iz75 s7p7£s tot/rtcase 4:04-cv-01017-rbp-hgd document 1 filed 05/17/2004 page 10 of 17 t~ it...

Case 4:04-cv-01017-RBP-HGD Document 1 Filed 05/17/2004 Page 1 of 17

.(//'Iz75D S7P7£S uI3'7?r7e.-r tOt/RT .'- I It· .. , ':)

/I(jf{ /;//E/?,N' ur.J J~;z-t;7 of /9//-?i3,c)m~:" : >. (:~"""'!.~ ~ ~/ 04 tt~ I: 41

u. S. o;~; T l', lC r COURT N.D. OF "\Lt~BAHA

Raf}t.t ,LJi;/n~k -#4 't-Z---l- b·L.-1-f 0 fLJ - - I if'- • I / f7UI1W 1"11Vl- A ~I 15'''Y?'l1

pr;6l1erlo.l ;::;nclrruk #It'tf,- 4-~r-()l2- C, I ~ct W ~ fI~~S. ,q!eXahQ'i 1'- Nc/;..U Ia # 1\ 1'B - b 35- ~?-3 t, rt' (.., B l-t , ;fem/" i3acC!US N /3 J.2f/ 3I!J/ Fr~~tc:,I\, tv\~~ ,I'//C(j) /36.1f ~ ~af!J E..~ ~ ~~ ~ :3A1Yl~S UA-re..s, Shev1f{1 £~ZtL, e..~ D.E:..~ ttocH) ic~ 50f'£1


{ohl?6/~ ~/J~;- lie c/u;;/ /fjJJJ /?e/s t!X £/~-C - Yee~;Jn /ffg 4/7/ c,;;;'/llj j, t!oM?6/~/ ?t/~Jt/(}nl ~ 4-/4 22 ~ L(,J~C- 5ec.,!/ln, 135/ _----~

;J!;~JS i)1t:&;U /1~.L:> YFN.t(£

~ IhJ.j /3 a C/0/ {lc..}&n ffC/&r/2e/ ~ {/z (/,j-t:. Seek't'n 1/.13, ,4 k~ess -lie. ~/?I/Va..i~n, 4'nAi' e"r-6/ 14" -'J. (1/ !fiJj} SeCI/I'e/ ~ de 6n:j~411 0/ &- .QJ7/.J/ s/a,4s. /he t'krl hS hr/sa!t:"i',:/1 ~n~r 23 Ll-S-I!. See£bn 133/ ctn//JC/Jlt:;J(3) P'/;/nlTJ1 feeA1 ck4m-'7 nfe/ forfU't:PJ7/ 4 2J 451 c- fec";;~n 22&/ tJn/ :?2(J,


, CIJl/f,7#/z77":;

'?ltJ,,,j-.,tf {j,t {;;l4c~{/ej 1~/n!1ro.~(;n and ('C(JrG;m f!lJfo-ee/J?en/ /zC'-c) ~4/~ees rVNen/f ~"/ru/ o! de tr,f~ tknj af4n4H &nhy In JacdcAn (j~,i;mai- Mr/ 0/ I!e ck,4nees ~(/e (oS'es p~~~ in u(2t/(}(/J MyJ t:Ut4 t'1a.1A"tJ11f de'11- /?/n(Jr/&/ CJnol /t;r .un dwr£/ od4n4" ~ 7-~-c ..

0e/ln~n/ J~m{ij, ~7~ ;s lAe S).er/!/ 8/ de e;t~ {$c;n4 c/e,{,k" &n;4y, Je Ij ~a/6- re~pOnJ/jj 4~ de ec/e-az// eP~ra4'erl 0/ e;ZWe- {'oun? tlhr/ t?cd /nH-j'/uh" .&~r d~ /Vt/scrfc.i'cn ~


(?ey 1J?'~7t1'£ IJn/ !it5/ (f/. Ct;/lte/ eo/} ~re/t~{}St3h()j,l, &cI'~//iJna4/ ~~;'eR-J ~Ye a//tKAlt/ /1 /I?{}~ /lre L;)JNtJ)J/4)1e/ ad ,/ &/r o/4rne7 J J 6fnJu/a/e;: de C't7CtJJ,Jt y'4 ffR/20 ,35:7 3.d .. /0 f3" Ilo() -(71 ad. (;-r./j'jy) (f;u/7A, kve rlecoJI1I'iw da-/ /JRJ'f!- 15 /ld ddFr!-)r?~ J~c/eY/JIJ?t?n~/ pat?oJ~ /0 k ad/~e/ ~ htJ/ a!Yt?Cc//:y. tL rreaJ(Jrtaiie aeceJJ /a de r: d;),ld}'7e" {lilt/' SuC'A aCt'eJ3 /J /)rCJ0'4/ ~ 4. .4-J/ 1J//lt'n~t'J11 // f/tJUj/ ~ /7tJ/e/ 4~ /);(:',h/-4f U'I'E all /h7/J7'3~tPu/ ~d ~/;d..J /h 4r.iJn {$~n4/#J ~ (dX~hna-~ r/,v{ a;tt1 ?4/?~ ad JZ/tf~1

(t=r0w!J In a/7CcJn/ ..w/)j' ;ib/o/ /e/ /e4/lcne Com;1?F~ IS {)/l Ulll7etJSOna64.. (In/ Im))rCle~;eoli O£/~f,9?~¢ e/ jj~ n:¥! ~ c;mmtll7/~d Ni//4i Jf/ena-f /)nc/ ~;6s /})'tJ/ec/e/ ~ 4. foJ/ tJ/J7Rn~"h-/ tJs -uR// II'S td/}/a/ e/ tlCCeJJ /0 #e Cbh4 ~

:;.,.qj ):,efjnen. /)4I n/jJ! dmh?(PJ/ea~(Jn ~'/J ~,J I71tJmitrs t}rz/ 4'"e~, 5eme 0/ ~'Ci /l~5/eds

abaW GC//e/ /"JtJ/ ~ (J:e&M"P~~/ ~ mta/~ 5;7J4/n Cy 03// ~ea0e. JblJ7e 4r/ ~r// {~/74-/C'5 /J?t}/~ JYJ4/Yl 4&J )e(/eya/ MAe,1J ~

7 IlltJ// /0 ~ a{~t/ere/.I/ cd,f(A~r/ 0/ (}// .. 0J/A~


'7--r(Jn? !f"efgn (dun i/eJ Is


t~

It ((.~- or HLCFSS. ~ [~E~-r;z-t1/V' , tAe c/o~ ~wh7 o//47h-z ~en;4y avt /?t1/ ~C/e t/)1.7 {jC// ~y aet'tea,4n -u/,ler~ ~~/neeJ &h ,/ac/e (ieCeJj /0 de. Ph 4..1/ C /o'rJa /»tJ;/'a 4,), on I 2- 3.#la// }nrr:ur ds/ #lIn :Ia//4 J/2e ()/ tt ~Ad# t'Ck!lh/ ~ e-uer (j/Je 4/1t#e(}// ~ 4n~eJ In (JJ'1e P//J//" , ;:;{ere 15 /Jo (J/f!j'tu,{ ffoee t'ly t;fq"/,Phl",,/ h exer6Je tlnd /e~/)~e5' tire /)e;-/)7tMt!/J/~ r:h))n've/ tJ/ &C/~r.eX:~rC/Je -# See £ee/)1t1b"e-- Yo /Jl~~l5. /2. 73J. /1/1/(/ (9£ t:'r, /flJ j);1S(}neos an/7()/ ~ af/?ni/e/ & /' &C/~r e:x?t'r6re,,,,t'r a 4'1/ "/Q7e. 5-ee (JAc,. /'0,5. ck~}4n, J,6"r.r:;/o/ s~...6;/ 2), /7'N:eahnJ' /""Te,j~/r/'!t .,{.;1- aaeJS ,4 d~~)/7eCr~Z Jf:- las 0{ 4


06'#'-2"/11. or, ;9C~6]J, '/(J, "IV//7Jrz'/zt1.N/lL, ho.-D 'i Iv £.j~, af +ne8 tJ~e hr1J ,;{/ ~'ff ;7Jepj 4'C/ dJif Ie /;JJt'lj!'C?,,/ h t1 j(4JAJ(}r~n d-dfl. d ~/ iJ je/f:7j /;J all /J~74/l ~n/ c/dr/e,f. TN .del c/'~ 5~r(/e/ de /. t: e. ~£/)t!es ~ d {1~5/ er/i7 ~/ uA d tine Sit'e 0/ /r~ .

(, ---;;;-- tl# /"Jl5c.// ,£ &. ;1IlI7' e,.['/ 0'/ tf)7 ~('a/ Srfre ;.1 ~~ SOY 4 ~ ~4~ReJ /tre ,4'y'; !ao, 'As a ;{t!Jt/// tYf4';}ee'J A ~)7n(f1 tl,4t/ rf ~

;/Ie~ c1mo//JJt2/;/ /Ap?f t1/l~ ~,e ~ s4r(/e &y/ 6nr#-/Ja/e IlJ a /1~Jt/// &/ ~~:J ~/IJ ~-/" ~

',uPon /;]~/)7a4/7 /f17/ tiehve eZ seri/ir //7ea-l .4 4 d~/I~~f tJn1- &)}Ce t2 aAer-~

~ 27 Ij ae5jJeCa~ J'&4//4/ ~/ e'/cd ae~n Or J:cK £'(.(1/ /J .-wn&/7J'/~/:~na/ 6/J ;/ ?~/)/j,(;J ~A/)eeJ ~~ t2re /ld/ bh~y I/n,7 (j,//J7///t,l/ )el?~lt'V' ~4 yA;rrAthn (lh/ ex4An ()/ 4J~ {-bn, ti~r/ /0 ?ure/t;SeJ /.Ie. (bm/J?/J-Jt2l? 4~ /~/»J .. Sea,lf(;/is) y, tOUJ)j;/1 72S 1 j-.2.d (2 n/. (!,Ya Ij!3) IJTlJIJ)1S tlre rtejtt/re/ ,4 j'~y(/e /00/ da/ /J /It/khws !J/i/ pJ'e~(Jre/ U/la4r ~ dan Ccnt?!-£cn t.


11-

(713"3 I /j:7 c: / .z t) PI tJH7'lr 65 ,;:)dO /l? () /: If&:" Iz r; 7 dt/ J ~.!ft9 C' ;:z·e E: ",Ldl)': /77 Uj~ h //J) ,:Jc= //9Z~ EE S

·'Ma.. /J?t/J,J~f Ci//~//)et!J &-/ e4~ d~n4J? ee'174r (jre ()nj a,4wv ;(e, /)J/


h;UDf.llfC/, ;::ill: /fcviEW. 0/ ' C 4//J?

:t~ ~~e //'a~ ai,j,-;;;:- ~:~!:J:j~~~£/let2,~;te . & ~t9/b/$ /1/ d'J aYe m~ ady "- de ($,...f-A?/7J &/ ?14;,;- aJ~eme»/ bnA.r ~e ,#raeeJ3 C'Aie.rJe.. SOme (!(){/n,-! ~ue /e// d/ YaM" da4~ s,lgaj/ ~ tlna)'2e/ .Q/7a1y /4(!. /'Se// v~ ~dYZ c;;'S//~ 45. S29

(191j}) y/t;I)~qy/ J>

J/uJec/ey. bl/er ~t?W7/f 4vI! ./e~ 4/' ///J hd/ '1~1 ed{/'l'! ~w' 1h;/J?/(J/64n ~,c{;/;1(2eJ C'/b,'/m sk~ ~ kea/e/ /~ /Jretk./ y, /feneJ, 2e3 ./-; ?d· 82/· ~;£'er2oot!) ~ 4;:;{/ (?r~lt/'/ n~t/erSe/ a. £wir a~n/ /l(/~~ On

0. &Je ImuJ,I/ tf, b,5, aIt4;j.,C¥!s iel?auk &.. 2'-rk,d COCi/1/ W afs////fJe/ -/h/r C~'/m .HS/nJ 7%~ J4n/-a:dl ;f,. /Jrl!"":;o/ ~~/';;et2s/ d~{// jl'w':J de 0/1"-I17ee5 JIe 8??~~/?,-¥j 4 t:l1Jue t9'k/ ~ ~/ree/ Y;/;n~rpt{ ..

¥ 7# ~ o/senee () /' o!~~n ,dm ~ S&/reMe (fvn/. 8f Ik e4c/e1J;;!/ 6;.eu/Y on & J'~t!l/dr/~' d .OSM J,. ~t/o:kknJ;, //;;/)?fjm,lM oI,4/;"ees C~;n?" 4. tJ;C/lZ/ H€5jJeC$t L/rt~/ ~ a/~I /Ie. /71tJre 41l/~nl s,,6nd/;~ /Ae S'/ohAr/ ~/ /5 ?rtJ4c~ve.. (f/

;/J7/)7{fl"tJPY{ Jr{f,.l.,t{ ~.17 de S4n~;zA £ j)rek,ah ~4/nee.5~ IT /j~ C/;rree/ S4n~l-trf /S bh~4t1h /0 & CotttTi' ~ C'bW/1/, S',.I~;{/ t1/~/j// a C"(%//}Je/ /0 r1ejJYeselli #e jJ/&/h ~$ //7 -dJ &5e.",


f:J/(lIi?J$ /T€t1~e (/17/ /~~(Ji-)/lJnu{ .& /7e;&reNe. j)artJJY&?Js / /0 ~e c¥f/7//i1 ()/ dCCeJ3 ~ de Cl~u&k /aJ ~ir~-

1")' (J17/ /1

/teatl~~ a& c//9~,4S /J.4h~# ./7~,1/s ;{ & ~~a/ 0/ /Ie dJ as s~/e/ /h /4e sdl ~1;~ /(/4 d//?t'/7Mt'mL tis // 1i1&/t,n64 &If'S~r/l/'l//}a/ej d'/keh ?4;//~

rf1n/ 6/J€r s/"/J//~4,1-~ ?44a4/ &~~1?5 ~4/~e/ a/ /' ,) (;., oal('~d, 8/;D,r, ~4(//tL, /leu./" 7&r~ e /c It


2b De4nu/;/7/, C'1tJ{J,' l?ajl75an. ".AI, d/)'&mhYl iJh/ J.#,hHS,a7 es Jui!tc;t// ;~~Z# ~ ua-e/ tln/ u/J.vsa/ ~~)J/Jkn/ olflj(JUJ! ;J4h/#/- (Ire /1fl/ u)lA, tI/1/ (lr//;//n/2/ S(Jfi~(e5 Bh/ CCt/j/ /Jtr/ /e /U/l)J/ a/ a/ )J4/"h/# Ju,Jm//f' Ij,,/ /JeTr /7{f//f P/l~:" ?fie til tl//?~A/~tJ/7/ /j (//tJ~A/ ~A4n lie. r;r{/lnt4I7/ tYk~/175 #e/Yi 1'0 t2 /l?t/Jt;/J?t//n sectlr/& ~cJr' u?~ ~;!tu/ t(({'eJ'3 ~ o(/,46:N- hee,ea4n

{})-1 (})17 s~h4// ~n/ Mh'7fhu/ jJr~.?-er /J7~at7:a/ Bdn-ill? tln/ /h/)v~/4vs ra/q

1/ --;Xe rf;;.-kn timen~t'Q/ /5 ~/h-t/eFSt}/ tfn/ tljJjJ)-C-5 /0 ~ver;78/1e,


/-1 /e1e;~I?(2,,;geCeS5," fJroJ)ti Q rea3ena./1., ;Jl'efJlJ// &~ tJlJ/ fade/' €'ad rohs, till/' (). j)roee"£rc ;I:. I;'~()n/ ~471eej 10 /)Jl1je l/ec. (Jg.4 .4h7,;/t'e~/'& a,C//1/' o/krne75 {lllc! glier 1Ja/ (;g '*

is /)ct.'ess, /0, ~J&I /7JtJdr/~~~ IJ~Othr~ tt~ck4/ du/ ieaAS ~ft~ /tr5 Bilei' (lm~uArs ()n/ a HetlJt!/)(J./;{ deL'eH /0 lies€.. /7Jo4:y/oA

e r?~C/tea~~N: /-}j{J /J7c>r~ ~7J?e ~ mt1rea4n &17/ /Jl'()(/ltJt aece~~ ~ t/h OU/~y ./?eerea~~n ~

at: I?el:Jliln / /9/4cJ d~ /l1t/J;{'PJ.f a/I~;/)I!.es 5~#Ft/enl ~»:t? a/ 4:;/ /-1 {tX


E

31

/fleu!'Ca/ 7;eetYi t;. ?rlJ(/lck IllRq/reo/ /J~ (C/?S/5~/ t2eOJr/-11J ~ t"nd ~4.rl4''en J~n4rtA' ()nd ~ .///7;/e/ S,hks aI75~,/u~n (olY7?{Jnj'~7 ~/r)~ In lie, olT1tXfnl ~ ~ sel /y II£- {tJU/77

iz75 s7p7£s tot/rtcase 4:04-cv-01017-rbp-hgd document 1 filed 05/17/2004 page 10 of 17 t~ it...

Documents