is 356 it for financial services foreign exchange trading december 24, 2015 pptallon/is356.htm
TRANSCRIPT
IS 356IS 356IT for Financial ServicesIT for Financial Services
Foreign Exchange Trading
April 21, 2023
http://www.evergreen.loyola.edu/~pptallon/is356.htm
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 2/18
BackgroundBackground According to the Bank for International Settlements
(BIS), the foreign exchange markets trade approx $1.2 trillion per day
− more than a month of combined NYSE and NASDAQ trades $8 trillion of foreign exchange trading is online
(Greenwich Associates )… that’s only about 2%
Characteristics: − digital good− no central clearinghouse (trading and clearing are in sync)− no physical trading floor− little regulation (central banks often get involved to stop outflows)− 24-hour global trading
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 3/18
The Foreign Exchange The Foreign Exchange MarketMarket
Minimizes foreign exchange risk (unpredictable rate swings)
There are different ways to trade currencies− Spot exchange rates: the day’s rate offered by a dealer/bank− Forward exchange rates:
– Agreed in advance rates to buy/sell a currency on a future date– Usually quoted 30, 90, 120 days in advance
Arbitrage: buying low and selling high … given slightly different exchange rate quotes in one location vs. another (e.g., London vs. Tokyo)
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 4/18
Spot Market Spot Market CharacteristicsCharacteristics
It is the oldest and largest financial market in the world:− Has no central trading floor where buyers and sellers meet.− Is open twenty-four hours a day, except for short gaps on
weekends.− The spot market is a market for immediate delivery.
Primarily an inter-bank or sell-side market, which is the trading of foreign-currency-denominated deposits between large banks.
− Global banks account for about two-thirds of the market volume, while foreign exchange brokers and dealers account for approximately 20 percent.
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 5/18
A Foreign Exchange A Foreign Exchange Transaction Transaction
Toshiba Japan receives a dollar denominated payment from Best Buy, which they present to their local Fuji Bank.
To exchange the dollar payment for the yen equivalent, Fuji Bank may contact another bank, such as Citigroup, or contact a FX broker.
buy Yen, sell $
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 6/18
Arbitrage: Consistency of Arbitrage: Consistency of RatesRates Arbitrage is the simultaneous buying and selling to
profit (as opposed to speculation). You can arbitrage around either spot or future rates but
either way, you need to move very fast The ability of market participants to arbitrage
guarantees that cross rates will be, in general, consistent.
If a cross rate is not consistent, the actions of currency traders (arbitrage) will bring the respective currencies into line very quickly.
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 7/18
Spatial ArbitrageSpatial Arbitrage Spatial Arbitrage refers to buying a currency in one
market and selling it in another Price differences at a point in time arise from spatial or
geographically dispersed markets− USD/EUR rate quoted in Paris: $1.2900 = €1.00− EUR/USD rate quoted in NY: €0.77=$1 but according to the
rate posted in Paris, the real rate should be €0.77519 (or 1 ÷ 1.29)
− NY trader buys €1 in Paris for $1.29 and sells €1 in New York for $1.2987(makes $0.0087 or 0.6744% profit)
Due to the low-cost rapid-information nature of the foreign exchange market, these price differences are arbitraged quickly and the rates return to equilibrium
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 8/18
Triangular ArbitrageTriangular Arbitrage Triangular arbitrage involves a third currency Arbitrage opportunities exist if an observed rate in
another market is not consistent with a cross-rate The US dollar is trading for 1.7936 ($/£) and the South
African Rand for 6.5492 (R/£) in London, while the Rand is trading for 3.7826 (R/$) in New York.
The cross-rate in London is:6.5492/1.7936 = 3.6514 (R/$)
Hence, an arbitrage opportunity exists. How do you take advantage of it?
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 9/18
Example ContinuedExample Continued A trader sells £1 for $1.7936 in London. The $1.7936 would purchase R6.7845 in New York. The R6.7845 purchases £1.0359 in London. This is a
profit of £0.0359 or 3.59 percent profit on a round trip transaction.
Sell £ in London
Purchase R in New YorkPurchase £ in London
1.
2.3.
profit
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 10/18
Market StructureMarket Structure
Source: Gallaugher & Melville (2004), CACM 47(8)
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 11/18
IssuesIssues Phone trading is still an important part of the market.
This often paperless approach helped John Rusnak of AllFirst to hide $691M in currency trading losses
Buy-side banks later developed proprietary systems that directly linked to clients. These systems did not support multiple counterparties which was a problem for trader seeking price competition.
This situation led to eFX portals− Single-bank sponsored (State St. – FX Connect)− Independents – Currenex− Bank consortia – FXall, Atriax (closed: Chase, Citibank & DB)
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 12/18
Source: Gallaugher & Melville (2004), CACM 47(8)
Technology InnovationTechnology Innovation
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 13/18
CurrenexCurrenexTo buy €1, it will cost you $1.2934
Roundtrip Example:$1.2934 = €1; €1 = ¥137.95; ¥137.95 = $1.2932
(no clear arbitrage opportunity;there is only a tiny difference)
Bought by State Street in January 2007
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 14/18
Trading (just like equities)Trading (just like equities)
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 15/18
Up to 200:1 leverage
No fees or commissions
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 16/18
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 17/18
April 21, 2023© Paul Tallon 18/18
For Next Class…For Next Class… Read
– There will be a 60-minute exam next class