ipl cases

4
McDonald’s Corp v MacJoy Fastfood Corp., G.R. No. 166115, February 2, 2007 Facts: McDonald’s Corporation the owner of the trademark McDonald’s and its well-known Golden Arches logo, shaped like the letter M, is a fast food corporation established in the US with stores in the Philippines. McDonald’s’ products include MacFries, McSpaghetti, Big Mac and McChicken. MacJoy is a Cebua based corporation who owns the fast food chain “MACJOY & DEVICE”. MacJoy’s logo is an artistic representation of the letter M which is similar to the Golden Arches of McDonald’s. MacJoy wants to register its mark in the Intellectual Property Office. McDonald’s opposed the registration because MacJoy’s logo resembles to its logo. Issue: Whether or Not MacJoy can register its logo? Ruling: No, because the logo of MacJoy is confusingly similar to McDonald’s mark. Using the dominancy test, both logos are confusingly similar that an ordinary purchaser can conclude that the two logos are related or associated. Both marks use a dominant “M” that are similar, MacJoy made a few alteration but the substance and the essence of its logo is still closely similar to McDonald’s. MacJoy’s use of the word “Mac” also attracts customers or people that are familiar the word “Mac” because of McDonald’s brand and products. In Addition, both establishments are engage in the same business and if these two have confusingly similar marks it may lead to confuse an ordinary purchaser the difference of the two brands. The dominant use of “M” and the prefix “Mc/Mac” will result a confusing similarities of both brands especially that the two corporation are both engaged in the same business.

Upload: lean-manuel-paragas

Post on 16-Aug-2015

212 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

IPL CASES

TRANSCRIPT

McDonalds Corp v MacJoy Fastfood Corp., G.R. No. 166115, February , !!"Facts# McDonalds Corporat$on t%e o&ner of t%e trade'ar( McDonalds and $ts &ell)(no&n Golden *rc%es lo+o, s%aped l$(e t%e letter M, $s a fast food corporat$onestabl$s%ed$nt%e,-&$t%stores$nt%e.%$l$pp$nes. McDonalds products$nclude MacFr$es, Mc-pa+%ett$, /$+ Mac and McC%$c(en. MacJoy $s a Cebuabased corporat$on &%o o&ns t%e fast food c%a$n 0M*CJ12 3D456C47.MacJoys lo+o $s an art$st$c representat$on of t%e letter M &%$c% $s s$'$lar tot%e Golden *rc%es of McDonalds. MacJoy &ants to re+$ster $ts 'ar( $n t%e6ntellectual .roperty18ce. McDonaldsopposedt%ere+$strat$onbecauseMacJoys lo+o rese'bles to $ts lo+o.6ssue# 9%et%er or Not MacJoy can re+$ster $ts lo+o:Rul$n+#No, because t%e lo+o of MacJoy $s confus$n+ly s$'$lar to McDonalds 'ar(.,s$n+ t%e do'$nancy test, bot% lo+os are confus$n+ly s$'$lar t%at an ord$narypurc%aser can conclude t%at t%e t&o lo+os are related or assoc$ated. /ot%'ar(s use a do'$nant 0M7 t%at are s$'$lar, MacJoy 'ade a fe& alterat$on butt%e substance and t%e essence of $ts lo+o $s st$ll closely s$'$lar toMcDonalds. MacJoys useof t%e&ord0Mac7 alsoattracts custo'ers orpeople t%at are fa'$l$ar t%e &ord 0Mac7 because of McDonalds brand andproducts.6n *dd$t$on, bot% establ$s%'ents are en+a+e $n t%e sa'e bus$nessand $f t%ese t&o %ave confus$n+ly s$'$lar 'ar(s $t 'ay lead to confuse anord$nary purc%asert%ed$;erenceof t%et&o brands.