ipv6 adoption, general recommendation to governments case...
TRANSCRIPT
___________________________________________________________________________
2009/TEL40/DSG/WKSP/003
IPv6 Adoption, Case Study of Malaysian Government
Submitted by: Malaysia
Workshop on IPv6: Facing the Future of Internet
Cancun, Mexico24 September 2009
IPv6 Adoption, Case study of Malaysian Government
Raja Kumar M
Head, IPv6 Research
APEC TEL 40, IPv6 Workshop 24 Sep 2009, Cancun, Mexico
Outline
• Government Initiatives on IPv6
• IPv6 Deployment in Malaysia
• ISPs Current Status of IPv6
• Awareness & Promotion
• Training
• General recommendations
• Conclusion
2
Governm
ent Initiatives on IPv6
�2004, N
ational IPv6 Council, established by MEW
C (MICC
now)
�To provide leadership, and strategic planning for IPv6 im
plementation
�M
embers: M
ICC, MO
F, EPU, M
AM
PU, M
OSTI, M
CMC, and
ISPs
�M
ar 2005, National A
dvanced IPv6 Centre of Excellence (N
Av6), established by M
EWC
�To spearhead IPv6 activities in M
alaysia
–Functions:
3
Core R&
DTraining &
HRD
Monitoring
& A
udit
Aw
areness &
Prom
otion
National A
genda w.r.to IPv6
SERVICES
INFRA
STRUCTU
REG
ROW
TH
1.H
igh Speed Broadband
2.3G
& Beyond
3.M
obile TV
4.D
igital M
ultimedia
Broadcasting
5.D
igital Hom
e
6.Short Range Com
munications
(e.g. RFID-based)
7.V
oIP/Internet Telephony
8.U
niversal Service Provision
Hard
1.M
ultiservice Convergence N
etworks
2.3G
Cellular N
etworks
3.Satellite N
etworks
Soft
4.N
ext G
eneration Internet Protocol (IPv6)
5.H
ome
Internet A
doption
6.Inform
ation &
Netw
ork Security
1.Content D
evelopment
(e.g. education, entertainm
ent, gam
es)
2.ICT Education H
ub
3.D
igital M
ultimedia
Receivers (set top box)
4.Com
municatio
n Devices (e.g.
VoIP phones)
5.Em
bedded Com
ponents, D
evices (e.g. RFID
)
6.Foreign V
entures
7.Com
petence D
evelopment
8.Product D
esign &
Manufacturing
Source: MyICM
SStrategy http://w
ww
.ktak.gov.my
Promoting Targeted Technologies for N
ew
sources of growth
12.55 IPv6, Grid Com
puting and Language engineering. The anticipatedM
igration from IPv4 to IPv6 w
ill spur R&D
activities in the areas of IPv6 com
patible applications, quality and security, w
hich are new
features available within the IPv6
ProtocolSource: http://w
ww
.epu.jpm.m
y/RM9/english/Chapter12.pdf
MyICM
S886 goals w
.r.to IPv6
RMK-9 (2006-2010)
MyICM
S886 Strategy
MyICM
S886 goals w
.r.to IPv6
ISPs to be IPv6 enabled by 2006
Governm
ent Agencies to
comm
ence IPv6 deployment
by 2008
IPv6 expected to be proliferated nationw
ide by 2010
4
National Strategic IPv6 Roadm
ap
�D
eveloped by N
Av6,
comm
issioned for M
EWC (M
ICC now
), done June 2008
5
MICCIPv6
Deployment in
Malaysia
MCM
CMTSFB
ISPs
National IPv6Council*
NAv6
MO
STI
MDeC
MIM
OS
MATRADE
MIDA
EPU MO
F
MO
HEResearch
&EducationalInstitutions
IndustryContent
Developers
Stakeholders
Shows Interaction
Shows Influence
MYNIC
SIRIM
MITI
Bank Negara M
alaysia
MAM
PUE-G
overnment
GITN
Stakeholders Influencing the deploym
ent of IPv6 in Malaysia
National Strategic IPv6 Roadm
ap -A
ction PlanN
o.
Strate
gy
Go
alsT
ime
p
erio
dM
ilesto
ne/T
arge
t L
ead
Ag
ency
Stake
hold
ers
Re
spo
nsible
Actio
n Re
quire
d1
IPv6
Tran
sition
/Mig
ration
a.T
ier-1 ISP
sIS
Ps to
dep
loy IP
v6 b
y the en
d o
f 20062
00
7i) IP
v6 C
om
plia
nce A
udit, P
hase
-1
: Ma
r' 07
MC
MC
ISP
s, MC
MC
and
N
Av6
Do
ne. M
CM
C co
mp
lete
d the
Pha
se-1
IPv6
co
mp
liance
aud
it on 2
7 M
arch 2
00
7
ii) IPv6
netw
ork b
ackb
one
should
run o
n dua
l-stack b
y 20
07
M
CM
CIS
Ps, M
CM
C a
nd
NA
v6
ISP
s IP ne
two
rk ba
ckbo
ne sho
uld run o
n IP
v4/IP
v6 d
ual-sta
ck. Do
ne. P
hase
-1 IP
v6
com
plia
nce a
udit co
mp
lete
d b
y MC
MC
on
27
Ma
rch 20
07
confirm
s this.
iii) Offe
r IPv6
for m
ob
ile a
nd 3
G
service
s in sele
cted
are
as o
f the
natio
n by 2
00
7
MC
MC
ISP
s, MC
MC
and
N
Av6
A
ll mo
bile
and
3G
netw
orks sho
uld sup
po
rt IP
v6 in se
lecte
d a
rea
s of the
country b
y 2
00
7. M
CM
C to
follo
w-up
with IS
Ps to
e
nsure this ha
pp
ens.
iv) MY
RE
N to
be
wo
rking o
n na
tive IP
v6 links w
ith othe
r N
RE
Ns (N
atio
nal R
ese
arch a
nd
Ed
ucatio
n Ne
two
rks)
MC
MC
ISP
s, MD
eC
, N
Av6
Do
ne. M
YR
EN
esta
blishe
d IP
v6 p
ee
ring
with T
EIN
2 in June
20
06
and
IPv6
multica
st in F
eb
ruary 2
00
7.
20
08
i) IPv6
Co
mp
liance
Aud
it, Pha
se-
2: 2
00
8 M
CM
CIS
Ps, M
CM
C a
nd
NA
v6
i) IPv6
Co
mp
liance
Aud
it, Pha
se-2
should
b
e d
one
by m
id 2
00
8. M
CM
C sho
uld
mo
nitor a
nd e
nsure tha
t the a
bo
ve ta
rge
t is m
et. N
Av6
as a
consulta
nt could
assist
MC
MC
in ISP
s IPv6
Co
mp
liance
Aud
it
ii) Co
mm
ercia
l roll-o
ut of IP
v6
service
s by 2
00
8
MC
MC
ISP
s and
MC
MC
ii) IPv6
conne
ctivity for Inte
rnet tra
ffic to a
ll custo
me
rs/pub
lic. ISP
s to co
mp
ly and
M
CM
C to
mo
nitor a
nd e
nsure tha
t the a
bo
ve
targ
et is m
et.
20
09
IPv6
Co
mp
liance
Aud
it, Pha
se-3
: 2
00
9M
CM
CIS
Ps, M
CM
C a
nd
NA
v6
IPv6
Co
mp
liance
Aud
it, Pha
se-3
should
be
d
one
by m
id 2
00
9. M
CM
C a
s a re
gula
tor fo
r IS
Ps sho
uld m
onito
r and
ensure
that the
a
bo
ve ta
rge
t is me
t. NA
v6 a
s a co
nsultant
could
assist M
CM
C in IS
Ps IP
v6
Co
mp
liance
Aud
it
20
10
Bro
ad
ba
nd se
rvices to
be
IPv6
a
nd IP
v4 d
ual-sta
ck for a
ll b
roa
db
and
users (2
00
8 - 2
01
0)
MC
MC
ISP
s and
MC
MC
Bro
ad
ba
nd Infra
structure a
nd a
ccess ne
two
rks are
IPv6
cap
ab
le w
ith supp
ort fo
r IP
v6 tra
ffic ove
r bro
ad
ba
nd se
rvices. IS
Ps to
co
mp
ly, and
MC
MC
to m
onito
r and
ensure
the
ab
ove
targ
et is m
et
6
National IPv6 R&
D Roadm
ap
�D
eveloped by NA
v6,comm
issioned for MO
STI, done Dec 2008
Stakeholders influencing IPv6 R&D
in Malaysia
7
Natio
nal IP
v6
R&
D
MO
STIM
OH
EM
ITI
R&
DC
en
tres
Aca
dem
iaIS
Ps
Ind
ustry
MIC
C
IPv6R&
D areas focused by m
ajor econom
iesU
nite
d S
tate
s��
IPv6
Dep
loym
en
tre
qu
irem
en
ts��
Qo
S��
Perfo
rman
ce
��
Mo
bile
IPv6
��
Secu
rity��
Intru
sio
n d
ete
ctio
n��
Tru
st m
od
els
��
Mo
bile
IPv6
Ro
utin
g��
MA
NE
TS
��
Mu
lticastin
g
Ch
ina
��
Netw
ork
Secu
rity A
rch
itectu
re��
Wire
less S
en
so
r Netw
ork
s��
Ho
me N
etw
ork
��
Real-tim
e M
ultim
ed
ia (V
oD
,IP
TV
,H
DT
V,
VR
)��
Inte
lligen
t Tra
nsp
ort S
yste
ms
��
Grid
Ap
plic
atio
ns
��
Qo
S��
Ro
utin
g a
nd
Mu
lticastin
g��
En
viro
nm
en
t Mo
nito
ring
��
Rem
ote
co
ntro
l��
Ad
van
ced
Man
ufa
ctu
ring
��
Rem
ote
Ed
ucatio
n,D
igita
l Lib
rary
��
Med
ical C
are
Ko
rea
��
WiB
ro(8
02.1
6e)
with
IPv6
��
NG
Mo
bile
Co
mm
un
icatio
ns
��
HD
TV
over IP
v6
Inte
rnet
��
Ho
me N
etw
ork
��
Vo
IPv6
��
IT S
oC
��
Next G
en
era
tion
PC
��
Em
bed
ded
S/W
��
Dig
ital C
on
ten
ts��
Tele
matic
s��
Inte
lligen
t Serv
ice R
ob
ot
��
RF
ID/U
SN
��
W-C
DM
A/C
DM
A��
BcN
Jap
an
��
IPv6
Pro
toco
l Sta
ck
��
DN
S��
DV
TS
/IPT
V��
Larg
e S
cale
Mu
lticast u
sin
gP
IM-S
IM(S
ou
rce S
pecific
Mu
lticast)
��
Mo
bile
Tech
no
log
y��
UD
LR
(Un
i-Dire
ctio
nal L
ink
Ro
utin
g)
��
Inte
rnetC
AR
��
Sch
oo
l of In
tern
et (S
OI)
��
Sen
so
r netw
ork
s��
Facility
Netw
ork
ing
��
Secu
rity M
od
el fo
r IPv6
Syste
m
Taiw
an
��
IPv6
Netw
ork
Pro
cesso
r��
IPv6
Mu
lti-ho
min
g S
OH
O
Ro
ute
r��
Netw
ork
Secu
rity/ID
S/IP
S��
Grid
v6
��
Qo
S��
Mu
ltimed
ia s
erv
ices/V
ideo
v6
��
ITS
��
IP b
ased
Ho
me A
pp
lian
ces
��
Ho
me N
etw
ork
ing
��
SIP
-based
Vo
IPv6
��
Mo
bile
IPv6/F
ast H
an
do
ver fo
r M
ob
ile IP
v6
(FM
IPv6)
��
NE
MO
��
An
ycast in
Mo
bile
IPv6
��
xD
SL
��
VP
N��
Mo
bile
IPv6
with
SIP
-based
Ap
plic
atio
ns
EU��
Bro
ad
ban
d��
Mu
lti-pla
y��
Ho
me N
etw
ork
ing
��
Tra
nsp
orta
tion
��
Ap
plic
atio
ns o
n e
merg
en
cy
an
d c
risis
man
ag
em
en
t��
So
cia
l Netw
ork
s��
RF
ID,M
2M
,C
om
mu
nic
atin
go
bje
ct n
etw
ork
s,S
en
so
rn
etw
ork
s��
Pu
sh
Ap
plic
atio
ns
8
IPv6 R&D
areas Malaysia to focus
Top down chart on IPv6 R&
D areas and tim
e frame
9
IPv6 Deploym
ent in Malaysia
•2003, M
Y6 a joint IPv6 network w
as formed
by ISPs -Jaring, Maxis, A
rcnet, TM, TIM
E, DIG
I, and Celcom
•To conduct trial and exploring the next generation IP services in M
alaysia
10
Malaysia Research &
Education N
etwork (M
YREN)
11
�2005,M
YRENw
asestablished
�Connected
toother
NREN
viaTEIN
3and
Internet2w
ithbackbone
capacityof155M
bps
Governm
ent Agencies
Transition to IPv6
Governm
ents agencies that uses PCN at Putrajaya
IPv6 Pilot Project, MEG
TW &
M
AM
PU
12
Pilot Implem
entation
13
Netw
ork Infrastructure
Planning
Security
Transition M
echanisms
Standards
Training
Testing
Cost of Transition
Areas of focus
Trial Implem
entationG
lobal IPv6 connectivity
Objective:
Toestablish
IPv6capability
with
theagencies
backboneand
LAN
1�
Lack of staff with IPv6 know
ledge & experience
2�
Budget constraints
3�
Configurations considerations
4�
Porting Applications considerations
5�
Time constraints
6�
Security considerations
7�
Vendor Support
Challenges of IPv6 deployment in
Governm
ent agencies
14
ISPs Current Status of IPv6•
Tier-1 ISPs IPv6 Compliance A
udit &
CertificationPhase 1 :-Basic netw
ork connectivity testsPhase 2 :-Interconnectivity testsPhase 3 :-Com
mercial &
Advanced N
etwork services
.my dom
ain registry is IPv6 enabled, validated M
ay ‘08
Tier1 ISPs are IPv6 enabled, validated M
ar ‘07
1516Source: http://w
ww
.ipv6forum.com
/ipv6_enabled/isp/approval_list.php
ISPs Current Status of IPv6
Aw
areness & Prom
otion28 Aug ’08, IPv6 Road show
,PICC, Putrajaya
16 –19 June,
Comm
unicAsia 2009
Singapore
INET KL 2009, IPv6 the next step 20 July ‘09
IPv6A
wareness
forM
alaysia’sG
overnmentA
gencies,26N
ov2007,PICC
17
Aw
areness & Prom
otionN
o.D
ateEvent
Venue
111 Aug 2009
MC
MC
Awareness Program
me
MC
MC
, Cyberjaya
220 July 2009
INET KL 2009, IPv6 the next step
Times Square H
otel, KL
38 July 2009
delegates from U
zbekistan for MutiaraC
om, Kuala Lum
purN
Av6 Centre
416
–19 June 2009
Com
mm
unicAsia2009, The 20
thInternational Com
munications and Inform
ation Technology Exhibition & C
onferenceSingapore Expo C
entre
523
–25 Feb 2009
ASEAN IC
T/IPv6 workshop
NAv6 C
entre
628
–30 O
ct 2008M
yBroadbandExhibition and C
onference 2008 KLC
C
728 August 2008
Towards Im
plementation of W
ireless Sensor Technology and Applications over IPv6 N
etwork
PICC
, Putrajaya.
817
–20 June
Com
mm
unicAsia2008, The 19
thInternational Com
munications and Inform
ation Technology Exhibition & C
onference.Singapore Expo C
entre
930
-31 July 2007ASEAN
IPv6 Workshop
Park Royal H
otel, Penang
1015-17 M
arch 2007N
ext-Generation N
etworks Sym
posium: M
alaysia IPv6 Forum Kickoff & IPv6
Certification Training.
IOI M
arriott, Putrajaya.
1117 N
ov 2006N
ational IPv6 Technology Forum, M
oving To IPv6 Enabled Nation
Park Royal H
otel, Penang
1226 Aug 2006
Penang IPv6 Awareness Forum
: Latest Technology & Deploym
ent StrategyU
SM, Penang
1327-30 July 2006
27th BKS-PTN-BAR
AT Rector M
eeting.Bengkulu, Indonesia
1417-21 July 2006
22nd APAN IPv6 Task force M
eeting Singapore
1527 Feb-1 M
arch 2006
APT-NAv6 Joint IPv6 W
orkshopBerjaya Langkaw
i Beach and Spa R
esort, Langkawi.
1622-47 Jan 2006
21st APAN IPv6 Task force M
eeting. Tokyo, Japan.
1722 to 23 Sept 2003
MC
MC
Next G
eneration Netw
orksW
orkshop 2003.PW
TC, Kuala Lum
pur.
1819
–20 June 2003
IPv6 Workshop 2003
NAv6, U
SM, Penang.
1915
–16 O
ct 2000AI3-IPv6 W
orkshop 2000N
Av6, USM
, Penang. 18
IPv6 Enabled websites
19
Source: http://ww
w.ipv6forum
.com/ipv6_enabled/approval_list.php?type=loc&
content=MY
10/229 are IPv6 enabled in Malaysia
Dom
ain name statistics
20
Source: http://ww
w.dom
ainregistry.my/statistics.php
IPv6 TrainingCN
E6 TrainingProfessional Certification
�Certified N
etwork Engineer in IPv6 (CN
E6) –Level 1, 2 &
3
�Certified N
etwork Program
mer in IPv6 (CN
P6) -Level 1, 2 & 3
�Curriculum
with system
atic approach and lots of hands-on
�Com
pletely developed by NAv6 at U
SM
�First of a program
to be offered in the world on IPv6
21
General Recom
mendations
to governments
•N
ational Strategic Plan–
Roadmap, IPv6 deploym
ent and R&D
–IPv6 Im
plementation A
ction Plan
–G
uidelines on IPv6 deployment
•Infrastructure capability on IPv6 (ISPs follow
ed by individual organizations)
•G
overnment support &
leadership
•A
wareness &
Promotion
•H
R Training on IPv622
Conclusion
•IPv6 is a critical infrastructural requirem
ent to the nation for a w
ide range of next generation services
•IPv6 opens up opportunity for innovation and is a catalyst for change w
ith increased economical benefits
•M
alaysia has targeted to be an IPv6 enabled nation by 2010
•This requires w
holehearted comm
itment by all the
stakeholders-Governm
ent, Industry and Academ
ia
•Society has and w
ill be benefited from IP based services
•Let us m
ove forward and em
brace IPv623
Thank you
24
Architecture &
Design
Transition PlanM
ajor Steps to Meet the P
roject’s Objective
•Identify the netw
ork devices that constitute the agencies' backbone, and LA
N.
•D
etermine the current level of IPv6 capability of the netw
ork devices.
•To do a risk assessm
ent of operating in dual-stack mode and
IPv4 to IPv6 translation.•
To Upgrade or purchase netw
ork devices as necessary for IPv6 capability
•D
emonstrate IPv6 routing, transport, and interoperability
across agency’s backbone and LAN
.•
Evaluate the effectiveness, requirements and issues w
ith IPv4 to IPv6 transition
25
T.O.R of the IPv6 Focus G
roup
#R
eference Field
1Identifying the readiness of agencies for the m
igration to IPv6 and providing support
2A
ssisting the Public Sector Coordination and Im
plementation Team
in preparing the IPv6 D
eployment G
uideline for Malaysian G
overnment
Agencies.
3Providing the necessary training and C
ore team developm
ent
4M
anaging the awareness program
for agencies
5Providing advice and consultancy on IPv6 deploym
ent to the agencies.
6M
onitoring the migration process of agencies
7Presenting the progress report of IP
v6 deployment by agencies to the
Public Sector Coordination and Im
plementation Team
26
Success Indicators
Deliverables
20082009
20102011
2012
1R
esearch publications in international conferences cited by ISI and refereed International journals.
3264
128256
600
2Patents of products, applications and
services.2
2448
96192
4R
esearch prototypes and innovative business m
odels.1
1224
4896
5C
omm
ercialized products (devices, applications and services)
224
4896
192
6Innovative business ventures w
ith local or international participation.
112
2448
96
Estimate of the deliverables to be achieved on IPv6 R&
D
27