intelligence failure or design? karkare, kamte and the campaign for 26/11 truth

Upload: sukumar-muralidharan

Post on 03-Apr-2018

223 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    1/27

    5

    Jot`iijg`oa` cejiur` hr m`sjgo8Ferfer`, Felt` eom tb` aelpejgo chr 43/55 trutb

    Qufuler Lureijmbereo (sufuler.lmNgleji.ahl)

    Khuroeijst, Gurgeho

    EDQ]TEA]; Chr eo `v`ot tbet treuletjs`m tb` oetjho eom ar`et`m e

    s`rjhus arjsjs hc ajtjz`o ihyeity th tb` Jomjeo Qtet`, tb`

    Ohv`ld`r 4>>2 t`rrhrjst etteafs jo Luldej bev` oht d``o put

    tbrhugb e rjghrhus prha`ss hc pudija eaahuotedjijty. Jochrletjho

    evejiedi` jo tb` pudija mhlejo bes cr`qu`otiy d``o joahosjst`ot

    eom tb` hccjajei r`sphos`s, hct`o r`ci`xjv` eom chrluieja, bev`

    `vem`m s`rjhus sarutjoy d`aeus` tb`y bev` ahochrl`m th e

    pr`m`t`rljo`m t`lpiet` ho t`rrhrjsl. ]bhugb tb` pr`ssur`s

    `ochrajog ahochrljty bev` d``o eaut`, e ould`r hc jom`p`om`ot

    eoeiys`s bev` `l`rg`m wbjab phjot th tb` o``m chr gr`et`r pudija

    `ogeg`l`ot wjtb tb` prha`ss hc uorev`iijog tb` trutb d`bjom tb`

    sjxty bhur sj`g` hc Luldej. Mjspessjhoet` `xeljoetjho hc eiievejiedi` `vjm`oa` jomjaet`s tbet t`rrhrjsl jo tb` aurr`ot

    ljii`oojul js e lhr` ahlpi`x pb`ohl`oho tbeo hrmjoerjiy supphs`m,

    wjtb e vestiy verj`get`m aest hc eathrs.

    F@ZWHTMQ; Luldej, 43/55, t`rrhrjsl, Jsielja kjbem, Bjomutve,Jot`iijg`oa` Dur`eu

    Qbhaf eom grj`c er` tb` cjrst r`eatjhos th vjhi`oa` ahlljtt`mwjtb aru`i pr`l`mjtetjho. Eom tb`o, eog`r eom jomjgoetjho. Qpeslshc reg` w`r` uoi`esb`m wb`o Jomjes lexjlul ajty e vest eomt``ljog luitjtum` wb`r` mr`els er` lem` eom lhr` hct`o uolem` --

    wes b`im uom`r sj`g` jo e 3>-bhur hrm`ei hc t`rrhr d`gjoojog 43Ohv`ld`r 4>>2. Ahv`r`m chr lhst pert jo r`ei-tjl` dy tb`ahuotrys oul`rhus o`ws abeoo`is, tb` jojtjei sbhaf et Luldejs

    bhrrhr wes chiihw`m shho `ohugb, dy tb` lhl`ot hc less m`rjsjho,hc r`vuisjho egejost tb` Jomjeo preatja` hc m`lharetja phijtjas.]b` phijtjaei aiess, gujity hc ahlpi`t` jomjcc`r`oa` th tb`

    mejiy eoxj`tj`s tbet p`hpi` cea`, wes emmjtjhoeiiy b`imr`sphosjdi` jo jts ahrrupt eom jo`pt weys, chr tb` mhudi`k`hpermy hc uopr`mjatedi` eom reomhliy terg`t`m t`rrhrjstvjhi`oa` cea`m dy tbhs` wbh `i`at`m tb`l.

    Ahlp`tjtjho elhog o`ws abeoo`is et tb` tjl` cjgbtjog tb` v`ry

    r`ei phssjdjijty hc ceiijog vjatjl th tb` Q`pt`ld`r 4>>2cjoeoajei l`itmhwo -- i`ct oh rhhl th st`p deaf crhl tb`byst`rje. ]b` l`mje sthf`m tb` tbjrst chr v`og`eoa`, dut mjmijtti` th l``t tb` gr`et`r pudija o``m chr e mjspessjhoet`jov`stjgetjho tbet whuim uorev`i tb` cuii ahospjreay. Eats hct`rrhr er` m`sjgo`m th fjii eom lejl wjtbhut mjsarjljoetjho.]b`r` ley d` e a`otrei terg`t wjtb e sp`ajcja jm`otjty, dut tb`hdk`at lhst hct`o js oht l`r`iy th fjii, dut th m`strhy ajtjz`oihyeity th tb` Qtet` eom ajvja hrm`r. ]bhs` wbh succ`r p`rshoei

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    2/27

    4

    ihss er` ahom`lo`m th ijv` wjtb jt jo e ljij`u tbet bes ijtti`tjl` chr tb`l. ]bhs` wbh `saep` pbysjaei jokury eom p`rshoeiihss, oho`tb`i`ss `oahuot`r tb`jr hwo vuio`redjijty et v`ry aihs`quert`rs eom whom`r jc tb`y ahuim d` i`ss chrtuoet` tb` o`xt tjl`erhuom. Jt js e lhl`ot wb`o retjhoei ljoms er` susa`ptjdi` thjrretjhoei qujaf cjx shiutjhos eom t`om th grevjtet` thwerms

    l`mje pietchrls tbet emvhaet` suab r`l`mj`s. Jo tb` m``piyhv`rwrhugbt lhl`ots hc Luldej 43/55, wjtb `lhtjhos rew eom tb`s`os` hc vjhietjho ruoojog m``p, gujit ley bev` d``o pr`kumg`m,eiihwjog ijtti` rhhl chr jochrl`m pertjajpetjho jo kumgjog bhwd`st th m`ei wjtb eo `v`ot tbet m``piy uom`rljo`m ajtjz`o ihyeityth tb` Qtet`.5

    Ho 45 Ohv`ld`r 4>54, kust eb`em hc tb` chur-y`er eoojv`rsery hcLuldejs bhrrhr, Jomje whf` up th tb` o`ws tbet Eklei Eljr Fesed,tb` hoiy survjvhr elhog tb` lereumjog geog hc t`rrhrjsts tbet bemb`im Luldej bhsteg`, bem d``o put th m`etb. O`wspep`r r`em`rstbet lhrojog whuim bev` whf`o up th e sthry tbet Feseds pi`e chr

    ahllutetjho hc tb` s`ot`oa` hc m`etb, bem d``o r`k`at`m dy^r`sjm`ot ^reoed Lufb`rk``, wbh bes tb` uitjlet` rjgbt thm`t`rljo` wb`o tb` queijty hc l`ray js jovhf`m.4 T`em`rs hceohtb`r aet`ghry hc o`wspep`rs whuim bev` d``o thim, wjtbhut eoyessureoa` tbet tb` jochrletjho wes eaauret` (sjoa` tb` b`emijo`wes b`mg`m erhuom dy eo jot`rrhgetjho lerf), tbet Fesed ley bev`d``o sbjct`m crhl Luldejs Ertbur Them prjsho th ^uo`s Z`rewemekeji. ]b`r` wes oh sugg`stjho tbet tb` jochrletjho, `v`o jc tru`,wes hc eoy sjgojcjaeoa`, htb`r tbeo tb` s`osjtjvjty hc tb` 43/55eoojv`rsery tbet epprheab`m.1

    Ahim prjot aeooht qujt` ahov`y tb` abhrtijog m`ijgbt wjtb wbjablhst hc Jomjes abeoo`is drhemaest tb` o`ws hc tb` beogjog, wb`otb`y w`r` oht querr`iijog eogrjiy hv`r wbh bem cjrst rjgbts hotb` dr`efjog o`ws. O`wspep`rs tb` chiihwjog mey aerrj`m cejot`abh`s hc tb` a`i`drethry tho`; E ^upp`ts Ijc` @oms ho e

    Qtrjog sejm ]b` ]jl`s hc Jomje (]hJ), uom`r e strep b`emijo`wbjab m`sarjd`m tb` `x`autjho es e thp-s`ar`t hp`retjho `x`aut`mwjtb surgjaei pr`ajsjho6 43/55 Dutab`r Beog`m, sejm ]b`Bjomusteo ]jl`s (B]). ]b` tjljog hc tb` `x`autjho eom jtseoohuoa`l`ot s``l`m prhgrell`m chr tb` l`mje, wjtb tb` ghv`rol`otcj`imjog sphf`sp`rshos th lexjleiiy `xpihjt tb` 4=-bhur ayai`

    5]brhugb tbjs ertjai` Qtet` jo upp`r aes` wjii r`c`r th tb` epperetus hcghv`roeoa` hc e oetjho, wbji` stet` jo ihw`r aes` wjii r`c`r th tb`

    prhvjoajei kurjsmjatjhos jo wbjab tb` Jomjeo uojho js hrgeojs`m chr purphs`s hcemljojstretjho.4]b` Jomjeo @xpr`ss, e luitj-`mjtjho o`wspep`r, pudijsb`m tbjs sthry es jtsi`em jo M`ibj ho Ohv`ld`r 45. Jt ley bev` epp`er`m jo htb`r `mjtjhos thh,tbhugb tb`r` js oh pertjauier purphs` s`rv`m dy curtb`r jov`stjgetjho hc tbjslett`r.1]b` ]jl`s hc Jomjebem tbjs sthry jo jts M`ibj `mjtjho ho Ohv`ld`r 45, tbhugbwjtbhut cjrl ettrjdutjho eom e cejriy strejgbtchrwerm ahoc`ssjho tbet jt wesoht sur` hc jts shura`s. ]b` l`r` streteg`l hc pieajog eo jot`rrhgetjho lerfect`r tb` sugg`stjho tbet Fesed bem d``o sbjct`m th ^uo`, s`rv`m tb` purphs` hcmjsteoajog tb` o`wspep`r crhl eoy r`sphosjdjijty chr jts r`phrtjog.

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    3/27

    1

    tbrhugb wbjab pudija byst`rje esa`oms eom kust es repjmiysudsjm`s. ]b`s` sphf`sp`rshos jo turo struaf e phstur` hcm`ajsjv` eatjho, hc bevjog ijv`m up th shl` ahostruat hc elesauijo` Qtet` tbet ahuim tef` berm l`esur`s et kust tb` tjl`tb`y w`r` d`jog eaaus`m hc `cc`t` shcto`ss. ]b` ahuotrys lejophijtjaei hpphsjtjho aeii`m chr lhr` `x`autjhos es e cjrl

    m`t`rr`ot egejost t`rrhrjsl, uosurprjsjogiy chausjog lhst m`leomschr cest-treaf mjspetab`s th tb` geiihws, ho p`rshos hc tb`r`ijgjhus ljohrjty. Egejo `abhjog tbjs rjsjog aielhur chrr`trjdutjho, ]hJ bem rjgbt uom`r jts deoo`r b`emijo`, e sthryesfjog jc Eczei Guru, tb` Fesbljrj s`ot`oa`m th m`etb jo ekumjajei v`rmjat tbet leoy qu`stjho, whuim d` o`xt. B] eishemmr`ss`m tb` qu`stjho ho jts crhot peg`, essurjog tb` r`em`rsbjptbet tb` Bhl` Ljojstry whuim tef` e qujaf aeii ho jt.

    Es tbrhugb bjs trjei, Feseds jm`otjty, bjs lhtjvetjhos eom bjs

    eot`a`m`ots, w`r` sbrhum`m jo lyst`ry tjii tb` v`ry lhl`ot hc bjsm`etb. Bjs durjei jo tb` pr`ljs`s hc tb` Z`reweme keji ect`r bjs

    putetjv` celjiy eom tb` ghv`rol`ot hc ^efjsteo r`cus`m th tef`phss`ssjho hc bjs dhmy, r`jochra`m tb` jleg` hc e yhuog vegreotwbh wes mrewo joth e drj`c aer``r jo `xtr`l` t`rrhr dy let`rjeijomua`l`ots eom tb` jiiushry prhljs` hc e peremjs` th ahl` jo tb`ect`r-ijc`. Ho` o`wspep`r pudijsb`m eo eaahuot hc Feseds ijc`wbjab wes es luab tb` mhaul`otetjho hc e m`t`rljo`m jov`stjgetjv``cchrt dy e o`ws r`phrt`r hc ^efjsteoj hrjgjo th ihaet` tb` `xeatahhrmjoet`s hc bjs hrjgjo, crhl sf`taby m`tejis pudijsb`m hc bjsjot`rrhgetjho=. E phpuier o`ws w`dsjt` r`v`ei`m tbet b` wes esberp eom aeooy i`ero`r wbh bem pjaf`m up tb` Leretbj ieogueg`wbji` jo austhmy, crhl phija` p`rshoo`i essjgo`m th bjs joo`rs`aurjty rjog. Es r`phrt`m ho e wjm`iy vjsjt`m o`ws w`dsjt`, b`bem, murjog tb` 43/55 trjei surprjs`m tb` Kumg`, phija`l`o eom

    ahurt hccja`rs wjtb bjs bulhur eom grespjog phw`r sh luab sh tbetb` pjaf`m up Leretbj eom `v`o ahov`rs`m jo jt wjtb `v`ryho`erhuom bjl. Jom``m, bjs uom`rsteomjog wes hc e v`ry bjgb hrm`r,sjoa` b` bem, `v`r sjoa` tb` trjei d`geo jo Ley 4>>: .... d``o

    f``oiy hds`rvjog tb` prha``mjogs eom (bem) pjaf`m up djts hc@ogijsb eom `v`o Leretbj es wjto`ss`s, iewy`rs eom tb` kumg`sphf` jo tbhs` ieogueg`s eitbhugb tb` `vjm`oa` wes r`ahrm`m [email protected]

    Htb`r eaahuots hc Fesed sphf` hc bjl es lhrhs` eom teajturo. EomLuldejs prjsho eutbhrjtj`s cjoeiiy put th r`st tb` cjatjho tbet

    b` bem d``o tr`et`m th uojlegjoedi` gestrhohlja iuxurj`s wbji` jo

    m`t`otjho. Fesed wes s`rv`m tb` sel` cer` es eii htb`r prjsho`rs,tb`y sejm, sjoa` m`pertur`s crhl tb` pr`sarjd`m r`gjl` w`r` hoiy

    =Qe``m Qbeb,Abesjog e oel` jo kjbemj b`ertieom, ]b` Bjomu, (M`ibj `mjtjho),44 Ohv`ld`r 4>54, peg` 55.0Q`` tb` ijv` hoijo` ahll`otery phst`m ho tb` w`dsjt` ho tb` mey hc Feseds`x`autjho et; bttp;//o`ws.r`mjcc.ahl/ahll`otery/4>54/ohv/45/ijv`upmet`s.btl.@xtreat`m et tbjs wrjtjog, ho 43 M`a`ld`r 4>54.

    http://news.rediff.com/commentary/2012/nov/21/liveupdates.htmhttp://news.rediff.com/commentary/2012/nov/21/liveupdates.htmhttp://news.rediff.com/commentary/2012/nov/21/liveupdates.htm
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    4/27

    =

    p`rljtt`m ho b`eitb grhuoms.3 B` wes d`jog guerm`m dy eo `xtreiey`r hc phija` m`pihyl`ot, dut tbet wes oh sp`ajei prjvji`g`,kust o`a`ssery pr`aeutjho egejost eo `cchrt th r`sau` hr`ijljoet` bjl.

    Jt wes e puzzijog eom joahosjst`ot pjatur` tbet `l`rg`m hc tb`

    p`rsho wbh bem ahl` chr eii hc Jomje, th syldhijs` tb` t`rrhrjstl`oea`. Aurjhusiy tbhugb, tb` r`omjtjho hc Feseds ijogujstjaedjijtj`s tbet `l`rg`m ect`r bjs `x`autjho, abjl`m wjtb e reomhldjt hc jochrletjho put hut murjog bjs trjei jo tb` bjgbiy s`aur`meom chrtjcj`m ahocjo`s hc e Luldej prjsho. ]bjs shijtery r`phrtcrhl ^]J (tb` ^r`ss ]rust hc Jomje), e o`ws eg`oay tbet mh`s oht`ld`iijsb ceatuei r`ahrmjog hc `v`ots wjtb rb`thrja, wesmjsteoa`m crhl eoy r`sphosjdjijty chr wbet wes sejm, dy tb`sjlpi` m`vja` hc jm`otjcyjog Feseds m`lhostretjho hc Leretbjijogujstja prhcjaj`oay, es eo eotja.7]bet r`omjtjho hc `v`otsbes e trhudijog r`shoeoa` wjtb a`rtejo t`iijog phjots lem` jo edhhf uom`r r`vj`w b`r`, wb`r` Q.L. Lusbrjc aeiis up `y`wjto`ss

    t`stjlhoy crhl ho` hc tb` sa`o`s hc leyb`l ho 43/55 LuldejsAele eom Eidi`ss Bhspjtei sugg`stjog tbet tb` etteaf`rs chuomtb`jr wey erhuom jo pert, dy jot`rrhgetjog tbhs` et tb` sa`o` joLeretbj.2

    Kust uom`r e lhotb ect`r Feseds `x`autjho, ^efjsteos C`m`rei

    Ljojst`r chr tb` Jot`rjhr, T`bleo Leijf, pejm tb` vjsjt th Jomjetbet bem d``o `erij`r sab`mui`m chr ljm-Ohv`ld`r, dut tb`om`c`rr`m et M`ibjs josjst`oa`. ]b`r` wes oh ai`er r`esho gjv`oet tb` tjl` chr tb` phstpho`l`ot hc tb` vjsjt, wbjab bem tb`eg`ome -- egr``m w`ii jo emveoa` -- hc chrleijsjog e o`werreog`l`ot chr tb` lutuei greot hc vjses. Dut tb` jlljo`oa` hctb` 43/55 eoojv`rsery th tb` met` hrjgjoeiiy cjx`m chr tb` vjsjt,uomhudt`miy piey`m e pert. Wb`o tb` vjsjt mjm cjoeiiy haaur, tb`ljojst`r wes abereat`rjstjaeiiy diuot, s``ljogiy uoljomcui hcmjpihletja oja`tj`s. Jt js oht ai`er tbet b` wes drj`c`msuccjaj`otiy jo emveoa` edhut tb` jssu`s b` whuim ijf`iy d`eldusb`m dy. Dut T`bleo Leijf lust sur`iy bev` d``o ewer` tbet^efjsteos jot`ot jo tb` lett`r hc Leuieoe Lhbellem Becjz Qe``m,tb` ai`rja d`ij`v`m th bev` jospjr`m eom pieoo`m tb` 43/55etteafs, whuim d` elhog tb` prjoajpei qu`stjhos b` whuim bev` th

    3Keji tei`; Djryeoj lytb eom tb` quj`t jolet`, ]b` Bjomusteo ]jl`s, Ohv`ld`r44, 4>54, p 5.7]b` r`phrt crhl ^]J wes b`emijo`m, Ohw, Fesed abhhs`s Leretbj th eosw`r

    qu`stjhos eom wes aerrj`m jo tb` ]jl`s hc Jomje tb` chiihwjog mey. Jt jsevejiedi` es hc 43 M`a`ld`r 4>54 et;bttp;//ertjai`s.tjl`shcjomje.jomjetjl`s.ahl/4>5>->5-4>/jomje/425=0000X5Xeklei-fesed-kumg`-l-i-tebeijyeoj-gjrgeul-abhwpetty.2Q.L. Lusbrjc, Wbh Fjii`m Ferfer`8 ]b` r`ei cea` hc t`rrhrjsl jo Jomje, (Cjctb@mjtjho), ^berhs L`mje eom ^udijsbjog, M`ibj, 4>55, pp 5:3. ]br`` l`mje r`phrtser` ajt`m jo supphrt hc tbjs ahot`otjho; crhl tb` Leberesbtre ]jl`s(e Leretbjieogueg` mejiy), eom tb` Luldej `mjtjhos hc tb` ]jl`s hc Jomjeeom tb`Bjomusteo ]jl`s. ]b` eutb`otjajty hc tb` ajtetjho crhl tb` ]jl`s hc Jomjebesd``o ab`af`m. Jt js evejiedi` et peg` 50 jo tb` Luldej `mjtjho hc Ohv`ld`r 4:,4>>2.

    http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-01-20/india/28145555_1_ajmal-kasab-judge-m-l-tahaliyani-girgaum-chowpattyhttp://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-01-20/india/28145555_1_ajmal-kasab-judge-m-l-tahaliyani-girgaum-chowpattyhttp://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-01-20/india/28145555_1_ajmal-kasab-judge-m-l-tahaliyani-girgaum-chowpattyhttp://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2010-01-20/india/28145555_1_ajmal-kasab-judge-m-l-tahaliyani-girgaum-chowpatty
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    5/27

    0

    emmr`ss jo tb` hmyss`y th Jomje. Wb`o tb` haaesjho erhs`, Leijfr`sphom`m wjtb eo eccjrletjho hc ^efjsteos ahlljtl`ot th tef`eii eatjho werreot`m dy tb` `vjm`oa` jt wes pr`s`ot`m. Jomjesdjii hc jomjatl`ot egejost Becjz Qe``m, des`m `otjr`iy ho Fesedsahoc`ssjho, dy jlpijaetjho, mjm oht l``t tb` steomerms hc prhhco``m`m chr eatjho uom`r arjljoei iew.

    ]b` vjsjtjog ^efjsteoj mjgojterys ihautjhos w`r` tef`o dy Jomjeoahuot`rperts es eo josucc`redi` eccrhot, eo `xpr`ssjho hc mjsmejochr tb` luitjpi` mhssj`rs tbet bem d``o pr`s`ot`m, wbjabhst`osjdiy iejm hut e ahlp`iijog eom ai`er-aut aes` egejost BecjzQe``m. Wjtb tb` l`mje prhvjog lhr` tbeo wjiijog th `abh eomelpijcy tb` hccjajei s`os` hc hcc`om`m beut`ur, tb` ijtti`jochrletjho eaa`ssjdi` th tb` pudija wes durj`m jo rht`stet`l`ots hc ihyeity th tb` tb`hihgy tbet t`rrhrjsl wes`xaiusjv`iy eom uojqu`iy e ar`etjho hc tb` ahuotry o`xt mhhr.

    Jo Eugust 4>>:, Jomjes Ljojstry hc @xt`roei Eccejrs aeii`m jo

    `ovhys hc lekhr w`st`ro oetjhos chr e drj`cjog ho tb` mjpihletjastet` hc piey jo s`aurjog kustja` chr 43/55. ]b` P.Q. `ldessy joM`ibj shho ect`rwerms put tb` prha``mjogs ho r`ahrm es emjpihletja aedi` th tb` P.Q. Qtet` M`pertl`ot eom f`y ljssjhosedrhem. Epp`om`m th tb` aedi` wes tb` cuii t`xt hc tb` mhssj`rpr`s`ot`m tbet v`ry mey th tb` ^efjsteo ghv`rol`ot. Jo Lerab4>55, es pert hc e ahiiedhretjv` `cchrt wjtb tb` ajtjz`okhuroeijsl w`dsjt` Wjfji`efs, ]b` Bjomupudijsb`m tb` t`xt hc tb`mjpihletja aedi` wjtb tb` eoo`x`m mhssj`r.:

    ]bhugb jt bem eaqujr`m ahlp`iijog lystjqu` es e mhaul`ot tbeteppij`m jrr`sjstjdi` lhrei pr`ssur` ho ^efjsteo, tb` jot`iijg`oa`mhssj`r prhv`m e cejriy sjlpi` mhaul`ot th o`ghtjet`. Drj`c eomr`ietjv`iy uoahlpijaet`m jo jts oerretjho hc ceats, jt wes des`m`otjr`iy ho tb` ahoc`ssjhos r`om`r`m dy Fesed eom twh c`iihwm`tejo``s; Cebjl Eoserj eom Qedebummjo Qb`jfb, wbh w`r` eir`emyjo Jomjeo austhmy et tb` tjl` hc 43/55 dut w`ot ho trjei wjtbFesed ho aberg`s hc phss`ssjog prjhr fohwi`mg` eom lefjog elet`rjei ahotrjdutjho th tb` etteafs.

    Ahosjm`rjog jts ahot`ots, jt r`eiiy o``ms th d` esf`m wby tb`mhssj`r wes oht lem` pudija et tb` v`ry tjl` jt wes pr`s`ot`m thtb` ^efjsteo ghv`rol`ot. ]b` t`rl pudija jo Jomje js sudk`at thverjhus jot`rpr`tetjhos, dut jt ahuim d` uom`rsthhm jo eojoaiusjv` s`os`, es eoydhmy wbh bes e stef` mjr`at hr jomjr`at

    jo fohwjog edhut eo `v`ot hc ahos`qu`oa`. ]b`r` js eish jophss`ssjho hc tbjs pudija, e cejri`gei fohwi`mg`, es eish tb`edjijty th errjv` et e r`eshoedi` ess`ssl`ot hc tb` veiu` hcahoc`ssjhos lem` jo phija` austhmy. Jot`roetjhoei arjljoei

    :Q``, Jomjes Grem` 5 @vjm`oa` Egejost Becjz Qe``m jo tb` Luldej Etteafs,]b` Bjomu, Lerab 47, 4>55, (M`ibj `mjtjho) peg` 56 `xtreat`m 43 M`a`ld`r 4>54crhl; bttp;//www.tb`bjomu.ahl/o`ws/tb`-jomje-aedi`s/ertjai`507=15=.`a .

    http://www.thehindu.com/news/the-india-cables/article1574314.ecehttp://www.thehindu.com/news/the-india-cables/article1574314.ecehttp://www.thehindu.com/news/the-india-cables/article1574314.ece
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    6/27

    3

    ahhp`retjho ohrleiiy r`qujr`s tbet strjog`ot arjt`rje d` l`t. ]b`Jomjeo ghv`rol`ot wes uomhudt`miy v`ry eldjtjhus jo `xp`atjog echr`jgo ghv`rol`ot th jojtjet` arjljoei prha``mjogs egejost eajtjz`o ho tb` desjs hc e m`teji`m oerretjv` hc `v`ots dy eojomjvjmuei hc uoa`rtejo prhv`oeoa` dut wjm` ijogujstja edjijty crhl ^uokedj th Prmu eom tb`o, Leretbj. Jt ley bev` d``o slert es

    phijtjas, dut oht sh ahovjoajog es i`gei stret`gy jo eojot`roetjhoei mhlejo.

    Feseds ijvjog t`stjlhoy retb`r tbeo tb` ahoc`ssjho r`om`r`m joausthmy whuim bev` d``o f`y jo drjogjog th dhhf htb`rs wbheii`g`miy piey`m e rhi` jo tb` 43/55 bhrrhr. Eom b`r`, tb`r` wes[efjur Tebleo Iefbvj, hst`osjdiy tb` ljijtery hp`retjhos b`em hctb` Iesbfer-`-]ejyede (I`]) ljijteot hutcjt, wbh wes epert crhlBecjz Qe``m -- jo tb` ijo` hc sjgbt hc Jomjeo `ochra`l`oteg`oaj`s.

    Sj`w`m jo tbjs leoo`r, Feseds `x`autjho ahuim d` s``o es e

    pht`otjei jlp`mjl`ot th tb` suaa`sscui prhs`autjho hc htb`r f`ycjgur`s jovhiv`m jo tb` ahospjreay. Jc tb` m`ajsjho th drjogchrwerm bjs `x`autjho es tb` lhrdjm jleg`ry hc tb` mey puts jt,dy kulpjog tb` qu`u` wes lem` ect`r mu` ahosjm`retjho hc tb`ihog`r-t`rl jlpijaetjhos, tb`r` js e o``m th `xpiejo wbet jtl`eos chr tb` jot`grjty hc tb` trjei prha`ss.

    Elhog tb` ahuots ho wbjab Fesed wes ahovjat`m eom `x`aut`m, westb` lurm`r hc `jgbt phija` p`rshoo`i kust hutsjm` tb` AeleBhspjtei pr`ljs`s. ]bhs` fjii`m joaium`m twh hccja`rs crhl tb`J^Q aemr`, B`leot Ferfer` eom Esbhf Felt`, ho` s`ojhr josp`athr,Sjkey Qeiesfer, eom cjv` ahostedi`s, Depureh Murgum`, Deieseb`dDbhsei`, Eruo Abjt`, Keyeweot ^etji eom Zhg`sb ^etji. M`teji`mphst-lhrt`l `xeljoetjhos eom deiijstjas letab`s chr tb` duii`tstbet aeus`m tb`s` m`etbs w`r` dy eii eaahuots aerrj`m hut. Eomtb` hutahl` hc tb`s` deiijstjas t`sts, jo tb` aes` hc Ferfer`,wes sullerjs`m jo tb` 5,0>> peg` trjei ahurt kumgl`ot jo cejriyai`er t`rls; ..tb` duii`ts r`a`jv`m crhl tb` m`em dhmy w`r` s`ot

    th tb` deiijstja (sja) `xp`rt. ]b` ahlperjsho mjm oht i`em th eoyahoaiusjv` hpjojho wb`tb`r tb` duii`ts teiij`m wjtb tbhs` t`stcjr`m crhl tb` w`ephos b`im dy tb` eaaus`m ould`r 5 (Fesed) hrtb` m`a`es`m eaaus`m ould`r 5 (Edu Jsleji).

    Qjljieriy, tb` trjei ahurt kumgl`ot sullerjs`s tb` cjomjogs crhltb` t`abojaei eoeiysjs hc twh duii`ts r`ahv`r`m crhl Qeiesfers

    dhmy jo tb` chiihwjog t`rls; ]b`y w`r` s`ot th deiijstja `xp`rtchr `xeljoetjho. ]b` ahlperjsho mjm oht i`em th eoy ahoaiusjv`hpjojho.5>

    5>Jo tb` Ahurt hc Q`ssjhos chr Gr`et`r Luldej, Q`ssjhos Aes` Ould`r 570 hc4>>:, ]b` Qtet` hc Leberesbtre v`rsus Lhbellem Eklei Lhbellem Eljr Fesed eomhtb`rs, kumgl`ot met`m 3tbLey 4>5>, peregrepbs 2>1-=.

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    7/27

    7

    ]b`s` cjomjogs w`r` r`eccjrl`m dy tb` Dhldey Bjgb Ahurt wbjabb`erm eom m`ajm`m Feseds epp`ei egejost tb` m`etb p`oeity.55Z`ttb`s` w`r` oht m``l`m th d` e s`rjhus jocjrljty jo tb` aes` hctb` prhs`autjho, sjoa` prhhc hc gujit mjm oht r`qujr` tbet `v`rypj`a` hc `vjm`oa` sbhuim teiiy; l`r`iy tbet tb` pr`phom`reoa` hc`vjm`oa` sbhuim sugg`st gujit. Et tb` cjoei steg` hc epp`ei, tb`

    Qupr`l` Ahurt b`im tbet tb` deiijstjas t`sts cjrliy `stedijsb`mFeseds r`sphosjdjijty jo tb` fjiijog hc et i`est sjx p`hpi`, oht

    joaiumjog `jtb`r Ferfer` hr Qeiesfer, wbji` Felt`s m`etb wes jo

    eii prhdedjijty aeus`m dy Edu Jsleji, wbh eaahlpeoj`m bjl jo tb`relpeg` hc t`rrhr tbrhugb Dhldey S] eom jts `ovjrhos.54

    Ceatueiiy, m`spjt` Feseds gujit d`jog `stedijsb`m eom tb` lhst`xtr`l` puojsbl`ot l`t`m hut, tb`r` js succjaj`ot r`esho th eiihwQ.L. Lusbrjc tb` jomuig`oa` hc phsjog tb` qu`stjho tbet tjti`sbjs dhhf; Wbh Fjii`m Ferfer`8ljgbt s``l e sup`rciuhus qu`stjhochr eii sjgo`m up m`vht``s hc tb` hccjajei tb`hihgy ho 43/55 eomtb` wjm`r jssu` hc t`rrhrjsl. Dut tb` piejo ceats, wbjab tb`

    `vjm`oa` r`ahrm`m jo kumjajei prha``mjogs vhuab chr, sbhw tbettbjs js e cer crhl s`tti`m qu`stjho.

    B`leot Ferfer` js tb` lhst s`ojhr Jomjeo hccjajei th ceii tht`rrhrjsl jo r`a`ot y`ers. Abj`c hc tb` Eotj-]`rrhrjsl Qquem(E]Q) hc Leberesbtre ^hija`, b` wes fjii`m jo e cjr`cjgbt jo tb`o`er vjajojty hc Luldejs jahoja rejiwey stetjho tb`Abbetrepetj Qbjvekj ]`rljous (AQ], hr Dhldey S] jo ahllho useg`) murjog tb` v`ry `eriy bhurs hc tb` etteafs. Bevjog khjo`mLeberesbtre ^hija` jo 5:73 eom d``o jomuat`m joth tb` J^Q jo5:25, Lusbrjc wes ho` y`er eb`em hc Ferfer` jo aemr` s`ojhrjty.Eom bjs kumgl`ot js tbet Ferfer` pejm e prja` tbet mey chr bevjogmjsleoti`m tb` hccjajei tb`hihgy wbji` jov`stjgetjog e Q`pt`ld`r4>>2 dhld diest jo Lei`geho thwo jo Leberesbtre, elhog tb` cjrstt`rrhrjst eats th haaur uom`r bjs wetab et tb` E]Q. ]b` hccjajeioerretjv` shugbt th ihaet` tbjs joajm`ot wjtbjo tb` t`lpiet` hctb` Jsielja bhiy wer hr kjbem. Dut Ferfer`s jov`stjgetjhosr`v`ei`m tb` beom hc e t`rrhr rjog hc e retb`r mjcc`r`otr`ijgjhus strjp`.

    ]bet dr`eftbrhugb hp`o`m up o`w ijo`s hc josjgbt joth eahiiedhretjv` v`otur` d`tw``o Bjomutve cuomel`oteijsts eom eoeatjv`-muty ljijtery jot`iijg`oa` hccja`r. Jt wes e aelpejgo hcprhvhaetjho, w`ii-`omhw`m eom syst`letja, wbjab wes essur`m hcjlpuojty l`r`iy d`aeus` tb` exjhl tbet eii eats hc t`rrhr bem

    tb`jr jospjretjho jo tb` jm`hihgy hc Jsielja kjbem, bem s`aur`mwjm` shajei mjccusjho eom eaa`pteoa`, jo pert tbrhugb tb` iezy

    55Jo tb` Bjgb Ahurt hc Kumjaetur` et Dhldey, Arjljoei Epp`iiet` Kurjsmjatjho,Ahocjrletjho Aes` Ould`r 4 hc 4>5> jo Q`ssjhos Aes` Ould`r 570 hc 4>>:, ]b`Qtet` hc Leberesbtre v`rsus Lhbellem Eklei Lhbellem Eljr Fesed eijes Edu

    Lukebjm, 45stC`druery 4>55, peregrepbs 144-=.54Jo tb` Qupr`l` Ahurt hc Jomje, Arjljoei Epp`iiet` Kurjsmjatjho, ArjljoeiEpp`ei Ould`rs 52:: eom 5:>> hc 4>55, Lhbellem Eklei Lhbellem Eljr Fesed eijesEdu Lukebjm v`rsus Qtet` hc Leberesbtre, Eugust 4:, 4>54, peregrepb 43=.

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    8/27

    2

    ahlpijeoa` hc tb` l`mje. @v`o wb`o tb` terg`ts hc t`rrhr w`r`ahlluojtj`s eom syldhis hc tb` Jsielja cejtb es wjtb tb`Lei`geho diests et e Lusijl a`l`t`ry jo Q`pt`ld`r 4>>3, tb` cjr`-dhldjog hc tb` Qelkbeute @xpr`ss o`er M`ibj jo C`druery 4>>7, hrtb` aeroeg` et Bym`redems L`aae Leskjm jo Ley 4>>7 eom Ekl`rsMergeb sberjc jo Hathd`r 4>>7 tb`hrj`s w`r` `esjiy m`pihy`m hc

    s`aterjeo mjvjsjhos d`tw``o verjhus sabhhis hc Jsiel, th put tb`etrhajtj`s mhwo th tb` bhiy werrjhrs.

    ]b` vhiul` tbet Lusbrjc bes eutbhr`m reog`s wjm`iy, joaiumjog joahosjm`rjog tb` cesbjho jo wbjab tb` luitjpi` t`rrhrjst joajm`otsjo Jomje hv`r tb` iest m`aem` bev` d``o jov`stjget`m, eom tb`auitur` hc edshiut` `x`lptjho crhl jochrl`m pudija sarutjoy tbetbes cihurjsb`m elhog tb` phija` chra` d`aeus` hc tb` r`ci`xjv`t`om`oay th diel` tb` ahuotrys Lusijl phpuietjho chr `v`ry

    hutreg` egejost jooha`ot ajvjijeo ijc`. Lusbrjcs chr`osjaedjijtj`s er` `vjm`ot jo tb` leoo`r tbet b` sjcts tbrhugblhuotejos hc jochrletjho, getb`r`m jo tb` lejo crhl l`mje

    r`phrts, uorev`iijog tb` truiy jlphrteot oerretjv` m`tejis. ]b`hccjajei oerretjv` hc `v`ots js piea`m jo tb` spetjei eomt`lphrei ahot`xt hc Luldej es jt wes tbet cet`cui ojgbt hc 43/55.

    Lusbrjc rejs`s e ould`r hc ahlp`iijog qu`stjhos, tbhugb tb``ld`iijsbl`ots b` emms ho bhw tb` phija` chra` js hrgeojs`m eomtb` jm`hihgjaei mhatrjo`s tbet jospjr` tb` ahuotrys lejo

    jot`iijg`oa` eg`oay, ley m`treat crhl tb` ceatuei oerretjv`.D`yhom eii tb` lystjcyjog m`tejis wbjab Lusbrjc ess`ldi`s, tb`joc`r`oa` b` phjots thwerms js sjlpi`; Ferfer` ley bev` d``ovjatjl hc e ahospjreay jot`om`m th f``p tb` ijm ho tb` Bjomutvet`rrhr rjog tbet Jomjes prjoajpei jot`iijg`oa` eg`oay bem

    `xt`om`m jts petrhoeg` th.

    ]b` prhphsjtjho js sjlpiy tbet tb` Jot`iijg`oa` Dur`eu js edestjho hc e pertjauier verj`ty hc abeuvjojsl, jot`ot ho ijtti`i`ss tbeo tb` treoschrletjho hc tb` abereat`r hc tb` JomjeoQtet`. Drebljojsl es Lusbrjc abereat`rjs`s jt, emhpt`m tb`

    ahlluoei rjht es tb` pr`c`rr`m streteg`l jo tb` cjrst c`w m`aem`shc Jomjeo jom`p`om`oa`, ahocjm`ot tbet mjss`ot whuim d`suppr`ss`m jo tb` eldj`oa` hc vjhi`oa` d`tw``o r`ijgjhusahlluojtj`s]b` Debukeo hr tb` mjs`ocreoabjs`m lekhrjty whuim jo tb` prha`ss, d` b`rm`m joth ahlpijeoa` m`sjgos hc tb`Drebljojaei lekhrjty. Wb`o tbjs streteg`l r`eab`m jts ijljts,wjtbhut r`eiiy leoegjog th qu`ii eii shura`s hc mjss`ot, tb`

    chaus sbjct`m th Jsielja t`rrhr.

    Lusbrjc pr`cea`s bjs chrlei `otry joth tb` chr`osja eoeiysjs hc43/55 wjtb eo `xaursus joth r`a`ot t`rrhrjst strjf`s. ]b`s`s``l`m th phjot tb` cjog`r hc suspjajho et Jsielja `xtr`ljsthrgeojsetjhos. Ho aihs`r `xeljoetjho tbhugb, tb`y w`r` s``o thsugg`st qujt` e mjcc`r`ot r`ijgjhus eom jm`hihgjaei jospjretjho.B` ieys hut e treji hc jochrletjho tbet phjots thwerms besty eomjii-ahosjm`r`m jov`stjgetjho joth tb`s` etteafs wbjab i`m

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    9/27

    :

    s``ljogiy, th josteot eom m`ajsjv` r`suits, sjlpiy d`aeus` tb`yw`r` s``o th cjt tb` lest`r oerretjv` hc Jsielja t`rrhr.

    Jochrletjho tbet Lusbrjc pr`s`ots ley oht, jo jts`ic, s``l`otjr`iy p`rsuesjv`. Dut tbjs js hoiy d`aeus` b` js ess`ldijogceats crhl mjv`rs` shura`s, lhstiy crhl tb` l`mje. ]b`s`

    jomjvjmuei wjsps hc mete succ`r crhl tb` desja jocjrljty hc l`mjeshura`s. ^ertiy d`aeus` hc tb` sbhrt ett`otjho speos tbet er` ec`etur` hc l`mje shura`s pertiy d`aeus` hc tb`jr eaquj`sa`oa`jo tb` lest`r oerretjv` hc Jsielja t`rrhrjsl -- tb`s` jshiet`mdjts hc jochrletjho er` oht jot`gret`m joth e drhem`r pjatur`.Lusbrjc d`gjos wjtb tb` s`rjei dhldjog hc e ould`r hc sudurdeotrejos murjog `v`ojog rusb bhur jo Luldej jo Kuiy 4>>3 e arjl`tbet wes r`ci`xjv`iy put mhwo th tb` Qtum`ots Jsielja Lhv`l`ot hcJomje (QJLJ) eom th verjhus ahoc`m`ret` dhmj`s hv`rs`es,joaiumjog tb` I`]. ]b` oerretjv` tb`o ihhfs et htb`r f`y `pjshm`sjo tb` abejo hc s`rjei dhldjogs tbet Jomje wjto`ss`m d`tw``o tb`oeom 43/55. Lusbrjc bes oh josjm` fohwi`mg`, dut tb`r` js e

    sa`ptjajsl erjs`s crhl tb` pjatur` b` ess`ldi`s tbet, jo ijgbt hcsuds`qu`ot r`v`ietjhos, s``ls elpiy w`ii-piea`m.

    ]bhugb Ferfer` mj`m ho tbet ojgbt hc aeroeg`, tb` prha`ss`s b`bem s`t jo lhtjho eaqujr`m e a`rtejo lhl`otul. Jov`stjgetjhosbev` ohw uoahv`r`m tbet tb` r`ietjv`iy ljohr t`rrhrjst joajm`othc Q`pt`ld`r 4>>2, wbjab cjrst i`m bjl th tb` Bjomutve t`rrhrrjog, wes pert hc e s`qu`oa` hc prhvhaetjv` eatjhos, eiiuom`rtef`o jo tb` `vjm`ot d`ij`c tbet tb` tru` p`rp`trethrs whuim`okhy jlpuojty jo eo `ovjrhol`ot mhljoet`m dy tb` d`ij`c tbet eiit`rrhrjsl wes o`a`sserjiy Jsielja jo hrjgjo. Mjijg`ot l`mjejov`stjgetjhos bev` eish uoahv`r`m bhw tb` prhs`autjho jo eiitb`s` aes`s, chiihw`m e s`t pett`ro, wbjab mjm oht s`rjhusiyabeii`og` tb` jot`iijg`oa` hr tb` jlegjoetjho, jo ess`ldijog wbetpurphrt`m th d` tb` `vjm`oa` egejost yhuog l`o hc tb` Lusijlcejtb pjaf`m up et reomhl. ]b` sel` QJLJ pelpbi`t eom e w`ii-tbuld`m ahpy hc tb` Jsielja sarjptur` bem e t`om`oay th turo upjo verjhus ihaetjhos. Eom eii tbhs` wbh w`r` tef`o jo ho t`rrhraberg`s sbhw`m v`ry sjljier prhaijvjtj`s th m`aiejl eogrjiy jopudija edhut tb` grj`veoa`s hc tb` Lusijl ahlluojty eom tb`jrjot`ot th s``f v`og`eoa`.51

    ]b` aes` aes` hc e Lusijl yhutb jlpijaet`m jo tb` Lei`geho diesthc 4>>3 wbh sjoa` turo`m epprhv`r, emms e curtb`r `i`l`ot hclyst`ry. Ohw et ijd`rty, tbjs jomjvjmuei bes t`stjcj`m tbet b`

    bem d``o pr`ssur`m dy tb` Leberesbtre E]Q th oel` e ould`r hchtb`r jooha`ot l`o crhl tb` ahlluojty es e prja` hc bjs cr``mhl.Es pert hc bjs whrf es eo jochrl`r, b` bem jo ceat, d``o tef`o dyhccjajeis hc tb` Leberesbtre E]Q th e l``tjog wjtb It-Ahi

    51Q`` tb` v`ry jlphrteot s`rj`s hc sjx ertjai`s dy Luzelji Kei``i uom`r tb`strep b`emijo` ]b` QJLJ Qaer` wbjab epp`er`m jo tb` M`ibj `mjtjho hc tb`

    Jomjeo @xpr`ss d`tw``o Q`pt`ld`r 40 eom Hathd`r 5 4>546 evejiedi` chr mhwoihemes hc 53 M`a`ld`r 4>54 et;bttp;//www.jomjeo`xpr`ss.ahl/cuiiahv`reg`/tb`-sjlj-saer`/=0:/.

    http://www.indianexpress.com/fullcoverage/the-simi-scare/459/http://www.indianexpress.com/fullcoverage/the-simi-scare/459/http://www.indianexpress.com/fullcoverage/the-simi-scare/459/http://www.indianexpress.com/fullcoverage/the-simi-scare/459/http://www.indianexpress.com/fullcoverage/the-simi-scare/459/http://www.indianexpress.com/fullcoverage/the-simi-scare/459/
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    10/27

    5>

    Qbrjfeot ^urhbjt, tb` ljijtery jot`iijg`oa` hccja`r sjoa`jm`otjcj`m dy Ferfer` eom err`st`m chr bjs jovhiv`l`ot jo tb`Bjomutve t`rrhr rjog.5=

    Lusbrjc puiis thg`tb`r e ould`r hc m`tejis th `stedijsb tbet tb`sthry hc Luldej 43/55 r`lejos joahlpi`t`iy thim. ]b`s` ley s``l

    ijf` p`tty qujddi`s th tbhs` wbh bev` ahlljtt`m tb`ls`iv`s th tb`hccjajei oerretjv`, dut tb`y emm up `sp`ajeiiy wb`o eugl`ot`mwjtb tb` jochrletjho evejiedi` crhl e ould`r hc htb`r shura`s th e sudsteotjv` aes`. Cjrst, eo `y`wjto`ss th tb` d`eabjog hctb` jocietedi` mjogby tbet drhugbt tb` t`rrhrjsts esbhr`, Lusbrjcphjots hut, js ho r`ahrm seyjog tbet sb` sew oh lhr` tbeo `jgbtjomjvjmueis g`ttjog hcc tb` arect. ]bjs ruos ahotrery th tb`hccjajei oerretjv` tbet tb`r` w`r` jo ceat, t`o t`rrhrjsts crhl^efjsteo wbh ael` esbhr`.50 Lusbrjcs joc`r`oa` crhl b`r` jssjlpiy tbet tb`r` w`r` eir`emy twh l`o jo Luldej et tb` tjl`, wbhaerrj`m hut e qujt` mjstjoat eg`ome uom`r tb` sbrhum]b` JomjeoOevys jot`iijg`oa` wjog, b` aiejls, bem sphtt`m tb` arect

    d`erjog i`tbei guol`o th Luldej eom bem ei`rt`m tb` JD thjlljo`ot meog`r. ]b` JD tbhugb, abhs` oht th eat sjoa` jthst`osjdiy, bem htb`r pieos.53

    Lusbrjc cjoms tb` ajraulsteoa` tbet tb` guol`o et Dhldey S]terg`t`m e ierg` ould`r hc Lusijl p`rshos, leoy hc wbhl dhr`vjsjdi` lerf`rs hc tb`jr cejtb, th d` `sp`ajeiiy suspjajhus.57]bjs reo ahotrery th l`mje r`phrts `l`rgjog hut hc Fesedspr`ijljoery jot`rrhgetjho, wb`r` b` js d`ij`v`m th bev` sejm tbetbjs ljssjho wes th fjii wjtbhut mjsarjljoetjho, dut th evhjmberljog tbhs` wbh ahuim d` jm`otjcj`m es Lusijls. Curtb`r,Lusbrjc cjoms jt cer crhl ahovjoajog tbet tb` hccjajei sthry hotb` aihs`m-ajraujt ]S ael`res josteii`m et Dhldey S], sbhuim bev`gho` tbrhugb e retb`r uosudti` abeog` jo e retb`r ijljt`m tjl`.@eriy r`phrts jomjaet`m tbet e ghhm pert hc tb` aeroeg` jo tb`Dhldey S] ahoahurs` tbrhugb wbjab ihog-mjsteoa` pess`og`rs pess,bem d``o aeptur`m jo AA]S chhteg`. Edhut e chrtojgbt ect`rwerms,tb` oerretjv` abeog`m; tb` aruajei s`aurjty `qujpl`ot, jt wes puthut, w`r` chuom th d` leicuoatjhojog tbet mey eom bem oht

    5=]b` sthry hrjgjoeiiy epp`er`m jo tb` o`wslegezjo` ]b` W``f, s``; QlhfjogGuo, ]b` W``f, pudijsb`m Ohv`ld`r 5:, 4>54, `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54crhl; bttp;//w``f.leohrelehoijo`.ahl/agj-djo/LLHoijo`.mii/phrtei/`p/tb`W``fAhot`ot.mh8ahot`otJm7.als8.50Lusbrjc, peg` 4>7.53Jdjm, peg` 523.57B` r`ahrms (peg` 5:2-:) tbet p`rshos hc tb` Lusijl cejtb w`r` 44 hut hc tb`=3 ceteijtj`s et Dhldey S]. Eaahrmjog th tb` aberg`sb``t cji`m egejost Fesedeom tef`o ho dherm dy tb` trjei ahurt, 52 hut hc e r`ahrm`m 04 m`etbs et DhldeyS] w`r` hc p`rshos wjtb jm`otjcjediy Lusijl oel`s. ]wh hc tb` aesueitj`sr`lejo`m uojm`otjcj`m et tb` tjl` hc tb` trjei.

    http://week.manoramaonline.com/cgi-%20bin/MMOnline.dll/portal/ep/theWeekContent.do?contentId=12855617&programId=1073755753&tabId=13&BV_ID=@@@&categoryId=-189461http://week.manoramaonline.com/cgi-%20bin/MMOnline.dll/portal/ep/theWeekContent.do?contentId=12855617&programId=1073755753&tabId=13&BV_ID=@@@&categoryId=-189461http://week.manoramaonline.com/cgi-%20bin/MMOnline.dll/portal/ep/theWeekContent.do?contentId=12855617&programId=1073755753&tabId=13&BV_ID=@@@&categoryId=-189461http://week.manoramaonline.com/cgi-%20bin/MMOnline.dll/portal/ep/theWeekContent.do?contentId=12855617&programId=1073755753&tabId=13&BV_ID=@@@&categoryId=-189461http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/NIA-puzzled-as-Malegaon-blast-witness-flip-flops/articleshow/17457707.cmshttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/NIA-puzzled-as-Malegaon-blast-witness-flip-flops/articleshow/17457707.cmshttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/NIA-puzzled-as-Malegaon-blast-witness-flip-flops/articleshow/17457707.cmshttp://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/NIA-puzzled-as-Malegaon-blast-witness-flip-flops/articleshow/17457707.cmshttp://week.manoramaonline.com/cgi-%20bin/MMOnline.dll/portal/ep/theWeekContent.do?contentId=12855617&programId=1073755753&tabId=13&BV_ID=@@@&categoryId=-189461http://week.manoramaonline.com/cgi-%20bin/MMOnline.dll/portal/ep/theWeekContent.do?contentId=12855617&programId=1073755753&tabId=13&BV_ID=@@@&categoryId=-189461http://week.manoramaonline.com/cgi-%20bin/MMOnline.dll/portal/ep/theWeekContent.do?contentId=12855617&programId=1073755753&tabId=13&BV_ID=@@@&categoryId=-189461
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    11/27

    55

    suaa``m`m jo r`ahrmjog luab tbet whuim d` hc jov`stjgetjv`veiu`.52

    @eriy r`phrts tbet Lusbrjc mjijg`otiy treafs mhwo, phjot th tb`shutb`ro Leberesbtre thwo hc Qetere es tb` shura` chr tb` QJLaerms us`m jo lhdji` t`i`pbho`s tbet Fesed eom Edu Jsleji

    aerrj`m. ]bjs treji hc jov`stjgetjho, ijf` luab `is` tbet aeii`mjoth qu`stjho tb` lest`r oerretjv`, shho reo mry. Eom murjog tb`sjxty bhurs hc sj`g`, tb` t`rrhrjsts wr`efjog bevha jo Luldej eomtb`jr beomi`rs jo ^efjsteo `ogeg`m jo oh c`w`r tbeo 42= t`i`pbho`aeiis tbrhugb tb` vhja` hv`r jot`ro`t prhthahi. Oht ho` hctb`s`, Lusbrjc phjots hut, jovhiv`m `jtb`r Fesed hr Edu Jsleji.Htb`r l`mje r`phrts quhtjog `y`wjto`ss`s, m`sarjd` tb` twh guol`owbh jocijat`m tb` meleg` et Dhldey S] ruoojog mhwo tb` pietchrleom mjsepp`erjog joth tb` ojgbt, retb`r tbeo es tb` hccjajeisthry sugg`sts weifjog hv`r e chht-drjmg` th arhss tb` rhem eomahotjou` tb` aeroeg` et tb` Aele Bhspjtei.5:Fesed eom Edu Jslejijo htb`r whrms, w`r` eir`emy et tb` Aele Bhspjtei et tbjs tjl`,

    `x`autjog e qujt` mjstjoat pert hc tb` pieo.

    Esjm` crhl d`jog shi` survjvhr hc tb` geog hc lereum`rs, Fesedeish haaupj`s eohtb`r uojqu` ojab`; hc tb` t`o t`rrhrjsts wbheii`g`miy ieom`m tb`jr arect ho e sleii str`tab hc d`eab jo tb`shutb hc Luldej, b` js tb` hoiy ho` th d` aeptur`m jo stjiijleg`s hc r`lerfedi` aierjty ho tb` ojgbt hc aeroeg`. ]bjs westb` eaahlpijsbl`ot hc twh pbhthkhuroeijsts crhl e o`wspep`r wjtbeo hccja` emkea`ot th Dhldey S]. Lusbrjc cjoms tbjs th d` tb` eshura` hc shl` lyst`ry. ]b` pudijsbjog hc tb` pbhthgrepb jo everj`ty hc o`ws pietchrls wjtbhut ai`er ettrjdutjho, b` sugg`sts,js e ajraulsteoa` jovjtjog suspjajho.4>Jom``m, lejoiy dy vjrtu`hc tb`s` pjatur`s, Feseds gujit wes r`germ`m sh luab hc etb`hihgjaei a`rtejoty, tbet tb` Qbjv Q`oe, e phijtjaei pertywbjab d`ij`v`s tbet jts wrjt sbhuim d` tb` iew jo Luldej, leoeg`met s`v`rei kuoatur`s th tbwert eoy phssjdjjty tbet b` ljgbt bev`ahlp`t`ot i`gei m`c`oa`.45

    52Jdjm, peg` 5:5.5:Jdjm, peg`s 5:1-3.4>Jdjm, peg` 4>0-3. ]b` ajraulsteoa`s jo wbjab tb` pjatur`s hc Fesed w`r` tef`oeom pudijsb`m bev` d``o oerret`m jo tb` Qupr`l` Ahurt v`rmjat m`eijog wjtbFeseds epp`ei. Q`destjeo MQhuze eom Qrjrel S`ro`fer, dhtb hc wbhl whrf et tb`

    ]jl`s hc Jomje dujimjog kust hpphsjt` Dhldey S], bev` d``o jm`otjcj`m es tb`pbhthgrepb`rs. MQhuze js wjm`iy ar`mjt`m wjtb tb` d`st fohwo pjatur` hc Fesed,

    strjmjog earhss tb` ahrrjmhrs hc Dhldey S] (s`` tb` ahll`otery ho tb` l`mje

    w`dsjt`, `xtreat`m 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl;bttp;//w`er`tb`d`st.whrmpr`ss.ahl/4>54/55/44/tb`-thj-i`osleo-wbh-oeji`m-eklei-feseds-cet`/). Eaahrmjog th tb` m`phsjtjho lem` d`chr` tb` Qupr`l` Ahurt es jtb`erm Feseds epp`ei, MQhuze sbht hv`r ho` buomr`m pbhthgrepbs, dut lhst hc

    tb`l w`r` diurr`m. ]bjs js d`aeus` b` wes oht usjog tb` ciesb-guo eom tb`ijgbt wes oht ghhm chr tefjog pbhthgrepbs. ]b` pjatur` hc Fesed tbet bes d``o

    wjm`iy pudijsb`m wes ho` elhog tbr`` tbet b` sbht crhl d`bjom e pjiier. (Q`` Jotb` Qupr`l` Ahurt hc Jomje, Lhbellem Eklei Lhbellem Eljr Fesed v`rsus Qtet` hcLeberesbtre, peregrepbs 544 th 51=).45]b` Qupr`l` Ahurt jo jts kumgl`ot (peregrepb 545) bem whrms hc bjgb prejs`chr tb` twh pbhthgrepb`rs; Wbji` m`eijog wjtb tb` S] aeroeg`, w` lust tef`

    http://wearethebest.wordpress.com/2012/11/22/the-toi-lensman-who-nailed-ajmal-kasabs-fate/http://wearethebest.wordpress.com/2012/11/22/the-toi-lensman-who-nailed-ajmal-kasabs-fate/http://wearethebest.wordpress.com/2012/11/22/the-toi-lensman-who-nailed-ajmal-kasabs-fate/http://wearethebest.wordpress.com/2012/11/22/the-toi-lensman-who-nailed-ajmal-kasabs-fate/http://wearethebest.wordpress.com/2012/11/22/the-toi-lensman-who-nailed-ajmal-kasabs-fate/
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    12/27

    54

    Lusbrjcs vhiul` `l`rg`m jo jts cjrst `mjtjho jo 4>>:, w`iid`chr` Feseds trjei wes ahoaium`m. Jt bes sjoa` gho` joth cjv``mjtjhos, r`pr`s`otjog oht kust e a`rtejo m`gr`` hc eumj`oa`jot`r`st, dut eish e ahotjouhus `cchrt et drjogjog joc`r`oa`sedr`est hc d`st evejiedi` ceats. Leoy hc tb` o`w r`v`ietjhos jo

    ceat, `l`rg`m ho eaahuot hc tb` mjijg`oa` hc Sjojte Felt`, wjmhwhc ho` hc tb` phija` hccja`rs fjii`m ho tb` ojgbt hc t`rrhr. Eiewy`r wjtb sp`ajeijsetjho jo iedhur lett`rs, Sjojte Felt` wesjlp`ii`m joth lefjog b`r hwo joqujrj`s edhut 43/55 dy e s`os` hcp`rshoei ihss eom dy e iewy`rs r`iuateoa` th eaa`pt jiihgjaeieom ceatueiiy jlpieusjdi` sa`oerjhs.44B`r eaahuot hc tbet ojgbtchaus`s `sp`ajeiiy ho tb` ajraulsteoa`s tbet aiejl`m tb` ijc` hcb`r busdeom Esbhf Felt`, Emmjtjhoei Ahlljssjho`r hc ^hija` chrLuldejs `est zho`. Qb` bem th jov`st e gr`et m`ei hc tjl` eom

    `o`rgy l`r`iy jo uoahv`rjog tb` desja ceats tbet sbhuim bev` d``ob`rs es e lett`r hc rjgbt. Dut et `v`ry phjot jo b`r `cchrt sb``oahuot`r`m e mhgg`m r`cusei dy tb` Luldej phija` bj`reraby th

    r`v`ei ceats edhut bhw jt bem ihst e ahosaj`otjhus eom bjgbiyr`germ`m hccja`r. Sjojte Felt`s dhhf wes pudijsb`m et erhuom tb`

    ho`-y`er eoojv`rsery lerf hc tb` Luldej etteafs. Jt js eo`lhtjhoeiiy lhvjog oerretjv`, ceatueiiy joveiuedi` jo jtspr`s`otetjho hc tb` wjr`i`ss r`ahrm hc l`sseg`s `xabeog`m es shl`hc Luldejs thp phija` hccjajeis shugbt th m`ei wjtb e abeii`og`

    tbet mrhpp`m ho tb`l, wjtb o`jtb`r eoy werojog ohr eoy bhw thjochrletjho d`jog evejiedi` crhl tb`jr trejojog leoueis.

    Es E]Q abj`c, Ferfer` wes elhog tb` cjrst th `ogeg` tb` erl`mm`sp`remh`s es tb`y d`geo th aut e m`struatjv` swetb` tbrhugbLuldej. B` wes fjii`m jo tb` o`er vjajojty hc Dhldey S], shhoect`r tb` erl`m rejm`rs bem uoi`esb`m e i`tbei sthrl hc duii`tsho tb` ahllut`r arhwm tefjog trejos bhl` ect`r e meys berm whrfeom tb`o ruo relpeg` tbrhugb tb` ihog-mjsteoa` trejo t`rljoei.Ferfer` wes fjii`m jo eo eldusb jo wbjab Felt` eom Qeiesfer -- eojosp`athr b`im jo ew` chr bjs chrljmedi` w`ephos `xp`rtjs` eombjs r`ahrm jo sullerjiy `ijljoetjog arjljoei susp`ats jo sh-aeii`m `oahuot`rs eish p`rjsb`m, eihogsjm` e ould`r hcahii`egu`s crhl tb` phija` chra`.

    ]b` tbr`` hccja`rs er` thmey r`l`ld`r`m chr tb`jr st`rijog s`os`hc muty jo ahocrhotjog t`rrhrjst etteaf`rs wbhs` jot`ot wessbrhum`m jo lyst`ry. Eaahrmjog th tb` prhs`autjho aes` wbjab i`m

    oht` hc twh wjto`ss`s. ]b`jr `vjm`oa` js `xtrehrmjoery jo tbet tb`y oht hoiywjto`ss`m tb` joajm`ot dut eish lem` e vjsuei r`ahrm hc tb` `v`ot dy tefjogpjatur`s hc tb` twh fjii`rs jo eatjho eom tb`jr vjatjls Dhtb tb` wjto`ss`s,aerjog ijtti` chr tb`jr hwo sec`ty eom mjspieyjog `x`lpiery prhc`ssjhoeijsl,chiihw`m tb` fjii`rs. Jt wes rer`, ahosjm`rjog tb` pr`-m`t`rljo`m abereat`r hcFeseds gujit, th cjom eoy leoo`r hc l`mje eoeiysjshc tb` oul`rhus prha`mureijocjrljtj`s jo bjs trjei. Eo `xa`ptjho js S. S`ofet`seo, Geps jo Fesed aes`,

    Crhotijo`, Ohv`ld`r 53 4>54, `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl;bttp;//www.crhotijo`.jo/ci4:44/sthrj`s/4>5455534:44>17>>.btl.44Sjojte Felt` wjtb Sjojte M`sblufb, ]h ]b` Iest Duii`t, ]b` Jospjrjog Qthry hcDrev`b`ert Esbhf Felt`, El`ye ^refesbeo, ^uo`, Ohv`ld`r 4>>:.

    http://www.frontline.in/fl2922/stories/20121116292203700.htmhttp://www.frontline.in/fl2922/stories/20121116292203700.htmhttp://www.frontline.in/fl2922/stories/20121116292203700.htm
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    13/27

    51

    th Feseds ahovjatjho, tb` t`rrhrjsts d`geo tb`jr less lurm`r etverjhus sphts jo Luldej Dhldey S] eom tb` I`hphim Aec` joAhiede d`tw``o 45;50 eom 45;1> bhurs tbet ojgbt. Ferfer`, Felt`eom Qeiesfer ahov`rg`m et Dhldey S] et mjcc`r`ot tjl`s, dut ect`rtb` twh (hr lhr`) m`sp`remh`s bem ci`m tb` v`ou`. ]b` tbr``phija`l`o tb`o chiihw`m tb` treji th tb` pr`ljs`s hc tb` o`erdy

    Aele Bhspjtei.

    Et ho` phjot, e phija` v`bjai`, m`sarjd`m jo prhs`autjhomhaul`ots es e Uueijs d`ihogjog th EA^ ^ymbhoj` hr, jo piejoieogueg`, e v`bjai` hc ]hyhte lef` essjgo`m th tb` EssjsteotAhlljssjho`r hc ^hija` jo tb` ^ymbhoj` mjvjsjho hc Luldej ajty --mrhv` up th tb` v`ou` hc tb` leyb`l. Es tb` prhs`autjho aes` tb`ostet`s, tb` tbr`` hccja`rs thhf hv`r tb` v`bjai` Qeiesfer ettb` wb``i, Felt` d`sjm` bjl eom Ferfer` jo tb` rhw d`bjom. Jo tb`r`er hc tb` v`bjai`, ohrleiiy ahocjgur`m wjtb tbr`` rhws hcs`ets, w`r` Keyweot ^etji, Zhg`sb ^etji eom Deieseb`d Dbhsei`. Echurtb ahostedi`, Eruo Kembev, Qeiesfers sudhrmjoet` jo tb`

    Eotj-@xthrtjho Wjog hc tb` Luldej phija`, wbh bem errjv`m et tb`sjt` r`sphomjog th sup`rjhr hrm`rs, eish thhf bjs piea` jo tb`r`er rhw. ]b` jm`e hst`osjdiy wes th mrjv` tbrhugb tb` TeogdbeveoIeo` (hccjajeiiy fohwo es tb` Demrummjo ]yedkj Lerg), wbjabahoo`at`m twh lekhr tbhrhugbcer`s jo tb` er`e eom `ot`r tb`bhspjtei tbet wes tb`o jo tb` grjp hc t`rrhr, tbrhugb tb` crhotget`. ]b` phija` t`el wes cjr`m upho eom r`turo`m cjr` es jtmrhv` tbrhugb Teogdbeveo Ieo`. Ho` elhog tb` `y`wjto`ss eaahuotssp`efs hc e b`cty leo jo e phija` uojchrlst`ppjog hut hc tb`crhot i`ct s`et hc tb` Uueijs eom cjrjog et tb` etteaf`rs, d`chr`e m`etbiy sji`oa` c`ii.41@v`rydhmy jo tb` v`bjai` bem d``o bjttbhugb p`rbeps oht jll`mjet`iy fjii`m. Hoiy Kembev ijv`m th t`iitb` tei`.

    Wbet Kembev bes sejm jo tb` ahurtrhhl teiij`s wjtb tb` eaahuotr`om`r`m dy ho` htb`r `y`wjto`ss.4= ]b` der` m`tejis eish letabFeseds eaahuot, wbjab hc ahurs` wes r`om`r`m crhl e retb`rmjcc`r`ot p`rsp`atjv`. Joaepeajtet`m dy tb` guocjr` eom arelp`mchr spea` dy tb` tbr`` jokur`m phija`l`o wbh bem ahiieps`m erhuombjl, Kembev wes uoedi` th r`eab chr bjs rjci` th `ogeg` tb`t`rrhrjsts eoy curtb`r. ^ieyjog m`em wes bjs hoiy r`ahurs`. Es b`iey jo wbet wes uomhudt`miy e stet` hc m``p treule jo tb` r`ers`et, jo aihs` prhxjljty wjtb tbr`` jo`rt dhmj`s, b` s`os`m tb`twh t`rrhrjsts tryjog th hp`o tb` r`er mhhr hc tb` v`bjai`.Cejijog jo tbet `cchrt sjoa` tb` mhhrs bem kell`m ect`r edshrdjog

    e s`v`r` vhii`y hc duii`ts, tb`y hp`o`m tb` crhot mhhr eom puii`mhut tb` dhmj`s hc tb` tbr`` s`ojhr phija`l`o. ]b` teii`r elhogtb` twh tb`o thhf tb` wb``i, wbji` tb` htb`r, hc lerf`miy sbhrt`r

    41Sjojte Felt`, peg` 0>. B`cty leo jo e phija` uojchrl js e m`sarjptjho tbetletab`s Esbhf Felt`.4=]b` cjrst l`mje r`phrts ajtjog Eruo Kembevs t`stjlhoy crhl tbet ojgbt w`r`eish ahosjst`ot wjtb wbet iet`r d`ael` tb` prhs`autjho aes`. Q`` ]b`y ]br`w

    Qeiesfer, Felt` eom Ferfer`s Dhmj`s crhl tb` S`bjai`, ]b` Jomjeo @xpr`ss,M`ibj, Ohv`ld`r 1>, 4>>2, peg` 7.

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    14/27

    5=

    stetur`, thhf tb` s`et d`sjm`. ]b` twh tb`o mrhv` thwerms Oerjleo^hjot, dut tb`jr v`bjai` bem d``o meleg`m eom jom``m, ho` hc tb`tyr`s bem d``o puoatur`m jo tb` `xabeog` hc guocjr`. T`eijsjogtb`y ahuim oht g`t cer, tb` t`rrhrjsts sthpp`m jo tb` vjajojty hcOerjleo ^hjot, eom wev`m mhwo e pessjog aer tbet wes ho jts weyth pjaf up shl`dhmy wbh bem prhvjm`otjeiiy `saep`m tb` lessear`

    jo tb` Hd`rhj ]rjm`ot bht`i. Kembev r`gjst`r`m tb` lef` hc tb`aer jo bjs ljoms `y` es e Bhome Eaahrm, dut suds`qu`ot phija`

    eatjho, wbjab i`m th tb` s`jzur` hc tb` aer, `stedijsb`m tbet jtwes e Qfhme.

    Fesed bes tb`o r`ahuot`m tbet bjs ahlpeojho wbh egejo thhf tb`wb``i , mrhv` thwerms Lerjo` Mrjv` wjtb tb` jot`otjho hc cjoeiiyerrjvjog et Leieder Bjii. ]bjs js ho` hc Luldejs lhst sthrj`mo`jgbdhurbhhms, wb`r` luab hc jts w`eitb r`sjm`s, dut Fesed ettbjs phjot wes uoai`er edhut tb` m``p`r jot`ot. ]b` pr`ajs`ihaetjho tb`y w`r` mrjvjog thwerms, wes th d` r`v`ei`m hoiy ect`rtb`y errjv`m jo tb` o`jgbdhurbhhm.

    Ei`rt`m dy ohw, phija` p`rshoo`i crhl verjhus ihaetjhos bemahov`rg`m et e c`w f`y phjots eom s`t up prht`atjv` derrjaem`s.Elhog tb`s` phjots wes Gjrgeho Abhwpetty, kust erhuom tb` beicweyphjot hc tb` jot`om`m trev`rs` hc tb` twh t`rrhrjsts. Chra`m thsthp dy tb` chrljmedi` mhudi` derrjaem` tb`y cea`m, tb` twhlereum`rs `l`rg`m, ho` hc tb`l cihppjog mhwo ho tb` rhem joc`jgo`m b`ipi`sso`ss, wbji` tb` htb`r, wbh ael` hut hc tb`mrjv`rs s`et, d`geo cjrjog et tb` ess`ldi`m phija` ahotjog`ot.]bhugb hoiy erl`m wjtb s`rvja` r`vhiv`rs eom w`ephos tbet w`r` ohletab chr tb` cjr`phw`r hc tb` EF =7 tb`y cea`m, tb` phija`ahotjog`ot leoeg`m th `ijljoet` tb` lhr` eggr`ssjv` elhog tb`muh, iet`r jm`otjcj`m es Edu Jsleji. Es Essjsteot Qud-Josp`athr]uferel Hldei` d`geo epprheabjog tb` prho` cjgur` hc tb` htb`rt`rrhrjst, jt summ`oiy spreog joth eatjho, sp`wjog m`emiy guocjr`et bjl. ]bhugb s`rjhusiy eom es jt turo`m hut, ceteiiy jokur`m, Hldei` c`ii upho bjs essejieot, eiihwjog ahii`egu`ssuccjaj`ot tjl` th ahl` joth tb` eatjho. Fesed, chr tbet wes tb`jm`otjty hc tb` t`rrhrjst wbh bem piey`m m`em et Abhwpetty, weshv`rphw`r`m jo qujaf tjl` eom tbus mjm b` `om up ho e bhspjteid`m, crhl wb`r` b` r`ahuot`m hv`r tb` o`xt c`w meys, tb` shrmjmahospjreay tbet i`m th Luldejs sjxtybhur hrm`ei hc t`rrhr.

    Eruo Kembev bes d``o e f`y wjto`ss chr tb` prhs`autjho, es thhbev` d``o tb` hwo`r eom htb`r haaupeots hc tb` aer tbet Fesed eom

    Jsleji supphs`miy bjkeaf`m et Oerjleo ^hjot. Kembev ley bev` etho` phjot emm`m eo uos``liy `ld`iijsbl`ot th bjs eaahuot, chrwbjab tb` trjei ahurt c`it ahlp`ii`m th emlhojsb bjl. Kembevst`stjlhoy jomjaet`m tbet murjog tb`jr mrjv` crhl Aele Bhspjtei thOerjleo ^hjot, tb` t`rrhrjsts wbh bem ahlleom``r`m tb` phija`v`bjai`, bem cjr`m dursts hc guocjr` et reomhl. ]bjs wes eohdvjhus uotrutb, tb` trjei ahurt hds`rv`m, tbhugb ho` tbet mjmoht joveijmet` tb` r`st hc Kembevs t`stjlhoy. ]b` phija`leo jotb` kumgl`ot hc tb` ahurt ahuim d` chrgjv`o chr tbjs s``ljog

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    15/27

    50

    `cchrt th s`osetjhoeijs` bjs treule tbet mey chr tb` d`o`cjt hco`ws abeoo`is jo s`erab hc s`osetjho `v`o et tb` ahst hcv`reajty.40

    ]b` ahurts m`t`rljoetjho esjm`, jt js e ceat tbet tb`r` wes e

    mrjv` dy sbhhtjog jo tb` vjajojty hc Dhldey S] tb` ojgbt hc

    43/55. ]bet joajm`ot, aeptur`m jo diurr`m jleg`s dy e ]S o`wsar`w es aurjhus hoihhf`rs saett`r`m jo peoja, bes oht d``oeaauret`iy piea`m wjtbjo tb` meys `v`ots.

    Eohtb`r f`y wjto`ss chr tb` prhs`autjho wbh piey`m m`em hoiy thijv` th t`ii tb` tei`, wes Lerutj ^bem, mrjv`r chr e s`ojhr ajvjis`rveot, aeii`m th muty et tb` iet` bhur ect`r eo urg`ot l``tjogwes sullho`m et tb` Leberesbtre stet` ghv`rol`ot s`ar`terjet.^bem, wbh ijv`m jo tb` vjajojty hc Dhldey S], stert`m bjs aer eomthhf tb` Teogdbeveo Ieo` th g`t th bjs sup`rjhr hccjajeis

    r`sjm`oa`, dut wes ahocrhot`m wjtb e wjtb`rjog beji hc guocjr`.Jokur`m jo bjs beom eom ihw`r edmhl`o, b` ihaf`m tb` aer crhl

    wjtbjo eom piey`m m`em. ]b` guol`o tb`o lem` eo `cchrt thahlleom``r tb` aer dut gev` up ho cjomjog jt ihaf`m eom r`tr`et`mjoth tb` dusb`s crjogjog Teogdbeveo Ieo`. ^bem ght e ai`er vj`whc tb` twh tbrhugb bjs wjomsbj`im eom wjto`ss`m tb` `xabeog` hccjr` tbet chiihw`m sbhrtiy ect`rwerms wjtb e phija` aer,`stedijsb`m dy t`lphrei ahrr`sphom`oa` th bev` d``o tb` v`bjai`aerryjog Ferfer`, Felt` eom Qeiesfer.

    Lekhr o`wspep`rs ho M`a`ld`r 5, bem pjatur`s hc Fesed jo bjsbhspjtei d`m. T`phrts jo tb` pr`ss et tb` tjl` hcc`r`m er`ahostruatjho hc tb` `otjr` hp`retjho, crhl tb` phjot hc`lderfetjho jo Fereabj th tb` rejm`rs ieomjog ho e sleii str`tabhc d`eab emkhjojog Dembwer ^erf o`er Luldejs Ahiedeo`jgbdhurbhhm. Feseds ahoc`ssjho crhl bjs bhspjtei d`m prhvjm`mveiuedi` aiu`s chr tb` s`erab hp`retjho eir`emy ieuoab`m dy tb`Jomjeo Oevy eom Ahest Guerm, wbjab sbhrtiy ect`rwerms drhugbt thsbhr` tb` L.S. Fud`r, e cjsbjog dhet r`gjst`r`m jo Gukeret, jowbjab tb` t`rrhrjsts bem ahlpi`t`m e aruajei str`tab hc tb`jrkhuro`y. Q`jz`m ho tb` bjgb s`es, tb` Fud`r stjii bem ho dhermtb` m`aepjtet`m dhmy hc tb` bepi`ss ar`w l`ld`r m`sjgoet`m thst``r tb` t`rrhrjsts th tb`jr m`stjoetjho eom druteiiy mjsphs`mhc, hoa` b` bem s`rv`m bjs purphs`. E b`emi`ss dhmy wes eishr`ahv`r`m jo tb` hp`o s`e eom jm`otjcj`m es tb` r`lejos hceohtb`r Fud`r ar`w l`ld`r, fjii`m et tb` lhl`ot tb` dhet wess`jz`m. Htb`rs elhog tb` cjv`-l`ld`r ar`w tbet `lderf`m crhl

    ^hrdeomer phrt ho Ohv`ld`r 5= chr wbet wes e rhutjo` cjsbjog`xp`mjtjho, bev` oht d``o trea`m.

    Ahurt prha``mjogs jomjaet` tbet tb` Fud`r wes drhugbt esbhr` eomr`ahrm`m es `vjm`oa` jo tb` arjljoei prhs`autjho iet` ho tb`ojgbt hc 47 Ohv`ld`r. ]b`peoabeoele-- hr wjto`ss t`stjlhoy tbet

    40Jo tb` Ahurt hc Q`ssjhos chr Gr`et`r Luldej, ]b` Qtet` hc Leberesbtre v`rsusLhbellem Eklei Lhbellem Eljr Fesed eom htb`rs, peg` 552: (peregrepb ::4).

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    16/27

    53

    ett`sts th tb` tb` eaaureay hc tb` hccjajei r`ahrm ho tb` `v`ot -- wes sjgo`m dy Abeomrefeot Kembev, e Qud-Josp`athr jo Luldej^hija`, wbh wes ho muty et bjs phst tbrhugb tb` ojgbt hc 43Ohv`ld`r eom d`yhom. Et 5>;1> ho tb` lhrojog hc 47 Ohv`ld`r, b`wes sullho`m th Luldejs Oejr Bhspjtei th r`ahrm tb` ahoc`ssjhoei

    stet`l`ot hc tb` iho` t`rrhrjst s`jz`m eijv`. Iet` tbet `v`ojog,

    b` wes aeii`m th Luldejs Qesshho Mhafs th hccjajeiiy sjgo tb`peoabeoeleho tb` s`jzur` hc tb` L.S. Fud`r. Mhudti`ss uom`r tb`pr`ssur` hc tb` whrfihem b` bem d``o esf`m th uom`rtef`,Abeomrefeot Kembev lem` tb` `rrhr hc r`ahrmjog tb` met` es 47Ohv`ld`r, wb`o tb` eatuei mhaul`otetjho hc tb` `vjm`oa` ho dhermtb` Fud`r, wes hoiy ahlpi`t`m tb` chiihwjog mey.

    ]b`s` m`tejis `l`rg`m crhl Feseds trjei jo tb` Luldej Q`ssjhosAhurt eom bev` d``o r`eccjrl`m es r`ijedi` cjomjogs hc ceat dytb` Dhldey Bjgb Ahurt eom tb` Qupr`l` Ahurt. Wbji` tb` trjeiprha`ss wes uom`rwey, htb`r m`v`ihpl`ots, mrjv`o jo pertjauier dytb` l`mje, s``l`m th aeus` e c`w mjsshoeoa`s jo tb` tb`hihgjaei

    oerretjv` hc gujit eom puojsbl`ot tbet bem `ov`ihp`m pudijap`ra`ptjhos hc 43/55. Ho 4: Kuo` 4>>:, Abeoo`i = jo Drjtejodrhemaest eo bhur-ihog mhaul`otery tjti`m ]`rrhr jo Luldej,wjtb `xt`osjv` chhteg` crhl tb` jot`rrhgetjho hc Fesed jo bjsbhspjtei d`m eom r`ahrmjogs hc pbho` ahov`rsetjhos d`tw``o tb`t`rrhrjst rejm`rs et tbr`` htb`r sphts jo Luldej eom tb`jrbeomi`rs. Aihs`-ajraujt ]S ael`res et tb` ]ek Lebei eom Hd`rhj]rjm`ot bht`is bem r`ahrm`m aruajei steg`s hc tb` uochimjogtedi`eu hc m`struatjho, r`v`eijog jo shl` perts tb` ahhim`ijd`retjho hc tb` erl`m jotrum`rs, tb`jr r`lhrs`i`ss jot`ot eomhaaesjhoei s`os` hc ew` et tb` hpui`oa` hc tb` ljij`u tb`y w`r`wr`efjog bevha wjtbjo.

    Jomjes hccjajei jov`stjgetjho wes tbrhwo joth m``p ahocusjho,dut sper`m s`rjhus `lderressl`ot dy tb` s``ljog ahlpijajty hc tb`l`mje jo f``pjog tb`s` vjtei djts hc jochrletjho hutsjm` tb`pudija mjeihgu`. Oh ai`er `xpieoetjho `xjsts chr tbjsjomjcc`r`oa` thwerms e mhaul`otery tbet iejm hut jo rutbi`ssm`teji bhw tbhs` meys hc t`rrhr uochim`m htb`r p`rbeps tbeo tb`s`ic-`vjm`ot ho`, tbet tb` Jomjeo o`ws abeoo`is w`r` jo ahlpi`t`m`ojei edhut tb` lhrei eom let`rjei sust`oeoa` tb`y bem phssjdiyr`om`r`m tb` t`rrhrjsts, wjtb tb`jr hv`r-b`et`m, dr`etbi`ss eomceatueiiy abeii`og`m ahv`reg`.43E Luldej-des`m tedihjm, elhog tb`c`w o`wspep`rs th tef` oht` hc tb` mhaul`otery, r`phrt`m tbet jtbem i`ct tb` phija` r`m-cea`m. Eo uooel`m s`ojhr hccja`r hc tb`

    Luldej phija`, ho ahomjtjho hc eohoyljty, thim tb` o`wspep`rtbet Abeoo`i = wes jo dr`eab hc e v`rdei uom`rsteomjog tbet tb`

    chhteg` whuim d` ejr`m hoiy ect`r Uesed's (sja) trjei wes hv`r.

    43]b` Qupr`l` Ahurt, jo mjsphsjog hc Fesedsepp`ei, r`s`rv`m e c`w abhja`whrms hc a`osur` chr tb` l`mje chr pr`ajs`iy tbjs. Q`` Jo tb` Qupr`l` Ahurt hcJomje, Lhbellem Eklei Lhbellem Eljr Fesed v`rsus Qtet` hc Leberesbtre,peregrepbs =>4-7.

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    17/27

    57

    ^rhmua`r Meo T``m m`oj`m eoy egr``l`ot v`rdei hr htb`rwjs` hv`rtb` us` hc tb` chhteg` jo bjs mhaul`otery; ]bjs let`rjei wes ohtr`i`es`m th us dy tb` Luldej phija`. Ly mhaul`otery bes d``osar``o`m jo tb` PF hoiy. Abeoo`i = w`dsjt`s aerryjog tb` let`rjeier` oht eaa`ssjdi` crhl Jomje. Jo htb`r whrms, tb` lejo whrry hc

    tb` Luldej phija` tbet tb` t`i`aest hc tb` mhaul`otery whuim

    pr`kumja` trjei prha``mjogs egejost Fesed wes wjtbhutsudsteoa`.47]b` Luldej phija` bhw`v`r, er` y`t th ahl` up wjtb ear`mjdi` `xpieoetjho hc bhw tb` `otjr` vjm`h mhaul`otetjho hc43/55 wes lem` evejiedi` th e Drjtjsb ]S abeoo`i, wb`o lhst hcJomje bem oh ai`er uom`rsteomjog, esjm` crhl tb` tb`hihgjaeir`omjtjho prhvjm`m jo tb` `eriy bhurs hc tb` etrhajty.

    Ajtjz`os jo Jomje whuim bev` eohtb`r r`esho th whrry et tb`m`ojei hc jochrletjho, joaiumjog tb` cjrst ahoc`ssjhoei stet`l`otcrhl tb` shijtery survjvhr. ]b`r` js e yhuog dhy, Ecrhz Eoserj,oht lhr` tbeo tw`iv` y`ers him, wbh epp`ers jo tb` Abeoo`i =mhaul`otery jo jts `eriy ljout`s, esfjog wbet tb` guol`o ahuim

    phssjdiy gejo crhl tb` sieyjog hc dhtb bjs per`ots, sjst`r eomtbr`` htb`rs elhog bjs jll`mjet` celjiy. ]b`r` js Dberet Oevemjewbh wes bjt ho tb` sbhuim`r jo tbet jojtjei fjiijog spr`` eom sewbjs wjc` ceiijog, wbji` bjs yhuog abjimr`o, uoedi` th uom`rsteomtb`jr lhtb`rs ahiieps` jo eo jo`rt b`ep, bugg`m b`r aihs` wjtb

    t`ers str`eljog mhwo tb`jr cea`s. Eom tb`o tb`r` js Sjojte Felt`,wbh wes oht c`etur`m jo tb` mhaul`otery dut bes `l`rg`m es elekhr sphf`sp`rsho chr tb` pudija rjgbt th fohw tb` cuii sthry,wbh chugbt e ihog detti` th mjsp`i tb` sbrhum hc tb`hihgjaeia`rtejoty hv`r 43/55, eom lhtjvet`m Fevjte Ferfer`, eohtb`rp`rsho wjtb e m``p s`os` hc ihss, th esf tb` qu`stjhos tbet whuimdrjog tb` hccjajei oerretjv` th e arjsjs hc ar`mjdjijty.42

    Dy Keouery 4>>:, Sjojte Felt` bem `xbeust`m eii bhp` hc gejojogar`mjdi` eosw`rs th tb` qu`stjhos tbet ael` arhwmjog joth b`rljom. Ho Keouery 55, ]b` Bjomu aerrj`m eo eaahuot hc b`rmjsepphjotl`ot tbet tb` Leberesbtre phija` -- wbjab sb`ahosjm`r`m pert hc b`r hwo `xt`om`m celjiy -- wes d`jogahlpi`t`iy joett`otjv` th b`r o``m th fohw.4: Sjojte Felt` wes`sp`ajeiiy hcc`om`m tbet b`r perto`rs m`etb wes d`jog put mhwo

    47]`rrhr jo Luldej js @y`-Hp`o`r chr ^hija`, LjmMey,Kuiy 51, 4>>:, evejiedi`es hc 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 uom`r tb` dyijo` Eijsbe Ah`ibh, et; bttp;//www.ljm-mey.ahl/o`ws/4>>:/kui/51>7>:-Luldej-t`rrhr-etteaf-Luldej-phija`-Eklei-Eljr-Uesed-ahoc`ssjho-43-55-Meo-T``m.btl.42Ferfer`s wjmhw jom``m chuom crhl b`r joqujrj`s, tbet tb` duii`t-prhhc keaf`t

    whro dy tb` E]Q abj`c es b` w`ot joth bjs erl`m `ogeg`l`ot wjtb tb` t`rrhrjsts,bem d``o ihst sbhrtiy ect`rwerms. Quspjajhos w`r` oetureiiy erhus`m hv`r ephssjdi` jot`ot th bjm` shl` melegjog jochrletjho. Eo hccjajei joqujry dy tb`Leberesbtre phija`, ahoaium`m dy ljm-4>5>, `stedijsb`m tbet tbjs wes sb``ro`gijg`oa`, retb`r tbeo jot`ot. ]b` o`ws eg`oaj`s r`phrt`m tbjs cjomjog ho Kuo`55 4>5>. Q`` e v`rsjho hc tb` sthry et tbjs ijof, `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54crhl; bttp;//www.jomjeo`xpr`ss.ahl/o`ws/Ferfer`--s-duii`t-prhhc-v`st-ljspiea`m-jo-bhspjtei--^hija`/314353.4:Ly Busdeom Mj`m e B`rhs M`etb; Sjojte Felt`, ]b` Bjomu, Keouery 55, 4>>:,p :; `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl;bttp;//www.bjomu.ahl/4>>:/>5/55/sthrj`s/4>>:>5553>=1>:>>.btl.

    http://www.mid-day.com/news/2009/jul/130709-Mumbai-terror-attack-Mumbai-police-Ajmal-Amir-Qasab-confession-26-11-Dan-Reed.htmhttp://www.mid-day.com/news/2009/jul/130709-Mumbai-terror-attack-Mumbai-police-Ajmal-Amir-Qasab-confession-26-11-Dan-Reed.htmhttp://www.mid-day.com/news/2009/jul/130709-Mumbai-terror-attack-Mumbai-police-Ajmal-Amir-Qasab-confession-26-11-Dan-Reed.htmhttp://www.mid-day.com/news/2009/jul/130709-Mumbai-terror-attack-Mumbai-police-Ajmal-Amir-Qasab-confession-26-11-Dan-Reed.htmhttp://www.indianexpress.com/news/Karkare--s-bullet-proof-vest-misplaced-in-hospital--Police/632616http://www.indianexpress.com/news/Karkare--s-bullet-proof-vest-misplaced-in-hospital--Police/632616http://www.hindu.com/2009/01/11/stories/2009011160430900.htmhttp://www.hindu.com/2009/01/11/stories/2009011160430900.htmhttp://www.hindu.com/2009/01/11/stories/2009011160430900.htmhttp://www.indianexpress.com/news/Karkare--s-bullet-proof-vest-misplaced-in-hospital--Police/632616http://www.indianexpress.com/news/Karkare--s-bullet-proof-vest-misplaced-in-hospital--Police/632616http://www.mid-day.com/news/2009/jul/130709-Mumbai-terror-attack-Mumbai-police-Ajmal-Amir-Qasab-confession-26-11-Dan-Reed.htmhttp://www.mid-day.com/news/2009/jul/130709-Mumbai-terror-attack-Mumbai-police-Ajmal-Amir-Qasab-confession-26-11-Dan-Reed.htmhttp://www.mid-day.com/news/2009/jul/130709-Mumbai-terror-attack-Mumbai-police-Ajmal-Amir-Qasab-confession-26-11-Dan-Reed.htm
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    18/27

    52

    th jlp`tuhsjty eom e t`om`oay th rusb jo th sjtuetjhos wjtbhut eoess`ssl`ot hc tb` rjsfs jovhiv`m. B`r joqujrj`s, joaiumjogjot`rvj`ws wjtb `y`wjto`ss`s th tb` Teogdbeveo Ieo` `oahuot`r,bem ahovjoa`m b`r tbet Esbhf Felt` bem gho` jo wjtb cuiifohwi`mg` hc wbet b` wes g`ttjog joth. Bjs w`ephos `xp`rtjs` joceat, bem d``o jostrul`otei jo joaepeajtetjog ho` hc tb`

    t`rrhrjsts tb`o bhimjog Aele bhspjtei bhsteg`. B` bem lem` equjaf ess`ssl`ot chiihwjog tbjs cjrst `xabeog` hc cjr` eom sphf`ohut eihum edhut tb` o``m th drjog tb` erly jo. Sjojte Felt` wesahovjoa`m tbet tb` r`sphos` hc tb` phija` chra` tb`o bem d``ojoem`quet`. Qb` bem r`esho th d`ij`v` tbet tb`r` w`r` leoy aeiis

    lem` th tb` (phija`) ahotrhi rhhl dy p`hpi` o`er tb` Aelebhspjtei wbh sew tb` twh t`rrhrjsts. Eom y`t, sb` mjsahv`r`m,

    tb`r` w`r` oh jostruatjhos r`iey`m th Ferfer`, Felt` eomQeiesfer, tbet mrjvjog joth Teogdbeveo Ieo` ahuim put tb`l etrjsf hc e vjajhus eldusb.

    Sjojte Felt` wes m``piy trhudi`m edhut tb` ajraulsteoa`s jo wbjab

    Esbhf wes sullho`m hut hc bjs mjsteot kurjsmjatjho thwerms evjrtuei detti` zho`, wb`o tb` hccja`rs wjtb mjr`at r`sphosjdjijtyw`r` oht v`ry luab jo `vjm`oa`. B`r hwo t`i`pbho` aeiis th Esbhfes b` s`t hut crhl bjs mjsteot Ab`ldur r`sjm`oa`, r`v`ei`m tbetbjs m`stjoetjho wes tb` Hd`rhj ]rjm`ot jo Oerjleo ^hjot, wb`r`Luldejs ^hija` Ahlljssjho`r, Beseo Gbechhr bem mjr`at`m bjl. Etshl` phjot, Esbhf Felt` wbh bem peaf`m bjs EF =7 w`epho es b` s`thut, wes hrm`r`m hcc tbet ahurs` eom sbjct`m hdvjhusiy dy eohccja`r jo tb` bjgb`r abejo hc ahlleom -- thwerms Dhldey S]. Eomtb`o chiihw`m tb` `v`ots tbet Eruo Kembev oerret`m crhl tb`bhspjtei d`m wb`r` b` wes ahocjo`m shho ect`r tb` `v`ots.1>

    Sjojte Felt`s joqujrj`s uorev`ii`m lhr` lystjcyjog m`tejis edhuttb` `v`ots hc 43/55. B`r r`qu`st th d` gjv`o Esbhfs euthpsyr`phrt wes tbwert`m eom grumgjogiy greot`m ect`r gr`et `cchrt hob`r pert. Eom wjtb eii tb` ahoo`atjhos sb` bem wjtbjo tb` J^Qaemr`, eiweys phrtrey`m es e celjiy uojt`m jo ahllho `om`evhur,sb` o`v`r ahuim cjom e setjsceathry `xpieoetjho hc tb` s`qu`oa`hc m`ajsjhos crhl bjgb`r jo tb` abejo hc ahlleom, wbjab drhugbtEsbhf th tb` Dhldey S] er`e. Eo jot`rvj`w wjtb ahlljssjho`r BeseoGbechhr r`v`ei`m tbet Esbhfs errjvei eom tb` cjrst dursts b` bemcjr`m crhl bjs EF =7 bem p`rbeps ahovjoa`m tb` t`rrhrjsts tb`obhimjog Aele bhspjtei, tbet tb`y cea`m e s`rjhus abeii`og`,chrajog tb`l th ci`` tb` sa`o`. Dut d`yhom tbjs ahoa`ssjho tbetEsbhfs jot`rv`otjho wes jo shl` l`esur`, aruajei, phija`

    ahlljssjho`r Gbechhr epp`er`m uowjiijog th gh joth tb` m`tejis.

    E l``tjog chiihw`m wjtb Tef`sb Lerje, tb`o khjot ahlljssjho`r hcLuldej phija` eom e f`y cjgur` jo tb` r`sphos` th tb` t`rrhrjst

    1>]b`y ]br`w Qeiesfer, Felt` eom Ferfer`s Dhmj`s crhl tb` S`bjai`; Qhi`Qurvjvhr hc tb` guodetti` wbjab aiejl`m E]Q abj`c eom t`el r`l`ld`rs tb``oahuot`r crhl bjs bhspjtei d`m, ]b` Jomjeo @xpr`ss, M`ibj, Ohv`ld`r 1> 4>>2,peg` 76 `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl; bttp;//www.jomjeo`xpr`ss.ahl/o`ws/-tb`y-tbr`w-seiesfer-felt`-eom-ferfer`-s-dhmj`s-crhl-tb`-v`bjai`-/1:4113.

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/-they-threw-salaskar-kamte-and-karkare-s-bodies-from-the-vehicle-/392336http://www.indianexpress.com/news/-they-threw-salaskar-kamte-and-karkare-s-bodies-from-the-vehicle-/392336http://www.indianexpress.com/news/-they-threw-salaskar-kamte-and-karkare-s-bodies-from-the-vehicle-/392336http://www.indianexpress.com/news/-they-threw-salaskar-kamte-and-karkare-s-bodies-from-the-vehicle-/392336
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    19/27

    5:

    esseuit. ]efjog aberg` hc tb` phija` ahotrhi rhhl shho ect`r tb`sbhhtjog d`geo, Lerje bem mjr`at`m tb` m`pihyl`ot hc l`o eomlet`rjei tbrhugb verjhus ohm`s hc tb` ajty wb`r` tb` lhst s`rjhustbr`ets w`r` eotjajpet`m. Lerje prhv`m e r`iuateot sp`ef`r esSjojte Felt` jot`rvj`w`m bjl, esfjog rjgbt et tb` d`gjoojog wbetsb` `xp`at`m. ]h e phjot`m qu`stjho edhut bhw Esbhf bem `om`m up

    jo tb` Dhldey S] er`e wb`o b` wes uom`r hrm`rs crhl ahlljssjho`rGbechhr th mrjv` thwerms Oerjleo ^hjot, Lerje pi`em`m jgohreoa`.

    Sjojte Felt` prhv`m e t`oeajhus cjgbt`r, p`tjtjhojog tb` Luldej^hija` tbrhugb tb` rjgbt th jochrletjho (T]J) iew th r`i`es` jtswjr`i`ss ihg crhl tbhs` aruajei bhurs. Gbechhr prhv`m el`oedi` thtb` r`qu`st eom r`c`rr`m jt th Lerje chr curtb`r eatjho. Eom tb`ochiihw`m e ahlpi`t` sji`oa`. Sjojte Felt` iet`r hdtejo`m tb`wjr`i`ss ihg r`ahrms es e s`t hc ihhs` i`ev`s. Qb` wes thim tbettb`s` w`r` ahpj`s sjoa` tb` hrjgjoeis bem d``o treosc`rr`m th tb`T.M. ^rembeo ahlljtt``, leomet`m dy tb` Leberesbtre stet`ghv`rol`ot th jm`otjcy tb` s`aurjty ieps`s tbet hp`o`m Luldejs

    mhhrs chr tb` 43/55 relpeg`. E mjr`at joqujry wjtb S.Deieabeomreo, e r`tjr`m hccjajei crhl Jomjes `spjhoeg` s`rvja`wbh lem` up tb` htb`r beic hc tb` ^rembeo ahlljtt``, r`v`ei`mtbet b` thh bem oht d``o edi` th g`t tb` hrjgjoei wjr`i`ss ihgcrhl tb` Luldej phija`.

    Wbet Sjojte Felt` cjoeiiy chuom, ect`r eii tb` ermuhus `cchrt, jsr`v`eijog. Q`ttjog hcc crhl Ab`ldur, Esbhf js r`v`ei`mp`rsjst`otiy esfjog phija` ahotrhi chr hrm`rs. ]b`s` er` r`c`rr`mth tb` ahlljssjho`r hc phija` th d`gjo wjtb, dut et 41;57 bhurs,b` js thim `xpijajtiy dy ahotrhi rhhl th r`phrt th tb` Qp`ajeiDreoab hccja`, wbjab js et ho` `xtr`ljty hc Teogdbeveo ieo`, ohtcer crhl tb` deaf get` hc Aele bhspjtei. Sjojte Felt` put tbrhugbe aeii th b`r busdeoms lhdji` pbho` et 41;02 bhurs eom chuom bjs

    hrm`riy Keyweot ^etji et tb` htb`r `om, eijv` eom edi` th emvjs`b`r tbet tb` tjl` wes oht qujt` rjgbt chr e ahov`rsetjho. Lerjees sb` oerret`s, f`pt e strejgbt cea` wb`o ahocrhot`m wjtbtb`s` cjomjogs hc ceat, dut lem` oh `cchrt th `xpiejo wby b` bemr`pr`s`ot`m tb` lhl`ot hc Esbhf Felt`s cetei `oahuot`r es 41;0>,hr mjsevhw`m eoy rhi` jo abejo hc ahlleom jostruatjhos tbetdrhugbt bjl th tb` Dhldey S] er`e.

    ]b` wjr`i`ss ihg eish r`v`eis Ferfer` th d` iuajm, jo ahotrhi eomw`ii ewer` hc wbet tb` d`st r`sphos` sbhuim d`, th e sjtuetjhotbet wes repjmiy spjreiijog hut hc ahotrhi. Et 41;42 bhurs b` js

    r`ahrm`m jo tb` wjr`i`ss ihg es seyjog tbet tb` UT] (pr`sulediytb` qujaf r`sphos` t`el) crhl tb` E]Q eom e Arjl` Dreoab t`elw`r` et tb` sjt`. ]bet m`pihyl`ot hc phija` p`rshoo`i wes ohtem`quet` jo bjs kumgl`ot. ]b`r`chr`, b` ahotjou`s, w` o``m e

    t`el crhl tb` crhot sjm`. W` o``m th `oajrai` Aele eom surrhuomjt. Eish t`ii Lr ^resem th sp`ef th tb` erly eutbhrjtj`s. Es

    Esbhf Felt` bem sejm kust erhuom tb`o, prhdediy tbjofjog eihumretb`r tbeo hrm`rjog eoy hp`retjhoei r`sphos`, tb` sjtuetjho ettb` tjl` s``l`m th r`qujr` eo erly m`pihyl`ot. Eom tb` ^resem

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    20/27

    4>

    tbet Ferfer` l`otjho`m wes hdvjhusiy tb` Khjot Ahlljssjho`r hcLuldej ^hija` chr Iew eom Hrm`r, F.I. ^resem, m`sjgoet`meutbhrjty wjtbjo tb` phija` bj`reraby th lef` eo ess`ssl`ot hcwb`o tb` ljijtery sbhuim d` aeii`m jo th ejm ajvji eutbhrjty.

    Ljout`s ect`r tbjs qujt` `xpijajt r`qu`st crhl Ferfer`, Josp`athr

    Depureh Mburgum` epprheab`m tb` crhot get` hc Aele bhspjtei eomepper`otiy sew tb` twh t`rrhrjst guol`o weifjog thwermsTeogdbeveo ieo`. ^bem wjto`ss`m bhw b` abeii`og`m tb` muh tbhugbb` ieaf`m eoy fjom hc deafup jo t`rls hc l`o, let`rjei hrcjr`phw`r, eom wes rutbi`ssiy guoo`m mhwo. ]b` twh lereum`rs tb`osupphs`miy muaf`m joth tb` Teogdbeveo ieo` wb`r` tb`y thhf ahv`rd`bjom tb` dusb`s ho ho` sjm`. Sjojte Felt` `stjlet`s tbet eould`r hc aeiis w`r` lem` crhl tb`o ho, th tb` phija` `l`rg`oayould`r 5>>, jomjaetjog tbet tb` twh fjii`rs w`r` jo Teogdbeveoieo`. Et 41;04 bhurs, e l`sseg` w`ot hut crhl tb` ahotrhi rhhl,esfjog p`rshoo`i crhl tb` o`er`st phija` stetjho th abeii`og` er`m v`bjai` jo tb` vjajojty hc Qt G`hrg`s bhspjtei, jo e qujt`

    mjcc`r`ot quert`r hc tb` ajty. E ljout` ect`r ljmojgbt, tb`jostruatjhos w`r` el`om`m th jm`otjcy tb` ihaetjho hc tb` susp`atv`bjai` es tb` L`trh Ajo`le kuoatjho, mhwo tb` rhem crhl tb`crhot get` hc tb` Aele bhspjtei. Qbhrtiy ect`r ljmojgbt ael` tb``oahuot`r jo wbjab Ferfer`, twh c`iihw hccja`rs eom tbr``ahostedi`s w`r` fjii`m eo `v`ot wbjab Sjojte Felt` `stjlet`s,wes r`phrt`m et tb` `l`rg`oay ould`r 5>> th tb` phija` ahotrhirhhl. @y`wjto`ss`s tb`o r`phrt`m s``jog e phija` v`bjai` wjtb eciesbjog d`eaho mrjv` pest tb` Uueijs jo wbjab tb` sjx phija`p`rshoo`i eom Eruo Kembev bem d``o bjt.

    Eruo Kembevs hwo eaahuot hc tb` `oahuot`r wes aihaf`m jo tb`

    ahotrhi rhhl et 40 ljout`s pest ljmojgbt. B` r`phrts tbet tb`Uueijs bem d``o bjkeaf`m eom tbet Ferfer`, Felt` eom Qeiesfer bemd``o sbht. Dut tb`r` js oh l`otjho hc tb` guol`o bevjog mrjv`ohcc jo e Qfhme hr e Bhome Eaahrm. @jgbt ljout`s ect`r Kembev besei`rt`m ahotrhi rhhl hc tb` bjkeaf eom tb` guoojog mhwo hc tb`tbr`` hccja`rs, e petrhi v`bjai` etteab`m th tb` Ezem Lejmeophija` stetjho r`phrts tbet tbr`` p`rshos w`r` iyjog jokur`m jotb` Teogdbeveo ieo` eom tbet e str`tab`r whuim d` r`qujr`m th`veauet` tb`l. Et chrty ljout`s pest ljmojgbt tb`r` js e sp`ajcjar`qu`st crhl tb` Josp`athr hc tb` Ihfleoye ]jief Lerg phija`stetjho, ihaet`m i`ss tbeo e fjihl`tr` crhl tb` sa`o` hc tb``oahuot`r, esfjog tbet essjsteoa` d` r`om`r`m jll`mjet`iy th tb`twh, tbr`` p`hpi` iyjog jokur`m, joaiumjog phssjdiy Felt`

    sebjd. Eom et =7 ljout`s pest ljmojgbt, Ferfer`s hwo wjr`i`ssareafi`s th ijc` wjtb eo urg`ot l`sseg` crhl e phija`leo wbh bemgejo`m eaa`ss th jt, ahocjrljog bjl d`jog tef`o th bhspjtei jos`v`r`iy jokur`m stet`, eihog wjtb Felt` eom Qeiesfer.

    Et 03 ljout`s pest ljmojgbt, ahotrhi rhhl r`ahrms sbhw tb`ahlljssjho`r hc phija` Beseo Gbechhr jo ahov`rsetjho wjtb khjotahlljssjho`r Tef`sb Lerje. Fesed bes dy tbjs tjl` d``o oedd`m etAbhwpetty eom Gbechhr js uom`rijojog tb` o``m chr sudk`atjog bjl

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    21/27

    45

    th eo jll`mjet` jot`rrhgetjho. Dut th e sp`ajcja qu`ry edhut tb`wb`r`edhuts hc Ferfer` eom Felt`, Lerje r`lejo`m uor`sphosjv`. B`l`otjhos tbet Qemeoeom Met`, eo Emmjtjhoei Ahlljssjho`r hc ^hija`chr a`otrei Luldej wes et tb` Aele Bhspjtei eom Felt` jo tb`Qp`ajei Dreoab hccja` er`e. Ferfer` wes th tb` d`st hc bjsfohwi`mg` jo Dhldey S]. ]h e sp`ajcja joqujry edhut tb`jr

    pbysjaei stet`, Lerje seys tbet b` wes tryjog th cjom hut.

    Sjojte Felt` js uoedi` th lef` eoy s`os` hc tb` phija` r`sphos`eom bermiy edi` th bjm` b`r s`os` hc d`treyei. Jo b`r cjrst l`mjejot`rvj`w sjoa` tb` sj`g` hc Luldej, sb` `xpr`ss`m b`rmjsepphjotl`ot et tb` jojtjei r`iuateoa` hc tb` bjgb`r phija`ahlleom th r`ahgojs` tb` ahotrjdutjho tbet Esbhf bem lem` thwermsaepturjog Fesed. Jt wes bjs m`t`rljo`m `ogeg`l`ot wjtb tb` erl`mlereum`rs jo tb` Teogdbeveo ieo` tbet bem joaepeajtet`m tb`l dhtbeom o`utreijs`m tb`jr phssjdi` jot`ot th ar`et` curtb`r bevha.Dut cer crhl b`erjog whrms hc ahll`ometjho chr tbjs eat hcahlljtl`ot, sb` hoiy `oahuot`r`m ahom`sa`osjho et tb` supphs`m

    chiiy tbet tb` tbr`` s`ojhr hccja`rs sbhw`m jo weifjog joth eoeldusb.15

    ]b`r` er` succjaj`ot qu`stjhos phs`m b`r` wjtbhut oul`rhus htb`rahlpijaetjhos d`jog ceathr`m jo. @y`wjto`ss t`stjlhoj`s eom tb`eaahuots r`om`r`m dy pertjajpeots jo tb` erl`m `oahuot`r wjtb tb`twh t`rrhrjsts wbh aerrj`m hut tb` Dhldey S]-Aele bhspjtei-Abhwpetty hp`retjho, ahoaur ho ho` jlphrteot m`teji; tbet tb`hoiy p`rsho aeptur`m eijv` tbet mey bem d``o s`rjhusiy whuom`m.Z`t, wjtbjo meys hc 43/55, tb` m`eo hc Oejr bhspjtei, wb`r` Fesedwes r`phrt`miy tef`o crhl tb` spht hc bjs aeptur`, wes mjsputjogtbet `otjr` eaahuot. E oetjhoei o`wspep`r ho M`a`ld`r 4 bem MrTevj Teoem` hc Oejr bhspjtei seyjog; B` bem shl` ed`rretjhos

    (sja, edresjhos) eom drujs`s ho bjs upp`r eom ihw`r ijlds. B` mjmoht bev` eoy duii`t jokury eom mjm oht r`qujr` surg`ry. B` wesgjv`o tr`etl`ot ho tb` spht eom tb`r` bes d``o oh eatjv`tr`etl`ot ho bjl ect`r tbet.14

    Jom``m, tb` `vjm`oa` hc tb` Abeoo`i = mhaul`otery t`i`aest joKuo` 4>>:, wbjab joaium`m tb` r`ahrmjog hc Feseds cjrstjot`rrhgetjho ho tb` lhrojog hc 47/55, jomjaet`s e p`rshosp`efjog wjtbhut mjccjauity, m`ijv`rjog s`t-pj`a` stet`l`otsedhut bjs qu`st chr lertyrmhl jo rjgbt`hus struggi` chr tb`cejtb. E ijc`tjl` jo peremjs` ewejt`m, hoa` tb` ljssjho wesahlpi`t`m. Eom tb`r` wes oh l`esur` hc eaahlpijsbl`ot, htb`r tbeo

    m`etb jo tb` aeus`. E phija` hccja`r sjts o`xt th bjl, phsjogqu`stjhos jo e shd`r eom i`v`i tho` tbet m`oht`s e bjgb m`gr`` hc

    15Q`` Ly busdeom mj`m e b`rhs m`etb; Sjojte Felt`, ]b` Bjomu, Keouery 554>>:, peg` :. E phjot curtb`r uom`rijo`m jo Felt` eom M`sblufb, ]h ]b` IestDuii`t, hp ajt.14Oh duii`t bjt Fesed, oh eatjv` tr`etl`ot ho, seys bhspjteis m`eo, ]b`Jomjeo @xpr`ss, M`a`ld`r 4 4>>:, peg` 56 `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl;bttp;//www.jomjeo`xpr`ss.ahl/o`ws/oh-duii`t-bjt-fesed-oh-eatjv`-tr`etl`ot-ho-seys-bhspjtei-s-m`eo/1:1553.

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/no-bullet-hit-kasab-no-active-treatment-on-says-hospital-s-dean/393116http://www.indianexpress.com/news/no-bullet-hit-kasab-no-active-treatment-on-says-hospital-s-dean/393116http://www.indianexpress.com/news/no-bullet-hit-kasab-no-active-treatment-on-says-hospital-s-dean/393116http://www.indianexpress.com/news/no-bullet-hit-kasab-no-active-treatment-on-says-hospital-s-dean/393116http://www.indianexpress.com/news/no-bullet-hit-kasab-no-active-treatment-on-says-hospital-s-dean/393116
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    22/27

    44

    prhc`ssjhoei trejojog eom jot`grjty. Feseds pbhthgrepb, espudijsb`m jo lekhr o`wspep`rs ho M`a`ld`r 5, wes tjgbtiy arhpp`m,wjtb kust tb` cea` vjsjdi`. ]b` vjm`h r`ahrmjog hc bjsjot`rrhgetjho utjijs`s e wjm`r crel`, tbet sbhws bjl wjtb edieof`t mrewo up th bjs ab`st eom e surgjaei petab ho tb` rjgbtsjm` hc bjs o`af. ]b`r` js e deom-ejm emb`rjog th bjs ihw`r i`ct

    kew (vjsjdi` eish jo tb` stjii pjatur`s) eom es tb` Oejr bhspjteim`eo jomjaet`m, shl` sjgos hc edresjhos ho bjs i`ct ab``f. ]b`vhja` tbhugb, js st`emy eom tb` `y`s chaus`m. Et a`rtejo phjots,b` sbhws e mjmeatja t`om`oay, es wb`o b` `xpiejos th bjsjoqujsjthr tbet bjs ljssjho wes th fjii p`hpi`. Eom wb`o esf`mwbh tb`s` p`hpi` ahuim d`, b` `xpiejos wjtb tb` petj`oa` tbet et`eab`r whuim ohrleiiy r`s`rv` chr e sihw stum`ot, tbet b` westb`r` th kust fjii wbh`v`r ael` joth bjs ijo` hc vjsjho.

    Joahlp`t`oa` eom jos`osjtjvjty s`rjhus aberg`s jo tb`ls`iv`s s``l `ljo`otiy werreot`m dy tb` ceats uoahv`r`m dy Sjojte Felt`.B`r oerretjv` eish pejots eo jotjlet` phrtrejt hc ceatjhoeijsl

    wjtbjo tb` phija` chra` eom e ahiieps` hc ahlleom eomahhrmjoetjho. E cejiur` th steom thg`tb`r jo eo bhur hc mjr`tbr`et wes eish `xphs`m jo tb` sthaftefjog, es wb`o Beseo Gbechhrwes r`ij`v`m hc aberg` es ahlljssjho`r, chr sugg`stjog tbeta`rtejo elhog bjs sudhrmjoet` hccja`rs ieaf`m tb` ahlljtl`ot thmjr`atiy tef` ho tb` abeii`og` hc 43/55.

    Es e chrl`r phija`leo celjijer crhl tb` josjm` wjtb tb`leabjoetjhos tbet mrjv` tb` chra`, Lusbrjc mjsp`os`s wjtb tb`prhprj`tj`s tbet Sjojte Felt` lejotejos jo emmr`ssjog tb` leoylyst`rj`s hc tbet ojgbt hc t`rrhr. B` oerret`s e tei` hcahospjreay p`rp`tret`m wjtb e m``p jm`hihgjaei eg`ome. Luldej43/55, b` ergu`s, wes oht edhut ho` sjogi` piht th strjf` etmjcc`r`ot ohm`s hc ajvja ijc` jo tb` ajty; jt wes edhut twhmjstjoat pihts. ]b` vjsjtetjho hc t`rrhr et Dhldey S], wbjab tb`oreo jts ahurs` tbrhugb Aele bhspjtei eom hst`osjdiy Lerjo`Mrjv` wes mjstjoat crhl tb` htb`r tbr`` esseuits ieuoab`m tbetojgbt. Crhl I`hphim Aec` jo Ahiede th tb` ]ek Lebei bht`i, tb`r`wes ho` treaf hc m`struatjho tbet tb` erl`m jotrum`rs aut. Eomtb`o tb`r` w`r` twh htb`r treafs, i`emjog th tb` Hd`rhj ]rjm`otjo Oerjleo ^hjot eom e a`otr` hc K`wjsb prhs`iytjsl supphrt`m dytb` Jsre`ij ghv`rol`ot, wjtbjo `esy weifjog mjsteoa` crhl Ahiede.

    Lusbrjc bes chuom t`stjlhoy jo s`ahomery shura`s, crhljomjvjmueis et tb` Aele bhspjtei et tb` tjl` hc tb` t`rrhrjst

    jogr`ss, wbh leoeg`m th `vem` tb` i`tbei ett`otjho hc tb`jotrum`rs dy prhaiejljog tb`jr Bjomu cejtb. ]bjs emms shl` b`ctth bjs `erij`r suspjajho, tbet tb` ould`r hc Lusijl p`rshosguoo`m mhwo et Dhldey S] sbhw`m tbet tb` rejm`rs tb`r` berdhur`moh s`os` hc sylpetby chr tb`jr cejtb. ]b`s` joc`r`oa`s eishr`shoet` wjtb tb` `xp`rj`oa` hc e ]urfjsb ahupi` jo tb` ]ek Lebei

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    23/27

    41

    bht`i, mjr`atiy jo tb` ijo` hc cjr` hc tb` rejm`rs, dut r`prj`v`md`aeus` tb`y pi`em`m tb`jr Jsielja eii`gjeoa`.11

    Mjijg`otiy sahurjog tbrhugb tb` o`ws r`phrtjog hc 43/55, Lusbrjccjoms tbet tb` Dhldey S] etteaf`rs w`r` oht kust twh jo ould`r,dut qujt` ijf`iy chur. ]wh hc tb` etteaf`rs, ect`r shwjog

    m`struatjho tbrhugb tb` rejiwey stetjho, w`r` r`phrt`m th bev`ci`m tb` sa`o`. ]b` muh wbh w`ot ho th gr`et`r eats hc bevha joAele bhspjtei eom `is`wb`r`, w`r` p`rbeps whrfjog ho e mjcc`r`oteg`ome.

    Jlpieusjdi` js tb` kumgl`ot Lusbrjc m`ijv`rs, edhut tb` hccjajeioerretjv` ho tb` Aele bhspjtei sbhht-hut. B` cjoms jt mjccjauitth d`ij`v`, chr josteoa`, tbet e s`v`r`iy jokur`m ahostedi` jotb` deafs`et hc e phija` v`bjai` ahuim bev` r`gjst`r`m eiim`tejis hc `v`ots uochimjog hutsjm`. ]bet mhudi` phija`derrjaem`s ahuim d` s`t et Abhwpetty, kust eo `jgbt ljout` mrjv`crhl tb` phjot et wbjab tb` bjkeaf`m phija` v`bjai` wes edeomho`m

    eom eohtb`r aer s`jz`m dy t`rrhrjsts wbh jot`om`m th mrjv`thwerms Leieder Bjii, js eohtb`r teii tei`. Lusbrjc js ahovjoa`mtbet c`w phija` stetjhos bev` tb` edjijty th r`sphom jo suabsbhrt tjl` th s`aurjty abeii`og`s hc tbjs legojtum`. Eom wjtb bjsfohwi`mg` hc tb` auitur` hc tb` phija` chra`, b` js edshiut`iyahovjoa`m tbet eoy arjljoei aeptur`m jo tb` ajraulsteoa`s tbetpr`veji`m jo Luldej tbet cet`cui mey, whuim oht bev` d``o i`cteijv`. ]b` cet` r`s`rv`m chr suab e aeptjv`, retb`r, whuim bev`d``o sullery `x`autjho, `jtb`r uom`r tb` w`jgbt hc phija` ietbjs,hr e duii`t th tb` b`em tbet ahuim d` phrtrey`m wjtbhut s`rjhuspudija mjss`ot, es i`gjtjlet` s`ic-m`c`oa`.

    Fesed bes d``o chr hdvjhus r`eshos, tb` prjoajpei chaus hc dhtbtb` prhs`autjho eom tb` l`mje. Dut tb`r` js e gr`et m`ei tbet jsr`v`ei`m crhl tb` aes` lem` egejost twh ah-m`c`omeots wbh w`ot hotrjei wjtb bjl. Cebjl Eoserj eom Qedebummjo Qb`jfb, oetjv`s hc eohrtb`ro Luldej sudurd eom Djbers Lembudeoj mjstrjatr`sp`atjv`iy, w`r` jo austhmy et tb` tjl` hc 43/55, ceajogaberg`s st`lljog crhl qujt` eohtb`r t`rrhrjst joajm`ot. Z`t tb`yw`r` jlpijaet`m jo 43/55 chr bevjog r`om`r`m let`rjei essjsteoa`th tb` pihtt`rs dy, elhog htb`r tbjogs, prhvjmjog e beom-mrewolep hc eii vjtei ihaetjhos jo tb` arhss-bejrs hc tb` t`rrhr piht.]b` lep jo tb` prhs`autjho oerretjho, wes arect`m dy Eoserj eombeom`m hv`r th Qb`jfb et e l``tjog jo Fetbleomu.

    11Q`ycj Lu`zzjohgiu js tb` oel` hc tb` ]urfjsb bhsteg` wbh epp`ers et tb`d`gjoojog hc tb` Abeoo`i = mhaul`otery eom tb`o et ljout` 57. Eom bjs oerretjhojs ai`er. B` eom e ould`r hc htb`r bhsteg`s w`r` b`rm`m up th eo hp`o er`e eomijo`m up egejost e weii. Kust es b` pr`per`m th cea` e vhii`y hc duii`ts, bjswjc` ihumiy sbhut`m hut bjs ]urfjsb oetjhoeijty eom Jsielja cejtb. Et tbetphjot, bjs t`rrhrjst aepthr sjgoei`m tbet b` sbhuim ij` ciet ho tb` grhuom.Cebemuiieb wes wbh b` jm`otjcj`m tb` i`em`r hc tb` t`rrhrjst rejm`rs es. EomCebemuiieb wes fjom th bjl, sjoa` `v`rydhmy `is` jo tbet getb`rjog, `xa`pt bjswjc` eom b`, wes sbht wjtb i`tbei jot`ot. Q`ycj Lu`zzjohgiu jo ceat westreuletjs`m dy tb` `cchrt b` bem th `xp`om jo mjggjog bjls`ic eom bjs wjc` hutcrhl uom`r e lhuotejo hc ahrps`s.

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    24/27

    4=

    ^rjl` `vjm`oa` jo tbjs r`germ wes ho` suab lep, pihttjog tb`rhut` th Dhldey S] eom crhl tb`r` th Leieder Bjii, chuom jo tb`phaf`t hc Feseds ahoc`m`ret` Edu Jsleji, ect`r b` wes fjii`m jo

    tb` `oahuot`r jo Gjrgeho Abhwpetty. M`c`oa` ahuos`i chr tb` twhl`o ergu`m tbet tb` lep, hst`osjdiy aerrj`m ho Edu Jslejis

    p`rsho crhl tb` tjl` b` s`t hcc crhl ^efjsteo, lust bev` gho`tbrhugb shl` s`v`r`iy ermuhus `v`ots d`chr` jts mjsahv`ry dy tb`phija`; eo `xt`om`m s`edhro` khuro`y ho tbr`` v`ss`is, e i`tbeisbhht-hut eom e cjoei, cetei `oahuot`r jo wbjab jts d`er`r wessiejo. Chr eii tbet, tb` lep es jt wes prhmua`m es `vjm`oa` joahurt, wes sphti`ss eom uoar`es`m.

    Jo mjsljssjog tbjs pj`a` hc `vjm`oa`, tb` trjei ahurt kumg`t`rl`m jt bjgbiy mhudtcui. B` eish whom`r`m wbet purphs` ebeom-mrewo lep whuim s`rv` wb`o tb` jot`ro`t eiihws tb` `esymhwoihem hc eii leps o`a`ssery chr eo hp`retjho suab es 43/55.]b` prhs`autjho aes` tbet Eoserj eom Qb`jfb bem l`t jo Fetbleomu

    th pieo hut a`rtejo `i`l`ots hc tb` t`rrhrjst strjf` ho Luldejwes eish mjsahuot`m , es wes tb` aiejl tbet Eoserj bem sp`ot leoyw``fs jo f``o dut uitjlet`iy cutji` qu`st hc e r`sjm`otjeiquert`r jo tb` shutb hc Luldej, o`er tb` d`eab wb`r` tb`t`rrhrjst geog pieoo`m th ieom.

    @vjm`otiy, m`spjt` tb` `xp`rj`oa` hc s`v`r`iy dhtab`m upjov`stjgetjhos sjoa` tb` Kuiy 4>>3 s`rjei dhldjogs jo Luldejs

    sudurdeo rejiwey syst`l eom tb` bjgb m`gr`` hc pudija sarutjoyijf`iy hv`r tb` 43/55 prhs`autjho, tb` Leberesbtre phija` w`r`oht qujt` wjiijog th gh deaf ho him prhaijvjtj`s. Wb`r` `vjm`oa`ahuim oht d` chuom, jt ahuim d` leouceatur`m th s`rv` epr`m`t`rljo`m aes`. ]bjs wes tb` hrgeojsetjhoei auitur`, mrewjogho wjm`r shajei pr`kumja`s, tbet Ferfer` pusb`m deaf egejost.

    Lusbrjc lef`s hut e aes` tbet Ferfer` pejm wjtb bjs ijc` chr tbjssjo hc oho-ahochrljty. Ho 5> C`druery 4>5>, es b`erjogs jo tb`43/55 trjei w`r` o`erjog ahoaiusjho, Qbebjm Ezlj, m`c`oa` ahuos`ichr Cebjl Eoserj, wes sbht m`em jo bjs Luldej hccja`. ^hija` puttb` arjl` mhwo th e mjsput` d`tw``o rjvei uom`rwhrim geogs eomerr`st`m tbr`` p`rshos sbhrtiy ect`rwerms. Jov`stjgetjhos bev`sjoa` d``o pereiys`m.

    Jo leoy weys, Qbebjm Ezljs ijc` sthry js eo jiiustretjho hc tb`

    auitur` hc iewi`sso`ss tbet bes cihurjsb`m uom`r tb` chg hc tb`

    wer ho t`rrhr. Temjaeijs`m dy bjs `xp`rj`oa` es e sjxt``o-y`erhim, hc Luldejs bhrrjcja ahlluoei vjhi`oa` jo 5::4 eom 5::1,Ezlj trev`ii`m th Fesbljr th vhiuot``r chr tb` kjbem tb`r`. B`chuom ijtti` th `ogeg` bjl eom shho r`turo`m th Luldej th r`sul`e ijc` jot`rrupt`m dy tb` treule hc ahlluoei betr`m s``o crhl upaihs`. Jo 5:::, b` wes pjaf`m up ho aberg`s hc jovhiv`l`ot jo eahospjreay th essessjoet` tb` i`em`r hc tb` Leretbj-Bjomuabeuvjojst hrgeojsetjho, tb` Qbjv Q`oe. B`im wjtbhut aberg` chrlhst hc tb` tjl` jo M`ibjs ]jber Keji -- b` wes s`t et ijd`rty

  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    25/27

    40

    jo 4>>=. Wbji` jo ]jber, Ezlj leoeg`m th ahlpi`t` bjs sabhhi eomgremuet` ahurs`s. Qjoa` s`aurjog bjs cr``mhl, b` ahlpi`t`m eahurs` jo iew eom w`ot hoth d`ahl` e r`mhudtedi` preatjtjho`r,`v`r wjiijog th tef` up tb` m`c`oa` hc yhutb eaaus`m hc t`rrhrjsthcc`oa`s chr oh r`esho htb`r tbeo ahlluoei pr`kumja`. Es tb`kumgl`ot hc tb` trjei ahurt lef`s ai`er, bjs chra`cui eom

    ahlp`iijog arhss-`xeljoetjho hc f`y prhs`autjho wjto`ss`s wes f`yjo s`aurjog Eoserjs eaqujttei jo tb` 43/55 aes`. Wb`tb`r tbetwes e prhc`ssjhoei sjo tbet ahst bjl bjs ijc`, js e lett`r tbetp`rbeps, o``ms curtb`r joqujry.1=

    Ho 45 Ohv`ld`r 4>>2, kust e c`w meys d`chr` b` wes fjii`m,Ferfer` bem uoahv`r`m t`rrhrjsl jo e quert`r wb`r` jt wes i`estsusp`at`m th `xjst. ]b` r`jgojog hrtbhmhxy et tb` tjl` wesertjauiet`m dy Oer`omre Lhmj, w`ii d`chr` b` `ero`m whrimwjm`ohthrj`ty es tb` erabjt`at hc tb` Gukeret 4>>4 dihhmdetb. ]b`ahot`xt wes tb` Q`pt`ld`r 4>>5 t`rrhr etteaf jo tb` P.Q., wb`oLhmj prhohuoa`m bjs eutbhrjtetjv` v`rmjat jo e ]S stumjh, tbet

    eii Lusijls er` oht t`rrhrjsts, dut eii t`rrhrjsts a`rtejoiy er`Lusijls. Jt wes e kustiy celhus chrluietjho, iet`r r`jt`ret`m dyoho` i`ss tbeo tb` Jsre`ij eldessemhr th tb` P.Q.10Ferfer` prhv`mhdijvjhus th tbjs wjsmhl wbjab hdvjhusiy wes elhog tb` uostet`mpr`ljs`s hc tb` gihdei wer ho t`rrhr, lhst eatjv`iy pursu`m sjoa`4>>5 dy tb` P.Q.-Jsre`ij exjs.

    Ferfer`s prjoajpei sjo ley bev` d``o tbet b` eatueiiy chiihw`m`vjm`oa` eom ihgja, retb`r tbeo tb`hihgy. Eom bjs joqujrj`s i`mbjl th e t`rrhr rjog jovhivjog e supphs`m sembvj(e whleo wbh bemtef`o tb` vhws hc r`ouoajetjho eom e ijc`tjl` hc r`ijgjhuspj`ty), tb` s`ic-prhaiejl`m b`em hc e r`ijgjhus chuometjho, es`rvjog erly hccja`r eom suomry htb`rs. ]b`y eii mr`w tb`jrjospjretjho crhl Bjomutve, tb` sel` jm`hihgjaei chuot et wbjabOer`omre Lhmj wes ourtur`m.

    Kust twh meys d`chr` b` wes fjii`m, Ferfer` bem l`t wjtb e o`wst`el eom ahoc`ss`m th e a`rtejo d`cummi`l`ot hv`r tb` hutreg`tbet bem chiihw`m bjs pursujt hc tb` Bjomutve t`rrhrjsl rjog. J

    1=Qbebjm Ezljs ijc` sthry bes d`ahl` e Dhiiywhhm cjil tjti`m Qbebjm, wbjabpr`lj`r`m et tb` Mudej Jot`roetjhoei Cjil C`stjvei jo M`a`ld`r 4>54. Dutwjtbhut eoy hc tb` `ld`iijsbl`ots hc ceoajcui cjil sarjpts, bjs ijc` sthry jsr`ahuot`m dy i`gei preatjtjho`rs eom eatjvjsts Ervjom Oerrejo eom Qeulye Ple joAeo tb` ihv` hc kustja` d` essessjoet`m8, evejiedi` es hc 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54

    et; bttp;//fecjie.hrg/4>54/55/4=/r`l`ld`rjog-sbebjm-ezlj-aeo-tb`-ihv`-hc-kustja`-d`-essessjoet`m-ervjom-oerrejo-seulye-ule/.Eish s`` Lebted Eiel,T`l`ld`rjog Qbebjm Ezlj, tb` Qbeb``m, wrjtt`o ho tb` ho`-y`er eoojv`rsery hctb` lurm`r eom evejiedi` es hc 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 et;bttp;//fecjie.hrg/4>55/>4/5>/r`l`ld`rjog-sbebjm-ezlj-tb`-sbeb``m-lebted-eiel/.10]b` quhtetjho crhl Oer`omre Lhmj aeo d` chuom jo tb` jotrhmuatjho th tb`joveiuedi` vhiul` `mjt`m dy Qjmmbertb Seremerekeo, Gukeret; ]b` Lefjog hc e]reg`my, ^`ogujo Dhhfs, M`ibj, 4>>1. ]b` r`lerfs dy tb` Jsre`ij eldessemhr w`r`wjm`iy r`phrt`m et tb` tjl` eom er` evejiedi` es hc 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 et tbjsijof; bttp;//www.wesbjogthophst.ahl/wp-myo/ahot`ot/ertjai`/4>>3/>1/>3/ET4>>3>1>3>5=33.btli.

    http://kafila.org/2012/11/24/remembering-shahid-azmi-can-the-love-of-justice-be-assassinated-arvind-narrain-saumya-uma/http://kafila.org/2012/11/24/remembering-shahid-azmi-can-the-love-of-justice-be-assassinated-arvind-narrain-saumya-uma/http://kafila.org/2012/11/24/remembering-shahid-azmi-can-the-love-of-justice-be-assassinated-arvind-narrain-saumya-uma/http://kafila.org/2011/02/10/remembering-shahid-azmi-the-shaheed-mahtab-alam/http://kafila.org/2011/02/10/remembering-shahid-azmi-the-shaheed-mahtab-alam/http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/06/AR2006030601466.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/06/AR2006030601466.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/06/AR2006030601466.htmlhttp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/03/06/AR2006030601466.htmlhttp://kafila.org/2011/02/10/remembering-shahid-azmi-the-shaheed-mahtab-alam/http://kafila.org/2012/11/24/remembering-shahid-azmi-can-the-love-of-justice-be-assassinated-arvind-narrain-saumya-uma/http://kafila.org/2012/11/24/remembering-shahid-azmi-can-the-love-of-justice-be-assassinated-arvind-narrain-saumya-uma/
  • 7/28/2019 Intelligence Failure or Design? Karkare, Kamte and the Campaign for 26/11 Truth

    26/27

    43

    mhot fohw wby tbjs aes` bes d`ahl` sh phijtjaei. ]b` pr`ssur` js

    tr`l`omhus eom J el whom`rjog bhw th `xtrjaet` jt crhl eii tb`phijtjas, b` sejm jo eo jot`rvj`w wjtb ]b` Jomjeo @xpr`ss,pudijsb`m ho Ohv`ld`r 42. ]b`s` w`r` r`lerfs lem` hcc tb` r`ahrm,wbjab tb` o`wspep`r tbhugbt ahuim d` pudijsb`m ect`r tb`uo`xp`at`m turo hc `v`ots hc 43/55. Ferfer`s ahlljtl`ot jom``m

    wes, es b` thim tb` o`wspep`r, th pursu` tbjs aes` v`ryhdk`atjv`iy eom oht stert wjtb essulptjhos.13

    Ferfer` bem `ero`m tb` djtt`r jr` hc tb` prjoajpei oetjhoeihpphsjtjho perty eom jts eiij`s, wbjab eaaus`m bjl hc i`emjog ephijtjaeiiy lhtjvet`m jov`stjgetjho eom jocijatjog tbhrhugbiyuoahosajhoedi` jomjgojtj`s ho p`rshos hc tb` tru` cejtb.Jrhojaeiiy, ho tb` v`ry mey tbet tb` t`rrhr etteaf jo Luldejd`geo, tb` Qbjv Q`oe bem eoohuoa`m pieos th hds`rv` e stet`-wjm`deomb th prht`st tb` supphs`m thrtur` hc tb` sembvjtbet Ferfer`bem err`st`m ho suspjajhos hc jovhiv`l`ot jo e ould`r hc dhldetteafs.17]b`r` wes grjl jrhoy tb`o, jo s``jog tb` sel` phijtjaei

    mjgojterj`s khstijog th hcc`r trjdut` th tb` ceii`o hccja`r, jo eayojaei `cchrt th i`v`reg` bjs m`etb chr lexjlul emveoteg`.

    Jo Lerab 4>54, e sthry tuaf`m ewey jo tb` lhr` hdsaur` ahro`rs hctb` Jomjeo pr`ss thim hc e p`tjtjho cji`m uom`r pudija jot`r`stkurjsmjatjho, s``fjog hccjajei aierjty ho tb` stetus hc JomjesJot`iijg`oa` Dur`eu (JD). ]b` p`tjtjho cji`m d`chr` tb` BjgbAhurt hc Feroetefe dy e chrl`r hccja`r hc tb` JD, l`otjho`m tbettb` eg`oay chrl`m jo 5227, dy tb` tb`o Drjtjsb s`ar`tery hc stet`es e sud-s`at hc tb` A`otrei Qp`ajei Dreoab, bem sjoa` r`lejo`mijf` e gbhst, wjtbhut e stetut`.12Jomje l`eowbji` lhv`m tbrhugbihog y`ers hc strjc` eom struggi` thwerms jom`p`om`ot oetjhobhhm,emhptjog e r`pudijaeo ahostjtutjho es e g`stur` hc cejtb jo tb`p`hpi`. Dut tb` JD r`lejo`m r`shiut`iy d`yhom tb` pei` hc pudijasarutjoy.

    Luldej 43/55 sbhw`m ho` phssjdi` petbwey tbet e m`lharetja phijtyahuim tef` th purg` jts`ic hc r`sjmuei v`stjg`s hc phw`r wjtbhuteaahuotedjijty job`rjt`m crhl ahihojeijsl. Jomje tbhugb, s``lsjot`ot ho tefjog tb` hpphsjt` petb. Jo Eprji 4>54, tb` P.Q.ghv`rol`ot jo e r`ieps` hc joceotjijsl r`ljojsa`ot hc tb` G`hrg`W. Dusb pr`sjm`oay, eoohuoa`m e t`o ljiijho mhiier dhuoty ho tb`b`em hc tb` ^efjsteoj ai`rja Becjz Lhbellem Qe``m, d`ij`v`mtbrhugb tb` repjmiy lutetjog hrgeojsetjhos tbet b` spewo`m wjtb

    13Bjs r`sphos` th e m`etb tbr`et; e slji`y, ]b` Jomjeo @xpr`ss (M`ibj@mjtjho), Ohv`ld`r 42, 4>>2, p 36 `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl;bttp;//www.jomjeo`xpr`ss.ahl/o`ws/ferfer`-s-r`sphos`-th-e-m`etb-tbr`et-e-slji`y/1:5140/.17Q`oe pjafs up eotj-E]Q detho crhl DK^, ]b` @ahohlja ]jl`s, 47 Ohv`ld`r4>>2, peg` 46 `xtreat`m ho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl;bttp;//ertjai`s.`ahohljatjl`s.jomjetjl`s.ahl/4>>2-55-47/o`ws/42=3=5:5X5Xlei`geho-diest-meyeoeom-peom`y-it-ahi-presem-purhbjt.12Q`` tb` ]jl`s O`ws O`twhrf sthry met`ijo`m Ab`ooej, Lerab 43 4>54, `xtreat`mho 15 M`a`ld`r 4>54 crhl; bttp;//ertjai`s.tjl`shcjomje.jomjetjl`s.ahl/4>54->1-43/jomje/1541:==1X5Xjd-r-o-fuiferoj-jot`iijg`oa`-dur`eu.

    http://www.indianexpress.com/news/karkare-s-response-to-a-death-threat-a-smiley/391325/http://www.indianexpress.com/news/karkare-s-response-to-a-death-threat-a-smiley/391325/http://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2008-11-27/news/28464191_1_malegaon-blast-dayanand-pandey-lt-col-prasad-purohithttp://articles.economictimes.indiatimes.com/2008-11-27/news/28464191_1_malegaon-blast-dayanand-pandey-lt-col-prasad-purohithttp://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-03-26/india/31239443_1_ib-r-n-kulkarni-intelligence-bureauhttp://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-03-26/india/31239443_1_ib-r-n-kulkarni-intelligence-bureauhttp://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2012-03-26/india/31239443_1_ib-r-n-kulkarni-intellig