innovative and new programs in biotechnology and biomanufacturing
DESCRIPTION
This year’s panel features programs noteworthy in their approach to biotechnology/biomanufacturing education and training and the workforce. Panelists include leaders of the Lone Star Biotechnology Institute at Lone Star College working with the local biomedical and biofuels industry in Houston, TX; the Biomass Production Training Certificate at Mira Costa College part of the EDGE (Educating and Developing Workers for the Green Economy) initiative for San Diego County, CA; the SoCalBio Biomanufacturing Consortium to develop biomanufacturing technician education and training programs to support the maturation of the industry in Los Angeles/Orange Counties, CA; and a new program, Biotechnology and Compliance, focusing on biomanufacturing and partnered with local industry at Quincy College in Quincy, MATRANSCRIPT
Sonia WallmanExecutive Director, NBC2January 13, 2012 – Bio-Link Conference
Partnerships
Partnerships
Community colleges traditionally have been tasked to support local industry by providing apt education and training for their industries.Key to this role are academia-industry partnerships and grants that support the development of such strategic alliances (NSF ATE and DOL ETA grants, for instance).Research questions that arise to understand these relationships are:What are the characteristics of effective partnerships and collaborations?How are they developed and how are they sustained?
NBC2 Partnerships Case Study12 partners were interviewed by Dr. Joanna Kile,
their conclusions were: Have a product and stay focused on delivering it.
Partnerships exist in the relationship: the more points of connection the stronger the relationship
Build trust by committing and then following throughRecognize that a successful partnership is a long-term commitment
Identify champions within the group Solicit the opinion of all partners
Be prepared to give more than to receive Share your success stories
Forget what you have done in the past; find out what you need in order to be in business five years from now.
NBC2 Biomanufacturing Products
GBC Laboratory Manual generic and customized Introduction to Biomanufacturing textbook Biofuels Production and Analysis textbook and lab manual Protein is Cash Teachers Workshop BIOMAN Annual Conference Adult 360hr/12wk Biomanufacturing Certificate Hybrid post-baccalaureate 120hr/15wk BIOMAN Certificate Future = modular curriculum to suit local biomanufacturing
needs; provision of supplies for teaching the modules
Virtual Biomanufacturing Production
Panelists Introduction
Danny Kainer from Lonestar Community College in Houston, TX
Bruce Van Dyke from Quincy College in Quincy, MA
Steve Dahms from SoCalBio in Los Angeles/Orange Counties, CA
A thumbnail sketch of our college
system
• Is now the 2nd largest community college system in Texas
• Opened in 1973 (as North Harris College) with anenrollment of 613 students and 15 staff members
• ~80,000 credit students; >90,000 if one includesCE!
• The LSC System coversover 1,400 square miles& includes 11 memberschool districts!
My personal favorite…
• >13,000 students
LSC-Montgomery• Only biotechnology program in
the LSC system, which is the oldest in the state & is recognized by TSSB
LSCBI – AAS & ATC Programs
SECOND YEAR
LSCBI - Graduates
LSCBI – Outreach
LSCBI Partners (a sampling)
Taking our Biotechnology
Institute in a New Direction
On Campus Research
Opportunities1. Algae-to-Oil
http://community.middlebury.edu/~cri/biodiesel_cycle.png
http://www.inhabitat.com/wp-content/uploads/algae6.jpg
http://www.freepatentsonline.com/6923914-0-large.jpg
http://ejournal.vudat.msu.edu/images/thumb232.jpg
2. Oil-to-Biodiesel3. Water Remediation4.Microbial Fuel Cells
Received Generous Donations & Loans from
local algae entrepreneurs (Thanks!)
Algal Culture
PBR Construction (lab scale)
PBR Construction (mid-scale)
The “Tea Cup” PBR
PBR Construction (mid-scale)
PBR Construction (commercial scale)
Inoculation
Flow Cytometry (with a visual
twist!)
Flow Cam Project –Contamination
DetectionContamination detection (wow – that Chlorella vulgaris sure is robust!)
Flow Cam Project – Cell
Count Validation
Flow Cam Project – Nile
Red Lipid Analysis
http://omlc.ogi.edu/spectra/PhotochemCAD/html/nilered.html
Algal Nutraceuticals
WVO-to-Biodiesel Project
WVO-to-Biodiesel Project
FeedstockLibrary Biodiesel
Library
LowerToxicity
WVO-to-Biodiesel Project
Biodiesel Project - Biorefinery
Biorefinery
http://oilgae.com/includes/site_img/origin_oil.jpg
WVO-to-Biodiesel Project
MFCs: Electricity From Mud!
http://i.treehugger.com/images/2007/10/24/microbial%20fuel%20cell-jj-001.jpghttp://i.treehugger.com/images/2007/10/24/microbial%20fuel%20cell-jj-001.jpg
http://parts.mit.edu/igem07/index.php/Image:Spbfc.jpg
Microbial Fuel Cell Project
Molecular Biology & Microbial Fuel
Cells?
WaterBioremediatio
n
Water Remediation Project
Water Remediation Project
Bionanotechnology?
Nanotech & Algae?
Nanotechnology & Microbial Fuel
Cells?
Nanotechnology & Microbial Fuel
Cells?
Nanotechnology & Microbial Fuel
Cells?
Nanotechnology & Water
Remediation?
(http://www.gizmag.com/go/6448/)“Nano Rust”
Thanks for your attention!
STARTING A BIOTECHNOLOGY PROGRAM
WHERE DO I START?
• College Performs a Gap Analysis – What is missingType of training
Research (biomedical, environmental, biofuels)Manufacturing (drugs, medical devices)
First Things First
Will the college support the program?FinanciallyFaculty Support
• Primary Purpose of the ProgramGet students job after completing the program?Prepare them to transfer to a university to obtain a B.S.
• Incumbent worker training – Short CoursesExpanding your student baseState and local biotechnology initiative grants
• Make sure the program aligns with industry needsYou can’t do this on your ownWhat state and local organizations track biotechnology
• Focus the program – Do not dilute student learning by being to broad based
• Corporate Partners – Who you know and who they knowThe primary way of getting in the doorThis opens the door to internships
The most surprising aspect of starting the Biotechnology &
Compliance program
The willingness of companies to work with me on every aspect of the program and to make commitments of time and resources to enable the program to produce competent students ready to enter the workforce.
Developing New Workforce Training Programs and Platforms: The Catalytic Role of Bioscience Trade Associations in Defibrillating Companies, College
Administrators and Faculty, WIBs, 1-Stop Centers and Government Agencies
A. Stephen Dahms President and CEO Emeritus, Alfred E. Mann Foundation
Vice President Academic, Industry and Government Affairs, So. California Biomedical Council Member Federal Emerging Technology and Research Advisory Committee
Eye-balling and Traversing the Bioscience Industries Workforce Development Arena
-Observations Over the Past 15 Years-
SEC DisclaimerChair, WF/Education Committees 1995-2006 (BODs)
– BIOCOM, BayBio, SoCalBio– California Healthcare Institute– Addressed the full span of regional WF development
activities -> national and international level, including the medical device arena (AdvaMed)
Chair, BIO WF Development Committee 1996-2007 (BIO/ECS BOD and BOD Committees 1994-2008)
– DOC, DOE, NSF, DOL, NIH, BLS, GAO, Beltway groups– House and Senate Science/Labor Committees– NRC/NAS/IOM/NAE: GUIRR, Federal Demonstration Pship– International organizations: EU and OECD (1998-2008) – Professional scientific societies– H1B visas, Skills Standards, training needs (#s and areas)
The Workforce Development Landscape
FederalAgencies
Regional/City& CountyAgencies
StateAgencies
Constellation of Actors in the Theaterof Workforce Development
?????County DD
NSF/NIH
DOLCity DD
StateEDD
CCDistrict
1-Stop Centers
State CC Office
DOE
Cos & Non-Profits
County WIB
City WIB
DOC
Research and Research and Product Product
DevelopmentDevelopment
Manufacturing Manufacturing and Productionand Production
Technical Technical AffairsAffairs
Information, Information, Finance and Finance and
AdministrationAdministration
Sales and Sales and MarketingMarketing
Research and Research and Product Product
DevelopmentDevelopment
Manufacturing Manufacturing and Productionand Production
Technical Technical AffairsAffairs
Information, Information, Finance and Finance and
AdministrationAdministration
Sales and Sales and MarketingMarketing
Layers of Complexity
?????
CountiesCCDs
NSF/NIH
DOL
CitiesCDDs
StateEDD
CCDistrict
X 1 -Stop Centers
State CC Office
DOE
Cos & Non-Profits
Counties WIBs
Cities WIBs
DOC
The Take Home Lesson
Trade Organizations to the Rescue!
T-ORG
CountiesCCDs
NSF/NIH
DOLCity DD
StateEDD
CCDistrict
X 1 -Stop Centers
State CC Office
DOE
Cos & Non-Profits
Counties WIBs
Cities WIBs
DOC
Human Capital
IntellectualCapital
Financial Financial CapitalCapital
The Trade Organization: Integrator of Regional Inputs to Build Industry Clusters
Regional IntegratorRegional Integrator
Industry ClusterIndustry Cluster Industry ClusterIndustry Cluster
T-ORGS: a WF development coordinator, organizer, catalyst and nucleating device…often a defibrillator
T-ORGsCounty DD
NSF/NIH
DOLCity DD
StateEDD
CCDistrict
1-Stop Centers
State CC Office
DOE
Non-Profits
County WIB
City WIB
DOC
Problems Facing T-ORGs in WF Development-Cities and Counties-
• Often naïve understanding of the playing field by the players: understanding of technology…some still bemoaning the loss of the buggy-whip industry
• Layers of complexity…especially in megacities• Pre-existing, high-walled political bailiwicks• Historical partnering among the players and segmentation
difficult to change: breaking up the “party”…divorces are difficult
• Time-lines for completion of projects: triage vs. long-term solutions
• “Project Product”: sustainability vs. triage• Players lack of understanding of the necessary resources
Problems Facing T-ORGs in WF Development-Cities and Counties-
• Unreasonable expectations of the WF development arena regarding companies
• CC’s: administrators, role of non-academic training operations, multiple CC’s aiming for the same targets, unrealistic expectations of companies, survey impacts, moving off the “molecular biology” raison d’etre dime
• T-ORG BOD’s: regional, state, and national• 2-year -> 4-year institutional programs: regionally-approved,
industry validated layered, stackable certificates• Research universities: often a considerable problem:
understanding the critical role of CC’s, intrusion into CC space, sparse laboratory training in some universities
• A battle of wills…and entrenched public service organizations very adept at survival
WIB, etc. & Naïve Understanding of the Biotech Industry
RecombDNA
1990
MonoclonalAntibodies
GeneTherapy
SmallMoleculesAntisense
RecombDNA
MonoclonalAntibodies
1985
Complexity of the Biotech Industry 2009-27 Years after 1986-
DNA-basedcomputation
Bioinformatics(Data management &
Data mining)
Proteomics- Computationalexpression analysis drug design
Genetic Novel Profiling Pharmacogenomics chemistries
Micro-arrays &nanotechnologies
Combinatorialchemistry
Biosensors
Highthroughputscreening
Genetherapy
RecombinantDNA technologies
Anti-sense RNAi, etc.
MAbs& phage display
Multiplexed Array of Technologies
Knowledge of Training Ingredients?
Wouldn’t It Be Nice If It Were This Easy!!
Regulatory Affairs Clinical AffairsQuality Built into core business courses for all
center degrees
5.0 FDA Compliance 3.3 Optimizing of chromatographic techniques4.5 IND, NDA and other regulatory submissions 3.3 Pharmacokinetics4.5 cGMP, GCP and GLP 3.3 Pharmacodynamics4.2 Clinical trial design and modeling 3.3 Drug discovery-Conventional & rational drug design4.1 Technical writing 3.3 Functional genomics4.1 cGMP documentation 3.3 Proteomics4.1 Process validation 3.3 Small molecule manufacturing & scale-up issues4.0 Project management 3.3 Toxicology and toxicokinetics4.0 Team-based approaches 3.3 Sterilization4.0 Analytical methods development and validation 3.2 Facility design4.0 Materials and document control 3.2 Principles of industrial hygiene4.0 cGMP training 3.2 Biotechnology and drug design3.9 Quality and production 3.2 General pharmaceutical science3.9 Regulatory strategies and negotiation 3.2 Design controls3.9 Clinical trial statistical analysis 3.2 Facility management3.9 Principles of information systems 3.2 Basic biochemical engineering3.8 Clinical data management 3.2 Combinatorial chemistry3.8 Implementation of clinical trials 3.1 Pharmaceutical delivery systems3.8 Control systems 3.1 Manufacturing execution systems3.8 Clinical trials administration 3.1 Separation and purification3.8 Team-based approaches in biotech. dev. & production 3.1 Protein stability and formulation3.8 cGMP audits 3.0 Statistical process control3.7 International regulatory affairs and ISO-9000 3.0 Pharmacoeconomics3.7 Systems documentation 3.0 Manufacturing personnel training3.6 Facility validation 2.9 Instrumentation in downstream monitoring3.6 Global CMC (chemistry, manufacturing and control) 2.9 Bio/pharmaceutical technology mgmt.3.6 Clinical trials audits 2.9 Mgmt. of development & tech.-based innovation3.5 Corporate partnering 2.8 Combinatorial biology3.5 Regulatory affairs professional training 2.8 Bio/pharmaceutical marketing3.5 CRA training 2.8 Computers in bioprocess engineering3.5 Process development strategies 2.8 Mammalian cell perfusion reactors3.5 Bioinformatics 2.7 Fermentation strategies3.5 Good statistical practices in drug development 2.7 Drug release technology3.5 Statistical process control 2.6 Robotics in drug discovery3.4 Hazardous waste management 2.6 Mgmt. & organizational behavior3.4 Electronic document management and submissions 2.4 Biochemical reactor design & configuration3.4 Pharmaceutical formulation and stability 2.3 Intelligent biomanufacturing3.4 Pharmacogenetics3.4 Computer and software validation3.4 Communications3.4 Manufacturing process technologies3.4 Operation scheduling
Points of Attack of T-ORGs in WF Development“Sector Intermediary Role”
-Cities and Counties-
• Facilitating an increased understanding of the playing field • Removing layers of complexity…especially in megacities• Circumventing or removing high-walled political bailiwicks• Expanding partnering among the technologically-naïve players• Encouraging departure from total reliance on triage approaches• Demanding sustainability• Educating the players on the true costs of training in the 21st century• Embracing CC administrators and engaging them in solutions• Catalyzing applied research and manufacturing programs: faculty training• Stimulation of specialized training facilities, especially in the megacities• Education of T-ORG boards of directors• Creating regionally-approved, industry validated layered, stackable certificates• Constant education of the research universities• Outreach to federal agencies• Triage of the DOL
Problems Facing T-ORGs-Operating In the Sphere of the DOL, one person’s experiences-
• Hooray…T-ORGs are recognized as Sector Intermediaries, but...there are DOL focal problems
– Little DOL concept of need for sustainability
– Little DOL concept of training costs– Entry-level employee predominant
focus– Reorientation of Congressional
mandates– “Spread the Geld” political mentality– Reviewers: Invaders from Planet X
• Underdeveloped appreciation of true vs. interpolated WF needs
– H1B Training Skills RFP case in point
H1B’s in the Biotechnology Industry 2000-2007
• 6-10% of the biotech WF = 18,000• 80% passed through US higher education• Degrees: in red, composition of the US biotech WF
– 40% PhD (19%)– 35% MS (17%)– 20% BS (50%)– 5% MD– 0% AA/AS/vocEd (14%)
• 85% acquired permanent residency ($150M)• And the role of the DOL is exactly what in addressing this
dependency upon foreign nationals?
What is/was the DOC Thinking? Is it really making the H1B problem go away…or is there
another agenda at work?….
Trade Organizations to the Rescue!
T-ORG
CountiesCCDs
NSF/NIH
DOLCity DD
StateEDD
CCDistrict
X 1 -Stop Centers
State CC Office
DOE
Cos & Non-Profits
Counties WIBs
Cities WIBs
DOC
T-ORGs: A Firm Foundation on Which to Coordinate and Facilitate Workforce Development