introduction permeate recycling · introduction title text permeate recycling harvesting and...

1
Harvesting of a fragile alga Dunaliella salina by membrane filtration with permeate recovery for microalgae cultivation Joana Monte a , Marta Sá a , Celina Parreira b , Rui Mota b , Joana Galante b , Pedro Nascimento b , Filipe Semião b , Cláudia F. Galinha a , Vanessa J. Pereira a , Diana Fonseca b , Luís Costa b , Vítor Verdelho b , Fons Jacobs c , Carla Brazinha a , João G. Crespo a Introduction Title Text Permeate Recycling Harvesting and Monitoring This project has been funded by the European Commission under the 7 th Framework Programme for Research and Development CollaboraAve project – GA no 613870 www.d-factoryalgae.eu D-Factory Partners P Harvey, P Lucas, V Verdelho, L Costa, D Fonseca, D Rooke, C Bright, F Jacobs, P Goacher, J Crespo, C Brazinha, G Reinhardt, H Keller, L Martinelli, D Schroeder, N Igl, A Kokossis, M Psycha, A Ben-Amotz, K Persson, L Brive, I Mira, D. Peñalosa, C Casanovas, D Arroyo Contact Details Carla Brazinha [email protected] iBET , Instituto de Biologia Experimental e Tecnológica, Apartado 12, 2781-901 Oeiras, Portugal a iBET, Instituto de Biologia Experimental e Tecnológica, Apartado 12, 2781-901 Oeiras, Portugal b A4F – Algae for future, Campus do Lumiar, Estrada do Paço do Lumiar, Edif. E, R/C, 1649-038 Lisboa,Portugal c Evodos, Weegbree 21, 4941 VT, Raamsdonksveer, the Netherlands Low-shear centrifuge (Spiral Plate Technology, SPT, Evodos) Membrane units Pre-concentra*on of biomass by membrane processing prior to centrifuga*on - Reduce overall energy and capital costs - Maximise volumetric fluxes while maintaining cell integrity at maximised values of concentraDon factors 12.5% (5.43h) 0 10 20 1 5 9 13 17 % Loss of integrity CF overall (-) 1st Harves6ng 2nd Harves6ng 3rd Harves6ng “Green” D. salina “Orange” D. salina 0 15 30 1 9 17 25 33 % Loss of integrity CF overall (-) 1st Harves0ng 2nd Harves0ng 3rd Harves0ng 0 20 40 1 5 9 13 17 Jv (L/(m 2 .h)) 1st Harves1ng 2nd Harves1ng 3rd Harves1ng CF overall =16.4 (or 94% permeate recovery) J v average = 22 L/(m 2 .h) Cell integrity loss = 13% CF overall =36.7 (or 97% permeate recovery) J v = 10 L/(m 2 .h) Cell integrity loss = 7% 2D Fluorescence Spectroscopy λ em (nm) 250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 λ ex (nm) 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650 700 I II III I. Proteins II. Humic compounds III. Pigments 0,0E+0 4,0E+5 8,0E+5 1,2E+6 0,0E+0 4,0E+5 8,0E+5 1,2E+6 Cell Conc. (cells/mL) Observed Cell Conc. (cells/mL) Predicted 2σ Train.: R 2 = 0.86, Slope = 1.00 Valid.: R 2 = 0.83, Slope = 0.78 RMSEP = 1.3E+5 cells/mL Train.: R 2 = 0.91, Slope = 1.00 Valid.: R 2 = 0.82, Slope = 0.70 RMSEP = 5.3% viability 60 70 80 90 100 110 60 70 80 90 100 110 Viability (%) Observed Viability (%) Predicted 0,0E+0 1,0E+7 2,0E+7 0,0E+0 1,0E+7 2,0E+7 Cells Conc. (cells/mL) Observed Cell Conc. (cells/mL) Predicted Train.: R 2 = 0.93, Slope = 1.00 Valid.: R 2 = 0.93, Slope = 1.15 RMSEP = 1.4E+6 cells/mL Train.: R 2 = 0.76, Slope = 1.00 Valid.: R 2 = 0.69, Slope = 1.10 RMSEP = 10% viability 20 40 60 80 100 20 70 Viability (%) Observed Viability (%) Predicted Cell number Principal Component Analysis(PCA) ProjecDon to Latent Structures(PLS) find correlaDons to predict cellular growth and other key performance parameters § Cell number § Cell integrity § Glycerol § Pigments § Enzymes § Proteins Train.: R 2 = 0.93, Slope = 1.00 Valid.: R 2 = 0.92, Slope = 1.11 RMSEP = 0.23 abs units (at 410 nm) 0 1 2 3 4 0 1 2 3 4 Units of Abs410 nm Observed Units of Abs410 nm Predicted % Viability Extracellular Glycerol 91 mg/L 262 mg/L 137 mg/L 0 100 200 300 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Glycerol content (mg/L) Time (h) UV+H2O2 Ozono+H2O2 0 25 50 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 Nitrites&Nitrates (mg/L) Time (h) Ozono+H2O2 UV+H2O2 Permeate recovery for microalgae cul*va*on media Medium recycling Maximum volumetric produc*vity of carotenoids (mg Car/L/d) Permeate without treatment 6.93 ± 0.48 Permeate + UV + H 2 O 2 5.98 ± 0.41 Evodos Dynamic settler liters/hour Intact cells harvested dry weight content Evodos 10 250 Yes, > 95% 20-30 % Evodos 10 300 Yes, > 95% 20-30 % Evodos50 harvest Dunaliella intact algae 40% solids high beta-carotene to above 10% AFDW Evodos 50: - 4000 L/h - 95% separaDon efficiency - >20 h/day Conclusions Evodos10 harvest Economic Evalua*on of Harves*ng “green” Dunaliella salina ü ReducDon of OPEX + CAPEX of 52% ü ReducDon of energy consumpDon of 45% ü Harves*ng of “green” Dunaliella salina by ultrafiltraDon allowed a final CF of 16.4 and J v.average of 22 L/(m 2 .h) with a loss of integrity of 13% ü Harves*ng of “orange” Dunaliella salina by ultrafiltraDon allowed an overall CF of 36.7 and J v of 10 L/(m 2 .h) with a loss of integrity of 7% ü Reduc*on of the OPEX + CAPEX of 52% and reduc*on of energy consump*on of 45% ü Fluorescence spectra disDnguish differences in microalgae media. Model for Dunaliella salina cultures predicted cell concentraDon and integrity ü UltrafiltraDon permeate treated by UV+H 2 O 2 allows for medium recycling for Dunaliella salina culture ü Successful harvesDng of Dunaliella salina with Evodos Spiral Plate Technology; intact/undamaged algae, high solid content, >95% separa*on efficiency ü Successful development from Pilot Evodos 10 unit to industrial automated Evodos 50 unit Based on: Energy consumpDon (membrane unit) = 0.87 kWh/m 3 Energy consumpDon (centrifuge) = 2.5 kWh/m 3 References [1] Monte J., et al, Sep. Pur. Technol., 2018, 190, 252, 260 [2] Sá M., el al, Algal Research, 2017, 24, 325–332 0 10 20 1 9 17 25 33 Jv (L/(m 2 .h)) 1st Harves0ng 2nd Harves0ng 3rd Harves0ng

Upload: others

Post on 24-Aug-2020

7 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Introduction Permeate Recycling · Introduction Title Text Permeate Recycling Harvesting and Monitoring This project has been funded by the European Commission under the 7th Framework

Harvesting of a fragile alga Dunaliella salina by membrane filtration with permeate recovery for microalgae cultivation

Joana Montea, Marta Sáa, Celina Parreirab, Rui Motab, Joana Galanteb, Pedro Nascimentob, Filipe Semiãob, Cláudia F. Galinhaa, Vanessa J. Pereiraa, Diana Fonsecab, Luís Costab, Vítor Verdelhob, Fons Jacobsc, Carla Brazinhaa, João G. Crespoa

Introduction

TitleText

Permeate Recycling

Harvesting and Monitoring

ThisprojecthasbeenfundedbytheEuropeanCommissionunderthe7thFrameworkProgrammeforResearchandDevelopmentCollaboraAveproject–GAno613870

www.d-factoryalgae.eu

D-Factory Partners P Harvey, P Lucas, V Verdelho, L Costa, D Fonseca, D Rooke, C Bright, F Jacobs, P Goacher, J Crespo, C Brazinha, G Reinhardt, H Keller, L Martinelli, D Schroeder, N Igl, A Kokossis, M Psycha, A Ben-Amotz, K Persson, L Brive, I Mira, D. Pen ̃alosa, C Casanovas, D Arroyo

Contact Details Carla [email protected] , Instituto de Biologia Experimental e Tecnológica, Apartado 12, 2781-901 Oeiras, Portugal

aiBET, Instituto de Biologia Experimental e Tecnológica, Apartado 12, 2781-901 Oeiras, Portugal bA4F – Algae for future, Campus do Lumiar, Estrada do Paço do Lumiar, Edif. E, R/C, 1649-038 Lisboa,Portugal

cEvodos, Weegbree 21, 4941 VT, Raamsdonksveer, the Netherlands

Low-shearcentrifuge(SpiralPlateTechnology,SPT,Evodos)Membraneunits

Pre-concentra*onofbiomassbymembraneprocessingpriortocentrifuga*on-  Reduceoverallenergyandcapitalcosts-  Maximisevolumetricfluxeswhilemaintainingcellintegrityatmaximisedvaluesof

concentraDonfactors

12.5%(5.43h)

0

10

20

1 5 9 13 17

%Lossofintegrity

CFoverall(-)

1stHarves6ng

2ndHarves6ng

3rdHarves6ng

“Green”D.salina “Orange”D.salina

0

15

30

1 9 17 25 33

%Lossofintegrity

CFoverall(-)

1stHarves0ng

2ndHarves0ng

3rdHarves0ng

0

20

40

1 5 9 13 17

Jv (L

/(m2 .

h))

1stHarves1ng

2ndHarves1ng

3rdHarves1ng

CFoverall=16.4(or94%permeaterecovery)Jvaverage=22L/(m2.h)

Cellintegrityloss=13%

CFoverall=36.7(or97%permeaterecovery)Jv=10L/(m2.h)

Cellintegrityloss=7%

2DFluorescenceSpectroscopy

λ em (nm)

250 300 350 400 450 500 550 600 650

λ ex

(nm

)

300

350

400

450

500

550

600

650

700

I II

III

I.  ProteinsII.  HumiccompoundsIII.  Pigments

0,0E+0

4,0E+5

8,0E+5

1,2E+6

0,0E+0 4,0E+5 8,0E+5 1,2E+6

CellCo

nc.(cells/m

L)

Observed

CellConc.(cells/mL)Predicted

2σ Train.:R2=0.86,Slope=1.00

Valid.:R2=0.83,Slope=0.78

RMSEP=1.3E+5cells/mL

Train.:R2=0.91,Slope=1.00

Valid.:R2=0.82,Slope=0.70

RMSEP=5.3%viability

60

70

80

90

100

110

60 70 80 90 100 110

Viability(%

)Observed

Viability(%)Predicted

0,0E+0

1,0E+7

2,0E+7

0,0E+0 1,0E+7 2,0E+7

CellsCon

c.(cells/mL)

Observed

CellConc.(cells/mL)Predicted

Train.:R2=0.93,Slope=1.00

Valid.:R2=0.93,Slope=1.15

RMSEP=1.4E+6cells/mL

Train.:R2=0.76,Slope=1.00

Valid.:R2=0.69,Slope=1.10

RMSEP=10%viability

20

40

60

80

100

20 70

Viability(%

)Observed

Viability(%)Predicted

Cellnumber

PrincipalComponentAnalysis(PCA)

ProjecDontoLatentStructures(PLS)

findcorrelaDonstopredictcellulargrowthandotherkeyperformanceparameters

§  Cellnumber§  Cellintegrity§  Glycerol§  Pigments§  Enzymes§  Proteins

300 400 500 600 700

300

400

500

600

700

X Axis Title

Y Ax

is Ti

tle

0

25.00

50.00

75.00

100.0

125.0

150.0

175.0

200.0

Train.:R2=0.93,Slope=1.00

Valid.:R2=0.92,Slope=1.11

RMSEP=0.23absunits(at410nm)

0

1

2

3

4

0 1 2 3 4

UnitsofA

bs410nm

Observed

UnitsofAbs410nmPredicted

%Viability

ExtracellularGlycerol

91mg/L

262mg/L

137mg/L

0

100

200

300

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

Glycerolco

nten

t(mg/L)

Time(h)

UV+H2O2

Ozono+H2O2

0

25

50

0 1 2 3 4 5 6

Nitrites&

Nitra

tes(mg/L)

Time(h)

Ozono+H2O2

UV+H2O2

Permeaterecoveryformicroalgaecul*va*onmedia

Mediumrecycling

Maximumvolumetricproduc*vityofcarotenoids(mgCar/L/d)

Permeatewithouttreatment 6.93±0.48

Permeate+UV+H2O2 5.98±0.41

Evodos Dynamic settler

liters/hour Intactcellsharvested dryweightcontentEvodos10 250 Yes,>95% 20-30%Evodos10 300 Yes,>95% 20-30%

Max.capacity350liters/hour

Evodos50 harvest

•  Dunaliellaintactalgae•  40%solids•  highbeta-carotenetoabove10%

AFDW

Evodos50:-4000L/h-95%separaDonefficiency->20h/day

Conclusions

Evodos10 harvest

EconomicEvalua*onofHarves*ng“green”Dunaliellasalina

ü ReducDonofOPEX+CAPEXof52%

ü ReducDonofenergy

consumpDonof45%

ü Harves*ngof“green”DunaliellasalinabyultrafiltraDonallowedafinalCFof16.4andJv.averageof22L/(m2.h)withalossofintegrityof13%

ü Harves*ngof“orange”DunaliellasalinabyultrafiltraDonallowedanoverallCFof36.7andJvof10L/(m2.h)withalossofintegrityof7%

ü Reduc*onoftheOPEX+CAPEXof52%andreduc*onofenergyconsump*onof45%

ü FluorescencespectradisDnguishdifferencesinmicroalgaemedia.ModelforDunaliellasalinaculturespredictedcellconcentraDonandintegrity

ü UltrafiltraDonpermeatetreatedbyUV+H2O2allowsformediumrecyclingforDunaliellasalinaculture

ü SuccessfulharvesDngofDunaliellasalinawithEvodosSpiralPlateTechnology;intact/undamagedalgae,highsolidcontent,>95%separa*onefficiency

ü SuccessfuldevelopmentfromPilotEvodos10unittoindustrialautomatedEvodos50unit

Basedon:EnergyconsumpDon(membraneunit)=0.87kWh/m3

EnergyconsumpDon(centrifuge)=2.5kWh/m3

References[1]MonteJ.,etal,Sep.Pur.Technol.,2018,190,252,260[2]SáM.,elal,AlgalResearch,2017,24,325–332

0

10

20

1 9 17 25 33

Jv(L/(m

2 .h))

1stHarves0ng2ndHarves0ng3rdHarves0ng