gender populations.Outcomesassessedwerecognition, fracturesandmortality. Regardingcognition,onestudyreportedthatpeopleover50withmildcognitiveimpairmentandwithlow-normalvitaminB12showedasignificantlypoorerlearningabilityandrecognitionperformancethanthosewithhigh-normalvitaminB12concentrationintheblood(Kobeetal,2016).Similarly,itwasalsoconcludedthatcognitiveimpairmentwasrelatedtolowbloodvitaminB12inaBrazilianpopulation(Martinho,TinocoandRibeiro,2015).LowvitaminB12concentrationswereidentifiedin13%ofolderpeopleandwereassociatedwithmemoryimpairmentanddepression(Hinetal,2006).AnotherstudyconcludedthattheratesofdementiaordeclineassociatedwithhomocysteineforthoseinthelowestandhighesttertilesofvitaminB12,respectively,weresignificantlyhigherandlowerthantheriskforthoseinthemiddletertile(Haanetal,2007).However,afurtherstudyfoundnoevidenceforavitaminB12-relatedmemorydeficitalthoughcognitiveprocessingspeedwaslower(Jelicic,JonkerandDeeg,2010).

Regarding fractures, one study reported that plasma vitamin B12 and B6 concentrations were inverselyassociated with hip fracture risk (McLean et al, 2008), with a second study reporting that osteoporosisoccurredmoreamongwomenwhoseB12statuswasmarginalordeficientthaninwomenwithanormalstatus(Dhonukshe-Ruttenetal,2002).

Inrelationtomortality,findingssuggestedthatinpatientsatnutritionalriskwhowereadmittedtohospitalandgivensupplements,thosewithhighvitaminB12hadincreasedmortalityandalongerlengthofstay(LOS)thanthosewithnormalconcentrations(median25days)versus23days,andelevatedvitaminB12wasanindependentpredictorofLOS(Cappelloetal,2017).

In summary, low vitamin B12 in the blood associated with poor cognitive performance and increasedfracturerisk.ThesestudiesdidnotconsidervitaminB12intake;absorptionfromthedietmaybeimpairedwithage.

VitaminC

FourstudieswereidentifiedwhichinvestigatedvitaminCandmettheinclusioncriteriaofthisreview.Healthoutcomesrelatedtocognition,infectionandmusclestrength.Allstudieswereconductedonsubjectsgreaterthan65yearsofage,withtwostudiesbeingundertakenonfemalepopulations.Investigatingcognition,onestudyconcludedthatconsumptionofvitaminCsupplementswasassociatedwithalowerprevalenceofmoreseverecognitiveimpairment(Paleologous,CummingandLazarus,1998),withanotherstudysuggestingthatoverall, long-termvitaminC intakeswerenotconsistently related tocognition (Devoreetal,2012). Withregardtoinfection,itwasconcludedthatserumvitaminC(measuredasascorbate)concentrationwasstronglyinversely related to fibrinogen, factor VIIC and acute phase proteins but not to self-reported respiratorysymptoms(KhawandWoodhouse,1995).PlasmavitaminCconcentrationwasalsoreportedtobepositivelycorrelatedwithhandgripstrength,lengthoftimestandingononelegwitheyesopenandwalkingspeed,andinverselycorrelatedwithbodymassindex(Saitoetal,2011).

Insummary,vitaminCintakeandbloodconcentrationswerenotassociatedwithhealthrisksand50%ofstudiesshowedbenefit;oneonstrengthandtheotheroncognition.

VitaminD

AtotalofonehundredstudiesthatfocusedonvitaminDandmettheinclusioncriteriaofthisreviewwereidentified.Seventy-onestudiesspecificallyexamineddata fromthoseabove65years. Thirty-twoof these

Page 21: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page21of40

studieswereconductedonfemalesonlyandelevenwereundertakenonamale-onlycohort.Healthoutcomewerecomprisedoffractures(30),cognition(15),frailty(16),musclestrength(14),bodyweight(6),falls(6)longevity(6),vitaminDlevels(2)dentalhealth(2)andinfection(2).

Fractures:Twenty-fouroutofthirtystudiesreportedaninverseassociationbetweenvitaminDandfractureincidence.EithersubjectswithhigherlevelsofvitaminDhadreducedincidenceoffracturesormoreoften,acorrelationbetweenlowvitaminD levelsandincreasefractureoccurrencewasevident(seeTable). Threestudies reported no obvious correlation between vitamin D levels and fracture risk (Garnero et al, 2007,Shinkovetal,2016,Steingrimsdottiretal,2014).Conclusionsfromfiveotherstudiesweremorecomplex.AstudycombinedwithvitaminK1reportedthata50%higherriskofhipfracturewasobservedinsubjectswithbothlowvitaminK1andvitaminD,butnoincreasedriskwasobservedinthegroupslowinonevitaminonly(Finnes et al, 2016). The same finding was reported by Dahl et al (2015). Similarly, looking at fractureincidence,lowvitaminK1and25(OH)Dwereindependentlyandsynergisticallyassociatedwiththeriskofhipfracture(Torbergsenetal,2015).AnotherreportshowedthatserumvitaminDwasalinearpredictorofmajorosteoporoticfractureandsignificantquadraticpredictorofhipfractureinthetotalsampleandamongthosewith<10yearsoffollow-up,butitwasnotrelatedtoriskoffractureamongthosewith>10yearsoffollow-up(Lookeretal,2013).Cauleyetal(2010)concludedthatvitaminDlevelswereunrelatedtonon-spinefracturesbutadecreaseinvitaminDwasassociatedwithincreasedriskofhipfracture.Age,height,weight,bodymassindex,fatmass,leanbodymass,waistcircumference,serumvitaminD,parathyroidhormone,andexercisewere also reported to be related to bonemineral density (Yang and Kim, 2015). Finally, the relationshipbetweenbaselinevitaminDandfractureriskwasdescribedasbeingU-shaped,withincreasedfractureriskinmenwitheitherloworhighserumvitaminDlevels(Bleicheretal,2014).

Cognition: FourteenofthefifteenstudiesreportedanassociationbetweenvitaminD levelsandcognitiveperformance.EithersubjectswithhigherlevelsofvitaminDwerelesslikelytohavecognitiveimpairmentorwithlowvitaminDlevelwereassociatedwithincreasedcognitiveimpairment(Wilkinsetal,2006,Annweileretal,2012,Milmanetal,2014,Bartalietal,2014,Pernaetal,2014,Jordeetal,2015,Breitlingetal,2012,Llewellynetal,2011,Llewellynetal,2010,Wilkinsetal,2009,Annweileretal,2016,Cheietal,2014,Seamansetal,2010,Milleretal,2010).OnestudyreportedthatthoseinthelowestandhighestvitaminDquartileshad an increased risk of impaired prevalent but not incident global cognitive functioning or decline infunctioningcomparedwiththoseinthemiddlequartiles(Granicetal,2015).

Frailty:SixteenoftheseventeenstudiesreportedaninversecorrelationbetweenvitaminDlevelsandfrailty,withlowvitaminDlevelsbeingassociatedwithfrailty(Shardelletal,2012,Pabstetal,2015,Gutierrez-Robledoetal,2015,Shardelletal,2009,Hiranietal,2013,Alvarez-Riosetal,2015,Trevisanetal,2017,Wongetal,2013,Vogtetal,2015,Tajaretal,2012,Butaetal,2016,Smitetal,2012,Wilhelm-Leenetal,2010,Changetal,2010,Schottkeretal,2014).LessablepatientsreportedlyhadsignificantlylowervitaminDlevelsinanotherstudy(Skalska,GalasandGrodzicki,2012).OnestudyreportedaU-shapedassociationatbaselinewasseenbetween25(OH)Dlevelandoddsoffrailty,withthelowestriskamongthosewithmid-rangeplasmavitaminDlevels20.0–29.9ng/ml(Ensrudetal,2010).

Musclestrengthandfalls:TenofthefifteenstudiesshowedasignificantcorrelationbetweenlowvitaminDlevelsandmusclestrength,withlowerlevelsassociatingwithpoorstrength(Gerdhemetal,2005,Houstonetal,2007,Mastagliaetal,2011,Iolasconetal,2015,Zambonietal,2002,Birdetal,2013,Inderjeethetal,2007,Gumieiroetal,2015,Salminenetal,2015,Pramyothinetal,2009).Fivestudiesreportednoassociation.Onesuchstudyconcludedthatfewsubjectshad25-hydroxyvitaminDconcentrations<30nmol/Landthatabovethisconcentration,therewasnodoseeffectrelationwithphysicalperformanceexceptforsingle-legstands(Chuangetal,2016).AsecondstudyreportedthattherewerenodifferencesintheGCSCompositeScale,aglobalmeasureofphysicalfunction,betweenthosewithhigherandlower25(OH)Dconcentrations(Haslam

Page 22: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page22of40

etal,2014).Afurtherstudyreportedthatnosignificantrelationshipbetweenbalance,gaitspeedandgripstrength, and serum25-OHDwas detected (Mathei et al, 2013). A fourth study concluded that althoughphysical performancedeclinedover time, thiswas not associatedwith baseline vitaminD (Houston et al,2012).ThiswasechoedbyChanetal(2012)whoreportedthatserum25OHDlevelswerenotassociatedwithbaselineor4-yearchange inphysicalperformancemeasuresandskeletalmusclemass.Fiveoutof thesixstudiesexaminingassociationbetweenvitaminDandfallsincidencereportedaninversecorrelation(Steinetal,1999,Lloydetal,2009,Rothenbacheretal,2014,Shimizuetal,2015andFlickeretal,2003).OnestudyhoweverreportedthatuseofvitaminDsupplementswasnotassociatedwithanymeasuresofneuromuscularfunction,changeinneuromuscularfunction,orfallrates(Faulkneretal,2006).

Longevity: Four of the six studies identified a correlation between low serum vitamin D and increasedmortality(Buchebneretal,2016,Sembaetal,2009,Kimetal,2015,Sameforsetal,2014).TwofurtherstudiesreportednoassociationbetweenvitaminDlevelsandall-causemortality(Cawthonetal,2010,Eatonetal,2011).

BodyWeight:FiveoutofthesixstudiesreportedacorrelationbetweenlowvitaminDlevelsandincreasedbodyweight,withthreeofthesestudiesincludingarelationshiptosarcopenia(Seoetal,2012,Hwangetal,2012,Huoetal,2016,Ohetal,2016,Sohletal,2015).OnlyonestudyconcludedthatvitaminDlevelswerenotassociatedwithoverallweightchangeorbodyfatloss(Vogtetal,2016).

DentalHealth:Ofthetwostudiesidentified,onereportedthatmenwithmoresevereperiodontaldiseasehavelowervitaminDlevelsandthatvitaminDlevelsacrossallperiodontitisgroupsareconsideredtobelow(Schulze-Spate et al, 2015). The second study concluded that there were no statistically significantassociationsfoundbetweenbaselinevitaminDlevelsandchangeinperiodontaldiseasemeasures,overallorinasubset (n=442)ofwomenwithstablevitaminDconcentrations (changeof<±20nmol/L) (Millenetal,2014).

Infection:Ofthetwostudiesidentified,onereportedthataftermultivariableadjustments,thesubjectsinthelowestserumvitaminDtertile(8.9-33.8nmol/L)hada2.6-foldhigherriskofdevelopingpneumoniacomparedwith the subjects in the highest tertile (50.8-112.8nmol/L) (Aregbesola et al, 2013). The second studyconcludedthatinmultivariableanalyses,aserumvitaminDlevelof<15ng/mLwasassociatedwithahigherriskofhospitalizationwithaninfectionbutnotofhospitalizationwithoutaninfection(Kempkeretal,2016).

Insummary,70%of100studiesreportedbenefitsofhighervitaminDlevelsforhealthoutcomes(orlowervitaminandpoorhealthoutcomes).ThehighestconcentrationsofvitaminDmayassociatewithincreasedprevalenceofcognitiveimpairment,fracturesandfrailty.VitaminKandvitaminDassociatesynergisticallywithbonehealth.

VitaminE

FourstudiesonvitaminEthatmettheinclusioncriteriaofthisreviewwereidentified.Allstudiedpeopleolderthan65yearsandonewasanall-femalepopulation.Healthoutcomesmeasuredwerecognition,dentalhealthandfractures.Withregardtocognition,onestudyconcludedthatparticipantswithplasmavitaminElevelsinthebottomtertile(<26umol/L)hadasignificantlyhigherprobabilityofbeingdementedandsufferingfromcognitiveimpairmentcomparedtothoseinthehighestvitaminEtertile(>32.93umol/L)(Cherubinietal,2005).Anothercognitionstudyreportedthatlowerriskofcognitiveimpairmentwasobservedinpeoplewithhigherlevelsofy-tocopherol,B-tocotrienolandtotaltocotrienols(Mangialascheetal,2013).WithregardtodentalhealthhigherintakeofvitaminEassociatedwithreducedperiodontaldiseaseseverityincommunity-dwellingolderJapanese(Iwasakietal,2012).AreportonfracturerecoveryidentifiedhighervitaminEconcentrations

Page 23: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page23of40

inpeoplewhowererecoveringfromhipfracturesthanincontrols,buttheywerehadhighercognitiveandphysicalfunctionthanthecontrolgroup(D'Adamoetal,2011).

Insummary,lowvitaminEintake/bloodconcentrationwasrelatedtopoorhealthoutcomesinolderadults.

Thiamin

Onestudythatfocusedonthiaminwasidentifiedasmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaforthisreview;theaverageageofthosestudiedwas83years.Cognitivestatusdidnotdifferaccordingtothiaminstatusbutthiamine-deficientsubjectsrepresentedalargerproportionofAlzheimer’spatients(Pepersacketal,1998).

Insummary,inhealthyolderadultsthiaminestatuswasnotassociatedwithcognitivefunction

Riboflavin

Twostudiesthatfocusedonriboflavinwereidentifiedasmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaforthisreview;thehealthoutcomewasfracturerisk.Lowriboflavinintakealonewasnotassociatedwithfractureriskandbonemineraldensity(Yazdanpanahetal,2007butasmall,butsignificantassociationwasfoundbetweenvitaminB6andriboflavinintakeandbaselineBMDofthefemoralneck(Yazdanpanahetal,2007).

Insummary,thereisaweaklinkbetweenbonehealthandriboflavinwithvitaminB6intake.

Calcium

Nineteenepidemiologicalstudiesthatfocusedoncalciumwereidentifiedasmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaforthisreview;onestudyinvestigatedcalciumcombinedwithzincandanotherwithprotein.FurtherstudieswithvitaminDandcalciumhavebeenconsideredpreviously.Fiveof thestudiesusedagegroupsof65+years,fourteenstudiesincludedpeopleover50yearsandonestudyincludepeopleaged41-79years.Tenstudieswereconductedonfemalepopulationsonlyandonestudyrecruitedanall-malecohort.Outcomesassessedincluded sarcopenia, cognitive function, bone mineral density, fractures, periodontitis, osteoporosis andmortality.

Two studies investigated the relationship between calcium intake and cognition; one study reported thatcognitive declinewas associatedwith elevated serum calcium (>1.29mmol/L; Tilvis et al, 2004) whereasanotherstudyconcludedthatcognitionincreasedwithcalciumuptoapoint(datacouldnotbeextractedfromthesource)andthencognitiondecreasedascalciumfurtherincreased(Emsleyetal,2000).Anotherstudyreportedthatdailycalciumintakewassignificantlylowerinsubjectswithsarcopeniathaninthosewithout(Seoetal,2013).

Fourteenstudiesinvestigatedtheassociationbetweencalciumandoutcomesrelatedtobonemineraldensity(BMD),fracturesandosteoporosis.Onestudyconcludedthatbonediseasewasassociatedwithalackofdairyproductsorcalciumsupplementation(Wangetal,2017),whilstanotherstudyreportedthatcalciumintakewasnotassociatedwithosteoporosisdiagnosisorfracture(Fardelloneetal,2009).FourstudiesreportedapositivecorrelationbetweenBMDandcalciumintakewherelowercalciumintakeswerelinkedtofractures(FormosaandXuereb-Anastasi,2016,Wlodareketal,2012,Radavelli-Bagatinietal,2014,Cauleyetal,2004).TworeportssuggestedthatdailydairycalciumintakeisnotassociatedwithBMD;infemoralneckBMD(VandenBergetal,2014)andpeoplewhoweregenerallyosteoporoticandosteopenic(Leeetal,2007).Urinarycalciumwas reported tobenegatively associatedwith trochanter, total femurand spineBMD (Ilichet al,2009).

Consideringtherelationbetweencalciumandbonefractures,onestudyreportedthatcalciumintakewasnotrelatedtotheriskoffractureinwomen,however,dailycalciumintakesabove1gassociatedwithlowerrisks

Page 24: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page24of40

inmen(Cooper,BarkerandWickham,1988).Khanetal(2015)concludedthatforoldermenandwomen,calciumintakesofupto1348mg/dfromfoodwereassociatedwithdecreasedrisksforfracture,non-fatalCVD,strokeandall-causemortality.

Finally,astudyonperiodontitisconcludedthatintakesoftotaldairycalcium,calciumfrommilkandfermentedfoodswereinverselyassociatedwithperiodontitisbutnon-dairycalcium,calciumfromcheeseandotherdairyfoodintakeswerenot(Adegboyeetal,2012).

Insummary,75%ofstudiesshowedanassociationbetweenhighercalciumintakeandbonehealth.Onestudyshowedthatlowcalciumintakeassociatedwithage-relatedmuscleloss.Twostudiesreportedthathigherbloodionisedcalciumwasassociatedwithpoorcognitionalthoughitisnotclearwhetherthiswasrelatedtohigherintakeorotherpathology.

CalciumandVitaminD

FivestudiesthatfocusedoncalciumandvitaminDwereidentifiedasmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaforthisreview,fourstudiedanall-femalecohort.HealthoutcomesincludedBMD,fracturesandcognition.OnestudyreportedthatlowvitaminDintakewasassociatedwithamorepronouncedrateoffractureandthathigherlevelsofcalciumintakedidnotfurtherreducetheriskoffracturesofanytype,orofosteoporosis(Warensjoetal,2011).AnotherstudyreportedthathighercalciumandvitaminDintakessignificantlyreducedtheoddsof osteoporosis but not the 3-year risk of fracture in Caucasian women (Nieves et al, 2008). OtherinvestigationsconcludedthatwomenconsumingvitaminD≥12.5g/dfromfood/supplementshada37%lowerriskofhipfracturethandidwomenconsuming<3.5g/d,buttotalcalciumintakewasnotassociatedwithhipfracture risk (Feskanich, Willett and Colditz, 2003). A further study reported that no dose–responseassociationbetweencalciumintakeandfractureriskwasfoundandthatvitaminDintakewasnotassociatedwithfracturerisk(Michaelssonetal,2003).

Regardingcognition,neitherserumionizedcalciumnor25-hydroxyvitaminDwasreportedtobeassociatedwithcognitivefunction(Tolppanen,WilliamsandLawlor,2011).

Insummary,fouroffivestudiesdidnotobserveanyassociationbetweenpoorhealthoutcomesascribedtolowvitaminDwhencalciumwasincreased.

Folate

Fivestudiesthat focusedonfolatewere identifiedasmeetingthe inclusioncriteria for this review,oneofwhichalsoinvestigatedvitaminD.Allstudiedpeopleover65years.Outcomemeasureswerecognition,fallsand dental health. All three studies of the relationship between folate and cognition reported positiveassociationswithcognition.OneofthesestudiesreportedthatcognitiveimpairmentanddementiadecreasedwithincreasingRBCfolateconcentration(Ramosetal,2005),anotherthathigherplasmafolateconcentrationsareassociatedwithbetterglobalcognitivefunction(Lauetal,2007)andthethirdconcludedthatmenhadincreasedcognitiveimpairmentandthiswasassociatedwithlowerserumfolate(Lee,ShaharandRajab,2009).Regardingfallsitwasreportedthatserumfolatewasnegativelyassociatedwiththenumberoffallsandinthosewithprescribedmedicationsitwastheonlyprotectivefactoragainstfalls(Shaharetal,2008).Astudyon dental health concluded that a low serum folate levelwas independently associatedwith periodontaldiseaseinolderadults(Yuetal,2007).

Insummary,allstudiesshowedassociationsbetweenlowfolateandpoorhealthoutcomesorhigherfolateandimprovedhealthoutcomes.

Page 25: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page25of40

FolateandVitaminB12

TwelvestudiesthatfocusedonfolateandvitaminB12wereidentifiedasmeetingtheinclusioncriteriaforthisreview.Tenofthetwelvestudiedpeopleolderthan65years,twostudiedall-femalepopulationsandonestudiedmales only. Health outcomesmeasured included cognition (11) and fracture incidence (1). Fivestudiesoncognitionreportedthatfolatewassignificantlycorrelatedwithcognition,butvitaminB12wasnot(Ravagliaetal,2005,Tettamantietal,2006,Agnew-Blaisetal,2015,Fengetal,2006,Mooijaartetal,2005).Onestudyreportedthatsubjectsinthelowestfolatetertilehadsignificantlyhigheradjustedoddsratiosformildcognitiveimpairmentanddementia(Quadrietal,2004)andanotherthatdietaryfolatewasaprotectiveagainstadeclineinverbalfluency(Tuckeretal,2005).OnlyplasmafolatelevelwaspositivelyassociatedwiththeMMSE-KCandBostonNamingTest inanotherstudy(Kimetal,2002). Onestudyreportedthathighervitaminlevelswerenotassociatedwitheitherinitialcognitiveperformanceorsubsequentcognitivedecline(Kang, IrizarryandGrodstein,2006). Anotherstudyconcludedthathigh folate intakewasassociatedwithfasterrateofcognitivedecline(Morrisetal,2005).Similarly,whenserumfolatewaslow,increasingthefolateconcentrationassociatedwithbetter cognitiveperformanceespeciallywhenvitaminB12 levelswere low,however, when folate was high and vitamin B12 was high, further increasing folate was associated withincreasedtheriskforimpairedcognitivefunction(Castillo-Lancellottietal,2014).

Asinglestudyfocusedonfracture incidencereportedthatparticipants inthe lowestserumfolatequartile(~9.3nmol/L)hadanincreasedriskoffracturethandidthoseinhigherquartilesbutnodose-relatedprotectiveeffectforincreasingserumfolatelevelswasfound(Ravagliaetal,2005).ThissamestudyalsoconcludedthatnoindependentassociationwasfoundforserumvitaminB12.

Insummary,lowfolatebutnotB12associatedwithpoorhealthoutcomesbutthatincreasingfolateinthosewithalreadyhighfolateandB12levelsassociatedwithpoorhealthoutcomes.

Iron

Six studies that focused on iron were identified as meeting the inclusion criteria for this review; healthoutcomesrelatedtoimmunity,anaemia,cognitionandbodyweightwereidentified.Regardingbodyweight,itwasreportedthatlowerserumFelevelswererelatedtotheinflammationlinkedwithhigherBMI(Oldewage-Theron, Egal,Grobler, 2014). Also, serum ferritinwas significantly correlatedwith the various indexes ofadiposity,suchasthehepaticfatcontent(negativeassociation),visceralandsubcutaneousfat(Iwasakietal,2005).Anotherstudyreportedthattheinfluenceofhighstorage-ironlevelsimpairedimmunityandincreasedtheprevalenceofobesityandabdominalfatness(Kouris-Blazosetal,1996).Itwasconcludedinanotherstudythat vegetarians' low serum ferritin levelmay reduce the risk ofmetabolic syndrome in postmenopausalwomen(KimandBae,2012).AstudyoncognitionconcludedthatMini-MentalStateExaminationscoresweremoderatelyandsignificantlycorrelatedwithironlevelsandtransferrinsaturation(Yavuzetal,2012).Astudyrelated to anaemia reported that iron deficiency anaemia was associated with positive urine culture forbacteriuria(Buttaetal,2014).

Insummary,highironconcentrationsrelatedtopoorhealthoutcomesinolderadultsbutthatlowironalsorelatedtopoorimmunefunctionandcognition.

Magnesium

Threestudiesthat focusedonmagnesiumwere identifiedasmeetingthe inclusioncriteria forthisreview;healthoutcomesweremetabolism,BMDandfractureincidence.Astronginverserelationshipbetweenserummagnesiumand thepresenceofmetabolic syndromewas reportedandas thenumberof componentsofmetabolic syndrome increased,magnesium levels decreased (Evangelopoulos et al, 2008). In relation to

Page 26: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page26of40

fractureincidence,itwasreportedthatBMI,serummagnesium,calciumandalbuminweresignificantlylowerin femaleswhenBMDwas lower (Saitoetal,2004). Riskof lower-armorwrist fractureswas reported toincreasewithhighermagnesiumintake,howeveritwasnotedthatthesewomenweremoreactiveandatahigherriskoffalls(Orchardetal,2014).

Insummary,intwoofthreestudies,lowmagnesiumassociatedwithpoorhealth.

Mixedvitamin/nutrientintake

Fifteenstudieswereidentifiedwhichinvestigatedmulti-vitaminintakeornutrient-richdiets,withtenstudyingagegroupsof65+yearsandtwostudyingall-femalepopulations.Healthoutcomeswerefrailty,bodyweight,obesity, fracture risk,dentalhealthandcognition. With regard todentalhealth,one study reported thatintake of non-starch polysaccharides, protein, calcium, non-haem iron, niacin, and vitamin C intakeweresignificantly lower inedentatesubjectscomparedwithdentatesubjects (Sheihametal,2001). Inanotherstudy, itwasalsoreportedthatsubjectswhohadat least5teethhadhighercarbohydrateandvitaminB1intakethanthosewhohad4orlessteeth(Suzukietal,2006).

Cognition: differences in cognitive functioning were related to specific nutrient intakes; protein, fibre,eicosapentaenoic acid, niacin and vitamin B6 (Guligowska et al, 2016). Another study concluded thatassociationsbetweenlifestyleandcognitionexisted,includingPUFAandvitaminB2,withfatintake,vitaminsA,B2,B3,C,fibreandvegetablesbeingassociatedwithdepression(Wooetal,2006).Athirdstudyreportedthatfemalesubjectswithpoorcognitivefunctionhadsignificantlylowerintakesofcereals,vegetables,fruits,milk,spicesandalso,protein,fat,calcium,iron,vitaminA,thiamin,riboflavinandniacinthanthoseofanormalcognition(Leeetal,2001). Malesubjects inthesamestudywithpoorcognitivefunctionhadsignificantlylowerintakeoffruits,fibre,andvitaminCthannormalsubjects.AfourthstudyconcludedthattheprevalenceoflowvitaminsB12,B6,folateandniacinwere6.7%,5.3%,1.3%and26.7%respectivelyandthattherewasnosignificantdifferenceamonggroupedintotertilesofcognition(Paulionis,KaneandMeckling,2005).

Fracture incidence: after adjustment, dose-dependent inverse associations were observed between thedietaryintakeofvitaminC,vitaminE,β-carotene,andSeandantioxidantscoreandtheriskofhipfracture(Sunetal,2014)butnosignificantassociationwasobservedbetweendietaryZnoranimal-derivedvitaminAintakeandhipfracturerisk. Asecondstudyconcludedthata“nutrient-dense”patternrichincalciumandphosphorous, iron,vitaminsB includingB12,vitaminsCandE,alcohol,proteins,andunsaturatedfatswasassociatedwitha19% lowerriskofwrist fractures (Samierietal,2013). Thesamestudyreportedthata“south-westernFrench”dietarypatternrich incalcium,phosphorous,vitaminsDandB12,retinol,alcohol,proteins,andfats-includingunsaturatedfats;poorinvitaminsC,E,andK,carotenes,folates,andfibres;wasrelatedtoa33%lowerriskofhipfractures.

Frailty:onestudyconcludedthatdailyenergyintake≤21kcal/kgwassignificantlyassociatedwithfrailtyandafteradjustingforenergyintake,alowintakeofprotein;vitaminsD,E,C,andfolate;andhavingalowintakeofmorethanthreenutrientsweresignificantlyandindependentlyrelatedtofrailty(Bartalietal,2006). Asecondstudyreportedthatwomeninthelowestquartileofserumcarotenoids,a-tocopherol,and25(OH)Dhadanincreasedriskofbecomingfrailandthatthenumberofnutritionaldeficiencieswasassociatedwithanincreased risk of becoming frail, after adjustment (Semba et al, 2006). A third study concluded that frailwomenweremorelikelytohaveatleast2deficienciesandthattheoddsratiosofbeingfrailweresignificantlyhigher for those participants whose concentrations were in the lowest quartile for total carotenoids, a-tocopherol,25(OH)D,andvitaminB6(Michelonetal,2006).OnestudyfocusedonaMediterraneandietandfrailtyonamixed-sexpopulationaged60yearsandgreaterconcludedthattheriskoffrailtywasinverselyassociatedwithfishandfruitconsumption(Leon-Munozetal,2014).

Page 27: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page27of40

Bodymass:Withregardtobodyweight,itwasreportedthatlowintakeofprotein,vitaminD,calciumandvitaminCwassignificantlyassociatedwithlossofmuscleinmen,butnotwomen(Ohetal,2015).Afurtherstudy concluded thatnooverall associationwas seenbetweenpatternsofnutrient intakeandabdominalobesityinbothgenders(Kosakaetal,2013).

Insummary,proteinandmicronutrient-lowdietsassociatewithpoorhealthoutcomesandhigherproteinandmicronutrientintakesassociatewithgoodhealthoutcomes.

Page 28: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page28of40

References

Abdelfatah,M.,R.Nayfe,B.Moftakhar,A.Nijim,M.ElZoghbi,C.J.Donskey,H.KandilandR.R.Watkins(2015)."LowvitaminDlevelandimpactonseverityandrecurrenceofClostridiumdifficileinfections."JInvestigMed63(1):17-21.

Adegboye,A.R., L.B.Christensen,P.Holm-Pedersen,K.Avlund,B. J.BoucherandB. L.Heitmann (2012). "Intakeofdairyproducts in relation toperiodontitisinolderDanishadults."Nutrients4(9):1219-1229.

Agnew-Blais,J.C.,S.Wassertheil-Smoller,J.H.Kang,P.E.Hogan,L.H.Coker,L.G.SnetselaarandJ.W.Smoller(2015)."Folate,vitaminB-6,andvitaminB-12intakeandmildcognitiveimpairmentandprobabledementiaintheWomen'sHealthInitiativeMemoryStudy."JAcadNutrDiet115(2):231-241.

Alvarez-Rios,A.I.,J.M.Guerrero,F.J.Garcia-Garcia,L.Rodriguez-Manas,P.Medrano-Campillo,M.A.delaTorreLanza,N.Alvarez-SanchezandA.Carrillo-Vico(2015)."AssociationsbetweenfrailtyandserumN-terminalpropeptideoftypeIprocollagenand25-hydroxyvitaminDinolderSpanishwomen:TheToledoStudyforHealthyAging."ExpGerontol69:79-84.

Al-Zahrani,M.S.(2006)."Increasedintakeofdairyproductsisrelatedtolowerperiodontitisprevalence."JPeriodontol77(2):289-294.

Annweiler,C.,D.Milea,H.E.Whitson,C.Y.Cheng,T.Y.Wong,M.K.Ikram,E.L.LamoureuxandC.Sabanayagam(2016)."VitaminDinsufficiencyandcognitiveimpairmentinAsians:amulti-ethnicpopulation-basedstudyandmeta-analysis."JInternMed280(3):300-311.

Annweiler,C.,Y.Rolland,A.M.Schott,H.Blain,B.Vellas,F.R.HerrmannandO.Beauchet(2012)."HighervitaminDdietaryintakeisassociatedwithlowerriskofalzheimer'sdisease:a7-yearfollow-up."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci67(11):1205-1211.

Annweiler,C.,A.M.Schott,Y.Rolland,H.Blain,F.R.HerrmannandO.Beauchet(2010)."DietaryintakeofvitaminDandcognitioninolderwomen:alargepopulation-basedstudy."Neurology75(20):1810-1816.

Aregbesola, A., S. Voutilainen, T. Nurmi, J. K. Virtanen, K. Ronkainen and T. P. Tuomainen (2013). "Serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D3 and the risk ofpneumoniainanageinggeneralpopulation."JEpidemiolCommunityHealth67(6):533-536.

Arshad,M.,S.Jaberian,A.Pazouki,S.Riazi,M.A.RangrazandS.Mokhber(2017)."Irondeficiencyanemiaandmegaloblasticanemiainobesepatients."RomJInternMed55(1):3-7.

Assantachai,P.,P.YamwongandT.Chongsuphaijaisiddhi(1997)."RelationshipsofvitaminB1,B12,folateandthecognitiveabilityoftheThairuralelderly."JMedAssocThai80(11):700-705.

Bahlous, A.,N. Farjallah, K. Bouzid, A. Klouz, A.Mohsni,H. Sahli,M. Lakhal, S. Sallami and J. Abdelmoula (2009). "HypovitaminosisD in Tunisianosteoporoticpostmenopausalwomenandtherelationshipwithbonefractures."TunisMed87(3):188-190.

Bailey,R.L.,J.H.Ledikwe,H.Smiciklas-Wright,D.C.MitchellandG.L.Jensen(2004)."Persistentoralhealthproblemsassociatedwithcomorbidityandimpaireddietqualityinolderadults."JAmDietAssoc104(8):1273-1276.

Bakhtiyarova,S.,O.Lesnyak,N.Kyznesova,M.A.BlankensteinandP.Lips(2006)."VitaminDstatusamongpatientswithhipfractureandelderlycontrolsubjectsinYekaterinburg,Russia."OsteoporosInt17(3):441-446.

Bartali,B.,E.Devore,F.GrodsteinandJ.H.Kang(2014)."PlasmavitaminDlevelsandcognitivefunctioninagingwomen:thenurses'healthstudy."JNutrHealthAging18(4):400-406.

Bartali,B.,E.A.Frongillo,S.Bandinelli,F.Lauretani,R.D.Semba,L.P.FriedandL.Ferrucci(2006)."Lownutrientintakeisanessentialcomponentoffrailtyinolderpersons."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci61(6):589-593.

Beasley,J.M.,A.Z.LaCroix,J.C.Larson,Y.Huang,M.L.Neuhouser,L.F.Tinker,R.Jackson,L.Snetselaar,K.C.Johnson,C.B.EatonandR.L.Prentice(2014)."Biomarker-calibratedproteinintakeandbonehealthintheWomen'sHealthInitiativeclinicaltrialsandobservationalstudy."AmJClinNutr99(4):934-940.

Beasley,J.M.,A.Z.LaCroix,M.L.Neuhouser,Y.Huang,L.Tinker,N.Woods,Y.Michael,J.D.CurbandR.L.Prentice(2010)."ProteinintakeandincidentfrailtyintheWomen'sHealthInitiativeobservationalstudy."JAmGeriatrSoc58(6):1063-1071.

Benetou,V.,P.Orfanos,D.Zylis,S.Sieri,P.Contiero,R.Tumino,M.C.Giurdanella,P.H.Peeters,J.Linseisen,A.Nieters,H.Boeing,C.Weikert,U.Pettersson, I. Johansson,H.B.Bueno-de-Mesquita,M.Dorronsoro,P.BoffettaandA.Trichopoulou (2011). "Dietandhip fracturesamongelderlyEuropeansintheEPICcohort."EurJClinNutr65(1):132-139.

Bird,M.L.,K.D.Hill,I.K.Robertson,M.J.Ball,J.PittawayandA.D.Williams(2013)."Serum[25(OH)D]status,anklestrengthandactivityshowseasonalvariationinolderadults:relevanceforwinterfallsinhigherlatitudes."AgeAgeing42(2):181-185.

Bleicher,K.,R.G.Cumming,V.Naganathan,F.M.Blyth,D.G.LeCouteur,D.J.Handelsman,L.M.WaiteandM.J.Seibel(2014)."U-shapedassociationbetweenserum25-hydroxyvitaminDandfractureriskinoldermen:resultsfromtheprospectivepopulation-basedCHAMPstudy."JBoneMinerRes29(9):2024-2031.

Breitling,L.P.,L.Perna,H.Muller,E.Raum,M.KliegelandH.Brenner(2012)."VitaminDandcognitivefunctioningintheelderlypopulationinGermany."ExpGerontol47(1):122-127.

Page 29: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page29of40

Brouwer-Brolsma,E.M.,R.A.Dhonukshe-Rutten,J.P.vanWijngaarden,N.L.vandeZwaluw,P.H.in'tVeld,S.Wins,K.M.Swart,A.W.Enneman,A.C.Ham,S.C.vanDijk,N.M.vanSchoor,N.vanderVelde,A.G.Uitterlinden,P.Lips,R.P.Kessels,W.T.Steegenga,E.J.FeskensandL.C.deGroot(2015)."CognitivePerformance:ACross-SectionalStudyonSerumVitaminDandItsInterplayWithGlucoseHomeostasisinDutchOlderAdults."JAmMedDirAssoc16(7):621-627.

Brown,I.R.,A.BakowskaandP.H.Millard(1976)."VitaminDstatusofpatientswithfemoralneckfractures."AgeAgeing5(3):127-131.

Buchebner,D.,F.McGuigan,P.Gerdhem,J.Malm,M.RidderstraleandK.Akesson(2014)."VitaminD insufficiencyover5years isassociatedwithincreasedfracturerisk-anobservationalcohortstudyofelderlywomen."OsteoporosInt25(12):2767-2775.

Buchebner,D.,F.McGuigan,P.Gerdhem,M.RidderstraleandK.Akesson(2016)."AssociationBetweenHypovitaminosisDinElderlyWomenandLong-andShort-TermMortality-ResultsfromtheOsteoporoticProspectiveRiskAssessmentCohort."JAmGeriatrSoc64(5):990-997.

Buta,B.,P.P.Choudhury,Q.L.Xue,P.Chaves,K.Bandeen-Roche,M.Shardell,R.D.Semba,J.Walston,E.D.Michos,L.J.Appel,M.McAdams-DeMarco,A.Gross,S.Yasar,L.Ferrucci,L.P.FriedandR.R.Kalyani(2017)."TheAssociationofVitaminDDeficiencyandIncidentFrailtyinOlderWomen:TheRoleofCardiometabolicDiseases."JAmGeriatrSoc65(3):619-624.

Caire-Juvera,G.,C.Ritenbaugh,J.Wactawski-Wende,L.G.SnetselaarandZ.Chen(2009)."VitaminAandretinolintakesandtheriskoffracturesamongparticipantsoftheWomen'sHealthInitiativeObservationalStudy."AmJClinNutr89(1):323-330.

Cappello,S.,E.Cereda,M.Rondanelli,C.Klersy,B.Cameletti,R.Albertini,D.Magno,M.Caraccia,A.TurriandR.Caccialanza(2016)."ElevatedPlasmaVitaminB12ConcentrationsAreIndependentPredictorsofIn-HospitalMortalityinAdultPatientsatNutritionalRisk."Nutrients9(1).

Carlsson,M.,P.Wanby,L.Brudin,E.Lexne,K.Mathold,R.Nobin,L.Ericson,O.NordqvistandG.Petersson(2016)."OlderSwedishAdultswithHighSelf-PerceivedHealthShowOptimal25-HydroxyvitaminDLevelsWhereasVitaminDStatusIsLowinPatientswithHighDiseaseBurden."Nutrients8(11).

Castillo-Lancellotti, C., P.Margozzini, G. Valdivia, O. Padilla, R. Uauy, J. Rozowski and J. A. Tur (2015). "Serum folate, vitamin B12 and cognitiveimpairmentinChileanolderadults."PublicHealthNutr18(14):2600-2608.

Cauley,J.A.,R.L.Fullman,K.L.Stone,J.M.Zmuda,D.C.Bauer,E.Barrett-Connor,K.Ensrud,E.M.LauandE.S.Orwoll(2005)."Factorsassociatedwiththelumbarspineandproximalfemurbonemineraldensityinoldermen."OsteoporosInt16(12):1525-1537.

Cauley,J.A.,A.Z.Lacroix,L.Wu,M.Horwitz,M.E.Danielson,D.C.Bauer,J.S.Lee,R.D.Jackson,J.A.Robbins,C.Wu,F.Z.Stanczyk,M.S.LeBoff,J.Wactawski-Wende,G.Sarto,J.OckeneandS.R.Cummings(2008)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDconcentrationsandriskforhipfractures."AnnInternMed149(4):242-250.

Cauley,J.A.,N.Parimi,K.E.Ensrud,D.C.Bauer,P.M.Cawthon,S.R.Cummings,A.R.Hoffman,J.M.Shikany,E.Barrett-ConnorandE.Orwoll(2010)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDandtheriskofhipandnonspinefracturesinoldermen."JBoneMinerRes25(3):545-553.

Cawthon,P.M.,N.Parimi,E.Barrett-Connor,G.A.Laughlin,K.E.Ensrud,A.R.Hoffman,J.M.Shikany,J.A.Cauley,N.E.Lane,D.C.Bauer,E.S.OrwollandS.R.Cummings(2010)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminD,parathyroidhormone,andmortalityinoldermen."JClinEndocrinolMetab95(10):4625-4634.

Chan,H.H.,E.M.Lau,J.Woo,F.Lin,A.ShamandP.C.Leung(1996)."Dietarycalciumintake,physicalactivityandtheriskofvertebralfractureinChinese."OsteoporosInt6(3):228-232.

Chan,R.,D.Chan,J.Woo,C.Ohlsson,D.Mellstrom,T.KwokandP.C.Leung(2012)."NotallelderlypeoplebenefitfromvitaminDsupplementationwithrespecttophysicalfunction:resultsfromtheOsteoporoticFracturesinMenStudy,HongKong."JAmGeriatrSoc60(2):290-295.

Chang,C.I.,D.C.Chan,K.N.Kuo,C.A.HsiungandC.Y.Chen(2010)."VitaminDinsufficiencyandfrailtysyndromeinolderadultslivinginaNorthernTaiwancommunity."ArchGerontolGeriatr50Suppl1:S17-21.

Chavance,M.,B.Herbeth,C.Fournier,C.JanotandG.Vernhes(1989)."Vitaminstatus,immunityandinfectionsinanelderlypopulation."EurJClinNutr43(12):827-835.

Chei,C.L.,P.Raman,Z.X.Yin,X.M.Shi,Y.ZengandD.B.Matchar(2014)."VitaminDlevelsandcognitioninelderlyadultsinChina."JAmGeriatrSoc62(11):2125-2129.

Cherubini,A.,A.Martin,C.Andres-Lacueva,A.DiIorio,M.Lamponi,P.Mecocci,B.Bartali,A.Corsi,U.SeninandL.Ferrucci(2005)."VitaminElevels,cognitiveimpairmentanddementiainolderpersons:theInCHIANTIstudy."NeurobiolAging26(7):987-994.

Choi,M.K.,H.J.Song,Y.J.PaekandH.J.Lee(2013)."GenderdifferencesintherelationshipbetweenvitaminCandabdominalobesity."IntJVitamNutrRes83(6):377-384.

Chuang,S.C.,H.L.Chen,W.T.Tseng,I.C.Wu,C.C.Hsu,H.Y.Chang,Y.I.Chen,M.M.Lee,K.LiuandC.A.Hsiung(2016)."Circulating25-hydroxyvitaminDandphysicalperformanceinolderadults:anationwidestudyinTaiwan."AmJClinNutr104(5):1334-1344.

Civelek,G.M.,N.O.Pekyavas,N.Cetin,S.N.CosarandM.Karatas(2014)."AssociationofvitaminDdeficiencywithmusclestrengthandqualityoflifeinpostmenopausalwomen."Climacteric17(4):472-477.

Page 30: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page30of40

Cooper,C.,D.J.BarkerandC.Wickham(1988)."Physicalactivity,musclestrength,andcalciumintakeinfractureoftheproximalfemurinBritain."Bmj297(6661):1443-1446.

Cuttitta,F.,D.Torres,D.Vogiatzis,C.Butta,M.Bellanca,D.Gueli,U.Lupo,C.Schimmenti,G.Virzi,R.Petrantoni,F.Balistreri,S.PaternaandG.Parrinello(2014)."Obesityandirondeficiencyanemiaasriskfactorsforasymptomaticbacteriuria."EurJInternMed25(3):292-295.

D'Adamo,C.R.,M.D.Shardell,G.E.Hicks,D.L.Orwig,M.C.Hochberg,R.D.Semba,J.A.Yu-Yahiro,L.Ferrucci,J.S.MagazinerandR.R.Miller(2011)."SerumvitaminEconcentrationsamonghighlyfunctioninghipfracturepatientsarehigherthaninnonfracturecontrols."NutrRes31(3):205-214.

Dahl,C.,A.J.Sogaard,G.S.Tell,L.Forsen,T.P.Flaten,D.Hongve,T.K.Omsland,K.Holvik,H.E.MeyerandG.Aamodt(2015)."Populationdataoncalciumindrinkingwaterandhipfracture:Anassociationmaydependonothermineralsinwater.ANOREPOSstudy."Bone81:292-299.

Dangour,A.D.,E.Allen,D.Elbourne,A.Fletcher,M.RichardsandR.Uauy(2009)."FishconsumptionandcognitivefunctionamongolderpeopleintheUK:baselinedatafromtheOPALstudy."JNutrHealthAging13(3):198-202.

deJonge,E.A.,J.C.Kiefte-deJong,N.Campos-Obando,L.Booij,O.H.Franco,A.Hofman,A.G.Uitterlinden,F.RivadeneiraandM.C.Zillikens(2015)."DietaryvitaminAintakeandbonehealthintheelderly:theRotterdamStudy."EurJClinNutr69(12):1360-1368.

deLau,L.M.,H.Refsum,A.D.Smith,C.JohnstonandM.M.Breteler(2007)."Plasmafolateconcentrationandcognitiveperformance:RotterdamScanStudy."AmJClinNutr86(3):728-734.

DelBrutto,O.H.,R.M.Mera,J.Gillman,M.ZambranoandJ.E.Ha(2016)."OilyFishIntakeandCognitivePerformanceinCommunity-DwellingOlderAdults:TheAtahualpaProject."JCommunityHealth41(1):82-86.

Deplas,A.,F.Debiais,M.Alcalay,D.BontouxandP.Thomas(2004)."Bonedensity,parathyroidhormone,calciumandvitaminDnutritionalstatusofinstitutionalizedelderlysubjects."JNutrHealthAging8(5):400-404.

Devore,E.E.,J.H.Kang,M.J.StampferandF.Grodstein(2013)."TheassociationofantioxidantsandcognitionintheNurses'HealthStudy."AmJEpidemiol177(1):33-41.

Dhonukshe-Rutten,R.A.,M.Lips,N.deJong,A.P.M.J.Chin,G.J.Hiddink,M.vanDusseldorp,L.C.DeGrootandW.A.vanStaveren(2003)."VitaminB-12statusisassociatedwithbonemineralcontentandbonemineraldensityinfrailelderlywomenbutnotinmen."JNutr133(3):801-807.

Diamond,T.,P.Smerdely,N.Kormas,R.Sekel,T.VuandP.Day(1998)."Hipfractureinelderlymen:theimportanceofsubclinicalvitaminDdeficiencyandhypogonadism."MedJAust169(3):138-141.

Dixon,T.,P.Mitchell,T.Beringer,S.Gallacher,C.Moniz,S.Patel,G.PearsonandP.Ryan(2006)."Anoverviewoftheprevalenceof25-hydroxy-vitaminDinadequacyamongstelderlypatientswithorwithoutfragilityfractureintheUnitedKingdom."CurrMedResOpin22(2):405-415.

Dretakis,O.E.,A.N.Margioris,C.Tsatsanis,K.E.Dretakis,N.MalliarakiandK.Steriopoulos(2011)."ElderlypatientswithtrochanterichipfracturehavelowerserumVitaminDlevelscomparedtopatientswithcervicalhipfracture."ArchGerontolGeriatr52(1):e15-18.

Eaton,C.B.,A.Young,M.A.Allison,J.Robinson,L.W.Martin,L.H.Kuller,K.C.Johnson,J.D.Curb,L.VanHorn,A.McTiernan,S.LiuandJ.E.Manson(2011)."ProspectiveassociationofvitaminDconcentrationswithmortality inpostmenopausalwomen:resultsfromtheWomen'sHealthInitiative(WHI)."AmJClinNutr94(6):1471-1478.

ElMaghraoui,A.,I.Ghozlani,A.Mounach,A.Rezqi,K.Oumghar,L.Achemlal,A.BezzaandZ.Ouzzif(2012)."Homocysteine,folate,andvitaminB12levelsandvertebralfractureriskinpostmenopausalwomen."JClinDensitom15(3):328-333.

Elias,M.F.,M.A.Robbins,M.M.Budge,P.K.Elias,S.L.Brennan,C.Johnston,Z.NagyandC.J.Bates(2006)."Homocysteine,folate,andvitaminsB6andB12bloodlevelsinrelationtocognitiveperformance:theMaine-Syracusestudy."PsychosomMed68(4):547-554.

Ellis,F.R.,S.HoleshandJ.W.Ellis(1972)."Incidenceofosteoporosisinvegetariansandomnivores."AmJClinNutr25(6):555-558.

Emsley,C.L.,S.Gao,Y.Li,C.Liang,R.Ji,K.S.Hall,J.Cao,F.Ma,Y.Wu,P.Ying,Y.Zhang,S.Sun,F.W.Unverzagt,C.W.SlemendaandH.C.Hendrie(2000)."TraceelementlevelsindrinkingwaterandcognitivefunctionamongelderlyChinese."AmJEpidemiol151(9):913-920.

Ensrud,K.E.,S.K.Ewing,L.Fredman,M.C.Hochberg,J.A.Cauley,T.A.Hillier,S.R.Cummings,K.YaffeandP.M.Cawthon(2010)."Circulating25-hydroxyvitaminDlevelsandfrailtystatusinolderwomen."JClinEndocrinolMetab95(12):5266-5273.

Evangelopoulos,A.A.,N.G.Vallianou,D.B.Panagiotakos,A.Georgiou,G.A.Zacharias,A.N.Alevra,G.J.Zalokosta,E.D.VogiatzakisandP.C.Avgerinos(2008)."Aninverserelationshipbetweencumulatingcomponentsofthemetabolicsyndromeandserummagnesiumlevels."NutrRes28(10):659-663.

Fardellone,P.,F.E.Cotte,C.Roux,E.Lespessailles,F.MercierandA.F.Gaudin(2010)."CalciumintakeandtheriskofosteoporosisandfracturesinFrenchwomen."JointBoneSpine77(2):154-158.

Faulkner,K.A.,J.A.Cauley,J.M.Zmuda,D.P.Landsittel,A.B.Newman,S.A.Studenski,M.S.Redfern,K.E.Ensrud,H.A.Fink,N.E.LaneandM.C.Nevitt(2006)."Higher1,25-dihydroxyvitaminD3concentrationsassociatedwithlowerfallratesinoldercommunity-dwellingwomen."OsteoporosInt17(9):1318-1328.

Page 31: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page31of40

Feng,L.,T.P.Ng,L.Chuah,M.NitiandE.H.Kua(2006)."Homocysteine,folate,andvitaminB-12andcognitiveperformanceinolderChineseadults:findingsfromtheSingaporeLongitudinalAgeingStudy."AmJClinNutr84(6):1506-1512.

Feskanich, D., W. C. Willett and G. A. Colditz (2003). "Calcium, vitamin D, milk consumption, and hip fractures: a prospective study amongpostmenopausalwomen."AmJClinNutr77(2):504-511.

Finnes,T.E.,C.M.Lofthus,H.E.Meyer,A.J.Sogaard,G.S.Tell,E.M.Apalset,C.Gjesdal,G.Grimnes,B.Schei,R.Blomhoff,S.O.SamuelsenandK.Holvik(2016)."AcombinationoflowserumconcentrationsofvitaminsK1andDisassociatedwithincreasedriskofhipfracturesinelderlyNorwegians:aNOREPOSstudy."OsteoporosInt27(4):1645-1652.

Flicker,L.,K.Mead,R.J.MacInnis,C.Nowson,S.Scherer,M.S.Stein,J.Thomasx,J.L.HopperandJ.D.Wark(2003)."SerumvitaminDandfallsinolderwomeninresidentialcareinAustralia."JAmGeriatrSoc51(11):1533-1538.

Formosa, M. M. and A. Xuereb-Anastasi (2016). "Biochemical Predictors of Low Bone Mineral Density and Fracture Susceptibility in MaltesePostmenopausalWomen."CalcifTissueInt98(1):28-41.

Fox,K.M.,W.G.Hawkes,J.Magaziner,S.I.ZimmermanandJ.R.Hebel(1996)."Markersoffailuretothriveamongolderhipfracturepatients."JAmGeriatrSoc44(4):371-376.

Frassetto,L.A.,K.M.Todd,R.C.Morris,Jr.andA.Sebastian(2000)."Worldwideincidenceofhipfractureinelderlywomen:relationtoconsumptionofanimalandvegetablefoods."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci55(10):M585-592.

Gallacher,S.J.,C.McQuillian,M.Harkness,F.Finlay,A.P.GallagherandT.Dixon(2005)."PrevalenceofvitaminDinadequacyinScottishadultswithnon-vertebralfragilityfractures."CurrMedResOpin21(9):1355-1361.

Garnero,P.,F.Munoz,E.Sornay-RenduandP.D.Delmas(2007)."AssociationsofvitaminDstatuswithbonemineraldensity,boneturnover,bonelossandfractureriskinhealthypostmenopausalwomen.TheOFELYstudy."Bone40(3):716-722.

Gerdhem,P.,K.A.Ringsberg,K.J.ObrantandK.Akesson(2005)."Associationbetween25-hydroxyvitaminDlevels,physicalactivity,musclestrengthandfracturesintheprospectivepopulation-basedOPRAStudyofElderlyWomen."OsteoporosInt16(11):1425-1431.

Gonzalez,S.,J.M.Huerta,S.Fernandez,A.M.PattersonandC.Lasheras(2010)."Therelationshipbetweendietarylipidsandcognitiveperformanceinanelderlypopulation."IntJFoodSciNutr61(2):217-225.

Granic,A.,T.R.Hill,T.B.Kirkwood,K.Davies,J.Collerton,C.Martin-Ruiz,T.vonZglinicki,B.K.Saxby,K.A.Wesnes,D.Collerton,J.C.MathersandC.Jagger(2015)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDandcognitivedeclineintheveryold:theNewcastle85+Study."EurJNeurol22(1):106-115,e106-107.

Guligowska,A.,M.Piglowska,E.Fife,J.Kostka,B.K.Soltysik,L.KrocandT.Kostka(2016)."Inappropriatenutrients intakeisassociatedwithlowerfunctionalstatusandinferiorqualityoflifeinolderadultswithdepression."ClinIntervAging11:1505-1517.

Gumieiro,D.N.,B.P.MurinoRafacho,B.L.BuzatiPereira,K.A.Cavallari,S.E.Tanni,P.S.Azevedo,B.F.Polegato,L.A.MamedeZornoff,D.I.Dinhane,K.G.InnocentiDinhane,G.J.CacaoPereira,S.A.dePaivaandM.F.Minicucci(2015)."VitaminDserumlevelsareassociatedwithhandgripstrengthbutnotwithmusclemassorlengthofhospitalstayafterhipfracture."Nutrition31(7-8):931-934.

Gutierrez-Robledo,L.M.,J.A.Avila-Funes,H.Amieva,C.Meillon,J.L.Acosta,A.P.Navarrete-Reyes,N.Torres-Carrillo,J.F.Munoz-ValleandN.M.Torres-Carrillo(2016)."Associationoflowserum25-hydroxyvitaminDlevelswiththefrailtysyndromeinMexicancommunity-dwellingelderly."AgingMale19(1):58-63.

Haan,M.N.,J.W.Miller,A.E.Aiello,R.A.Whitmer,W.J.Jagust,D.M.Mungas,L.H.AllenandR.Green(2007)."Homocysteine,Bvitamins,andtheincidenceofdementiaandcognitiveimpairment:resultsfromtheSacramentoAreaLatinoStudyonAging."AmJClinNutr85(2):511-517.

Harris,T.B.,X.Song,I.Reinders,T.F.Lang,M.E.Garcia,K.Siggeirsdottir,S.Sigurdsson,V.Gudnason,G.Eiriksdottir,G.Sigurdsson,L.Steingrimsdottir,T.Aspelund,I.A.BrouwerandR.A.Murphy(2015)."Plasmaphospholipidfattyacidsandfish-oilconsumptioninrelationtoosteoporoticfractureriskinolderadults:theAge,Gene/EnvironmentSusceptibilityStudy."AmJClinNutr101(5):947-955.

Haslam,A.,M.A.Johnson,D.B.Hausman,M.E.Cress,D.K.Houston,A.DaveyandL.W.Poon(2014)."VitaminDstatusisassociatedwithgripstrengthincentenarians."JNutrGerontolGeriatr33(1):35-46.

Hin,H.,R.Clarke,P.Sherliker,W.Atoyebi,K.Emmens,J.Birks,J.Schneede,P.M.Ueland,E.Nexo,J.Scott,A.Molloy,M.Donaghy,C.FrostandJ.G.Evans(2006)."ClinicalrelevanceoflowserumvitaminB12concentrationsinolderpeople:theBanburyB12study."AgeAgeing35(4):416-422.

Hirani,V.,R.G.Cumming,V.Naganathan,F.Blyth,D.G.LeCouteur,D.J.Handelsman,L.M.WaiteandM.J.Seibel(2014)."Associationsbetweenserum25-hydroxyvitaminDconcentrationsandmultiplehealthconditions,physicalperformancemeasures,disability,andall-causemortality:theConcordHealthandAgeinginMenProject."JAmGeriatrSoc62(3):417-425.

Hirani,V.,V.Naganathan,R.G.Cumming,F.Blyth,D.G.LeCouteur,D.J.Handelsman,L.M.WaiteandM.J.Seibel(2013)."Associationsbetweenfrailtyandserum25-hydroxyvitaminDand1,25-dihydroxyvitaminDconcentrationsinolderAustralianmen:theConcordHealthandAgeinginMenProject."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci68(9):1112-1121.

Page 32: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page32of40

Holbrook,T.L.,E.Barrett-ConnorandD.L.Wingard(1988)."Dietarycalciumandriskofhipfracture:14-yearprospectivepopulationstudy."Lancet2(8619):1046-1049.

Holvik,K.,L.A.Ahmed,S.Forsmo,C.G.Gjesdal,G.Grimnes,S.O.Samuelsen,B.Schei,R.Blomhoff,G.S.TellandH.E.Meyer(2013)."Lowserumlevelsof25-hydroxyvitaminDpredicthipfractureintheelderly:aNOREPOSstudy."JClinEndocrinolMetab98(8):3341-3350.

Houston,D.K.,M.Cesari, L.Ferrucci,A.Cherubini,D.Maggio,B.Bartali,M.A. Johnson,G.G.SchwartzandS.B.Kritchevsky (2007). "AssociationbetweenvitaminDstatusandphysicalperformance:theInCHIANTIstudy."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci62(4):440-446.

Houston,D.K.,J.A.Tooze,R.H.Neiberg,D.B.Hausman,M.A.Johnson,J.A.Cauley,D.C.Bauer,P.M.Cawthon,M.K.Shea,G.G.Schwartz,J.D.Williamson,F.A.Tylavsky,M.Visser,E.M.Simonsick,T.B.HarrisandS.B.Kritchevsky(2012)."25-hydroxyvitaminDstatusandchangeinphysicalperformanceandstrengthinolderadults:theHealth,Aging,andBodyCompositionStudy."AmJEpidemiol176(11):1025-1034.

Houston,D.K.,J.A.Tooze,R.H.Neiberg,D.B.Hausman,M.A.Johnson,J.A.Cauley,D.C.Bauer,P.M.Cawthon,M.K.Shea,G.G.Schwartz,J.D.Williamson,F.A.Tylavsky,M.Visser,E.M.Simonsick,T.B.HarrisandS.B.Kritchevsky(2012)."25-hydroxyvitaminDstatusandchangeinphysicalperformanceandstrengthinolderadults:theHealth,Aging,andBodyCompositionStudy."AmJEpidemiol176(11):1025-1034.

Huang,T.L.,P.P.Zandi,K.L.Tucker,A.L.Fitzpatrick,L.H.Kuller,L.P.Fried,G.L.BurkeandM.C.Carlson(2005)."BenefitsoffattyfishondementiariskarestrongerforthosewithoutAPOEepsilon4."Neurology65(9):1409-1414.

Hung,H.C.,W.Willett,A.Ascherio,B.A.Rosner,E.RimmandK.J.Joshipura(2003)."Toothlossanddietaryintake."JAmDentAssoc134(9):1185-1192.

Huo,Y.R.,P.Suriyaarachchi,F.Gomez,C.L.Curcio,D.Boersma,P.Gunawardene,O.DemontieroandG.Duque(2016)."Phenotypeofsarcopenicobesityinolderindividualswithahistoryoffalling."ArchGerontolGeriatr65:255-259.

Hwang,B.,J.Y.Lim,J.Lee,N.K.Choi,Y.O.AhnandB.J.Park(2012)."Prevalencerateandassociatedfactorsofsarcopenicobesityinkoreanelderlypopulation."JKoreanMedSci27(7):748-755.

Hwang,J.S.,K.S.Tsai,Y.M.Cheng,W.J.Chen,S.T.Tu,K.H.Lu,S.M.Hou,S.H.Yang,H.Cheng,H.J.Lai,S.LeiandJ.F.Chen(2014)."VitaminDstatusinnon-supplementedpostmenopausalTaiwanesewomenwithosteoporosisandfragilityfracture."BMCMusculoskeletDisord15:257.

Ilich,J.Z.,S.Cvijetic,I.C.Baric,I.Cecic,M.Saric,Z.Crncevic-Orlic,M.BlanusaandM.Korsic(2009)."NutritionandlifestyleinrelationtobonehealthandbodyweightinCroatianpostmenopausalwomen."IntJFoodSciNutr60(4):319-332.

Inderjeeth,C.A.,T.Barrett,Y.Al-Lahham,J.Mulford,F.NicklasonandC.Reberger(2002)."Seasonalvariation,hipfractureandvitaminDlevels inSouthernTasmania."NZMedJ115(1152):183-185.

Inderjeeth, C.A.,D.Glennon,A. Petta, J. Soderstrom, I. Boyatzis and J. Tapper (2007). "VitaminD andmuscle strength in patientswithpreviousfractures."NZMedJ120(1262):U2730.

Iolascon,G.,A.deSire,D.Calafiore,A.Moretti,R.GimiglianoandF.Gimigliano(2015)."HypovitaminosisDisassociatedwithareductioninupperandlowerlimbmusclestrengthandphysicalperformanceinpost-menopausalwomen:aretrospectivestudy."AgingClinExpRes27Suppl1:S23-30.

Isaia,G.,R.Giorgino,G.B.Rini,M.Bevilacqua,D.MaugeriandS.Adami(2003)."PrevalenceofhypovitaminosisDinelderlywomeninItaly:clinicalconsequencesandriskfactors."OsteoporosInt14(7):577-582.

Iwasaki,M.,P.Moynihan,M.C.Manz,G.W.Taylor,A.Yoshihara,K.Muramatsu,R.WatanabeandH.Miyazaki (2013). "Dietaryantioxidantsandperiodontaldiseaseincommunity-basedolderJapanese:a2-yearfollow-upstudy."PublicHealthNutr16(2):330-338.

Iwasaki,M.,G.W.Taylor,P.Moynihan,A.Yoshihara,K.Muramatsu,R.WatanabeandH.Miyazaki(2011)."Dietaryratioofn-6ton-3polyunsaturatedfattyacidsandperiodontaldiseaseincommunity-basedolderJapanese:a3-yearfollow-upstudy."ProstaglandinsLeukotEssentFattyAcids85(2):107-112.

Iwasaki,M.,A.Yoshihara,P.Moynihan,R.Watanabe,G.W.TaylorandH.Miyazaki(2010)."Longitudinalrelationshipbetweendietaryomega-3fattyacidsandperiodontaldisease."Nutrition26(11-12):1105-1109.

Iwasaki,T.,A.Nakajima,M.Yoneda,Y.Yamada,K.Mukasa,K.Fujita,N.Fujisawa,K.WadaandY.Terauchi(2005)."Serumferritinisassociatedwithvisceralfatareaandsubcutaneousfatarea."DiabetesCare28(10):2486-2491.

Jacqmin, H., D. Commenges, L. Letenneur, P. Barberger-Gateau and J. F. Dartigues (1994). "Components of drinking water and risk of cognitiveimpairmentintheelderly."AmJEpidemiol139(1):48-57.

Jang,W.Y.,M.S.Chung,G.H.Baek,C.H.Song,H.E.ChoandH.S.Gong(2012)."VitaminDlevelsinpost-menopausalKoreanwomenwithadistalradiusfracture."Injury43(2):237-241.

Jelicic,M.,C.JonkerandD.J.Deeg(2001)."EffectoflowlevelsofserumvitaminB12andfolicacidoncognitiveperformanceinoldage:apopulation-basedstudy."DevNeuropsychol20(3):565-571.

Page 33: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page33of40

Johnell,O.,B.Gullberg,J.A.Kanis,E.Allander,L.Elffors,J.Dequeker,G.Dilsen,C.Gennari,A.LopesVaz,G.Lyritisandetal.(1995)."RiskfactorsforhipfractureinEuropeanwomen:theMEDOSStudy.MediterraneanOsteoporosisStudy."JBoneMinerRes10(11):1802-1815.

Jorde,R.,E.B.Mathiesen,S.Rogne,T.Wilsgaard,M.Kjaergaard,G.GrimnesandH.Schirmer(2015)."VitaminDandcognitivefunction:TheTromsoStudy."JNeurolSci355(1-2):155-161.

Kalmijn,S.,E.J.Feskens,L.J.LaunerandD.Kromhout(1997)."Polyunsaturatedfattyacids,antioxidants,andcognitivefunctioninveryoldmen."AmJEpidemiol145(1):33-41.

Kang,J.H.,M.C.IrizarryandF.Grodstein(2006)."Prospectivestudyofplasmafolate,vitaminB12,andcognitivefunctionanddecline."Epidemiology17(6):650-657.

Kempker,J.A.,M.J.Magee,J.P.CegielskiandG.S.Martin(2016)."AssociationsBetweenVitaminDLevelandHospitalizationsWithandWithoutanInfectioninaNationalCohortofMedicareBeneficiaries."AmJEpidemiol183(10):920-929.

Khan,B.,C.A.Nowson,R.M.Daly,D.R.English,A.M.Hodge,G.G.GilesandP.R.Ebeling(2015)."HigherDietaryCalciumIntakesAreAssociatedWithReducedRisksofFractures,CardiovascularEvents,andMortality:AProspectiveCohortStudyofOlderMenandWomen."JBoneMinerRes30(10):1758-1766.

Khaw,K.T.andP.Woodhouse(1995)."InterrelationofvitaminC,infection,haemostaticfactors,andcardiovasculardisease."Bmj310(6994):1559-1563.

Kim,G.,H.Kim,K.N.Kim,J.I.Son,S.Y.Kim,T.TamuraandN.Chang(2013)."RelationshipofcognitivefunctionwithBvitaminstatus,homocysteine,andtissuefactorpathwayinhibitorincognitivelyimpairedelderly:across-sectionalsurvey."JAlzheimersDis33(3):853-862.

Kim,H. J., J.G. Jang, K. S.Hong, J. K. Park andE. Y. Choi (2015). "Relationshipbetween serumvitaminD concentrations and clinical outcomeofcommunity-acquiredpneumonia."IntJTubercLungDis19(6):729-734.

Kim,M.H.andY.J.Bae(2012)."Postmenopausalvegetarians'lowserumferritinlevelmayreducetheriskformetabolicsyndrome."BiolTraceElemRes149(1):34-41.

Kim,S.H.,H.S.KwonandH.J.Hwang(2017)."Whitebloodcellcounts,insulinresistance,vitaminDlevelsandsarcopeniainKoreanelderlymen."ScandJClinLabInvest77(3):228-233.

Kobayashi,S.,K.Asakura,H.SugaandS.Sasaki(2013)."HighproteinintakeisassociatedwithlowprevalenceoffrailtyamongoldJapanesewomen:amulticentercross-sectionalstudy."NutrJ12:164.

Kobayashi,S.,H.SugaandS.Sasaki(2017)."DietwithacombinationofhighproteinandhightotalantioxidantcapacityisstronglyassociatedwithlowprevalenceoffrailtyamongoldJapanesewomen:amulticentercross-sectionalstudy."NutrJ16(1):29.

Kobe,T.,A.V.Witte,A.Schnelle,U.Grittner,V.A.Tesky,J.Pantel,J.P.Schuchardt,A.Hahn,J.Bohlken,D.RujescuandA.Floel(2016)."VitaminB-12concentration,memoryperformance,andhippocampalstructureinpatientswithmildcognitiveimpairment."AmJClinNutr103(4):1045-1054.

Kouris-Blazos,A.,M.L.Wahlqvist,A.Trichopoulou,E.PolychronopoulosandD.Trichopoulos(1996)."HealthandnutritionalstatusofelderlyGreekmigrantstoMelbourne,Australia."AgeAgeing25(3):177-189.

Laurent,M.,S.Bastuji-Garin,A.Plonquet,P.N.Bories,A.LeThuaut,E.Audureau,P.O.Lang,S.Nakib,E.Liuu,F.Canoui-PoitrineandE.Paillaud(2015)."Interrelationsofimmunologicalparameters,nutrition,andhealthcare-associatedinfections:prospectivestudyinelderlyin-patients."ClinNutr34(1):79-85.

LeBoff,M.S.,L.Kohlmeier,S.Hurwitz,J.Franklin,J.WrightandJ.Glowacki(1999)."OccultvitaminDdeficiencyinpostmenopausalUSwomenwithacutehipfracture."Jama281(16):1505-1511.

Lee,L.,S.A.Kang,H.O.Lee,B.H.Lee,J.S.Park,J.H.Kim,I.K.Jung,Y.J.ParkandJ.E.Lee(2001)."RelationshipsbetweendietaryintakeandcognitivefunctionlevelinKoreanelderlypeople."PublicHealth115(2):133-138.

Lee,L.K.,S.ShaharandN.Rajab(2009)."Serumfolateconcentration,cognitiveimpairment,andDNAdamageamongelderlyindividualsinMalaysia."NutrRes29(5):327-334.

Lee,Y.H.,Y.W.Lim,P.S.Ling,Y.Y.Tan,M.CheongandK.S.Lam(2007)."Inadequatedietarycalciumintakeinelderlypatientswithhipfractures."SingaporeMedJ48(12):1117-1121.

Leon-Munoz,L.M.,P.Guallar-Castillon,E.Lopez-GarciaandF.Rodriguez-Artalejo(2014)."Mediterraneandietandriskoffrailtyincommunity-dwellingolderadults."JAmMedDirAssoc15(12):899-903.

Li,S.,Y.Ou,H.Zhang,Z.Zhang,H.Zhou,L.Liu,Z.ShengandE.Liao(2014)."VitaminDstatusanditsrelationshipwithbodycomposition,bonemineraldensityandfractureriskinurbancentralsouthChinesepostmenopausalwomen."AnnNutrMetab64(1):13-19.

Lim,L.S.,L.J.Harnack,D.LazovichandA.R.Folsom(2004)."VitaminAintakeandtheriskofhipfractureinpostmenopausalwomen:theIowaWomen'sHealthStudy."OsteoporosInt15(7):552-559.

Page 34: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page34of40

Llewellyn,D.J.,I.A.Lang,K.M.LangaandD.Melzer(2011)."VitaminDandcognitiveimpairmentintheelderlyU.S.population."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci66(1):59-65.

Llewellyn,D.J.,I.A.Lang,K.M.Langa,G.Muniz-Terrera,C.L.Phillips,A.Cherubini,L.FerrucciandD.Melzer(2010)."VitaminDandriskofcognitivedeclineinelderlypersons."ArchInternMed170(13):1135-1141.

Lloyd,B.D.,D.A.Williamson,N.A.Singh,R.D.Hansen,T.H.Diamond,T.P.Finnegan,B.J.Allen,J.N.Grady,T.M.Stavrinos,E.U.Smith,A.D.DiwanandM.A.FiataroneSingh(2009)."Recurrentandinjuriousfallsintheyearfollowinghipfracture:aprospectivestudyofincidenceandriskfactorsfromtheSarcopeniaandHipFracturestudy."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci64(5):599-609.

Looker,A.C.(2013)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDandriskofmajorosteoporoticfracturesinolderU.S.adults."JBoneMinerRes28(5):997-1006.

Looker,A.C.andM.E.Mussolino(2008)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDandhipfractureriskinolderU.S.whiteadults."JBoneMinerRes23(1):143-150.

Lopes,J.B.,C.F.Danilevicius,L.Takayama,V.F.Caparbo,M.Scazufca,E.BonfaandR.M.Pereira(2009)."VitaminDinsufficiency:ariskfactortovertebralfracturesincommunity-dwellingelderlywomen."Maturitas64(4):218-222.

Lu, J., Y. Y. Chen, L. Zhang, Y. G. Li and C.Wang (2016). "Laboratory nutritional parameters predict one-year mortality in elderly patients withintertrochantericfracture."AsiaPacJClinNutr25(3):457-463.

Lv,J.T.,Y.Y.Zhang,S.Q.TianandK.Sun(2016)."Serumof25-HydroxyvitaminDandIntactParathyroidHormoneLevelsinPostmenopausalWomenwithHipandUpperLimbFractures."JAmGeriatrSoc64(5):1068-1072.

Machado,K.L.,D.S.Domiciano,L.G.Machado,J.B.Lopes,C.P.Figueiredo,L.Takayama,R.M.Oliveira,P.R.MenezesandR.M.Pereira(2015)."Persistent hypovitaminosis D and loss of hip bonemineral density over time as additional risk factors for recurrent falls in a population-basedprospectivecohortofelderlypersonslivinginthecommunity.TheSaoPauloAgeing&Health(SPAH)Study."OsteoporosInt26(5):1535-1542.

Maier,G.S.,J.B.Seeger,K.Horas,K.E.Roth,A.A.KurthandU.Maus(2015)."TheprevalenceofvitaminDdeficiencyinpatientswithvertebralfragilityfractures."BoneJointJ97-b(1):89-93.

Mangialasche,F.,A.Solomon,I.Kareholt,B.Hooshmand,R.Cecchetti,L.Fratiglioni,H.Soininen,T.Laatikainen,P.MecocciandM.Kivipelto(2013)."SerumlevelsofvitaminEformsandriskofcognitiveimpairmentinaFinnishcohortofolderadults."ExpGerontol48(12):1428-1435.

Martinez-Ramirez,M.J.,A.D.Delgado-Martinez,M.Ruiz-Bailen,C.delaFuente,M.A.Martinez-GonzalezandM.Delgado-Rodriguez(2012)."Proteinintakeandfractureriskinelderlypeople:acase-controlstudy."ClinNutr31(3):391-395.

Martinez-Ramirez,M.J.,S.PalmaPerez,A.D.Delgado-Martinez,M.A.Martinez-Gonzalez,C.DelaFuenteArrillagaandM.Delgado-Rodriguez(2007)."VitaminC,vitaminB12,folateandtheriskofosteoporoticfractures.Acase-controlstudy."IntJVitamNutrRes77(6):359-368.

Mastaglia,S.R.,M.Seijo,D.Muzio,J.Somoza,M.NunezandB.Oliveri(2011)."EffectofvitaminDnutritionalstatusonmusclefunctionandstrengthinhealthywomenagedoversixty-fiveyears."JNutrHealthAging15(5):349-354.

Mathei,C.,G.VanPottelbergh,B.Vaes,W.Adriaensen,D.Grusonand J.M.Degryse (2013). "No relationbetweenvitaminD statusandphysicalperformanceintheoldestold:resultsfromtheBelfrailstudy."AgeAgeing42(2):186-190.

McAuley,K.A.,S.Jones,N.J.Lewis-Barned,P.ManningandA.Goulding(1997)."LowvitaminDstatusiscommonamongelderlyDunedinwomen."NZMedJ110(1048):275-277.

McLean,R.R.,P.F.Jacques,J.Selhub,L.Fredman,K.L.Tucker,E.J.Samelson,D.P.Kiel,L.A.CupplesandM.T.Hannan(2008)."PlasmaBvitamins,homocysteine,andtheirrelationwithbonelossandhipfractureinelderlymenandwomen."JClinEndocrinolMetab93(6):2206-2212.

McLean,R.R.,K.M.Mangano,M.T.Hannan,D.P.KielandS.Sahni(2016)."DietaryProteinIntakeIsProtectiveAgainstLossofGripStrengthAmongOlderAdultsintheFraminghamOffspringCohort."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci71(3):356-361.

Melhus,H.,G.Snellman,R.Gedeborg,L.Byberg,L.Berglund,H.Mallmin,P.Hellman,R.Blomhoff,E.Hagstrom,J.ArnlovandK.Michaelsson(2010)."Plasma25-hydroxyvitaminDlevelsandfractureriskinacommunity-basedcohortofelderlymeninSweden."JClinEndocrinolMetab95(6):2637-2645.

Meyer,H.E.,C.Henriksen,J.A.Falch,J.I.PedersenandA.Tverdal(1995)."Riskfactorsforhipfractureinahighincidencearea:acase-controlstudyfromOslo,Norway."OsteoporosInt5(4):239-246.

Meyer,H.E.,A.Tverdal,C.Henriksen,J.I.PedersenandJ.A.Falch(1996)."[RiskfactorsoffemoralneckfracturesinOslo]."TidsskrNorLaegeforen116(22):2656-2659.

Michaelsson,K.,H.Melhus,R.BelloccoandA.Wolk(2003)."DietarycalciumandvitaminDintakeinrelationtoosteoporoticfracturerisk."Bone32(6):694-703.

Michelon,E.,C.Blaum,R.D.Semba,Q.L.Xue,M.O.RicksandL.P.Fried(2006)."Vitaminandcarotenoidstatusinolderwomen:associationswiththefrailtysyndrome."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci61(6):600-607.

Page 35: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page35of40

Millen,A.E.,C.A.Andrews,M.J.LaMonte,K.M.Hovey,M.Swanson,R.J.GencoandJ.Wactawski-Wende(2014)."VitaminDstatusand5-yearchangesinperiodontaldiseasemeasuresamongpostmenopausalwomen:theBuffaloOsteoPerioStudy."JPeriodontol85(10):1321-1332.

Miller,J.W.,D.J.Harvey,L.A.Beckett,R.Green,S.T.Farias,B.R.Reed,J.M.Olichney,D.M.MungasandC.DeCarli(2015)."VitaminDStatusandRatesofCognitiveDeclineinaMultiethnicCohortofOlderAdults."JAMANeurol72(11):1295-1303.

Miller,R.R.,G.E.Hicks,M.D.Shardell,A.R.Cappola,W.G.Hawkes,J.A.Yu-Yahiro,A.KeeganandJ.Magaziner(2007)."AssociationofserumvitaminDlevelswithinflammatoryresponsefollowinghipfracture:theBaltimoreHipStudies."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci62(12):1402-1406.

Milman,S.,M.Schulder-Katz,J.Deluty,M.E.Zimmerman,J.P.Crandall,N.Barzilai,M.L.MelamedandG.Atzmon(2014)."IndividualswithexceptionallongevitymanifestadelayedassociationbetweenvitaminDinsufficiencyandcognitiveimpairment."JAmGeriatrSoc62(1):153-158.

Misra,D.,S.D.Berry,K.E.Broe,R.R.McLean,L.A.Cupples,K.L.Tucker,D.P.KielandM.T.Hannan(2011)."Doesdietaryproteinreducehipfractureriskinelders?TheFraminghamOsteoporosisStudy."OsteoporosInt22(1):345-349.

Moniz,C.,T.DewandT.Dixon(2005)."PrevalenceofvitaminDinadequacyinosteoporotichipfracturepatientsinLondon."CurrMedResOpin21(12):1891-1894.

Mooijaart,S.P.,J.Gussekloo,M.Frolich,J.Jolles,D.J.Stott,R.G.WestendorpandA.J.deCraen(2005)."Homocysteine,vitaminB-12,andfolicacidandtheriskofcognitivedeclineinoldage:theLeiden85-Plusstudy."AmJClinNutr82(4):866-871.

Morris,M.C.,D.A.Evans,J.L.Bienias,C.C.Tangney,L.E.Hebert,P.A.ScherrandJ.A.Schneider(2005)."DietaryfolateandvitaminB12intakeandcognitivedeclineamongcommunity-dwellingolderpersons."ArchNeurol62(4):641-645.

Munger,R.G.,J.R.CerhanandB.C.Chiu(1999)."Prospectivestudyofdietaryproteinintakeandriskofhipfractureinpostmenopausalwomen."AmJClinNutr69(1):147-152.

Nagel,G.,F.Herbolsheimer,M.Riepe,T.Nikolaus,M.D.Denkinger,R.Peter,G.Weinmayr,D.Rothenbacher,W.Koenig,A.C.LudolphandC.A.vonArnim (2015). "Serum Vitamin D Concentrations and Cognitive Function in a Population-Based Study among Older Adults in South Germany." JAlzheimersDis45(4):1119-1126.

Nakamura,K.,T.Saito,M.Oyama,R.Oshiki,R.Kobayashi,T.Nishiwaki,M.NashimotoandY.Tsuchiya(2011)."VitaminDsufficiencyisassociatedwithlowincidenceoflimbandvertebralfracturesincommunity-dwellingelderlyJapanesewomen:theMuramatsuStudy."OsteoporosInt22(1):97-103.

Naqvi,A.Z.,B.Harty,K.J.Mukamal,A.M.Stoddard,M.VitolinsandJ.E.Dunn(2011)."Monounsaturated,trans,andsaturatedFattyacidsandcognitivedeclineinwomen."JAmGeriatrSoc59(5):837-843.

Nguyen,T.V.,J.R.Center,P.N.SambrookandJ.A.Eisman(2001)."Riskfactorsforproximalhumerus,forearm,andwristfracturesinelderlymenandwomen:theDubboOsteoporosisEpidemiologyStudy."AmJEpidemiol153(6):587-595.

Nieves,J.W.,E.Barrett-Connor,E.S.Siris,M.Zion,S.BarlasandY.T.Chen(2008)."CalciumandvitaminDintakeinfluencebonemass,butnotshort-termfracturerisk,inCaucasianpostmenopausalwomenfromtheNationalOsteoporosisRiskAssessment(NORA)study."OsteoporosInt19(5):673-679.

Nishihira,J.,T.Tokashiki,Y.Higashiuesato,D.C.Willcox,N.Mattek,L.Shinto,Y.OhyaandH.H.Dodge(2016)."AssociationsbetweenSerumOmega-3FattyAcidLevelsandCognitiveFunctionsamongCommunity-DwellingOctogenariansinOkinawa,Japan:TheKOCOAStudy."JAlzheimersDis51(3):857-866.

Nuzzo,V.,A.Zuccoli,F.deTerlizzi,A.ColaoandL.Tauchmanova(2013)."Low25-hydroxyvitaminDlevelsandlowbonedensityassessedbyquantitativeultrasonometryinacohortofpostmenopausalItaliannuns."JClinDensitom16(3):308-312.

Oh,C.,B.H.Jeon,S.N.ReidStorm,S.JhoandJ.K.No(2017)."ThemosteffectivefactorstooffsetsarcopeniaandobesityintheolderKorean:Physicalactivity,vitaminD,andproteinintake."Nutrition33:169-173.

Oh,C.,S.Jho,J.K.NoandH.S.Kim(2015)."BodycompositionchangeswererelatedtonutrientintakesinelderlymenbutelderlywomenhadahigherprevalenceofsarcopenicobesityinapopulationofKoreanadults."NutrRes35(1):1-6.

Oldewage-Theron,W.H.,A.A.EgalandC.J.Grobler(2015)."Isobesityassociatedwithironstatusintheelderly?AcasestudyfromSharpeville,SouthAfrica."PublicHealthNutr18(3):521-529.

OliveiraMartinho,K.,A.LuizAraujoTinocoandA.QueirozRibeiro(2015)."PREVALENCEANDFACTORSASSOCIATEDWITHVITAMINB12DEFICIENCYINELDERLYFROMVICOSA/MG,BRASIL."NutrHosp32(5):2162-2168.

Olsson,E.,B.Karlstrom,L.Kilander,L.Byberg,T.CederholmandP.Sjogren(2015)."Dietarypatternsandcognitivedysfunctionina12-yearfollow-upstudyof70yearoldmen."JAlzheimersDis43(1):109-119.

Orchard,T.S.,J.C.Larson,N.Alghothani,S.Bout-Tabaku,J.A.Cauley,Z.Chen,A.Z.LaCroix,J.Wactawski-WendeandR.D.Jackson(2014)."Magnesiumintake,bonemineraldensity,andfractures:resultsfromtheWomen'sHealthInitiativeObservationalStudy."AmJClinNutr99(4):926-933.

Page 36: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page36of40

Ortega,R.M.,P.Andres,A.Melendez,E.Turrero,M.J.Gaspar,M.Gonzalez-Gross,G.Garrido,M.Chamorro,E.Diaz-AlboandO.Moreiras-Varela(1992)."[EffectofnutritiononthefunctionalcapacityofagroupofelderlySpaniards]."ArchLatinoamNutr42(2):133-145.

Ortega,R.M.,L.R.Manas,P.Andres,M.J.Gaspar,F.R.Agudo,A.JimenezandT.Pascual(1996)."Functionalandpsychicdeteriorationinelderlypeoplemaybeaggravatedbyfolatedeficiency."JNutr126(8):1992-1999.

Orwoll,E.,C.M.Nielson,L.M.Marshall,L.Lambert,K.F.Holton,A.R.Hoffman,E.Barrett-Connor, J.M.Shikany,T.DamandJ.A.Cauley(2009)."VitaminDdeficiencyinoldermen."JClinEndocrinolMetab94(4):1214-1222.

Pabst,G.,A.K.Zimmermann,C.Huth,W.Koenig,T.Ludwig,A.Zierer,A.PetersandB.Thorand(2015)."Associationoflow25-hydroxyvitaminDlevelswiththefrailtysyndromeinanagedpopulation:resultsfromtheKORA-ageAugsburgstudy."JNutrHealthAging19(3):258-264.

Paleologos,M.,R.G.CummingandR.Lazarus(1998)."CohortstudyofvitaminCintakeandcognitiveimpairment."AmJEpidemiol148(1):45-50.

Pasco,J.A.,M.J.Henry,M.A.Kotowicz,K.M.Sanders,E.Seeman,J.R.Pasco,H.G.SchneiderandG.C.Nicholson(2004)."SeasonalperiodicityofserumvitaminDandparathyroidhormone,boneresorption,andfractures:theGeelongOsteoporosisStudy."JBoneMinerRes19(5):752-758.

Passeri,G.,G.Pini,L.Troiano,R.Vescovini,P.Sansoni,M.Passeri,P.Gueresi,R.Delsignore,M.PedrazzoniandC.Franceschi(2003)."LowvitaminDstatus,highboneturnover,andbonefracturesincentenarians."JClinEndocrinolMetab88(11):5109-5115.

Paulionis,L.,S.L.KaneandK.A.Meckling(2005)."Vitaminstatusandcognitivefunctioninalong-termcarepopulation."BMCGeriatr5:16.

Pepersack,T.,J.Garbusinski,J.Robberecht,I.Beyer,D.WillemsandM.Fuss(1999)."Clinicalrelevanceofthiaminestatusamongsthospitalizedelderlypatients."Gerontology45(2):96-101.

PerezCano,R.,F.GalanGalanandG.Dilsen(1993)."RiskfactorsforhipfractureinSpanishandTurkishwomen."Bone14Suppl1:S69-72.

Perna,L.,U.Mons,M.KliegelandH.Brenner(2014)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDandcognitivedecline:alongitudinalstudyamongnon-dementedolderadults."DementGeriatrCognDisord38(3-4):254-263.

Pramyothin,P.,S.Techasurungkul,J.Lin,H.Wang,A.Shah,P.D.Ross,R.PuapongandR.D.Wasnich(2009)."VitaminDstatusandfalls,frailty,andfracturesamongpostmenopausalJapanesewomenlivinginHawaii."OsteoporosInt20(11):1955-1962.

Quadri,P.,C.Fragiacomo,R.Pezzati,E.Zanda,G.Forloni,M.TettamantiandU.Lucca(2004)."Homocysteine,folate,andvitaminB-12inmildcognitiveimpairment,Alzheimerdisease,andvasculardementia."AmJClinNutr80(1):114-122.

Radavelli-Bagatini,S.,K.Zhu,J.R.LewisandR.L.Prince(2014)."Dairyfoodintake,peripheralbonestructure,andmusclemassinelderlyambulatorywomen."JBoneMinerRes29(7):1691-1700.

Ramos,M. I.,L.H.Allen,D.M.Mungas,W.J. Jagust,M.N.Haan,R.GreenandJ.W.Miller (2005)."Lowfolatestatus isassociatedwith impairedcognitivefunctionanddementiaintheSacramentoAreaLatinoStudyonAging."AmJClinNutr82(6):1346-1352.

Ranstam,J.andJ.A.Kanis(1995)."InfluenceofageandbodymassontheeffectsofvitaminDonhipfracturerisk."OsteoporosInt5(6):450-454.

Ravaglia,G.,P.Forti,F.Maioli,M.Martelli,L.Servadei,N.Brunetti,E.PorcelliniandF.Licastro(2005)."HomocysteineandfolateasriskfactorsfordementiaandAlzheimerdisease."AmJClinNutr82(3):636-643.

Ravaglia,G.,P.Forti,F.Maioli,L.Servadei,M.Martelli,N.Brunetti,L.Bastagli,D.CucinottaandE.Mariani (2005)."Folate,butnothomocysteine,predictstheriskoffractureinelderlypersons."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci60(11):1458-1462.

Ravaglia,G.,P.Forti,F.Maioli,V.Zanardi,E.Dalmonte,G.Grossi,D.Cucinotta,P.MaciniandM.Caldarera(2000)."BloodhomocysteineandvitaminBlevelsarenotassociatedwithcognitiveskillsinhealthynormallyageingsubjects."JNutrHealthAging4(4):218-222.

Reinders,I.,X.Song,M.Visser,G.Eiriksdottir,V.Gudnason,S.Sigurdsson,T.Aspelund,K.Siggeirsdottir,I.A.Brouwer,T.B.HarrisandR.A.Murphy(2015)."PlasmaphospholipidPUFAsareassociatedwithgreatermuscleandkneeextensionstrengthbutnotwithchangesinmuscleparametersinolderadults."JNutr145(1):105-112.

Ribot,C.,F.Tremollieres,J.M.Pouilles,J.L.Albarede,M.Mansat,G.Utheza,M.Bonneu,P.BonnissentandC.Ricoeur(1993)."Riskfactorsforhipfracture.MEDOSstudy:resultsoftheToulouseCentre."Bone14Suppl1:S77-80.

Roberts,R.O.,J.R.Cerhan,Y.E.Geda,D.S.Knopman,R.H.Cha,T.J.Christianson,V.S.Pankratz,R.J.Ivnik,H.M.O'ConnorandR.C.Petersen(2010)."PolyunsaturatedfattyacidsandreducedoddsofMCI:theMayoClinicStudyofAging."JAlzheimersDis21(3):853-865.

Roberts,R.O.,Y.E.Geda,J.R.Cerhan,D.S.Knopman,R.H.Cha,T.J.Christianson,V.S.Pankratz,R.J.Ivnik,B.F.Boeve,H.M.O'ConnorandR.C.Petersen(2010)."Vegetables,unsaturatedfats,moderatealcoholintake,andmildcognitiveimpairment."DementGeriatrCognDisord29(5):413-423.

Robinson,P.J.,R.J.Bell,A.Lanzafame,C.Kirby,A.Weekes,L.PitermanandS.R.Davis(2013)."TheprevalenceofvitaminDdeficiencyandrelationshipwithfractureriskinolderwomenpresentinginAustraliangeneralpractice."AustralasJAgeing32(3):177-183.

Page 37: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page37of40

Robinson,S.M.,K.A.Jameson,S.F.Batelaan,H.J.Martin,H.E.Syddall,E.M.Dennison,C.CooperandA.A.Sayer(2008)."Dietanditsrelationshipwithgripstrengthincommunity-dwellingoldermenandwomen:theHertfordshirecohortstudy."JAmGeriatrSoc56(1):84-90.

Rothenbacher, D., J. Klenk,M. D. Denkinger, F. Herbolsheimer, T. Nikolaus, R. Peter, B. O. Boehm, K. Rapp, D. Dallmeier andW. Koenig (2014)."Prospectiveevaluationofrenalfunction,serumvitaminDlevel,andriskoffallandfractureincommunity-dwellingelderlysubjects."OsteoporosInt25(3):923-932.

Saarela,R.K.,E.Lindroos,H.Soini,K.Hiltunen,S.Muurinen,M.H.SuominenandK.H.Pitkala(2016)."Dentition,nutritionalstatusandadequacyofdietaryintakeamongolderresidentsinassistedlivingfacilities."Gerodontology33(2):225-232.

Saito,K.,T.Yokoyama,H.Yoshida,H.Kim,H.Shimada,Y.Yoshida,H.Iwasa,Y.Shimizu,Y.Kondo,S.Handa,N.Maruyama,A.IshigamiandT.Suzuki(2012)."AsignificantrelationshipbetweenplasmavitaminCconcentrationandphysicalperformanceamongJapaneseelderlywomen."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci67(3):295-301.

Saito,N.,N.Tabata,S.Saito,Y.Andou,Y.Onaga,A.Iwamitsu,M.Sakamoto,T.Hori,H.SayamaandT.Kawakita(2004)."Bonemineraldensity,serumalbuminandserummagnesium."JAmCollNutr23(6):701s-703s.

Salminen,M.,P.Saaristo,M.Salonoja,S.Vaapio,T.Vahlberg,C.Lamberg-Allardt,P.AarnioandS.L.Kivela (2015)."VitaminDstatusandphysicalfunctioninolderFinnishpeople:Aone-yearfollow-upstudy."ArchGerontolGeriatr61(3):419-424.

Samefors,M.,C.J.Ostgren,S.Molstad,C.Lannering,P.MidlovandA.Tengblad(2014)."VitaminDdeficiencyinelderlypeopleinSwedishnursinghomesisassociatedwithincreasedmortality."EurJEndocrinol170(5):667-675.

Samieri,C.,C.Feart,C.Proust-Lima,E.Peuchant,J.F.Dartigues,H.AmievaandP.Barberger-Gateau(2011)."omega-3fattyacidsandcognitivedecline:modulationbyApoEepsilon4alleleanddepression."NeurobiolAging32(12):2317.e2313-2322.

Samieri,C.,V.GinderCoupez,S.Lorrain,L.Letenneur,B.Alles,C.Feart,D.PaineauandP.Barberger-Gateau(2013)."Nutrientpatternsandriskoffractureinoldersubjects:resultsfromtheThree-CityStudy."OsteoporosInt24(4):1295-1305.

Sato,R.,K.J.Helzlsouer,G.W.Comstock,S.C.Hoffman,E.P.NorkusandL.P.Fried(2006)."Across-sectionalstudyofvitaminCandcognitivefunctioninolderadults:thedifferentialeffectsofgender."JNutrHealthAging10(1):37-44.

Sato,Y., Y.Honda,T.Asohand J. Iwamoto (2006). "Longitudinal studyofboneandcalciummetabolismand fracture incidence in spinocerebellardegeneration."EurNeurol56(3):155-161.

Schottker,B.,K.U.Saum,L.Perna,J.M.Ordonez-Mena,B.HolleczekandH.Brenner(2014)."IsvitaminDdeficiencyacauseofincreasedmorbidityandmortalityatolderageorsimplyanindicatorofpoorhealth?"EurJEpidemiol29(3):199-210.

Schulze-Spate,U.,R.Turner,Y.Wang,R.Chao,P.C.Schulze,K.Phipps,E.OrwollandT.T.Dam(2015)."RelationshipofBoneMetabolismBiomarkersandPeriodontalDisease:TheOsteoporoticFracturesinMen(MrOS)Study."JClinEndocrinolMetab100(6):2425-2433.

Schwartz,N.,E.K.Kaye,M.E.Nunn,A.Spiro,3rdandR.I.Garcia(2012)."High-fiberfoodsreduceperiodontaldiseaseprogressioninmenaged65andolder:theVeteransAffairsnormativeagingstudy/DentalLongitudinalStudy."JAmGeriatrSoc60(4):676-683.

Scott,D.,L.Blizzard,J.Fell,G.GilesandG.Jones(2010)."Associationsbetweendietarynutrientintakeandmusclemassandstrengthincommunity-dwellingolderadults:theTasmanianOlderAdultCohortStudy."JAmGeriatrSoc58(11):2129-2134.

Seamans,K.M.,T.R.Hill,L.Scully,N.Meunier,M.Andrillo-Sanchez,A.Polito,I.Hininger-Favier,D.Ciarapica,E.E.Simpson,B.J.Stewart-Knox,J.M.O'Connor,C.CoudrayandK.D.Cashman(2010)."VitaminDstatusandmeasuresofcognitivefunctioninhealthyolderEuropeanadults."EurJClinNutr64(10):1172-1178.

Sellmeyer,D.E.,K.L.Stone,A.SebastianandS.R.Cummings(2001)."Ahighratioofdietaryanimaltovegetableproteinincreasestherateofbonelossandtheriskoffractureinpostmenopausalwomen.StudyofOsteoporoticFracturesResearchGroup."AmJClinNutr73(1):118-122.

Semba,R.D.,B.Bartali,J.Zhou,C.Blaum,C.W.KoandL.P.Fried(2006)."Lowserummicronutrientconcentrationspredictfrailtyamongolderwomenlivinginthecommunity."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci61(6):594-599.

Semba,R.D.,D.K.Houston,L.Ferrucci,A.R.Cappola,K.Sun,J.M.GuralnikandL.P.Fried(2009)."Lowserum25-hydroxyvitaminDconcentrationsareassociatedwithgreaterall-causemortalityinoldercommunity-dwellingwomen."NutrRes29(8):525-530.

Seo,J.A.,H.Cho,C.R.Eun,H.J.Yoo,S.G.Kim,K.M.Choi,S.H.Baik,D.S.Choi,M.H.Park,C.HanandN.H.Kim(2012)."AssociationbetweenvisceralobesityandsarcopeniaandvitaminDdeficiencyinolderKoreans:theAnsanGeriatricStudy."JAmGeriatrSoc60(4):700-706.

Seo,M.H.,M.K.Kim,S.E.Park,E.J.Rhee,C.Y.Park,W.Y.Lee,K.H.Baek,K.H.Song,M.I.KangandK.W.Oh(2013)."Theassociationbetweendailycalciumintakeandsarcopeniainolder,non-obeseKoreanadults:thefourthKoreaNationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey(KNHANESIV)2009."EndocrJ60(5):679-686.

Seton,M.,V.Jackson,K.E.Lasser,S.Doppelt,M.Pierre-JacquesandM.Connelly(2005)."Low25-hydroxyvitaminDandosteopeniaareprevalentinpersons>or=55yrwithfractureatanysite:aprospective,observationalstudyofpersonsfracturinginthecommunity."JClinDensitom8(4):454-460.

Page 38: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page38of40

Shahar,A.,L.Feiglin,D.R.Shahar,S.LevyandU.Seligsohn(2001)."HighprevalenceandimpactofsubnormalserumvitaminB12levelsinIsraelieldersadmittedtoageriatrichospital."JNutrHealthAging5(2):124-127.

Shahar,D.,M.Levi,I.Kurtz,S.Shany,I.Zvili,E.Mualleme,A.Shahar,O.SaridandI.Melzer(2009)."Nutritionalstatusinrelationtobalanceandfallsintheelderly:apreliminarylookatserumfolate."AnnNutrMetab54(1):59-66.

Shahar,S.,L.K.Lee,N.Rajab,C.L.Lim,N.A.Harun,M.F.Noh,S.Mian-ThenandR.Jamal(2013)."AssociationbetweenvitaminA,vitaminEandapolipoproteinEstatuswithmildcognitiveimpairmentamongelderlypeopleinlow-costresidentialareas."NutrNeurosci16(1):6-12.

Shardell,M.,C.D'Adamo,D.E.Alley,R.R.Miller,G.E.Hicks,Y.Milaneschi,R.D.Semba,A.Cherubini,S.BandinelliandL.Ferrucci(2012)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminD,transitionsbetweenfrailtystates,andmortalityinolderadults:theInvecchiareinChiantiStudy."JAmGeriatrSoc60(2):256-264.

Shardell,M.,G.E.Hicks,R.R.Miller,S.Kritchevsky,D.Andersen,S.Bandinelli,A.CherubiniandL.Ferrucci(2009)."AssociationoflowvitaminDlevelswiththefrailtysyndromeinmenandwomen."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci64(1):69-75.

Sheiham,A.,J.G.Steele,W.Marcenes,C.Lowe,S.Finch,C.J.Bates,A.PrenticeandA.W.Walls(2001)."Therelationshipamongdentalstatus,nutrientintake,andnutritionalstatusinolderpeople."JDentRes80(2):408-413.

Shikany,J.M.,E.Barrett-Connor,K.E.Ensrud,P.M.Cawthon,C.E.Lewis,T.T.Dam,J.ShannonandD.T.Redden(2014)."Macronutrients,dietquality,andfrailtyinoldermen."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci69(6):695-701.

Shimizu,Y.,H.Kim,H.Yoshida,H.ShimadaandT.Suzuki(2015)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDlevelandriskoffallsinJapanesecommunity-dwellingelderlywomen:a1-yearfollow-upstudy."OsteoporosInt26(8):2185-2192.

Shinkov,A.,A.M.Borissova,L.Dakovska,J.Vlahov,L.Kassabova,D.SvinarovandS.Krivoshiev(2016)."DifferencesintheprevalenceofvitaminDdeficiencyandhipfracturesinnursinghomeresidentsandindependentlylivingelderly."ArchEndocrinolMetab60(3):217-222.

Simonelli,C.,T.W.Weiss,J.Morancey,L.SwansonandY.T.Chen(2005)."PrevalenceofvitaminDinadequacyinaminimaltraumafracturepopulation."CurrMedResOpin21(7):1069-1074.

Skalska,A.,A.GalasandT.Grodzicki(2012)."25-hydroxyvitaminDandphysicalandcognitiveperformanceinolderpeoplewithchronicconditions."PolArchMedWewn122(4):162-169.

Smit,E.,C.J.Crespo,Y.Michael,F.A.Ramirez-Marrero,G.R.Brodowicz,S.BartlettandR.E.Andersen(2012)."TheeffectofvitaminDandfrailtyonmortalityamongnon-institutionalizedUSolderadults."EurJClinNutr66(9):1024-1028.

Sohl,E.,R.T.deJongh,M.W.Heymans,N.M.vanSchoorandP.Lips(2015)."ThresholdsforSerum25(OH)DConcentrationsWithRespecttoDifferentOutcomes."JClinEndocrinolMetab100(6):2480-2488.

Solfrizzi,V.,A.D'Introno,A.M.Colacicco,C.Capurso,R.Palasciano,S.Capurso,F.Torres,A.CapursoandF.Panza(2005)."Unsaturatedfattyacidsintakeandall-causesmortality:a8.5-yearfollow-upoftheItalianLongitudinalStudyonAging."ExpGerontol40(4):335-343.

Stein,M.S.,J.D.Wark,S.C.Scherer,S.L.Walton,P.Chick,M.DiCarlantonio,J.D.ZajacandL.Flicker(1999)."FallsrelatetovitaminDandparathyroidhormoneinanAustraliannursinghomeandhostel."JAmGeriatrSoc47(10):1195-1201.

Steingrimsdottir,L.,T.I.Halldorsson,K.Siggeirsdottir,M.F.Cotch,B.O.Einarsdottir,G.Eiriksdottir,S.Sigurdsson,L.J.Launer,T.B.Harris,V.GudnasonandG.Sigurdsson(2014)."Hipfracturesandbonemineraldensityintheelderly--importanceofserum25-hydroxyvitaminD."PLoSOne9(3):e91122.

Sun,L.L.,B.L.Li,H.L.Xie,F.Fan,W.Z.Yu,B.H.Wu,W.Q.XueandY.M.Chen(2014)."AssociationsbetweenthedietaryintakeofantioxidantnutrientsandtheriskofhipfractureinelderlyChinese:acase-controlstudy."BrJNutr112(10):1706-1714.

Suzuki,K.,T.Nomura,M.Sakurai,N.Sugihara,S.YamanakaandT.Matsukubo(2005)."Relationshipbetweennumberofpresentteethandnutritionalintakeininstitutionalizedelderly."BullTokyoDentColl46(4):135-143.

Swanson,C.M.,P.Srikanth,C.G.Lee,S.R.Cummings, I. Jans, J.A.Cauley,R.Bouillon,D.Vanderschueren,E.S.OrwollandC.M.Nielson(2015)."Associations of 25-Hydroxyvitamin D and 1,25-Dihydroxyvitamin D With Bone Mineral Density, Bone Mineral Density Change, and IncidentNonvertebralFracture."JBoneMinerRes30(8):1403-1413.

Tajar,A.,D.M.Lee,S.R.Pye,M.D.O'Connell,R.Ravindrarajah,E.Gielen,S.Boonen,D.Vanderschueren,N.Pendleton,J.D.Finn,G.Bartfai,F.F.Casanueva,G.Forti,A.Giwercman,T.S.Han,I.T.Huhtaniemi,K.Kula,M.E.Lean,M.Punab,F.C.WuandT.W.O'Neill(2013)."Theassociationoffrailtywithserum25-hydroxyvitaminDandparathyroidhormonelevelsinolderEuropeanmen."AgeAgeing42(3):352-359.

Tanaka,S.,T.Kuroda,Y.Yamazaki,Y.Shiraki,N.YoshimuraandM.Shiraki(2014)."Serum25-hydroxyvitaminDbelow25ng/mLisariskfactorforlongbonefracturecomparabletobonemineraldensityinJapanesepostmenopausalwomen."JBoneMinerMetab32(5):514-523.

Tanphaichitr,V.,P.Senachack,S.Nopchinda,P.LeelahagulandR.Pakpeankitvatana(1997)."Globalassessmentofnutritionriskfactorsintheelderly."SoutheastAsianJTropMedPublicHealth28Suppl2:94-99.

Tettamanti,M.,M.T.Garri,A.Nobili,E.RivaandU.Lucca(2006)."Lowfolateandtheriskofcognitiveandfunctionaldeficits intheveryold: theMonzino80-plusstudy."JAmCollNutr25(6):502-508.

Page 39: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page39of40

Tilvis,R.S.,M.H.Kahonen-Vare,J.Jolkkonen,J.Valvanne,K.H.PitkalaandT.E.Strandberg(2004)."Predictorsofcognitivedeclineandmortalityofagedpeopleovera10-yearperiod."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci59(3):268-274.

Tolppanen,A.M.,D.M.WilliamsandD.A.Lawlor(2011)."TheassociationofserumionizedcalciumandvitaminDwithadultcognitiveperformance."Epidemiology22(1):113-117.

Torbergsen,A.C.,L.O.Watne,T.B.Wyller,F.Frihagen,K.Stromsoe,T.BohmerandM.Mowe(2015)."VitaminK1and25(OH)Dareindependentlyandsynergisticallyassociatedwithariskforhipfractureinanelderlypopulation:acasecontrolstudy."ClinNutr34(1):101-106.

TotBabberichEde,N.,C.Gourdeau,S.Pointel,B.Lemarchant,O.BeauchetandC.Annweiler(2015)."Biologyofsubjectivecognitivecomplaintamongstgeriatricpatients:vitaminDinvolvement."CurrAlzheimerRes12(2):173-178.

Trevisan,C.,N.Veronese,S.Maggi,G.Baggio,E.D.Toffanello,S.Zambon,L.Sartori,E.Musacchio,E.Perissinotto,G.Crepaldi,E.ManzatoandG.Sergi(2017)."FactorsInfluencingTransitionsBetweenFrailtyStatesinElderlyAdults:TheProgettoVenetoAnzianiLongitudinalStudy."JAmGeriatrSoc65(1):179-184.

Tucker,K.L.,N.Qiao,T.Scott,I.RosenbergandA.Spiro,3rd(2005)."HighhomocysteineandlowBvitaminspredictcognitivedeclineinagingmen:theVeteransAffairsNormativeAgingStudy."AmJClinNutr82(3):627-635.

Tyrovolas, S., T. Psaltopoulou, G. Pounis, N. Papairakleous, V. Bountziouka, A. Zeimbekis, E. Gotsis, M. Antonopoulou, G. Metallinos, E.Polychronopoulos,C.LionisandD.B.Panagiotakos(2011)."NutrientintakeinrelationtocentralandoverallobesitystatusamongelderlypeoplelivingintheMediterraneanislands:theMEDISstudy."NutrMetabCardiovascDis21(6):438-445.

vandeRest,O.,Y.Wang,L.L.Barnes,C.Tangney,D.A.BennettandM.C.Morris(2016)."APOEepsilon4andtheassociationsofseafoodandlong-chainomega-3fattyacidswithcognitivedecline."Neurology86(22):2063-2070.

vandenBerg,P.,P.M.vanHaard,J.P.vandenBergh,D.D.Niesten,M.vanderElstandD.H.Schweitzer(2014)."Firstquantificationofcalciumintakefromcalcium-densedairyproductsinDutchfracturepatients(theDelftcohortstudy)."Nutrients6(6):2404-2418.

vanGelder,B.M.,M.Tijhuis,S.KalmijnandD.Kromhout(2007)."Fishconsumption,n-3fattyacids,andsubsequent5-ycognitivedeclineinelderlymen:theZutphenElderlyStudy."AmJClinNutr85(4):1142-1147.

Vidal,J.S.,C.Dufouil,V.DucrosandC.Tzourio(2008)."Homocysteine,folateandcognitioninalargecommunity-basedsampleofelderlypeople--the3CDijonStudy."Neuroepidemiology30(4):207-214.

Vinknes,K.J.,S.deVogel,A.K.Elshorbagy,E.Nurk,C.A.Drevon,C.G.Gjesdal,G.S.Tell,S.E.VollsetandH.Refsum(2011)."Dietaryintakeofproteinispositivelyassociatedwithpercentbodyfatinmiddle-agedandolderadults."JNutr141(3):440-446.

Virtanen,J.K.,D.Mozaffarian,W.C.WillettandD.Feskanich(2012)."Dietaryintakeofpolyunsaturatedfattyacidsandriskofhipfractureinmenandwomen."OsteoporosInt23(11):2615-2624.

Vogt,S.,S.Decke,T.deLasHerasGala,B.Linkohr,W.Koenig,K.H.Ladwig,A.PetersandB.Thorand(2015)."ProspectiveassociationofvitaminDwithfrailtystatusandall-causemortalityinolderadults:ResultsfromtheKORA-AgeStudy."PrevMed73:40-46.

Vogt,S.,A.Zierer,M.Laxy,W.Koenig,B.Linkohr,J.Linseisen,A.PetersandB.Thorand(2016)."AssociationofserumvitaminDwithchangeinweightandtotalbodyfatinaGermancohortofolderadults."EurJClinNutr70(1):136-139.

Waerhaug,J.(1967)."PrevalenceofperiodontaldiseaseinCeylon.Associationwithage,sex,oralhygiene,socio-economicfactors,vitamindeficiencies,malnutrition,betelandtobaccoconsumptionandethnicgroup.Finalreport."ActaOdontolScand25(2):205-231.

Wang,W.J.,K.L.Kuo,C.K.Liaw,T.Y.Wu,W.C.ChieandJ.M.Chen(2017)."BonehealthamongolderadultsinTaiwan."ArchGerontolGeriatr70:155-161.

Warensjo,E., L.Byberg,H.Melhus,R.Gedeborg,H.Mallmin,A.WolkandK.Michaelsson (2011). "Dietarycalcium intakeand riskof fractureandosteoporosis:prospectivelongitudinalcohortstudy."Bmj342:d1473.

Wengreen,H.J.,R.G.Munger,N.A.West,D.R.Cutler,C.D.Corcoran,J.ZhangandN.E.Sassano(2004)."DietaryproteinintakeandriskofosteoporotichipfractureinelderlyresidentsofUtah."JBoneMinerRes19(4):537-545.

Wham,C.,F.Baggett,R.Teh,S.Moyes,M.Kepa,M.Connolly,S.JatranaandN.Kerse(2015)."DietaryproteinintakemayreducehospitalisationduetoinfectioninMaoriofadvancedage:LiLACSNZ."AustNZJPublicHealth39(4):390-395.

Wilhelm-Leen,E.R.,Y.N.Hall,I.H.DeboerandG.M.Chertow(2010)."VitaminDdeficiencyandfrailtyinolderAmericans."JInternMed268(2):171-180.

Wilkins,C.H.,S.J.Birge,Y.I.ShelineandJ.C.Morris(2009)."VitaminDdeficiencyisassociatedwithworsecognitiveperformanceandlowerbonedensityinolderAfricanAmericans."JNatlMedAssoc101(4):349-354.

Wilkins,C.H., Y. I. Sheline,C.M.Roe, S. J. Birgeand J. C.Morris (2006). "VitaminDdeficiency is associatedwith lowmoodandworse cognitiveperformanceinolderadults."AmJGeriatrPsychiatry14(12):1032-1040.

Page 40: INCluSilver European Personalised Nutrition Strategy · The SACN concluded that the dietary reference value for total carbohydrate intake of an average adult ... Dietary reference

This project has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under grant agreement No 731349

Page40of40

Wlodarek, D., D. Glabska, A. Kolota, P. Adamczyk, A. Czekajlo, W. Grzeszczak, B. Drozdzowska and W. Pluskiewicz (2014). "Calcium intake andosteoporosis:theinfluenceofcalciumintakefromdairyproductsonhipbonemineraldensityandfractureincidence-apopulation-basedstudyinwomenover55yearsofage."PublicHealthNutr17(2):383-389.

Wong,Y.Y.,K.A.McCaul,B.B.Yeap,G.J.HankeyandL.Flicker(2013)."LowvitaminDstatusisanindependentpredictorofincreasedfrailtyandall-causemortalityinoldermen:theHealthinMenStudy."JClinEndocrinolMetab98(9):3821-3828.

Woo, J., E. Lau, R. Swaminathan, C. P. Pang and D. MacDonald (1990). "Biochemical predictors for osteoporotic fractures in elderly Chinese--alongitudinalstudy."Gerontology36(1):55-58.

Woo,J.,H.Lynn,W.Y.Lau,J.Leung,E.Lau,S.Y.WongandT.Kwok(2006)."NutrientintakeandpsychologicalhealthinanelderlyChinesepopulation."IntJGeriatrPsychiatry21(11):1036-1043.

Yang,Y.J.andJ.Kim(2014)."FactorsinrelationtobonemineraldensityinKoreanmiddle-agedandoldermen:2008-2010KoreaNationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey."AnnNutrMetab64(1):50-59.

Yavuz,B.B.,M.Cankurtaran,I.C.Haznedaroglu,M.Halil,Z.Ulger,B.AltunandS.Ariogul(2012)."Irondeficiencycancausecognitiveimpairmentingeriatricpatients."JNutrHealthAging16(3):220-224.

Yazdanpanah,N.,A.G.Uitterlinden,M.C.Zillikens,M.Jhamai,F.Rivadeneira,A.Hofman,R.deJonge,J.Lindemans,H.A.PolsandJ.B.vanMeurs(2008)."LowdietaryriboflavinbutnotfolatepredictsincreasedfractureriskinpostmenopausalwomenhomozygousfortheMTHFR677Tallele."JBoneMinerRes23(1):86-94.

Yazdanpanah,N.,M.C.Zillikens,F.Rivadeneira,R.deJong,J.Lindemans,A.G.Uitterlinden,H.A.PolsandJ.B.vanMeurs(2007)."EffectofdietaryBvitaminsonBMDandriskoffractureinelderlymenandwomen:theRotterdamstudy."Bone41(6):987-994.

Yu,Y.H.,H.K.KuoandY.L.Lai(2007)."Theassociationbetweenserumfolatelevelsandperiodontaldiseaseinolderadults:datafromtheNationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey2001/02."JAmGeriatrSoc55(1):108-113.

Zamboni,M.,E.Zoico,P.Tosoni,A.Zivelonghi,A.Bortolani,S.Maggi,V.DiFrancescoandO.Bosello(2002)."RelationbetweenvitaminD,physicalperformance,anddisabilityinelderlypersons."JGerontolABiolSciMedSci57(1):M7-11.

Zeng,F.F.,H.L.Xie,F.Fan,W.Q.Xue,B.H.Wu,H.L.ZhuandY.M.Chen(2015)."AssociationofdietaryfatintakewiththeriskofhipfracturesinanelderlyChinesepopulation:Amatchedcase-controlstudy."GeriatrGerontolInt15(10):1171-1178.

Zhong,Y.,C.A.OkoroandL.S.Balluz(2009)."Associationoftotalcalciumanddietaryproteinintakeswithfractureriskinpostmenopausalwomen:the1999-2002NationalHealthandNutritionExaminationSurvey(NHANES)."Nutrition25(6):647-654.