inpact 2012 presentation
DESCRIPTION
TRANSCRIPT
International Psychological Applications
Conference and Trends
2012 Lisbon, Portugal | 24-26 May
Fonte: http://www.slowtrav.com/blog/deborah/2007/06/lisboa_dreamin.html
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough;
anorectic testimonials in the web
Teresa Castro, António OsórioInstitute of Education, University of Minho
This work is funded by POPH – QREN – Type 4.1 – Advanced Training, by European Social Fund and national funds of MCTES through FCT - Foundation for Science and Technology, under Research Grant with ReferenceSFRH/BD/68288/2010.
Framework of the exploratory study
Methodology
Results and initial conclusions
1
2
3
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
http://www.agenciars.com.br/blog/criancas-brasileiras-sao-as-que-entram-mais-cedo-nas-redes-sociais/
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
PhD research online violence involving children
Receptient [content]
Participant [contact]
Actor [conduct]
the use of digital devices and/or Internet to actively engage in physical, verbal, psychological or emotional aggression, that being repeated can lead to serious physical or psychological self-harm or deliberately and intentionally cause harm to another human being
http://www.agenciars.com.br/blog/criancas-brasileiras-sao-as-que-entram-mais-cedo-nas-redes-sociais/
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
i) Public availabilty ii) Production and disseminationiii) Corncern for parents
Aim: pro-anorexia portuguese written blogs
Potentially harmful and risky content
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
Fonte: http://www.1000wordsinside.com
Anorexia and Bulimia- Disease- Obsessive concern with weight and
image- Loss of weigh by withdrawal of food- Psychiatric problems (depression,
anxiety, mutilation, suicidal behaviour, drug use)
‘Ana’ and ‘Mia’- Social movement - Lifestyle grounded on anorexic
behaviours- Extreme diets- Psychiatric problems (depression,
anxiety, mutilation, suicidal behaviour, drug use)
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
two thirds of adolescent girls search online for health information
Numbers…
Nearly half are about losing weight
13% engage in binge eating and purging behaviours
(Wilson, Peebles, Hardy, & Litt, 2006)
>From solitary to solidary movement
social phenomenon that is unique to the Internet age (...) having no offline equivalent (Giles, 2006) that allows socially isolated or stigmatized individuals to share experiences in relative anonymity, in an apparent safe haven (Giles, 2006), creating a sense of community
- Neutral space (Brotsky & Giles, 2007);
- Non-judgemental space (Dias, 2003; Brotsky & Giles, 2007; Williams, 2009;
Gavin et al., 2008; Williams & Reid, 2007));
- Express their feelings (Wold et al., 2009);
- Alleviates the loneliness (Csipke & Horne, 2007)
- A “sanctuary” (Dias, 2003)
- support and understanding (Gavin et al., 2008; Williams & Reid, 2007)
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
• Reinforces the person’s identity of being eating disordered (Gavin et al., 2008; Rich, 2006; Tierney, 2006)
• Makes it difficult to leave the community behind and recover (Csipke & Horne, 2007)
• Reinforces and normalises the pro-anorexic identity (Gavin et al., 2008)
• Helps keeping their behaviours a secret from ‘others’ in the offline environment for fear that they would intervene and attempt to ‘fix’ their disorder (Gavin et al., 2008; Williams & Reid, 2007)
• Promotes anorexia as a lifestyle and encourage aggressive self-inflicted practices and are an example of inappropriate content disseminated over the Internet (Bell, 2007)
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
Methodology…
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
Methodology…
Sample
11 Weblogs (B1 to B11)♀ 9 / ♂ 2
Portugal 6 / Brazil 7y 13...19
1st stage
ExploratoryPublic data
Passive observation
2st stage
In depthBlogs authors
Interview
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
Content…
Highly shocking, intimate and emotional
“I’m a loser. Can’t stand this... I want to disappear... Nobody understands my pain... ” (B9)
“I know I’m killing myself, but being fat is far worse than being dead” (B3)
“I look at my body and I only see fat... And more fat... I feel disgusted with myself.” (B9)
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Content…
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
self-mutilation, punishment or suicide attempt
“I want to cut myself (...) it provides me a sense of relief...” (B9)
“I hurt myself when I’m depressed” (B8)
“(...) cutting brings me peace” (B5)
Content…
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
Peter Pan syndrome
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Content…
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
Support from followers
“Passed by to leave you my support”
“I’m following you”
“Reading your post made me sad...”
“Please, don’t cut yourself...”
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Messages…
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
This public available blogs may represent a real dangerous for children because
easily provide potentially harmful content (such as tips and tricks to deceive family and friends
incite the use of dangerous diets and drugs
promote anorexia as a normal behaviour, a sense in life wich is worth dying for;
promote thin as a guarantee to be happy and loved
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
International Psychological Applications Conference and Trends Lisbon | 26 May 2012
Online violence: not beautiful enough… not thin enough; anorectic testimonials in the web
1st conclusions…
Fonte: http://fashioningcircuits.com/?p=226
International Psychological Applications
Conference and Trends
2012 Lisbon, Portugal | 24-26 May
Fonte: http://www.slowtrav.com/blog/deborah/2007/06/lisboa_dreamin.html
THANK YOU!
Teresa Castro, António OsórioInstitute of Education, University of Minho
This work is funded by POPH – QREN – Type 4.1 – Advanced Training, by European Social Fund and national funds of MCTES through FCT - Foundation for Science and Technology, under Research Grant with ReferenceSFRH/BD/68288/2010.