it d tiintroduction to fem‐ - eth...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
I t d ti t FEM S ftIntroduction to FEM‐Software
1Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 2: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
C t tContents
FEM d l t• FEM development• Introduction to the use of Finite Elements
M d ll h h l bl• Modelling the physical problem• Finite elements as a tool for computer‐aided
d i d tdesign and assessment• An overview of FEM‐Software (Open source
and commercial)and commercial)• Example: Abaqus
2Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 3: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
MFE d l tMFE development
• MFE is the confluence of three ingredients: matrix• MFE is the confluence of three ingredients: matrix structural analysis, variational approach and computer
• 1950s, M.J. Turner at Boeing (aerospace industry in J g ( p ygeneral): Direct Stiffness Method
• Academia: J.H. Argyris, R.W. Clough (name “finite ele e t”) H C Ma ti a d O C Zie kie ielement”), H.C. Martin and O.C. Zienkiewicz –popularisation
• 1960s, Melosh and De Veubeke: Variational Approach1960s, Melosh and De Veubeke: Variational Approach• Commercial finite element computer codes
3Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 4: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
I t d ti t th U f Fi itIntroduction to the Use of Finite ElementsElements
• Within the framework of continuum mechanics dependencies between geometrical and physicaldependencies between geometrical and physical quantities are formulated on a differentially small element and than extended to the whole continuum
• As a result we obtain differential, partial differential or integral equations for which, generally, an analytical solution is not available they have to be solved usingsolution is not available – they have to be solved using some numerical procedure
• MFE is based on the physical discretization of the p yobserved domain, thus reducing the number of the degrees of freedom; moreover the governing equations are in general algebraic
4Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
are, in general, algebraic
![Page 5: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
St i th MFESteps in the MFE
• Continuum is discretized in a mesh of finite elementsEl t t d t d l t d l t• Elements are connected at nodes located on element boundaries
• State of deformation stresses etc in each element is• State of deformation, stresses, etc. in each element is described by interpolation (shape) functions and corresponding values in the nodes; these node values
b i k f h h d f fi i lare basic unknowns of the method of finite elements
• The way in which these three steps are approached has• The way in which these three steps are approached has a great influence on the results of the calculations
5Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 6: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
B i T f MFEBasic Types of MFE
• Direct MEF: analogue to displacement methodV i ti l MFE b d th i i l f t ti it• Variational MFE: based on the principle of stationarity of a functional, which is usually total potential energy or complementary potential energyp y p gy
• Residual MFE: based on the differential equations that are used to describe the problem
• Energy Balance MFE: based on the balance of different energy types, mostly used to solve thermodynamic problemsproblems
6Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 7: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
M d lli f th h i l blModelling of the physical problem
7Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 8: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
M d lli f th h i l blModelling of the physical problemMFE i l f l i th th ti l d l• MFE is only a way of solving the mathematical model
• The solution of the physical problem depends on the quality of the mathematical model the choice of thequality of the mathematical model – the choice of the mathematical model is crucial
• Thus mathematical model must be reliable and effective• Thus, mathematical model must be reliable and effective• The chosen mathematical model is reliable if the required
response can be predicted within a given level ofresponse can be predicted within a given level of accuracy measured on the response of a very comprehensive mathematical model
• The most effectivemathematical model for the analysis is the one that gives the required response with sufficient
d l
8Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
accuracy and at least costs
![Page 9: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
E lExample
Complex physical problem (steel bracket) modelled
9Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
p p y p ( )by a simple mathematical model
![Page 10: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
E lExample
Detailed reference model – 2D plane stress model
10Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
pfor MFE analysis
![Page 11: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
E lExample
• Choice of mathematical model must correspond to desired responsedesired response
• The most effective mathematical model delivers reliable answers with the least amount of effortanswers with the least amount of effort
• Any solution (including MFE) of a mathematical model is limited to information contained in or fed into the model:limited to information contained in or fed into the model: bad input – bad output (garbage in – garbage out)
• Assessment of accuracy is based on comparisons with the y presults from very comprehensive models – but in practice it has to be based on experience (experiments…)
11Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 12: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
MFE T l f CAD/CAMMFE as a Tool for CAD/CAM
• Practical application requires that solutions obtained by MFE are reliable and efficientMFE are reliable and efficient
• However, it is also necessary that the use of MFE is robust – this implies that minor changes in any input torobust this implies that minor changes in any input to an MFE analysis should not change the response quantity significantlyg y
• Engineer (user) should be able to judge the quality of the obtained results (i.e. for plausiblity)
12Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 13: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
I l t ti f MFEImplementation of MFE
• Calculation of system matrices K, M, C and Rwhichever applicable (nodal point and element information are read;applicable (nodal point and element information are read; element stiffness matrices, mass and damping matrices and equivalent loads are calculated; structure matrices qare assembled)
• Solution of equilibrium equations
• Evaluation of element stresses
13Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 14: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
I l t ti f MFEImplementation of MFE• General flowchart of program
STRAP (Bathe, page 989)
• Equation solver COLSOL (Bathe, S ti 8 2 3)Section 8.2.3)
G l U i ffi i t fi it l t• Goal: Using efficient finite elements programs
• Packages: Open source and commercial
14Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
commercial
![Page 15: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
O kOpen source packages
• CalculiX is an Open Source FEA project. The solver uses a partially compatible ABAQUS file formatpartially compatible ABAQUS file format.
• DUNE, Distributed and Unified Numerics Environment GPL Version 2 with Run‐Time ExceptionGPL Version 2 with Run Time Exception
• FEniCS Project: a software package developed by American and European researchersAmerican and European researchers
• ForcePAD: educational software forcepad.sourceforge.net• freeFEM: a software from freefem.orgfreeFEM: a software from freefem.org • Sundance: a software package developed at Sandia
National Laboratories
15Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 16: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
C i l kCommercial packages
• Abaqus: Franco‐American software from SIMULIAADINA R&D I S htt // di /• ADINA R&D, Inc. See http://www.adina.com/
• ANSYS: American softwareCOMSOL M l i h i• COMSOL Multiphysics
• COSMOSWorks: A SolidWorks module• GTSTRUDL30• LS‐DYNA, LSTC ‐ Livermore Software Technology
C tiCorporation• Nastran: American software
CUBUS
16Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
• CUBUS
![Page 17: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
E l AbExample: Abaqus• Abaqus modules: Abaqus/Standard, Abaqus/Explicit and
Abaqus/CAE• Abaqus/Standard is a general‐purpose solver using a
traditional implicit integration scheme to solve finite element analyses
• Abaqus/Explicit uses an explicit integration scheme to l hi hl li t i t d i d i t tisolve highly nonlinear transient dynamic and quasi‐static
analyses • Abaqus/CAE provides an integrated modeling• Abaqus/CAE provides an integrated modeling
(preprocessing) and visualization (postprocessing) environment for the analysis products
17Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
e i o e o e a a y i p o u
![Page 18: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
Ab f tAbaqus features
• Wide material modeling capabilityWide material modeling capability • Ability to be customized • A good collection of multiphysics capabilities such as• A good collection of multiphysics capabilities, such as
coupled acoustic‐structural, piezoelectric, and structural‐pore capabilitiesp p
• Attractive for production‐level simulations where multiple fields need to be coupled
18Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 19: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
Ab M lti h iAbaqus: Multiphysics• Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g. blast loading• Response of a submerged cylinder to an underwater p g y
explosion shock wave (Abaqus/Explicit)• Geometryy
19Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 20: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
Ab M lti h iAbaqus: Multiphysics• Loading
20Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 21: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
Ab M lti h iAbaqus: Multiphysics• Stand‐off point and source point
21Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 22: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Ab M lti h iAbaqus: Multiphysics• Structure and surroundings
22Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 23: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
Ab M lti h iAbaqus: Multiphysics• Displacements at the center of the end caps
23Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09
![Page 24: It d tiIntroduction to FEM‐ - ETH Zarchiv.ibk.ethz.ch/emeritus/fa/education/FE_II/Lecture_14.pdf · • freeFEM: a software from ... •Coupled acoustic‐structural analysis e.g](https://reader034.vdocument.in/reader034/viewer/2022042801/5b012a507f8b9ab9598be74b/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
Ab M lti h iAbaqus: Multiphysics• Accumulated equivalent plastic strains
24Method of Finite Elements II18-Dec-09