indefense#of#eavesdropping: twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf ·...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
In defense of eavesdropping: Twi2er as conversa4on, not self-‐indulgence
Shannon Sindorf PhD student, Journalism and Mass Communica6on
University of Colorado @shannonsindorf
Presenta4on for Theorizing the Web 2013
![Page 2: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
The “self-‐indulgence” frame
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
Social media are thought of as performances
Par4cipa4on in social media is oGen considered a self-‐indulgence
Twi2er carries the baggage
of Facebook
![Page 3: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
The “conversa4on” frame
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
A be2er frame with which to view Twi2er is to see it as a broad conversa4on
года з канвеера Ніжагародскага аўтамабільнага завода (сышоў першы грузавы аўтамабіль НАЗ-‐АА[ Першыя тры з паловай тысячы машын НАЗ-‐АА з-‐за недахопу штампавальнага абсталявання былі выпушчаныя з драўлянай кабінай.
Überprüfe anschließend bioe auch die weiteren Beiträge des Benutzers – wenn jemand eine. Hört der Benutzer trotz Ansprache mache den Fall auf der Vandalismusmeldung bekannt.
Oes, os wnawn ni gychwyn sgwennu erthyglau! Mae yna hefyd
gynlluniau gan Wici Cymru i hyfforddi golygyddion, a bydd cyhoeddiad am hyn cyn hir.
Überprüfe anschließend bioe auch die weiteren Beiträge des Benutzers –. Vandalismusmeldung bekannt.
Oes, os wnawn ni gychwyn sgwennu golygyddion, a bydd cyhoeddiad am hyn
cyn hir.
![Page 4: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
Conversa4on in Democracy
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
Delibera4ve democracy theory: Democracy works primarily not through formal processes such as vo4ng, but through the debate and discussion that precede vo4ng
Twi2er can be one venue for that crucial,
informal delibera4on
![Page 5: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
What we gain when we see Twi2er as a conversa4on
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
The “self-‐indulgence” frame is a hindrance to conversa4on
Twee4ng is not (necessarily) a self-‐indulgence, but rather the taking of one’s turn
![Page 6: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
On Twi2er, eavesdropping is invited but
unacknowledged
Eavesdropping is not an an4-‐social act, but a
pro-‐social one
Eavesdropping on Twi2er
![Page 7: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
Good and bad conversa4on
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
A lot of online conversa4on is
very bad conversa4on
A “conversa4on” frame allows us to dis4nguish between good and bad forms of conversa4on
![Page 8: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
We need to acknowledge and talk about the fact that we’re in a conversa4on if it’s going to be a produc4ve one
Irony and self-‐reflexivity are tools of meta-‐conversa4on
Meta-‐conversa4on
![Page 9: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
# A conversa4on is more than a hashtag
Discourse analysis and cri4cal discourse analysis are great
methods to use to analyze Twi2er-‐as-‐conversa4on
DA and CDA will likely need to be more autoethnographic—mass media methods won’t work on Twi2er
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
Twi2er and scholarship
![Page 10: Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon ...shannonsindorf.com/twitter_eavesdropping.pdf · Indefense#of#eavesdropping: Twierasconversaon, notself8indulgence!! ShannonSindorf#](https://reader033.vdocument.in/reader033/viewer/2022041919/5e6b409bf8b6185cb231af36/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
Shannon Sindorf v In Defense of Eavesdropping v Theorizing the Web 2013 v @shannonsindorf
Benhabib. S. (2002). The Claims of Culture: Equality and Diversity in the Global Era. Princeton: Princeton University Press. Mansbridge, J. (2012). Everyday talk in the delibera4ve system. In Barker, D. W. M., N. McAfee, & D. W. McIvor (Eds.), Democra<zing Delibera<on: Poli<cal Theory Anthology. Dayton, OH: Ke2ering Founda4on Press. Marwick, A.E. & boyd, d. (2010). I tweet honestly, I tweet passionately: Twi2er users, context collapse, and the imagined audience. New Media & Society, 13(1), 114-‐133. Van Den Eede, Y. (2010). ‘‘Conversa4on of mankind’’ or ‘‘idle talk’’?: a pragma4st approach to social networking sites. Ethics of Informa<on Technology, 12, 195-‐206.
Selected References