india - updated inter-link

Upload: urmila-patel

Post on 07-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    1/51

    India, and Investment Potential

    in India

    for

    The Center For American and InternationalLaw

    By:Gautam Mahajan

    President - Inter-Link Services Pvt. Ltd.

    June 13, 2006

    Inter-Link Services Pvt. Ltd. Tel: 011-26922006, 26831226; Fax: 011-26929055; E-mail: [email protected] /

    [email protected] Website: www.interlinkindia.net

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]
  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    2/51

    1. General Business Tips

    2. India, and Investment Potential inIndia

    3. Foreign Lawyers and Legal Servicesin India: Frequently Asked Questions

    DISCUSSION POINTS

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    3/51

    1. General Business Tips General Business Tips

    American Companies in India

    Legal Opportunities

    2. India, and Investment Potential in

    India

    3. Foreign Lawyers and Legal Services inIndia: Frequently Asked Questions

    DISCUSSION POINTS

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    4/51

    General Business Tips

    From the American Business Experiencein India:Lessons from successfulAmerican companies:

    Know the rules and the law and follow them Conduct rigid due diligence

    Do not get guided by quick methods orshort-cuts

    Avoid un-ethical practices

    Hire a good knowledgeable consultant onIndia

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    5/51

    American Companies in India

    Top 5 American employers in India 2 years ago:

    General Electric: : 17,800 employeesHewlett-Packard : 11,000 employeesIBM : 6,000 employeesAmerican Express : 4,000 employeesDell : 3,800 employees (today 10,000, growing to 20,000)

    General Electric (GE) with $80 Million invested in India employs 16,000 staff,1,600 R&D staff who are qualified with PhDs and Masters degrees.

    The number of patents filed in USA by the Indian entities of some of the MNCs(upto September, 2002) are as follows: Texas Instruments - 225, Intel - 125,Cisco Systems - 120, IBM - 120, Phillips - 102, GE - 95.

    Staff at the offices of Intel (India) has gone up from 10 to 1,000 in 4 years,

    and will reach 2000 staff by 2006.

    GE's R&D centre in Bangalore is the company's largest research outfit outsidethe United States. The centre also devotes 20% of its resources on 5 to 10 yearfundamental research in areas such as nanotechnology, hydrogen energy,photonics, and advanced propulsion.

    It is estimated that there are 150,000 IT professionals in Bangalore as against120,000 in Silicon Valley.

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    6/51

    Legal Opportunities

    Help Indian companies wishing to enterUSA, China etc.

    Help Indian companies and lawyers incollaborative projects with American

    companies outside India

    Buy legal and paralegal services fromIndia at low rates.. Example is GE

    Send lawyers to India acceptable to theIndian bar rules or willing to pass theIndian bar exam

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    7/51

    "There are lots of opportunities to use [foreign]lawyers in place of outside counsel or other

    lawyers at a lower cost structure," saysSuzanne Hawkins, senior counsel at GeneralElectric Co. For two GE businesses -- GEPlastics and GE Consumer Finance -- savings

    from those lower rates are adding up. GEbegan adding lawyers and paralegals to itsoffice in Gurgaon, India, in late 2001. It nowhas eight lawyers and nine paralegals thereand has saved more than $2 million in legalfees that would otherwise have been spent onoutside counsel, according to Hawkins.

    Jennifer Fried

    The RecorderAugust 25, 2004

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    8/51

    1. General Business Tips

    2. India, and Investment Potential in

    India

    Foreign Direct Investment in India

    An overview of Indian Economy

    Investing in India Entry Routes

    Foreign Direct Investment: Policy

    Indias Competitive Advantage

    Investment Opportunities

    3. Foreign Lawyers and Legal Services

    in India: Frequently Asked Questions

    DISCUSSION POINTS

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    9/51

    Foreign Direct Investment in India

    Largest democracy

    political stability

    & consensus on

    reforms

    Liberal &

    transparent

    investment

    policiesLargest

    reservoir of

    skilled

    manpower

    Long-term

    sustainable

    Competitive

    advantage

    - High growth rate

    economy

    Fourth largest

    Economy (PPP) - A

    safe place

    to do business

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    10/51

    An overview of Indian Economy

    Economic Performance

    Foreign Trade

    Investment

    Mature Capital Markets

    A well developed banking system

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    11/51

    An overview of Indian Economy

    Economic Performance

    o Sustained economic growtho Average last 10 years 6.5%

    o 2004-05 6.9%o Forecast up to 2006-07 >7.0%

    o Forecast till 2050 Goldman Sachs 5 % p.a.

    o Services share in GDP over 50% (52.4% share in

    GDP in 2004-05)

    o Manufacturing sector grew at 8.8% in 2004-05 (17.4%share in GDP in 2004-05)

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    12/51

    An overview of Indian Economy

    Foreign Tradeo Merchandise exports grew by 25% in 2004-05, now

    US$80 billion

    o Imports grew by 36%, now US$106 billion

    Investmento Foreign Investment over US$14 billion in 2004-05

    (FDI US$5.5 billion, FII US$8.9 billion)

    Mature Capital Marketso NSE third largest, BSE fifth largest in terms of number

    of trades

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    13/51

    Goldman Sachs Report of 1 October,2003"Dreaming with BRICs: The path to 2050"

    India's GDP will reach $ 1 trillion by 2011,$ 2 trillion by 2020,$ 3 trillion by 2025,

    $ 6 trillion by 2032,$ 10 trillion by 2038, and$ 27 trillion by 2050,becoming the 3rd largest economy after USA

    and China.

    In terms of GDP, India will overtake Italy by theyear 2016, France by 2019, UK by 2022,Germany by 2023, and Japan by 2032.

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    14/51

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    15/51

    Economic Reforms - Liberalisation ofInvestment & Trade Policies

    Industrial Licensingo Progressive movement towards delicensing and deregulation

    Licensing limited to only 5 sectors (security, public health & safetyconsiderations)

    Foreign Investmento Progressive opening of economy to FDIo Portfolio investment regime liberalisedo Liberal policy on technology collaboration

    Trade Policyo Most items on Open General License, Quantitative Restrictions

    lifted

    Foreign Trade Policy seeks to double Indiasshare in global merchandise trade in 5 years

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    16/51

    Economic Reforms - ExchangeControl & Taxation

    Exchange Control

    All investments are on repatriation basis

    Original investment, profits and dividend can be freely

    repatriated Foreign investor can acquire immovable property

    incidental to or required for their activity

    Rupee made fully convertible on current account

    Taxation Companies incorporated in India treated as Indian

    companies for taxation

    Convention on Avoidance of Double Taxation with 65

    countries

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    17/51

    Manufacturing CompetitivenessMade in India

    Second most attractive destination for manufacturingo AT Kearneys FDI Confidence Index 2004

    Indian industry globally competitive in a wide range ofmanufacturing skill-intensive products:

    o Apparels, electrical and electronics components; specialitychemicals; pharmaceuticals; etc.

    Automotive components: Major MNCs & their OEMssourcing high-quality components from India

    o Volvo, GM, GE, Chrysler, Ford, Toyota, Unilever, Cliariant,Cummins, Delphi

    Indian companies now having manufacturing presence inmany countries

    o Over 55% of approved outward investment by India companies

    in manufacturing activities

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    18/51

    Evolution of FDI Policy

    FDI Policy Liberalization

    Pre 1991

    1991

    1997

    2000

    2000-05

    Allowed selectively up to40%

    Up to 74/51/50% in 112 sectors under theAutomatic Route 100% in some sectors

    Up to 100% under Automatic Route in all sectors except asmall negative list

    More sectors opened ; Equity caps raised in many other sectorsProcedures simplified

    FDI up to 51% allowed under theAutomatic route in 35 Priority sectors

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    19/51

    Investing in India Entry Routes

    Automatic RoutePrior Permission

    (FIPB)

    Investing in India

    General RuleNo prior permission

    requiredInform Reserve Bankwithin 30 days ofinflow/issue of shares

    By ExceptionPrior Government

    Approval needed.Decision generallywithin 4-6 weeks

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    20/51

    FDI Policy Initiatives : 2000-2004

    New sectors opened to FDIo to 26% divestment in 5 years Defence production, Insurance,

    print media - up to 26%o Development of integrated townships up to 100%o e-commerce, ISP with out gateway, voice mail, electronic mail,

    tea plantation -100% subject

    FDI equity limits raisedo Private sector banks raised from 49% to 74%o Drugs and pharmaceuticals from 74% to 100%o Advertising from 74% to 100%o Private sector refineries, Petroleum product marketing,

    exploration , petroleum product pipelines 74% to 100%

    Procedural simplificationo Issue of shares against royalty payable allowed

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    21/51

    Recent Initiatives : June 2004 onward

    FDI in domestic airlines increased from 40% to 49%.Automatic route allowed

    FDI up to 100% allowed under the automatic route indevelopment of townships, housing, built upinfrastructure and construction development projects

    Foreign investment limit in Telecom services increased

    to 74% FDI and portfolio investment up to 20% allowed in FM

    Broadcasting. Hitherto only Portfolio investment wasallowed.

    Transfer of shares allowed on automatic route in most

    cases Fresh guidelines for investment with previous joint

    ventures

    A WTO (TRIPs) IPR regime compliant in position since

    2005 Patents Act amended to provide for productpatent in pharma and agro-chemicals also.

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    22/51

    Policy on FDI

    FDI up to 100% allowed under the AutomaticRoute in all activities except for

    o Sectors attracting compulsory licensing

    o Transfer of shares to non-residents (foreign investors)

    o In Financial Services, oro Where the SEBI Takeovers Regulation is attracted

    o Investor having existing venture in same field

    o Sector specific equity/route limit prescribed under

    sectoral policy Investments made by foreign investors are given

    treatment similar to domestic investors

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    23/51

    Main Sectors withFDI Equity/Route Limit

    FDI equity limit-

    Automatic route

    Insurance 26%

    Domestic airlines 49%

    Telecom services- Foreignequity 74%

    Private sector banks- 74%

    Mining of diamonds andprecious stones- 74%

    Exploration and mining of coaland lignite for captiveconsumption- 74%

    FDI requiring prior

    approval

    Defence production 26%

    FM Broadcasting - foreign

    equity 20% News and current affairs- 26%

    Broadcasting- cable, DTH, up-linking foreign equity 49%

    Trading- wholesale cash andcarry, export trading, etc.,100%

    Tea plantation 100%

    Development of airports- 100%

    Courier services- 100%

    Corrected as of December 05

    F i T h l

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    24/51

    Foreign TechnologyCollaboration Policy

    Foreign technology agreements also allowedunder Automatic route:o Lump-sum fees not exceeding US$2 Milliono Royalty @ 5% on domestic sales and 8% on exports,

    net of taxeso Royalty up to 2% on exports and 1% also permitted

    for use of Trade Marks and Brand name, without anytechnology transfer

    Wholly owned subsidiaries can also pay royaltyto their parent company

    Payment of royalty without any restriction on theduration allowed.

    I di FDI O l k

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    25/51

    India: FDI Outlook

    2nd most attractive investment destination among

    the Transnational Corporations (TNCs) -UNCTADs World Investment Report, 2005

    3rd most attractive investment destination ATKearney Business Confidence Index, 2004

    o Up from 6th most attractive destination in 2003 and 15th in 2002

    o 2nd Most attractive destination for manufacturing

    Among the top 3 investment hot spots for the

    next 4 yearso UNCTAD & Corporate Location April 2004 Most preferred destination for services - AT

    Kearneys 2005 Global Services Location Index

    (previously Offshore Location Attractiveness Index)

    I di C titi Ad t

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    26/51

    Indias Competitive AdvantageHuman Capital

    Indias competitive edge - its highly-skilled manpower

    and entrepreneurial expertiseo Over 380 universities (11,200 colleges)

    o 1500 research institutions

    o Over 200,000 engineering graduates

    o Over 300,000 post graduates from non-engineering colleges

    o 2,100,000 other graduates

    o Around 9,000 PhDs

    Knowledge workers in software industry increased from56,000 in 1990-91 to over 1 million by 2004-05;

    54% of Indias population under 25 years of age

    India would continue to be surplus in working populationfor a long-time

    o Would contribute 25% to the additional working population globally over

    the next 5 years.

    I di C titi St th

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    27/51

    Indias Competitive StrengthsHRD Contd.

    Rank out of 102 countries

    Availability of scientist and engineers 3

    Quality of management schools 8

    Quality of scientific research institutions 20

    Quality of educational system 36

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    28/51

    IT Advantages

    ITITES Industryo Exports US$17.2 billion in 2004-

    05, growth of 34% over previousyear

    o 2008 exports target : US$60billion, to be 35% of Indias totalexports

    High quality standardso 76 SEI/CMM level 5 companies,

    two third of worlds total, areIndian

    o Over 250 of the Fortune 500companies are clients of Indianfirms

    o R&D base of over 100 FORTUNE

    500 companies

    Investment Opportunitieso Collaborative ICT researcho Joint Software development in a

    variety of applications

    IT- ITES Exports

    In US $ Billion

    6.2

    10

    12.8

    17.2

    8

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    16

    18

    20

    2000-01 2001-02 2002-03 2003-04 2004-05

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    29/51

    Recent Infrastructure Initiatives

    National Highway Development Programme to developover 24,000 km of highways

    o Golden Quadrilateralo NSEW Corridoro Links to ports and State capitals

    Modernisation of airportso Metro and other airports

    Development of ports with private sector The Electricity Act, 2003 provides the framework for

    development of power sector Bharat Nirman Programme to develop rural

    infrastructure at an estimated cost of Rs. 1,74,000 crore(~US$40 billion)

    Jawhar Lal Nehru Urban Renewal MissionRs. 100,000crore (US$22 billion)

    Country wide rural connectivity programme to link allunconnected village having population of 500 with fairweather road undertaken

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    30/51

    Telecommunications

    Among the fastest growing telecom

    marketso 550,000 km of optical fibre cable

    laid

    2 million Cellular phones added everymonth

    o Among the lowest mobile tariff inthe world

    Share of private sector 50%

    Tele-density of 10.66, expected to be20 in next three years

    New Broad Band Policy announced:o 690,000 connections since April

    2005o Internet subscribers 6 million

    (March 05)

    Investment Opportunitieso Setting up manufacturing facilities;o Supply of hand sets and

    equipmentso Telecom & Value added service.

    5.53.11.6

    10.5

    28.2

    48.717.7

    52.41.5

    19.5

    19.25

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    70

    80

    2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005

    (up to

    Oct.)

    No.

    inmillio

    R d

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    31/51

    Roads

    Policyo

    FDI up to 100% is permitted for construction andmaintenance of roads, highways, vehicular bridges,toll roads, vehicular tunnels

    o Ten year tax holiday for road and highway projects

    Recent Initiatives

    o Existing road network of 3.3 million kilometerso 24,000 km of Highways being developed under

    National Highway Development Programmeo billion envisaged Golden Quadrilateral : 5846 kms- 5000 kms

    completedo NSEW Corridor: 7300 kms 784 kms completed, 3691 kms

    under implementationo Investment US$20 billion

    Investment Opportunitieso Projects for 12,000 km would be on offero Many more opportunities in the States

    P

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    32/51

    Power Policy & Incentive

    o FDI up to 100% is permitted onthe automatic route in all

    segments except atomic powero Ten-year tax holiday for

    generation and distribution ortransmission and distribution ofpower

    Institutional Reformso The Electricity Act 2003 allows

    trading in power and provides forfurther deregulation;

    o Independent Regulator in moststates

    Investment Opportunitieso Additional capacity required

    100,000 MW till 2012

    o Investment US$120 billion needed

    o Financial closure of over 6000MW capacity achieved in last oneyear

    Share of Installed Capacity

    Hydro+Wind

    22%

    Thermal

    76%

    Nuclear

    2%

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    33/51

    Ports

    Policy & Incentiveso FDI up to 100% permitted for construction and

    maintenance of ports and harbors.o Ten year tax holiday

    Public-private partnershipo 12 major ports, 185 minor portso 14 private/ captive projects with investment of US$

    600 million completedo 24 projects with investment of US$1.6 billion under

    implementation/award

    Investment requirement of US$22 billion todevelop maritime sector

    o Ports & Shipping

    o Inland waterways

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    34/51

    Special Economic Zones

    Policyo Duty free zones, deemed foreignterritories

    o FDI up to 100% permitted inalmost all manufacturing activities

    o Transfer of goods from DTA toSEZ treated as exports,

    o Units to be net foreign exchangeearner within 5 years. No exportcommitments

    o No limits on DTA sales

    o Can be set up in the public,private or joint sector

    o Single Window Clearance

    Incentives

    o For developer: Income tax exemptionfor a block of 10 years in 15 years

    o For units: 100% Income Taxexemption for first 5 years, 50% fornext 5 years and 50% of the ploughedback export profits for next 5 years

    o Exemption from indirect taxes; excise,sales, services tax, etc.

    o Freedom to raise ECB with out anymaturity restrictions

    New Law onSEZ enacted

    Cont

    S i l E i Z

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    35/51

    Special Economic Zones

    11 Special Economic Zones are functionalo SEEPZ Mumbai, Kandla, Cochin, Chennai,

    Visakhapatnam, Falta, NOIDA, Surat, Salt Lake,Indore and Jaipur

    o Over 800 functional units employing over 100,000persons

    o Exports of US$4 billion in 2004-05

    42 new Special Economic Zones have beenapproved and are under establishment

    o Many have participation with State Governments andPrivate Sector

    Major Industries in Special Economic Zoneso Gems & Jewellery, Electronics & Hardware, Software,

    Textile & Garment, Engineering Goods, SportsGoods, Leather Products, Chemicals & AlliedProducts

    P blic Pri ate Partnership

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    36/51

    Public Private Partnership

    Infrastructure projects might not be financially viable on

    their own;

    Public Private Partnership to bring in private sectorresources and techno-managerial capabilities;

    Viability Gap Funding foro Roads, railways, seaports, airports;o Powero Water supply, sewerage, solid waste disposal in urban areas;o International convention centres.

    Funding in the form of capital grant, Operation &Management support, interest subsidy, etc.

    Support linked with predefined milestones.

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    37/51

    Food Processing Third largest producer of food items

    o Largest milk producer

    o Largest livestock population;o 2nd largest in fruits & vegetables

    Opportunities in food processing sectoro 50% of household income spent on food itemso With increasing income levels and urbanisation fast growth in demand

    of processed food expected; over 250 million strong middle classo Low levels of value addition in food sector: only 7%

    New Integrated Food Law being enacted

    Investment of US$ 28 billion required to raise foodprocessing from 2% to 8-10%.

    Investment opportunities ino Processing of fruit & vegetable, meat, fish & poultry, milk products,

    packaged food & drinks.o Establishing infrastructure, cold chain, etc.

    Incentives for the Development of

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    38/51

    Incentives for the Development ofIndustrially Backward Areas

    A special package of incentives to promoteindustrialization of industrially backward regionso North Eastern states, Skim, Jammu & Kashmir,

    Uttaranchal and Himachal Pradesh

    Incentiveso 100% Income Tax Exemptions for 10 years

    o Excise Duty Exemptions for 10 years

    o Transport Subsidy for transportation of raw materialand finished products,

    o Investment Subsidy (50-90%)

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    39/51

    Governance and Regulatory System

    Central, State and Local levels of Government with

    their specified powers and responsibilities seen ascomplicated in regulatory administration by investors

    11.9% of Senior Managements time spent in dealingwith Government agencies(Source: World Banks Report - India Investment ClimateAssessment, 2004)

    World Banks Report Doing Business in 2006o 71 days required to set up a Company and start business

    Incorporation of Company and PAN/TAN allotment taking mosttimeo Paying taxes: 59 transactions taking 264 hours in a yearo Closing a business: time taken 10 years

    Governance Initiatives

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    40/51

    Governance - Initiatives

    Major e-governance initiatives undertaken at Central andState level

    National e-Governance Action Plano Projects being taken up in Mission mode at Central and State

    level.o Integrated services projects for services across Departments.o MCA-21 - Ministry of Company Affairs, to cover all Registrar of

    Companies by June 2006

    e-Biz project being taken up by the Department of IPPo To set up a web enabled portal to provide for the services at the

    Central, State and Local level during the entire life cycle ofbusiness

    o To begin with a pilot project covering 25 services in four states

    o Project capable of rapid upscaling to cover other services andextend to other areas

    Right to Information Act for greater transparency inpublic administration

    Investment Opportunities

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    41/51

    Investment Opportunities

    Development and management of infrastructure

    Food processing, including logistic and supportservices, development of cold chain

    Manufacturing relocation into India

    R&D leveraging on abundant skilledmanpower

    IT & ITES, Software as well as hardware

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    42/51

    1. General Business Tips

    2. India, and Investment Potential in

    India

    3. Foreign Lawyers and Legal Services inIndia:

    o Frequently Asked Questions

    o Judgment of Bombay High Court

    DISCUSSION POINTS

    Foreign Lawyers and Legal Services in

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    43/51

    Foreign Lawyers and Legal Services inIndia: Frequently Asked Questions

    1.Can I give advice on USA legal issues to Indiancompanies?No. (see below)

    2.Can I give advice to Indian companies in India on

    Indian issues?No. Please refer to the attached extract of a Bombay High CourtJudgment attached

    3.If I have an associate law firm in India, what can

    my partners do or not do when they come toIndia?

    They can only provide inputs to the Indian firm. They can beemployed by an Indian firm. They can (if qualified) enroll but thatis a difficult process requiring eligibility, qualifications andreciprocity. Cont

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    44/51

    Foreign Lawyers and Legal Services inIndia: Frequently Asked Questions

    4. Can I set up a rep. office in India? If yes, Whatam I allowed to do and not do?Yes, but not much at all. Liaison and no commercialbusiness (same judgment).

    5. Is my legal degree recognised in India?No. In most cases of US degrees. Some may berecognised (like Oxford degree) but youll need to checkwith the Bar Council of Delhi which ones are covered (ifany) from the U.S.

    6. What do I have to do be a solicitor in India?This is a complex question. Probably not allowed.

    Cont

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    45/51

    Foreign Lawyers and Legal Services inIndia: Frequently Asked Questions

    7. What do I have to do if I wish to appear inan Indian court?

    Enroll as an advocate.

    8. How is the law on the above likely tochange and when?

    Some change and a minor easing is likely in this year or

    over the next years but it is likely to be cosmetic.

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    46/51

    Extract of a Bombay High CourtJudgment

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAYORIGINAL SIDE

    WRIT PETITION NO. 1526 OF 1995

    Lawyers Collective Petitioner

    Versus

    Bar Council of India & Ors.

    OCTOBER 4 & 9, 1995

    "In our view, considering the aforesaid quotations from the New York Judiciary

    Law and Halsburys Laws of England, it is apparent that the phrase topracticethe profession of law would be wide enough which would includenot only appearance before the Court but also to carry on such activitieswhich are specifically provided in the aforesaid paragraphs which providefor restrictions on unqualified persons against drawing or preparing anyinstrument, agreement, power of attorney or such other things. If that wasnot so, there was no necessity of restricting it by specific regulations."

    Cont

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    47/51

    Extract of a Bombay High CourtJudgment

    The Court quoted with approval:

    "As there is no direct decision on the question involved, the learned Counselappearing for the Petitioner has brought to our notice a decision rendered by theCourt of Appeals of New York. In the Matter of New York County LawyersAssociation v. Lorenzo J. Roel, (165 N. Y. S. 2d 31, page 14,) wherein the Courthas interpreted Section 270 of the Penal Law which, inter alia, provides as

    under:-

    It shall be unlawful for any natural person to practice as an attorney-at-law orto hold himself out to the public as being entitled to practice law as aforesaid, orin any other manner, or advertise the title of lawyer in such manner oradvertise the title of lawyer in such manner as to convey the impression thathe conducts or maintains a law office without having first been duly and

    regularly licensed and admitted to practice law in the courts of record of thisstate, and without having taken the constitutional oath.

    Cont

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    48/51

    Extract of a Bombay High CourtJudgment

    In that case it was contended by the appellant that his practice is restricted toMexican law and he does not practice law in New York since he onlygives advice and prepares instruments based on Mexican law andMexican law is not law in New York. Therefore he is not covered bySection 270 of the Penal Law. The Court negatived the said contentionby holding that whether a person gives advice as to New York law.Federal law, the law of a sister State, or the law of a foreign country, he is

    giving legal advice. It was further held that when legal documents areprepared for a layman by a person in the business of preparing suchdocuments, that person is practicing law whether the documents beprepared in conformity with the law of New York or any other law. TheCourt further observed that to hold otherwise would be to state that amember of the New York Bar only practices law when he deals with locallaw. It was further observed: A foreign lawyer who is familiar with the law

    of the country in which he is a lawyer is in a similar position. He is aspecialist in a particular field of the law, but is nevertheless a layman inthis state when he is not a member of the Bar here. The Court held thatprotection of the members of the lay public of State, when they seek legaladvice and that was what defendant purported to furnish was thebasis of the requirements of licensing of attorneys by the State.

    Cont

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    49/51

    Extract of a Bombay High CourtJudgment

    From the aforesaid discussion, the submissions made before this Court andthe affidavit in reply filed on behalf of Respondent Nos. 12, 13 and 14, primafacie, it appears that the activities mentioned above carried on byRespondent Nos. 12 to 14 would amount to practising the profession of law.As stated above, Respondent Nos. 12 to 14 have established liaison officesin this country; they are carrying on work of drafting documents, reviewingand providing comments on documents, conducting negotiations and

    advising clients on international standards and customary practice relatingto clients transactions; gathering information from prospective clients inIndia and conducting market research to assess the feasibility of providinglegal services in India.If, therefore, the said activities are held to be not covered by the phrase topractice the profession of law, then the whole objects of the Advocates Actwould be frustrated, in the sense that there would not be any disciplinary

    control nor these activities can be controlled by any method.

    " [End of quote]

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    50/51

    We gratefully acknowledge the help given by the

    Department of Industrial Policy and Promotion - Ministry ofCommerce, Government of India, New Delhi

  • 8/4/2019 India - Updated Inter-Link

    51/51

    THANK YOU

    For further Information, Contact:Gautam MahajanPresident - Inter-Link Services Pvt. Ltd.K-185 Sarai JullenaNew Delhi, India 110025

    Tel: +91-11-26922006, 26831226; Fax: +91-11-26929055;E-mail: [email protected] /[email protected]: www.interlinkindia.net

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]