iso 9001:2015 top management’s leadership role in a ... · iso 9001:2015 top management’s ......
TRANSCRIPT
MID-HUDSON CHAPTER of APICSSEPTEMBER 13, 2017
ISO 9001:2015TOP MANAGEMENT’S
LEADERSHIP ROLE IN A PLANNEDMANAGEMENT REVIEW
DONALD M. COSTELLODMC Services
CELL: (475) 279-7115CT PHONE: (203) [email protected]
APICS MEETING
“Review a roadmap to helpenable top business managers to
demonstrate their leadershipcommitment to deliver quality
products and services in today’scompetitive environment in a
planned Management Review”
WINSTON CHURCHILL
“A PESSIMIST SEES THEDIFFICULTY IN EVERY
OPPORTUNITY; ANOPTIMIST SEES THE
OPPORTUNITY IN EVERYDIFFICULTY.”
Presented by DMC Services
TODAY’S CHALLANGES
• A new top managementmindset - Take more
responsibility, and leadershipcommitment for quality
performance, and to• Join the competitive Global ISO
9001 Community
Presented by DMC Services
TODAY’S CHALLANGES
The ISO 9001:2015 Standardoutlines basic and
contemporary qualitymanagement principles intoday’s competitive world
Presented by DMC Services
QUESTION 1
Does your organizationconduct planned periodicManagement Reviews to
assess quality managementperformance?
Presented by DMC Services
QUESTION 3
Do you integrate yourManagement Review with
other site/business orproduction meetings?
Just don’t forget to include requiredMR “inputs” and “outputs”somewhere.
Presented by DMC Services
TIP
MAKE A CURRENTMANAGEMENT OR EXECUTIVE
MEETING REQUIREMENTSMATRIX DOCUMENT
Sample Matrix available upon request
Presented by DMC Services
QUESTION 8
Does your top or seniormanager(s) attend yourManagement Review?
Presented by DMC Services
BONUS “RBT” QUESTION 10
Does your organizationreview predeterminedrelevant business and
process risks, consequencesand opportunities during the
Management Review(s)?
Presented by DMC Services
EXTRA CREDIT QUESTION
Should Finance orAccounting be included
in your ManagementReview?
Presented by DMC Services
LET’S REVIEW – A FEW MAINDRIVERS OF “QUALITY
MANAGEMENT”VERSESOLUTIONS.COM SURVEY (NOV 16,2016) -• 41% - MEET CUSTOMER AND REGULATORY
REQUIREMENTS• 27% - ISO STANDARDS• 22% - PRODUCT AND PROCESS
IMPROVEMENTS• 10% - STRATEGIC DIRECTIONS FOR
OPERATIONAL EFFICIENCY (E.G. REDUCECOSTS AND PRODUCT DEFECTS)
Presented by DMC Services
NEW 21st CENTURY LEADERSHIPMINDSET
TOP MANAGEMENT ISACCOUNTABLE FOR THE
EFFECTIVENESS OF THE QUALITYMANAGEMENT SYSTEM (QMS) AND
ITS ALIGNMENT WITH THECOMPANY’S “STRATEGIC
DIRECTION”
Presented by DMC Services
7 NEW ISO 9001:2015 QUALITYMANAGEMENT PRINCIPLES
• QMP 1 – CUSTOMER FOCUS• QMP 2 – LEADERSHIP• QMP 3 – ENGAGEMENT OF PEOPLE• QMP 4 – PROCESS APPROACH• QMP 5 – IMPROVEMENT• QMP 6 – EVIDENCE-BASED DECISION
MAKING• QMP 7 – RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT (with
other “interested parties”, e.g.suppliers)
Presented by DMC Services
7 MALCOLM BALDRIGE QUALITYAWARD CRITERIA
1. LEADERSHIP2. STRATEGIC PLANNING3. CUSTOMER & MARKET FOCUS4. PERFORMANCE MEASUREMENT5. HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT AND
MANAGEMENT6. PROCESS MANAGEMENT7. BUSINESS RESULT
Presented by DMC Services
KEY LEADERSHIP RESPONSIBILITIES
• DEMONSTRATE LEADERSHIP COMMITMENTTO QUALITY & “STRATEGIC DIRECTION”
• QMS COMMUNICATION TO OTHER PARTIES• CUSTOMER FOCUS• REVIEW RISKS AND OPPORTUNITIES• PROCESS APPROACH (ASSIGN RELEVANT
PROCESS OWNERS & NECESSARY KPICRITERIA)
• PROFIT• OTHER, e.g. PROMOTE IMPROVEMENT, ETC.
Presented by DMC Services
NEW LEADERSHIP EXPECTATIONSIN ISO 9001:2015
• 5.1.1 a) - TOP MANAGEMENT TO TAKEACCOUNTABILITY FOR THEEFFECTIVENESS OF THE QMS
• 5.1.1 b) - TOP MANAGEMENT ENSURETHAT THE QUALITY POLICY AND THEQUALITY OBJECTIVES ARECOMPATIBLE WITH THE CONTEXTAND STRATEGIC DIRECTION OF THEORGANIZATION.
(Con’t)
Presented by DMC Services
NEW LEADERSHIP EXPECTATIONSIN ISO 9001:2015
• 5.1.1 c) - TOP MANAGEMENT TO INTEGRATETHE QMS INTO ITS BUSINESS PROCESSES.
• 5.1.1 d) - TOP MANAGEMENT TO PROMOTETHE USE OF RISK-BASED THINKING.
• 5.1.1 f) & g) - TOP MANAGEMENT TOCOMMUNICATE THE IMPORTANCE OFEFFECTIVE QUALITY MANAGEMENT ANDTO ENSURE THAT THE QMS ACHIEVES ITSINTENDED RESULTS.
Presented by DMC Services
THEME OF PRESENTATION: ONEWAY TO MEET THE
DEMONSTRATED LEADERSHIPCOMMITMENT
VIA A PLANNED AND PERIODICMANAGEMENT REVIEW BY THETOP MANAGER(S) FOR –
– QMS EFFECTIVENESS– QMS ALIGNMENT WITH COMPANY’S
“STRATEGIC DIRECTION” ANDBUSINESS PROCESSES
Presented by DMC Services
A BASIC MANAGEMENT REVIEWMAY TYPICALLY INCLUDE
• HOW ARE WE DOING• CORRECTIVE ACTIONS• WHAT TO DO TO GET BETTER• REVIEW IDENTIFIED RISKS AND ANY
CUSTOMER ISSUES• REVIEW RESOURCES• REVIEW “BUSINESS STRATEGY” AND
POLICY• PREVIOUS ACTION ITEMS• MEET ISO REQUIREMENTS
Presented by DMC Services
SUMMARY OF BASIC MANAGEMENTREVIEW EXPECTATIONS - FROM ISO
9001:2015, 9.3
1. PREVIOUS ACTIONS2. RELEVANT CHANGES (INTERNAL &
EXTERNAL-SUPPLIER ISSUES)3. QMS PERFORMANCE ITEMS (NEXT
SLIDE)4. CONTINUAL IMPROVEMENT
DECISIONS5. DOCUMENT THE REVIEW
Presented by DMC Services
MANAGEMENT REVIEWPERFORMANCE ITEMS
(ISO 9001:2015, 9.3)1. CUSTOMER SATISFACTION2. QUALITY OBJECTIVES & POLICY3. PROCESS KPIs4. CARS/NCNs/SCARS5. SUPPLIER DATA6. AUDITS7. QMS RELEVENT INTERNAL &
EXTERNAL CHANGES
Presented by DMC Services
MANAGEMENT REVIEWPERFORMANCE ITEMS (Cont.)
(ISO 9001:2015, 9.3)8. RESOURCES9. PERTINENT RISK ISSUES &OPPORTUNITIES10. CONSIDER CONTINUALIMPROVEMENT OPPORTUNITIES11. MAKE QMS, OBJECTIVE METRIC,POLICY, SUPPLIER, RESOURCE, ETC.PERFORMANCE CHANGE DECISIONS12. DOCUMENT IS AVAILABLE
Presented by DMC Services
MANAGEMENT REVIEWPERFORMANCE ITEMS (Cont.)
(ISO 9001:2015, 9.3)13. INTERESTED PARTIES REVIEW(4.2) – OPPORTUNE TIME TO REVIEWINTERESTED PARTIES THAT ARERELEVANT TO THE ORGANIZATION
Presented by DMC Services
MANAGEMENT REVIEW TOOLSAND TIPS
• MANAGEMENT REVIEW PREPARATIONCHECKLIST
– include required MR “inputs” and “outputs”
• A NETWORK ELECTRONIC MANAGEMENTREVIEW WITH AUTOMATED RESPONSECHECKLIST WITH PERFORMANCEATTACHMENTS FOR TRAVELLING TOPMGRS
• MAY CONDUCT “MINI” MANAGEMENTREVIEWS OR MELD INTO SCHEDULED“PRODUCTION REVIEWS”
Presented by DMC Services
THE FUTURE AS DRIVEN BY ISO9001:2015 MANAGEMENT REVIEW?
• TOP MANAGEMENT TAILORED“DASHBOARDS” OR SCORECARDS TOMONITOR AND DRIVE STRATEGICIMPROVEMENT INITIATIVES, and ASSESS“RISKS AND OPPORTUNITIES”
• INCLUDE KEY LEAN (REMOVE WASTE)PROJECTS IN THEIR DASHBOARD TOMONITOR IMPROVEMENT STATUS,SUPPLIER and NEW TECHNOLOGICALCHANGES (ref. next slide)
• CONSIDER THIS A NEW WAVE, LEAN TYPEOF GEMBA WALK MODEL?
Presented by DMC Services
DASHBOARD IDEA*
CONSIDER MELDING A MANAGER’S“DASHBOARD” WITH KEY
STRATEGIC AND MARKETINGELEMENTS OF ASQ.ORG’s
“CUSTOMER JOURNEY MAPS” FOR“INTERESTED PARTY”
CUSTOMERS
Presented by DMC Services
THE FUTURE AS DRIVEN BY ISO9001:2015 MANAGEMENT REVIEW?
LEAN REFERENCE;“Update: Why "Lean Manufacturing"Does Not Guarantee Business Success”,Sept. 13, 2016 by Terence T. Burton• “The future (of Lean) is the cloud, big data,
predictive and preventive business analytics,mobility, real time digital performancedashboards, instant digitizedsynchronization, and augmented realitysupply chains.”
Presented by DMC Services
THERANOS CASE STUDY
• DID THERANOS CONDUCT A PROPERMANAGEMENT REVIEW TO EVALUATETHE RISKS OF ALLEGEDLYBYPASSING FULL LAB VERIFICATIONOF THEIR NEW BLOOD TESTINGMACHINE FOR WALGREENS?
Re. Wall Street Journal, May 26, 2016
Presented by DMC Services
MORE PRODUCT RISK CASES• ISO registrar and CE Mark Notified
Body TUV Rheinland fined 60m euros($64m) in French court for its role in aninternational scandal involvingdefective breast implants-CE Markcertification issue (not ISO).
• Takata airbag failures• Deepwater Horizon disaster• Samsung Note 7 cell phone battery fires• VW emission scandal
Presented by DMC Services
NEW “SMART MANAGEMENTREVIEW”* FOCUS COULD INCLUDE -
• “LEADING INDICATOR” (FUTUREDRIVEN) LEADERSHIP THINKING (i.e.RBT) VS USING ONLY “LAGGINGINDICATORS”
• SIMILAR TO FINANCIAL KPI’S, e.g.FORWARD P/E VS TRAILING P/E
• RESOURCE TRAINING THINKING• “INVENTORY TURNS” (ALSO RBT)
(Cont.)
Presented by DMC Services
REFERENCE
“LEADING AND LAGGING INDICATORSCAN HELP YOU BUILD A SUSTAINABLEORGANIZATION”, - Aug 18, 2017,AVETTA Whitepaper
Presented by DMC Services
NEW “SMART LEADINGINDICATOR MANAGEMENT
REVIEW” FOCUS
CONSIDER –CHANGES IN EXTERNAL AND INTERALISSUES THAT ARE RELEVANT TO THEORGANIZATION. SUCH AS, FOREXAMPLE – (Next Slide)
Presented by DMC Services
POSSIBLE SMART “LEADINGINDICATOR” MANAGEMENT REVIEW*
FOCUSRISK & OPPORTUNITY “RBT” FOCUS -• E.G., DELL: CUSTOMER
SATISFACTION, DAYS OF SUPPLY ININVENTORY
• E.G. DUANE, OR CROW-AMSAAEXPECTED RELIABILITY GROWTHTEST MODEL PREDICTION STATUS
• EU DIRECTIVE & EMC DESIGN-RISKPROGRESS (e.g. REACH/RoHS)
Presented by DMC Services
POSSIBLE SMART “LEADINGINDICATOR”* MANAGEMENT REVIEW*
FOCUS (Con’t)RISK & OPPORTUNITY “RBT” FOCUS -• CONFLICT MINERALS REPORTING STATUS• INVENTORY METRICS• “EXPECTED VALUE” RISK MANAGEMENT
TOOL = (O+4*ML+P)/4• CTPAT COMPLIANCE AND 3RD PARTY AUDIT
READINESS.Note: CTPAT means Customs Trade
Partnership Against Terrorism, sponsored bythe Custom Border Patrol regulatory body.
Presented by DMC Services
KEEP IN MIND
• “RISK BASED THINKING” DOESNOT REQUIRE USING “RISKMANAGEMENT” TECHNIQUES INTHE ISO 9001:2015 STANDARD
• RISK RECORDS AND REGISTERSARE NOT REQD BY THE STD.
Presented by DMC Services
POSSIBLE SMART “LEADING”MANAGEMENT REVIEW* FOCUS
(CON’T)
• e.g., SUBMIT ANNUAL HAZARDOUSCHEMICAL INVENTORY-TIER II REPORT BYMARCH 1ST IF YOUR FACILITY USED ORSTORED ANY LISTED EHS
– 40 CFR 355 Appendix A, in excess of 500 pounds(lb) or the threshold planning quantity, whicheveris lower, or if your facility used or stored anyother hazardous substance in excess of 10,000 lb.report.
• AND, FORM R (SECT 313)TRI REPORT JULY1ST.
Presented by DMC Services
“KEY” TAKE-AWAY• “LEADERSHIP” COMMITMENT MAY BE
DEMONSTRATED, AS YOU SEE FIT, IN THEMANAGEMENT REVIEW.
• FORWARD-LEADING INDICATOR THINKINGTO MANAGE & MINIMIZE RISK
• DOCUMENT THE REVIEW AS EVIDENCE.• MAY COMBINE WITH OTHER MEETINGS.• DON’T FORGET TO COVER “INPUTS” &
“OUTPUTS” MIN REQUIREMENTS.– OMNEX, Inc. reports “inputs” (9.3.2) a top major IATF
16949 automotive industry audit N/C (Aug 22, 2017)
Presented by DMC Services
TAKE-AWAY NOTES
• THE REVISED ISO 9004“GUIDELINES” VERSION ISDUE TO BE PUBLISHED IN2018
Presented by DMC Services
MANAGEMENT REVIEWPRESENTATION
Questions?Contact Don Costello:
[email protected](475) 279-7115 cell(203) 792-1421 Connecticut
Presented by DMC Services
OTHER DMC SERVICES BESTPRACTICE PRESENTATIONS
• ISO 14001 EMS & BENEFITS• SAFETY PRACTICES IN THE WORKPLACE• ENERGY MANAGEMENT COST REDUCTION• HUMAN FACTORS & ERGONOMICS FOR
QUALITY• ERGONOMICS TO IMPROVE HEALTH &
PROCESS EFFICIENCY• EXPERIENCES WITH CHINA/JAPAN and
EUROPEAN MANUFACTURINGCHALLENGES
• GAP AUDIT TO UNCOVER SHORTFALLS