6/20/14 10:46 PMIndonesia's Orangutan Action Plan a Bad Joke

Page 1 of 4http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/opinion/orangutan-action-plan-bad-joke/

HOME HEALTH

Index & Stocks

Joko, If Elected,Would Build 100Fish Centers, SetUp Maritime Bank

Prabowo, IfElected, WouldPursue Plan toCut Fuel Subsidyby Half ...

Prabowo Has ʻNoNeed to Respondʼto WirantoʼsClaims

Indonesiaʼs Orangutan Action Plan a Bad JokeBy Erik Meijaard on 05:30 pm Mar 21, 2014

Category Commentary, Featured, OpinionTags: conservation, Orangutan, wildlife

(JG Graphics/Josep Tri Ronggo Laksono)

In December 2007, President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono launched Indonesiaʼs Strategy and Action Plan for NationalConservation of Orangutans. Quoting the president from his speech, “this will serve as a blueprint for our efforts to save some ofour most exotic but endangered wildlife.” Furthermore, the president said that “the Orangutan action plan formally endorsesIndonesiaʼs commitment to orangutan conservation as expressed in 2005 when Indonesia signed the Kinshasa Declaration onthe Protection of Great Apes in the Democratic Republic of Congo.”

And a final quote: “A key understanding that stems from this Action Plan is that to save orangutans, we must save the forests.And by saving, regenerating, and sustainably managing forests, we are also doing our part in reducing global greenhouse gasemissions, while contributing to sustainable economic development of Indonesia. Successful orangutan conservation is thesymbol of responsible management of the earthʼs resources.”

Excellent stuff. Finally a ray of hope for Indonesiaʼs endangered species.

We are now over six years into the 10 years action plan, so signs of progress should be easy to find. The action plan commitsIndonesia to stabilizing all wild populations by 2017. With habitat loss and hunting being the main threats, this simply means thatall remaining wild orangutan populations should either be incorporated in formally protected areas or other compatible land uses,

Latest Comments Most Popular

NEWS BUSINESS INTERNATIONAL OPINION SPORTS LIFE & STYLE COUNT ME IN BLOGS MULTIMEDIA ENVIRONMENT

11.976,00/11.856,00) Index Regional » AGRI 2,340.12 -13.84 BASIC-IND 522.55 -3.90 COMPOSITE 4,847.70 -16.57 CONSUMER 2,013.34 11.48 DBX 710.82 -3.12 FINANCE

Joko, If Elected, Would Build 100 FishCenters, Set Up Maritime Bank 1

Indonesia Starts Korean ExchangeBadminton Training Program 2

Indonesian Pairs Keep Hostʼs HopesAlive 3

Prabowo, If Elected, Would PursuePlan to Cut Fuel Subsidy by Half in 3Years

4

Prabowo Has ʻNo Need to Respondʼto Wirantoʼs Claims 5

Ahok Says Religion Has No Place onIdentity Card 6

Alleged Megawati-AGO TransJakartaConversation Transcript is a Fraud:Police

7

Mahfud MD Gives ʼ56%ʼ ChancePrabowo Gets Back Together WithEx-Wife

8

Japan to Unveil Review of WartimeSex Slave Apology 9

W. Java Governor Ahmad Heryawanto Run for President in 2019 10

Prabowo

Joko

Both are about even

Vote View Results

Total Votes 146

Debate Poll

Presidential hopefuls Prabowo Subianto andJoko Widodo will face off again on Sundaynight, June 22, in the third of five debates withthe focus on international affairs and nationaldefense. Some polls suggest that Prabowo isnarrowing the gap over Joko, who had beenleading by a significant margin just a few weeksago. Who do you believe is leading?

Search

6/20/14 10:46 PMIndonesia's Orangutan Action Plan a Bad Joke

Page 2 of 4http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/opinion/orangutan-action-plan-bad-joke/

such as sustainably managed timber concessions, and that conservation laws should be enforced.

Unfortunately there is almost no sign of such progress. In the six years since the planʼs launch, not a single orangutan populationhas experienced a land use change that will make it any more likely to survive. No new protected areas have been set up fororangutan conservation. And few if any plantation licenses have been canceled because of the presence of orangutans, and thearea subsequently turned into permanent forest estate.

In fact, the opposite has happened. Vast areas of orangutan habitat have been converted to oil palm. The Tripa swamps in Acehare a prime example of disastrous conservation management and the total irrelevance of Indonesiaʼs stated commitment toorangutan conservation.

But other examples abound. An example from Kalimantan is the situation around the Danau Sentarum National Park. In 2007,the orangutan population here was estimated at 500 individuals in 109,000 hectares of deep peat swamp forest. But as you readthis, excavators are taking down trees and clearing peat land for planting oil palms in those same swamp forests. Give it a fewmore years, and most of those 500 orangutans will be gone, starved to death, caught and stuck in a cage, clubbed over thehead, or set on fire, as sometimes happens.

A cynical interpretation would be that a population of zero animals is stable after all, exactly as prescribed by the action plan, butI doubt that this is what the president had in mind in 2007.

Now, to be upfront, I was heavily involved in the development of Indonesiaʼs orangutan action plan. Indonesia, we thought,urgently needed some kind of government-endorsed strategy for the conservation of orangutans and many other threatenedspecies. The idea was to develop the national strategy, then translate this into local strategies at province and district level,ultimately leading to recommended land use changes that are compatible with conservation, and allocation of sufficiently largebudgets and institutional support to ensure that those areas are effectively managed.

Step one was taken, and a bit of step two, but that was pretty much it. I would be very interested to know what further steps areenvisaged by the Directorate General of Forest Protection and Nature Conservation (PHKA) for implementing the action plan.How much is the present budget allocation and how many staff are assigned to the process? Also, what are the annual targetsand milestones, and what corrective actions are taken when it is clear that those targets are missed?

Indonesia has an additional target for its key conservation species, including the orangutan. This prescribes a goal of 3 percentpopulation growth, which is even more ambitious than stabilization. Surely, the authorities realize that this target is never going tobe met.

After all, every year, several thousand orangutans in Kalimantan are killed in conflicts with people or for food, as reported in threerecent studies in the journals PLOS ONE and Biological Conservation. Also, another study in PLOS ONE shows that Kalimantanlost 123,428 square kilometers (four times the area of the Netherlands) of lowland forest, i.e., prime orangutan habitat, between1973 and 2010. Not all of this area was within the orangutan range, but with good orangutan habitat in Kalimantan containing upto 3 orangutans per square kilometer, it gives some indication of the scale of the population decline.

I may be misreading the numbers, but there seems to be a slight discrepancy between the loss of some 100,000 orangutansover 40 years, and the official goal to increase the population by 3 percent.

More than anything, Indonesia needs to realize what it is losing along with its orangutans. It is obviously not helping the countryʼs“green” image. More importantly, the present race to convert most lowland forest areas to plantations for the production of oilpalm, rubber, timber, and pulp and paper, is going to generate large environmental costs that will mostly be borne by its rural andurban people.

For example, developing plantations on low-lying peats will inevitably lead to massive flooding after the peat has decomposedand the plantations are basically standing in semi-permanent lakes. No forest, no palm oil yields, no agriculture, no development.

Economic and social development is needed, but badly planned and implemented development primarily benefits the few whoare lucky enough to own a plantation, mining lease, or timber concession, and those that help them in the process. The scienceand knowledge is there to guide development that ensures optimal economic, social, and environmental outcomes in the shortand longer term. Our Borneo Futures initiative, for example, has plenty to say about this.

After all, section 14, article 33, of Indonesiaʼs constitution states that “the land and the waters as well as the natural riches thereinare to be controlled by the state to be exploited to the greatest benefit of the people.” Also, “the organization of the nationaleconomy shall be based on economic democracy that upholds the principles of solidarity, efficiency along with fairness,sustainability, keeping the environment in perspective…”

This to me seems pretty clear about the responsibilities of the government.

I strongly urge Indonesiaʼs government institutions to uphold their national and international commitments and legal dutiestowards environmental protection and social fairness. I also urge them not to ignore the extensive scientific information on whatworks and what doesnʼt in natural resource use, and based on that create and implement realistic policies for sustainabledevelopment and species conservation. Only thus will orangutans have any chance to survive in this country.

Erik Meijaard is a long-term conservation scientist based in Jakarta. Among other activities, he coordinates the science-basedBorneo Futures initiative.

Twitter Facebook Instagram

Joko, If Elected, Would Build 100 Fish Centers, Set Up Maritime Bank jglo.be/ilxG

Retweeted by Yoes C. Kenawas

The Jakarta Globe @thejakartaglobe

Expand

Joko, If Elected, Would Build 100 Fish Centers, Set Up Maritime Bank jglo.be/ilxG

Retweeted by Rinawati Eko

The Jakarta Globe @thejakartaglobe

Expand

The Jakarta Globe @thejakartaglobe

12m

12m

12m

Tweets

Compose new Tweet…

TweetTweet 70 0 45Share This: 166LikeLike

Related Articles:

Subscribe to our newsletter to get a briefingon the day's top stories, photos and more.

Email Address

Video:Honoring theAncestors

Video:Interview —Globe Asiaʼs150 RichestIndonesians,ʻRising SonsʼVideo: BecakDriverʼsDaughterTops ClassVideo:Support forCandidatesTakesMultipleFormsVideo:SupportersRally OutsideIndonesiaʼsSecondPresidentialDebate

Corporate News

BII Maybank Bali Marathon MeetsBoston Marathon Quali...

Aqua Group Accepts CSRSustainability Award

Telkom Announces Telkom SmartCampus Award Winners

BII Maybank Bali Marathon MeetsBoston Marathon Quali...

Aqua Group Accepts CSRSustainability Award

Telkom Announces Telkom SmartCampus Award Winners

Aqua Group Accepts CSRSustainability Award

Telkom Announces Telkom SmartCampus Award Winners

6/20/14 10:46 PMIndonesia's Orangutan Action Plan a Bad Joke

Page 3 of 4http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/opinion/orangutan-action-plan-bad-joke/

Indonesia Seeks to Boost Trade With PacificIslands, Aid in Combating Climate Change2 comments • a day ago

JAHAAN — The type of cooperation is in the rightspirit, much needed, boding well for the future.Probably more needs to be done to avert climate …

Hundreds of Entertainment Venues in Jakarta toShut Down During Ramadan13 comments • a day ago

a human — How weak minded are you if you can't fastor observe your religion because a bar is open?Stupidity knows no limits when it's inspired by …

Bekasi Police Seize 103 Kg of Dried MarijuanaFrom Mobile-Phone Store1 comment • a day ago

Max Headroom — "...Jakarta Police chief Insp. Gen.Priyatno said .... that the discovery proved Indonesiawas no longer just a transit country for …

Editorial: Agricultural Sector Needs Urgent Action1 comment • 20 hours ago

Neutral Bystander — Then the no-brainer choice wouldbe Prabowo as president. What you just wrote aboutabove is EXACTLY what Prabowo aims to …

ALSO ON THE JAKARTA GLOBE

3 Comments The Jakarta Globe Login

Sort by Newest Share

Join the discussion…

• Reply •

billy • 2 months ago

of course there is no progress!!! sby has been so busy with his corruption plans and sucking the moneyelsewere!!!!!!whilst the world slept... borneo became a desert!!!!! i would hate to know how much forest has been cut downsince SBY became president!!!!!!!lets hope the deforestation of borneo stops .... it should be totally shutdown as it cannot sustain moremadneesssssss....it is erreversible once its gone ..so time to stop...

• Reply •

Ia Uaro • 3 months ago

Thank you for bringing this up, Mr Mejaard. Environmentalists need to persevere educating and reminding thegovernment and the people until effective measures are implemented. Let's hope this year's election will ridIndonesia of executhieves, legislathieves, yudicathieves and bring Indonesia active pro-environment honestleaders who won't stop until conservation work is responsibly and successfully carried out. Until then, pleasecontinue to speak up.

2

• Reply •

Bummed • 3 months ago

This saddens me.

2

Subscribe Add Disqus to your site

Favorite

Share ›

Share ›

Share ›

Baby Orangutan SavedFrom Smugglers

The Ugly Truth AboutGarbage and IslandBiodiversity

APRIL Policy CementsUnprecedented 1-for-1Conservation Pledge

With Loss ofIndonesiaʼs Forests, aLitany of Problems

PR Newswire

Photo & Imaging Shanghai 2014 to be Held atShanghai World Expo Exhibition & ConventionCenter on 3-6 JulySHANGHAI, June 20, 2014, 1 hours ago 45minutes ago

HOTELEX Shanghai 2015 Sales Progress ReportSHANGHAI, 1 hours ago 45 minutes ago

CNOOC Signed PSC with EniHONG KONG, 5 hours ago 21 minutes ago

DHL Supply Chain Announces New ManagingDirector for MalaysiaKUALA LUMPUR, Malaysia, June 20, 2014,Friday, June 20, 4:35 AM

More News

HOME ABOUT US COMMENT POLICY PRIVACY POLICY RSS BACK TO TOP

6/20/14 10:46 PMIndonesia's Orangutan Action Plan a Bad Joke

Page 4 of 4http://www.thejakartaglobe.com/opinion/orangutan-action-plan-bad-joke/