international accounting – emerging issues fair value accounting update
DESCRIPTION
International Accounting – Emerging Issues Fair Value Accounting Update. Gareth Kennedy. Section I Agenda. Overview of the International Accounting Standards Board (IASB) Discussion Paper (DP) with tentative American Academy of Actuaries (AAA) Working Group (WG) feedback: Measurement model - PowerPoint PPT PresentationTRANSCRIPT
Click to edit Master title styleClick to edit Master title style
!@#
Casualty Loss Reserving Seminar – San Diego, CA September 10 – 11, 2007 www.ey.com/us/actuarial
INSURANCE AND ACTUARIAL ADVISORY SERVICES
International Accounting – Emerging Issues International Accounting – Emerging Issues Fair Value Accounting UpdateFair Value Accounting Update
Gareth KennedyGareth Kennedy
2
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Section I Agenda Overview of the International Accounting
Standards Board (IASB) Discussion Paper (DP) with tentative American Academy of Actuaries (AAA) Working Group (WG) feedback:– Measurement model– Estimate of future cash flows– The time value of money– Risk margins– Unit of account– Reinsurance
3
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPMeasurement Model
Single measurement model to be used for future cash flows:– For P&C and Life insurance contracts
– For insurance and reinsurance contracts
– During claims period and pre-claims period
DP proposes that insurance liabilities be measured at Current Exit Value (CEV)
Continued
4
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPMeasurement Model
Definition of CEV:– “…the amount an insurer would expect to pay at
the reporting date to transfer its remaining contractual rights and obligations immediately to a market participant.”
IASB has not yet identified any significant difference between the notion of CEV and fair value
Continued
5
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPMeasurement Model
To measure CEV the IASB proposes that three explicit building blocks are required for insurance contracts:
Estimated future cash flows
Effect of the time value
of money
Risk and service margin
6
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPEstimate of Future Cash Flows
IASB’s preliminary view is that cash flows should be:– Explicit
– Consistent with observable market prices
– Unbiased
– Current
– Exclude entity specific cash flows
7
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPThe Time Value of Money
Requires that best estimates of future cash flows are explicitly reduced for the time value of money
Discount rate should be based on current market rates for cash flows with the same timing as the weighted average contract cash flows
Continued
8
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPThe Time Value of Money
DP does not specify a discount rate although it is presumed by many that a risk-free rate or close to one will be used
P&C members of the AAA WG believe discounting with the addition of a separate risk margin is compliant with Actuarial Standard of Practice 20 and is a good measure of economic value
9
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPRisk Margins IASB’s preliminary view is:
– “the risk margin should be an explicit and unbiased estimate of the margin that market participants require for bearing risk”
– It is not intended as a shock absorber for unexpected losses nor to enhance the insurer’s solvency
– “the observed price for a transaction with a policyholder …. should not override an unbiased estimate of the margin another party would require to take over the insurer’s contractual rights and obligations” Continued
10
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPRisk Margins
The last point may result in profits or losses at a policy’s inception
Some IASB members are in favor of an alternative definition that calibrates the risk margin to the premium at inception, combined with a liability adequacy test
Supporters of CEV believe this is an entry value approach
Continued
11
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPRisk Margins
IASB does not plan to prescribe what methods are appropriate to develop a risk margin
Instead the IASB will publish attributes that the methods should have and leave industry practitioners to develop further guidance
12
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPUnit of Account
Definition: “portfolio of contracts that are subject to broadly similar risks and managed together as a single portfolio”
When developing risk margins, the DP proposes that it should be calculated at a unit of account level
No benefit of diversification beyond unit of account
13
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Overview of the IASB DPReinsurance
There is a lack of mirror accounting and recognition between a ceded reinsurance asset and an assumed liability in the DP for a reinsurance contract written on a policies attaching basis
DP argues remaining asset has little contractual value if underlying policies are issued at CEV
Reinsurance liability would be valued using all future cash flows
14
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
Section II Agenda
Comparison of DP to Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) Statements 157 and 159:– FASB Statement 159
– FASB Statement 157
– Comparison to IASB DP
15
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
FASB Statements 157 and 159FAS 159 – Fair Value Option
Provides a voluntary election to account for certain assets and liabilities at their fair value – including P&C insurance liabilities
Provides a one-time chance to elect fair value option for any existing liabilities without affecting income
Option is irrevocable and all future changes in fair value must be recognized in income
16
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
FASB Statements 157 and 159FAS 157 – Fair Value Measurement Defines fair value for financial reporting
purposes under U.S. GAAP as the “… price that would be received to sell an asset or paid to transfer a liability in an orderly transaction between market participants at the measurement date”
Market based not entity specific entity specific measurement
Statement is not insurance specific
17
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
FASB Statements 157 and 159Comparison of FAS 157 to IASB DP
FAS 157 more general than IASB DP
Principles from DP currently fit well into the more general FAS 157 principles
Impact of FAS 157 currently optional for P&C insurance liabilities – IASB standard that will arise from DP will be compulsory
18
© 2007 Ernst & Young LLP
International Accounting – Emerging IssuesFair Value Accounting Update
Gareth Kennedy
312-879-4459