introduction to quantum optics [theory]2.pdf · 2018-04-19 · p zoller, cirm preschool:...
TRANSCRIPT
P Zoller, CIRM Preschool: Measurement & Control of Quantum Systems, 2018-04-17/18
Introduction to Quantum Optics [Theory]
University of Innsbruck and IQOQI, Austrian Academy of SciencesPeter Zoller
quantum control
perspective
Lectures 1 + 2
uibkOutline
Lectures 1+2:
Lectures 3+4:
• Basic systems & concepts of quantum optics - an overview
• Illustrations / Applications [in quantum information]
Isolated / Driven Hamiltonian quantum optical systems
Quantum Optical Systems & Control
Open quantum optical systems [a modern perspective]
• Example / Application: Ion Trap Quantum Computer
• Continuous measurement theory, Quantum Stochastic Schrödinger Equation, master equation & quantum trajectories
uibkLiteratureThe Quantum World of Ultra-Cold Atoms and Light: Book I: Foundations of Quantum OpticsBook II: The Physics of Quantum-Optical DevicesBook III: Ultra-cold Atoms
by Crispin W Gardiner and Peter Zoller
Quantum Noise
A Handbook of Markovian and Non-Markovian Quantum Stochastic Methods with Applications to Quantum Optics
by Crispin W Gardiner and Peter Zoller
uibkA Short Preview
What is Quantum Optics?… a Short Tour & Overview
[Experiment + Theory]
• Quantum Properties of Light
• [Quantum] Interaction of Light & Mattercontrol
… a Few Examples
uibkEx 1: Quantum Computing with Trapped Ions
• general purpose quantum computing
R. Blatt
Exp.: Innsbruck, NIST, JQI, MIT, Mainz, MPQ ...
laser control of atoms + phonons = quantum gates
qubits quantum gates read out
time|√Ut |√
coherent Hamiltonian evolution - quantum gates - deterministic
quantum logic network model
• atomic physics: trapped ionsJ. I. Cirac
internal states of ions
as qubits
uibkEx 1: Quantum Computing with Trapped Ions
• general purpose quantum computing
qubits quantum gates read out
time|√Ut |√
coherent Hamiltonian evolution - quantum gates - deterministic
quantum logic network model
• atomic physics: trapped ions
R. Blatt
phonon bus
… in Lecture 1+2 we will go in detail over the underlying theory.
coherent control
uibkEx 2: Atomic Hubbard Models - QSimulators
Quantum Many-Body Atomic Physics
• Hubbard models etc.
Bosons, Fermions - strongly correlated system - quantum phase transitions
H = ∑ =
J a†a +
1
2U∑
a† a
† a a
˙ = i
h[H, ]+L
L ∑2cc† c†cc†c
HBEC = †b(r)
h
2∇2
2mb
b(r)d
3r+gbb
†b(r)
†b(r) b(r) b(r)d
3r
E0+ ∑k =0
(k) b†kbk
HBEC = E0+ ∑k =0
(k) b†kbk (1)
where
b†k
and
bk
hk
(k)
Hint = gab
†a(r) a(r)
†b(r) b(r)d
3r (2)
gab = 4 h2aab/(2mr)
mr = (mamb)/(ma+mb)
b =0+ b
b =1V∑k
ukbke
ik.r+ vkb†keik.r
, (3)
uk =Lk1L2k
, vk =11L2k
(4)
Lk =k (hk)2/(2m)mc2
mc2. (5)
k = [c2(hk)2+(hk)4/(2mb)2]1/2 (6)
c=gbb0/mb
gbb = 4 habb/mb
= 0V∑k
(uk+ vk)bkeik.r+(uk+ vk)b†ke
ik.r
.
S(k,) = (uk+ vk)2
S(k,)1/2
Hint gab∑k
S(k,)1/2w1|eik.r|w0bk|10|+h.c.
spontaneous emission rate
as = 100a0
0 = 51014cm3
= 2100 KHz
Γ= 21.1 KHz
Γ 0a2s
• atoms in optical lattices
Hubbard Hamiltonian
• We “build” a quantum system with desired Hamiltonian & controllable parameters,e.g. Hubbard models of atoms in optical lattices
Analog quantum simulation: “always on”
tunneling
onsite interactionU
optical potential
~ light intensity
AMO Hubbard toolbox
From Artificial Quantum Matter to Real Materials
Universality of Quantum Mechanics!
Quantum Regime
dl/d & 1
de Broglie Wavepackets
l
Ultracold Quantum Matter Real Materials
Same !l/d(Neuchatel)
Densities: 1014/cm3
Temperatures: few nK
Densities: 1024-1025/cm3
Temperatures: mK – several hundred K
uibkI QOIEngineered Atomic Many-Body Systems
Rydberg Spin-Models [as Quantum Simulator]
Hamiltonian Engineering
Rydbergstates
Hamiltonian
H =X
i
12≠iæ
i
x°
X
i
¢i ni +X
i< j
Vi j ni n j
æix = |gi ihri |+ |ri ihgi |
|gi ⟩
|ri ⟩
Ωi
∆i
Vi j =C6/r 6i j
Exp:Lukin-Greiner-Vuleticgroups(Harvard-MIT),Browaeys(Palaiseau),Saffman(Wisconsin),Biedermann(Sandia)
ni = |ri ihri |¥12
(1+æiz )
uibkQuantum Optics - Theory
Example: Trapped Ion Quantum Computer
P1/2
S1/2
D5/2
40Ca+
Quantumbit
QubitDetecLon,
LaserCooling
uibkTheory 1. Single Trapped Laser-Driven Ion
atominternal
harmonic trap
motion
• driven two-level atom in a harmonic oscillator trap
two-level atom trap (phonons)
⊗<latexit sha1_base64="Ao34VwfeXzy0cVFF7amddbdNs/c=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2pWmt8VV26KRbBhYSJgra7ghuXFewDmlIm4207NDMJMxNpCQV/wZ0oKG77PW78G9NWwVL0rC7nnPs6fhRwbQj5tDIrq2vZ9dyGvbm1vbOb39uv6zBWDGssDELV9KnGgEusGW4CbEYKqfADbPiDq6neuEeleShvzSjCtqA9ybucUZNSDS80XKDu5IvEIeUSOS8XlgvXITMUK9nJ6wMAVDv5D+8uZLFAaVhAtW6h7KXX9k9dEpl2ojAKlRnbx/+6NFOpceqzvVhjRNmA9jCJmR7/Jlqx6ZaG7YTLKDYo2YKYUKEFNf0lUo+Ev0ii5jLd5Qk6QJoGZQwq25tNLfQdg0M7jeHn18LfRf3McYnj3qR5XMAcOTiEIzgBFy6hAtdQhRowGMAjPMOLpawn6816n1sz1nfPASzAmnwBJymUEA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yEhRuGVaiiiXvF/TsMEqMiV8gYQ=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVxIWGioO2u4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOTSbDzERaQj/CnSgobvs9bvwGf8K0VbAUPavLOee+ji8Drg0hH1ZmaXlldS27bm9sbm3v5Hb3ajqKFcMqi4JINXyqMeACq4abABtSIQ39AOt+/2qi1+9RaR6JWzOU2AppV/AOZ9SkVN2LDA9Rt3MF4pBSkZyX8ouF65ApCuXV8Yv4lMeVdu7du4tYHKIwLKBaN1F002t7py6RppUolJEyI/voX5dmKjVOfLYXa5SU9WkXk5jp0W+iGZtOcdBKuJCxQcHmxISGOqSmt0DqYejPk6i5SHd5Ie0jTYMyBpXtTafme47BgZ3G8PNr/u+idua4xHFv0jwuYIYsHMAhnIALl1CGa6hAFRj04QGe4NlS1qP1ar3NrBnru2cf5mCNvwAVEJV/</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yEhRuGVaiiiXvF/TsMEqMiV8gYQ=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVxIWGioO2u4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOTSbDzERaQj/CnSgobvs9bvwGf8K0VbAUPavLOee+ji8Drg0hH1ZmaXlldS27bm9sbm3v5Hb3ajqKFcMqi4JINXyqMeACq4abABtSIQ39AOt+/2qi1+9RaR6JWzOU2AppV/AOZ9SkVN2LDA9Rt3MF4pBSkZyX8ouF65ApCuXV8Yv4lMeVdu7du4tYHKIwLKBaN1F002t7py6RppUolJEyI/voX5dmKjVOfLYXa5SU9WkXk5jp0W+iGZtOcdBKuJCxQcHmxISGOqSmt0DqYejPk6i5SHd5Ie0jTYMyBpXtTafme47BgZ3G8PNr/u+idua4xHFv0jwuYIYsHMAhnIALl1CGa6hAFRj04QGe4NlS1qP1ar3NrBnru2cf5mCNvwAVEJV/</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yEhRuGVaiiiXvF/TsMEqMiV8gYQ=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVxIWGioO2u4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOTSbDzERaQj/CnSgobvs9bvwGf8K0VbAUPavLOee+ji8Drg0hH1ZmaXlldS27bm9sbm3v5Hb3ajqKFcMqi4JINXyqMeACq4abABtSIQ39AOt+/2qi1+9RaR6JWzOU2AppV/AOZ9SkVN2LDA9Rt3MF4pBSkZyX8ouF65ApCuXV8Yv4lMeVdu7du4tYHKIwLKBaN1F002t7py6RppUolJEyI/voX5dmKjVOfLYXa5SU9WkXk5jp0W+iGZtOcdBKuJCxQcHmxISGOqSmt0DqYejPk6i5SHd5Ie0jTYMyBpXtTafme47BgZ3G8PNr/u+idua4xHFv0jwuYIYsHMAhnIALl1CGa6hAFRj04QGe4NlS1qP1ar3NrBnru2cf5mCNvwAVEJV/</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="U2HZtT4FDcelFVET2EJRyJ6qFwg=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO2u4MZlBdMWmlIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPFvTGsFS9Gzupxz7usEScS1IeTTKqysrq1vFDftre2d3b3S/kFTx6li6LE4ilU7oBojLtEz3ETYThRSEUTYCsLrqd56QKV5LO/MOMGuoAPJ+5xRk1MtPzZcoO6VKsQhtSq5qJWXC9chM1Rgjkav9OHfxywVKA2LqNYdlIP82uGZSxLTzRQmsTIT++Rfl2YqN059tp9qTCgL6QCzlOnJb6KTmn511M24TFKDki2IGRVaUDNcIvVYBIskai7zXb6gIdI8KGNQ2f5sannoGBzZeQw/v5b/Lprnjksc95ZU6pfzQIpwBMdwCi5cQR1uoAEeMAjhEZ7hxVLWk/VqvX1bC9a85xAWYL1/AV0MkgI=</latexit>
system of interestcoherent control
[quantum gates etc.]
Lectures 1+2:
laser
|g ⟩<latexit sha1_base64="JC1NYvNteSZPANEkt5RATcGX5Vs=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVXGli2ARXEiYKGi7K7hxWcE+oCllMt6mIZlJmJlIS+hHuBNdiFu/x41/Y9oqWIqe1eWcc1/HS6JAaUI+jcLS8srqWnHd3Njc2t4p7e41VZxKhg0WR7Fse1RhFAhs6EBH2E4kUu5F2PLC64neekCpgljc6VGCXU59EfQDRnVOtdwQdeaPe6UysUm1Qi6q1mLh2GSKcu3giFsAUO+VPtz7mKUchWYRVaqDws+vHZw5JNHdTGISSz02T/51KSZz48RnuqnChLKQ+pilTI1/E51U9yvDbhaIJNUo2JyYUa441YMFUo24N0+iCkS+y+U0RJoHpTVK051OtQa2xqGZx/Dzq/V30Ty3HWI7t3kelzBDEQ7hGE7BgSuowQ3UoQEMQniEZ3gxpPFkvBpvM2vB+O7ZhzkY71/RppMS</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="P872B+kzm0sCq0vac6as9rC43F0=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUXGlSLEILiRMFLRdWXDjsoJ9QFPKZLxth2SSMDORltA/cONOdCFu/R43/o1pq2ARPavLOee+jhcHXGlCPozc3PzC4lJ+2VxZXVvfsDa36ipKJMMai4JINj2qMOAh1jTXATZjiVR4ATY8/3KsN+5QKh6FN3oYY1vQXsi7nFGdUQ3XR532Rh2rSGxSLpHTcuF34dhkgmJlZ0/sW/cX1Y717t5GLBEYahZQpVoY9rJr+8cOiXU7lRhHUo/Mw39disnMOPaZbqIwpsynPUwTpkY/iVaiu6VBO+VhnGgM2YyYUqEE1f1fpBoKb5ZExcNslyuojzQLSmuUpjuZWujbGgdmFsP3r4W/i/qJ7RDbuc7yOIMp8rALB3AEDpxDBa6gCjVg4MMDPMGzIY1H48V4nVpzxlfPNszAePsE9RqT6w==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="P872B+kzm0sCq0vac6as9rC43F0=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUXGlSLEILiRMFLRdWXDjsoJ9QFPKZLxth2SSMDORltA/cONOdCFu/R43/o1pq2ARPavLOee+jhcHXGlCPozc3PzC4lJ+2VxZXVvfsDa36ipKJMMai4JINj2qMOAh1jTXATZjiVR4ATY8/3KsN+5QKh6FN3oYY1vQXsi7nFGdUQ3XR532Rh2rSGxSLpHTcuF34dhkgmJlZ0/sW/cX1Y717t5GLBEYahZQpVoY9rJr+8cOiXU7lRhHUo/Mw39disnMOPaZbqIwpsynPUwTpkY/iVaiu6VBO+VhnGgM2YyYUqEE1f1fpBoKb5ZExcNslyuojzQLSmuUpjuZWujbGgdmFsP3r4W/i/qJ7RDbuc7yOIMp8rALB3AEDpxDBa6gCjVg4MMDPMGzIY1H48V4nVpzxlfPNszAePsE9RqT6w==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="P872B+kzm0sCq0vac6as9rC43F0=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUXGlSLEILiRMFLRdWXDjsoJ9QFPKZLxth2SSMDORltA/cONOdCFu/R43/o1pq2ARPavLOee+jhcHXGlCPozc3PzC4lJ+2VxZXVvfsDa36ipKJMMai4JINj2qMOAh1jTXATZjiVR4ATY8/3KsN+5QKh6FN3oYY1vQXsi7nFGdUQ3XR532Rh2rSGxSLpHTcuF34dhkgmJlZ0/sW/cX1Y717t5GLBEYahZQpVoY9rJr+8cOiXU7lRhHUo/Mw39disnMOPaZbqIwpsynPUwTpkY/iVaiu6VBO+VhnGgM2YyYUqEE1f1fpBoKb5ZExcNslyuojzQLSmuUpjuZWujbGgdmFsP3r4W/i/qJ7RDbuc7yOIMp8rALB3AEDpxDBa6gCjVg4MMDPMGzIY1H48V4nVpzxlfPNszAePsE9RqT6w==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Ex4hj5KzVpx32cgS/fw+Hsao1d8=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQdtdwY3LCvYBTSmT8TYdkkzCzERaQj/CnehC3Po9bvwb01rBUvSsLuec+zpeEgptKP0khZXVtfWN4qa1tb2zu1faP2jpOFUcmzwOY9XxmMZQSGwaYULsJApZ5IXY9oLrqd5+QKVFLO/MOMFexHwpBoIzk1NtN0CT+ZN+qUJtWqvSi1p5uXBsOkMF5mj0Sx/ufczTCKXhIdO6i9LPrx2eOTQxvUxhEiszsU7+dWmucuPUZ7mpxoTxgPmYpVxPfhPd1Ayqo14mZJIalHxBzFikI2aGS6QeR94iiVrIfJcbsQBZHpQxqCx3NrU8tA2OrDyGn1/Lfxetc9uhtnNLK/XLeSBFOIJjOAUHrqAON9CAJnAI4BGe4YUo8kReydu3tUDmPYewAPL+BXhnkhQ=</latexit>
|e⟩<latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/JCRQ1NerzxeZsLE3E1Xy9C6nKM=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioHZXcOOygn1AU8pkvG2HJJMwcyOW0I9wJ7oQt36PG//GtFawFD2ryznnvo6fhNIQY59WYWl5ZXWtuG5vbG5t75R295omTrXAhojDWLd9bjCUChskKcR2opFHfogtP7ia6K171EbG6pZGCXYjPlCyLwWnnGp5AVKG416pwhxWvWRn1fJi4TpsigrMUO+VPry7WKQRKhIhN6aDapBfOzxxWULdTGMSaxrbR/+6jNC5ceKzvdRgwkXAB5ilwox/E52U+pcP3UyqJCVUYk7MeGQiTsMF0owif55EI1W+y4t4gDwPigi17U2nlocO4YOdx/Dza/nvonnquMxxb1ildj4LpAgHcAjH4MIF1OAa6tAAAQE8wjO8WNp6sl6tt29rwZr17MMcrPcvdVmSEg==</latexit>
|0⟩<latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="cYka771FiZmkPJF8v3UJJKblovM=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioHZXcOOygn1AU8pkvG2HJJMwcyOW0I9wJ7oQt36PG//GtFawFD2ryznnvo6fhNIQY59WYWl5ZXWtuG5vbG5t75R295omTrXAhojDWLd9bjCUChskKcR2opFHfogtP7ia6K171EbG6pZGCXYjPlCyLwWnnGp5AVLGxr1ShTmsesnOquXFwnXYFBWYod4rfXh3sUgjVCRCbkwH1SC/dnjisoS6mcYk1jS2j/51GaFz48Rne6nBhIuADzBLhRn/Jjop9S8fuplUSUqoxJyY8chEnIYLpBlF/jyJRqp8lxfxAHkeFBFq25tOLQ8dwgc7j+Hn1/LfRfPUcZnj3rBK7XwWSBEO4BCOwYULqME11KEBAgJ4hGd4sbT1ZL1ab9/WgjXr2Yc5WO9fJGaR3Q==</latexit>
|1⟩<latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JGAMd2OHTWI7l8+hsE7/zabhMzY=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioHZXcOOygn1AU8pkvG2HJJMwcyOW0I9wJ7oQt36PG//GtFawFD2ryznnvo6fhNIQY59WYWl5ZXWtuG5vbG5t75R295omTrXAhojDWLd9bjCUChskKcR2opFHfogtP7ia6K171EbG6pZGCXYjPlCyLwWnnGp5AVLmjnulCnNY9ZKdVcuLheuwKSowQ71X+vDuYpFGqEiE3JgOqkF+7fDEZQl1M41JrGlsH/3rMkLnxonP9lKDCRcBH2CWCjP+TXRS6l8+dDOpkpRQiTkx45GJOA0XSDOK/HkSjVT5Li/iAfI8KCLUtjedWh46hA92HsPPr+W/i+ap4zLHvWGV2vkskCIcwCEcgwsXUINrqEMDBATwCM/wYmnryXq13r6tBWvWsw9zsN6/ACXtkd4=</latexit>
|2⟩<latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="AfUe6yLqrDb1eTkRZKOBPp0Rkmc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtN0V3LisYB/QlDIZr+2QZBJmbqQl9CPciS7Erd/jxr8xrRUsRc/qcs65r+MnoTTE2Ke1tLyyurZe2LA3t7Z3dot7+00Tp1pgQ8RhrNs+NxhKhQ2SFGI70cgjP8SWH1xN9NYDaiNjdUujBLsR7yt5LwWnnGp5AVJ2Nu4Vy8xh1Qo7r5YWC9dhU5Rhhnqv+OHdxSKNUJEIuTEdVP382sGpyxLqZhqTWNPYPv7XZYTOjROf7aUGEy4C3scsFWb8m+ikdF8ZdjOpkpRQiTkx45GJOA0WSDOK/HkSjVT5Li/iAfI8KCLUtjedWho4hEM7j+Hn19LfRfPMcZnj3rBy7WIWSAEO4QhOwIVLqME11KEBAgJ4hGd4sbT1ZL1ab9/WJWvWcwBzsN6/ACd0kd8=</latexit>
…
System Hamiltonian isolated driven system
∆=ωL −ωeg<latexit sha1_base64="+MhTLt1TuZgaaLvycadKReqFrFY=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUZdFKBbBhQ2JgrYLoaALFy4q2Ac0JU7GaxqamYTMRFpCF+78E3eiC3HrR7jxb0wfgqXoWR3OOfde7nFC3xPSML6UzNz8wuJSdlldWV1b39A2t+oiiCOKNRr4QdR0iEDf41iTnvSxGUZImONjw+meDf3GPUbCC/i17IfYZsTl3p1HiUwlW8tZ5+hLcmoFDF1iXxYnJEF3YGsFQzfKJeOonJ8lpm6MUKjsFIMbAKja2qd1G9CYIZfUJ0K0kLvpD50D0whlO4kwDCI5UPf+TQkapcFhTrVigSGhXeJiElMx+C20YnlX6rUTj4exRE6nzIQwwYjszIiiz5xpEYXH01sWI10kaX1SYqRao635ji6xp6Y1/Pya/5vUD3XT0M2rtI9jGCMLOdiFfTDhBCpwAVWoAYUHeIIXeFUelWflTXkfRzPKZGYbpqB8fAM+DZuv</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Chsz3vzRb+He53st4PdnuaYfOa4=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqMsiFIvgwoZEQduFUNCFoIsKfUFTwmS8TYdmMiEzkZbQhTv/xJ3ahbj1I9z4N6YPwVL0rA7nnHsv9ziBR4U0jC8ltbC4tLySXlXX1jc2t7TtnZrgUUigSrjHw4aDBXjUh6qk0oNGEAJmjgd1p3sx8uv3EArK/YrsB9Bi2PVpmxIsE8nWMtYleBKfW5yBi+2b/JTE4A5sLWfoRrFgnBSz88TUjTFypb08r1wPX8q29mndcRIx8CXxsBBN8N3kh86RaQSyFYcQ8FAO1IN/U4KESXCUU61IQIBJF7sQR0QMfgvNSLYLvVZM/SCS4JMZM8ZMMCw7c6LoM2dWBEH95JbFcBdwUp+UEKrWeGu2o0voqUkNP79m/ya1Y900dPM26eMUTZBGGbSPDpGJzlAJXaEyqiKCHtATekVD5VF5Vt6U90k0pUxndtEMlI9va1edTg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Chsz3vzRb+He53st4PdnuaYfOa4=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqMsiFIvgwoZEQduFUNCFoIsKfUFTwmS8TYdmMiEzkZbQhTv/xJ3ahbj1I9z4N6YPwVL0rA7nnHsv9ziBR4U0jC8ltbC4tLySXlXX1jc2t7TtnZrgUUigSrjHw4aDBXjUh6qk0oNGEAJmjgd1p3sx8uv3EArK/YrsB9Bi2PVpmxIsE8nWMtYleBKfW5yBi+2b/JTE4A5sLWfoRrFgnBSz88TUjTFypb08r1wPX8q29mndcRIx8CXxsBBN8N3kh86RaQSyFYcQ8FAO1IN/U4KESXCUU61IQIBJF7sQR0QMfgvNSLYLvVZM/SCS4JMZM8ZMMCw7c6LoM2dWBEH95JbFcBdwUp+UEKrWeGu2o0voqUkNP79m/ya1Y900dPM26eMUTZBGGbSPDpGJzlAJXaEyqiKCHtATekVD5VF5Vt6U90k0pUxndtEMlI9va1edTg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Chsz3vzRb+He53st4PdnuaYfOa4=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqMsiFIvgwoZEQduFUNCFoIsKfUFTwmS8TYdmMiEzkZbQhTv/xJ3ahbj1I9z4N6YPwVL0rA7nnHsv9ziBR4U0jC8ltbC4tLySXlXX1jc2t7TtnZrgUUigSrjHw4aDBXjUh6qk0oNGEAJmjgd1p3sx8uv3EArK/YrsB9Bi2PVpmxIsE8nWMtYleBKfW5yBi+2b/JTE4A5sLWfoRrFgnBSz88TUjTFypb08r1wPX8q29mndcRIx8CXxsBBN8N3kh86RaQSyFYcQ8FAO1IN/U4KESXCUU61IQIBJF7sQR0QMfgvNSLYLvVZM/SCS4JMZM8ZMMCw7c6LoM2dWBEH95JbFcBdwUp+UEKrWeGu2o0voqUkNP79m/ya1Y900dPM26eMUTZBGGbSPDpGJzlAJXaEyqiKCHtATekVD5VF5Vt6U90k0pUxndtEMlI9va1edTg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="jjO0tLHbMoa1PGAYamS5aHXb1KM=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ34rPEVddlNsQguNEwUtF0IBV24cFHBPqApZTLepkMzkzAzkZbQhTv/xJ3oQtz6EW78G9MawVL0rA7nnHsv93hRwJTG+NOYm19YXFrOrZira+sbm9bWdl2FsaRQo2EQyqZHFARMQE0zHUAzkkC4F0DD65+P/cYdSMVCcaOHEbQ58QXrMkp0KnWsvHsBgSZnbsjBJ52rw4wk4I86VhHbuFzCx+XCLHFsPEERZah2rA/3NqQxB6FpQJRqgfDTH3oHDo50O5EQhVKPzL1/U4rKNDjOmW6sICK0T3xIYqpGv4VWrLulQTthIoo1CDplJoQrTnRvRlRD7k2LoJhIb7mc9IGk9WkN0nQnWws9W8PATGv4+bXwN6kf2Q62nWtcrJxkheRQHu2ifeSgU1RBl6iKaoiie/SIntGL8WA8Ga/G23d0zshmdtAUjPcvaYWaVg==</latexit>
ν<latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="V7NiOn05TWlCoYjIGJE+pKfJNjQ=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFiQdtdwY3LivYBTSmT8TYdmkyGmYm0hH6CO9GFuPWL3Pg3prWCpehZXc4593V8GXJtCPm0ciura+sb+U17a3tnd6+wf9DUcaIYNlgcxqrtU40hF9gw3ITYlgpp5IfY8odXU731gErzWNyZscRuRAPB+5xRk1G3nkh6hRJxSLVCytXicuE6ZIYSzFHvFT68+5glEQrDQqp1B0WQXTo4c4k03VShjJWZ2Cf/ujRTmXHqs71Eo6RsSANME6Ynv4lOYvqVUTflQiYGBVsQUxrpiJrBEqnHkb9IouYi2+VFdIg0C8kYVLY3m1ocOAZHdhbDz6/Fv4vmueMSx70hpdrFPJA8HMExnIILl1CDa6hDAxgE8AjP8GIJ68l6td6+rTlr3nMIC7DevwAyoJAs</latexit>
Ω<latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="6u6B747tHp2meYPrOiav85avrZU=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO2u4MadFewDTCmT8TYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3Pg3prWCpehZXc4593X8OOTaEPJp5RYWl5ZX8qv22vrG5lZhe6eho0QxrLMojFTLpxpDLrFuuAmxFSukwg+x6ffPx3rzAZXmkbw2wxjbggaSdzmjJqMa3qXAgHYKJeKQSpmcVIrzheuQCUowRa1T+PBuI5YIlIaFVOsblEF2bO/IJbFppwrjSJmRffCvSzOVGcc+20s0xpT1aYBpwvToN3GTmG550E65jBODks2IKRVaUNObI/VQ+LMkai6zXZ6gfaRZTsagsr3J1GLPMTiwsxh+fi3+XTSOHZc47hUpVU+ngeRhD/bhEFw4gypcQA3qwOAOHuEZXqx768l6td6+rTlr2rMLM7DevwA1AJFQ</latexit>
atom: electronic atomic motion
laser drive
Engineer interesting quantum states?
uibkTheory 2. Single Trapped Laser-Driven Ion
atominternal
harmonic trap
empty radiation modes
phonon damping
reservoirs decoherence :-( laser cooling :-)
Lectures 1+2:
Lectures 3+4:
laser
system of interestcoherent control
[quantum gates etc.]
open system
laser drive
motion
• driven two-level atom in a harmonic oscillator trap
two-level atom trap (phonons)
⊗<latexit sha1_base64="Ao34VwfeXzy0cVFF7amddbdNs/c=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2pWmt8VV26KRbBhYSJgra7ghuXFewDmlIm4207NDMJMxNpCQV/wZ0oKG77PW78G9NWwVL0rC7nnPs6fhRwbQj5tDIrq2vZ9dyGvbm1vbOb39uv6zBWDGssDELV9KnGgEusGW4CbEYKqfADbPiDq6neuEeleShvzSjCtqA9ybucUZNSDS80XKDu5IvEIeUSOS8XlgvXITMUK9nJ6wMAVDv5D+8uZLFAaVhAtW6h7KXX9k9dEpl2ojAKlRnbx/+6NFOpceqzvVhjRNmA9jCJmR7/Jlqx6ZaG7YTLKDYo2YKYUKEFNf0lUo+Ev0ii5jLd5Qk6QJoGZQwq25tNLfQdg0M7jeHn18LfRf3McYnj3qR5XMAcOTiEIzgBFy6hAtdQhRowGMAjPMOLpawn6816n1sz1nfPASzAmnwBJymUEA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yEhRuGVaiiiXvF/TsMEqMiV8gYQ=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVxIWGioO2u4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOTSbDzERaQj/CnSgobvs9bvwGf8K0VbAUPavLOee+ji8Drg0hH1ZmaXlldS27bm9sbm3v5Hb3ajqKFcMqi4JINXyqMeACq4abABtSIQ39AOt+/2qi1+9RaR6JWzOU2AppV/AOZ9SkVN2LDA9Rt3MF4pBSkZyX8ouF65ApCuXV8Yv4lMeVdu7du4tYHKIwLKBaN1F002t7py6RppUolJEyI/voX5dmKjVOfLYXa5SU9WkXk5jp0W+iGZtOcdBKuJCxQcHmxISGOqSmt0DqYejPk6i5SHd5Ie0jTYMyBpXtTafme47BgZ3G8PNr/u+idua4xHFv0jwuYIYsHMAhnIALl1CGa6hAFRj04QGe4NlS1qP1ar3NrBnru2cf5mCNvwAVEJV/</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yEhRuGVaiiiXvF/TsMEqMiV8gYQ=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVxIWGioO2u4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOTSbDzERaQj/CnSgobvs9bvwGf8K0VbAUPavLOee+ji8Drg0hH1ZmaXlldS27bm9sbm3v5Hb3ajqKFcMqi4JINXyqMeACq4abABtSIQ39AOt+/2qi1+9RaR6JWzOU2AppV/AOZ9SkVN2LDA9Rt3MF4pBSkZyX8ouF65ApCuXV8Yv4lMeVdu7du4tYHKIwLKBaN1F002t7py6RppUolJEyI/voX5dmKjVOfLYXa5SU9WkXk5jp0W+iGZtOcdBKuJCxQcHmxISGOqSmt0DqYejPk6i5SHd5Ie0jTYMyBpXtTafme47BgZ3G8PNr/u+idua4xHFv0jwuYIYsHMAhnIALl1CGa6hAFRj04QGe4NlS1qP1ar3NrBnru2cf5mCNvwAVEJV/</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yEhRuGVaiiiXvF/TsMEqMiV8gYQ=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVxIWGioO2u4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOTSbDzERaQj/CnSgobvs9bvwGf8K0VbAUPavLOee+ji8Drg0hH1ZmaXlldS27bm9sbm3v5Hb3ajqKFcMqi4JINXyqMeACq4abABtSIQ39AOt+/2qi1+9RaR6JWzOU2AppV/AOZ9SkVN2LDA9Rt3MF4pBSkZyX8ouF65ApCuXV8Yv4lMeVdu7du4tYHKIwLKBaN1F002t7py6RppUolJEyI/voX5dmKjVOfLYXa5SU9WkXk5jp0W+iGZtOcdBKuJCxQcHmxISGOqSmt0DqYejPk6i5SHd5Ie0jTYMyBpXtTafme47BgZ3G8PNr/u+idua4xHFv0jwuYIYsHMAhnIALl1CGa6hAFRj04QGe4NlS1qP1ar3NrBnru2cf5mCNvwAVEJV/</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="U2HZtT4FDcelFVET2EJRyJ6qFwg=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO2u4MZlBdMWmlIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPFvTGsFS9Gzupxz7usEScS1IeTTKqysrq1vFDftre2d3b3S/kFTx6li6LE4ilU7oBojLtEz3ETYThRSEUTYCsLrqd56QKV5LO/MOMGuoAPJ+5xRk1MtPzZcoO6VKsQhtSq5qJWXC9chM1Rgjkav9OHfxywVKA2LqNYdlIP82uGZSxLTzRQmsTIT++Rfl2YqN059tp9qTCgL6QCzlOnJb6KTmn511M24TFKDki2IGRVaUDNcIvVYBIskai7zXb6gIdI8KGNQ2f5sannoGBzZeQw/v5b/Lprnjksc95ZU6pfzQIpwBMdwCi5cQR1uoAEeMAjhEZ7hxVLWk/VqvX1bC9a85xAWYL1/AV0MkgI=</latexit>
|g ⟩<latexit sha1_base64="JC1NYvNteSZPANEkt5RATcGX5Vs=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVXGli2ARXEiYKGi7K7hxWcE+oCllMt6mIZlJmJlIS+hHuBNdiFu/x41/Y9oqWIqe1eWcc1/HS6JAaUI+jcLS8srqWnHd3Njc2t4p7e41VZxKhg0WR7Fse1RhFAhs6EBH2E4kUu5F2PLC64neekCpgljc6VGCXU59EfQDRnVOtdwQdeaPe6UysUm1Qi6q1mLh2GSKcu3giFsAUO+VPtz7mKUchWYRVaqDws+vHZw5JNHdTGISSz02T/51KSZz48RnuqnChLKQ+pilTI1/E51U9yvDbhaIJNUo2JyYUa441YMFUo24N0+iCkS+y+U0RJoHpTVK051OtQa2xqGZx/Dzq/V30Ty3HWI7t3kelzBDEQ7hGE7BgSuowQ3UoQEMQniEZ3gxpPFkvBpvM2vB+O7ZhzkY71/RppMS</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="P872B+kzm0sCq0vac6as9rC43F0=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUXGlSLEILiRMFLRdWXDjsoJ9QFPKZLxth2SSMDORltA/cONOdCFu/R43/o1pq2ARPavLOee+jhcHXGlCPozc3PzC4lJ+2VxZXVvfsDa36ipKJMMai4JINj2qMOAh1jTXATZjiVR4ATY8/3KsN+5QKh6FN3oYY1vQXsi7nFGdUQ3XR532Rh2rSGxSLpHTcuF34dhkgmJlZ0/sW/cX1Y717t5GLBEYahZQpVoY9rJr+8cOiXU7lRhHUo/Mw39disnMOPaZbqIwpsynPUwTpkY/iVaiu6VBO+VhnGgM2YyYUqEE1f1fpBoKb5ZExcNslyuojzQLSmuUpjuZWujbGgdmFsP3r4W/i/qJ7RDbuc7yOIMp8rALB3AEDpxDBa6gCjVg4MMDPMGzIY1H48V4nVpzxlfPNszAePsE9RqT6w==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="P872B+kzm0sCq0vac6as9rC43F0=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUXGlSLEILiRMFLRdWXDjsoJ9QFPKZLxth2SSMDORltA/cONOdCFu/R43/o1pq2ARPavLOee+jhcHXGlCPozc3PzC4lJ+2VxZXVvfsDa36ipKJMMai4JINj2qMOAh1jTXATZjiVR4ATY8/3KsN+5QKh6FN3oYY1vQXsi7nFGdUQ3XR532Rh2rSGxSLpHTcuF34dhkgmJlZ0/sW/cX1Y717t5GLBEYahZQpVoY9rJr+8cOiXU7lRhHUo/Mw39disnMOPaZbqIwpsynPUwTpkY/iVaiu6VBO+VhnGgM2YyYUqEE1f1fpBoKb5ZExcNslyuojzQLSmuUpjuZWujbGgdmFsP3r4W/i/qJ7RDbuc7yOIMp8rALB3AEDpxDBa6gCjVg4MMDPMGzIY1H48V4nVpzxlfPNszAePsE9RqT6w==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="P872B+kzm0sCq0vac6as9rC43F0=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUXGlSLEILiRMFLRdWXDjsoJ9QFPKZLxth2SSMDORltA/cONOdCFu/R43/o1pq2ARPavLOee+jhcHXGlCPozc3PzC4lJ+2VxZXVvfsDa36ipKJMMai4JINj2qMOAh1jTXATZjiVR4ATY8/3KsN+5QKh6FN3oYY1vQXsi7nFGdUQ3XR532Rh2rSGxSLpHTcuF34dhkgmJlZ0/sW/cX1Y717t5GLBEYahZQpVoY9rJr+8cOiXU7lRhHUo/Mw39disnMOPaZbqIwpsynPUwTpkY/iVaiu6VBO+VhnGgM2YyYUqEE1f1fpBoKb5ZExcNslyuojzQLSmuUpjuZWujbGgdmFsP3r4W/i/qJ7RDbuc7yOIMp8rALB3AEDpxDBa6gCjVg4MMDPMGzIY1H48V4nVpzxlfPNszAePsE9RqT6w==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Ex4hj5KzVpx32cgS/fw+Hsao1d8=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQdtdwY3LCvYBTSmT8TYdkkzCzERaQj/CnehC3Po9bvwb01rBUvSsLuec+zpeEgptKP0khZXVtfWN4qa1tb2zu1faP2jpOFUcmzwOY9XxmMZQSGwaYULsJApZ5IXY9oLrqd5+QKVFLO/MOMFexHwpBoIzk1NtN0CT+ZN+qUJtWqvSi1p5uXBsOkMF5mj0Sx/ufczTCKXhIdO6i9LPrx2eOTQxvUxhEiszsU7+dWmucuPUZ7mpxoTxgPmYpVxPfhPd1Ayqo14mZJIalHxBzFikI2aGS6QeR94iiVrIfJcbsQBZHpQxqCx3NrU8tA2OrDyGn1/Lfxetc9uhtnNLK/XLeSBFOIJjOAUHrqAON9CAJnAI4BGe4YUo8kReydu3tUDmPYewAPL+BXhnkhQ=</latexit>
|e⟩<latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PaPnY99PiW3P51qncdClZW8p+JU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoElx3C2UiEMqZXJWKS4WrkOmKF1+whS1buHdu4tZEqEwLKRat1H0s2sHJy6RppMqlLEyY/voX5dmKjNOfLaXaJSUBbSPacL0+DfRTkyvPOykXMjEoGBzYkojHVEzWCD1KPLnSdRcZLu8iAZIs6CMQWV706nFgWNwaGcx/Pxa/LtonDoucdwbUqqez/KAPBzAIRyDCxdQhWuoQR0YBPAAT/BsKevRerFeZ9ac9d2zD3Ow3r4AEsmTQQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/JCRQ1NerzxeZsLE3E1Xy9C6nKM=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioHZXcOOygn1AU8pkvG2HJJMwcyOW0I9wJ7oQt36PG//GtFawFD2ryznnvo6fhNIQY59WYWl5ZXWtuG5vbG5t75R295omTrXAhojDWLd9bjCUChskKcR2opFHfogtP7ia6K171EbG6pZGCXYjPlCyLwWnnGp5AVKG416pwhxWvWRn1fJi4TpsigrMUO+VPry7WKQRKhIhN6aDapBfOzxxWULdTGMSaxrbR/+6jNC5ceKzvdRgwkXAB5ilwox/E52U+pcP3UyqJCVUYk7MeGQiTsMF0owif55EI1W+y4t4gDwPigi17U2nlocO4YOdx/Dza/nvonnquMxxb1ildj4LpAgHcAjH4MIF1OAa6tAAAQE8wjO8WNp6sl6tt29rwZr17MMcrPcvdVmSEg==</latexit>
|0⟩<latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QUwyqe7YNosFtKwJTYoZuIuMqpU=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEnJuFsoEYdUyuSsUlwsXIdMUbr8hClq3cK7dxezJEJhWEi1bqPoZ9cOTlwiTSdVKGNlxvbRvy7NVGac+Gwv0SgpC2gf04Tp8W+inZheedhJuZCJQcHmxJRGOqJmsEDqUeTPk6i5yHZ5EQ2QZkEZg8r2plOLA8fg0M5i+Pm1+HfROHVc4rg3pFQ9n+UBeTiAQzgGFy6gCtdQgzowCOABnuDZUtaj9WK9zqw567tnH+ZgvX0BwceTDA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="cYka771FiZmkPJF8v3UJJKblovM=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioHZXcOOygn1AU8pkvG2HJJMwcyOW0I9wJ7oQt36PG//GtFawFD2ryznnvo6fhNIQY59WYWl5ZXWtuG5vbG5t75R295omTrXAhojDWLd9bjCUChskKcR2opFHfogtP7ia6K171EbG6pZGCXYjPlCyLwWnnGp5AVLGxr1ShTmsesnOquXFwnXYFBWYod4rfXh3sUgjVCRCbkwH1SC/dnjisoS6mcYk1jS2j/51GaFz48Rne6nBhIuADzBLhRn/Jjop9S8fuplUSUqoxJyY8chEnIYLpBlF/jyJRqp8lxfxAHkeFBFq25tOLQ8dwgc7j+Hn1/LfRfPUcZnj3rBK7XwWSBEO4BCOwYULqME11KEBAgJ4hGd4sbT1ZL1ab9/WgjXr2Yc5WO9fJGaR3Q==</latexit>
|1⟩<latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="HUL9lmc40QRco8DUW5j/Kt5reZc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO3KghuXFewDmlIm4207JJkMMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7Or4MuTaEfFi5peWV1bX8ur2xubW9U9jda+g4UQzrLA5j1fKpxpALrBtuQmxJhTTyQ2z6wdVEb96j0jwWt2YksRPRvuA9zqjJqKYXoEndcbdQIg6plMlZpbhYuA6ZonT5CVPUuoV37y5mSYTCsJBq3UbRz64dnLhEmk6qUMbKjO2jf12aqcw48dleolFSFtA+pgnT499EOzG98rCTciETg4LNiSmNdETNYIHUo8ifJ1Fzke3yIhogzYIyBpXtTacWB47BoZ3F8PNr8e+iceq4xHFvSKl6PssD8nAAh3AMLlxAFa6hBnVgEMADPMGzpaxH68V6nVlz1nfPPszBevsCw06TDQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="JGAMd2OHTWI7l8+hsE7/zabhMzY=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioHZXcOOygn1AU8pkvG2HJJMwcyOW0I9wJ7oQt36PG//GtFawFD2ryznnvo6fhNIQY59WYWl5ZXWtuG5vbG5t75R295omTrXAhojDWLd9bjCUChskKcR2opFHfogtP7ia6K171EbG6pZGCXYjPlCyLwWnnGp5AVLmjnulCnNY9ZKdVcuLheuwKSowQ71X+vDuYpFGqEiE3JgOqkF+7fDEZQl1M41JrGlsH/3rMkLnxonP9lKDCRcBH2CWCjP+TXRS6l8+dDOpkpRQiTkx45GJOA0XSDOK/HkSjVT5Li/iAfI8KCLUtjedWh46hA92HsPPr+W/i+ap4zLHvWGV2vkskCIcwCEcgwsXUINrqEMDBATwCM/wYmnryXq13r6tBWvWsw9zsN6/ACXtkd4=</latexit>
|2⟩<latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="W4eWziX6RJXgCagc7MkBQdyJOso=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFSQduVBTcuK9gHmFIm4207JDMJMxNpCf0Id6ILcev3uPEv/ATTVsFS9Kwu55z7On4ccm0I+bByS8srq2v5dXtjc2t7p7C719RRohg2WBRGqu1TjSGX2DDchNiOFVLhh9jyg8uJ3rpHpXkkb8woxo6gfcl7nFGTUS0vQJOWx91CiTikWiGn1eJi4TpkitLFJ0xR7xbevbuIJQKlYSHV+hZlP7t2cOKS2HRShXGkzNg++telmcqME5/tJRpjygLaxzRhevybuE1MrzLspFzGiUHJ5sSUCi2oGSyQeiT8eRI1l9kuT9AAaRaUMahsbzq1OHAMDu0shp9fi38XzbLjEse9JqXa2SwPyMMBHMIxuHAONbiCOjSAQQAP8ATPlrIerRfrdWbNWd89+zAH6+0LxNWTDg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="AfUe6yLqrDb1eTkRZKOBPp0Rkmc=">AAAB8HicfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtN0V3LisYB/QlDIZr+2QZBJmbqQl9CPciS7Erd/jxr8xrRUsRc/qcs65r+MnoTTE2Ke1tLyyurZe2LA3t7Z3dot7+00Tp1pgQ8RhrNs+NxhKhQ2SFGI70cgjP8SWH1xN9NYDaiNjdUujBLsR7yt5LwWnnGp5AVJ2Nu4Vy8xh1Qo7r5YWC9dhU5Rhhnqv+OHdxSKNUJEIuTEdVP382sGpyxLqZhqTWNPYPv7XZYTOjROf7aUGEy4C3scsFWb8m+ikdF8ZdjOpkpRQiTkx45GJOA0WSDOK/HkSjVT5Li/iAfI8KCLUtjedWho4hEM7j+Hn19LfRfPMcZnj3rBy7WIWSAEO4QhOwIVLqME11KEBAgJ4hGd4sbT1ZL1ab9/WJWvWcwBzsN6/ACd0kd8=</latexit>
…∆=ωL −ωeg
<latexit sha1_base64="+MhTLt1TuZgaaLvycadKReqFrFY=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfUZdFKBbBhQ2JgrYLoaALFy4q2Ac0JU7GaxqamYTMRFpCF+78E3eiC3HrR7jxb0wfgqXoWR3OOfde7nFC3xPSML6UzNz8wuJSdlldWV1b39A2t+oiiCOKNRr4QdR0iEDf41iTnvSxGUZImONjw+meDf3GPUbCC/i17IfYZsTl3p1HiUwlW8tZ5+hLcmoFDF1iXxYnJEF3YGsFQzfKJeOonJ8lpm6MUKjsFIMbAKja2qd1G9CYIZfUJ0K0kLvpD50D0whlO4kwDCI5UPf+TQkapcFhTrVigSGhXeJiElMx+C20YnlX6rUTj4exRE6nzIQwwYjszIiiz5xpEYXH01sWI10kaX1SYqRao635ji6xp6Y1/Pya/5vUD3XT0M2rtI9jGCMLOdiFfTDhBCpwAVWoAYUHeIIXeFUelWflTXkfRzPKZGYbpqB8fAM+DZuv</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Chsz3vzRb+He53st4PdnuaYfOa4=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqMsiFIvgwoZEQduFUNCFoIsKfUFTwmS8TYdmMiEzkZbQhTv/xJ3ahbj1I9z4N6YPwVL0rA7nnHsv9ziBR4U0jC8ltbC4tLySXlXX1jc2t7TtnZrgUUigSrjHw4aDBXjUh6qk0oNGEAJmjgd1p3sx8uv3EArK/YrsB9Bi2PVpmxIsE8nWMtYleBKfW5yBi+2b/JTE4A5sLWfoRrFgnBSz88TUjTFypb08r1wPX8q29mndcRIx8CXxsBBN8N3kh86RaQSyFYcQ8FAO1IN/U4KESXCUU61IQIBJF7sQR0QMfgvNSLYLvVZM/SCS4JMZM8ZMMCw7c6LoM2dWBEH95JbFcBdwUp+UEKrWeGu2o0voqUkNP79m/ya1Y900dPM26eMUTZBGGbSPDpGJzlAJXaEyqiKCHtATekVD5VF5Vt6U90k0pUxndtEMlI9va1edTg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Chsz3vzRb+He53st4PdnuaYfOa4=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqMsiFIvgwoZEQduFUNCFoIsKfUFTwmS8TYdmMiEzkZbQhTv/xJ3ahbj1I9z4N6YPwVL0rA7nnHsv9ziBR4U0jC8ltbC4tLySXlXX1jc2t7TtnZrgUUigSrjHw4aDBXjUh6qk0oNGEAJmjgd1p3sx8uv3EArK/YrsB9Bi2PVpmxIsE8nWMtYleBKfW5yBi+2b/JTE4A5sLWfoRrFgnBSz88TUjTFypb08r1wPX8q29mndcRIx8CXxsBBN8N3kh86RaQSyFYcQ8FAO1IN/U4KESXCUU61IQIBJF7sQR0QMfgvNSLYLvVZM/SCS4JMZM8ZMMCw7c6LoM2dWBEH95JbFcBdwUp+UEKrWeGu2o0voqUkNP79m/ya1Y900dPM26eMUTZBGGbSPDpGJzlAJXaEyqiKCHtATekVD5VF5Vt6U90k0pUxndtEMlI9va1edTg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Chsz3vzRb+He53st4PdnuaYfOa4=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqMsiFIvgwoZEQduFUNCFoIsKfUFTwmS8TYdmMiEzkZbQhTv/xJ3ahbj1I9z4N6YPwVL0rA7nnHsv9ziBR4U0jC8ltbC4tLySXlXX1jc2t7TtnZrgUUigSrjHw4aDBXjUh6qk0oNGEAJmjgd1p3sx8uv3EArK/YrsB9Bi2PVpmxIsE8nWMtYleBKfW5yBi+2b/JTE4A5sLWfoRrFgnBSz88TUjTFypb08r1wPX8q29mndcRIx8CXxsBBN8N3kh86RaQSyFYcQ8FAO1IN/U4KESXCUU61IQIBJF7sQR0QMfgvNSLYLvVZM/SCS4JMZM8ZMMCw7c6LoM2dWBEH95JbFcBdwUp+UEKrWeGu2o0voqUkNP79m/ya1Y900dPM26eMUTZBGGbSPDpGJzlAJXaEyqiKCHtATekVD5VF5Vt6U90k0pUxndtEMlI9va1edTg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="jjO0tLHbMoa1PGAYamS5aHXb1KM=">AAACBnicfVDLSsNAFJ34rPEVddlNsQguNEwUtF0IBV24cFHBPqApZTLepkMzkzAzkZbQhTv/xJ3oQtz6EW78G9MawVL0rA7nnHsv93hRwJTG+NOYm19YXFrOrZira+sbm9bWdl2FsaRQo2EQyqZHFARMQE0zHUAzkkC4F0DD65+P/cYdSMVCcaOHEbQ58QXrMkp0KnWsvHsBgSZnbsjBJ52rw4wk4I86VhHbuFzCx+XCLHFsPEERZah2rA/3NqQxB6FpQJRqgfDTH3oHDo50O5EQhVKPzL1/U4rKNDjOmW6sICK0T3xIYqpGv4VWrLulQTthIoo1CDplJoQrTnRvRlRD7k2LoJhIb7mc9IGk9WkN0nQnWws9W8PATGv4+bXwN6kf2Q62nWtcrJxkheRQHu2ifeSgU1RBl6iKaoiie/SIntGL8WA8Ga/G23d0zshmdtAUjPcvaYWaVg==</latexit>
ν<latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="dP+OvXB1slJBRwCK8ZC+NT6i/ck=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL1TXzW+qi7dFIvgQsJEQduVBTcuK9pWaEqZjLfp0GQSZibSEvoJ7kQX4tYvcuNf+AmmrYKl6Fldzjn3dbw4ENpQ+kFyC4tLyyv5VWttfWNzq7C909BRojjWeRRE6tZjGgMhsW6ECfA2VshCL8Cm178Y6817VFpE8sYMY2yHzJeiKzgzGXXtyqRTKFGbVsr0pFKcLxybTlA6/4QJap3Cu3sX8SREaXjAtG6h9LNLe0cOjU07VRhHyoysg39dmqvMOPZZbqIxZrzPfEwTrke/iVZiuuVBOxUyTgxKPiOmLNQhM705Ug9Db5ZELWS2yw1ZH1kWkjGoLHcytdizDQ6sLIafX4t/F41j26G2c0VL1dNpHpCHPdiHQ3DgDKpwCTWoAwcfHuAJnokkj+SFvE6tOfLdswszIG9f0AGRWw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="V7NiOn05TWlCoYjIGJE+pKfJNjQ=">AAAB7HicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFiQdtdwY3LivYBTSmT8TYdmkyGmYm0hH6CO9GFuPWL3Pg3prWCpehZXc4593V8GXJtCPm0ciura+sb+U17a3tnd6+wf9DUcaIYNlgcxqrtU40hF9gw3ITYlgpp5IfY8odXU731gErzWNyZscRuRAPB+5xRk1G3nkh6hRJxSLVCytXicuE6ZIYSzFHvFT68+5glEQrDQqp1B0WQXTo4c4k03VShjJWZ2Cf/ujRTmXHqs71Eo6RsSANME6Ynv4lOYvqVUTflQiYGBVsQUxrpiJrBEqnHkb9IouYi2+VFdIg0C8kYVLY3m1ocOAZHdhbDz6/Fv4vmueMSx70hpdrFPJA8HMExnIILl1CDa6hDAxgE8AjP8GIJ68l6td6+rTlr3nMIC7DevwAyoJAs</latexit>
Ω<latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="6u6B747tHp2meYPrOiav85avrZU=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO2u4MadFewDTCmT8TYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3Pg3prWCpehZXc4593X8OOTaEPJp5RYWl5ZX8qv22vrG5lZhe6eho0QxrLMojFTLpxpDLrFuuAmxFSukwg+x6ffPx3rzAZXmkbw2wxjbggaSdzmjJqMa3qXAgHYKJeKQSpmcVIrzheuQCUowRa1T+PBuI5YIlIaFVOsblEF2bO/IJbFppwrjSJmRffCvSzOVGcc+20s0xpT1aYBpwvToN3GTmG550E65jBODks2IKRVaUNObI/VQ+LMkai6zXZ6gfaRZTsagsr3J1GLPMTiwsxh+fi3+XTSOHZc47hUpVU+ngeRhD/bhEFw4gypcQA3qwOAOHuEZXqx768l6td6+rTlr2rMLM7DevwA1AJFQ</latexit>
atom: electronic atomic motion
Γ<latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="uThmtIYGzBkF4T779QSpFAHl75g=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFiQdtdwYUuK9gHNKVMxtt2bGYSZybSEvoP7kQX4tb/cePfmNYKlqJndTnn3Nfxo4BrQ8inlVlaXlldy67bG5tb2zu53b26DmPFsMbCIFRNn2oMuMSa4SbAZqSQCj/Ahj+4mOiNB1Sah/LGjCJsC9qTvMsZNSlV9y6pELSTKxCHlEukWM4vFq5DpijADNVO7sO7DVksUBoWUK1bKHvpsf0Tl0SmnSiMQmXG9tG/Ls1Uapz4bC/WGFE2oD1MYqbHv4lWbLqlYTvhMooNSjYnJlRoQU1/gdQj4c+TqLlMd3mCDpCmORmDyvamU/N9x+DQTmP4+TX/d1E/dVziuNekUDmbBZKFAziEY3DhHCpwBVWoAYM7eIRneLHurSfr1Xr7tmasWc8+zMF6/wIrrpFK</latexit>
Γ<latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="En/m3LWWBeI/eDXZy2pGDxXTd78=">AAAB23icfVC7SgNBFL0bX3GNGmubYBAsZJm10VKwsYxgHpANYXZyk4zZmR1m7krCkh+wEizE/7Lxb9zEFMaApzqcc7iPE5tEOmLsyyttbe/s7pX3/YOKf3h0XK20XJpZgU2RJqntxNxhIjU2SVKCHWORqzjBdjy5W/jtZ7ROpvqRZgZ7io+0HErBqZAa/WqdBWyJ2iYJV6QOK/Srn9EgFZlCTSLhznVRj4orx5chM9TLLZrU0tw//zflhC2Ci5wfZQ4NFxM+wjwTbv5b6GY0vJn2cqlNRqjFmplz5RSn8YboZipeF9FJXeyKFJ8gLwoiQutHy6m1cUA49YsWwr8/b5LWVRCyIHxgUIZTOIMLCOEabuEeGtAEAQN4gTfvyXv13n/aKnmr2k5gDd7HN3UTjEQ=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PD9uxubvRrpERLuMac3HxRRWyas=">AAAB5HicfVC7TgJBFL2LL1xR0daGSEwszGbWRksTCy0xkUfCEjI7XmBkZ3aZuWsgG/7Bzmhh/Cgb/8YFKUQST3Vyzsl9nDCJpCXGvpzC2vrG5lZx290p7e7tlw9KDRunRmBdxFFsWiG3GEmNdZIUYSsxyFUYYTMcXs/85hMaK2N9T5MEO4r3texJwSmXGsENV4p3y1XmsTkqq8RfkCosUOuWP4OHWKQKNYmIW9tG3c+PHZz5LKFOZjCJDU3dk39TVpg8OMu5QWox4WLI+5ilwk5/C+2UepfjTiZ1khJqsWRmXFnFabAi2okKl0W0Uue7AsWHyPOeiNC4wXxqZeARjt28Bv/v06ukce75zPPvGBThCI7hFHy4gCu4hRrUQcAjPMMrvDkj58V5/yms4CyaO4QlOB/fcgePqQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="xViT03jS8O2x8pgO9V4zKAVbS2w=">AAAB5HicfVDLTsJAFL3FF1ZUdOuGSExcmGaqC2Fn4kKXmMgjoYRMxwuMdKbjzNRAGv7BndGF8aPc+DcWxERC9KxOzjm5jxOqiBtLyKeTW1ldW9/Ib7pbhe2d3eJeoWHiRDOssziKdSukBiMusW65jbClNFIRRtgMh5dTv/mI2vBY3tqxwo6gfcl7nFGbSY3gigpBu8Uy8Ui1Qs6qpWXie2SGMsxR6xY/gruYJQKlZRE1po2ynx07OPGJsp1Uo4q1nbhH/6YM01lwmnODxKCibEj7mCbMTH4L7cT2KqNOyqVKLEq2YKZUGEHtYEk0YxEuimi4zHYFgg6RZj1Zi9oNZlNLA8/iyM1q+Pm19DdpnHo+8fwbAnk4gEM4Bh/O4QKuoQZ1YHAPT/ACr86D8+y8fReWc+bN7cMCnPcv7MWQAA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="uThmtIYGzBkF4T779QSpFAHl75g=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFiQdtdwYUuK9gHNKVMxtt2bGYSZybSEvoP7kQX4tb/cePfmNYKlqJndTnn3Nfxo4BrQ8inlVlaXlldy67bG5tb2zu53b26DmPFsMbCIFRNn2oMuMSa4SbAZqSQCj/Ahj+4mOiNB1Sah/LGjCJsC9qTvMsZNSlV9y6pELSTKxCHlEukWM4vFq5DpijADNVO7sO7DVksUBoWUK1bKHvpsf0Tl0SmnSiMQmXG9tG/Ls1Uapz4bC/WGFE2oD1MYqbHv4lWbLqlYTvhMooNSjYnJlRoQU1/gdQj4c+TqLlMd3mCDpCmORmDyvamU/N9x+DQTmP4+TX/d1E/dVziuNekUDmbBZKFAziEY3DhHCpwBVWoAYM7eIRneLHurSfr1Xr7tmasWc8+zMF6/wIrrpFK</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="uThmtIYGzBkF4T779QSpFAHl75g=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFiQdtdwYUuK9gHNKVMxtt2bGYSZybSEvoP7kQX4tb/cePfmNYKlqJndTnn3Nfxo4BrQ8inlVlaXlldy67bG5tb2zu53b26DmPFsMbCIFRNn2oMuMSa4SbAZqSQCj/Ahj+4mOiNB1Sah/LGjCJsC9qTvMsZNSlV9y6pELSTKxCHlEukWM4vFq5DpijADNVO7sO7DVksUBoWUK1bKHvpsf0Tl0SmnSiMQmXG9tG/Ls1Uapz4bC/WGFE2oD1MYqbHv4lWbLqlYTvhMooNSjYnJlRoQU1/gdQj4c+TqLlMd3mCDpCmORmDyvamU/N9x+DQTmP4+TX/d1E/dVziuNekUDmbBZKFAziEY3DhHCpwBVWoAYM7eIRneLHurSfr1Xr7tmasWc8+zMF6/wIrrpFK</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="yyLk/JrRGyOFmtSSDUxShnr9RkM=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcKHLCvYBTSmT8bYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8KuDaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVhrBhWWBiEqu5TjQGXWDHcBFiPFFLhB1jze+cjvXaPSvNQXptBhE1BO5K3OaMmpareBRWCtrJ54pBigRwXc7OF65Ax8mefMEa5lX33bkIWC5SGBVTrBspOemz30CWRaSYKo1CZob3/r0szlRpHPtuLNUaU9WgHk5jp4W+iEZt2od9MuIxig5JNiQkVWlDTnSH1QPjTJGou012eoD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsXyQ+SeQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="uThmtIYGzBkF4T779QSpFAHl75g=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWFiQdtdwYUuK9gHNKVMxtt2bGYSZybSEvoP7kQX4tb/cePfmNYKlqJndTnn3Nfxo4BrQ8inlVlaXlldy67bG5tb2zu53b26DmPFsMbCIFRNn2oMuMSa4SbAZqSQCj/Ahj+4mOiNB1Sah/LGjCJsC9qTvMsZNSlV9y6pELSTKxCHlEukWM4vFq5DpijADNVO7sO7DVksUBoWUK1bKHvpsf0Tl0SmnSiMQmXG9tG/Ls1Uapz4bC/WGFE2oD1MYqbHv4lWbLqlYTvhMooNSjYnJlRoQU1/gdQj4c+TqLlMd3mCDpCmORmDyvamU/N9x+DQTmP4+TX/d1E/dVziuNekUDmbBZKFAziEY3DhHCpwBVWoAYM7eIRneLHurSfr1Xr7tmasWc8+zMF6/wIrrpFK</latexit>
spontaneous emission
P Zoller, CIRM Preschool: Measurement & Control of Quantum Systems, 2018-04-17/18
Ion Trap Quantum Computer
• single ion- Hamiltonians, examples for quantum state engineering
•many ions - Hamiltonians, entangling gate
… as a Quantum Optical Problem
Appendices: • quantum information: qubits, quantum gates etc.
• From real atoms to two-level atoms & Rabi oscillations
P Zoller, CIRM Preschool: Measurement & Control of Quantum Systems, 2018-04-17/18
Side-Remarks
From Real Atoms to Two-Level SystemsRabi Oscillations
uibkTwo-Level Atom & Rabi Oscillations
|g i
|ei|ni
|Ei
Eg =fl!g
Ee =fl!e
En =fl!n
E
fl!L
...
energy
Real Atom
laser
~Ecl(~x = 0, t ) = E~≤e°i!t +E §~≤§e+i!t
¥ ~Ecl(+)
(0, t )+~E (°)cl (0, t )
<latexit sha1_base64="w/djFd9jOrX+sd1xnwK0QN4aNik=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="w/djFd9jOrX+sd1xnwK0QN4aNik=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="w/djFd9jOrX+sd1xnwK0QN4aNik=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="w/djFd9jOrX+sd1xnwK0QN4aNik=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="BCBMkHjI4nwLRWsTOdcwlZcfcEE=">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</latexit>
Electric field of laser
Problem: We drive an atom near-resonant with a laser (no motion)
Schrödinger Equation
ifl d
d t|√(t )i=
°H0A °~µ ·~Ecl(~x = 0, t )
¢|√(t )i
<latexit sha1_base64="KumcLdWmf438Ftja5Oyf8hZB1PM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KumcLdWmf438Ftja5Oyf8hZB1PM=">AAACZ3icfZFdSxwxFIYzU9tupx+uForgzbZLYQUdMhZavZAqUvDSQleFzTJksmd3wmY+SM7ISsy/7E1ve9e7/gRnxgpupT1XJ89584bzJimVNEjpD89/tPL4ydPOs+D5i5evVrtr62emqLSAoShUoS8SbkDJHIYoUcFFqYFniYLzZH7czM8vQRtZ5N/wqoRxxme5nErBsUZx95qNAsnShGs21VzYibMTdNesNHKAW0zzfKbggCmY4uAktvTI7bBLEJZllWNiUmB7+uLimnBMdWaFcm7Q0oU7oNuNiZyluPWXZ8DGQdzt05Du79EP+72HTRTStvqff5O2TuPudzYpRJVBjkJxY0ZQW0mTbke0xLHVUBYaXfD+vyojdC1sdAGrDJRczPkMbCWMuw9GFU73FmMr87JCyMXS0PLMNPs+gOYqS5YhGJnXb9XxzIHX/4MIOmCtay8NERZNDHe79v7dnO2GEQ2jr7v9w4+3eZAO2STvyIBE5BM5JCfklAyJID+9jrfmrXu//FX/jb9xK/W9P3dek6Xy394ANLq9BA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KumcLdWmf438Ftja5Oyf8hZB1PM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KumcLdWmf438Ftja5Oyf8hZB1PM=">AAACZ3icfZFdSxwxFIYzU9tupx+uForgzbZLYQUdMhZavZAqUvDSQleFzTJksmd3wmY+SM7ISsy/7E1ve9e7/gRnxgpupT1XJ89584bzJimVNEjpD89/tPL4ydPOs+D5i5evVrtr62emqLSAoShUoS8SbkDJHIYoUcFFqYFniYLzZH7czM8vQRtZ5N/wqoRxxme5nErBsUZx95qNAsnShGs21VzYibMTdNesNHKAW0zzfKbggCmY4uAktvTI7bBLEJZllWNiUmB7+uLimnBMdWaFcm7Q0oU7oNuNiZyluPWXZ8DGQdzt05Du79EP+72HTRTStvqff5O2TuPudzYpRJVBjkJxY0ZQW0mTbke0xLHVUBYaXfD+vyojdC1sdAGrDJRczPkMbCWMuw9GFU73FmMr87JCyMXS0PLMNPs+gOYqS5YhGJnXb9XxzIHX/4MIOmCtay8NERZNDHe79v7dnO2GEQ2jr7v9w4+3eZAO2STvyIBE5BM5JCfklAyJID+9jrfmrXu//FX/jb9xK/W9P3dek6Xy394ANLq9BA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="huLrFM7IAeCZVwXfFh5T8QiJXcE=">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</latexit>
Two-Level System (TLS)
|√(t )i= ag (t )|g i+ae (t )|ei<latexit sha1_base64="7o0JmFRW/Q4yrZ8B5pxEyu7ChvQ=">AAACJXicfZDLSsNAFIZP6q3GW9Slm2IRKkpIKmgriAU3LivYCzSlTMbTdGhuzEykJe27uPNN3IkuiuDKV/ARTC+CRfRfnfOd/5xhfjt0mZCG8a6kFhaXllfSq+ra+sbmlra9UxVBxClWaOAGvG4TgS7zsSKZdLEeciSe7WLN7l6N57V75IIF/q3sh9j0iOOzNqNEJqilnVsNdWCFguXkocWJ77h4QVqxM0z6gTMjRwnBCcEZUa2m2tKyhm4UC8ZJMfO7MHVjouzlJ0xUbmkj6y6gkYe+pC4RooHJKSY6x6YRymbMMQy4HKoH/7oE5Ylx7FOtSGBIaJc4GEdUDH+CRiTbhV4zZn4YSfTp3DAmnvCI7PyCou/Z8xAF85O3LI90kSTpSolctSZXMx1dYm8cw/dfM38X1bxuGrp5k8+WTqd5QBr2YB9yYMIZlOAaylABCg/wBC/wqjwqz8pIeZtaU8psZxfmpHx8AZcLp10=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7o0JmFRW/Q4yrZ8B5pxEyu7ChvQ=">AAACJXicfZDLSsNAFIZP6q3GW9Slm2IRKkpIKmgriAU3LivYCzSlTMbTdGhuzEykJe27uPNN3IkuiuDKV/ARTC+CRfRfnfOd/5xhfjt0mZCG8a6kFhaXllfSq+ra+sbmlra9UxVBxClWaOAGvG4TgS7zsSKZdLEeciSe7WLN7l6N57V75IIF/q3sh9j0iOOzNqNEJqilnVsNdWCFguXkocWJ77h4QVqxM0z6gTMjRwnBCcEZUa2m2tKyhm4UC8ZJMfO7MHVjouzlJ0xUbmkj6y6gkYe+pC4RooHJKSY6x6YRymbMMQy4HKoH/7oE5Ylx7FOtSGBIaJc4GEdUDH+CRiTbhV4zZn4YSfTp3DAmnvCI7PyCou/Z8xAF85O3LI90kSTpSolctSZXMx1dYm8cw/dfM38X1bxuGrp5k8+WTqd5QBr2YB9yYMIZlOAaylABCg/wBC/wqjwqz8pIeZtaU8psZxfmpHx8AZcLp10=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7o0JmFRW/Q4yrZ8B5pxEyu7ChvQ=">AAACJXicfZDLSsNAFIZP6q3GW9Slm2IRKkpIKmgriAU3LivYCzSlTMbTdGhuzEykJe27uPNN3IkuiuDKV/ARTC+CRfRfnfOd/5xhfjt0mZCG8a6kFhaXllfSq+ra+sbmlra9UxVBxClWaOAGvG4TgS7zsSKZdLEeciSe7WLN7l6N57V75IIF/q3sh9j0iOOzNqNEJqilnVsNdWCFguXkocWJ77h4QVqxM0z6gTMjRwnBCcEZUa2m2tKyhm4UC8ZJMfO7MHVjouzlJ0xUbmkj6y6gkYe+pC4RooHJKSY6x6YRymbMMQy4HKoH/7oE5Ylx7FOtSGBIaJc4GEdUDH+CRiTbhV4zZn4YSfTp3DAmnvCI7PyCou/Z8xAF85O3LI90kSTpSolctSZXMx1dYm8cw/dfM38X1bxuGrp5k8+WTqd5QBr2YB9yYMIZlOAaylABCg/wBC/wqjwqz8pIeZtaU8psZxfmpHx8AZcLp10=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="7o0JmFRW/Q4yrZ8B5pxEyu7ChvQ=">AAACJXicfZDLSsNAFIZP6q3GW9Slm2IRKkpIKmgriAU3LivYCzSlTMbTdGhuzEykJe27uPNN3IkuiuDKV/ARTC+CRfRfnfOd/5xhfjt0mZCG8a6kFhaXllfSq+ra+sbmlra9UxVBxClWaOAGvG4TgS7zsSKZdLEeciSe7WLN7l6N57V75IIF/q3sh9j0iOOzNqNEJqilnVsNdWCFguXkocWJ77h4QVqxM0z6gTMjRwnBCcEZUa2m2tKyhm4UC8ZJMfO7MHVjouzlJ0xUbmkj6y6gkYe+pC4RooHJKSY6x6YRymbMMQy4HKoH/7oE5Ylx7FOtSGBIaJc4GEdUDH+CRiTbhV4zZn4YSfTp3DAmnvCI7PyCou/Z8xAF85O3LI90kSTpSolctSZXMx1dYm8cw/dfM38X1bxuGrp5k8+WTqd5QBr2YB9yYMIZlOAaylABCg/wBC/wqjwqz8pIeZtaU8psZxfmpHx8AZcLp10=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="nsJC/YBaN4924F4Bpr1Y0sW8jqM=">AAACJXicfZDLSsNAFIYn9VbjLerSTbEIFSUkFbQVhIIblxXsBZoQJuNpOjSZhJmJtKR9F3e+iTvRRRFc+SqmNYKl6L865zv/OcP8buRTIQ3jQ8ktLa+sruXX1Y3Nre0dbXevKcKYE2iQ0A9528UCfMqgIan0oR1xwIHrQ8vtX0/nrQfggobsTg4jsAPsMdqlBMsUOdql1VFHViRoSR5bHDPPhyvsJN447UdeRk5SAjMCGVEtW3W0oqEb1YpxVi0sFqZuzFREmeqONrHuQxIHwCTxsRAdSE9R0Ts1jUjaCYco5HKsHv3rEoSnxqlPtWIBESZ97EESEzH+DTqx7FYGdkJZFEtgZG6Y4EAEWPYWoBgG7jwEQVn6lhXgPuA0XSmBq9bsaqGnSxhMY/j5a+HvolnWTUM3b8vF2nkWSB4doENUQia6QDV0g+qogQh6RM/oFb0pT8qLMlHev605JdvZR3NSPr8A+ZumLg==</latexit>
keep resonant
levels
Rotating Wave Approximation
~µ ~Ecl(0, t ) °!~µeg~≤ ~Ecl(+)
(0, t )|eihg |+~µg e~≤~E(°)cl (0, t )|g ihe|
<latexit sha1_base64="ohow2e7lKe/9uKEz58E8fJBnSyE=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ohow2e7lKe/9uKEz58E8fJBnSyE=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ohow2e7lKe/9uKEz58E8fJBnSyE=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ohow2e7lKe/9uKEz58E8fJBnSyE=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="m+AEg2R2HinwQaKXlROnfNgnVr0=">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</latexit>
emissionabsorption
uibkTwo-Level Atom & Rabi Oscillations
|g i
|ei|ni
|Ei
Eg =fl!g
Ee =fl!e
En =fl!n
E
fl!L
...
energy
Real Atom
laser
Hamiltonian TLS + RWA
Problem: We drive an atom near-resonant with a laser (no motion)
H =fl!eg |eihe|°~µeg~≤E e°i!t |eihg |°~µg e~≤E
§e
i!t |g ihe|<latexit sha1_base64="KYALN75pdS+J7qiY7bHeCq8tiuQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KYALN75pdS+J7qiY7bHeCq8tiuQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KYALN75pdS+J7qiY7bHeCq8tiuQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="KYALN75pdS+J7qiY7bHeCq8tiuQ=">AAACsXicfZFLTsMwEIad8A6vAks2ERUSixIlIAFdIJAQUpcFUR6qS3HMkFp1nMh2KpDJ9TgBG27BEUhTkKgqmI3H//z+7BmHKWdK+/6HZU9Nz8zOzS84i0vLK6uVtfVrlWSSQosmPJG3IVHAmYCWZprDbSqBxCGHm7B/NqzfDEAqlogr/ZJCJyaRYE+MEl1I3cobbjuNY9wLicRJDBHpGojyV8CSiIgD5uXiwusuHgA1OM7y0jHaQaoYT0SOY6J7lHBznuMa3JtdNoK5ehIVjaEi+Bt1bzBROi94v3DRxMsc3HG6larv+fUjf7/uTiaB55dRPflEZTS7lXf8mNAsBqEpJ0q1oaAx1asFfqo7RkKaSJ072/+6FJWFcehzcKYgJbRPIjAZVflvoZ3pp6PnjmEizTQIOlY0JFbDlidE9RKH4yIoJoq7ign1gRQ/rTVIB5dUt+dpeB6O4adX9+/kes8LfC+42KueHozmgebRJtpCOyhAh+gUNVATtRC1atal1bawvW/f2Q92OLLa1veZDTQWdv8L4GPc/w==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/CH18+kI2iCiIjaG14i0DF4PjWI=">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</latexit>
id
d t
µaeag
∂=
µ°¢ °~µeg~≤E
°~µg e~≤§E § 0
∂µaeag
∂
<latexit sha1_base64="FD/TsqW6dtjO4nWfI8IXasSn8og=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="FD/TsqW6dtjO4nWfI8IXasSn8og=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="FD/TsqW6dtjO4nWfI8IXasSn8og=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="FD/TsqW6dtjO4nWfI8IXasSn8og=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="TDNG2w1wkarRNuOL6yGHPjiWAJQ=">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</latexit>
ae (t ) = ae (t )e°i!t<latexit sha1_base64="vfDaR9CvuErqFx8LxD7Q6d6+34Y=">AAACFXicfZDLSsNQEIYn9VbjrerSTbEVqmhIKmi7EAtuXFawVTC1nByn7aG5kTORlpB3cOebuBNdiFs3bnwLH8H0IlhE/9XwzT8zzG/5tpCk6x9Kamp6ZnYuPa8uLC4tr2RW1+rSCwOONe7ZXnBpMYm2cLFGgmy89ANkjmXjhdU9GfQvbjGQwnPPqe9jw2FtV7QEZ5SgZmYnz5oRxgXaPjJJ2DcYsXgM8DraE6bnYJtlKc6rzUxO1/RySd8vZ38XhqYPlTv+hKGqzcy7eePx0EGXuM2kvEK3nbzU2TV0nxpRgL4XUKxu/euSPEiMA59qhhJ9xrusjVHIZfwTXIXUKvUakXD9kNDlE82IOdJh1PkFZd+xJiFK4Sa3TId1kSVpEmGgmsOt2Y5G2BvE8P1r9u+iXtQMXTPOirnKwSgPSMMGbEIBDDiECpxCFWrA4Q4e4AmelXvlUXlRXkfWlDKeWYcJKW9fJQCg2A==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="vfDaR9CvuErqFx8LxD7Q6d6+34Y=">AAACFXicfZDLSsNQEIYn9VbjrerSTbEVqmhIKmi7EAtuXFawVTC1nByn7aG5kTORlpB3cOebuBNdiFs3bnwLH8H0IlhE/9XwzT8zzG/5tpCk6x9Kamp6ZnYuPa8uLC4tr2RW1+rSCwOONe7ZXnBpMYm2cLFGgmy89ANkjmXjhdU9GfQvbjGQwnPPqe9jw2FtV7QEZ5SgZmYnz5oRxgXaPjJJ2DcYsXgM8DraE6bnYJtlKc6rzUxO1/RySd8vZ38XhqYPlTv+hKGqzcy7eePx0EGXuM2kvEK3nbzU2TV0nxpRgL4XUKxu/euSPEiMA59qhhJ9xrusjVHIZfwTXIXUKvUakXD9kNDlE82IOdJh1PkFZd+xJiFK4Sa3TId1kSVpEmGgmsOt2Y5G2BvE8P1r9u+iXtQMXTPOirnKwSgPSMMGbEIBDDiECpxCFWrA4Q4e4AmelXvlUXlRXkfWlDKeWYcJKW9fJQCg2A==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="vfDaR9CvuErqFx8LxD7Q6d6+34Y=">AAACFXicfZDLSsNQEIYn9VbjrerSTbEVqmhIKmi7EAtuXFawVTC1nByn7aG5kTORlpB3cOebuBNdiFs3bnwLH8H0IlhE/9XwzT8zzG/5tpCk6x9Kamp6ZnYuPa8uLC4tr2RW1+rSCwOONe7ZXnBpMYm2cLFGgmy89ANkjmXjhdU9GfQvbjGQwnPPqe9jw2FtV7QEZ5SgZmYnz5oRxgXaPjJJ2DcYsXgM8DraE6bnYJtlKc6rzUxO1/RySd8vZ38XhqYPlTv+hKGqzcy7eePx0EGXuM2kvEK3nbzU2TV0nxpRgL4XUKxu/euSPEiMA59qhhJ9xrusjVHIZfwTXIXUKvUakXD9kNDlE82IOdJh1PkFZd+xJiFK4Sa3TId1kSVpEmGgmsOt2Y5G2BvE8P1r9u+iXtQMXTPOirnKwSgPSMMGbEIBDDiECpxCFWrA4Q4e4AmelXvlUXlRXkfWlDKeWYcJKW9fJQCg2A==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="vfDaR9CvuErqFx8LxD7Q6d6+34Y=">AAACFXicfZDLSsNQEIYn9VbjrerSTbEVqmhIKmi7EAtuXFawVTC1nByn7aG5kTORlpB3cOebuBNdiFs3bnwLH8H0IlhE/9XwzT8zzG/5tpCk6x9Kamp6ZnYuPa8uLC4tr2RW1+rSCwOONe7ZXnBpMYm2cLFGgmy89ANkjmXjhdU9GfQvbjGQwnPPqe9jw2FtV7QEZ5SgZmYnz5oRxgXaPjJJ2DcYsXgM8DraE6bnYJtlKc6rzUxO1/RySd8vZ38XhqYPlTv+hKGqzcy7eePx0EGXuM2kvEK3nbzU2TV0nxpRgL4XUKxu/euSPEiMA59qhhJ9xrusjVHIZfwTXIXUKvUakXD9kNDlE82IOdJh1PkFZd+xJiFK4Sa3TId1kSVpEmGgmsOt2Y5G2BvE8P1r9u+iXtQMXTPOirnKwSgPSMMGbEIBDDiECpxCFWrA4Q4e4AmelXvlUXlRXkfWlDKeWYcJKW9fJQCg2A==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="lYpxvKkXiKRgIqiBvu7p6agqY1E=">AAACFXicfZDLSsNQEIZP6q3GW9Slm2ArVNGQVNB2IRTcuKxgL9DUcnI6bQ/NjZyJtIS8gzvfxJ3oQty6cePbmNYIlqL/avjmnxnmt3ybC9T1TymzsLi0vJJdldfWNza3lO2duvDCgEGNebYXNC0qwOYu1JCjDU0/AOpYNjSs4eWk37iDQHDPvcGxD22H9l3e44xigjrKUZ52IogLeHhhIre7ENE4BXAbnXDTc6BPVYzzckfJ6ZpeLumnZXW+MDR9qhxJVe0oH2bXY6EDLjKbCtECt5+8NDg2dB/bUQC+F2AsH/zrEixIjBOfbIYCfMqGtA9RyET8G7RC7JVG7Yi7fojgsplmRB3hUBzMQTF2rFkIgrvJLdOhQ6BJmogQyOZ0qzrQEEaTGH5+Vf8u6kXN0DXjupirnKWBZMke2ScFYpBzUiFXpEpqhJF78kieyYv0ID1Jr9LbtzUjpTO7ZEbS+xeHkJ+p</latexit>
Parameters: Rabi frequency ≠c ¥ 2~µeg~≤E /fl¥≠e°i' and detuning ¢=!°!eg<latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">AAACinicfVHBbtNAEF0bCsUUSOHIxSJBQoIaOxRoQIhKFIkbAZG2Uje1xpuJvYq9XnbXUSPL38JPceEv+ATWMUhEFcxlZ968mad9k8icaxOGPxz3ytWta9e3b3g3d27dvtPbvXusy0oxnLAyL9VpAhpzLnBiuMnxVCqEIsnxJFm8a/snS1Sal+KLWUmcFpAKPucMjIXi3rcxKCjQWMor/zMk3J8r/FqhYCt/QD8WmEJcs4ZajC+HdImspkXVxDWmTVeh1DwvRUMLMBmDvH7fPKVZAqqb6Xb4eF7vcboEJTPeDDwQM3+GphJcpFbnCHMDb2jZUve6Z60w8OJePwzC0UH4bORfTqIgXEf/7U+yjnHc+05nJasKFIbloPUZitT6mD2JQmmmtUJZKtN4D//L0kxZYsvzaKVRAltAinXFdPM3cFaZ+cHFtOZCVsZattGsodCtJZdAvSqSTRA1F1bLOrhAsCc09hweXW/1s8DgRWvDn7/6/06Oh0EUBtGnYf/wRecH2Sb3yQPyiETkJTkkH8iYTAhztpzHzr7z3N1xh+7Ifd1RXef3zD2yEe7RL/scyc8=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="En/m3LWWBeI/eDXZy2pGDxXTd78=">AAAB23icfVC7SgNBFL0bX3GNGmubYBAsZJm10VKwsYxgHpANYXZyk4zZmR1m7krCkh+wEizE/7Lxb9zEFMaApzqcc7iPE5tEOmLsyyttbe/s7pX3/YOKf3h0XK20XJpZgU2RJqntxNxhIjU2SVKCHWORqzjBdjy5W/jtZ7ROpvqRZgZ7io+0HErBqZAa/WqdBWyJ2iYJV6QOK/Srn9EgFZlCTSLhznVRj4orx5chM9TLLZrU0tw//zflhC2Ci5wfZQ4NFxM+wjwTbv5b6GY0vJn2cqlNRqjFmplz5RSn8YboZipeF9FJXeyKFJ8gLwoiQutHy6m1cUA49YsWwr8/b5LWVRCyIHxgUIZTOIMLCOEabuEeGtAEAQN4gTfvyXv13n/aKnmr2k5gDd7HN3UTjEQ=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="aXpr44JMNcbXf77zn7gNFZlHxnA=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="hPhGQJfkPf2zzBZbdCiK8jAW9pQ=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="wjckFxTURzHyFBoEHpeomUHhDfM=">AAACinicfVHBbtNAEF0bCsUUSOHIxSJBQoIaOxRoQEiVKBI3AiJtpW6wxpuJvYq9XnbXUSPL38JPceFvWMdBIqpgLjvz5s087ZtE5lybMPzluNeu79y4uXvLu7135+693v79U11WiuGElXmpzhPQmHOBE8NNjudSIRRJjmfJ4n3bP1ui0rwUX81K4rSAVPA5Z2AsFPd+jEFBgcZS3vhfIOH+XOH3CgVb+QP6qcAU4po11GJ8OaRLZDUtqiauMW26CqXmeSkaWoDJGOT1h+Y5zRJQ3Uy3w8dv9QGnS1Ay483AAzHzZ2gqwUVqdU4wN/COli31oHvWCgMv7vXDIBwdhS9G/tUkCsJ19MkmxnHvJ52VrCpQGJaD1hcoUutj9iwKpZnWCmWpTOM9/i9LM2WJLc+jlUYJbAEp1hXTzd/ARWXmR5fTmgtZGWvZVrOGQreWXAH1qki2QdRcWC3r4ALBntDYc3h0vdXPAoOXrQ1//ur/OzkdBlEYRJ/D/vGrjSG75CF5RJ6QiLwmx+QjGZMJYc6O89Q5dF66e+7QHblvO6rrbGYekK1wT34DXRvIng==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kcAvkcINpWhTRaOw3SrWcV8gCKM=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="IzEoayQPS/h+RImUxyrQ6KZLzes=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kcAvkcINpWhTRaOw3SrWcV8gCKM=">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</latexit>
emissionabsorption
Transformation to “rotating frame”:
H =°fl¢|eihe|° 12fl≠e
°i'|eihg |° 12fl≠e
+i'|g ihe|<latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kmYWCjIU2Znzpw2SJpAbkFyBLR4=">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</latexit>
Validity ≠, |¢|ø!º!eg<latexit sha1_base64="oswoDySoY9zCTJaMbaBcaBKiUD4=">AAACGHicfZDPSsNAEMYn/q3xX9Wjl2IreNCQVND2ZEEP3qxgVXBL2axjGrpJlt2NtKR9Cm++iTfRg3gVL76Fj2DaKliKfqeZ33yzy3yu4L7Stv1hTExOTc/MZubM+YXFpeXsyuq5imLJsMYiHslLlyrkfog17WuOl0IiDVyOF27rsD+/uEWp/Cg80x2B9YB6oX/jM6pT1MjuFMhJgB7d7pIj5Jp2Ceck6hNChZBRe9g0EvR6BbORzduWXS7Zu+XceOFY9kD5g08YqNrIvpPriMUBhppxqtQVhl56VXPbsYWuJxJFJHXP3PzXpZhMjX2fSWKFgrIW9TCJmer9Blexvim164kfilhjyEaGCQ1UQHVzDKpO4I5CVH6Y/kUC2kKaBqo1SpMMXs01LY3tfgw/t+b+Ls6LlmNbzmkxX9kb5gEZWIcN2AIH9qECx1CFGjC4gwd4gmfj3ng0XozXoXXC+N5ZgxEZb1/8fqML</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="oswoDySoY9zCTJaMbaBcaBKiUD4=">AAACGHicfZDPSsNAEMYn/q3xX9Wjl2IreNCQVND2ZEEP3qxgVXBL2axjGrpJlt2NtKR9Cm++iTfRg3gVL76Fj2DaKliKfqeZ33yzy3yu4L7Stv1hTExOTc/MZubM+YXFpeXsyuq5imLJsMYiHslLlyrkfog17WuOl0IiDVyOF27rsD+/uEWp/Cg80x2B9YB6oX/jM6pT1MjuFMhJgB7d7pIj5Jp2Ceck6hNChZBRe9g0EvR6BbORzduWXS7Zu+XceOFY9kD5g08YqNrIvpPriMUBhppxqtQVhl56VXPbsYWuJxJFJHXP3PzXpZhMjX2fSWKFgrIW9TCJmer9Blexvim164kfilhjyEaGCQ1UQHVzDKpO4I5CVH6Y/kUC2kKaBqo1SpMMXs01LY3tfgw/t+b+Ls6LlmNbzmkxX9kb5gEZWIcN2AIH9qECx1CFGjC4gwd4gmfj3ng0XozXoXXC+N5ZgxEZb1/8fqML</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="oswoDySoY9zCTJaMbaBcaBKiUD4=">AAACGHicfZDPSsNAEMYn/q3xX9Wjl2IreNCQVND2ZEEP3qxgVXBL2axjGrpJlt2NtKR9Cm++iTfRg3gVL76Fj2DaKliKfqeZ33yzy3yu4L7Stv1hTExOTc/MZubM+YXFpeXsyuq5imLJsMYiHslLlyrkfog17WuOl0IiDVyOF27rsD+/uEWp/Cg80x2B9YB6oX/jM6pT1MjuFMhJgB7d7pIj5Jp2Ceck6hNChZBRe9g0EvR6BbORzduWXS7Zu+XceOFY9kD5g08YqNrIvpPriMUBhppxqtQVhl56VXPbsYWuJxJFJHXP3PzXpZhMjX2fSWKFgrIW9TCJmer9Blexvim164kfilhjyEaGCQ1UQHVzDKpO4I5CVH6Y/kUC2kKaBqo1SpMMXs01LY3tfgw/t+b+Ls6LlmNbzmkxX9kb5gEZWIcN2AIH9qECx1CFGjC4gwd4gmfj3ng0XozXoXXC+N5ZgxEZb1/8fqML</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="oswoDySoY9zCTJaMbaBcaBKiUD4=">AAACGHicfZDPSsNAEMYn/q3xX9Wjl2IreNCQVND2ZEEP3qxgVXBL2axjGrpJlt2NtKR9Cm++iTfRg3gVL76Fj2DaKliKfqeZ33yzy3yu4L7Stv1hTExOTc/MZubM+YXFpeXsyuq5imLJsMYiHslLlyrkfog17WuOl0IiDVyOF27rsD+/uEWp/Cg80x2B9YB6oX/jM6pT1MjuFMhJgB7d7pIj5Jp2Ceck6hNChZBRe9g0EvR6BbORzduWXS7Zu+XceOFY9kD5g08YqNrIvpPriMUBhppxqtQVhl56VXPbsYWuJxJFJHXP3PzXpZhMjX2fSWKFgrIW9TCJmer9Blexvim164kfilhjyEaGCQ1UQHVzDKpO4I5CVH6Y/kUC2kKaBqo1SpMMXs01LY3tfgw/t+b+Ls6LlmNbzmkxX9kb5gEZWIcN2AIH9qECx1CFGjC4gwd4gmfj3ng0XozXoXXC+N5ZgxEZb1/8fqML</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="6dERv0MKoNywelMkCDvtE2LufoM=">AAACGHicfZDLSsNAFIYn9VbjLerSTbEVXNSQVNB2V9CFOyvYC3RKmYynaegkGWYm0pL2Kdz5Ju5EF+JW3Pg2phfBUvRfnfOd/8xwfoczTyrL+tJSS8srq2vpdX1jc2t7x9jdq8kwEhSqNGShaDhEAvMCqCpPMWhwAcR3GNSd3sV4Xr8HIb0wuFUDDi2fuIHX8ShRCWobJzl87YNL8kN8CUyRIWYMh2OCCeci7E+bdgzuKKe3jaxlWqWidVrKLBa2aU2URTNV2sYnvgtp5EOgKCNSNiFwk6u6edviqhUL4KFQI/3oX5ekIjGOfTqOJHBCe8SFOKJy9Bs0I9Up9luxF/BIQUDnhjHxpU9UdwHKge/MQ5BekPyFfdIDkgSqFAgdT17NdE0F/XEMP7dm/i5qBdO2TPumkC2fzQJJowN0iI6Rjc5RGV2hCqoiih7QE3pBr9qj9qy9ae9Ta0qb7eyjOWkf318dodw=</latexit>
Hamiltonian in “rotating frame”
uibkTwo-Level Atom & Rabi Oscillations
Two-Level Atom
H =°fl¢|eihe|° 12fl≠e
°i'|eihg |° 12fl≠e
+i'|g ihe|<latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="27c0t6jkI4G7esty8pM9fH8Pp00=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kmYWCjIU2Znzpw2SJpAbkFyBLR4=">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</latexit>
Hamiltonian in “rotating frame”
|g i
|eilaser
Discussion: on-resonance Rabi oscillations (¢= 0)<latexit sha1_base64="8OlGPRtPVvhURLzV/Go48ZaEW3U=">AAAB9nicfVBLSwJRGP3GXja9rJZtJA0MYrhjULqIhFq0NMgHOIPcuX3qxXl1751QBn9Hu6hFtO3HtOlf9BMatSCROquPc873Ok7ocqkI+dBSC4tLyyvpVX1tfWNzK7O9U5dBJBjWWOAGoulQiS73saa4crEZCqSe42LD6V+M9cY9CskD/0YNQ7Q92vV5hzOqEsou5K1LdBU9I/lDvZ3JEYOUS+S4nJ0vTINMkDv/hAmq7cy7dRuwyENfMZdK2UK/m9zcOzJJqOxYYBgINdIP/nVJJhLj2KdbkcSQsj7tYhwxOfpNtCLVKQ3smPthpNBnM2JMPelR1Zsj5dBzZkmU3E92WR7tI03iUgqFbk2mZnuGwsE4hp9fs38X9aJhEsO8LuYqJ9M8IA17sA8FMOEUKnAFVagBgzt4gCd41gbao/aivU6tKe27ZxdmoL19AYZkk9g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="8OlGPRtPVvhURLzV/Go48ZaEW3U=">AAAB9nicfVBLSwJRGP3GXja9rJZtJA0MYrhjULqIhFq0NMgHOIPcuX3qxXl1751QBn9Hu6hFtO3HtOlf9BMatSCROquPc873Ok7ocqkI+dBSC4tLyyvpVX1tfWNzK7O9U5dBJBjWWOAGoulQiS73saa4crEZCqSe42LD6V+M9cY9CskD/0YNQ7Q92vV5hzOqEsou5K1LdBU9I/lDvZ3JEYOUS+S4nJ0vTINMkDv/hAmq7cy7dRuwyENfMZdK2UK/m9zcOzJJqOxYYBgINdIP/nVJJhLj2KdbkcSQsj7tYhwxOfpNtCLVKQ3smPthpNBnM2JMPelR1Zsj5dBzZkmU3E92WR7tI03iUgqFbk2mZnuGwsE4hp9fs38X9aJhEsO8LuYqJ9M8IA17sA8FMOEUKnAFVagBgzt4gCd41gbao/aivU6tKe27ZxdmoL19AYZkk9g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="8OlGPRtPVvhURLzV/Go48ZaEW3U=">AAAB9nicfVBLSwJRGP3GXja9rJZtJA0MYrhjULqIhFq0NMgHOIPcuX3qxXl1751QBn9Hu6hFtO3HtOlf9BMatSCROquPc873Ok7ocqkI+dBSC4tLyyvpVX1tfWNzK7O9U5dBJBjWWOAGoulQiS73saa4crEZCqSe42LD6V+M9cY9CskD/0YNQ7Q92vV5hzOqEsou5K1LdBU9I/lDvZ3JEYOUS+S4nJ0vTINMkDv/hAmq7cy7dRuwyENfMZdK2UK/m9zcOzJJqOxYYBgINdIP/nVJJhLj2KdbkcSQsj7tYhwxOfpNtCLVKQ3smPthpNBnM2JMPelR1Zsj5dBzZkmU3E92WR7tI03iUgqFbk2mZnuGwsE4hp9fs38X9aJhEsO8LuYqJ9M8IA17sA8FMOEUKnAFVagBgzt4gCd41gbao/aivU6tKe27ZxdmoL19AYZkk9g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="8OlGPRtPVvhURLzV/Go48ZaEW3U=">AAAB9nicfVBLSwJRGP3GXja9rJZtJA0MYrhjULqIhFq0NMgHOIPcuX3qxXl1751QBn9Hu6hFtO3HtOlf9BMatSCROquPc873Ok7ocqkI+dBSC4tLyyvpVX1tfWNzK7O9U5dBJBjWWOAGoulQiS73saa4crEZCqSe42LD6V+M9cY9CskD/0YNQ7Q92vV5hzOqEsou5K1LdBU9I/lDvZ3JEYOUS+S4nJ0vTINMkDv/hAmq7cy7dRuwyENfMZdK2UK/m9zcOzJJqOxYYBgINdIP/nVJJhLj2KdbkcSQsj7tYhwxOfpNtCLVKQ3smPthpNBnM2JMPelR1Zsj5dBzZkmU3E92WR7tI03iUgqFbk2mZnuGwsE4hp9fs38X9aJhEsO8LuYqJ9M8IA17sA8FMOEUKnAFVagBgzt4gCd41gbao/aivU6tKe27ZxdmoL19AYZkk9g=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="iQHdXRPFnl2Im8dgujHusDCEzmg=">AAAB9nicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduiq1QQcKkgrYLoaALlxXsA5pSJuNtOzSZxJmJtIR+hzvRhbj1Y9z4N6a1gqXoWV3OOfd13NDjShPyaaSWlldW19Lr5sbm1vZOZnevroJIMqyxwAtk06UKPS6wprn2sBlKpL7rYcMdXE70xgNKxQNxq0chtn3aE7zLGdUJ1S7knSv0NL0g+WOzk8kRi5RL5LScXSxsi0yRgxmqncyHcxewyEehmUeVaqHoJTf3T2wS6nYsMQykHptH/7oUk4lx4jOdSGFI2YD2MI6YGv8mWpHulobtmIsw0ijYnBhTX/lU9xdINfLdeRIVF8kux6cDpElcWqM0nenUbN/SOJzE8PNr9u+iXrRsYtk3xVzlbBZIGg7gEApgwzlU4BqqUAMG9/AIz/BiDI0n49V4+7amjFnPPszBeP8C6PSSqQ==</latexit>
Ut = e°i H t/fl =
µcos 1
2≠t °i e°i' sin 1
2≠t
°i e+i' sin 1
2≠t cos 12≠t
∂
<latexit sha1_base64="Girte9mL9GZsiD2COobqRSq9vB0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Girte9mL9GZsiD2COobqRSq9vB0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Girte9mL9GZsiD2COobqRSq9vB0=">AAACvXichZFdb9MwFIad8LFhvsq45CaiAg3BQtJJrLuYNomb3TEkuk2qu8pxTxOrjhPZJ2OV5T+JuOFf8BNI2yFRjcF7dfSex+fYr7NaSYtJ8iMI79y9d39j8wF9+Ojxk6edZ1untmqMgIGoVGXOM25BSQ0DlKjgvDbAy0zBWTb7uOifXYKxstJfcF7DqOS5llMpOLbWuPONDelg7NAfwIXbkQylmoA79vieFRk3/oApmOI2yyCX2nFj+Nw7ITxlorJsarhwqXc9zz6VkPMIo9fRjlyNuuSmLqRnVuq/gIzRJfj2f2A78ZZdlIGeXN+JGZkX+IayER13ukmc7PeT3f3oZpHGyVLdw59kqZNx5zubVKIpQaNQ3Noh6LyNvniXJjWOnIG6Mujpq39SVpgWXHCUNRZqLmY8B9cI6/80hg1O+1cjJ3XdIGix1nS8tCXH4oZp52W2bkIbVruLlXwGvP11RDCULadGRYxwtYjh91uj24vTXpwmcfq51z36sMqDbJIX5CXZJinZI0fkmJyQARFBP7gI8qAID0MIVahXaBhcn3lO1hR+/QVnF907</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Girte9mL9GZsiD2COobqRSq9vB0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Xu+sV/FnyHP31PPCyd0S7Iqohf4=">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</latexit>
eg
Examples:
• transition probability g → e
Pe√g (t ) = 12
[1°cos≠t ]<latexit sha1_base64="oB9j21zABZLPzx7etG+s68hRS1U=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="oB9j21zABZLPzx7etG+s68hRS1U=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="oB9j21zABZLPzx7etG+s68hRS1U=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="oB9j21zABZLPzx7etG+s68hRS1U=">AAACLXicfVBNS+NQFL1xdNTozFRdugkWwYGZkHRA7UJGdOPOClYLfaG8vLlNH80X791oJeT/uPOfuFJUELdu/QmmdQYsxTmryznn3ss5fhpKTY7zYEx9mp75PDs3by4sfvn6rbK0fKKTTAlsiiRMVMvnGkMZY5MkhdhKFfLID/HU7+8P9dMzVFom8TFdpOhFPIhlVwpOJdWp7LG22ejkyELsElcqObeCYoO+77Cu4iJ3i7xWjLS2+5OJRLPDCANuEVMy6JFnMs/sVKqO7dS3nV91a3JwbWeE6u8XGKHRqdywP4nIIoxJhFzrNsZBGbX3w3VS8nKFaaKoMNf/69JClcahz2SZxpSLPg8wz4Qu3hPtjLrbAy+XcZoRxmJMzHmkI069CVJfRP44iVrG5S8W8T7ysmUiVCYbXbV6NuFgWMO/rNbHw0nNdh3bPapVdzff+oA5WIU12AAXtmAXDqABTRBwCddwB/fGlXFrPBpPb9Yp4+/OCozBeH4FtQ+qdg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="6Gr2lkF7LjfyTYfdO1lLC11veQU=">AAACLXicfVDLSsNAFJ34rPFVdekmWAQFDUkFHwuh6MadFWwrdEKZjLfp0LyYudGWkP9x55+4UlQQt/6Gaa1gET2ryznn3ss5buwLhZb1qk1MTk3PzBbm9PmFxaXl4spqXUWJ5FDjkR/JK5cp8EUINRTow1UsgQWuDw23ezrQGzcglYjCS+zH4ATMC0VbcIY51Sqe0KZebaVAfWgjkzK6NbxsC7ePaVsyntpZWs6GWtPepTxS9DwAjxlIpfA66OjU0VvFkmVaR4fW3pHxe7BNa4gSGaHaKj7S64gnAYTIfaZUE0Ivj9rZsa0YnVRCHEnM9M1/XYrL3Djw6TRREDPeZR6kCVfZT6KZYPuw56QijBOEkI+JKQtUwLDzi1T9wB0nQYkw/0UD1gWWt4wIUqfDq0bHROgNavjOavw91MumbZn2RblU2R8VUiDrZINsEZsckAo5I1VSI5zckQfyTF60e+1Je9Pev6wT2mhnjYxB+/gEF66pRw==</latexit>
º-pulse ≠t =º inverts the TLS<latexit sha1_base64="iF+3j1tALUX8wBzGmClmiFWM03Q=">AAACF3icfZDNSsNAFIVv/K3xr+rSTbAKLjQkCmoXYsGNC8GKVoWmlMl4bYcmkyFzIy2lL+HON3EnuhC3ghvfwkcwbRUsRc/q8N1zZ7jHV4HQ5Dgfxsjo2PjEZGbKnJ6ZnZvPLixe6CiJOZZ4FETxlc80BkJiiQQFeKViZKEf4KXfOOzOL28x1iKS59RSWAlZTYobwRmlqJrdsFY9JVY3VRJoTP1JiDVm0X4XWkKmq6QtqqN1fnxmVrM5x3bye8523ho2ru30lDv4hJ6K1ey7dx3xJERJPGBal1HW0qPqG66jqNKOUUUxdcy1f1Oax2mwmzO9RKNivMFq2E647vwG5YRu9pqVtpAqIZR8YNhmoQ4Z1YegboX+IEQtZPqXF7IGsrRPIoxNr/eqVbcJm90afm61/jYXW7br2O7pVq6w0+8DMrAMK7AOLuxCAY6gCCXgcAcP8ATPxr3xaLwYr/3oiPG9swQDMt6+AFRGoDg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="iF+3j1tALUX8wBzGmClmiFWM03Q=">AAACF3icfZDNSsNAFIVv/K3xr+rSTbAKLjQkCmoXYsGNC8GKVoWmlMl4bYcmkyFzIy2lL+HON3EnuhC3ghvfwkcwbRUsRc/q8N1zZ7jHV4HQ5Dgfxsjo2PjEZGbKnJ6ZnZvPLixe6CiJOZZ4FETxlc80BkJiiQQFeKViZKEf4KXfOOzOL28x1iKS59RSWAlZTYobwRmlqJrdsFY9JVY3VRJoTP1JiDVm0X4XWkKmq6QtqqN1fnxmVrM5x3bye8523ho2ru30lDv4hJ6K1ey7dx3xJERJPGBal1HW0qPqG66jqNKOUUUxdcy1f1Oax2mwmzO9RKNivMFq2E647vwG5YRu9pqVtpAqIZR8YNhmoQ4Z1YegboX+IEQtZPqXF7IGsrRPIoxNr/eqVbcJm90afm61/jYXW7br2O7pVq6w0+8DMrAMK7AOLuxCAY6gCCXgcAcP8ATPxr3xaLwYr/3oiPG9swQDMt6+AFRGoDg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="iF+3j1tALUX8wBzGmClmiFWM03Q=">AAACF3icfZDNSsNAFIVv/K3xr+rSTbAKLjQkCmoXYsGNC8GKVoWmlMl4bYcmkyFzIy2lL+HON3EnuhC3ghvfwkcwbRUsRc/q8N1zZ7jHV4HQ5Dgfxsjo2PjEZGbKnJ6ZnZvPLixe6CiJOZZ4FETxlc80BkJiiQQFeKViZKEf4KXfOOzOL28x1iKS59RSWAlZTYobwRmlqJrdsFY9JVY3VRJoTP1JiDVm0X4XWkKmq6QtqqN1fnxmVrM5x3bye8523ho2ru30lDv4hJ6K1ey7dx3xJERJPGBal1HW0qPqG66jqNKOUUUxdcy1f1Oax2mwmzO9RKNivMFq2E647vwG5YRu9pqVtpAqIZR8YNhmoQ4Z1YegboX+IEQtZPqXF7IGsrRPIoxNr/eqVbcJm90afm61/jYXW7br2O7pVq6w0+8DMrAMK7AOLuxCAY6gCCXgcAcP8ATPxr3xaLwYr/3oiPG9swQDMt6+AFRGoDg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="iF+3j1tALUX8wBzGmClmiFWM03Q=">AAACF3icfZDNSsNAFIVv/K3xr+rSTbAKLjQkCmoXYsGNC8GKVoWmlMl4bYcmkyFzIy2lL+HON3EnuhC3ghvfwkcwbRUsRc/q8N1zZ7jHV4HQ5Dgfxsjo2PjEZGbKnJ6ZnZvPLixe6CiJOZZ4FETxlc80BkJiiQQFeKViZKEf4KXfOOzOL28x1iKS59RSWAlZTYobwRmlqJrdsFY9JVY3VRJoTP1JiDVm0X4XWkKmq6QtqqN1fnxmVrM5x3bye8523ho2ru30lDv4hJ6K1ey7dx3xJERJPGBal1HW0qPqG66jqNKOUUUxdcy1f1Oax2mwmzO9RKNivMFq2E647vwG5YRu9pqVtpAqIZR8YNhmoQ4Z1YegboX+IEQtZPqXF7IGsrRPIoxNr/eqVbcJm90afm61/jYXW7br2O7pVq6w0+8DMrAMK7AOLuxCAY6gCCXgcAcP8ATPxr3xaLwYr/3oiPG9swQDMt6+AFRGoDg=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="6j8Vufvqw06F9tt+qvTRJvxPFQ8=">AAACF3icfZBLS8NAFIUn9VXjq+rSTbAVXNSQVNB2IRTcuBCs2Bc0pUzG23ZoMhkyN9JS+ifc+U/ciS7EreDGf2NaK1iKntXhu+fOcI8rPa7Qsj61xMLi0vJKclVfW9/Y3Ept71RVEIUMKizwgrDuUgUeF1BBjh7UZQjUdz2oub3z8bx2B6HigSjjQELTpx3B25xRjFErlTUyjuSZIxl5CmJ/5UOHGng2hgYX8SoqA7tglC9v9FYqbZlWIW8dF4x5Y5vWRGkyVamV+nBuAxb5IJB5VKkGiE58VDdrWxKbwxBkEOJIP/g3pVgYB8c53YkUSMp6tAPDiKnRb9CIsJ3vN4dcyAhBsJnhkPrKp9idg2rgu7MQFBfxX45Pe0DjPhEh1J3Jq0bXROiPa/i51fjbVHOmbZn2dS5dPJkWkiR7ZJ8cEpuckiK5ICVSIYzck0fyTF60B+1Je9XevqMJbbqzS2akvX8BttafCQ==</latexit>
2º pulse<latexit sha1_base64="mppQFQ7T35Bq6uLY5DZdi70N1G4=">AAAB9nicfVC7TgJBFL2LL1xfqKXNRjCxMJtZTBQqSWwsMZFHwm7I7HiBCfsYZ2YNhPAddkYLY+vH2PgXfoILaCIheqqbc859HV8EXGlCPozM0vLK6lp23dzY3Nreye3u1VWcSIY1FgexbPpUYcAjrGmuA2wKiTT0A2z4/cuJ3rhHqXgc3eihQC+k3Yh3OKM6pbxC0RW8YIkkUGi2c3lik3KJnJatxcKxyRT5i0+YotrOvbu3MUtCjDQLqFItjLrpzb0ThwjtjSSKWOqxefSvSzGZGic+000UCsr6tIujhKnxb6KV6E5p4I14JBKNEZsTRzRUIdW9BVINQ3+eRMWjdJcb0j7SNC6tUZrudKrVszUOJjH8/Gr9XdSLtkNs57qYr5zN8oAsHMAhHIMD51CBK6hCDRjcwQM8wbMxMB6NF+N1Zs0Y3z37MAfj7QuNWpSE</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="mppQFQ7T35Bq6uLY5DZdi70N1G4=">AAAB9nicfVC7TgJBFL2LL1xfqKXNRjCxMJtZTBQqSWwsMZFHwm7I7HiBCfsYZ2YNhPAddkYLY+vH2PgXfoILaCIheqqbc859HV8EXGlCPozM0vLK6lp23dzY3Nreye3u1VWcSIY1FgexbPpUYcAjrGmuA2wKiTT0A2z4/cuJ3rhHqXgc3eihQC+k3Yh3OKM6pbxC0RW8YIkkUGi2c3lik3KJnJatxcKxyRT5i0+YotrOvbu3MUtCjDQLqFItjLrpzb0ThwjtjSSKWOqxefSvSzGZGic+000UCsr6tIujhKnxb6KV6E5p4I14JBKNEZsTRzRUIdW9BVINQ3+eRMWjdJcb0j7SNC6tUZrudKrVszUOJjH8/Gr9XdSLtkNs57qYr5zN8oAsHMAhHIMD51CBK6hCDRjcwQM8wbMxMB6NF+N1Zs0Y3z37MAfj7QuNWpSE</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="mppQFQ7T35Bq6uLY5DZdi70N1G4=">AAAB9nicfVC7TgJBFL2LL1xfqKXNRjCxMJtZTBQqSWwsMZFHwm7I7HiBCfsYZ2YNhPAddkYLY+vH2PgXfoILaCIheqqbc859HV8EXGlCPozM0vLK6lp23dzY3Nreye3u1VWcSIY1FgexbPpUYcAjrGmuA2wKiTT0A2z4/cuJ3rhHqXgc3eihQC+k3Yh3OKM6pbxC0RW8YIkkUGi2c3lik3KJnJatxcKxyRT5i0+YotrOvbu3MUtCjDQLqFItjLrpzb0ThwjtjSSKWOqxefSvSzGZGic+000UCsr6tIujhKnxb6KV6E5p4I14JBKNEZsTRzRUIdW9BVINQ3+eRMWjdJcb0j7SNC6tUZrudKrVszUOJjH8/Gr9XdSLtkNs57qYr5zN8oAsHMAhHIMD51CBK6hCDRjcwQM8wbMxMB6NF+N1Zs0Y3z37MAfj7QuNWpSE</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="mppQFQ7T35Bq6uLY5DZdi70N1G4=">AAAB9nicfVC7TgJBFL2LL1xfqKXNRjCxMJtZTBQqSWwsMZFHwm7I7HiBCfsYZ2YNhPAddkYLY+vH2PgXfoILaCIheqqbc859HV8EXGlCPozM0vLK6lp23dzY3Nreye3u1VWcSIY1FgexbPpUYcAjrGmuA2wKiTT0A2z4/cuJ3rhHqXgc3eihQC+k3Yh3OKM6pbxC0RW8YIkkUGi2c3lik3KJnJatxcKxyRT5i0+YotrOvbu3MUtCjDQLqFItjLrpzb0ThwjtjSSKWOqxefSvSzGZGic+000UCsr6tIujhKnxb6KV6E5p4I14JBKNEZsTRzRUIdW9BVINQ3+eRMWjdJcb0j7SNC6tUZrudKrVszUOJjH8/Gr9XdSLtkNs57qYr5zN8oAsHMAhHIMD51CBK6hCDRjcwQM8wbMxMB6NF+N1Zs0Y3z37MAfj7QuNWpSE</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="2J3LgaxveNOWm0ixMrYwzobgJ8I=">AAAB9nicfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZdugq3gQsKkgra7ghuXFewDmlAm4207NI9xZiItod/hTnQhbv0YN/6Naa1gKXpWl3POfR1fBFxpQj6N3Mrq2vpGftPc2t7Z3SvsHzRVnEiGDRYHsWz7VGHAI2xorgNsC4k09ANs+cOrqd56QKl4HN3qsUAvpP2I9zijOqO8UtkVvGSJJFBodgtFYpNqhZxXreXCsckMRZij3i18uHcxS0KMNAuoUh2M+tnNgzOHCO2lEkUs9cQ8+delmMyMU5/pJgoFZUPaxzRhavKb6CS6Vxl5KY9EojFiC2JKQxVSPVgi1Tj0F0lUPMp2uSEdIs3i0hql6c6mWgNb42gaw8+v1t9Fs2w7xHZuysXaxTyQPBzBMZyCA5dQg2uoQwMY3MMjPMOLMTKejFfj7duaM+Y9h7AA4/0L7+qTVQ==</latexit>
Ut=º/≠ =µ
0 °i e°i'
°i e+i' 0
∂
<latexit sha1_base64="F9tmnwP0qJofOOqNY2EyCO7oRSU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="F9tmnwP0qJofOOqNY2EyCO7oRSU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="F9tmnwP0qJofOOqNY2EyCO7oRSU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="F9tmnwP0qJofOOqNY2EyCO7oRSU=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="LD6ypctg2I+xmP4x2WVDLZeiGpY=">AAACV3icfZFPT9tAEMXXhkLY/gv0yMUiKqJqcdcgtXBAQuqlN0BqACmbRutlYq9ir1e7Y0Rk+UtWXPgm3MAJAREh+k6j37yZ1b6JTaYcMnbj+QuLb5aWWyv07bv3Hz62V9dOXVFaCV1ZZIU9j4WDTGnoosIMzo0FkccZnMWjX5P+2SVYpwr9B8cG+rlItBoqKbBBg3bGe7Q7qPCAG/WdH+WQiPqAZzDELR5DonQlrBXjupKypizYDLYV/K22Fb8U1qSq5pxOydcn0ngY5aAvZpPcqiTFL5T36aDdYSHb32O7+8HLIgrZVB0y0/Ggfc0vClnmoFFmwrke6KQJJf0WMYP9yoIpLNb0839dTtrGOPFRXjowQo5EAlUpXf0c9Eoc7l31K6VNiaDlXLMSucsFpi+gG+fxPASndPMWz8UIRHMPRLCUT7cGaYhwNYnh8a/B68XpThixMDrZ6Rz+mAXSIutkg2yRiPwkh+Q3OSZdIsk/cut5nu/deHf+kt96sPrebOYTmZO/eg+rK7Rc</latexit>
Ut=2º/≠ =µ°1 00 °1
∂
<latexit sha1_base64="QYAkKRisUIfsaU+nfKSl4mPrN2s=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QYAkKRisUIfsaU+nfKSl4mPrN2s=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QYAkKRisUIfsaU+nfKSl4mPrN2s=">AAACPnicfVDBTttAEB0DLXRpSwrHXiwiKioVs06lFg6oSL30VlAbQMpG0XqZOKvYa2t3jIgsfxg3PqIXTtwQPVTtsUecQKVGCN5lRu+9mdG8KE+0I84vvJnZuSdP5xeescXnL14uNV4tH7issArbKksyexRJh4k22CZNCR7lFmUaJXgYDT+P9cMTtE5n5juNcuymMja6r5Wkmuo1vokOa/dK2mmJXG+KrynGstoRCfZpXUQYa1NKa+WoKpWq2Ebov/G5EIzXdSNkAs3xnS6sjgf0loku6zWaPODbW/z9tn+/CQM+QfPTH5hgr9f4IY4zVaRoSCXSuQ6auP598C7kOXVLi3lmqWJrj7qcsrVx7GOicJhLNZQxloVy1f9Ep6D+1mm31CYvCI2aEkuZulTS4B7pRmk0TaLTpr4lUjlEWcdOhJaJyVZ/EBCejmP496v/cHPQCkIehPut5u6H2zxgAV7DKqxDCB9hF77AHrRBwRlcwjX89M69K++X9/vWOuPdzazAFLy/N2ZQruI=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QYAkKRisUIfsaU+nfKSl4mPrN2s=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PsQRHfF16Lm1m0fVETV5RzQH2Pc=">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</latexit>
t
Δ=2Ω
Δ=0
Rabi oscillations
Ω<latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="1TdHLkNc/88x6S138chP61N+FU0=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1ZcOPOCvYBTSmT8TYdm5nEmYm0lP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8OuTaEfFhz8wuLS8uZFXt1bX1jM7u1XdVRohhWWBRGqu5TjSGXWDHchFiPFVLhh1jzu+cjvXaPSvNIXpt+jE1BA8nbnFGTUlXvUmBAW9k8cUixQI6LudnCdcgY+bNPGKPcyr57NxFLBErDQqp1A2WQHts5dElsmgOFcaTM0N7/16WZSo0jn+0lGmPKujTAQcL08DfRSEy70GsOuIwTg5JNiQMqtKCmM0PqvvCnSdRcprs8QbtI05yMQWV746m5jmOwZ6cx/Pya+7uoHjkucdwrki+dTPKADOzCHhyAC6dQggsoQwUY3MIDPMGzdWc9Wi/W68Q6Z3337MAUrLcv0mGSfw==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="6u6B747tHp2meYPrOiav85avrZU=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO2u4MadFewDTCmT8TYdm5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3Pg3prWCpehZXc4593X8OOTaEPJp5RYWl5ZX8qv22vrG5lZhe6eho0QxrLMojFTLpxpDLrFuuAmxFSukwg+x6ffPx3rzAZXmkbw2wxjbggaSdzmjJqMa3qXAgHYKJeKQSpmcVIrzheuQCUowRa1T+PBuI5YIlIaFVOsblEF2bO/IJbFppwrjSJmRffCvSzOVGcc+20s0xpT1aYBpwvToN3GTmG550E65jBODks2IKRVaUNObI/VQ+LMkai6zXZ6gfaRZTsagsr3J1GLPMTiwsxh+fi3+XTSOHZc47hUpVU+ngeRhD/bhEFw4gypcQA3qwOAOHuEZXqx768l6td6+rTlr2rMLM7DevwA1AJFQ</latexit>
∆<latexit sha1_base64="GtYU7gnVvOCNLij3tE0BGdH4u0U=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1Z0IXLCvYBTSmT8bYdO5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8SXBtCPqy5+YXFpeXMir26tr6xmd3aruowVgwrLBShqvtUo+ASK4YbgfVIIQ18gTW/dz7Sa/eoNA/ltRlE2AxoR/I2Z9SkVNW7QGFoK5snDikWyHExN1u4Dhkjf/YJY5Rb2XfvJmRxgNIwQbVuoOykx3YPXRKZZqIwCpUZ2vv/ujRTqXHks71YY0RZj3YwiZke/iYasWkX+s2Eyyg2KNmUmNBAB9R0Z0g9CPxpEjWX6S4voD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsX076SgA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="GtYU7gnVvOCNLij3tE0BGdH4u0U=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1Z0IXLCvYBTSmT8bYdO5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8SXBtCPqy5+YXFpeXMir26tr6xmd3aruowVgwrLBShqvtUo+ASK4YbgfVIIQ18gTW/dz7Sa/eoNA/ltRlE2AxoR/I2Z9SkVNW7QGFoK5snDikWyHExN1u4Dhkjf/YJY5Rb2XfvJmRxgNIwQbVuoOykx3YPXRKZZqIwCpUZ2vv/ujRTqXHks71YY0RZj3YwiZke/iYasWkX+s2Eyyg2KNmUmNBAB9R0Z0g9CPxpEjWX6S4voD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsX076SgA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="GtYU7gnVvOCNLij3tE0BGdH4u0U=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1Z0IXLCvYBTSmT8bYdO5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8SXBtCPqy5+YXFpeXMir26tr6xmd3aruowVgwrLBShqvtUo+ASK4YbgfVIIQ18gTW/dz7Sa/eoNA/ltRlE2AxoR/I2Z9SkVNW7QGFoK5snDikWyHExN1u4Dhkjf/YJY5Rb2XfvJmRxgNIwQbVuoOykx3YPXRKZZqIwCpUZ2vv/ujRTqXHks71YY0RZj3YwiZke/iYasWkX+s2Eyyg2KNmUmNBAB9R0Z0g9CPxpEjWX6S4voD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsX076SgA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="GtYU7gnVvOCNLij3tE0BGdH4u0U=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeOr6tJNsQguJEwUtF1Z0IXLCvYBTSmT8bYdO5nEmYm0hP6DO9GFuPV/3PgXfoJpq2ApelaXc859HT8SXBtCPqy5+YXFpeXMir26tr6xmd3aruowVgwrLBShqvtUo+ASK4YbgfVIIQ18gTW/dz7Sa/eoNA/ltRlE2AxoR/I2Z9SkVNW7QGFoK5snDikWyHExN1u4Dhkjf/YJY5Rb2XfvJmRxgNIwQbVuoOykx3YPXRKZZqIwCpUZ2vv/ujRTqXHks71YY0RZj3YwiZke/iYasWkX+s2Eyyg2KNmUmNBAB9R0Z0g9CPxpEjWX6S4voD2kaU7GoLK98dRc1zHYt9MYfn7N/V1UjxyXOO4VyZdOJnlABnZhDw7AhVMowSWUoQIMbuEBnuDZurMerRfrdWKds757dmAK1tsX076SgA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="kTr86fpBFxvLllFhbYtMres9wBk=">AAAB73icfVDLSsNAFL2prxpfVZduikVwIWGioO2uoAuXFewDTCmT8bYdm0zizI20lP6DO9GFuPV/3Pg3prWCpehZXc4593X8OJCGGPu0MguLS8sr2VV7bX1jcyu3vVMzUaIFVkUURLrhc4OBVFglSQE2Yo089AOs+73zsV5/QG1kpK5pEGMz5B0l21JwSqmad4EB8VauwBxWKrKTUn6+cB02QQGmqLRyH95tJJIQFYmAG3ODqpMe2z1yWUzNocY40jSyD/51GaFT49hne4nBmIse7+AwEWb0m7hJqF3sN4dSxQmhEjPikIcm5NSdI80g9GdJNFKlu7yQ95CnORGhtr3J1HzXIezbaQw/v+b/LmrHjssc94oVyqfTQLKwB/twCC6cQRkuoQJVEHAHj/AML9a99WS9Wm/f1ow17dmFGVjvXzZdkVE=</latexit>
P Zoller, CIRM Preschool: Measurement & Control of Quantum Systems, 2018-04-17/18
Quantum State Engineering & Quantum Computingwith Trapped Ions
P1/2
S1/2
D5/2
40Ca+
Quantumbit
QubitDetecLon,
LaserCooling
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
traplaser
spontaneous emission
ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
• system = internal + external degrees of freedom
internal:electronic levels
external: motion
dipole-allowedtransition
dipole-forbiddentransition
• strong dissipation
ü laser cooling / state preparation
ü state measurement
• small dissipation
ü Hamiltonian: quantum state engineering
The System
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
laser
ion
laser
ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
optical wavelength
trap size
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
blue sideband
red sideband
…
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
…
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
red sideband
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
blue sideband
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
blue sideband
red sideband
…
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
…
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
…
uibkSingle Laser-Driven Trapped Ion
…
…
…
…
…
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
Xlaser
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
Xlaser
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
laser
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
center of mass mode
stretchmode
ºfor N ions the separation remains with increasing N
º
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
center of mass mode
stretchmode
º for N ions the separation remains with increasing N
P Zoller, CIRM Preschool: Measurement & Control of Quantum Systems, 2018-04-17/18
Background Material
Basic Quantum Computing
uibkQuantum Computing
system
input
ouput
• computing as a physical process
time
• quantum computing
- preparation
- unitary evolution
- state measurement
• no coupling to environment (decoherence)
uibkQuantum Memory
• Qubit:
superposition
• Quantum register
entangled stateN spin-1/2 systems
spin-1/2
-quantum parallelism
- interference of computational paths(+ cleverness) = quantum algorithms
uibkQuantum Gates
• Single qubit gate
with U unitary
U1
• A general unitary transformation can be decomposed into single bit rotations and a universal two-bit quantum gate
U1
targetcontrol
• Two qubit gate
uibk3. Read out
• state measurement
0 1 0 1 1 0
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
• Cold ions in a linear trap
Qubits: internal atomic states
1-qubit gates: addressing ions with a laser
2-qubit gates: entanglement via exchange of phonons of quantized collective mode
• State vector
quantum register databus
• QC as a time sequence of laser pulses • Read out by quantum jumps
Ion Trap Quantum Computer '95
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
state measurement via quantum jumps
qubit
auxiliary level
addressing with different light polarizations
Level scheme
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
• step 1: swap first qubit to phonon
laser
m nπ pulse
first atom: m
...
...
Two-qubit phase gate
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
• step 2: conditional sign change
laser
m n
second atom: n
-
2 pulse
flip sign
...
...
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
• step 3: swap phonon back to first qubit
laser
atom m
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
• summary: we have a phase gate between atom m and n
phonon mode returned to initial state
Rem.: this idea translates immediately to CQED
uibkString of Laser-Driven Trapped Ions
input
output
Quantum gates with ions: Nature March 2003
truth table CNOT
Ibk
P Zoller, CIRM Preschool: Measurement & Control of Quantum Systems, 2018-04-17/18
Where we are today …
Digital and Analog Quantum Simulation with Trapped Ions
uibkDigital Quantum Simulation
idea: approximate time evolution by a stroboscopic sequence of gates
qubitsor
spins
time0
...
tt1
eiHeff t
H = Jz1z
2 + B(x1 + x
2 )
U(t) eiHt/ = eiHtn/ . . .iHt1/
eiHt/ eiH1t/ eiH2t/ e12
(t)2
2 [H1,H2]
first term second termTrotter errors for
non-commuting terms
Trotter expansion:
Seth Lloyd
when subducted lithosphere entered the shallowlower mantle and stagnated because of densityinversion and increased mantle viscosity (14, 27)(Fig. 3B). If heated to ambient mantle tempera-tures, carbonated basaltic lithologies form carbo-natedmelts, which can then be reduced to diamondduring reactions with surrounding mantle (8, 28).Our results also indicate that the diamonds weretransported by convection from the lower to theupper mantle, where the originally homogeneousinclusions unmixed. For example, phase relationsalong the NaAlSiO4-MgAl2O4 boundary (29) in-dicate that the bulk composition of inclusionJu5-20 would yield the observed assemblage ofnepheline plus spinel (Fig. 1A and fig. S1B) atdepths of ~150 km; other inclusions in diamondsfrom the Juina region (3, 4, 8) also suggest equil-ibration near the base of the Brazilian lithosphere(~150 to 200 km). Thus, the diamonds record ahistory of upward transport on the order of 500to 1000 km or more before being sampled by aCretaceous kimberlite and brought to the surface.
On the basis of seismological and petrologicalevidence, previous workers have argued for a man-tle plume beneath Brazil during the Cretaceous(30, 31). Furthermore, paleo-plate reconstruc-tions show that the Juina region of Brazil was lo-cated at the margin of the African large low shearvelocity provinces during the Cretaceous, whichmay be indicative of the presence of deep mantleplumes (32). We suggest that some portion ofstagnated subducted lithosphere in which the di-amonds grew was transported from the lowermantle to the base of the Brazilian lithosphere ina rising mantle plume (Fig. 3B). The Juina-5 di-amonds and their inclusions provide compellingevidence for deep cycling of oceanic crust and
surface carbon into the lower mantle and, ulti-mately, exhumation back to the upper mantle andEarth’s surface.
References and Notes1. T. Stachel, G. P. Brey, J. W. Harris, Elements 1, 73
(2005).2. B. Harte, Mineral. Mag. 74, 189 (2010).3. G. P. Bulanova et al., Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 160,
489 (2010).4. B. Harte, N. Cayzer, Phys. Chem. Miner. 34, 647 (2007).5. F. V. Kaminsky et al., Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140,
734 (2001).6. T. Stachel, G. P. Brey, J. W. Harris, Contrib. Mineral. Petrol.
140, 1 (2000).7. R. Tappert et al., Geology 33, 565 (2005).8. M. J. Walter et al., Nature 454, 622 (2008).9. R. Tappert et al., Geology 37, 43 (2009).10. P. Cartigny, Elements 1, 79 (2005).11. B. Harte, J. W. Harris, M. T. Hutchison, G. R. Watt,
M. C. Wilding, in Mantle Petrology: Field Observationsand High Pressure Experimentation, Y. Fei, C. M. Bertka,B. O. Mysen, Eds. Geochemical Society SpecialPublications, 125 (1999).
12. P. C. Hayman, M. G. Kopylova, F. V. Kaminsky,Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140, 734 (2005).
13. T. Stachel, J. W. Harris, G. P. Brey, W. Joswig,Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140, 16 (2000).
14. Y. Fukao, M. Obayashi, T. Nakakuki, Deep Slab ProjectGroup, Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 37, 19 (2009).
15. R. D. van der Hilst, S. Widiyantoro, E. R. Engdahl, Nature386, 578 (1997).
16. K. Hirose, N. Takafuji, N. Sata, Y. Ohishi, Earth Planet.Sci. Lett. 237, 239 (2005).
17. S. Ono, E. Ito, T. Katsura, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 190,57 (2001).
18. A. Ricolleau et al., J. Geophys. Res. 115, (B8), B08202(2010).
19. L. Heaman, N. A. Teixeira, L. Gobbo, J. C. Gaspar, U-Pbmantle zircon ages for kimberlites from the Juina andParanatinga Provinces, Brazil. Extended Abstracts, 7thInternational Kimberlite Conference, Cape Town,South Africa, 322 (1998).
20. See supporting material on Science Online.
21. F. E. Brenker et al., Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 236, 579(2005).
22. F. Brenker, T. Stachel, J. W. Harris, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.198, 1 (2002).
23. B. J. Wood, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 174, 341 (2000).24. M. B. Kirkley, J. J. Gurney, M. L. Otter, S. J. Hill,
L. R. M. Daniels, Appl. Geochem. 6, 477 (1991).25. S. Shilobreeva, I. Martinez, V. Busigny, P. Agrinier,
C. Laverne, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 75, 2237 (2011).26. S. Poli, E. Franzolin, P. Fumagalli, A. Crottini, Earth
Planet. Sci. Lett. 278, 350 (2009).27. S. Goes, F. A. Capitanio, G. Morra, Nature 451, 981
(2008).28. A. Rohrbach, M. W. Schmidt, Nature 472, 209 (2011).29. M. Akaogi, A. Tanaka, M. Kobayashi, N. Fukushima,
T. Suzuki, Phys. Earth Planet. Inter. 130, 49 (2002).30. S. A. Gibson, R. N. Thompson, O. H. Leonardos,
A. P. Dickin, G. J. Mitchell, J. Petrol. 36, 89 (1995).31. J. C. VanDecar, D. E. James, M. Assumpcao, Nature 378,
25 (1995).32. T. H. Torsvik, K. Burke, B. Steinberger, S. J. Webb,
L. D. Ashwal, Nature 466, 352 (2010).33. Y. N. Palyanov, Y. M. Borzdov, A. F. Khokhryakov,
I. N. Kupriyanov, N. V. Sobolev, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.250, 269 (2006).
Acknowledgments: We thank I. Buisman and S. Kearnsfor assisting in the collection of electron microprobedata and L. Gobbo on behalf of Rio Tinto for providingsamples. Supported by UK Natural Environment ResearchCouncil grant NE/H011242/1 (M.J.W.) and NSF grantEAR-1049992 (S.B.S. and J.W.). See (20) for additionalcompositional data on inclusion phases, experimental runproducts, and Raman spectroscopy.
Supporting Online Materialwww.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/science.1209300/DC1Materials and MethodsSOM TextFigs. S1 to S3Tables S1 to S5References (34–45)
3 June 2011; accepted 22 August 2011Published online 15 September 2011;10.1126/science.1209300
REPORTS
Universal Digital Quantum Simulationwith Trapped IonsB. P. Lanyon,1,2* C. Hempel,1,2 D. Nigg,2 M. Müller,1,3 R. Gerritsma,1,2 F. Zähringer,1,2
P. Schindler,2 J. T. Barreiro,2 M. Rambach,1,2 G. Kirchmair,1,2 M. Hennrich,2 P. Zoller,1,3
R. Blatt,1,2 C. F. Roos1,2
A digital quantum simulator is an envisioned quantum device that can be programmed to efficientlysimulate any other local system. We demonstrate and investigate the digital approach to quantumsimulation in a system of trapped ions. With sequences of up to 100 gates and 6 qubits, the fulltime dynamics of a range of spin systems are digitally simulated. Interactions beyond those naturallypresent in our simulator are accurately reproduced, and quantitative bounds are provided for theoverall simulation quality. Our results demonstrate the key principles of digital quantum simulation andprovide evidence that the level of control required for a full-scale device is within reach.
Althoughmany natural phenomena are ac-curately described by the laws of quan-tum mechanics, solving the associated
equations to calculate properties of physical sys-tems, i.e., simulating quantum physics, is in gen-
eral thought to be very difficult (1). Both thenumber of parameters and differential equationsthat describe a quantum state and its dynamicsgrow exponentially with the number of particlesinvolved. One proposed solution is to build a
highly controllable quantum system that can ef-ficiently perform the simulations (2). Recently,quantum simulations have been performed inseveral different systems (3–13), largely follow-ing the analog approach (2) whereby an analo-gousmodel is built, with a directmapping betweenthe state and dynamics of the simulated systemand those of the simulator. An analog simulatoris dedicated to a particular problem, or class ofproblems.
A digital quantum simulator (2, 14–16) is aprecisely controllable many-body quantum sys-tem onwhich a universal set of quantum operations(gates) can be performed, i.e., a quantum computer(17). The simulated state is encoded in a register
1Institut für Quantenoptik und Quanteninformation, Öster-reichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Otto-Hittmair-Platz 1,A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institut für Experimentalphysik, Uni-versity of Innsbruck, Technikerstr. 25, A-6020 Innsbruck,Austria. 3Institut für Theoretische Physik, University ofInnsbruck, Technikerstr. 25, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:[email protected]
www.sciencemag.org SCIENCE VOL 334 7 OCTOBER 2011 57
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
when subducted lithosphere entered the shallowlower mantle and stagnated because of densityinversion and increased mantle viscosity (14, 27)(Fig. 3B). If heated to ambient mantle tempera-tures, carbonated basaltic lithologies form carbo-natedmelts, which can then be reduced to diamondduring reactions with surrounding mantle (8, 28).Our results also indicate that the diamonds weretransported by convection from the lower to theupper mantle, where the originally homogeneousinclusions unmixed. For example, phase relationsalong the NaAlSiO4-MgAl2O4 boundary (29) in-dicate that the bulk composition of inclusionJu5-20 would yield the observed assemblage ofnepheline plus spinel (Fig. 1A and fig. S1B) atdepths of ~150 km; other inclusions in diamondsfrom the Juina region (3, 4, 8) also suggest equil-ibration near the base of the Brazilian lithosphere(~150 to 200 km). Thus, the diamonds record ahistory of upward transport on the order of 500to 1000 km or more before being sampled by aCretaceous kimberlite and brought to the surface.
On the basis of seismological and petrologicalevidence, previous workers have argued for a man-tle plume beneath Brazil during the Cretaceous(30, 31). Furthermore, paleo-plate reconstruc-tions show that the Juina region of Brazil was lo-cated at the margin of the African large low shearvelocity provinces during the Cretaceous, whichmay be indicative of the presence of deep mantleplumes (32). We suggest that some portion ofstagnated subducted lithosphere in which the di-amonds grew was transported from the lowermantle to the base of the Brazilian lithosphere ina rising mantle plume (Fig. 3B). The Juina-5 di-amonds and their inclusions provide compellingevidence for deep cycling of oceanic crust and
surface carbon into the lower mantle and, ulti-mately, exhumation back to the upper mantle andEarth’s surface.
References and Notes1. T. Stachel, G. P. Brey, J. W. Harris, Elements 1, 73
(2005).2. B. Harte, Mineral. Mag. 74, 189 (2010).3. G. P. Bulanova et al., Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 160,
489 (2010).4. B. Harte, N. Cayzer, Phys. Chem. Miner. 34, 647 (2007).5. F. V. Kaminsky et al., Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140,
734 (2001).6. T. Stachel, G. P. Brey, J. W. Harris, Contrib. Mineral. Petrol.
140, 1 (2000).7. R. Tappert et al., Geology 33, 565 (2005).8. M. J. Walter et al., Nature 454, 622 (2008).9. R. Tappert et al., Geology 37, 43 (2009).10. P. Cartigny, Elements 1, 79 (2005).11. B. Harte, J. W. Harris, M. T. Hutchison, G. R. Watt,
M. C. Wilding, in Mantle Petrology: Field Observationsand High Pressure Experimentation, Y. Fei, C. M. Bertka,B. O. Mysen, Eds. Geochemical Society SpecialPublications, 125 (1999).
12. P. C. Hayman, M. G. Kopylova, F. V. Kaminsky,Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140, 734 (2005).
13. T. Stachel, J. W. Harris, G. P. Brey, W. Joswig,Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140, 16 (2000).
14. Y. Fukao, M. Obayashi, T. Nakakuki, Deep Slab ProjectGroup, Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 37, 19 (2009).
15. R. D. van der Hilst, S. Widiyantoro, E. R. Engdahl, Nature386, 578 (1997).
16. K. Hirose, N. Takafuji, N. Sata, Y. Ohishi, Earth Planet.Sci. Lett. 237, 239 (2005).
17. S. Ono, E. Ito, T. Katsura, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 190,57 (2001).
18. A. Ricolleau et al., J. Geophys. Res. 115, (B8), B08202(2010).
19. L. Heaman, N. A. Teixeira, L. Gobbo, J. C. Gaspar, U-Pbmantle zircon ages for kimberlites from the Juina andParanatinga Provinces, Brazil. Extended Abstracts, 7thInternational Kimberlite Conference, Cape Town,South Africa, 322 (1998).
20. See supporting material on Science Online.
21. F. E. Brenker et al., Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 236, 579(2005).
22. F. Brenker, T. Stachel, J. W. Harris, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.198, 1 (2002).
23. B. J. Wood, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 174, 341 (2000).24. M. B. Kirkley, J. J. Gurney, M. L. Otter, S. J. Hill,
L. R. M. Daniels, Appl. Geochem. 6, 477 (1991).25. S. Shilobreeva, I. Martinez, V. Busigny, P. Agrinier,
C. Laverne, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 75, 2237 (2011).26. S. Poli, E. Franzolin, P. Fumagalli, A. Crottini, Earth
Planet. Sci. Lett. 278, 350 (2009).27. S. Goes, F. A. Capitanio, G. Morra, Nature 451, 981
(2008).28. A. Rohrbach, M. W. Schmidt, Nature 472, 209 (2011).29. M. Akaogi, A. Tanaka, M. Kobayashi, N. Fukushima,
T. Suzuki, Phys. Earth Planet. Inter. 130, 49 (2002).30. S. A. Gibson, R. N. Thompson, O. H. Leonardos,
A. P. Dickin, G. J. Mitchell, J. Petrol. 36, 89 (1995).31. J. C. VanDecar, D. E. James, M. Assumpcao, Nature 378,
25 (1995).32. T. H. Torsvik, K. Burke, B. Steinberger, S. J. Webb,
L. D. Ashwal, Nature 466, 352 (2010).33. Y. N. Palyanov, Y. M. Borzdov, A. F. Khokhryakov,
I. N. Kupriyanov, N. V. Sobolev, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.250, 269 (2006).
Acknowledgments: We thank I. Buisman and S. Kearnsfor assisting in the collection of electron microprobedata and L. Gobbo on behalf of Rio Tinto for providingsamples. Supported by UK Natural Environment ResearchCouncil grant NE/H011242/1 (M.J.W.) and NSF grantEAR-1049992 (S.B.S. and J.W.). See (20) for additionalcompositional data on inclusion phases, experimental runproducts, and Raman spectroscopy.
Supporting Online Materialwww.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/science.1209300/DC1Materials and MethodsSOM TextFigs. S1 to S3Tables S1 to S5References (34–45)
3 June 2011; accepted 22 August 2011Published online 15 September 2011;10.1126/science.1209300
REPORTS
Universal Digital Quantum Simulationwith Trapped IonsB. P. Lanyon,1,2* C. Hempel,1,2 D. Nigg,2 M. Müller,1,3 R. Gerritsma,1,2 F. Zähringer,1,2
P. Schindler,2 J. T. Barreiro,2 M. Rambach,1,2 G. Kirchmair,1,2 M. Hennrich,2 P. Zoller,1,3
R. Blatt,1,2 C. F. Roos1,2
A digital quantum simulator is an envisioned quantum device that can be programmed to efficientlysimulate any other local system. We demonstrate and investigate the digital approach to quantumsimulation in a system of trapped ions. With sequences of up to 100 gates and 6 qubits, the fulltime dynamics of a range of spin systems are digitally simulated. Interactions beyond those naturallypresent in our simulator are accurately reproduced, and quantitative bounds are provided for theoverall simulation quality. Our results demonstrate the key principles of digital quantum simulation andprovide evidence that the level of control required for a full-scale device is within reach.
Althoughmany natural phenomena are ac-curately described by the laws of quan-tum mechanics, solving the associated
equations to calculate properties of physical sys-tems, i.e., simulating quantum physics, is in gen-
eral thought to be very difficult (1). Both thenumber of parameters and differential equationsthat describe a quantum state and its dynamicsgrow exponentially with the number of particlesinvolved. One proposed solution is to build a
highly controllable quantum system that can ef-ficiently perform the simulations (2). Recently,quantum simulations have been performed inseveral different systems (3–13), largely follow-ing the analog approach (2) whereby an analo-gousmodel is built, with a directmapping betweenthe state and dynamics of the simulated systemand those of the simulator. An analog simulatoris dedicated to a particular problem, or class ofproblems.
A digital quantum simulator (2, 14–16) is aprecisely controllable many-body quantum sys-tem onwhich a universal set of quantum operations(gates) can be performed, i.e., a quantum computer(17). The simulated state is encoded in a register
1Institut für Quantenoptik und Quanteninformation, Öster-reichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Otto-Hittmair-Platz 1,A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institut für Experimentalphysik, Uni-versity of Innsbruck, Technikerstr. 25, A-6020 Innsbruck,Austria. 3Institut für Theoretische Physik, University ofInnsbruck, Technikerstr. 25, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:[email protected]
www.sciencemag.org SCIENCE VOL 334 7 OCTOBER 2011 57
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
when subducted lithosphere entered the shallowlower mantle and stagnated because of densityinversion and increased mantle viscosity (14, 27)(Fig. 3B). If heated to ambient mantle tempera-tures, carbonated basaltic lithologies form carbo-natedmelts, which can then be reduced to diamondduring reactions with surrounding mantle (8, 28).Our results also indicate that the diamonds weretransported by convection from the lower to theupper mantle, where the originally homogeneousinclusions unmixed. For example, phase relationsalong the NaAlSiO4-MgAl2O4 boundary (29) in-dicate that the bulk composition of inclusionJu5-20 would yield the observed assemblage ofnepheline plus spinel (Fig. 1A and fig. S1B) atdepths of ~150 km; other inclusions in diamondsfrom the Juina region (3, 4, 8) also suggest equil-ibration near the base of the Brazilian lithosphere(~150 to 200 km). Thus, the diamonds record ahistory of upward transport on the order of 500to 1000 km or more before being sampled by aCretaceous kimberlite and brought to the surface.
On the basis of seismological and petrologicalevidence, previous workers have argued for a man-tle plume beneath Brazil during the Cretaceous(30, 31). Furthermore, paleo-plate reconstruc-tions show that the Juina region of Brazil was lo-cated at the margin of the African large low shearvelocity provinces during the Cretaceous, whichmay be indicative of the presence of deep mantleplumes (32). We suggest that some portion ofstagnated subducted lithosphere in which the di-amonds grew was transported from the lowermantle to the base of the Brazilian lithosphere ina rising mantle plume (Fig. 3B). The Juina-5 di-amonds and their inclusions provide compellingevidence for deep cycling of oceanic crust and
surface carbon into the lower mantle and, ulti-mately, exhumation back to the upper mantle andEarth’s surface.
References and Notes1. T. Stachel, G. P. Brey, J. W. Harris, Elements 1, 73
(2005).2. B. Harte, Mineral. Mag. 74, 189 (2010).3. G. P. Bulanova et al., Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 160,
489 (2010).4. B. Harte, N. Cayzer, Phys. Chem. Miner. 34, 647 (2007).5. F. V. Kaminsky et al., Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140,
734 (2001).6. T. Stachel, G. P. Brey, J. W. Harris, Contrib. Mineral. Petrol.
140, 1 (2000).7. R. Tappert et al., Geology 33, 565 (2005).8. M. J. Walter et al., Nature 454, 622 (2008).9. R. Tappert et al., Geology 37, 43 (2009).10. P. Cartigny, Elements 1, 79 (2005).11. B. Harte, J. W. Harris, M. T. Hutchison, G. R. Watt,
M. C. Wilding, in Mantle Petrology: Field Observationsand High Pressure Experimentation, Y. Fei, C. M. Bertka,B. O. Mysen, Eds. Geochemical Society SpecialPublications, 125 (1999).
12. P. C. Hayman, M. G. Kopylova, F. V. Kaminsky,Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140, 734 (2005).
13. T. Stachel, J. W. Harris, G. P. Brey, W. Joswig,Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 140, 16 (2000).
14. Y. Fukao, M. Obayashi, T. Nakakuki, Deep Slab ProjectGroup, Annu. Rev. Earth Planet. Sci. 37, 19 (2009).
15. R. D. van der Hilst, S. Widiyantoro, E. R. Engdahl, Nature386, 578 (1997).
16. K. Hirose, N. Takafuji, N. Sata, Y. Ohishi, Earth Planet.Sci. Lett. 237, 239 (2005).
17. S. Ono, E. Ito, T. Katsura, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 190,57 (2001).
18. A. Ricolleau et al., J. Geophys. Res. 115, (B8), B08202(2010).
19. L. Heaman, N. A. Teixeira, L. Gobbo, J. C. Gaspar, U-Pbmantle zircon ages for kimberlites from the Juina andParanatinga Provinces, Brazil. Extended Abstracts, 7thInternational Kimberlite Conference, Cape Town,South Africa, 322 (1998).
20. See supporting material on Science Online.
21. F. E. Brenker et al., Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 236, 579(2005).
22. F. Brenker, T. Stachel, J. W. Harris, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.198, 1 (2002).
23. B. J. Wood, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 174, 341 (2000).24. M. B. Kirkley, J. J. Gurney, M. L. Otter, S. J. Hill,
L. R. M. Daniels, Appl. Geochem. 6, 477 (1991).25. S. Shilobreeva, I. Martinez, V. Busigny, P. Agrinier,
C. Laverne, Geochim. Cosmochim. Acta 75, 2237 (2011).26. S. Poli, E. Franzolin, P. Fumagalli, A. Crottini, Earth
Planet. Sci. Lett. 278, 350 (2009).27. S. Goes, F. A. Capitanio, G. Morra, Nature 451, 981
(2008).28. A. Rohrbach, M. W. Schmidt, Nature 472, 209 (2011).29. M. Akaogi, A. Tanaka, M. Kobayashi, N. Fukushima,
T. Suzuki, Phys. Earth Planet. Inter. 130, 49 (2002).30. S. A. Gibson, R. N. Thompson, O. H. Leonardos,
A. P. Dickin, G. J. Mitchell, J. Petrol. 36, 89 (1995).31. J. C. VanDecar, D. E. James, M. Assumpcao, Nature 378,
25 (1995).32. T. H. Torsvik, K. Burke, B. Steinberger, S. J. Webb,
L. D. Ashwal, Nature 466, 352 (2010).33. Y. N. Palyanov, Y. M. Borzdov, A. F. Khokhryakov,
I. N. Kupriyanov, N. V. Sobolev, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.250, 269 (2006).
Acknowledgments: We thank I. Buisman and S. Kearnsfor assisting in the collection of electron microprobedata and L. Gobbo on behalf of Rio Tinto for providingsamples. Supported by UK Natural Environment ResearchCouncil grant NE/H011242/1 (M.J.W.) and NSF grantEAR-1049992 (S.B.S. and J.W.). See (20) for additionalcompositional data on inclusion phases, experimental runproducts, and Raman spectroscopy.
Supporting Online Materialwww.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/science.1209300/DC1Materials and MethodsSOM TextFigs. S1 to S3Tables S1 to S5References (34–45)
3 June 2011; accepted 22 August 2011Published online 15 September 2011;10.1126/science.1209300
REPORTS
Universal Digital Quantum Simulationwith Trapped IonsB. P. Lanyon,1,2* C. Hempel,1,2 D. Nigg,2 M. Müller,1,3 R. Gerritsma,1,2 F. Zähringer,1,2
P. Schindler,2 J. T. Barreiro,2 M. Rambach,1,2 G. Kirchmair,1,2 M. Hennrich,2 P. Zoller,1,3
R. Blatt,1,2 C. F. Roos1,2
A digital quantum simulator is an envisioned quantum device that can be programmed to efficientlysimulate any other local system. We demonstrate and investigate the digital approach to quantumsimulation in a system of trapped ions. With sequences of up to 100 gates and 6 qubits, the fulltime dynamics of a range of spin systems are digitally simulated. Interactions beyond those naturallypresent in our simulator are accurately reproduced, and quantitative bounds are provided for theoverall simulation quality. Our results demonstrate the key principles of digital quantum simulation andprovide evidence that the level of control required for a full-scale device is within reach.
Althoughmany natural phenomena are ac-curately described by the laws of quan-tum mechanics, solving the associated
equations to calculate properties of physical sys-tems, i.e., simulating quantum physics, is in gen-
eral thought to be very difficult (1). Both thenumber of parameters and differential equationsthat describe a quantum state and its dynamicsgrow exponentially with the number of particlesinvolved. One proposed solution is to build a
highly controllable quantum system that can ef-ficiently perform the simulations (2). Recently,quantum simulations have been performed inseveral different systems (3–13), largely follow-ing the analog approach (2) whereby an analo-gousmodel is built, with a directmapping betweenthe state and dynamics of the simulated systemand those of the simulator. An analog simulatoris dedicated to a particular problem, or class ofproblems.
A digital quantum simulator (2, 14–16) is aprecisely controllable many-body quantum sys-tem onwhich a universal set of quantum operations(gates) can be performed, i.e., a quantum computer(17). The simulated state is encoded in a register
1Institut für Quantenoptik und Quanteninformation, Öster-reichische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Otto-Hittmair-Platz 1,A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institut für Experimentalphysik, Uni-versity of Innsbruck, Technikerstr. 25, A-6020 Innsbruck,Austria. 3Institut für Theoretische Physik, University ofInnsbruck, Technikerstr. 25, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria.
*To whom correspondence should be addressed. E-mail:[email protected]
www.sciencemag.org SCIENCE VOL 334 7 OCTOBER 2011 57
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
on
Janu
ary
5, 2
015
ww
w.s
cien
cem
ag.o
rgD
ownl
oade
d fro
m
experiments (≈1 to 2 ms). The current leadingsources of error, which limit both the simulationcomplexity and size, are thought to be laserintensity fluctuations (23). This is not currentlya fundamental limitation and, once properly ad-dressed, should enable an increase in simulationcapabilities.
The digital approach can be combined withexisting tools and techniques for analog simu-lations to expand the range of systems that can besimulated. In light of the present work, and cur-
rent ion trap development (35), digital quantumsimulations involving many tens of qubits andhundreds of high-fidelity gates seems feasible incoming years.
References and Notes1. R. P. Feynman, Int. J. Theor. Phys. 21, 467 (1982).2. I. Buluta, F. Nori, Science 326, 108 (2009).3. S. Somaroo, C. H. Tseng, T. F. Havel, R. Laflamme,
D. G. Cory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 5381 (1999).4. M. Greiner, O. Mandel, T. Esslinger, T. W. Hänsch,
I. Bloch, Nature 415, 39 (2002).
5. D. Leibfried et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 247901 (2002).6. A. Friedenauer, H. Schmitz, J. T. Glueckert, D. Porras,
T. Schaetz, Nat. Phys. 4, 757 (2008).7. R. Gerritsma et al., Nature 463, 68 (2010).8. K. Kim et al., Nature 465, 590 (2010).9. B. P. Lanyon et al., Nat. Chem. 2, 106 (2010).
10. K. R. Brown, R. J. Clark, I. L. Chuang, Phys. Rev. Lett. 97,050504 (2006).
11. J. T. Barreiro et al., Nature 470, 486 (2011).12. J. Simon et al., Nature 472, 307 (2011).13. R. Islam et al., Nat Commun 2, 377 (2011).14. S. Lloyd, Science 273, 1073 (1996).15. E. Jane, G. Vidal, W. Dür, P. Zoller, J. I. Cirac, Quantum
Inf. Comput. 3, 15 (2003).
Fig. 3. Digital simulations of three-spin systems.Dynamics of the initial state |↑↑↑⟩ in three cases.(A) Long-range Ising system. Spin-spin coupling be-tween all pairs with equal strength and a transversefield. C = O2(p /32), D = O4(p /16,0). (B) Inhomog-eneous distribution of spin-spin couplings, decom-posed into an equal-strength interaction andanother with twice the strength between one pair.E = O1(p /2,1). (C) Three-body interaction, whichcouples the ∑jsy
jeigenstates |←←←⟩y and |→→→⟩y.An O3(p /4,0) operation before measurementrotates the state into the logical sz basis. F =O1(q,1), 4D = O4(p/4,0). Any point in the phaseevolution is simulated by varying the phase q ofoperation F. Inequalities bound the quantum pro-cess fidelity Fp [see (23) for details].
Fig. 4. Digital simulations of four and six spin sys-tems. Dynamics of the initial state where all spinspoint up. (A) Four spin long-range Ising system.Each digital step is D.C = O4(p/16,0).O2(p/32).Error bars are smaller than point size. (B) Six spinsix-body interaction. F = O1(q,1), 4D = O4(p/4,0).The inequality at f = 0.25 p bounds the quantumprocess fidelity Fp at q = 0.25 p [see (23) for details].Lines; exact dynamics. Unfilled shapes: ideal digitized;filled shapes: data (P0 ♦P1 P2 P3 P4 P5 P6,where Pi is the total probability of finding ispinspointing down).
7 OCTOBER 2011 VOL 334 SCIENCE www.sciencemag.org60
REPORTS
B. Lanyon C. Roos
4 & 6 Spins
remarks:• scalability (?)• error correction (?)
5 1 6 | N A T U R E | V O L 5 3 4 | 2 3 J U N E 2 0 1 6
LETTERdoi:10.1038/nature18318
Real-time dynamics of lattice gauge theories with a few-qubit quantum computerEsteban A. Martinez1*, Christine A. Muschik2,3*, Philipp Schindler1, Daniel Nigg1, Alexander Erhard1, Markus Heyl2,4, Philipp Hauke2,3, Marcello Dalmonte2,3, Thomas Monz1, Peter Zoller2,3 & Rainer Blatt1,2
Gauge theories are fundamental to our understanding of interactions between the elementary constituents of matter as mediated by gauge bosons1,2. However, computing the real-time dynamics in gauge theories is a notorious challenge for classical computational methods. This has recently stimulated theoretical effort, using Feynman’s idea of a quantum simulator3,4, to devise schemes for simulating such theories on engineered quantum-mechanical devices, with the difficulty that gauge invariance and the associated local conservation laws (Gauss laws) need to be implemented5–7. Here we report the experimental demonstration of a digital quantum simulation of a lattice gauge theory, by realizing (1 + 1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (the Schwinger model8,9) on a few-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer. We are interested in the real-time evolution of the Schwinger mechanism10,11, describing the instability of the bare vacuum due to quantum fluctuations, which manifests itself in the spontaneous creation of electron–positron pairs. To make efficient use of our quantum resources, we map the original problem to a spin model by eliminating the gauge fields12 in favour of exotic long-range interactions, which can be directly and efficiently implemented on an ion trap architecture13. We explore the Schwinger mechanism of particle–antiparticle generation by monitoring the mass production and the vacuum persistence amplitude. Moreover, we track the real-time evolution of entanglement in the system, which illustrates how particle creation and entanglement generation are directly related. Our work represents a first step towards quantum simulation of high-energy theories using atomic physics experiments—the long-term intention is to extend this approach to real-time quantum simulations of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.
Small-scale quantum computers exist today in the laboratory as programmable quantum devices14. In particular, trapped-ion quan-tum computers13 provide a platform allowing a few hundred coherent quantum gates to act on a few qubits, with a clear roadmap towards scaling up these devices4,15. This provides the tools for universal digital quantum simulation16, where the time evolution of a quantum system is approximated as a stroboscopic sequence of quantum gates17. Here we show how this technology can be used to simulate the real-time dynamics of a minimal model of a lattice gauge theory, realizing the Schwinger model8,9 as a one-dimensional quantum field theory with a chain of trapped ions (Fig. 1).
Our few-qubit demonstration is a first step towards simulating real-time dynamics in gauge theories: such simulations are funda-mental for the understanding of many physical phenomena, including thermalization after heavy-ion collisions and pair creation studied at high- intensity laser facilities6,18. Although existing classical numerical methods such as quantum Monte Carlo have been remarkably success-ful for describing equilibrium phenomena, no systematic techniques exist to tackle the dynamical long-time behaviour of all but very small
systems. In contrast, quantum simulations aim at the long-term goal of solving the specific yet fundamental class of problems that currently cannot be tackled by these classical techniques. The digital approach we employ here is based on the Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories9, and enables direct access to the system wavefunction. As we show below, this allows us to investigate entanglement generation during particle–antiparticle production, emphasizing a novel perspec-tive on the dynamics of the Schwinger mechanism2.
Digital quantum simulations described in the present work are con-ceptually different from, and fundamentally more challenging than, previously reported condensed-matter-motivated simulations of spin and Hubbard-type models4,19,20. In gauge theories, local symmetries lead to the introduction of dynamical gauge fields obeying a Gauss law6. Formally, this crucial feature is described by local symmetry generators G i that commute with the Hamiltonian of the system ˆ ˆ =H G[ , ] 0i and
restrict the dynamics to a subspace of physical states | Ψphysical⟩ which satisfy ˆ Ψ Ψ| ⟩= | ⟩G qi iphysical physical , where qi are background charges. We will be interested in the case qi = 0 for all i (see Methods). Realizing such a constrained dynamics on a quantum simulator is demanding and has been the focus of theoretical research6,7,11,21–24. Instead, to opti-mally use the finite resources represented by a few qubits of existing quantum hardware, we encode the gauge degrees of freedom in a long-range interaction between the fermions (electrons and positrons), which can be implemented efficiently on our experimental platform. This allows us to explore quantum simulation of coherent real-time
1Institute for Experimental Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information of the Austrian Academy of Sciences, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 3Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 4Physics Department, Technische Universität München, 85747 Garching, Germany.* These authors contributed equally to this work.
a
+
e–Globalbeam
Addressing
beam
t
x
b
Vacuum
e+
–
e+
e–
e+
e–
+
+ +
–
–
Figure 1 | Quantum simulation of the Schwinger mechanism. a, The instability of the vacuum due to quantum fluctuations is one of the most fundamental effects in gauge theories. We simulate the coherent real-time dynamics of particle–antiparticle creation by realizing the Schwinger model (one-dimensional quantum electrodynamics) on a lattice, as described in the main text. b, The experimental setup for the simulation consists of a linear Paul trap, where a string of 40Ca+ ions is confined. The electronic states of each ion, depicted as horizontal lines, encode a spin | ↑ ⟩ or | ↓ ⟩ . These states can be manipulated using laser beams (see Methods for details).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
5 1 6 | N A T U R E | V O L 5 3 4 | 2 3 J U N E 2 0 1 6
LETTERdoi:10.1038/nature18318
Real-time dynamics of lattice gauge theories with a few-qubit quantum computerEsteban A. Martinez1*, Christine A. Muschik2,3*, Philipp Schindler1, Daniel Nigg1, Alexander Erhard1, Markus Heyl2,4, Philipp Hauke2,3, Marcello Dalmonte2,3, Thomas Monz1, Peter Zoller2,3 & Rainer Blatt1,2
Gauge theories are fundamental to our understanding of interactions between the elementary constituents of matter as mediated by gauge bosons1,2. However, computing the real-time dynamics in gauge theories is a notorious challenge for classical computational methods. This has recently stimulated theoretical effort, using Feynman’s idea of a quantum simulator3,4, to devise schemes for simulating such theories on engineered quantum-mechanical devices, with the difficulty that gauge invariance and the associated local conservation laws (Gauss laws) need to be implemented5–7. Here we report the experimental demonstration of a digital quantum simulation of a lattice gauge theory, by realizing (1 + 1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (the Schwinger model8,9) on a few-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer. We are interested in the real-time evolution of the Schwinger mechanism10,11, describing the instability of the bare vacuum due to quantum fluctuations, which manifests itself in the spontaneous creation of electron–positron pairs. To make efficient use of our quantum resources, we map the original problem to a spin model by eliminating the gauge fields12 in favour of exotic long-range interactions, which can be directly and efficiently implemented on an ion trap architecture13. We explore the Schwinger mechanism of particle–antiparticle generation by monitoring the mass production and the vacuum persistence amplitude. Moreover, we track the real-time evolution of entanglement in the system, which illustrates how particle creation and entanglement generation are directly related. Our work represents a first step towards quantum simulation of high-energy theories using atomic physics experiments—the long-term intention is to extend this approach to real-time quantum simulations of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.
Small-scale quantum computers exist today in the laboratory as programmable quantum devices14. In particular, trapped-ion quan-tum computers13 provide a platform allowing a few hundred coherent quantum gates to act on a few qubits, with a clear roadmap towards scaling up these devices4,15. This provides the tools for universal digital quantum simulation16, where the time evolution of a quantum system is approximated as a stroboscopic sequence of quantum gates17. Here we show how this technology can be used to simulate the real-time dynamics of a minimal model of a lattice gauge theory, realizing the Schwinger model8,9 as a one-dimensional quantum field theory with a chain of trapped ions (Fig. 1).
Our few-qubit demonstration is a first step towards simulating real-time dynamics in gauge theories: such simulations are funda-mental for the understanding of many physical phenomena, including thermalization after heavy-ion collisions and pair creation studied at high- intensity laser facilities6,18. Although existing classical numerical methods such as quantum Monte Carlo have been remarkably success-ful for describing equilibrium phenomena, no systematic techniques exist to tackle the dynamical long-time behaviour of all but very small
systems. In contrast, quantum simulations aim at the long-term goal of solving the specific yet fundamental class of problems that currently cannot be tackled by these classical techniques. The digital approach we employ here is based on the Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories9, and enables direct access to the system wavefunction. As we show below, this allows us to investigate entanglement generation during particle–antiparticle production, emphasizing a novel perspec-tive on the dynamics of the Schwinger mechanism2.
Digital quantum simulations described in the present work are con-ceptually different from, and fundamentally more challenging than, previously reported condensed-matter-motivated simulations of spin and Hubbard-type models4,19,20. In gauge theories, local symmetries lead to the introduction of dynamical gauge fields obeying a Gauss law6. Formally, this crucial feature is described by local symmetry generators G i that commute with the Hamiltonian of the system ˆ ˆ =H G[ , ] 0i and
restrict the dynamics to a subspace of physical states | Ψphysical⟩ which satisfy ˆ Ψ Ψ| ⟩= | ⟩G qi iphysical physical , where qi are background charges. We will be interested in the case qi = 0 for all i (see Methods). Realizing such a constrained dynamics on a quantum simulator is demanding and has been the focus of theoretical research6,7,11,21–24. Instead, to opti-mally use the finite resources represented by a few qubits of existing quantum hardware, we encode the gauge degrees of freedom in a long-range interaction between the fermions (electrons and positrons), which can be implemented efficiently on our experimental platform. This allows us to explore quantum simulation of coherent real-time
1Institute for Experimental Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information of the Austrian Academy of Sciences, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 3Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 4Physics Department, Technische Universität München, 85747 Garching, Germany.* These authors contributed equally to this work.
a
+
e–Globalbeam
Addressing
beam
t
x
b
Vacuum
e+
–
e+
e–
e+
e–
+
+ +
–
–
Figure 1 | Quantum simulation of the Schwinger mechanism. a, The instability of the vacuum due to quantum fluctuations is one of the most fundamental effects in gauge theories. We simulate the coherent real-time dynamics of particle–antiparticle creation by realizing the Schwinger model (one-dimensional quantum electrodynamics) on a lattice, as described in the main text. b, The experimental setup for the simulation consists of a linear Paul trap, where a string of 40Ca+ ions is confined. The electronic states of each ion, depicted as horizontal lines, encode a spin | ↑ ⟩ or | ↓ ⟩ . These states can be manipulated using laser beams (see Methods for details).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
5 1 6 | N A T U R E | V O L 5 3 4 | 2 3 J U N E 2 0 1 6
LETTERdoi:10.1038/nature18318
Real-time dynamics of lattice gauge theories with a few-qubit quantum computerEsteban A. Martinez1*, Christine A. Muschik2,3*, Philipp Schindler1, Daniel Nigg1, Alexander Erhard1, Markus Heyl2,4, Philipp Hauke2,3, Marcello Dalmonte2,3, Thomas Monz1, Peter Zoller2,3 & Rainer Blatt1,2
Gauge theories are fundamental to our understanding of interactions between the elementary constituents of matter as mediated by gauge bosons1,2. However, computing the real-time dynamics in gauge theories is a notorious challenge for classical computational methods. This has recently stimulated theoretical effort, using Feynman’s idea of a quantum simulator3,4, to devise schemes for simulating such theories on engineered quantum-mechanical devices, with the difficulty that gauge invariance and the associated local conservation laws (Gauss laws) need to be implemented5–7. Here we report the experimental demonstration of a digital quantum simulation of a lattice gauge theory, by realizing (1 + 1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (the Schwinger model8,9) on a few-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer. We are interested in the real-time evolution of the Schwinger mechanism10,11, describing the instability of the bare vacuum due to quantum fluctuations, which manifests itself in the spontaneous creation of electron–positron pairs. To make efficient use of our quantum resources, we map the original problem to a spin model by eliminating the gauge fields12 in favour of exotic long-range interactions, which can be directly and efficiently implemented on an ion trap architecture13. We explore the Schwinger mechanism of particle–antiparticle generation by monitoring the mass production and the vacuum persistence amplitude. Moreover, we track the real-time evolution of entanglement in the system, which illustrates how particle creation and entanglement generation are directly related. Our work represents a first step towards quantum simulation of high-energy theories using atomic physics experiments—the long-term intention is to extend this approach to real-time quantum simulations of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.
Small-scale quantum computers exist today in the laboratory as programmable quantum devices14. In particular, trapped-ion quan-tum computers13 provide a platform allowing a few hundred coherent quantum gates to act on a few qubits, with a clear roadmap towards scaling up these devices4,15. This provides the tools for universal digital quantum simulation16, where the time evolution of a quantum system is approximated as a stroboscopic sequence of quantum gates17. Here we show how this technology can be used to simulate the real-time dynamics of a minimal model of a lattice gauge theory, realizing the Schwinger model8,9 as a one-dimensional quantum field theory with a chain of trapped ions (Fig. 1).
Our few-qubit demonstration is a first step towards simulating real-time dynamics in gauge theories: such simulations are funda-mental for the understanding of many physical phenomena, including thermalization after heavy-ion collisions and pair creation studied at high- intensity laser facilities6,18. Although existing classical numerical methods such as quantum Monte Carlo have been remarkably success-ful for describing equilibrium phenomena, no systematic techniques exist to tackle the dynamical long-time behaviour of all but very small
systems. In contrast, quantum simulations aim at the long-term goal of solving the specific yet fundamental class of problems that currently cannot be tackled by these classical techniques. The digital approach we employ here is based on the Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories9, and enables direct access to the system wavefunction. As we show below, this allows us to investigate entanglement generation during particle–antiparticle production, emphasizing a novel perspec-tive on the dynamics of the Schwinger mechanism2.
Digital quantum simulations described in the present work are con-ceptually different from, and fundamentally more challenging than, previously reported condensed-matter-motivated simulations of spin and Hubbard-type models4,19,20. In gauge theories, local symmetries lead to the introduction of dynamical gauge fields obeying a Gauss law6. Formally, this crucial feature is described by local symmetry generators G i that commute with the Hamiltonian of the system ˆ ˆ =H G[ , ] 0i and
restrict the dynamics to a subspace of physical states | Ψphysical⟩ which satisfy ˆ Ψ Ψ| ⟩= | ⟩G qi iphysical physical , where qi are background charges. We will be interested in the case qi = 0 for all i (see Methods). Realizing such a constrained dynamics on a quantum simulator is demanding and has been the focus of theoretical research6,7,11,21–24. Instead, to opti-mally use the finite resources represented by a few qubits of existing quantum hardware, we encode the gauge degrees of freedom in a long-range interaction between the fermions (electrons and positrons), which can be implemented efficiently on our experimental platform. This allows us to explore quantum simulation of coherent real-time
1Institute for Experimental Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information of the Austrian Academy of Sciences, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 3Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 4Physics Department, Technische Universität München, 85747 Garching, Germany.* These authors contributed equally to this work.
a
+
e–Globalbeam
Addressing
beam
t
x
b
Vacuum
e+
–
e+
e–
e+
e–
+
+ +
–
–
Figure 1 | Quantum simulation of the Schwinger mechanism. a, The instability of the vacuum due to quantum fluctuations is one of the most fundamental effects in gauge theories. We simulate the coherent real-time dynamics of particle–antiparticle creation by realizing the Schwinger model (one-dimensional quantum electrodynamics) on a lattice, as described in the main text. b, The experimental setup for the simulation consists of a linear Paul trap, where a string of 40Ca+ ions is confined. The electronic states of each ion, depicted as horizontal lines, encode a spin | ↑ ⟩ or | ↓ ⟩ . These states can be manipulated using laser beams (see Methods for details).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
Schwinger pair production ion trap quantum computer
5 1 6 | N A T U R E | V O L 5 3 4 | 2 3 J U N E 2 0 1 6
LETTERdoi:10.1038/nature18318
Real-time dynamics of lattice gauge theories with a few-qubit quantum computerEsteban A. Martinez1*, Christine A. Muschik2,3*, Philipp Schindler1, Daniel Nigg1, Alexander Erhard1, Markus Heyl2,4, Philipp Hauke2,3, Marcello Dalmonte2,3, Thomas Monz1, Peter Zoller2,3 & Rainer Blatt1,2
Gauge theories are fundamental to our understanding of interactions between the elementary constituents of matter as mediated by gauge bosons1,2. However, computing the real-time dynamics in gauge theories is a notorious challenge for classical computational methods. This has recently stimulated theoretical effort, using Feynman’s idea of a quantum simulator3,4, to devise schemes for simulating such theories on engineered quantum-mechanical devices, with the difficulty that gauge invariance and the associated local conservation laws (Gauss laws) need to be implemented5–7. Here we report the experimental demonstration of a digital quantum simulation of a lattice gauge theory, by realizing (1 + 1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (the Schwinger model8,9) on a few-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer. We are interested in the real-time evolution of the Schwinger mechanism10,11, describing the instability of the bare vacuum due to quantum fluctuations, which manifests itself in the spontaneous creation of electron–positron pairs. To make efficient use of our quantum resources, we map the original problem to a spin model by eliminating the gauge fields12 in favour of exotic long-range interactions, which can be directly and efficiently implemented on an ion trap architecture13. We explore the Schwinger mechanism of particle–antiparticle generation by monitoring the mass production and the vacuum persistence amplitude. Moreover, we track the real-time evolution of entanglement in the system, which illustrates how particle creation and entanglement generation are directly related. Our work represents a first step towards quantum simulation of high-energy theories using atomic physics experiments—the long-term intention is to extend this approach to real-time quantum simulations of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.
Small-scale quantum computers exist today in the laboratory as programmable quantum devices14. In particular, trapped-ion quan-tum computers13 provide a platform allowing a few hundred coherent quantum gates to act on a few qubits, with a clear roadmap towards scaling up these devices4,15. This provides the tools for universal digital quantum simulation16, where the time evolution of a quantum system is approximated as a stroboscopic sequence of quantum gates17. Here we show how this technology can be used to simulate the real-time dynamics of a minimal model of a lattice gauge theory, realizing the Schwinger model8,9 as a one-dimensional quantum field theory with a chain of trapped ions (Fig. 1).
Our few-qubit demonstration is a first step towards simulating real-time dynamics in gauge theories: such simulations are funda-mental for the understanding of many physical phenomena, including thermalization after heavy-ion collisions and pair creation studied at high- intensity laser facilities6,18. Although existing classical numerical methods such as quantum Monte Carlo have been remarkably success-ful for describing equilibrium phenomena, no systematic techniques exist to tackle the dynamical long-time behaviour of all but very small
systems. In contrast, quantum simulations aim at the long-term goal of solving the specific yet fundamental class of problems that currently cannot be tackled by these classical techniques. The digital approach we employ here is based on the Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories9, and enables direct access to the system wavefunction. As we show below, this allows us to investigate entanglement generation during particle–antiparticle production, emphasizing a novel perspec-tive on the dynamics of the Schwinger mechanism2.
Digital quantum simulations described in the present work are con-ceptually different from, and fundamentally more challenging than, previously reported condensed-matter-motivated simulations of spin and Hubbard-type models4,19,20. In gauge theories, local symmetries lead to the introduction of dynamical gauge fields obeying a Gauss law6. Formally, this crucial feature is described by local symmetry generators G i that commute with the Hamiltonian of the system ˆ ˆ =H G[ , ] 0i and
restrict the dynamics to a subspace of physical states | Ψphysical⟩ which satisfy ˆ Ψ Ψ| ⟩= | ⟩G qi iphysical physical , where qi are background charges. We will be interested in the case qi = 0 for all i (see Methods). Realizing such a constrained dynamics on a quantum simulator is demanding and has been the focus of theoretical research6,7,11,21–24. Instead, to opti-mally use the finite resources represented by a few qubits of existing quantum hardware, we encode the gauge degrees of freedom in a long-range interaction between the fermions (electrons and positrons), which can be implemented efficiently on our experimental platform. This allows us to explore quantum simulation of coherent real-time
1Institute for Experimental Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information of the Austrian Academy of Sciences, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 3Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 4Physics Department, Technische Universität München, 85747 Garching, Germany.* These authors contributed equally to this work.
a
+
e–Globalbeam
Addressing
beam
t
x
b
Vacuum
e+
–
e+
e–
e+
e–
+
+ +
–
–
Figure 1 | Quantum simulation of the Schwinger mechanism. a, The instability of the vacuum due to quantum fluctuations is one of the most fundamental effects in gauge theories. We simulate the coherent real-time dynamics of particle–antiparticle creation by realizing the Schwinger model (one-dimensional quantum electrodynamics) on a lattice, as described in the main text. b, The experimental setup for the simulation consists of a linear Paul trap, where a string of 40Ca+ ions is confined. The electronic states of each ion, depicted as horizontal lines, encode a spin | ↑ ⟩ or | ↓ ⟩ . These states can be manipulated using laser beams (see Methods for details).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
Schwinger Model: 1+1D QED
Kogut-Susskind Hamiltonian (Wilson LGT)
Hlat =°i w
N°1X
n=1
h©†
ne
i µn ©n+1 °h.c.i+ J
N°1X
n=1L
2n+m
NX
n=1(°1)n©†
n©n
E. Martinez C. Muschik
5 1 6 | N A T U R E | V O L 5 3 4 | 2 3 J U N E 2 0 1 6
LETTERdoi:10.1038/nature18318
Real-time dynamics of lattice gauge theories with a few-qubit quantum computerEsteban A. Martinez1*, Christine A. Muschik2,3*, Philipp Schindler1, Daniel Nigg1, Alexander Erhard1, Markus Heyl2,4, Philipp Hauke2,3, Marcello Dalmonte2,3, Thomas Monz1, Peter Zoller2,3 & Rainer Blatt1,2
Gauge theories are fundamental to our understanding of interactions between the elementary constituents of matter as mediated by gauge bosons1,2. However, computing the real-time dynamics in gauge theories is a notorious challenge for classical computational methods. This has recently stimulated theoretical effort, using Feynman’s idea of a quantum simulator3,4, to devise schemes for simulating such theories on engineered quantum-mechanical devices, with the difficulty that gauge invariance and the associated local conservation laws (Gauss laws) need to be implemented5–7. Here we report the experimental demonstration of a digital quantum simulation of a lattice gauge theory, by realizing (1 + 1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (the Schwinger model8,9) on a few-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer. We are interested in the real-time evolution of the Schwinger mechanism10,11, describing the instability of the bare vacuum due to quantum fluctuations, which manifests itself in the spontaneous creation of electron–positron pairs. To make efficient use of our quantum resources, we map the original problem to a spin model by eliminating the gauge fields12 in favour of exotic long-range interactions, which can be directly and efficiently implemented on an ion trap architecture13. We explore the Schwinger mechanism of particle–antiparticle generation by monitoring the mass production and the vacuum persistence amplitude. Moreover, we track the real-time evolution of entanglement in the system, which illustrates how particle creation and entanglement generation are directly related. Our work represents a first step towards quantum simulation of high-energy theories using atomic physics experiments—the long-term intention is to extend this approach to real-time quantum simulations of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.
Small-scale quantum computers exist today in the laboratory as programmable quantum devices14. In particular, trapped-ion quan-tum computers13 provide a platform allowing a few hundred coherent quantum gates to act on a few qubits, with a clear roadmap towards scaling up these devices4,15. This provides the tools for universal digital quantum simulation16, where the time evolution of a quantum system is approximated as a stroboscopic sequence of quantum gates17. Here we show how this technology can be used to simulate the real-time dynamics of a minimal model of a lattice gauge theory, realizing the Schwinger model8,9 as a one-dimensional quantum field theory with a chain of trapped ions (Fig. 1).
Our few-qubit demonstration is a first step towards simulating real-time dynamics in gauge theories: such simulations are funda-mental for the understanding of many physical phenomena, including thermalization after heavy-ion collisions and pair creation studied at high- intensity laser facilities6,18. Although existing classical numerical methods such as quantum Monte Carlo have been remarkably success-ful for describing equilibrium phenomena, no systematic techniques exist to tackle the dynamical long-time behaviour of all but very small
systems. In contrast, quantum simulations aim at the long-term goal of solving the specific yet fundamental class of problems that currently cannot be tackled by these classical techniques. The digital approach we employ here is based on the Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories9, and enables direct access to the system wavefunction. As we show below, this allows us to investigate entanglement generation during particle–antiparticle production, emphasizing a novel perspec-tive on the dynamics of the Schwinger mechanism2.
Digital quantum simulations described in the present work are con-ceptually different from, and fundamentally more challenging than, previously reported condensed-matter-motivated simulations of spin and Hubbard-type models4,19,20. In gauge theories, local symmetries lead to the introduction of dynamical gauge fields obeying a Gauss law6. Formally, this crucial feature is described by local symmetry generators G i that commute with the Hamiltonian of the system ˆ ˆ =H G[ , ] 0i and
restrict the dynamics to a subspace of physical states | Ψphysical⟩ which satisfy ˆ Ψ Ψ| ⟩= | ⟩G qi iphysical physical , where qi are background charges. We will be interested in the case qi = 0 for all i (see Methods). Realizing such a constrained dynamics on a quantum simulator is demanding and has been the focus of theoretical research6,7,11,21–24. Instead, to opti-mally use the finite resources represented by a few qubits of existing quantum hardware, we encode the gauge degrees of freedom in a long-range interaction between the fermions (electrons and positrons), which can be implemented efficiently on our experimental platform. This allows us to explore quantum simulation of coherent real-time
1Institute for Experimental Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information of the Austrian Academy of Sciences, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 3Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 4Physics Department, Technische Universität München, 85747 Garching, Germany.* These authors contributed equally to this work.
a
+
e–Globalbeam
Addressing
beam
t
x
b
Vacuum
e+
–
e+
e–
e+
e–
+
+ +
–
–
Figure 1 | Quantum simulation of the Schwinger mechanism. a, The instability of the vacuum due to quantum fluctuations is one of the most fundamental effects in gauge theories. We simulate the coherent real-time dynamics of particle–antiparticle creation by realizing the Schwinger model (one-dimensional quantum electrodynamics) on a lattice, as described in the main text. b, The experimental setup for the simulation consists of a linear Paul trap, where a string of 40Ca+ ions is confined. The electronic states of each ion, depicted as horizontal lines, encode a spin | ↑ ⟩ or | ↓ ⟩ . These states can be manipulated using laser beams (see Methods for details).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
Schwinger pair production ion trap quantum computer
5 1 8 | N A T U R E | V O L 5 3 4 | 2 3 J U N E 2 0 1 6
LETTERRESEARCH
windows. By repeating the sequence multiple times, the resulting time evolution of the system U(t) closely resembles an evolution where the individual parts of the Hamiltonian act simultaneously, as can be shown using the Suzuki–Lie–Trotter expansion:
ˆ ˆ( )= =⎛⎝⎜⎜⎜ ⊗
⎞⎠⎟⎟⎟
−→∞ =
− /U t e lim eiHtn k
KiH t n
n
1k
Our scheme is depicted in Fig. 2f–h. It allows for an efficient realization of the required dynamics and implements the coupling matrix shown in Fig. 2d, e with a minimal number of time steps, scaling only linearly in the number of sites N. The scheme is therefore scalable to larger systems. A discussion of finite size effects can be found in Methods.
We realize the simulation in a quantum information processor based on a string of 40Ca+ ions confined in a macroscopic linear Paul trap (Fig. 1b). There, each qubit is encoded in the electronic states | ↓ ⟩ = 4S1/2 (with magnetic quantum number m = − 1/2), | ↑ ⟩ = 3D5/2 (m = − 1/2) of a single ion. The energy difference between these states is in the optical domain, so the state of the qubit can be manipulated using laser light pulses. More specifically, a universal set of high-fidelity quantum operations is available, consisting of collective rotations around the equator of the Bloch sphere, addressed rotations around the z axis and
entangling Mølmer–Sørensen (MS) gates26. With a sequence of these gates, arbitrary unitary operations can be implemented27. Thus, we are able to simulate any Hamiltonian evolution, and in particular the interactions required here, by means of digital quantum simulation techniques, as shown in Fig. 2. Each of the implemented time evolu-tions consists of a sequence of over 200 quantum gates (see Extended Data Fig. 3). In order to realize the non-local interactions Hzz and H± with their specific long-range interactions, we use global MS entan-gling gates together with a spectroscopic decoupling method to tailor the range of the interaction. For the decoupling, the population of the ions that are not involved in the specific operations are shelved into additional electronic states that are not affected by the light for the entangling operations (see Methods). The local terms in Hz correspond to z rotations that are directly available in our set of operations. The strength of all terms can be tuned by changing the duration of the laser pulses corresponding to the physical operations.
Within our scheme, a wide range of fundamental properties in one-dimensional lattice gauge theories can be studied. To demonstrate our approach, we concentrate on simulating the coherent quantum real-time dynamics of the Schwinger mechanism, that is, the creation of particle–antiparticle pairs out of the bare vacuum | vacuum⟩ , where matter is entirely absent (see Methods). After initializing the system in this state, which corres ponds to the ground state for m → ∞ (Fig. 3a), we apply HS (Fig. 2d) for different masses and coupling strengths. As a first step, we measure the particle number density
e+
vac
e–
vac
vac
vac
vac
vac
a
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
wtπ/2
Ideal evolution
Discretization errors
Exp. error model
0
wtπ/20
4
0
2
wt0
π/40.0
Par
ticle
num
ber d
ensi
ty, Q
Experimental data
m/w
Par
ticle
num
ber d
ensi
ty, Q
π/2
b c
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
Figure 3 | Time evolution of the particle number density, ν. a, We show the ideal evolution under the Schwinger Hamiltonian HS shown in Fig. 2d, the ideal evolution considering time discretization errors (see Fig. 2), the expected evolution including an experimental (exp.) error model (see Methods) and the experimental data for electric field energy J = w and particle mass m = 0.5w (see equation (1)). After postselection of the experimental data (see Methods), the remaining populations are 86 ± 2, 79 ± 1, 73 ± 1, 69 ± 1% after 1, 2, 3, 4 time steps (averaged over all data sets). Error bars correspond to standard deviations estimated from a Monte Carlo bootstrapping procedure. The insets show the initial state of the simulation (left inset), corresponding to the bare vacuum with particle number density ν = 0, as well as one example of a state containing one pair (right inset), that is, a state with ν = 0.5, represented as filled/empty arrows as in Fig. 2. b, Experimental data and c, theoretical prediction for the evolution of the particle number density ν as a function of the dimensionless time wt and the dimensionless particle mass m/w, with J = w.
a b
c d
0.0
1.0
J/w = 2.0
m/w = 1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
|G(t)
|2
E n
x |(0)⟩ =
|vacuum⟩
Experimental data Error model
wtπ /2
wt
1.0
0.0
1.4
0.0
|G(t)
|2
1.0
0.0
E n
1.4
0.00 0 π /2
Ψ|(t)⟩Ψ
t
e
Figure 4 | Time evolution of the vacuum persistence amplitude and entanglement. We show the square of the vacuum persistence amplitude | G(t)| 2 (the Loschmidt echo), which quantifies the decay of the unstable vacuum, and the logarithmic negativity En, a measure of the entanglement between the left and the right halves of the system. a, b, The time evolution of | G(t)| 2 (a) and En (b) for different values of the particle mass m and fixed electric field energy J = w, where w is the rate of particle–antiparticle creation and annihilation (compare equation (1)), as a function of the dimensionless time wt. c, d, The time evolution of | G(t)| 2 (c) and En (d) changes for different values of J and fixed particle mass m = 0. Circles correspond to the experimental data and squares connected by solid lines to the expected evolution assuming an experimental error model explained in Methods. Error bars correspond to standard deviations estimated from a Monte Carlo bootstrapping procedure. e, Illustration of the creation of a particle–antiparticle pair starting from the bare vacuum state.
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
Digital Quantum Simulation of an Exotic Spin Model
- obtained after integrating out gauge field
experiment
5 1 6 | N A T U R E | V O L 5 3 4 | 2 3 J U N E 2 0 1 6
LETTERdoi:10.1038/nature18318
Real-time dynamics of lattice gauge theories with a few-qubit quantum computerEsteban A. Martinez1*, Christine A. Muschik2,3*, Philipp Schindler1, Daniel Nigg1, Alexander Erhard1, Markus Heyl2,4, Philipp Hauke2,3, Marcello Dalmonte2,3, Thomas Monz1, Peter Zoller2,3 & Rainer Blatt1,2
Gauge theories are fundamental to our understanding of interactions between the elementary constituents of matter as mediated by gauge bosons1,2. However, computing the real-time dynamics in gauge theories is a notorious challenge for classical computational methods. This has recently stimulated theoretical effort, using Feynman’s idea of a quantum simulator3,4, to devise schemes for simulating such theories on engineered quantum-mechanical devices, with the difficulty that gauge invariance and the associated local conservation laws (Gauss laws) need to be implemented5–7. Here we report the experimental demonstration of a digital quantum simulation of a lattice gauge theory, by realizing (1 + 1)-dimensional quantum electrodynamics (the Schwinger model8,9) on a few-qubit trapped-ion quantum computer. We are interested in the real-time evolution of the Schwinger mechanism10,11, describing the instability of the bare vacuum due to quantum fluctuations, which manifests itself in the spontaneous creation of electron–positron pairs. To make efficient use of our quantum resources, we map the original problem to a spin model by eliminating the gauge fields12 in favour of exotic long-range interactions, which can be directly and efficiently implemented on an ion trap architecture13. We explore the Schwinger mechanism of particle–antiparticle generation by monitoring the mass production and the vacuum persistence amplitude. Moreover, we track the real-time evolution of entanglement in the system, which illustrates how particle creation and entanglement generation are directly related. Our work represents a first step towards quantum simulation of high-energy theories using atomic physics experiments—the long-term intention is to extend this approach to real-time quantum simulations of non-Abelian lattice gauge theories.
Small-scale quantum computers exist today in the laboratory as programmable quantum devices14. In particular, trapped-ion quan-tum computers13 provide a platform allowing a few hundred coherent quantum gates to act on a few qubits, with a clear roadmap towards scaling up these devices4,15. This provides the tools for universal digital quantum simulation16, where the time evolution of a quantum system is approximated as a stroboscopic sequence of quantum gates17. Here we show how this technology can be used to simulate the real-time dynamics of a minimal model of a lattice gauge theory, realizing the Schwinger model8,9 as a one-dimensional quantum field theory with a chain of trapped ions (Fig. 1).
Our few-qubit demonstration is a first step towards simulating real-time dynamics in gauge theories: such simulations are funda-mental for the understanding of many physical phenomena, including thermalization after heavy-ion collisions and pair creation studied at high- intensity laser facilities6,18. Although existing classical numerical methods such as quantum Monte Carlo have been remarkably success-ful for describing equilibrium phenomena, no systematic techniques exist to tackle the dynamical long-time behaviour of all but very small
systems. In contrast, quantum simulations aim at the long-term goal of solving the specific yet fundamental class of problems that currently cannot be tackled by these classical techniques. The digital approach we employ here is based on the Hamiltonian formulation of gauge theories9, and enables direct access to the system wavefunction. As we show below, this allows us to investigate entanglement generation during particle–antiparticle production, emphasizing a novel perspec-tive on the dynamics of the Schwinger mechanism2.
Digital quantum simulations described in the present work are con-ceptually different from, and fundamentally more challenging than, previously reported condensed-matter-motivated simulations of spin and Hubbard-type models4,19,20. In gauge theories, local symmetries lead to the introduction of dynamical gauge fields obeying a Gauss law6. Formally, this crucial feature is described by local symmetry generators G i that commute with the Hamiltonian of the system ˆ ˆ =H G[ , ] 0i and
restrict the dynamics to a subspace of physical states | Ψphysical⟩ which satisfy ˆ Ψ Ψ| ⟩= | ⟩G qi iphysical physical , where qi are background charges. We will be interested in the case qi = 0 for all i (see Methods). Realizing such a constrained dynamics on a quantum simulator is demanding and has been the focus of theoretical research6,7,11,21–24. Instead, to opti-mally use the finite resources represented by a few qubits of existing quantum hardware, we encode the gauge degrees of freedom in a long-range interaction between the fermions (electrons and positrons), which can be implemented efficiently on our experimental platform. This allows us to explore quantum simulation of coherent real-time
1Institute for Experimental Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 2Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information of the Austrian Academy of Sciences, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 3Institute for Theoretical Physics, University of Innsbruck, 6020 Innsbruck, Austria. 4Physics Department, Technische Universität München, 85747 Garching, Germany.* These authors contributed equally to this work.
a
+
e–Globalbeam
Addressing
beam
t
x
b
Vacuum
e+
–
e+
e–
e+
e–
+
+ +
–
–
Figure 1 | Quantum simulation of the Schwinger mechanism. a, The instability of the vacuum due to quantum fluctuations is one of the most fundamental effects in gauge theories. We simulate the coherent real-time dynamics of particle–antiparticle creation by realizing the Schwinger model (one-dimensional quantum electrodynamics) on a lattice, as described in the main text. b, The experimental setup for the simulation consists of a linear Paul trap, where a string of 40Ca+ ions is confined. The electronic states of each ion, depicted as horizontal lines, encode a spin | ↑ ⟩ or | ↓ ⟩ . These states can be manipulated using laser beams (see Methods for details).
© 2016 Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved
220 quantum gates
uibkI QOIAnalog Quantum Simulation
• spin models • trapped ions
• We “build” a quantum system with desired Hamiltonian & controllable parameters,e.g. Hubbard models of atoms in optical lattices
H =
i , jJi j
(i )x
( j )x +B
i(i )
z<latexit sha1_base64="BXwPZePDQPMurZX16hWgNrWf9mg=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="BXwPZePDQPMurZX16hWgNrWf9mg=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="BXwPZePDQPMurZX16hWgNrWf9mg=">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</latexit>
K. Kim, C. Monroe et al., Nature (2010)
tunable range interaction
Ji j 1
|i j |<latexit sha1_base64="cjSBsb0f/e7TSCWRJqNexIqYr+0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="cjSBsb0f/e7TSCWRJqNexIqYr+0=">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</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="cjSBsb0f/e7TSCWRJqNexIqYr+0=">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</latexit>
0. . .3<latexit sha1_base64="WJ6ED8Hw0agBUeOLw/dl+lRL27Y=">AAACPnicdVDLTsJAFJ3iC+sLdOnCRkLiqhkgQdiRuHGJCRUikGY6XMqk02nTmRpIw1+41X/xM/wCV8atSyuWBCTe1Z1zzr1zz3FCzqTC+E3LbW3v7O7l9/WDw6Pjk0Lx9F4GcUTBogEPop5DJHAmwFJMceiFERDf4dB1vJsfvvsIkWSB6KhZCEOfuIKNGSUqhR6wMeCjQEmjZhdK2MTNBq41jc2mYuJFlVBWbbuoXZSXXxmcKJgypQ9GAY19EIpyImUfhJt6mAyTCMIgUnO9PIglhIR6xIV+pzJMxoFQIOgfJl3HRHOYMBHGGT1mUyP2OYmV1FekSUzlfBXox2rcmK6OrqqJL32iJhugnPnOOgiSifTggU88IGmsSkGkp1cu9hoTM/WrLx92Zt92GeeSCFmt2h7M0kiXuRn/N1bVrJv4Dpda9SzbPDpHl+gKVdA1aqFb1EYWokigJ/SMXrRX7V370D5/pTktmzlDa6V9fQNflq9f</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="WJ6ED8Hw0agBUeOLw/dl+lRL27Y=">AAACPnicdVDLTsJAFJ3iC+sLdOnCRkLiqhkgQdiRuHGJCRUikGY6XMqk02nTmRpIw1+41X/xM/wCV8atSyuWBCTe1Z1zzr1zz3FCzqTC+E3LbW3v7O7l9/WDw6Pjk0Lx9F4GcUTBogEPop5DJHAmwFJMceiFERDf4dB1vJsfvvsIkWSB6KhZCEOfuIKNGSUqhR6wMeCjQEmjZhdK2MTNBq41jc2mYuJFlVBWbbuoXZSXXxmcKJgypQ9GAY19EIpyImUfhJt6mAyTCMIgUnO9PIglhIR6xIV+pzJMxoFQIOgfJl3HRHOYMBHGGT1mUyP2OYmV1FekSUzlfBXox2rcmK6OrqqJL32iJhugnPnOOgiSifTggU88IGmsSkGkp1cu9hoTM/WrLx92Zt92GeeSCFmt2h7M0kiXuRn/N1bVrJv4Dpda9SzbPDpHl+gKVdA1aqFb1EYWokigJ/SMXrRX7V370D5/pTktmzlDa6V9fQNflq9f</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="WJ6ED8Hw0agBUeOLw/dl+lRL27Y=">AAACPnicdVDLTsJAFJ3iC+sLdOnCRkLiqhkgQdiRuHGJCRUikGY6XMqk02nTmRpIw1+41X/xM/wCV8atSyuWBCTe1Z1zzr1zz3FCzqTC+E3LbW3v7O7l9/WDw6Pjk0Lx9F4GcUTBogEPop5DJHAmwFJMceiFERDf4dB1vJsfvvsIkWSB6KhZCEOfuIKNGSUqhR6wMeCjQEmjZhdK2MTNBq41jc2mYuJFlVBWbbuoXZSXXxmcKJgypQ9GAY19EIpyImUfhJt6mAyTCMIgUnO9PIglhIR6xIV+pzJMxoFQIOgfJl3HRHOYMBHGGT1mUyP2OYmV1FekSUzlfBXox2rcmK6OrqqJL32iJhugnPnOOgiSifTggU88IGmsSkGkp1cu9hoTM/WrLx92Zt92GeeSCFmt2h7M0kiXuRn/N1bVrJv4Dpda9SzbPDpHl+gKVdA1aqFb1EYWokigJ/SMXrRX7V370D5/pTktmzlDa6V9fQNflq9f</latexit>
LETTERS
Quantum simulation of frustrated Ising spins withtrapped ionsK. Kim1, M.-S. Chang1, S. Korenblit1, R. Islam1, E. E. Edwards1, J. K. Freericks2, G.-D. Lin3, L.-M. Duan3 & C. Monroe1
A network is frustrated when competing interactions betweennodes prevent each bond from being satisfied. This compromiseis central to the behaviour of many complex systems, from social1
and neural2 networks to protein folding3 and magnetism4,5.Frustrated networks have highly degenerate ground states, withexcess entropy and disorder even at zero temperature. In the caseof quantum networks, frustration can lead to massively entangledground states, underpinning exotic materials such as quantum spinliquids and spin glasses6–9. Here we realize a quantum simulation offrustrated Ising spins in a system of three trapped atomic ions10–12,whose interactions are precisely controlled using optical forces13.We study the ground state of this system as it adiabatically evolvesfrom a transverse polarized state, and observe that frustrationinduces extra degeneracy. We also measure the entanglement inthe system, finding a link between frustration and ground-stateentanglement. This experimental system can be scaled to simulatelarger numbers of spins, the ground states of which (for frustratedinteractions) cannot be simulated on a classical computer.
Linus Pauling predicted in 1945 that the frustrated oxygen–hydrogenbond lengths in the pyrochloric lattice of ice would lead to a macro-scopic degeneracy of the ground state near zero temperature14. Thiszero-point entropy has been observed in spin-ice materials5,15, wherethe competing interactions are magnetic in nature. In the simple caseof a two-dimensional triangular lattice with frustrated antiferromag-netic Ising interactions, the ground-state degeneracy can easily be seen(Fig. 1a): only two of the three spins on each triangular cell can alignantiparallel, so all possible mixed configurations in each triangle(three-quarters of all cases) are ground states. Quantum super-position of these degenerate states leads to massive entanglement thatis important in our understanding of the complex phase structure ofmany frustrated materials, ranging from molecular and liquid crystalsto high-temperature superconductors5,16.
In our experiment, we implement a quantum simulation of thesmallest possible frustrated magnetic network, which consists of threespins. This work builds on earlier results for two trapped ions12, in asystem that can be scaled to much larger numbers of spins. We controlthe sign and strength of the individual magnetic interactions, directlymeasure all possible spin correlation functions and characterizeentanglement using techniques borrowed from quantum informationscience12,17. The experiment is based on a linear chain of three trappedatomic 171Yb1 ions, where the effective spin-1/2 system is representedby the 2S1/2 jF 5 1, mF 5 0æ and jF 5 0, mF 5 0æ hyperfine ‘clock’ statesin each ion, depicted by j"æz and j#æz, respectively18, and separated infrequency by nHF 5 12.642821 GHz.
The ions are confined in a three-layer linear trap13 and form acrystal along the trap’s z axis with a centre-of-mass trap frequencyof nz 5 1.49 MHz. The three normal modes of transverse motionalong the principal x axis occur at frequencies n1 5 4.334 MHz,
n2 5 4.074 MHz and n3 5 3.674 MHz. Off-resonance laser beamsuniformly illuminate the ions, driving stimulated Raman transitionsbetween the spin states and also imparting spin-dependent forces inthe x direction. As discussed in Methods, this allows quantum simu-lation of the Ising Hamiltonian with a transverse field10–12
H~X
ivj
Ji,js(i)x s (j)
x zBy
X
i
s (i)y ð1Þ
where By is an effective uniform transverse magnetic field with eachspin having unit magnetic moment, and we have set Planck’s constant,h, equal to one. For three spins, we define J1 ; J1,2 5 J2,3 as the nearest-neighbour interaction and J2 ; J1,3 as the next-nearest-neighbourinteraction (Fig. 1b), and s (i)
a denote the Pauli matrices of the ith spin.We initialize each spin parallel to a strong transverse field and thenadiabatically lower the field relative to the Ising couplings so that the
1Joint Quantum Institute, University of Maryland Department of Physics and National Institute of Standards and Technology, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA. 2Department ofPhysics, Georgetown University, Washington DC 20057, USA. 3MCTP and Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, USA.
–3–3 –2 –1 0
0
3
a b
J1 J1
J2
J2
J1
1 2 3?
CMTiltZigzagc
IIIIIIIV
J (k
Hz)
µ~
Figure 1 | Frustrated Ising spins. a, Simplest case of spin frustration, withthree antiferromagnetic spins on a triangle. b, Image of three trapped atomic171Yb1 ions in the experiment, taken with an intensified charge-coupled-device camera, with nearest-neighbour (J1) and next-nearest-neighbour (J2)interactions. c, Expected form of the Ising interactions J1 and J2, controlledthrough the detuning, m, of an optical spin-dependent force, scaled to theaxial (nz) and transverse (n1) centre-of-mass (CM) normal-mode frequenciesof motion such that the CM, tilt and zigzag modes of transverse motionoccur at ~mm:(m2n2
1)=n2z 5 0, 21 and 22.4, respectively13.
Vol 465 | 3 June 2010 | doi:10.1038/nature09071
590Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved©2010
LETTERS
Quantum simulation of frustrated Ising spins withtrapped ionsK. Kim1, M.-S. Chang1, S. Korenblit1, R. Islam1, E. E. Edwards1, J. K. Freericks2, G.-D. Lin3, L.-M. Duan3 & C. Monroe1
A network is frustrated when competing interactions betweennodes prevent each bond from being satisfied. This compromiseis central to the behaviour of many complex systems, from social1
and neural2 networks to protein folding3 and magnetism4,5.Frustrated networks have highly degenerate ground states, withexcess entropy and disorder even at zero temperature. In the caseof quantum networks, frustration can lead to massively entangledground states, underpinning exotic materials such as quantum spinliquids and spin glasses6–9. Here we realize a quantum simulation offrustrated Ising spins in a system of three trapped atomic ions10–12,whose interactions are precisely controlled using optical forces13.We study the ground state of this system as it adiabatically evolvesfrom a transverse polarized state, and observe that frustrationinduces extra degeneracy. We also measure the entanglement inthe system, finding a link between frustration and ground-stateentanglement. This experimental system can be scaled to simulatelarger numbers of spins, the ground states of which (for frustratedinteractions) cannot be simulated on a classical computer.
Linus Pauling predicted in 1945 that the frustrated oxygen–hydrogenbond lengths in the pyrochloric lattice of ice would lead to a macro-scopic degeneracy of the ground state near zero temperature14. Thiszero-point entropy has been observed in spin-ice materials5,15, wherethe competing interactions are magnetic in nature. In the simple caseof a two-dimensional triangular lattice with frustrated antiferromag-netic Ising interactions, the ground-state degeneracy can easily be seen(Fig. 1a): only two of the three spins on each triangular cell can alignantiparallel, so all possible mixed configurations in each triangle(three-quarters of all cases) are ground states. Quantum super-position of these degenerate states leads to massive entanglement thatis important in our understanding of the complex phase structure ofmany frustrated materials, ranging from molecular and liquid crystalsto high-temperature superconductors5,16.
In our experiment, we implement a quantum simulation of thesmallest possible frustrated magnetic network, which consists of threespins. This work builds on earlier results for two trapped ions12, in asystem that can be scaled to much larger numbers of spins. We controlthe sign and strength of the individual magnetic interactions, directlymeasure all possible spin correlation functions and characterizeentanglement using techniques borrowed from quantum informationscience12,17. The experiment is based on a linear chain of three trappedatomic 171Yb1 ions, where the effective spin-1/2 system is representedby the 2S1/2 jF 5 1, mF 5 0æ and jF 5 0, mF 5 0æ hyperfine ‘clock’ statesin each ion, depicted by j"æz and j#æz, respectively18, and separated infrequency by nHF 5 12.642821 GHz.
The ions are confined in a three-layer linear trap13 and form acrystal along the trap’s z axis with a centre-of-mass trap frequencyof nz 5 1.49 MHz. The three normal modes of transverse motionalong the principal x axis occur at frequencies n1 5 4.334 MHz,
n2 5 4.074 MHz and n3 5 3.674 MHz. Off-resonance laser beamsuniformly illuminate the ions, driving stimulated Raman transitionsbetween the spin states and also imparting spin-dependent forces inthe x direction. As discussed in Methods, this allows quantum simu-lation of the Ising Hamiltonian with a transverse field10–12
H~X
ivj
Ji,js(i)x s (j)
x zBy
X
i
s (i)y ð1Þ
where By is an effective uniform transverse magnetic field with eachspin having unit magnetic moment, and we have set Planck’s constant,h, equal to one. For three spins, we define J1 ; J1,2 5 J2,3 as the nearest-neighbour interaction and J2 ; J1,3 as the next-nearest-neighbourinteraction (Fig. 1b), and s (i)
a denote the Pauli matrices of the ith spin.We initialize each spin parallel to a strong transverse field and thenadiabatically lower the field relative to the Ising couplings so that the
1Joint Quantum Institute, University of Maryland Department of Physics and National Institute of Standards and Technology, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA. 2Department ofPhysics, Georgetown University, Washington DC 20057, USA. 3MCTP and Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, USA.
–3–3 –2 –1 0
0
3
a b
J1 J1
J2
J2
J1
1 2 3?
CMTiltZigzagc
IIIIIIIV
J (k
Hz)
µ~
Figure 1 | Frustrated Ising spins. a, Simplest case of spin frustration, withthree antiferromagnetic spins on a triangle. b, Image of three trapped atomic171Yb1 ions in the experiment, taken with an intensified charge-coupled-device camera, with nearest-neighbour (J1) and next-nearest-neighbour (J2)interactions. c, Expected form of the Ising interactions J1 and J2, controlledthrough the detuning, m, of an optical spin-dependent force, scaled to theaxial (nz) and transverse (n1) centre-of-mass (CM) normal-mode frequenciesof motion such that the CM, tilt and zigzag modes of transverse motionoccur at ~mm:(m2n2
1)=n2z 5 0, 21 and 22.4, respectively13.
Vol 465 | 3 June 2010 | doi:10.1038/nature09071
590Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved©2010
LETTERS
Quantum simulation of frustrated Ising spins withtrapped ionsK. Kim1, M.-S. Chang1, S. Korenblit1, R. Islam1, E. E. Edwards1, J. K. Freericks2, G.-D. Lin3, L.-M. Duan3 & C. Monroe1
A network is frustrated when competing interactions betweennodes prevent each bond from being satisfied. This compromiseis central to the behaviour of many complex systems, from social1
and neural2 networks to protein folding3 and magnetism4,5.Frustrated networks have highly degenerate ground states, withexcess entropy and disorder even at zero temperature. In the caseof quantum networks, frustration can lead to massively entangledground states, underpinning exotic materials such as quantum spinliquids and spin glasses6–9. Here we realize a quantum simulation offrustrated Ising spins in a system of three trapped atomic ions10–12,whose interactions are precisely controlled using optical forces13.We study the ground state of this system as it adiabatically evolvesfrom a transverse polarized state, and observe that frustrationinduces extra degeneracy. We also measure the entanglement inthe system, finding a link between frustration and ground-stateentanglement. This experimental system can be scaled to simulatelarger numbers of spins, the ground states of which (for frustratedinteractions) cannot be simulated on a classical computer.
Linus Pauling predicted in 1945 that the frustrated oxygen–hydrogenbond lengths in the pyrochloric lattice of ice would lead to a macro-scopic degeneracy of the ground state near zero temperature14. Thiszero-point entropy has been observed in spin-ice materials5,15, wherethe competing interactions are magnetic in nature. In the simple caseof a two-dimensional triangular lattice with frustrated antiferromag-netic Ising interactions, the ground-state degeneracy can easily be seen(Fig. 1a): only two of the three spins on each triangular cell can alignantiparallel, so all possible mixed configurations in each triangle(three-quarters of all cases) are ground states. Quantum super-position of these degenerate states leads to massive entanglement thatis important in our understanding of the complex phase structure ofmany frustrated materials, ranging from molecular and liquid crystalsto high-temperature superconductors5,16.
In our experiment, we implement a quantum simulation of thesmallest possible frustrated magnetic network, which consists of threespins. This work builds on earlier results for two trapped ions12, in asystem that can be scaled to much larger numbers of spins. We controlthe sign and strength of the individual magnetic interactions, directlymeasure all possible spin correlation functions and characterizeentanglement using techniques borrowed from quantum informationscience12,17. The experiment is based on a linear chain of three trappedatomic 171Yb1 ions, where the effective spin-1/2 system is representedby the 2S1/2 jF 5 1, mF 5 0æ and jF 5 0, mF 5 0æ hyperfine ‘clock’ statesin each ion, depicted by j"æz and j#æz, respectively18, and separated infrequency by nHF 5 12.642821 GHz.
The ions are confined in a three-layer linear trap13 and form acrystal along the trap’s z axis with a centre-of-mass trap frequencyof nz 5 1.49 MHz. The three normal modes of transverse motionalong the principal x axis occur at frequencies n1 5 4.334 MHz,
n2 5 4.074 MHz and n3 5 3.674 MHz. Off-resonance laser beamsuniformly illuminate the ions, driving stimulated Raman transitionsbetween the spin states and also imparting spin-dependent forces inthe x direction. As discussed in Methods, this allows quantum simu-lation of the Ising Hamiltonian with a transverse field10–12
H~X
ivj
Ji,js(i)x s (j)
x zBy
X
i
s (i)y ð1Þ
where By is an effective uniform transverse magnetic field with eachspin having unit magnetic moment, and we have set Planck’s constant,h, equal to one. For three spins, we define J1 ; J1,2 5 J2,3 as the nearest-neighbour interaction and J2 ; J1,3 as the next-nearest-neighbourinteraction (Fig. 1b), and s (i)
a denote the Pauli matrices of the ith spin.We initialize each spin parallel to a strong transverse field and thenadiabatically lower the field relative to the Ising couplings so that the
1Joint Quantum Institute, University of Maryland Department of Physics and National Institute of Standards and Technology, College Park, Maryland 20742, USA. 2Department ofPhysics, Georgetown University, Washington DC 20057, USA. 3MCTP and Department of Physics, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan 48109, USA.
–3–3 –2 –1 0
0
3
a b
J1 J1
J2
J2
J1
1 2 3?
CMTiltZigzagc
IIIIIIIV
J (k
Hz)
µ~
Figure 1 | Frustrated Ising spins. a, Simplest case of spin frustration, withthree antiferromagnetic spins on a triangle. b, Image of three trapped atomic171Yb1 ions in the experiment, taken with an intensified charge-coupled-device camera, with nearest-neighbour (J1) and next-nearest-neighbour (J2)interactions. c, Expected form of the Ising interactions J1 and J2, controlledthrough the detuning, m, of an optical spin-dependent force, scaled to theaxial (nz) and transverse (n1) centre-of-mass (CM) normal-mode frequenciesof motion such that the CM, tilt and zigzag modes of transverse motionoccur at ~mm:(m2n2
1)=n2z 5 0, 21 and 22.4, respectively13.
Vol 465 | 3 June 2010 | doi:10.1038/nature09071
590Macmillan Publishers Limited. All rights reserved©2010
P Jurcevic, BP Lanyon, R Blatt, C. Roos et al. (2014)
~ 20 - 50 ions
64
magnetization of each spin
2
ated excitations act as radiating sources of entangled quasi-particles with dispersion relations determined by the under-lying system interactions. Possibly here start wtih: in thecase of short-range interactions get well defined group veloc-ity - supoerpositions of left and right travelling wavepacketsemerge and distribute entanglement. for long-range....
Our system, realised with trapped ions in a linear Paul trap,is accurately described by the transverse Ising model
HIsing = ~X
i, j
Ji j(i)x
( j)x + ~B
X
i
(i)z
where (i) ( = x, y, z, ) are the spin-1/2 Pauli operators
for the ith spin, B is the e↵ective transverse magneticfield and Ji j is the coupling matrix with approximatelypower-law decay with the lattice distance |i j| that can betuned between infinite-range (↵ = 0) and, asymptotically,short-range (↵ = 3). The chosen interaction range deter-mines the magnon quasi-particle dispersion relationship andtheir interactions in the system (fig 1). In the case whereB >> max(Ji j) the number of spin excitations is conservedand HIsing reduces to the XY model of hopping hardcorebosons HXY =
Pi< j Ji j(+ + +). (somewhere say:?
our quasi-particles are hardcore bosons, maybe figure 1caption)We can varify the system behaviour by directlymeasuring the exact spatial distribution of the spin-spininteractions in our system, i.e. the underlying Hamiltonian,and the corresponding quasi-particle dispersion relationship(see methods), which are seen to closely match theoreticalpredictions (Fig 1b-c).
Starting with the steady state of all spins down we per-form arbitrary local and global quenches of system. For localquenches this means fully flipping or making superpositions(|+i = (| #i+| "i)/
p2) of individual spins. (something about?:
with local quench probe low lying excitations of system andQP dispersion relation. With global quench probe high lyingexcitations and QP interactions become really important.) Inthis case the spread of information from the quench site(s)around system can be seen in spatially and temporally re-solved single spin observables like the magnetisation hZ(t)i.At early times wavefronts radiating away from single spin-excitations are clearly visible while at later times reflectionsresult in complex interference patterns (fig 1a-b). Creatingexcitations at either end of the spin chain creates counter-propagating wavefronts resulting in quasi-particle collisions,with properties dependant on the underlying interaction range(Fig 1c).
For global quenches rotate all spins are prepared in thesuperposition state |+i. This corresponds to a superpositionof all possible system excitations and therefore all super-positions of magnon dynamics will occur. In this case theunderlying physics can be investigated by measuring two-spincorrelation functions (fig 1d). The propagation of correlationsfollowing global quenches in spin chains is explored in a
FIG. 2: Magnon dynamics in a systems of 7 interacting quantumspins following local and global quenches. a-c. Time evolution ofthe magnetisation hZ(t)i of each spin in the system following a localquench at: a the centre spin, for ↵ ??. a.i, data, a.ii, theory: bthe left hand spin, for ↵ ??, b.i, data, b.ii, theory and: c both endsof the chain resulting, for ↵ ??, (data only). d. Time evolutionof two-spin correlation function C = hZi(t)Zj(t)i hZi(t)ihZj(t)i fol-lowing a global quench, for ↵ ?? (see methods, where we mustexplain that done with smaller B field).
complimentary paper by Monroe [? ].
To reveal the quantum correlations carried by quasi-particles we tomographically measure the full quantum stateof pairs of spins at many points during the dynamics. In thiscase we employ short-range interactions (↵ 2) for which aclear wavefront is apparent following a local quench in thecentre of the spin chain (fig 3a). The results clearly show thatmagnons emerging from either side of the initial excitation areentangled, and distribute this entanglement across the spin-chain at a finite velocity (fig 3b-c). In general it is possible tomeasure the quantum state of any subset of spins at any pointin the dynamics.
In the case of nearest-neighbour interactions, LR boundssay that information is restricted to propagate within well de-fined wavefronts, beyond which the signal amplitude decaysexponentially (both in space and time). In that case, the sys-tems maximal group velocity tightly bounds the propagatingwave front. In the presence of power-law interactions thatdecay suciently fast, one can still obtain an approximatelight cone by considering only the nearest-neighbor interac-tions [8? ], but now the signal decays algebraically outsideof this approximate light cone. When the interactions becomeof longer range, there are more magnons that propagate fasterthan the nearest-neighbor wave front, and the light-cone con-cept breaks down.
This e↵ect is exemplified in Fig. 4a-c for local quenchesat three values of ↵, chosen roughly equally spaced around↵ = 1. In the shortest-range case (Fig. 4a, ↵ 1.41), the ob-
time
[ms]
Magnon propagation
entanglement
2 642 64
0
10
5
15
20
25Ti
me
(ms)
0
0.2
1
0.4
0.6
0.8a b
0
0.2
0.1
0.3
0.4
0.6
0.5
Con
curr
ence
0 105 15 20 3025Time (ms)
spin 3&5spin 2&6
spin 1&7
Entanglement
Light-cone-like spreading of entanglement
breakdown of the quantum speed-limit due to long range interactions
[exp & theory indistinguishable]
2
ated excitations act as radiating sources of entangled quasi-particles with dispersion relations determined by the under-lying system interactions. Possibly here start wtih: in thecase of short-range interactions get well defined group veloc-ity - supoerpositions of left and right travelling wavepacketsemerge and distribute entanglement. for long-range....
Our system, realised with trapped ions in a linear Paul trap,is accurately described by the transverse Ising model
HIsing = ~X
i, j
Ji j(i)x
( j)x + ~B
X
i
(i)z
where (i) ( = x, y, z, ) are the spin-1/2 Pauli operators
for the ith spin, B is the e↵ective transverse magneticfield and Ji j is the coupling matrix with approximatelypower-law decay with the lattice distance |i j| that can betuned between infinite-range (↵ = 0) and, asymptotically,short-range (↵ = 3). The chosen interaction range deter-mines the magnon quasi-particle dispersion relationship andtheir interactions in the system (fig 1). In the case whereB >> max(Ji j) the number of spin excitations is conservedand HIsing reduces to the XY model of hopping hardcorebosons HXY =
Pi< j Ji j(+ + +). (somewhere say:?
our quasi-particles are hardcore bosons, maybe figure 1caption)We can varify the system behaviour by directlymeasuring the exact spatial distribution of the spin-spininteractions in our system, i.e. the underlying Hamiltonian,and the corresponding quasi-particle dispersion relationship(see methods), which are seen to closely match theoreticalpredictions (Fig 1b-c).
Starting with the steady state of all spins down we per-form arbitrary local and global quenches of system. For localquenches this means fully flipping or making superpositions(|+i = (| #i+| "i)/
p2) of individual spins. (something about?:
with local quench probe low lying excitations of system andQP dispersion relation. With global quench probe high lyingexcitations and QP interactions become really important.) Inthis case the spread of information from the quench site(s)around system can be seen in spatially and temporally re-solved single spin observables like the magnetisation hZ(t)i.At early times wavefronts radiating away from single spin-excitations are clearly visible while at later times reflectionsresult in complex interference patterns (fig 1a-b). Creatingexcitations at either end of the spin chain creates counter-propagating wavefronts resulting in quasi-particle collisions,with properties dependant on the underlying interaction range(Fig 1c).
For global quenches rotate all spins are prepared in thesuperposition state |+i. This corresponds to a superpositionof all possible system excitations and therefore all super-positions of magnon dynamics will occur. In this case theunderlying physics can be investigated by measuring two-spincorrelation functions (fig 1d). The propagation of correlationsfollowing global quenches in spin chains is explored in a
FIG. 2: Magnon dynamics in a systems of 7 interacting quantumspins following local and global quenches. a-c. Time evolution ofthe magnetisation hZ(t)i of each spin in the system following a localquench at: a the centre spin, for ↵ ??. a.i, data, a.ii, theory: bthe left hand spin, for ↵ ??, b.i, data, b.ii, theory and: c both endsof the chain resulting, for ↵ ??, (data only). d. Time evolutionof two-spin correlation function C = hZi(t)Zj(t)i hZi(t)ihZj(t)i fol-lowing a global quench, for ↵ ?? (see methods, where we mustexplain that done with smaller B field).
complimentary paper by Monroe [? ].
To reveal the quantum correlations carried by quasi-particles we tomographically measure the full quantum stateof pairs of spins at many points during the dynamics. In thiscase we employ short-range interactions (↵ 2) for which aclear wavefront is apparent following a local quench in thecentre of the spin chain (fig 3a). The results clearly show thatmagnons emerging from either side of the initial excitation areentangled, and distribute this entanglement across the spin-chain at a finite velocity (fig 3b-c). In general it is possible tomeasure the quantum state of any subset of spins at any pointin the dynamics.
In the case of nearest-neighbour interactions, LR boundssay that information is restricted to propagate within well de-fined wavefronts, beyond which the signal amplitude decaysexponentially (both in space and time). In that case, the sys-tems maximal group velocity tightly bounds the propagatingwave front. In the presence of power-law interactions thatdecay suciently fast, one can still obtain an approximatelight cone by considering only the nearest-neighbor interac-tions [8? ], but now the signal decays algebraically outsideof this approximate light cone. When the interactions becomeof longer range, there are more magnons that propagate fasterthan the nearest-neighbor wave front, and the light-cone con-cept breaks down.
This e↵ect is exemplified in Fig. 4a-c for local quenchesat three values of ↵, chosen roughly equally spaced around↵ = 1. In the shortest-range case (Fig. 4a, ↵ 1.41), the ob-
P Jurcevic, et al., PZ, R Blatt & CF Roos, Nature (2014); related work by C. Monroe group
deleted
uibk
Tomorrow …
uibkA Short Preview
What is Quantum Optics?… a Short Tour & Overview
[Experiment + Theory]
• Quantum Properties of Light
• [Quantum] Interaction of Light & Mattercontrol
… a Few Examples
uibkEx 4: Quantum Metrology with Cold Atoms
… measurements beyond the Standard Quantum Limit
2/π
2/π
time
Ramsey interferometer
'<latexit sha1_base64="RsrwMBkl249j/eLpupgw4OcPe5E=">AAAB8nicfVDLTsJAFL31ifWFunRDBBMXpmkxUVhJ4sYlJvIwlJDpeKETOtNmZkogDV/hzujCuPVz3PgXfoIFNJEQPaubc859HS8KmNK2/WEsLa+srq1nNszNre2d3ezefl2FsaRYo2EQyqZHFAZMYE0zHWAzkki4F2DD619N9MYApWKhuNWjCNuc9ATrMkp0St0V3AGRkc8KnWzetuxyyT4r5xYLx7KnyF9+whTVTvbdvQ9pzFFoGhClWih66b3+qWNHup1IjEKpx+bxvy5FZWqc+Ew3VhgR2ic9TGKqxr+JVqy7pWE7YSKKNQo6JyaEK060v0CqEffmSVRMpLtcTvpI0qi0Rmm606k539I4NNMYfn7N/V3Ui5ZjW85NMV85n+UBGTiEIzgBBy6gAtdQhRpQ4PAAT/BsaOPReDFeZ9Yl47vnAOZgvH0BrAmTiA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="RsrwMBkl249j/eLpupgw4OcPe5E=">AAAB8nicfVDLTsJAFL31ifWFunRDBBMXpmkxUVhJ4sYlJvIwlJDpeKETOtNmZkogDV/hzujCuPVz3PgXfoIFNJEQPaubc859HS8KmNK2/WEsLa+srq1nNszNre2d3ezefl2FsaRYo2EQyqZHFAZMYE0zHWAzkki4F2DD619N9MYApWKhuNWjCNuc9ATrMkp0St0V3AGRkc8KnWzetuxyyT4r5xYLx7KnyF9+whTVTvbdvQ9pzFFoGhClWih66b3+qWNHup1IjEKpx+bxvy5FZWqc+Ew3VhgR2ic9TGKqxr+JVqy7pWE7YSKKNQo6JyaEK060v0CqEffmSVRMpLtcTvpI0qi0Rmm606k539I4NNMYfn7N/V3Ui5ZjW85NMV85n+UBGTiEIzgBBy6gAtdQhRpQ4PAAT/BsaOPReDFeZ9Yl47vnAOZgvH0BrAmTiA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="RsrwMBkl249j/eLpupgw4OcPe5E=">AAAB8nicfVDLTsJAFL31ifWFunRDBBMXpmkxUVhJ4sYlJvIwlJDpeKETOtNmZkogDV/hzujCuPVz3PgXfoIFNJEQPaubc859HS8KmNK2/WEsLa+srq1nNszNre2d3ezefl2FsaRYo2EQyqZHFAZMYE0zHWAzkki4F2DD619N9MYApWKhuNWjCNuc9ATrMkp0St0V3AGRkc8KnWzetuxyyT4r5xYLx7KnyF9+whTVTvbdvQ9pzFFoGhClWih66b3+qWNHup1IjEKpx+bxvy5FZWqc+Ew3VhgR2ic9TGKqxr+JVqy7pWE7YSKKNQo6JyaEK060v0CqEffmSVRMpLtcTvpI0qi0Rmm606k539I4NNMYfn7N/V3Ui5ZjW85NMV85n+UBGTiEIzgBBy6gAtdQhRpQ4PAAT/BsaOPReDFeZ9Yl47vnAOZgvH0BrAmTiA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="RsrwMBkl249j/eLpupgw4OcPe5E=">AAAB8nicfVDLTsJAFL31ifWFunRDBBMXpmkxUVhJ4sYlJvIwlJDpeKETOtNmZkogDV/hzujCuPVz3PgXfoIFNJEQPaubc859HS8KmNK2/WEsLa+srq1nNszNre2d3ezefl2FsaRYo2EQyqZHFAZMYE0zHWAzkki4F2DD619N9MYApWKhuNWjCNuc9ATrMkp0St0V3AGRkc8KnWzetuxyyT4r5xYLx7KnyF9+whTVTvbdvQ9pzFFoGhClWih66b3+qWNHup1IjEKpx+bxvy5FZWqc+Ew3VhgR2ic9TGKqxr+JVqy7pWE7YSKKNQo6JyaEK060v0CqEffmSVRMpLtcTvpI0qi0Rmm606k539I4NNMYfn7N/V3Ui5ZjW85NMV85n+UBGTiEIzgBBy6gAtdQhRpQ4PAAT/BsaOPReDFeZ9Yl47vnAOZgvH0BrAmTiA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="8hLXN/4SFYG8nART6rf8kQU5tUg=">AAAB8nicfVDLTsJAFL31ifWFunRDBBMXpmkxUdiRuHGJiTwMJWQ6XmBCZzqZmRJIw1e4M7owbv0cN/6NBTGRED2rm3POfZ1Ahkwb1/20VlbX1jc2M1v29s7u3n724LCuo1hRrNEojFQzIBpDJrBmmAmxKRUSHoTYCAbXU70xRKVZJO7MWGKbk55gXUaJSan7gj8kSvZZoZPNu45bLrkX5dxy4TnuDHmYo9rJfvgPEY05CkNDonULRS+9t3/uudK0E4UyUmZin/7r0lSlxqnP9mONktAB6WESUz35TbRi0y2N2gkTMjYo6IKYEK45Mf0lUo95sEiiZiLd5XMyQJJGZQwq259NzfUdgyM7jeHn19zfRb3oeK7j3Rbzlct5IBk4hhM4Aw+uoAI3UIUaUODwCM/wYhnryXq13r6tK9a85wgWYL1/AQ6oklk=</latexit>
|#i<latexit sha1_base64="Sa9QFQcXtrRajQDumJDLF+Pi+OI=">AAAB/XicfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr1qWbYiu4kDCpoO3KghuXFewDmlIm420bkkzCzMS2hOKfuBNdiFt/xI1/4SeYtgqWomd1Oefc13Ei35WKkA9taXlldW09s6Fvbm3v7Bp72boMY8GwxkI/FE2HSvRdjjXlKh+bkUAaOD42HO9yojfuUEg35DdqFGE7oD3udl1GVUp1jGzB9lAl9m044FSIcDAudIw8MUm5RE7LucXCMskU+YtPmKLaMd7TdhYHyBXzqZQt5L309P6JRSLVTgRGoVBj/ehfl2QiNU58uh1LjCjzaA+TmMnxb6IVq25p2E5cHsUKOZsTExrIgKr+AilHgTNPonR5ussOqIc0TU0pFLo9nZrrmwqHehrDz6+5v4t60bSIaV0X85WzWR6QgQM4hGOw4BwqcAVVqAGDITzAEzxr99qj9qK9zqxL2nfPPsxBe/sCoVuYBA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Sa9QFQcXtrRajQDumJDLF+Pi+OI=">AAAB/XicfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr1qWbYiu4kDCpoO3KghuXFewDmlIm420bkkzCzMS2hOKfuBNdiFt/xI1/4SeYtgqWomd1Oefc13Ei35WKkA9taXlldW09s6Fvbm3v7Bp72boMY8GwxkI/FE2HSvRdjjXlKh+bkUAaOD42HO9yojfuUEg35DdqFGE7oD3udl1GVUp1jGzB9lAl9m044FSIcDAudIw8MUm5RE7LucXCMskU+YtPmKLaMd7TdhYHyBXzqZQt5L309P6JRSLVTgRGoVBj/ehfl2QiNU58uh1LjCjzaA+TmMnxb6IVq25p2E5cHsUKOZsTExrIgKr+AilHgTNPonR5ussOqIc0TU0pFLo9nZrrmwqHehrDz6+5v4t60bSIaV0X85WzWR6QgQM4hGOw4BwqcAVVqAGDITzAEzxr99qj9qK9zqxL2nfPPsxBe/sCoVuYBA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Sa9QFQcXtrRajQDumJDLF+Pi+OI=">AAAB/XicfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr1qWbYiu4kDCpoO3KghuXFewDmlIm420bkkzCzMS2hOKfuBNdiFt/xI1/4SeYtgqWomd1Oefc13Ei35WKkA9taXlldW09s6Fvbm3v7Bp72boMY8GwxkI/FE2HSvRdjjXlKh+bkUAaOD42HO9yojfuUEg35DdqFGE7oD3udl1GVUp1jGzB9lAl9m044FSIcDAudIw8MUm5RE7LucXCMskU+YtPmKLaMd7TdhYHyBXzqZQt5L309P6JRSLVTgRGoVBj/ehfl2QiNU58uh1LjCjzaA+TmMnxb6IVq25p2E5cHsUKOZsTExrIgKr+AilHgTNPonR5ussOqIc0TU0pFLo9nZrrmwqHehrDz6+5v4t60bSIaV0X85WzWR6QgQM4hGOw4BwqcAVVqAGDITzAEzxr99qj9qK9zqxL2nfPPsxBe/sCoVuYBA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Sa9QFQcXtrRajQDumJDLF+Pi+OI=">AAAB/XicfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr1qWbYiu4kDCpoO3KghuXFewDmlIm420bkkzCzMS2hOKfuBNdiFt/xI1/4SeYtgqWomd1Oefc13Ei35WKkA9taXlldW09s6Fvbm3v7Bp72boMY8GwxkI/FE2HSvRdjjXlKh+bkUAaOD42HO9yojfuUEg35DdqFGE7oD3udl1GVUp1jGzB9lAl9m044FSIcDAudIw8MUm5RE7LucXCMskU+YtPmKLaMd7TdhYHyBXzqZQt5L309P6JRSLVTgRGoVBj/ehfl2QiNU58uh1LjCjzaA+TmMnxb6IVq25p2E5cHsUKOZsTExrIgKr+AilHgTNPonR5ussOqIc0TU0pFLo9nZrrmwqHehrDz6+5v4t60bSIaV0X85WzWR6QgQM4hGOw4BwqcAVVqAGDITzAEzxr99qj9qK9zqxL2nfPPsxBe/sCoVuYBA==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="ZydewvjKMX+tmXjeHhgZ74voC34=">AAAB/XicfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr1qWbYiu4kDCpoO2u4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOTSZhZmJbQvFP3IkuxK0/4sa/Ma0VLEXP6nLOua/jRT5XmpBPY2V1bX1jM7Nlbu/s7u1bB9m6CmPJsMZCP5RNjyr0ucCa5trHZiSRBp6PDW9wNdUb9ygVD8WtHkfYDmhP8C5nVKdUx8oW3AHqxL0Lh4JKGQ4nhY6VJzYpl8h5ObdcODaZIQ9zVDvWR9rO4gCFZj5VqoWil57eP3NIpNuJxCiUemKe/OtSTKbGqc90Y4URZQPawyRmavKbaMW6Wxq1Ey6iWKNgC2JCAxVQ3V8i1TjwFklUXKS73IAOkKapaY3SdGdTc31b48hMY/j5Nfd3US/aDrGdm2K+cjEPJANHcAyn4MAlVOAaqlADBiN4hGd4MR6MJ+PVePu2rhjznkNYgPH+BQP6ltU=</latexit>
|"i<latexit sha1_base64="NQ3bR/J+EszGvkm0vwbPuC7HA2k=">AAAB+3icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr6tJNsRVcSEgqaLuy4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOeQ0zk9oS8ifuRBfi1j9x41/4CaatgqXoWV3OOfd1XO4zqSzrQ1taXlldW89t6Jtb2zu7xt5+Q0axoFinkR+Jlksk+izEumLKxxYXSALXx6brXU305hCFZFF4q8YcOwHph6zHKFEZ1TWMouOhSpyYEyGi+7TYNQqWaVXK1lklv1jYpjVF4fITpqh1jXfnLqJxgKGiPpGyjWE/O3xwaltcdRKBPBIq1Y//dUkqMuPEpzuxRE6oR/qYxFSmv4l2rHrlUSdhIY8VhnROTEggA6IGC6QcB+48iZKF2S4nIB6SLDOlUOjOdGp+YCoc6VkMP7/m/y4aJdO2TPumVKiez/KAHBzCEZyADRdQhWuoQR0oDOEBnuBZS7VH7UV7nVmXtO+eA5iD9vYFCIuXHQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="NQ3bR/J+EszGvkm0vwbPuC7HA2k=">AAAB+3icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr6tJNsRVcSEgqaLuy4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOeQ0zk9oS8ifuRBfi1j9x41/4CaatgqXoWV3OOfd1XO4zqSzrQ1taXlldW89t6Jtb2zu7xt5+Q0axoFinkR+Jlksk+izEumLKxxYXSALXx6brXU305hCFZFF4q8YcOwHph6zHKFEZ1TWMouOhSpyYEyGi+7TYNQqWaVXK1lklv1jYpjVF4fITpqh1jXfnLqJxgKGiPpGyjWE/O3xwaltcdRKBPBIq1Y//dUkqMuPEpzuxRE6oR/qYxFSmv4l2rHrlUSdhIY8VhnROTEggA6IGC6QcB+48iZKF2S4nIB6SLDOlUOjOdGp+YCoc6VkMP7/m/y4aJdO2TPumVKiez/KAHBzCEZyADRdQhWuoQR0oDOEBnuBZS7VH7UV7nVmXtO+eA5iD9vYFCIuXHQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="NQ3bR/J+EszGvkm0vwbPuC7HA2k=">AAAB+3icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr6tJNsRVcSEgqaLuy4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOeQ0zk9oS8ifuRBfi1j9x41/4CaatgqXoWV3OOfd1XO4zqSzrQ1taXlldW89t6Jtb2zu7xt5+Q0axoFinkR+Jlksk+izEumLKxxYXSALXx6brXU305hCFZFF4q8YcOwHph6zHKFEZ1TWMouOhSpyYEyGi+7TYNQqWaVXK1lklv1jYpjVF4fITpqh1jXfnLqJxgKGiPpGyjWE/O3xwaltcdRKBPBIq1Y//dUkqMuPEpzuxRE6oR/qYxFSmv4l2rHrlUSdhIY8VhnROTEggA6IGC6QcB+48iZKF2S4nIB6SLDOlUOjOdGp+YCoc6VkMP7/m/y4aJdO2TPumVKiez/KAHBzCEZyADRdQhWuoQR0oDOEBnuBZS7VH7UV7nVmXtO+eA5iD9vYFCIuXHQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="NQ3bR/J+EszGvkm0vwbPuC7HA2k=">AAAB+3icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr6tJNsRVcSEgqaLuy4MZlBfuAppTJeNsOeQ0zk9oS8ifuRBfi1j9x41/4CaatgqXoWV3OOfd1XO4zqSzrQ1taXlldW89t6Jtb2zu7xt5+Q0axoFinkR+Jlksk+izEumLKxxYXSALXx6brXU305hCFZFF4q8YcOwHph6zHKFEZ1TWMouOhSpyYEyGi+7TYNQqWaVXK1lklv1jYpjVF4fITpqh1jXfnLqJxgKGiPpGyjWE/O3xwaltcdRKBPBIq1Y//dUkqMuPEpzuxRE6oR/qYxFSmv4l2rHrlUSdhIY8VhnROTEggA6IGC6QcB+48iZKF2S4nIB6SLDOlUOjOdGp+YCoc6VkMP7/m/y4aJdO2TPumVKiez/KAHBzCEZyADRdQhWuoQR0oDOEBnuBZS7VH7UV7nVmXtO+eA5iD9vYFCIuXHQ==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="f/Ol7zh1ZwyAzoBnUyzI3doPPNo=">AAAB+3icfVDLSsNAFL3xWeMr6tJNsRVcSJhU0HZXcOOygn1AU8pkvG2HJpMwM6ktIX/iTnQhbv0TN/6Naa1gKXpWl3POfR0v8rnShHwaK6tr6xubuS1ze2d3b986OGyoMJYM6yz0Q9nyqEKfC6xrrn1sRRJp4PnY9IbXU705Qql4KO70JMJOQPuC9zijOqO6llV0h6gTN46olOFDWuxaBWKTSplcVPLLhWOTGQowR61rfbj3IYsDFJr5VKk2in52+ODcIZHuJBKjUOrUPP3XpZjMjFOf6cYKI8qGtI9JzFT6m2jHulcedxIuolijYAtiQgMVUD1YItUk8BZJVFxku9yADpFmmWmN0nRnU/MDW+PYzGL4+TX/d9Eo2Q6xndtSoXo5DyQHx3ACZ+DAFVThBmpQBwYjeIRneDFS48l4Nd6+rSvGvOcIFmC8fwFrG5Xu</latexit>
phase shift
N - independent atoms N - entangled atoms
product state ª |#1i . . . |#N i<latexit sha1_base64="PpamZeh7f4ChdKulohjstiHssgM=">AAACK3icfVBNS8NAEJ34bfyqevQSrIIHCYmC2pMFL55EwapgStlsx3Zpsht2J7Yl9O9485948wMUr979CcaqYCn6TsN7b2Z4L0wiYcjznq2R0bHxicmpaXtmdm5+obC4dGZUqjlWuIqUvgiZwUhIrJCgCC8SjSwOIzwPWwef+vk1aiOUPKVugtWYNaS4EpxRTtUK5USresrJMcQInbXAiNgJWkhZUFdtybRW7ZrfC6K6IjMkHPXWaoWi53qlPW+75AwPvuv1Udx/hz6Oa4WH/ABPY5TEI2bMJcpGHrS56XsJVTONidLUs9f/dRmuc+Onzw5SgwnjLdbALOWm95u4TOlqr1PNhExSQskHxIzFJmbUHCJNNw4HSTRC5r+CmLWQ5R0TobaD/lWn6RJ27LyGn6zO38PZlut7rn+yVSzvfPUBU7ACq7ABPuxCGQ7hGCrA4Qbu4BGerFvr3nqxXr+sI9b3zjIMwHr7AGEKq60=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PpamZeh7f4ChdKulohjstiHssgM=">AAACK3icfVBNS8NAEJ34bfyqevQSrIIHCYmC2pMFL55EwapgStlsx3Zpsht2J7Yl9O9485948wMUr979CcaqYCn6TsN7b2Z4L0wiYcjznq2R0bHxicmpaXtmdm5+obC4dGZUqjlWuIqUvgiZwUhIrJCgCC8SjSwOIzwPWwef+vk1aiOUPKVugtWYNaS4EpxRTtUK5USresrJMcQInbXAiNgJWkhZUFdtybRW7ZrfC6K6IjMkHPXWaoWi53qlPW+75AwPvuv1Udx/hz6Oa4WH/ABPY5TEI2bMJcpGHrS56XsJVTONidLUs9f/dRmuc+Onzw5SgwnjLdbALOWm95u4TOlqr1PNhExSQskHxIzFJmbUHCJNNw4HSTRC5r+CmLWQ5R0TobaD/lWn6RJ27LyGn6zO38PZlut7rn+yVSzvfPUBU7ACq7ABPuxCGQ7hGCrA4Qbu4BGerFvr3nqxXr+sI9b3zjIMwHr7AGEKq60=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PpamZeh7f4ChdKulohjstiHssgM=">AAACK3icfVBNS8NAEJ34bfyqevQSrIIHCYmC2pMFL55EwapgStlsx3Zpsht2J7Yl9O9485948wMUr979CcaqYCn6TsN7b2Z4L0wiYcjznq2R0bHxicmpaXtmdm5+obC4dGZUqjlWuIqUvgiZwUhIrJCgCC8SjSwOIzwPWwef+vk1aiOUPKVugtWYNaS4EpxRTtUK5USresrJMcQInbXAiNgJWkhZUFdtybRW7ZrfC6K6IjMkHPXWaoWi53qlPW+75AwPvuv1Udx/hz6Oa4WH/ABPY5TEI2bMJcpGHrS56XsJVTONidLUs9f/dRmuc+Onzw5SgwnjLdbALOWm95u4TOlqr1PNhExSQskHxIzFJmbUHCJNNw4HSTRC5r+CmLWQ5R0TobaD/lWn6RJ27LyGn6zO38PZlut7rn+yVSzvfPUBU7ACq7ABPuxCGQ7hGCrA4Qbu4BGerFvr3nqxXr+sI9b3zjIMwHr7AGEKq60=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="PpamZeh7f4ChdKulohjstiHssgM=">AAACK3icfVBNS8NAEJ34bfyqevQSrIIHCYmC2pMFL55EwapgStlsx3Zpsht2J7Yl9O9485948wMUr979CcaqYCn6TsN7b2Z4L0wiYcjznq2R0bHxicmpaXtmdm5+obC4dGZUqjlWuIqUvgiZwUhIrJCgCC8SjSwOIzwPWwef+vk1aiOUPKVugtWYNaS4EpxRTtUK5USresrJMcQInbXAiNgJWkhZUFdtybRW7ZrfC6K6IjMkHPXWaoWi53qlPW+75AwPvuv1Udx/hz6Oa4WH/ABPY5TEI2bMJcpGHrS56XsJVTONidLUs9f/dRmuc+Onzw5SgwnjLdbALOWm95u4TOlqr1PNhExSQskHxIzFJmbUHCJNNw4HSTRC5r+CmLWQ5R0TobaD/lWn6RJ27LyGn6zO38PZlut7rn+yVSzvfPUBU7ACq7ABPuxCGQ7hGCrA4Qbu4BGerFvr3nqxXr+sI9b3zjIMwHr7AGEKq60=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="cYuuYzUWJFzgwfl5ehlQy8gXbhQ=">AAACK3icfVDLSsNAFJ34rPEVdekm2AouJCQVtO4KblxJBauFpoTJ9LYdmsyEmRsfhPyOO//EnQ9Q3PofRq1gKXpWl3POvZdzwiTiGl33xZianpmdmy8tmItLyyur1tr6uZapYtBkMpKqFVINERfQRI4RtBIFNA4juAiHR5/6xSUozaU4w5sEOjHtC97jjGJBBVY9UbKbMrQ1UgS74mse2/4QMPO78kpQpeRV4OV+1JWoJ4STvBJYZddxD2vu3qE9OXiO+4UyGaERWI/FAZbGIJBFVOs2iH4RdLDruQl2MgWJVJib2/+6NFOF8dNn+qmGhLIh7UOWMp3/Jtop9mrXnYyLJEUQbEzMaKxjioMJUt/E4TgJmovilx/TIdCiY0RQpv911R44CNdmUcNPVvvv4bzqeK7jnVbL9f1RISWySbbIDvHIAamTY9IgTcLILbknT+TZuDMejFfj7ds6ZYx2NsgYjPcPw5qqfg==</latexit>
GHZ ª |#1 . . . #N i+|"1 . . . "N i<latexit sha1_base64="MQGyutxA1kzT/uDEeLEu5e/KilY=">AAACPXicfZBLS8NAEMcn9R1fUY9egq0gKCGp4ONkwYM9iYptRVPKZp22S5NN2N34IPR7efNLePHiTfQg4s2raavQWnROw29+u8P8vchnUtn2o5YZGR0bn5ic0qdnZufmjYXFsgxjQbFEQz8UZx6R6DOOJcWUj2eRQBJ4Pla81n5nXrlCIVnIT9VthNWANDirM0pUimrGyUHx3My5kgWm20KVuJfhNSdChNc1x/UvQyXNPnTYXu9ZcfTL+QGH7VzNyNqWvbtjb+6aw41j2d3K7n1At45qxkO6gsYBckV9IuUF8kZ6enPDsSNVTQRGoVBtffVfS1KRih1Pd2OJEaEt0sAkprLdDy5iVd+5qSaMR7FCTgeGCQlkQFRzCMrbwBuEKBlPd7kBaSFJU1cKhe52fzWblsIbPY3h51bz76actxzbco7z2cJWLw+YhGVYgTVwYBsKUIQjKAGFO3iCF3jV7rVn7U1776kZ7fvNEgyU9vkF0Rqy6g==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="MQGyutxA1kzT/uDEeLEu5e/KilY=">AAACPXicfZBLS8NAEMcn9R1fUY9egq0gKCGp4ONkwYM9iYptRVPKZp22S5NN2N34IPR7efNLePHiTfQg4s2raavQWnROw29+u8P8vchnUtn2o5YZGR0bn5ic0qdnZufmjYXFsgxjQbFEQz8UZx6R6DOOJcWUj2eRQBJ4Pla81n5nXrlCIVnIT9VthNWANDirM0pUimrGyUHx3My5kgWm20KVuJfhNSdChNc1x/UvQyXNPnTYXu9ZcfTL+QGH7VzNyNqWvbtjb+6aw41j2d3K7n1At45qxkO6gsYBckV9IuUF8kZ6enPDsSNVTQRGoVBtffVfS1KRih1Pd2OJEaEt0sAkprLdDy5iVd+5qSaMR7FCTgeGCQlkQFRzCMrbwBuEKBlPd7kBaSFJU1cKhe52fzWblsIbPY3h51bz76actxzbco7z2cJWLw+YhGVYgTVwYBsKUIQjKAGFO3iCF3jV7rVn7U1776kZ7fvNEgyU9vkF0Rqy6g==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="MQGyutxA1kzT/uDEeLEu5e/KilY=">AAACPXicfZBLS8NAEMcn9R1fUY9egq0gKCGp4ONkwYM9iYptRVPKZp22S5NN2N34IPR7efNLePHiTfQg4s2raavQWnROw29+u8P8vchnUtn2o5YZGR0bn5ic0qdnZufmjYXFsgxjQbFEQz8UZx6R6DOOJcWUj2eRQBJ4Pla81n5nXrlCIVnIT9VthNWANDirM0pUimrGyUHx3My5kgWm20KVuJfhNSdChNc1x/UvQyXNPnTYXu9ZcfTL+QGH7VzNyNqWvbtjb+6aw41j2d3K7n1At45qxkO6gsYBckV9IuUF8kZ6enPDsSNVTQRGoVBtffVfS1KRih1Pd2OJEaEt0sAkprLdDy5iVd+5qSaMR7FCTgeGCQlkQFRzCMrbwBuEKBlPd7kBaSFJU1cKhe52fzWblsIbPY3h51bz76actxzbco7z2cJWLw+YhGVYgTVwYBsKUIQjKAGFO3iCF3jV7rVn7U1776kZ7fvNEgyU9vkF0Rqy6g==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="MQGyutxA1kzT/uDEeLEu5e/KilY=">AAACPXicfZBLS8NAEMcn9R1fUY9egq0gKCGp4ONkwYM9iYptRVPKZp22S5NN2N34IPR7efNLePHiTfQg4s2raavQWnROw29+u8P8vchnUtn2o5YZGR0bn5ic0qdnZufmjYXFsgxjQbFEQz8UZx6R6DOOJcWUj2eRQBJ4Pla81n5nXrlCIVnIT9VthNWANDirM0pUimrGyUHx3My5kgWm20KVuJfhNSdChNc1x/UvQyXNPnTYXu9ZcfTL+QGH7VzNyNqWvbtjb+6aw41j2d3K7n1At45qxkO6gsYBckV9IuUF8kZ6enPDsSNVTQRGoVBtffVfS1KRih1Pd2OJEaEt0sAkprLdDy5iVd+5qSaMR7FCTgeGCQlkQFRzCMrbwBuEKBlPd7kBaSFJU1cKhe52fzWblsIbPY3h51bz76actxzbco7z2cJWLw+YhGVYgTVwYBsKUIQjKAGFO3iCF3jV7rVn7U1776kZ7fvNEgyU9vkF0Rqy6g==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="iAC1q264ypcUN4Ypja28I9IEylc=">AAACPXicfZBLT8JAEMe3+ML6Qj16aQQTE03TYqJwI/EgJ4JGHpESsl0G2NBum92tQBq+lze/hBcv3owejFevllcCGp3T5De/3cn8bd+hQhrGsxJbWl5ZXYuvqxubW9s7id29svACTqBEPMfjVRsLcCiDkqTSgarPAbu2AxW7ezmaV+6BC+qxWznwoe7iNqMtSrCMUCNxc5W/01KWoK5mdUGGVtPrMcy512uYltP0pNDmUGF4MrEC/4czA4VhqpFIGrqRzRhnWe13Y+rGuJJoWsVG4ilaQQIXmCQOFqIGrB2d3jk1DV/WQw6+x+VQPfrXEoRH4shTrUCAj0kXtyEMiBjOg1ogW5l+PaTMDyQwsjAMsStcLDu/oBi49iIEQVm0y3JxF3CUupTAVWv8q9bRJfTVKIbZrdrfTTmtm4ZuXqeTufNpIHF0gA7RMTLRBcqhPCqiEiLoAb2gN/SuPCqvyofyOVFjyvTNPloo5esbM7mxuw==</latexit>
δϕ∼ 1"
N<latexit sha1_base64="0/GNk/51B6dyDwLkslaZ3L47GVw=">AAACEXicfVC7SgNBFL0b3+tr1dJmMSgWsuwqatIFbKxEwTwgE8Ls5CYZsi9nZkPCsn9g54+InWghtrY2dn6Ka1QwBD3V5Zxz7+UcN/K4VLb9puWmpmdm5+YX9MWl5ZVVY229IsNYMCyz0AtFzaUSPR5gWXHlYS0SSH3Xw6rbO/nUq30UkofBpRpG2PBpJ+BtzqjKqKaxQ1roKWqSPhVRl5tEct8kbUFZ4qQJkVdCJWdp2jTytmUXC/ZB0ZwcHMseIV86jG/fAeC8abySVshiHwPFPCplHYNOFqe759iRaiQCo1CoVN/+1yWZyIyfPp3EEiPKerSDScxk+puox6pdGDQSHkSxwoCNiQn1pU9Vd4KUQ98dJ1HyIPtFfNpDmjWpFAqdjK6aXUvhQM9q+Mlq/j1U9i3HtpyLrI8j+MI8bMIW7IIDx1CCUziHMjC4hjt4gEftRrvXnrTnL2tO+97ZgDFoLx/X9qHM</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/SkDlk/Zms8hu2uEd3ZwS/7nVho=">AAACEXicfVC7SgNBFJ2Nr7i+Vi1tFoNiIcuuoiZdwMZKIpgHZEKYndxkh+zLmdmQsGxjbeePiJ1oIba2NhZ+iuAmUTAEPdXlnHPv5Rw7dJmQpvmuZGZm5+YXsovq0vLK6pq2vlERQcQplGngBrxmEwEu86EsmXShFnIgnu1C1e6eDvVqD7hggX8pByE0PNLxWZtRIlOqqe3iFriS6LhHeOgwHQvm6bjNCY2tJMbiisv4PEmaWs40zELePCzo04NlmCPkikfR3cf1Z6/U1N5wK6CRB76kLhGiDn4njePsW2YoGzGHMOAyUXf+dQnKU+PQp+JIQEhol3QgjqhIfhP1SLbz/UbM/DCS4NMJMSae8Ih0pkgx8OxJEgTz01/YI10gaZNSAlfx6KruGBL6alrDT1b976FyYFimYV2kfRyjMbJoC22jPWShE1REZ6iEyoiiG3SPHtGTcqs8KM/Ky9iaUb53NtEElNcvdVmjvg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/SkDlk/Zms8hu2uEd3ZwS/7nVho=">AAACEXicfVC7SgNBFJ2Nr7i+Vi1tFoNiIcuuoiZdwMZKIpgHZEKYndxkh+zLmdmQsGxjbeePiJ1oIba2NhZ+iuAmUTAEPdXlnHPv5Rw7dJmQpvmuZGZm5+YXsovq0vLK6pq2vlERQcQplGngBrxmEwEu86EsmXShFnIgnu1C1e6eDvVqD7hggX8pByE0PNLxWZtRIlOqqe3iFriS6LhHeOgwHQvm6bjNCY2tJMbiisv4PEmaWs40zELePCzo04NlmCPkikfR3cf1Z6/U1N5wK6CRB76kLhGiDn4njePsW2YoGzGHMOAyUXf+dQnKU+PQp+JIQEhol3QgjqhIfhP1SLbz/UbM/DCS4NMJMSae8Ih0pkgx8OxJEgTz01/YI10gaZNSAlfx6KruGBL6alrDT1b976FyYFimYV2kfRyjMbJoC22jPWShE1REZ6iEyoiiG3SPHtGTcqs8KM/Ky9iaUb53NtEElNcvdVmjvg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="/SkDlk/Zms8hu2uEd3ZwS/7nVho=">AAACEXicfVC7SgNBFJ2Nr7i+Vi1tFoNiIcuuoiZdwMZKIpgHZEKYndxkh+zLmdmQsGxjbeePiJ1oIba2NhZ+iuAmUTAEPdXlnHPv5Rw7dJmQpvmuZGZm5+YXsovq0vLK6pq2vlERQcQplGngBrxmEwEu86EsmXShFnIgnu1C1e6eDvVqD7hggX8pByE0PNLxWZtRIlOqqe3iFriS6LhHeOgwHQvm6bjNCY2tJMbiisv4PEmaWs40zELePCzo04NlmCPkikfR3cf1Z6/U1N5wK6CRB76kLhGiDn4njePsW2YoGzGHMOAyUXf+dQnKU+PQp+JIQEhol3QgjqhIfhP1SLbz/UbM/DCS4NMJMSae8Ih0pkgx8OxJEgTz01/YI10gaZNSAlfx6KruGBL6alrDT1b976FyYFimYV2kfRyjMbJoC22jPWShE1REZ6iEyoiiG3SPHtGTcqs8KM/Ky9iaUb53NtEElNcvdVmjvg==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="QY+xF4f/ixXdlRktx4lAO8txwe4=">AAACEXicfVDLSsNAFJ34rPEVdekmWBQXEiYK2u4KblxJBfuATimT6W07NJPEmUlpCfkDd/6JO9GFuHXrxr8xrRUsRc/qcs6593KOF/lcaYw/jYXFpeWV1dyaub6xubVt7exWVRhLBhUW+qGse1SBzwOoaK59qEcSqPB8qHn9y7FeG4BUPAxu9SiCpqDdgHc4ozqjWtYRaYOvqU0GVEY9bhPFhU06krLETROi7qROrtO0ZeWxg4sFfFa05wfXwRPk0RTllvVB2iGLBQSa+VSpBgTdLE7vxMWRbiYSolDq1Dz816WYzIxjn0liBRFlfdqFJGYq/U00Yt0pDJsJD6JYQ8BmxIQKJajuzZFqJLxZEhQPsl9E0D7QrEmtQZpkctXuORqGZlbDT1b776F66rjYcW9wvnQ+LSSH9tEBOkYuukAldIXKqIIYukeP6Bm9GA/Gk/FqvH1bF4zpzh6agfH+BXusn1I=</latexit>
δϕ∼ 1N
<latexit sha1_base64="O2ZEfxF0nSvjzKGQpXh0E6H0jrk=">AAACCnicfVC7SgNBFL0bX3F9rVpYWLgYBAtZZhU06QIiWEkE84BsCLOTm2TIvpiZDQlLSjv/xE60EFs/wca/cZMoGIKe6nLOufdyjht5XCpCPrXMwuLS8kp2VV9b39jcMrZ3KjKMBcMyC71Q1Fwq0eMBlhVXHtYigdR3Pay6vcuxXu2jkDwM7tQwwoZPOwFvc0ZVSjWNA6eFnqKm06ci6nLTkdw3nbagLLFHyc2oaeSIRQp5clYw5wfbIhPkimTvqggApabx4bRCFvsYKOZRKesYdNIc3RObRKqRCIxCoUb60b8uyURqHPt0J5YYUdajHUxiJke/iXqs2vlBI+FBFCsM2IyYUF/6VHXnSDn03VkSJQ/SX45Pe0jTCpVCoTuTq2bXUjjQ0xp+spp/D5VTyyaWfZv2cQ5TZGEfDuEYbLiAIlxDCcrA4B4e4RletAftSXvV3qbWjPa9swsz0N6/AMeLnPo=</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="fUjFwE9zSKjcokSTkoInc8sALAA=">AAACCnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqAsXLgwWwYWEiYq2u4IIrqSCbYWmlMn0th2aTMLMpLSELN35J+5EF+LWTxDEr/AXTFsFS9Gzupxz7r2c44YekwrjDy0zMzs3v5Bd1JeWV1bXjPWNigwiQaFMAy8QNy6R4DEOZcWUBzehAOK7HlTd7tlQr/ZASBbwazUIoe6TNmctRolKqYax4zTBU8R0ekSEHWY6kvmm0xKExnYSXyYNI4ctXMjjo4I5PdgWHiFXxFvn+c/j91LDeHOaAY184Ip6RMoa8Haao3Ng41DVYwFhIFSi7/3rklSkxqFPdyIJIaFd0oY4ojL5TdQi1cr36zHjYaSA0wkxJr70iepMkXLgu5MkSMbTX45PukDSCpUCoTujq2bHUtDX0xp+spp/D5VDy8aWfZX2cYLGyKJttIv2kY1OURFdoBIqI4pu0T16RE/anfagPWsvY2tG+97ZRBPQXr8AZPCe7A==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="fUjFwE9zSKjcokSTkoInc8sALAA=">AAACCnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqAsXLgwWwYWEiYq2u4IIrqSCbYWmlMn0th2aTMLMpLSELN35J+5EF+LWTxDEr/AXTFsFS9Gzupxz7r2c44YekwrjDy0zMzs3v5Bd1JeWV1bXjPWNigwiQaFMAy8QNy6R4DEOZcWUBzehAOK7HlTd7tlQr/ZASBbwazUIoe6TNmctRolKqYax4zTBU8R0ekSEHWY6kvmm0xKExnYSXyYNI4ctXMjjo4I5PdgWHiFXxFvn+c/j91LDeHOaAY184Ip6RMoa8Haao3Ng41DVYwFhIFSi7/3rklSkxqFPdyIJIaFd0oY4ojL5TdQi1cr36zHjYaSA0wkxJr70iepMkXLgu5MkSMbTX45PukDSCpUCoTujq2bHUtDX0xp+spp/D5VDy8aWfZX2cYLGyKJttIv2kY1OURFdoBIqI4pu0T16RE/anfagPWsvY2tG+97ZRBPQXr8AZPCe7A==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="fUjFwE9zSKjcokSTkoInc8sALAA=">AAACCnicfVDLSsNAFJ3UV42vqAsXLgwWwYWEiYq2u4IIrqSCbYWmlMn0th2aTMLMpLSELN35J+5EF+LWTxDEr/AXTFsFS9Gzupxz7r2c44YekwrjDy0zMzs3v5Bd1JeWV1bXjPWNigwiQaFMAy8QNy6R4DEOZcWUBzehAOK7HlTd7tlQr/ZASBbwazUIoe6TNmctRolKqYax4zTBU8R0ekSEHWY6kvmm0xKExnYSXyYNI4ctXMjjo4I5PdgWHiFXxFvn+c/j91LDeHOaAY184Ip6RMoa8Haao3Ng41DVYwFhIFSi7/3rklSkxqFPdyIJIaFd0oY4ojL5TdQi1cr36zHjYaSA0wkxJr70iepMkXLgu5MkSMbTX45PukDSCpUCoTujq2bHUtDX0xp+spp/D5VDy8aWfZX2cYLGyKJttIv2kY1OURFdoBIqI4pu0T16RE/anfagPWsvY2tG+97ZRBPQXr8AZPCe7A==</latexit><latexit sha1_base64="Yd4d94ldHcDVM1WihovGpI7hOIk=">AAACCnicfVC7SgNBFJ2Nr7i+Vi0tXAyChSyzCpp0ARsriWAekAlhdnKTHbKPYWY2JCwp7fwTO9FCbP0EG//GTYxgCHqqyznn3ss5ngi40hh/Grml5ZXVtfy6ubG5tb1j7e7VVJxIBlUWB7FseFRBwCOoaq4DaAgJNPQCqHv9q4leH4BUPI7u9EhAK6S9iHc5ozqj2tYh6UCgqU0GVAqf20Tx0CZdSVnqjtObcdsqYAeXivi8ZC8OroOnKKAZKm3rg3RiloQQaRZQpZoQ9bIc/qmLhW6lEkQs9dg8/telmMyME59JEgWCsj7tQZowNf5NNBPdLQ5bKY9EoiFic2JKQxVS7S+QahR68yQoHmW/SEj7QLMKtQZpkulV23c0DM2shp+s9t9D7cxxsePe4kL5YlZIHh2gI3SCXHSJyugaVVAVMXSPHtEzejEejCfj1Xj7tuaM2c4+moPx/gVbQZvu</latexit>
standard quantum noise limit Heisenberg limit
input states
Tutorial: J Huang et al., arxiv1308.6092
parameter estimation of phase shift[Fisher information, Cramer-Rao bound etc.]
prepare initial state
or: spin squeezed state
quantum measurement
quantum optical systems allow measurements beyond SQL
coherent control
uibkEx 5: Cavity QED & Quantum Networks
waveguide
• CQED
atom
cavity
photon(flying qubit)
For a review see: P. Lodahl, A Rauschenbeutel, P.Z. et al., Nature 2017
& light-matter interface
(stationary qubit)
chiral = unidirectional
input
output
input
output
open quantum system
uibkEx 5: Cavity QED & Quantum Networks
waveguide
• CQED
qubit 1
& light-matter interface
qubit 2
• Quantum State Transfer
qubit 1 wavepacket in waveguide qubit 2
°Æ |g i1 +Ø |ei1
¢|0ip |g i1 ! |g i1
°Æ |0ip +Ø |1ip
¢|g i1 ! |g i1 |0ip
°Æ |g i2 +Ø |ei2
¢
fidelity of transfer ~ quantum control problem… see Lecture 4
uibkEx 5: Cavity QED & Quantum Networks
waveguide
• CQED
qubit 1
& light-matter interface
qubit 2
• Quantum Networks
node
channel
~ quantum computer:'stationary qubits’
~ photonic waveguide:‘flying qubits’