individual freedom, international trade and international conflict

7/30/2019 Individual Freedom, International Trade and International Conflict

1/19

93

Te Journal Of

Peace, Prosperity & Freedom

Ale Roson

Iv F, I

, I C:

Cb W Rgh

T vb h g .

- B L

I h g w g h bk, h hh h b h.

- L V M

T .

- B Mq

Introduction

F gg g w, bh v gh .1 A, w Hk k Te Constitution o

F v h , Ch (4).
http://www.wise-pdf-tools.com/?product-split-demo


2/19

9

Journal of Peace, Prosperity and Freedom Summer 2012

Libertyh v x wh b h bw h b h b,2 h h h g - bw h h, v h h. I b v w x.3

Db v h w b, v b g , h vhw hv h g whh hvv hg, b h hv ; h v g h w h h b k. M bg h g hv g g b w h gw,4 b gh , b bg h h h q , xhg wh . h b gbg v v; v w h g wh h k

g g h v gh g ; gh h vb h g h h h h gv v b w h v hgh h w h b h b gv.F b h, vb h vg h b h h v g vb g bv b, h h x.

bg x h h, v vg x wh, gv , gg wh h. Oh h, w b wg; h h h, h g b , bv g g k h g wh h . T h w w bk . I h bhv . M , g h w h v h w .5 I h x g

Ch , g Te Constitution o Liberty. Cb, x, h b w h h j ; h , wh bh g h , vvg h x h , h b hgh, gg , b whh b h j b. [Cb, , ]4 S, x, Hgg (). Pz () k h vw g h h vgg h gv w gw.5 W w hgh h h h h h h w-, wh - b . I w b h v h w w bhv g h v b v

vb h. I (b ), Sg () (g x-x) g vg h h k gv g h w h h v h z


3/19

9

Ale Roson Indiidual Freedom, International rade, and International Conflict

g bw z h v, h h g h b .B w vh b h h, h w vw, h hghh v , h k h w v wh

h .

6

A , h k b bw z h v w b b , , h, k , b h h b g. A h bhv h v, h, w b h v b , v . T k vg b h x hw h b , hw h gh b x v h g h bhv gv .

I. International Organizations And International Rules: The Problems Of

Incomplete Knowledge And Imperfect Enforcement

I Law, Legislation and Liberty, Hk hz h h notgz: h w bv made , wh Hk taxis.7Hk bv hv . I k h U N S C, h W Ogz,h I M F h W Bk are gz hHk . T w h w , b

h h bw h z b vg g , , w, g .

T gz hv v ,8 , w, hv v w v; h, h hv h v . T h b h. A V M :

I , , h b

h Lg N h U N. P, k

h g h hv. T h UN S C h Iq bw F, R G h h, h US h UK h h, hw h w g -b , wh h b b wh. T bhv h g h v h h hg v h b h .

S Hk, Law Legislation and Liberty, V I, . F x, h C W, h K W, h V W, h w G W hv h UN .


4/19

96


x k hw ghg g. T q bh b .9

Hk h A hz h taxisw b b h kwg h h z , h vb h, hv vb (g h vb h q h ).10 F b , gz h kwg h q h z , h v h whh b v h ( b b ), h kh . D commands b gz hv vhg g (h w ) w h b b, hghinternational rules b b w g h .

T w j b wh gz h taxis.11 F, h b w v hv kwg h v h v. T h , wh b k v , wh , b, v bw , whh bh v h k whh hg g b. T b h enorcement: wh w b bg h gv bg ? T bh w gv vb , w h b wh kwg ( xb h).

I b b h g; , h g h h w bv grown spontaneous wh Hk kosmos.B hw gw? I g h w , h z gv gg g h z gv h . International rules o conduct g bhv bw gh b q z h . Sh bg

gh , b h b , h g , . T h vv . F x, h h j w, b S. Ag T Aq, h g bk C.I h v , b k h

S V M (), g 5. W g h h h v hv

; , h . B h , b hv, . T g h q w v gv wh gh g .


5/19

97


v.12 T q b , h hb h x wh h x. T h wk wh w kwg h h v j , wh v k kwg h

k b bg kwg h abstract. Iv qkwg b, g, q . B h kwg h , h bw g , international law, international governmenth k g hw gw.13

Sh b g g- g bv , h b w, . B w kwg, h g b, g h , h

h g gh hv v bh . T, wh b wh h k kwg h , h h b ; w, w wh h q: h bh, wh h?

T w h h g , h w b bv b gv h v h h . I h w, z w v h, h b sel-enorcing. T q, h, hw b, -g -g kosmos whh xz v z g v .

II. Growing An International Order By Increasing The Opportunity Costs

Of Conflict: The Positive Security Externality Of Free Trade

A.Te Classical Liberal Position: Cobden, Smith and Montesquieu

A -g bw h g h vvg, h g wh ex post , h h hgh, v h b. T gh gg - vk gg x gg v whh b g h x vk, gg. Sh b, hwv,

T vw w h g , g bk h Dh j w h

Hg G. S, x, Bk (), Ch . N h v, , b z b . M b, h h .


6/19

98


bk b h v w - b . I h w b v , h qb wb h b. T h, h gh h gg , whh b k unilaterallyb :

(b ). A V M :T gh w h ggv .B h g. W ggv h gwhh k w. Aggv h vv h v g. Wh z h , gv whb whh b .Wh g v bh z h , v

v z h b h . Wh h h w bw w, h h bw, h , b h b h w h z- .14

T w w whh h x b h b h , hb w h.F, xhg h b b ggh v , v g whh b g low-intensity confictbw , h, v w- ( vb ), w w.

S, , h h kh bg h . I w gz h g v, , h xhg gg wh.15 B g h h, h xhg g bw h z , h h b ghw w: h g h bw z , h g h

, k v . I , h w , v , h , h, ceteris paribus, h h v k, b h g b w , b h , k xwhh w h g. I bw h v z hw b gh, h gv h

4 Human Action, 4.5 S B bw.


7/19

99


b h b h w b k , k h.

T w. T b h wg E C, FQ, Dv H, A Sh, B Mq, Jh Bgh, RhCb h h. F x, 5, Cb :

I bv h g h h h h h b Cb Fg O. A v h b whh hv k b q g , wv h g q, h w g, b v b h.16

Cb v h -v h h w h h , h h v ,17 h w wh h g bw . H bv, Sh, Mq h b h, h , hh v h h , w k , v h g . I g , Cb bg h v h - . I h w,Cb, Sh, Mq h g h positive securityexternalitywhh w h h g v .18

F () k :

I kg g g gv h hb g wh h g

T q h gv b Cb h H C J , 5. Cb wg gg h g L P (H Jh ),wh w h g h Whg gv L Jh R. E, J 5, Ph 5 h h R Nv v b Bh bj

(wh , ) g h Gk gv. A Gk v v w z hb w bk, b ,4 h g b w hb Cb gv h h. P w v k b R 5 ggL N B h F, gzg h gv b Nwh g wh h w b . F h h , H (),h . M h gg h Cb v v h h w k w w wg x, h h g g v h h . S, x, M (), x-xv. Ahgh Cb w hv vv h v bh h C Lw [, x,P ()], h k h b b b .

F x, h gv , h w h I v h gv - . A v h h. [h g] (L Ck, 5 J 4).


8/19

100


h h g hb hg w . W h w: Wbv w . N b . T b. B w q . O

k . S h wh wh wh . U h b wh wh. I h w g v b w w .19

Cb , h, h z h g h h k . I h g gv,h w j Cb hh. O h h h, w h h g g , h h x Cb hh w.

B.Te Gains rom Free rade

Ahgh h h g q hghgh b b , h b g gg h z h w g h whhg k . T gh w v xhgh h w b h v g g hg hgh gh -q h v, hg h v xhg b.Hwv, b h g Cb, Sh, Mq h gg

h v x explicitly h z h b v , h g .20

T g g k bw h g v h k h h, h xg h v w k hh. I h , h g x. P h ( w, hg b, ). T gv

Capitalism and Freedom, g 4. W g h h h h h h k g . F, k v h b: h h w v wh w v h, v wh hgh v h, v, b h, wh bg w. Wh h g h h k w h j v vkw g j, q - b x w wh b v , h b k v h v j b q: h h h kw h h h

, k . S, v k g v hw h h h , v hgh hv kw ( ) wh hgg. S Hk (45).


9/19

101


h v vg: h v vg h g h g h g wh h g g h g h h w. I h h w v vg:

hg , whh w b Dv R; v w, whh w b Hkh Oh.

Ahgh h v vg h w h, hq g h , h .21 I k, x h .I h w k , h w g. F, h h k v . T w xhg h w

k w , g wh . Tconsumption gain w g h w whhw b k, v . S, h b g w g h w h w b k, v z h g g. T production gain b g h k, b h h w h h w vg w . Nh h g whh w hgh w h

k h whh g h w x .

22

T hv, , b whh h w g vg v , b h g vg complete k complete , k b. Hwv, h x. F x, , Hb () x h v b J v k 5 h h MjR, h h g w b h 5 5 , h J v b 4 .

T h g h hv b x h . F x, hz b hgh x , h k b g, h g . U w h k g, h hv v v h w b g , v hgh h g hg . 23

Ivg Fh w h h . T g b g. F x, Bhgw (), g . S, x, Kg () H ().


10/19

102


T v vg b x wh intertemporal ghw h. I h , hvg v vg h g g , hv w b w v .24

Ag, h x k h ggg vg () q ggg v gv . B g g w w g, g h k h h v w k.A h vg w , bh w gh v bw h h wh. Aggg vg g q ggg vh ( h bw) ( h ).

F, h v vg trade across states onature, k hg, whh k q k.25I k v k, hv w k, hv h bb vv, h h w b g w g h b g g h k k. Ag, h h :g v h h vk q .26

I g h h b ( x, b ) b g v.27 I h w, v gg g, w b, h h w g h z g v. T x h b h qz h wh h g v hg . U , w g x g h . T g hg , h g whh h hv v vg, hg. Wh g qz, h

, h h b q. T, v w gh g w w b, qz. S, h , q, b h h g q, whh g g

4 S, x, MDg (). F xbk , Ob Rg ().5 S, x, Sv () Ob (4). Ag, xbk , Ob Rg (). T h g k hg

q h , b Db (5), h g gh b h vb, , h whh h vb. S, x, M (5) , , Wg ().


11/19

103


v hv b xh. I h , h g , w q b h, h zg h x . I h w, whh w hkg b g v, ,

xhg ; , w h x g g .

C.rade, Security and Confict: Te Security Externalities o International rade

. E Rh: T M Phk

E hv x h g g v h w b Dv R A Sh, b v hh b v h h bw h h,

h h. T g b g,b hw x h hb ?

I , Phk28 h z h , g bv b b h , h g h b bw . T Phk g ghw. C gv v g gv h, whh w , hv q h g h , . Bh g h h h v h. T

h bw w k whh g h w x. I bhvg , w h g h h w h h g h q g b.

I Phk , h g h gv hg h h v hg h v h x. A vb hg h b ( h ), h g h, k h h h gg . S, h w x h g , k h. I k, h h x g w b, h h g hgh b. H,k h x h, w j v x k h h w. T g h g , h g h v x. Q h q h ggg h h w v, wh h b.

S Phk (, , , ); Phk Gwk (); Phk ().


12/19

10


. R Rh

T Phk wk h k h hh hstrategic vb. I , Sk S () [SS] x h x , g h -v g h. T w , w gg-qb , whh h gh v h . C v w h , whh h b w k x w v . T probabilistic , g -kg h whh w b b h h, whh w gv b k () xz b Sk ().29

Sk S h v h

h w k, v h h b k. Ih w h bv h k , h g k h vb, g h v , g h g w bh . T,k b , bh b w w h g . T x gv h . Hwv, h w v h w, h g wh h h w v v , hg b g w, h vb h wk. I h , h x v. T h Phk, h h xg hg w h v gg . T wh, hwv, h h SS , k h . T b.

D.Anti-Liberal Arguments

I v b x h g wh k h h bw h b.

Wh h g b gg h b whh w j b g g, Cbhh h . F x, h US v Iq, Bk L w:

Wh h b g h v w k w?I , h x g g v k. I , k h vg v

Hh () h h z v q . Oh wk h A M () A ().


13/19

10


gv kg g , gg v, g v , .Ag, gg h v h k v h x k. B . . . h

vb h g . T qbg h bk h Hbb h -- h gv h, h U S w , hg w g w h w h b .30

S v L gg v k. F x, h hgh g xhg gv g. Ahgh h h g h h bk bw k , h h h k g v k x , whh

h gg g .31

A g b wh h, gb , h k bw . I h h, h gb.32 I g gv wh . C k P qb , whhh w k h h h b gb k!

A h hgh b b hbv gv w h w z. Sh hh g h gbz h b g h h z, b h k x h b, gg hh k bw , wk vb h b h wh gbz h .33

S h j h b h h v b v h h b v g.34 T g h hgh g b w g , relative g h v h bhv . I h w, h

g h h v g , j v h gg h wh h. I h h, k - whh w w k zgb b h bh wh h gb q h

S L (). W kg b h w h US v Iq;w gg h L h h vb h g . S, x, Hb (). T h h b h wg L, wh h h bk

h h hgh g . S Wz ().4 S, x, Gw (4).


14/19

106


vb .

F, g h g w g vg g h. Tb h wh b v gb , h whh b h v.A F (5), B () L () , v gw h g . Oh hv h hgg g . F x, A D () h g w b g h b g v, A W () h gv v g .

E. Was Cobden Right? Empirical Studies o the rade-Confict Nexus

Wh gh b h h -b h - q, g h hg bSk S Phk g . T b b xg h v. H Cb b v h 5 PxB h g h w h 5 h, h b h w w h hv b . B h w hv b g b h h F W W h h w . T h w , v wh b Cb . F, h

wh h . T j h Cb hh.35

T b g v vg g vbw h vb, wh g , g , hg, ( b w v GDP), ggh g, , b, gwh, h vb. B h , h h

b h x h . I Phk g , h -,h , h wh h g v gg h h. H h vg, bg h bw .

I wk, Phk () h 4 v 5, wh Phk () h 5 . . Phk (), g h Phk (), x hq wh gh h h, h h

5 T v b Rv (/), MM (), Mw () Bb Sh ().


15/19

107


g b , h h per se. T h, b b h -, h wgg wh h b k, h h b .

Oh h hv . O () z v h 55 , g , ggh g, v w. T h h w , gg , whh , vg, w . O R (, )b , g w v .

S gv Cb hh . P () b w v h 5 .H h w g b b

bw . Rh Kg () z g bw h U S 5 g bw 5 , h g wh US g .

Ex g h Bb (). Gwk() Bb Lv () v h bh hCb hh. B MM (), h h b wk, zh g w . Ov, h h h j hhh h hb v . O h wh, h, Cb hh.

III. Concluding Remarks

T h g v, , , w h b b kg , w v h b hwg E C, F Q, Dv H, A Sh, Mq,Jh Bgh , , Lwg v M. Rh Cb, w wv h . Ahgh b

h , h , b hv, g hb w h g, h gh . B, bg q, h g g hz b b h w gh w g . A x w, h h v , bh wh hgh h w.

T h gh A h Hk v M , h Cb vg gg g h g v ,


16/19

108


. W h b x h h wk b h k bw . T j Cb : h is, , vbh g , h v vb h -,

xhg, whh A Sh bgh h Te Wealtho Nations.

References

A, A. D, D. () Wh Gv Fg A Wh Wh? NBERWkg P Nb w, NBER, Cbg, MA.

A, A. W, B. () D C Gv Rv L Fg A?NBER Wkg P Nb w, NBER, Cbg, MA.

A, J. M, D. () S I: Ah. Ubh, B Cg, Ob.

A, C., A, R. C, J. (). E Av h Shw C, E Iq, J, (), . .

Bb, K. () E I: A Ph P S IC? J P Rh, (): 4.

B, P. () D Dv, L: W N.

Bk, R. () () I R: Ah I Lw I R, Ox: Ox Uv P.

Bhgw, J. () L I , S E, Cbg: MIP.

Bgh, J. Rg, J. () () Sh Q Pb P b RhCb, M.P., L: M C.

Ch, S. (4) M, M h WA F C M P? J C R, : 4.

Cb, R. () T P Wg Rh Cb, L: W Rgw.

Db, G. (5) T V, Nw Yk: W.

F, M. (5) Fg E A, Y Rvw, 4: 55.

F, M. () C F, Chg: Uv Chg P.


17/19

109


Gwk, M. () E I I C: SC-N Ev I S Q, (): .

Gw, J (4). A, Av, I . P, NJ: PUv P.

Hk, F. (45) T U Kwg S A E Rvw, 5, N.4; Sb, 5.

Hk, F. (4) T C Lb, Chg: Uv Chg P.

Hk, F. (4b) Lw Lg Lb, V, Chg: Uv ChgP.

H, E. () I h P P D,

E S M C: A Chb, Hkh-OhAh J I E, : 44.

Hgg, R. () C Lvh: C E h Gwh AGv, Nw Yk: Ox Uv P.

H, W. () Rh Cb: A V O, Nw Hv: Y UvP.

H, F. () () F Oh F D h Mh

Sh, Nw Yk: Ag M. K Pbh.

Hh, Jk () T Dk S h F, Cbg: Cbg UvP.

Hb, J. () I: A S, A Ab: Uv Mhg P.

Hb, J. () T E P J E I W C 5J P E, : 4.

Kg, P. () Ig R, M C h G J I E, : 44.

L, D. () T Pv Dv E, S E, L: I E A.

L, B. () T N Ivb H Fg A, bh h WW Wb h://www.bk./hv/44.h

MDg, G. () T B C Pv Iv Ab: A

T Ah E R, (S I): 5.


18/19

110


MM, S. () I C Mh I SRvw, 4(): 5.

M, L. () I Cb, R. T P Wg Rh Cb,L: W Rgw.

Mq (4) T S h Lw, Cbg Uv P , b Ch, A., M, B. S, H.

M, R. (5) I F Mb A E Rvw,: 5.

Ob, M. (4) Rk-kg, Gb Dv, Gwh AE Rvw, 4(5): .

Ob, M. Rg, K. () F I M,Cbg, MA: MI P.

O, J. () T Lb P: I, D IC: 55 J P Rh, (): .

Pz, S. () T Gwh Gv, J Lw E, :.

Phk, S. () D D: A E Pv, P h P

S S, : .

Phk, S. () C J C R, 4(): 55.

Phk, S. () C : A E Ah P II, I, W. & A. C. (), E A R hP P, Nw Yk: Ev S, .

Phk, S () Wh D C M Fgh L: T RhBw I C Rvw I E, 5:5.

Phk, S., Chg, Y. Rb, J. () Lb I: Exgh -C M, J P Rh, (4): 454.

Phk, S. Gwk, M. () C I: E-W Lkg h E D, J C R, (4): .

P, B. () C, C, C: T E IP I B Fw A J P S,(): .


19/19

111


P, A. () H h A-C Lg, V , L: FkC C.

Rv, R. (/) T C Db: A Sv T, Ev F Rh, P E, P S Pb P, (): 4.

Rh, N. Kg, C. () D Fg P C:A Lg A I S Q, 4(): .

Sk, S. () C S F, E T, : .

Sk, S. S, C. () G, B, O: O h RhBw S A E Rvw, M, (): 55.

Sg, G. () I Sg, G. () Chg S P E,

Chg: Uv Chg P.

Sv, L. () Rk A, A E Rvw, (): 54.

k, G. () E R Skg, Bh, J., , R. k, G.() w T h R Skg S, Cg S: x A & M P.

V M, L. () H A: A E, Fh Rv E,S F: Fx Wk.

Wz, K. () T Mh I, Kbg, C. () T IC, Cbg, MA: MI P.

Wg, K. () A I F Mb Sb? J I E, (/): 544.

individual freedom, international trade and international conflict

Documents