india public: private partnership models for · pdf filecandidate vaccines/vaccine development...

23
INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR R&D (INFECTIOUS DISEASES) – OPPORTUNITIES AND CONSTRAINTS Prof. V.K.Vinayak Senior Advisor Department of Biotechnology Ministry of Science & Technology Block # 2, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road New Delhi – 110003 INDIA

Upload: dinhquynh

Post on 25-Mar-2018

216 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FORR&D (INFECTIOUS DISEASES) –

OPPORTUNITIES AND CONSTRAINTS

Prof. V.K.Vinayak

Senior Advisor

Department of Biotechnology

Ministry of Science & Technology

Block # 2, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road

New Delhi – 110003

INDIA

Page 2: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

R&D RELATING TO INFECTIOUS DISEASES

- Diagnostics for Infectious Diseases.

- Vaccines:- New Generation.

- Drug Delivery System.

- New Therapeutics.

- Genomics – Applications for better diagnostics/vaccines/new

drug molecules.

Page 3: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)� RAPID agglutination of erythrocytes for HIV 1&2.

� Peptide based ELISA System for HIV-1 & 2.

� Western immunoblot for HIV-1 & 2 infection.

� Mac IgM ELISA for detection of Dengue infection.

� Mac IgM ELISA/RT-PCR for Japanese Encephalitis.

� PCR for detection of Pulmonary/ Extrapulmonary tuberculosis.

� LDH Based Test System for Malaria.

� DAT for Toxoplasmosis.

� IFA for Rabies - Monoclonal antibody to nuclear protein.

� Haemagglutination Assay for Visceral Leishmaniasis.

� ELISA for H.pylori.

� IgM ELISA System for Leptospirosis.

� ELISA for Amoebiasis.

Page 4: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

CURRENT STATUS ON VACCINE TECHNOLOGIES

DEVELOPMENT IN INDIA

APPROACHES:

•Avirulent organism

•Recombinant Vaccines

•Tissue cultured based vaccine

•Genetically modified microbe

•DNA candidate vaccines.

•Plant – based vaccines.

Page 5: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

CANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT

�ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized.

�ANTI CHOLERA CANDIDATE In Phase-II Clinical Trial

�ANTI ROTA VIRAL DIAORRHEAL VACCINE In Phase-I Clinical Trial

�JAPANESE ENCEPHALITIS Under Preclinical Studies

�ANTI RABIES VACCINE Awaiting approval for commercialization

�ANTI TUBERCULOSIS Under Preclinical Studies

�ANTI MALARIA Preclinical/Phase-I Clinical Studies

�ANTI HIV CANDIDATE VACCINE Animal Experimentation (HIV-I - Subtype c)

�PLANT BASED VACCINES – Cholera/Rabies Animal Experimentation

Page 6: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

2005(Projected)

20001997

145600 (100)94000 (100)71540 (100) TOTAL

3970 (02.7)1300 (01.4)430 (00.6)OTHER BIOTECH PRODUCTS

36470 (25.0)28850 (30.3)24470 (34.2)INDUSTRIAL PRODUCTS

47680 (32.8)28880 (30.7)20270 (28.3)AGRICULTURE (INCLUDINGSEEDS)

57480 (39.5)35320 (37.6)26370 (36.9)HUMAN & ANIMALHEALTHCARE PRODUCTS

CONSUMPTIONBIOTECH SECTOR

INDIATRENDS IN INDIAN BIOTECH

INDUSTRY (RS. IN MILLION)

Page 7: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

9575*53572950INDIA

2258560330400234135GLOBAL

200520001997

(RS. IN MILLION)

* Estimated potential 3-5 times

INDIA

MARKET SCENARIO

Page 8: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

� CURRENT MARKET SIZE - RS. 300 CRORES

� ANNUAL GROWTH RATE - 25%

� MARKET POTENTIAL (2005) - RS.500 CRORES

� EXCL. IMPORTERS - 70%

� INDG.PRODUCERS - 30%

� STATUS : IMPORT INTENSIVE

LIMITEDPRODUCTION

INDIA

IMMUNODIAGNOSTICSCOMMERCIAL RELEVANCE

Page 9: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

* Key Academic Institutes involved in Research & Development forInfectious Diseases

- Academic Institutes: -National Institute of Immunology - Central Institute of Medicinal & Aromatic Plants

-Jawahar Lal Nehru University - Centre for Cellular & Molecular Biology

-University of Delhi (South Campus) - Centre for DNA Fingerprinting & Diagnostics

-All India Institute of Medical Sciences - National Centre for Cell Sciences

-Centre for Biochemical Technology - Indian Institute of Chemical Biology

-Institute of Microbial Technology - Central Drug Research Institute

-Indian Institute of Science -JN Centre for Advance Research

-Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education & Research

Page 10: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

* Key Academic Institutes and Pharma involved in Research &Development for Infectious Diseases

B) Major Pharma:

-Shantha Biotech Ltd. - Ranbaxy Labs.

- Bharat Biotech Ltd. - Zydus Cadila

- Sudershan Biotech Ltd. - Cadila Pharmaceuticals

- Biological E. Ltd. - Dabur Research Foundations

- Reddy’s Laboratory - Panacea Biotech

- Wockhardt

Page 11: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

PUBLIC : PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS

THREE APPROACHES:

•Transfer of validated technologies to Pharmaceuticalcompanies / entrepreneurs.

•Entrepreneurs/Pharmaceutical Companies and Public/Academic Institute joint development of technologies/products.

•Public Institute/Academic Centres partnership before initiationof R&D.

Page 12: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

Bio-Medical Technologies transferred and launched in themarket

Technology Developed By Launched By

Leprosyimmunomodulator

NII, New DelhiM/s Cadilapharmaceuticals, Ahmedabad

Leishmaniasis detection kit CDRI, Lucknow Span Diagnostics Ltd.

Western Blot for HIV-I & II CRI, Mumbai

M/s J.Mitra & Co., New Delhi

Naked Eye agglutination system for HIV-I&II

University of Delhi, South Campus

Cadila pharmaceuticals,

Ahmedabad

Xcytron, BangaloreHepatitis C DiagnosticsELISA Based

ICGEB, New Delhi

Page 13: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

Bio-Medical Technologies Transferred (not yet Launched)

Technology Developed By Transferred to

The IgM Mac ELISA -Dengue

NIV, Pune Zydus Cadila HealthCare, Ahmedabad

The IgM Mac ELISA -Japanese Encephalitis

-----do----- -----do-----

The IgM Mac ELISA - West Nile-----do-----

-----do-----

ELISA -alphafeto protein levels. IICB,Kolkata

Shantha Biotechnics, Hyderabad

An IgM - Hepatitis A. NIV, PuneBharat Biotech Ltd.,Hyderabad

Page 14: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)Bio-Medical Technologies Transferred (not yet

Launched)

hCG expression Pichiapatoris system.

IISc, BangaloreCadila Pharmaceuticale,Ahmedabad

Recombinant candidate Anthrax Vaccine

JNU, NewDelhi andCBT, Delhi.

Panecea Biotech, Delhi

Urine based systems (ELISA)- FourReproductive Hormones.

IRR,Mumbai

Zydus Cadila HealthCare, Hyderabad

Yarrowia lipolytica expressing system.University ofBaroda,Baroda

Biological evans Ltd.,Hyderabad

Technology Developed By Transferred to

Page 15: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

JOINT DEVELOPMENT OF PRODUCT/PROCESS

- Anti-Rota Virus Vaccine: AIIMS/Bharat Biotech

- Antimalaria Vaccine: ICGEB/MRC/Bharat (recombinant) Biotech

- Anthrax Vaccine: JNU/ Panacea Biotech. (recombinant)

- Antirabies DNA Vaccine: IISc/Indian Immunologicals

Page 16: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

PUBLIC: PRIVATE INTERACTION LEADING TOCOMMERCIALIZATION OF PRODUCTS

- Antileprosy Vaccine: NII/Cadila Pharmaceuticals

- r Hepatitis B Vaccine: CCMB/ Shantha Biotech

- NEVA diagnostic forHIV-I/II: DU(sc)/Cadila

Pharmaceuticals-Western immunoblot for

HIV-I/II: CRI/ J Mitra & Co.

- ELISA for Hepatitis C ICGEB/ Xcytron Co.

- Amoebiasis detection kit NII/ Span diagnostics.

Page 17: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

� 12 PRODUCTS APPROVED

HUMAN INSULIN FSH*STREPTOKINASE ERYTHROPOIETIN*HBsAg HGHINTERLEUKIN GSFGCSF *a INTERFERON

BLOOD FACTOR VII g INTERFERON

* Products indigenously manufactured

INDIA

INDIAN SCENARIO

Page 18: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

CONSTRAINS IN TRANSFER OF TECHNOLOGIES

• Lack of interactions at the initial stages of technology processdevelopment.

• Market need & techno-economic feasibility not conductedseriously

• Lack of funds/facilities at inventor level to upscale bench levelprocesses

• Entrepreneurs – do not take risks with unproven/untriedtechnologies.

• Procedural delays in various approvals.

Page 19: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

FOUR DISTINCT ROUTES:

•Diversification from chemical manufacturing to use of

Biotechnological tools/tie up with MNC.

•Start up on indigenous production of first generation

recombinant therapeutics/vaccines.

•Investing profits in discoveries (R&D set up).

•Utilising / grafting biology onto IT – Bioinformatics & genomic

companies.

Page 20: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

OPPORTUNITIES FOR INDIAN PHARMA

A) Global Partners Tie Up With Indian Pharma

- Low cost of innovation in India

- Chemical capabilities – Cheap & World class

- Drug discovery: 80-90% cheaper in India

- Alliance of upstream & down stream activities.

B) Positioning to partners to enter American & European markets.

Page 21: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH (INFECTIOUS DISEASES)

SIGNIFICANT BARRIERS:

•Complicated regulatory system.

•Uncertainty about Intellectual property protection

•Slow pace of integration between academic and pharma companies.

Page 22: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

INDIA

TO OVERCOME BARRIERS

•Government – Environment for innovation & entrepreneurship

•Strong patent protection

•Predictable regulatory mechanism(s).

•Create more business friendly environment.

Page 23: INDIA PUBLIC: PRIVATE PARTNERSHIP MODELS FOR · PDF fileCANDIDATE VACCINES/VACCINE DEVELOPMENT ANTI LEPROSY VACCINE Commercialized. ... - Wockhardt. INDIA BIOTECHNOLOGY FOR HEALTH

� Several lessons have been learnt.

� Great opportunities for public/private partnership.More successes with mid level and start uppharmaceuticals companies.

� Need to create business friendly environment.

� Indian industry is looking out for global partnersfor joint innovation research.

INDIA

SUMMARY