investigating vowel length in cordobésspanish logo meghan ... · logo methods •participants: 20...

1
The goal of this study is to focus on vowel duration by quantifying pretonic lengthening, and to evaluate the role played by linguistic factors such as position in the IP and sociolinguistic factors such as gender and socioeconomic status (SES). Table 1: Distribution of participants according to sex and neighborhood. Objectives Conclusions Investigating Vowel Length in Cordobés Spanish Meghan Dabkowski, María Laura Lenardón & Marta Ortega-Llebaria DEPARTMENT OF LINGUISTICS • UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH Logo Selected References u The pretonic vowel lengthens at least to match the duration of its adjacent tonic vowel in both prenuclear and nuclear positions. u In fact, 54% of the pretonic vowels measured exceeded their tonic counterpart in duration by at least 15%. u Absolute values of the pretonic vowels are higher due to the longer durations of tonic vowels in phrase-final position. Thus, a constant ratio between the two is maintained. u No significant differences between genders were found in whether pretonic vowels were lengthened or in the amount of lengthening. u SES plays a role in pretonic lengthening. The mean of the ratio (pretonic to tonic) for middle class speakers was 1.24 and for lower middle class speakers 1.45. This shows that: ² 1) All speakers lengthen the pretonic vowel at least to match the duration of the tonic vowel. ² 2) On average, lower middle class speakers lengthen the pretonic vowel 15% more than middle class speakers. u The results of this study reveal that: ² All speakers lengthen the pretonic vowel in both prenuclear and nuclear positions as predicted by Yorio (1971). ² While SES played a role in the amount of lengthening observed, gender did not. ² In order to maintain the pretonic to tonic ratio, pretonic vowels in nuclear position exhibit the longest durations, due to the expected lengthening of tonic vowels in sentence final position (Navarro Tomás, 1948; Hualde, 2005). This suggests that the ratio may act as a cue to stress in Cordobés Spanish. u Additionally, an analysis of micro-level data, such as this, provides insight into the richness of intonation patterns that can be found even within one variety of Spanish (Rioplatense). u Future experimental research should include: ² A larger pool of participants, specifically encompassing distinct age groups and other socioeconomic groups. ² Controlled phrase types and vowel types. Introduction Results Logo Methods Participants: 20 native speaker life-long residents of 2 neighborhoods (representing 2 distinct SES) in Córdoba participated in this study. All were between 18-35 years of age. Data collection process & instrument: Spontaneous speech was obtained from recorded sociolinguistic interviews with participants. Interview questions were adapted from Tagliamonte (2006). Data analysis: 635 tokens (≥ 30 per participant) containing a pretonic and tonic syllable within the same word were analyzed. Tokens selected were clearly distinguishable from adjacent segments, otherwise excluded. Vowel lengths of the pretonic and tonic syllables were measured using Praat and coded for gender, SES and position within the IP. Catinelli, A. (1985). El habla de la provincia de Córdoba. Córdoba, Argentina: Centro de Estudios de la Lengua. Fontanella de Weinberg, M.B. (1971). La entonación del Español de Córdoba (Argentina). Thesaurus, 16: 11-21. Hualde, J. I. (2005). The Sounds of Spanish. New York: Cambridge University Press. Lang, J. (2010, October). Prosody in Córdoba, Argentina: a sociolinguistic analysis of the tonada cordobesa. Poster session presented at the Hispanic Linguistics Symposium 2010, Bloomington, IN. Tagliamonte, S. (2006). Analyzing Sociolinguistic Variation. New York: Cambridge University Press. Vidal de Battini, B. E. (1964). El español de la Argentina: estudio destinado a los maestros de las escuelas primarias. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Consejo Nacional de Educación. Yorio, C.A. (1973). Phonological Style in the Dialect of Spanish of Cordoba, Argentina. Doctoral dissertation. University of Michigan. Acknowledgments We would like to thank the following people for their support and guidance: Prof. Kiesling, Prof. O’Rourke, Ezequiel Lenardón, Chris Kosin and the Center for Latin American Studies at the University of Pittsburgh. Research questions: How does the length of the pretonic syllable compare to that of the tonic syllable? Does the word’s position in the intonational phrase affect lengthening? Do social factors such as gender or socioeconomic status favor pretonic lengthening? Research Question 1: How does the length of the pretonic syllable compare to that of the tonic syllable? Research Question 2: Does the word’s position in the IP affect pretonic lengthening? Example: tran·qui·lo peacefulpre-tonic tonic Data Collection Men Women San Vicente (middle class) 5 5 Surrounding neighborhoods (lower middle class) 5 5 Totals 10 10 During the last forty years, the peculiar intonation of the people from Córdoba (Argentina), informally known as the tonada cordobesa, has been of interest among linguists (Catinelli, 1985; Fontanella de Weinberg, 1971; Lang, 2010; Yorio, 1973). This tonada is characterized by the lengthening of the pretonic syllable of certain words (Catinelli, 1985; Fontanella de Weinberg, 1971; Yorio, 1973). In some instances, this vowel’s duration exceeds that of its corresponding tonic vowel (Yorio, 1973). This phenomenon, often attributed to the contact of Spanish with indigenous languages of the region, has not been attested in other varieties of Spanish (Vidal de Battini, 1964). In standard varieties of Spanish, the tonic vowel exhibits longer duration and higher pitch than its pretonic counterpart (Hualde, 2005). However, in Cordobés, these cues are distributed among the pretonic and tonic vowels as can be seen in figure 1. Figure 1: Duration and pitch distribution in pretonic and tonic syllables (Standard Spanish vs. Cordobés Spanish) (a) tran·qui·lo (Standard Sp.) (b) tran·qui·lo(Cordobés Sp.) Previous studies: u The earlier studies (Fontanella de Weinberg, 1971; Yorio, 1973) present impressionistic descriptions of the phenomenon, while the most recent study performs acoustic measurements of the vowels on words at the end of sentences (Lang, 2010). u There is no agreement on where the pretonic lengthening occurs within the intonational phrase (IP). Fontanella de Weinberg (1971) claims it occurs in words in nuclear position, whereas Yorio also finds it in prenuclear position (1973). Lang’s study (2010) does not address this, as measurements were taken only from words in nuclear position. +duration +duration +pitch +pitch Research Question 3: Do social factors such as gender and socioeconomic status favor pretonic lengthening? Figure 3: Duration ofpretonic and tonic vowels in prenuclear and nuclear positions Figure 2: Waveform and spectrogram showing pretonic and tonic vowel lengths in the word pantalla ‘screen’ (24, male, middle class)

Upload: others

Post on 05-Oct-2020

0 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Investigating Vowel Length in CordobésSpanish Logo Meghan ... · Logo Methods •Participants: 20 native speaker life-long residents of 2 neighborhoods (representing 2 distinct SES)

The goal of this study is to focus on vowel duration by quantifyingpretonic lengthening, and to evaluate the role played by linguisticfactors such as position in the IP and sociolinguistic factors suchas gender and socioeconomic status (SES).

Table 1: Distribution of participants according to sex and neighborhood.

Objectives Conclusions

Investigating Vowel Length in Cordobés SpanishMeghan Dabkowski, María Laura Lenardón & Marta Ortega-Llebaria

DEPARTMENT OF LINGUISTICS • UNIVERSITY OF PITTSBURGH

Logo

Selected References

u The pretonic vowel lengthens at least to match the duration of itsadjacent tonic vowel in both prenuclear and nuclear positions.

u In fact, 54% of the pretonic vowels measured exceeded their toniccounterpart in duration by at least 15%.

u Absolute values of the pretonic vowels are higher due to the longerdurations of tonic vowels in phrase-final position. Thus, a constantratio between the two is maintained.

u No significant differences between genders were found in whetherpretonic vowels were lengthened or in the amount of lengthening.

u SES plays a role in pretonic lengthening. The mean of the ratio(pretonic to tonic) for middle class speakers was 1.24 and for lowermiddle class speakers 1.45. This shows that:

² 1) All speakers lengthen the pretonic vowel at least to matchthe duration of the tonic vowel.

² 2) On average, lower middle class speakers lengthen thepretonic vowel 15% more than middle class speakers.

u The results of this study reveal that:

² All speakers lengthen the pretonic vowel in both prenuclear andnuclear positions as predicted by Yorio (1971).

² While SES played a role in the amount of lengtheningobserved, gender did not.

² In order to maintain the pretonic to tonic ratio, pretonic vowelsin nuclear position exhibit the longest durations, due to theexpected lengthening of tonic vowels in sentence final position(Navarro Tomás, 1948; Hualde, 2005). This suggests that theratio may act as a cue to stress in Cordobés Spanish.

u Additionally, an analysis of micro-level data, such as this, providesinsight into the richness of intonation patterns that can be foundeven within one variety of Spanish (Rioplatense).

u Future experimental research should include:

² A larger pool of participants, specifically encompassing distinctage groups and other socioeconomic groups.

² Controlled phrase types and vowel types.

Introduction Results

Logo

Methods

•Participants: 20 native speaker life-long residents of 2neighborhoods (representing 2 distinct SES) in Córdobaparticipated in this study. All were between 18-35 years of age.

•Data collection process & instrument: Spontaneous speechwas obtained from recorded sociolinguistic interviews withparticipants. Interview questions were adapted fromTagliamonte (2006).

•Data analysis: 635 tokens (≥ 30 per participant) containing apretonic and tonic syllable within the same word were analyzed.Tokens selected were clearly distinguishable from adjacentsegments, otherwise excluded. Vowel lengths of the pretonic andtonic syllables were measured using Praat and coded for gender,SES and position within the IP.

Catinelli, A. (1985). El habla de la provincia de Córdoba. Córdoba, Argentina: Centro deEstudios de la Lengua.

Fontanella de Weinberg, M.B. (1971). La entonación del Español de Córdoba (Argentina).Thesaurus, 16: 11-21.

Hualde, J. I. (2005). The Sounds of Spanish. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Lang, J. (2010, October). Prosody in Córdoba, Argentina: a sociolinguistic analysis of thetonada cordobesa. Poster session presented at the Hispanic LinguisticsSymposium 2010, Bloomington, IN.

Tagliamonte, S. (2006). Analyzing Sociolinguistic Variation. New York: CambridgeUniversity Press.

Vidal de Battini, B. E. (1964). El español de la Argentina: estudio destinado a losmaestros de las escuelas primarias. Buenos Aires, Argentina: Consejo Nacional deEducación.

Yorio, C.A. (1973). Phonological Style in the Dialect of Spanish of Cordoba, Argentina.Doctoral dissertation. University of Michigan.

AcknowledgmentsWe would like to thank the following people for their support and guidance:

Prof. Kiesling, Prof. O’Rourke, Ezequiel Lenardón, Chris Kosin and the Center for Latin American Studies at the University of Pittsburgh.

•Research questions: How does the length of the pretonicsyllable compare to that of the tonic syllable? Does the word’sposition in the intonational phrase affect lengthening? Do socialfactors such as gender or socioeconomic status favor pretoniclengthening?

•Research Question 1: How does the length of the pretonic syllable compare to that of the tonic syllable?

•Research Question 2: Does the word’s position in the IP affect pretonic lengthening?

Example: tran·qui·lo ‘peaceful’

pre-tonic tonic

Data Collection

Men Women

SanVicente(middleclass) 5 5

Surroundingneighborhoods (lower middleclass) 5 5

Totals 10 10

During the last forty years, the peculiar intonationof the people from Córdoba (Argentina), informallyknown as the tonada cordobesa, has been ofinterest among linguists (Catinelli, 1985; Fontanellade Weinberg, 1971; Lang, 2010; Yorio, 1973).

This tonada is characterized by the lengthening of the pretonicsyllable of certain words (Catinelli, 1985; Fontanella de Weinberg,1971; Yorio, 1973). In some instances, this vowel’s duration exceedsthat of its corresponding tonic vowel (Yorio, 1973). This phenomenon,often attributed to the contact of Spanish with indigenous languages ofthe region, has not been attested in other varieties of Spanish (Vidalde Battini, 1964).

In standard varieties of Spanish, the tonic vowel exhibits longerduration and higher pitch than its pretonic counterpart (Hualde, 2005).However, in Cordobés, these cues are distributed among the pretonicand tonic vowels as can be seen in figure 1.

Figure 1: Duration and pitch distribution in pretonic and tonic syllables (StandardSpanish vs. Cordobés Spanish)

(a) tran·qui·lo (Standard Sp.) (b) tran·qui·lo(Cordobés Sp.)

Previous studies:

u The earlier studies (Fontanella de Weinberg, 1971; Yorio, 1973)present impressionistic descriptions of the phenomenon, while themost recent study performs acoustic measurements of the vowelson words at the end of sentences (Lang, 2010).

u There is no agreement on where the pretonic lengthening occurswithin the intonational phrase (IP). Fontanella de Weinberg (1971)claims it occurs in words in nuclear position, whereas Yorio alsofinds it in prenuclear position (1973). Lang’s study (2010) does notaddress this, as measurements were taken only from words innuclear position.

+duration +duration+pitch +pitch

•Research Question 3: Do social factors such as gender andsocioeconomic status favor pretonic lengthening?

Figure 3: Durationofpretonic and tonicvowels in prenuclearand nuclear positions

Figure 2: Waveform andspectrogram showing pretonicand tonic vowel lengths in theword pantalla ‘screen’(24, male, middle class)