interim report - jan-2013
TRANSCRIPT
National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
Revenue (DM) Department Government of Andhra Pradesh
THIRD PARTY QUALITY AUDIT (TPQA)
in Joint Venture with
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
INDEX
1.0 Project Background 1
1.1 Third Party Quality Audit Consultant 2
1.2 Mobilization of Team 3
1.3 Setting up offices and logistics for the consultant teams 6
2.0 Review Meetings and Other Activities 7
3.0 Status of TPQA Visits 11
4.0 Third Party Quality Audit by Egis – India consulting services Summary of Works 13
5.0 Progress of NCRMP works 14
6.0 District wise status of tests conducted by TPQA 27
7.0 Tasks carried out by TPQA Consultants 28
8.0 Reporting Requirement 31
9.0 Highlights of TPQA Consultant’s Performance 35
10 Environmental & Social Report 39
11 Photo Documentation 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
1.0 PROJECT BACKGROUND
Andhra Pradesh (AP) state has one of the longest coastal belts in India. Out of 67,362 Km of road network in the state, the
nine coastal districts cover 26,000 km of road length. Every year during the period of April-May and September-December,
cyclonic situations set in to the Bay of Bengal. With the recent changes in climatic conditions, the catastrophic events are
increasing resulting in very devastating cyclones like Laila, Jal etc where the loss is enormous. In the 97 years ranging
from 1892 to 1989, there were as many as 67 cyclones within the State.
It is essential to provide safe residential accommodation to the vulnerable population during any eventuality or disaster due
to natural calamities such as cyclones and associated tidal waves and storm surges. The project is formulated based on
experiences of Government of Andhra Pradesh in mitigating such disasters during the past and also keeping in view the
existing facilities available in the project area in Andhra Pradesh.
The Government of India has applied for a credit of US$ 255 Million equivalent from the International Development
Association (IDA) toward the cost of National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP), and it intends to apply the
proceeds to payments for goods, works, related services and consulting services under this Project.
National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP) – Project Implementation Unit (PIU), Andhra Pradesh, headquartered at
Hyderabad has invited the consultants to submit proposals for providing the consultancy services for Third Party Quality
Audit for 9 coastal districts namely Srikakulam, Vijayanagaram, Visakhapatnam, East Godavari, West Godavari, Krishna,
Guntur, Prakasam and Nellore. The project “Construction of Multipurpose Cyclone Shelters, Roads to CycloneShelters, and Roads to habitations and Roads & Bridges under NCRMP” is funded by International Development
Association and received through Government of India. This consultancy is envisaged to audit the quality of works being
implemented by various line departments working under PIU. The number of works under progress / for which
agreements are concluded in each district is shown in the table below.
District
No. of works(Under Concluded Agreements) No. of works under Progress No. ofworks
notstartedRHB RCS MPCS Bridges Roads
(R&B) Total RHB RCS MPCS Bridges Roads(R&B)
Srikakulam 6 8 2 4 1 21 6 8 2 4 1 0
Vizianagaram - - - 2 1 3 - - - 2 1 0
Visakhapatnam 8 6 7 - - 21 8 6 7 - - 0
East Godavari 2 8 3 - - 13 2 7 3 - - 1
West Godavari 10 - - - - 10 10 - - - - 0
Krishna 5 3 - - - 8 5 3 - - - 0
Guntur 3 12 - 2 - 17 3 12 - 2 - 0
Prakasam 14 7 2 1 - 24 14 7 2 1 - 0
Nellore 17 9 - - - 26 17 9 - - 0
Page 1 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
1.1 THIRD PARTY QUALITY AUDIT CONSULTANT.
To provide Consulting Services of Third Party Quality Auditor for Construction of Multipurpose Cyclone Shelters, Roads to
Cyclone Shelters, Roads to habitations, and Roads and Bridges under NCRMP in 9 coastal districts The Commissioner for
Disaster Management & Project Director, Project Implementation Unit (PIU) NCRMP has selected Egis International in JV
with Egis India Consulting Engineers (I) Pvt. Ltd. On 31st May’2011, the Contract for Consultancy Service was signed
between The Commissioner for Disaster Management & Project Director, Project Implementation Unit (PIU) NCRMP and
the Egis International in JV with Egis India Consulting Engineers (I) Pvt. Ltd.
1.2 MOBILIZATION OF TEAM
In accordance with the Contract for Consultant Services, executed on 31st May’2011, by The Commissioner for Disaster
Management & Project Director, Project Implementation Unit (PIU) NCRMP and the Egis India, professional services were
authorized to commence work. The detail of team mobilization and organization chart is shown below.
Sr.No. Name Designation Date Of
JoiningLast Day of
WorkingNCRMP Project Office, Hyderabad
1 Bhavanna Rao Project Manager 01.06.2011
2 Dr. Surjit Singh Deepak Environmental Management Expert 09.06.2011
3 Dr. Sudesh Kaul Social Management Expert 01.06.2011
4 Mrityunjay Kumar MIS Expert 01.06.2011
5 V.Ravi Kumar Electrical 06.06.2011
6 Ch.Giridhar Electrical 02.06.2011 13.12.2012
Page 2 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
Prakash Rao Electro Mechanical 17.12.2012
7 Hari Shankar Prasad Field Staff - Environmental Engineer 09.06.2011
8 M. Venkata Ramana Field Staff - Social Expert 04.07.2011
9Viraj Premi Office Manager HYD 01.06.2011 31.03.2012
Suchan Kumar K P Office Manager HYD 02.04.2012
VISHAKAPATANAM
10 Ch.V.S.Sivakumar DPM / Vishakapatnam 28.09.2011
11 K.Siva Ramprasad Site Engineer 02.06.2011
12 Mallela Shyam sunder Site Engineer 07.07.2011
13 B.Srinivasulu Reddy Site Engineer 06.06.2011 22.09.2012
14 H.Venugopal Site Engineer 06.06.2011
15Siva Kishore Vedula Site Engineer 09.06.2011 04.01.2012
Sivaji Raju Site Engineer 13.02.2012
16Srinivas.Y Site Engineer 27.06.2011 06.01.2012
Venkateshwara Prasad Site Engineer 13.02.2012
17
Babu.G Office Manager 01.06.2011 19.06.2012
KNVS.Malleswara Swamy Office Manager 20.06.2011 14.11.2012
N.Ramakrishana Office Manager 17.11.2012
ELURU
18M. Manohar DPM / Eluru 27.06.2011
R. Sathi Babu Randhi Deputy Project Manager 02.06.2011
19 Gudla Rama Naresh Site Engineer 06.06.2011
20 Nakka Jayasimha Site Engineer 06.06.2011
21 K. Jyothi Prasad Site Engineer 06.06.2011
22P.Durga Rao Site Engineer 06.06.2011 02.01.2012
Sridhar G Site Engineer 27.02.2012
23 N.Srinivas Site Engineer 01.07.2011
24 Vijaya Bhaskar Nalli Site Engineer 01.03.2012
25 Avinash Babu Gunnam Office Manager 01.06.2011
Page 3 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
ONGOLE
26 Arun Kumar DPM / Ongole 22.02.2012
27P.Ramesh Reddy Site Engineer 06.06.2011 13.03.2012
T.SreeVishnu Site Engineer 14.03.2012
28Shaik Zaheer AhamadGori Site Engineer 02.06.2011 31.08.2012
S.Narendar Site Engineer 10.09.2012
29 K. Rama Rao Site Engineer 22.06.2011
30 Suresh Babu.P Site Engineer 06.06.2011
31 R.Balakrishna Reddy Site Engineer 02.06.2011
32Mallikarjuna Rao Site Engineer 02.06.2011 01.03.2012
Ravinder Reddy Site Engineer 15.07.2011
33 Neelakantan Office Manager 01.06.2011
Page 4 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
Organization Chart of TPQA, NCRMP
Page 5 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
1.3 SETTING UP OFFICES AND LOGISTICS FOR THE CONSULTANT TEAMS
We have established a Main office at Hyderabad, where all the necessary expertise that is required for this project. There
is a core team of national experts to monitor the project activities and discipline specialist will appropriately support this
core team. These experts will again be supported from the respective home office. Other than the experts, support staff is
also be stationed in this office. This office will be the base office during the project period of consultants.
The details of our site offices are given in table below. These offices are provided with required communication equipment,
transportation facilities and necessary infrastructure. The offices are also equipped with computers with basic software
programmes, printers, and other electronic gadgets like telephone, fax machines, etc. as felt needed. Apart from the above
PM and DPM offices, we have established site offices in all other districts
PM Office – Hyderabad
9-1-77/3, No.31, Third Floor
S.D. Road, Secundrabad – 500 003
Fax:=91-04-40179496
E- mail: [email protected]
DPM Office – Vishakhapatnam
Pavan Residency, Dr. No. 31-7-2/73,
Flat NO 503Kurmannapalem,
Opp to Bus Depot,
Vishakhapatnam - 530046
DPM Office – Eluru
Flat No. 504, Fourth Floor,
Yemireddy Residency Apartment,
Shekar Street, Gandhinagar,
Eluru, West Godavari Dist. A.P.
DPM – Ongole Office
H. No. 6-277, 2nd lane
Beside computer Centre
Maruthi Nagar
Ongole - 523002
Site Office for Krishna Dist.
D. No. 20-516-3/4,NGO Colony,
Frenchpet, Machilipatnam,Krishna Dist.,
Site Office for Srikakulam Dist.
Flat No T-1,3rd Floor Indiranagar Colony,
Ganesh Apartments,Srikakulam - 532421
Site Office for Guntur Dist.
H.No. 10-32,
Opposite Bhaskar Theatre,
Tenali road,Cherukapalli, Guntur-522309.
Site Office for East Godavari Dist.
D. No. 70-6-19/1,Upstairs,
Nagendragudi Veedhi,Ramanayyapet, Kakinada, E G Dist
Site Office for Nellore Dist.
Door No.23/218,2nd Floor Ravichettu Centre,
Fathekhanpet, Nellore – 524 003
Page 6 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
2.0 REVIEW MEETINGS AND OTHER ACTIVITIES
S.No. Date Place Activity
1 02.09.2011 Guntur Review meeting by SE, PR, Guntur - Meeting was organized to reviewthe progress and issues of NCRMP works
2 07.09.2011 Vizianagaram Review meeting by SE, PR, Vizianagaram - Meeting was organized toreview the progress and issues of NCRMP works
3 15.09.2011Chambers of theCDM & EOPS &PD CRMP.
Kick Off meeting arranged for starting the PMC Activities by M/sFeedback Ventures India Ltd; Introduction of PMC, and brief descriptionof activities of PMC in Phase 1 &2, and activities of EPTRI for Phase 2.
4 17.09.2011 Bapatla, Guntur
NCRMP works review by Shri. M. Sasidhar Reddy, Vice chairmen,DM, followed by works inspection Guntur works by PD, NCRMP, andHyderabad. Two bridge works taken up by R&B, Guntur, wereinspected by PD, NCRMP.
5 20.09.2011 Guntur, HotelSindhuri
All the contractors, Department Officers from R&B and PR of WestGodavari, Krishna, Guntur, Prakasham and Nellore along with TPQA andPMC of NCRMP had participated in the workshop.
6 22.09.2011 VisakhapatnamHotel Meghalaya
One day State level workshop for contractors on World Bankprocurement guidelines organized by PIU, NCRMP - All thecontractors, Department Officers from R&B and PR of East Godavari,Visakhapatnam, Vizianagaram, and Srikakulam along with TPQA andPMC of NCRMP had participated in the workshop
7 18-10-2011 VijayanagaramTPQA Engineers as attended the inspection of NCRMP works inVijayanagaram District by Project Director NCRMP accompanied by PMand other PIU officers
8 18-10-2001 SrikakulamTPQA Engineers as attended the inspection of NCRMP works inVijayanagaram District by Project Director NCRMP accompanied by PMand other PIU officers
9 19-10-2011 Vishakhapatnam
PIU NCRMP has conducted a State level Workshop on Coastalconstruction of Roads & Bridges by CRRI scientists from Newdelhi TPQAhas also attended the workshop and attended review meeting conductedby PD NCRMP
10 29-10-2011 Ongole PM TPQA presented on measures to be taken for improving quality ofNCRMP works along with on field examples.
11 29-10-2011 Ongole PM NCRMP has given presentations on Quality aspects of Roads,Buildings & Bridges for NCRMP works.
Page 7 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
12 11-01-2012 HyderabadAttended World Bank Quick Mission Review meeting at Golconda Hotelattended along with Client and Line Departmental officers and presentedthe status of TPQA NCRMP works.
13 23-01-2012 Vijayawada Convened a Training Program for all TPQA DPM’s and SE’s at IlapuramHotel.
14 24-01-2012 Vijayawada Attended Review Meeting by SPIU officers along with Line departmentalofficers of Three Districts (Guntur, Krishna, and West Godavari).
15 04-02-2012 Hyderabad Attended to ENC PR Office and conducted interaction secession withCE, NCRMP and her staff.
16 09-02-2012 Nellore Attended review meeting by PM (SPIU-NCRMP).
17 28-02-2012 Hyderabad Attended to NCRMP Office and held discussions with Sri. Manohar Rao& with other Technical officers.
18 06-03-2012 Hyderabad Attended Review meeting at NCRMP office
19 14-03-2012 Hyderabad Attended Review meeting at NCRMP office
20 16-03-2012 Hyderabad Attended video conference at ‘C’ Block in the Secretariat on NCRMPworks of Panchayat Raj Department
21 02-04-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP, SPIU’s office (discussed about the TPQA Activation.
22 07-04-2012 Rajahmundry Convened a meeting with TPQA field Engineers and Line DepartmentalOfficers regarding NCRMP works.
23 11-04-2012 Vishakhapatnam Attended Review Meeting by World Bank Team for 3 districts Srikakulam,Vijayanagaram, and Vishakhapatnam at Palm Beach Hotel.
24 12-04-2012 Vishakhapatnam Attended to World bank Team’s inspection of NCRMP works inVishakhapatnam District.
25 13-04-2012 Hyderabad Attended World bank Team Review Meting at Hotel Golconda alongTPQA Staff, PMC staff, SPIU and PIU officers
26 17-04-2012 Hyderabad Attended SPIU, NCRMP’s office.
27 26-04-2012 Guntur Convened a QA workshop for PR engineers of Guntur District at ZPmeeting hall.
Page 8 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
28 09-05-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP, SPIU’s office for review of Srikakulam,Vijayanagaram and Vishakhapatnam districts.
29 18-05-2012 Krishna Attended PM, SPIU's inspection of NCRMP Phase II works inKrishna District.
30 23-05-2012 Nellore Convened a QA workshop for PR engineers and Contractors inNellore.
31 24-05-2012 Vishakhapatnam Attended SPIU Review Meeting at Palm Beach Hotel.
32 25-05-2012 Vishakhapatnam Attended to Inspection of NCRMP Works by Joint Secretary andProject Director, NDMA.
33 26.05.2012 Srikakulam Attended EE, SPIUs inspection of NCRMP works in SrikakulamDistrict.
34 28-05-2012 Hyderabad Attended Commissioners office at H block for a review meeting byWorld Bank Social expert.
35 02-07-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP Office in L block received instructions from PDNCRMP.
36 10-07-2012 Hyderabad Attended Review meeting at PD NCRMP office
37 12-07-2012 Hyderabad Attended SPIU NCRMP’s review meeting at H block in APSecretariat.
38 12-07-2012 Hyderabad Attended video conference on review of NCRMP works by NDMAin 3rd floor of D block in AP secretariat.
39 19-07-2012 Hyderabad Attended Review meeting at commissioner DMA’s office onNCRMP Review and
40 19-07-2012 Hyderabad Attended Annual Review of PMC meeting.
41 04-08-2012 Kakinada Conducted QA Workshop at Kakinada in ZP meeting hall forPRED Engineers
42 21-08-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP office
43 30-08-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP office
44 26.09.2012 Srikakulam Conducted QA Workshop at ZP Meeting hall at Srikakulam
Page 9 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
45 10-10-2012 Hyderabad Attended ENC (PR) office and attended discussion with PD SPIUin ENC (PR) chambers.
46 15-10-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP office for Review meeting by PM SPIU onTPQA Performance.
47 17-10-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP office for Review meeting by PM SPIU.
48 19-10-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP Review meeting in chambers of CommissionerDMA at 5th floor ‘L’ block AP Secretariat.
49 29-10-2012 Hyderabad Attended NCRMP Review meeting in Chief Secretary Peshi in ‘C’block AP Secretariat.
50 21.11.2012 Srikakulam Attended Review meeting at Srikakulam with World Bank ISRmission
51 22.11.2012 Visakhapatnam Attended Review meeting at Visakhapatnam with World Bank ISRmission
52 23.11.2012 Hyderabad Attended Review meeting at H Block in AP Secretariat with WorldBank ISR mission
53 17.12.2012 Hyderabad Attended Review meeting at H Block in AP Secretariat withCommissioner and PD
Page 10 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
3.0 STATUS OF TPQA VISITS
The following table shows the details of TPQA visits to sites in respective districts.
District
Total Number of Visits
June.'11
July.'11
Aug.'11
Sep.'11 Oct.
'11Nov.'11
Dec.'11 Jan
.'12Feb.'12
Mar.'12
Apr.'12
May.'12
June.'12
July.'12
Aug.'12
Sep.'12
Oct.'12
Nov.'12 Dec.'12 Total
Srikakulam 6 13 14 29 20 19 18 19 25 25 24 43 34 17 26 28 28 28 36 452
Vizianagaram 4 5 4 4 7 4 3 3 5 6 5 5 2 2 2 0 5 5 1 72
Vishakhapatnam 9 15 15 12 15 19 26 16 21 36 29 18 24 25 10 18 19 11 23 361
EastGodavari 6 10 11 16 21 39 40 44 48 65 64 57 41 31 25 24 16 32 22 612
WestGodavari 8 10 10 12 35 35 32 21 41 43 39 37 24 17 5 18 10 13 26 436
Krishna 11 11 7 8 8 31 27 12 22 29 21 17 11 9 3 10 10 14 38 299
Guntur 11 12 13 17 15 24 20 22 18 15 22 12 15 34 19 28 23 21 32 373
Prakasam 10 18 25 17 24 29 27 24 22 27 21 25 24 19 10 18 27 17 23 407
Nellore 8 17 25 23 25 11 14 9 26 18 17 28 13 25 13 13 9 13 16 323
Page 11 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
Monthly Visits by TPQA
Page 12 of 49
INTERIM REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
4.0 THIRD PARTY QUALITY AUDIT BY EGIS – INDIA CONSULTING SERVICES SUMMARY OF WORKS
The district wise progress of works is shown below. The works in the West Godavari are not started and the works inKrishna District has just started. At many places the first milestone is completed but works are not started. The linedepartments are to analyze the reasons for the slow progress and if necessary penalty for the slow progress as per theagreement conditions should be imposed
Third Party Quality Audit by Egis – India consulting services
Summary of Activities
S.No. District
Agreements for PackagesCommunicated Status of works
PR R&B Progress Not Started
1 Srikakulam 6 5 21 0
2 Vizianagaram - 3 3 0
3 Visakhapatnam 13 0 21 0
4 East Godavari 7 0 12 1
5 West Godavari 3 0 10 0
6 Krishna 4 0 8 0
7 Guntur 6 2 17 0
8 Prakasam 12 1 24 0
9 Nellore 16 0 26 0
Total 67 11 142 1
Total Packages for which Agreements are received 79
Total Number of works in the above packages 143
.
Page 13 of 49
QUARTERLY SUMMARY REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
TPQA STATUS REPORT FOR NCRMP WORKS TO THE END OF DECEMBER 2012
S.No. District
Packages /Works
entrustedStatus of Works No. of
Visitsof
TPQA
Total No.of QCtestsdone
NCRs AuditReportsIssued
Environmental& SocialReportsIssuedPR R&B Started Not
Started Issued closed Pending
1 Srikakulam 16 5 21 0 452 1475 54 54 0 77 57
2 Vizianagaram - 3 3 0 72 461 3 1 2 11 9
3 Visakhapatnam 21 - 21 0 361 2237 25 25 0 71 41
4 East Godavari 13 - 12 1 612 1128 28 28 0 58 31
5 West Godavari 10 - 10 0 436 349 20 20 0 52 37
6 Krishna 8 - 8 0 299 85 3 3 0 35 21
7 Guntur 15 2 17 0 373 606 14 13 1 60 32
8 Prakasam 23 1 24 0 407 1905 36 30 6 116 50
9 Nellore 26 - 26 0 323 1174 32 28 4 109 48
Total 132 11 142 1 3335 9420 215 202 13 589 326
Average number of TPQA visits done per work = 23
Average number of QC Tests done per work = 66
Page 14 of 49
First Second Third
1Road from DPN R&B road to
Uddandapalem/2010-11, Dt.30.04.2011
31.08.11 31.12.11 30.04.12 work completed -
2Road from K. Umilada Junction to Koduru
(Link Road)/2010-11, Dt.30.04.2011
31.08.11 31.12.11 30.04.12 work completed -
3Road from Borubhadra, Malagam toKollipadu via Seepuram, Gantapeta
/2010-11, Dt.30.04.2011
31.08.11 31.12.11 30.04.12 work completed -
4NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/
01/Polaki/006Road from Talasamudram to Dola
Regulator/2010-11, Dt.30.04.2011
30.08.11 31.12.11 30.04.12First Milestone i.e
Earthwork & Cd works&GSB
-
5NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/01/
Surampeta/003
Construction of Minor Bridge at Km 12/2-4of NH-5 to Surampeta Road via Naruva,
mentada
45/2010-2011,Dt17.12.2010
17.05.11 17.10.11 17.03.12Completion of entire
work-
6NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/
01/Bendigedda/004
Construction of High level bridge acrossBendi gedda at KM 4/10 of Pundi-
Parlakimidi road in Srikakulam
1/2010,Dt.11.11.2010
11.08.11 11.01.12 11.06.12 work completed -
7 R&BNCRMP/B-W/AP/RD/R&B/
01/Nowpada/006)Improvesments Naupada-Venkatapuram
road from 0/0to15/0km43/2010-11,17.12.2010
17.05.11 17.10.11 17.03.12 work completed -
8 Road from NP road to URKpuramG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2010
29.01.12 29.05.12 29.09.12 work completed -
9Road from Deppuru,Bahadapalli road to
onkuluru & to cyclonishelterG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2011
29.01.12 29.05.12 29.09.12 work completed -
10 Road from R&B road to DevunthaladaG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2012
29.01.12 29.05.12 29.09.12 work completed -
11Road from pollada to Komarthalada & to
cyclonic shelterG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2013
29.01.12 29.05.12 29.09.12 work completed -
12Road from Koyyam R&B Road to
MoosavanipetaG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2010
07.11.11 07.02.12 07.06.12 work completed -
13 Road from Mentada to DovupetaG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2010
07.11.11 07.02.12 07.06.12 work completed -
14Road from Kotcherela road to
Kollibhemavaram & cyclonicshelterG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2010
07.11.11 07.02.12 07.06.12 work completed -
15Road from Kotcherla road to
PathasundarapalemG.o rt No 451dt 06.04.2010
07.11.11 07.02.12 07.06.12 work completed -
16
VIZI
ANAG
ARAM
RoadNCRMP/B-W/AP/RD/R&B/
02/Konada/009
Improvements to Road from KonadaRamatheertham (R&B) Road toKonathalapalem (Via) Pasupam,
Yerukonda, Kollayavalasa from Km 12/0to 16/5 (Km 0/0 to 4/0 i.e. upto NH-5
crossing)
33/2010-2011Dt. 08.12.2010
07.06.11 07.12.11 07.03.12 work completed -
Bridges
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t.milestone up to
15.01.2013Remarks
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/01/V.KOTTURU/002
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/01/ETCHERLA/005
SlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
Names of works under each packageAgreementNo. /Date
SRIK
AKU
LAM
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/01/Santhabommali/003
RHS
STATEMENT SHOWING THE LIST OF NCRMP YEAR-1 WORKS COMPLETED AND AUDITED UP TO 15-01-2013
RHB
1 of 9Page 15 of 49
First Second Third
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t.milestone up to
15.01.2013Remarks
SlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
Names of works under each packageAgreementNo. /Date
17NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/
03/Anandapuram/001Road from NH-5 to Ramaraidupalem
/2011-12, Dt.15.09.2011
14.12.11 14.03.12 14.06.12 Work completed -
18 Road from R & B road to Rajakoduru/2011-12, Dt.15.09.2011
14.01.12 14.05.12 14.09.12 Work completed -
19Road from R & B road to Kattubolu to
Marripalem/2011-12, Dt.15.09.2011
14.01.12 14.05.12 14.09.12 Work completed -
20 Road from R & B road to Krishnampalem/2011-12, Dt.15.09.2011
14.01.12 14.05.12 14.09.12 Work completed -
21Road from R&B road to Pedateenarla to
Chinateenarla/2011-12, Dt.15.09.2011
14.12.11 14.03.12 14.06.12 Work completed -
22Road from Upamaka Rajayyapeta R&B
road to Janakayyapeta/2011-12, Dt.15.09.2011
14.12.11 14.03.12 14.06.12 Work completed -
23 Road from Vempadu to Patimeeda/2010-11, Dt.11.01.2011
10.05.11 10.09.11 10.01.12 Work completed -
24Road from R&B road to Mullaparra upto
Beach end/2010-11, Dt.27.01.2011
26.04.11 26.07.11 26.10.11 Work completed -
25NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/
03/Anandapuram/003Road from R&B B.P Kallalu to
Matchvanipalem/2010-11, Dt.10.03.2011
09.06.11 09.09.11 09.12.11 Work completed -
26Road from R & B road to Pothu
Rajannapalem/2010-11, Dt.28.03.2011
27.06.11 27.09.11 27.12.11 Work completed -
27 Road from R & B road to Jalaripeta/2010-11, Dt.28.03.2011
27.06.11 27.09.11 27.12.11 Work completed -
28NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/03/Rambilli/006
Road from R & B road to Venkayyapalem/2010-11, Dt.11.01.2011
10.04.11 10.07.11 10.10.11 Work completed -
29 Road from R&B road to Ava- Somavaram/2011-12, Dt.27.04.2011
26.07.11 26.10.11 26.01.12 Work completed -
30 Road from R&B Road to Avarajam/2011-12, Dt.27.04.2011
26.07.11 26.10.11 26.01.12 Work completed -
31NCRMP/B-W/RHB/
PRED/04/Katrenikona/003Road from PR roads to Dasarivanipeta and
to Cyclone Shelter18/2011-12
Dt:27.04.201130-11-2011 30-11-2011 20-01-2012 Work completed -
32NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/04/Karapa/001
Road from Gurajanapalli toBandulavaripalem
24/2011-12Dt:27.04.2011
30-09-2011 31-10-2011 31-01-2012 Work completed -
33NCRMP/B-W/RCS/
PRED/04/Karapa/001Approach Road to cyclone Shelter at
Adavipudi32/2011-12
Dt:20.05.201130-11-2011 31-10-2011 31-01-2012 Work completed -
34NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/004Road from R&B Road to P.Chodipallipeta
CS73/2011-12
Dt:07.09.201106.12.2011 06.03.2012 06.06.2012 Work completed -
35NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/004Road from R&B Road to K.Chodipallipeta
CS73/2011-12
Dt:07.09.201106.12.2011 06.03.2012 06.06.2012 Work completed -
36NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/004Road from R&B Road to Hukumpeta CS
73/2011-12Dt:07.09.2011
06.12.2011 06.03.2012 06.06.2012 Work completed -
37NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/004Road from R&B Road to Gaddipeta CS
73 /2011-12Dt:07.09.2011
06.12.2011 06.03.2012 06.06.2012 Work completed -
RHB
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/03/Paravada/004
RHBNCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/03/Atchutapuram/007
RHB
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/03/Nakkapalli/003
EAST
GO
DAV
ARI
RCS
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/03/Nakkapalli/001
VISA
KHAP
ATN
AM
RCS
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/03/Rambilli/002
2 of 9Page 16 of 49
First Second Third
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t.milestone up to
15.01.2013Remarks
SlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
Names of works under each packageAgreementNo. /Date
38NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/004Road from R&B Road to Danavaipeta CS
73 /2011-12Dt:07.09.2011
06.12.2011 06.03.2012 06.06.2012 Work completed -
39NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/
04/Uppalaguptam/003Road from R&B Road to
Chinaraghavulapeta Cyclone Shelter22.11.2011 22.06.2011 ----------- Work completed -
40Road from NH 214 A at Ranga Statue
centre to Harijanawada of Kalipatnam (E)Work completed -
41R&B road at Panchayat Office toPulaparthivarithota via Badava
Work completed -
42Mogalthuru Vempa R&B Road at UchinthaKalava Bridge to Gogulamma Harijanapeta
Work completed -
43From Narsapur Mogalthur R&B road to
Dayadaldaspeta via Venkateswara Swamytemple
Work completed -
44Road from NH 214 A road to Harijanapeta
of KothotaWork completed -
45R&B road to Indira Nagar (via) Pochamma
templeWork completed -
46 Road from R&B road to Pedalanka Work completed -
47Road from LB Cheria CC road to
Chillapalemm of LB CheriaWork completed -
48From A-U R&B Road toSatyanarayanapuram
Work completed -
49 From A-U R&B Road to Mekaladibba Work completed -
50NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/06/Machipatnam/001Road connecting R&B road through
Gantalammapalem8/2011-
12/27.04.201126.07.2011 26.10.2011 26.01.2012 Work completed -
51 Road from R & B Road to B.V Thota7/2011-
12/27.04.201126.07.2011 26.10.2011 26.01.2012 Work completed -
52Road from Potlapalem Z.P road to
Chikativanipalem7/2011-
12/27.04.201126.07.2011 26.10.2011 26.01.2012 Work completed -
53Road from Intheru R&B Road to
Rangaraopet9/2011-
12/27.04.201126.07.2011 26.10.2011 26.01.2012 Work completed -
54Road from R&B road to Cyclone Shelter
at Chandala9/2011-
12/27.04.201126.07.2011 26.10.2011 26.01.2012 Work completed -
55Road from Bhogireddipalli R&B Road to
Ramakhandam32/2011-12/
Dt.02.09.201101.12.2011 01.03.2012 01.06.2012 Work completed -
56Road from R&B RoadChinnapuram to
Gundupalem32/2011-
12/27.04.201101.12.2011 01.03.2012 01.06.2012 Work completed -
57Road from Potlapalem Z.P road to
Pothepalli.32/2011-12/
Dt.02.09.201101.12.2011 01.03.2012 01.06.2012 Work completed -
RHBNCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/05/Mogaltur/001
16 /2011-12Dt.27.04.2011
RCSNCRMP/B-W
/AP/RCS/PRED/06/Machipatnam/001
EAST
GO
DAV
ARI
RCS
27/4/2011to
22/9/2011
23/9/2011 to
24/2/2012
WES
T G
OD
AVAR
IKR
ISH
NA
25/2/2012to
26/7/2012
RHB
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/05/Narsapur/002
21 /2011-12Dt.09.05.2011
09/05/2011to
04/09/2011
05/09/2011to
06/01/2012
07/01/2011to
08/5/2012
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/05/Kalla/003
26/5/2011 To20/8/2011
20/8/2011to
21/11/2011
22/11/2011To
23/2/2012
RHB
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/06/Machipatnam/002
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/06/Kruthivennu/003
25 /2011-12Dt.26.05.2011
3 of 9Page 17 of 49
First Second Third
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t.milestone up to
15.01.2013Remarks
SlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
Names of works under each packageAgreementNo. /Date
58NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/07/KARLAPALEM/001R/f Ganapavaram R&B
Road to Kesavapuri ST colony7/2011-201227.04.2011
26.7.2011 26.10.2011 26.01.2012 Work completed -
59 R/f R&B Road to Mohammad Alipalem Work completed -
60 R/f R&B Road to Katurivaripalem. Work completed -
61NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/07/PV Palem/001Road from R&B road to Mandevaripalem
2011-20121.11.2011
31.01.2012 30.04.2012 31.07.2012 Work completed -
62 From R&B road toYaramvaripalem 29.02.2012 30.06.2012 31.10.2012 Work completed -
63Road from R&B Road to Pedagollapalem
Cyclone Shelter29.02.2012 30.06.2012 31.10.2012 Work completed -
64Pedagollapalem P.R road to
Bonthagorlapalem29.02.2012 30.06.2012 31.10.2012 work completed -
65 Road from R&B Road to Gurunadhanagar 16.01.2012 16.04.2012 16.07.2012 Work completed -
66Road from R & B Road to Adavala H/O
Bavajipalem16.01.2012 16.04.2012 16.07.2012 Work completed -
67 Road from R & B Road to Atlavaripalem 16.01.2012 16.04.2012 16.07.2012 Work completed -
68Road from R & B Road to
Hanumanthanagar26.01.2012 26.04.2012 26.07.2012 Work completed -
69 Road from R & B Road to Adarsanagar 26.01.2012 26.04.2012 26.07.2012 Work completed -
70Road from Pakala ZP Road toAulavaripalem Cyclone shelter
Work completed -
71 Road from R&B Road to Somarajupalli Work completed -
72 Road from R&B road to Narravaripalem Work completed -
73NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/08/Kothapatnam/003Road from R&B Road Allur to M T Raju
colony
8/26/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
12/26/2011WBM, Grade II
& III
4/26/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furnitureWork completed -
74Road from KEM R&B Road toSankuvarigunta
Work completed -
75Road from KEM R & B Road toPullareddypalem
Work completed -
76NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/08/Ulavapadu/07Road from MC Road to Subbarayudu
Satram
8/26/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
12/26/2011WBM, Grade II
& III
4/26/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furnitureWork completed -
77NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/08/Ulavapadu/08Road from R&B road Tettu to
Ramayapatnam
8/26/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
12/26/2011WBM, Grade II
& III
4/26/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furnitureWork completed -
78NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/Tangutur/10
Road from R&B road to Kesupalem7/18/2011
Earth work, CDwork, GSB
10/18/2011WBM, Grade II
& II
1/18/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furnitureWork completed -
RCSNCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/07/Karlapalem/0022011-20121.11.2011
26.8.2011 26.12.2011
GU
NTU
R
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/S.Konda/001
8/24/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
26.4.2012
RHBNCRMP/B-W/AP/PRED/
07/Nagaram/0028/2011-201227.04.2011
RCS
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/07/Nizampatnam/003
12/24/2011WBM, Grade II
& III
4/24/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furniture
2011-201217.10.2011
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/07/Bapatla/004
2011-201227.10.2011
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/Kothapatnam/004
9/26/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
2/26/2012WBM, Grade II
& III
7/26/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furnitureRHB
PRAK
ASAM
4 of 9Page 18 of 49
First Second Third
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t.milestone up to
15.01.2013Remarks
SlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
Names of works under each packageAgreementNo. /Date
79Road from R&B road to vijayanagar colony
cyclone shelterWork completed -
80 Road from NH road to Challareddypalem Work completed -
81Road from R&B road to jeevaraksh nagar
colony cyclone shelterWork completed -
82Road from R&B road to Ramnagar colony
cyclone shelterWork completed -
83Road from R&B road to cyclone shelter at
MankenavaripalemWork completed -
84Road from R&B Road to Keertivaripalem
cyclone shelterWork completed -
85Road from R&B Road to Devinutalacyclone shelter of chirala mandal in
prakasham district.Work completed -
86 MPCSNCRMP/B-W/APMPCS/
PRED/08/Ulavapadu/001Chakicherla cyclone shelter in Ulavapadu
mandal prakasam district
24.11.2011 Allitems up to stilt
floor slabincluding
ramp,stair casefoundations,columns,beams,pcc flooring etc.,
24.02.2012 Allitems up tosecond floorslab includingfirst floor, andin 2nd floor
including staircase, columns
etc.,
24.05.2012 Head room,plastering, flooring,
water supplyarrangements, sanitryfitting,electrical items,
compound wall, ccpavement. Earthen
mounds (raised portion),water harvesting, septic
tank, slump & soakpit.etc.,
work completed -
87 1. Road from NH5 to Sambhasivapuram work completed -
88Road from 9/6 of Juvvaladinne R&B Roadto 11/0 of Juvvaladinne R&B Road Via
Vekateshpalemwork completed -
89NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/09/CHITTAMURU/003Road from R&B Road to Muttambeka Via
Pittuvanipalla18.01.2011
17.6.20115Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
17.11.2011 10Months: WBMGrII, GrII and
Shoulders
17.4.2012 15 Months:BT and Road
Furniturework completed -
90Road from5/8 of Chennayapalem Road to
Gummadi bandlawork completed -
91Road from pedattapupalem R&B road to
chennyapalam H.wadawork completed -
92Road from K.T R&B Road to
Alliguntapalemwork completed -
93NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/09/VIDAVALURU/0051)Road from KT R&B road to
Allaganipadu to Vavilla27.04.2011
26.9.20115Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
26.2.201210Months: WBMGrII, GrII and
Shoulders
26.7.2012 15Months: BT and Road
Furniturework completed -
5/29/2012shoulders, Gr-
III
9/29/2012 BT, CCpavement and road
furniture
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09/BOGOLO/RHB/001
19-01-20115Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
RCS
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/08/Vetapalem/001
1/29/2012Earth work,
GSB
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/08/Chirala/002
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09/RHB/KAVALI/004
17.01.2011
16.6.20115Months: Earthwork,
CDWorks,ccpavem
ent and GSB
16.11.2011 10Months: WBMGrII, GrII and
Shoulders
16.4.2012 15Months: BT and Road
Furniture
PRAK
ASAM
NEL
LORE
RHB
10 Months:WBM GrII,GrIIand Shoulders
15 Months: BT andRoad Furniture
5 of 9Page 19 of 49
First Second Third
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t.milestone up to
15.01.2013Remarks
SlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
Names of works under each packageAgreementNo. /Date
94NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09V.CHALEM/RHB/007
Road from Suvepalli-Pudiparthi road toSrikanth Colony
27.04.2011
26.8.20114Months: EarthWork, PipeCulverts,GSB
26.12.2011 8Months: WBMGrII, GrII andShoulders
26.4.2012 12 Months:BT and RoadFurniture
work completed -
95NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/
09/Allur/009Road from R&B road Alluru to Galidibbalu
(via) Chukavani dibba24.01.2011
23.6.20115Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
23.11.2011 10Months: WBMGrII,GrII and
Shoulders
23.4.2012 15 Months:BT and Road
Furniturework completed -
96Ring Road to TP Gudur- Salipeta R & B
Road via CS Puram and Mandapam Villagework completed -
97Road from R & B Road C S Puram to
Sivaramapuramwork completed -
98NCRMP/B-W/AP/PRED/
09/kota/RCS/001Road from R&B road to A.S PURAM work completed -
99NCRMP/B-W/AP/PRED/
09/kota/RCS/001Road from GD Road to Vavillapalem work completed -
100NCRMP/B-W/AP/PRED/
09/MUTHUKUR/RCS/002Road from R&B Road kappaladoruvu to
bandla palem H.wada21.04.2011
20.7.20113Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
20.10.2011 6Months: WBMGrII, GrII, CCPavement and
Shoulders
20.1.2012 9 Months:BT CC road and Road
Furniturework completed -
101NCRMP/B-W/AP/PRED/09/Chillakur/RCS/004
Road from kakuvaripalem R&B road tovellapalm
23.05.2011
22.8.20113Months: Earth
Work,CDWorks,GSB
22.11.2011 6Months: WBMGrII, GrII and
Shoulders
22.2.2012 9 Months:BT, CC Pavement and
Road Furniturework completed -
102NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/09/T.P.GUDUR/005Road from7/2 M.C Road to
venkannapalem pattapupalem17.05.2011
16.8.20113Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
16.11.2011 6Months: WBM
GrII, GrIIShoulders andCC Pavement
16.2.2012 9 Months:BT, CC Pavement and
Road Furniturework completed -
103NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/09/KAVALI/006
Road Connecting R&B Road throughVoturu Village in SPSR Nellore District.
21.09.2011
20.1.2012 4Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,
GSB
20.5.2012 4Months: WBM
GrII, GrII,Shoulders andCC Pavement
20.9.2012 4 Months:BT, CC Pavement and
Road Furniturework completed -
104NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/
09/KAVALI/007
Road from Kotha satram R&B toIndrsanagar (via) Thumalapenta palam
,Patharavadu palam ,Ramudu palam,Karaduvari palam &Sreeramapuram in
SPSR Nellore District.
29.08.2011
28.12.20114Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
28.4.2012 4Months: WBM
GrII, GrII,Shoulders andCC Pavement
28.8.2012 4 Months:BT, CC Pavement and
Road Furniturework completed -
105NCRMP/B-W/AP/PRED/
09/D.V.SATRAM/RCS/008Road from R&B road to sullurpeta mallam
to berijengalapalli cyclone shelter09.05.2011
8.8.20113Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
8.11.2011 6Months: WBM
GrII, GrIIShoulders andCC Pavement
8.2.2012 9 Months:BT, CC Pavement and
Road Furniturework completed -
RCS
18.2.2012 9 Months:BT and Road
Furniture
10.05.2011
9.8.20113Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
9.11.11 6Months: WBMGrII,GrII and
Shoulders
9.2.2012 9 Months:BT, CC Pavement and
Road Furniture
NEL
LORE
RHB
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/009/T.P.GUDUR/012
19.05.2011
18.8.20113Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
18.11.2011 6Months: WBMGrII, GrII, CCPavement and
Shoulders
RCS
6 of 9Page 20 of 49
First Second Third
1NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/
01/Polaki/006Road from R&B road Mobagam to
Duubakavanipeta via Gajapathinagaram/2010-11, Dt.30.04.2011
30.08.11 31.12.11 30.04.12First Milestone i.e Earthwork & Cd
works &GSB
300 mts CC road completed,GSB laying is in progress,road formation width varyfrom 6.00mts to 7.50mts
2NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/
01/Polaki/005Road from R&B road Edulavalasa - Killam
to Jonnam via Talasamudram/2011-12, Dt.30.04.2011
31.07.11 31.10.11 31.01.12First Milestone i.e Earthwork & Cd
works &GSB
BT layer completed from Km5/670 to Km 7/270, and WBMGr- III metal collection is inprogress from Km 5/000 to
Km 5/670
3 BridgesNCRMP/B-W/ AP/Br/R&B/01/
Patnavanipeta/001
Construction of bridge at Km 11/6-8 of NH-5 to Patnavanipeta Connecting
Sundarapalem
46/2011, Dt.17.12.2010
17.08.11 17.01.12 17.06.12 Completion of entire work
Slab A2-pier completed andSlab A1-pier sis in progress,Approach road e/w, GSB,
WMM, SDBC completed. CD,Retainingwall completed.
4Construction of Cyclone shelter at
KollipaduG.o rt No 451 dt
06.04.201007.03.12 07.08.12 07.01.13 Completion of stilt floor & first floor Silt floor level slab completed.
5 Construction of Cyclone Shelter at RunkuG.o rt No 451 dt
06.04.201007.03.12 07.08.12 07.01.13 Completion of stilt floor & first floor
Upto plinth beam completed,and columns above plinth
beam is in progress
6NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/
02/Puligadda/007
Construction of Minor Bridge at Km. 7/2near Puligadda of Konada –
Ramatheertham R&B Road toKonathalapalem via Yerukonda, Pasupam,
Kollayavalasa (Z.P. Road)
31/2010-2011Dt. 01.12.2010
30.06.11 31.01.12 31.05.12 NCR PendingAs against of 100 % in the
3rd Milestone
7NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/
02/Chakaligadda/008
Construction of Minor Bridge at Km 15/2near Chakaligedda of KonadaRamatheertham R&B road to
Konatalapalem (via) Yerukonda, Pasupam,Kollayavalasa (ZP Road)
34/2010-2011Dt. 08.12.2010
07.07.11 07.02.12 07.06.1295% of work completed;
NCR Pending
Minor deviation approval isawaited. It takes 15 days time
to complete the work afterdeviation approval
8Construction of cyclone shelter at
Gajapathi Nagaram/2011-12, Dt.03.10.2011
05.06.12 05.10.12 05.02.13
Plinth beam & Staircase, Stilt floorslab, First floor slab, ramp slabs are
completed,Ceiling plastering andBrick masonry work is in progress.
EOAT submitted on 24.08.12
likely to be completed beforeMarch.2013
9Construction of cyclone shelter at
Ratnayampeta/2011-12, Dt.03.10.2011
02.02.12 02.06.12 02.10.12
All Slabs are completed. Inside andoutside wall plastering work
completed.White cementapplications,wood joinery , Electrical
works and compound wall workare to be progress.
likely to be completed before15.02.2013
10NCRMP/B-W/AP/MPCS/PRED/03/Nakkapalli/002
Construction of cyclone shelter atPatimeeda
/2011-12, Dt.03.10.2011
02.03.12 02.08.12 02.01.13
Plinth beam & Staircase, Stilt floorslab, First floor slab, ramp slabs arecompleted .IInd floor slab form workto be progress EOAT submitted on
24.08.12
likely to be completed beforeMarch.2013
STATEMENT SHOWING THE LIST OF NCRMP YEAR-1 WORKS WHICH ARE IN PROGRESS AND AUDITING IS TO BE DONE UP TO 15-01-2013Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t. milestone up to
30.05.2012Remarks
VISA
KHAP
ATN
AM
Names of works under each packageAgreement No.
/Date
NCRMP/B_W/AP/MPCS/PRED/01/Santhabommalli/005
NCRMP/B-W/AP/MPCS/PRED/03/Payakaraopeta/003
Bridges
VIZI
ANAG
ARAM
MPCS
SRIK
AKU
LAM
RHB
SlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
MPCS
Page 21 of 49
First Second Third
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t. milestone up to30.05.2012
RemarksNames of works under each packageAgreement No.
/DateSlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
11Construction of cyclone shelter at
Mullaparra/2011-12, Dt.03.10.2011
02.03.12 02.08.12 02.01.13
Stilt Slab & stilt floor, First floor andhead room slabs are completed.
ceiling plastering work and first floorbrick work are in progress.
likely to be completed beforeMarch.2013
12Construction of cyclone shelter at
Bangarrampeta/2011-12, Dt.03.10.2011
02.03.12 02.08.12 02.01.13
Stilt floor, First floor, second floor,Head room slabs are completed. Istfloor and second floor brick masonry
work and plastering work are inprogress.
likely to be completed beforeMarch.2013
13NCRMP/B-
W/AP/MPCS/PRED/03/Rambillii/004
Construction of cyclone shelter atVenkayyapalem
/2011-12, Dt.03.10.2011
02.01.12 02.04.12 02.07.12
Plinth beam completed and fillingunder floorcompleted.Stilt floor slab
form work tobe progress. EOATproposals submitted on 29.06.12.
likely to be completed beforeJune.2013
15NCRMP/B-W/AP/MPCS/PRED/
03/Parawada/001Construction of cyclone shelter at
Tikkavanipalem/2011-12, Dt.07.10.2011
06.01.12 06.04.12 06.07.12Work not started due to site
problem
15 RCSNCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/004Road from R&B Road to G.Musalayyapeta
CS73/2011-12
Dt:07.09.201106.12.2011 06.03.2012 06.06.2012 Nil Not yet Started
16NCRMP/B-W/AP/MPCS/
PRED/04/Uppalaguptam/002
Construction of Cyclone Shelter atPedaraghavulapeta of Uppalaguptam
Mandal E.G.Dt.
78/2011-12Dt:17.10.2011
16.01.2012 16.04.2012 16.07.2012 30%Likely to be completed by
June 2013
17NCRMP/B-W/AP/MPCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/001Construction of Cyclone Shelter at
Laxamanudupadu inThondangi77/2011-12
Dt:07.09.201116.02..2012 16.06.2012 16.10.2012 75%
Likely to be completed byMarch 2013
18NCRMP/B-W/AP/MPCS/
PRED/04/Thondangi/001Construction of Cyclone Shelter at
Avulamanda77/2011-12
Dt:07.09.201116.02.2012 16.06.2012 16.10.2012 75%
Likely to be completed byMarch 2013
19NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/07/Bapatla/010
Reconstructuion of Highlevel Bridge@Km5/2 of Bapatla-Suryalaka Road across
perli drain in Guntur Dt.
79/2010-20111.12.2010
31.5.2011 30.11.2011 31.5.2012Likely to be completed by end of Jan
2013NCR Pending
20NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/07/Bapatla/011
Reconstructuion of Highlevel Bridge@Km2/4 of Bapatla-PandurangapuramRoad across perli drain in Guntur Dt.
78/2010-20111.12.2010
31.5.2011 30.11.2011 31.5.2012Buildings are to be removed in theapproaches. Amount was paid to
RDO Tenali towards compensation.
Likely to be completed beforeMarch 2013
21NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/
PRED/07/PV Palem/001Road from R&B Road Alluru to
Yadavapalem31.01.2012 30.04.2012 31.07.2012
From Km 0.574 to km 0.964 CCcompleted.
Likely to be completed beforeFeb 2013
22Road from Ganapavaram R&B Road to
Pedamarpuvaripalem29.02.2012 30.06.2012 31.10.2012 WBM Gr-III completed.
Likely to be completed beforeJan 2013
23Road from R&B Road toChinapuluguvaripalem
29.02.2012 30.06.2012 31.10.2012CC completed, shoulders is to be
done.Likely to be completed before
Jan 2013
24 BridgesNCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/ R&B/08/
Kanaparthi/012
Construction of High level Bridge at Km16/10 of Naguluppalapadu – Kanaparthi
road in Prakasam District
5/31/2011Completion up
to sill level
12/31/2011Completion up tobelow deck slab
5/31/2012 Completionof entire work
including approches
Work completedNCR Pending
As per milestone completed
25 RHBNCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/Tangutur/09
Road from R&B road Pellur toVasepallipadu
7/15/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
11/15/2011WBM, Grade II &
III
3/15/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furniture
Work completedNCR Pending
As per milestone completed
VISA
KHAP
ATN
AM
MPCS
2011-20121.11.2011
RCS
GU
NTU
R
MPCS
EAST
GO
DAV
ARI
NCRMP/B-W/AP/MPCS/PRED/03/Nakkapalli/002
PRAK
ASAM
Bridges
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/07/Karlapalem/002
Page 22 of 49
First Second Third
Milestone Completion Dates Progress w.r.t. milestone up to30.05.2012
RemarksNames of works under each packageAgreement No.
/DateSlNo
District
Category
Packages allotted underPhase - 1
26 Road from NH5 to MulaguntapaduWBM-Grade-III Layer Completed.OGPC + Seal Coat To be taken up
work is not going on
27 Road from R&B road to ChalivendradibbaWBM-Grade-III Layer Completed.OGPC + Seal Coat To be taken up
work is not going on
28Road from Pakala R&B road to
MosanaladinneWBM-Grade-III material laying work
is in progresslikely to be completed before
Feb 2013
29Road from R&B road to Binginapalli
Harijanawada Cyclone ShelterCC road work is completed.
Shoulders work is to be taken up.likely to be completed before
Jan 2013
30 MPCSNCRMP/B-W/APMPCS/PRED/08/NG Padu/003
Kanaparthy cyclone shelter inNagulappapadu mandal prakasam district
23.11.2011 Allitems up to stilt
floor slabincluding
ramp,stair casefoundations,columns,beams,pcc flooring etc.,
23.02.2012 Allitems up to firstfloor slab and
head room slb in2 nd floor
including staircase, columns
etc.,
23.05.2012 plastering,flooring, water supplyarrangements, sanitryfitting,electrical items,
compound wall, ccpavement. Earthen
mounds(raised portion),water harvesting, septictank, slump and soak
pit.etc.,
Work completed; NCR pending Not as per Milestone
31NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09/BOGOLU/002
Road from 1/6 of Zuvvaladinne R&B Roadto Tellagunta KM to 2/720
07.02.2011
6.5,20113Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
6.8.2011 6Months: WBMGrII, GrII and
Shoulders
6.11.20119 Months:BT and Road Furniture
OGPC+ Seal coat completedNCR Pending
completed
32NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/
PRED/09/CHITTAMURU/003Road from R&B Chittamur to Soma
Samudram18.01.2011
17.6.20115Months: EarthWork, PipeCulverts,GSB
17.11.2011 10Months: WBMGrII, GrII andShoulders
17.4.2012 15 Months:BT and Road Furniture
OGPC+ Seal coat completedNCR Pending
completed
33NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09/VIDAVALURU/005
Road from R&B road Kancharlapalam HWto Alaganipadu.
WBM Gr-III is in progress & CDWorks completed.
77%
34NCRMP/B-W/AP/PRED/
09/MUTHUKUR/RHB/006Road from R&B road to Patuvarikandriga 25.4.11
24.7.20113Months: Earth
Work, PipeCulverts,GSB
24.10.2011 6Months: WBMGrII, GrII, CCPavement and
Shoulders
24.1.2012 9 Months:BT and Road Furniture
OGPC+ Seal coat completedNCR Pending
35NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09V.CHALEM/RHB/007
providing BT Surface to the road fromR&B road to Edagali kandriga
27.04.2011
26.8.20114Months: EarthWork, PipeCulverts,GSB
26.12.2011 8Months: WBMGrII, GrII andShoulders
26.4.2012 12 Months:BT and Road Furniture
Work completedNCR Pending
36Providing BT road to Pedapannam gadu
in Tada Mandal
14.02.2013(5Months)
Earth Work,Pipe Culverts,GSB & CC road
13.06.2013 (4Months): WBM
GrII,GrIIShoulders
13.09.2012(3 Months)BT and Road
FurnitureWBM Gr-II work is in progress 59%
37Road from @ 56/8 to C.K road to
Periyavettu kuppam cyclone shelter
14.02.2013(5Months)
Earth Work,Pipe Culverts,GSB & CC road
13.06.2013 (4Months): WBM
GrII, GrIIShoulders
13.09.2012(3 Months)BT and Road
Furniture
Sub grade with selected earth is inprogress
5.88%
PRAK
ASAM
RHB
NEL
LORE
6/9/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
10/9/2011 WBM,Grade II & III
2/9/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furniture
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/S.Konda/002
6/9/2011Earth work, CD
work, GSB
10/9/2011 WBM,Grade II & III
2/9/2012 BT,Shoulders & road
furniture
NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/09/TADA/009
14.09.2012RCS
RHB
RHBNCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/S.Konda/002
Page 23 of 49
QUARTERLY SUMMARY REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
LIST OF NCR'S PENDING FOR NCRMP WORKS TO THE END OF DECEMBER 2012
Sl.No
Distric
t
sl.no
Date ofInspecti
onName of Work/Package No. Observation Remarks Status
1
VIZ
INA
GA
RA
M
1
06.04.12
Construction of Minor Bridge at Km15/2 near Chakaligadda of KonadaRamatheertham R&B road toKonathalapalem (via) Yerukonda,Pasupam, Kollayavalsa (ZP Road)NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/02/Chakaligadda/008
Revetment, Apron stone samples arecollected and verified for size andweight. Some samples are notsatisfying the requirements of MORT& H Clause 2504.Required minimumweight is 40 kgs and minimum size is300 MM minimum.
NCR-2 Issued to takesuitable remedialaction beforeproceeding withfurther layers.
The Contractor toldthat the under sizestones will be removedand repacked withsuitable stones as peragreement. NCRPending.
2 2
25.07.12
Construction of Minor Bridge at Km.7/2 near Puligedda of Konada –Ramatheertham R&B Road toKonathalapalem via Yerukonda,Pasupam, Kollayavalsa (Z.P. Road)NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/02/Puligedda/007
Rain cuts and gullies are formed inshoulder portion. Shoulders aredisturbed at some places. The sameshall be rectified.
NCR-3 Issued to takesuitable remedialaction beforeproceeding withfurther work.
The Contractorintimated that thegullies will be rectifiedby filling, compactingand sectioning theslopes after thecompletion of Raineyseason. NCR Pending.
3
GU
NTU
R
1 30.10.12 Reconstruction of HLB @ km5/2 ofBapatla - Suryalanka road acrossperali drain in Guntur DtPackage No.: NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/07/Bapatla/010.
Revetment thickness is varying from220 mm to 275 mm as against thespecified thickness 300 mm. rectifythe same before tacking up thegrouting.
NCR-13 Issued, R&BDepartment officers isrequest to takesuitable remedialaction beforepreceding the furtherwork.
NCR Pending
4
PR
AK
ASA
M
1
01.09.12
Road from R&B road Pellur toVasepallipadu. NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/Tangutur/09
The sign boards which are providedin site are not semi reflective. Semireflective sign boards are to beprovided as per agreement.
NCR-27 Issued, PRDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken beforeproceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
Page 24 of 49
QUARTERLY SUMMARY REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
5 2
11.10.12
Construction Thoupula Kanaparthycyclone shelter in Nagulappapadumandal Prakasam districtNCRMP/B-W/APMPCS/PRED/08/NGPadu/003
1. Street light fittings are not ofapproved brand specified in theagreement.2. Exhaust fans (2no's) of 225mmsize are provided whereas theagreement specifies 300mm size.3. For ceiling fans & tube lightsceiling roses are not provided.
NCR-32 Issued, PRDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken beforeproceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
6 3
19.10.12
Construction of High level Bridge atKm 16/10 of Naguluppalapadu –Kanaparthi road in PrakasamDistrict NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/08/Kanaparthi/012
Rain cuts & dip gullies are formed inthe bridge approaches. Shoulders aredisturbed at many places. The sameshall be rectified immediately.
NCR-33 Issued, R & BDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken beforeproceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
7 4
21.11.12
Construction of High level Bridge atKm 16/10 of Naguluppalapadu –Kanaparthi road in PrakasamDistrict NCRMP/B-W/AP/Br/R&B/08/Kanaparthi/012
Grouted rough stone revetment workfor quadrants is damaged, deepgullies are formed in the bridgeapproaches and shoulders aredisturbed at many places (NCR no-33). These damages shall be rectifiedimmediately and compliance reportfurnished.
NCR-34 Issued R & BDepartment officers isinform to take suitableremedial action beforeproceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
8 5
28.11.12
Road from Pakala R&B road toMosanaladinneNCRMP/BW/AP/RHB/PRED/08/S.Konda/002
WBM Grade-III layer is badlydisturbed in the stretch km 0/000 tokm 0/450 which is to be rectifiedimmediately and compliancefurnished.
NCR-35 Issued, P RDepartment officers isinforming to takesuitable remedialaction beforeproceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
9 6
28.11.12
Road from NH5 to MulaguntapaduNCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/08/S.Konda/002
WBM Grade-III layer is badly disturbedin the stretches from km 0/000 to km0/310 and from km 0/400 to km 0/600.The disturbed stretches are to berectified immediately and compliancefurnished.
NCR-36 Issued, P RDepartment officers isrequested to takesuitable remedial actionbefore proceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
Page 25 of 49
QUARTERLY SUMMARY REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
10N
ELLO
RE
1 18.07.12 Road from 1/6 of Zuvvaladinne R&BRoad to Tellagunta NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/ 09/BOGOLU/001
1. Non Reflective type sign boards areprovided. As per agreementspecifications all the sign boards shallbe semi reflective in nature. Suitableremedial action is to be taken up2. in KM 1/6, big hole is left inbetween road and sluice head wall. it isvery dangerous to the public.Immediate protective action she betaken to prevent accidents.
NCR-14 Issued, PRDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken beforeproceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
11 2 17.07.12 Road from R&B road to PatuvariKandriga NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09/MUTHUKUR/006
Sump is constructed in the formationwidth of the road near slab culvertlocation in km 0/200. Proper safetymeasures shall be taken to avoidaccidents
NCR-28 Issued, PRDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken before proceedingwith further work.
NCR Pending
12 3
17.08.12
Road from R&B Chittamur to SomaSamudram NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09/CHITTAMURU/003
l)At Km 1.380(RHs),collection chamberhas to be covered with suitablemeasures to avoid accident.2.At Km 1.250(LHS)a deep ditch existat the BT edge where a water Bump islocated. It is hazardous to the roaduser and it shall be protected bysuitable arrangements
NCR-29 Issued, PRDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken beforeproceeding withfurther work.
NCR Pending
13 4
17.08.12
Providing BT Surface to the Road tothe Road from R&B Road to EdagaliKandriga NCRMP/B-W/AP/RHB/PRED/09/Chalam/007
At Km 0,010(RHs), uncovered waterpump chamber is located on theshoulder of the road. It has to becovered immediately
NCR-30 Issued, PRDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken before proceedingwith further work.
NCR Pending
14 5
08.10.12
Road Connecting R&B Roadthrough Voturu Village in SPSRNellore District. NCRMP/B-W/AP/RCS/PRED/09/KAVALI/006
Road is badly damaged in somestretches from km 1/8 to km 2/6.Thorough rectification is to be done
NCR-31 Issued, PRDepartment officersinform that suitableremedial action will betaken before proceedingwith further work.
NCR Pending
Page 26 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
6.0 DISTRICT WISE STATUS OF TESTS CONDUCTED BY TPQA
Apart from monitoring the tests being conducted by the implementation team (contractors & Line department) at various
stages, the Third party Quality Audit team also conducted tests to confirm its compliance with the standards. These tests
are carried out in the site itself and in some cases samples are collected and testing done in outside laboratories. The
details of tests conducted in the field till end of December 2012 are presented.
Summary of QC Tests - Up to 31.12.2012
S.No. DistrictNo. Tests
Conductedduring the
Month
Total no. of TestsCumulativeTests Done
Total no. of Tests
Passed Failed Passed Failed
1 Srikakulam 82 82 0 1475 1469 6
2 Vizianagaram 4 4 0 461 461 0
3 Visakhapatnam 106 106 0 2237 2191 46
4 East Godavari 54 54 0 1128 1128 0
5 West Godavari 0 0 0 349 349 0
6 Krishna 3 3 0 85 85 0
7 Guntur 23 23 0 606 595 11
8 Prakasam 6 6 0 1905 1901 4
9 Nellore 81 81 0 1174 1153 21
Total 359 359 0 9420 9332 88
Average Number of tests conducted for each work was - “66”.
Page 27 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
7.0. TASKS CARRIED OUT BY THE CONSULTANT
The scopes of services for the Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) assignment areA. As per Appendix–A, Cl.8a: Consultants are regularly assisting the PIU in maintaining good quality standards at
various stages during construction by both Panchayat Raj and R&B Departments.
B. As per Appendix–A, Cl.8b: Compliance with the requirements of environment and social frame works including
measures provided is regularly being monitored and regular reports are being submitted.
C. As per Appendix–A, Cl.9: Consultants conducted a preliminary review of standard documents, drawings,
specifications, material reports and status of works etc; as desired.
D. As per Appendix–A, Cl.10: Consultants are following the conditions scrupulously. Electrical drawings were not
furnished by the design consultant for Multi-Purpose cyclone Shelters. To save delay, TPQA Consultant has prepared
drawings of electrical wiring for Multi-purpose cyclone shelters (Type-A, B, C &D) as per SPIU instructions.
E. As per Appendix–A, Cl.11: Consultant has submitted Inception report on 09.08.2011.
F. As per Appendix–A, Cl.12 a: Audit plan was submitted along with inception report. All sites are being audited at least
once during each stage.
G. As per Appendix–A, Cl.12 b: Execution of audits are in accordance with the approach and methodology as mentioned
in inception report and Quality Assurance Plan.
H. As per Appendix–A, Cl.13: Quality is being assessed independently by the Consultant vis-a vis the standards
specified in the bidding documents and good engineering practices including disaster resistant construction standards.
I. As per Appendix–A, Cl.14: Consultants are reviewing the degree of quality control exercised during the
construction by the contractor in maintaining adequate arrangements / practices (tests, numbers, frequency, approach
and timing etc.) / documentation (QC registers, test reports, observations of supervisory staff, compliances etc) and
the degree of monitoring done by the line department. Identifying non-compliances and suggesting necessary
improvements and compliance methodologies for all the works.
J. As per Appendix–A, Cl.15: Consultants have reviewed the material procured in accordance with quality
standards. All the stipulations are being followed for all the works. The details are being given in QCRs, WPRs, MPRs,
Check memos attached to invoices and QPRs etc.
K. As per Appendix–A, Cl.16: Consultants have carried out some additional tests like Alkali Aggregate reaction tests,
mortar jar tests, core tests for CC roads, Chemical tests on steel and SBC confirmatory tests at foundation level etc.
as per SPIU’s instructions.
L. As per Appendix–A, Cl.17: Consultants are issuing NCRs as and when non compliance is observed and after
compliance is achieved the NCR is being closed. NCR status report is also being submitted regularly.
M. As per Appendix–A, Cl.18: TPQA is facilitating the PIU in rectifying the defects instead of merely pointing out the
mistakes. The TPQA consultant is acting as a fault preventing mission rather than a fault finding team.
Page 28 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
N. As per Appendix–A, Cl.19: Consultants are maintaining photo documentation, including geo-tagging, for all the
works district wise and work wise. Photos are uploaded to Picasa web album and links are being sent to SPIU and
World Bank TL etc.; Also a DVD is being submitted every month with all the photos. In the MPRs and QPRs photos
are being included. As per SPIU’s instructions, photos are attached to QCRs also. TPQA was not provided with any
platform or website for uploading the photos or documents. Hence, TPQA has opened an internet blog,
http://apncrmptpqa.wordpress.com and placing the documents and photos for viewing and downloading.
O. As per Appendix–A, Cl.20: Environment and Social reports covering Environment Management Plan (EMP),
Resettlement Action Plans (RAP), Environment laws / regulations of Govt. of India and rules formulated by the
concerned State Government, Labor laws/ regulations applicable to construction sites, Safety management at the
construction sites as per the relevant IS codes such as (but not limited to) IS 3764: Code of safety for excavation work
(first revision), IS:5916: Safety code for construction involving use of hot bituminous materials etc. Specifications of
agencies like Indian Road Congress, Ministry of Shipping and Road Transport, Central Public Health Engineering
Organization, Bureau of Indian Standards, Ministry of Rural Development (MORD), Ministry of Road Transport and
Highways (MORTH) etc as applicable. All these aspects are being looked into for all the ongoing works and reports
are submitted at regular intervals.
P. As per Appendix–A, Cl.21: Consultants have Inspected, reviewed the adequacy of contractor’s staff, labor and
machinery etc.; No contractors work program was given to the TPQA for review. However during TPQA inspections
the work progress/program is being reviewed with the line departmental officers and contractors present.
Q. As per Appendix–A, Cl.22: Consultants have reviewed the works progress in accordance with agreed milestones
and work schedules and provide regular updates including need for increasing resources and / or change in work plan
for timely execution. The related observations are given in detail in QCRs reported.
R. As per Appendix–A, Cl.23: Once the compliance to NCR is satisfied and its confirmation by TPQA, the NCR is
being closed.
S. As per Appendix–A, Cl.24: All the apparatus and equipment for the field testing were procured and all the details
are furnished in inventory reported. As and when necessary, samples are being tested in accredited / approved
laboratories.
T. As per Appendix–A, Cl.25: In case any specific quality testing is required by the PIU for any work within the site,
they are being carried out.
U. As per Appendix–A, Cl.26: Sampling is being done in the presence of Engineer / Contractor. All possible site tests
are being conducted in site in their presence. And the process is being photo documented with geo tagging also.
V. As per Appendix–A, Cl.27: The Consultants are using approved laboratories / Engineering college laboratories in
the region. Mostly reputed engineering colleges like Bapatla Engineering college, Kakinada Engineering college,
Andhra University Engineering college, Gitam Engineering college and Civil Aid Techno clinical Laboratories,
Hyderabad.
W. As per Appendix–A, Cl.29: Consultants are also visiting sites randomly without prior information to the contractor
or line department.
Page 29 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
X. As per Appendix–A, Cl.30: ‘stop work’ notice to the contractors and assist in remedying the defects. For the work
of construction of MPCS at Kollipadu, bulging and apparent sagging of beams is noticed after removing the shuttering.
Stop the work order was issued and the line department and the contractor were asked to ensure structural safety
before proceeding. Beam load tests were conducted under the supervision of Andhra University (Government of AP)
Consultancy services in the presence of TPQA engineers, contractor’s representative and line departmental officers.
As the deflection is found to be lesser than the permissible deflection, stop work order was revoked and further work is
going on.
Y. As per Appendix–A, Cl.33: The Consultant would facilitate the implementing agencies in uploading the site visit
reports, audit findings, suggested corrective action, status of completion of corrective action etc. in the project
monitoring system or in such monitoring system that may be designed for NCRMP. Consultants are sending reports
by e-mail as MIS site provided by Client has some technical problems. TPQA has opened an internet blog,
http://apncrmptpqa.wordpress.com and placing the documents and photos for viewing and downloading.
Page 30 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
8.0 REPORTING REQUIREMENT
The Consultant shall prepare following reports and submit five (5) copies to the PIU of the following reportsand documents in English:
Table – 2.4: Schedule of Submission of Reports
S.No. Reports Schedule of submission
No. copiesto besubmitted
1 Inception Report Within 30 days of signing the contract -
2 Audit strategy Within 1 month of signing the contract (for the first
year) as part of Inception Report.
Next years-Within 7 days from end of financial year
(subsequent years)
-
3 Quality Assurance Plan and
Reporting Formats
By the end of 2nd Month -
4 Weekly Audit Report Within 3 days of completion of week. -
5Non compliance event
report/ Critical issue reports
Immediate -
6 Monthly progress report Within seven days of the end of reporting month -
7 Quarterly Summary Report Within 15 days from end of quarter -
8 Annual Review Report Within 15 days from end of financial year -
9
Final Review Report Three months prior to winding up of the Project or
completion of the Consultant’s contract, whichever
is earlier
-
10
Presentation to the SPIU on
the findings of the audit and
suggestions
Every quarter -
Page 31 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
So far the consultants have submitted the following reports to the Client:
1. Inception Report An Inception report was submitted on 26.07.2011 containing approach and
methodology. And the revised Inception was submitted on 09.08.2011.
2. Audit strategy An Inception report containing Audit strategy (Audit planning & scheduling) report
was submitted on 09.08.2011.
3. Quality Assurance Plan and Reporting Formats: Submitted on 18.08.2011,Revised plan submitted incorporating
World bank & SPIU suggestions on 25.11.2011 ( 3 Volumes of QAP)
4. Weekly Audit Report Weekly Audit reports were being submitted
5. Noncompliance event report/ Critical issue reports NCR statement are being submitted every month along
with the Monthly Progress Reports.
6. Monthly Report Consultants have Submitted monthly progress reports till May, Details are as
given below:
1 Monthly Progress Report for the month of September 2011 27.10.2011
2 Monthly Progress Report for the month of October 2011 15.11.2011
3 Monthly Progress Report for the month of November 2011 14.12.2011
4 Monthly Progress Report for the month of December 2011 09.01.2012
5 Monthly Progress Report for the month of January 2012 08.02.2012
6 Monthly Progress Report for the month of February 2012 12.03.2012
7 Monthly Progress Report for the month of March 2012 09.04.2012
8 Monthly Progress Report for the month of April 2012 05.05.2012
9 Monthly Progress Report for the month of May 2012 05.06.2012
10 Monthly Progress Report for the month of June 2012 09.07.2012
11 Monthly Progress Report for the month of July 2012 16.08.2012
12 Monthly Progress Report for the month of August 2012 06.09.2012
Page 32 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
13 Monthly Progress Report for the month of September 2012 05.10.2012
14 Monthly Progress Report for the month of October 2012 06.11.2012
15 Monthly Progress Report for the month of November 2012 03.12.2012
16 Monthly Progress Report for the month of December 2012 04.01.2013
7. Quarterly Report Consultants have Submitted Quarterly progress reports till May 2012
1 Quarterly Progress Report for the months of June, July and August 2011 15.09.2011
2 Quarterly Progress Report for the month of September, October, November and December
201125.01.2012
3 Quarterly Progress Report for the months of January, February and March 2012 18.04.2012
4 Quarterly Progress Report for the months of April, May and June 2012 13.07.2012
5 Quarterly Progress Report for the months of July, August and September 2012 08.10.2012
6 Quarterly Progress Report for the month of October, November and December 2012 08.01.2013
8. Presentation to the SPIU on the findings of the audit and suggestions
Consultants are giving presentations at various locations with PPT. Conducted 2 times in Hyderabad dated
11.01.2012 and 13.04.2012. In Visakhapatnam also twice conducted dates are 19.010.2011 and 22.09.2011. And
also conducted in Guntur on 20.09.2011.
“Ok Cards” are being issued at every stage of work in case the work is found qualitatively and quantitatively
satisfactory.
So far one case of "Stop Work" notice was issued for MPCS at Kollipadu in Srikakulam District.
Photo documentation with Geo-Tagging presentations attached with MPRs and QPRs. Now photos are being
attached to QC Reports also
9. Details of Trainings conducted on key audit findings, construction techniques, social & environmentalmanagement aspects etc:-
i. Convened QA Workshop for Engineers and Contractors of 9 Districts at Vijayawada on 28.06.2011.
Page 33 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
ii. Convened Workshop for TPQA staff at our office on 06.08.2011.
iii. Attended Workshop for Contractors and Engineers of 5 districts at Guntur on 20.09.2011.
iv. Convened QA Workshop for Engineers and Contractors of Prakasham District on 29.10.2011 at Ongole.
v. Conducted Training Programme for TPQA Staff at Vijayawada on 23.01.2012.
vi. Convened QA Workshop for Engineers at Guntur on 26.04.2012.
vii. Convened QA Workshop for PR Engineers and Contractors at Z.P meeting hall, Nellore on 23.05.2012 for SPSR
Nellore district.
viii. Convened QA workshop for PRED Engineers in ZP meeting hall, Kakinada on 04.08.2012.
ix. Convened QA workshop for PRED Engineers in ZP meeting hall, Srikakulam on 26.09.2012.
In all the workshops convened by TPQA consultant, presentations were given on maintaining good quality
standards in the construction for various items of roads, bridges and Multi-purpose Cyclone Shelters. Special focus
was given on the ongoing works and the areas of improvement required. Suggestions were also given for better
construction methodology. All the agreement specifications of the works were explained in detail along with quality
requirements. Importance was given for interaction with the participants and all their doubts are clarified. Copies of
Presentations were also distributed to the participants. The response for all the workshops is very good and it was
reaffirmed during the World Bank ISR mission review meeting at Hyderabad on 23-11-2012.
Page 34 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
Immediately after concluding the agreement on31st May, 2011, TPQA Consultant has mobilized the team veryquickly and inspected all the works, which were in progress at that time, before 15-06-2011 as per the wishes ofthe Project Director.
All the contract documents were obtained from the PIU officers and perused the specifications stipulated in them.A booklet (QAP Volume III) of technical presentations covering all the construction and quality aspects of ruralroads, R&B roads, bridges and cyclone shelters, was prepared for distribution.
A state level Quality Assurance workshop was organized at Vijayawada on 28-06-2011 for the line departmentalofficers and contractors related to NCRMP works in Andhra Pradesh. The above mentioned booklet and a CD withQA manuals of PMGSY and quality control test videos was distributed to more than 200 participants. Specialemphasis was given to make the PIU officers and contractors understand the main provisions of wideningformation, GSB, WBM and OGPC+SC etc., in road works and concrete, reinforcement and workmanship etc., inbridge and building works respectively. Many contractors and some engineers are having some misconceptionsabout GSB and OGPC + Type A seal coat. TPQA took extra care in making them understand the importance ofthese items correctly as specified in the agreement to facilitate the quality improvement in the constructed roads.In several areas, initially, the materials collected for GSB were not good and TPQA was very rigid in getting therequired good quality materials collected.
Similarly many contractors are of the opinion about OGPC+type A seal coat can be executed with smaller sizedchips suitable for MSS mix and they can be done in one operation for a total compacted thickness of 20mm only.Some field officers were of the opinion that the total thickness shall not exceed 20mm. These misconceptions
lead to sub-standard work and loss to the Government as had happened in other works. TPQA has to put up apersevering effort in convincing the engineers and contractors about the correct practices in execution of thisitem in rural road construction. TPQA team ensured that OGPC and type A seal coat are executed as peragreement specifications, by using correct sized chips, required bitumen content, good workmanship, executedin two layers and to get a minimum thickness of 26mm as per agreement drawing. The durability of road with26mm thick bituminous carpet is about 25 to 30% more than that of a road laid with 20mm thick bituminouscarpet.
Due to the execution of GSB and OGPC+type A seal coat as per the agreement specification requirements, the lifeof the road will increase by 2 to 3 years. Without TPQA's insistence and persistence, it would not have beenpossible as can be visualized from the way the other scheme of works executed by them. However, OGPC+SC isan outdated specification in the present day scenario wherein many contractors are having latest roadconstruction machinery. It is practically difficult to execute it as 13.2mm chips are not available at many crushers.The finishing of OGPC+SC is not as good as the paver finishing of MSS or SDBC and public do not like itsappearance. But it is much costlier than MSS or SDBC which are executed using paver.
Page 35 of 49
9. HIGHLIGHTS OF TPQA CONSULTANT’S PERFORMANCE
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
TPQA consultant has also suggested to change the specifications for NCRMP year II works during the World Bank Quick
Mission review meeting on 11-01-2012 at Hyderabad and the World Bank Quick Mission was pleased to instruct the TPQA
consultant to give suggestions to the PIU officers. Accordingly necessary suggestions were submitted to the SPIU for
taking further action.
Some important suggestions given by TPQA:
1) Sand gravel mix is not an appropriate specification either for GSB or shoulders. It is practically very difficult to mix
sand and gravel on site.
a) In the sand gravel mix for GSB, due to mixing of sand, presence of voids is high and gravel contains high clay
content passing 425 micron IS sieve. This clay content attracts and absorbs water and becomes a soft paste
when water enters the sand gravel layers. During persistent or heavy rains or due to seepage water, sand and
gravel separate and form several soft pockets in sand gravel layers. When a few heavy vehicles pass on the
road in the above condition, extensive damage occurs to the road.
Suggestion: Adopt GSB with HBG/HBT/HBQ crushed chips conforming to grading III of MORD table400.1. Most of the Government Departments in AP are following the above specification.
Advantages: It gives 2 to 5 times higher resilient modulus than sand gravel mix layer. Durability getsmanifold increase. It can be executed in any season thus speeding up the progress of work.
b) Sand gravel mix for shoulders: Due to mixing of sand, sand gravel mix layer is getting disturbed quickly.
Plasticity Index of gravel (red soil) is varying from 12 to 18% whereas the maximum permissible PI is 45% for
shoulders. Hence there is no need to mix sand to reduce the PI value and increase the cost.
Suggestion: Selected earth with a minimum MDD of 1.85g/cc or 1.9g/cc is a far better option.
Advantages: It can be compacted very satisfactorily and the cost reduces when compared with sandgravel mix.
c) Execution of OGPC+SC (type A) is very difficult and its non-paver finishing is not satisfactory.
Suggestion: MSS or SDBC of 25mm thick layer is much vis-à-vis with its cost and surface finish.
d) WBM layers: Correct sized metal is not available at many places and it is causing a lot of delay in execution of
works.
Suggestion: WMM is a better option because we get paver finished surface at no extra cost. Compactioncan be done more efficiently and the availability of correct sized material is not a problem.
e) Adequate crust: In some road works of year 1, adequate crust was not provided. For example, one layer
metalling and OGPC+SC was provided over road stretches improved under NREGS. In this scheme, gravel
base (red soil), one layer of WBM and a cover of 40mm thick gravel layer. During TPQA inspections and review
meetings, it was brought to the concerned officials that such roads are likely to get damaged pre-maturely.
Suggestion: Adequate crust shall be provided as per the existing road condition. In this way, pre-maturedamages and wasteful expenditure can be avoided.
Page 36 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
For year 2 works, most of the line departmental engineers changed most of the specifications as suggested byTPQA consultant. It enables very fast construction and completion of works. Durability and surface finish of roadsimprove considerably bringing good name to the client and line departments. Many road works are likely to becompleted in less than 3 months resulting in a lot of savings in cost escalation payments. Early completion ofroad works benefits the road users and facilitates the line department officers to concentrate more on Multi-Purpose Cyclone Shelters.
In bridge works and buildings, which are being constructed very close to the sea coast, protection of steel fromrusting is very important. Regarding this, cement slurry painting on collected steel was insisted and ensured itsimplementation by TPQA consultant.
Good quality construction practices and efficient workmanship was ensured by TPQA consultant by conductingnumber of inspections at close intervals, conducting numerous quality control tests and clarification of theirdoubts by interaction.
On an average, each NCRMP work was inspected by TPQA consultant 16 times and number of QC tests done ineach work works out to 51.The same would not have been possible if the QA job was not entrusted to the TPQAconsultant.
Also, due to issue of NCRs and maintaining OK cards, several likely mistakes are avoided.
When the original consultant failed to furnish electrical designs and drawings for all types of Mult i PurposeCyclone Shelters, TPQA consultant has prepared electrical drawings with all details for all the four types of MPCSas per the instructions of SPIU.
TPQA consultant brought awareness among the contractors and line departmental officers about the importance of
protecting environment, safety aspects during and after construction and social aspects needing solution in this project.
Some important Environmental and Social aspects in which TPQA consultant rigorously pursued with the contractors
and line departments are:
1.Shifting of electrical poles close to the road edge.
2.Painting black and white stripes for trees in the formation.
3.Providing painted guard stones along the outer edge of sharp curves and accident prone locations.
4.Providing extra width at sharp curves.
5.White washing to parapet walls of old and new culverts.
6.Providing semi reflective sign boards at appropriate locations.
7.Providing safety covers for wells located in shoulder portion.
8.Providing safety barricading to excavated pits for buildings, bridges and culverts.
9.Providing safe accommodation, potable drinking water, helmets, boots and other safety gear during working for
the contractor’s workers.
10. Preventing pollution control methods at work sites.
Page 37 of 49
ANNUAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
Saving Rs2crores in the construction of bridge across Uppugadda in km7/6 of Srikakulam limits to Pukkalapeta:
The excavation work for laying raft foundation was started prior to the conclusion of the agreement with TPQA consultant.
Existing minor bridge was dismantled and diversion road formed but the foundation excavation could not be completed due
to slipping of slopes and tilting of earth moving machinery. The R&B Engineers and the contractor opined that proposed
foundation was not suitable at the site of construction. The soil contains clay mixed with very fine sand. They submitted a
revised estimate for Rs3.28crores with well foundations.
Several inspections were done and number of meetings was held but no decision was taken. Finally, SPIU has asked the
TPQA consultant to examine the proposals thoroughly and furnish a suitable solution. Along their bridge expert, TPQA
team conducted a detailed inspection and concluded that well foundation is not the only option for the site.
Designs were done and alternative proposal with box cell type structure was proposed without exceeding the original cost.
Detailed drawings were furnished to the SPIU and the same were transmitted to the line department. However, R&B
Department has not accepted the proposal because it has not executed such constructions previously.
TPQA consultant suggested another alternative proposal which is exactly similar to the original proposal but the raft bottom
level is raised by 1m. at the site, scour problem is insignificant and original depth of foundation is not necessary. If the raft
bottom level is raised, excavation for foundation becomes practicable. Structural safety was ensured with all the necessary
checks.
TPQA consultant has to take lot of pains to convince the concerned field engineers, design engineers and the contractor
about the safety and practicability of the proposal. After prolonged deliberations and calculations, necessary green signal
was given to go ahead with the work as suggested by the TPQA consultant.
Excavation was resumed; plain concrete layer and raft foundation with skin reinforcement was completed. The most feared
and presumed to be very difficult part was completed without much difficulty. Now, the bridge is expected to be completed
within 3 months. Thus TPQA is instrumental in saving more than 2crores of rupees to the Government exchequer.
Page 38 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
ENVIRONMENT&
SOCIAL REPORT
Page 39 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
LIST OF ABBREVIATIONASI : Archaeological Survey of IndiaCD : Cross DrainageCES : Consulting Engineering ServicesCITES : Convention of International Trade on Wildlife Flora and FaunaCRZ : Coastal Regulation zoneCS : Cyclone SheltersCSMMC : Cyclone Shelter Management & Maintenance CommitteeEA : Environmental AssessmentEAC : Expert Appraisal CommitteeEC : Environmental ClearanceEIA : Environmental Impact AssessmentEMP : Environmental Management PlanESMF : Environmental and Social Management FrameworkFLC : Fish Landing CentreGoI : Government of IndiaGPS : Global Positioning SystemHTL : High Tide LineIIT : Indian Institute of TechnologyIRC : Indian Road CongressLA : Land AcquisitionLTL : Low Tide LineMCS : Multipurpose Cyclone SheltersMOEF : Ministry of Environment & ForestNCRMP : National Cyclone Risk Mitigation ProjectProject : Environmental & Social Screening from National Cyclone Risk Mitigation ProjectEnvironment & Ecology Department : 2009105/EC/Screening Report Date: July 2010NDMA : National Disaster Management AuthorityORSAC : Orissa Remote Sensing Application CentreOSDMA : Orissa State Disaster Management AuthorityPAP : Project Affected PersonsPCM : Public Consultation MeetingPF : Protected ForestPMGSY : Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak YojanaRAP : Resettlement Action PlanRCC : Reinforced Cement ConcreteRF : Reserved ForestRFP : Request for ProposalRI : Revenue InspectorRoW : Right of WaySEAC : State Expert Appraisal CommitteeTOR : Terms of Reference
Page 40 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
1.0 INTRODUCTION
The National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP), a World Bank funded project, had identified
13 cyclone prone States and Union Territories (‘UT’s) for implementation. These States & Union
Territories have been classified into High and Low vulnerability categories based on the frequency of
occurrence of cyclones, size of population and the existing institutional mechanism for disaster
management. A.P. comes under high vulnerability states. Andhra Pradesh and Orissa are the first
two states for implementation of the project. The Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) is a part of the
project. For this in Andhra Pradesh, The Egis International SA France and Egis India consulting
Engineers Pvt. Ltd. have entered into a contract with Commissioner for Disaster Management, Ex-
Officio Principal Secretery & Project Director, SPIU, NCRMP, Revenue (DM) Department, A.P.
Secretariat-22 on 31st May, 2011. The assessment of Environment and Social Management by the
implementing agency is one of the major components of the TPQA.
As a part of the Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project
(NCRMP) and social management, the following approach has been followed during the last 20
months. After analyzing several practices, a revised methodology has been devised for applicability
of social audit for the present projects. In summary, this document will deal with the operational
guidelines for institutionalization of social audit carried out during the project Period up to December
2012.
2.0 OBJECTIVES OF THE THIRD PARTY QUALITY AUDIT
The objectives of the assignment:
a) Assist the SPIU in maintaining the quality standards of the civil works by independent
assessment/audit of quality of works at various stages of construction of multipurpose
cyclone shelters, roads, bridges and culverts etc. being implemented by P.R. and R&B
Departments.
b) Assess and report on the compliance with the requirements of Environmental and Social
Framework (ESMF), including the management measures provided in the Environmental
Management Plans and the Resettlement Action Plans, wherever required.
Page 41 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
3.0 PROJECT AREA
The works are spread over 9 coastal districts in Srikakulam, Vijayanagaram, Visakhapatnam, East
Godavari, West Godavari, Krishna, Guntur, Prakasam and SPSR Nellore.
4.0 COMPONENTS & IMPLEMENTATION
The Project envisages implementation of following components:
ImplementingAgency Components Total number of
unitsImplementation status,
Phase–I(year-1)
Panchayat Raj(PR)Department, A.P.
a) MultipurposeCyclone Shelters
b) Roads to habitationc) Roads to Cyclone
shelters
148 Nos.
273 Nos.( 477.51 km)205 Nos.(281.56 km )
55 Nos.
102 Nos. (198.82 km)81 Nos. ( 95.86 km)
Roads & BuildingDepartment
Connectinga) Bridgesb) Roads
22 Nos.2 Nos. (19.5 km)
9 Nos.2 Nos.(19.5 km)
Irrigation Department Saline Embankments 2 Nos. (33.6 km). Nil
NOTE: The present consultancy does not cover saline embankments.
The following departments were reasonable for implementation:
Panchayat Raj Department:
a. Construction of multipurpose Cyclone Shelters.
b. Construction of Roads to Cyclone Shelters
c. Construction of Roads to habitations
Roads & Buildings (R & B) Department:
a. Construction of Roads & Bridges
Page 42 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
5.0 Project Implementation Arrangements
1. A Project Implementing Unit (‘SPIU’) in the State of Andhra Pradesh has been set up. The
Commissioner for Disaster Management and ex-Officio Principal Secretery, Revenue (DM)
Department, A.P. Secretariat, Hyderabad heads the SPIU as Project Director. The SPIU is
responsible for coordinating and monitoring the implementation of the Project by the respective
implementation agencies. The line departments are the implementation agencies on ground,
and are responsible to ensure timely completion of the works at desired quality levels.
2. A review of literature along with agreement was made available to the consultant for this
project
3. After reviewing the literature and field data a revised approach has been prepared for the audit
in completion of work in proper time frame.
6.0 WHY SOCIAL AUDIT
One of the major social accountability tool practiced across the world is social audit. In India, social
audit is evolved as a mechanism to demand accountability from public servants and is practiced
under the leadership of many civil society organizations. Social audit practices of Mazdoor Kisan
Shakti Sanghatan (MKSS), Parivarthan, Action-aid etc., are a few examples. Recently, the
Government of Andhra Pradesh introduced social audit as part of NREGS, 2005, the Mid-day Meal
Scheme (MMS) and Scholarship Schemes for the Backward Classes, thereby recognizing the
importance of social audit in establishing transparency and accountability. After analysing several
practices, a methodology has been devised for applicability of social audit for projects taken up as
part of the Basic Services. Social auditing can be used as a tool in providing critical inputs and to
correctly assess the impact of government activities on the social well-being of the citizens, assess
the social costs, and measure the social benefits accrued as a result of any programme
implementation.
Social audit have both positive and negative social outcomes. However, it is significant in the
following aspects:
o Inculcates transparency in the organization, department or activity;
o Increases accountability and improves allocation of resources;
o Monitors the social and ethical impact and performance of the organisation by revisiting the
core values and objectives.
Page 43 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
7.0 APPROACH OF THE ASSIGNMENT BY EGIS
o In order to assist the PIU to carry out the tasks, the entire Field Support Team of Egis has
been stationed in the project area. The following action plan has been adopted during the
last year.
o The community participation approach and social inclusion has been adopted in this project.
To fulfill the objectives of the Project, the task force of Egis posted and stationed in the
project area for establishing close contact with the Local People by paying frequent visit to
them and disseminating all project related information. One to one meeting followed by
small group meeting was the main key to gain confidence of the Locals.
o After establishing close bonds with Project People, Social team has also identified the elite
persons of that area. Volunteers of the area. Additional efforts had been made to make
Project People aware of the adverse impacts and mitigation measures.
o District level meetings with revenue staff as well as other district level functionaries have
been regularly carried out to brief them about the project and the need for seeking their
support.
o Along with the above, Focus Group Discussions were carried out frequently with the people,
line department & people to establish mutual cooperation and to resolve the social issues.
o Transect walk in the sites with line department, people and the staff of the Contractor for
physical verification and identification of issues.
o Semi structured check list with the points agreed by the line department and contractor to
know how far they were compliant and issues where intervention is needed.
The community based approach has helped the Social Team in
o Reaching out to the affected persons
o Assessing the magnitude of adverse impacts
o Resolving some issues with participation of people
8.0 Site Visits by the Field Team
As a part of the project work, the Social Team visited the sites and submitted 135 reports up to 31st
May 2012. A team approach is followed and the technical team in the sites also helped the Social
Team in making a follow up of the issues by contacting the line department and the contractors. The
district wise frequency of the visits made by the Social Team is as follows:
Page 44 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
DISTRICT WISE FREQUENCY OF SITE VISITS BY ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL TEAM(TPQA, NCRMP) UPTO 31-12-2012
S.No. Name of the District
Frequency of Site VisitsTotalOnce Twice Thrice Four
timesFivetimes
1 Guntur - 14 1 2 - 172 Srikakulam - 7 12 1 1 213 Vizianagaram - 1 1 1 - 34 Visakhapatnam - 18 1 1 1 215 Prakasam 23 1 246 Nellore - 24 2 - 267 East Godavari - 8 3 1 - 128 West Godavari - 1 2 6 1 109 Krishna - 2 6 8
Total 98 29 12 3 142
9.0 ISSUES RESOLVED BY THE SOCIAL TEAM
The Social Team as a part of the project work has raised the issues and discussed with the Line
department and Contractor. Apart from that, the Social Team was able to resolve some issues
with community involvement with the coordination of Line Department, people & the contractor.
The district wise issues resolved by the Social Team are as follows:
SOCIAL ISSUES resolved by TPQA Social team in NCRMP works DISTRICT WISE TILL THE ENDOF Dec, 2012
S.No
Name ofthe
District
Category
Name of theWork Social Issues Issues solved
1 Prakasam RHBRoad from R&BRoad toChalivendradibba
A cement bench in thebeginning and turning ofthe road in the LHS wasobstruction to the road
The cement bench wasshifted back
2 Visakhapatnam
With Communityconsultation duringconstruction, no majorissue emerged.
Page 45 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
3 EastGodavari RHB
Road from PR roadto Dasarivanipetaand to CycloneShelter
Drinking water pipe linewas broken on the carriageway from Km.0.000 to0.500(LHS) 2.Temporaryhuts were there on bothsides of the road in thevillage area.
Measures have beentaken to rectify the pipeline and proper drainageof waste water for the10 taps in LHSthroughout the stretchof the road. WithCommunity consultation,all the temporary huts inobstruction are removedvoluntarily from thesides of the road
4 WestGodavari
RHBR&B road to Indira
Nagar (via)Pochamma temple
At Km. 0.500 RHS, a templewas obstruction to road.Electrical poles are close tothe road.
With Communityconsultation, this issuewas resolved. Electricalpoles are being shifted.
RHB Road from R&Broad to Pedalanka
Electrical poles are near thecarriageway edge.
With Communityconsultation, this issuewas resolved. Electricalpoles are being shifted.
RHB
Road from LBCheria CC Road toChillapalem of LBCheria
Public water taps were inthe shoulders on both thesides of the road and therewas problem of waterstagnation on the road.Electrical poles are close tothe road
With Communityconsultation this issuewas resolved. Electricalpoles are being shifted
RHB
Road from NH 214A at Ranga Statuecentre toHarijanawada ofKalipatnam (E)
Electrical poles are near thecarriageway edge.
With Communityconsultation this issuewas resolved. Electricalpoles are being shifted
RHB
R&B road atPanchayat Office toPulaparthivarithotavia Badava
Public water taps were inthe shoulders on both thesides of the road and therewas problem of waterstagnation on the road.Electrical poles are close tothe road.
With Communityconsultation this issuewas resolved. Electricalpoles are being shifted.
RHB
Mogalthuru VempaR&B Road atUchintha KalavaBridge toGogulammaHarijanapeta
Electrical poles are near thecarriageway edge.
Electrical poles areshifted away.
Page 46 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
RHB
From NarsapurMogalthur R&Broad toDayadaldaspeta viaVenkateswaraSwamy temple
Electrical poles are near thecarriageway edge.
With Communityconsultation this issuewas resolved. Electricalpoles are being shifted.
RHB
Road from NH 214A road toHarijanapeta ofKothota
Temporary huts wereobstruction to road on theLHS in the entire stretch.Electrical poles are close tothe road.
With Communityconsultation, this issuewas resolved. Electricalpoles are being shifted.
5 Krishna
RHBRoad from IntheruR&B Road toRanagraopet
One out of Ten Electricalpoles were mainobstruction on the RHSfrom Km. 0.000 toKm.0.625
One pole in the carriageway was shifted. Actionhas to be taken for theremaining poles in theshoulders
RCSRoad fromchinnapuram R&BRoad to Gundpalam
8 Electrical poles weremain obstruction on theRHS of the roadKm.0.000to Km. 0.485
The line departmenthas applied to TRANSCOfor shifting of theelectric poles
RCSRoad fromPotlapalem Z.P.Road to Potepalli
20 Electrical poles are inobstruction on the LHS ofthe roadKm.0.000 to Km.0.645
The line departmenthas applied to TRANSCOfor shifting the electricpoles
RCS Road fromBhogireddipalli
1. Fifteen Electrical polesare in obstruction on boththe sides of the road fromKm.0.000 to Km. 1.470.2).Compound walls andramps of thirty houses arecoming as obstruction tothe road
The line department hasapplied to TRANSCO forshifting the electricpoles. 2. The people arerequested to removethose compound walls &ramps which are inobstruction to road.
6 Srikakulam MPCSConstruction ofCyclone Shelter atKollipadu
The issue is lack ofresponsibility for thecommunity. There is aschool by the side of theCyclone Shelter. The villagecommunity irresponsiblyleaving the drainage waterinto the premises of thecyclone shelter. They don'tmind even though theirchildren are going to theschool. There is a maindrainage for which thedrain water is connected.But the peopledisconnected it and leavingthe water into the premisesof the cyclone shelter. Localpolitics are involved in it.
Met the people andrequested theircooperation. Somepeople came forwardthat they will make thereconnection to drainagebut a letter is requiredfrom the concerneddepartment to thePanchayat that thedrainage should bereconnected. Insistedthe contractor and linedepartment to contactthe concerned official inPanchayat Rajdepartment andreconnect the drainagewith public cooperation.
Page 47 of 49
CONSOLIDATED ENVIRONMENT & SOCIAL REPORT
Consultancy Services for Third Party Quality Audit (TPQA) for National Cyclone Risk Mitigation Project (NCRMP)
7 Guntur Discussed Separately inSuccessful Stories
8 Nellore No social issues No major issueemerged.
9 Vizianagaram No social issues No major issue
emerged.
Successful Stories
S.No.Name of
theDistrict
Category
Name of theWork Social Issues Issues solved
1 Guntur Bridge
Reconstruction of High level
Bridge@Km5/2 of
Bapatla-SuryalankaRoad across
Perali drain inGuntur
8 PAPshave hutsin the sitewhich areunauthoriz
edconstructio
ns
The PAPs evacuated their houses voluntarily.The Social Team of Egis conducted the
meetings; Discussions were made with thepeople. The line department, public and the
contractor met the local MLA. Anunderstanding was arrived to recommend
alternative housing to the PAPs in Indira AwasaYojana, a Govt. scheme, by the local MLA. The
formalities are processed and the work iscompleted. Meetings were conducted by theSocial team Discussions were made with thepeople. The line department, people and the
contractor met the local MLA. Anunderstanding was arrived to recommend
alternative housing to the PAPs in Indira AwasaYojana, a govt. scheme by the local MLA. Theformalities required for this has already been
started.
To conclude with, the Social Team is able to interact with the Stake Holders of this project and help
the implementing agency to a major extent in achieving the goals. To describe the status of NCRMP
works, Annexure is attached in continuation to the report.
Page 48 of 49
In JointVenture
Photo Presentation byThird Party Quality Audit
Consultantof AP NCRMP Works
Page 49 of 49
In JointVenture
Photo Presentation byThird Party Quality Audit
Consultantof AP NCRMP Works
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93